this report was prepared prior to the public hearing center/land use and resource... · this report...

14
This report was prepared prior to the public hearing. This report may be supplemented or amended to reflect the review of additional information presented at the public hearing and written material submitted up to the meeting at which the decision is made by the Walworth County Zoning Agency. PRELIMINARY STAFF PLANNING REPORT TO THE WALWORTH COUNTY ZONING AGENCY TYPE OF PETITION: ________REZONE ___X____CONDITIONAL USE NAME: S T Evenignasiak LLC c/o Steven Ignasiak Owner LOCATION: The property of concern is located in the NE ¼ of Section 26, LaFayette Township and is identified as part of Tax Parcel K LF-26-1. TOWN RESPONSE: Approved__X__ Denied: _____ No Action: _X__ Tabled_____ Town recommendation for approve a separate CU for a pier business in Building #5 was advanced with continued table position on the remainder of the changes for bringing the PUD into compliance based on needed clean up. ZONING: The property is zoned M-2 Heavy Industrial PROJECT DESCRIPTION: The application indicates: In order to bring an existing site into compliance, the property owner has obtained conditional use approval for addition of a pier construction business to the existing Planned Unit Development (PUD) in March of 2017. The remainder of the conditional use request and revisions were tabled until such time as the property was cleaned up to a level consistent with the existing approval. The property owner has indicated the required clean-up has been completed. The property owner is now requesting conditional use approval for contractor storage for temporary projects facility for buildings # 7 and 8 and amendment to the existing PUD to allow change to the length of storage time for in transit material and alternate and increased storage area locations for various equipment and materials as specified by a revised site plan and narrative. There are three separate business entities that use the site as a Planned Unit Development as follows: RSR Services LLC is a short haul trucking company. RSR Services LLC operates a truck depot for a fleet of approximately 15 trucks, trailers and construction equipment with 22 full time and 10 part time employees out of a 10,000 sq. ft. area of Buildings #1 and additional area in building #4. The shop is open to both first and second shift for repair and maintenance of fleet trucks as well as repairs and maintenance for other local businesses trucks and heavy construction equipment. Building #2 and 3 are currently used entirely for office space for RSE Services LLC and Fifth St. Transport LLC and retail sales of truck parts are no longer proposed from a portion of building #3 as previously approved. RSR Services specializes in hauling material for the recycling industry. As such at times there is proposed to be different types of in transit recyclable material truck loads parked in the designated storage yard. Fifth St. Transport LLC is a sister company of RSR Services LLC and is a Regional Transport Carrier owner by Steven J Ignasiak. Fifth St. Transport LLC currently operates six tractor trailers and has one on-site office employee. Fifth St. uses 3,000 sq. ft. building #6 for maintenance and repair of its fleet and park trucks and

Upload: vanxuyen

Post on 01-Mar-2019

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

This report was prepared prior to the public hearing. This report may be supplemented or amended to reflect

the review of additional information presented at the public hearing and written material submitted up to the

meeting at which the decision is made by the Walworth County Zoning Agency.

PRELIMINARY STAFF PLANNING REPORT TO THE WALWORTH COUNTY ZONING AGENCY

TYPE OF PETITION: ________REZONE

___X____CONDITIONAL USE

NAME: S T Evenignasiak LLC c/o Steven Ignasiak – Owner

LOCATION: The property of concern is located in the NE ¼ of Section 26, LaFayette Township and is

identified as part of Tax Parcel K LF-26-1.

TOWN RESPONSE: Approved__X__ Denied: _____ No Action: _X__ Tabled_____

Town recommendation for approve a separate CU for a pier business in Building #5 was advanced with

continued table position on the remainder of the changes for bringing the PUD into compliance based on needed

clean up.

ZONING: The property is zoned M-2 Heavy Industrial

PROJECT DESCRIPTION:

The application indicates: In order to bring an existing site into compliance, the property owner has obtained

conditional use approval for addition of a pier construction business to the existing Planned Unit Development

(PUD) in March of 2017. The remainder of the conditional use request and revisions were tabled until such

time as the property was cleaned up to a level consistent with the existing approval. The property owner has

indicated the required clean-up has been completed. The property owner is now requesting conditional use

approval for contractor storage for temporary projects facility for buildings # 7 and 8 and amendment to

the existing PUD to allow change to the length of storage time for in transit material and alternate and

increased storage area locations for various equipment and materials as specified by a revised site plan

and narrative.

There are three separate business entities that use the site as a Planned Unit Development as follows:

RSR Services LLC is a short haul trucking company. RSR Services LLC operates a truck depot for a fleet of

approximately 15 trucks, trailers and construction equipment with 22 full time and 10 part time employees out

of a 10,000 sq. ft. area of Buildings #1 and additional area in building #4. The shop is open to both first and

second shift for repair and maintenance of fleet trucks as well as repairs and maintenance for other local

businesses trucks and heavy construction equipment. Building #2 and 3 are currently used entirely for office

space for RSE Services LLC and Fifth St. Transport LLC and retail sales of truck parts are no longer

proposed from a portion of building #3 as previously approved. RSR Services specializes in hauling

material for the recycling industry. As such at times there is proposed to be different types of in transit

recyclable material truck loads parked in the designated storage yard.

Fifth St. Transport LLC is a sister company of RSR Services LLC and is a Regional Transport Carrier owner by

Steven J Ignasiak. Fifth St. Transport LLC currently operates six tractor trailers and has one on-site office

employee. Fifth St. uses 3,000 sq. ft. building #6 for maintenance and repair of its fleet and park trucks and

trailers on site in addition to the north half of building #5 during weekends but is mostly on the road during

the week. There is no maintenance of other company trucks by this business and no retail sales.

Both RSR Services and Fifth St. Transport LLC would use 7,000 sq. ft. of building space (# 7 & 8) for

warehousing of in-transit freight and truck parts. It is proposed that buildings #7 and 8 and the designated

outdoor apron storage area would also be used for contractor storage by companies needing six month

temporary space for off-site construction projects in the local area by approval of a new conditional use.

The south half of Building # 5 is now used for a Forever Pier pier construction business as approved on March

15, 2017. The pier business may expand into the remaining of the building in the future. Until such time the

north half of building #5 is used by Fifth St. Transport LLC.

Buildings # 2, 4, are no longer proposed for available lease. Potential tenants would be required to obtain

separate conditional use approval from the Town and County prior to use of the site.

Building # 9 was used by the Town of LaFayette but is now used for storage of heavy equipment and

parts and materials for RSR Services LLC.

The new conditional use request includes a 70 ft. by 100 foot area for construction of a steel building

which would be used for building materials storage until such time as the proposed building is

constructed.

The new proposed site plan and narrative showing and describing revised outside storage areas are

provided in the packet.

CONFORMANCE WITH COUNTY LAND USE PLAN:

The Walworth County 2035 Land Use Plan identifies this area as the I Industrial land use category.

COMPATIBILITY WITH SURROUNDING LAND USES:

To the north is land zoned A-1.

To the east are properties zoned P-2, M-3, A-5 and A-1.

To the south are lands zoned P-2, A-1.

To the west are properties zoned A-5 and A-1.

SITE CHARACTERISTICS: The following soil types are found on this site:

MpB Class II McHenry Silt Loam, 2 to 6% slopes

Ph Class II Pella Silt Loam

GP Gravel Pit

W Open water

IMPACT ON ROADS AND TRAFFIC:

The site is served by Hwy 11 to the south of the parcel.

OTHER RELEVANT DATA – RECOMMENDATIONS:

The property owner has obtained a Tier II State Industrial Permit and review approval from the WI. D.N.R.

Currently there are two vehicles along Hwy 20 that are for sale. The narrative provided does not state any

proposed parking stalls along Hwy 20 to be used for sales of trucks and equipment display. The committee may

wish to inquire about vehicle sales on the site.

The new conditional use request includes a 70 ft. by 100 foot area for construction of a future steel building.

The area of the proposed building is also proposed to be used for building materials storage until such time as

the building is constructed. The narrative is unclear as to when the building would be constructed, which

company would use the building, and whether all the materials to be stored in the location are intended to be

used for construction of the proposed building.

The narrative states attachment for equipment (buckets, plows etc.) shall be stored in the gravel pit. This is a

misstatement as the bucket and plows are in the M-2 zoned area adjacent to the M-3 zoned gravel pit but not in

the M-3 area. No equipment storage or other industrial use shall be allowed in the M-3 area of the property.

APPLICATION STATUS: ____X_____COMPLETE _________INCOMPLETE

Amended 6/15/2017 for contractor storage for temporary project facilities, length of storage time for in transit

materals, increased storage areas see #s 1, 27, 35.

Amended 3/23/2017 for the addition of a pier construction business with all other conditions as shown, and with the

revised site plan.

NAME: S T Evenignasiak LLC c/o Steven Ignasiak – Owner

TOWN: LaFayette – Part of Tax Parcel K LF-26-1

Has been APPROVED subject to the following conditions:

General:

1. Approved as per plan submitted and narrative submitted for multiple conditional uses as a Planned Unit

Development (PUD) being a truck depot, truck depot with truck and heavy construction equipment

repair and retail truck part service, a pier construction business, contractor storage for temporary

projects for buildings # 7 & 8 and amendment to the existing PUD to allow addition to the length

of storage time for in transit material and alternate and increased storage area locations for

various equipment and materials as specified by a revised site plan and narrative as approved

6/15/2017 as and indoor and outdoor in transit materials storage depot with all additional conditions.

2. All uses shall meet applicable Federal, State, County and local regulations including commercial

building inspection.

3. Outside lighting shall be shielded and directed on site.

4. The applicant must obtain all required zoning permit approvals including a sign permit.

5. The applicant must obtain the required State Highway D.O.T. approval for any changes to the access.

6. No fill, debris, branches or leaves may be disposed of on site. No burning of waste materials shall occur

on site.

7. The applicant must obtain a County Land Disturbance Erosion Control and Stormwater Management

Permit from the County Conservation Office if required by ordinance.

8. All parking and access to the site shall meet County requirements. All parking shall be installed

according to County requirements within 60 days of this approval. Vehicle parking shall be located as

identified on the approved plan of operations.

9. The project site must be kept neat, clean, and mowed. The site shall be maintained in a nuisance free

condition. The owner shall be held solely responsible for the control of dust, odors, fire, vermin, insects,

rodents, filth, fluid/oils spills, groundwater and surface water contamination and windblown materials

resulting from past and future operations on this site.

10. Implementation of dust and noise control measures shall occur at all times on site.

11. On site hours of operation shall be from 7:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. Monday through Saturday for the indoor

and outdoor in transit materials storage depot and retail sales of truck parts. Hours of operation shall be

7:00 a.m. to 11: 00 p.m. Monday through Saturday for the truck repair facility. Hours of operation shall

allow parking of trucks and trailers on site 24 hours per day, seven days a week.

12. Truck drivers shall not spend the night in the trucks on site.

13. All perimeter fencing shall be maintained as identified on the project plan.

14. The operator shall obtain adequate liability insurance and keep the insurance current during the life

of this conditional use.

15. Public retail sales of truck parts shall be restricted to the area identified on the site plan.

16. No general public sales allowed from the indoor and outdoor in transit materials storage depot.

17. No business activities other than specified in the plan of operations may be conducted from out of the

truck depot facilities.

18. Outside storage shall be limited to the type, quantities and location of material identified on the plan of

operations. No outside storage areas including displays of goods shall be allowed in the required setback

areas.

19. No storage of chemicals, petroleum products and flammable materials shall occur on site unless stored

in a containment facility meeting State requirements.

20. The owner must provide a waste disposal plan stating where all trash, drain oil and other auto fluids are

disposed and shall follow the approved plan during operations on site.

21. Staff may conduct inspections necessary to ensure site is operated and maintained according to

applicable regulations.

22. Any changes to the PUD that may affect this approval must obtain additional County conditional use

review and approval.

23. The proper preservation, care and maintenance by the original and all subsequent owners of the design

of the PUD and all common structures, facilities, essential services, access and open spaces including

use of the open space shall be assured by deed restriction referencing the plat.

24. If the Land Management Department determines that changes in either the character of the use or the

intensity of the use are not consistent with this approval, then those changes must be brought before the

County Zoning Agency for approval.

25. Failure to actively exercise this conditional use within three years of the approval date shall result in

automatic dismissal without prejudice. The property owner may request a time extension for actively

exercising the conditional use. A time extension for actively exercising the conditional use must be

requested in writing during the original three year period. Any extension requested during the three year

active exercise period greater than one year beyond the original three year period shall require additional

Town and County committee approvals.

Specific:

26. All inventories of truck parts, trailer parts, and equipment parts to be use or sold on site shall be kept

indoors at all times except for parts located in the temporary use outdoor storage location. Truck parts,

trailer parts and equipment parts stored in the temporary use outdoor storage location shall be removed

within 14 days of being stored outdoors.

27. No outside storage other than the trucks, trailers, equipment and materials in transit specified in the

approved plan of operations shall to be stored in the designated outside storage areas. Materials not on

trailers shall be set on pallets, or wood dunnage as needed, and shall be wrapped as needed. All

trucks, trailers, equipment and materials in transit shall be allowed to be stored on site for a maximum of

14 contiguous days at which point they shall be removed as specified on the approved site plan and

according to the following area time specification:

Areas 1-4: To be used by Fifth St. Transport LLC and RSR Services for short term 30 days or

less truck and custom trailer parking.

Area 5: To be used by to be used by Fifth St. Transport LLC and RSR Services for trailer for up

to 1 year for the businesses rental and storage fleet.

Area 6: Trailer parking and in house storage of supplies for Fifth St. Transport LLC up to 3

years.

Area 7: Fifth St. Transport LLC and RSR Services long term storage of equipment and materials

intended for reuse by the onsite businesses up to 3 years.

Areas 8-9: Overflow parking of trailers for no longer than 1 year.

28. The County reserves the authority to require any outside stored materials to be removed from the site

within 48 hours of a determination the storage is inconsistent with this approval, has become unsightly

or is detrimental to human health and safety.

29. No outside storage of chemicals shall occur on site.

30. Any painting and finishing areas of the industrial building must have proper ventilation meeting the

requirements of the State and Federal codes. Exhaust system shall meet all requirements of the code

including hours of operation and noise.

31. No dumping of chemical waste shall be conducted outside of the building. All discharge of chemical

waste to the holding tank or septic system shall be pre-approved by the County sanitarian.

32. All flammable waste materials shall be stored in a non-flammable, enclosed container and be gated in a

non-combustible fence.

33. The owner shall obtain approval of a pollution prevention plan from the County Land Conservation

Office and a hazardous spill plan from the State if required by law.

34. No occupancy shall be allowed for the business activity approved by this conditional use until all

conditions of approval are met.

35. The property owner shall be required to conduct an annual Tier III study as per the Town.

36. All transient loads shall be stored on non-pervious surfaces as per the Town.

37. The conditional use shall be valid for five years from this approval date. The property owner may apply

for a renewal of the conditional use within six months of expiration. The renewal shall be subject to

inspection and approval by the County as per the Town.

38. No fill shall be placed in the buffer area identified on the north end of the outside storage area for

transient storage. No storage activities shall be located within the buffer area.

Dated this 16th

day of July, 2015.

_________________________________

COUNTY ZONING AGENCY

RICK STACEY, CHAIRMAN

S.T. Evenignsiak, LLC CU for Additional Uses to PUD

Section 26, LaFayette Township Zoning Map

S.T. Evenignsiak, LLC CU for Additional Uses to PUD

Section 26, LaFayette Township Soils & Topo Map

S.T. Evenignsiak, LLC CU for Additional Uses to PUD

Section 26, LaFayette Township Land Use Plan