cost-benefit analysis of retbus (goni ross)
DESCRIPTION
TIL/T&P Masterclass presentation by Bernat Goni Ross on his MSc research and reporting tips. September 2012.TRANSCRIPT
WHO AM I?
BernatBernatBernatBernat GoñiGoñiGoñiGoñi RosRosRosRos
• BSc Environmental Science, specialization in Urban Planning (Autonomous
University of Barcelona)
• Worked as urban planner in Barcelona for 3 years
• MSc Transport, Infrastructure and Logistics (TU Delft)
• PhD Researcher (TU Delft)
• Driving behavior
• Traffic modeling and simulation
• Intelligent transport systems
MY MASTER THESIS
Committee membersCommittee membersCommittee membersCommittee members
Prof. dr. ir. Bart van Arem (TU Delft, CEG)
Dr. ir. Rob van Nes (TU Delft, CEG)
Dr. Hans van Ham (TU Delft, TPM)
Dr. ir. Miquel Estrada (UPC Barcelona TECH)
Final presentation date Final presentation date Final presentation date Final presentation date
21st June 2011
TRANSIT NETWORKS IN BARCELONA
THE RETBUS PROJECTElementsElementsElementsElements
a)a)a)a) New BRT system
- High frequency (1 service/3 min)
- High speed (15 km/h)
- Hybrid grid-radial network concept
b)b)b)b) Changes to the existing bus network
ObjectiveObjectiveObjectiveObjective
Min [Transit User Costs + (Investment
Costs + Operating Costs)]
ImplementationImplementationImplementationImplementation
2012-2015
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
1) To what extent will the implementation of the RetBus project be socially
beneficial and financially profitable?
2) What modifications could be made to the RetBus project so as to
improve its social and/or financial value?
COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS
Financial CostFinancial CostFinancial CostFinancial Cost----Benefit Analysis (FCBA)Benefit Analysis (FCBA)Benefit Analysis (FCBA)Benefit Analysis (FCBA)
• Will the project result in sufficient financial returns to justify the costs incurred by
the investors and operators?
Social CostSocial CostSocial CostSocial Cost----Benefit Analysis (SCBA)Benefit Analysis (SCBA)Benefit Analysis (SCBA)Benefit Analysis (SCBA)
• Will the project produce an increase in social welfare?
TWO PROJECT ALTERNATIVES
Alternative 1: Alternative 1: Alternative 1: Alternative 1: TMB plan / Alternative 2: Alternative 2: Alternative 2: Alternative 2: Cost-reduction plan
TRAVEL DEMAND FORECASTING MODEL
RESULTS:
CBA
RESULTS: SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS (I)
RESULTS: SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS (II)
CONCLUSIONS
REPORT WRITING: MY EXPERIENCE
Pay attention to:Pay attention to:Pay attention to:Pay attention to:
1. Report structure
2. Report presentation
3. Writing process
4. Yourself
a)a)a)a) Guidelines on report writingGuidelines on report writingGuidelines on report writingGuidelines on report writing****
b)b)b)b) CompletenessCompletenessCompletenessCompleteness
c)c)c)c) Quality Quality Quality Quality
d)d)d)d) BalanceBalanceBalanceBalance
REPORT STRUCTURE
1. Title page
2. Acknowledgements
3. Table of contents
4. List of tables
5. List of figures
6. Summary
7. Introduction
8. Research objectives
9. Methodology
10. Results
11. Conclusions
12. Recommendations
13. Bibliography
14. Appendices
**** Example: www.canberra.edu.au/studyskills/writing Example: www.canberra.edu.au/studyskills/writing Example: www.canberra.edu.au/studyskills/writing Example: www.canberra.edu.au/studyskills/writing
a)a)a)a) Facilitate the job to the reader.Facilitate the job to the reader.Facilitate the job to the reader.Facilitate the job to the reader.
b)b)b)b) Explain a story, don’t present only Explain a story, don’t present only Explain a story, don’t present only Explain a story, don’t present only facts.facts.facts.facts.
c)c)c)c) Keep it simple, but also complete and coherent.Keep it simple, but also complete and coherent.Keep it simple, but also complete and coherent.Keep it simple, but also complete and coherent.
d)d)d)d) Leave out all the irrelevant information.Leave out all the irrelevant information.Leave out all the irrelevant information.Leave out all the irrelevant information.
e)e)e)e) Report formatting tools, e.g. LaTeX.Report formatting tools, e.g. LaTeX.Report formatting tools, e.g. LaTeX.Report formatting tools, e.g. LaTeX.
f)f)f)f) ProofProofProofProof----reading.reading.reading.reading.
g)g)g)g) Language review.Language review.Language review.Language review.
REPORT PRESENTATION
WRITING PROCESS
a)a)a)a) Write when the content is fresh in your mind.Write when the content is fresh in your mind.Write when the content is fresh in your mind.Write when the content is fresh in your mind.
b)b)b)b) Start writing early. Start writing early. Start writing early. Start writing early.
� Make use of the meetings with your supervisors to write drafts of some parts
of the report and getting them reviewed (e.g. intermediate meeting report).
� Get (parts of) the report reviewed by classmates, friends, etc.
c)c)c)c) Keep track of the comments you receive from your supervisors.Keep track of the comments you receive from your supervisors.Keep track of the comments you receive from your supervisors.Keep track of the comments you receive from your supervisors.
YOURSELF
Ten Principles to Live by (Ten Principles to Live by (Ten Principles to Live by (Ten Principles to Live by (Tony Schwartz, Harvard Business Review)Tony Schwartz, Harvard Business Review)Tony Schwartz, Harvard Business Review)Tony Schwartz, Harvard Business Review)
1. Always challenge certainty, especially your own.
2. Excellence is an unrelenting struggle.
3. Emotions are contagious, so it pays to know what you're feeling.
4. When in doubt, ask yourself, "How would I behave here at my best?"
7. Accept yourself exactly as you are but never stop trying to learn and grow.
9. You can't change what you don't notice and not noticing won't make it go away.
10. When in doubt, take responsibility.