social media at school
TRANSCRIPT
The Future of Learning:
Steve WheelerUniversity of Plymouth, UK
LearnTEC, Karlsruhe, Germany: 2 February 2011
prolearn-academy.org
Digital Learning Futures
Steve WheelerPlymouth University
Where have we come from?http://photos.jeremybrooks.net/?p=65
Stev
e W
heel
er, P
lym
outh
Uni
vers
ity, 2
012
The Future...?
www.abebooks.com
It is very difficult to predict the future. It’s difficult to even
predict what will happen in the next
year.
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
The Future...?
www.abebooks.com
When he saw a demonstration of the telephone in
1880, a U.S Mayor declared: “One day
every town in America will have a
telephone!”
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Source: Kelly Hodgkins http://gizmodo.com/5813875/what-happens-in-60-seconds-on-the-internet
Social media and learning
So Me use
>800 Million
>200 Million >150 Million
>260 Million
>14 million
articles
>4 Billion images
Source: http://econsultancy.com
2 Billion views/day24 hours/minute
Stev
e W
heel
er, P
lym
outh
Uni
vers
ity, 2
012
>170 Million
Social networks and digital tribes
Stev
e W
heel
er, P
lym
outh
Uni
vers
ity, 2
012
Learning
User generated
content
Wisdom of crowds?
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Learning 2.0
ToolsCollaborating
Sharing
Voting
Networking
User generated
content
Architecture of participation
Tagging
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
http://www.geeky-gadgets.com
Stev
e W
heel
er, P
lym
outh
Uni
vers
ity, 2
012
Twitter as a libraryTwitter as a street corner
Twitter as a soapbox Twitter as amplification
What my students said about Twitter...
http://jcbarrington.blogspot.com/2011/05/on-twitter.html
Stev
e W
heel
er, P
lym
outh
Uni
vers
ity, 2
012
Digital Content Curation
www.scoop.it/t/future-school
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
‘New’ learners are...• more self-directed• better equipped to capture information• more reliant on feedback from peers• more inclined to collaborate• more oriented toward being their own “nodes of production”.
Education Trends | Featured NewsJohn K. Waters—13 December 2011
http://coolshots.blogspot.com/2007_02_01_archive.html
Stev
e W
heel
er, P
lym
outh
Uni
vers
ity, 2
012
‘New’ learners are...• more self-directed• better equipped to capture information• more reliant on feedback from peers• more inclined to collaborate• more oriented toward being their own “nodes of production”.
Education Trends | Featured NewsJohn K. Waters—13 December 2011
http://coolshots.blogspot.com/2007_02_01_archive.html
Stev
e W
heel
er, P
lym
outh
Uni
vers
ity, 2
012
But they need
much more...
http://www.csmonitor.com
Stev
e W
heel
er, P
lym
outh
Uni
vers
ity, 2
012
Camera
Coloured caps
Coloured caps
Mirror
Projector
Phone blogs.fayobserver.com
MIT’s “Sixth Sense” Wearable...
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
0
Web meets World
Mash-upGPSQR codes
Camera
Mobile phone
Bar codesBrowser
Projector
GeomappingGeotaggingPersonalised
Ambient
3-D
Video
Navigation
Communication
Haptic
cc S
teve
Whe
eler
, Uni
vers
ity o
f Ply
mou
th, 2
010
Learners need ‘digital wisdom’
Stev
e W
heel
er, P
lym
outh
Uni
vers
ity, 2
012
“60% of all Internet pages contain
misleading information.”
- Thomas Edison
Learners need ‘digital literacies’
Stev
e W
heel
er, P
lym
outh
Uni
vers
ity, 2
012
language
Managing identity
nameimages
netiquettereputation
avatar interaction
privacy
personal data
identity
legacy
reputationname
privacy
images
cc S
teve
Whe
eler
, Uni
vers
ity o
f Ply
mou
th, 2
010
interaction
http://i.dailymail.co.uk
Learners need e-safety
Learners will need new ‘literacies’
• Social networking• Privacy maintenance• Identity management• Creating content• Organising content• Reusing and repurposing• Filtering and selecting• Self presenting
http://www.mopocket.com/
Stev
e W
heel
er, P
lym
outh
Uni
vers
ity, 2
012
Learners will need new ‘literacies’
• Social networking• Privacy maintenance• Identity management• Creating content• Organising content• Reusing and repurposing• Filtering and selecting• Self broadcasting
http://www.mopocket.com/
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
The new web environments are game
changers. learners now need new
(digital) literacies
“Knowledge that is acquired under compulsion obtains no hold on the mind.”
- SocratesPlato
http://www.fotopedia.com/items/flickr-713124904
Stev
e W
heel
er, P
lym
outh
Uni
vers
ity, 2
012
Here’s a problem for teachers:
“For the first time we are preparing students for a future we cannot clearly describe.” - David Warlick
http://communications.nottingham.ac.uk/podcasts/
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Formal and Informal learning
Formal Learning Informal Learning
20% 80%
Source: Cofer, D. (2000). Informal Workplace Learning.
Shouldn’t we now start to blend formal and informal learning?
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
www.newmediamusings.com
Is learning simply about gaining knowledge...? St
eve
Whe
eler
, Uni
vers
ity o
f Ply
mou
th, 2
011
... or about making connections?
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Funnels and Webs
Ivan Illich
http://zumu.com
One size does not
fit all
Participation, not passive reception of knowledge
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
“It's not what you know that counts anymore. It's what you can learn.”
– Don Tapscott
http://www.nationalpost.com
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Connections to your community
of practice
Digital Natives?
http:
//so
cial
ente
rpris
eam
bass
ador
s.or
g.uk
The Net Generation?
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
We shouldn’t be categorising learners like this!
Digital Natives?
http:
//so
cial
ente
rpris
eam
bass
ador
s.or
g.uk
Net Generation?
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Expectations
Needs
.....are not the same as...
Engaging and fun!
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Serious gamesInteractive narratives
Role play simulationsMassively Online Role Playing Games
anytime
personalised
anyplacehttp://ithalas.com
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
http://www.flickr.com/photos/luc/
Personalised Learning?
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Personalisation of learning means ensuring that individual differences are
acknowledged
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Personal Learning Environments
PersonalLearning Environment
Personal Learning Network
PersonalWeb Tools
Source: http://steve-wheeler.blogspot.com/2010/07/anatomy-of-ple.html
PLEs are not only personal web tools and personal learning networks. PLEs
are much wider than this, taking in experiences and realia, as well as learning through TV, music, paper based materials, radio &
more formal contexts.
Learning content is not as important now as where (or who) to connect to, to
find it.
PWTs are any web tools, (usually Web 2.0) chosen
by learners to support their lifelong learning.
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Source: Maria Webster - http://www.ntdaily.com/
Intuitive handheld devices
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Natural gesture interface
Connection to my learning network
Online, En massehttp://steve-wheeler.blogspot.com
Communication
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Collaboration
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
‘The wisdom of crowds’
Common interests and purpose
http://www.eastone.co.uk/
The ‘Architecture of Participation’
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
From ‘sticky’ to participative
Web 2.0
http://www.uksmallbusinesswebsites.co.uk
Social Media gives everyone a voice in the community St
eve
Whe
eler
, Uni
vers
ity o
f Ply
mou
th, 2
011
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
http://www.lifehack.org
Blogging on the move to capture images, sounds, experiences
Moblogging
Microblogging
http://www.xenstudio.co.uk
Retweeting is not repetition. It is amplification.
- Steve Wheeler
Microblogging has potential for the future of learning -
http://www.flickr.com/photos/161/
- if we see it as a newcommunication Channel
- Ebner et al
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Media Sharing
http://flickr.com/photos/22409393@N03/4348233990/
Video, audio and images ...
... all contribute to the richness of the narrative.
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
http://media1.break.com/
Collaborative tools
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Human activities are mediated by
culturally established instruments such as tools and language.
Vygotsky, L. S. (1978) Mind in Society: The development of higher
psychological processes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
http://www.phillwebb.net
Social Learning
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
We can use computers to extend
the capabilities of our own minds. They
can become the repositories of our
knowledge.http://www.phillwebb.net
Social Learning
Computers as mind tools
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Source: George Siemens www.connectivism.ca/http://www.sciencedaily.com
Connectivism
We live in a techno-social world
Learning occurs inside and outside of people – we store our knowledge in
computers and in other people – George Siemens
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
0
Since we cannot experience everything, other people’s experiences, and hence other people,
become the surrogate for knowledge.
http://bradley.chattablogs.com
‘I store my knowledge in my friends’ is an axiom for collecting knowledge through collecting people. - Karen Stephenson
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
0
http:
//so
cial
ente
rpris
eam
bass
ador
s.or
g.uk
Learning to learn
Critical thinking
Collaboration
Creativity
Reflection
Evaluation
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Web 1.0: Anything can link to anything
Source: Sabin-Corneliu Buraga www.localseoguide.com
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Web 3.0Semantic Web
Web 1.0The Web
Web x.0Meta Web
Web 2.0Social Web
Degree of Social Connectivity
Deg
ree
of In
form
ation
Con
necti
vity
Connects information Connects people
Connects knowledge Connects intelligence
The eXtended Web
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
We are already seeing early evidence of the Smart eXtended Web
http://chemistscorner.com
Intelligent Filtering Recommender systems
Stev
e W
heel
er, U
nive
rsity
of P
lym
outh
, 201
1
Malinka Ivanova, Technical University – Sofia, Bulgaria
The 5th International Scientific Conference eLSE - eLearning and Software for Education, BUCHAREST, April 09-10, 2009
From Personal Learning Environment Building to Professional Learning Network FormingFrom Personal Learning Environment Building to Professional Learning Network Forming
Social network sites can be defined as web-based services that allow individuals to:(1) construct a public or semi-public profile within a bounded system (2) articulate a list of other users with whom they share a connection (3) view and traverse their list of connections and those made by others
within the system.
Danah Boyd, School of Information, University of California-Berkeley Nicole Ellison, Department of Telecommunication, Information Studies, and Media, Michigan State University
Social-oriented applications and professional networks - new opportunities for learners and educators
Social Networks
Professional network generally refers to a professional network service, a virtual community that it is focused on professional interactions instead of social interactions.
Wikipedia
Social-oriented applications and professional networks - new opportunities for learners and educators
Professional Networks
A learning network is a group of personswho create, share, support and studylearning resources (“units of learning”)in a specific knowledge domain.
Rob Koper, Open University of the Netherlands
Social-oriented applications and professional networks - new opportunities for learners and educators
Special-formed learning networks for life-long learners
Social-oriented applications and professional networks - new opportunities for learners and educators
Special-formed learning networks for life-long learners
Because of their possibilities for:
data, information and “knowledge fusion” enhancing accessibility, productivity and innovative solutions research tools providing forming groups of personal and professional interests
Social-oriented applications and professional networks - new opportunities for learners and educators
To be successful at knowledge creation, analysis and dissemination, learners need from network inter-personal and inter-group interactions
PLEs are systems that help learners take control of and manage their own learning. This includes providing support for learners to set their own learning goals, manage their learning; managing both content and process; communicate with others in the process of learning and thereby achieve learning goals.
Wikipedia
Building PLE on start pages
Personal Learning Environment
Web 2.0 applications called “start pages” are designed to provide a personalized place on the internet where users can mashup data, information and knowledge available anywhere, anytime, including mobile login.
Wikipedia
Building PLE on start pages
Start pages
Forming the learning network of the course Internet Technologies is to:(1) provide sustainable value to students, not only during the
course, but also after its finishing(2) stimulate them to contribute their knowledge, insights
and experiences on a continuous basis
Forming Learning Network for Competence Development
LMS, Social network, Start page
• Of relationship and connections among peers and knowledge
• Of own opportunity for value-created involvement
IAware
•In engaging in informal knowledge exchange
•In revising/extending competence development objectives
IIInterested
•In individual or collaborative learning
•In social and knowledge network activities
•In pro-actively contributing own insights and expertise
IIITrying
engaging
- To subject mater- To peers and educators- To another professionals
IVActively
involved and connected
Personal competence development objectives
Competence development lifecycle in a learning network (according Rogers)
More of the students who are deeply involved in the subject matter of the course and think in perspective are interested in:
more professional information contact to experts and specialists they joint to groups with special interests, professional networks they receive professional network services they can discuss interests stay informed share knowledge
Professional Network Organizing
• Add tools/services• Connect to data,
information, knowledge• Create artifacts
Personal Learning Environment
• Connect to peers, educators, family and friends
• Share thoughts, ideas, resources, artifacts
Personal Learning Network • Connect to professionals
and experts via professional organizations and networks
• Collaborate• Contribute
Professional Learning Network
Professional Network Organizing
LMS, Social network, Start page
Development of Professional Learning Network
Personal Learning Environment
Personal Learning Network
Professional Learning Network
Receive professional network services
Self-arrangement of network services
Professional Network Organizing
PLE as part of Personal Learning Network and Professional Learning Network
Some advanced students during the PLE building self-orient and arrange content, knowledge and contacts in two different networks: personal and professional
The transition from PLE to PfLN passes through a middle step of PLN set up
This process is dynamic and continuously adapted to the present students’ interests
In some cases the boarders between PLN and PfLN are blurred, because of coincidence of personal and professional interests
PLE can be presented as a core for networks expanding
The PLE building supports students in socialization and network processes set up
Professional Network Organizing
Professional (Personal) Learning Networks
Sherry Crofut
http://conference2009.tie2.wikispaces.net/Professional+(Personal)+Learning+Networks
Reasons to use a social bookmarking network:•Saved bookmarks will not be deleted when computers are re-imaged•You can access your bookmarks from any computer with the Internet from anywhere•You can form a network and share bookmarks with friends and colleagues
Online Learning
• Has been around since 1995 or so
• Really grew with the World Wide Web
• Has advanced tremendously
Many positive developments in the last few years worth sharing…
Open Source Applications
• Learning Management Systems such as Moodle, Sakai, Bodington, ATutor
• Development and CommunityTools such as LAMS, Connexions, ELGG, Drupal, WordPress
• Supporting Software such as Firefox, Thunderbird, OpenOffice, Audacity
Open Educational Resources
• MIT’s OpenCourseWare projectand the OpenCourseWare Consortium
• Open University’s Open Courses
• OER initiatives Hewlett, Wellcome, OECD, UNESCO
• Creative Commons and CC materials in Flickr, Yahoo, Google, Wikipedia, Wikiversity, etc.
New Environments
• Multimedia explosion podcasts, vodcasts, YouTube, Slideshare, more
• Mobile computingmobile phones, PDAs, etc.
• The 3D web Second Life is a start, we will see more of this
Access…
• One-to-one computing such as the Maine laptop project, now spreading rapidly
• One Laptop per Child has launched –computers in Nigeria
• Wireless access 3G networks, WLAN…
The Concept…
• Learning is centered around the interests of the learner
• This learning is immersive – learning by doing
• The computer connects the student to the rest of the world
Social Networking in eLearning
What you will learn today:Understand how social networking is
impacting societySee examples of common social
networking applicationsHave an opportunity to try social
networking applicationsSee resources and data regarding how
social networking can be used within eLearning
Social Networking in eLearning
• Boyd and Ellison (2007) define social networks as “…web-based services that allow individuals to….
1) construct a public or semi-public profile within a bounded system
2) articulate a list of other users with whom they share a connection
3) view and traverse their list of connections and those made by others within the system. The nature and nomenclature of these connections may vary from site to site.”
Social Networking in eLearning
The first officially recognized social network was sixdegrees.com that launched in 1997 and officially shut down in 2000. According to the Wharton School of Business, as of October 2008 social networks impacted more than 230 million people worldwide.
Social Networking in eLearning
• Social networks now represent the fastest growing Internet segment – 3x the rate of overall Internet growth. (2009)
• Social networking sites are growing at the rate of 47% annually, reaching 45% of total web users. (2006)
• Social networking and blogging are now the 4th most popular online activities, according to Nielsen’s recently released Global Faces and Networked Places report. (2009)
Social Networking Factoids (Nielson Netratings)
Social Networking in eLearning
• 67% of the global online population now visit a social network site, and this sector accounts for 10% of all Internet time. (Germany, Switzerland, Great Britain, and Italy are the fastest growing segments.)
• Social networks and blogs are now the 4th most popular online category – ahead of personal Email
• Member sites now account for 1 in every 11 minutes online
Social Networking Factoids (Nielson Netratings)
Social Networking in eLearning
Orkut.com in Brazil (operated by Google) has the largest domestic online reach (70%) of any social network anywhere in the world, whereas Facebook has the highest average time per visitor among the 75 most popular brands online worldwide. However, the amount of time spent on Facebook.com increased by more than 566% in only one year. (Nielsen, 2009)
Social Networking Factoids (Nielson Netratings)
Social Networking in eLearning
According to the web site Social Media Defined (http://www.socialmediadefined.com), Twitter is a microblogging
application that is more or less a combination of instant messaging and blogging.
Social Networking in eLearning
• Back-channel chat where participants at conferences provide bursts of feedback regarding conference proceedings to both other conference participants, and to people who cannot attend the conference (Hargadon, 2009); or preceding a conference via keywords (Parry, 2008). Use Twitter during a webinar to post specific keywords denoted by a hash (#facebook), and then participants search on those keyword to see what other people in the webinar (at other locations) were saying about the topic. (Mullings, 2009)
in Academia
Social Networking in eLearning
• Class chatter that allows students to continue discussion topics outside the classroom (Parry, 2008)
• Follow professionals who are actively engaged in particular topics or events. For example, students can follow any number of correspondents at MSNBC, CNN, and other news outlets
• Writing assignments where students build on each other’s tweets to generate a story, poem, or haiku. (Parry, 2008)
• Collaboration with students from other countries regarding specific topics of political or historical significance
in Academia
Social Networking in eLearning
Social Networking in eLearning
• Use Twitter to “track” a word. This will subscribe you to any post that contains said word. So, for example, a student may be interested in how a particular word is used. They can track the word and see the varied phrases in which people use it. Or, they can track an event, a proper name, or a movie title. (Send the message “track ______” to Twitter) (Parry, 2008)
• Storytelling - George Mayo, an eighth grade English teacher, recently used Twitter as a tool to collaboratively write a story with his students. Mayo invited his students and students around the world via his Many Voices Twitter account to add to an ongoing story with individual "tweets." After six weeks and the help of more than 100 students and six different countries, the story was finished. (Parry, 2008)
in Academia
Use twitterfall.com• Type in a keyword and watch the results in real time
Use twittervision.com• Twittervision and Twittervision 3D allow you to GeoTag users and their posts to know where certain topics are being discussed
in Academia
Social Networking in eLearning
http://twittervision.com/maps/show_3d
Social Networking in eLearning
Use Freshlogic Atlas• Type in a keyword and watch the results in real time
in AcademiaUse historicaltweets• Learn what it may have been like for historical figures to tweet
Use tweetdeck• Create “groups” of students
Social Networking in eLearning
in AcademiaUse YouTube or twiddeo• Link to video files from Twitter
Social Networking in eLearning
Facebook is a social networking website that was originally designed for college students, but is now open to anyone 13 years of age or older. Facebook users can create and customize their own profiles with photos, videos, and information about themselves. Friends can browse the profiles of other friends and write messages on their pages. (TechTerms.com)
Social Networking in eLearning
in Academia
Use academia.edu• A facebook-like application
Use Facebook Groups• Create a class-centric group
Social Networking in eLearning
Social Networking in eLearning
in Academia
Research• Analysis of how social networks are formed
Academics• Journalism
http://snipr.com/j5di5
http://snipr.com/j5d2m
Academic Networking• Create a networkedblog
in Academia
Social Networking in eLearning
•http://www.facebook.com/pages/wwwdonquijoteorg/27485153678?ref=ts/
•http://www.inigral.com/products/schools.htm
•http://www.inigral.com/products/standardissimo.php
•http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=18977111129
•http://phoenix.facebook.com/group.php?gid=12471635541
•http://usask.facebook.com/group.php?gid=12256460391
http://www.networkedblogs.com
A blog (an abridgment of the term ‘web log’) is a website, usually maintained by an individual, with regular entries of commentary, descriptions of events, or other material such as graphics or video. Entries are commonly displayed in reverse chronological order. "Blog" can also be used as a verb, meaning to maintain or add content to a blog.
Co-Winner, Word-of-the-Year: 2004
Social Networking in eLearning
in Academia
Social Networking in eLearning
Wordpress.com (no fee; hosted option)Wordpress.org (free software; non-hosted)
Variety of fee-based hosts that support WordpressHosticanLaughing SquidBluehost
Mu.wordpress.org (Fee-based; multi-user; multi-host)
From http://onlinedegreetalk.org/blogs/• The instructor posts various announcements, information,
assignments, and abbreviated lessons for student reference• More aptly called an interactive medium of study, students get
an opportunity to express their opinions about a particular topic or subject posted for discussion over the net
• Articles on various topics provide extensive knowledge on the subject. Students, in turn, post their comments on these articles
• Used as a writing portfolio, blogs are found to be very helpful in expressing thoughts by students about their subject of study
Social Networking in eLearning
in Academia
• Students find it very useful to post comments, throw questions to their instructor about the course and the subjects in particular and talk to fellow students about course progress and related benefits
• Activities and presentations pertaining to a particular subject can be discussed over the net by way of blog posts
• Students get to know each other, by not just chatting, but instead by responding to the posts offered by various students
• As a means of evaluation, assignments are cross verified and the qualities of presentations are evaluated by fellow students positively by way of blog posts and related responses
Social Networking in eLearning
in Academia
http://snipr.com/j5rqk
Social Networking in eLearning
in Academia
Scholarly CitationsWordpress Plugins (5,000+)
•Twitter Tools•Wordbook•Daiko’s Video Widget•Flickr plugin
A wiki is a website that uses wiki software, allowing the easy creation and editing of any number of interlinked
Web pages, using a simplified markup language. Wikis are often used to create collaborative websites
and to power community websites (Wikipedia)
Social Networking in eLearning
Where are we now?http://photos.jeremybrooks.net/?p=65
Stev
e W
heel
er, P
lym
outh
Uni
vers
ity, 2
012