university of massachusetts amherstvis- ·...

67

Upload: others

Post on 23-Aug-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

����������� �� ������ ������������������������ �� ��! �#"$ ��% �&�' ���(���#� �) *������+ ��

,�-/.�0214351�68740214029;:<0>=

?;@

A ,B-/-�CEDBF GIHJGLKM,ON�PQCIRIS

N&T ?�U 3V:W:W02=):<XY:W.�0[Z\7W]^=�T_]`:W0aNcbd.�X&XfegX^hi:<.�0j 9k3Vlf0>7W143V: @ X^h A ]^141<]^bd.�T�140>:4:<1O, U .�0>7W1m:E3V9on_]^74:W3p]^eqhrT�eVs�e5e U 029;:

X^hi:<.�0\7W0>t�T�35740 U 029;:<1/hrXf7Q:W.�0\=�02uf74020aX^h

A ,�Nc-/D8vwS�x�N�PLyzD8{OPLD

A ] @o|^}f};~

PLX U n�Tk:W027ENcb23V029�b>0

Page 2: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

b� PLXfn @ 7W35u^.�: ?;@ A ] :W:<.k0�� GIHJG ep]^14bd.��^X |^}f};~

,IeVegv�35uf.;:<1�v�0214027mlf02=

Page 3: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

����������� �� ������ ������������������������ �� ��! �#"$ ��% �&�' ���(���#� �) *������+ ��

,�-/.�0214351�68740214029;:<0>=

?;@

A ,B-/-�CEDBF GIHJGLKM,ON�PQCIRIS

,Inkn�7WX lf0>= ]^1/:WX�1m: @ e50[]^9�=ob2Xf9;:W029;: ?;@��

D 7W3 �)ZYHJKM02]^7W9k02=�� A 35eVe5027�PL.�]^357

D = �L]^7W= A HJv�3V1W0 U ]^9�A 0 U ? 0>7

F HJGL74T�b20[PL7WX`h :�� 02n�]^74: U 0>9�:EPL.�]^357

PLX U n�Tk:W027ENcb23V029�b>0

Page 4: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

�����������

Page 5: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

�#���� � % �� ��w"$! ��

-/._]^9���1I:WX U[@ h ] U 3Ve @�hr7W3V029�=k1

�hr02eVe5X ��u^7<]^= 14:<Tk=�029;:<1

�]^9k=*n�74X^hr02141WXf7412H/, ? 35u :<.�]^9���1

:<X � 3 U ] hrXf7E1WT�u^uf021m:<359ku �^0>7W9�0>e51�X lf0>7�e5X&b ]^eghr0 ] :<T�740212H�-/.�]^9���1\]^e514X :WX��;]^9�D 35bd.�.kXf7W9*hrX^7

359chrXf7 U ]`:<3VXf9 7402u;]`7W=�3V9�u .�351/3 U n�eV0 U 029;:d] :<35X^9�X^hi:<.�0 U ]`:<bd.�3V9�u �^0>7W9�0>e H

-/.�351 � Xf7 � �L]^1B1WT�nkn Xf7m:<0>= ?;@ :W.�0/{E]`:<3VXf9_]^ekNcb23V029�b>0�x_XfT�9�=_] :<35X^9 T�9�=�0>7Buf7<]`9�: 9�T U ? 0>7

,B- A � }��;|f~�� � H�x_Xf7�7W02e5]`:<0>= � Xf7 �oXf9*b2ep]`1W1W3 s_b ] :<35X^9 X^hB]^t�T_]`:<3Vb[n�]^74:W35b2eV021�]^9�= ]^=�=�3 :<35X^9_]^e

359chrXf7 U ]`:<3VXf9)] ? XfTk:�:<.k0 U ]^7W3V9�0�1Wb>350>9�b20[=_]`:d] 1W0 :OT�1402= 359o:<.�3V1�:W.�0214351�n�eV0 ]^140al&3V1W3V:������ ���

������� �������� �"!��#�%$�&(')���#�+*�,�$-� �/./0�1 *(! � � �32��54*/6 0 �7� H

l

Page 6: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

��� �E��#�#��

����������� �� ������ ������������������������ �� ��! �#"$ ��% �&�' ���(���#� �) *������+ ��

A ,�� |^}f};~

A ,B-/-�CEDBF GIHJGLKM,ON�PQCIRIS

GIH N H�P/S�K jEA GLyz, j {�y��OD8vIN&yz-��

A H N H�j {�y��OD8vIN&yz-�� S�x A ,�NkNc,�PQC j NcD -/-�N�, A CED8vENc-

� 357402b>:W02= ?;@�� 6 74X^hr02141WXf7�D 7W3 ��Z H�KM02]^7W9k02=�� A 35eVe5027

-/.�0E1WT�n�nqXf7m:Llf0>b>:WXf7 hr7W] U 0 �LX^7 �Y351 ][u^029�0>7<]^e U 0>:<.kXc=�hrXf7 b>ep]^141W3 s_b ]`:W35Xf9 =�0>7W3 lf02= hr7WX U

359k9�027�n�7WX&=�T�b :<1OX l^027Ehr02]`:<Tk7W0[l^02b :<Xf7412HI-/.k0 hr7<] U 0�� Xf7 � �LXf7 ��1 ?;@ b>Xf9�1m:<7WTkb>:<3V9�u U ]��c3 U ]^e

U ]^7Wuf3V9 1402n_]^7W]`:<3V9�uO. @ n 0>7Wn�e5]^9�0>1 ? 0 : �L0>029�b2ep]`1W1W0>12HB, �`0 @ hr0 ]`:WT�7W0QX`hq:W.�351 ]^n�n�74X;]^bd. 351i:<._] :

3V:B]^e5eVX ��1ihrXf7 :<.k0/7W02nkep]^b>0 U 029;:BX^h 14:W7W35b :B359k9�027Bn�74Xc=kT�b>:W1B359 :<.k0/Xf7W3Vuf359_]`e�hr02]`:<Tk7W0/1Wn�]^b20 ��3V:W.

�� � ���� �� ��������hrT�9�b>:W35Xf9k1 :<._] : ]^7W0L02t�T�3Vl`]^eV029;: :WX�359�9k027 n�74Xc=kT�b>:W1 ? 0 : �L0>029�n�7WX��402b>:W35Xf9k1 X^h

:<.k0OXf7W3Vuf359�]^e_lf02b :<Xf7/3V9;:<XY] .�3Vuf.�0>7�n Xf141W3 ? e @ 359ks�9�3V:W0I=�3 U 0>9�1W3VXf9_]^e_hr0 ] :<T�740O1Wn_]`b20^H -/.�X^T�uf.

:<.k0 =_]`:<] U ] @ 9kX^: ? 0 � 02eVe 1402n_]^7W]`:<0>=�359 :<.�0[e5X �L0>7I=�3 U 0>9�1W3VXf9_]^eg14n_]^b>0�:W.�023V7En�74X��402b :<3VXf9

359;:WX�.k35uf.�0>7/=�3 U 029k1W35X^9�1 U ] @ ? 0`H

R�027W9k02e51 ]^740�021Wnq02b>3p]^eVe @ 359;:<0>7W0>14:<3V9�u�359+:<.k02357o]`n�n�e53Vb ]`:W35Xf9:<X U ] :<.�0 U ]`:W35b2]^eIX ? �402b>:W1

:<.�]`:�=�X 9kX^:�e5029k= :W.�0 U 1W0>eVlf0>1E:WX ? 0\0��cn�e53Vb23 :<e @ 7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:W02=�]^1�] 1W3V9�ufe50�l^02b>:WXf7�359 ] s�9�3V:W0

=�3 U 0>9�1W3VXf9_]^eQ14n_]^b>0^H+v�02b>029;:�n�74Xfuf74021W1�359�:W.�0 s�02e5=�X^h�PLX U nkTk:<0>7��I351W3VXf9�._]^1�7W0>e5350>=�Xf9

7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:<]`:<3VXf9�1 X^h[3 U ]^uf021 :<._]`:ob>Xf9�143514: X^h[T�9�X^7W=�0>7W02=$1W0 :<1 X^h[hr02]`:<Tk7W021):W._]`:o=�0>1Wb2743 ? 0

e5X&b ]`e83 U ]`uf0 7W02u^35Xf9�1>H*y\0��cn�eVXf7W0 .�02740�1W0 lf0>7<]^eQ7402b>029;:<e @ =�0 lf0>e5Xfnq02= �`027W9k02e51 ? 0 : �L0>029�1W0>:W1

l&3

Page 7: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

X^h8lf0>b>:<X^7W1a]^9�=�=�0 lf02eVXfn�]�b2X U�U X^9�n�7WX ? ] ? 35eV351m:<35b\:<.k02Xf7 @ :<X)0 �knkep]^3V9�:W.�023V7O=�0>1W35u^9 H -/.�3V1

:<.k02Xf7 @ 351 ? ]^1402=�Xf9 ]an�74359�b>35n�eV02= U 0 ]^14T�7W0�X^h 1W3 U 3Vep]^743V: @\? 0>: � 02029 :<.�0/lf0>b>:WXf7 140>:W1 ��3 :<.Yhr0��

]^141WT U nk:<3VXf9�1i7W0>u;]^7W=k359�uE14:<74T�b>:WT�7W0L359[:W.�0L=�]`:d]kH v�021WTkeV:<1 ]^7W081W.kX ��9 hrX^7 140>lf0>7<]^ek3 U ]^uf0B=_]`:<]

1W0 :<1�359kb2e5Tk=�359�u\]abd._]^eVe5029kuf359�u�740 ]^e � � Xf7WeV= U ]^74359�0�14b2350>9�b20E]^n�nke535b2]`:<3VXf9 H v�0>1WT�e :<180��cb20>02=�3V9�u

:<.k0�b2T�747W0>9�: 14:d] :<0 X`h/:<.�0 ]^74:[hrXf7 ? ]`u*X^h/hr02]`:<T�74021 7402n�740214029;:d]`:W35Xf9k1Y]^7W0 ]^bd.�3V0>lf0>= ��3V:<.�]

9�0 ��e @ n�7WXfnqXf1402=Yh ] U 35e @ X^h �^02749�02eV12H -/.k0 ? 0>14: 7W0>1WT�e :<1 :WX�=_]`:W0QXf9 :<.k0��O68v U ]^74359�0 1Wb23V029�b>0

=_]`:<]�1W0>:L]^740E]`bd.�350 lf02= ��3V:W. ] �^0>7W9�0>e_:<._]`:8b>X U ? 3V9�021BeVXcb2]^e_]^9�=�ufeVX ? ]^e&lc3V1WT_]`e_359khrXf7 U ] :<35X^9 H

lc3V3

Page 8: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

� ��� � � ��� � * ��

�������

��� ��������������������� � HfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H�!

��"#�$�&%���'� H H;HfHfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H(!*)

�,+(�$�-�/.0�1��" �,�&� H;HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H�2

�,+(�$�-�/.0.1+3�54�%�&� HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H(2*)

�'6�� � �&��%

7�8 +9� �&%�/�54��'�&+3�/� HfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H 7

� H � KgXcb2]^egx_0 ]`:WT�7W0>1�HfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^H |

� H � H � N&y x - x_0 ] :<T�74021)H;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^H �

� H | NcT�n�nqXf7m:�� 02b>:WXf7 A ]^bd.�3V9�021YH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^H ~

:$8 � �&� %�'���'6 ���;� �<=��%��=���>�?��+@�'6A�>��'����.1���B�&45%C�&� HfH;HfHfHfH 7ED

| H � A T�e :<3 � yz9�14:<]^9�b>0\R\0>7W9�0>e51oHfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H � }| H | R�027W9k02eg6 7W3V9�b23Vn_]^e ,E9�ufe50>1�HfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H ���| H � GL._]`:4:d]^bd.�]^7 @�@ ]�R�02749�02eMH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H ���| HGF A ]`:Wbd.�359�u�R�02749�02e�H;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H � |

| HGF�H � PL.kXf35b>0aX`h A 3V9�Xf7�R�02749�02e HfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H � �

| H ~ 6 @ 7W] U 35= A ]`:Wbd. R�02749�02e8HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H � ~

H$8 � � %�/" ��"�+@��+3�*��+(�I.1%������J�K�L%� HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH 7�M

� H � 6 7WX ? ] ? 35eV3V: @ 6 7WX&=�T�b>:ER�02749�02eV1+HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H �5�� H | R�027W9k02e � 029k1W3V: @ D81m:<3 U ]`:W35Xf9 H HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H �3N

� H | H � 6 74X ? ] ? 3Ve53 : @ 6 7WX&=�T�b :ER\0>7W9�0>e51/,En�n�e53V02=):<X�R�02749�02e � 0>9�1W3 : @D 14:W3 U ]`:<0>1�HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH |^}

l&353V3

Page 9: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

� H | H � H � D �k] U n�e50�3V9o- �LX � � 3 U 029�1435Xf9k1 H^H;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H |�

� H | H | GL]^9�= ��3V=k:<. Nc0>e502b :<3VXf9 HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H |��

� H � Nc3 U 35e5]^7W3 :<3V0218GL0>: � 020>9 :W.�0\D �cnq02b :<02= KM3 �^0>e535.kXcX&=)R�02749�02e ��3V:W. � 029�143V: @D81m:<3 U ]`:W35Xf9�]^9�= 68740>l&35X^T�1�,In�n�74X;]^bd.�0>1QH�HfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH | F

� H � H � v�X ? Tk14:<9k021W1�yz1W14T�021�H^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H | F

� 8 �L�/� "�+9�=+9� � � 45� �&+ � �,�I� �/4�%�&�&� �/. +9� .>� %�� ����+(�L� HfH;HfHfHfH : M

F�H � A T�e :<35nke50 �I350���R�02749�02eV1�HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H | N

�$8 ��� � ��%+@� �����1��� %�&�$45� � � HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7

~ H � �O3V=�02X 6 ep]^9 ��:WXf9 v�0>b2Xf74=�027 � ]`:<]�Nc0>: HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H �)�

~ H � H � PLX U n_]`7W3514Xf9)X^h A ]`:Wbd.�359�u R�02749�02eM]^9k= D �cn 0>b>:W02= Kg3 �^02eV35.�X&X&=R�02749�02e HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH �)�

~ H � H | v�X ? Tk14:<9k021W1�D �cn 0>7W3 U 029;:W1�H;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H �;~~ H � H � PLX U ? 359k359�u KgX&b ]^eg]`9�= Z�e5X ? ]^e x_02]`:<T�74021MHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H � N

~ H � H � H � N&T U X^h KgXcb2]^eg]^9�=*Z�e5X ? ]`e R�02749�02eV1gHfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H ���~ H � H � H | 6 74Xc=�Tkb>:�X^h KMX&b ]`eg]^9�=*Z\eVX ? ]^e R�027W9k02e51#HfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H F �~ H � H � H � 6 Xfe @ 9�X U 35]^egPLX U ? 359_] :<35X^9�X^h KMX&b ]`eg]^9�=*Z\eVX ? ]^e

R�02749�02eV1 HfH;HfH^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH F |

~ H | D -�C � N^} � ] :d]�Nc0>: H;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H F �

�$8 �L�/���'��4�� +3�/� H;HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH ���

H � x_Tk:<T�740OF�X^7 �oH;HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H ~^}

"�+@" ��+3���%� � 6 H;HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH ��:

3 �

Page 10: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

�Y���E �� ������ ��

� ����� � �������

~ H � - ]��kX^9�X U 35bOb2]`:<0>ufXf7W3V021�X^h 3 U ]^uf0>1Q359):<.k0 �I68v =_]`:d]Y140>:�HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H �;|

~ H | �O68v�3 U ]^u^021/T�1402= hrX^7/=�351m:d]^9�b>0�0��cnq027W3 U 0>9;:<1/H�HfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H �;~

~ H � CE3V14:<X^uf7<] U 1QX^h =�3V14:d]`9�b20>1�X l^027E]^e5e n_]^357 ��35140Ohr0 ]`:WT�7W0 U ]`:<bd.�0>12H D8]^bd.*74X �7W02nk7W0214029;:<1I]Y=�3�� 0274029;:�t&Tk027 @ 3 U ]`uf0

���.�35eV0O:<.�0\b2X^e5T U 9�1/]^740\0 ]^bd.*]

=�3�� 0274029;:�:d]^74uf0>:�3 U ]^u^0^H^H`HfHfH;HfH^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH ��

~ HGF CE3V14:<X^uf7<] U 1QX^h =�3V14:d]`9�b20>1�X l^027 U ]��c3 U T U hr0 ]`:WT�7W0 U ]`:<bd.�0>12H D8]^bd.*74X �7W02nk7W0214029;:<1I]Y=�3�� 0274029;:�t&Tk027 @ 3 U ]`uf0

���.�35eV0O:<.�0\b2X^e5T U 9�1/]^740\0 ]^bd.*]

=�3�� 0274029;:�:d]^74uf0>:�3 U ]^u^0^H^H`HfHfH;HfH^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH � �

Page 11: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

�Y���E �� ����"$���+ ��

. ) ����� � �������

� H � �O3V1WT_]^eV3��2]`:<3VXf9 X^h Ncy x -(hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1E3V9o] U ]^74359�0O14b23V029�b>0[3 U ]^u^0^HaHfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^H F� H | -/.�0��ES�v n�7WX ? e50 U 351/9�X`:EeV359�02]^7We @ 1W02n�]^7<] ? e50\359):<.k0\hr02]`:<Tk7W0\1Wn_]`b20

�? Tk:

351/1W0>n_]^7W] ? e50\3V9�:<.�0\0 U ? 0>=�=�359ku 14n_]^b20`H HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH N

| H � ����� �� ������������ ���� 351/nke5X^:4:<02= ]^eVXf9�u ��3 :<. ]^9 351WX �zb2Tk74lf0\X^h� ������� ��� ������� � �

���.�3Vbd. 740214T�eV:�3V9 ]Yn�e5]^9�0a]^9�= ] b @ e53V9�=�0>7

7W0214n 0>b>:W3Vlf0>e @ H8-/.k0 ] lf0>7<]^u^359�u Xfnq027W]`:<3VXf9)359o02t�T_] :<35X^9�� | H F �8351/=�3"! b>T�eV::<X 359;:<0>7Wn�740>:E]^1 � 0 � XfT�eV= 0 �cn 0>b>:�:<X ._] lf0a02t�T_]^egb>Xf9;:<743 ? Tk:W35Xf9 ]^eVXf9�u:<.�0\3514X �zb>T�74l^0^H -/.�0\02t�T_] :<35X^9 3V1/9�X^:�b2X&Xf74=�359_] :<0Ohr7W0>0a]^1�bd._]^9�uf3V9�uY:<.�0Xf7W3Vuf359 ��3Ve5e 740214T�eV:�3V9 =k3�� 027W0>9;:E7402e5]`:<3 lf0Il`]^eVT�021/hrXf7/nqXf359;:W1/1W02eV02b :<02= ?;@:<.�0a]^74u U 3V9�Xfnq027W]`:<3VXf9o359o02t�T_]`:W35Xf9#� | H ~ ��HfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH � F

� H � 6 7WX ? ] ? 35eV3V: @ n�74Xc=�Tkb>:�]^n�nke5350>= :<XY=k029�143V: @ 0>14:W3 U ]`:<3VXf9�1LX`hg: �LX � =�3 U 029k1W35X^9_]^e=_]`:d]�H^H;HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH |f|

~ H � , hr0���0��k] U n�e50\3 U ]^uf0>1Lhr7WX U :<.k0 �I68v =_]`:d]Y140>: HoHfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H ���

~ H | GQ]^9�= ��35=k:W.�%$ � 3V1/n�e5X^:4:<0>=ol&1>HL]^b>b2T�7W]^b @ Xf9 :W.�0 �O68v =_]`:<]Y1W0>:2H8v�0>1WT�e :<1

]^7W0O14.�X ��9 hrX^7L:<.�0 U ]`:Wbd.�359�u �^02749�02e�]^9�=�hrXf7 :<.�0�0 �knq02b :<0>= eV3 �^0>e53V.�XcX&=

�^02749�02e H\HfHfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH � F

~ H � x_7<]^b :<35X^9�X^h U 3V9�Xf7 �^02749�02eg0 l`]^e5T_] :<35X^9�1� & � 351Qnke5X^:4:<02=�l&1>H ]`b2b2Tk7<]^b @ Xf9):<.�0

�O68v =_]`:<] 140>:2H8-/.k0 �`027W9k02eM351/b>X U nkTk:<0>=*]^1�3V9)02t�T_]`:W35Xf9 ~ H � H`H^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH � N

~ HGF GQ]^9�= ��35=k:W.�%$ � 3V1/n�e5X^:4:<0>=ol&1>HL]^b>b2T�7W]^b @ Xf9 :W.�0 �O68v =_]`:<]Y1W0>:2H8v�0>1WT�e :<1

]^7W0�14.�X ��9 hrXf7/ufeVX ? ]^e hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1�Tk1W359ku ] Z\]^T�1W143p]^9 v�GQx �^0>7W9�0>e HoH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH ���

~ H ~ PLep]^141W3 s_b ]`:W35Xf9o]`b2b2Tk7<]^b>35021/hrXf7Q:W.�0 U 02]^9oX^hi:<.�0 �^0>7W9�0>e51�hrXf7/ufeVX ? ]^e ]^9�=e5X&b ]^eqhr0 ]`:WT�7W0>12HiHfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH F }

~ H PLep]^141W3 s_b ]`:W35Xf9o]`b2b2Tk7<]^b>35021/hrXf7 � 023Vuf.;:<0>= ] lf0>7<]^uf0>1EX`h :W.�0 �^02749�02eV1/hrXf7ufe5X ? ]^e ]^9k= eVXcb2]^e hr02]`:<T�74021>H[H;HfH^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH F �

~ H � PLep]^141W3 s_b ]`:W35Xf9o]`b2b2Tk7<]^b>35021/hrXf7Q:W.�0\n�7WX&=�T�b :�X^h :W.�0 �^0>7W9�0>e51�hrXf7/ufe5X ? ]^e ]`9�=e5X&b ]^eqhr0 ]`:WT�7W0>12HiHfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH F |

�c3

Page 12: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

~ H N PLep]^141W3 s_b ]`:W35Xf9 ]^b2b>T�7<]`b2350>1QhrXf7Q]`9�T�9 �L0>35uf.;:W02= n Xfe @ 9�X U 3p]^e_b>X U ? 3V9_]`:<3VXf9 X`h:<.�0 �^0>7W9�0>e51�hrXf7/ufeVX ? ]^e ]^9�= e5X&b ]^eqhr0 ]`:WT�7W0>12HOH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH F F

~ H � PLep]^141W3 s_b ]`:W35Xf9o]`b2b2Tk7<]^b>35021/hrXf7�] � 023Vuf.;:<02= n X^e @ 9�X U 3p]^eqb2X U ? 359�]`:<3VXf9�X^h:<.�0 �^0>7W9�0>e51�hrXf7/ufeVX ? ]^e ]^9�= e5X&b ]^eqhr0 ]`:WT�7W0>12HOH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH F ~

~ H � } D ��] U n�eV0�3 U ]^uf0>1Lhr7WX U :<.�0\D -�C � Nf} =_]`:d]Y140>: H HfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H F

~ H ��� GQ]^9�= ��35=k:W.�%$ � 3V1/n�e5X^:4:<0>=ol&1>HL]^b>b2T�7W]^b @ Xf9 :W.�0\D -�C � N^} =�]`:d] 1W0 : Hv�0>1WT�e :<1�]^7W0�14.�X ��9 hrXf7Q:W.�0 U ] :<bd.�3V9�u �^02749�02e

�]^9�=ohrXf7Q:<.k0a0 �cn 0>b>:<0>=

e53 �`02eV35.�X&Xc= �^0>7W9�0>e H�HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH;H^HfH F �

~ H � | x_7<]^b :<35X^9�X^h U 3V9�Xf7 �^02749�02eg0 l`]^e5T_] :<35X^9�1� & � 351Qnke5X^:4:<02=�l&1>H ]`b2b2Tk7<]^b @ Xf9):<.�0D8-�C � Nf} =_] :d] 1W0>:2H -/.�0 �^02749�02ei351/b>X U n�Tk:<0>= ]^1�359o02t�T_]`:W35Xf9 ~ H � H8HfHfHfH;H^HfH F N

�k3V3

Page 13: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

��' �(��� *� �

�� �� � ��� ������

yz9 X ? �40>b>:�7402b>Xfuf9�3 :<35X^9�:<.�0a: �LX U ]^3V9 b>X U nqXf9�0>9;:<1OX^h hr0 ]`:WT�7W0[0��&:<7W]^b>:W35Xf9*]^9�= b>ep]^141W3 �

s_0>7�359�=�Tkb>:<3VXf9 ? X^:<.�.�] l^0 b2029;:W7<]^e 3 U nqXf7m:d]^9�b>0^H �I35=_]^e � {E]^t�T�0>:O]^9�= j eVe U ]^9*.�] l^0 1W.�X ��9

:<.�]`:�uf029k027W3Vb�hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1 ��3 :<.ob2X U n�eV0���b2ep]`1W1W3 s_027/3V9�=�T�b :<3VXf9 ]^9�= 359khrXf7 U ] :<3Vl^0Ehr02]`:<T�74021 ��3V:W.

e53V9�0 ]`7�b2ep]`1W1W3 s_b ] :<35X^9�b2]^9 ? X^:W.�nq027mhrXf7 U � 02eVe8X^9�X ? �402b>:[7W0>b2Xfu^9�3V:W35Xf9�:d]`1 ��1�� F F�� H ,En�n�7WX �

n�743p]`:W0 hr0 ]`:WT�7W0Y7402n�740214029;:d]`:W35Xf9k1a02]^1W0Y:W.�0 ? T�7W=k029�Xf9 :<.�0 b>ep]^141W3Vs�027 ?;@ n�74X lc3V=�359ku)uf7W02]`:<0>7

b2e5]^1W1L1W02n�]^7<]`:W35Xf9�]^9�= U 359k3 U 3��20�1m:<7WTkb>:<Tk7<]^e 74351 �

�U ] ��3V9�u 3 :Qe50>1W1/eV3 �^0>e @ :<.�]`:Q:<.k0Ob2e5]^1W143Vs_0>7

��35eVe/X lf027ms�:�:W.�0 =�]`:d]�� F � � H#yz9 14X U 0 b2]^1W0>1�hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1 :W._]`: =�X�9�X`:�e50>9�=:W.�0 U 1W0>eVl^021 :WX

7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:<]`:<3VXf9�359 ] 1W3V9�ufe50\lf0>b>:WXf7�b ]^9 ]^=�=�1W3Vuf9�3 s_b ]^9;:E=�3514b2743 U 359_] ? 35e53 : @�? Tk:\]^eVufXf7W3 :<. U 1

U T�1m: ? 0�3V9�l^029;:<0>= Xf7�]^=�]^nk:<0>= :WX�]^b2b>XfT�9;:�hrXf7/:<.�0\14:W7WT�b :<T�740\X^h :W.�0�hr0 ]`:WT�7W0\=_] :d]kH

A Xf1m:[X ? �402b :[7402b>Xfuf9�3 :<35X^9 1 @ 14:W0 U 1�:<029k=�:WX Tk1W0 023 :<.�0>7�ufe5X ? ]^e 3 U ]`uf0[hr02]`:<T�74021���.k35bd.

=�0>1Wb2743 ? 0L]`9 3 U ]^uf0 ]^1 ] ��.�XfeV0�Xf7Me5X&b ]^e^hr02]`:<Tk7W021

���.�3Vbd. 7402n�74021W0>9;:B3 U ]^uf0 n�]`:<bd.�0>1B]`:i359;:W027 �

021m:8n Xf3V9;:<1 359 :W.�0E3 U ]`uf0^H Z\eVX ? ]^e&hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1 ._] lf0�:<.�0�] ? 3Ve53 : @ :WXau^029�0>7<]^eV3��20�]`9�0>9;:<35740�X ? �402b :��3V:W.�] 14359�ufeV0al^02b :<Xf7>H\PLXf9�1402t�T�029;:We @

�:W.�023V7ET�140 359*14:d]`9�=_]^74=�b2ep]`1W1W3 s_b ] :<35X^9 :W02bd.�9�3Vt�T�021�3V1

14:W7<]^3Vuf.;:WhrXf7 �Q]`7W= HLKMX&b ]`eMhr02]`:<Tk7W021�Xf9 :W.�0[X`:<.�0>7E._]`9�=

�]^7W0ab2X U n�Tc:<02=*]`: U T�e :<35nke50OnqXf359;:W1

359�:<.k0 3 U ]^uf0 ]`9�=�]^740 b>Xf9�1402t�T�029;:We @�U Xf740 7WX ? Tk14: :WX X&b2b>e5T�1435Xf9�]^9�=�b2eVTk:W:W0272HoC�X �L0 lf027�

:<.k0 @ U ] @ 7402t�T�3V7W0 14n 0>b235]^e53 �202= b2e5]^1W143Vs_b2]`:<3VXf9 ]^e5u^Xf7W3 :<. U 1L:<X ._]^9�=ke50\b ]^14021O3V9 ��.k35bd. :W.�02740

]^740[] l`]^743p] ? eV0O9�T U ? 027�X^hihr0 ]`:WT�7W0�l^02b>:WXf7W1�nq027/3 U ]^uf0`H

yz9�=�021435uf9�3V9�u b>ep]^141W3Vs�b ]`:W35Xf9�]`e5ufXf743V:W. U 1\hrXf7 3V9�14:<]^9�b>021Y7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:W02= ?�@�U T�e :<35nke50 lf02b �

:<X^7W1�Xf9k0Yb2XfT�eV=�b2Xf9�1435=�0>7�1W0 lf027W]^e8]^n�n�74X;]^bd.�0>1

�0 ]^bd.�uf3 lc3V9�uo])=�3�� 0274029;:\e50 lf0>eBX^hQ] ? 14:W7<]^b �

:<3VXf9 H D �c351m:<3V9�u�]^e5ufX^7W3V:W. U 1L._] lf0aX^h :W029 ? 0>029 ? ]^1W0>= X^9 ? ]`uf1�X^h l^02b :<Xf741�359 ��.�3Vbd. X ? �402b>:W1

]^740 7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:W02= ?;@ T�9kXf7W=�0>7W0>=�140>:W1OX^hBlf0>b>:WXf7W1>H�-/.�351O3V1O]^b :<T_]`e5e @ t�T�3 :<0 ] 7W0>14:<7435b :<3Vl^0Y]^n��

Page 14: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

n�74X;]^bd.#]^1 359khrXf7 U ] :<35X^9�7402u;]`7W=�3V9�u�:W.�0*eVXcb2]`:<3VXf9X`h�:<.�0 lf02b :<Xf741)359�:<.�0 3 U ]^uf0 n�ep]^9k0 3V1

b2X U n�eV0>:W02e @ 3Vuf9�Xf7402= HEF�0>e5ei=�021435uf9�0>=�b2e5]^1W143Vs_b2]`:<3VXf9*1 @ 1m:<0 U 1O:W._]`:O:<] �^0 3V9;:<X)]^b>b2XfTk9�:I:<.�3V1

1Wn�]`:<35]^e/359khrX^7 U ]`:<3VXf9 ��35eVe/e53 �^02e @ nq027mhrXf7 U ? 0>:4:<027 :<.�]^9X^9�0 ? ]^1W0>= 1WXfeV02e @ Xf9�:<.�0 ? ]^u�X^h

lf0>b>:WXf7W1/]`n�n�7WXf]^bd. HB-/.�3V1 � Xf7 ��.�X �L0 lf027

�hrX&b2T�14021/]^e U X^14: 0��cb>e5T�143Vlf0>e @ Xf9)]`n�n�7WXf]^bd.�0218:<._] :

=�X 9�X^:\:d] �^0 359;:<X ]^b>b2XfTk9�:[1Wn�]`:<35]^e 359chrXf7 U ]`:<3VXf9 H[-/.�351\bd.�Xf3Vb20�351 ? ]`1W02=�Xf9�:<.�0�]^141W027m:<3VXf9

:<.�]`:\:<.�0Y:<0>bd.�9�3Vt&Tk021a0��cn�e5X^7W02=�359�:W.�351�:<.k021W3V1\b ]^9 ? 0Y:W.�0 ? ]^1W3V1�hrXf7�1 @ 14:W0 U 1a:W._]`:aTk:W35e53 �20]^=�=k3V:<3VXf9_]^ei359chrXf7 U ]`:<3VXf9 ]`n_]^74:�hr74X U :<.�3V1\] ? 14:W7<]^b :<3VXf9 H G @ hrXcb>T�1W3V9�u)Xf9�e @ Xf9�:W.�0Y1W0 :<1\X^h

lf0>b>:WXf7W1L:W.�0 U 1W0>eVl^021��L0I=�0>l^02e5X^n)][n�74X ? ] ? 35e53V14:W35bQhr7<] U 0 �LXf7 � hrXf7 ][n�74359�b>35n�eV02=�b2X U n_]^74351WX^9

? 0>: � 02029 : � X 140>:W1IX^h lf02b :<Xf741���.�35bd. hrXf7 U 1/:<.�0 ? ]^14351�X^hB] b2X U n_]`7W3514Xf9 ? 0 : �L0>029 : � X 3 U �

]^uf0>12HOF�0 :<.k029�1W.kX � .�X � :<.�3V1Ehr7W] U 0 �LX^7 � b ]^9 ? 0 0 �c:W029�=k02=�:<X)]^=k=�]^=�=�3 :<35X^9_]^eg1WX^T�7Wb>021

X^h =�3514b2743 U 359_]`:W3Vl^0I359chrXf7 U ]`:<3VXf9 H

Ncnq02b23 s_b ]`e5e @�:<.�3V1 � Xf7 � 0 �knke5Xf74021 �`02749�02eV1 ? 0>: � 02029o140>:<1 X^h l^02b>:WXf7W1>H , �`027W9k02e 3V1L]\hrT�9�b �

:<3VXf9 :<._]`: 7W0>ep]`:W021B: � X 359�nkTk:<1�T�14T_]^eVe @ ]^9 359�=k35b ] :<35X^9YX^h :<.k02357 143 U 35ep]`7W3V: @

�]^9k= 3518b20>9;:<7<]`eJ:WX

1W0 lf0>7<]^e U ]^bd.�3V9�0LeV0 ]^749�359kuO]^eVufXf7W3 :<. U 1g359kb2e5Tk=�359�uONcT�n�nqXf7m:�� 02b :<Xf7 A ]^bd.�3V9�021 � Nc02b :<3VXf9 � H | �dHG @ 1Wnq02b>3Vh @ 359ku�] �^02749�02e ? 0 : �L0>029#1W0 :<1 X^hOlf0>b>:WXf7W1 :W._]`: 351 ]^n�n�74Xfn�743p]`:W0o:WX�:W.�0*eV0 ]^749�359�u

n�74X ? e50 U nqXf1402= ?;@ e5X&b ]`e 3 U ]^uf0\hr0 ] :<T�74021�� 0 e50 lf027W]^uf0 :W.�0 0��&:W029�143Vlf0�0��c3V14:<3V9�u�eV3V:<0>7<]`:WT�7W0

Xf9 �^0>7W9�0>e � ? ]^1W0>=*eV0 ]^749�359�u � 0^H u�H � ��� � �dH

� � � � ������� � ���� � ��

yz9 nk7<]^b :<35b>0�:W.�0�uf0>9�027W]`:<3VXf9oX^hie5X&b ]^eqhr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1�3V1/b2X U�U Xf9�e @ ] : � X n_]`74:/n�74Xcb>021412H8-/.�0

s_7414:)7402t�T�3574021 ]^9�� ��� �� ������� � � ����� ��� � ��� � :<X�1W0>e502b :)nqXf359;:<1 ��3V:W.�359�:<.�0*3 U ]^uf0):<._] :)]^740

e5X&b ] :<02=�] : l&351WT�]^e5e @ =k3514:W359�b :<3 lf0 n�]`:<bd.�0>12H�-/.k0)1W02b>Xf9�=�14:W02n�uf029k027<] :<021 ]�=�0>1Wb>7W35nc:<35X^9�X^h

:<.k0Y7W02u^35Xf9�]`7WXfT�9k= :<._]`:On Xf3V9;: H\-/.�0Y=_]`:<]�n�7WX&=�T�b>02=�359 :<.�0>1W0 : � X 1m:<0>n�1\b2Xf9�14351m:<1�X^h :<.k0

e5X&b ] :<35X^9)]^9�= =�0214b27435nk:W35Xf9oX^hi:<.�0\3 U ]^u^0On_]`:Wbd.�021E]^7WX^T�9�=o:<.�0\359;:W027W0>14:�nqXf359;:<1>H

yz9;:<0274021m:on Xf3V9;: =�0 :<0>b>:<X^7W1)e5X&X ��hrXf7�l&351WT�]^e5e @ =�351m:<3V9�b>:W3Vlf0 7W0>uf35Xf9k1 359 ]^9 3 U ]^u^0^H(-/.�0

CI]`7W7W3V1�b2Xf749�027�=�0>:W02b :<Xf7�351�] 1W3 U n�eV0�0��k] U n�e50\X^h 1WT�bd.�] =�0 :<02b :<Xf7�:W.�XfT�u^.*] ��35=�0�l`]^7W3V0>: @

X^h/bd.kXf35b>021 0 �c3514:[359�:<.k0 e53 :<0>7<]`:WT�7W0 � |��������)���f} � H)-/.�0 U Xf14:a3 U nqXf74:<]^9;:[]^1Wnq02b : X^h/]^9

|

Page 15: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

359;:W027W0>14:BnqXf3V9�: =�0>:W02b :<Xf7 3V1 7402nq0 ]`:<] ? 35eV3V: @�3 H 0`H :<.�]`: :<.k0Q=�0>:W02b :<Xf7 ��3Ve5e�1W0>e50>b>: :W.�0Q1<] U 0QnqXf3V9�:

Xf9 ]^9 X ? �402b :I14T�74h ]`b20a357W740214n 0>b>:<3 lf0\X^h U 3V9�Xf7Qbd._]`9�uf021�359 e53Vuf.;:<3V9�uY]^9�= nqXf1W0 � �f~ � H yz9;:<0>7W0>14:

nqXf359;:�=�0>:W02b :<Xf741E: @ n�35b2]^e5e @ =�0 :<0>b>:Ihr02]`:<Tk7W021I]^b274Xf1W1�=�3 � 0>7W029;:E1Wb2]^e50>1�]^9�= U ] @ 359kb2Xf74n Xf7W]`:<0

] !�9�0O3V9;l^]`7W3p]`9�b20`H yz9):<.�3V1Lb ]`1W0�:W.�0O3V9�:W02740214:Qn Xf3V9;:Q=�0 :<02b :<Xf7/nk7WX l&35=�0>1/359khrXf7 U ] :<35X^9 ] ? XfTc:

:<.k0a14b ]^eV0a]^9�=o9�Xf7 U ]^eV3��>359�ua:<7<]`9�14hrXf7 U ] :<35X^9)359 ]^=�=�3 :<3VXf9 :<X�e5X&b ] :<35X^9 ��3V:W.�359�:W.�0\3 U ]^uf0^H

KgXcb2]^e 7W02u^35Xf9�1�U Xf1m:[143 U n�e @

�b2XfT�eV= ? 0�=�0214b27W3 ? 0>= ?;@ ] l^02b>:WXf7 b>Xf9�143514:W359�u X^h :<.�0�359��

:<0>9�1W3 : @ l`]^eVT�021 ]^7WX^T�9�=�:W.�0�3 U ]^uf0 n_] :<bd. H�SIh :W029�.kX � 0>l^027

�3 U ]^u^0�n�]`:<bd.�0>1 ]^7W0 359�1m:<02]^=

7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:W02= ?�@ 14:<]`:<3V14:<3Vb21QX`hg:<.�0�3 U ]^u^0Euf7W]^=�3V029;: H8PLX U�U Xf9�e @ n�74XfnqXf1W0>=�hr0 ]`:WT�7W0�=�0>1Wb>7W35n �

:<X^7W1[]^7W0�.�351m:<Xfu^7<] U 1�X^hQ:W.�0 u^7<]^=�3V029;:aXf7W3V029;:d] :<35X^9�Xf7[X`hL:<.k0 b>T�74l`]`:WT�7W0 X^hL:W.�0 3V9�:W029�143V: @

1WTk74h ]^b>0 � � ���f} � HB, ! 9k0O359;l`]^7W35]^9�b>0Ib ]`9 ? 0�]^bd.k350>l^02= ?;@ 1402e50>b>:W359�uY] ! 9k0O359;l`]^7W35]^9;:Q1m:d]`:W351 �

:<3Vb21�Xf7 ?�@ :<7W]^9�1mhrXf7 U 359�uo:<.k0 3 U ]^uf0 n_] :<bd. ?;@ :<.�0 ] !�9�0 :<7W]^9�1mhrXf7 U ]`:<3VXf9�0214:W3 U ]`:<0>=�3V9

:<.k0Y359;:<0>7W021m:\n X^359;:�=�0 :<02b :<3VXf9�n�._]^140 � � F � H � 0214n�3V:W0 :<.�0 l`]^74350>: @ X^h ]^n�nk7WX;]^bd.k021\359 :W.�0Y359��

:<0>7W0>14:En Xf3V9;:E=k0>:<0>b>:W35Xf9 14:<]^uf0�b>ep]^141W3Vs�b ]`:W35Xf9 ]^eVufXf7W3 :<. U 1 ? ]`1W02= Xf9 e5X&b ]^e hr02]`:<Tk7W021�:<0>9�= :WX

? 0a3V9��_T�0>9�b20>= U Xf740 ?�@ :W.�0\=�0214b27435nk:WXf7/:<._]^9 ?;@ :<.k0a3V9;:<0274021m:EnqXf3V9�:Q=�0>:W02b>:WXf7 � �;~ � H

7�8 7 8 7 �$+@.>� . � ������� ���-/.�0 Ncb ]`e50Yyz9;l`]^7W35]^9;:\x_0 ]`:WT�7W0Y-i7<]^9k14hrXf7 U � N&y x - � �Q]`1aX^7W35u^359_]^eVe @ nk7WXfnqXf1W0>= ?�@ KMX � 0

359 � | � �B]^9�=�740>s_9�0>=�359 � �f} � H[-/.k0Y1W3Vh :O]^e5u^Xf7W3 :<. U b>Xf9�1W3V14:W1�X^h hrXfT�7On_]`74:<1 � � � ��1Wb2]^e50 1Wn_]^b>00��&:W7W0 U ][=k0>:<0>b>:W35Xf9

�� | � �`0 @ n X^359;:QeVXcb2]^e53 � ]`:W35Xf9

�� � � Xf7435029;:<]`:<3VXf9�]^1W1435uf9 U 029;:

�]^9k= � F � �`0 @ �

nqXf359;:O=k021Wb>7W3Vnk:<3VXf9 H�-/.�0 s_7414:\1m:<02n�0 ! b>350>9�:We @ 1W02]^7Wbd.�0>1a]^b274Xf1W1�14b ]^eV0 1Wn_]`b20 :<X�s�9�=�n 02] ��1359):W.�0\uf7<]^=k35029;:�T�14359�u�]Y=�3 � 0>7W029kb20 � X^h �mZ\]^T�141W35]^9)hrT�9�b>:W35Xf9

� � ��� � � $ ��� �� � ��� � �� $ � � � � ����� � $ � � ����� ����� � � � H � �

��.�0>7W0 3V1�]�b>Xf9�1m:d]^9;: U T�e :<35nke50I3V9�=�3Vb ]`:W359�u :W.�0\1<] U n�eV359�uY7W]`:<0�3V9 14b ]^eV0�� 351Q:W.�0\b2Xf9;l^X �

e5Tc:<35X^9 Xfnq027<] :<35X^9 359 � ]^9�= ��]^9�=�� 351�] : � Xo=�3 U 029�1435Xf9�]^e Z\]^T�141W35]^9 Ha,I1\KgX �L0YnqXf359;:W1

XfTk:�:<.�0o=�3 � 0>7W029kb20 � X^h �mZ\]^T�141W35]^9�351 ] b>e5Xf140o]^n�n�74X �c3 U ]`:W35Xf9�:<X�:<.�0 KM]^n�e5]^b235]^9�X^hIZ\]^T�1 �

1W35]^9 H D �&:W7W0 U ] ]^740 1W] U nke502=�]`:[s �k0>=�1Wb ]`e5021ahrXf7 0 !�b2350>9�b @ H -/.�0�1402b>Xf9�=�14:W02n�e5X&b ]`e53��>021

Page 16: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

����������� ���� ������������ �����������! #"��$�&%'���$()��*�+,�&%-.*���(/���-�0(12*&34���5)%12�6%7�����* "8%-12�9���-�*&3�(;:�(-+;� �.��<(=(12*&34���5>%12�?���;�2� %1@:�� ��ABAC*��)�������%8*����;��%7�&%�*����5�%1��DAC���$+E%�*��@�

. ) ����� � 7�8 7�8 �I351WT�]^e53 � ]`:W35Xf9 X^hBN&y x -$hr02]`:<T�74021�359 ] U ]`7W359k0O1Wb>35029kb20a3 U ]^uf0^H

�^0 @ n Xf3V9;:<1Q:<X 1WT ? � n�3 �c0>e ]^b>b2T�7W]^b @ ]^9�= :W.�7WX ��1/XfTc:QnqXf359;:<18:<._] :/]^740I9�X^:L14:<] ? e50�eV0 ] l&359�u[T�1

��3V:W. ]�b ]^9�=k35=_]`:W0Q1W0 :8X^hq359;:<0>7W021m: n X^359;:<1>H yz9Y:<.�0/:W.�3574=Y14:<0>n�=�X U 359�]^9;:BXf7W3V029;:d] :<35X^9�1 X^hq:<.k0

�^0 @ n Xf3V9;:<1a]^7W0 hrX^T�9�= ? ]^1402=�Xf9�:<.�0Y14T�7W74XfT�9�=k359�uo3 U ]^uf0[n_]`:Wbd. H -/.�0 3 U ]^uf0[n_]`:Wbd.�021a]^740

7WX`:d]`:W02= ]^9�= 14b ]^eV02=�]^n�n�74Xfn�743p]`:W02e @ 0>e53 U 359�]`:<3V9�uE14029�143V:W3Vl&3V: @ :<X�143 U 35ep]`7W3V: @ :W7<]^9k14hrXf7 U ]`:W35Xf9k12H

-/.�0/hrXfT�7m:<. 14:W02n�3V=�029;:<3 s_02= ?;@ A 3 �^Xfe5]��4b�� @ �Y]^9�= Ncbd. U 35=Y:WX ? 0Q:<.k0 U Xf1m: 3 U n X^74:d]`9�: � �f~ �

�351/=k351Wb>T�1W1402= 359):<.�0�hrXfeVe5X ��359ku n_]^7W]^uf7<]`n�. H

-/.�0\s_9_]^eg1m:d]^uf0\X^hi:<.k0 N&y x - ]^eVufXf743V:<. U uf0>9�027W]`:<0>1�]�=�0>1Wb>7W35nc:<35X^9 X`h :W.�0\3 U ]^uf0On_] :<bd.

? ]^1402= X^9[:<.k0L3 U ]^uf0Bu^7<]^=�3V029;: ]`:i:<.�0 9�Xf7 U ]^eV3��20>=\e5X&b ]^e;3 U ]^u^0Bn_]`:<bd. H -/.�0 ufX;]^e�351M:<X�b2740 ]`:W0] 7402n�740214029;:d]`:W35Xf9 :W._]`:E351E1W3 U T�eV:<]^9�02X^T�1We @ =�351m:<3V9�b>:W3Vlf0�� 3 H 0`H�3 U ]^uf0\n_]`:Wbd.�021 ��3 :<. =k3�� 027W0>9;:]^n�nq0 ]`7<]^9�b>021 ��3Ve5e ? 0�n�e5]^b20>=�h ]^7/]^n�]^74:L359�hr0 ] :<T�740O1Wn_]`b20 �

���.�35eV0 ? 023V9�uY7WX ? T�14:/:WXYbd._]^9�uf0>1

359)3Ve5eVT U 3V9_]`:W35Xf9�]^9�=ob2] U 0>7<] nqXf1W3 :<3VXf9 H D8]^bd. n_]`:Wbd. 3V1Q=�0>1Wb2743 ? 02= ?;@ ] :<.�74020 �z=�3 U 0>9�1W3VXf9_]^e

.�3V14:<X^uf7<] U X`h�uf7<]^=k35029;: Xf7W3V029;:d]`:W35Xf9k1���.k027W0 : �LX�=�3 U 0>9�1W3VXf9�1[]^7W0 :<.�0 � ]`9�= � e5X&b ]`:W35Xf9

7W0>ep]`:W3Vl^0 :<X�:<.k0�3 U ]`uf0 n_]`:Wbd.�]^9�=�:<.k0 :W.�3574=�=�3 U 029�1435Xf9*351O:<.k0�X^7W350>9;:d]`:W35Xf9�3 :<1W0>eVh H KMX � 0

bd.�X&Xf1W0>1 � 1Wn�]`:<35]^e ? 3V9�1�]^9�= N X^7W350>9;:d]`:W35Xf9 ? 3V9�1/hrXf7�] :WX^:d]^e hr02]`:<Tk7W0ae5029ku^:<. X^h � | N H8-/.�0

F

Page 17: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

.�3V14:<X^uf7<] U 3V1[9kXf7 U ]^e53 �20>= ��3 :<.�]*Za]`T�1W143p]^9 �L0>35uf.;:<3V9�u h ] l^Xf7W3V9�u :W.�0 b>029;:<0>7 X^hQ:W.�0CF ?�@

F�uf7435= X^hB1Wn�]`:<35]^eMe5X&b ]`:W35Xf9�1>H�, l&3514T_]^e53 � ]`:W35Xf9oX^h N&y x - hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1OXf9�]`9 0��k] U n�e50a3 U ]^uf0\3V1

uf3 lf029�3V9�x 35ufTk7W0 � H � H[y U n�74X lf0 U 029;:W1a.�] l^0 ? 0>029�1WT�ufu^0214:W02=�:<._] :\b2Xf9�14351m:\X^hLTk1W359kuo]oeVXfu �

nqXfep]^781Wn�]`:<35]^e .�3V14:WXfuf7<] U 7W]`:<.k027L:W._]^9o] 7402b>:<]^9�ufTkep]^7Q.k3514:WXfuf7W] U � �;~ ��Xf7LX^hiT�14359�u 6LPL, :WX

n�74X��402b :/:<.�0O3 U ]`uf0In_] :<bd.o=�X ��9):<X ] eVX � 027/=k3 U 029�1435Xf9 ��.k35e50E7W0 :d]^3V9�359�u[=�351m:<3V9�b>:W3Vlf0>9�02141/X^h

:<.k0I3 U ]^uf0�n_] :<bd. � | F�� HB{E0 lf027m:<.�0>e50>1W1�N&y x -+hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1Q]^1Q=k021Wb>7W3 ? 0>=�.�02740�]^740O]^9�0 �&:<7W0 U 0>e @

nqXfn�T�e5]^7O7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:<]`:<3VXf9�:<._] :\._]^1�nq0274hrX^7 U 02= � 02e5e 359�1W3V=�0 ?;@ 1435=�0Yb>X U n�]^7W3V1WXf9�1IX^h8e5X&b ]^e

hr0 ] :<T�740a=k021Wb>7W3Vnk:<Xf741 � �;~ � HByz9;:<0>7W0>14:<3V9�ufe @�b2eVT�14:W0274359�u Ncy x -(hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1/:<029k=�1/:<X�uf7WXfTknol&3V1WT_]^e

n�743 U 3V:<3 lf0>1L:<._] :�b2Xf747W0214n X^9�= :WX :W.�0\1<] U 0�X ? �40>b>:En_]^7m: � � | � H

� ��� � ������ � � � � � � � ! � ������ �NcT�n�nqXf7m: � 0>b>:WXf7 A ]^bd.�3V9�021 � N � A 1 �B]^740/b2e5]^1W143Vs_0>7W1B:<._] : 1W02n�]^7<]`:W0/: �LX[b2ep]`1W1Bn�74X ? e50 U 1�

��3V:W.�] U ]��c3 U T U U ]^7Wu^359�. @ nq0274n�ep]^9k0 � ��� � H yz9�:<.�0 b ]^140 :<.�]`:[:W.�0 =�]`:d] ]^7W0 1W02n�]^7<] ? e50�

:<.k0 ]^eVufXf743V:<. U b>X U nkTk:<0>1 ]o. @ nq0274n�ep]`9�0�:W._]`:[1W0>n_]^7<] :<021\:<.k0 =_] :d] ��.�35eV0 U ]��c3 U 3��>359�u 3V:W1=�3V14:d]`9�b20 :WX*:<.k0�9�0 ]`7W021m: =_]`:<]*n X^359;: H , U 0>bd._]^9�3Vb ]^e ]^9_]^eVXfu @ 351a:<._] : : � X�. @ nq027Wnkep]^9�0>1

:<.�]`:B]^740Lb>Xf9�14:W7<]^3V9�02=[:<X ? 0Qn_]^7W]^e5eV02e�]^740Ln�e5]^b20>= ? 0>: � 02029Y:W.�0Q0��c0 U n�e5]^7W1 X^h_:<.k0 : � X�b2ep]`1W1W0>1

��3V:W.�] 14n�7W3V9�u�n�Tk1W.�3V9�u :<.k0 U ]^n_]^7m: H�-/.�02140 : �LX�. @ nq027Wnkep]^9�0>1Ob ]`9�9�X^:�n�]^1W1�:<.�74XfT�uf.�]`9 @

0��c0 U n�e5]^7Yhr7WX U 023V:W.�027�b2e5]^1W1>H+SO9�b>0 :<.k0 14n�7W3V9�u�.�]^1 0 �cn_]^9�=�0>=+]^1 h ]^7�]^1�n Xf141W3 ? e50�:<.k0

n�e5]^9�0 U 35= �L] @ ? 0>: � 020>9 :W.�0O: �LX n�e5]^9�0>1�]^9�=)n_]^7W]^e5eV02eJ:<X :W.�0 U 3V1L:<.k0�=�02b>351W3VXf9 ? XfT�9�=_]`7 @ H

-/.�3V1L351L]^e514X[:W.�0On�e5]^9�0E:W._]`: ? 351402b>:W1L:<.k0I1W.kXf74:W0214:�eV359�0�1W0>u U 029;: ? 0>: � 020>9 :W.�0Ib>Xf9;lf0��).&Tke5e51

X^hQ:W.�0 : �LX b>ep]^141W0>12H yz9�:<.k0 b ]`1W0 :W._]`:a:<.�0 =_]`:<]*]^740 9�X`: 1402n_]^7W] ? eV0�� 0 3V9;:<7WX&=�T�b>0 14ep]^b �

l`]^7W35] ? eV021� ��� � :<X�]^e5eVX �(hrX^7/1WX U 0�359�b>Xf7W7402b :<e @ b2ep]`1W1W3 s_02=o0 �k0 U nkep]^7412H

A Xf740�hrXf7 U ]`e5e @�:W.�0 nk7WX&b202=kT�7W0 hrXf7�b2X U n�Tc:<359kuo:W.�0 U ]��k3 U 3 �23V9�u�. @ n 0>7Wn�e5]^9�0�=�0>s_9k02=

?;@

� ?12�=����%�,��( �*��>%* �/'2�.%�� + �<� (-(��2�-* �2���;��( �(8�����2��* �-�,A>��D��� ��5�3=* ���C( : ������56*�"23412<+71B� �� ���A2��� �;��AC�,��%*�"@%-12�6�C'���� * �%�� �,+ %*��=���-� �)�;3=* �����!��* �)�������2�-*�� +71��,( ���+;�.'�AC�4* �2���C( �!��$(�%?+ �<� (-( � +;�&%-�* �"! #�$�% :�������-34<( �+ �<��((���+;��%�* ��! &('�% :�����A �,��-* �?+ *���-�,+ %��2� * 'C%��2'C% + *CAC�$()!+*-,�% �

~

Page 18: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

��� ��� ����� � } � � H | ���.�0>7W0 �����

�����

�351�uf3 lf0>9 ? 02eVX �

�]^9�= �� ��� � 3V1O:<.�0Y3V9�9�0>7�n�7WX&=�T�b : H[F�0 =�0>s�9�0

� ������������� ��� :<X ? 0 :W.�0�0 �k0 U nkep]^741�]^9k= � � � � ������ :<.k0 b2e5]^1W1 ep] ? 02eV12H � 351[uf3Vl^029�3V9

:<0>7 U 1�X^h 3 :<1/0 �kn�]^9�1W3VXf9

� ���

��� �� � � � � � � � H � �?;@ :<.k0\hrX^e5e5X ��3V9�u t�T_]^=�7W]`:<3Vb\n�7WXfu^7<] U�U 3V9�u nk7WX ? eV0 U �

U 3V9�3 U 3��>0���� � � ! � ��� ��� �"�$# �&% ���� ��� � � H F �

1WT ? �402b :E:WX � � � �'� ��� � �(�$� �*) � � ��� � + � ��������� ��, � � H ~ �]^9k= ��� ) } � + � ������������, � � H �

F�0ab2]^9 359)h ]^b>: U ]��c3 U 3��>0E:W.�0aKi]`uf7<]^9kuf3p]^9)=kT_]^e�359 ��.�35bd.o:<.k0 � � =�351W]^n�nq0 ]^7 �

U ]��c3 U 3 �20.-0/2103 % ���� � � � �4% �

��� %�5 � � � � 5

� � � 5 � � � � � 5 � � � H � �14T ? �40>b>:�:<X }76

� � 698� hrX^7�]^e5e + � ��������� ��,�

� � H N �]^9�= % �

��� � � � � � }:� � � H � �

��.�0>7W0�02]^bd.� � 351 ] KM]^uf7<]`9�uf3p]`9 U TkeV:<3Vn�e53V027>H�-/.�0�=�0>b23V1W35X^9�hrT�9�b :<35X^9�3V:W1W0>eVh/b2]^9�:<.k029 ? 0

��7W3 :W:W029]^1 ] � 023Vuf.;:<0>=14T U X^hE359�9�0>7 n�7WX&=�T�b :<1 ��.�02740 :W.�0 �L0>35uf.;:W1 b>Xf7W74021WnqXf9�=�:<X�:<.k0

KM]^uf7W]^9�uf35]^9 U T�e :<35nke5350>7W1

; � � � �=<�>@? ���

��� � � � � � ����� � �"��� � � � H � } �

x_Xf7 ]^=�=�3 :<35X^9_]^e�=�0 :d]^3Ve518Xf9 :W.�0EhrX^7 U T�e5]`:<3VXf9 X^h :W.�0It�T_]^=k7<]`:W35b�n�7WXfu^7<] U�U 3V9�u�n�74X ? e50 U�:<.k0

7W02]^=�0>7I351�7W0 hr02747W02= :<X � ��� � H�GLT�74uf021I]^e514X nk7WX l&35=�0>1O]^9�]`b2b20>1W143 ? eV0a:WTk:<Xf743p]^eg3V9;:<7WX&=�T�b :<3VXf9 :WX

NcT�nkn Xf7m: � 02b>:WXf7 A ]^bd.�3V9�021 � � H

Page 19: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

, �^0 @ hr0 ] :<T�740�X^h�:<.�3V1[hr7W] U 0 �LX^7 ��3V1[:W._]`: :W.�0�359k9�027 nk7WX&=�T�b>:�� � � � � 5 � 359�02t�T_] �

:<3VXf9 � � H � � b ]^9 ? 0[7402n�e5]^b20>= ��3V:W.*] hrT�9�b :<35X^9_]^e� � �� �

�:<._]`:�3V1�0>t�T�3Vl`]^eV029;:E:WX ] =�X^:En�74Xc=��

T�b :\359 14X U 0 1Wn_]^b>0� � � � ��� 5 � � ��� � � � � ��� � � 5 � � H\-/.�0Ybd.�Xf3Vb20 � � � ��� 5 � � � � � � � 5 � 3V1

:<.k0�1W3 U n�eV021m: 14T�bd.�]^1W1435uf9 U 029;: ��.k027W0 � 0�n�e5]^b20 ] 1W0>n_]^7<] :<359ku . @ nq0274n�ep]`9�0�359�:<.�0�X^7W35u^3 �

9_]^ei1Wn�]^b20�? Tk:�3V9*uf0>9�027W]^e

�:<.k0 n�7W0 �z3 U ]^u^0a3V9*:<.k0 Xf7W3Vuf359�]^e hr0 ] :<T�740 1Wn_]`b20 X^hB:W.�0 =k02b23V1W3VXf9

? XfT�9�=_]`7 @ 9�0>02= 9�X^: ? 0�e53V9�0 ]^7>H ,I1�]Y1W3 U nke50I0 �k] U nke50�3 U ]^uf359k0E:<.�]`:�XfT�7/=_] :d] ]^7W0�3V9 � � H

, U ]`n�n�359ku

� � � � �������

� � � | � ���� ��

����� � � H ��� �

b2X^7W7W0>1WnqXf9�=�1�:<X�]Y1W3 U nke50Ob>X U nkTk:d]`:W35Xf9 �

� � � ��� 5 � � � � � � 5 � � � � H � | �

F#.�0>9 T�1402=�359�]�N&T�n�nqXf74: � 0>b>:<X^7 A ]^bd.�359k0�:W.�0 �^0>7W9�0>e ��3Ve5eLs�9�= ]�1402n_]^7W]`:<3V9�u�. @ nq027 �

n�e5]^9�0 3V9�:<.k0 :<7W]^9�14hrX^7 U 02=�1Wn�]^b20���.k35bd.�b2X^9�1W3V14:<1 X^h�:<.�0�nqX �L0>7Y1W0 :YX^h � H�F#.�35eV0�:W.�02740

351I9�Xoe5359k0 ]^7E1WXfeVTk:<3VXf9 :<X�:W.�0 �ES�v n�7WX ? e50 U � s�ufT�7W0 � H | ��:<.k0 � � � � � � � ��� � � � � �� ����� ��� �

� �� ����� � 02t�T_] :<35X^9 � � H � | � �B351/e53V9�0 ]`7We @ 1402n_]^7W] ? eV0�359�:<.k0O:<7<]`9�14hrXf7 U 0>=o1Wn_]^b>0^H8x_T�74:W.�027 U X^7W0�

:<.k0 1W3 U nke53Vs�02= b2X U n�Tk:<]`:<3VXf9*]`e5e5X ��1�T�1I:WX 0 ! b>350>9�:We @ b ]`e5b2Tkep]`:W0a:W.�351�. @ nq0274n�ep]`9�0 ��3 :<.�XfTc:0��cn�eV35b>3V:<e @ b ]`e5b2Tkep]`:W359�uY:<.k0[:<7W]^9�1mhrXf7 U ]`:<3VXf9

�� HINc3 U 35e5]^7We @

��L0 7402n�e5]^b20\:<.k0 359k9�027En�7WX&=�T�b :

��3V:W. ] �`02749�02ei0>l`]^eVT_]`:<3VXf9�3V9o:W.�0\=�02b>351435Xf9)hrT�9�b :<3VXf9#� 02t�T_] :<35X^9�� � H � } � �<HF�0 b ]^9 14020 :W._]`:OX^T�7Ibd.�X^35b20 X^h �^0>7W9�0>eB]^eVe5X ��1ETk1I:<X)]`=�= 9�Xf9 �ze53V9�0 ]`7W3V: @ :WX�] =k02b23V1W3VXf9

hrT�9�b :<3VXf9 ?;@ b>X U nkTk:<3V9�ua]aeV359�02]^7 =�0>b2351435Xf9 ? XfT�9�=_]`7 @ 3V9 ]�:<7W]^9�14hrX^7 U 02= 1Wn_]`b20^H -/.�3V1 1Wn_]^b>0

351 X^h :<0>9�.�35uf.k027 =k3 U 029�1435Xf9_]`e8:W._]^9�:<.k0�Xf7W3Vuf359�]^e 359�n�Tc: hr0 ] :<T�740)1Wn_]^b>0^H�x_Xf7 0 ��] U n�eV0�3V9

02t�T_] :<35X^9� � H ��� ��l^02b>:WXf7W1�359 � � ._] lf0 ? 0>029�:<7<]`9�14hrXf7 U 0>=�:<X�e53V0�359 ��� H A 0>7Wb20>7�� 1�:W.�02X �

7W0 U :W02eVe51ITk1 ��.�029�] �^0>7W9�0>e 351I02t�T�3Vl`]^eV029;:I:WXo]^9�359k9�027En�7WX&=�T�b :�359�] :W7<]^9k14hrXf7 U 0>=�1Wn_]^b>0

� � � %-12<( +,� (��: %1�� +;* � �2'C%7�&%-.*�� <(B� "�'2��+E%-�* � * "���� ��2���;� ���*CAC'�+ %;: ��'C% %12<( �(B�2*�% �2�$+ �,(-(-���-5 ��� �,�2�;�7��� �

Page 20: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

−1 −0.8 −0.6 −0.4 −0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

�����0 ?12������� ���*��2���;� <( �2*�% ����2�,� ���5( ������7�����.� ������5 ( ������7�&%-.��� 1�5 � �;���2�<���2��(�����*�� +71�34���� "����� * � %1��(4A��&%-�2�

−1−0.5

00.5

11.5

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

�����/ ?12� A2�&%7� � �� ( ������7���2���)�� %-12� �,� ����$A2AC��2� ( ��� + � ��� *�%� %1��&% %12� %�3=* ��� ���� �2���$( * "/�$� +71 + �<� (-( ��* %1 ���������$A %-*%12�4(-���)����*�.��%!AC'2�=%*>( 5��)�)�;%�-.�$(@��9%1��A2�&%7�C�

��+$�D ?12� ����,.��� � �/*�"4%-12��(�,+ *���A AC�,� �-�;���*���5���* �)<��� � �,����;��<( 1�5 � �;�-��*����+=� �,+,��'�(��2* <(� 3?� ( � A2AC�$A>%*�%1��=+;*�*��-A2.���&%�$( �2�-�* �%* +;* � �2'2%-�&%-�* �@�0� � %12� ��.�).%,:@%12<(D34�������2� + %��5 �����%.%�* � %-12� ( ��� +;� ���%*��'���A ��-� ��%-(;�

. ) ����� � 7�8 :*8 -/.k0 �ES�v n�74X ? e50 U 351/9kX^:�e5359k0 ]^74e @ 1W02n�]^7<] ? e50\359):<.k0ahr02]`:<T�740\1Wn_]^b>0�? Tk:�3V1

1W0>n_]^7W] ? e50\3V9�:<.�0\0 U ? 0>=�=�359ku 14n_]^b20`H

N

Page 21: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

��3V:W.�XfTk: 7W02t�T�3V7W3V9�u�T�1 :<X�0 �cn�e53Vb23V:We @ hrXf7 U T�ep] :<0 :W.�0�:<7W]^9�1mhrXf7 U ]`:<3VXf9�]`1 �L0o=�3V=�359�02t�T_] �

:<3VXf9 � � H ��� �dH A 0>7Wb20>7�� 1�:W.�02X^7W0 U 14:d] :<021/:W._]`:/:<X ufT�]^7<]^9;:W020�:<._] : � � ����� �8351/02t�T�3 l`]^e50>9�:/:WX� � � � � ��� � ��� � � � 3 H 0`H :<._]`:�3 :�351�]^9o359k9�027�n�74Xc=�Tkb>:�359o1WX U 0�14n_]^b20��

�3V:�3V1/9�02b>02141<]^7 @ ]`9�=

1WT ! b>350>9�:�:<.�]`:/:<.�0\b>Xf9�=�3 :<35X^9

�8�8 � � ����� � > � � � > � ��� ��� � � ��� ) } � � H � � �

? 0 l^]`e535= hrX^7\]^e5e > ����� � # ����.�0>7W0 # 3V1\]ob>X U n_]^b>:\14T ? 140>:[X^h ��� � F � � H�Nc3 U n�e @ 14:d] :<02=

�]^9 @ nqXf1W3 :<3 lf0�=�0 s_9�3V:W0�hrT�9�b>:W35Xf9o3V1/02t�T�3Vl`]^eV029;:�:<X�]Y=�X^:�n�74Xc=�Tkb>:�359o14X U 0\14n_]^b20`H

Nc0>l^027W]^e 3 U nqXf74:<]^9;:�b2e5]^1W14021IX`h A 0>7Wb20>7 �^0>7W9�0>e51E._] lf0 ? 020>9 =�0 lf02eVXfnq02=*hrXf7/l^02b>:WXf7I=�]`:d]kH

F�0)._] lf0 1W020>9 ]`9�0 �k] U nke50�X^hI]�n X^e @ 9�X U 3p]^e �`027W9k02e�359�:W.�0)n�7W0>b20>=�359�u�n_]^7W]^uf7W]^n�.�1>H�yz9

uf0>9�027W]^e�

�� � � � ��� 5 � � � � � � ��� 5 ��� � � � � � H � F �351Q:W.�0�:<. =�0>uf7W0>0anqXfe @ 9kX U 35]^e �^02749�02e H -/.�0[=k02uf74020aX^h :W.�0\n X^e @ 9�X U 3p]^eq=�0 :<027 U 3V9�021 ��.k35bd.nqX � 02741oX^h X^T�7)Xf7W3Vuf359�]^e�1Wn_]^b>0 ��35e5e ? 0�7402n�740214029;:<0>=�359+:W.�0�.�35u^.�027�=k3 U 029�1435Xf9_]`eI1Wn�]^b20`H

� ]`:<] :<._] :\]^7W0 9�X^:�1402n_]^7W] ? eV0Y359 eVX �wXf74=�027E:<027 U 1IX^h :<.�0>357InqXfe @ 9kX U 35]^eM0��cn_]^9k1W35X^9�1 U ] @

? 0[1402n_]^7W]`:<0>= 359 .�3Vuf.�027�Xf74=�027�:<0>7 U 12HQF�0 ]^=k= � :WX :W.�0[=kX^:Ink7WX&=�T�b>:I359 02t�T_]`:W35Xf9�� � H � F �359)X^7W=�0>7Q:<X 359�b>Xf7WnqXf7W]`:<0I:W.�0�e5X � 027�Xf74=�027Q:W027 U 1/359)X^T�7/1Wn_]`b20a]^1 � 02e5e HBy :�351Q3 U nqXf7m:d]^9;:L:WX

9�X^:W0�.�X �L0 lf027

�:<._] :O3V:E351�t�T�3V:W0 02]^1 @ :<X�X l^0274sk:\]^1 � 0 b2]^9 U ] �^0 l^027 @ b>X U nke50�� =k02b23V1W3VXf9

? XfT�9�=_]`7W350>1 ?;@ 1W0>:4:<3V9�uY:<.�0\0��cnqXf9�0>9�:�:<X&X .�35u^. H

,I9�X`:<.�0>7�3 U n Xf7m:d]^9;:E0��k] U n�e50 X^h ] h ] U 3Ve @ X^h A 0>7Wb>027 �^0>7W9�0>e51\351E:<.�0 Z\]^T�141W35]^9�7<]^=k3p]^e

? ]^14351BhrT�9�b :<3VXf9 � vEGLx � �^0>7W9�0>e HB,$Za]`T�1W143p]^9 vEGLx �`027W9k02eq7W0>:WT�7W9k18:WX ]\b2Xf9k14:d]`9�:8h ]^b :<Xf7B:<.k0

0>l`]^eVT_]`:W35Xf9�X^hQ] �>027WX � U 0 ]^9�Za]`T�1W143p]^9�]`:[] nqXf3V9�:\u^3Vlf0>9 ?;@ :<.k0 =�3 � 0>7W0>9�b20 ? 0 : �L0>029�: � Xlf0>b>:WXf7W1>H

�� � � � � � 5 � �� �������������������� ��� � � � � H � ~ �-/.�0a=�02u^7W020\X^h 1 U X&X^:<.�3V9�u

� $ � =�0>:W027 U 3V9�021�]`: ��._] :�1Wb ]`e50 �L0ab2X U n_]`7W0O:<.k0a=�]`:d]kH

Page 22: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

��' �(��� *� ��(����� ���#��'� �� �� �� �+ � *��� % �&�' ���#���#� �) ����$�+ ��

v�0>b ]^eVe&:W._]`: �L0Q]^7W0 359;:<0>7W021m:<0>=Y359 bd._]`7<]^b :<02743��>359�uE3 U ]^uf021 ?;@ n Xf141W3 ? e @ l`]^7 @ 3V9�uI9�T U ? 02741X^hMeVXcb2]^eqhr02]`:<Tk7W021>H - XYb>X U n�]^7W0O3 U ]`uf021

�� 0 �LX^T�e5=)eV3 �^0�:<X b>Xf9�1435=�0>7 �^02749�02e hrT�9�b>:W35Xf9k1L:<._] :

b2X U n_]`7W0\1WT�bd.*1W0>:W1EX`h e5X&b ]`e hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1E3V9): �LX 3 U ]^uf021>HLv�02b>029;:<e @�l`]^7W3VXfT�1Q:W02bd.�9�3Vt�T�021O.�] l^0

? 02029 n�7WXfnqXf1402= hrX^7 �`027W9k02e51 ? 0 : �L0>029)140>:<1 X^h l^02b>:WXf7W1 � � ~�|f~�F �F ~�� � � H8SOh :<.�0>1W0

��^0>7W9�0>e

n�74359�b>35n_]^e&]^9kufe50>1 � F ��:<.�0LGL._]`:4:d]^bd.�]^7 @�@ ] �`027W9k02e � |f~ �

�]^9k= :<.�0 U ]`:Wbd.�359�u �^0>7W9�0>e � F ~ ��.�] l^0

7W0>b20>3Vlf0>=o1WX U 0O]`:4:<0>9�:W35Xf9 H Nc35=k0 ?;@ 1435=�0Eb2X U n_]^743514Xf9�1 ? 0>: � 020>9o1WX U 0IX^hg:W.�02140\]^n�n�74X;]^bd.�0>1

��3V:W. 740214n 0>b>:8:<Xa3 U ]^uf0Q7402b2X^uf9�3V:W35Xf9�]^740�] l`]^3Vep] ? e50L3V9 � � F �q]^9�= � �5� � H Z�7<]`T U ]`9 ]`9�= � ]`7W7W0>e5e

]^eV1WX hrX^7 U T�e5]`:<0a] h ]^14:O]^e5ufX^7W3V:W. U hrXf7�b2X U n�Tc:<359ku ] �`02749�02ei:<._]`: ? 02]^7W1E1WX U 0a7W02140 U ? ep]^9�b>0

:<X 0��c351m:<3V9�u �`027W9k02e51�� �5� � H)F�0 =�0>1Wb2743 ? 0 02]^bd.�X^hQ:W.�0 U ]��4Xf7�:<0>bd.�9�3Vt&Tk021Y359�:<.�0�hrXfe5eVX ��359�u

1W0>b>:W35Xf9�1�]^9�=(0>l`]^eVT_]`:<0�14X U 0�X^ha:<.k02357obd._]`7<]^b :<0274351m:<35b>1 3V9+:<.�0�b2Xf9;:W0��&:*X`h e5X&b ]`eO3 U ]^uf0

hr0 ] :<T�740212H

� � � ! � � ��� � � � � � �� � � � � �PLep]^141W3 s_b ]`:W35Xf9a]^eVufXf743V:<. U 1qhrXf7 U T�e :<35nke50 l^02b :<Xf741 3V9�b2eVT�=�0 :<.kXf1W08uf029k027<] :<02=\hrXf7 :W.�0 U T�eV:W3 �

359k14:d]`9�b20 e50 ]`7W9�3V9�u nk7WX ? eV0 U � ����� ~ �

���.k35bd. �L]^1 =k0>lf0>e5Xfnq02=�:WX*n�7402=�3Vb>:a:<.�0 ? 0>._] l&35Xf7aX^h

b ]`9�=�35=�]`:<0�bd.k0 U 35b ]`e51[hrX^7 n�._]`7 U ]^b20>Tk:<3Vb ]^eV12H�-/.�3V1 hrXf7 U T�ep]`:W35Xf9�.�X � 0>l^027

�14:<]`:<0>1 :<._] : ]

1W0 : X^h/lf0>b>:WXf7W1Y3V1 b2Xf9k1W35=k027W0>=�:<X ? 02eVXf9�u*:WX�] b2e5]^1W1 3 h�]`: eV0 ]^1m:YXf9�0 U 0 U ? 0>7[l^02b>:WXf7Y351 ]

U 0 U ? 027[X^hQ:<.k0�b2e5]^1W1 � X^9�e @ Xf9�0�lf0>b>:<X^7 9�020>=�359�=k35b ] :<0 U 0 U ? 0>7W1W.k35n ��.k35e50 :<.k0�7W0>14:Yb2]^9

? 0 l&3V0�� 02=�]^1�9�Xf3V1W0�Xf7�3V7W7402e50 l`]^9;: HYKgX&b ]^eihr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1ahrXf7I3 U ]^uf0 b>ep]^141�7W02b>Xfuf9�3 :<3VXf9

�Xf9�:<.k0

X^:W.�027/._]`9�=�b ]`9 U ] �`0aTk1W0\X^h U ]^9 @ lf02b :<Xf741E3V9�:<.�0\140>:E]`:/Xf9kb20^H8D8]^bd.olf02b :<Xf7�Xf1m:<0>9�1W3 ? e @

b2X^7W7W0>1WnqXf9�=�1�:<X ] b>X U nqXf9�0>9;:IX^h :<.�0aX ? �40>b>:�:<X ? 0ab2e5]^1W143Vs_0>=�]^9�= 3V:�351/:<.k351�b2XfeVe502b :<3VXf9)X^h

� }

Page 23: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

b2X U nqXf9�0>9�:W1L:<.�]`:Q3V9�=�35b2]`:<0>1Lb>ep]^141 U 0 U ? 02741W.�3Vn HByz9�b2e5]^1W143Vh @ 359ku X ? �40>b>:W1�]^1 ? 02e5X^9�uf359kua:WXY]

b2e5]^1W1�:W.�0Ink7W0214029�b>0OX^hg3 U ]`uf0/hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1 hr7WX U U ]^9 @ =�3 � 0>7W0>9�: nqXf359;:<18Xf9�:<.�0EX ? �402b :Q14T�74h ]^b>0

]^740 3V9�=�35b2]`:<3 lf0)X^hIb2e5]^1W1 U 0 U ? 027W14.�35n�9�X^:�:<.k0 n�740214029�b>0 X^hOX^9�e @ X^9�0 X`hI:<.k021W0 hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1

]^eVXf9�0^HQG @ Tk:<3Ve53��>359�u[:<.�0[1W0>:EX^h l^02b :<Xf741O359 3V:W1�0>9;:<35740>: @�� 0 b ]`9*b2X^9�14:W7WT�b :Ob2e5]^1W143Vs_0>7W1�:<._] :

]^740 7WX ? T�14:O:WX)n_]^7m:<3p]`eiX&b2b>e5T�1435Xf9 ]^9�=�b2e5]^1W1El^]`7W3p] ? 35eV3V: @ HIPLXf9�1402t�T�0>9�:We @ :W.�351 �^02749�02eB3V1I9�X`:

]^n�nk7WXfn�743p]`:W0a:WX :<.k0Y]^n�n�eV35b2]`:<3VXf9 X`h 3 U ]^uf0ab2ep]`1W1W3 s_b ] :<35X^9*]^1 U ]^9 @ l&3514T_]^e b>T�021�14.�XfT�eV= ? 0

0 U n�eVX @ 02= 7<]`:W.�027Q:W._]^9 �4T�14:�Xf9k0^H

� ��� � � � � � � ��� �� ��� � ��� � ��R�027W9k02ein�7W3V9�b23Vn_]^eg]^9kufe50>1 �L]^1I] U X^9�uY:<.�0as_7W1m: �`027W9k02e51 ? 0>: � 02029�140>:W1IX^h lf02b :<Xf741E:WX ? 0

n�74Xfn X^1W02= � F � H -/.�3V1I:<0>bd.�9�3Vt&Tk0�b>X U n�Tk:<0>1a] �^02749�02e ? ]^1W0>=�Xf9�nk7W359kb235nke50Y]^9kufe50>1 ? 0 : �L0>029

:<.k0 1WT ? 1Wn_]^b>021\1Wn�]^9�9�0>= ?;@ :<.�0 nk7WX��40>b>:<3VXf9�1OX`hB:<.�0 l^02b>:WXf7W1�3V9 0 U ? 0>=�=�359ku�1Wn_]`b20�� � � � �dH

GL0>b ]^T�140 :<.�0*1WT ? 14n_]^b>021 ]^7W0*b2Xf9�1m:<7W]^359�0>= :<X ? 0�]`: U X^14:�=k3 U 029�1435Xf9_]`e53V: @ 02t�T_]^e�:<X�:<.k0

9�T U ? 027/X^hMl^02b>:WXf7W1�3V9 :<.�0�14n_]^b>0�:<.k0\]^Tk:<.kXf7W1Q74021m:<7W3Vb>:Q:W.�0 �^0>7W9�0>e :<X l^02b>:WXf7�1W0 :<1/X^hi02t�T_]`e

b ]`7W=�3V9_]^e53 : @�� H -/.�0 �^02749�02eM3 :<1W0>eVh 351/=�0 s_9�0>= :<X ? 0

�� � ��� � � ��

��� b2Xf1 �� � �

� � | H � �

��.�0>7W0� � 351O:W.�0 + :W.�nk7W359kb235n�]^e ]^9kufe50 ? 0>: � 020>9�:W.�0 1WT ? 1Wn_]^b>021>HY-/.�0 n�7W3 U ]^7 @ �L02] ��9�02141W021

X^h :W.�0a7W021m:<7435b>:W35Xf9o:<X 1W0 :<1IX`h 02t�T_]`e b2]^7W=�3V9_]^eV3V: @�]`9�= :W.�0[7402e5]`:<3 lf02e @ nqXcXf7�nq027mhrXf7 U ]^9�b>0[3V9

b2X U n_]`7<]`:W3Vlf0I14:<Tk=�350>1 � � F�� 1WT�ufu^0214:�:W._]`:/:<.k351 �^0>7W9�0>eg351/X^h e53 U 3 :<0>= T�140\:WX 3 U ]^uf0Ib>ep]^141W3 s_b ] �

:<3VXf9 H

� ��� � ���� � � � �� �� � � � � � �-/.�0�GL.�]`:W:<]^bd._]^7 @&@ ] �^02749�02e �Q]^1Ln�7WXfnqXf1402= ?;@ R�Xf9k=�Xf7 ]^9�= �f0 ? ]^7<][:WX n_]^7W] U 0>:<7435b2]^e5e @

7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:�:W.�0 =_] :d] 3V9*0 ]`bd.�1W0>:OX^hBlf0>b>:<X^7W1�]^9�= :<.k029 T�140 GL._]`:4:d]^bd.�]^7 @�@ ] � 1\] !�9�3 : @ � 1W0>0

1W0>b>:W35Xf9 � H � hrXf7 U X^7W0o=�0>:<]^35eV1 � ? 0>: � 02029 :W.�Xf140*n_]^7W] U 0>:<7435bo7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:<]`:<3VXf9�1 ]^1�:W.�0 �^027 �

���

Page 24: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

9�0>e � |f~ � HENcn 0>b23 s_b ]^eVe @��`02749�02e 6LPL, � F } � 3V1ETk1W02= :<X sk:�]�Z\]^T�141W35]^9 :WX�] 140>:�X`h lf0>b>:<X^7W1O3V9

]^9 0 U ? 02=�=k359�ua1Wn_]`b20I3V9�=�T�b>02= ?�@ :W.�0Ebd.kXf35b>0EX^h ]^9�]`=�=�3V:W35Xf9�]^e�1W0>n_]^7W]`:<0 �^0>7W9�0>e���9�X ��9)]`1

] U 3V9�Xf7 �`02749�02e H8-/.k0[]`Tk:<.�X^7W1�1W.�X ��.kX �$:<X b2X U n�Tc:<0\GL._] :W:d]`bd._]^7 @�@ ] � 1E] !�9�3 : @)? 0 : �L0>029Z\]^T�1W143p]^9k183V9 b2e5X^1W02= hrXf7 U

���.k35bd.�]`e5e5X ��1 hrX^780 �k]^b>:8b2X U n�Tc:d]`:W35Xf9YX^h :<.�0 �`027W9k02e H C�X �L0 lf027

�:<.k351/7W0>t�T�3574021�1W0>l^027W]^e U ]`:W7W3 ��3V9�l^02741W35X^9�1

�]^9k= :W.�0�:<02bd.k9�35t�T�0a351�] U Xf9�uY:W.�0 U Xf1m:�b2X U n�T��

:d] :<35X^9_]^e5e @ =�0 U ]^9�=k359�u�? 0>359�u b2T ? 35b�3V9o:W.�0�9�T U ? 027�X^hilf0>b>:<X^7W1�n 0>7/1W0>: ��.�3Ve50 U Xf14:�X`:<.�0>7

:<0>bd.�9�3Vt&Tk021 ]^740 t�T_]^=�7W]`:<3Vb�U ] ��3V9�u*3 : 3 U n�7W]^b>:W35b2]^e hrXf7aep]^74uf0 140>:W1 X^hQl^02b>:WXf7W1Y=k021Wnk3V:<0 3V:W1

7W0>ep]`:W3Vl^02e @ .�3Vuf.on 0>74hrXf7 U ]^9kb20�359ob>X U n�]^7<]`:W3Vl^0O:<021m:<1 � � F � H

� ��� ! ��� � ���-��� � � � �-/.�0 A ]`:<bd.k359�u[R�027W9k02e �Q]`18nk7WXfnqXf1W0>= 3V9 � F ~ �_:<Xa._]^9�=�eV0/1W0 :<1LX`h l^02b>:WXf7W187W0>1WT�e :<3V9�u�hr7WX U

359;:W027W0>14: n Xf3V9;: =�0 :<0>b>:<X^7W1Y]^9k=�e5X&b ]^eB3 U ]`uf0 =�0214b27W3Vnk:<X^7W12H , 140>: X`h/hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1 7W0>1WT�e :<1ahr7WX U

:<.k0Ye5X&b ]^ei=�0214b27435nk:WXf7W1 ��.�3Vbd.�]^7W0 :W.�029�:W7W0 ] :<02=�]^1�140>:W1�X^h lf02b :<Xf741\=�0214b27W3 ? 359ku�:<.�0Y3 U ]^u^0^H

-/.�0 �`02749�02e b2Xf9�14351m:<1QX^hg] � � ��� � �� ��������.�35bd.)3V1 b>X U n�Tk:<0>= ? 0>: � 02029o3V9�=�3Vl&3V=�T_]^e�l^02b>:WXf7W1

�]^9�= ]�hrT�9�b>:W35Xf9 hrXf7Bb>X U ? 3V9�359�u�:W.�0�7W0214T�eV:W1 X`h :W.�0 U 359kXf7 �^0>7W9�0>e 0 l`]^e5T_] :<35X^9�1 hrXf7 :<.k0E0>9�:W35740

1W0 : H -/.�0\hrT�9�b :<35X^9o:W._]`:�b>X U nkTk:<0>1�:W.�0\X lf027W]^e5eg740214T�eV:/:<] �^0>1�:W.�0�hrXf7 U

� � � � � � � �| ��� �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � | H | �

� � � � � � � � ��

�����

U ]��5 � ������� � ���� � � � ��� �5 � � | H � ���.�0>7W0 �)]`9�= � � ]^7W0a1W0 :<1EX^h l^02b>:WXf7W1Ib2Xf747W0214n X^9�=�359ku�:WX X ? �40>b>:W1 � � � ]^9k= � �5 ]^7W0a359k=�3Vl&35=kT_]^elf0>b>:WXf7W1a359�:<.kXf1W0�1W0 :<1

�7W0>1Wnq02b :<3Vl^02e @

�� 3V1O:<.�0 9�T U ? 027\X^h lf02b :<Xf741[3V9 �

�]^9k= � � � � � � �5 ��3V1

:<.k0 U 359kXf7 �^0>7W9�0>e H ,E1 � � F �JnqXf3V9�:W1 XfTk:�0>t&T�]`:<3VXf9 � | H � � 351B9�X`: 3V9Yh ]^b>:8nqXf1W3 :<3Vl^0/=�0>s�9�3V:W0�=kT�0

:<XY:W.�0 U ]���Xfnq027<] :<35X^9�]^9k= 14X 3V1/9�X^:�] A 0>7Wb20>7 �`02749�02eM=�0>1Wn�3 :<0�:<.�0\b>ep]^3 U 3V9�:<.�0\Xf7435uf3V9_]^e

n_]^nq027>H {E0 lf027m:<.�0>e50>1W1�7402nqXf74:W02=�740214T�eV:W1L359 � F ~ � ]^9�= � � F�� 359�=k35b ] :<0/:<._] :L:<.k351 :<02bd.k9�35t�T�0�b2]^9

? 0a14T�b2b>021414hrT�eVe @ ]^n�nke5350>=�:<X 1W3 U nke50OX ? �402b>:E7W0>b2Xfu^9�3V:W35Xf9�:<]^1 ��12H

� |

Page 25: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

:$8 � 8 7 ����� )�� � ���J� )� � � � � � � �-/.�T�1)h ]^7 � 0�._] lf0�9�X^:)=k351Wb>T�1W1402= ��._]`:�:W.�0�bd.�Xf3Vb20 X`h ] U 359kXf7 �`027W9k02e�1W.kXfT�e5= ? 0^H

-/.�0>7W0*.�] l^0 ? 020>9 ]�l^]`7W350 : @ X^hObd.kXf35b>021 hrX^7 U 359kXf7 �^0>7W9�0>e51 359�:<.�0 e53 :<027W]`:<Tk7W0^H NcX U 0oX^h

:<.k021W0 =�X*9�X`: 1W0>0 U :<X s�: ? ]^1W3Vb 359;:WT�3V:W3Vlf0 7402t�T�35740 U 029;:<1[hrXf7[14T�bd.�] �`02749�02e�1WT�bd.�]`1[:<.k0

h ]^b :Y:<.�0 U ]��c3 U T U �`027W9k02e/l`]^e5T�0 hrXf7 ] n X^359;: � � ? 0)u^3Vlf0>9 ��3 :<. � 5 � � � H�yz9�:W.�0)b ]^140X^hQ] =�X^:[n�74Xc=�Tkb>: U 3V9�Xf7 �^0>7W9�0>e

�hrX^7[]os �c02=�t�T�0>7 @ nqXf359;:B2 � �� ��������� � � � � � 2 �� � � ]

hrT�9�b :<3VXf9�X^h �351�]�. @ nq027Wnkep]^9�0Y:W._]`:�n_]`1W1W0>1�:<.�74XfT�uf. :W.�0YXf7W3Vuf359 H�yz9�:WT�3V:W3Vl^02e @

�� 0 � XfT�eV=

e53 �^0 U ]�� 5 � ������� � � � � � � � � � �5 � :<X�1W0>e502b :�] l^]`e5T�0�hrXf7 � :<._] :Ib>Xf7W74021WnqXf9�=k1E:<X ]�l^02b>:WXf7Ib>e5Xf140a:WX� � 3V9�:<._]`: 1Wn_]`b20^H j 140)X^h�] 1W3 U nke50�=�X^:Yn�74Xc=kT�b>: � .�X �L0 lf027 � ��3Ve5eBh ] lfXf7YnqXf359;:W1[:<.�]`: ]^740359cs_9�3V:W02e @ h ]^7Qhr74X U � � H

y h � 0\359�1m:<0 ]`= U Xc=k3Vh @ 02t�T_]`:W35Xf9#� | H � � :WX ? 0

� �� � ��� � � ��

��� � � � � � � � �5��� � � | H F �

��.�0>7W0

���� � ]^7Wu U 3595 � ������� � � � � � � � � �5 � � | H ~ �� 0 b2Xf9k14:<7W]^359XfT�741W02e lf0>1 :<X U ]`:Wbd.�359�u�nqXf359;:<1 :<.�]`:)]^740*143 U 35ep]`7 359�:<.�0 1W029k1W0 :<.�]`: :W.�0 @

]^740 b2eVXf1W0�:<Xfu^0>:<.k027 � �L0 b ]^9�3V9�h ]^b : T�140)] U 0>:<7435b�359�]^9�359k=�T�b20>=�1Wn_]`b20 � ~ � �dH C�X �L0 lf027�

:<.k351�:<0>bd.�9�3Vt&Tk0�3V1)3 U n�e53Vb23 :<e @ =�02nq029�=k029;:*X^9#:W.�0�bd.�Xf3Vb20�X^h\:<.k0�X^7W35u^359�]^9k=#:W.�0�7W0>1WT�e :

X^h ] l^027W]^uf359ku =�X^: n�74Xc=kT�b>:W1*351o=�3"!�b2T�e : :WX3V9;:<0274n�7W0 : hr74X U :<.k0�nq02741Wnq02b>:W3Vl^0�X^hY14n_]`:W3p]^e

1W3 U 3Vep]^743V: @ X`h ] 140>:�X^hMlf0>b>:WXf7W1 � x 35ufT�740 | H � �<HB-/.�02740>hrXf740�:<.k0 U 3V9�Xf7 �`02749�02eg3 :<1W0>eVh U Tk14:�]^b :

]^1�]Y1W3 U 3Vep]^743V: @ U 0 ]^14T�7W0\359)0>t�T_]`:<3VXf9 � | H � �dHBPL.�XcX^1W359ku ] 7<]`=�3p]^eVe @ 1 @cU�U 0>:<7435b �`027W9k02eg:<._] :351 U X^9�X^:<X^9�35b2]^e5e @ =�02b>7W02]^1W3V9�u�]^1 � � � � � �5 � 74021WTkeV:<1 359�0>t&T�]`:<3VXf9�1 � | H � �\]^9�= � | HGF � ? 02359ku02t�T�3 l`]^e50>9�:2HI-/.�0Y740214T�eV:IX^h 3V:W1E0 l^]`e5T_]`:W35Xf9 b ]^9 ? 0 :W.�XfT�u^.�:IX^h8]^1I:W.�0 eV3 �`02e53V.�X&Xc=):<.�]`:O:<.k0

: � X�l^02b>:WXf7W1 U ]`:<bd. 0 ]^bd. X^:W.�027�359):W._]`:�1Wn�]^b20`H

, 14n 0>b23p]`e b2]^1W0 ��.k027W0o] 1W3 U n�eV0 =kX^: n�74Xc=kT�b>: 351[]^n�n�74Xfn�7W35]`:<0�351a:<.�0 b ]^140 ��.�0>7W0�:<.k0

=_]`:<]o]^7W0 9�Xf7 U ]`e53��>02= H[yz9�:W.�351�b2]^1W0�:W.�0 =_]`:<] ]`7W0 b2Xf9k14:<7W]^359k02=�:<X e53V0 Xf9�]). @ nq02741Wn�.�0>7W0

� �

Page 26: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

. ) ����� � :$8 7�8 � ������� � � ������ � � 3V1 n�eVX^:W:W02=�]^eVXf9�u ��3V:<.�]^9�3514X �zb>T�74l^0�X^h � ���� �� � �������� � �

���.�3Vbd.�740214T�eV: 3V9 ]On�ep]^9k0�]^9�=�]Ob @ e53V9�=�0>7B7W0214n 0>b>:W3Vlf0>e @ H -/.�0�] lf027W]^uf3V9�u�Xfnq027<] :<35X^9

359 02t�T_]`:W35Xf9�� | HGF �Q351�=�3 !�b2TkeV:�:<X 3V9;:<0274n�7W0 :�]^1 �L0 �LXfTke5=*0 �cn 0>b>:O:WX�._] lf0 0>t�T_]^e b>Xf9;:<743 ? T��:<3VXf9�]^eVXf9�u�:<.�0 3V1WX � b2T�7mlf0`Ha-/.k0Y02t�T_]`:W35Xf9 3V1O9�X^:Ib2X&Xf7W=k359_]`:W0[hr74020Y]^1Ibd._]^9�uf3V9�u�:<.k0 Xf7W3Vuf359��35eVe 740214T�eV:\3V9 =�3�� 0274029;:\7W0>ep]`:W3Vl^0 l`]^e5T�0>1IhrXf7OnqXf3V9�:W1O1W0>e50>b>:<0>= ?;@ :<.�0 ]^74u U 359 Xfnq027W]`:<3VXf9 3V902t�T_] :<35X^9 � | H ~ �

]^9�=:<.�0 =kX^: nk7WX&=�T�b>:�351�359h ]`b>: :W.�0 b>Xf1W3V9�0*X^hI:<.�0�]`9�ufe50 ? 0>: � 02029+: � X�lf0>b>:<X^7W12H�-/.�0

b2X^1W359k0EX^h :<.�0E]^9�ufeV0�35187<]^=�35]^e5e @ 1 @cU�U 0>:<7435b ��3V:W. 740214n 0>b>:Q:WX ]an Xf3V9;: X^9 :<.k0 U ]^9�3VhrX^e5=�]`9�=

� 0�359 h ]^b :�]^747W3Vl^0O]`:/] 7<]^=k3p]^eVe @ 1 @cU�U 0>:<7435b�U Xf9�X^:WXf9�35b2]^e5e @ =�0>b2740 ]^14359�u 1W3 U 3Vep]^743V: @ U 0 :<7W3Vb

�:<.kXfT�uf. �L0�.�] l^0 9�X b2Xf9;:W7WXfe8X lf027a:<.�0 1Wb2]^e50 ]`: ��.�35bd. � 0 b>X U n_]^7W0 :<.k0 =_]`:<]kH�F#3V:W.�XfTk:

1WTkbd. ]Yuf02X U 0 :<7W3Vb�b2Xf9k14:<7W]^359;:��L0 U T�1m:�:d] �`0au^7W0 ] :<027�b2]^7W0 ��3 :<. XfT�7/bd.�Xf3Vb20\X^h �^0>7W9�0>e H

- X 0��cn�eV35b23 :<e @ 3V9�:W0274n�7W0 :E:W.�0 U 3V9�Xf7 �^0>7W9�0>e ]`1�7402n�740214029;:<3V9�u :<.k0aeV3 �`02e53V.�X&Xc=�X`hB] U ]`:Wbd.

? 0>: � 02029olf0>b>:WXf7W1�:<.�0 �`027W9k02e :<] �^0>1�:W.�0O14._]^nq0�X^hi] =�029k1W3V: @ X lf027Q:W.�0�1Wn�]^b20`H8y h � 0�7W0>e @ Xf9

:<.k0�hr02]`:<T�740 14n_]^b>0�X^7[]):<7W]^9�1mhrXf7 U ]`:<3VXf9�X^h :<._]`:a14n_]^b20

�:WX 1402n_]^7W]`:<0 :<.k0 =_] :d]

�:<.�0>9 � 0

7W0>t�T�35740�:W._]`: :<.k0 �`02749�02eq._] lf0�=�029k1W3V: @ 3V9;lf02741W0>e @ n�74Xfn X^74:<3VXf9_]^e&:<Xa] U Xf9kX^:<Xf9k35bLhrT�9kb>:<3VXf9 X^h

] =�3V14:<]^9�b20 U 0 :<7435b�359 :W.�0O14n_]^b20`H ,�Z\]^T�1W143p]^9 vEGLx �^0>7W9�0>e 351 359�h ]^b>: :<XY] b>Xf9�1m:d]^9;:Lh ]`b>:<X^7

] =�029�143V: @ X lf0>7�:W.�0[X^7W35u^359_]^eqhr0 ]`:WT�7W0a1Wn�]^b20a:<._]`:�._]`1E=�0>9�1W3 : @ 359;lf0>7W1W0>e @ n�74XfnqXf74:W35Xf9_]`e :<X ]

U Xf9�X^:WXf9�35bEhrT�9�b>:W35Xf9oX^h =�3V14:d]`9�b20`H

� F

Page 27: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

� ��� � �� ��� ��� ! ����� � � � � �,I9�X`:<.�0>7a7402b>029;:<e @ n�7WXfnqXf1402= �^02749�02e ? 0>: � 020>9�1W0 :<1\X^h8lf02b :<Xf741[3V1O:<.�0 6 @ 7<] U 35= A ] :<bd.

R�02749�02e � �5� � H GQ]^74ep] 0>:Y]`e H)s_7W1m: n�74XfnqXf1W0>=�.�351m:<Xfu^7<] U X lf0>7We5]^n�]^1 ] �^0>7W9�0>e ? 0>: � 02029�3 U �

]^uf0>1 � � � H)Z�7<]^T U ]^9�]^9k= � ]^747W0>e5e 0 �c:W029�=�:<.�3V1a3V=�0 ]):<X ] �L0>35uf.;:<0>= U TkeV:<3 �z74021WX^e5Tk:W35Xf9 .k351 �

:<X^uf7<] U 359;:<0>7W1402b>: U 0 ]^14T�7W0aX lf027�e5X&b ]`e hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1 � �5� � H8yz9 X^7W=�0>7�:WX .�] l^0 ]Ys �c02= ? ]^140[14b ]^eV0

hrXf7/:<.k0a.k3514:WXfuf7W] U�:<.�0 @ ]^1W14T U 0�:W._]`:�:<.�0a=_]`:<] ]^7W0�s_7414:E1Wb ]`e502= 1WX�:<._] :�:W.�02740\351�] U 359k3 �

U T U 359;:W027 � lf0>b>:<X^7Q=�351m:d]^9kb20OX^h ��]^9k=�:<._]`: :<.�0I=_]`:d]Y]`7W0 ? XfT�9k=�02= ?;@ ][1Wn�.�0>7W0�X^h ��9�X ��9

7<]`=�35T�1 ��� HEGL02uf3V9�9�3V9�u ��3 :<.�] ? 359 ��35=k:W. X^h � � 0 ]^bd.�14T ? 1W0>t�T�029;:ae50 lf02ei359 :<.�0[n @ 7W] U 3V=_]^e

.�3V14:<X^uf7<] U ._]^1Q] ? 359 ��35=k:W. =�X^T ? e50�:<.k0Ie50>9�u^:W. X^h :<.�0En�7W0 lc3VXfT�1L]^9�= .�]^1L._]`eVh :W.�0I9�T U ? 0>7

X^h ? 359k12H -/.�0 �^0>7W9�0>ei3 :<1402eVh 351/=k0>s_9�0>= :WX ? 0

�� � � � � � � �� � � � �� � � � � �%� � �� � � � � �

� | H �

� � � � � �"� ���� ��������

����� � � ��������� ��� ��� � � � � � ������� � � � ��� � � � � � � � | H � �

��.�0>7W0� � ]^740 � 023Vuf.;:<1 hrX^7 02]^bd.).�351m:<Xfu^7<] U 74021WX^e5Tk:W35Xf9

�]^9k=�������� ��� ��� � � � �`3518:<.�0E.�351m:<Xfuf7W] U

359;:W027W1402b : ? 0>: � 020>9*:<.k0a3 U ]`uf021Qb2]^e5b>T�ep] :<02= ��3 :<. ] ? 359 ��35=k:W.oX^h | � �

� ����� � � ��� � � � � � �� U 359 ���"! �$#��� � � �%! �$#� � � � � � | H N �

,Q:8:<.�0 ? ]^140EeV0>lf0>e�0>l^027 @ hr02]`:<T�740/h ]^e5eV1B359;:<Xa3V:W18X ��9 ? 359�=�T�0�:<X\:<.�0 ? XfT�9�= Xf9 3V9�:W027Blf0>b>:WXf7

=�3V14:d]`9�b20�]^9�= ]`:/eV0>l^02e'& eVXfu | ��( � ]^eVe X`hi:W.�0Ohr0 ] :<T�74021/359)02]^bd.o3 U ]^uf0�h ]^e5eq359;:<X �4Tk14:�Xf9�0 ? 359 H

-/.�0a1W0 :W:<3V9�uYhrXf7Q:<.k0 � 023Vuf.;:<1

� � ��| � � | H � �

� ��* %�?%1��&% �����! "��$�&%'���$( ���-� %�5 �2<+;� ���.5>+ *�� �2'C%-�,AD34.%-1 ���%�,� �;�!���-.%12�)�;%<+ ��B*��-A2�;� %*6%�7� A2� ��'�� ��%��) ��%�* �B�;�-�*��8"�*��!( � �;�,A@: � ����2� �6��*�'2��A * �B%12�4���%�,� ���,+E%-* � AC<( %-����+ ��� � A2AC.%-.*���������5�:,%12�,5B���-�=�2* �-������ ) �$A����A�%-12�;�-� "�*���>�����*�� �/1�5 ���,�-( �212�,��>*�" ���2*&34� �7� A2.'�( ! #�, % �

� ~

Page 28: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

�L]^1Enk7WXfnqXf1W0>= ?;@ Z�7<]^T U ]^9o]^9k= � ]^747W0>e5e�:<.�X^T�uf. X^:<.�0>7 � 023Vuf.;:<3V9�uf1/:<._] :�]^7W0\=�0>b27W02]^1W3V9�u

]^1 + U ] @ ? 0E]^n�n�74Xfn�7W35]`:<0`H ,Q:Q02]^bd.�eV0>lf0>e�][b>0274:<]^359 9�T U ? 027LX`h hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1L3V9 :<.k0E74021Wnq02b :<3 lf0

3 U ]^uf0>1L]`7W0Ob>e5Xf140I029kXfT�uf.�:WX h ]^e5eJ3V9�:WX :<.k0I1<] U 0 ? 359 H -/.k0Ihr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1L:<.�]`:�]^740Ib2eVXf1W0I029�XfTkuf.

359 ? 3V9 + ? Tc: 9kX^: b2eVXf1W0�029kXfT�uf. 359 ? 359 + � � 0 ]^bd. b2Xf9;:W7W3 ? Tk:<0� � :WXa:W.�0�1W3 U 3Vep]^743V: @aU 02]^1WTk7W0^H

-/.�0/n�740>l&35X^T�1 U ]`:<bd.�0>1 ]^7W0L1WT ? :W7<]^b :<0>=�14XO:<._] : hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1 :<.�]`:B._] lf0�]`e57W02]^= @[? 0>029 U ]`:<bd.�0>=

]^740)9�X^:�b2XfTk9�:W02= U T�e :<35nke50 :W3 U 021>H�,I=�=�3 :<3VXf9_]^eVe @�:<.�0 �`027W9k02e�351Y9�Xf7 U ]`e53��>02= ?;@ :W.�0o1W0>eVh

1W3 U 3Vep]^743V: @ X^h/:<.�0)3 U ]`uf021a359�X^7W=�0>7 :<X�] l^Xf35=�h ] lfX^7W359ku 3 U ]^uf0>1 ��3 :<.�] e5]^7Wuf0>7[9�T U ? 0>7 X^h

hr0 ] :<T�740212H

D8]^bd.�X`h8:W.�0 �^0>7W9�0>e51�=�0>1Wb>7W3 ? 02=�359 :<.�3V1�bd._]^nk:W027�._] lf0 14X U 0 359;:<T�3 :<3 lf0 ? ]`1W351�? Tk:\3 :O3V1

T�9�b>e502]^7 ��.�02740�:W.�0 @ ]^7W0�1W3 U 3Vep]^7M:<X\Xf9k0E]`9�X^:<.k027 ]^9�= ��.�0>7W0�:<.�0 @ =�3�� 027�]^9�=�3VhJ:<.k027W0�3V1 ]^9

X lf0>7<]^74bd.�359�u �4Tk14:<3 s_b ] :<35X^9 hrXf7Ebd.�XcX^1W359ku Xf9�0 X l^027�]`9�X^:<.k0272HI-/.�0 9�0 �c:O1W02b :<3VXf9 359;:W7WX&=�T�b20>1

]on�7WX ? ] ? 35eV351m:<35bahr7<] U 0�� Xf7 �*hrXf7�T�9�=k027W1m:d]^9k=�359�u :<.�0 �`027W9k02e51 ��3V:W.�7W0214n 0>b>:[:<X):<.�0 hr0 ] :<T�740

1Wn�]^b20`H

Page 29: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

��' �(��� *� �

� ��� � ��������� ���E���� �)�#�#! % �� �

R�027W9k02e51 ? 0>: � 02029*1W0>:W1IX^h lf0>b>:<X^7W1I3V9�=�3Vb ]`:W0\]�=�0>uf7W0>0[X`h 1W3 U 3Vep]^743V: @�? 0>: � 02029 : � X nqXf3V9�:

b2eVXfT�=�1>HB-/.�351 bd._]^nk:W027Q=k021Wb>7W3 ? 0>1/] n�74X ? ] ? 3Ve53V14:<3VbQhr7<] U 0�� Xf7 � hrX^7 =�0>1Wb>7W3 ? 359�u :W.�0I143 U 35e5]^7W3 : @

X^hBnqXf3V9�:�b>e5XfT�=k1 ? ]`1W02=*Xf9 :W.�0[0>14:W3 U ]`:<3VXf9oX^h ]^9 T�9�=�0>7We @ 3V9�u =k3514:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9)hrXf7�0 ]^bd. 140>:EX^h

lf0>b>:WXf7W1>H -/.�3V1g0214:W3 U ]`:<3VXf9O3V1 =�Xf9�0 9�X^9��zn_]`7<] U 0>:W7W35b2]^e5e @�]^9�=�:<.k0 s_9_]^e �`02749�02e�351 b2X U n�Tk:<] ? e50

359ob>e5Xf1402=ohrXf7 U H

� � � � � ��� ��� � �� � � � � � � � � � � � �, uf0>9�027W]^ec]^n�n�74X;]^bd.[hrX^7 uf0>9�027W]`:<3V9�uO] �^0>7W9�0>e ? 0>: � 02029 =�3V14:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9�1gX lf0>7 X ? 140274l`]`:W35Xf9k1

�L]^1EX^Tk:<eV359�0>=)359 � |^| � H8-/.k0 @ n�74Xfn X^1W0 � ��� � � � � � �� � � ��� ��� �`02749�02eV1EX^hi:<.k0\hrX^7 U � � � � � � �� � ���� � � � ���� � � � H � �

��.�0>7W0 ]^9k= � ]^740\=�351m:<7W3 ? Tk:W35Xf9�1Q:W._]`:�7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:E:<.�0�: � X X ? �402b>:W1I]`9�=� 351�]Yn_]^7W] U 0 :<0>7X^hq:<.�0/h ] U 35e @ X^h �^02749�02eV12HB-/.�0>7W0E]^7W0Q: � Xa1Wnq02b235]^e_b ]`1W021 X^h 359;:W027W0>14: hrXf7� � GL._]`:4:d]^bd._]`7 @�@ ] � 1] !�9�3 : @)? 0 : �L0>029 =�351m:<7W3 ? Tk:W35Xf9�1 � | �

� � ��"� � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � H | �

]^9�=o:<.k0a0 �cn 0>b>:<0>=*eV3 �^0>e53V.�XcX&= �`027W9k02e

� � � � � � �� � � � � � ��� � ��� � � � � � � � ��� � � � �� � � � � � H � �

�5�

Page 30: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

F#.�3Ve50 GL._]`:4:d]^bd._]`7 @�@ ] � 1 ] !�9�3 : @�? 0>: � 020>9�=k3514:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9�1a351[02t�T_]^e8:<X Xf9k0 ��.�0>9�:W.�0 : � X

=�3V14:<743 ? Tc:<35X^9�1o]^7W0�35=k029;:<3Vb ]^e�:<.k0�0 �knq02b :<0>=�e53 �`02eV35.�X&Xc= �^02749�02e[351oT�9 ? XfT�9�=�0>=�hrXf7o02t�T_]`e

=�3V14:<743 ? Tc:<35X^9�1�]^9�=oh ] l^Xf7W1�=�3V14:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9�1 ��3 :<. e5X ��0>9;:<7WX^n @ H

�f0 ? ]`7<]�R�Xf9k=�Xf7

�]^9�= CEX �L]^7W= =�02743Vl^0�b2e5X^1W02=)hrXf7 U 0 �knk7W02141W3VXf9�1/hrXf7 U ]^9 @ n_]`7<] U 0>:W7W35b

hrXf7 U 1QhrXf7 �� � � � |^| � HLSIh n_]^7m:<35b>T�ep]`7Q359;:<0>7W0>14:�351Q:W._]`:�X^hi:<.�0[Z\]^T�141W3p]`9 =�3V14:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9 ��1�� �� � ���� � � � ����� � �

�� � |�� � ! � ��� # � � �

����� � � ���� � � � � ��� � � � � � �� � !��� ������������ � �� � ����� � � ���� �������� # � � H F �

��.�0>7W0

� � � ��� � � � � � � � � � H ~ �]^9�=

� �!� � � � � � � � � H �-/.�0Y0 �knq02b :<0>=�eV3 �`02e53V.�X&Xc= �^0>7W9�0>eB]^n�n�eV350>= :<X�: � X)1Wnk.�027435b ]`eBZ\]^T�1W143p]^9k1OX^h 02t�T_]`e l`]^7W35]^9�b>0

351/0>t�T_]^eg:<X

� � � � � �� F � $ � � � � ���� �

� � � � � � !�" � � # � � H � ���.�3Vbd. � |f| � nqXf359;:OX^Tk:�351E359*h ]`b>:�0>t&Tk3Vl`]^e50>9;:I:<X�:W.�0 Z\]^T�141W3p]`9�vEGLx �^02749�02e :<Xo] b>Xf9�14:<]^9;:

h ]^b :<Xf7>H*,Ie :<.�X^T�uf.�X^9�0 U 35uf.;: ]^7Wu^T�0 :W._]`: :W.�0 0 �cn�7W0>1W1W3 lf0ob ]`n_]^b23 : @ X^h�1W3V9�ufe50 Z\]^T�1W143p]^9k1

351 X lf0>7We @ 7W0>14:<7435b :<3Vl^0 ��L0 ��35eVeL1W0>0 3V9�:W.�0)hrXfe5eVX ��359�u 1402b :<35X^9�1�:W._]`: :<.k0 �`02749�02e ? 0 : �L0>029

Z\]^T�1W143p]^9k1�3V1/3 U n X^74:d]`9�:L359):<.k0a=k027W3 l`]`:<3VXf9)X^h U Xf740�1WXfnk.�351m:<35b2]`:<0>=o7W0214T�eV:W12H

� ��� � � � � �� � � � �� � � ��� ��� � � �GL02b2]^T�140�XfT�7�140>:W:W359�u�b2Xf9�14351m:<1)X^h\3 U ]^u^021�7W02nk7W0214029;:<0>=�]`1�1W0 :<1)X^h�l^02b>:WXf7W1

�� 0�9�0>02=

:<X�021m:<3 U ]`:W0o]�=�3V14:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9�X lf027 :<.k0 14n_]^b20 359 ��.�3Vbd.:<.k0 l^02b>:WXf7W1 e53V0^H�R�027W9k02e�=�029k1W3V: @

� � �)"�� + %;:�"�* � %12�6�)* �-�4�-�,( %�-�+ % � � "�* �-�/'2�<�&%�*��B��)� ��'���%�* � � #2��# � 3=� 1������4�2*B�)*���4��C"�*������%�* �B%1�� �3=�;�-�63=�6%* �-���2�-�,(�;��%?%12�DA��&%-�/��5)%-12�;���+ �,��%�-* <A �

�3N

Page 31: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

021m:<3 U ]`:W35Xf9Y0>14:W3 U ]`:<0>18=k3514:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9�1 hr74X U 1<] U n�eV02=�=_]`:<] ��3 :<.�XfTc:L]`1W1WT U 3V9�ua]an_]`7<] U 0>:W7W35b

hrXf7 U � � ��F | � H -iX�0>14:W3 U ]`:<0\]Y=�0>9�1W3 : @ ]`:�]Y1Wnq02b23 s_ban Xf3V9;:

���� 0\T�1W0\:<.�0�hrXf7 U T�e5]

�� � � � ��� � � � H N �

��.�0>7W0 ��� 351L][lfX^e5T U 0O]^74XfT�9�=�:W.�0OnqXf359;:� 3V1 :<.k0O9�T U ? 027QX^hi1W] U nke50218:<._] :Lh ]^eVe 3V9�:WX :<.k0

lfX^e5T U 0�]`9�= � 3V1Q:<.�0\9�T U ? 027/X^h nqXf359;:<1�1W] U nke502= H , ��359�=�X �$hrT�9�b>:W35Xf9

� � � 3V1/bd.�Xf14029 :WXn�7402b23V1W0>e @ =�0>s_9k0\:W.�0O7402uf3VXf9)]^74XfT�9�= � hr7WX U ��.�3Vbd.o:WX b2X^9�14:W7WT�b :/:<.�0Ol^Xfe5T U 0

�]^9�=o] 14b ]^eV0

n_]^7W] U 0>:<0>7��)351Q3V9�:W7WX&=�T�b>02=�:<X l`]^7 @ :W.�0 ��35=c:<.)X^hM:<.k0 ��359�=kX �\H -/.�0�9�T U ? 0>7/X^hM1<] U n�eV021�

�:W._]`:/h ]^eVe51Q3V9�:WX�] 7402uf3VXf9o=�0>s�9�02= ?�@ :<.�3V1 ��359�=�X ��351

���

��� �� � � � �� � � � H � �

F�0�7W0>14:<7435b : � :WX ? 0�9�Xf7 U ]^eV3��>02=�]^9�=�9�X^9��z9�0>u;]`:W3Vlf0�3 H 0^H*]*=�351m:<743 ? Tk:W35Xf9 H NcT ? 14:W3V:<Tc:<35X^9

359;:WX�0>t�T_]`:<3VXf9#� � H N � @ 350>e5=�1

�� � � � ��

�����

���� �� � � � �� � � � H � } �

,I9�359;:<0>7Wn�740>:<]`:<3VXf9�X`h��� 3V1\:W._]`:[3V:a7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:W1 :<.�0�1Wb2]^e53V9�uoh ]^b>:WXf7�:<._]`:[9�Xf7 U ]`e53��>021�:<.k0��359k=�X � =�0>n 0>9�=�029;:EXf9o:<.�0\=�3 U 0>9�1W3VXf9_]^eV3V: @ X^hi:<.�0\1Wn�]^b20 �

� ���� �� � � � �� � � � � �

� ��������� � � � � H ��� �

F�0 ��3Ve5ek]^1W14T U 0�:<.�]`: XfT�7 ��359k=�X � hrT�9�b :<3VXf9�1� � � ]^7W0�9�Xf7 U ]`e53��>02= 14X � 0 ��35e5ec9�X^:80��cn�eV35b>3V:<e @

]^b>b2XfT�9;: hrXf7 � 359�1WT ? 1W0>t&Tk029;:�02t�T_]`:W35Xf9k12H8SIhgn_]^7m:<3Vb2T�e5]^7B359;:<0>7W0>14:LhrX^78X^T�7 nkT�7WnqXf1W0>1Q351 :<.k0Z\]^T�1W143p]^9 �`027W9k02e

�=k0>s_9�0>= ?;@ �

� � �0(�.���1�%-��5 ���2'�( � �2*�%7�&%�*�� 1��;�-����5 %�-�,�&%-��2��� � ( � "�'2��+E%�*�� *�"�*��2�"�&���-<���2���)��� * � � ��� ( �� %1��� �,����;�4AC�;��( .%�5 �,( %����&%-�* � �� %-�;�7�&%-'2�� �7: ����A ��(/� "�'2��+ %�* � *�"�%�3=* � � �<� �2���,(9� �;��*&3>� � � �2�-��+E%-�+;��: %-12<(

� �

Page 32: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

� � � � � � � ��

� |�� $ � � � � ����������� � � ���� � � � H � | �

H$8 :*8 7 � � � � � � ) � ) � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � ����� � ) � � � � � � � � � � � � � ) � � � � )�� ���3���F�0)9kX � b2X^9�1W3V=�027 ��.�]`: ._]^n�nq029k1 ��.�029 � 0)T�1W0�:W.�0)n�7WX ? ] ? 3Ve53V: @ nk7WX&=�T�b>: �^02749�02eQ:WX

b2X U n_]`7W0B: �LXI=�351m:<7W3 ? Tk:W35Xf9�1 :W._]`: ._] lf0 ? 0>029 0>14:W3 U ]`:<0>=ahr74X U 1<] U n�eV021MT�1W3V9�u �`02749�02e&=�029k1W3V: @

021m:<3 U ]`:W35Xf9 �

� � � � � � � ��

����� � � � � ��� �� � �

� �

� ��5 � � � � �5 ��� �� � � � � H � � �

��.�0>7W0 � � � � ��� � 351�uf3Vl^029 ]^1�359o02t�T_]`:W35Xf9 � � H � | �dH v�02]^7W7W]^9�uf3V9�uY:<027 U 1�3V9 0>t�T_]`:<3VXf9 � H ��� � 0

]^747W3Vl^0\]`:

� � � � � ��

�� �

��� �

� ��5 �

�� � � � ��� � � � � �5 ��� ��� � � � H � F �

Nc3V9�b20a:<.�0 3V9�9�0>7I359;:W02uf7W]^eM351I143 U n�e @ :<.�0 0 �cn 0>b>:<0>=�e53 �`02eV35.�X&Xc= �`027W9k02e ? 0>: � 020>9�Z\]^T�141W35]^9�1�

:<.k0a0>9�= 7W0214T�eV:�3V1

� � �� � � ��

�� �

�� F � $ � � � �

�����

� ��5 �

����� �� ����������� !�" � � # � � H � ~ �

��.�0>9 :<.�0 Za]^Tk1W1W35]^9 3V1 3V1WX^:W7WXfn�3Vb*]`9�= 02t�T_]`e�l`]^743p]^9�b>0^H$R�027W9k02e51 X^h�:<.k351 hrXf7 U � 027W0 ]^9

359;:W027 U 02=k3p]`:W0 1m:<0>n 359�:<.�0 =�0>l^02e5X^n U 0>9;:�X^h U T�eV:W3 �z3V9�14:<]^9�b>0 �^02749�02eV1 � � ~ � ? Tk: ��3V:W.�XfTk: ]

n�74X ? ] ? 3Ve53V14:<3Vb �4T�14:W3Vs_b2]`:<3VXf9 H A Xf740*7402b20>9;:<e @�:<.�3V1�hrXf7 U �Q]^1 1WT�u^uf021m:<02=+hrXf7 U 3 �&:<T�74021�X^h

0��cnqXf9�0>9�:W3p]^eE=�351m:<743 ? Tk:W35Xf9k1 X^h ��.�3Vbd.(Za]`T�1W143p]^9 �`02749�02e�=�0>9�1W3 : @ 0>14:<3 U ] :<35X^93V1�]�1Wnq02b>3p]^e

b ]`1W0 � |�� � H

GL._]`:4:d]^bd.�]^7 @�@ ] � 1�] ! 9k3V: @o? 0>: � 02029�Za]^Tk1W1W35]^9�1�._]^1�359;:<Tk3V:<3 lf0a]^n�nq0 ]`eg=�T�0[:WX�:W._]`:E3V:�3V102t�T_]`ei:WX � ��.k029 :<.k0[: � X�=�351m:<743 ? Tk:W35Xf9k1E]`7W0a35=�0>9�:W35b2]^e

�]^9�= 02t�T_]^eM:<X } ��.�0>9 :<.�0>7W0[351�9�X

���(���,(>�2* AC�� �,��,��+ �)3412�,� AC�$������2� 34.%-1 %12�� >��'�(-( <� � ���;�-�2�;� � �,+,��'�(��.%;: � ( ��� * � � : <(B� "�'2��+E%�*�� *�"%1��BAC�� �,��,��+ �9� � %�3=�;�,�0%�3 * � * ���%-(;�4�2�-* � ��*&3 *��@: � �-���2�-�,(�;��%-(4�/"�'���+E%-.*�� *�"!%�3=* � � �<� �2���,(=� (��� %1��� �,����;�@��.%�;�7�&%-'2�-���

|^}

Page 33: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

X lf0>7Wep]`n�n�359ku 14T�n�nqXf74:2H�,I1a1WT�bd.�� 0 0��cnq02b : :<.�]`: �L0 �LXfTke5= ? 0�e50>1W1ae53 �`02e @ :<X 029kb2XfT�9;:W027

T�9�0 �cn 0>b>:<0>= ? 0>._] l&35Xf7M359\:<.k0 �`027W9k02e&359\:<.�08b ]^140 ��.�0>7W0 �L08._] lf0 e5X ��0>9�:W7WXfn @ =�3V14:<743 ? Tc:<35X^9�1�

��.�3Vbd.[b2]^9\7W0>:WT�7W9\lf0>7 @ .k35uf. �`027W9k02e�0>l`]^eVT_]`:<3VXf9�1>H j 9khrXf7m:<T�9_] :<02e @�]/b2eVXf1W0>=\hrX^7 U 0 �cn�7W0>1W1W3VXf9

351i9�X^: ]^n�n�]^7W0>9�: 359\:<.�0 b ]^140 :W._]`: Y]^9�= � ]`7W0 U 3 �c:WT�7W0>12H ,I9 ]`n�n�7WX �c3 U ]`:W35Xf9�hrXf7 U 3 �&:<T�74021 ���.�3Vbd. ��.�0>9 ]^nkn�e53V02=�:<X �`027W9k02ei=�029�143V: @ 0>14:W3 U ]`:<3VXf9 @ 3502eV=�1

� � ��

����� � � � � ��� �� �� � �

� �

� ��5 � � � � �5 � � �� �� � ��� �

��� �

�����

� ��5 �

� �� � � � ��� �

�� � � �5 ��� ��� �� � H � �

�L]^1Ln�74XfnqXf1W0>=�359 � |� ����.�35eV0EZ\3 ?�? 181<] U n�e53V9�u �Q]`1L1WTkufuf021m:<0>=)359 � |f| � HB-/.�0E.�02Tk7W351m:<3VbE14Xfe5T��

:<3VXf9 =�X&021�9kX^:�._] lf0 :W.�02X^7W0>:W35b2]^e 7435ufXf7���.�3Ve50 Z\3 ?�? 1I1W] U n�e53V9�u 3V1OT�9�=�0>1W3V7<] ? eV0

�0>1Wnq02b>3p]^eVe @

359 .�35uf.=�3 U 029k1W35X^9�12H(F�0 hrT�74:W.�027)]`9_]^e @ �>0 :<.k0 0��cnq02b>:W02=#e53 �^0>e535.kXcX&=�X^h �^0>7W9�0>eO=�029k1W3V: @021m:<3 U ]`:W35Xf9k1Q359):<.k0\hrX^e5e5X ��3V9�u 1W0>b>:W35Xf9�1>H

H$8 :*8 7�8 7 � 2 � � � � � )�� ��� ��� � ) � � � � ) � � �x 35u^T�7W0 � H � XfTk:<eV359�0>1g:<.�0 n�74X ? ] ? 3Ve53 : @ n�74Xc=�Tkb>: �^0>7W9�0>ek]^nkn�e53V02=�:<X�: �LX �z=�3 U 0>9�1W3VXf9_]^ef=�]`:d]kH

yz9�x 3VufT�740 � H � � ] ��] 140>:IX^hBlf0>b>:<X^7W1�351�7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:W02= ?;@ 3 :<1�1Wb ] :W:<0>7On�eVX^: H�-/.�0 l^02b>:WXf7W1 � 02740uf0>9�027W]`:<0>= hr7WX U ] U 3 �&:WT�7W0aX^h � } Za]^Tk1W1W35]^9�1 ��3V:<. U 02]^9�1I=k7<] ��9*hr7WX U ] T�9�3VhrX^7 U =�3V14:<743 �

? Tk:W35Xf9�X lf0>7 :<.k0ET�9k3V: 1Wt�T_]^740�]`9�= $ � }:� };~ H x 35ufTk7W0 � H � � ? � 14.�X ��1 :<.k0I021m:<3 U ]`:W02=�=�029k1W3V: @

X lf0>7 :<.�]`:�1<] U 0o1W0>: X^hElf02b :<Xf7412H#x 3VufT�74021 � H � � b��Y]^9k= � H � � = �[1W.�X � =�0>9�1W3 :<350>1 0>14:W3 U ]`:<0>=

hr7WX U 1<] U n�eV021�X^h :<.�0 1<] U 0 U 3 �&:<T�740 ]^9�=�X^h/])=�3 � 0>7W0>9�: U 3 �&:<Tk7W0�74021Wnq02b :<3 lf02e @ H x 359_]`e5e @

�x 3VufT�7W0>1 � H � � 0��E]^9�= � H � � h ��1W.�X � :W.�0 n�7WX&=�T�b :aX^h :W.�02140Y: �LX =�029�143V:W35021 ��3 :<.�:<.k0�X^7W35u^359_]^e H

,I1 :<.�0O=k029�143V:<3V021Q0>14:W3 U ]`:<0>= hr7WX U : � X =�3�� 0274029;:Q140>:<1/X`hM1<] U n�e50>1Lhr7WX U :W.�0O1W] U 0E=�351m:<743 ? T��

:<3VXf9�._] lf0�.�3Vuf.�027�X l^027We5]^n�:<._]^9�:W.�0Y: �LX =�029k1W3V:W350>1a0>14:W3 U ]`:<0>=�hr74X U 1W] U n�e50>1�X^hL=k3�� 027W0>9;:

=�3V14:<743 ? Tc:<35X^9�1�:W.�0�359;:<0>uf7<]^e_X`h :W.�0Enk7WX ? ] ? 35eV3V: @ n�7WX&=�T�b : ��3Ve5e ? 0 U T�bd. .k35uf.�0>7 hrXf7 =�029k1W3V:W350>1

021m:<3 U ]`:W02=)hr7WX U :<.k0a1W] U 0aTk9�=�0274e @ 359ku�=k3514:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9 H

x_Xf7Q1W3 U nke535b>3V: @�� 0�b2X^9�:W359�T�0 ��3 :<.�:<.k0\]^1W14T U nc:<35X^9 :<._] :/:<.�0 �`02749�02eg3V1Q3514X^:<74Xfn�35b`H -/.�3V1

359�h ]`b>:/=�X&021/9kX^:Q:<Tk7W9oXfTk:Q:WX ? 0�]Ye5]^7Wuf0E1W0 : ? ]^b ��]^1Q:<.�0�14n_]^b>0a3 :<1402eVhMb2]^9 ? 0E:<7<]`9�14hrXf7 U 0>=

|�

Page 34: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 10

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

����� � ���,+E%-* �4(� %0

0.20.4

0.60.8

1

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

10

2

4

6

8

10

12

���������;��(.%�5 �$(�%-����&%�$A "��*�� ( �;% *�"�� �,+��%*��-(

00.2

0.40.6

0.81

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

10

2

4

6

8

10

12

��+$��� ( %����&%-�,A AC�;��(.%�5 "��*�� � AC�� �;�-�;��%(� � �2��� * " %-12�D(� �)�6+;�<� (-(

00.2

0.40.6

0.81

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

10

2

4

6

8

10

12

��A���� (�%-����&%�$A�AC�,��( %�5 "��-* � �/(-��� ���.��*�"� AC�� �,��,��%�+;����((

00.2

0.40.6

0.81

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

10

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

��� ��� �-* �����2���.%�5 ���*CAC'�+ % *�"!%-12� AC�,��( %-��,(( 1�*&34� �� ��� '2�-�,( #2��*������=� ��A #2��*���+$�

00.2

0.40.6

0.81

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

10

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

�<"-��� �*������2���.%�5 �2�-*�A2'�+E%6*�" %1��/AC�,��( %-��,(( 1�*&34� �� ��� '2�-�,( #2��*������=� ��A #2��*���A��

. ) ����� � H$8 7�8 6 7WX ? ] ? 35eV3V: @ n�74Xc=�Tkb>:a]^n�nke5350>=*:<X =�029�143V: @ 0214:W3 U ]`:<3VXf9�1EX^hB: �LX �z=�3 U 0>9�1W3VXf9_]^e=_]`:<]

|f|

Page 35: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

n�7435Xf7�:<X)b2e5]^1W143Vs_b2]`:<3VXf9 � � � H\,Ie :<02749_]`:W3Vlf0>e @ � 0�b>XfT�eV= T�1W0 :W.�0 U Xf7W0[uf029�0>7<]^e hrXf7 U Tkep]`:W35Xf9

X^h :W.�0 �^02749�02e ? 0 : �L0>029�Z\]^T�141W3p]`9�1E3V9 � |f| �M:W._]`:En�ep]^b>021�9�X 74021m:<7W3Vb>:W35Xf9�1�Xf9 :<.�0ab2X l`]^7W35]^9�b>0

U ]`:<7435b20>1 � 0>t&T�]`:<3VXf9#� � HGF � �<H

H$8 :*8 : " � � � � ) � � � � � � � � � ) � �yz9#bd.�XcX^1W359ku�:<.�0 n�]^7<] U 0>:W027

� $ � :W.�02740�]^7W0 140>l^027<]`e�1W029k1W3 ? e50�]^nkn�7WX;]`bd.�021oXf9�0*b2XfT�eV=b2X^9�1W3V=�027>H , b2X U�U X^9�:W02bd.�9�3Vt�T�0 ]^nkn�e53V02=�:<X�=�029k1W3V: @ 0>14:<3 U ] :<35X^9�351Y:<X�e502] l^0*XfTc: 02]^bd.

1W3V9�ufeV0�n Xf3V9;:EX^9�0 ] :I]Y:<3 U 0\]`9�= U ]��c3 U 3��>0I:<.�0ae53 �^0>e535.kXcX&=�X^h :<._]`:EnqXf359;: ��3V:W.*74021Wnq02b :E:WX]^eVe :<.k0aX`:<.�0>7�nqXf3V9�:W1

$ � ��]^74u U ]�����

� � eVXfu � �

? � ��5��� � � � � � � ��� 5 � � � � H �5� �

��.�0>7W0 � � 351E:W.�0 ��359k=�X � hrT�9kb>:<3VXf9�b ]`e5b2Tkep]`:W02=�]`:O1Wb ]`e50 $ H\-/.�3V1�=�Xc0>1�9�X^:�0 �k]^b>:We @ U ] �`01W0>9�1W0�359+:<.k0�b2]^1W0 ��.�0>7W0 �L0�]^7W0�eV0 ]^749�359ku�X l^027o1W0 :<1 X^h l^02b>:WXf7W1

�.�X �L0 lf0>7

�]^1 �L0�]^740

U ]��c3 U 3��23V9�u�:<.�0�e53 �^0>e535.kXcX&= X^hqXf9ke @ 3V9�=�3 lc3V=�T_]^e&nqXf359;:<1 ��3 :<.Y74021Wnq02b : :WX�X^:<.k027 n X^359;:<1>H -/.�3V1=�X&021�9�X^:�=k357W0>b>:We @ 1W] @ ]^9 @ :W.�359ku ] ? XfTc:�:W.�0\e53 �^02eV35.�X&X&= X^hi:<.�0\140>:�X^h n Xf3V9;:<1�]^1�] ��.�Xfe50`H

F�0�b2X^T�e5=#359k14:<02]^=(e50 ] l^0�XfTc:o0 ]^bd.$1W359kufe50�b>Xfe5eV02b>:W35Xf9+X`h nqXf359;:W1 ]`9�= U ]��c3 U 3��>0*:<.k0e53 �^0>e535.kXcX&= X^hi:<.�]`:�1W0>:�X^h nqXf359;:<1 ��3 :<. 7W0>1Wnq02b>:�:WX ]^eVe :W.�0\X^:<.�0>7�n Xf3V9;:<1

$ � ��]`7Wu U ]�����

��� e5Xfu � �

? � ��5��� �

� � ��� � � 5 � � �� � � H �3N �

��.�0>7W0 � � � ]`9�= 5 � � ]^740\=�029�143V: @ 0>14:W3 U ]`:<0>1�]`:�1Wb2]^e50 $ ]^9�=o:<.�0�0 �cn 0>b>:d] :<35X^9 3V1/b ]^eVb2T�e5]`:<0>=]^1\359�02t�T_] :<35X^9 � � H � ~ �dH -/.�3V1[14Xfe5Tk:W35Xf9 :W7W02]`:<1\:<.�0�n�74X ? e50 U ]^1a]^9�021m:<3 U ]`:W35Xf9�X^hL=�029k1W3V: @

X lf0>7I]Y1W0 :�X^h =k3514:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9�1���.�02740\0 ]^bd. =�351m:<7W3 ? Tk:W35Xf9�7402n�740214029;:<1�]`9 0>9;:<35740\3 U ]^uf0^H

, =k351Wb>7W3 U 3V9_]`:<3 lf0\]^nkn�7WX;]`bd. U ] @ @ 3V02eV= ? 0>:4:<027�7W0>1WT�e :<1 ��3V:W.*7W0>1Wnq02b :I:<X�b2e5]^1W143Vs_b2]`:<3VXf9 H

v�02b20>9;: � Xf7 ��X^9�0>14:<3 U ] :<359ku�=�3514b2743 U 359_]`:W3Vl^0 =�029k1W3V:W350>1a3V9�b2eVT�=�0>1 � �;| � H A Xf740�=k357W0>b>:We @�� 0

b2X^T�e5=o0 U n�eVX @ ] ��7<]^n�nq027/:W02bd.�9�3Vt�T�0a:WX =�0>:W027 U 359k0 ? ]^9�= ��3V=k:<. =�3V7W02b :<e @ hr7WX U :<.k0anq027mhrXf7 �

U ]^9�b20�X`h :<.k0ab>ep]^141W3 s_027/Xf9 ]Y:<0>14:�1W0 :EX`h 3 U ]^u^0212H

|��

Page 36: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

� ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � �� � � � � � ��� �-����� � � � � ��� � � ��� � � � �� � � ��� ��� � � � � � � � � �� � � �� ��� � � � � � �

-/.�0�0 �cn 0>b>:<0>=�e53 �^02eV35.�X&X&= �^0>7W9�0>e ? 0>: � 02029 �`02749�02ea=�029k1W3V: @ 0>14:<3 U ] :<35X^9�1)._]^1 ]�l^027 @

1W3 U 3Vep]^7 hrX^7 U :<Xa:<.�0 U ]`:Wbd.�359�u �^0>7W9�0>e ��3V:W.)]YZ\]^T�141W3p]`9�v�GQx�]^18:<.�0 U 359kXf7 �^02749�02e � 02t�T_] �:<3VXf9�1 � | H | �/]^9�= � � H � ~ � �<H�,E1W3V=�0[hr74X U ] b2X^9�14:<]^9;:Oh ]^b>:WXf7

�:<.k0 Xf9�e @ =�3�� 0274029�b>0 351�:<._] :I:<.k0

U ]`:<bd.�3V9�u �^0>7W9�0>eq14T U 18:W.�0�b2Xf9;:<743 ? Tc:<35X^9�X^9�e @ hr7WX U :W.�0�b2eVXf1W0>14: U ]`:Wbd.Ylc35]\:W.�0 U ]�� Xfnq027 �

]`:W35Xf9���.�35eV0[:W.�0 0��cnq02b :<02=�e53 �^0>e535.kXcX&= �^02749�02e ? 0>: � 020>9 �`02749�02e =k029�143V: @ 0>14:W3 U ]`:<3VXf9�1I14T U 1

X lf0>7�0>lf0>7 @ b>Xf9;:<7W3 ? Tk:W35Xf9 H � 0>9�1W3 : @ 0>14:<3 U ] :<35X^9*T�14021a]�e5X � 027Il`]^743p]^9�b>0 14:<]`:<3V14:W35b[:W._]^9�:<.k0

U ]`:<bd.�3V9�u �^02749�02eL]^9�=�:W.�02740�]^740 9kX =�3514b2Xf9;:W359�T�3V:W350>1a3V9;:<7WX&=�T�b>02=�]`1 ] 7W0214T�eV: X^hQ:W.�0 U ]��

Xfnq027W]`:<3VXf9 H

-/.�0�n @ 7<] U 35= U ]`:Wbd. �^0>7W9�0>e � 0>t�T_]`:<3VXf9 � | H � �B3 :<1402eVh b ]^9 ? 0El&350 �L0>= ]^1Q]^9o]`n�n�7WX �c3 U ] �:<3VXf9 :<X):W.�0 U ]`:Wbd.�359ku �^02749�02e

�]`9�=�:<.�0>7W0>hrX^7W0�]^9�]^n�n�74X �k3 U ] :<35X^9*:<X):<.k0�0>14:W3 U ]`:<0YX^h8:<.k0

0��cnq02b :d]`:W35Xf9�X^hQXf9k0 =�3V14:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9 � ��.�3Vbd.�uf029k027<] :<02=�Xf9�0�1W0 : X^hLn Xf3V9;:<1 � ��3V:W.�740214n 0>b>: :WX]^9�X`:<.�0>7�=k3514:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9 � ��.k35bd. uf029�0>7<]`:W02= :<.�0\1W0>b2Xf9k= 1W0 :EX`h nqXf359;:<1 �dH ,Q:�0 ]^bd. e50 lf02egX`h :<.k0n @ 7<] U 35=

�:<.k0O=�351m:d]^9kb20 ? 0>: � 020>9 :W.�0O9�0 ��e @ U ]`:Wbd.�02=�l^02b :<Xf741/351Qb>Xf9�14:W7<]^3V9�02= :<X ? 0O1WX U 0 �

��.�0>7W0 ? 0>: � 02029 | � � ]^9k= � � | � � ��.�0>7W0 � 3V1L:<.�0I9&T U ? 0>7/X^hM=�3 U 0>9�1W3VXf9�1QX^hg:W.�0Ohr0 ] :<T�740

1Wn�]^b20`H y h �L0 ��9�X � ]�=�029�143V: @ hrXf7I:<.k0 hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1�X lf027�:W.�0 U ]`9�3VhrXfeV= 3V9 ��.�3Vbd.�:W.�0 @ e53V0�X^7

3Vh � 0 ]^141WT U 0 ]�T�9�3 hrXf7 U =�0>9�1W3 : @�� 0�b2]^9�021m:<3 U ]`:W0 :<.k0 0��cnq02b>:W02=�=�351m:d]^9kb20

�� � � ? 0 : �L0>029

9�0 ��e @ U ] :<bd.�0>= hr0 ] :<T�74021O] :I02]^bd. e50 lf0>e H/y h � 0 7402n�e5]^b20\:<.�0[]^141W35u^9 U 0>9;:<1EhrX^7�:W.�0 � 023Vuf.;:<1�

� � � uf3 lf029 359)0>t�T_]`:<3VXf9 � | H � � ��3V:W. ]^9 ]^1W1435uf9 U 029;:�:<.�]`:�1<] U n�eV021�] Za]^Tk1W1W35]^9 vEGLx �`02749�02e

� � �� � �� � ��� � � � H � � �

:<.k0a143 U 35e5]^7W3 :<350>1 ? 0 : �L0>029*:W.�0�: �LX ? 0>b2X U 0a]^n�n_]`7W029;:2H

H$8 H*8 7 % � � ��� � � ��� � + � ��� ���-/.�0 1W3 U 35e5]^7W3 : @�? 0 : �L0>029�:<.�0 U ]`:<bd.�3V9�u �^0>7W9�0>e�]^9�=�:<.�0o0��cnq02b :<02=e53 �^02eV35.�X&X&= �^0>7W9�0>e

uf3 lf021a7W3V1W0Y:<Xo:<.k0 t�T�0>14:<3VXf9�X`h ��._]`:[14:<]`:<3V14:W35b21a]^740�]^n�n�74Xfn�7W35]`:<0Y:WX*]^eVe5X � U ]��c3 U T U =k351 �

| F

Page 37: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

b2743 U 359_] :<35X^9 ��.�3Ve50 U ]^3V9;:d]^3V9�359�u�7WX ? T�14:W9�021412H v�X ? T�1m:B021m:<3 U ]`:WXf7W1 ]^7W0 :<.�Xf140Q:<._] : U ] �^0QT�140

X^h 1WX U 0[14T ? 140>:OX^7 � 023Vuf.;:<359ku X^h :<.�0a=_]`:<]�:WX 7402=�T�b>0[:W.�0[0 � 0>b>:IX^h XfTc:<e53V02741 � �3N�� � � H/S�9k0

X^h :W.�0 U Xf14: 1W3 U nke50/:<0>bd.�9�35t�T�0>1QhrXf781W02eV02b :<359ku ] 14T ? 1W0 :/X^h :W.�0O=_] :d][3V18l&35][Xf74=�027 14:d] :<351m:<3Vb212H

G @ 359�b>e5T�=�3V9�u X^9�e @ ]�b20>74:d]`359�t�T_]^9;:<3Ve50 X`h =�]`:d]�XfTk:<eV350>7W1 ��3Ve5eMh ]^e5ei359 :W.�0 0 �kb>e5T�=k02=�7<]^9�u^0

]^9�=�:<.�0�0>14:W3 U ]`:<Xf7 ��3Ve5e 9�X^: ? 0 0 � 02b>:W02= H*-/.�0 U ]���Xfn 0>7<]`:W35Xf9�359�:<.�0 U ]`:Wbd.�359ku �^0>7W9�0>e

351�359 h ]^b>:I]^9 X^7W=�0>7I14:<]`:<3V14:W35b�:<._] :I0 �kb>e5T�=k021�0>l^027 @ =_] :d] nqXf3V9�:E0��cb>02nk:O:W.�0 b>e5Xf14021m: U ]`:<bd. H

-/.�3V1Y351Y] 740 ]^14Xf9_] ? eV0)bd.�Xf3Vb20)359�:W.�0)0>l^029;:�:<._]`: 3V:Y3V1Y]^1W14T U 02=�:<._] : 0 ]^bd.�e5X&b ]`e hr0 ] :<T�740

359�X^9�0Y3 U ]^uf0 U ]`:Wbd.�021\0 ��]`b>:<e @ Xf9k0 hr0 ]`:WT�7W0Y3V9 :<.�0YX^:W.�027>H ,EeV:<0>7W9_] :<3Vl^0Y14:<]`:<3V14:<3Vb21 � XfT�eV=

359kb2e5Tk=�0 ] lf0>7<]^u^359�u�X l^027�t�T_]^9;:<3Ve50>1IX^hB:W.�0 Xf74=�027402=�=_]`:<]�X^7I. @&? 7W3V=�]^n�n�74X;]^bd.�0>1�359 ��.k35bd.

:<.k0 :<7W]^=�02X � ? 0>: � 020>9�]^9*0214:W3 U ]`:<X^7 ? ]`1W02=�X^9�]^e5eM:<.k0 =_]`:<]�X^7IXf9 �4T�1m:\] nqXf74:W35Xf9 X^hB:<.k0

=_]`:<]�]^740\b2Xf9;:<74Xfe5eV02= ?;@ ]Yn_]^7W] U 0 :<0>7/X^h :W.�0\021m:<3 U ]`:WXf7 � � � � H

yz9�:<0>7 U 1LX^hM=�3V1Wb>7W3 U 359�]`:<3VXf9�� 0 ��3514.�:<X 1402e50>b>:�]`9�021m:<3 U ]`:WXf78:W._]`:L351L74X ? T�1m:Q:<X[l^]`e5T�0>1

:<.�]`: u^3Vlf0 e53 :W:<eV0BXf7 U 3514e502]^=�359ku�3V9khrXf7 U ]`:W35Xf9\] ? XfTc: b>ep]^141 U 0 U ? 02741W.�3Vn H yz9 uf029�0>7<]^e�� 0 ��3514.

:<X bd.�X&Xf1W0Y]�14:<]`:<3V14:<3Vba:W._]`:Iuf3Vl^021O]�.�35u^.�027�1W3 U 3Vep]^743V: @ l^]`e5T�0a:<X X ? �402b :<1OX^h :<.�0[1<] U 0 b>ep]^141

]^9�=*] eVX � 027E1W3 U 3Vep]^743V: @ l^]`e5T�0�:<X X ? �40>b>:<1IX^hB=�3 � 0>7W029;:Eb2e5]^1W140212H�-/.�3V1E3V1I]�=_]`:d]�=�02nq029k=�029;:

bd.�Xf3Vb20�]^9�= ��3V:<.kXfTk:/hrT�7m:<.�0>7E]`1W1WT U nk:W35Xf9k1E] ? XfTc:/:<.�0a=�351m:<743 ? Tk:W35Xf9 hr7WX U ��.k35bd.o:<.�0\=_]`:<]

]^740a=k7<] ��9�:<.k0a1m:d]`:W351m:<35b�Tk1W02= U T�1m: ? 0\bd.�Xf14029 0��cn 0>7W3 U 0>9�:<]^e5e @ H

-/.�02740 3V1 359�h ]^b :i]/b2027m:d]^3V9\] U XfT�9;:MX^hc7WX ? Tk14:<9k021W1 ? T�3VeV: 359;:<X�]^9 @ 1 @ 1m:<0 U :<._]`:Mb2]^e5b>T�ep] :<021

14:<]`:<3V14:W35b21/X l^027IZa]^Tk1W1W35]^9 �^0>7W9�0>ei0 l`]^e5T_] :<35X^9�12HBG 02b ]`T�1W0

eV3 U� ��� ��� �� � ��� � � � � � � �5 � � } � � H |^} �

XfTk:We53V027W1 ��3Ve5e :W029�= :<X .�] l^0 ] e53 U 3 :<02=)0 � 0>b>:IXf9 :W.�0a1WT U�U ] :<35X^9 HLC�X �L0 lf027�0��cnq02743 U 029;:d]^e

7W0>1WT�e :<1 14.�X �:W._]`: :W.�0Qbd.�X^35b20/X`hJ0214:W3 U ]`:<X^7 =�X&021B.�] l^0�]O1W3Vuf9�3Vs�b ]^9;: 0 � 0>b>: Xf9 b2ep]`1W1W3 s_b ] :<35X^9

nq0274hrX^7 U ]^9�b20`H

yz9 :<.k351Mbd._]^nk:W027 �L0 ._] lf0Lnk7W0214029;:<0>= ]En�74X ? ] ? 35e53V14:W35b hr7W] U 0 �LX^7 �OhrXf7M9�Xf9 �zn_]^7W] U 0>:<7435b2]^e5e @

021m:<3 U ]`:W359�u�:W.�0I143 U 35ep]`7W3V: @[? 0>: � 02029)140>:W1QX^h l^02b>:WXf7W1LT�1W3V9�u �`027W9k02e =k029�143V: @ 021m:<3 U ]`:W35Xf9 ��3V:W.

n�74X ? ] ? 3Ve53 : @ n�7WX&=�T�b : �^02749�02eV12Ha-/.�351�.�]^1Oe502]^= :<X�:W.�0Y=�0 lf02eVXfn U 029;:\X^hB:W.�0Y0��cnq02b>:W02=�e53 �^0 �

|f~

Page 38: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

e53V.�X&Xc= �^0>7W9�0>e � 02t�T_]`:W35Xf9�� � H � ~ � �dHQyz9;:<0>7W0>14:<3V9�ufe @ :W.�0an @ 7W] U 3V= U ]`:<bd. �^0>7W9�0>e ��3V:W. ]^nkn�7WX �

n�743p]`:W0 � 023Vuf.;:<359ku 351E]^9*]^n�n�74X �c3 U ]`:W35Xf9o:<X�:<.�0 U ] :<bd.�3V9�u �`02749�02e ��3V:<.*])Z\]^T�1W143p]^9 U 3V9�Xf7

�^0>7W9�0>e�]^9�= ? X^:W.�X^h :<.�0>1W0 �^02749�02eV1 b2]^9 ? 0 ? 0>:4:<0>7[T�9k=�027414:<X&X&= ?;@ :<.�0>357\7W0>ep]`:W35Xf9�:WX :<.k0

0��cnq02b :<02= e53 �^02eV35.�X&X&= �^0>7W9�0>e H

|�

Page 39: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

��' �(��� *� ���! ���� �� " ! ���������� ����$�+�� �� �� �� �����+! ������

D 9�1W0 U ? e50 U 0>:W.�X&=�1Q]^740Oe502]^7W9k359�u ]^e5ufX^7W3V:W. U 1 :W._]`:L._] lf0 ? 02029o14.�X ��9o:WX 3 U n�74X l^0Inq027 �

hrXf7 U ]^9kb20 ?;@ b2X U ? 359k359�uL:W.�0 XfTk:Wn�Tk:<1gX`h U TkeV:<3Vn�e50 b2X U nqXf9�029;:Mb>ep]^141W3Vs�027W1>H D 9�140 U ? e50 U 0 :<.��

X&=�1OhrXf7�b2e5]^1W143Vs_b2]`:<3VXf9 ._] l^0 ? 020>9�14.�X ��9�:WX)._] lf0 ? 0 :W:<0>7\]^b2b>T�7<]`b @ :W._]^9�:<.�0 b>X U nqXf9�0>9;:

b2e5]^1W143Vs_0>7W1B3 hq:W.�0�b2X U nqXf9�029;: b>ep]^141W3Vs�027W1 ]`7W0�]^b>b2T�7W]`:<0�]^9k= =�3 lf0>7W1W0 � � � H ,I9 ]^b>b2T�7W]`:<0/b>ep]^141W3 �

s_0>7i3V1MXf9�0B:<._] : X^Tk:<nq027mhrXf7 U 1g7<]^9k=�X U ufTk021W14359�u�]^9�=a=�3 lf02741W08b2e5]^1W143Vs_0>7W1i]^7W0B:W.�Xf1W0 :<.�]`:in�7WX �

=�T�b>0 3V9�=�02nq029k=�029;:O0>7W74Xf7W1>H/- @ n�3Vb ]^eVe @�]`n�n�e53Vb ]`:W35Xf9oX^h 029�140 U ? e50 U 0>:W.�X&=�1/hrXcb>T�1W0>1Iep]`7Wuf0>e @

Xf9�359�=�Tkb2359ku 3V9�=�02nq029k=�029�b>0�X^hL027W74Xf7W1 ?;@�U ]^9k35n�T�e5]`:<3V9�u�:<.k0�:W7<]^3V9�359�uo140>:�U ]`9�35n�Tkep]`:W359�u

:<.k0a3V9�n�Tk:/hr02]`:<Tk7W021�Xf7/359��40>b>:W359�uY7W]^9�=�X U 9�0>1W1�359):<.k0aeV0 ]^749�359ku ]^e5ufX^7W3V:W. U H

� 0214n�3V:W0 :<.�0�]^=kl`]^9;:<]^uf021\X^h8eVXcb2]^e hr02]`:<T�74021�ufeVX ? ]^eMhr0 ] :<T�74021a]^7W0 1m:<35eVe Tk1W0>hrTke83V9�]^n�n�eV3 �

b ] :<35X^9�1 ��.�02740 ] 7WX^T�uf.o1W0>u U 0>9;:d]`:W35Xf9 X^hi:<.�0\X ? �40>b>:EX^h 359;:<0>7W021m:�351�] l^]`35ep] ? e50`H � T�0�:<X :<.k0

hrT�9�=�] U 0>9;:d]^e�=k3�� 027W0>9�b20�3V9�.kX � e5X&b ]^ek]^9�=�ufe5X ? ]^echr02]`:<Tk7W0218]^740/b2X U n�Tk:W02=�� 0�0��cn 0>b>:8:<._] :

:<.k0O: �LX 7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:<]`:<3VXf9�1 � XfT�e5=)nk7WX l&35=�0�=�3 � 0>7W0>9�: ��3V9�=�1QX^hi3V9khrXf7 U ]`:W35Xf9 H A Xf1m:�e5X&b ]^eqhr0 ] �

:<Tk7W021E7W0>n�7W0>1W029;:�:W0��&:<T�740 3V9 ]^9 3 U ]^uf0\n_]`:Wbd. � b`H h HENc0>b>:<3VXf9 � H � �<HEZ\eVX ? ]^e hr02]`:<Tk7W021I359�b>e5T�=�0b2X^9�:WXfT�7�7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:<]`:<3VXf9�1

�14._]^nq0[=�0>1Wb>7W35nc:<Xf741

�]^9�=o:<0 �c:WT�7W0\hr0 ] :<T�740212HQZ\eVX ? ]^eq:<0 �c:WT�7W0ahr0 ] �

:<Tk7W021 ]^9�=�eVXcb2]^eBhr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1 n�7WX l&35=k0�=�3�� 0274029;: 3V9khrXf7 U ]`:W35Xf9�] ? XfTk:[:<.�0 3 U ]^uf0 ? 0>b ]^Tk1W0�:<.k0

1WTkn�n X^74:EX l^027 ��.�35bd. :<0 �c:WT�7W0[351�b2X U n�Tc:<02=ol`]^7W3V021>H F�0a0 �cn 0>b>:Ob>ep]^141W3 s_02741�:W._]`:�T�1W0aufeVX ? ]^e

hr0 ] :<T�74021 ��35e5eLb2X U�U 3 :Y02747WXf741Y:<._]`:�=�3 � 0>7Yhr7WX U :W.�Xf140 X^hIb2e5]^1W143Vs_0>7W1 ? ]^1402= X^9 e5X&b ]`eLhr0 ] �

:<Tk7W021 � | N � H

F�0\b>0274:<]^359ke @ ._] lf0a]Y=�02uf74020�X^h 359k=�02nq029�=k029�b>0 ? 0>: � 020>9*e5X&b ]`e ]^9k= u^e5X ? ]`e hr0 ] :<T�74021�14X

] b>ep]^141W3Vs�b ]`:W35Xf9 1 @ 14:W0 U :<._]`: U ]`=�0[Tk1W0 X^h ? X^:W. ��359�=k1IX^hBhr02]`:<T�74021 �LXfTke5= eV3 �^0>e @ nq027mhrXf7 U

U T�bd. ? 0 :W:<0>7L:<.�]^9)][b>ep]^141W3 s_027 ? ]^1W0>=)Xf9�0>3V:<.k027 : @ nq0�]^eVXf9�0`H SO9�0Ib>XfT�e5= b2X U ? 359�0�:<.�0IXfTk: �

|��

Page 40: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

n�Tk:W1LX^h 1W0 lf027W]^e ? ]^1W0Eb2ep]`1W1W3 s_027418:W7<]^3V9�02=�Xf9 023V:W.�0278e5X&b ]`e_Xf7 u^e5X ? ]`e�b2e5]^1W143Vs_0>7W18T�1W3V9�u ]\s �c02=

14:W7<]`:W02u @�Xf7[] U 0>:<] �zeV0 ]^749�359�u�:W02bd.�9k35t�T�0�14T�bd.�]^1a14:d]`b �&3V9�u � F �

�| N � Ho,Ie :<02749_]`:W3Vlf0>e @

�Xf9k0

b2X^T�e5= =�021435uf9�] �^02749�02e :<._]`:Eb2X U ? 359k021E:W.�0 =�3V1Wb>7W3 U 359�]`:<3 lf0\] ? 3Ve53 :<350>1/X^h �^0>7W9�0>e51Ob>X U n�Tk:<0>=

X lf0>7 =�3 � 0>7W0>9�:8hr0 ] :<T�740�: @ nq021>HB-/.�3518351 ]\uf029k027<]`eJ:W02bd.�9k35t�T�0�:<._]`:80 �c:W029�=k1 :<X U T�e :<3Vn�e50Ll&3V0��

e502]^7W9k359�u 359*u^029�0>7<]^e�0^H u�HOb>ep]^141W3 s_b ]`:W35Xf9 X^hBl&35=�0>X�1W0>u U 029;:<1OTk1W359ku ? X`:<.�]^Tk=�35X)]`9�=*l&35=�0>X

bd._]^9k9�02eV1�143 U TkeV:d]`9�02XfTk1We @ � �� � H

��� � ! � � ��� � �� � � � � � � �y :�351/b2X U U Xf9on�7<]`b>:<3Vb20O:WX b>X U ? 3V9�0 U T�e :<35nke50I14XfT�74b2021EX^h 359khrXf7 U ] :<35X^9 359 ] 1W3V9�ufe50 �^027 �

9�0>e Hox_Xf7a0��k] U n�e50���.�0>9�:<.�0 U ]`:<bd.�3V9�u �^02749�02e �Q]`1[s_7414: nk7WXfnqXf1W0>= � F ~ �

�] l`]^743p]^9;: �L]^1

1WTkufuf021m:<0>=�:<._] : U ]^=k0�Tk1W0�X^hL:W.�0 7W02e5]`:<3 lf0YnqXf1W3 :<3VXf9�1�X^h :<.�0 e5X&b ]`e hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1[3V9�:<.�0�3 U ]^uf0

1Wn�]^b20`H -/.�3V1Ql`]^7W35]^9;:�7W02nkep]^b>02=o:<.�0 U 359�Xf7 �^02749�02eM3V9 0>t�T_]`:<3VXf9#� | H � � ��3 :<.

� � � � � ��� �5 � � � � � � ��� �5 � � !�� ! ��� # � � ! � �� # # � � ��� � � F�H � �

��.�0>7W0�� � � � �Y3V1 :W.�0*b>XcX^7W=�3V9_]`:<0 X^hO:W.�0ohr0 ]`:WT�7W0 359:W.�0 3 U ]^uf0^H -/.�0�]^Tk:W.�Xf741 14XfT�uf.;: :WXb2X^9�14:W7<]^3V9 :<.�0 �^02749�02e :<X U ]`:<bd.�X ? �402b :<1Q:<.�]`:Q._] l^0�b2X U n X^9�029;:<1 ��3V:<. 1W3 U 35e5]^7 ]^n�nq0 ]`7<]^9�b>0

]^1 � 02e5e�]`1 143 U 35ep]`7[14n_]`:<35]^e/ep] @ XfTk: ��3V:W.�359�:W.�0 3 U ]`uf0�]^9�=�:<.k0 @ =�3V=�14X ?;@ � � � � � � �� � � �

:<.k0 U 359�Xf7 �`02749�02e ��3V:<.�] Z\]^T�141W3p]`9�v�GQx �`02749�02e ? 0 : �L0>029�]^e :<02749_]`:W0 7402n�74021W0>9;:d]`:W35Xf9�1[X^h

:<.k0[eVXcb2]^e hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1�9_] U 02e @ :<.�0>357 � ]^9�= � b2X&Xf7W=�3V9_]`:W0212HQF#.�]`:E:W02bd.�9k35t�T�0[hrX^7Eb>X U ? 3V9�359�u

�^0>7W9�0>e51IhrX^7E=�3 � 0>7W0>9�:IX ? �40>b>:O7402n�740214029;:d]`:W35Xf9k1O351�:<.�0 U X^14:E0 � 02b>:W3Vl^0[hrXf7E3 U n�7WX l&359�u b>ep]^141W3 �

s_b2]`:<3VXf9�]^b2b>T�7<]`b @�� -iX ? 02u^359�:<Xo]^9k1 � 027\:<.�3V1Ot�T�021m:<35X^9�e50>:OT�1\b2Xf9�1435=�0>7O: �LXo:<0>bd.�9�3Vt&Tk021

hrXf7/b>X U ? 3V9�359�u �`02749�02eV1�U T�e :<35nke535b2]`:<3VXf9�� ]^1�] ? X lf0��/]^9k= ]`=�=�3V:W35Xf9 H

- X�T�9�=k027W1m:d]^9k= :<.�0 0 � 02b :<1�X^h�]`=�=�359ku�: � X �`02749�02eV1�b>Xf9�1W3V=�027Y:W.�0 3V9;:<0274n�7W0 :d]`:W35Xf9�3V9

0 U ? 0>=�=�359ku�14n_]^b>0^H8,I1W14T U 0\: � X�n Xf143V:W3Vlf0�=k0>s_9�3 :<0 �^0>7W9�0>e51

� � ����� � � � � � � � ��� � ��� � � � F�H | �0� � � ����� � � � � � � � � ��� � � ��� � � � F�H � �

| N

Page 41: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

-/.�0a1WT U X^h :W.�0�: �LX�351

���� � � ����� � � � � ����� � � 0� � � ����� � � F�H F �

� � � � � � ��� � ��� � �"� � � � � � � ��� � � ��� � � � F�H ~ �

��� � � � ! �

# ��� �

� � � � ! � # � � ��� � ! � #� �

�� � � � ! �# ��

5 � � � � � � ! 5 # � � � ��� � ! 5 #

� � F�H ���.�0>7W0 � � � � ! � # 351Q:W.�0 + :W. 0>e50 U 0>9�:QX^h :W.�0Olf0>b>:WXf7 � � � �83V9�:<.�0�0 U ? 0>=�=�3V9�uY1Wn_]`b20^H8-/.�3V1351�3V:W1W0>eVhB0>t&Tk3Vl`]^e50>9;:I:<X�] =�X^:In�7WX&=�T�b :O3V9�]^9*3V9�=�T�b>02=�14n_]^b20 X^h =�3 U 029k1W35X^9_]^e53 : @ � � � � � � �� � � � � � � H�SO9�0)b2]^9�1W0>0�:<._]`: =_]`:d]*:W._]`: ]`7W0)1W0>n_]^7W] ? e50 359�023 :<.�0>7 X^h�:<.k0 : �LX�0 U ? 0>=�=�3V9�u1Wn�]^b20>1 ]^740 1402n_]^7W] ? eV083V9a:W.�0 ]^T�u U 029;:<0>=[14n_]^b>0^H -iXE:W.�0 =�02uf740208:<._]`:M:W.�0 3V9�=�3 lc3V=�T_]^e �^02749�02eV1

]^740�3V9�=�0>n 0>9�=�029;:�:<.�3V1 ��35e5eE359�b>7W02]^1W0�X lf0>7<]^eVe�1W02n�]^7<] ? 35e53 : @ ]`9�=(:W.�02740>hrXf740�b2ep]`1W1W3 s_b ] :<35X^9

]^b>b2T�7W]^b @ H�y h �L0 ��3V1W. :WX�b2Xf9;:W7WXfeM:<.�0 ? 3p]^1I]^b2b>Xf7W=k02= :<X 0 ]^bd.�X^hB:W.�0 b>X U n Xf9k029;: �^0>7W9�0>e51�

� 0[b2]^9 �L0>35uf.o:<.�0 U =�3 � 0>7W029;:We @

���� � � ����� � � �

� � ����� � � � � ��� � � � ����� � � F�H � �

��.�0>7W0 } 6�6 � H

- X T�9k=�027414:d]`9�= :W.�0�0 � 02b :<1�X^h U T�eV:W35n�e @ 359�ua: �LX �^0>7W9�0>e51�b>Xf9�1435=�0>7�]^u;]^3V9�:<.�0�3V9�:W0274n�7W0 �

:d] :<35X^9)359o0 U ? 02=k=�359�u 14n_]^b20`H

����� � � ����� � � � � ����� � 0� � � � ��� � � F�H N �� � � � � � � � � ��� � �= � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � F�H � �

��� � � � ! �

# ��� �

� � � � ! � # � � ��� � ! � #� �� � � � ! �

# ��5 �

� � � � � ! 5 # � � � ��� � ! 5 #� � F�H � } �

�� �� ! � # �����

� � � ! � # ��5 �

� � � � � ! � # � � � � � ! 5 # � � � � ��� � ! � # � � � ��� � ! 5 # � � F�H ��� �

F�0 b2]^9�n 0>74hrXf7 U ] l^]`7W3p] ? e50�14T ? 1m:<3V:WTk:<3VXf9 ��.�02740*]�9�0 � l`]^7W35] ? e50 7W]^9�uf0>1�X l^027 + ]`9�=��]`9�= � 0�1W020�:<._] :a:W.�0 1WT U 3V9�0>t�T_]`:<3VXf9 � F�H ��� ��3V1a3 :<1402eVh 02t�T�3 l`]^e50>9�:\:WX*]o=�X^:an�74Xc=�Tkb>: H

| �

Page 42: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

-/.�0 =�3 U 029�1435Xf9k1�X^hL:W.�351\:<7W]^9�14hrX^7 U 02=�1Wn_]^b>0 b>Xf9�1W3V14:aX^hQ:W.�0�n�7WX&=�T�b :<1aX^hQ0 lf027 @ n�]^357 ��351W0

b2X U ? 359�]`:<3VXf9�X^h =�3 U 029�1435Xf9k1Q359):<.k0a0 U ? 02=�=�3V9�u 1Wn_]`b2021�X^hi:<.�0�: � X b>X U nqXf9�0>9;: �^02749�02eV12H

y :I3V1�9�X^:Eb2e502]^7�3Vh ]^9�= ��.�029*:W.�0an�7WX&=�T�b :IX^h : �LX �^02749�02eV1 � XfT�eV= nq027mhrXf7 U ? 0>:4:<027�:<.�]^9

:<.k0[14T U�? Tk:E:W.�0\1WT U 3V1�]`:W:W7<]^b :<3Vl^0�hrXf7�3V:<1�3V9�:W0274n�7W0 :d]`:W35Xf9 ��3V:W. 740214n 0>b>:�:<X�1W02n�]^7<] ? 35e53 : @ H

y :O3V1IX^h b>XfT�741W0 nqXf1W143 ? eV0[:WX�1W3 U T�eV:<]^9�0>XfT�1We @ b ]^nc:<T�740 :<.�0 ]^=kl`]^9;:d]`uf021OX`h ? X^:W.*:<0>bd.�9�3Vt&Tk021

��3V:W. U 3V9�3 U ]^eqb2X U n�Tk:<]`:<3VXf9

�� �� �

� � ����� � � � � � ����� � � � � � � � � ����� � � � � � F�H � | �� � � ����� � 0� � � ����� � � � � ����� � � 0� � � ����� � � � � F�H � � �

,I9 @ 1W0>n_]^7W] ? 35eV3V: @ 359;:<74Xc=�Tkb202= ?;@ 023V:W.�027�:<.k0[14T U Xf7/:<.�0an�74Xc=�Tkb>:EX^h :W.�0 Xf7435uf3V9_]^e �^02749�02eV1

��35eVe_]^eV1WX ? 0�] l`]^35e5] ? eV0L359Y:W.�351 �^0>7W9�0>e H SO9�0�b ]`9 14020�:<.�3V1 ?�@ 9kX^:<3V9�u�:<._]`:80>t&T�]`:<3VXf9 � F�H � � �i3V1:<.k0E14T U X^h 02t�T_]`:W35Xf9�1 � F�H N � ]`9�= � F�HGF � ]^9�= :<.�0>9�]^n�nke @ 359�uO:W.�0E]^9_]^e @ 14351B3V9 0>t&T�]`:<3VXf9 � F�H �dHF�0 b ]`9�]^u;]^3V9 Tk1W0Y]�n_]^7<] U 0 :<027

� � �:<X�b>Xf9;:<7WX^eM:W.�0 � 023Vuf.;:Ouf3 lf0>9*:<X 0 ]^bd. :W027 U 3V9*02t�T_] �

:<3VXf9#� F�H � � ��� �

� �

� � ����� � � � � � ����� � � � � ��� � � 0� � � ����� � � �

� � F�H � F �F�08b2]^9a7W02b>T�7W143Vl^02e @ ]`n�n�e @ :<.�08]^9_]`e @ 1W3V1M] ? X l^08:WXET�9k=�027414:d]`9�=[:W.�0 0 U ? 02=�=k359�u�1Wn_]`b208X^h�]`9 @

U T�e :<3 l^]`7W3p] :<0 nqXfe @ 9kX U 35]^e ��3V:<.�]^9�]^7 ? 3V:<7W]^7 @ 9�T U ? 027aX^hLb>X U n Xf9k029;: �^02749�02eV12H)C�X �L0 lf027�

� 0Q9�020>= :<X ? 0 b ]^740>hrT�ec] ? XfTk: X lf027ms�:W:W359�u���.�3Vbd. 351it�T�3V:W0L0 ]`1 @ :<XI=kX ?;@ b>Xf9�1435=�0>7W359kuE.�3Vuf.�0>7

Xf74=�027/:<0>7 U 12H

�f}

Page 43: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

��' �(��� *� � ��(�� � ��! * �(� �+ ���������

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � ��� � �� �

SO9�0\X^hM:<.�0a]^n�nke535b2]`:<3VXf9�1 X^hM:<.�0>1W0\:<02bd.k9�35t�T�0>1E3V1L:<X U ]^7W3V9�0O1Wb>350>9�b20\=_]`:<]Yb2XfeVe502b :<0>= ?�@

] :<X&Xfe b ]^eVe502= :<.�0 �I35=�0>XY68e5]^9��;:<X^9 v�02b>Xf7W=k027 � �I68v�� � N � H -/.�0 �O3V=�02XY6 ep]`9��;:<Xf9ov�02b>Xf7W=�0>7b ]`nk:<T�74021�3 U ]^uf0>1YX^h U TkeV:<3Vb20>e5e5Tkep]^7aXf7Wuf]^9�351 U 1 :W._]`:�._] lf0 Xf7Wuf]^9�1�]^9�=]^n�nq029�=�]^uf021 ��3V:W.

=�3V14:<3V9�b>: l&3514T_]^e�]^n�nq0 ]`7<]^9�b>021 � x 3VufT�7W0 ~ H � �<H -/.�0*=�]`:d]�1W0 :�b2X^9�1W3V14:<1 X^h � N;|� uf7<] @ �z14b ]^eV03 U ]^uf0>1a:W._]`: ? 02eVXf9�u*:WX Xf9�0 X^h � F b>ep]^141W021 � - ] ? e50 ~ H � �

���.�3Vbd.�._] lf0 ? 02029�3V=�029;:W3Vs_0>= ?�@

0��cnq027m:<1�� | N � H)-/.�0 =_]`:d] 1W0 : 3V1[bd._]`e5e50>9�uf3V9�u)hr7WX U ] b2ep]`1W1W3 s_b ] :<35X^9�l&3V0���nqXf359;:ahrXf7\1W0>l^027W]^e

7W02]^1WX^9�12H�SO7Wuf]^9�351 U 1O]^7W0Yn�.kX^:<Xfu^7<]^n�.k02=�hr7WX U ]^7 ? 3 :<7W]^7 @ :<.�74020 �z=�3 U 0>9�1W3VXf9_]^eilc3V0���1>HY-/.�0

1W3 �20/X^hJ:W.�0/Xf7Wuf]^9�351 U 1 7W02e5]`:<3 lf0L:WXO:<.�0Qs�02e5= X^hJl&350 � X`hq:W.�0/b ] U 0>7<]O7W0>1WT�e :<1 359 U ]^9 @ 3 U ]^uf021

359 ��.�35bd.�:<.k0 Xf7Wuf]^9�351 U 351OXf9ke @ n_]^7m:<3p]`e5e @ lc3V1W3 ? e50`H�y :�351Eb2Xf9�1402t�T�0>9�:We @ ]�bd.�]^e5eV029�uf3V9�u�]`9�=

]`:4:<7<]`b>:<3 lf0[=_]`:d] 1WXfT�74b20 hrXf7�:<0>14:<3V9�u�XfTk7 U 0 :<.�X&=�1>HO-/.�0 =_] :d]�1W0 :�351E=�0214b2743 ? 02=�359*uf7W02]`:<0>7

=�0 :d]^3Ve 359 � | N � H

�$8 7 8 7 ��� � � � � ) � � � ���J� ��� � � )�� � � � � � �1� � � � 2 � � � �3� � � )�� � � ) ��� � � � � � � �F�0\7402nqXf74:�7W0>1WT�e :<1�.�0>7W0�hrXf7�]Yb2X U n_]^743514Xf9oX^h :W.�0 U ] :<bd.�3V9�u �^0>7W9�0>e ]`9�= :W.�0\0��cnq02b>:W02=

e53 �^0>e535.kXcX&= �^0>7W9�0>e � 0>t&T�]`:<3VXf9 � � H � ~ � �<H�-/.k0[s_7414:O0 �cn 0>7W3 U 029;:Ib2Xf9�14351m:<02=*X^h b2X U n_]^74359�u :<.k0]^b>b2T�7W]^b @ 021m:<3 U ]`:W0Bhr7WX U :W029�� hrXfe5=\b274Xf1W1il`]^e53V=_]`:<3VXf9OhrXf7i]E7W]^9�uf08X^h ? ]^9�= ��3V=k:<.k1 � $ �dH PLep]^141W3 �s_b2]`:<3VXf9�1 � 027W0�b2X U n�Tc:<02=�T�14359�u�:<.k0�eV3 ? 1ml U e53 ? 7<]^7 @ � � � H v�0214T�eV:W1 ]`7W0�1W.�X ��9 359�x 35u^T�7W0 ~ H | H

F�0*1W0>0 :W._]`:�:<.�0 U ] :<bd.�3V9�u �`02749�02eEb2Xf9�14351m:<029;:We @ XfTk:Wn 0>74hrXf7 U 1Y:<.k0*0��cnq02b :<02=+eV3 �`02e53V.�X&Xc=

�^0>7W9�0>eQhrXf7Y]^eVe ? ]^9�= ��3V=k:<.�1�]^9�=�:<.�]`:Y:<.�0 U ]��c3 U T U ]^b2b>T�7<]`b @ hrXf7 ? X`:<.�:<.k0 U ]`:Wbd.�359ku

�^0>7W9�0>eQ]^9k=�:<.�0 0��cnq02b>:W02=�eV3 �^0>e53V.�XcX&= �^0>7W9�0>eQX&b2b2Tk7W1 ] : ]^74XfT�9�= $ � |��f~ H -/.k0 1WTkn 0>7W35X^7

�)�

Page 44: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

� ����� � �$8 7 8 - ]��cXf9kX U 3Vb�b ]`:W02ufX^7W350>1/X^h 3 U ]^uf021/3V9):<.�0 �O68v�=�]`:d] 1W0 :

PQ]`:<0>ufXf7 @ {I] U 0 - ]��cXf9kX U 3VbaZ\74XfT�n 3 U ]^uf021 0 ��] U n�eV0� � � � � � ��� � � � ��� � � � � b2Xfnq02nqXc= 1Wnq02b>350>1 ���;|

PL._]^0>:WXfuf9_] :<.�1 �2X&Xfn�ep]`9��;:<Xf9on�. @ e5T U N�

� � � ��� �� � ���[SO1m:<7<]`b2X&=�1 Xf14:W7<]^b>Xc= uf029�T�1 � }f}

P :<029kXfn�.�Xf74021 �2X&Xfn�ep]`9��;:<Xf9on�. @ e5T U � F

D8Tkn�._]^T�14353V=�1 �2X&Xfn�ep]`9��;:<Xf9oXf74=�027 ���)�

C @ n 0>7W3V35=), U n�.�3Vn X&=�1 �2X&Xfn�ep]`9��;:<Xf9o1WT ? Xf74=�027 N

6 :W0274Xfn X&=�1 �2X&Xfn�ep]`9��;:<Xf9oXf74=�027 � F |

� 3p]`:WX U v�X&=�1 n�. @ :WXfn�e5]^9��;:<Xf9 b2e5]^1W1 ���

Ki]`74l`]^b202]^9�1 �2X&Xfn�ep]`9��;:<Xf9ob2e5]^1W1 �����

N U ]`e5egPLX^n 0>n X&=�1 �2X&Xfn�ep]`9��;:<Xf9ob2e5]^1W1 F ���

j 9�3V=�029;:<3 s_02=*PLep]`=�Xcb>027W]^9�1 �2X&Xfn�ep]`9��;:<Xf9oXf74=�027 � } N

Nc35n�.kXf9�Xfn�.kXf7W0>1 �2X&Xfn�ep]`9��;:<Xf9o1WT ? Xf74=�027 |`};|

� � ��� � ��� � ��� �� ��� � � � b2Xfnq02nqXc= 1Wnq02b>350>1 N�

=�0>l^02e5X^n U 0>9;:d]^eg1m:d]^uf0\X^hNc35n�.kXf9�T�ep]^0 �2X&Xfn�ep]`9��;:<Xf9o1WT ? Xf74=�027 � N

�;|

Page 45: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

� ����� '��21�� '�( �<A �����4�C���12* �2* �212*��� ��+,��� %-�;�2* �212*���

. ) � ��� � �$8 7�8 ,�hr0 � 0��k] U n�eV0�3 U ]^uf021 hr7WX U :W.�0 �O68v =_]`:<]Y1W0>:2H

nq0274hrX^7 U ]^9�b20�X^hg:W.�0 U ]`:<bd.k359�u �^0>7W9�0>e U ] @ ? 0I=�Tk0I:<Xa:<.�0�h ]^b>: :<._]`:8:<.k027W0O]^7W0E359�14T !�b2350>9;:1<] U n�eV021�359 ]^9 @ uf3Vl^029 3 U ]^u^0O:<X 74X ? T�1m:<e @ 0>14:W3 U ]`:<0a] =k029�143V: @ HEGL0>b ]^T�140 b>e5T�1m:<02741IX^h e5X&b ]^e

hr0 ] :<T�74021[:W029�=�:WX*._] l^0�1W0 U ]^9;:W35b b>Xf.�0>7W029kb20 � � | ��� 0�0��cnq02b : :<._] : :<.k0 b2X �zX&b2b2Tk7W7W0>9�b20 X^h

1<] U n�eV021Qhr74X U :W.�02140[b>e5T�1m:<02741 ��3Ve5eqhrXf7 U n 02] ��1E3V9o:W.�0\021m:<3 U ]`:W02=)=�0>9�1W3 : @ H8y h :W.�02740 ]^740�359��

1WT ! b>350>9�:�1W] U nke5021L359)]^9o3 U ]^u^0�n 02] ��1 U ] @ 9kX^: ? 0�7WX ? Tk14:<e @ 0>14:W3 U ]`:<0>=o]^9�=):<.�0�nk7WX&b202141

U ] @ ? 0\X lf0>7 ��.�0>e U 02= ?�@ 1Wn�T�7435XfTk1�hr02]`:<Tk7W021>H

yz9�Xf7W=�0>7O:<XoT�9�=k027W1m:d]^9k= ? 0>:4:<027O:W.�0Y7W02]^1WX^9�1 ��. @ :<.�0 U ]`:<bd.k359�u �`02749�02e XfTk:Wn 0>74hrXf7 U 1

:<.k0L0��cnq02b :<02= eV3 �^0>e53V.�XcX&= �^0>7W9�0>e�� 0Q._] lf0Q74T�9 0 �knq02743 U 029;:<1 :<._]`: 0��cn�eVXf7W08:<.�0 =�351m:<7W3 ? Tk:W35Xf9�1

X lf0>7 =�351m:d]^9kb2021 ? 0 : �L0>029Y:<.k0Q359�=k3Vl&35=�T�]^efhr0 ]`:WT�7W0>12H -/.�0Q0��cnq02743 U 029;:<1 b2Xf9�14351m:<02=YX`h_1W0>e502b :<3V9�u

: � X�0��k] U n�e50o3 U ]^u^021Yhr7WX U :<.�74020*=k3�� 027W0>9;: b>ep]^141W021>H F�0 =�0>1W35u^9_]`:<0 Xf9�0 X^hI:W.�0 3 U ]^uf021

hr7WX U 0 ]^bd.�b2e5]^1W1[]^1a] t�T�0>7 @�]^9�=�:<.�0�X^:W.�027\351\=�0>1W3Vuf9_]`:W02=�] :d]`7Wuf0 : H F�0�Xf9�e @ 0>l`]^eVT_]`:W0

Xf9�0Y1435=�0>=�=�351m:d]^9kb20Y359 :<.�3V1Ob ]^140^H[-/.�0Y3 U ]^uf0>1IT�1402=�]^7W0 14.�X ��9�3V9 - ] ? e50 ~ H | Ha- ] ? eV0 ~ H �

1W.kX ��1a:<.�0 .�3V14:WXfuf7<] U 1�X^hL=�351m:d]^9kb2021 ? 0>: � 02029�]^e5e n�]^35741aX`hLnqXf359;:W1 ��.k027W0�Xf9�0�nqXf359;:\351\3V9

:<.k0 t�T�027 @ 3 U ]^uf0 ]^9k= :<.�0 X^:<.�0>7�351 359�:<.�0*:<]^7Wu^0>:�3 U ]`uf0���.k35e50 - ] ? e50 ~ H F�1W.�X ��1�:<.k0

.�3V14:<X^uf7<] U 1�X^h =k3514:<]^9�b>021 ? 0>: � 020>9�]^e5egnqXf3V9�:W1E3V9 :W.�0 t�T�0>7 @ 3 U ]^uf0�]^9�= :<.�0ab2eVXf1W0>14:OnqXf3V9�:

359�:<.�0 :d]^74uf0>:[3 U ]^uf0`HoF�0�b2]^9�1W0>0 :<.�]`: :W.�0�0��cnq02b :<02=�eV3 �`02e53V.�X&Xc= �^0>7W9�0>eQ._]^1a:<X bd.kXcXf140

? 0>: � 02029 =�351m:<743 ? Tk:W35Xf9k1QX lf027�=�3V14:<]^9�b20>1Q:<._] :/l^]`7 @ X^9�e @ lf027 @ 1WeV35uf.;:We @���.�35eV0I:<.k0 U ]`:Wbd.�359ku

���

Page 46: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 45030

35

40

45

50

55

60

accu

racy

(%

)

bandwidth

Matching Kernel

Expected Likelihood Kernel

. ) ����� � �$8 :$8 GQ]^9k= ��35=k:W. ��$ � 3V1�n�e5X`:W:<0>=�l&1>H�]^b>b2T�7W]^b @ Xf9�:<.�0 �I6 v =_] :d]o1W0>:2H�v�0214T�eV:W1]^740a14.�X ��9 hrX^7�:W.�0 U ] :<bd.�3V9�u �^0>7W9�0>e

�]^9�=ohrXf7Q:W.�0\0��cn 0>b>:W02=*eV3 �`02e53V.�X&Xc= �`02749�02e H

� F

Page 47: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

� � � � � �$8 :$8 �O68v 3 U ]^uf0>1QT�1W0>= hrXf7/=k3514:<]^9�b>0a0 �cn 0>7W3 U 029;:W1

PLe5]^1W1 ��Tk027 @ y U ]^u^0 - ]^74uf0>:�y U ]^uf0

� � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � �PL.�]^0>:WXfuf9_]`:W.�1

� � � ��� �� � ���aSO14:W7<]^b>Xc=k1�^0>7W9�0>e ._]`1 U Xf7W0�l`]^7W35]`:<3VXf9Y359 :<.k0I=�3V14:<743 ? Tc:<35X^9�1Bhr7WX U ]auf3Vl^029 t&Tk027 @ 3 U ]^uf0`H yz9 h ]^b>:

�X^9�e @

lf0>7 @ hr0���hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1�:W._]`:�b2eVXf1W0>e @)U ]`:<bd. ��35eVe ._] lf0a.�3Vuf. l`]^eVT�021�X^h :<.�0 U 359�Xf7 �^02749�02ei359o:<.k0

] lf0>7<]^uf0aXfnq027W]`:<3VXf9)359):<.k0 U ]`:Wbd.�359�u �`02749�02e � 0>t�T_]`:<3VXf9 � | H � � �<H

�$8 7 8 : % � � ��� � � ��� � � 2 � � � ) � � � � �GL02b2]^T�140 X^hI:W.�0 1WT�nq027435Xf7�n 0>74hrXf7 U ]`9�b20oX^hO:W.�0 U ]`:Wbd.�359ku �`02749�02eEX l^027�:<.�0 0��cnq02b>:W02=

e53 �^0>e535.kXcX&= �^0>7W9�0>e�� 0 =k0>s_9�0 ] b2e5]^1W1EX^h �`027W9k02e51En_]^7W] U 0 :<743��20>= ?;@ :<.�0[Xf7W=k027I1m:d]`:W351m:<35b>1I]`1

hrXfeVe5X ��1

�� �� � � � � � �| � ��� �� � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � ~ H � �

��� �� � � � � � ��

�& & � � (

�����

�� � �� � � ! ��� � � �� #�� � ! ��� � � �� # �

� � � ��� �5 � � ~ H | �

��.�0>7W0 � � � � � � �� � 3V1i:W.�0 & & � � ( :<.[ep]^74uf021m: �`02749�02ec0>l`]^e5T�]`:<3VXf9[7W]^9�uf3V9�u�X l^027i:<.�0 1W0>: X^h�l^02b>:WXf7W1 �� � H & 7W02nk7W0214029;:<1�:W.�0[hr7W]^b>:W35Xf9 X^h �^0>7W9�0>e 0>l`]^eVT_]`:W35Xf9�1�:<.�]`: ��3Ve5e ? 0 ] lf0>7<]^uf0>=�359 :W.�0 3V9�9�0>7e5X&Xfn�X^h�:<.�0 =�XfT ? e50o1WT U U ]`:<3VXf9 H�yz9�:<.�0 b ]^140 :W._]`: & � � � :<.�3V1 351 02t�T�3 l^]`e5029;: :<X�:<.k0U ]`:<bd.�3V9�u �`027W9k02e

�]`9�=�359�:W.�0�b2]^1W0�:W._]`: & � � :W.�0 �`027W9k02e ? 02b>X U 0>1Y02t�T�3 l^]`e5029;:[:<X :<.k0

0��cnq02b :<02= e53 �^02eV35.�X&X&= �^0>7W9�0>e H

x_Xf7 :<.k021W0)0 �cn 0>7W3 U 029;:W1 �L0o.�0>e5=�:<.k0 ? ]^9�= ��35=k:W.�s �k0>=�]`: $ � |��f~ ]^9�=�l`]^7W3V02=�:<.k0

n_]^7W] U 0>:<0>7 & H v�021WTkeV:<1E]^740[14.�X ��9*359 x 3VufT�7W0 ~ H � H8F�0ab ]`9 14020[:W._]`: � 0[=�X 359)h ]^b :Iuf0 :E]^9

�;~

Page 48: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

� ����� � �$8 H$8 C�3514:WXfuf7W] U 1 X^hI=�351m:d]^9kb2021 X lf027 ]^e5e/n�]^357 ��351W0)hr02]`:<T�740 U ]`:Wbd.�021>H+D ]`bd. 7WX �7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:W1 ]�=�3�� 0274029;: t&Tk027 @ 3 U ]`uf0

���.�35eV0 :<.�0�b2X^e5T U 9�1o]^740�02]^bd. ]�=�3 � 0>7W029;:o:d]`7Wuf0 :

3 U ]^uf0`H

� � � � � � ��� � � � ��� � � � � PL.�]^0>:WXfuf9_]`:W.�1 � � � ��� �� � ���aSO14:W7<]^b>Xc=k1

� �� 100 200 300 400 500 600 7000

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

100 200 300 400 500 600 7000

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

100 200 300 400 500 600 7000

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

PL. H100 200 300 400 500 600 7000

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

100 200 300 400 500 600 7000

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

100 200 300 400 500 600 7000

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

� S H100 200 300 400 500 600 7000

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

100 200 300 400 500 600 7000

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

100 200 300 400 500 600 7000

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

��

Page 49: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

� ����� � �$8 � 8 CE3V14:WXfuf7<] U 1oX^h =�351m:d]^9�b>021 X l^027 U ]��c3 U T U hr02]`:<Tk7W0 U ]`:Wbd.�021>H D ]`bd. 7WX �7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:W1 ]�=�3�� 0274029;: t&Tk027 @ 3 U ]`uf0

���.�35eV0 :<.�0�b2X^e5T U 9�1o]^740�02]^bd. ]�=�3 � 0>7W029;:o:d]`7Wuf0 :

3 U ]^uf0`H

� � � � � � ��� � � � ��� � � � � PL.�]^0>:WXfuf9_]`:W.�1 � � � ��� �� � ���aSO14:W7<]^b>Xc=k1

� �� 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 5500

2

4

6

8

10

12

100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 5500

2

4

6

8

10

12

100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 5500

2

4

6

8

10

12

PL. H100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 5500

2

4

6

8

10

12

100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 5500

2

4

6

8

10

12

100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 5500

2

4

6

8

10

12

� S H100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 5500

2

4

6

8

10

12

100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 5500

2

4

6

8

10

12

100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 5500

2

4

6

8

10

12

� �

Page 50: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 0.14 0.16 0.18 0.248

50

52

54

56

58

60ac

cura

cy (

%)

fraction of evaluations

Robust Kernel

. ) ����� � �*8 H$8 x_7<]^b :<35X^9 X^h U 3V9�Xf7 �^0>7W9�0>e 0>l`]^eVT_]`:<3VXf9�1 ��& � 351�n�e5X`:W:<0>= l&12HI]^b2b>T�7<]`b @ Xf9*:<.k0�O68v =_] :d]Y1W0 : H -/.�0 �^02749�02eM3V1/b2X U n�Tk:W02= ]^1�359)02t�T_] :<35X^9 ~ H � H

359kb27W02]^1W0�359�nq0274hrX^7 U ]^9�b20 ?;@ ] lf027W]^uf3V9�u X lf0>7Q]\1 U ]^e5e�hr7W]^b>:W35Xf9 � ]^n�n�74X �c3 U ]`:W02e @�~�� � X^h :<.k0�^0>7W9�0>eM0>l`]^e5T�]`:<3VXf9�1/]^1�Xfnkn Xf1402=o:<X�Xf9�e @ :<.k0 U ]��c3 U T U U ]`:Wbd. H

�$8 7 8 H ��� � � )� )� � � � � ���1� � � � � � � � � . � ��� ��� ���D �knq02743 U 029;:<1�._] lf0[]^eV1WX ? 0>029 7WT�9 T�1W3V9�u ufe5X ? ]^e hr02]`:<T�74021 ��3V:W. :W.�0\35=�02]YX^h b>X U ? 3V9�359�u

ufeVX ? ]^e�]^9�= e5X&b ]^e/hr0 ] :<T�74021 hrX^7 3 U n�74X l^02= b>ep]^141W3 s_b ]`:W35Xf9�nq0274hrX^7 U ]^9�b20`H�Z�e5X ? ]^eQhr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1

T�1402=�.�02740o]^7W0 :<.�Xf140)7W0>n Xf7m:<0>=�359 � | N � H�v�0>1WT�e :<1 hrXf7 ] ufe5X ? ]^e hr0 ]`:WT�7W0�b>ep]^141W3 s_027 Tk1W359ku�]

Z\]^T�1W143p]^9*vEGLx �^0>7W9�0>e ��3 :<. l`]^7 @ 359�u ? ]^9�= ��3V=k:<.k1O]^740 7W0>n X^74:<0>= 359 s_ufT�740 ~ HGF�H�-/.�0[e5X&b ]^e

� N

Page 51: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

0 2 4 6 8 10 1220

25

30

35

40

45

50

55

60

bandwidth

accu

racy

(%

)

Global Features

. ) ����� � �$8 � 8 GQ]^9k= ��35=k:W. ��$ � 3V1�n�e5X`:W:<0>=�l&1>H�]^b>b2T�7W]^b @ Xf9�:<.�0 �I6 v =_] :d]o1W0>:2H�v�0214T�eV:W1]^740a14.�X ��9 hrX^7�u^e5X ? ]`e hr0 ] :<T�74021�T�1W3V9�u�] Z\]^T�141W35]^9 vEGQx �`027W9k02e H

hr0 ] :<T�740 �^0>7W9�0>e T�1402=o.�02740O3518:<.�0 U ] :<bd.�3V9�u �^0>7W9�0>e HB-/.�0>7W0 �L]^1/9�X 14:d] :<351m:<3Vb ]^eVe @ 1435uf9�3 s_b ]`9�:

3 U n�74X l^0 U 029;: ��.�0>9 :<.k0a74X ? T�1m: �^02749�02e �L]^1�T�1W0>=*359)b>X U ? 3V9_]`:W35Xf9)0 �knq02743 U 029;:<1>H

�$8 7 8 H$8 7 � � � ���J� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �F#.�029 �L0 b2X U ? 359�0)eVXcb2]^e/]^9k= ufeVX ? ]^e8hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1 T�14359�u�:<.k0 U 0 ]^9�X^h�:<.�0>357 �^0>7W9�0>e51

�]

1W3Vuf9�3 s_b ]^9;:/3V9�b2740 ]^140O359o]`b2b2Tk7<]^b @ 7W0>1WT�e :<1 �rs_ufT�740 ~ H ~ �dHB-/.�0\]`b2b2Tk7<]^b>35021/14.�X � ] nkep]`:W0 ]^T)3V9

:<.k0 lc3Vb23V9�3V: @ X^h�:<.�0 U ]��c3 U T U���.�35bd.auf3Vl^021gT�1g14X U 0B7WX ? Tk14:<9k021W1M:<X/14T ? Xfnk:<3 U ]`e ? ]^9k= ��35=k:W.

1W0>e50>b>:<3VXf9 H/yz9;:<0>7W0>14:<3V9�ufe @�:<.�XfTkuf.

�:<.�0 U ]��k3 U T U =kXc0>1E9�X`:IX&b2b>T�7O]`:�:<.k0[b>X U ? 3V9_]`:<3VXf9oX^h

:<.k0 U ]��k3 U T U U ]`:<bd.�3V9�u �`027W9k02e�]^9�=�:W.�0 U ]��c3 U T U u^e5X ? ]`e8hr02]`:<T�740 �^0>7W9�0>e H�-/.�0�nq0 ] �

���

Page 52: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

100150

200250

300350

400

0

2

4

6

8

1030

35

40

45

50

55

60

65

70

matching kernel bandwidthglobal features bandwidth

accu

racy

(%

)

. ) ����� � �$8 �$8 PLe5]^1W143Vs_b2]`:<3VXf9 ]^b2b>T�7<]^b>350>1 hrXf7 :<.�0 U 02]^9 X^h :<.�0 �^02749�02eV1LhrXf78ufe5X ? ]^eJ]^9�= e5X&b ]^ehr0 ] :<T�740212H

359k14:<02]^=\351geVXcb2]`:<0>=\]`:i]Qn X^359;: ��.�0>7W0 :<.�0 U ]`:<bd.k359�u �`027W9k02e ? ]^9�= ��35=k:W.a3V1g1WX U 0���.�]`:M1 U ]^e5eV027

:<.�]^9+:<._]`:o3V9�=�3Vb ]`:W02=+359 s�ufT�7W0 ~ H |�]^9�=(]`:o]�nqXf359;: ��.k027W0�:W.�0�ufe5X ? ]^eEhr02]`:<Tk7W0 �^0>7W9�0>e

? ]^9k= ��35=k:W. 351 1WX U 0���.�]`:�e5]^7Wuf0>7�:W._]^9 :W._]`: 359�=k35b ] :<02=359 s�ufT�7W0 ~ HGF�H$yz9 ]^9 029k1W0 U ? e50�

:<.k0 ]`b2b2Tk7<]^b @ X^hE:W.�0ob2e5]^1W143Vs_0>7Y351 =�02nq029k=�029;: Xf9�:W._]`: 0>7W7WX^7W1 ? 0 : �L0>029 b>X U n Xf9k029;:<1�]^740

359k=�02nq029�=k029;:�7<] :<.�0>7�:W._]^9):<.�]`:�:<.�0a]^b>b2T�7W]^b @ X`h 02]^bd.*b>X U nqXf9�0>9;:�351 U ]��k3 U 3 �20>= H

x 3 �c3V9�u):<.�0 e5X&b ]^e ? ]^9�= ��3V=k:<.�]`: � ]^9�=�:<.�0 ufe5X ? ]^e ? ]`9�= ��35=c:<.�] : |^}^}�� 0�._] lf0�74T�9

0��cnq02743 U 029;:<1 359 ��.�35bd. :W.�0 � 023Vuf.;:�]`b2b2X^7W=�0>= :<X�ufe5X ? ]^e�]^9�=e5X&b ]^e �`027W9k02e51�l`]^7W3V021 ]^1 3V9

02t�T_] :<35X^9�F�H � H v�0214T�eV:W1B]^740L1W.kX ��9Y3V9 x 3VufT�740 ~ H HiF�0 b ]^9 14020L:W._]`: :<.�0Qnq027mhrXf7 U ]^9�b>08l`]^74350>1

F }

Page 53: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 155

60

65

70

weight accorded to global features

accu

racy

(%

)

Weighted Average of Local and Global Kernels

. ) ����� � �$8 �$8 PLep]^141W3Vs�b ]`:W35Xf9 ]^b2b>T�7<]`b2350>1EhrXf7 � 023Vuf.;:<02= ] l^027W]^uf021EX^h :W.�0 �`02749�02eV1EhrXf7�ufeVX ? ]^e]^9�= e5X&b ]`e hr0 ] :<T�740212H

]^1I:W.�0 n_]`7<] U 0>:W027�bd._]^9�u^021 ��3 :<.�] U ]��c3 U T U n 0>74hrXf7 U ]^9kb20 ��.k029�ufe5X ? ]^eghr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1�]^740

uf3 lf029 ] �L0>35uf.;:�X^h ]^n�n�74X �k3 U ] :<02e @�}@� � ]^9�= e5X&b ]`e hr0 ] :<T�74021E] � 023Vuf.;:�X^h }@� � H

�$8 7 8 H$8 : � � ��� � � � ���J� � � � �1� � � � � � � � � � � � � � �v�0>1WT�e :<1B]`7W0Q]`e51WXI1W.�X ��9 359 x 35ufTk7W0 ~ H � hrXf7 :W.�0Qn�74Xc=�Tkb>:BX^h_:W.�0Lb>X U n Xf9k029;: �^0>7W9�0>e51>H ,Ib �

b2Tk7<]^b>35021 ]^740E143 U 35ep]`7 ? 0>: � 02029�:W.�0�n�7WX&=�T�b :Q]^9k= :<.k0 U 0 ]^9�:W.�XfT�u^. :<.k0En�74Xc=kT�b>: n 0>74hrXf7 U 1

1WeV35uf.;:We @Y? 0>:4:<027 hrXf7 ][e5]^7Wuf0>7 ufe5X ? ]^e�hr0 ]`:WT�7W0 ? ]^9�= ��35=k:W. H -/.�0E=�3�� 0274029�b>0 ? 0>: � 02029):W.�0 ? 021m:

F �

Page 54: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

100150

200250

300350

400

0

5

10

1520

30

40

50

60

70

matching kernel bandwidthglobal features bandwidth

accu

racy

(%

)

. ) ����� � �$8 M 8 PLe5]^1W143Vs_b2]`:<3VXf9�]^b2b>T�7<]`b2350>1[hrXf7�:W.�0 nk7WX&=�T�b>:[X^hQ:W.�0 �^02749�02eV1[hrXf7\ufeVX ? ]^e ]`9�=e5X&b ]`e hr0 ] :<T�740212H

nq0274hrX^7 U ]^9�b20 X^h�:<.�0 U 0 ]^9�]^9�=�:<.�0 ? 021m: n 0>74hrXf7 U ]`9�b20 hrX^7[:<.k0)n�7WX&=�T�b : 351 1m:d]`:W351m:<35b2]^e5e @

359k1W35u^9�3Vs_b2]^9;:�;~@� ��� |@� � � l&1 ��@� F � �:� � �

�74021Wnq02b :<3 lf02e @ H

�$8 7 8 H$8 H � � � � � � ) � � � � � � )� ��� ) � � ��� � � � � �1� � � � � � � ��� � � � � � �x_Xf7i:W.�02140/0��cnq027W3 U 0>9;:<1

��L0Q7W]^9 ]E1W3 U n�eV08nqXfe @ 9kX U 35]^efb>X U ? 3V9_]`:<3VXf9aX^hJe5X&b ]^e�]`9�= ufeVX ? ]^e

hr0 ] :<T�74021 ]^1 3V90>t�T_]`:<3VXf9 F�H � F�H yz9�:<.�0os_7W1m: 0 �cn 0>7W3 U 029;:�� 0*T�1402=+]^9�02t�T_]`e � 023Vuf.;:<359ku

? 0>: � 02029�:W.�0 �^0>7W9�0>e51Lb>X U n�Tk:<0>= hrXf7 eVXcb2]^e_]^9�=�ufeVX ? ]^ekhr02]`:<Tk7W021�14.�X ��9�359 x 3VufT�7W0 ~ H N H -/.�0

U ]��c3 U T U ]`b2b2Tk7<]^b @ X^h ]^n�nk7WX �c3 U ]`:<0>e @��f|�� 3V1I:<.�0 ? 0>14:\]^b>b2T�7W]^b @ ]^bd.�3V0>lf0>=�:<.�T�1Oh ]^7EXf9

:<.k0��I6 v =_] :d]o1W0>:2H�,I=k=�3V:W35Xf9_]`e5e @�� 0 b2]^9�14020�359�x 35ufTk7W0 ~ H N :W._]`:a:<.�0>7W0�351a]o7W02e5]`:<3 lf0>e @

F |

Page 55: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

? 74X;]^=�n�e5]`:<02]^T�3V9�:W.�0�uf7W]^n�.�X^hL:<.�0)]`b2b2Tk7<]^b @�359k=�35b2]`:<3V9�u :W._]`:[:<.�0 �^02749�02eQ]^e5eVX ��1\hrXf7[]

ufX&Xc= ] U X^T�9;:OX^h :<X^e5027W]^9�b>0[:<X)=k3�� 027W0>9;:�1W0 :W:<3V9�uf1OX`h8:W.�0 n_]`7<] U 0>:W027W1 ��3V:<.kXfTk:�1435uf9�3 s_b ]`9�:

e5X^1W1/X^h b2e5]^1W143Vs_b2]`:<3VXf9 ]^b2b>T�7<]^b @ H

yz9�:<.�0 1W0>b2Xf9�=�0 �cn 0>7W3 U 029;:��L0 l^]`7W350>=�:<.k0 � 0235u^.�: X^h/:<.k0 e5X&b ]`e ]`9�=�ufeVX ? ]^e �^0>7W9�0>e51>H

� T�0Q:WXa:W.�0�.�35uf.Ynq027mhrXf7 U ]^9�b>0/X^hq:<.�0 � 0235u^.�:W359�u\3V9 N&02b>:W35Xf9 ~ H � H � H � � 0�1W0>: :W.�0 �^02749�02eJX lf0>7

ufeVX ? ]^e hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1Y:<X�._] lf0 ] � 023Vuf.;: X^h }:� � ]^9k=�:<.�0 �`027W9k02e�X lf027YeVXcb2]^e hr02]`:<Tk7W021 ] � 023Vuf.;:

X^h }:� � H\v�021WTkeV:<1OhrX^7E:<.k351 � 023Vuf.;:<359kuo]^7W0 14.�X ��9�359 s_ufTk7W0 ~ H � H\-/.�0 � 023Vuf.;:<359ku�n 0>74hrXf7 U 0>=

1WeV35uf.;:We @ � Xf741W0[:W._]^9 :<.�0[T�9 �L0>35uf.;:<0>= 0��cnq02743 U 029;:I=k021Wb>7W3 ? 0>= 359o:<.�0an�740>l&35XfTk1En_]`7<]^uf7W]^n�. H

-/.�3V1Q359�=k35b ] :<0218:<._] :L:<.k0 �L0>35uf.;:W359�u U ] @ 9�X^:/]`=�=)1W3Vuf9�3Vs�b ]^9;:<e @ :<X :W.�0O=�3V1Wb>7W3 U 359�] ? 35eV3V: @ X^h

:<.k0 �`02749�02e H

� ��� �' ����� � ��� � �� �

PLX U n_]^7<] :<3Vl^0 14:<Tk=�350>1 � � F��5� �&._] l^0LT�1402= :W.�0 D -�C � Nf} =_]`:d]�1W0 :B]^1 ] ? ]^1W0>e53V9�0 � |�� � H -/.�0

D -�C � Nf} =�]`:d] 1W0 :Ob2X^9�1W3V14:<1�X^h N =�3 � 0>7W0>9�:Eb2e5]^1W14021 ��3V:W. F � =�3 � 0>7W029;:�l&350���1�X^h � } =k3�� 027W0>9;:

0��k] U n�eV021Onq027�b>ep]^1412H D �k] U n�e50 3 U ]^uf021I]^7W0 1W.�X ��9�359 s_ufTk7W0 ~ H � } Hav�021WTkeV:<1\]`7W0Y7W0>n X^74:<0>=

.�0>7W0IhrXf7 1W0 lf027W]^e l`]^743p]`:W35Xf9�18X^hMeVXcb2]^e �^02749�02eV1L:<X ]^35=�3V9 b>X U n�]^7W3V1WXf9 ��3 :<.�X`:<.�0>7 :<0>bd.�9�3Vt&Tk021

:<.�]`:\._] lf0 7W0>1WT�e :<1\7W0>n X^74:<0>=�hrXf7O:<.�0 1W] U 0Y=�]`:d]�140>: HYyz9�XfT�7�0 �cn 0>7W3 U 029;:W1�.�02740��L0 T�1402=

:<0>9�� hrX^e5=Yb274Xf1W1 � l`]^eV35=_]`:W35Xf9 ��3V:W. ]`e5e&3 U ]^uf021 X^hqXf9�0/X ? �40>b>: hr7WX U 0 ]`bd. b>ep]^141B.�02eV=YXfTk: 359Y02]^bd.

hrXfeV= H

v�0>1WT�e :<1�]^740O1W.kX ��9ohrXf78:<.�0 U ]`:<bd.k359�u �`02749�02eM]^9k=)0��cn 0>b>:W02= e53 �`02eV35.�X&Xc= �^0>7W9�0>eM]^n�n�eV350>=

:<X :<.�0 D -�C � N^} =_]`:<] 140>:[359�s�ufT�7W0 ~ H ��� H F�0 b2]^9�14020 :W._]`:a:<.�0 U ] :<bd.�3V9�u �`027W9k02e ]^u;]^3V9

XfTk:Wn 0>74hrXf7 U 1�:W.�0 0 �cn 0>b>:<0>=�e53 �^02eV35.�X&X&= �^0>7W9�0>e ?;@ t&Tk3V:<0�] ep]^74uf0 U ]`7Wuf3V9 H -/.�0�7W0>1WT�e :<1aX^h

:<.k0 U ]`:Wbd.�359�u �`02749�02e ]^7W0�b>Xf9�143514:W029;: ��3V:<.):W.�Xf1W0\7402nqXf74:W02= 359 � � F�� H

v�X ? T�14:W9�02141 0��cnq02743 U 029;:<1[._] lf0 ? 020>9�7WTk9�Xf9�:W.�0 D -�C � Nf} =_]`:d]o1W0 :Y]^1[=�0214b2743 ? 02=�3V9

Nc0>b>:<3VXf9 ~ H � H | HO,Iuf]^359�:<.�0 ? ]^9�= ��3V=k:<. �L]^1O.k02e5=�b>Xf9�1m:d]^9;:

� $ � |��f~���.k35e50a:<.�0[hr7<]^b :<35X^9

X^hL0>l`]^e5T�]`:<3VXf9�1O3V9�b2eVT�=�02=�359�:<.k0 �`02749�02e��& � �Q]`1 ]^eVe5X � 02=�:<Xol^]`7 @ H v�021WTkeV:<1a]^740 1W.�X ��9�3V9

s_ufTk7W0 ~ H � | H F�0�b ]`9�1W0>0 :<._] : T�9�eV3 �`0�:W.�0 �O68v =_]`:<]*1W0 :�:W.�02740�351a9�X�]^=cl^]`9�:<]^uf0�hr7WX U

F �

Page 56: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

100150

200250

300350

400

0

5

10

1530

35

40

45

50

55

60

65

70

75

matching kernel bandwidthglobal features bandwidth

accu

racy

(%

)

. ) ����� � �$8��$8 PLep]`1W1W3 s_b ] :<35X^9 ]^b>b2T�7W]^b23V021OhrXf7I]^9 T�9 � 0235u^.�:W02=�n X^e @ 9�X U 3p]^egb>X U ? 3V9_]`:W35Xf9 X^h:<.k0 �`02749�02eV1�hrXf7/u^e5X ? ]`e ]^9�= e5X&b ]`e hr0 ] :<T�740212H

F F

Page 57: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

100150

200250

300350

400

0

5

10

1530

35

40

45

50

55

60

65

70

75

matching kernel bandwidthglobal features bandwidth

accu

racy

(%

)

. ) ����� � �*8 �$8 PLep]^141W3 s_b ]`:W35Xf9 ]^b>b2T�7W]^b23V021IhrXf7E] � 023Vuf.;:<02=*n Xfe @ 9�X U 3p]^egb>X U ? 3V9_]`:<3VXf9oX^hB:<.k0�^0>7W9�0>e51�hrXf7/ufeVX ? ]^e ]^9�= e5X&b ]^eqhr0 ]`:WT�7W0>12H

F ~

Page 58: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

. ) ����� � �$8 7ED*8 D ��] U n�eV0�3 U ]^uf0>1Qhr7WX U :<.�0\D -�C � Nf} =�]`:d]Y1W0 : H

F

Page 59: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 70020

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

bandwidth

accu

racy

(%

)

Matching Kernel

Expected Likelihood Kernel

. ) ����� � �$8 7�7�8 GL]^9�= ��3V=k:<. ��$ � 351 n�e5X`:W:<0>= l&12HB]`b2b2Tk7<]^b @ Xf9 :W.�0QD -�C � Nf} =_]`:<]O1W0 : HBv�0214T�eV:W1]^740a14.�X ��9 hrX^7�:W.�0 U ] :<bd.�3V9�u �^0>7W9�0>e�]^9�=ohrXf7Q:W.�0\0��cn 0>b>:W02=*eV3 �`02e53V.�X&Xc= �`02749�02e H

F �

Page 60: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 0.14 0.16 0.1855

60

65

70

75

80

85

fraction of evaluations

accu

racy

(%

)

robust kernel

. ) ����� � �*8 7 :$8 x_7<]^b :<35X^9 X^h U 359�Xf7 �^0>7W9�0>eg0>l`]^eVT_]`:<3VXf9�1 � & � 3V1Ln�eVX^:W:W02=�l&12H ]`b2b2Tk7<]^b @ Xf9�:<.k0D -�C � Nf} =�]`:d]Y1W0 : H -/.�0 �^0>7W9�0>e 3V1/b2X U n�Tk:W02= ]^1/359o0>t&T�]`:<3VXf9 ~ H � H

] lf0>7<]^uf3V9�u X l^027/]a1 U ]^e5e�hr7W]^b>:W35Xf9�X^h :W.�0I=_] :d]kH -/.k0On 0>74hrXf7 U ]`9�b20�1W0>0 U 1 :<X U X^9�X^:<X^9�35b2]^e5e @

=�0>b27W02]^1W0 ��3V:W.�:W.�0o9&T U ? 0>7 X`h U 359�X^7 �^02749�02e�0 l^]`e5T_]`:W35Xf9k12H�-/.�351 T�9k=�02741Wb2X^7W021 :<.�0o=_]`:<]

=�0>n 0>9�=�029;:�9�]`:<T�740 X^h :<.�0[n 0>74hrXf7 U ]`9�b20aX^h :W.�0 74X ? T�1m: �`027W9k02e ]`9�=*7W]^3514021�:<.�0[t&Tk0214:W35Xf9 X^h

��.�0 :<.�0>7 359;:<0>7W0>14:YnqXf359;:[=�0>:W02b :<35X^9�]^e5u^Xf7W3 :<. U 1 U 3Vuf.;: ? 0�=�0>1W3Vuf9�02=�:<X 1402e50>b>: 1W0>:W1Y3 U ]^uf0

n_]`:Wbd.�021�:<.�]`: �LX^T�e5= ? 0>9�0>sk:�hr74X U :W.�0\7WX ? Tk14: �^0>7W9�0>e ]`n�n�7WXf]^bd. H

F N

Page 61: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

��' �(��� *� �

�� ����� �����

yz9;:<0274021m:<359kufe @�:<.�0 ? 0>14:Ynq027mhrXf7 U ]^9�b>0 T�14359�u X^9�e @�? ]^u^1 X^h/hr02]`:<T�74021 X`h ~� H � Xf9�:<.k0

�O68v =�]`:d]�1W0 :8351 9�X`: 1WX\=�3�� 0274029;:Bhr7WX U :<.�]`: X^h ]�7W02e5]`:<0>= :<0>bd.�9�35t�T�0�359 ��.k35bd. ] U ]��c3 U T U

e53 �^0>e535.kXcX&= b2ep]`1W1W3 s_027L351L0 U nke5X @ 0>=)T�1W3V9�u 9�Xf9 �zn_]^7W] U 0>:<7435b�=�029k1W3V: @ 021m:<3 U ]`:W35Xf9 � | N � HByz9�:<.�3V1

:<0>bd.�9�3Vt&Tk0Y] 1W3V9�ufeV0[=�3V14:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9 X l^027OeVXcb2]^eghr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1O351�021m:<3 U ]`:W02=*hrXf7E]^9 � ��� � � ��� � � � ?�@021m:<3 U ]`:W359�u ])=�029�143V: @ T�1W3V9�uo]^e5eihr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1�359 :W.�0 :<7W]^359�3V9�u 3 U ]`uf021>Ha, t�T�0>7 @ 3 U ]^uf0 3V1O1W0 :

:<X :W.�0 U ]��c3 U T U eV3 �`02e53V.�X&Xc= 021m:<3 U ]`:W0Ib>X U nkTk:<0>= ��3 :<. :W.�0�]^141WT U nk:W35Xf9)X^hM3V9�=�0>n 0>9�=�029kb20

? 0>: � 02029 ]^e5eqhr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1�3V9):<.�0\3 U ]^uf0

e5Xfu �� � � # � � ���

��5 �

eVXfu �� � 5 � # � � � H � �

��.�0>7W0 # � 351 ]\b2ep]`1W1Le5] ? 02e Hi-/.�0 U ]��c3 U T U eV3 �^0>e53V.�XcX&= :<0>bd.�9�3Vt&Tk0O]^bd.�3V0>l^02=)]^9 ]^b2b>T�7<]`b @ X^h

~f| H � � Xf9 :W.�0 �O68v =_]`:<]^1W0 : H

y : 3V1[3V9;:<0274021m:<359ku :<X b2X^9�1W3V=�027 ��.�029�0>3V:W.�027aX^hQ:W.�0�:W02bd.�9k35t�T�021 U 3Vuf.;:[nq027mhrXf7 U ? 0>:4:<0>7

:<.�]^9 :<.�0*X^:<.�0>72H�-/.�0 U ]��c3 U T U e53 �`02eV35.�X&Xc=�b>ep]^141W3Vs�027�3V1 ? ]^1402=#Xf9#]^9 ]^1W14T U nc:<35X^9 X^h

359k=�02nq029�=k029�b>0 ? 0>: � 020>9 hr02]`:<Tk7W021/3V9o]^9)359k=�3Vl&35=kT_]^eJ3 U ]^uf0�]^9k=)Xf9o]^9o]^141WT U nk:<3VXf9�:<.�]`:/3V:

351�]`n�n�7WX^n�7W35]`:<0I:WX 0214:W3 U ]`:<0\]Y=�3V14:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9�X lf0>7I]^9o0>9�:W35740�b2ep]`1W12H -/.�3V1/ep]`:4:<0>7�]^1W14T U nc:<35X^9

U ] @#? 7W0 ] �+=�X ��9 359#:<.�0�0>l^029;:*:W._]`:*]�b>ep]^141 b>Xf9�143514:W1*X^h ] U 3 �&:<Tk7W0�X^h : � X X^7 U Xf7W0

1WT ? �zb>ep]^141W021[:<._]`: ]^7W0 =�7<] ��9�hr74X U =�3�� 0274029;: =k3514:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9�1>H yz9�:W.�351ab ]`1W0�:W.�0 :W02bd.�9�3Vt�T�0

b2X^9��J]`:W021�:<.�0�: � X =�3V14:W7W3 ? Tk:<3VXf9�12H -/.�0 �`02749�02ei]^n�nk7WX;]^bd.�X^9o:W.�0\X^:<.k027�._]^9�=

�351 ? ]^1402= Xf9

n_]^3V7 ��3V1W0 b>X U n�]^7W3V1WXf9�1>H G 02b ]`T�1W0 :<.�0 U ]`:Wbd.�359�u �^02749�02e�:<.�0Y0 �knq02b :<0>=�e53 �^0>e535.kXcX&= �`02749�02e

�]^9�=a:<.�0 74X ? T�1m: �`027W9k02e&T�1W0L]IZ\]^T�141W3p]`9 v�GQx �^02749�02ec]^1M:<.�0 U 359�Xf7 �^02749�02e

�:W.�0 @ 359�h ]^b : .�] l^0

F �

Page 62: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

359cs_9�3V:W0��EP =�3 U 0>9�1W3VXf9 H�PLXf9�1402t�T�0>9�:We @�:W.�0 �`02749�02e/]`n�n�7WXf]^bd.�b ]`9�e50 ]`7W9 U Xf740 �_0 �c3 ? eV0

=�0>b2351435Xf9 ? XfT�9k=_]^7W3V021Q3V9 :<.k0�n�7W0>1W029kb20aX^hM1WT ? �zb2e5]^1W14021�]^9�= ��3Ve5eq9�X^:/b>Xf9��J] :<0�=�3V14:<743 ? Tc:<35X^9�12H

, � 0 ] �&9k021W1\X^hB:W.�0 �`027W9k02e ]`n�n�7WXf]^bd.�.�X � 0>l^027

�3V1Ib>e5Xf1402e @ :W3502= :<X�3 :<1E14:<74029�u`:<. H�G @ X^9�e @

e5X&X ��359ku ]`:�:<.�0\lf0>b>:<X^7W1�n�7W0>1W029;:I359o: �LX 3 U ]^uf021�] :I]`9 @ :W3 U 0�:W.�0a]^n�n�74X;]^bd. 351�e53 U 3 :<02= ?�@

:<.k0O9�T U ? 027QX^hghr02]`:<Tk7W021L359)]^9 3 U ]^uf0^H D83Vbd.�.�Xf749)]^9�= PL.�]^n 0>e5eV0I7W0>n X^74:L:W._]`:Lb2ep]`1W1W3 s_b ] :<35X^9

nq0274hrX^7 U ]^9�b20oT�14359�u�e5X&b ]`eLhr0 ]`:WT�7W0 �^0>7W9�0>e51�359�b>7W02]^1W0>= ��3V:W.�:W.�0 9&T U ? 0>7 X`hIhr0 ] :<T�74021�n 0>7

3 U ]^uf0 � � F � HB-/.�3V1L35189�X^: 1WTk7Wn�74351W3V9�u ]`1 :<X&X[hr0 �#1<] U n�eV021 ��35e5e @ 3V02e5= ][nqXcX^7 0>14:<3 U ] :<0�X^hg:<.k0

=�3V14:<743 ? Tc:<35X^9�hrXf7�]Yuf3Vl^029 3 U ]^uf0^H

,I=�=k3V:<3VXf9_]^eVe @�:<.�0 �^0>7W9�0>e8:W._]`:ab2X U ? 359k021\:<.�0 U ] :<bd.�3V9�u �^02749�02e ��3V:W.�u^e5X ? ]`e hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1

]^bd.�3V0>l^021 ] U ]��c3 U T U nq0274hrX^7 U ]^9�b20�X^h ]^n�n�74X �k3 U ] :<02e @ �f| ����.�35bd.(351o1WeV35uf.;:We @ ? 0>:4:<0>7

:<.�]^9(:W.�0 ? 0>14:*]^b2b>T�7<]^b @ uf3Vl^029$359 � | N ��359 ��.�35bd.(:<.�0 U ]��c3 U T U e53 �^02eV35.�X&X&= b2e5]^1W143Vs_0>7

� 0>t�T_]`:<3VXf9 H � �8351/b>X U ? 3V9�02= ��3V:W. ] N � A b2ep]`1W1W3 s_027�X lf0>7�ufe5X ? ]^e hr02]`:<T�74021�T�14359�u�14:<]^b ��359�u�H

-/.�3V1 ]^n�n�74X;]^bd.�:W.�02740>hrXf740

�._]^1B14X U 0/X`hq:W.�0/1<] U 0/0 �knk7W02141W3 lf0�b ]^n_] ? 35eV3V: @ ]^1 U 0>:d] �ze502]^7W9k359�u

:<0>bd.�9�3Vt&Tk021�=k021Wnk3V:<0O:W.�0O1435uf9�3 s_b ]`9�:L359�b>7W02]^1W0�3V9�b2X U n�Tk:<]`:<3VXf9_]^eJ0 ! b>350>9�b @ 7W0214T�eV:W359�u[hr7WX U

:<.k0a14T�n�nqXf74:�l^02b>:WXf7�hr7<] U 0�� Xf7 �JH

� � � � �� � % � � �

-/._]`:\:<.k0 U ]`:Wbd.�359ku �^02749�02e XfTc:<nq0274hrX^7 U 02=�:<.�0 0 �knq02b :<0>=�e53 �^0>e535.kXcX&= �`027W9k02e 359�=k35b ] :<021

:<.�]`: ]an�74359�b>35n�eV02=�]^n�nk7WX;]^bd. T�1W3V9�ua9�Xf9�� n_]^7<] U 0 :<7W3VbQ=�0>9�1W3 : @ 0>14:W3 U ]`:<3VXf9Y351 9�X^:83V=�0 ]^e_u^3Vlf0>9

:<.k0 =�351m:<743 ? Tk:W35Xf9 X^hBhr02]`:<T�74021O3V9 7W02]^ei=_]`:d]cHI,Ie :<.�X^T�uf. T�14359�u�]^9 Xf74=�027O1m:d]`:W351m:<35ba359kb27W02]^1W0>1

nq0274hrX^7 U ]^9�b20�? 0 :W:W027 U Xc=�0>e53V9�uIX^hJ:W.�0�=_]`:d]I:W.�0 U 1W0>eVl^021 U ] @ 7W0214T�eV: 359 U Xf7W0/]`b2b2Tk7<]`:W0�=k351 �

:<743 ? Tc:<35X^9�1BX lf027 ��.�3Vbd. :<.k0�0 �cn 0>b>:<0>=�e53 �^0>e535.kXcX&= �^0>7W9�0>e 3V1 Xfnk:<3 U ]`e HMD �knke535b>3V:We @ ]^b2b>XfT�9;:<3V9�u

hrXf7�1WT ? b>ep]^141W021I359o:<.�0[=_]`:d]�]`n�n�e @ 3V9�u�:WXfn�3Vb U X&=�02eV1 � �

�|^} �

�]^9�= U X&=�02eV359�uY14n�T�7435XfT�1�hr0 ] �

:<Tk7W021�3V9o:W.�0\3 U ]^uf0�]`7W0\n�7WX U 3V1W359ku n�ep]`b2021/:WX�1m:d]^7m: H

� ?12� � �(�2�2 ��� � 12�;��� *��2�;����<(@AC��)�;��( �* �><( ���)�,��( '��� * "2%1��?+,�(����+ .%�5 * "��6( �;% * "C"�'2��+E%-�* ��( %*>(����� �-��%�(� %-(?* "!A��&%-�/���%* %�3 *)AC�� �;�-�;��%�+ �<� (-(�,( ! ��#�% �

~^}

Page 63: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

A X&=�02eV359�u�:<.�0 =_]`:<]�n�7435Xf7Y:WX�]^n�nke535b2]`:<3VXf9�X^hI:W.�0 �`02749�02e U ] �`021�T�1W0 X^h�3V9khrXf7 U ]`:W35Xf9

7W0>u;]^74=�359�u�:W.�0Yb2X �zX&b2b2Tk7W7W0>9�b20 X^h hr02]`:<T�74021\359 :W.�0Y=_]`:<]�359chrXf7 U ]`:<3VXf9o:<._]`: �L]^1\9�X^:�] l`]^3Ve �

] ? eV0 ��.�029�=�0>1W3Vuf9�359ku ] �^02749�02ei359k=�02nq029�=k029;:�X^h 0 U n�357435b ]`e X ? 140274l`]`:W35Xf9 H/,I1 � 0 U ] �`0[T�140

X^h8]^=k=�3V:W35Xf9_]`eg359khrXf7 U ] :<35X^9 14XfT�74b2021�hr0 ]`:WT�7W0 e5X&b ]`:W35Xf9�1�]^740 eV3 �^0>e @ :WX�3 U n�7WX l^0 7W0>1WT�e :<1O1435u �

9�3 s_b ]^9;:We @ H#6 ]^74: � ? ]^1402= U X&=�02eV1 ? ]`1W02= Xf9 1Wn�]`:<35]^e/b2eVT�14:W027W1 X^hOhr0 ] :<T�74021 3V1 X^9�0*7402b20>9;:<e @

n�74Xfn X^1W02= ]^n�nk7WX;]^bd. � F�� H

,I1 9k0���1WXfTk7Wb20>1 X^hJ3V9khrXf7 U ]`:W35Xf9\]^740Q]^b>b2XfTk9�:W02=YhrXf7�:<.k0 h ]^b :<Xf743�� ] :<35X^9[X^hk:<.�0Q0>14:W3 U ]`:<0>=

=�3V14:<743 ? Tc:<35X^9 U ] @ Xf7 U ] @ 9�X^: ? 0 14:<74T�b>:WT�7W0>=�359�1WT�bd.�] �L] @ :W._]`:[n�7WX ? ] ? 3Ve53V: @ n�7WX&=�T�b :

�^0>7W9�0>e51�b2]^9 ? 0Yb>X U nkTk:<0>=�359�b2eVXf1W0>= hrXf7 U H\-/.�351I0 !�b23V029�b @ 351 �`0 @ 3 hB:<.�0Yb>X U n�Tk:d] :<35X^9_]^e]^=kl`]^9;:<]^uf021LX^h N � A 1�]`7W0I:WX n_] @ X � H PLXf9k1W02t�T�0>9;:<e @

�]^n�n�74X �c3 U ]`:W35Xf9k1 X^hMX^nk:<3 U ]^e U Xc=k02e51

U T�1m: ? 0�0 �knke5Xf7402=o:<._]`:�b2]^9 ? 0�b2X U n�Tc:<02= 0 !�b>35029;:We @ H

~�

Page 64: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

��� ��� ���#"$�#�#��'��

� � �[GQ]^74ep]�, H�xJ7W]^9�b>021Wbd.k3

�D�H�SO=�Xf9k0

�xLH�]^9�= � 02747W3

�, H[y U ]^u^0 �^0>7W9�0>e512HYyz9�� � � � � ���

� � ��� � � � � ��� ��� �� � � � � � � � �� � � � � ��� � � � � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � ��� � � �� � � � � ������ ��� � � ��� � ����� � |^}f}f| �dH

� | �[GL._]`:4:d]^bd.�]^7 @�@ ]�, HOSO9�] U 0 ]^14T�7W0 X^hB=�3 lf0274uf029kb20 ? 0>: � 020>9�: � X)14:<]`:<3V14:W35b ]`einqXfn�Tkep] �

:<3VXf9�1a=�0>s_9k02= ?;@ :W.�023V7 n�74X ? ] ? 3Ve53 : @ =�351m:<743 ? Tk:W35Xf9k12H�� � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � ���� � � � F � �dH

� � �[GLe50>3�� H�Z�7W3"! :<.�1

�-�H��fX^7W=_]^9

�A H

�]`9�= -i029�0>9 ? ]^T U

���HiCE3V027W]^7Wbd.�3Vb ]^e�:WXfn�3Vb U Xc=k02e51

]^9�=�:<.�0 9�0>14:W02=�bd.�3V9�02140 74021m:d]^T�7W]^9;: nk7WX&b2021412H yz9 � � � � � � ��� � ��� � � � ��� � � � �� � � � � �� � � ��� � � � �� ���� � � �����

�NqH -/.�74T�9

�KBH Nc]^T�e

�]^9�=�GIH Ncbd.��Xfe �^Xfnch

�D8=k12H A yz- 6 74021W1

�PQ] U ? 7435=�u^0�A ,

�|^}f} FkH

� F��[GLXfT�bd.�]^7W=�ZYH�]`9�=�-i7W3Vufuf1

�GIHYCE3V027W]^7Wbd.�3Vb ]^e n_]^74: � ? ]`1W02=�l&3514T_]^e X ? �402b>:ab2]`:<0>ufXf7W3 � ] �

:<3VXf9 HJyz9 � � � ��� ��� �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ���� � � ���� � � � � � � � � � � � � �� �� � � � ���� � � � � � � |^}f}f~ �dH

� ~ �[GLT�74uf021�PIH���H&PIHiZ�02X U 0>:W7 @ ]^9k= 3V9�l`]^743p]^9kb20�359 �^0>7W9�0>e ? ]`1W02= U 0 :<.�X&=�1>H yz9 � � � � � � ���

� ��� �� ����� ��� � � � ���� � � � � �� ��� ��� � "! � � � � � ��GIH�Ncbd.��Xfe �^Xfnch

�PIH�GLT�7Wu^021

�]`9�=

, HJN U Xfe5]�D =�1>H A yz-�6 7W0>1W1

�PQ] U ? 7W3V=�uf0

�A ,

�� � � N H

� �[GLT�74uf021�PIH���HqPIH8,�:<Tk:WXf7W35]^e Xf9o14T�n�nqXf74:�lf0>b>:<X^7 U ]^bd.�3V9�021/hrXf7/n_] :W:<0>7W9 7W0>b2Xfuf9k3V:<3VXf9 H

# � � � � � � � � � � �$� ���%� � � � � �&# � ��� � � ��� ('�| � � ��� N �

�� |�*)7�� � H

� � � PL._]^9�u�PIH �mPIH

�]`9�=�Kg3V9

�PIH � ��H Kgy G/N � A � ] eV3 ? 7W]^7 @ hrXf7�1WTkn�n X^74:alf02b :<Xf7 U ]^bd.�359k0212H

NcX^h : �L]^7W0a] l`]^35e5] ? eV0O]`:������ ��� ��������� �"!�����* �,+ � $�� *�,�$ � � �(�.-�! 1 6�/+-��6�527�5��&�|^}^})� H

� N � � ] lc3V1�PIH N H

�Z\]^e5e5]^uf0>7

�N H A H

�G 027 U ]^9

�A H N H

�CE]^T�7 @

�K Hqv\H

�]^9k=�N&:W7W35b ��eV027

���HqvaH

-/.�0Yl&35=�0>X n�e5]^9��;:<X^9�7402b>Xf7W=�0>7 � �O68v � � =�0>1W3Vuf9�]`9�=�3V9�3V:W3p]^ei7W0>1WT�e :<1>H � ��� � � �10� �2 ��� ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��3! � � ��� � � � � �54.� � � ���f| �

� �6) N)� H

� � � � 350 :W:<0>7W3Vbd.�-�H�Z HiD 9�1W0 U ? eV0 U 0 :<.�X&=�1 359 U ]^bd.�3V9�0Oe502]^7W9k359�u�Hgyz987 � ����� ��� �� � � � � � � � �

� � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��& ���� � � � � |^}f}f} ��nkn H �*)7� ~ H

� � } � � 350 :W:<0>7W3Vbd.�-�HkZYH

�]^9�=oGQ] ��3V7W3

�ZYH N&XfeVl&359ku U T�e :<3Vb2ep]`1W1 e502]^7W9�3V9�u nk7WX ? eV0 U 1 l&3p][027W74Xf7 �

b2Xf747W0>b>:<3V9�u�XfTk:<nkTk: b>Xc=k0212H:9 � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� �;� ��� ��� � � � � � � �� ��� � � ���<' � � ���f~ ��|���/)c| N� H

� ��� � � 350 :W:<0>7W3Vbd.�-�HiZ H

�KM]`:<.�74Xfn

�v\HMC[H

�]`9�=�KgX��2]^9�X � 6 0>7W0��

�-�H NcXfe l&359�u):<.k0 U T�eV:W35n�eV0 �

359�1m:d]^9kb20�n�74X ? e50 U ��3 :<.(]��c351 �zn_]`7<]^eVe502e�7402b>:<]^9�ufeV021>H � �� � � � ��� �=� ��� ��� � � � � � � �?>A@��*)c|

� � � � � ���)�*))��� H

~f|

Page 65: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

� � | � � Xf7 ���X�ZYH�]^9�=�Ncbd. U 35=

�PIHoS ? �40>b>:[b2e5]^1W1a7W0>b2Xfuf9k3V:<3VXf9�T�1W3V9�u =�3514b27W3 U 3V9_]`:W3Vlf0 e5X&b ]^e

hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>12H$NcT ?kU 3 :W:<0>=�:WX�yzD D D -i7<]`9�1<]^b :<3VXf9�1 X^9 6 ] :W:<0>7W9 ,E9_]^e @ 14351 ]^9�= A ]^bd.�3V9�0yz9;:<02eVe53Vuf029�b>0

�|^}f} F�H

� � � � � T�=_]�v\H S H

�CE]^74:

�6 H D�H

�]^9k=�N&:WXf7 �

�� HiZYH�� � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

�1402b2X^9�=�02= H

�fXf.�9)F#35eV0 @�� NcXf9k1�yz9�b

�|`}f})� H

� � F��aD 35bd.�.�X^7W9���H�]^9�= PL._]`n 0>e5e50

�S HqS ? �402b : b ]`:W02ufXf743��2]`:<3VXf9 ��3 :<.�N � A � �^0>7W9�0>e51 hrXf7 e5X&b ]^e

hr0 ]`:WT�7W0>12HM-i02bd. H�7402n H�A ]���6 e5]^9�b � yz9�14:W3V:WTk:<0�hrXf7QGL3VXfe5X^uf35b2]^e_P @&? 027W9k0>:<3Vb21

�- �T ? 359kuf029

�Z\0>7 U ]^9 @�|`}f} F�H

� � ~ � Z$�]`74:<9k027�-�H�x ep]^bd.

�6 H/, H

�R�X �L]^eVb�� @ �

�,[H�]`9�= N U Xfe5]

�, H ��H A TkeV:<3 �z3V9�14:<]^9�b20

�^0>7W9�0>e512H�yz9 � � ����� � � ��� ��� ��� �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ��� � ����! � � � � � � � |^}f}f| ��n�n H �5� �/)7�3N� H

� � � Z\X^e5= ? 0274uf027���H�v�X � 023V1

�N H�C�359;:<Xf9

�ZYH�]`9�=Nk]^ep] �&.�Tk:W=�359kX l

�vaH�{E0>35uf. ? Xf7W.�X&X&=

b2X U nqXf9�029;:W1 ]`9_]^e @ 143512HJyz9 ��� � � � � ��� � � � � � � ��� � � � �� � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � ���� � � � ����KM] ��74029�b>0�RYHiNk]^Tke

�� ]^357OF�023V1W1

�]^9�=�K��02Xf9�GLX^:4:<XfT

�D =�12H A yz- 6 74021W1

�PQ] U ? 7W35=kuf0

�A ,�|`}f};~ H

� �5� � Z\7W]^T U ]^9�RYH�]^9�= � ]`7W7W0>e5e

�-�H 6 @ 7<] U 35= U ] :<bd. �`027W9k02e51 � � 3514b27W3 U 3V9_]`:W3Vlf0/b>ep]^141W3 s_b ] �

:<3VXf9 ��3V:W.\1W0>:W1MX^h&3 U ]^uf0 hr02]`:<T�74021>H^-i02bd. H 7W0>n H�A ]`1W1<]`bd.&Tk1W0>:4:<1 yz9�14:W3V:<Tc:<0BX^h&-i02bd.�9�X^e5Xfu @

�LPLX U n�Tk:<0>7�Ncb23V029�b>0 ]`9�=o,I74:W3Vs_b>3p]^e yz9;:<02eVe53Vuf029�b>0\KM] ? X^7<]`:WXf7 @�|^}f};~ H

� �3N �[CI] U nq02e�xLHgv\H

�v�Xf9kbd.�0>:4:<3

�D�H A H

�v�XfT�1W14020>T �

�6 H ��H

�]^9�=�N&:<]^.�0>e

�F H ,[H ��� � ���

�� � � � ��� � ������� � � � � � � � ��� � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � 7 � � ��� � � � � H(�fXf.k9 F#35e50 @�� NcXf9k1�yz9�b

�� � N� H

� � � �[CE0 :W: U ]^9�14n 0>7Wuf0>7�-�H 6 H

�]^9�= A b2R\02]^9

���H F H ��� � ��� � � � � � � � ��� � �� �� � � � ��� � � � �

��� � � � � H �fXf.�9oF#35eV0 @�� NcXf9k1�yz9�b

�� ��� N H

� |^} �[CEX^h U ]^9�9�-�HB6 7WX ? ] ? 35eV351m:<35bEep]`:W029;:�1W0 U ]`9�:W35b�]`9_]^e @ 143512HByz9� � � ���� � � ��� � � � � � � � ��� �

� ��� ��� � � � � � � � � � ����� �<H� |� � �f0 ? ]`7<]

�-�H�]^9�=�R�Xf9k=�Xf7

�vaHEGL._] :W:d]`bd._]^7 @�@ ])]^9�= 0 �knq02b :<0>=�eV3 �`02e53V.�X&Xc= �^0>7W9�0>e51>HOyz9

� � � � �� � � � � � �8! � � � � � � � � � � � � |^}f}�� �<H� |f| � �f0 ? ]`7<]

�-�H�R�Xf9�=�X^7

�vaH�]`9�=�C�X �L]^74=

�,[Hg6874X ? ] ? 35e53 : @ n�74Xc=kT�b>: �^02749�02eV12H 9 � � � � ��� �

� ��� � ���&! � � � � � �( ��� � � ����� � |`}f} F ��N)� �6) N F F�H

� |�� �[R\]^=�357�-�H�]^9k=�GL7W]^= @

�A H Nc]^e53V029�b @

�1Wb2]^e50 ]^9k=�3 U ]^u^0 =�0214b27435nk:W35Xf9 H � ��� �� � � � � � � � �

9 � � � � � � � � ���� � � ���� � � � � � � |`}f})� �<H� | F��[R�0

��YH�]^9�=�NcT��;:<.�]^9�� ]^7

�vaH 6LPL, �mNcy x - � , U X^7W0 =�351m:<3V9�b>:W3Vlf0�7W0>n�7W0>1W0>9�:<]`:<3VXf9�hrX^7

e5X&b ]^eq3 U ]^uf0I=�0214b27W3Vnk:<X^7W12HByz9 � � � � � ��� �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ���� � � ���� � � � � �� � � � � � � �� �" � � � � � � � � � � � |^}f} F �dH� |f~ �[R�Xf9�=�Xf7

�v\H�]^9k= �f0 ? ]^7W]

�-�H , �`02749�02e ? 0>: � 02029�1W0 :<1\X^h lf0>b>:<X^7W12H yz9 � ��� �� � � � � � � � �

� � � � �� � � � � � � � ��� � ��� ! � � � � � � � |^}f}�� �dH

~��

Page 66: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

� |� �[R�7W0��^02e�j H 6 ]^3V7 ��35140ob2ep]`1W1W3 s_b ] :<35X^9]`9�= 14T�n�nqXf74:�lf0>b>:<X^7 U ]^bd.�359k0212Hyz9 � � � � � � ���

� ��� �� ����� ��� � � � ���� � � � � �� ��� ��� � "! � � � � � ��GIH�Ncbd.��Xfe �^Xfnch

�PIH�GLT�7Wu^021

�]`9�=

, HJN U Xfe5]�D =�1>H A yz-�6 7W0>1W1

�PQ] U ? 7W3V=�uf0

�A ,

�� � ��� H

� |�� �[Kg023 ? 0�GIH�]^9k=oNcbd.�3V02e50

�GIHi,I9�]^e @ �23V9�u ]`n�n 02]^7<]`9�b20�]`9�=�b2X^9�:WXfT�7 ? ]^1W0>= U 0 :<.�X&=�1 hrX^7

X ? �40>b>:Yb2]`:<0>ufXf7W3 � ]`:W35Xf9 H*yz9 � � � � � ��� �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ���� � � �� � � � � � �� � � � � � � �� �" � � � � � � � � � � � |^}f}�� �dH� | N �[Kg351W3V9

�� H , H

�A ]`:W:<]^7

�A HB, H

�GLep]^14bd.��^X

�A H8GIH

�G 029ks_0>e5=

�A H8PIH

�]^9�=Kg0 ]^749�02= �

A 35eVe50>7�D�H_ZYHBPLX U ? 359�3V9�u eVXcb2]^e ]`9�=)ufe5X ? ]^eq3 U ]^uf0Ehr02]`:<Tk7W021 hrXf7QX ? �40>b>:�b>ep]^141Q7W0>b2Xfuf9 �

:<3VXf9 HMyz9 � � � � � � �� � � ��� � ��! � � � � � � � � � ���� � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� �8 � � � � � � �� � � � � |^}f}f~ �dH

� | � �[KgX � 0�� H8ZYH#S ? �40>b>:�7402b>Xfuf9�3 :<35X^9�hr74X U e5X&b ]`e/1Wb ]`e50 � 359;l`]^7W35]^9;:Yhr0 ]`:WT�7W0>12H#yz9 � � �

� ��� �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ���� � � ��8� � � � � � � � ��� � �dH� �f} �[KgX � 0

�� HqZYH � 351m:<3V9�b>:W3Vlf0�3 U ]`uf0Ihr0 ] :<T�74021/hr7WX U 1Wb ]`e50 � 359;l`]^7W35]^9;: �^0 @ n Xf3V9;:<12H � ��� �� � � �

� � � � � � 9 � � � � � � � � ���� � � ��8� � � � � � � |^}^} F �dH� �)� � A ]`:<]^1

���H�PL.&T U

�SYH�j 7 ? ]`9

�A H

�]`9�=�6 ] �4=�ep]

�-�H v�X ? T�14: ��35=k0 ? ]`1W02eV359�0�14:W027402X

hr7WX U U ]��c3 U ]^eVe @ 1m:d] ? e50 0 �&:<7W0 U ]`e 7402uf3VXf9�12HEyz9�� � � � � � � � ����� � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � ���� � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � |^}^};| �dH

� �;| � A 023V9�35b �`0�6 H�- � 02eVe U ]^9�9

�-�H�]`9�=�v�3V:4:<027

�C[H � 3V1Wb2743 U 359_] :<3Vl^0L=�0>9�1W3 :<3V021 hr7WX U U ]��c3 �

U T U b>Xf9;:<7W]^14: 0214:W3 U ]`:<3VXf9 Hfyz9 ��� � � � � ��� � � � � � � ��� � � � �� � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � ���� � � �� ��NqH GL0>b �^027

�N H -/.k7WT�9

�]`9�=�RYHgS ? 027 U ] @ 0>7

�D =�1>H A yz-w6 7W02141

�PQ] U ? 7W3V=�uf0

�A ,

�|^}f}�� H

� ��� � A 3 �`Xfep] �4b�� @ ��RYH�]^9�=�Ncbd. U 35=

�PIH yz9�=�0 �k3V9�u ? ]^1W0>=�Xf9#14b ]^eV0�3V9;l^]`7W3p]`9�:�359;:<0>7W021m:

n X^359;:<1>H yz9"� � � � ��� �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ���� � � ���� � � � � � � |^}f})� ��nkn H ~f|f~ )

~��)� H

� � F�� A 3 �`Xfep] �4b�� @ ��R H�]^9�= Ncbd. U 35=

�PIHQ,E9 ] !�9�0[359;l`]^7W35]^9;:�359;:<0>7W021m:OnqXf359;:�=�0 :<02b :<Xf7>H/yz9

��� ��� � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ���� � � ���� � � � � � � |^}f};| ��n�n H � | N ) � F | H

� �;~ � A 3 �`Xfep] �4b�� @ ��RYH�]^9�=*Ncbd. U 35=

�PIHB, nq027mhrXf7 U ]^9�b>0�0>l`]^e5T�]`:<3VXf9�X^h e5X&b ]^e =�0214b27435nk:WXf7W1>H

� � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � ��� � � � ��� � � � � � �� � ��� � �� �� � � � � � � ��� � ��� � ��� ��� � � � � � � �� |^}^} F �dH

� �� � A T�14e50 ]�ydH � ��� � � �"! � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � H 6 . � :<.k021W3V1

�j 9�3Vl^02741W3V: @ X^h

NcXfTk:W.�02749 PQ]`e53VhrX^7W9�35]�|^}f};| H

� � � �[vE] l^02ep]�N H�� � � � � � � � � � �=# ��� �� � ��� ��� � 7 � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � ��� � ��� � � � � � � � � � �(�� � � ��� � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � H�6 . � :W.�0214351

�j 9�3 lf02741W3 : @ X`h A ]^141<]^bd.�T�140>:W:W1 , U .�027414:

�|^}f};| H

� � N �[v�3 h ��359�vaH�]^9�=�R�e5]^Tk:d]`T

�,[H yz9�=�0>hr0>9�1W0oX^h�X^9�0 � lc1 � ]^eVe b2ep]`1W1W3 s_b ] :<35X^9 H�9 � � � � � � �

� ��� � ���&! � � � � � �( ��� � � ����� � |`}f} F ��� })� )7� F � H

~ F

Page 67: University of Massachusetts Amherstvis- · HfHfHfH;H^HfHfH;HfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH^H;HfHfHfH;HfH^HfH;HfHfHfH H$7 ~ H O3V= 02X 6 ep]^9 :WXf9 v0>b2Xf74= 027]`::

� ��� � Ncbd.��Xfe �^Xfnch�GIH�]^9k= N U Xfe5]

�, H ! � � � � � �$� � � � � �� ��������� � � � � ����� ��� � � ��� � �������

��� � � � ��� � � � � ��� � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � H A yz- 6 7W02141�|^}f}f| H

� F } � Ncbd.��Xfe �^Xfnch�GEH�N U Xfe5]

�, H�]^9�= A �T�e5eV027

�RYH �zvaH {EXf9ke5359k0 ]^7/b>X U nqXf9�0>9;:I]`9_]^e @ 14351�]^1�]

�^0>7W9�0>ei0>35uf0>9;l^]`e5T�0�n�74X ? eV0 U H � � � � � � ���� � � � � � � � ��� � � ��� N ��� | ���/)7���)� � H

� F � � Nc020 �Q]`e5=�, H RYH � �%� � � � � � �� ��� � � � � � � �� � ��� � � ��� �� ��� � ��� � � ��� � ���� � � � � �

� � � ��� � ! � � � � � �� ��� � � � H�6 . � :<.k021W3V1�,IT�1m:<7W35]^9 v�02140 ]^74bd.�yz9�14:W3V:WTk:<0ahrXf7E,E74:W3Vs_b>3p]^e

yz9;:<02eVe53Vuf029�b>0 � x&,Iy ��|^}f}�� H

� F | � Nc35e lf0>7 U ]^9�GIH F H # � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � �� � � � ��� � ��� � � �3# � � � ��� � �� �� � � H�PL.�]^n U ]^9

� CE]^e5efPQv/P�� � N� H

� F � � �8]^n�9�3 ��� HJ{aH �� � � � ��� � � � � ! � � � � � � � � � � � H �fXf.�9oF#35e50 @ � NcXf9�1

�yz9�b

�� ��� N H

� F F�� �O3V=_]^e �z{I]^t�T�0 :�A H

�]^9k= j eVe U ]^9

�N H/S ? �40>b>:E7W0>b2Xfuf9k3V:<3VXf9 ��3V:W. 3V9khrXf7 U ]`:W3Vl^0Ihr0 ]`:WT�7W0>1

]^9�=\e53V9�0 ]`7 b2e5]^1W143Vs_b2]`:<3VXf9 H yz9 � ��� �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ���� � � ��5� � � � � � � |^}f}�� �dH� F ~ �\F�]`e5e57W] lf029

�PIH�PQ]^n�Tk:WX

�GIH�]^9�=�Z�7<]`h

�,[H GEH ,[HEv�02b>Xfuf9�3 :<3VXf9 ��3 :<. e5X&b ]^e hr02]`:<T�74021 �

:<.�0 �`027W9k02eM7W0>b235nq0^HByz9 � ��� �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ���� � � ���� � � � � � � |^}f}�� �dH� F �\F�X^eVh

�K H�]`9�= N&._]^1W.�T_]

�, H Kg0 ]^749�359ku�X l^027 1W0>:W1 Tk1W359ku �`02749�02ean�7W3V9�b23Vn_]^eI]^9�ufeV0212H

9 � � � � � � � � ��� � ����! � � � � � �( ��� � � ����� � |^}f}�� ���)���/) ���)� H

~f~