work-based learning - education's next horizon...work-based learning provides two primary...
TRANSCRIPT
WORK-BASEDLEARNING
A BRIEF GUIDE FOR LOUISIANA EMPLOYERS
JUNE 2018
2
INTRODUCTION
This guide provides an overview of work-based
learning (WBL), one of the proven strategies for
helping students and out-of-school youth to acquire
the skills and knowledge they need to be successful
in the workplace. The guide is designed specifically
for Louisiana employers -- to encourage and assist
their adoption and expansion of work-based expe-
riences as an effective workforce building strategy.
The guide defines the various types of work-based
learning practices, provides a general framework
of how many schools, businesses, and community
partners are building comprehensive work-based
learning programs, and discusses various ways in
which WBL practices are taking place in Louisiana.
Lastly, the brief suggests steps that employers can
take to initiate or expand work-based learning in
their communities.
LOUISIANA’S MIDDLE SKILLS CHALLENGEMiddle-skill jobs, which require education beyond
high school but not a four-year degree, currently
account for 57 percent of Louisiana’s labor market,
but only 46 percent of the state’s workers are
trained to the middle-skill level. Between 2014 and
2024, 54 percent of job openings in Louisiana will be
middle-skill.1 According to the Georgetown Uni-
versity Center on Education and the Workforce, by
2020, 55.6 percent of all job openings in Louisiana
will require some form of postsecondary education.2
The “skills gap” makes it increasingly difficult for
businesses to find qualified workers and remain
economically competitive. This is especially true for
high-demand occupational groups such as informa-
tion technology and health services. Skilled craft
occupations continue to experience acute labor
shortages, partly as a result of the lack of emphasis
on middle skills career education in past years
and partly due to the ongoing boom in industrial
construction, particularly along the 1-10/I-12
corridor.
According to the Education Commission of the
States, “business leaders in Louisiana cannot
find the science, technology, engineering and
mathematics (STEM) talent they need to stay
competitive.” In Louisiana, between 2017 and
2027, STEM jobs are projected to grow by 10% as
compared to the 5% growth of non-STEM jobs.3
WORK-BASED LEARNING (WBL)
One of the more effective strategies for helping
in-school students and out-of-school Opportunity
Youth to better prepare for careers and post-sec-
ondary opportunities is work-based learning.
WBL programs are designed to provide real-life
experiences and opportunities for youth and young
adults to achieve employment-related competencies
in the workplace. WBL could include paid or unpaid
internships, mentorships, on-the-job training pro-
grams, apprenticeships, micro-industry engagement,
3
and virtual externships. Work-based learning could
also be career awareness activities such as career
fairs, company tours, job shadowing, and company
classroom visits.
• Employer-Based Internships, paid or unpaid, take
place while the youth or young adult is working
directly with an employer and receiving classroom
instruction, mentor guidance, or training in order
to gain skills that would lead to certification or
permanent employment.
• Apprenticeships provide paid, relevant workplace
experiences and opportunities to develop skills
that employers value. By engaging students in
extensive training and actual work experience,
apprenticeships provide affordable paths to good
jobs and, ultimately, careers. According to the
Urban Institute, more than 80 percent of U.S. com-
panies that utilize registered apprenticeship say
it is an effective strategy for helping them meet
their demand for skilled labor, and 94 percent of
employers would recommend registered appren-
ticeship as a strategy to other employers.4
In Louisiana, any apprenticeship sponsor who pays
the wages of an apprentice that is registered with
the Louisiana Workforce Commission Apprentice-
ship Division may receive a tax credit equal to $1/
hour worked per calendar year, with a maximum
allowable amount for each apprentice of $1,000
/year. Guidelines for the tax credit program are
available at: http://www.laworks.net/Downloads/App/RegisteredApprenticeshipTaxCreditGuide.pdf.
• Micro-Industry Engagement involves a series
of structured exercises that enable students to
master increasingly sophisticated workplace skills
while learning about the true universe of career
opportunities available to them. These exercises
enable students to virtually engage with work-
place experts in every industry sector that they
want to explore.
• Virtual Externships offer educators (both career
and technical education (CTE) and academ-
ic-subjects) a unique professional development
opportunity connecting the classroom to the
workplace. Externships enable teachers and coun-
selors to spend time in one or more work sites.
These site-based experiences enable educators
to learn through direct experience about trends,
skill requirements and opportunities in industries,
enriching their teaching and bringing greater
relevance to student learning. Externships range
from a day of job shadowing to longer externships
that are usually project-based and can last as
long as a full summer. Teacher externships offer a
professional development experience that is often
transformative for educators and their students.
• Virtual Mentoring refers to any mentoring activity
that does not take place face-to-face. With today’s
technology there is a suite of communication tools
open to this style of mentoring, including Skype,
telephone, email and messaging.
BENEFITS OF WORK-BASED LEARNING
Work-based learning programs provide benefits to
businesses and to students or young adult workers:
Benefits to Employers
• Provide an opportunity to nurture student inter-
est in jobs and careers with their company.
• Help future workers understand what is needed to
grow and be successful in their company.
• Reduced training costs and turnover.
• Improved employee retention and morale.
Benefits to Students
Work-based learning provides two primary benefits
for students: (1) connects classroom learning to
the skills (including “soft skills”) needed for success
in the workplace, and (2) increases awareness of
career options, particularly for jobs that are in high
demand.
4
According to Jobs for the Future, work-based
learning offers the following additional benefits to
students:5
• Help students put into practice their classroom
learning, while crystallizing their education and
career goals and improving their immediate and
longer-term employment prospects.
• Foster academic success for individuals—includ-
ing low-skilled workers and opportunity youth,
who may have low levels of formal education,
limited English proficiency, negative experiences
with school, or long gaps in direct educational
experiences.
• Can potentially provide a critical source of income
that is linked to a student’s program of study and
supports progress toward career goals.
WORK-BASED LEARNING FRAMEWORK
Many schools, businesses, and community partners
across the country are taking a comprehensive
approach to building work-based learning programs.
The non-profit group, Change the Equation,
suggests the framework below as components for
an effective, comprehensive work-based learning
program.6 The extent to which these components
will exist or be adopted as policies can and will vary
depending upon the location. They are merely pre-
sented here as a model of what components might
be included in a comprehensive WBL program.
Alignment of Classroom and Workplace Learning
• Help meet industry demands for a more skilled
workforce by providing opportunities for students
to receive training, learn skills, and gain experience
in all aspects of an industry.
• Map academic content to authentic workplace
tasks and integrate workplace tasks and classroom
instruction.
• Allow students to reflect on their learning process
and experience.
• Require training for instructors on how to
integrate WBL experiences into curriculum and
instruction.
Application of Academic, Technical, and Employability Skills
• Rigorous academic and employability skill
requirements.
• In-depth and hands on work experiences (either
on site or through simulated/virtual methods),
with activities ranging from career awareness and
exploration to career preparation and training.
Support from a Classroom or from Workplace Mentors
• Promote student engagement through men-
torship from supervisors, instructors, and WBL
coordinators.
• Allow students to develop relationships with
industry and community professionals.
• Monitor and evaluate progress.
• Provide training for mentors on providing stu-
dents with industry-specific support, career and
education guidance, personal and professional
growth, and a caring connection.
JUMP START
Louisiana’s Jump Start initiative, designed to help
high school students earn an industry-based certi-
fication in high-demand industry sectors, offers a
number of opportunities for employers to engage in
work-based learning activities.7
Program Components
• Developed by the Baton Rouge Area Chamber
of Commerce, the Micro-Enterprise Credential incorporates mentor engagement (i.e. micro-in-
dustry engagement) as a required component.
• Louisiana has launched the concept of Jump Start Summers, where students: (a) earn indus-
try-based credentials, (b) earn academic credits,
5
(c) participate in WBL, and (d) earn a summer
wage.
• Virtual Workplace Experience (VWE) II Course
has embedded in its curriculum a series of exer-
cises (mentor engagement, team problem-solving,
workplace communication skills) in each of
Louisiana’s high-demand industry sectors. This
WBL opportunity enables employers to support
student career development, which is especially
relevant for students who don’t have access to
workplace-based leaning. It also saves valuable
employer time by enabling business personnel to
spend time mentoring students without any travel
time, and with minimal disruption to an employee’s
work day.
• The Louisiana Council for Economic Education
(LCEE) is enlisting employers to serve as virtual mentors, with a special focus on recruiting individ-
uals dedicated to serving students with disabilities.
• Preventive Associates, a consulting firm, is leading
the effort to train teachers and industry stake-
holders in using Nepris, a web-based system used
to coordinate structured micro-industry engage-
ment interactions between students, teachers, and
industry experts.
• Working with workforce development boards
(WDBs) across the state, Education Subcommit-tees of the boards have been created to establish
Jump Start implementation goals for districts and
charter schools.
• The Louisiana Department of Education and LCEE
are working with Bossier Parish to create a local
initiative to increase the number of hands-on WBL opportunities for students with disabili-ties, including more counseling and support.
USE OF INTERMEDIARIES
Many successful work-based learning programs
are operated by an intermediary, an entity that
functions as the employer of record – hiring the
youth and assuming all responsibility for insurance
and workers’ compensation. The intermediary also
brings all key stakeholders together to plan the
startup and operation of the WBL program. Several
intermediary models are producing strong results:
YouthForce NOLA is an education, business, and civic
collaborative that prepares New Orleans public
school students for successful pursuit of high-wage,
high-demand career pathways. The YouthForce
NOLA Internship program (YFI) provides a paid
internship experience and exposure to the soft
skills needed for success in high school, college, and
the world of work. YFI is open to rising seniors at
YouthForce NOLA partner schools, all of which are
open enrollment Orleans Parish public high schools.
YFI focuses on career pathways in three high-wage,
high-demand regional industry clusters:
6
• Bio & health sciences (including bio-innovation
and medical professions)
• Digital media/IT (including programming and
development, networking, and visual design)
• Skilled crafts (including architecture, construction,
water management, and engineering)
Students participate in 60 hours of paid training,
followed by their 90 hour placement with an em-
ployer in targeted industries.
Manufacturing Careers Internship Program (MCIP)
is operated by Business and Career Services, Inc.
in Northeast Illinois. At MCIP, youth participate in
a four-week boot camp session, where they learn
soft skills and job preparation training and receive
OSHA-10 and forklift credentials. After boot camp,
participants enter and eight-week paid internship
program with an employer.8 A video of the MCIP
program can be seen at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ue6NBCeNZxw.
OPPORTUNITY YOUTH
In Louisiana, an estimated 19.8 percent of 16-24
year olds are Opportunity Youth, young adults who
are neither connected to school nor work. This com-
pares to 13.8 percent in the nation. A recent study
by the Cowen Institute noted that Opportunity
Youth cost Louisiana taxpayers $1.7 billion each
year in the form of increased government spending
on crime, healthcare, and welfare.9 In the case of
New Orleans, which had an estimated 6,820 Op-
portunity Youth in 2014, a majority of these youth
had at least a high school credential, which would
suggest that disconnection for many of them could
be occurring after graduation. Cowen suggests that
ensuring students leave high school with career
plans and links to additional education and training
should be a priority.10
Opportunity Youth are a potential source of skilled
workers. Work-based learning experiences in the
form of paid internships, on-the-job training, and
apprenticeships help to reconnect Opportunity
Youth with school and work.
Title I of the Workforce Innovation and Op-
portunity Act (WIOA) requires that workforce
development boards spend at least 20 percent
of youth funds to support “work experiences” for
out-of-school youth 16-24 years old.11
STEPS TO EMPLOYER ENGAGEMENT
Work-based learning programs rely on partnerships
between businesses, community-based organiza-
tions, local workforce development boards, and
secondary / postsecondary schools.12 Whether the
WBL program is provided by an intermediary, vir-
tually, or directly by an employer, the success of the
program requires employer engagement. Employers
wanting to start or participate in a work-based
learning program can take the following steps:
• Contact the Career and Technical Education (CTE)
Supervisor at your local school district to explore
engagement with Work-Based Learning part-
nerships with schools in your area. For In-Person
Mentoring and/or to help facilitate specific Work
Based Learning partnerships with schools, contact
Laura Smith at LCEE: [email protected], (225)
241-1524.
• Become part of the Regional Communities of
Practice through the Career and Technical Edu-
cation (CTE) Leadership Academy https://www.lacteleaders.com.
• Engage directly with Transition students and/or
contribute resource videos, known as 5 Minute
7
Films, for use in Transition classrooms. 5 Minute
Films are available at www.Nepris.com, made
possible through LCEE. Interested parties should
contact Laura Smith at [email protected], (225)
241-1524.
• Sign up as an Industry Professional at Louisiana Nepris Mentors (https://www.nepris.com/go/la)
and begin engaging with high school students to
share information about preferential skills for
job-seekers, employment opportunities/outlook
and specific industry sector needs.
• Serve on a local Workforce Development Board
(WDB) in your area. Contact your local chief
elected official or the WDB Development Coor-
dinator, Deidra Jackson, Opus Capitol Strategies,
[email protected], (832) 545-5506, to express
your interest in serving.
• For out-of-school Opportunity Youth, contact the
Workforce Development Board or boards in your
area to explore opportunities for internships or
apprenticeships. A list of local board contacts can
be obtained at: https://www.laworks.net/Downloads/PR/Local_Workforce_Contacts.pdf.
ADDITIONAL HELPFUL RESOURCES
All Things Jump Start, the official portal of the
Louisiana Department of Education for the Jump
Start Program. https://www.louisianabelieves.com/courses/all-things-jump-start.
A detailed, step-by-step guidebook for starting,
joining, or operating a Jump Start Regional Team is
available at: https://www.louisianabelieves.com/docs/default-source/jumpstart/jump-start-regional-team-guidebook.pdf?sfvrsn=7.
A list of Registered Apprenticeship Programs
and contact information for each program can be
obtained at: http://www.laworks.net/apprenticeship/
app_info.asp. To obtain information about the steps
involved in developing a registered apprenticeship
program in Louisiana, submit a formal request to
YouthForce Nola, an education, business, and civic
collaborative that prepares New Orleans public
school students for successful pursuit of high-wage,
high-demand career pathways. https://youthforceno-la.org/
GNO, Inc. Headed2, and online career assessment
and planning tool for New Orleans-area students.
https://gno.headed2.com/index
Nepris, an online tool that matches employee skills
to classroom and curriculum needs to create mean-
ingful virtual interactions with the next generation
of workers, anywhere, anytime.
https://www.nepris.com/
Local Workforce Development Board Contacts:
https://www.laworks.net/Downloads/PR/Local_Work-force_Contacts.pdf
National Skills Coalition, Work-Based Learning Policy Toolkit https://m.nationalskillscoalition.org/resources/publica-tions/file/NSC-WBL_PolicyToolkit.pdf
National Skill Coalition, Promising Practices in Work-Based Learning https://www.nationalskillscoalition.org/resources/publi-cations/file/10-4-NSC-YouthWorkBasedLearning _v4.pdf
Jobs for the Future, Making Work-Based Learning Work https://www.jff.org/resources/making-work-based- learning-work/
1 National Skills Coalition, Louisiana’s Forgotten Middle.2 Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce. “Recovery: Job Growth and Educational Requirements through 2010.”3 Education Commission of the States, http://vitalsigns.ecs.org/.4 Robert Lerman, Lauren Eyster and Kate Chambers, The Benefits and Challenges of Registered Apprenticeship: the Sponsors’ Perspective (2009) http://www.
urban.org/sites/default/files/alfresco/publication-pdfs/411907-The-Benefits-and-Challenges-of-Registered-Apprenticeship-The-Sponsors-Perspective.PDF.5 Jobs for the Future, http://www.jff.org/sites/default/files/publications/materials/WBL%20Principles%20Paper%20062416.pdf.6 Change the Equation, “Work-Based Learning, An Employer’s Guide,” https://cte.ed.gov/wbltoolkit/engaging.html.7 Louisiana Department of Education. 8 National Skills Coalition, “Promising Practices in Work-Based Learning for Youth.”9 The Cowen Institute, http://www.speno2014.com/oydataguide/.10 Ibid.11 National Skills Coalition, Work-Based Learning Policy, 50 State Scan.12 National Skills Coalition, “Promising Practices in Work-Based Learning for Youth.”
Funding for Work-Based Learning: A Brief Guide for Louisiana Employers was provided by:
EDUCATION’S NEXT HORIZON
412 N. Fourth Street, Suite 104A | Baton Rouge, LA 70802
225.383.3844 | www.ednexthorizon.org
John Warner Smith, CEO | [email protected]
Education’s Next Horizon is a convener, advocate and honest broker – a statewide nonprofit organization dedicated to framing the debate on top education issues and connecting Louisiana’s education, government and business leadership as a
force supporting school improvement. Since its inception in 2007, the organization has been a leading policy advocate for high-quality early childhood education,
increasing high school graduation rates, and better preparing students for careers and post-secondary education.