global digital fundraising
TRANSCRIPT
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 1/29
Digital fundraising - a world
of opportunity
April 2014
Amina Ali, Andrea de Ruiter, Michele Madden and Secil
Muderrisoglu, in collaboration with the Resource Alliance
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 2/29
ContentsContents ....................................................................….2 Foreword ....................................................................... 3 Introduction .................................................................. 4
The digital environment in a changing world……………………………………………….4 Success factors for digital fundraising around the globe 5
Factor 1: Trust in non-profits………………………………………………………………....…5
Factor 2: Giving culture among the population……………………………………..…..10
Factor 3: Access to digital technology……………………………………………………….14 Pulling it all together: summary and conclusions ..…...20 What should you do?.....................................................22
Further information…………………………………………………………………………….…..24 Appendices……………………………………………………….25
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 3/29
Foreword
High levels of public trust and confidence are at the heart of an effective civil
society. Therefore it is perhaps not surprising that this report identifies trust as one
of the most important factors in successful digital fundraising.
The way in which non-profits raise and spend money is the most important factor
relating to trust. Here in the UK, for example, ensuring that a reasonable proportion
of donations make it to the end cause was cited by the public as the top factor
influencing levels of trust, according to recent data from nfpSynergy. Meanwhile, as
this report identifies, there is a relationship between high levels of corruption and a
poor culture of giving. Russia provides an apt example of this. Consequently, a
willingness to explain how an organisation operates and why it spends money on
the things it does is crucial to enhancing and maintaining confidence in the work of
our sector.
Digital tools and channels provide an effective means by which to demonstrate
openness and transparency, as well as to ask for donations. Websites, social media,
SMS and others allow non-profits to demonstrate how they are making a positive
difference to the cause they serve. These platforms can also be used to help
address many of the issues identified in this report, including concerns of corruption
and the need to build a culture of giving.
Technology is so fast moving that it can be hard to keep up. From MySpace to
Facebook to WhatsApp, to smart phones and responsive web design, a week
doesn’t seem to pass without another new tool being announced or trend taking
favour. Here at the Resource Alliance we have always had a keen interest in how
digital fundraising is developing. Our International Fundraising Congress is often the
first place to explore the potential of new techniques, while our free Fundraising
Online conference is renowned worldwide for being the best digital fundraising
event of its kind – offering participants access to strategic and tactical advice,
support and case studies that will help them ensure digital is fully integrated into
their communications. As this report identifies, shared learning of this nature is an
effective way to ensure non-profits arm themselves with the knowledge and skills
they need to capitalise on opportunities as they arise.
This report provides rich material to reflect on, as well as serving as an excellent
reminder that while new digital tools and techniques are exciting and their potential
should be explored, ultimately non-profits must never lose sight of the key principles
of fundraising. Enhancing public trust and confidence should be at the heart of
everything they say and do, no matter what communications channel is being used.
Neelam Makhijani, chief executive of the Resource Alliance
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 4/29
Introduction
The digital environment in a changing worldTechnology has changed the world we live in. Global communication has created
possibilities and connections that did not exist before. Undoubtedly this has broughtproblems with it nor is it distributed evenly across the globe. However, it has opened
up new opportunities for non-profits everywhere to engage with their communities
and key audiences, whatever their size and purpose. From our work with non-profits
in the UK we know that digital fundraising is an area for growth. But what does this
mean for non-profits operating in very different environments? What are non-profits
doing in very diverse cultures and developmental stages? Is this an area they should
be investing in? Our aim with this report is to explore the different contexts and try
and tease out what different elements, stages of development and culture mean for
digital fundraising in countries across the globe. With this in mind we set out three
success factors for digital fundraising: trust, culture and access to technology.
This report is by no means a definitive picture of digital fundraising in these regions.
Rather, we have used existing sources of information along with data from our
interviews to explore the area. Most importantly, we wanted to discover whether
digital fundraising is an area of development that non-profits should invest their
valuable resources in - and to a certain extent the results surprised us. A variety of
variables affecting digital fundraising were explored and of course these have
different weights and differ in how easy they are to tackle. Obviously a small non-
profit in any country cannot on its own tackle the endemic corruption that may exist
in the sphere it operates in, or change the banking system so that people trust itmore.
We found that in emerging economies digital fundraising is still in its infancy. The
reasons for this are complex and differ across the countries and regions that we
examined. During the data collection and analysis we considered a range of
variables that might be influencing the development of digital fundraising. These
included, but were not limited to: the percentage of the population living below the
poverty line, school life expectancy, literacy rates, GDP and perceived corruption
levels. We were able to identify three key success factors that influence the
development of digital fundraising in the countries we examined. These were:
Trust – what level of trust exists towards public institutions and non-profits?
Culture of giving – how do the public give and volunteer?
Technology – how widespread is internet and mobile phone use?
We do not pretend that this report represents an empirical analysis of the weight of
the various elements as the three we focus on are to a degree a subjective choice.
This report unpacks our findings in these key areas in further detail and explores
what the implications might be for non-profits. Further research will need to beundertaken as this area develops and we hope this is only the beginning of this
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 5/29
conversation.
Digital fundraising manifests itself in many different ways. For the purposes of this
report we focused on the following forms: mobile (SMS/text and mobile web),
internet and email.
Our research focused on emerging economies within the following regions: Central
Eastern Europe, Latin America, South Asia, Asia Pacific and Africa, with particular
attention paid to emerging economies such as the BRICS nations (Brazil, Russia,
India, China and South Africa).
For this report we conducted desk research using existing sources of data to help
understand the factors that influence digital fundraising development in these
regions. We then carried out telephone interviews with nine non-profit practitioners
and three non-profit digital fundraising experts from countries in the identified
regions plus the UK as a comparator. Raw data from the desk research is availableon request.
Success factors for digitalfundraising around the globe
Factor 1: trust in non-profits
What do we mean by trust in non-profits?We defined public trust in non-profits in relation to trust in the integrity of a non-
profit’s operations and the effective use of donations. We also considered what
factors influence trust. Our research probed how concern over public trust
influences how non-profits approach digital fundraising and the effects of public
confidence in the safety of online financial transactions.
Key issues on trust
The influence of public sector corruption on trust in non-profits
The Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI), carried out by Transparency International,
measures levels of perceived public sector corruption in 177 countries (Chart 1).
Corruption is ranked from 0 (very corrupt) to 100 (very clean).
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 6/29
The UK has a CPI score of 76/100 making the UK the country ranked 14th globally
for least corruption. A survey of the UK general public shows that two thirds (66%)
trust non-profits a great deal or quite a lot, making non-profits the fourth most
trusted institution1. This is not to say that public trust in non-profits in the UK is not
disturbed by revelations of non-profit financial misconduct (e.g. the Cup Trust tax-
avoidance scandal in 2013). However, survey data consistently shows high levels of
trust in non-profits so we can suppose that belief in the integrity of publicinstitutions or in regulation mechanisms persists despite these revelations.
Research shows there are connections between levels of perceived corruption in a
country and concerns non-profits have about being able to fundraise among the
public. India has a CPI score of 36/100 and ranks 94th for least corruption which is
in the bottom half of countries. Interviews with non-profit practitioners in India
reveal apprehension about lack of public trust towards non-profits. One digital
fundraising practitioner discussed a focus on building trust in a new non-profit over
a period of years before attempting to solicit donations from the public – attempting
to fundraise before building a trustworthy reputation having proved disastrous forother organisations.
Give India, an online donation site, was partly set-up to provide a mechanism for
people to be sure that non-profits were credible and trustworthy. However non-
profits still struggle against perceptions that many non-profits are corrupt.
1 nfpSynergy, Charity Awareness Monitor, May 2013
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 7/29
“[Non - profits are often] automatically accused of misusing people’s money…
[and so] even the good people have a bad name and it becomes important
for them to establish their credibility.”
- Expert, India
We can consider a willingness to give to a non-profit one measure of trust in non-
profits. Looking at the other high growth BRICS countries (Brazil, Russia, India,
China and South Africa) we see a relationship (no study was made of causality)
between high corruption levels and the proportion of people giving money to
charity. Russia has a high level of perceived corruption (28/100) and also one of the
lowest reported levels for donating money to non-profits with a score of 6 per cent2.
Brazil and China have less perceived corruption but still score in the bottom half of
the corruption scale 42/100 and 40/100 respectively. Accordingly both have
moderate-low giving levels with 10 per cent of people in China and 23 per cent in
Brazil reporting have donated money to charity.
Trust in the safety of digital financial transactions
In some parts of the world non-profits face the challenge of large proportions of the
general public being wary of making financial transactions online. Our interviews
with non-profit practitioners reveal low take-up of online donation methods and
reports of public concerns about the use of personal information provided during
donations. In Romania a non-profit practitioner linked this to the political context of
being a former communist state.
In other cases, the difficulty of engaging the public in making digital donations is
linked to the lack of infrastructure to support it in some countries. Mobile broadbandpenetration rates in Mexico are very low at 10 per cent and only 38 per cent of
Mexicans report having internet access at all3. The lack of internet access for the
majority of the Mexican population is a strong barrier to engaging in digital
fundraising. Furthermore those that do have some kind of internet access may be
relying on internet cafés which are often regarded as unsafe for financial
transactions.
“[In Mexico many people] don’t have a computer at home so they have to go
to a cafe… where they use the internet. They don’t want their debit card or
personal information on public computers.”
- Practitioner, Mexico
Internet commerce is also not widespread among the general public, only 8 per cent
of Mexican adults reporting having bought a product online in the last 12 months
(Chart 2).
2
CAF, World Giving Index 20133 ITU World Telecommunication/ICT Indicators Database, http://www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Statistics/Pages/stat/default.aspx
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 8/29
This corresponds with insight from a depth interview in Mexico which raised the
issue of the general public lacking experience of carrying out financial transactions
online and that this was an activity usually limited to the wealthy
“Rich people or middle class people, they purchase online all the time, not
only from Mexico they buy from all over the world. They don’t care t hey do
it. The poor people, they don’t do it, they don’t know how to do it.” - Practitioner, Mexico
Levels of trust and their implications for digital
fundraisingNon-profits operating in countries with high corruption levels face a challenge in
changing public perception that non-profits may be wasteful or spend donations
fraudulently. Non-profits are, quite rightly, highly concerned about their reputation,
but this may lead to a reluctance to engage in the necessary fundraising among thepublic in early years, either digitally or by traditional methods.
New developments for combatting corruption or public resistance against corruption
continue to emerge; a non-profit in India created the “zero-rupee” note made to
resemble a 50 rupee note. These valueless zero-rupee notes are given by the public
to officials who request bribes as a way of voicing opposition4. This campaign
developed by a non-profit also helps show the non-profit sector as in opposition to
corruption. Research from the Charity Awareness Monitor show the main factors
4 Global Corruption Barometer 2013
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 9/29
that put the UK public off from giving to non-profits are too little money going to the
cause (62% of the public) and not being clear on how donations are spent (51% of
the public)5. Transparency about how donations will be used and how much of
donations are spent on the cause is core to develop donor trust and support –
perhaps even more so in countries where perceived corruption is high.
In some countries safe and accessible means to make digital donations (e.g. mobile
broadband or fixed internet access) is not prevalent among many people. It is also
apparent that familiarity and ease with making transactions online, for example
experience of buying commercial products online and being comfortable and familiar
with providing credit/debit card details would mean a smoother transition into
donating online to charity.
5 nfpSynergy, Charity Awareness Monitor, July 2013
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 10/29
Factor 2: a giving culture among thepopulation
What do we mean by a giving culture?
A giving culture exists when, on balance, a particular social group holds positive
views and behaviours towards giving time or money to others
The Charities Aid Foundation (CAF)’s annual survey provides insight into giving
behaviour in 135 countries. The World Giving Index is a composite score based on
three measures of giving behaviour: the percentage of people who, in a typical
month, donate money to charity, volunteer their time, and help a stranger. The
percentage that represents each country’s score is the outcome of averaging the
responses from these three measures.
Key findings on giving cultures
In CAF’s 2013 survey, the countries scoring the highest world giving indices were
the US (61%), Canada, Myanmar, New Zealand (all 58%), Ireland and the United
Kingdom (both 57%). With the exception of Myanmar, this top six consists of
developed nations (Chart 3 and 4). However, the list as a whole demonstrates a
systemic shift in global giving – rising engagement in emerging economies.
Out of the BRICS, India and China are particularly representative of this shift. In
India, more people donate money to non-profits in a typical month than in any
other country in the world. Despite the fact that its population is not as large as
China’s (870 million vs. 1,100 million) more than twice as many people donatedmoney in India than in China (244 million vs 113 million). Considering India’s
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 11/29
relatively large middle class, it makes sense that a larger proportion of its population
has the capacity to give. Although China’ overall World Giving Index ranks it near
the bottom (16%, rank 133), the large increase in number of people helping a
stranger (from 283 million in 2011 to 373 million in 2012) suggests attitudes
towards giving are shifting.
One of the key factors underlying these differences in attitudes towards giving is
each country’s respective giving culture. Religion, in particular, seems to beimportant. There are relatively high levels of religiosity in India (80%) and Brazil
(74% Roman Catholic) – the two BRICS where donating to a non-profit is more
common than in others (28% and 23% respectively). Russia, in contrast, has the
lowest levels of religion (15% Russian Orthodox) and also the lowest percentage of
people donating (6%).
Myanmar is the only emerging economy in the World Giving Index top 6. Its position
comes as a result of an exceptionally high incidence of donating money (85%). CAF
has suggested that this high incidence, in turn, may be attributed to the fact that
about 90% of people in Myanmar consider themselves Buddhist.6
Our own research with the UK public consistently shows that a higher proportion of
regular worshipers are donors (nfpSynergy, Charity Awareness Monitor). The link
between religion and donating to a non-profit also became apparent in our in-depth
interviews. For instance a digital fundraiser working in the Arab region said that
giving is promoted primarily by Islam religion, which dictates people to donate a
6
CIA Factbook:https://www.cia.gov/lobrary/publications/the=world=factbook/geos/bm/html
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 12/29
certain percentage of their salaries:
“In Ramadan, people use all their charity money to feed people. […] In the
region here it is very common that you put in front of your house a table
[with food] and you give it to whoever shows up.”
- Practitioner, Arab region
Although religion fosters giving, in this case, the type of giving tends to be tangible
and short-term rather than strategic and long-term:
“To me, it’s like the Chinese saying: Giving people fish rather than the tools
to fish. That’s why I advocate for more strategic giving rather than giving to
satisfy the conscience, the religious obligation.”
- Practitioner, Arab region
Digital fundraising and giving, according to our interviewee, could provide a means
to stimulate people to donate to non-profits that strategically use the money so thatit yields the best results for the cause in the long run.
A digital fundraising practitioner working in Romania said religion was the main
motivation to give and donations are being made mostly to church. The next
challenge, she said, would be to encourage giving to non-profits:
“The big change would have to be the philanthropic behaviour. Basically,
here, people are accounting a donation when they give to a church.”
- Practitioner, Romania
A country or region’s socio-political history is another important factor defining its
giving culture. A digital fundraising expert working in Romania said, “We have
everything related to technology, internet is present everywhere, but we have
cultural problems,” and suggested these may be due to Romania being a former
communist country. It could be that in countries which have historically experienced
a high level of surveillance, there is less public trust in digital platforms.
In countries where digital fundraising is a relatively new phenomenon, the culture of
giving often still has to accept it and use it before it will be a success. A digital
fundraiser practitioner from India said that he is deliberately holding off from digital
funding in the first three years of his charity’s existence. He had seen other
organisation fail because they started fundraising online before they had won
people’s trust. He therefore felt there was a need to build trust and develop a giving
culture first:
“I’ve seen a lot of organisations within one month asking for money. […]
Most of the money goes to buil ding their own personal activities. I don’t like
the idea when the money goes to their own activities. […] Most of the
philanthropies are not doing the proper channels. Before raising money, I
want to be able to show that I can make a difference. I want to show that so
much can be done without funds.” - Practitioner, India
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 13/29
Giving cultures and its implications for digital fundraising
A giving culture is crucial to digital fundraising. Even if a country has all the
necessary infrastructure in place, if cultural barriers to digital giving persist, digital
fundraising is unlikely to be successful.
Knowing about the giving culture in a country or region provides insight into thetype of fundraising that will be most effective. In Mexico, for instance, the giving
culture is inspired by a strong sense of community. Unsurprisingly, therefore, people
are much more likely to help a stranger (38%) than to donate money (22%) or
volunteer (25%):
“Mexico has a great volunteering culture. People are happy to donate
‘human resources’. If you post on Facebook about a community event or help
needed at a school people will turn up to volunteer.”
- Practitioner, Mexico
More generally, each country has its cultural features that digital fundraising can
benefit from (religion, strong sense of community), but similarly culture can limit
digital giving (lack of trust, socio-political history). Sometimes, the perceived
barriers to fundraising don’t present a problem in reality. When speaking about
support needs in emerging economies, a digital fundraising practitioner said there
are cultural fears around “getting into the culture of asking money.” Although
fundraisers were under the impression that there would be a bad response from
people when asked for money, this was not at all the case. Indeed, when we ask
people in our research with the public why they donated to a charity, 5-10% usually
say “simply because I was asked to” (Charity Awareness Monitor).
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 14/29
Factor 3: access to digital technology
What do we mean by digital technology?Technology fashions social behaviour and attitudes in a number of ways. Increased
access to technology and innovation broadly refers to new technologies and
improved user experiences that have a positive impact on those outside thetechnical industry, empowering everyone at an increasing scale. People now have
greater access to use and purchase technological products as well as a chance to
directly contribute to the development of these products and services. Today,
technology seems much more user friendly and affordable than it used to be and
this is not only fostering global connectivity but also helping the promotion of
transparency, citizen advocacy and democracy.
In this report increased access to technology is explored in terms of global mobile
phone usage, internet penetration, smartphone ownership and use of social media.
Key findings on digital technologyThe latest figures show that mobile phones have now become widely accessible
worldwide (Chart 5). Although access to the internet is not as prevalent as
possession of a mobile phone subscription, mobile internet use is on a steady rise in
emerging economies (Chart 6). Interestingly, the increase is almost as fast in
emerging economies as it is in developed countries, most prominently in the BRICS.
Mobile internet users – defined as those people who have engaged with at least one
mobile internet activity in the last six months – mostly use their phones to check
their emails. Looking at our interview analysis, we gather that there is a perception
within emerging economies that non-profits are not fully aware of their potential
reach through mobile technology.
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 15/29
“They [Brazilian non-profits ] don’t explore new opportunities through
fundraising companies; through mobile phones, smart phones, apps for
example…”
- Practitioner, Brazil
Internet penetration is considerably higher in developed than in emerging
economies (Chart 7). While across most developed markets at least two-thirds ofthe population use the internet, the figure is around a third of people in Latin
America and the Middle East, a quarter in Asia and a tenth in Africa. However, the
number of actual internet users in Asia reached one billion in 2012, dwarfing the
number of users in other regions.7 Over the last five years, emerging economies
have increased their share of the world’s total number of internet users from 44% in
2006, to 62% in 2011. Today, internet usage in China represents almost 25% of the
world’s total internet usage and 37% of emerging economies’ internet usage. 8
7 nVision Research ‘Beyond 2020: The future of customer service 8 Ibid
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 16/29
Keeping this in mind, there are significant differences between the BRICS countries,
as well as among other emerging economies. For instance, Brazil has more internet
users (45%) than the Latin American average of 34%. Also India has fewer internet
users (10%) than Southern Asia on average (25%). Although there is a divergence
between and within the BRICS, there are factors applicable to both BRICS and
developed countries, such as the fact that young people tend to go online more
than older people do. In emerging economies, 30% of those under the age of 25use the internet, compared to 23% of those aged 25 years and older. At the same
time, 70% of the under 25-year-olds — a total of 1.9 billion — are not online yet at
all.9 As highlighted in the quote below, the age discrepancy between technology
users and the potential donors make digital fundraising more so challenging for
emerging economies where this gap is wider.
“[Our] target audience is mostly youngsters below 35 -40 [years old], when
we target (let’s say) housewives of over 35 or 40, we have to redefine our
approach. We do offline; we target hot spots such as malls, parties, sari
shops, gold shops etc.- Practitioner, India
There is also a clear increase in the level of smartphone ownership in each of the
BRICS countries. This is true even in India, although levels are substantially lower
than elsewhere (Chart 8). Surprisingly, levels of ownership in Russia are higher than
in the US and though behind Russia in terms smartphone ownership, China has
higher levels of regular mobile internet users.10 Another key trend is the increase in
9 ITU World Telecommunication ICT statistics http://www.itu.int/ITU-D/ict/facts/2011/10 nVision Research ‘Beyond 2020: The future of customer service
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 17/29
access to the internet on the go. The smartphone enables people to be online
throughout the day, wherever they are. They might hear about a non-profit in the
news, ask it a question on Twitter, visit its website and make a donation, all while
waiting for the bus. A practitioner working in Brazil highlighted this increased access
to the internet:
“In Brazilian markets, people have much more access to online, because
they can access at their work, at their home but [smart] mobile phones are
not that spread out within the country, still expensive.”
- Practitioner, Brazil
Research into global social media usage by Global Web Usage found that in the first
quarter of 2013:
Facebook is the largest social platform in the world in terms of monthly
active users, followed by Google+.
There is a rise in active engagement across all social platforms with Twitter
the fastest growing.
Older internet users are driving social platforms growth globally. Local social platforms continue their decline around the world with the
exception of China and Russia.
6 out of the top 10 social platforms are Chinese social media sites. Since
China has the world’s biggest internet population and many of the global
sites including Twitter, Facebook and YouTube are banned there, the size and
popularity of these local alternatives is not surprising.
Still, the proportion of adults who are social networkers is higher in the UK and US
than in the BRICS (particularly India, where it is just 11%); the proportion of the
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 18/29
online population regularly using social networking apps is higher in the BRICs
(including India) than in the UK and US.11
Overall, the view on digital fundraising via social media is that it is good for visibility
but does not necessarily generate successful outcomes in terms of fundraising:
“We have tried fun draising with Facebook, was about a year and a half ago,
wasn’t really successful. What we found more successful was when we pass
people back to our website and then actually they would make a donation. ..
They don’t stay on one page long enough to want to make donation.”
- Practitioner, Malaysia
Level of digital technology and their implications for
digital fundraisingNeedless to say, access to technology and innovation lie at the heart of successful
digital fundraising. Global use of mobile finance has surged in recent years – e.g.
using the ‘mobile wallet’ (paying by mobile instead of cash or card) and using
mobile banking services. This is driven by the spread of new technology and a
mobile banking infrastructure. Besides, increasing levels of mobile banking indicate
strong public trust in the safety of making financial transactions online and public
digital know-how. These are both important precursors to the success of online
fundraising. However, looking at the qualitative research we have conducted with
practitioners and experts from emerging economies, we understand that lack of
technological infrastructure thwarts online giving. In addition, issues such as
overregulation, lack of regulation, lack of transparency and lack of tax benefits actpresent obstacles to successful digital fundraising. This causes non-profits to focus
on collecting one-off donations which does not secure long-term income and is an
expensive fundraising method that is affordable only for very large non-profits.
“Infrastructu re of online giving is easier in the UK; in the Arab region you
have difficult[ies], because mature online giving mechanisms might not
accept banks in the region as recipients .”
- Practitioner, Jordan
“We don’t do mobile fundraising… In India when you do nate you need toshare quite a few details and giving all these details is just not possible over
the phone.”
- Expert, India
“There are very few mobile texting fundraising campaigns going on [in
Brazil] mainly because of the high costs charged by telecommunication
companies…”
- Practitioner, Brazil
11 Ibid
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 19/29
In addition, technological access is still not homogenous among BRICS or other
emerging economies. More specifically, access to computers, mobile phones and the
internet is still an issue in many places, especially among older age groups,
although increasingly less so.
Considering the noticeably higher internet penetration in developed countries, lack
of access to technology is likely to pose an important challenge for digital
fundraising in emerging economies. It is important to note that technology does not
present a serious barrier from non-profits’ perspective, especially not when
compared to culture and capacity:
“Technology is important but most of them [the small non-profits in
emerging economies ] will have a computer […] I think technology is almost
a less of a barrier. […] You can use an old computer to do all those stuff; you
don’t have to have the newest technology. It doesn’t feel like that that’s the
barrier it feels like its people and time to do it.”- Practitioner, UK
“We have everything related to technology; internet is present everywhere
but we have cultural problems.”
- Practitioner, Romania
All in all, the future for global digital fundraising looks positive in terms of the impact
of increased access to technology and innovation. There has been an increase in
platforms which allow people to engage and interact virtually with their local
community. This kind of neighbourhood networking is likely to grow, offering aconvenient means to connect to the locality and to feel (at least virtually) part of the
local community. This is an opportunity for non-profits to virtually access local
communities and encourage them to fundraise together for a cause, whether it is
local or not. Also, as access to internet and phones increase, non-profits will need to
be aware of their supporters’ increasing expectations in terms of customer service
and they should be able to focus and make use of their supporters’ data more
efficiently in order to develop better and more influential digital fundraising methods
and campaigns.
Pulling it all together: summary andconclusionsPoverty, war and disease mean that the development of non-profits around the
globe is as necessary as ever. There are obvious differences in the role and purpose
of NGOs in different countries but at their heart they are all working to make a
better world for all citizens. Money, stable political systems and development have
resulted in voluntary sector growth in developed countries. However, in emerging
economies, the non-profit sector has not had the same opportunity for growth.Unstable political situations, fragile environments and poor infrastructure all add to
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 20/29
the issues non-profits face in terms of lack of capacity and funding to grow. This
also affects their ability to engage in effective fundraising activities and
compromises further growth.
Fundraising is intrinsic to the delivery of objectives and growth for most non-profits.
Wherever it is undertaken it can only be successful if it is inspiring, attention
grabbing, convincing and enables donors to see the impact of their donations.
These principles hold true whether it is a small community project in rural India or a
mass participation event in the USA.
In a nutshell, this research demonstrates that these basic principles, as stated
above, are crucial for all types of fundraising, including digital fundraising. On the
other hand, it also reveals that although digital fundraising brings in innovative and
unique ways to achieve success, it appears to be still in its infancy in developing
areas of the world.
Summarising the key success factors
This research highlights that the above mentioned factors are crucial for successful
fundraising anywhere in the world and they manifest themselves as layers of a
pyramid as shown below.
Chart 7 underlines the fact that non-profits should take into account all these three
factors; the ground layer is trust in non-profits, the next layer is a giving culture and
the top layer is digital technology.
According to our findings, trust in public institutions is the primary issue non-profits
should consider. This is because if there is lack of public trust in a country it is highly
likely that non-profits would find it difficult to succeed in any form of fundraising
methods. Perceptions of (and evidence of) corruption in public institutions can
extend to the non-profit sector. This influences both how non-profits feel about
soliciting donations from the public and also public trust that donations won’t beused fraudulently. A precursor to engaging in digital fundraising is familiarity with
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 21/29
using online financial transactions and trusting that these transactions are safe. In
many countries this is not yet the case except among the upper middle class or
wealthy.
The middle layer of the pyramid shows that the existence of a giving culture or
warmness towards giving to non-profits as an external provider (rather than giving
or supporting individuals within a community’s own sphere of influence) is also
significant. If there is an absence of this type of giving in a country, it is hard to
encourage people to donate and non-profits would experience different set of
challenges. Actions will be around introducing and promoting giving in general prior
to engaging with or developing digital fundraising. According to our research, for
some countries, cultural factors make its people more likely to donate to a charity,
help a stranger or volunteer their time, these same factors may have the opposite
effect in others. Religion, for instance, is often a stimulus to charitable behaviour,
but sometimes encourages people to focus their giving on religious institutions,
making it difficult for non-religious non-profits to get in on the fundraising. Anawareness of and sensitivity to these kinds of cultural nuances is crucial to fundraise
effectively.
Contrary to possible presumptions, our findings discovered that technological
infrastructure actually comes at the top of the pyramid, on the way to successful
digital fundraising. Although internet penetration, mobile internet usage and
smartphone ownership are all rising globally, levels still vary significantly depending
on the country and demographic groups, (and are relatively low when compared to
UK and US levels). Considering that mobile internet usage goes hand in hand with
social media usage and the relatively light levels of usage of both in emergingeconomies it does not come as a surprise that fundraising organisations use digital
platforms to gain visibility, raise awareness and market their non-profit rather than
to fundraise directly.
In other words any organisation which creates a digital giving platform where there
is no trust in non-profits and no giving culture is very unlikely to succeed.
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 22/29
As the diagram above suggests, all non-profits need to first answer several key
questions before committing any of their resources to digital fundraising efforts. Key
to success in digital fundraising initially lies in understanding the parameters, threats
and opportunities around public trust and giving culture in an organisations home
country. Technological infrastructure and advancement, whilst crucial, is not enough
to be the silver bullet on its own.
What should you do?
In this section we would like to present three models for the non-profits considering
attempting to tap into digital fundraising methods. Please note that we are not able
to cover the situation in every country with these models. Nevertheless we believe,
with some degree of flexibility, these three scenarios are broad enough to
encompass most individual situations.
Situation 1: Weak foundations make digital fundraisinghard
Weak Medium Strong
Trust in public institutions Giving culture Technology
In situation 1 we present a country that scores low on all factors in the model that
we view as necessary for success in digital fundraising. Assuming that a non-profit is
operating in such an environment, where trust in public institutions is low due tohigh levels of corruption, giving culture is non-existent and internet penetration is
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 23/29
low, e.g. around 15%, we would recommend this non-profit not to spend time and
money developing digital fundraising methods. This is because it is not within the
non-profits sphere of influence to tackle these issues.
Situation 2: Promising but donors need reassurance
Weak Medium Strong
Trust in public institutions Giving culture Technology
In situation 2, we suggest that there is scope for non-profits to develop and run
successful digital fundraising activities. Although trust in public institutions is weak,
there seems to be some sort of giving culture, possibly at a micro/local level. Also,
this country enjoys moderate levels of technological advancements such as healthy
levels of mobile phone usage, fair levels internet penetration and broadband
subscriptions. To a non-profit operating under these circumstances we would
recommend that it is as transparent, professional and accountable as possible in all
its communications order to raise its profile as reputable, honest and fair
organisation in a country where public trust is low.
Situation 3: Digital rewards are down to fundraisingcreativity
Weak Medium Strong
Trust in public institutions Giving culture Technology
Under situation 3, an organisation tempted to develop and utilise digital fundraising
would be in a great place to do so. Having a high level of trust in institutions and amedium strength culture of giving coupled with moderate levels of internet
penetration, mobile phone usage and broadband subscriptions provides a favourable
environment for effective digital fundraising practices. Non-profits operating under
these circumstances would benefit from committing their funds to, and developing
expertise in, generating effective online mechanisms.
Some things to bear in mind on the digital journey
Here are some recommendations aimed at organisations which are interested in
advancing at digital fundraising, which is an increasingly appealing and a potentially
cheaper way of increasing donations.
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 24/29
Build the knowledge base available to you. Study what successful
fundraising non-profits are doing - examine the donation pages on their
website, even try making a donation. See how other non-profits
communicate with donors on social media or through other communication
channels. Accessing successful examples of digital fundraising can provide a
road-map for different methods and help gain the buy-in of senior
management or key stakeholders.
Exchange knowledge and share best practice with other organisations;
fundraising can be competitive but it shouldn’t be seen as a zero-sum game
where one charity’s gain is another’s loss.
Grow digital literacy by providing training opportunities for staff and the
infrastructure to carry out digital fundraising activities. In some countries
there also needs to be a growth of experts in areas such as website
development, social media, CRM and communications that specifically deal
with not-for-profit sector.
Start developing digital communications through using social media,
email and website communications. Any non-profit which goes straight to
digital fundraising will struggle. Digital communications by non-profits allow
supporters (in the broadest sense) to get used to communications by Twitter,
Facebook, YouTube and other media, before any asking for money is made.
Learn to be comfortable with asking for donations by dispelling fears
around being perceived negatively and receiving bad reactions from the
public. In many countries with a developed fundraising culture ‘street
fundraising’ is often perceived as annoying by the public but non-profits do it
because it’s successful!
Try developing micro-donations, these can enable people to donate
without worrying as much about how they will afford it, and the small
amount may even be a way of testing new methods of donating e.g. micro-
donations by text. Donations added onto purchases could recruit donors
already engaging in e-commerce. The affiliation with trusted stores/brands
can also increase trust in the legitimacy of the charity.
Be prepared. People who are used to shopping online may haveexpectations of a similar quick and easy user experience when making online
donations to non-profits. Ensure everything is working smoothly and that
digital fundraising messages and traditional marketing communications are
integrated and do not contradict each other.
Develop strong internal financial controls. Ensure there is up-to-date
information to account for donors funds and increased reporting to donors.
This can lead to improved public perception and confidence in non-profits.
Further information The Resource Alliance: http://www.resource-alliance.org/
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 25/29
Appendices
About nfpSynergy
nfpSynergy is a research consultancy that aims to provide the ideas, the insights
and the information to help non-profits thrive.
We have over a decade of experience working exclusively with charities, helping
them develop evidence-based strategies and get the best for their beneficiaries. The
organisations we work with represent all sizes and areas of work and include one in
three of the top 100 fundraising charities in the UK.
We run cost effective, syndicated tracking surveys of stakeholder attitudes towards
charities and non-profit organisations. The audiences we reach include the general
public, young people, journalists, politicians and health professionals. We also work
with charities on bespoke projects, providing quantitative, qualitative and deskresearch services.
In addition, we work to benefit the wider sector by creating and distributing regular
free reports, presentations and research on the issues that charities face.
Our size and our story: nfpSynergy was created in 2002 as a division of the
Future Foundation. Two years later, the founder Joe Saxton led a management buy-
out. We now have an annual turnover of £1.4 million and 18 staff members,
including a variable number of interns. We also own our own premises in
Spitalfields.
Tracking research: We run tracking surveys that monitor the attitudes and
opinions of key stakeholder groups relating to the not-for-profit sector. The research
is carried out on behalf of a syndicate of participating charities who share costs and
data. The aim of our tracking studies is to provide lower cost, more frequent and
more detailed research than any organisation could achieve by acting on its own.
Our monitors include:
Charity Awareness Monitor (CAM) - the general public
Journalists’ Attitudes and Awareness Monitor – journalists
Charity Parliamentary Monitor (CPM) - MPs and Lords
Youth Engagement Monitor (YEM) – young people
Brand Attributes (BA) – brand awareness among the general public
In addition, we have developed syndicated tracking studies on local authorities,
politicians in the devolved bodies, the general public in the Republic of Ireland and
regional audiences across England.
Qualitative research and consultancy: Each year we deliver around 30 projectsfor non-profit clients. We carry out focus groups, conduct face-to-face and
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 26/29
telephone depth interviews, run workshops and perform small and large scale desk
research projects. Our clients include charities, housing associations and public
bodies who use our research to inform their strategies and planning.
Our consultancy work and projects cover a vast range. For example, we have
recently worked with The Scout Association to develop a new membership strategy
with current and former members, parents and Scout leaders. We have worked with
Macmillan Cancer Support on a number of projects enhancing their service provision
and delivery using qualitative research. Last year, we completed a piece of work for
Scope, evaluating their vital ‘Face 2 Face’ befriending service for parents of disabled
children.
Some of our clients include:
Social investment: Our social investment programme runs as a thread through
every aspect of our business. At its core is the range of free research reports and
briefings we produce each year to benefit non-profit organisations, which can be
downloaded from our website. We use evidence from our research to campaign on
behalf of charities on key issues, such as reducing the costs charged by mobilephone companies for charitable donations by SMS. We also support small non-
profits by providing free places at our seminars, giving talks to groups all over the
UK and through pro bono research assistance. In addition, we support
CharityComms (the sector body for communications) by providing them with free
office space. Our approach to business shows that even a small company can put
social investment at the heart of a business, contribute a huge amount to help
voluntary and community organisations and still be profitable.
Topics on which we have produced free reports include:
understanding young people’s
help seeking behaviour
branding
fundraising
volunteeringhow charities use the internet
and new technology
governance
By producing free reports, editorials and presentations we help small charities (with
little or no budget for research) to benefit from our wealth of data and knowledge of
the third sector. Please see descriptions of all of our free research at
www.nfpsynergy.net/freereports
As full members of the Market Research Society, we comply with their
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 27/29
code of conduct at all times, ensuring that research is carried out in a professional
and ethical manner. We also have high standards of data protection – find out more
about on our website at www.nfpsynergy.net/dataprotection
About the Resource Alliance
The Resource Alliance works with civil society organisations and their leadersaround the world to help them be more sustainable and more effective in theirworld-changing work.
Our visionOur vision is of a strong and sustainable civil society through which people canbetter give voice to their aspirations, exercise their rights and change their world forthe better.
What we doThe Resource Alliance works with civil society organisations and their leaders
around the world to help them be more sustainable and more effective in theirworld-changing work.
We help organisations become more financially sustainable by developing theirfundraising skills and capability to enable them to diversify their funding.
We support leadership development and governance to help organisations improvetheir effectiveness and be better at managing their resources, delivering theirmission, and to have greater impact.
We facilitate the opportunity for philanthropy and partners to join forces for greater
impact.
How we do itThe Resource Alliance works in partnership with well-known and established NGOsat both a global and national level, as well as with local community organisations.
We deliver training courses and conferences, as well as consultancy, coaching andmentoring, drawing on the expertise of both international and local trainers andconsultants.
We promote and recognise excellence and promote the sharing of skills, knowledge
and best practice and encourage establishing of local and international networks.
We engage with philanthropists and corporate sector leaders to stimulate ideas forstrengthening civil society.
We work globally, delivering conferences and workshops, training programmes andawards programmes:
Conferences and workshops: The International Fundraising Congress - an annual conference which
brings together around 1000 fundraisers from 60 different countries.
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 28/29
The International Workshop on Resource Mobilisation – held everyyear in both Asia and Africa, renowned as the leading workshop forfundraisers in emerging economies.
Fundraising Online – a free annual conference delivered entirely online,covering digital fundraising techniques and their integration with otherchannels.
Regional events – we hold a number of regional events in collaborationwith partner organisations in Africa, Asia Pacific, Central and Eastern Europe,Latin America and South Asia.
Training: Future Leaders Programme - an exciting and innovative course, aimed at
transforming middle and senior managers into future leaders.
School of Fundraising – a series of courses to develop professionalfundraisers.
Tailored Capacity Development - a comprehensive and customisedcapacity development service, equipping NGOs with the skills, knowledgeand capacity to mobilise resources.
Emerge – a 12 month programme for NGOs comprising of a cumulative mixof feasibility study, training and mentoring to improve resource mobilisation.
Knowledge Hub – a free resource including case studies, research, guides,blogs, videos, webinars, events, news and other valuable information.
Awards: The NGO Awards - celebrating and rewarding the best non-governmental
and non-profit organisations
Fundraising Awards - we proudly support national fundraising awardsprogrammes organised around the world, as well as organising some of ourown.
Global Awards for Fundraising - this award programme sees winners ofnational fundraising awards compete against one another to be recognisedwith a Global Award.
8/12/2019 Global Digital Fundraising
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/global-digital-fundraising 29/29
2-6 Tenter Ground. London E1 7NH
t: 020 7426 8888 e: [email protected]
www.nfpsynergy.net