saeed ullah janprr.hec.gov.pk/jspui/bitstream/123456789/840/1/2232s.pdf · acs american chemical...
TRANSCRIPT
UNIVERSITY OF SINDH JAMSHORO
PhD Thesis
DIGITAL TECHNOLOGY AND ITS IMPACT ON LIBRARY AND INFORMATION SERVICES AND
RESOURCES IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR UNIVERSITIES OF PAKISTAN
By
SAEED ULLAH JAN
A thesis submitted to the University of Sindh in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the award of degree of Doctor of Philosophy
in Library and Information Science
DEPARTMENT OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION SCIENCE AND ARCHIVE STUDIES
UNIVERSITY OF SINDH, JAMSHORO- PAKISTAN
2011
II
CERTIFICATE
Certified that Mr. Saeed Ullah Jan S/o Mr. Karim Khan has carried out PhD
research on the topic “DIGITAL TECHNOLOGY AND ITS IMPACT ON
LIBRARY AND INFORMATION SERVICES AND RESOURCES IN THE
PUBLIC SECTOR UNIVERSITIES OF PAKISTAN” under my supervision and
that his work is original and distinct. The thesis is worthy of presentation for the
award of degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Library and Information Science of the
University of Sindh.
Prof. Dr. Rafia A Sheikh Supervisor
III
DECLARATION I declare that “DIGITAL TECHNOLGY AND ITS IMPACT ON LIBRARY
AND INFORMATION SERVICES AND RESOURCES IN THE PUBLIC
SECTOR UNIVERSITIES OF PAKISTAN” is my own work and that all the
sources I have used or quoted have been indicated and acknowledged by means of
complete references.
Signature………………………………. Date….........……………………
IV
DEDICATION
To my little
LATE SON
TALHA SAEED KHAN
WHOM I LOST DURING
THE COURSE OF THIS STUDY
V
LIST OF ACRONYMS
AACR Anglo-American Cataloguing Rules AJK & NA Azad Jammu and Kashmir & Northern Areas ACS American Chemical Society ALA American Library Association ASPT American Society of Physics Teachers APAN Asia Pacific Advanced Network API Applications Programming Interface APS American Physical Society ASCE American Society of Civil Engineering ASCII American Standard Code for Information Interchange ASLIB Association of Special Libraries and Information Bureaux BBS Bulletin Board Service BCR Bar Code Reader BLDDS British Library Documents Delivery Service BULIMS Bahria University Library Information Management System BNB British National Bibliography CAS Current Awareness Service CCD Charged-Coupled Devices CDS/ISIS Computerized Documentation System-Integrated Set for
Information Systems CPU Central Processing Unit CIP Catalogue in Publication CD-ROM Compact Disc/ Read Only Memory
VI
COM Computer Output Microfilm CV Co-efficient of Variation DAI Degree Awarding Institute DDC Dewey Decimal Classification DLIS Department of Library and Information Science DLP Digital Library Program DVDs Digital Versatile Disc ERNET Education and Research Network ETD E-Theses and Dissertations FAQs Frequently Asked Questions GDP Gross Domestic Product ICC Integrated Circuit Card ICT Information Communication Technology IFLA International Federation of Library Associations ICT Information Communication Technology IT Information Technology ILL Inter Library Loan ISBD International Standard Bibliographic Description ISBN International Standard Book Number HEC Higher Education Commission HTML Hyper Text Markup Language KP Khyber Pakhtunkhwa LC Library of Congress LCD Liquid Crystal Display LAN Local Area Network
VII
LIBCOOP Library Cooperation Group LISTA Library, Information Science and Technology Abstracts MARC Machine Readable Cataloguing MICR Magnetic Ink Character Recognition NCIP National Circulation Interchange Protocol NAS National Academy of Science NDLTD Networked Digital Library of Theses and Dissertation NREN National Research & Education Network NTC National Telecommunication Corporation NUML National University of Modern Languages OCLC Online Computer Library Center OCR Optical Mark Recognition OPAC Online Public Access Catalogue Pak LAG Pakistan Library Automation Group PASTIC Pakistan Scientific and Technological Information Centres PC Personal Computer PDF Portable Document Format PERN Pakistan Education and Research Network PERI Program for Enhancement of Research Information PhD Doctor of Philosophy PLA Pakistan Library Association PSLM Pakistan Social and Living Standards Measurement PSUL Public Sector University Libraries PRR Pakistan Research Repository PTCL Pakistan Telecommunications Co. Ltd.
VIII
RAM Random Access Memory R & D Research and Development RFID Radio Frequency Identification SPSS Statistical Package for Social Sciences SD Standard Deviation SDI Selective Dissemination of Information TA/DA Travelling Allowance/ Dearness Allowance UNDP United Nations Development Program UNESCO United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization UPS Un-interrupted Power Supply URL Universal Resource Locator WINISIS Windows version - Integrated Set for Information Systems WORM Write Once Read Many
IX
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
All praise belongs to the Almighty Allah because without His Blessing this study
would not have been completed.
Many people were involved in the undertaking of this study. It is not possible to
mention all of them by name. However, a few deserve to be mentioned here.
First and foremost, I appreciate the tremendous efforts of Prof. Dr. Rafia A Sheikh,
my supervisor. Very special thanks go to her, whose guidance and suggestions made
me work through the writing of this dissertation. Her keen interest in my work, valued
comments and supervision were a great source of encouragement.
There were friends and well-wishers who assisted me in various ways: academically,
socially and administratively. Without their support, I would not have been able to
pursue this research project. These include: Prof. Dr. Allah Rakio Butt, Prof. Shereen
Gul Soomro, Prof.Manzoor Ahmad Hajano, Dr. Nisar Ahmad Subhpoto from the
Department of Library and Information Science University of Sindh. My thanks also
go to Prof. Hamid Rehman (my honorable teacher and Chairman Department of
Library and Information Science, Peshawar University). I thank them all for their co-
operation.
I would also like to express my gratitude to all my colleagues working in various
public sector universities who had responded by filling out the questionnaires and
agreed to be interviewed by me as a follow-up to the questionnaire. These include
librarians and select users/ patrons.
This study was made possible through the financial assistance provided to me by the
Higher Education Commission (HEC) Islamabad under Indigenous Scholarship Scheme.
At the same time, my employer, Department of Higher Education, Archives and Libraries
Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa granted me study leave, which provided me the
opportunity to come to the University of Sindh to pursue my doctorate program. I am
very grateful to HEC and my employer for their material and moral help.
Finally, my sincere thanks and appreciation go to my beloved parents, wife, brothers,
sisters and my kids: Hamza Saeed Khan, Ali Saeed Khan, Mamoona Saeed and Dua
X
Saeed. Without their prayers, sacrifice, patience and support, the completion of this
work would not have been possible.
XI
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CERTIFICATE ……………………………………………………………………..II
DECLARARTION .................................................................................................... III
DEDICATION........................................................................................................... IV
LIST OF ACRONYMS .............................................................................................. V
ACKNOWLEGMENT ............................................................................................. IX
TABLE OF CONTENTS ........................................................................................ XI
LIST OF TABLES ............................................................................................... XVII
ABSTRACT .............................................................................................................. XX
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction…………………………………………… ....................................1
1.2 University libraries in Pakistan……………………… ......................................4
1.3 Digitization…………………………………… ................................................7
1.4 Digital library .....................................................................................................8
1.5 Digital Library Program (DLP) in Pakistan.………………………………. 10
1.5.1 Historical background …………………………………….. 10
1.5.2 Components of DLP ………………………………………. 10
1.5.3 Allocation of financial aid ………………………………… 18
1.5.4 Recapitulation and monitoring ……………………………. 19
1.5.5 Impact of DLP on research output in Pakistan ……………. 19
1.6 Need of networking of university libraries in Pakistan …………………… 20
1.7 Pakistan Education and Research Network(PERN)……………………… 21
1.8 Video conferencing …………………………………………………….. 22
1.9 Pakistan Research Repository (PRR) ……………………………..................24
1.10 Automation of library procedures ....................................................................25
1.10.1 Why library automation? .................................................................... 26
XII
1.10.2 Barriers to library automation…………… ..........................................26
1.11 Areas of library automation……………… .....................................................28
1.11.1 Acquisition procedures …………………………………………… 28
1.11.2 Technical processing of documents ………………………………. 29
1.11.3 Circulation procedures ……………………………………………. 30
1.11.4 Serials control …………………………………………………….. 31
1.11.5 Stock verification …………………………………………………. 32
1.12 Automated services to users .............................................................................32
1.12.1 Current Awareness Service (CAS)……………. .................................32
1.12.2 Selective Dissemination of Information(SDI)…. ................................33
1.12.3 Reference services……………………………. ..................................33
1.12.4 Content page services………………………… ..................................33
1.12.5 Internet services………………………………. ..................................34
1.13 Impact of emerging technologies on university libraries .................................34
1.13.1 Impact of digital technology on library services ..................................35
1.13.2 Impact of digital technology on library resources ...............................36
1.14 Statement of the problem .....................................................................37
1.14.1 Objectives of the study .........................................................................37
1.14.2 Hypotheses ...........................................................................................37
1.14.3 Need and Significance of the study .....................................................37
1.14.4 Definitions of terms .............................................................................38
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Literature review: an introduction ...................................................................39
2.2 Digital technology and library automation: an introduction ...........................39
2.3 Emerging library technologies in developed and developing countries ..........44
XIII
2.4 Emerging library technologies in Pakistan .....................................................52
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1 Need and significance of the study .................................................................58
3.2 Research design ...............................................................................................58
3.3 Sources of data .................................................................................................59
3.4 Data Collection methods ..................................................................................60
3.4.1 Questionnaire survey ...........................................................................60
3.4.2 Personal visit and observation of libraries ...........................................61
3.5 Data Analysis techniques .................................................................................61
3.5.1 Percentage analysis ..............................................................................61
3.5.2 Basic statistical tools ............................................................................61
3.5.3 Chi-square test .....................................................................................62
CHAPTER FOUR: ANALYSIS OF DATA AND INTERPRETATION
4.1 Librarians' response towards the application and impact of emerging
technologies on public sector university libraries ............................................63
4.1.1 Available services, resources and digital technology infrastructure in
the university libraries .........................................................................63
4.1.1.1 Broad-spectrum information …… ...........................................64
4.1.1.2 Available services provided by the P.S.U libraries .................70
4.1.1.3 Available resources in the P.S.U libraries of Pakistan .............82
4.1.1.4 Library software used for the operation of hardware ...............97
4.1.1.5 Database of library holdings ....................................................98
4.1.1.6 Websites of the university libraries ………………………...99
4.1.1.7 Physical Resources.................................................................100
4.1.2 Impact of digital technology on library services and resources in the
public sector universities (P.S.U) of Pakistan ....................................102
XIV
4.1.2.1 Technology based services are better than manual
services? ………………………………………… 102
4.1.2.2 Technology based technical services have a positive
impact on library services and resources?............... 104
4.1.2.3 Attitude of university librarians towards the application
of Digital Technology (DT) in the P.S.U libraries of
Pakistan …………………………………………… 105
4.1.2.4 Networking of P.S. university libraries in Pakistan.. 106
4.1.2.5 Librarians’ opinion in response to various queries.. 107
4.1.2.6 Barriers to the application of emerging library
technologies in the university libraries …………….109
4.1.2.7 Comparing advantages of digital/ electronic resources
over conventional print version of library resources 110
4.1.2.8 Librarians’ reply to an open ended question …… 113
4.2 Users' response towards the application and impact of emerging technologies
on university libraries ....................................................................................115
4.2.1 General information ...........................................................................115
4.2.2 Use of library and information services resources /utilities
/ tools/devices ....................................................................................118
4.2.3 Rating the quantity and quality of the traditional learning resources in
university libraries .............................................................................120
4.2.4 Analyses of attitude of users towards the application and impact of
digital technology on university library services and resources .......122
4.2.5 Users’ opinion about significant changes in the speed of academic/
research work by using digital library technologies .........................126
4.2.6 User’s feedback to an open- ended query ..........................................128
References .................................................................................................................129
CHAPTER FIVE: SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND SUGGESTIONS
XV
5.1 Summary of the major findings .....................................................................130
5.1.1 General information ...........................................................................130
5.1.2 Library services ..................................................................................131
5.1.3 Library resources ...............................................................................132
5.1.4 Technology- based resources .............................................................135
5.1.5 Physical services …………………………………………………... 135
5.2 Digital technology and university library services and resources ...................... 137
5.3 Users' response towards the application and impact of emerging technologies
on university libraries ....................................................................................141
5.4 Suggestions for improving modern university library and information services
and resources in Pakistan ...............................................................................144
Bibliography ............................................................................................................148
Suggestions for further studies ............................................................ 165
Contribution to knowledge......................................................................................166
APPENDIX-A
Questionnaire for Chief Librarians .......................................................................167
XVI
APPENDEX-B
Questionnaire for users ...........................................................................................184
APPENDIX-C
A structured interview -schedule with chief librarians ........................................192
APPENDIX –D
Definitions ………………………………………………………………… 193
APPENDIX- E
Functions of library automation ……………………… ...................................... 196
APPENDIX- F
Emerging library technologies ………………………… ...................................... 197
APPENDIX- G
Online Public Access Catalogue …………………………. ................................ 200
APPENDIX-H
Overview of the public sector university libraries in Pakistan ...........................201
LIST OF TABLES
Table 4.1: Response rate of participated universities ............................................64
XVII
Table 4.2: Establishment of Public Sector Universities (PSU). .................................... 65
Table 4.3: Commencement of library automation in PSU libraries .....................65
Table 4.4: Status of library automation in PSU libraries of Pakistan ..................66
Table 4.5: Users’ visit to libraries ........................................................................67
Table 4.6: No. Of users visiting digital library sections of PSU universities ......69
Table 4.7: General services provided by PSU libraries Under study ....................70
Table 4.8: Technical services offered by the PSU libraries .......................................... 71
Table 4.9: Satisfaction about the usage of technical services ...............................72
Table 4.10: Availability of internet connectivity ....................................................73
Table 4.11: Speed of internet connections .............................................................74
Table 4.12: Computers having internet connections ..............................................75
Table 2.13: Status of internet "whether internet is fee based or free?". ..................76
Table 2.14: Provision of user education .................................................................77
Table 4.15: Frequency and timings of user education ...........................................78
Table 4.16: Duration of user education program ....................................................79
Table 4.17: Who and how to conduct user education ............................................81
Table 4.18: Impact of user education program on users’ library services and
resources ..............................................................................................82
Table 4.19: Learning resources ..............................................................................82
Table 4.20: Strength of library staff .......................................................................85
Table 4.21: Qualification of the library professionals ...........................................86
Table 4.22: Nature of human resources .................................................................87
Table 4.23: Information about the no. Of training received by the library
XVIII
professionals in emerging library technologies ..................................88
Table 4.24: Impact of trainings on human resources .............................................89
Table 4.25: Additional qualification required for incharge automation section .....89
Table 4.26: University library budget from 2005-2010 .........................................90
Table 4.27: Library budget for automation sections of university libraries under
study ....................................................................................................91
Table 4.28: Views of librarians about satisfaction of library automation budget ..93
Table 4.29: Views of librarians about allocation of library automation budget ....93
Table 4.30: Technology based resources/hardware ...............................................94
Table 4.31: Library software used for the operation of hardware ..........................97
Table 4.32: Database of library holdings ...............................................................99
Table 4.33: Website of university libraries ...........................................................100
Table 4.34: Views about physical resources in comparison with a modern
university library ................................................................................101
Table 4.35: Technology based services are better than manual services .............103
Table 4.36: Why technology-based services are better than manual services .....103
Table 4.37: Impact of technology based technical services on university libraries
............................................................................................................104
Table 4.38: Attitude of librarians towards the application of emerging library
technology .........................................................................................105
Table 4.39: Networking of public sector university libraries at in Pakistan ........106
Table 4.40: Librarians’ opinion in response to various queries ...................................108
Table 4.41: Barriers to emerging library technologies ..........................................109
XIX
Table 4.42: Comparing advantages of digital/electronic resources over
conventional print version of library resources .................................111
Table 4.43: Status of university library users........................................................115
Table 4.44: Purpose of library visits by the users ................................................116
Table 4.45: Frequency of library visits by the users ............................................ 117
Table 4.46: Average time spent by the users in the library on a visit .................118
Table 4.47: Use of library services /resources /utilities/tools / devices ................119
Table 4.48: Rating the quantity and quality of the traditional learning resources in
university libraries ..............................................................................121
Table 4.49: Users’ opinion about skills and expertise to use technology based
services and resources .......................................................................122
Table 4.50: Users’ opinion about training/orientation .........................................124
Table 4.51: Purpose of internet use .......................................................................125
Table 4.52: User's opinion about significant change in speed of academic/ research
work ..................................................................................................126
XX
ABSTRACT
This research project is a case study of the public sector university libraries in
Pakistan. This thesis investigates and documents the impact of digital technology on
library and information services and resources in the public sector universities of the
country. All 73 public sector universities in Pakistan have been covered.
Questionnaires, interviews, observation, web analyses and documentary sources of
information were the major data collection techniques.
The findings of the study reveal that the implementations of emerging library
technologies have positive impact on library services and resources in the public
sector universities in Pakistan. It was pinpointed that inadequate funding for library
automation, lack of skilled library professionals, lack of user education programs on
emerging library technologies, frequent power failure are the major barriers to the
implementation of latest technologies in university libraries of the country. The
findings also reflect that public sector university libraries of Islamabad and Punjab are
far ahead in modernization of library services and resources as compared with Sindh,
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Balochistan and Azad Jammu and Kashmir& Northern Areas.
Recommendations are given at the end. Among other things, it is suggested that
separate budget for automation and digitization, recruitment of IT skilled human
resources, supply of powerful generators/ UPS, provision of latest hardware and
standardized library software, revision of LIS curriculum, systematic planning for
modernization of university libraries, digitization of library own publications,
provision of high bandwidth of internet speed connections , effective periodic
training for library professionals and continuing user education on modern library
trends for library users are the tools which can be used for the improvement of
modern library culture in the universities of Pakistan .
1
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction
This chapter throws light on the subject under study, ‘Digital technology and its impact
on library and information services and resources in the public sector universities of
Pakistan’. All related areas including introduction, role of university libraries in the
promotion of higher education, need for implementation of emerging technologies in
university libraries, hardware and software requirements for automation and digitization
processes, areas of digital technology application in university libraries, various services
provided under automated technology-based environment and National Digital Library
Program (NDLP).
According to the current Pakistan Social and Living Standards Survey (2008-2009), the
average literacy rate for both males and females is 75%. The gender-wise rate is 69% for
males and 44% for females. The Report reflects that literacy rate is higher in urban than
in rural areas of Pakistan. Literacy rate for men is higher than women. The province-
wise report reveals that literacy rate in Punjab and Sindh is 59%, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa is
50% and Balochistan is 45%. It was also observed that Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) and
Sindh have achieved considerable improvement during 2007-2008 to 2008-2009.
According to a statistical report (2010), the allocation of budget for education in Pakistan
was as follow:
Financial year % of GDP
2006-2007 2.5
2007-2008 2.47
2008-2009 2.1
2009-2010 2.0
2
UNESCO’s EFA (Education For All) Global Monitoring Report submitted in 2009
reveals that budget allocation for promotion of education in other South Asian countries
is as follow:
Country Year % GDP
Bangladesh 2008-09 2.6
Nepal 2008-09 3.2
India 2008-09 3.3
Iran 2008-09 5.2
Maldives 2008-09 8.3
This simply shows that we lag behind even Bangladesh.
With the establishment of Higher Education Commission (HEC) in Islamabad, the
Government of Pakistan raised the budget for higher education in the country. Several
projects have been launched for the enhancement of quality higher education. The
financial condition of Government of Pakistan is in descending order for the last five
years. This financial constraint has affected the higher education sector of the country.
During the financial year 2007-2008, non- developmental budget has been reduced. The
same financial level has been maintained in the financial year 2008-2009. With the
financial assistance of the World Bank, an increase has been made in the funding of
higher education sector for development expenditure in the financial year 2009-2010.
It is reported that with the inception of Higher Education Commission, considerable
increase in the students’ enrolment in universities of Pakistan has been observed. The
statistical data reveals that the enrolled students at the universities were 803,507 in the
year 2008-09, which shows an increase of 190.94% over the total enrolment of 2001-
2002 which was 276,274. This also reflects that 354% increase has been recorded in the
number of PhDs produced (624) in the year 2010 as compared with the number of PhDs
(176) produced in the year 2000.
3
Pakistani universities constitute one of the largest higher education systems in the
Muslim world, with 132 university level institutions which comprise of 73 universities
in the public sector and 59 in the private sector.
Education is a tool used for stamping out poverty and expediting the pace of progress of a
nation in the right direction. It brings about happiness and awareness. It provides an
opportunity to the masses to change their lifestyles and can also change the behavior and
outlook of the people. Education is the gateway to explore new ways of prosperity. It is
the most influential instrument to get rid of the social evils of the society. In order to get
quality and standard education, the establishment of well-resourced academic institutions
is need of the day. In Pakistan, the situation is changing for the better. However, the rapid
change in the establishment of academic institutions especially universities and degree-
awarding institutions, rapid increase in the students’ enrolment, an emphasis on modern
teaching methodologies, attention of Government towards research productivity,
introduction of modern technologies and the interest of Higher Education Commission in
the advancement of higher education have brought about a reasonable change in the
promotion of higher education in the country.
In order to achieve the objectives of a university or a degree awarding institution, the
establishment of a well organized, well-resourced modern library is of great importance.
The university library is considered to be the heart of the university. It provides a
platform to the students, faculty members and researchers to fulfill their information
needs. The emergence of modern library technologies has dramatically changed the
nature of services and resources of the libraries. The increasing demands of users have
also been changed with the changing library environment, with the emergence of new
technologies and with the awareness brought about by the media.
The university library was regarded as a store-house of books and their role was limited
in teaching and learning processes. The importance of a university library has now been
realized by the students, faculty members, researchers and higher ups of the university.
Now a university library is considered as the most important element and integral part of
4
the university system. The ultimate aim of the university library is to support the learning
activities of the university.
Wilson and Tauber (1964:25) describe that the main theme behind the establishment of a
university library is to quench the information thirst of their readers. It should support the
activities of the library like teaching, research, publication and interpretation.
Butler (1995:1) explains that central libraries of universities will play a prominent role in
the dissemination of information and will act as a hub for the other learning procedures of
the university. The students, teachers and other staff of the university will get the required
information on the screen of their personal computers without the restrictions of time and
four walls.
Haider (2007:173-176) states that the university library is a growing organism and need
to give due attention to its planning. It should be given equal importance as with the other
curricular disciplines. It should work with the other departments on parallel lines. In
Pakistan, the status of central libraries in the public sector universities do not get the same
status as libraries in India or Iran. It has not been given the due rank it deserves. It is
reported that a good number of public sector university libraries has no chief librarians.
These libraries are run by junior librarians. The availability of emerging library
technologies in these university libraries is also a question mark. The provision of budget
for central libraries is also not satisfactory. These issues have been raised by many
educationists and library experts in the educational reports, education policies, seminars,
conferences and symposia. Foreign experts have also been assigned the task to analyze
the situation of libraries and submit reports for the advancement of library culture in
Pakistan. However, it is a sad observation that no due importance has been given to these
reports and the efforts made in this direction have been proved fruitless.
1.2 University libraries in Pakistan
Pakistan came into being on 14th August, 1947 on the map of the world. Pakistan is the
seventh populous country of the world. The country is basically an Islamic State with
more than three- quarters of the population being Sunni Muslims. The rest of the
5
population include Shiite sect (20%) and other religions like Christians (1.56%), Hindus
(1.51%), Sikhs and others (0.26%). In Pakistan we have the world’s second highest peak
named K-2. The topography of Pakistan is variable. Climate is also a diverse
phenomenon. The inland areas can get up to 50 degree centigrade temperatures while the
hilly areas drop to freezing point. Rice, Tobacco, Wheat, Cotton and Cane are the major
crops of the country.
There are 132 university level institutions in the country. Each and every university or
Degree Awarding Institute (DAI) has a main university library. The size and services of a
university library depend on the nature, students’ strength and overall infrastructure of
the university.
The library was considered a building, room or a number of rooms containing books for
study, reading, consultation or reference. Heartsill Young (1983:130) in the American
Library Association (ALA) Glossary of Library and Information Science has defined a
library as:
“A collection of resources ordered to offer physical, bibliographical and scholarly access
to target group, with a staff that is trained to provide services and programs related to
the information needs of the target group.”
Ranganathan (1940:25) was right in saying that “a library is a place established for the
preservation, processing and circulation of collection of books. It is the duty of this public
institution to convert general readers or library goers into potential library users.”
S.Gopinath , A. Pathak (2001:31-32) writes that “the libraries are built to acquire,
preserve, process, access, retrieve and disseminate information to their patrons.” It is also
stated that no change has occurred in the objectives of the libraries.
Ifidon and Okoli (2002: 22-33) are of the view that additional functions of universities
are:
• Search, encouragement, and propagation of facts;
• Stipulation of logical headship;
6
• Human resource improvement;
• Encouragement of societal and financial renovation;
• Endorsement of intra- and transnational and global understanding.
University libraries have derived their objectives from the above functions which
include:
• Stipulation of resources for undergraduate training, term papers, and
projects, as well as for additional reading;
• Provision of resources for students, teachers and researchers;
• Provision of costly standard mechanism, especially in the professional
disciplines.
The main theme behind the establishment of an academic library is to satisfy the reader
community. The information needs of the academic community may be satisfied with the
provision of necessary information resources and documents for study, reference and
research.
Kanwal Ameen (2008) is of the view that university libraries are receiving better funding
for acquisition of print material. These funds may not be spent on what is available in the
market but what is the need. The use of online resources should be given due importance
to achieve efficiency, economy and speed.
In the present era of information explosion, the universities’ libraries in Pakistan need
latest library technologies to cope with the challenges by modernizing their services. The
emergence of internet and online facilities have enhanced the increasing demands of
library clientele.
Muhammad Sajid Mirza &.Khalid Mahmood (2009:1) state that there is a dire need for
the development of a library web page within the university home page. The web-based
library services should be introduced in all public sector university libraries. Pakistan
Library Association (PLA), HEC and LIS schools to take necessary measures for
arranging training, seminars, conferences for library professionals and users to enhance
7
their capabilities. Surveys should be conducted to show the barriers in the way of
implementation of emerging technologies in libraries.
The advent of digital technology in the libraries and information centers of Pakistan took
place two and half decades ago. As a matter of fact, most of the universities in the public
sector in Pakistan have recently introduced the adoption of emerging technologies in their
libraries or planning to introduce the same. The public sector university libraries of
Islamabad and Punjab have better digital technology infrastructure as compared with the
rest of the university libraries of the country because of comparatively better financial
affluence and proximity to the federal capital Islamabad as well as the HEC headquarters.
The major limiting factors for hesitation in the use of emerging technologies in university
libraries are lack of technology-based set up, deficiency of IT trained human resource,
lack of awareness of the digital resources, low user demand rate, financial constraints,
limited computer network system, lack of awareness about the digital protection methods
and lack of technological education for digital access. The projects of introducing
modern technologies in the public sector university libraries will be possible if and only if
the above mentioned barriers are overcome.
1.3 Digitization
Digitization is a process by which a character or text, chart, picture, sound, video is
converted into digital format. Digitization changes the reading material into digital form
that is easier to store and retrieve.
McQuail (2000:16-34) highlights the practice of digitization having enormous
consequences to the computing standards as it "permits information of all types in all
shapes to be carried with the same competencies and also intermingled"
Chepesuik ( 1997:47-49) discusses that digitized information has many advantages like
universal availability, minimum cost, easy use, and does not perish for a long time.
Digitization requires expensive infrastructure and this is considered to be the main
barrier. A report submitted by the University of Michigan at Ann Arbor, which noted that
the cost of digitization of a single page is from $2 to $6 US Dollars.
8
What documents need to be digitized in the library? Different criteria are used for
selecting individual items for digitization (Gary Cleveland, 1998). These are:
Their capability for permanent use
Their scholarly or civilizing grading
Whether the digitized material have easy and quick accessibility than the
manuscripts.
Whether copyright issues will allow digitization of the materials.
Muhammad Ahsan (2009) discusses that digitization process in information centers or
libraries of Pakistan is at the stage of infancy. Pakistan has not achieved the required
progress in the field of digitization due to inadequate finances, lack of computer
knowledge and lack of skilled professionals in the area of digitization; these are the main
reasons due to which our country is lagging behind the developed countries. Although
some of our institutions are trying to digitize some of their library documents. These
organizations/ universities include HEC, National Library of Pakistan, Central Library of
Quaid-e-Azam University in Islamabad, Central Library of the University of Punjab and
some private organizations. In order to preserve the intellectual heritage in the form of
manuscripts and other rare materials related to arts, social sciences (especially culture and
history of the country), these are in the process of digitization. The total collection of
manuscripts in our country is 0.15 million placed in libraries and in some personal
custody. It is the necessary that we digitize their materials to preserve the cultural
heritage.
1.4 Digital library
The Digital Library Reference Model defines a digital library as: an organization, which
might be virtual, that comprehensively collects, manages and preserves for the long term
rich digital content, and offers to its user communities specialized functionality on that
content, of measurable quality and according to codified policies.
9
A digital library is comprised of collections, services and infrastructure to support
lifelong learning, research, scholarly communication and preservation (“Digital
Libraries”: 2006). The digital library is not a single entity; the digital library requires
technology to link the resources of many services that are transparent to the end users;
Universal access to digital libraries and information services is a goal; digital library
collections are not limited to document surrogates: they extend to digital artifacts that
cannot be represented or distributed in printed format (ARL, 1995). The digital library is
the collection of services and the collection of information objects that support users in
dealing with information objects available directly or indirectly via electronic /digital
means (Leiner, 1998).
Janet Gertz (2000:97-104) outlines the major advantages of a digital library:
No physical boundary
Round the clock availability
Multiple accesses.
Information retrieval.
Preservation and conservation.
Space.
The main problems in building a digital library are digital security, copyright and
licensing and metadata creation.
Ashfaq Hussain, et.al (2008:1) describe that digital library is a sine qua non and can play
a vital role to enhance research and development in the country. He further mentions that
the present situation of digital libraries in Pakistan is not satisfactory, although some
efforts have been made.
The respondents to the questionnaire distributed to them under this study laid emphasis
on training workshops, seminars, lectures for the promotion of digital libraries in
Pakistan. It was recommended that library schools and professional associations should
also take necessary steps for promoting the concept of digital librarianship in Pakistan.
10
1.5 Digital Library Program (DLP) in Pakistan.
1.5.1 Historical background
The digital library program in Pakistan traces back to a collaborative project of England.
The main purpose of the project was to make possible the access of developing and
backward countries to the latest scientific publications of Program for the Enhancement
of Research Information (PERI). PERI was founded by International Network for the
Availability of Scientific Publications (INASP) in 1999/2000. The second purpose of this
program was to develop knowledge, encourage creation and production of information, to
develop sustainable and equitable access to information, to poster collaboration and
networking, and to strengthen the local capacities to manage and implement information
and knowledge. By modifying PERI in Pakistan in 2004, the HEC got the distinction of
providing immense knowledge to its users particularly Degree Awarding Institutions
(DAIs), Research Centres (RC) and Universities in the form of scholarly publications
through Digital Library Program (DLP). As a result, the users may have access to this
store of learning not only from Pakistan, but also across the world. Public as well private
sector universities can equally enjoy the fruits of this program. The program has
permitted a large number of institutions to have access to more than 20,000 scholarly
journals/publications. These publications include articles on general topics and issues and
subject specific journals of national and international standards.
However, the question arises as to how will it be possible to have access to this store of
information? To solve this problem of the users, HEC has provided easy access on online
basis to this repository of knowledge. HEC allows users after the verification of their
Internet Protocol (IP) addresses. The verification of these IP addresses is carried out
automatically by the Local Area Network (LAN).
1.5.2 Components of DLP
There are four different categories of Digital Library Program (DLP): (A) Content
Acquisition and Development (CAD), (B) User Training, (C) Technical Support and the
(D) Promotion of E-Resources. These four categories are discussed briefly as under:
11
A- Content Acquisition and Development (CAD)
This category is the most important one. More than 75 percent of the total DLP budget is
reserved for this category, which indicates its significance. The purpose of CAD is to
cope with the changing research requirements of higher institutions in Pakistan. This area
demands special attention. CAD has enabled Pakistani universities to have access to
electronic journals of international quality on all science subjects. In this race CAD is
competing with the world ranking universities of Europe, America and other developed
countries.
In order to analyze the merits and demerits of this program, HEC conducted a workshop
in March 2004 at Islamabad under the supervision of Project Coordinator of the Digital
Library Program. The workshop was attended by Information Technology (IT)
professionals and librarians across the country. The main purpose of the workshop was to
determine the demand for journals in all subjects and to assess the current status of off-
line research materials available in different libraries of the various institutions.
At the end of the workshop, it was known that due to insufficient budget allocated to the
libraries, it was necessary for the Commission to use its consortium approach to provide
access to online resources. For public sector universities, electronic resources were
sponsored and funded by HEC, while private universities shared only 50 percent of the
total cost of acquiring specialized resources. HEC has asked all institutions of higher
learning to provide feedback so that it is aware of the current information requirements.
The Higher Education Commission is constantly and needlessly seeking for more and
more opportunities for its institutions to have access to the store of knowledge of all the
leading universities of the world. To achieve the purpose, Pakistan has signed an
agreement under the title of ‘Pak-US Cooperation in Science and Technology” in 2004
with National Academy of Science (NAS) Washington DC to allow its institutions for
using their journals and other sources of knowledge via internet.
12
The agreement was highly successful from the point of view that less than half of the
allocated budget had been utilized in the first year. Only a year later in 2005, the
remaining balance was also used to broaden access to some of the societies’ databases.
Besides, subscription to additional journal resources has been made available. Some of
the available e-databases through the digital library program included: American Society
of Physics Teachers (ASPT), American Society of Civil Engineering (ASCE), American
Physical Society (APS), American Chemical Society (ACS), Association of Computing
Machinery (ACM), Institute of Physics and many others.
Sometime a user requests for such an article/publication which is not available in the
digital library of HEC. PERI has entered into an agreement with the British Library to
provide easy access to these articles on the request of the users through HEC. To provide
the user with the required material, orders are placed through the British Library
Documents Delivery Service (BLDDS). The cost of articles is reimbursed by the HEC,
and the orders are put through a systematic procedure. Any individual including student,
faculty member and researcher can order two articles at a time in a month from any
institution.
B- User training
The Digital Library Program (DLP) is although very useful and it has produced
successful results so far in our country as well as across the globe, but at the same time, it
has to face many challenges and barriers to overcome. Of these barriers and challenges,
the most significant one is the spreading of awareness among the users and institutions
and encouraging the use of acquired resources. The sole reason of the problem is that,
these resources have been introduced into an environment that is very narrow and limited
in a sense. Persons who understand the digital libraries at length are very few in number.
A large number of people do not know about such latest trends introduced in the libraries.
To solve the problem, it is essential to find out user groups through which this change is
to be introduced. This group will have to undergo a specialized training module to obtain
the maximum impact and achieve the target. What is a user group?
13
B (i )- User Groups
The user group is the very first step and corner- stone of all future progress in training.
The first thing to be decided and taken into consideration is that what change/changes are
to be brought about and who can be the most effective person/persons who can be
helpful in bringing about such a change.
The objectives of this program is to make sure that the users have been provided with
information and training on the range of content available to them in order to enable them
to codify their knowledge that they have acquired through their research and lastly to
apply it in a new style to their own work.
B(ii) - Highly qualified active researchers; developing capacity
This group is the most important one from the view point of digital library resources.
They are the people who have an immediate need to conduct research on subjects/topics
according to their learning, skill and taste. They will use the digital library as a tool to
enhance the quality of their research work and to polish it more and more so that it may
compete with international standards. Digital library can be helpful to them in realizing
their dreams of producing quality research by providing them with the latest research and
information. In a nutshell, we can say that they are the most effective users of this
program. To build and polish their skill of conducting research has been a first priority of
this program.
B(iii)- Subject specific; Refining capacity
The members of this group include PhD supervisors, heads of departments and PhD
students. All these members are active researchers. They constitute another important
group of users who can play a leading role in the promotion of the use of resources and
can encourage students to take advantage of the available research literature.
B(iv)- General training; Building capacity
The development of information literacy courses to be included into the curricula of the
Master level courses is one of the current issues. This step will include training of
14
students in all available resources that are related to their course of studies and setting
up of compulsory assignments on the available content.
B(v)- Training imparted
It has been reported and taken for granted from different sources like print and electronic
media that the available vast resources of all universities of Pakistan through Digital
Library Program would have value and uses only if they are to be used effectively by the
faculty members as well as the students. To achieve this objective, HEC has designed a
comprehensive training strategy by which a group of resource persons will arrange
workshops and seminars across Pakistan from time to time. In 2005-06, the first step was
taken in this direction. The purpose of which was to promote awareness and the usage of
Digital Library resources among the users. The training was conducted in different
regions of Pakistan, and different teams, consisting of two or three members actively
conducted onsite promotion and training activities for the users. In the first phase 43
public sector institutions and some private institutions in Pakistan availed this facility of
initial training. Initially around 7500 teachers and students were given training at the
different seminars conducted in 2005. The trainings have been varied in its scope and
content.
General Awareness Training (GAT) was conducted in universities where the graph of
awareness about the use of electronic resources was extremely low. These programs
provided the participants with general information on the subject. Presentations were
given on the available resources to the newly established universities. The participants
were given training as how to use search techniques and modules on copyright issues,
intellectual property rules and regulations and ethics of research.
Some institutions where the graph of general awareness was at a satisfactory level, a
more focused approach was adopted. HEC skilled personnel developed subject specific
course modules in areas relating to the Chemical Sciences, Physical Sciences, Life
Sciences, Earth Sciences, Engineering Sciences and Biological Sciences. The training
was arranged for PhD supervisors in their respective fields. The students under the
15
supervision of these supervisors were also given training. The training had an enormous
effect on all the trainees. The trainees gained comprehensive information on the range
and depth of resources available to them in their subject area through the seminars. They
also learnt the skills of utilizing these resources effectively.
C- Technical Support
Technical support means the unbreakable and effective communication between the
publisher and institutions registered for having access to digital library resources. Project
Coordinator is a person who manages this operation of digital library. Moreover, the
Project Coordinator is responsible for establishing long term guidelines for the successful
implementation of the program and developing plans for diversification and expansion.
The responsibility of the subordinates is further divided geographically, where each
member is held responsible to play a number of roles by attending to the need of his
region. In order to provide full access to the resources, a central database is maintained of
IP addresses and contact details of each member institution. In case a university changes
its IP address, they will have to notify the digital library team and through an automatic
system access to the resources is updated immediately and without any delay. Some of
the tasks which a team is supposed to complete are as under:
C (i) - Confirmation of available resources
Keeping in view the nature and function of this program, the country has been divided
into five major zones. Each zone has been assigned to a person known as Regional
Coordinator. Each institution which lies in the premises of the Regional Coordinator is
directed to keep in touch with their regional Coordinator via e-mail or voice mail. Every
institution is provided with a contact number and e-mail of their respective Coordinator
for updates and to answer their queries. Every issue and problem regarding access to the
resources is solved by the Coordinator in due time. Problems usually arise due to the
following reasons:
Internet Protocol(IP) range
disorder;
16
Issues related to publishers
and publications of the content
Problems related to the
universities and degree awarding institutions
New institutions and organizations which are desirous to have an access to the resources
are directed to provide their IP addresses for registration with the publisher and for
making available the repositories. At the first stage, access is made available to some
organizations with the help of user name and password. No institution is allowed to have
an access in the absence of an IP address.
C(ii)- Lawful use of available resources
In order to facilitate the users, access to the resources is replaced from user name/
password to IP address. The problem with user names and passwords are that the
resources can be accessed from any location and from any address. The result of such
access is that the resources are used unlawfully such as hiking and the user is not easily
traced. Contrary to this problem by providing IP addresses to the member institutions, it
becomes quite easy for server to trace the unlawful use of resources with the help of IP
address which is allotted to an institution at the time of registration with HEC. No one
can have access to the resources from that institution without a legal IP address which
prevents the unlawful use of resources. In case the resources are unlawfully used, the
concerned institution is held responsible for unauthorized usage. Unlawful usage includes
hiking and excessive downloads with web crawlers or other software. In case of such
incidents, the Vice Chancellors/ Deans / Principals/Heads are notified of such illegal
usage.
C(iii - Monitoring of users
The Higher Education Commission has a well-defined system of monitoring the member
institutions regarding the unauthorized use of its electronic resources. In this respect, the
technical expert points out the technical problems and extends his co-operation for
solving of all such problems. These experts weed out the resources which are no longer
17
used by the universities. The extra funds are allocated to support those institutions where
the usage of such resources is required more than the other institutes. The technical team
uses the collected data to analyze the impact of training programs and to know the extent
to which these changes are useful.
The role of a librarian is manifold and of greater importance in creating awareness of the
digital library program. Librarians have played a leading role in shortening the distance
between HEC and the users of its member institutions. The librarians in many universities
have conducted many workshops on their own on this subject. The responsibility of the
librarian is to receive the users’ requests for journals/ research articles/ books and to
provide the users with their demands by forwarding their requests to the Digital Library
Project Coordinator. The Coordinator seeks help from the British Library to fulfill the
need of the users.
D- Promotion of electronic
resources
In order to improve the quality and standard of surveys carried out locally by the
Pakistani scholars, the Higher Education Commission has taken important steps. The
aim of these steps is to improve the quality of local research and to bring it on parallel
lines with international standard research and to make it accessible to the local needy
students, faculty members, researchers and scientists. These things are possible only if
our libraries are fully digitized and furnished with the latest technology.
To achieve this target, HEC has provided access to more than 20,000 e- journals and
other research papers to the readers with the help of DLP. According to another survey
conducted by Elsevier Publishing, more than 70 percent of the world’s peer-reviewed
scientific literature is launched by this Program. The number of institutions who are
regular participants of this program is more than 150. These institutions include public as
well as private sector universities, Degree Awarding Institutions and Research Centres.
The only drawback with this program is that it is not widely used due to the lack of
awareness on the part of the readers. In order to create awareness amongst the users,
18
various ways and techniques have been adopted by the HEC and other member
institutions. These techniques include poster and pamphlets which are distributed
regularly in the campuses. Besides, book marks containing Universal Resource Locator
(URL) of all the major publishers, databases are also distributed among the users.
A website has also been developed in 2005 to expedite the promotion of Digital Library
Program. The purpose of this website is to develop a trend of digital library use among
the traditional readers. The website offers a number of user friendly hyper links and feeds
the visitors with the details of the content information about the Digital Libraries. These
links are of enormous use for all categories of users including library users, general users,
librarians, researchers and students. The website contains a link called Frequently Asked
Questions (FAQs). This section assists the users who want to know about the basic
concepts, mechanism and applications of digital libraries. It also helps in providing
membership procedure, terms and conditions related to the membership of the program.
1.5.3 Allocation of financial aid
No project can ever run longer to achieve its objectives in the absence of financial aid as
economy is the backbone of every project and again it is economy that determines the
extent of success of a plan whatsoever it may be. As stated earlier in this discussion,
public sector universities have been provided the privilege of free access and absolutely
free of cost to all the available resources. Their charges are funded by HEC, while in case
of private sector universities, 50 percent of the total costs are levied from these
universities due to their own sufficient budgets. The funds are divided into different
categories according to the nature, function and need of the category. Content Acquisition
and Development category gets the lion share of the total budget, almost over 75 percent.
The second category, which is the promotion section, takes 7 percent of the total budget
while the third section which is technical support takes 5 percent of the budget and the
remaining amount is allocated for training and miscellaneous purposes.
In 2005-06, a huge amount of Pakistani rupees amounting to Rs 200,000,000(Rs 200 m)
was allocated for the DLP. Approximately Rs 65000 were reserved for training,
19
conferences, workshops and seminars. Every following year, the amount was doubled to
meet the increasing demands of this program.
1.5.4 Recapitulation and monitoring
The program was launched in 2003, but with the passage of time, the DLP got strength
and its roots got deeper and deeper with every passing year in respect of available
contents and usage. In 2005, the DLP underwent a revolutionary phase as by that time, a
large number of researchers, faculty members and librarians got acquainted with the
program through seminars, workshops and training.
The member institutions downloaded a number of articles from this project and these
downloads were put as a standard for measuring the performance of these institutions.
Every year the number of downloaded articles went on increasing. In 2004, the number of
these full-text articles downloads was around 100,000 while in 2005, the figure jumped to
one million which was a proof of the increasing interest of the users in DLP. Not only the
number of users was increasing, but also the number of available resources and
participant institutions were growing with every passing year, due to the effectiveness
and usefulness of this program. The institutions having the best performance were
awarded additional funds, while institutions with poor performance the supply of funds
were reduced.
1.5.5 Impact of DLP on research output in Pakistan
Digital Library Program (DLP) has affected the research output of all major educational
institutions including universities, DAIs and research centres in a positive manner.
During a short span of time, the figure of research output by these institutions increased
considerably. With every successive year, research output has been doubled which owes
to many factors, but the major one is DLP.
20
The future of National Digital Library Program of Pakistan is promising and has a great
potential. The number of users is increasing by leaps and bounds with every passing day,
which is a proof of its popularity, effectiveness and usefulness for all categories of
readers, scholars and faculty members. In the coming years, this program will have to
expand its resources and repository of learning, knowledge and research articles in order
to cope with the future challenges and needs of the users. The sustainability of the
program highly depends on researchers and professionals who are playing a vital role in
managing libraries and optimizing the use of its resources.
1.6 Need of networking of university libraries in Pakistan
A network is a combination of modern technologies. It consists of hardware, software
and media for connecting computer terminals. This setup will enable these computers to
interact, communicate, exchange and share resources in real time. Network can also be
defined as the interconnection of several different computer terminals by communication
channels. It is a logical extension of data communication system.
It usually consists of a number of terminals in which some are local and some are placed
in remote areas. The remote computers are attached with telephone line or any wireless
system.
In the present era of emerging technologies, networking of libraries is a must. With the
help of library networking, we can get the benefits of resource sharing, easy technical
processing, saving of time and money, improvement in the skill of manpower and
standardization of library services. The library networking, if developed, will achieve the
following:
• It will allow data transmission to far-flung libraries
• It will provide an opportunity to various departments of a library to communicate
with each other frequently
• It will allow the users to interact with their libraries without the restriction of time
and boundary walls.
• With this facility, we can share our views and resources with other international
professionals and information centers.
21
Library networking is meant to promote and facilitate sharing of the resources available
within a group of libraries in order to provide maximum information to users at lower
operational costs and also make optimum use of national resources (Kaul, H.K: 1998).
SD Vyas (1997:4) states that the major objective of networking of university libraries is
to get maximum output with less input. The writer further adds that networking is
necessary for all kinds of libraries i.e. academic, special, public and national. This is the
tool with the help of which readers can utilize the resources of many other libraries. It can
be considered as a modern resource sharing technique.
The rapid advancement of IT and network technology has made it possible for people to
produce, access, and disseminate information and knowledge through the computer
networks. Traditional publishers, information intermediaries, and users of books,
magazines, and other publications have started to re-invent and re-position themselves in
the broader and the more ubiquitous Digital Library (DL) arena.
1.7 Pakistan Education and Research Network (PERN)
Pakistan Education and Research Network (PERN) is one of the most important
objectives of information technology action plan that was initiated by Dr. Atta-Ur-
Rehman, the then Minister of Science and Information Technology in Pakistan in 2002.
This project was sponsored by the Government of Pakistan through the Pakistan
Telecommunications Co. Ltd (PTCL). The plan was designed, operated and maintained
formally by National Telecom Corporation (NTC) in its embryonic stage and now the
responsibility has been assigned to PTCL.
The main objective of this project was to establish a continuous link among all the
chartered universities of Pakistan including public and private sectors which are
registered with Higher Education Commission of Pakistan. By linking all these
universities, it has become possible to facilitate sharing of data banks, co-operation in the
fields of research and development activities and up-gradation of teaching faculties by
providing highly learned people to all these Degree Awarding Institutions. The HEC is
now looking for reshaping PERN as PERN2 and by doing so HEC will be able to
22
establish a faster, effective and dedicated National Research and Education Network
(NREN) as PERN2 for all DAIs and universities of Pakistan. This program is useful in
providing communication via advanced Information and Communication Technologies
(ICTs) to the students and scholars. The PERN2 is also trying to get access to other
NREN of the world, especially developed countries including Asia Pacific Advanced
Network (APAN), TransEurasia Information Network (GEANT2) and Internet 2 (USA).
PERN2 will attempt to meet all the requirements of the researchers by providing them
with the latest technologies along with proper security and management. It will be the
responsibility of PERN2 to connect all the public and private sector universities and
research centres in one link using IP based infrastructure through metro fiber ring
(Gigabit Ethernet) in the areas which have these facilities. Other locations which are out
of range will be connected to HEC and other universities with the help of leased dark
fiber and Time- Division Multiplexing (TDM) system.
PERN2 is a more advanced and effective shape of PERN that is designed to meet the
requirements of advanced studies and to cope with the challenges that our institutions and
scholars will have to face in future. After PERN2 launch, all the responsibilities,
functions and duties would be transferred to PERN2. It is working on the same pattern as
PERN.
1.8 Video Conferencing
Peter Norton (2006:258) writes that one of the most interesting usages of digital
technology is the exchange of written messages, voice and videos along with the
computer networks. These shared ideas include e-mail and teleconferencing. The
subtypes of teleconferencing include video-conferencing, audio- conferencing and data-
conferencing.
Video conferencing generates a communication channel over a distance by permitting
people at two or more far off places to exchange views with each other by seeing a video
picture of the person at the other place. Each conference room has two or more cameras,
microphones, loud speakers and LCD or monitors.
23
To meet the future challenges and fulfill the requirements of advanced studies and needs
of the scholars, HEC has launched a useful project that is called Video Conferencing.
Video Conferencing is a system of net meetings and online lecturing through IP
addresses. The main purpose of this program is to deliver online lectures by scholars and
professionals to benefit those who do not have easy access to HEC repository and other
advanced libraries. When the program was initiated, it was decided that the facility would
be provided to 18 universities in 2006 in the first phase on a trial basis. If the program is
successful it will be extended to all other universities and research centres. Video
Conferencing consists of supplying, installing, integrating, testing and maintenance of
fully functional video conferencing system. The system helps in distant learning as well.
The objective of this project is to minimize the distance between students and teachers
and provide more and more opportunities to the researchers to learn from the experiences
and skills of competent supervisors registered with HEC. By bridging the gap of
communication between learners and learned, universities having shortage of faculty
members will not feel the sense of depravity of good faculty. This program also helps to
raise the standard and quality of education and to prepare the younger generation of this
country to take the responsibility of spreading quality education in the future and bring
Pakistan parallel with developed countries in education.
When this program was started in September 2006, learned scholars, professionals and
experts from all over Pakistan were invited to deliver interactive lectures on
miscellaneous topics according to the needs and wishes of the students. These lectures
were recorded and preserved by HEC to be broadcasted in future on the demand of the
scholars. The purpose of these lectures was to develop basic concepts, critical thinking
and a scientific attitude in graduate, under -graduate and other high level learners. The
lectures were equally beneficial for the teachers. If need be, noble laureates, professors,
scientists, researchers and experts from world ranking universities will be invited and
requested to deliver lectures as per demand. In second phase, the program was extended
to 32 universities as there was a dire need of this project in these universities.
24
Video conferencing is also helpful in the selection of university faculty. The desiring
candidates need not come to HEC Islamabad to be interviewed for final selection. They
have to come to the concerned university and in the university they will be online
interviewed for final selection using video conferencing facility.
The facility has saved a lot of time and money. Prior to this facility, students who were to
be sent to foreign countries under overseas scholarship program used to be interviewed
by foreigners, who were invited by HEC and paid their TA/DA /Remuneration.
Currently, the HEC need not to invite these foreigners for interviewing the provisionally
selected candidates. HEC has only to take prior appointment for online interviews of all
such candidates.
1.9 Pakistan Research Repository (PRR)
The Pakistan Research Repository is a continuing project of HEC (Higher Education
Commission) to encourage the publication of research output of international standard
carried out in the universities/ Degree Awarding Institutions or Research Institutes in
Pakistan and promote open access to scientific literature. The main aim of this system is
to build an online archive of PhD theses produced in Pakistan and to make available these
resources to the research scholars and faculty members of universities in Pakistan. The
following are some of the salient features of this repository:
To obtain and upload the research work of local scholars
Systematic and well-planned system of digitization of indigenous resources
Exchange of resources with leading other repositories of the world
Permission of browsing, accessing and downloading of full-text theses to
scholars
Permanent preservation of scholarly literature
Facility of other leading online search engines
Facility of browsing by subject, year or by type of institution
25
1.10 Automation of library procedures
Library automation may de defined as “the system which is designed to replace the
manual library system “. The application of computer based services and resources in the
operation of library activities are also termed as library automation. The conversion of
information into digital form is termed as digitization. This process makes it easier to
preserve access and share this information.
The impact of computers has affected all areas of librarianship. The application of
computers in library house keeping routines include Acquisitions’ control, Technical
processing of documents, Serials control, Circulation control and Stock verification. The
automation of library house keeping routines is more suited for automation due to its
repetitive nature. The application of computers help in gaining greater standardization,
efficiency, cooperation and advanced services.
Muhammad Riaz ( 1991: 65-66) discussed that the factors responsible to bringing about
change from conventional to automated library operations are: growth of documents,
users services, greater efficiency and cooperation and resource sharing. The objectives of
library automation have been summed up by Venkata Ramana P and Rao (2003: 31) as:
To expedite access to learning resources;
To standardize the present library collection;
To minimize the daily repetitive official work;
To give pace to the technical processing of library documents.
To offer improved range of services;
To develop networking and resource sharing environment among the libraries
and
26
To provide latest and current updates of library information to managers.
1.10.1 Why library automation?
Over the past two and a half decades, university libraries have observed dramatic changes
in their services and resources. The advent of emerging technologies is now diminishing
the central role of traditional libraries. With shrinking or reduced budget, price hike of
documents, shift in the medium of publication, information explosion and changing and
prompt user demands, traditional libraries are unable to satisfy the diverse needs of users.
Due to these reasons, it is a matter of urgent necessity to automate libraries in order to
cope with national and international challenges by providing them with modern services
and up to date information.
Kamath (1983:178) wrote 28 years ago that in the field of Science and Technology alone,
approximately three million documents are published each year which include articles,
conference papers, books, technical reports and theses. He added that the rate doubles
every eight to 10 years. In order to resolve the matter of space, technical processing of
these exploded information and access by users to these resources, the automation of the
university library services and resources is mandatory. However, the rate doubles every
2-3 years.
1.10.2 Barriers to library automation
The following could be the few possible barriers to library automation:
i. Fright of unfavorable effect on employment
ii. Hesitation that the implementation of emerging technologies could be very costly
iii. The library professionals require continuing training.
27
iv. Will of higher authorities about modern library technology is absent.
v. Retrospective conversion of data
Though library technologies have the capability of modernizing the library services, there
is a wide gap between what is told and what has been gained. It is calculated that that a
large per cent of library professionals in Pakistan are unaware of the proper use of
emerging library technologies. The barriers to the rapid progress of modern library trends
are many.
M. Bavakutty, et.al ( 2006: 249) states that the following are some of the barriers to the
implementation of library automation:
Insufficient funds
Inadequate ICT infrastructure
inadequate trained library professionals
Lack of initiatives on the part of the library professionals
Lack of support from higher authorities
Lack of awareness among library professionals about the potential of ICT
Lack of coordination among library professionals
Technology illiteracy of users
Lack of interest on the part of users
Lack of long-term approach towards ICT application
Poor marketing of technology - based library resources and services
28
Daunting approach of library staff towards their users
1.11 Areas of library automation
Computers are widely used in selection of material, ordering, procurement, invoice
processing, accessioning, labeling, cataloguing, issue /return, recall, fine collection,
addition/deletion/modification of membership details, serials control. However, the
computerization of library documents can be broadly classified into:
1.11.1 Acquisition procedure
The major duties of acquisitions section are to select and purchase documents for the
library. The major functions of acquisition process are as under: ordering, claiming,
receiving, preserving and paying of all library bills. It is much suited for automation due
to their repetitive clerical nature. The module of acquisition procedure, the following
basic functions of the acquisition module have been identified as under (Muhammad
Riaz, 1991: 67):
Assortment of library documents
Scrutiny of doubling
Ordering procedure
Updating official record
Confirmation of materials with bills and invoices
Accessions procedure
Maintaining record of received and non- received books
29
Accounting and management activities
The module should also manage databases like vendors, financial sources, currencies and
its corresponding local rates.
1.11.2 Technical processing of documents.
Due to the use of computers in libraries, the jobs involved in the technical processing of
documents have been minimized. A catalogue has always played a central role in the
technical processing of documents and considered as primary record of the library
holdings for the users. In the past, there were several physical forms of catalogue like
book form, card form and different cataloguing rules. The application of computers to
libraries has changed the scenario. The functions of the computerized cataloguing system
as ( Nair ,R Raman , 1992) puts it are:
Input of complete details of new documents that is bibliographical and indexing
elements;
Maintaining the database of master file of bibliographic records and index files.
Carry out functions like add, delete and modify;
Generating various lists like author, subject and other bibliographies, list of
additions and indexes
Providing for search of the databases through various access points;
Generating selected records in book form or card form;
Generating output in various catalogue formats like ISSD(M), AACR
Integrate with other subsystems like circulation, acquisition and reference
30
systems.
1.11.3 Circulation procedures
Rowley (1988) noted that in order to achieve maximum availability of material, all
libraries must control circulation, by keeping record to specify:
What documents are available in the library collection that are accessible through
other means;
Which book is issued to a user, and from whom or where can it be obtained;
When will the issued book be next available in the library for other readers.
Muhammad Riaz (1991: 68) gives the job description of circulation control amenable to
automation as:
listing of readers
provision of readers’ card
issue/ return of library documents
issuance of reminders
maintaining statistics of necessary fines for overdue books
accounting and statistics
Barcode technology is a technology used in the libraries for circulation purposes.
G K.Manjunath and Pujar, SM (2002:119) write that major objectives of barcode
technology are to improve operational efficiency, to achieve accuracy, to make stock
verification and to reduce overall cost. The Radio Frequency Identification System is
31
used for various library operations like charging and discharging of documents, stock
verification, theft detection and other library matters in an effective manner. The major
drawback is cost required for the implementation of RFID system.
1.11.4 Serials control
Serials include a wide variety of periodical material including newspapers, magazines
and journals. As these items arrive periodically, they can be difficult to maintain. The
automated systems allows the holdings, or issues the library has received, to be updated
as issues arrive and checked against the dates on which items were expected to arrive to
ensure a complete collection. Serials module is an automated library system responsible
for the procurement, processing and other operations related to serial publications. The
basic functions of serials control system are: ordering new serials, renewing of already
subscribed serials, accessioning of received serials, keeping record of the amount spent
on serials acquisition and binding process. Automated serials control system consists of
the following sub systems (Muhammad Riaz 1991: 139):
Inventory – preparation of lists of serials.
Ordering and acquisition- selection, ordering and acquisition of serials newly
subscribed.
Accessions- receiving of serials, checking-in, placing claims if not received,
renewal of subscription, updating of records, placing orders for back volumes,
preparation of data files and record maintenance.
Indexing- preparation of index of serials and other records designed to meet the
32
needs of users.
Circulation- making available serials issues in separate volumes in bound form,
keeping records of circulation, checking and arrangement for binding.
1.11.5 Stock verification
This is an inventory control system used to collect information about lost documents.
The barcode technology is used for this purpose. Latest technologies are being used for
such purposes. Radio Frequency Identification System (RFID) can sort documents
automatically and the library staff can shelve documents very easily. There are portable
readers. These portable readers can report the lost, hidden or unordered documents easily.
RFID tags have greater storage capacity and can hold large amount of information about
a document.
1.12 Automated services to users
User services refer to what a library does to make possible the retrieval of information
and access to information for the clientele. M.Bavakutty ( 2006:19) describes that there
are various kinds of user services which can be provided to library readers through an
automated library system such as current awareness services, selective dissemination of
information, reference services, circulation of accessions lists, content page service,
online database services, online bibliographic services, online full text e-Journals, CD
ROM and DVD- based services including multimedia, internet services and computer
aided user- education program.
1.12.1 Current Awareness Services (CAS)
Current awareness services offers to provide up to date information feeds tailored to the
33
specific subject needs of the requester. A computerized CAS system reviews the
information source immediately upon its receipt. The automated system can provide
such services in an easy manner by patron matching techniques. This can be routed
through the email id of the user by matching the subject contents and users’ subject areas.
1.12.2 Selective Dissemination of Information (SDI)
SDI refers to tool and resource used to keep a user informed of new resources on
specified topics. Just like CAS, it also routes the required information to the user
depending upon the broad subject area. To keep SDI services functioning, it is necessary
to develop and store the user profile in the system and clearly indicate the subject area of
the user.
1.12.3 Reference services
The major function of the reference service is to help library users in obtaining access to
required information. Automated reference services are requested and provided over a
network or the internet, usually via e-mail, chat, web-based submission forms, and are
also answered by the librarian in the reference section of the library. Synonyms used for
this service are e-reference, online reference, digital reference, paperless reference or
virtual reference.
1.12.4 Content page service
This type of service is provided to the readers to make them aware of the contents of the
latest journals. It saves time and energy of the users by providing the table of contents of
the latest documents rather than searching the whole journal. The contents of an issue can
be scanned/digitized in PDF or other format and then routed to the concerned user. If the
reader needs one of the articles, then he/she can consult the source journal and get the
34
article.
1.12.5 Internet services
The network of networks is called internet. Internet contains information on a variety of
subjects, in different languages and in various forms. In Pakistan, the university libraries
are providing internet services to their readers for the last one decade free of cost. The
Higher Education Commission (HEC) has played a vital role in this connection. In order
to provide latest information resources to the students, faculty members and researchers,
the HEC has developed HEC Digital Library.
1.13 Impact of emerging technologies on university libraries
Today’s world is a world of emerging technologies, because it has affected all spheres of
our lives. Digital technology has revolutionized our office work, transactions in banks,
industries, education, simulation for training, business, health care, law, police, airline
system and homes. As library is also an integral part of our community, it is equally
affected by this technological revolution.
Choo Ming Ding (1996:79-87) states that the impact of technology on all levels of library
operations cannot be underestimated. In the age of 21st century, Library and Information
Science professionals must be aware of emerging technologies. The librarians need to
develop technology based skills to cope with the modern challenges. Pervez Ahmad &
M. Yaseen (2009:3) highlights the positive effects of automation which are as follows:
a raise in expertise level
probably higher job satisfaction
an increase in the multiplicity of everyday jobs
better elasticity
T.A.V. Murthy and V.S.Cholin (2004) express that libraries today are faced with
planning for automation within a rapidly changing and uncertain technological
35
environment. For academic libraries, the past was rocky, the present is uncomfortable,
and the future is uncertain. It is often thought to be folly to project the impact of
technology more than five years because technological change and organizational
dynamics are so volatile. In 1930's it was possible to predict the future for the next 50
years; but today we are reluctant to look at the next 15 years. When automation was first
introduced in libraries, the main purpose was to decrease staff costs and to enhance the
effectiveness of inner operations. As it became clear that automation would have minimal
effect on staff costs and increase the efficiency of internal operations. Automation was
yielding benefits and the resulting improved services, both to staff and patrons; as it can
be seen for example, it is possible to search an online catalogue in many ways that would
never be possible in a manual catalogue.
1.13.1 Impact of digital technology on library services
As discussed earlier that the university libraries usually offer circulation, user education,
reference, CAS, SDI, internet, OPAC, web services and bulletin board services to their
users, all these library services are nowadays modernized as per demand of the users and
changing scenario. It is a fact that the emergence of latest trends has changed the nature
of library services. We can access the resources of other online libraries with a single
click and can get our required information. It is the duty of the library staff to educate the
readers about the modern library culture and trends.
Shivram Verma (2005), in his book “Academic library system” discusses the emerging
technologies that have had a marvelous effect on university information resource centers
over the past two decades and hardly any one will differ that this effect has been positive.
Hans- Christoph Hobohm (1996:303-307) is of the view that library has not to alter for
the sake of changing. It is the responsibility of the librarian to know the taste of the
readers and provide such an environment that automatically attracts the readers, because
the ultimate aim of a university library is to serve and satisfy the information needs of
their reader community. It has to adapt to the user behavior which has changed as a result
36
of new technological possibilities. That is why, it is necessary to reassess some
fundamental concepts of librarianship like:
The position of library professionals in the international publication
market
The tools for information management
The media
Krishan Gopal (2003) describes that digital technology has enhanced the ability of
libraries to serve their communities, lower their costs, and full participation in the new
networked world. It also enables the readers to understand the process of electronic
transmission of information, the impact of the internet on information resource centers ,
the shifting of household tasks of librarians and library managers, the new standards of
evaluating information, and characteristics and functions of today’s library personnel.
Roswitha Poll (2005) opines that, in the present era of digital technology, university
libraries have offered many modern services by transforming the traditional services into
automated library services. These services have opened new ways of information
handling, accessing and processing. These services comprise of specialized e- delivery
services, online learning tools, e-reference, digitized library stock, electronic publishing
and introduction of some new and latest information portals. These services have helped
the researcher, faculty member and student in getting their required information. These
services require adequate funding and also systematic planning to utilize these fundings.
It is reported that these new services have a very positive impact on the demands of
users’ community.
1.13.2 Impact of digital technology on library resources
Digital technology has gained a reasonable pace in the last couple of decades and has
acquired a central place in almost all walks of life. It has a greater impact on education
especially on universities and libraries. In the past, computers were used for clerical jobs
and handling house keeping routines like technical processing of documents, acquisitions
control, circulation control, serials’ control, stock verification and management purposes.
37
The libraries have adopted the emerging technologies due to explosion of knowledge and
non-stop information, access to unlimited literature, improvement of existing collection,
development of network environment, time and space control.
1.14 Statement of the problem
Keeping in view the above discussions, it seems very necessary to assess the impact of
modern trends on university libraries in the country.
1.14.1 Objectives of the study
The aim of the research study is to investigate the application and impact of digital
technology on university libraries in Pakistan. However, the specific objectives identified
are:
To analyze the impact of digital technology on library and information
services and resources.
To examine the impact of digital technology on library administration.
To study the present physical, human, financial and learning resources.
To explore the various barriers to automation and digitization of public
sector university libraries in Pakistan.
1.14.2 Hypotheses
Application of digital technology enhances the library efficiency and
services in an effective manner.
Networking of university libraries is essential to improving library
cooperation and resource sharing.
Implementation of digital technology is not a barrier to the smooth
functioning of the university libraries in Pakistan.
1.14.3 Need and significance of the study
The major university libraries in Pakistan started automation of their library
resources and services almost two decades ago. In this thesis, an attempt is being
made to examine whether the libraries have applied computers in all the potential
areas of university libraries. It is to be also ascertained whether the libraries have
38
provision of adequate finance, learning resources, human resources, physical
resources (hardware/software) and other necessary infrastructure for the
automation and digitization of libraries. Such a study will help to suggest
measures for improvement of university libraries in Pakistan.
1.14.4 Definitions of terms
Digital library is an organization, which might be virtual, that comprehensively
collects, manages and preserves for the long term rich digital content, and offers to
its user communities specialized functionality on that content, of measurable
quality and according to codified policies. A digital library is a type of information
retrieval system.
Digitization is a process by which a character or text, chart, picture, sound, video
is converted into digital format. Digitization changes the reading material into
digital form that is easier to store and retrieve.
Digital Technology is the study and development of devices that store and
manipulate numbers. Digital devices can translate words and pictures into numbers
for a computer to process and then translate the numbers back into pictures or
words.
Electronic library is a library requires electronic devices for their establishment,
processing, retrieval and communication of information.
Library resources include physical, financial, learning, human and Technology-
based resources.
Library services are the basic services provided to the users for the fulfillment of
their information needs.
Public Sector University Libraries are those attached to the universities working
under the umbrella of Government.
University library is a library or library system established, administered, and
funded by a university to meet the information, research, and curriculum needs of
its students, faculty, and staff.
39
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Literature review: an introduction
Bruce (1994:217-229) stated that literature reviews are included in each and every
research thesis as they provide a background and justification for the research being
conducted. According to Taylor (2005) a literature review should be organized and
directly related to the topic on which the research is being conducted. Secondly, it should
describe a brief summary of what is known as well as unknown to the readers so far.
Thirdly, it should point out the areas of controversy and certain queries that require more
investigation.
Leedy (1993:87-88) identifies the following as the reasons for reviewing literature:
“The review can suggest ways of solving problems the researcher may
meet; the review can reveal sources of data that are not known by the
researcher; and the review may help the researcher to know new ideas
and new approaches.”
This chapter includes the concept of digital technology and libraries, library automation,
digital library technology in developed world and developing world and digital library
technologies in university libraries of Pakistan. This chapter also consists of the available
literature on the current status of digital library technology, automation and digitization
infrastructure and barriers to automation and digitization in Pakistan.
2.2 Digital technology and library automation: an introduction
Digit stands for any of the numbers from 0 to 9 while digital means “having digits”.
Technology refers to, behavior of manufacturing or doing things. Technology is derived
from the Greek word ‘tekhne’, which means an art or craft, and logia, refers to an area of
study; thus technology means an area of study, or science, of crafting. Technology may
be regarded as the application of science to useful ends. Digital Technology is the branch
of science which deals with the study of devices that work on digital numbers. Electronic
devices are used to translate textual or photographic data into binary form for processing
40
and then convert this binary form of data into photographs or text. Digital technology can
also be defined as the electronic communication technology used to operate on binary
numbers of 1’s (on) and 0’s (off). This technology enables the digital devices to make
possible faster and simpler communication of various kinds of information.
Digit is a Latin word which means “finger” or “toe”. In ancient times, people used to
count things with the help of their finger tips. The digital technology has become a
gateway to information and it forms the major support to higher education. The digital
collections have become the integral part of teaching and learning processes. The first
attempt in developing digital technology was made by the American Engineers in the
mid-20th century. The mathematical concept of binary computing system of 17th century
German mathematicians provided them a base for their experiments. Information to be
stored is first digitized with the help of digital technology and in the second step it is
processed in the binary form and is converted into 0 and 1. These are called bits.
The concept of Digital Technology was introduced in 1950’s by the American scientists.
It was based on the mathematical concept given by Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz. That
system provided a base for American Standard Code for Information Interchange
(ASCII). The basic unit of information is bit. Digital technology makes it possible to
compress huge amounts of data in small storage space that can be saved, processed,
transmitted easily. Digital technology has changed the style of communication, learning
and working environment to a great extent.
Telecommunication is a form of modern technology. The invention of optical fiber has
changed and expedited the speed of communication. The analog signals were replaced
with digital signals. Cellular phones and cable system are the output of
telecommunication technologies. Wireless technologies have innovated the mode of
faster communication among different information centers. Digital publishing is also a
product of modern technologies. It has changed the way and style of book and journal
publications. The L.C National Digital Library Projects initiated to conserve, develop and
increase access to rare resources.
41
In the telecommunication process, all messages are transmitted with the help of digital
technology. In 1980s, fiber optics paved the way for digital communication network and
analog signals for many communication forms like cellular phone etc was replaced by
digital technology. Pulse Code Modulation is used to convert analog data into digital
signals. Direct Broadcast Satellite (DBS) is used to transmit compressed digital signals
for viewers to watch hundreds of programs of their choice. Digital printers have brought
a revolution in the world of publication. With the help of this technology, the Library of
Congress has preserved and made access easy to the rare items in 1973. The Electronic
Numerical Integrator and Calculator was the first electronic digital computer, but in
2000s digital computers appeared in many sizes and forms like laptop, notebook, IPODs,
digital cameras and super computers. All these machines performed different functions
like guiding air traffic, analysis of data and complex mathematical calculations and other
functions. The purpose of all technology is to make human life easier and comfortable
and also to reduce labour. Modern technology has made life richer and fascinating.
In the context of a library and its services, digital technology means the use or application
of various technologies such as computer, scanner, digital cameras, telecommunication,
micrographics and other electronic tools for the storage, recovery, copying and
propagation of information(Smitha,S.J:2007). The digital technology has become a
gateway to information and it forms the major support to higher education.
Library automation may be defined as the application of computers in the operation of
various library activities and other modern sources of information technology. It is the
application of automated machines to perform routine manual in-house library activities
such as collection management, charging and discharging of library materials, technical
processing of books and journals.
Khalid Mahmood (1995:24-25) explains that library automation started in 1950s in
America and the developed countries of the world. In Pakistan, it was introduced in
1980s. Since 1987, some libraries have been automated and some of the others are in the
process of automation.
42
Keralapura (2009: 184-185) maintains that information technology has changed the
functions of libraries on the one hand, and information seeking behavior of the readers on
the other hand. If a library is to satisfy the needs and demands of the readers, then it must
have modern information technology resources.
Chu (2009:170-176) conducted a survey. The survey report of 60 well known universities
show that where electronic services are becoming more and more popular, a large number
of libraries are applying or intend to apply for web technologies.
A university library is supposed to play a very important role in maintaining its position
as the chief information resource and service provider. A librarian at the university level
may face two-fold challenges. The first challenge is to automate his library operations as
well as to develop the capacity to deal with large quantities of information in a variety of
modern electronic format. The second challenge for a librarian in a university is to
strengthen the growth of his traditional collection and services and for automation in
order to keep pace with increased resources.
Dissanayake (1995) is of the view that automating a library is only the first and initial
step, while keeping up with new trends in the field of communication and information
technology is equally important.
T.L Chrishantha Dilroshan ( 1998: 82-98) describes that library services, resources and
the investment made by the authorities will seriously be underestimated if libraries fail to
adopt these latest technologies. Abbot Wendy and Mark Sutherland (2008: 5-7) state that
in the past few decades, libraries have undergone tremendous changes. New opportunities
for learning are being provided to the new learners via modern sources of communication
and other advanced technologies.
M.Bavakutty (2006: 6-9) explains that information explosion, shrinking budget and price
hike of documents, shift in the medium of publication and lack of adequate staff are the
major reasons that necessitate dependence on latest technologies in university libraries.
S.R.Das (2008:221-223) writes that the major technological changes that had a thorough
impact are the growth and development of bibliographical utilities and integrated
43
automated cataloguing system with the help of MARC format. The working environment
of the technical section of the library is changing gradually and will assume a new shape
in the near future in almost all academic libraries.
Theja Kuruppu Arachchi & De Silva ( 2007), in “Library automation: strategies for
library human resource management” write about library automation and human resource
management. They discuss that automation is a technological change that replaces people
with machines. Automation of library functions has revolutionized library activities. It
enables libraries to provide an effective service while saving the employee time by
transferring low-level, repetitive operations to a machine. Library automation systems
have been developed for library in-house operations including acquisition (identifying,
ordering , receiving and paying for library resources), cataloguing (arranging materials
together by subjects and providing access to them), circulation (making library resources
available to users by lending), serials control, theses and dissertations processing and
reference services such as selective dissemination of information and interlibrary loans.
While changing from traditional library services to automated library services, new
equipment and processes are introduced changing the work process or work activities in
the library. It has changed the nature and the scope of library work. Introduction of
computer library systems cause technological organizational and sociological changes.
The most important of these is sociological changes.
Over the past three decades, university libraries have seen a revolutionary impact of
emerging technologies on key library functions. The introduction of these library
technologies has diminished the central role of traditional libraries. There are several
reasons for the implementation of latest technologies in information centres and libraries.
Mohammad Haneefa K (2006:246) highlights the barriers to the application of emerging
technologies in libraries, the important among them are:
Explosive growth of information
Wastage of time in handling routine and repetitive library operations.
Advantage like speed, accuracy and reliability in the process of information
handling
44
Widespread availability of digital information.
Multi and simultaneous use of digital information.
Facility to access resources and services of a library without visiting the library.
Saving of library or information centre.
Facilities to accommodate increased work load of library professionals
Provision of an effective control over the entire library resources, services and
operations.
Improvement of the existing resources and services as well as the introduction of
new resources and services.
Facility to share the resources and services among various libraries and
information centres through library networking and library consortia.
Avoidance of duplication of resources and services.
2.3 Emerging library technologies in developed and developing countries
Library automation was started in developed world in 1950. The libraries of developed
world initiated the adoptation of emerging technologies well in time. Automation in the
USA libraries started with automated circulatory system in the same year. The
developing portion of the world was in quite different position. They still lacked these
modern library trends. The developing countries always looked forward to developed
world for technology transfer and funding opportunities to run these projects in their
countries. They started library automation in late 1980's, except for some countries in
South Asia which initiated automation in the 1970's. The rest of the developing world
was deprived of availing emerging library technologies due to late arrival of technology,
lack of expertise, professional skills and adequate funding.
Mauritius V.D Graff (2007) presented an inventory study titled “Driver inventory study”.
The main aim of the driver inventory investigation is to highlight the current state of
digital repository in 27 European countries. The study covers the areas; coverage;
contents; access forms of full-text records; work processes; software packages and
accessibility by search engine or portals. Shivram Verma (2005) in “Academic library
system" discusses the three latest technologies which have had greater positive impacts
45
on universities libraries over the past generations. The modern technology has replaced
card based catalogue with Online Public Access Catalogue, while print- based periodicals
indexes have been replaced with online periodical indexes.
Karen Coyle (2004) "Rights management and digital library requirements", intended to
provoke discussion on the requirements of the digitization like right expression; the
encoding of license terms and files protection. The article concluded that there are two
distinct and major areas where libraries can exert their impact on the right management
modern sources of communication. One is the stage where information resource centre
approached the resources of other organizations, e.g. clients of digital publishing.
Secondly, when digital libraries disseminating their digital works.
Alan Hopkinton (2010) in this connection says, library automation was introduced in the
developed nation of the world about three decades ago. The situation in developing
countries was not up to the level due to some constant constraints. The developing world
is facing a series of problems like power supply, finance, internet availability and their
speed. The introduction of open source software has solved the financial problem to some
extent in developing world like Nigeria and Thailand. It is expected that internet
bandwidth speed will improve in developing countries and library automation will get
pace. The issues of power supply and economic deficiency will still continue.
Krishen Gopal (200) describes that digital technology has enhanced the ability of libraries
to serve their communities, lower their costs, and full participation in the new networked
world. It also enables the reader to understand the process of sending information via
electronic media, the role of internet in information centers, the new role of all concerned
to information and resource centers, the new techniques of analyzing information and
capacities as well as the role of present library concerns.
Ramesh Chandra & A.P Shrivastara (2003) "Technological changes in libraries", study
recent developments in technological capabilities such as high resolution capture devices,
dramatic increase of digital storage media, explosive growth of internet and www,
46
sophisticated search engines, fast processing power and reducing cost of computer, high
bandwidth network and increasing number of electronic publications make it possible for
the establishment of digital libraries. With the appearance of latest technologies in the
form of digital resources, the role of libraries in helping to explore new vistas of learning
has enormously increased. We need such effective technology that could preserve and
transmit large amount of data in the form of images, knowledge, audio-video materials
and others in a speedy way and also to perform searches that are impractical manually. At
present the modern technology has such invention that can perform the task very quickly
and easily and at the same time without any error. The invention has revolutionized the
role of all information and resource centers. These centers are now not only preserving
the library documents and other rare data, but also play a leading role in facilitating the
users to have an easy and quick access to the library stock. The practice also has positive
impact on the processes of teaching and learning.
Aravind Tiwari (2002), “Evaluation of electronic libraries", writes that automation which
took place in 1990s is a very controversial issue in respect of various resources,
capabilities and dexterity. In recent times, the role and functions of libraries have
changed to a great extent. At present people who do not know how to use a computer and
internet will have no access to online library stock of knowledge.
K. Sambasvan (2000), Investigating library resources: problems and prospects in the
internet age", studies the technology development that has made profound and
undoubtedly permanent change in libraries. The traditional services that the users were
getting from the library so long and so forth are undertaking a vast and fast change during
these days. The clients have started making new types of demands before the professional
staff. These transitions are gradually spreading to almost all types of libraries and
information centers. All information centers are experiencing technological changes
mainly due to three phenomena. They are information explosion, spiraling of library
costs, and technology revolution.
47
Gary Cleveland (1998) explains the digital library from various angles in detail. The
article discusses various issues and challenges to digital libraries. These are technical
architectures; building digital collections; digitization; metadata; identifiers and
precipitance; copyright/right management and preservation.
K.R Mulla (2006) states that in the last two decades digital technology has made room for
itself in every field and sphere of life. Libraries are no exception in this regard. In modern
era, all the libraries store information not only in the form of books, but also in the form
of audio, video and other multimedia sources. The digital libraries of today are faster and
effective in transmitting information to the users. These libraries are network- based
distribute system. The server is responsible for maintaining local collection of digital
documents. These libraries have made knowledge easily accessible to every one.
Grace Nok (2006:6-8) commenting on the automation of libraries says that the success of
automation of a university library largely depends upon the efficiency, skill, abilities and
training of its staff. To what extent the staff is able to facilitate and implement the
process. The staff of library should be well trained if a library is to be successful in
automation services. For effective automation services, a library has to adopt new
approaches of latest trends. The major factor on which the success of library automation
depends is the availability of skilled staff. The success of library automation also depends
on the periodic and appropriate technology-based training of library professionals. It was
further added that if a library has the capability to manage and bring into practical usage
the latest inventions in the field of information technology, it will bring its success.
Veranna S.Cholin ( 2005: 189-197) states that approximately 45 libraries of different
campuses in India are passing through different stages of library automation
development. INFLIBNET, an inter University center, has taken the responsibility to
provide all the universities’ libraries with latest information technology and to upgrade
the existing ones. The said center will provide assistance of all sorts to digitize their
libraries on modern basis. With the help of these latest resources these universities will be
able to approach all the available library documents of the campus information centers.
48
Anusha Wijayaratne (2005:21-22) explains the barriers to the implementation of
automated technologies in the libraries. He says that we had all sorts of difficulties,
problems and limitations such as network problems, power fluctuations, system failures,
lack of funds, hardware/software problems, fear of retrospective conversion, lack of
manpower and fear of staff during the initial stages of implementation. The situation
gradually became calm once the staff and users became familiar with the system,
strengthened the infrastructure, identified and treated the shortcomings in the software/
hardware solutions etc. This did not mean that every thing is fine and perfect at the
library, but the situation is now under control.
Smith S.J and Chethana M. (2007:1) explain the influence of digital technology on
information users of higher education and research centers in Mysore District of India.
The study shows that the digital technology has become a gateway to information and it
forms the major support to higher education. The digital collections have become the
integral part of teaching and learning processes. The present study will try to address the
problem of users’ literacy towards digital technology, digital tools, information resources
and services in higher education institutions and research centers. It also discussed about
the digital infrastructure available in different institutions and reasons for negative
responses on the direct influence of digital sources.
James W.Marcum (2003:2) writes that keeping in view the increasing usage of emerging
library technologies, it is supposed that in a year or so, all the libraries will be dependent
on information technology for their proper operation and effective functions. The
libraries will be using all sorts of technologies like audio, video and other multimedia
resources.
Charlene L. Al-Qalaf (2006:168-179) highlights the following points as most important
for successful implementation of library technologies:
The recruitment of competent and expert human resource;
49
Provision of technology-based training to library professionals and para-
professionals;
Hiring of resource persons/expertise for training from local experts and abroad
Speedy technical support;
Availability of better working environment for technical staff;
Regular up-gradation of hardware and software;
Implementation of attractive salary packages being the basic tools that can be
used to improve the current slack and slow position of library automation.
According to a survey report which was published by D. Rosenberg (1997) on several
African libraries which underlines that with the provision of Unesco Micro CDS/ISIS or
commercial library software, the emergence of internet and other latest sources of
information, the libraries have come across a best chance to enhance value added services
to their parent institutions. These modern libraries are now providing an easy access to
the locally conducted researches, indexing and abstracting services to fulfill the
information needs of their learning communities.
Neelakandan.B (2010: 149-176) delineates the following as the major problems faced in
implementation of automated library management system in the School of Chemistry
Library.
I. Lack of Infrastructure facility
II. Lack of environment support
III. Lack of financial resources.
M.Shariful Islam of Bangladesh (2007) explains that emerging technologies are
influencing the basic functions of information resource centers in different aspects. The
different aspects include a growing demand of library documents, information explosion,
modern libraries trends, and the exploration of latest and affordable computers. These
trends in turn have greatly increased the number of library users. The urban libraries are
surpassing the rural libraries in this race of technology. Keeping in view the modern age
50
and development, the government must struggle seriously to equip all the libraries with
latest technology according to the demands of the library persons and subscribers.
Chinwe V.Anunobi ( 2008) while commenting says that with the appearance of modern,
fast, cheap and effective technology, the role, function and responsibilities of every
library has undergone a revolution. The manual system has been replaced by current
technology. The technology is now making ways in the developing countries as well. All
the university libraries need to adopt the same if they want to bring a change and increase
the number of users. The step should be taken after giving due consideration to
expandability, tractability and compatibility.
Chinwe V.Anunobi (2010) approves that information centers at universities should take
major steps in modernizing their serials’ unit. The university libraries should seek
financial assistance from donor agencies in order to manage to purchase necessary
hardware and software for the serials’ functions.
Aina (2004) believes that the services which the libraries used to provide in the past to
the users have absolutely changed as a result of modern invention and discoveries in the
field of communication technology. The libraries are now taking full advantage of these
inventions and bringing them into practical usage for the services of their subscribers.
ICT has played a leading role in this connection. ICT is now used in the storage,
analyzing and communication of information. This trend has facilitated the users and
library personnel to a great extent. Not only this, it has also made the function of a library
faster and more effective as compared with the past. At present each and every member
of library staff must have sufficient knowledge about the practical usage of this
technology, that is if a library is to be successful in providing the best services to its
users. The technology that is being used in a modern library must form a part of library
science curriculum.
A.M.Adegbore (2010) recommends that designing secure and reasonable library
automation project, adequate funding, arranging unconventional power supply, periodic
51
working training for staff, sharing of ideas between universities and effective user
education program are the key to extend library automation culture in Africa.
O.O.Onilude and O.R.Apampa (2010) discuss that major barriers to the implementation
of latest library technologies include irregular electricity failure , expensive local Internet
Service Providers (ISPs), poor regulatory, licensing, and taxation regime, inadequate
grants sustainability, poor organizational structure, and user frustration with low
bandwidth.
Amer I.Kindilchie and Iman F.Sammarai (2008: 281-293) describe that information
resource centre or Qatar University Library provides all users with free access to e-
resources. Although the university library has subscribed to 30 databases of electronic
resources, but it is reported that these e-resources did not meet the information needs of
user community. It is suggested that there is a dire need of more online resources for the
researchers, faculty members, students and other users. Johnson (1991: 22-30) analyzes
that main cause for collapse of library automation plan in developing countries is that the
human resources or library professionals plan without adequate awareness about the
procurement of hardware, software, and power supply equipment
Kumar Parveen, Mamta Mestri and S Pararmeshwar (2006:150-158) describe that
growing population, poverty, illiteracy, less importance to modern facilities, energy crisis
are the root causes of slow progress of emerging library technologies in the developing
world.
Rohit Kelapure (2003) writes that there are two types of digital library services. These
services include infrastructure services and information satisfaction services. Searching,
indexing, linking, browsing, collecting and rating are the examples of infrastructure
services whereas filtering, question answering, feed back search and multi-classification
search are termed as information satisfaction services.
Partha Bhattacharya (2003) is of the view that virtual library tours, library websites,
library portals, web-based user education, Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ), library
calendar, web forms, bulletin boards and discussion forums are the major services of
52
digital libraries. The writer highlights that copyright and intellectual right issues, access
control, bandwidth constraints, interoperability and preservation problems are the
challenges for digital information services.
Wijnhoven, Fons and Jeroen Kraaijenbrink,(2008) states that electronic publishing, e-
communities and technical report writing are the basic digital information services. The
paper also explains the design problems and requirements of digital information services.
2.4 Emerging library technologies in Pakistan The Government of Pakistan invited Mr.L.C.Key in early 1950s to build up a plan for
Liaquat Library Karachi. At that time this library was established as the National Library
of Pakistan. This was the first effort made by the Government for the promotion and
development of library culture in Pakistan (Mushahid Hussain: 1994)..(a) The Pakistan
Library Association also played a prominent role in this direction and collaborated with
the Netherlands Library Development Project (NLDP), (b) the Asia Foundation and
USAID collaboration with PASTIC (Pakistan Scientific and Technological Information
Centre) and (c) UNESCO CDS/ISIS are the first three and major library automation
projects launched in Pakistan. These projects ended with the stoppage of foreign funding.
Farzana Shafique and Khalid Mehmood (2008: 6-13) suggested that: before software
selection for their libraries, the librarians should visit different automated libraries to get
technical knowledge about their installation, implementation, operation and maintenance.
The Departments of Library and Information Science in the country, the Library
Associations and automation groups should arrange training on various library softwares.
The librarians may be informed about open source software and their technical issues.
Conferences and Workshops be arranged to discuss the merits and demerits of different
library softwares in use in various libraries of the country. Special attention be given to
the comments and views of the working librarians.
Shehnaz Zubere ( 2007) discusses that for successful management of electronic flood of
information, librarians need to collect, process, save, protect and provide access to users.
In this connection, the librarians need to do more hard work for budget allocation to build
53
up digital libraries. The main hindrances in the way of digitization are continuous varying
technology, technical and legal limitations in copying and long term preservation for
future use. These barriers are difficult to be resolved by a single entity. To cope with
these challenges, joint efforts are required by information professionals, librarians,
publishers and management to find ways and means to solve these issues. It is the
responsibility of the eight Departments of Library and Information Science in the country
to carry out digital library research and education to equip the new generation with
modern library tools and tactics.
Syed Jalal-ud-din Haider ( 2007:173-176), “Library scenario & management problems in
Pakistani libraries” throws light on the barriers to the effective implementation of latest
technologies in the libraries of Pakistan, there is no organized planning for library
automation, selection of appropriate hardware and software, financial constraints,
absence of standards, ambiguity and most important lack of consent of library
professionals and lack of competent manpower. In order to resolve the situation, the
author stresses that special attention need to be given to the designing of information
policy; motivating professionals and higher authorities for the usage of modern
technologies in library operations; training and advancement of staff; arrangement of
information literacy programs for readers; and emphasis on comprehensive planning by
the library to computerize the library activities.
Rahman Shafiq & Pervaz Ahmad (2007) spell out the various challenges and
opportunities which include those of finance; collection development; information and
communication technologies (ICTs); library education; human resources; assessment and
evaluation; role of library associations; library cooperation; planning; promotion of
library services research and development. It is concluded that there is a dire need of
genuine hard work, absolute devotion and firm determination from the profession to
serve the cause of librarianship and promote library associations.
Muhammad Ajmal Khan and Khalid Mehmood (2010) write that the Pakistan Library
Automation Group (PakLAG) was formed in the year 2000 as a non- profitable Trust.
54
The main aim of this Trust is to motivate the young library professionals regarding the
latest and modern library tends. The group started its activities in Lahore. These activities
were soon extended to all over the country. A good number of young and senior
professionals joined the group. They are working hard for the promotion and use of ICTs
in libraries. During the decade (2000-2010), Pakistan Library Automation Group ( Pak
LAG) organized its units in other provinces. The Group charges no fees from their
members. The Group offers advice to information centers, libraries and documentation
centers on their automated projects. They arrange training programs to update the
librarians regarding the modern library technologies. These trainings provide
opportunities to librarians to automate their libraries and documentation centers. The
Trust promotes research in librarianship. The automation group has also developed a link
with local as well as international agencies. Recommendations are forwarded by the
Group to government and legislative bodies regarding the modernization of libraries.
Amjad Ali (2005), in his book “Digital libraries in the making” discusses multiple types
of information media references. This book also highlights the contribution of various
agencies at national and international levels in digitization and automation of libraries. It
also provides information about information networks and digital information.
Munawar Sultana Raziuddin (2004) explains that a digital library must contain e-
resources related to all disciplines of human activities. The article discusses the historical
background of digital library. It also explains the resources; digital objects; maintenance
of digital library and problems in digital library development.
Shaheen (2008: 142-147) presented a survey report of 420 students of public sector
universities of Islamabad and Rawalpindi. In this survey usage of internet was discussed
and frequent use of Face book, You Tube, Classmates, MSN, My Space provide an
opportunity to the students and general users to interact with each other freely. This
practice has promoted the political awareness and freedom of speech among the masses.
Muhammad Arif & Khalid Mehmood (2010:10) discuss that computer illiteracy; poor
technological infrastructure and internet connectivity are the main barriers to the
55
implementation of web 2.0 technologies in information centers and libraries. They
suggest that regular trainings on web 2.0 technologies will enhance the professional
capabilities of the librarians.
Farasat Shafi-Ullah and Stephen A. Roberts (2009) write that developing countries are far
behind in emerging library technologies. The developing countries like Pakistan have
realized the importance of modern library trends. Program for the Enhancement of
Research Information (PERI) and International Network for the Availability of Scientific
Publications (INASP) type programs have motivated the higher ups in the government for
automation of libraries. They also point out that poor funding, lack of bureaucracy
interest in libraries and slow speed of library automation projects are the major
hindrances in the way of adoptation of latest technologies.
Malik Khalid Mahmmod and Muhammad Ajmal Khan ( 2007: 418-427) conducted a
study on the ICT trainings for library professionals in Pakistan. The authors addressed
some key questions regarding the issue: What is the computer literacy level of library
professionals in Pakistan? What do the library professionals expect from the technology-
based library trainings? What do they require to gain from these trainings?
Muhammad Ramzan and Singh Diljit (2009 :573-587) focus on more computer terminals
in the libraries, availability of e-mail services, internet provision, integrated library
management software, computerized services to the reader communities, appropriate
budget allocation for electronic resources. The study explores poor IT infrastructure and
low bandwidth internet speed. It is suggested by them that standard integrated library
software is necessary. However, the role of HEC Digital Library was appreciated by
them.
Bushra Almas Jaswal (2005: 87-104) writes that the emergence of digital technology has
broken the time and four walls’ restrictions for the users of the academic libraries. The
librarians are expected to cope with modern challenges with their skill and expertise. In
the present era of information explosion, it is impossible for a single library to manage
56
the flood of information. Resource sharing is the tool with which we can control this
problem.
Kanwal Ameen (2008) says that the pace of adaptation of modern library trends is very
slow. Library professionals need to acquire such a potential that they may be able to
develop Web OPACS. The emergences of PAKLAG, Library Cooperation (LIBCOOP)
and other professional groups in Pakistan have provided the platform to the professionals
to share their skills and knowledge with local professionals and also with international
library expertise.
Pakistan Libraries Project (PLP) was started by Relief International in collaboration with
the Ministry of Education and local educational organizations in 2008. Under this
program, four libraries or information resource centers in schools had been established.
The main aim of this program is to promote the use of modern technologies in school
libraries. The project also included a training program for teachers and students to
enhance their IT skills.
Noor Shed Khan (2005: 532-540) is of the view that we are still providing traditional
library services to the user community. The use of ICT is still at the stage of infancy in
our libraries. The users are keenly interested in modern library services. The major
factors are the provision of proper funding for equipment, training and creating
awareness among the users.
Muneera Nasreen Ansari and Bushra Adeeb Zuberi (2010) say that electronic resources
are the best means to get up- to- date information. The problem in network and lack of
training are the main barriers to the proper utilization of these resources. These problems
can be solved by providing IT expert staff with continuing training facilities.
Rubina Bhatti (2010) highlights that academic resources offered online in various
faculties are inadequate as compared with the science faculty. Lack of formal training on
how to access e-resources, lack of computers, slow speed, time limitation and lack of far-
off access are the main problems to the effective use of internet.
57
Syed Attaullah Shah, Shah Masood and Azra Quraishi (2005) write that there are three
major digital library services in Aga Khan University Library in Karachi. These are: CD
library, non-book material and Selective Dissemination of Information (SDI) services.
2.5 Conclusion
Literature reviewed shows that the applications of digital technology have
affected all spheres of libraries. The emergence of modern library trends has a
positive impact on university library services and resources in the developed and
developing countries. It has also modernized the university libraries in Pakistan.
The literature reviewed also highlights some of the barriers to the adaptation of
modern library technologies in the world. The literature also contains solutions to
these barriers.
58
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The purpose of this study is to take a survey of the technology-based services and
resources of the public sector university libraries in Pakistan. This work will help in
obtaining a clear picture of the level of application of emerging technologies and its
impact on university libraries. This chapter covers the research design, sources of data,
method of analysis of data and its interpretation.
The importance of a university library in the academic setup as the basic source of
information to satisfy the information needs of the academics is well established. It is
evident that the traditional methods of management of university libraries will not be able
to deal with the onslaught of ‘information explosion’. Uses of emerging technologies in
university libraries prove to be a better solution to this. Digital technology capabilities
such as tremendous speed, huge capacity to store ocean of information on a tiny storage
media like CDs and DVDs, enormous capabilities to repetitive jobs in libraries without
exhaustion, the radical power to sort, arrange, retrieve and disseminate information, its
capacity to collect information from anywhere in the world-wide networks has made the
digital technology indispensable in the university libraries.
3.1 Research design
To arrive at a concrete conclusion and to meet the specific objectives of the present
research study, different research methodologies (questionnaires, interviews and
observation) have been employed. The study is also supported by comprehensive
literature review and web analysis.
The total population of the present investigation was the libraries and information
resource centers of the public sector universities of the country. The detailed information
about the mailing addresses, contact numbers, web addresses and nature of these
universities and university libraries have been accessed from the website of Higher
59
Education Commission in Islamabad. There are a total 132 Universities / Degree
Awarding Institutions (DAIs) in Pakistan. Out of these, 73 are public sector universities
while the rest are working in private sector. As the universe of the investigation was not
too large, therefore no sampling was made and questionnaires were distributed to all
librarians of the 73 public sector universities. At the same time, separate questionnaires
were designed and distributed among the users of the university libraries. The response
rate was good. The province wise feedback of the questionnaires is recorded in Table 4.1
and Table 4.43
The data collected through present survey was complemented by interviews, observation
and visits to the university libraries and web analyses. Basic statistical tools and simple
percentage analyses have been used for the processing of data. Statistical Package for
Social Sciences Software (SPSS) and Excel have been used, which will be explained later
on.
3.2 Sources of data
The methodology is based on primary and secondary data; both these tools have helped to
understand the cause and solution of the problem in drawing conclusions.
1. Primary data has been collected by means of questionnaires, personal
meetings and discussions with library professionals and from interviews of
library clientele, researchers, faculty of the university who visit the library.
2. Secondary data has been collected from the different published sources i.e
Reports and publications of various associations connected with library
and information science profession.
Conference proceedings and other such documents of various social
sciences and cultural bodies.
Books
Periodicals/Library Journals and Newspapers.
60
Documents published by International Organizations.
Internet and browsing of various problem- oriented web pages.
Libraries of reputed institutions.
HEC Digital Library.
3.3 Data collection methods
3.3.1 Questionnaire survey
Two different questionnaires with different designs, pattern and questions were
developed and used in the study namely: Questionnaire for Chief Librarians and
Questionnaire for readers. The questionnaires for librarians and readers were prepared
through a pilot study carried out by the researcher in 13 university libraries of Khyber
Pakhtunkhwa. Khyber Pakhtunkhwa was selected for the simple reason that this is the
researcher’s resident province. The main goal of piloting was to enhance the validity of
the questionnaire.
The questionnaire distributed to the librarians aimed to get data about general information
of the university libraries, current services provided by the libraries, existing resources,
emerging technology infrastructure, modern information literacy (user education)
programs, university library networking, barriers to the implementation of emerging
library technologies, attitude of library managers towards modern library trends in
university libraries and comparative analyses of hard and soft learning resources. A cover
letter was attached to the questionnaire highlighting the significance of the research topic.
The questionnaire administered to users was to obtain information about the status of
library users, purpose and frequency of library visits by the users, use of library and
information services/tools, rating of the quantity and quality of the traditional learning
resources in university libraries, opinion about skills and expertise to use technology
based services and resources, actual use of emerging technologies(if offered), views
about the need for a workshop/orientation program in technology based services and
61
resources, purpose of using internet in the library and opinions about significant change
in speed of academic/ research work by using digital library technologies. Efforts had
been made to know the extent of their satisfaction with this technology based services
and resources.
3.3.2 Personal visit and observation of the libraries
Observation technique of data collection is more effective for testing and checking of
data obtained through the questionnaire. For the present study, visits were made from
time to time to the libraries of different major universities to observe and collect
information about the existing library facilities, resources and functions, to ascertain the
technology based skill and expertise of the library professionals and users and to assess
the degree of utilization of these facilities.
3.4 Data analysis techniques
The data collected from different resources were analyzed and inferences were made
using standard statistical methods. The analyses of the questionnaire, interview schedules
and observation data provided the researcher an in-depth interpretation of research
objectives. The objectives and hypotheses of the present study required the application of
the following major statistical techniques:
3.4.1 Percentage analysis
Simple percentage analysis had been undertaken to study the available services and
resources and the implementation of digital technology in public sector university
libraries of Pakistan.
3.4.2 Basic statistical tools (Mean, SD, CV)
The mean (X), standard deviation (SD) and co-efficient of variation (CV) are the simplest
statistical tools widely used to measure the concentration and dispersion of respondents’
opinion. The average X had been calculated. This step has been followed by SD and CV.
The processed data had been recorded and presented in table forms. These basic
statistical tools have been calculated to examine the concentration and dispersion of
62
librarians’ and users’ opinion. The minimum value of Standard Deviation and Co-
efficient of Variation exhibits the consistency of respondents’ opinion, while the highest
value of these basic statistical techniques indicate the variability of librarians’
/users’opinion.
3.4.3 Chi-square test
This test is one of the simple and most widely used statistical tools in statistical analysis.
Chi –square is a measure of actual divergence of the observed and expected frequencies
(or values). If the actual and observed frequencies are the same, then the value of the chi-
square is zero. The greater the discrepancy between observed and expected frequencies,
the greater is the value of c2. If the table value is greater than the calculated value of chi-
square, it indicates that the difference between actual and observed frequencies may have
risen due to chance of fluctuation and can be ignored. The quantity Chi-Square is defined
as:
Chi-square= ∑(O-E)(O-E)/E
1- Calculate the expected frequencies
2- Take the difference between observed and expected frequencies and obtain the
square of these differences i.e. obtain the value of (O-E)2
3- Divide the quantity (O-E)2 obtained in step(ii) by the expected frequency and
obtain the overall sum .
This gives the value of chi square and is compared with the table value of chi square for
given degree of freedom at a certain specified level of significance. If the table value of
chi square is less than the calculated value of chi-square, the difference between theory
and observation is considered to be significant. If, on the other hand, table value is more
than the calculated value of chi-square, the difference between theory and observation is
not considered as significant.
63
CHAPTER FOUR
ANALYSIS OF DATA AND INTERPRETATION
The data collected from university library websites and central libraries of public sector
universities have been evaluated and interpreted. Data were collected using questionnaire
and interview techniques from the university libraries and from select sample of users of
the universities in the country. The analyses of the data and interpretation are presented in
two major sections with subsections as under:
1. Librarians’ response towards the implementation and impact of digital technology
on public sector university libraries
2. Users' response towards the implementation and impact of digital technologies on
university libraries.
4.1 Librarians' response towards the application and impact of digital
technology on university libraries
The role of university librarians has changed to some extent with the emergence of
modern library technologies. These latest library technologies have enhanced the
users’ approach towards the accessibility of information. As a result, university
librarians are engaged in serving the users on modern library lines.
In order to explore the impact of digital technology on the central libraries of the
public sector universities in the country, it was felt necessary to collect data from the
Librarians about the existing manual as well as automated library services and
resources. The interpretation of the collected data has helped the researcher to make
recommendations for solving the problem in the final chapter.
4.1.1 Available services, resources and digital technology infrastructure in
university libraries
This section contains data about general information regarding university libraries,
number of library users visiting the libraries and digital library sections of university
libraries, available services, traditional and technology-based resources. Following are
64
the details of the statistical analysis and interpretation of the data collected from the
librarians through the structured questionnaires, interviews, visits to the libraries and
web analysis. Keeping in view the objectives of the study, the analysis of the
consolidated data has been accomplished using Excel and Statistical Package for
Social Sciences (SPSS).
4.1.1.1 Broad-spectrum information
This section contains the general information about the number of libraries
participated in the survey, establishment of PSU libraries, inception and current
position of modern library technologies in university libraries, status of library users
and their visits to the libraries and digital library sections of the relevant university
libraries.
Response rate of participated universities in the survey
In Pakistan there are a total of 73 public sector universities as of 2010. The
questionnaire framed for university librarians were distributed to the central libraries
of the public sector universities in the country. The responses have been received
from 61 public sector universities i.e. 84 % of the universities.
Table 4.1 - Response rate of participated universities
Geographical Zone Total PSUL Responded PSUL Not responded Response rate
Islamabad 13 11 02 84%
Punjab 22 18 06 82%
Sindh 14 12 02 85%
Khyber Pakhtun Khwa 15 13 02 87%
Balochistan 06 05 01 84%
AJK & NA 03 02 01 66%
Total 73 61 12 84%
Those university librarians who have not responded are due to their busy schedule and some
could not respond because the political conditions were sensitive.
65
Establishment of PSU libraries
The following table shows the details of the establishment of Public Sector Universities.
Table 4.2 shows that 27(44%) out of 61 responded Public Sector Universities (PSU) of the
country have been established after year 2000. This Table also shows that there were only
two universities for the whole population of the country in 1947. These universities were the
University of the Punjab and the University of Sindh.
Table 4.2- Establishment of Public Sector Universities (PSU) -
___________________________________________________________________________________
Date of Estt: of PSU Islamabad Punjab Sindh Balochistan KPK AJK&NA Total
Before Independence 00 01 01 00 00 00 02
1947-1959 01 01 02 00 01 00 05
1960-1969 01 03 01 00 00 00 05
1970-1979 01 03 04 01 01 00 10
1980-1989 01 00 01 01 02 01 06
1990-1999 01 03 02 00 00 00 06
2000- to 2010 06 07 01 03 09 01 27
Total 11 18 12 05 13 02 61
Commencement of library automation in the PSU libraries
The data regarding inception of library automation in these university libraries has been
categorized into two groups: commencement of library automation before year 2000 and after
year 2000. Table 4.3 gives the information regarding library automation commencement in
the university libraries.
Table 4.3-Commencement of library automation in PSU libraries
Date of Commence of Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Library Automation
Before Year 2000 04(36%) 02(12%) 01(13%) 02(18%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 09
After Year 2000 07(64%) 15(88%) 07(87%) 07(45%) 02(40%) 01(50%) 39
Total 11 17 08 09 02 01 48
Note: The remaining 13 out of 61 universities are not mentioned here because they have not
automated their university libraries
66
It is clear from Table 4.3 that 39(81%) out of 48 university libraries were computerized or
have started automation after year 2000. Only 09(19%) university libraries were automated
before year 2000.
When the librarians were asked to provide information about the current status of automation
of public sector university libraries in Pakistan, the respondents gave their opinion in the
following manner. Table 4.4 contains the data which reflects the situation of automation of
university libraries of Pakistan.
Table 4.4 -Status of library automation in PSU libraries under study
Status of library Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Automation
Fully automated 10(91%) 10((56%) 06(50%) 02(15%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 28
Partially automated 01(9%) 07(39%) 02(17%) 07(54%) 02(40%) 01(50%) 20
Not automated 00(00%) 01(5%) 04(33%) 04(31%) 03(60%) 01(50%) 13
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Table 4.4 reveals that 28 (46%) out of 61 are fully automated, 20 (33%) have partial
automation and 13 (21%) have not yet started automation.
Province-wise automation
Table 4.4 shows that 10(91 %) out of 11 of the university libraries of Islamabad,
10(56%) out of 18 in Punjab,
06(50%) out of 12 in Sindh and
02(15%) out of 13 in Khyber Pakhtun Khwa (KPK) .
Province-wise partial automation
01(9%) in Islamabad,
07(39%) out of 18 in Punjab,
02(17%) out of 12 in Sindh
The analysis of the data reflects that 07(54%) out of 13 university libraries in KPK,
67
02(40%) out of 05 in Balochistan and
01(50%) out of 02 in AJK and Northern Areas.
Province-wise non-automated libraries
According to Table 4.4,
01(5%) out of 18 in Punjab,
04(33%) out of 12 in Sindh,
04(31%) out of 13 in KPK,
03(60%) out of 05 university libraries in Balochistan and
01(50%) out of 02 in AJK and NA are not automated
Not a single university library in Balochistan has been reported as fully automated library
while Islamabad university libraries are all automated.
No. of users who visit university libraries on a daily basis
This section contains information about the average daily visits of the users to the public
sector university libraries. Table 4.5 contains the details of the users' visits to the university
libraries.
Table 4.5 –Users’ visits to libraries per day
No. of Library users' Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Visit
Users visit <=200 02(18%) 07(39%) 06(50%) 04(31%) 03(60%) 00(00%) 22
Users visit between 04(36%) 07(39%) 01(08%) 04(31%) 01(20%) 01(50%) 18
200 and 500
Users visit >500 05(46%) 04(22%) 05(42%) 05(38%) 01(20%) 01(50%) 21
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Province-wise users’ visit per day (>500)
It is evident from Table 4.5 that 05(45%) out of 11 of the university libraries of Islamabad,
04(22%) out of 18 in Punjab,
05(42%) out of 12 in Sindh,
05(39%) out of 13 in KPK,
68
01(20%) out of 5 in Blaochistan and
01(50%) out of 02 in AJK and NA have more than 500 users’ visit per day.
Province-wise users’ visit per day (between 200 and 500)
04(36%) out of 11 in Islamabad,
07(39%) out of 18 in Punjab,
01(8%) out of 12 in Sindh,
04(31%) in KPK,
01(20%) out of 5 in Balochistan and
01(50%) out of 2 in AJK and NA have users’ visit between 200 and 500.
Province-wise users’ visit per day (<200)
02(18%) out of 11 university libraries in Islamabad
07(39%) out of 18 in Punjab,
Half 06(12) of the university libraries of Sindh,
04(31%) out of 13 in KPK,
03(60%) out of 05 of the university libraries in Balochistan have less than or equal to 200
users’ visit per day.
Table 4.5 shows that 22(36%) out of 61 university libraries recorded, average daily users’
visit less than or equal to 200,
18 (30%) university libraries recorded average daily users’ visit between 200 and 500 and
21(34%) claimed average daily users’ visits greater than 500.
No. of users who visit digital library sections of university libraries
The library which contains digital materials and services can be accessed both online and
offline through electronic media. Table 4.6 shows information about the users' visits to the
digital library section of the university libraries.
69
Table 4.6- No. of users visiting digital library sections of the PSU universities on a daily
basis
No. of Library users’ Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Visit
Users visited <=100 05(45%) 09(50%) 06(50%) 08(72%) 05(100%) 00(00%) 33
Users visited between 05(45%) 03(17%) 03(25%) 03(27%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 15
100 and 200
Users visited >200 01(9%) 06(33%) 03(25%) 02(15%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 13
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Province-wise visit to digital section on a daily basis (les than or equal to 100 users)
Table 4.6 shows that 05(45%) out of 11 in Islamabad,
09(50%) out of 18 in Punjab,
06(50%) out of 12 university libraries of Sindh,
08(72%) out of 13 university libraries of KPK and
05(100%) out of 5 university libraries of Balochistan reported less than or equal to 100 users’
visit the digital section of the concerned libraries.
Province-wise visit to digital section on a daily basis (between 100 and 200 users)
05(45%) out of 11 university libraries in Islamabad,
03(17%) out of 18 in Punjab,
03(25%) out of 12 in Sindh,
03(27%) out of 13 in KPK and
01(50%) university libraries of AJK and NA users visit the digital section as between 100 and
200.
Province-wise visit to digital section on a daily basis (greater than 200 users)
01(9%) out of 11 university libraries in Islamabad,
06(33%) out of 18 in Punjab,
03(25%) out of 12 in Sindh,
02(15%) out of 13 in KPK and
01(50%) of the university libraries of AJK and NA recorded the average daily users’ visit to
70
the digital section is more than 200.
Table 4.6 reveals that 33 (54%) out of 61 university libraries recorded daily users’ visit as
less than or equal to 100,
15(25%) of the university libraries claimed daily users’ visit to digital library section as
between 100 and 200 and
13(21%) university libraries reported about the daily users’ visits to digital section is above
200.
4.1.1.2 Available services provided by the PSU libraries
This sub-section contains data related to general and technical services provided, user
education, internet provision to the users, availability of library webpage.
General services provided by the public sector university libraries in Pakistan
The general or basic library services include circulation, new arrivals’ lists, inter library loan,
reference services, current awareness services, photocopying facilities, fax and newspaper
clipping services. The following Table 4.7 provides information about the availability of
basic library services.
Table 4.7-General services provided by PSU Libraries under study
Services provided Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Circulation services 11(100%) 18(100%) 12(100%) 13(100%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 61
New Arrival List 11(100%) 17(94%) 09(75%) 09(81%) 05(100%) 01(50%) 52
Inter Library Loan 08(72%) 11(61%) 01(9%) 04(36%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 24
Reference services 11(100%) 18(100%) 12(100%) 13(100%) 05|(100%) 02(100% 61
Current Awareness 11(100%) 13(72%) 03(25%) 10(80%) 03(60%) 01(50%) 41
Services
Selective Dissemination 06(54%) 10(55%) 02(16%) 07(58%) 01(20%) 00(00%) 26
Of Information
Photocopying services 11(100%) 17(94%) 12(100%) 06(50%) 04(80%) 2(100%) 52
71
Fax 06(54%) 10(55%) 02(16%) 05(42%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 24
Newspaper clipping 04(36%) 08(44%) 03(25%) 03(27%) 04(80%) 00(00%) 22
It is clearly evident from Table 4.7 that all the public sector university libraries of the country
offer circulation and reference services.
52 (85%) out of 61 provide New Arrivals’ Lists and Photocopying facilities to their readers.
41(67%) out of 61 provide Current Awareness Services to the users.
24 (39%) out of 61 offer Inter Library Loan and Fax services to their readers.
22(36%) out of 61 provide Newspaper Clipping Services to their readers and potential users.
Technical services provided by the PSU libraries
Technical processing includes classification, cataloguing and assigning subject headings to
the documents and is carried out to provide better services to the readers. Moreover, adopting
international standards help the libraries in sharing the library resources in the present global
village. Table 4.8 shows the technical services carried out by the university libraries.
Table 4.8 Technical services offered by the PSU Libraries
Technical processing Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Baluchistan AJK&NA Total
Classification Scheme followed:
DDC 10(91%) 18(100%) 11(92%) 011(85%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 57
Others 01(09%) 00(00%) 01(8%) 02(15%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 04
Cataloguing rules applied:
AACR2 10(91%) 16(89%) 12(100%) 11(81%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 56
Other 01(09%) 02(11%) 00(00%) 01(09%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 04
Not using any rule 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 01(09%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 01
Assignment of Subject headings:
SLSH 02(18%) 05(28%) 02(08%) 03(23%) 03(60%) 01(20%) 16
LCSH 05(45%) 05(28%) 02(08%) 05(38%) 02(40%) 00(0%) 19
Other 02(18%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 02(18%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 04
Not using SHL 02(18%) 08(44%) 08(67%) 03(27%) 00(00%) 01(500%) 22
Note: SLSHL= Sears List of Subject Headings List LCSHL= Library of Congress Subject Headings List
It is obvious from the Table 4.8 that 57(93%) out of 61 public sector university libraries in
72
the country are using Dewey Decimal Classification (DDC) for the classification of library
collection.
Table 4.8 shows that 56(92%) out of 61 of university libraries are using Anglo-American
Cataloguing Rules-2 (AACR-2) Revised Edition (2002) for the cataloguing of their library
materials.
When asked about the usage of Subject Headings Lists by university libraries, it was stated
that 22(36%) out of 61 are not using any Subject Headings Lists for assigning subject
headings in technical processing of library collection.
Satisfaction about the usage of technical services provided by the university libraries
A question was asked from the chief librarians of the university libraries to know about the
satisfaction of technical services provided by these libraries. The response rate has been
recorded in Table 4.9.
Table 4.9 -Satisfaction about the usage of technical services
Satisfaction about the Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
usage of technical services
Classification scheme
Yes 11(100%) 18(100%) 12(100%) 13(100%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 61(100%)
No -------- ------ ------- ------- ------- ------- 00(00%)
Cataloguing rules
Yes 11(100%) 16(89%) 12(100 12(95%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 58(95%)
No ------- 02(11%) ----- 1(05%) ------- -------- 03(05%)
Subject Headings List
Yes 09(81%) 10(56%) 04(33%) 10(77%) 05(100%) 01(50%) 39(64%)
No 02(18%) 08(44%) 08(67%) 03(23%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 22(36%)
The analysis of Table 4.9 shows that all the librarians (100%) of the public sector
universities are satisfied with the classification scheme they are using.
58(95%) out of 61 university librarians are satisfied with the AACR-2 Revised Edition used
for the cataloguing of library materials.
73
39(64%) out of 61 respondents are satisfied with the subject headings list in use.
Availability of internet in PSU Libraries of Pakistan
Internet is the international network of online computer terminals. It is a world- wide system
of interrelated links. The internet facilitates information exchange across the globe.
University libraries or information centres in Pakistan need this facility in the present digital
era. Emerging technologies have made it possible to produce, share and utilize the flood of
information. The speed and quality of internet facility is of utmost importance in research.
Table 4.10 shows the availability of internet facility in the public sector university libraries of
Pakistan.
Table 4.10: Availability of internet connectivity
Internet availibity Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
10 Years + 04(36%) 08(44%) 06(50%) 02(15%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 21(34%)
3-9 Years 07(64%) 06(33%) 06(50%) 07(54%) 04(80% 01(50%) 31(51%)
Less than 2 years 00(00%) 04(22%) 00(00%) 04(31%) 01(20% 00(00%) 09(15%)
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
04(36%) out 11 public sector university libraries in Islamabad,
08(44%) out of 18 in Punjab,
06(50%) out of 12 in Sindh,
02(15%) out of 13 in KPK and
01(50%) out of 2 in AJK and NA have more than 10 years old internet availability.
This shows that 07(64%) out of 11 university libraries in Islamabad,
06(33%) out of 18 in Punjab,
06(50%) out of 12 in Sindh,
07(54%) out of 13 in KPK,
04(80%) out of 5 in Balochistan and
01(50%) out of 02 in AJK and NA have 3-9 years old internet connectivity.
74
It is also evident that 04(22%) out of 18 in Punjab,
04(31%) out of 13 in KPK and
01(20%) out of 05 in Balochistan have only two or less than two years old internet
connectivity.
Table 4.10 shows that 31(50%) out of 61 public sector university libraries have 3-9 years old
internet connectivity.
21(34%) out of 61 university libraries have more than 10 years old internet connectivity.
09(15%) out of 61 have two or less than two years old internet facility.
Speed of internet
The speed of internet plays a vital role in the exchange of data, ideas and information. It is the
tool which can save time, money and labour of a user. In Pakistan, slow speed of internet is
also considered as a barrier to the promotion of digital library system. The following table
indicates the speed of internet connection.
Table 4.11-Speed of internet connection
___________________________________________________________________________
Speed of internet Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
< 100 mbps 02(18%) 09(50%) 05(42%) 08(65%) 04(80%) 00(00%) 28(46%)
= 100 mbps 09(82%) 09(50%) 03(25%) 05(35%) 01(20%) 01(50%) 28(46%)
>100 mbps 00(00%) 00(00%) 04(33%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 05(08%)
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Table 4.11 reflects that 28(46%) out of 61 in public sector university libraries have less than
100 mbps internet speed,
28(46%) out of 61 have equal to 100 mbps speed and
only 05(8%) of university libraries have more than 100 mbps internet speed.
02(18%) out of 11 in university libraries of Islamabad,
09(50%) out of 18 in Punjab,
75
05(42%) out of 12 in Sindh,
08(65%) out of 13 in KPK,
o4 (80%) in Balochistan have less than 100 mbps internet speed.
09(82%) out of 11 university libraries in Islamabad,
09(50%) out of 18 university libraries of Punjab,
03(25%) out of 12 in Sindh,
05(35%) out of 13 in KPK ,
01(20%) out of 05 in Balochistan and
01(50%) out of 02 in AJK and NA have 100 mbps internet speed.
04(33%) out of 12 university libraries in Sindh and
01(50%) out of 02 university libraries of AJK and NA have more than 100 mbps internet
speed.
Computers having internet connectivity
The following Table contains information about the number of computers having internet
connection.
Table 4.12- Computers having internet connection
Number of computers Islamabad Punjab Sindh K PK Balochistan AJK& NA Total
having internet
<= 15 07(64%) 06(33%) 07(58%) 08(60%) 04(80%) 01(50%) 33(54%)
Between 16 and
50 02(18%) 06(33%) 02(17%) 03(24%) 01(20%) 01(50%) 15(25%)
More than 50 02(18%) 06(34) 03(25%) 02(16%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 13(21%)
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Table 4.12 shows that 33(54%) out of 61 public sector university libraries in Pakistan have
internet connections on less than or equal to 15 computers,
15(25%) out of 61 have internet connections on 16- 50 computers and
76
13(21%) out of 61 have internet connections on more than 50 computers.
A break-down of province-wise internet connection is shown as under
Internet connection on 15 or less than 15 computers:
07(64%) out of 11 of the university libraries in Islamabad,
06(33%) out of 18 in Punjab,
07(58%) out of 12 in Sindh,
08(60%) in KPK,
04(80%) out of 05 in Balochistan and
01(50%) in AJK and NA.
Internet connection on 16-50 computers:
02(18%) out of 11 in Islamabad,
06(33%)) out of 18 in Punjab,
02(17%) out of 12 in Sindh,
03(24%) out of 13 in KPK,
01(20%) out of 05 in Balochistan and
01(50%) out of 02 in AJK and NA.
Internet connection on more than 50 computers:
02(18%) out of 11 in Islamabad,
06(34%) out of 18 in Punjab,
03(25%) out of 12 in Sindh and
02(16%) out of 13 in KPK have internet connections on more than 50 computers.
Whether internet is fee or free based?
Table 4.13 Status of internet
___________________________________________________________________________
Charges of internet Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Free 11(100%) 18(100%) 10(83%) 13(100%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 59(97%)
Fee based 00(00%) 00(00%) 02(17%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 02(03%)
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
77
Table 4.13 shows that 59(97%) out of 61 public sector university libraries of the country
provide free internet facilities to their users.
Only 02(03%) out of 61 charge a very nominal fee from the internet users at their respective
university libraries.
All the public sector university libraries in Islamabad, Punjab, KPK, Balochistan and AJK
and NA provide free internet facility to their library patrons.
Only two libraries charge nominal fee from their internet users.
Provision of user education by libraries
With the emergence of Digital Technology (DT), which has influenced almost all the
functions of the university libraries, it is necessary to see the working of a library to new
entrants in detail. The main aim of the user education program is to enable the patrons to fully
utilize the resources of the library. Bello (2003:1-6)1 states that user education program of the
library is a device through which the librarians try to educate the users. The following Table
4.14 shows provision of user education to the users by library professionals.
Table 4.14-Provision of User Education
Provision of User Education Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
User Education 09(82%) 10(56%) 07(58%) 07(54%) 02(40%) 02(100%) 37(61%)
Provided
User Education 02(18%) 08(44%) 05(42%) 06(46%) 03(60%) 00(00%) 24(39%)
Not provided
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
According to Table 4.14, 37(61%) out of 61 university libraries provide user education to
their users, while 24(39%) out of 61 have no such program of educating their users.
09(82%) out of 11 university libraries of Islamabad,
10(56%) out of 18 in Punjab,
07(58%) in Sindh,
07(54%) in KPK,
78
02(40%) in Balochistan and
02(100%) in AJK and NA provide user education to educate the users in emerging library
technologies, library services and resources.
Table 4.14 shows that 02(18%) out of 11 in Islamabad,
08(44%) out of 18 in Punjab,
05(42%) out of 12 in Sindh,
06(46%) out of 13 in KPK and
03 (60%) out of 05 in Balochistan have no program for the user education of their clientele.
Frequency and timings of user education
This Table contains information regarding the frequency and duration of user education
provided to the library users.
Table 4.15 Frequency and timings of user education
Frequency Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
In the beginning 06(54%) 06(60%) 05(71%) 04(57%) 01(50%) 01(50%) 23(62%)
of academic year
In every semester 02(18%) 02(20%) 01(14%) 01(14%) 01(50%) 00(00%) 07(19%)
When requested 01(09%) 02(20%) 01(14%) 02(29%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 07(19%)
Total 09 10 07 07 02 02 37
When inquired about the frequency and timings of user education program provided by the
librarians, 23 (62%) out of 37 respondents reported that they provide user education in the
beginning of the academic year, 07(19%) out of 37 librarians claimed that they provide this
service in the beginning of every semester and the same number of librarians responded that
they provide user education as per request.
06(54%) out of 9 university librarians in Islamabad, 06(60%) out of 10 librarian in Punjab,
05(71%) out of 7 librarians in Sindh,
04(57%) out of 7 university librarians in KPK,
79
01(50%) out of 02 in Balochistan and
01(50%) out of 02 in AJK and NA are providing user education in the beginning of every
academic year.
Table 4.15 shows that 02(18%) out of 09 university librarians in Islamabad,
02(20%) out of 10 in Punjab,
01(14%) out of 7 in Sindh,
01(14%) in KPK and
01(50%) in Balochistan have the routine to provide user education in the beginning of every
semester.
As per Table 4.15, 01(09%) out of 09 in Islamabad,
02(20%) out of 10 in Punjab,
01(14%) out of 07 in Sindh,
02(29%) out of 07 in KPK and
01(50%) out of 02 in AJK and NA provide the service when the users request for it.
Duration of user education program
When asked about the duration of user education program, respondents expressed their
opinion as shown in the following Table 4.16. The librarians were given five options
mentioned below:
Table 4.16- Duration of user education program
Duration of User
Education Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Half an hour 00(00%) 02(20%) 02(29%) 02(29%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 07(19%)
One hour 05(56%) 05(50%) 03(43%) 02(29%) 01(50%) 01(50%) 17(46%)
One day 04(44%) 03(30%) 02(28%) 02(43%) 01(50%) 00(00%) 12(32%)
Two days 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 01(14%) ` 00(00%) 00(00%) 01(03%)
Any other ----- ------- ------ ------ --- ---- ----
Total 09 10 07 07 02 02 37
80
Table 4.16 shows that 17(46%) out of 37 university libraries provide one hour user education
to their users,
12(32%) out of 37 university libraries have one day user education program,
07(19%) out of 37 reported that they provide half an hour user education to their patrons and
01(03%) out of 37 claimed two days user education program.
02(20%) out of 10 in Punjab,
02(29%) out of 07 in Sindh,
02(29%) out of 07 in KPK and
01(50%) out of 02 in AJK and NA provide half an hour user education program.
Table 4.16 shows that 05(56%) out of 09 university libraries in Islamabad,
05(50%) out of 10 in Punjab,
03(43%) out of 07 in Sindh,
02(29%) in KPK,
01(50%) out of 02 in Balochistan and
01(50%) out of 02 in AJK and NA provide one hour user education program.
04(44%) out of 09 public sector university libraries in Islamabad,
03(30%) out of 10 in Punjab,
02(29%) in Sindh and
01(50%) out of 02 university library in Balochistan provide one day user education program.
The above Table 4.16 also show that 01(14%) out of 07 in KPK reported that they have two
days user education program for their users.
Who conducts user education
When asked from the librarians of public sector university libraries about the statement “who
is responsible for providing user education to the users?”. The response of the respondents is
given in Table 4.17
81
Table 4.17-Who conducts user education
Who conduct Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
User education
Librarian 08(89%) 08(80%) 07(100%) 06(85%) 02(100%) 02(100%) 33(89%)
Assistant Librarian 01(11%) 02(20%) 00(00%) 01(15%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 04(11%)
Faculty member ------- ------- --------- -------- ------ -------- 00
Any Other ----- ------ --------- ------- -------- ------ 00
Total 09 10 07 07 02 02 37
It is evident from Table 4.17 that 33(89%) out of 37 university librarians conduct user
education program in their respective libraries. 04(11%) out of 37 reported that the task is
performed by the Assistant Librarians.
08(89%) out of 09 university librarians in Islamabad,
08(80%) out of 10 in Punjab,
07(100%) out of 7 in Sindh,
06(85%) out of 07 in KPK,
02(100%) in Balochistan and
02(100%) out of 02 university librarians in AJK and NA are responsible for educating their
users in their respective libraries.
Table 4.17 shows that 01(11%) out of 09 university libraries in Islamabad,
02(20%) out of 10 in Punjab and
01(15%) out of 07 university libraries in KPK have assigned this duty to the Assistant
librarian.
82
Impact of user education program
The librarians were inquired whether user education program has positive impact on
university library services and resources or not? The response of the library professionals has
been recorded in Table 4.18
Table 4.18-Impact of user education program on users’ library services and resources
Whether UEP has positive Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&N Total
Impact on Library services and
Resources
Yes 09(100%) 10(100%) 07(100%) 07(100%) 02(100%) 02(100%) 37(100%)
No --------- -------- ---------- ---------- --------- -------- 00
Total 09 10 07 07 02 02 37
Table 4.18 elucidates that all the responded university librarians are of the opinion that user
education program has a positive impact on library services and resources.
4.1.1.3 Available resources in the PSU libraries of Pakistan
The library resources include learning resources, human resources, financial resources,
technology based resources and physical resources. Data has been collected about various
library resources to explore the current situation of and suggest ways and means for their
improvement.
Learning resources
Learning resources means printed and electronic resources. The printed resources include
books, journals, magazines, technical reports, theses, manuscripts, rare books, newspapers
and non-book materials. The electronic resources include online and offline learning
resources. The following Table contains information about the learning resources.
Table 4.19 - Learning resources of the public sector universities
_______________________________________________________________________
Learning Resources Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total _____________________________________________________________________________________
Books <=50000 08(72%) 08(44%) 05(42%) 08(62%) 04(80%) 01(50%) 34(56%) 50001-100000 01 (09%) 06(33%) 03(25%) 02(15%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 13(21%) 100001-200000 02(19%) 02(11%) 02(17%) 03(23%) 01(20%) 00(00%) 10(16%) 200000+ 00(00%) 02(11%) 02(17%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 04(07%)
83
______________________________________________________________________________________ Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Research Journals
<= 50 09(81%) 09(50%) 12(100%) 09(69%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 46 50+ 02(19%) 09(50%) 00(00%) 04(31%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 15
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61 ______________________________________________________________________________________ Newspaper
<= 10 09(82%) 14(78%) 09(75%) 10(77%) 03(60%) 02(100%) 47 10+ 02(18%) 04(22%) 03(25%) 03(23%) 02(20%) 00(00%) 14
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Manuscripts <= 200 02(18%) 04(22%) 02(17%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 08
200+ 00(00%) 01(5%) 01(08%) 02(15%) 01(20%) 00(00%) 05 No manuscripts 09(82%) 13(72%) 09(75%) 11(85%) 04(80%) 02(100%) 48 Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
NBM
<=1000 04(37%) 14(78%) 08(67%) 09(69%) 02(40%) 02(100%) 39 1000+ 07(63%) 04(22%) 04(33%) 04(31%) 03(60%) 00(00% 22 Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Digital Resources CD-Rom 06(54%) 10(56%) 05(42%) 05(38%) 01(20%) 00(00%) 27 HEC Digital Library 11(100%) 18(100%) 12(100%) 13(100%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 61
Table 4.19 shows that 34 (58%) out of 61 public sector university libraries have less than
or equal to 50000(fifty thousand) learning resources.
13 (21%) out of 61 university libraries have library collection ranging from 50001-
100000,
10 (16%) out of 61 have library materials ranging from 100001-200000 and
04(6%) out of 61 have more than 200,000 learning resources in their library premises.
Table 4.19 shows that 08(72%) out of 11 university libraries in Islamabad,
08(44%) out of 18 university libraries in Punjab,
05(42%) out of 12 in Sindh,
08(62%) out of 13 in KPK,
04(80%) out of 05 in Balochistan and
01(50%) out of 02 in AJK and NA have less than or equal to 50000 library books in their
84
respective libraries.
01(09%) out of 11 in Islamabad,
06(33%) out of 18 in Punjab, 03(25%) out of 12 in Sindh,
02(15%) in KPK and
01(50%) in AJK & NA have library books ranging from 50001- 100001.
02(19%) out of 11 public sector university libraries in Islamabad,
02(11%) out of 11 in Punjab,
02(17%) out of 12 in Sindh, 03(23%) out of 13 in KPK and
01(20%) out of 05 in Balochistan have library books ranging from 100001-200000.
02(11%) out of 18 university libraries in Punjab and
02(17%) in Sindh have more than 200,000 library books.
46(75%) out of 61 university libraries subscribes less or equal to 50 research journals
while rest 15(25%) out of 61 university libraries reported that they subscribe to more than
50 research journals.
09(81%) out of 11 of public sector university libraries in Islamabad,
09(50%) out of 18 in Punjab,
09(69%) out of 13 university libraries in KPK and
all (100 %) university libraries of Sindh , Balochistan and AJK &NA subscribe to less
than or equal to 50 research journals.
02(19%) out of 09 in Islamabad,
09(50%) out of 18 in Punjab and
04 (31%) out of 13 in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa subscribe to more than 50 research journals
for their university libraries.
When asked about the frequency of daily newspapers of the public sector university
libraries, it was explained that 47(77%) out of a total of 61 are purchasing less than or
equal to 10 daily newspapers for the readers while remaining 14(23%) out of 61 have
more than 10 daily newspapers for the reading purposes of their clientele.
85
02(19%) out of 11 in Islamabad,
04(22%) out of 18 in Punjab,
03(25%) out of 12 in Sindh,
03(23%) out of 13 in KPK and
02(40%) out of 05 in Balochistan subscribe to more than 10 daily newspapers.
The respondents were asked to report the presence of manuscripts in their respective
libraries. They replied that 48(79%) out of 61 have no manuscripts while 08(13%) out of
61 university libraries have less than or equal to 200 manuscripts and 05(8%) out of 61
university libraries reported that they have more than 200 manuscripts in their libraries.
Table 4.19 also includes non-book materials (nbms). It is seen from this Table that
39(64%) out of 61 university libraries have less than or equal to 1,000 number of Non-
Book Materials, while rest 22(36%) have more than 1000 nbms in their respective
university libraries.
Table 4.18 shows that all the public sector university libraries have access to HEC
National Digital Library Program.
Human Resource
Qualified and competent workforce is the backbone of any library. It is more important
than any other source. Nothing, but people can bring about a change and make a
difference. Table 4.20 consist of data about the strength of library staff in university
libraries in Pakistan.
Table 4.20- Strength of library staff
____________________________________________________________________
Human resources Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
1-10 staff 05(46%) 12(67%) 03(25%) 09(69%) 04(80%) 01(50%) 34(56%)
11-20 03(27%) 01(05%) 03(25%) 02(15%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 10(16%)
20+ 03(27%) 05(28%) 06(50%) 02(15%) 01(20%) 00(00%) 17(28%)
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
86
It is seen from Table 4.20 that a majority 34(56%) out of 61 university libraries have
human resources between the 1-10 workforce,
17(28%) out of 61 university libraries have more than 20 staff members for the operation
of their library functions and
10(16%) out of 61 have human resources ranging from 11-20.
Table 4.19 shows that 05(46%) out of 11university libraries from Islamabad,
12(67%) out of 18 in Punjab,
03(25%) out of 12 in Sindh,
09(69%) out of 13 in KPK,
04(80%) out of 05 in Balochistan and
01(50%) out of 02 public sector university libraries in AJK and NA have library staff
ranging from 1-10.
Table 4.19 shows that 03(27%) of the university libraries in Islamabad,
01(05%) in Punjab,
03(25%) in Sindh,
02(15%) in KPK and
01(50%) out of 02 from AJK and NA have library human resource ranging from 11-20.
Qualification of Library staff
A question was asked from the librarians of the university libraries of the country to
comment on the qualification attained by the university librarians. Various qualification
options were given like PhD, MPhil, MLISc( Master of Library and Information Science),
BLISc(Bachelor of Library and Information Science), PGD-LISc( Post Graduate Diploma
in Library and Information Science) and CLISc(Certificate in Library and Information
Science). Table 4.21 gives the information about the qualification of the librarians.
Table 4.21- Qualification of the library professionals
Qualification Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
PhD 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 Mphil 01 04 00 01 00 00 06(1%) MLISc 55 85 80 51 12 05 288(68%) BLISC/PGD LIS 15 14 16 08 02 01 56(13%) CLS 27 15 14 09 03 04 72(18%)
Total 98 118 110 69 17 10 422
87
Note: The above Table contains the detail of staff of central libraries only. The seminar libraries are not included in this study.
Table 4.21 shows that not a single librarian holds a PhD degree in the public sector university
libraries of the country. There are only 06(1.4%) MPhil degree holders out of 422 total
professional and para-professional library staff in the country.
Majority 288(68%) out of 422 University librarians possess Masters’ degree in Library and
Information Science (MLISc).
Some 56(13%) out of 422 library professionals have Bachelor in Library and Information
Science (BLISc) or Post Graduate Diploma in Library and Information Science (PGD-LISc)
degrees.
27(6.4%) out of 422 library staff are Certificate holders in Library Science (CLISc).
Nature of human resources
A sub-question was asked to know as to how many library staff members are professional,
para-professional and non-professional among the library human resources. Table 4.21 shows
the nature of human resources in the university libraries.
Table 4.22-Nature of human resources
Nature of HR Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Professional 71 103 96 60 24 06 360
Staff
Para prof.staff 27 15 24 09 03 01 79
Non-prof 108 190 307 80 19 11 715
Lib+autom staff 16 10 09 07 00 00 42
Total 222 318 436 156 46 18 1196
Note: Lib+autom staff = staff reserved for automation and digitization
Table 4.22 shows that among 1196 total workforce in the university libraries, 715(60%)
are non-professional and 360(30%) are professional.
A few 79(6.6%) are para-professional and 42(3.5%) out of 1196 are reserved for library
automation in the university libraries.
Table 4.21 shows that there are 222(19%) out of a total of 1196 workforce in public
88
sector university libraries of Islamabad,
318(27%) out of 1196 in Punjab,
436(36%) out of 1196 in Sindh,
156(13%) in KPK,
46(04%) in Balochistan and
18(1.5%) are in AJK&NA.
Training attended by human resources
Training plays a dynamic role in the promotion of modern library culture in the country.
Periodic training is the key to update the library professionals in emerging library trends.
Table 4.23 contains information about the number of trainings received by the library
professionals in emerging library technologies.
Table 4.23 Training attended by library staff
________________________________________________________________________
Training received Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
No. of training 00(00%) 01(05%) 02(17%) 00(00%) 03(60%) 00(00%) 06(10%)
Attended
<=5 02(18%) 07(39%) 05(42%) 06(46%) 02(40%) 01(50%) 23(38%)
6-10 04(37%) 03(17%) 03(25%) 04(31%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 15(25%)
10+ 05(45%) 07(39%) 02(17%) 03(23%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 17(27%)
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Table 4.23 shows that 06(10%) out of 61 university librarians reported that they have not
received any training in modern library trends. Majority 23(38%) out of 61 university
librarians reported that they have attended less than or equal to five training on modern
library trends. Some 15(25%) out of 61 university librarians responded that they have
received training ranging from 6-10. 17(28%) out of 61 librarians claimed that they have
attended more than 10 library training programs on emerging library technologies.
89
Impact of training on human resources
The University librarians were asked to comment on the impact of training on the
performance of the library professionals. It is observed from Table 4.23 that 55(90%) out
of 61 university librarians were of the opinion that these trainings on modern library
trends have positive impact on the smooth performance of library professionals.
Table 4.24 Impact of training on human resources
Impact of training Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total on HR
+ impact 11(100%) 17(85%) 10(83%) 13(100%) 02(40%) 02(100%) 55(90%) -Impact 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) Uncertain 00(00%) 01(05%) 02(17%) 00(00%) 03(60%) 00(00%) 06(10%)
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
It is seen from Table 4.24 that all university librarians of Islamabad, KPK, Balochistan
and AJK&NA were of the opinion that trainings on modern library technologies have
positive impact on the smooth operation of university libraries and library professionals.
Only 06(10%) out of 61 university librarians were uncertain about the issue.
Additional qualification required for the incharge of automation section of the
university library
When asked about the additional qualification required for the head of automation section
of the university libraries, the views of the respondents have been recorded in Table 4.25.
Table 4.25-Extra skill required for incharge of automation section
Additional qualification Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
MLIS+MCS/MIT 08(73%) 08(44%) 02(17%) 02(15%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 20
MLIS+DIT/DCS 02(18%) 01(05%) 02(17%) 08(61%) 05(100%) 01(50%) 19
MLIS+Training in 01(9%) 09(51%) 08(66%) 03(23%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 22
IT
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Note: MCS= Master of Computer Science DCS= Diploma of Computer Science
90
MIT= Master of Information Technology DIT= Diploma of Information Technology
Table 4.25 shows that 22(36%) out of 61 university librarians reported that head of
automation section of the university libraries must have some expertise in computer and
information technology along with Masters’ degree in Library and Information Science.
20(33%) out of 61 respondents expressed their opinion that the incharge of automation
section must have Masters’ degree in Computer Science (MCS) or Information
Technology(IT) along with Masters’ degree in Library Science.
Table 4.25 elucidates that 19(31%) out of 61 librarians reported that they must possess
Diploma in IT or Computer Science along with Masters’ degree in Library Science.
Table 4.25 therefore shows that the incharge of automation section must have expertise in
other disciplines such as MIT, MCS, DCS and DIT etc along with Masters’ degree in
Library and Information Science.
Financial resources
Finance is a major issue for the promotion of Modern library culture in the public sector
university libraries of Pakistan. It is the backbone of any organization. Without proper
allocation of budget, these libraries cannot achieve the required objectives of a university.
University library budget from 2005-2010
A financial resource is one of the most important resources in the overall infrastructure of
a university library. The respondents were asked to provide university library budget for
five financial years i.e. 2005-2010. Table 4.26 contains data about five financial years
from 2005-2010.
Table 4.26- University library budget from 2005-2010
Budget in million
rupees (m) Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Per annum
Below 5m 05(45%) 14(78%) 09(75%) 10(77%) 04(80%) 02(100%) 44(72%)
91
5m-10m 03(28%) 01(05%) 02(17%) 02(15%) 01(20%) 00(00%) 09(15%)
11m-15m 02(18%) 02(06%) 01(8%) 01(8%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 06(10%)
16m-20m 01(9%) 01(11%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 02(3%)
20m+ 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Note: as of 17/12/2011: One Pound Sterling is equivalent to Rs 139.15, One US Dollar is equivalent to Rs 89.61
and One Euro is equivalent to Rs117
It is clear from Table 4.26 that a majority 44(72%) out of 61 university libraries have an
average annual budget of less than Rs. five million. 09(15%) out of 61 university libraries
have annual budget ranging from Rs 5m-10m.
06(10%) out of 61university libraries have library budget ranging from Rs 11m-15m. It is
also observed from Table 4.26 that only two university libraries have Rs 16m-20 m
average annual budget.
It is seen from Table 4.26 that 05(45%) out of 11 university libraries of Islamabad,
14(78%) out of 18 university libraries in Punjab,
09(75%) out of 61 from Sindh,
10(77%) out of 13 in KPK,
04(80%) in Balochistan and
02(100%) in AJK and NA have less than Rs 5 million annual budget.
Table 4.26 shows that, only two university libraries namely COMSAT Institute of IT
Islamabad and University of Engineering and Technology Lahore have an annual average
budget ranging from Rs 16m-20m.
This Table also reflects that there is not a single university library who gets more than Rs
20 million university library budget.
Library budget for automation sections of the university libraries
The university librarians were asked whether they have a separate budget for automation
section of their respective libraries or not? The data collected in this connection is shown
92
in Table 4.26. A majority of 57(93%) out of 61 libraries reported that there is no special
allocation of budget for automation section.
Table 4.27- Library budget for automation sections of university libraries under study
Budget Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
No separate budget 09(82%) 16(89%) 12(100%) 13(100%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 57(93%)
Below Rs 1 Million 01(09%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 01(2%)
Rs 1 Million + 01(09%) 02(11%) 00(00% 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 03(5%)
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Table 4.27 shows that only one public sector university library namely International
Islamic University Islamabad has been allocated Rs one million budget per year
separately for automation of library functions.
Only three public sector universities namely (a) COMSAT Institute of Information
Technology,(b) Pir Mehar Ali Shah (PMAS) University of Arid Agriculture Rawalpindi
and (c) University of Engineering and Technology Lahore each have more than Rs one
million annual budget for the implementation of emerging library technologies in their
respective libraries.
Satisfaction about allocation for automation and digitization budget.
The librarians were asked to express their opinion regarding the matter “whether they are
satisfied with the budget allocation for the automation of their university libraries or not?”
Majority 57(93%) out of 61 respondents reported that since they had no separate
allocation of budget for automation section, they mentioned that there is a need for
separate budget for this purpose. Table 4.28 contains the information about the
satisfaction of automation budget.
Table 4.28 elucidates that only 04(7%) out of 61 university librarians are satisfied with
allocation of budget for the automation of their university libraries.
93
Table 4.28- Views of librarians about satisfaction of library automation budget
Satisfaction about Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Auto digit budget
Yes 02(22%) 02(11%) 00(00% 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 04(07%)
No 09(88%) 16(89%) 12(100%) 13(100%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 57(93%)
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Opinion about allocation of library budget for automation and digitization
The university librarians were given an option to suggest allocation of budget for
automation sections of their respective libraries. The respondents were given six options
to opt for one of them. The respondents’ opinion in this regard have been reproduced in
Table 4.29.
Table 4.29-Opinion about allocation of library budget for automation and digitization
Opinion Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Below 10% 00(00%) 01(5%) 02(17%) 01(8%) (00%) 00(00%) 04(7%)
of the total library budget
10-20% 04(36%) 05(28%) 02(17%) 05(38%) 02(40%) 00(00%) 18(29%)
21-30% 05(45%) 08(45%) 08(64%) 06(46%) 03(60%) 00(00%) 30(49%)
31-40% 00(00%) 01(05%) 00(00%) 01(8%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 03(5%)
40%+ 00(00%) 01(05%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 02(3%)
Satisfied, have no 02(18%) 02(11%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 04(7%)
Suggestion
__________________________________________________________________________________
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Table 4.29 shows that a majority of 30(50%) out of 61 university librarians have opted for
21 to 30 percent of total library budget for the automation purposes of their university
94
libraries.
18(30%) out of 61 university librarians opted for 10-20% of total library budget for
library automation.
A few 04(7%) out of 61 university librarians were of the opinion that there is no need of
more budget for the automation and digitization of their respective university libraries and
that they were satisfied.
Table 4.29 reveals that 01(5%) out of 18 university libraries in Punjab have opted for
below 10% for the automation budget,
02(17%) out of 18 in Sindh,
01(08%) out of 13 university libraries in KPK
Table 4.29 shows that 05(45%) out of 11university libraries in Islamabad have opted for
21-30% of total library budget,
08(45%) out of 18 in Punjab,
08(64%) out of 12 in Sindh,
06(46%) out of 13 in KPK and
03(60%) out of 05 in Balochistan
It is concluded from the Table 4.29 that the majority of the librarians have opted for 21 to
30 percent of the total library budget for the modernization of public sector university
libraries of the country.
Technology- based resources
In present era of emerging library technologies, technology-based resources are the back
bone of a modern university library. Technology based library resources include
computers, servers, scanners, barcode readers, printers , digital cameras, Radio Frequency
Systems and Un-Interrupted Power Supply/ Generators. Table 4.30 gives information
about technology-based resources in the university libraries of the country.
95
Table 4.30- Technology- based resources/hardware
Hardware Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Computers
1-15 07(64%) 08(44%) 06(50%) 08(62%) 04(80%) 02(100%) 35
16-50 02(18%) 05(28%) 06(50%) 05(38%) 01(20%) 00(00%) 19
50+ 02(18%) 05(28%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 07
Servers
No server 07(64%) 13(72%) 10(83%) 10(77%) 05(100%) 01(50%) 46
1-3 04(36%) 05(28%) 02(17%) 03(23%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 15
3+ 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00
Printers
No printer 01(09%) 03(17%) 01(08%) 01(8%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 06
1-3 08(72%) 13(83%) 07(54%) 10(77%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 45
3+ 01(09%) 00(00%) 04(33%) 02(15%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 07
Scanners
No scanner 04(36%) 13(72%) 06(50%) 05(38%) 03(60%) 01(50%) 32
1-3 06(55%) 03(17%) 06(50%) 08(62%) 02(40%) 01(50%) 26
3+ 01(09%) 02(11%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 03
Bar Code Reader
Yes 02(18%) 09(50%) 07(58%) 04(31%) 00(00%) 01(50%) 23
No 09(82%) 09(50%) 05(42%) 09(69%) 05(100%) 01(50%) 38
Digital Camera
No digital 07(64%) 13(72%) 09(75%) 08(62%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 44
Camera
1-3 04(36%) 03(17%) 03(25%) 05(38%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 15
3+ 00(00%) 02(11%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 02
UPS/Generator
Yes 05(45%) 16(89%) 09(75%) 03(23%) 01(20%) 00(00%) 34
No 06(55%) 02(11%) 03(25%) 10(77%) 04(80%) 02(100%) 27
RF Security System
Yes 02(18%) 03(17%) 01(08%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 06
No 09(82%) 15(83%) 11(92%) 13(100%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 55
Table 4.30 shows that 35(57%) out of 61 university libraries have computers ranging
from 1 to 15,
96
19(31%) out of 61 university libraries have 16-50 computers in their libraries and
07(11%) out of 61 university libraries have more than 50 computers.
07(64%) out of 11 university libraries in Islamabad have1-15 computers in their
university libraries,
08(44%) out of 18 in Punjab,
06(50%) out of 12 in Sindh,
08(62%) out of 13 in KPK,
04(80%) out of 05 in Balochistan and
02(100%) in AJK&NA.
Table 4.30 shows that majority 46(75%) out of 61 university libraries have no servers in
the libraries. The library computer network is usually controlled from Information
Technology/ Computer Science Department of the concerned university.
As per Table 4.30, majority 45 (74%) out of 61 of the university libraries under study
have 1 to 3 printers in their libraries,
A few 07(11%) out of 61 have more than 3 printers in their respective libraries.
Some 06(10%) of them reported that they have no printer in the premises of their
libraries. It is concluded that most of the university libraries have less than or equal to 3
printers for their routine work.
32(52%) out of 61 university libraries in the country have no scanner,
26(43%) out of 61 university libraries have 1 to 3 scanners and only 03 university
libraries have more than 3 scanners for the automation and digitization purposes of the
library materials.
Table 4.30 shows that majority 38(63%) out of 61 university libraries have no bar code
readers, while the rest 23(37%) out of 61 have bar code readers for the automation of
university libraries.
When asked about the presence of digital camera in their university libraries, the
librarians reported that 44(72%) out of 61 university libraries have no digital cameras,
15(25%) out of the total contain digital cameras from 1 to 3. Only 02 university libraries
claimed more than 3 digital cameras for the digitization of library documents.
97
Table 4.30 shows that 34 (56%) out of 61 university libraries have UPS/Generators to
cope with the power failure problems, while the remaining 27 (44%) out of 61 have no
such facility.
The respondents reported that 55(90%) out of 61 universities have no Radio Frequency
Systems (RF) for the implementation of modern library technologies in their respective
libraries. The rest 06(10%) out of 61university libraries claimed Radio Frequency System
in the premises of their libraries.
4.1.1.4 Library software used for the operation of hardware
In order to provide up-to-date information to their users, appropriate modern library
facilities are the need of the hour. For the effective use of hardware, standard software is
also very important. The software plays the role of gateway between technology and end
user. Table 4.31 gives the availability of library software in university libraries.
Table 4.31- Library software used for the operation of Hardware
Software in use Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Operating System
XP 11(100%) 18(100%) 12(100%) 13(100%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 61
Others -------- -------- -------- --------- ----------- -------- 00
Library Management
Software
LIMS 04(36%) 12(67%) 04(50%) 02(22%) 01(50%) 00(00%) 23(48%)
LAMP 02(18%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 01(09%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 03(6%)
WINISIS 03(27%) 01(00%) 00(00%) 03(27%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 07(15%)
KOHA 01(09%) 01(06%) 04(50%) 03(27%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 09(19%)
Any Other 01(09%) 03(22%) 00(00%) 00 (00%) 01(50%) 01(50%) 06(12%)
Anti Virus Software
Yes 11(100%) 18(100%) 12(100%) 13(100%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 61
No ------ --------- ------- -------- ----- ------ ---
Anti Plagiarism
Software
Yes 02(18%) 10(56%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 12 (20%)
No 09(82%) 08(44%) 12(100%) 13(100%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 49(80%)
98
It is fairly evident from Table 4.31 that almost all the university libraries of the country
have installed Windows XP as operating system in their computers.
Table 4.31also shows that 23(48%) out of 48 automated university libraries are using
Library and Information Management System (LIMS) for the operation of library
functions, 09(19%) out of 48 automated university libraries are using Koha as integrated
library software,
07(15%) out of 48 are using WINISIS (CDS/ISIS for Windows) for automation of library
procedures,
03(06%) out of 48 have Library Automation and Management Program (LAMP) and
06 (13%) are using different Integrated Library Softwares like Academic Management
System (AMS) used by Institute of Space Technology Islamabad, Library Manager (LM)
by Pakistan Institute of Engineering & Applied Sciences (PIEAS), Islamabad, UET-
Libas by University of Engineering and Technology Taxila, Alice for Windows by
National College of Arts, Lahore, Virtua by Fatima Jinnah Woman University
Rawalpindi and Hazara University Mansehra Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.
All public sector university libraries have anti-virus software installed in their computer
terminals.
Majority 49(80%) out of 61 university libraries have no anti-plagiarism software for
checking plagiarism of research papers and dissertations. Only 12 university libraries
have such facility.
Table 4.31 shows that majority of the university libraries are using LIMS as integrated
library software.
4.1.1.5 Database of library holdings
Library holdings include books, back volumes of journals, magazines, theses and
dissertations, manuscripts, technical reports, newspapers and non-book materials. The
automation of library holdings is highly important for the modernization of university
libraries. University Librarians were asked to report about the database developed for
library holdings of their respective libraries. The data obtained is seen in Table 4.32
99
Table 4.32- Database of library holdings
Data base Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Data base of
Lib.holdings
Yes 11(100%) 17(94%) 08(67%) 09(69%) 02(40%) 01(50%) 48(79%)
No 00(00%) 01(06%) 04(33%) 04(31%) 03(60%) 01(50%) 13(21%)
% of of library holdings that have been
Automated
Below 50% 00(00%) 05(29%) 03(38%) 05(56%) 01(50%) 01(100%) 15(31%)
51-80 % 01(09%) 07(47%) 03(38%) 02(22%) 01(50%) 00(00%) 14(30%)
81-100% 10(91%) 05(29%) 02(25%) 02(22%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 19(39%)
Table 4.32 shows that majority 48(79%) out of 61 have developed database of their
library holdings.
Majority 19(40%) out of 48 automated university libraries have completed more than
80% of their library automation process and have developed databases of their library
holdings.
15(31%) out of 48 automated libraries are in the process of automation and have fed
about 51-80% of their library collection into their computers.
Some 14(29%) out of 48 automated university libraries have entered below 50% of their
documents into their computer terminals.
Table 4.32 elucidates that majority of the university libraries have completed or are in the
process of completion of their databases in their respective libraries.
4.1.1.6 Websites of the university libraries
Library website is a specialized facility for the users. With the help of this tool, a user can
search his/her required document anywhere and without time restrictions.
In order to know the exact situation, the respondent were given a query to report whether
their university libraries have a separate websites or uploaded in the main home pages as
hyper links. Table 4.33 shows the status of library website or a link in the university web
page.
100
Table 4.33 Websites of university libraries
_____________________________________________________________________
Websites of University Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Library
Library own website 01(09%) 02(11%) 02(17%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 00(00%) 05
A link within
University homepage 10(91%) 16(89%) 10(83%) 13(100%) 05(100%) 02(100%) 56
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Table 4.33 shows that a majority 56(92%) out of 61 university libraries have no separate
library websites. The libraries of these universities are uploaded in the main home pages
as hyper links. Only five university libraries namely (a) COMSAT Institute of
Information Technology Islamabad, (b) University of Engineering and Technology
Lahore,(c) Punjab University Lahore,(d) Nadirshaw Edulji Dinshaw (NED), University of
Engineering and Technology Karachi and (e) University of Karachi have their own
separate websites.
These websites contain general information related to the libraries, rules and regulations,
staff details, services and resources and Online Public Access Catalogue.
4.1.1.5 Views about physical resources in comparison with a modern university
library
Physical resources play a pivotal role in the use of the university libraries. These
resources include furniture/ seating arrangement, lighting/ventilation, reading area, air
conditioning system, library safety measures and research cubicles. An effort was made to
enquire from the respondents whether the university libraries in the country can compete
with the modern university libraries or not? For this purpose the librarians were given a
number of queries to rate the situation as per current position of their respective libraries.
The queries in Table 4.34 are rated in 5 point scale (very good, good, uncertain, poor,
very poor). The average Mean (X), Standard Deviation (S.D) and Co-efficient of
Variation (C.V) have been calculated. These tools are used to examine the concentration
and dispersion of respondents’ opinion. The least value of SD and CV shows the
consistency of librarians’ opinion, while maximum values of A.M, SD and C.V shows the
101
variability of opinions.
Librarians were asked particular queries to compare the physical facilities available in
their own university library with a modern university library and rank their university
libraries in the given point scale against each query.
Table 4.34 Views about physical resources in comparison with a modern university
library
S.No Description of Query Mean(X) S.D C.V
1- Furniture/Seating Arrangement 2 0.63 31.53
2- Lightning/ Ventilation 1 0.50 50.00
3- Reading Area 2 0.80 40.00
4- Research Cubicles/Cabins 3 1.3 43.30
5- Air Conditioning 2 0.78 39.00
6- Library Building (Safety aspects) 3 1.18 39.33
7- Printing Facilities/ Soft copy Facility 2 1.05 52.5
8- Photocopying Facilities 2 0.51 25.5
Note: A-Mean (X), Standard Deviation (SD), Coefficient of Variation (CV)
1-Strongly Agree, 2- Agree, 3-Uncertain, 4-Disagree, 5-Strongly Disagree
Table 4.34 shows that respondents of the university libraries agreed (x=2) with the statement
that “furniture/ seating arrangement of these university libraries are levelled with the
furniture/ seating arrangement of a modern university library”.
Librarians strongly agreed (x=1) with the statement that “lighting/ ventilation of university
libraries is upto the standard of a modern university library”.
Librarians have been asked to comment on the query “comparison of reading areas of P S U
libraries in the country with the modern university libraries”, the respondents agreed (x=2)
that space reserved for reading in these university libraries is adequate as per international
standards.
Librarians were uncertain (x=3) about the research cubicles/cabins reserved for research
scholars in the public sector university libraries. The librarians were also uncertain (x=3)
about the safety of their university library buildings by comparing it with modern university
102
libraries.
Librarians agreed (x=2) with the statement that these university libraries have enough
facilities of printing/ soft copy facility in comparison with a modern university library. They
also agreed (x=2) that university libraries have photocopying facilities while comparing them
with modern university libraries.
Table 4.34 shows that lightning/ventilation system of the university libraries in the public
sector is up to the international standards. The computed Mean , SD and CV confirm that
university libraries have good seating arrangements, proper ventilation /lighting system,
reading areas for readers, need based soft copy /printing facilities and photocopying facilities
in their premises. However, situation regarding research cubicles/cabins and building safety
is not up to the mark.
4.1.2 Impact of digital technology on library services and resources in the public sector
universities of Pakistan
Technology has affected all walks of life. Emerging technologies has had a considerable
impact on university library services and various resources and has successfully changed the
traditional library into a modern library. In order to determine the impact of digital
technology on university library and information services and resources, university librarians
were asked various questions to obtain information about the issue. The queries in the most of
the questions in this section were rated in 5 point scale (strongly agree, agree, uncertain,
disagree and strongly disagree). The average Mean (X), Standard Deviation and Coefficient
of Variation have been calculated. These tools are used to examine the concentration and
dispersion of respondents’ opinion. The least value of Standard Deviation and Coefficient of
Variation show the consistency of librarians’ opinion while maximum values of A.M, SD and
C.V shows the variability of opinions.
4.1.2.1 Technology based services are better than manual services?
Various questions have been asked from the university librarians to discover whether
technology based services are better than manual services? If yes, then what are the features
that distinguish technology based services from manual services. Table 4.35 presents the
librarians’ views in this regard.
103
Table 4.35 Technology based services are better than manual services
Comparison Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Agree 11(100%) 17(94%) 08(67%) 09(69%) 02(40%) 01(50%) 48(79%)
Disagree ---------- ---------- --------- --------- -------- --------- 00
No such facility 00(00%) 01(06%) 04(33%) 04(31%) 03(60%) 01(50%) 13(21%)
Total 11 18 12 13 05 02 61
Table 4.35 shows that majority 48(79%) out of 61 university libraries under study agreed that
technology-based library services are better than manual services. Some 13(21%) university
libraries reported that they have no such facilities in their university libraries.
Table 4.35 shows that all respondents in Islamabad agreed with the query “technology-based
services are better than manual services”.
Majority 17(94%) out of 18 university librarians in Punjab,
08(67%) out of 12 in Sindh and
09(69%) out of 13 in KPK agreed that technology-based services are better than manual
services.
It is observed from the above Table that a majority of the university librarians have reported
that technology-based library services are better than manual services.
If yes, then why?
Table 4.36 Why technology-based services are better than manual services
Statement Mean S.D C.V
1- They are accurate 2 0.41 20.50
2- They are consistent 1 0.50 25.00
3- They can be provided with lesser time 2 0.87 43.22
4- They can occupy lesser space 1 0.53 26.50
5- They can be provided round the clock 2 0.45 21.11
6- Can be tailor made for specific needs 2 0.40 20.23
Note: M-Mean, S.D- Standard Deviation, C.V- Coefficient of Variation
1-Strongly Agree, 2- Agree, 3-Uncertain, 4-Disagree, 5-Strongly Disagree
Librarians were asked specific questions to find out as to what are those features that
distinguish technology based services from the manual services. The respondents agreed that
technology based information services are consistent (X=1 with S.D=0.50). They can occupy
104
lesser space (X=1, SD=0.53). Technology based services are accurate; can be provided with
lesser time, can be provided round the clock and can be tailor-made for specific purposes
(X=2, SD=0.41, 0.45, 0.87).
The statements, “technology based information services are accurate” produced the most
positive response (C.V=20.50) among all the above statements.
4.1.2.2 Technology- based technical services have a positive impact on library services
and resources?
The respondents were asked to report whether technology based technical services have a
positive impact on library services and resources or not? For this purpose, the librarians were
given various library services. The comments have been rated in a scale: (Strongly Agree to
Strongly Disagree)
Table 4.37 Impact of technology based technical services on university libraries
Description Mean S.D C.V
1- Acquisition work 2 0.60 30.00
2- Cataloguing of documents 1 0.36 18.00
3- OPAC 2 0.76 38.00
4- Use of e-DDC 2 0.70 35.00
5- Digitization of documents 2 0.52 26.00
6- Circulation Control 1 0.47 23.50
7- Information retrieval 1 0.35 17.33
8- Stock verification 2 0.54 27.07
9- Accounting and management 2 0.60 30.00
10- Electronic theft detection system 1 0.50 30.00
Note: M-Mean, S.D- Standard Deviation, C.V- Coefficient of Variation
1-Strongly Agree, 2- Agree, 3-Uncertain, 4-Disagree, 5-Strongly Disagree
Table 4.37 shows that university librarians strongly agreed with the statement that “emerging
library technology has positive impact on cataloguing of documents and information
retrieval” (X=1; SD=0.35, 0.36). Table 4.37 reveals that library technology has a positive
impact on circulation control of the university libraries (X=1; SD=0.47). It is also seen from
the same table that technology based technical services have positive impact on electronic
theft detection system (X=1; SD=0.60).
Table 4.37 reveals that librarians agreed with the statement that technology has positive
105
impact on acquisition work of the university libraries, accounting and management work
(X=2; SD=0.60). This table also shows that emerging technologies have positive impact on
stock verification (X=2; SD=0.54). The impact of technology on use of Electronic Dewey
Decimal Classification(E-DDC) and Online Public Access Catalogue(OPAC) has also been
recorded as positive (X=2; SD=0.70,0.76).
The Co-efficient of Variation (CV) for statement No.07 of the above Table is least (17.33),
most of the librarians have answered to this statement that “technology has a positive impact
on information retrieval”. This reflects the consistency among the responses of the librarians.
Statement No.2 of the same Table gives the (CV=18.00 per cent) which is the next least co-
efficient of variation and shows consistency among the responses of the respondents. There
are diverse opinions about the use of OPAC (CV=42 .67 per cent).
It is concluded that technology based library services have a positive impact on cataloguing
of documents and information retrieval.
4.1.2.3 Attitude of university librarians towards the application of Digital Technology
(DT) in the PSU libraries of Pakistan
The attitude of librarians towards the application of digital technology in university library
services and resources is an important factor because librarians are the people who introduce
and provide new services and resources to the users. The librarians have the responsibility to
fulfil the needs and demands of their clientele. Librarians with positive attitude towards the
application of digital technology in university libraries can help the libraries to introduce
modern information sources and services. It is highly relevant to assess the attitude of
librarians towards the application of digital technology in libraries. Librarians were asked to
indicate their attitude and responses towards this matter.
Table 4.38 elucidates the attitude of university librarians towards the application of digital
technology in the university libraries.
Table 4.38- Attitude of librarians towards the application of emerging library technology
Description Mean S.D C.V
1- DT are to improve the quality of library services 2 0.89 44.85
2- DT applications improve the efficiency of Library 2 0.40 20.10
106
3- DT enhances the knowledge and expertise 2 0.66 33.33
4- DT reduces the work load of the library
Professional 4 0.50 12.54
5- DT increases the regular budgeting 2 1.08 53.90
6- DT takes over the traditional way of information
handling in the library 3 0.54 26.98
______________________________________________________________________________________
Note: M-Mean, S.D- Standard Deviation, C.V- Coefficient of Variation
1-Strongly Agree, 2- Agree, 3-Uncertain, 4-Disagree, 5-Strongly Disagree
Table 4.38 shows that librarians have positive attitude and agreed with the statement: digital
technology application improves the efficiency of the library(X=2; SD=0.40). It is also seen
that the emergence of digital technologies improve the knowledge and expertise of the library
professionals (X=2; SD=0.50). The above Table reflects that university librarians agreed that
digital technology applications improves the quality of library services (X=2; SD=0.89). The
librarians also agreed with the statement that: digital technology increases the regular
budgeting of the university libraries (X=2; SD=1.08).
However, librarians are uncertain about whether digital technology takes over the traditional
way of information handling or not? (X=3; SD=0.54). It is also observed from the Table 4.38
that librarians disagreed with the statement: “DT reduces the workload of the library
professionals” (X=4; SD=0.54).
The calculated mean(X), Standard Deviation (SD) and Coefficient of Variation (CV) prove
that the “applications of digital technology improves the efficiency of the library and it does
not reduces the workload of the library professionals”.
4.1.2.4 Networking of public sector university libraries in Pakistan
It is an accepted fact that digital resources can be shared easily with the establishment of a
network system among the university libraries. In this connection, the librarians were asked
to express their opinion about the statement on the following scale.
107
Table 4.39- Networking of public sector university libraries in Pakistan
Description Mean S.D C.V
1 By forming a network of university libraries in Pakistan, we will be able to enhance resource sharing 1 0.45 47.23
2 It will standardize library services 2 0.68 34.00 3 It will help in building standard collection 2 0.72 36.00 4 The efficiency of human resources will
be improved 2 0.51 25.50
5 Duplication of cataloguing entries will be avoided 1 0.40 20.00
Note: M-Mean, S.D- Standard Deviation, C.V- Coefficient of Variation
1-Strongly Agree, 2- Agree, 3-Uncertain, 4-Disagree, 5-Strongly Disagree
Table 4.39 shows that university librarians strongly agreed with the statement: “networking
of university libraries will help in avoiding of duplication of catalogue entries” (X=1;
SD=0.40). The librarians also strongly agreed with the statement: “by forming a network of
university libraries in Pakistan, we will be able to enhance resource-sharing” (X=1;
SD=0.45).
Therefore, the above Table shows that librarians agreed with the query: “the efficiency of
human resources will be improved” (X=2; SD=0.51). This Table elucidates that library
services will be standardized with university library networking (X=2; SD=0.68). The
librarians also agreed with the statement: “it will help in building standard collection” (X=2;
SD=0.72).
It is also observed that among all these statements: “university libraries will help in avoidance
of duplication of cataloguing entries” generated the most positive response (CV=20.00).
4.1.2.5 Librarians’ opinion in response to various queries
The university librarians were asked to express their opinion about the following statements
on the scale given below. They were given the queries: “whether the computers and other
equipment placed in the university libraries are always in good condition and whether library
staff is well trained in library technologies or not”? The librarians were also given two
queries about the users: “users prefer electronic resources or print version of that document
108
and whether users require orientation to make the maximum use of technology based services
or not?” Table 4.40 has recorded the responses of university librarians in this connection.
Table 4.40 - Librarians’ opinion in response to various queries
Description Mean S.D C.V
1 Computers and other equipment are always in good condition 2 0.52 26.11
2 library staff is well trained in library technologies 2 0.67 33.50 3 users prefer to search electronic resources
to a manual search of printed versions 2 0.78 39.00
4 users require orientation to make the maximum use of technology based information services 2 0.40 20.23
Note: M-Mean, S.D- Standard Deviation, C.V- Coefficient of Variation
1-Strongly Agree, 2- Agree, 3-Uncertain, 4-Disagree, 5-Strongly Disagree
The calculated mean (X=2) obtained from the Table 4.40 reflects that librarians agreed with
all the four above mentioned queries. However, the calculated values of Standard Deviation
(SD) show the consistency among the opinion of the respondents. Among all four statements,
university librarians agreed more consistently with the statement: “users require orientation to
make the maximum use of technology based information services” (X=2; SD=0.40), followed
by statement: “computers and other equipment are always in good working condition” (X=2;
SD=0.52).
Table 4.40 also points out that librarians agreed with the statements: “library staff is well
trained in emerging library technologies” (X=2; SD=0.67) and “users prefer to search
electronic resources to a manual search of printed version” (X=2; SD= 0.78).
The calculated mean, Standard Deviation (SD) and Co-efficient of Variation (CV) show that
among all statements in Table 4.40, the statement: “users require orientation to make the
maximum use of technology based information services” has generated a more positive
response ((CV=20.23) followed by the statement: “computers and other equipment are
always in good condition” ( CV=26.11).
109
4.1.2.6 Barriers to the application of emerging library technologies in the university
libraries
Farasat (2009)2 describes that the library automation in Pakistan is still in the stage of infancy
and offers many barriers to their implementation. Efforts are in the pipeline to eradicate the
hindrances in their way. However, an effort was made to know from the university librarians
about the barriers to the implementation of emerging technologies in their respective
university libraries. Table 4.41 contains the data about barriers to the adoption of modern
library technologies.
Table 4.41- Barriers to emerging library technologies
Barriers Mean S.D CV
Information technology infrastructure 2 0.57 28.5
Copyright 1 0.51 25.5
Security 2 0.62 31.00
Professional skills 2 0.75 37.33
Frequent electricity failures 1 0.78 78.00
The will/motivation is lacking 3 0.55 27.5
Internet provision by the institutions /organization
within which the Library is located: 2 0.77 38.51
Internet, Internet Speed etc 2 0.55 27.52
Financial constraints 1 0.31 31.11
Systematic planning for digitization 2 0.44 22.23
Note: M-Mean, S.D- Standard Deviation, C.V- Coefficient of Variation
1-Strongly Agree, 2- Agree, 3-Uncertain, 4-Disagree, 5-Strongly Disagree
It is seen from Table 4.41 that university librarians strongly agreed with the view that
finance is a major barrier in the way of adopting emerging library technologies(X=1;
110
SD=0.31).They strongly agreed and pinpointed that copyright is another major issue in the
way of automation and digitization (X=1; SD= 0.51). It was also observed that respondents
strongly agreed with the query that frequent electricity failure is also a barrier (X=1;
SD=0.78).
Table 4.41 shows that university librarians agreed with the statement: “lack of systematic
planning for automation and digitization” is also a barrier to the implementation of emerging
technologies in university libraries of Pakistan (X=2; SD=0.44).
It can also be observed that university librarians also agreed with the statement: “Internet,
internet speed, information technology infrastructure, security and professional skills are the
main barriers to the implementation of modern library technologies” (X=2; SD= 0.51, 0.62,
0.75 and 0.77).
As seen from Table 4.41, it is clear that librarians were uncertain about the statement: “the
will/motivation of the university librarians towards modern library trends is lacking” (X=3;
SD= 0.55).
The calculated mean, SD and CV prove the view that among all the statements “ lack of
systematic planning for automation and digitization of university libraries” generated the
most positive response (CV=22.23).
4.1.2.7 Comparing advantages of digital/ electronic resources over conventional print
version of library resources
The librarians of public sector universities were asked to comment on the issue: “comparison
of advantages of digital/electronic resources over conventional print version of library
resources”. Five options were given to the respondents namely: strongly agree, agree,
uncertain, disagree and strongly disagree. They rated as per options and analysis has been
made on the basis of received responses. Table 4.42 shows the respondents’ opinion in this
regard.
111
Table 4.42- Comparing advantages of digital/ electronic resources over conventional
print version of library resources
Description Mean S.D C.V
1- It is not necessary to retain journals’ bound volumes 3 0.87 43.54
Even after the library has all the back volumes in
digital/electronic form or has access to them from
a digital repository
2- we can save a lot storage space by having resources
like journals’ back volumes, dissertations, reports in
electronic form 1 0.54 27.11
3- It saves substantial amount of money being spent on
maintenance(binding, cleaning, etc) of books ,
bound volumes by having them in electronic/ digital form 4 0.63 31.23
4- It is easy & convenient to conduct a search on
electronic resources 1 0.34 17.12
5- Electronic resources are not very expensive compared to
their print version. 4 0.45 22.56
6- It is better to procure an electronic version of a
book/ journal if its price is equal to or not much higher
than the print version 3 0.77 38.34
7- In this networked environment, electronic resources
achieve the objectives of resource sharing in a far better
way than print versions 2 0.38 19.67
8- Electronic resources require expensive infrastructure to
disseminate information contained in them 1 0.29 14.50
9- Despite being user friendly, it requires certain
degree of computer knowledge to get the maximum
benefit of these electronic resources 2 0.65 32.56
10- Electronic resources can be updated easily and
immediately in case of online sources. 2 0.35 17.50
112
11- Copyright is ignored/violated when using
electronic resources 2 0.39 19.44
12- As electronic devices are used to operate
electronic resources which are power dependent,
electricity failure act as a barrier. 1 0.55 27.32
______________________________________________________________________________________
Note: M-Mean, S.D- Standard Deviation, C.V- Coefficient of Variation
1-Strongly Agree, 2- Agree, 3-Uncertain, 4-Disagree, 5-Strongly Disagree
It was recorded that librarians strongly agreed with the statement: “electronic resources
require expensive infrastructure to disseminate information contained in them” (X=1; SD=
0.29). It is reported that librarians strongly agreed with the statement: “it is easy and
convenient to conduct a search on electronic resources” (X=1; SD=0.34). The respondents
also strongly agreed with the view that : “we can save a lot storage space by having resources
like journals’ back volumes, dissertations, reports in electronic form and as electronic devices
are used to operate electronic resources which are power dependent, electricity failure acts as
a barrier”( X=1; SD=0.54 & 0.55).
It has also been reported that librarians agreed with the statement: “electronic resources can
be updated easily and immediately in case of online sources” (X=2; SD=0.35). The
respondents agreed with the view that: copyright is ignored/violated when using electronic
resources (X=2; SD=0.39). The librarians agreed with the statement: “in this networked
environment, electronic resources achieve the objectives of resource sharing in a far better
way than print versions” (X=2; SD=0). The respondents also agreed that: “despite being user
friendly, it requires certain degree of computer knowledge to get the maximum benefit of
these electronic resources.”
However, the university librarians were uncertain about : “it is better to procure an electronic
version of a book/ journal if its price is equal to or not much higher than print version” and
“It is not necessary to retain journals bound volumes even after the library has all the back
volumes in digital/electronic form or has access to them from a digital repository” (X=2;
SD=0.77 & 0.87).
It has also been reported that respondents disagreed with the statements: “electronic resources
113
are not very expensive as compared to their print version” and “it saves substantial amount of
money being spent on maintenance (binding, cleaning, etc) of books, bound volumes to by
having them in electronic/ digital form” (X=4; SD=0.45 , 0.63).
The calculated mean, Standard Deviation (SD) and Co-efficient of Variation (CV) prove the
opinion that among all the statements “electronic resources require expensive infrastructure
to disseminate information contained in them” (CV=14.50), and “electronic resources can be
updated easily and immediately in case of online sources.” (CV=17.50) generated the most
positive responses.
Librarians' reply to an open ended question
The professional librarians were given an open ended question “Any other information /experience that you want to share about the impact of digital technology on library services and
resources?” at the end of the questionnaire. They were asked to express their views in this regard. They replied about the impact of emerging technologies on university library services and resources in the following manner. A total of 47 out of 61 university librarians responded to this question. Out of these 47,12 (26%) pointed out that they have access to modern library facilities like access to electronic books and scholarly journals, databases, Online Public Access Catalogue and other electronic tools. They opined that modern library technologies have positive impact on house keeping routines of information centres. They also expressed their views that insufficient finance, regular power break down and lack of interest of higher authorities are the main obstacles in the way of library modernization. They stressed on the provision of teleconferencing and Radio Frequency Systems.
11(23.41%) out of 47 respondents commented that modern technological skills of the
postgraduate students should be improved. Faculty members should emphasise on Library
and Information Science (LIS) postgraduate students to learn as how to access e-resources
and how to manage e-records? This can be an integral part of the course on information
storage and retrieval taught to LIS Masters’ students. It was also proposed that university
libraries should increase the awareness campaigns concerning the availability of electronic
resources. The use of e-mail alert system, text messages and prizes for those who use a lot of
e-resources should be encouraged by the university library as methods of promotion. There is
a need for regular and continuous review of the curriculum so as to incorporate new and
emerging areas especially in the area of modern library trends. Recruitment of IT trained LIS
faculty is also suggested by the library professionals. There is a serious and dire need of IT
based teaching staff in the LIS schools to provide the necessary technology –based training
needed in the 21st century.
114
It is observed from the interpretation of collected data that 08 (17%) out of 47 university
librarians demanded for a committee of library experts. They may determine the strategy for
the implementation of modern university library system. Their suggestions may be given due
attention for applying in the university libraries. Own publications including theses, research
journals and reports may be digitized and should be uploaded online for the general use.
06 (13%) out of 47 commented about HEC digital library. They suggested that the
bibliographical details of total collection especially theses and own journals placed at the
universities/ DAIs/ R and D organizations should be obtained by HEC digital library to avoid
duplication. The digitization of these materials should be carried out. Although this is a huge
project but once completed and implemented, it will achieve the goals like space, time, labour
and cost savings and avoiding duplication of resources. If that database was launched online,
it may provide round the clock availability to the users of all academic and other authorized
institutions. This effort will provide us the opportunity to sell our e-resources to other
organizations of the world and get a source of revenue for the country. This practice will also
give an opportunity to the researchers, faculty members and students to access the resources
of all university libraries. The concept of library without walls should be developed.
Copyright issues should be resolved with the fair use. The issue of security should be solved
with various security tools like firewall and encryption etc. Information literacy program of
HEC digital library should be made more effective. The librarians and end users should be
the targets of the program.
The respondents 02 (4.25%) out of 47 further commented that there is no digital library
policy in Pakistan. There is a dire need of a digital library policy in the country, which will
provide the library a chance to develop standard collection. The responses received from the
feedback of open ended question reveal that 04(8.5%) out of 47 responded librarians were of
the opinion that development and implementation of a uniform standard integrated library
software is the need of the day. They stressed that library standards used in university
libraries must be uniform. The librarians also urged that required modern technology be
provided to all university libraries of the country. The professionals be given periodic
trainings on these emerging library technologies.
Majority of the librarians working in the university libraries commented that the introduction
of emerging technologies in libraries will have positive impact on library and information
services and resources. They were also of the view that the online resources have solved
115
many problems of researchers, students and faculty members in their required literature
search.
From the expression and suggestions of 04(8.5 %) librarians out of 47, it is clear that they are
unable to implement emerging technologies in their university libraries due to non
availability of a uniform standard library software, required latest hardware and skilled
library personnel. They also stressed on the importance of digital technology in the area of
library operations.
User’s Survey
4. 2 Users' response towards the application and impact of digital technology on
university libraries.
The following are the details of the statistical analysis and interpretation of the data collected
from the library users through the structured questionnaire. The questionnaire distributed
among the users was to obtain information about the status of library users, purpose and
frequency of library visits by the users, use of library and information services/tools , rating
of the quantity and quality of the traditional learning resources in university libraries, opinion
about skills and expertise to use technology based services and resources, views about the
need for a workshop/orientation program in technology based services and resources, purpose
of internet use in the library and views about significant change in speed of academic/
research work by using digital library technologies. Finally, to find out to what extent they
are satisfied with this technology based services and resources.
4.2.1 General Information
Users were asked to indicate their status, i.e. whether the user is undergraduate student,
research scholar or teacher. Table 4.41 indicates the status wise distribution of university
library users. The users’ community of the universities include under graduate students,
teachers, research scholars and others.
Table 4.43-status of university library users
Status Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Undergraduate students/ 20 30 25 25 10 05 115
Postgraduate students
Research Scholars 18 30 20 20 10 03 101
Teachers 12 24 10 15 05 02 68
116
Other 05 06 05 05 00 00 21
Total 55 90 60 65 25 10 305
Note: Undergraduate/postgraduate students=B.A/M.A Research Scholar=MPhil, PhD
Table 4.43 shows that 115(38%) out of 305 are undergraduate students, 101(33%) out 305 are
research scholars, 68(23%) are teachers and 21(07%) are other users. The other users include
non-teaching staff of the universities.
It is observed that from all universities, a good number of users who responded are either
undergraduate students or research scholars.
Purpose of library visits by the users
The purpose of the university library visits by the users was obtained through a question with
various options. The users were also given the opportunity to indicate any other purpose. The
options were study, research, issue/ return/renew of books, use of OPAC, search of CD-ROM
databases, internet, access to HEC Digital Library and any other purpose. Table 4.44 shows
the purpose of library visits by the users of the university libraries.
Table 4.44-Purpose of library visits by the users
Purpose Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Study 25 48 51 57 21 08 210 Research 17 38 26 32 13 06 132 Borrow/return/renew of books 40 78 49 61 20 03 251 Use of OPAC 10 24 08 14 05 03 130 Search CD ROM 15 21 11 10 06 00 63 Internet 45 76 55 59 17 10 262 Access to HEC Digital Library 35 48 33 37 16 06 175 Any Other 18 09 11 13 07 00 58 ______________________________________________________________________________________
117
In Table 4.44 a majority of 262 (86%) out of 305 users visit the library for using internet. A
large number 251(82%) out of 305 users visit the library for issue/return/renew of books. A
good number 210 (69%) out of 305 users use the library for study purposes.
About 175(57%) out of 305 visit the library to access HEC Digital Library. Some of the users
132 (43%) out of 305) visit the library for research purposes and 130 (43%) of the patrons
visit the library for using OPAC.
Frequency of library visits by the users
This gives an idea about the use of library made by the users as well as how important the
library is to them. The following table explains:
Table 4.45-Frequency of library visits by the users
Frequency Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Daily 20 50 28 30 12 04 144
Alter native days 18 20 12 22 10 03 85
Once in three days 12 08 09 07 01 03 40
Once in a week 02 04 07 04 02 00 19
Once in a month 00 03 03 00 00 00 06
Rarely 03 05 01 02 00 00 11
Total 55 90 60 65 25 10 305
Table 4.45 reveals that majority of the users 144 (47%) out of 305 visit the library on a daily
basis. 85 (28%) out of 305 visit the library on alternate days. Some 40 (13%) of the users
visit once in three days. The rest of the users reported that they visit the library once in a
week (06%), once in a month (02%) and rarely (04%).
Average time spent by the users in the Library on a visit
The following table determines the average time spent by the users in the library on a visit.
118
Table 4.45-Average time spent by the users in the Library on a visit
Time spent Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Less than 30 minutes 20 35 23 20 08 03 109
Between 30 minutes
and Two Hours 29 45 27 38 11 06 156
Between 2 and 5 hours 03 06 05 03 04 00 21
More than 5 hours 03 04 05 04 02 01 19
______________________________________________________________________________________
Total 55 90 60 65 25 10 305
The users were asked to report that how much time they spend in the library on a visit. For
this purpose four options were given to the users to respond.
Table 4.45 shows that majority of the users 156(51%) out of 305 of the public sector
universities reported that they spend between 30 minutes and two hours in the library for
study, internet and other purposes.
About 109 (36%) out of 305 of users expressed that they spend less than 30 minutes on a
single visit to the university library. A few 21 (07%) out of 305 claimed that they spend
between 2 and 5 hours. A few 19(06%) out of 305 users spend more than 5 hours on a visit to
the library.
Thus a majority of the users spend between 30 minutes and two hours on a visit to a
university library.
4.2.2 Use of library and information services / resources/utilities/tools/devices received
used by the users
Users were asked whether they use any of the services/resources/utilities/tools/devices in
their university libraries. Table 4.45 shows the data related to the above services/resources.
119
Table 4.46- Use of library services/resources/utilities/tools/devices
Utilities Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Library services
Circulation 43 80 54 60 23 09 269
Reference 34 58 40 49 20 07 208
User education 40 79 49 43 16 08 235
Bulletin Board services 05 14 06 08 05 02 40
Photocopying 48 72 48 27 18 07 220
Printing 30 51 45 22 19 06 173
Any Other 15 12 09 08 11 02 57
Information services
Bibliographic services 36 34 24 31 16 07 148
Current Awareness services 23 22 12 10 09 02 78
Selective Dissemination of
Information (SDI) 16 14 09 12 08 00 59
Indexing/ abstracting services 19 24 13 13 11 03 83
Utilities/resources/devices
USB 50 67 39 48 21 07 232
DVD 25 34 27 11 13 04 114
VCD 20 33 08 07 08 00 76
Printer 30 51 45 22 19 06 173
Scanner 04 20 21 26 08 02 81
Smart card ---- --- ---- ---- ---- ---- 00
120
Laptop 14 07 03 06 00 00 30
Telnet 00 00 00 00 00 00 00
Table 4.47 shows that a large number of users 269 (88%) out of 305 reported that they are
visiting the university libraries for circulation purposes i,e for issue/ return/renew of library
documents.
235(77%) out of 305 opined that they receive user education about the various services and
resources of the university libraries.
A good number of users 220 (72%) out of 305 responded that they receive the facility of
photocopying in their libraries.
208(68%) out of 305 users reported that they use reference services in the library.
Some 173(58%) out of 305 users claimed availability of printing facilities in their libraries.
148 (49%) out of 305 of users visit the library to use bibliographical services. 68(24%) of
them are utilizing Selective Dissemination of Information services (SDI), Current Awareness
Services (CAS) and indexing and abstracting services.
When asked about the devices they use in the library, the respondents (users) were of the
opinion that majority 232 (76%) out of 305 of users were using Universal Serial Bus (USB)
for access and retrieval of information. A good number of users 173 (58%) out of 305 were
using printers in the libraries. Some 81 (27%) out of 305 were using scanners for digitization
of documents in the libraries. A very small number 30(10%) out of 305 users were using
laptop in the premises of university libraries.
4.2.3 Rating the quantity and quality of the traditional learning resources in university
libraries
Users were asked certain queries about the rating of quantity and quality of learning
resources. The users were given a five point scale (very good, good, uncertain, poor, very
poor) to choose the closest one. Table 4.48 indicates the above mentioned rating. Statistical
tools were used for the analysis of the data in this Table.
121
Table 4.48- Rating the quantity and quality of the traditional learning resources in university
libraries
Description Mean S.D C.V
Books 2 0.82 41.22
Reference Sources 2 0.65 32.50
Journals 2 1.30 65.12
Project Reports/Dissertation 3 1.24 41.33
Govt. Reports 4 1.03 25.75
Newspapers/Business dailies 1 0.56 56.00
Note: M-Mean, S.D- Standard Deviation, C.V- Coefficient of Variation
1-Strongly Agree, 2- Agree, 3-Uncertain, 4-Disagree, 5-Strongly Disagree
It is observed from Table 4.46 that users strongly agreed with the query “quality and quantity
of Newspaper/Business daily placed in the university libraries for general reading are up to
the satisfactory level of the users (X=1; SD=0.56). The users of the university libraries rated
the quality and quantity of reference sources of the university libraries as good (X=2;
SD=0.65). The users responded with the remarks that the quality and quantity of the books
placed for reading of the patrons inside the university libraries is good (X=2; SD=0.82). The
users rated the quality/quantity of journals as good (X=2; SD=1.30).
The users were uncertain about the usage of project reports/dissertations in their university
libraries (X=3; SD=1.24).
However, the users were not satisfied with the quality and quantity of government reports
placed in their university libraries.
From the calculated X, SD analysis and CV of Table 4.46 reveals that “quality and quantity
of the reference sources was rated good” has generated most positive response (CV= 32.50)
followed by “rating of books” (CV=41.22).
122
4.2.4 Analyses of attitude of users towards the application and impact of modern
library trends on university library services and resources
This section elaborates on the attitude of users towards emerging library technologies.
Users’ opinions about skills and expertise to use technology based services and
resources
Users were asked whether the expertise and skills you have, are adequate for the utilization of
emerging library technologies or not? They were given the options of more adequate,
adequate and inadequate. The users were asked to opt for the level of expertise they have.
The following Table shows the users’ opinions in this regard.
Table 4.49- Users’ opinion about skills and expertise to use technology based services
and resources
Geographical zone More adequate Adequate Inadequate Total
Islamabad 15 (27%) 30(55%) 10(18%) 55
KPK 10(15%) 28(43%) 27(42%) 65
Balochistan 05(20%) 10(40%) 10(40%) 25
Sindh 10(17%) 30(50%) 20(33%) 60
Punjab 20(22%) 40(44%) 30(34%) 90
AJK & NA 02(20%) 04(40%) 04(40%) 10
Total 62(20%) 142(79%) 101(33%) 305
Chi-square test value=15.51
Chi-Square test was used to point out whether there is any dependency in the opinion of users
on the universities of specific geographical zone about the skills and expertise to use
technology based services and resources or not?. The calculated value of Chi-Square test was
found to be significant at 5 per cent level indicating that there exists dependency between the
variables.
A few 62 (20%) out of 305 recorded that they have more adequate approach towards the use
123
of modern library services and resources.
A majority of 242 (79%) out of 305 library users indicated that their skills and expertise are
adequate for the use of technology based services and resources.
Some 101(33%) out of 305 have reported inadequacy about their skill and expertise in the use
of technology based services and resources.
Table 4.49 shows that a few 15(27%) out of 55 users in Islamabad reported that they have
more adequate skills and expertise about the use of technology based services and resources.
About half 30 (55%) out of 55 of the users in the capital city of Islamabad claimed adequate
approach towards the usage of modern library procedures.
In KPK, only 10(15%) out of 65 users have claimed more adequacy in skills and expertise for
the use of technology based services and resources in their respective university libraries.
28(43%) out of 65 users in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa reported that they have adequate skills for
the technology based services and resources. The rest of the users reported that they have
inadequate skills and expertise in this field.
In Balochistan, a few 5(20%) out of 25 reported that they have more adequate skill in this
area.
A good number 10 (40%) out of 25 of library users have claimed adequate skills for using
modern library technologies.
The rest of the users reported that they have inadequate skills for this modern library
practices.
A few library users 10 (17%) out of 60 in Sindh reported that they have more adequate skills
in this connection.
About half 30(50%) out of 60 of the library users in Sindh claimed adequate skills for the
usage of technology based services and resources.
20(33%) out of 60 reported inadequate skills for the usage of modern library technologies.
In Punjab, 20(22%) out of 90 more adequate approach towards the usage of emerging library
technologies,
40(44%) out of 90 reported adequate approach,
The rest of the users opined that they have inadequate skills for the use of modern library
procedures.
124
The Library clientele at AJK and NA university libraries reported that 02(20%) have more
adequate skills, 04(40%) out of 10 have adequate skills and 04(40%) out of 10 have
inadequate skills about the usage of modern library procedures.
User's opinion about the need for a workshop/orientation program in technology- based
services and resources
To ascertain the need for workshop/orientation in technology based services and resources,
users had been asked as to whether they "agree", "disagree", or are "uncertain"? Table 4.50
shows the users’ opinion about the need for orientation/workshop.
Table 4.50 –Users’ opinion about training/orientation
Geographical Zone Agree Disagree Uncertain Total
Islamabad 50(91%) 05(9%) 00(00%) 55
KPK 58(89%) 04(06%) 03(05%) 65
Balochistan 21(84%) 02(08%) 02(08%) 25
Sindh 55(92%) 03(05%) 02(03%) 60
Punjab 83(92%) 05(6%) 02(2%) 90
AJK&NA 08(80%) 01(10%) 01(10%) 10
Total 267(89%) 19(07%) 9(04%) 305
Chi-Square value=15.51
Whether or not there is any dependency in the opinion of users on the university libraries of
specific geographical zone about the need for a workshop/ orientation program in technology
based services and resources? The calculated value of Chi-Square test was found to be
significant at 5 per cent level indicating that there exists dependency between the variables.
Table 4.48 reveals that 267 (89%) out of 305 library users agreed with the statement that they
need training programs on emerging library technologies. Only 19(07%) out of 305 library
users disagreed with the view that there is a need of trainings/ workshop on modern library
trends.
125
A majority of library users in Islamabad, Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa , Balochistan
and Azad Jammu, Kashmir and Northern Areas have felt an intense need of
training/workshop programs for refining of their modern library skills.
Purpose of internet usage in the library
I.Luambano and Nawe (2004)3 discuss that with the help of internet, scholars in different
positions can share their ideas and views. It has reduced the distances and made the world a
global village.
Internet services under usage have been listed in the questionnaire as “study” , “research”,
“collection of general information”, “recreational”, “communication”, “accessing HEC
digital library” and “any other”. An option has also been placed in the question about “not
using internet". Internet usage is given in Table 4.51.
Table 4.51 -Purpose of internet use
Purpose of internet Islamabad Punjab Sindh KPK Balochistan AJK&NA Total
Study 20(36%) 25(28%) 14(25%) 19(29%) 04(16%) 02(20%) 84(28%)
Research 20(36%) 35(39%) 27(45%) 31(47%) 11(44%) 05(50%) 129(42%)
Collection of general
Information 02((3.6%) 10(11%) 09(15%) 05(8%) 02(8%) 01(10%) 29(09%)
Recreational 03(5.4%) 04(4.4%) 02(3.3%) 04(7%) 02(8%) 01(10%) 16(5.5%)
Communication 04(7.2%) 04((4.4%) 03(5%) 03(5%) 02(8%) 00(00%) 16(5.5%)
Access of HEC
Digital library 05(08%) 12(13%) 03(5%) 03(5%) 03(12%) 01(10%) 27(8.8%)
Any others 01(02%) 00(0%) 02(3.3%) 00(0%) 01(4%) 00(0%) 04(1.3%)
Total 55(18%) 90(30%) 60(20%) 65(21%) 25(8%) 10(3%) 305
Chi- Square test value=8.26
Chi-Square test is used to point out whether or not there is any dependency in the opinion of
users on the universities of specific geographical zone about the purpose of internet usage in
126
the university libraries? The calculated value of Chi-Square test was found to be significant at
5 per cent level indicating that there exists dependency between the variables.
It is observed from the analysis of the data that majority 129 (42%) out of 305 users are
using internet for research purposes in the university libraries.
A good number 84(28%) out of 305 users are using internet facility for study purposes in
their respective libraries.
27 (8.8%) out of 305 library clientele reported that they are using internet to access HEC
Digital Library.
29 (09%) out of 305 library users are using internet for browsing of general information.
It is also observed that majority of the university library users in Islamabad, Khyber
Pakhtunkhwa, Sindh, Punjab, Balochistan and AJK&NA are using internet facilities for study
and research purposes.
4.2.5 Users’ opinion about significant change in speed of academic/ research work by
using digital library technology
Users were asked to indicate whether there is a significant change in the speed of
academic/research work by using digital library technologies by giving the options of "highly
significant", "significant", or "not significant". Table 4.50 indicates the distribution of users
according to the query mentioned above.
Table 4.52-Users’ opinion about significant change in speed of academic/ research work
Geographical Zone Highly significant Significant Not significant Total
Islamabad 40(73%) 15(27%) 00 55
KPK 53(82%) 12(18%) 00 65
Balochistan 19(76%) 06(24%) 00 25
Sindh 41(68%) 19(32%) 00 60
Punjab 78(87%) 12(13%) 00 90
AJK &NA 07(70%) 03(30%) 00 10
Total 238(78%) 67(23%) 00 305
127
The Table 4.52 shows that majority 238(78%) out of 305 library users reported that a rapid
increase in the pace of research and academic work in universities has been noticed with the
emergence of latest technologies.
Some 67 (23%) out of 305 library users declared the increase in speed of academic or
research work as significant. Majority of the respondents from Islamabad, Punjab, Sindh,
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Balochistan and AJK and NA have declared the speed of
research/academic work as more significant with the application of modern library
technologies in the public sector universities of Pakistan.
4.2.6 Users’ feedback to an open ended query
The different views expressed by the users about the application and impact of modern
library technologies on library resources and services are grouped and processed. 160
comments were given by the users. 25 (15.62 %) out of 160 demanded for more PCs with
high internet speed connection in the premises of the library.
12(7.5%) out of 160 users demand a strong relationship between faculty members and
librarians, so that teachers may be able to inform the students about new arrivals of the
library.
36 (22.5%) out of 160 users need modern user- education program. This program should lay
emphasis on the proper use of the information centres, importance of reference sources, use
of e-resources, emerging library technologies and the relation of student and librarian
13(8%) out of 160 library readers request that the library users should be treated with respect
and they should be made to feel important.
18(11.25%) out of 160 users recommend that attitude of library staff towards them should
be friendly. There should be some attraction for the students to use a library. Some of
the users 16 (10%) out of 160 suggested that small in-depth interviews with users may be
conducted to know the real problems faced by them.
6 (4 %) users made a demand for the digitization of documents.
23 (14.34%) stated that they are satisfied with accessibility and importance of electronic
resources. 7(4.5%) out of 160 users demanded for more rapid updating of e-books and e-
journals repositories.
128
Majority 156 (98%) out of 160 users commented that the digital technology has a positive
impact on library services and resources and emergence of modern library trends have helped
them in proper utilization of university libraries.
129
References
1 Bello, A.S. (2003). Library user education evaluation at the Ibadan Polytechnic.
Nigerian Library and Information Science Review 21(1):1-6. Retrieved
from: http://www.answers.com/topic/librarian#Technology_in_libraries Accessed on
20/11/2010
2 Shafiullah, Farasat and Stephen A. Robert (2010). Is ICT Infrastructure capable to
accommodate standardized library management systems? : Case studies of library
automation from public sector universities in Islamabad (Pakistan). Technology,
Policy and Innovation. 273-280
3 Luambano, I., & Nawe, J. (2004). Internet use by the students of the University of
Dar-us- Salaam. Library Hi Tech News. No. 10, 13-17.
130
CHAPTER FIVE
SUMMARY OF THE FINDINGS AND SUGGESTIONS
This chapter provides a summary of the major findings of the research study and
suggestions for improving the technology- based infrastructure in public sector
university libraries in Pakistan.
5.1 Summary of the major findings
Digital technology has a tremendous impact on library services and resources.
Application of emerging technologies on university libraries is an interesting
subject of library and information science research. The present investigation has
achieved its aim, in that it has given a summary of the impact and application of
digital technology in public sector university libraries. The major findings of the
study are the following:
5.1.1 General information
1. 45 percent Public Sector Universities (PSU) of the country have been established
after year 2000. It has also been noted that at the time of Independence of
Pakistan in 1947, there existed only two universities in the country, namely
University of the Punjab and University of Sindh.
2. Public sector university libraries of federal capital Islamabad (100%) have gone
far ahead in library modernization followed by the province of Punjab (95%) as
compared with the other provinces of the country.
69 percent university libraries in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and
67 percent in Sindh are automated or in the process of automation.
The situation regarding automation is not satisfactory in Balochistan.
60 percent university libraries are not automated in Balochistan.
131
3. On personal visits to the digital section of the university libraries in the country, it
was found out that in 54% university libraries , 100 number of users use this
section on a daily basis,
While in 21% university libraries, 100 to 200 users use this section on a daily
basis and in 25% university libraries, more than 200 users visit this section per
day.
5.1.2 Library services
4. All the university libraries offer basic library services (circulation, reference, and
new arrivals’ lists) to their readers. 67 percent university libraries offer Selective
Dissemination of Information (SDI), Current Awareness Services (CAS) and
Newspapers’ Clipping Services.
5. Majority i.e 93 percent public sector university libraries in the country are using
Dewey Decimal Classification (DDC) for the classification of library documents
and that the librarians of the public sector universities are satisfied with the
classification scheme they are using.
6. 92 percent university libraries are using Anglo American Cataloguing Rules-2
(AACR-2) Revised edition (2002) for the cataloguing of their library materials
and the university librarians are satisfied with AACR-2 Revised edition is being
used for the cataloguing of library collection.
7. 96 percent of the public sector university libraries of the country are providing
free internet facilities to their users: the detail are as under:
46 percent university libraries have less than 100 megabytes per second
(mbps) internet speed,
46 percent have equal to 100 mbps speed and
8 percent university libraries have more than 100 mbps internet speed.
With the advent of internet, the pace of research has also increased rapidly.
8. 61 percent public sector university libraries provide user education on modern
library trends to their users while 39% have no such program of educating the
users.
62 percent librarians reported that they provide user education in the
132
beginning of the academic year,
19 percent librarians claim that they provide this service in the beginning of
every semester and the same number of librarians responded that they
provide user education as per request.
All those who responded were of the opinion that user education
program has a positive impact on the use of library services and resources.
5.1.3 Library Resources
9. 56 percent public sector university libraries of the country have less than or equal
to 50000(fifty thousand) learning resources.
21 percent the university libraries have library collection ranging from 50001-
100000,
16 percent university libraries have library materials ranging from 100001-
200000 and only four (7%) university libraries have more than 200,000
learning resources in their library premises.
10. 75 percent public sector university libraries have purchased less than or equal to
50 research journals, while 25 percent university libraries reported that they are
subscribing to more than 50 research journals.
76 percent public sector university libraries are purchasing less than or equal to
10 daily newspapers for the general readings of their readers, while 24 percent
subscribe to more than 10 daily newspapers for their users.
79 percent university libraries reported that there are no manuscripts in their
libraries. 13 percent libraries reported less than or equal to 200 manuscripts
and only 5 university libraries reported having more than 200 manuscripts in
their collection.
11. All the public sector university libraries are availing the services of HEC National
Digital Library (which has 75,000 electronic contents. These contents include
peer-reviewed journals, databases, articles and e-books).
133
12. 56 percent public sector university libraries have human resources between 1-10
workforce, 28 percent university libraries have more than 20 staff members for
the operation of their library functions and 16 percent have human resources
ranging from 11-20.
There is a total of 1196 library staff in the university libraries (central libraries
only) under study.
30 percent are professional and 7 percent are para-professional staff members,
60 percent are non-professionals and 3 percent are the staff reserved for
automation and digitization.
Not a single university librarian holds a PhD degree. There are only 06(1.4%)
MPhil degree holders out of 422 total professional and para-professional
library staff in the country.
68 percent university librarians possess Masters’ Degree in Library and
Information Science (MLISc),
14 percent library professionals have Bachelor in Library Science (BLISc) also
known as Post Graduate Diploma in Library and Information Science (PGD-
LISc).
18 percent library staff is Certificate holders in Library and Information
Science (CLISc).
13. All university librarians of Islamabad, Punjab, Sindh, KPK, Balochistan and AJK
& NA are of the opinion that training on modern library technologies have a
positive impact on smooth operation of university libraries and library
professionals. It was suggested that the incharge of automation and digitization
section must have Masters Degree in Library and Information Science in addition
to Masters’ Degree in Computer Science (CS) or Information Technology (IT) or
Diploma in IT.
14. 72 percent university libraries have an average annual budget of less than Rs five
million.
15 percent university libraries have an annual budget ranging from Rs 5m-
134
10m.
Only 6(10%) out of 61university libraries have library budget ranging from
11m-15m. Only two (3%) university libraries namely COMSATS Institute of
IT Islamabad and University of Engineering and Technology each have
an annual average budget ranging from Rs 16m-20m
15. 93.4 percent university libraries reported that there is no separate budget for the
modernization of their university libraries.
Only one (1.6%) public sector university library namely International Islamic
University Islamabad has been allocated Rs one million budget separately for
automation of library functions. Three (5%) public sector universities i.e.,
COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, Pir Mehr Ali Shah (PMAS)
University of Arid Agriculture Rawalpindi and Lahore University of
Engineering and Technology have more than Rs one million annual budget for
the implementation of emerging library technologies in their respective
libraries.
16. 96 percent librarians reported that they are not satisfied with the present
allocation of budget for automation purposes of their libraries. They have
mentioned that there is a need for a separate budget for automation and
digitization program.
5 percent university librarians have opted below 10 percent of the total library
budget for library automation.
30 percent university librarians have opted for 10 to 20 percent of total library
budget for library automation.
Half of the population of the university librarians have opted for 21 to 30
percent of total budget for the automation purposes of their university libraries.
5 percent university librarians have opted for 30 to 40 percent of total library
budget.
3 percent university librarians have opted for more than 40 percent of the total
library budget.
135
7 percent university librarians are satisfied and have no demand for more
budget allocation for the automation and digitization of their respective
university libraries.
5.1.4 Technology- based resources
17. 57 percent public sector university libraries have computers from 1-15,
31 percent university libraries have 16-50 computers and
12 percent university libraries have more than 50 computers.
72 percent university libraries have 1 to 3 printers in their libraries,
9 percent have more than 3 printers in their respective libraries,
9 percent reported that they have no printer in the premises of their libraries.
72 percent librarians reported that the university libraries have no digital
camera, 25 percent do have digital cameras from 1 to 3.
Only 02(3%) university libraries claimed of having more than 3 digital
cameras for the digitization of library documents.
18. 55 percent university libraries have UPS/Generator to cope with the electricity
failure problems, while 45 percent have no such facility.
82 percent universities have no Radio Frequency Systems (RF) for the
implementation of modern library technologies in their respective libraries.
The remaining 18 percent university libraries reported that Radio Frequency
System is available in the premises of their libraries.
48 percent automated public sector university libraries are using Library and
Information Management System (LIMS) for the operation of library
functions.
19 percent automated university libraries are using Koha as integrated library
software,
136
15 percent university libraries are using WINISIS (CDS/ISIS for Windows) for
automation of library procedures,
6 percent have Library Automation and Management Program (LAMP) and
12 percent are using different integrated library softwares like Academic
Management System (AMS) used by Institute of Space Technology Islamabad,
Library Manager (LM) by Pakistan Institute of Engineering & Applied
Sciences (PIEAS) Islamabad, UET- Libas by University of Engineering and
Technology Taxila, Alice for Windows by National College of Arts Lahore,
Virtua by Fatima Jinnah Woman University Rawalpindi and Hazara University
Mansehra Khyber Pukhtoonkhwa.
19. 39 percent automated university libraries have completed more than 80% of their
library automation process and have developed data bases for their library
holdings.
30 percent libraries are in the process of automation and have fed about
51- 80% of their library collection into their computers.
31 percent automated university libraries have entered below 50% of their
documents into their computer systems.
20. 92 percent university libraries have no separate library websites. The libraries of
these universities are uploaded in the main home page of the university as a
hyper link.
Only 8 percent university libraries namely COMSATS Institute of Information
Technology Islamabad; UET Lahore; Punjab University Lahore; Nadirshaw
Edulji Dinshaw (NED) UET Karachi; and University of Karachi have their
own separate websites. These websites contain general information related to
their respective libraries, rules and regulations, staff details, services, resources
and OPAC etc.
137
5.1.5 Physical resources
21. The Librarians of the public sector university libraries reported that space
reserved for reading in their respective university libraries is adequate as per
international standards. They also pointed out that the furniture/ seating
arrangements of these university libraries are as good as with the furniture/
seating arrangements of a modern university library. These libraries also have
adequate facilities of printing/ softcopy as compared with a modern university
library. They were also of the opinion that university libraries have photocopying
facilities as per modern university library standards. They also commented that
lighting/ventilation system of the public sector university libraries is up to the
international standards. It is concluded that the university libraries have good
seating arrangement, proper ventilation /lighting system; enough reading area for
readers, need based softcopy /printing facilities and photocopy facilities in their
premises. However the situation regarding the provision of research
cubicles/cabins and building safety is not up to the mark.
5.2 Digital technology and university library services and resources
22. Most of the respondents reported that technology-based library services are
better than manual services. They occupy lesser space, they are accurate, can be
provided in no time, can be provided round the clock and can be tailor- made for
specific purposes.
23. Librarians agreed with the statement that emerging library technologies have a
positive impact on cataloguing of documents, information retrieval and circulation
control. Librarians also agreed that modern technology has positive impact on
stock verification, use of electronic Dewey Decimal Classification (e-DDC) and
Online Public Access Catalogue (OPAC). Therefore, we may safely conclude that
technology based library services have a positive impact on library house keeping
routines and technical processing of library documents.
24. Librarians agreed that digital technology applications have improved the
138
efficiency of the library. Emerging digital technologies have improved the
knowledge and expertise of the library professionals. University librarians agreed
that digital technology applications have increased the regular budgeting of the
university libraries. However, librarians are uncertain whether digital technology
takes over the traditional way of information handling or not? However, librarians
disagreed with the view that DT reduces the work load of the library
professionals.
25. There was a unanimous view on the statements: networking of university libraries
will help in avoiding duplication of catalogue entries; will be able to enhance
resource sharing; library services will be standardized and will help in building
standard collection.
26. University librarians agreed more consistently that users need user- education to
fully utilize technology based information services and they maintained that
computers and other equipment are always in good condition.
Librarians also agreed that the library staff is able to train in emerging library
technologies and users give preference to electronic resources as against
manual printed version of a document.
27. University librarians are of the general opinion that financial constraint and
copyright (for digitization of documents) are the barriers in the way of adopting
emerging library technologies. University librarians agreed with the statement that
lack of systematic planning for automation and digitization, provision of internet
facilities, internet speed, information technology infrastructure, security and
professional skills are the main barriers to the implementation of modern library
technologies. It was observed that librarians were uncertain about the statement
that the will/motivation of the university librarians towards modern library trends
which tends to be slack and slow.
28. There was a complete agreement among the librarians about the two queries:
139
- electronic resources need expensive tools to access required information
- electronic devices are used to operate electronic resources which are power
dependent, so electricity failure does also act as a barrier.
29. Librarians agreed with the statement that updating of electronic resources is more
easy and time saving. Electronic resources have achieved the objectives of
resource sharing through networking. Although these resources are user friendly,
but need some basic computer knowledge to get the maximum benefit.
30. Librarians were of the general opinion that modern technological skills of the
students should be improved. Faculty members should lay emphasis on LIS
postgraduate students to learn how to access e-resources and how to manage e-
records. This should be an integral part of the course on Information Storage and
Retrieval taught at the MLISc Degree Program. They suggested that practical
problems of modern trends should be targeted through research by Library and
Information Science schools as well as by regular publication of Pakistan Library
Association (PLA) and LIS academia research papers. It was also pointed out that
university libraries should increase their awareness campaigns concerning the
availability of electronic resources.
31. University librarians reported that the use of e-mail alert system, text messages
and prizes for those who make frequent use of e-resources should be considered
by the university libraries as incentive and promotion of use of library resources.
Cell phone short message services should also be introduced in library electronic
resources services. Encouragement to students through academic staff for
promotion of the use of electronic resources be given.
32. The librarians emphasized on the recruitment of IT trained LIS faculty. There is a
serious and dire need of IT based teaching staff in the LIS schools to provide the
necessary technology –based training needed in the 21st century. It is also
necessary that regular and continuous review of the curriculum be made so as to
140
incorporate new and emerging knowledge especially in the area of modern library
trends.
33. The university librarians suggested that a committee representing experts and
skilled professionals be constituted, who may suggest strategies for developing
the modern university library system for Pakistan and give recommendations
relating to the operation of automated university libraries, including requirements
of infrastructure, software, training and skills. It was also suggested that present
policies should be revised and re-designed to lay stress on the provision of
digitized publications and development of modern library systems.
34. The librarians are of the view that the bibliographical details of total collection
especially theses and own journals placed at the universities/ DAIs/ R& D
organizations should be obtained by HEC digital library to avoid duplication. The
digitization of these materials should be carried out. Although this is a huge
project but once completed and implemented, it will achieve the goals like saving
space, time, labour and cost savings. Moreover, it will improve the efficiency and
bring about effective services for the users. If that database was launched online,
it may provide round the clock availability to the users of all academic and other
authorized institutions. It would multiply accessed source of information. This
effort will provide the opportunity to sell e-resources to other organizations of the
world and get a source of revenue for the country. This practice will also give an
opportunity to the researchers, faculty members and students to utilize the
collection of all university libraries. The concept of library without four walls be
developed. The issue of security be solved with various security tools like firewall
and encryption etc.
35. A few librarians commented that user education program of HEC digital library
should be boosted. The librarians and end users should be the target of the
program. The respondents further commented that there is no digital library policy
in Pakistan. There is an urgent need of digital library policy in the country which
will give the library a target to develop useful collection of library materials.
141
36. The librarians are of the opinion that development and implementation of uniform
standard integrated library software was necessary. They stressed that library
standards used in university libraries must be uniform. The librarians also urged
that required modern technologies be provided to all university libraries of the
country. The professionals be given periodic training on these emerging library
technologies.
37. Majority of the librarians working in the university libraries of the country are of
the view that the introduction of emerging technologies in libraries has a positive
impact on library and information services and resources. They are also of the
view that the online resources have solved many problems of researchers, students
and faculty members in their requisite literature search. They also highlighted that
digital technology is important for providing standard information to the readers
in short span of time.
5.3 Users’ response towards the application and impact of emerging technologies on
university libraries.
38. It was revealed that users’ community of the universities include under- graduate
students, research scholars and teachers. The other users include non-teaching
staff of the universities.
39. 86 percent users visit the library for using internet,
82 percent users visit the library for issue/return/renew of books,
69 percent of users use the library for study purposes,
57 percent users visit the library to access HEC digital library,
43 percent users’ visit the library for research purposes and an equal number
visit the library for using of OPAC.
47 percent users visit the library on a daily basis.
28 percent library users visit on alternate days.
142
13 percent users visit once in three days.
The rest of the users (12%) reported that they visit the library once in a week,
once in a month or rarely.
40. 57 percent users of the public sector universities reported that they spend
between 30 minutes to two hours in the library for study and internet.
36 percent users expressed that they spend less than 30 minutes on a single visit to
the university library.
7 percent claimed that they spend between 2 to 5 hours. 6 percent users spend
more than 5 hours on a visit to the library.
41. 88 percent users from the public sector universities reported that they are visiting
the university libraries for circulation purposes i,e for issue/ return/renew of
library documents.
77 percent opined that they receive user education about the various services and
resources of the university libraries under study.
72 percent users responded that they receive the facility of photocopying in their
libraries.
68 percent users reported that they utilize reference services in the library.
76 percent users are using Universal Serial Bus (USB) for access and retrieval of
information in the university libraries.
42. 49 percent users are visiting the library to use bibliographical services.
19 percent are on the list of Selective Dissemination of Information services
(SDI),
26 percent are availing Current Awareness Services (CAS) as well as indexing
and abstracting services.
58 percent are using printers in the libraries.
27 percent are using scanners for digitization of documents in the libraries.
10 percent are using laptops in the premises of the university libraries.
43. Users were of the general view regarding the query “quality and quantity of
143
newspapers/business dailies placed in the university libraries for general reading
were satisfactory. The users of the university libraries rated the quality and
quantity of reference sources of the university libraries as good. The users
responded with the remarks that the quality and quantity of the books placed for
reading/borrowing purposes of the patrons inside the university libraries are good.
The users rated the journals as good. The users were uncertain about the usage of
project reports/dissertations and government reports in their university libraries.
44. Users made a general demand for more PCs in the library building. They also
wanted increase in the speed of internet.
45. Users requested for a more modern user education program. This practice should
be introduced in all the institutions of higher learning in the universities of
Pakistan. The training session to focus on importance of libraries of emerging
library technologies and requisite skills for using these.
46. Users recommended that libraries should be appealing and attractive. Users
suggested that small interviews with readers be conducted to know the real
problems faced by the users.
47. Users agreed that there is a highly significant change in the speed of academic and
research work by using digital library technologies.
48. Users reported that browsing of e-resources have satisfied their information
needs. Users requested for regular updating of databases.
49. Most of the readers commented that the digital technology has a positive impact
on library services and resources and the emergence of modern library trends have
helped them in proper utilization of university libraries.
144
5.4 Suggestions for improving university library and information services and
resources on modern lines
On the basis of the findings arrived at, the following are some of the suggestions
that will help in the improvement of public sector university libraries of
Islamabad, Punjab, Sindh, KPK, Balochistan, Azad Jammu & Kashmir and
Northern Areas.
1. Collections of the university libraries should be developed in a
balanced manner giving due share to digital resources also. University
libraries should make efforts in making available their collections
(especially specialized collections/local journals, rare archival
material, theses, local government reports etc) on their websites to
share their resources with the other university libraries. Libraries
should invest in developing library home pages to provide web-based
services to their readers. In order to fulfil the deficiency of collection
and to quench the information thirst of the users, they may be given
access to the HEC digital library.
2. In order to provide standard and effective information services to the
users, university libraries need appropriate funding. The allocation of
reasonable budget should be made available to the university libraries
for obtaining required hardware and software. Modern library trends
require more finance. Therefore a special budget may be reserved for
the automation and modernization of university libraries. A separate
budget should be reserved for the automation and digitization of
university libraries. It is suggested that 30 percent of the total library
budget may be allocated for the implementation of modern library
technologies. Well-defined planning for the utilization and
categorization of this budget be given due importance.
3. University libraries should have latest computer systems, printers,
scanners, Bar Code Readers, DVD writers and CD Writers etc. It is
essential to have a good integrated multilingual latest version software.
145
To protect the computers from virus attack, active latest version anti-
virus software is also available and need to protect automated system.
4. Development and implementation of uniform standard integrated
library software is absolutely necessary. The standards used in
university libraries must be uniform. It is also recommended that
required modern technologies be provided to all the university libraries
of the country. The professionals be given periodic training on these
emerging library technologies.
5. Electricity failure is a major obstacle to the smooth operation of
emerging library technologies. To resolve this issue, the provision of a
powerful Un-interrupted Power Supply or generator be installed in the
premises of the library.
6. A modern library website is a more useful tool for providing latest
information to the readers without the space and time restrictions. In
Pakistan, separate university library websites are far and few. The
libraries are linked with the main home pages of the university
websites. It is recommended that separate websites be designed for
each university library of the country.
7. The manpower in university libraries should be skilled in emerging library
technologies. The selection and appointment of IT human resource, research
and professional development programs in modern technologies are
indispensible tools for the development of expert and professionally sound
library professionals.
8. It is suggested that recruitment of IT trained LIS faculty is the need of the
day. There is a serious and dire need of IT based teaching staff in the LIS
Departments to provide the necessary technology-based training needed in
the 21st century. There is also a need for regular and continuous review of
the curriculum so as to incorporate new and emerging areas in library trends.
146
9. It is suggested that the librarians should receive the users with open arms.
The behaviour of the librarians should be user-friendly. Small interviews
with users are also helpful to tackle the problems of the readers. Certain
techniques like e-mail alert system, text messages and rewards for the
frequent and potential library users should be taken into consideration by the
library personnel as this method can promote and encourage the readers and
reading habits.
10. HEC digital library staff should train the librarians of the central libraries of
the universities in introducing new library tools. The skills of these
librarians may be developed in such a manner that they may be able to teach
users how to search /browse for e-information, evaluate their validity, and
make use of these resources. The librarians should be expert in creation and
usage of digital libraries. It is suggested that library professionals with
sound computer background should be recruited so as to assist the computer
professionals working in HEC Digital Library.
11. In order to exploit all the available resources of all the university libraries, a
comprehensive and effective network system should be developed. This
practice will improve the services, role and performance of the libraries.
This system will be also helpful in avoiding duplication of cataloguing
entries.
12. Keeping in view the limited resources of the university libraries, it is
suggested that all the available library materials (theses, own journals,
manuscripts, rare materials and other specialized collection) should be
digitized. By doing so, we will be able to have access to vast amount of
literature and to raise the standard of our libraries to international level and
ultimately this will enable us to create a room for our library resources in
international market and thus we can bring a source of revenue like other
147
digital library systems of the world. Moreover, the current problems of
space and security will be rooted out and the concept of library without
walls will take deeper roots. The said project will indeed cost a lot as it
needs huge financial resources, but once it gets completed, it will be a
source of learning for our students, research scholars and teachers.
13. In order to reach the destination of digitization of our libraries at the national
level, it is suggested that a committee of relevant professionals be
constituted. The responsibility of the committee will be as under:
To critically analyse the existing digital library policies of the
world especially in the developing countries;
Keeping in view the outcome of the analysis, a digital library
policy be framed;
To fix standards for hardware, software and other relevant
parameters as per requirements of a modern digital library;
To frame laws for the prevention of cyber crimes like hacking and
copyright violations and unauthorized access of e- resources
14. To put the public sector university libraries on modern library trends,
maximum opportunities as well as resources be provided to all the libraries
of the country. The provinces of Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Balochistan
and AJK & NA should be given preference by providing more financial
grants for the modernization of their university libraries.
It is safely concluded that modern library services and resources are better than
manual services and resources. Islamabad and Punjab are far ahead in
modernization of university libraries as compared to Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa,
Balochistan and Azad Jammu and Kashmir & Northern Areas. Digital technology
has a positive impact on university library services and resources. It has enhanced
the image and effectiveness of the university libraries.
148
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Abbot, Wendy & Mark Sutherland. (2008) Transforming the library for the new
millennium. Presented at the VALA2008 14th Biennial Conference and
Exhibition, 5-7 February, Melbourne, Australia. Available at:
http://www.valaconf.org.au/vala2008/papers2008/54 Abbott Final.pdf
Abubakar, Bappah Magaji (2011). Academic libraries in Nigeria in the 21st
Century .Library Philosophy and Practice. Retrieved from:
http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/~mbolin/abubakar.htm
Adegbore, A.M (2010). Automation in two Nigerian university libraries. Library
Philosophy and Practice.
Retrieved from: http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/~mbolin/adegbore.pdf
Ajmal Khan, Muhammad and Khalid Mahmood (2010). A study of the usefulness
of Pakistan Library Automation Group's (PakLAG) services. Library
Philosophy and Practice. Retrieved from:
http://unllib.unl.edu/LPP/khan-mahmood.htm
Ahmad, Pervez and Mohd Yaseen (2009). The role of library and information
science professionals as manager: a comparative analysis. Electronic
Journal of Academic and Special Librarianship. 10(3).
http://southernlibrarianship.icaap.org/content/v10n03/ahmadpo1.html
Ahsan, Muhammad. (2009). Digital divide and digitization initiatives in Pakistan
:a bird’s eye view. Nuova Cultura. p. 515 Retrieved from:
http://conferences.aepic.it/index.php/elpub2009/paper/v iewfile/78/34
Aina, L.O (2004). Coping with the challenges of library and information delivery
services: the need for institutionalized professional development. Nigerian
149
Library Association Conference Proceedings, p.4
Ali, Amjad, (2005). Digital libraries in making. New Delhi. Ess Ess
Publications.p.419
Al-Qalaf, Charlene L. (2006). Librarians and technology in academic and
research libraries in Kuwait: perceptions and effects. Libri, vol. 56, 168–
179
Ameen, Kanwal (2008). Barriers in collection sharing among libraries of
Pakistan: university library managers’ viewpoint. LIBRES Library and
Information Science Research Electronic Journal, 18( 1).
Retreived from: http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/~mbolin/ameen.html
Ameen, Kanwal (2008). Issues of book acquisition in university libraries: a case
study of Pakistan. Library Philosophy and Practice. Retrieved from:
http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/~mbolin/ameen.html
Ansari, Munira Nasreen and Bushra Adeeb Zuberi. (2010). Use of electronic
resources among academics at the University of Karachi. Library
Philosophy and Practice Retreived from:
http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/~mbolin/ansari-zuberi.pdf
Anwar, Mumtaz, A. (1992). Use of information technology in the libraries of
Pakistan. Pakistan Library Association Journal, No.13 (August-1992). 17-
19.
Arif, Muhammad & Khalid Mahmood. (2012). The changing role of librarians in
the digital world: adoption of Web 2.0 technologies in Pakistani libraries.
The electronic library, 30(4). Retrieved from: Error! Hyperlink
reference not valid.
150
Awuku, Ohene Sakyi ( 1995). Productivity in university libraries of developing
countries: a West and Southern African perspective. Library Management,
16(3): 24-33.
Bhattacharya, Partha (2003). Digital information services: challenges and opportunities. Foundation for Innovation and Technology Transfer: Delhi,
2-9
Bansode, Sadanand Y. & Shamin Periera (2008). A survey of library automation
in college libraries in Goa State, India. Library Philosophy and Practice.
1-7. Retrieved from: http://www.webpages.uidas.edu/~moblin/bansode-
periera.htm
Barlow, Lisa J. and Margaret E.Graham. (1999). The use of information and
communication technologies in commercial libraries in the UK. program.
Electronic Library and Information Systems.33 ( 2), 109-128
Bavakutty, M, Muhammad Salih T.K.,et.al. (2006). Research on library
computerization. New Delhi: Ess Ess publications. p.19
Bello, A.S. (2003). Library user education evaluation at the Ibadan
Polytechnic. Nigerian Library and Information Science Review, 21(1):1-6.
Bhatti, Rubina (2010). Internet use among faculty members in the changing
higher education environment at the Islamia University of Bahawalpur,
Pakistan. Library Philosophy and Practice
Available: http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/~mbolin/bhatti3.pdf
Boss R.W. (2003). RFlD technology for libraries. Library technology report
39(6).
Bruce, C. S. (1994). Supervising literature reviews, in Zuber-Skerritt, O. and
151
Ryan, Y.(eds), Quality in postgraduate education. London: Kogan Page ,
217- 229. [Online]. Retrieved from:
http://www.deakin.edu.au/library/findout/research/litrev.php
Butler, M. (1995). Envisioning the libraries in the year 2000. Library Update
Fall, 1-2
Candela, L. et al (2008). The DELOS Digital Library Reference Model -
Foundations for digital libraries. Version 0.98,
Chand, Kuldip(ed) (1993). Current trends in information technology: its impact
on information scene in India. New Delhi: Batra.
Chandra, Ramesh and A.P Shrivastara ed.( 2003|). Technological changes in
libraries. Delhi: Kalmpus Publications.
Chepesuik, R. (1997).The future is here: America’s libraries go digital.
American Libraries, 27(1); 47-49.
Chethana, M., & Smith (2007). Influence of digital technology on information
users: an analytical study. Pearl: A Journal of Library and Information
Science. 1(3). P.1
Chowdhury, Salma (2001). Role of college libraries in education of Bangladesh.
Social Science Review, 18(2), 287-296.
Chinwe v. Anunobi (2008). The role of academic libraries in universal access to
print and electronic resources in the developing countries. Library
Philosophy and Practice. Available at :
http://unllib.unl.edu/LPP/anunobi-okoye.htm
152
Chinwe v. Anunobi (2010). Use of ICT facilities for serials functions in Southern
Nigerian federal university libraries. Library Philosophy and Practice.
Retrieved from: http://unllib.unl.edu/LPP/anunobi-okoye.htm
Chrishantha Dilroshan, T.L (2006 ). Identification of problems faced by
university libraries in the process of automation: with special reference to
the libraries of Moratuwa and Colombo Universities. Sri Lanka Journal of
Librarianship and Information Management, 1(2), 82-98.
Chu, S., K., W (2009). Ageism in Academic Librarianship. The Journal of
Academic Librarianship, 35 (2), 170–176.
Cleveland, Gary (March 1998). Digital libraries: definitions, issues and
challenges. International Federation of Library Associations and
Institutions”.UDT Occasional Paper#8.
Coyle,Karen (2004).Rights management and digital library requirements .Ariadne
.Issue 40
Cholin, Veeranna S.(2005). Study of the application of information technology
for effective access to resources in Indian university libraries. Library
Review,189-197
Das, R.S. (2008). Library automation and information technology. New Delhi:
Arise Publishers, 221-223
Ding, Choo Ming(1996). Assessing the impact of IT on university library services
in the 21st Century. Malaysian Journal of Library and Information
Science, 1(2) , 79-87
Dissanayake, B.G. (1995). A study of automation of university libraries in Sri
153
Lanka.Unpublished MLS thesis. University of Colombo.
Doty, Phillip and R.E Wyllys. (2001).Information technologies and the
information professions: overview of OPACs. School of Information,
University of Texas. slides 14-31
Frenzel, E.Louis, Jr.(1999). Crash course in artificial intelligence and expert
systems, Indianpoli, H.W.Sams.X,358pp.
Fons Wijnhoven, Jeroen Kraaijenbrink (2008). Product-oriented design theory
for digital information services: a literature review, Internet Research,
18( 1), 93 - 120
Gibbs,Frobes.(1992). Bibliography on the application of expert systems, artificial
intelligence and natural language processing in the library and information
sciences, 1978-1992. Expert systems for information management, 4(3),
143-220
Gopinath, S., Pathak, A., Kumar, M., & Sreekumar, M.G (2001). Fourth
generation libraries: from independence to interdependence. In: R.L.
Raina & I.V Malhan (Eds), Proceedings of the 3rd National Convention of
Management Libraries Network (MANLIBNET): Lucknow, 31-32.
Gertz, Janet. (2000). Selection for preservation in the digital age. Library
Resources & Technical Services. 44(2):97-104.
Gopal, Krishan .(2003). Impact of information technology services in libraries.
Delhi: Authors Press, 47-64
Graff, Mauritius V.D (2007). Driver: Seven items on a European agenda for
digital libraries .Ariande.Issue 53.
154
Haider, Syed Jala-ud-Din (2007). Library management scenario & management
problems in Pakistani libraries. Library Administration & Management.
21(4), Fall 2007. 173-176.
Hanifa K, Mohammad (2006). Computerization of university libraries. Ess Ess
Publications.New Delhi P.50
Higher Education Commission, Islamabad. Retrieved from : www.hec.gov.pk
(Accessed on 09/06/2010)
Hans-Chritoph, Hobohm, (1996). The impact of new technology on libraries: an
introductory note. Paper delivered at the Open Session of the Section
Social Science Libraries at the 62nd IFLA General Conference at Beijing ,
27 August. Available at: http//:forge.fh-potsdam.de/~IFLA/62-hobh.htm
Hopkinson, Alan (2010). Library automation in developing countries: last 25
years. Information development, 25(4), 304-312. Available at
http://idv.sagepub.com/content/25/4/304.abstract Accessed on
12/07/2010
Hussain, Ashfaq, Khalid Mahmood & Farzana Shafiq (2008). Perception of LIS
professionals about digital libraries in Pakistan: the Pakistani perspective.
Electronic Journal of Academic and Special Librarianship,9(1),1
Hussain, Mushahid (1994). Effectiveness of NLDP's activities towards the
development of library profession in Pakistan. University of Balochistan.
Ifidon, Sam E., Okoli, Godwin N., (2002). 40 Years of academic and research
library service to Nigeria: past, present, and future. Paper presented at the
40th Nigerian Library Association, ASCON, Badagry, 22-33.
155
Koneru, Indira. (2004). RFID technology: a revolution in library management. IN:
Proceedings of the Second International CALIBER on Road Map to New
Generation of Libraries Using Emerging Technologies, Feb 11-13, New
Delhi. Ahmedabad, INFLIBNET Centre, 414. Available at:
http://icfaiuniversity.academia.edu/Indirakoneru/Papers/81074/RFID
Technology A Revolution in Library Management
Jan, Saeed ullah & Rafia A Sheikh (2009). Use and impact of digital technology
on library services and resources in the public sector universities of N-
W.F.P. Paper presented at 6th Pakistan Library Science Conference held
at Baragali Abbotabad, Jun28-July 02.
Jan , Saeed ullah & Rafia A. Sheikh (2011). Automation of University Libraries: a
comparative analysis of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Islamabad, Pakistan.
Library Philosophy and Practice,USA, July issue. Available at:
http://www.webpages.uidadho.edu/~moblin/jan-sheikh.htm
Jan, Saeed ullah & Rafia A. Sheikh (2011). HEC Digital Library: an overview.
Microeconomics: Search; Learning; Information Costs & Specific
Knowledge; Expectation & Speculation, New York: 2(149), September
issue.
Jaswal, Bushra Almas (2005). Impact of digital technology on library resource
sharing: revisiting LABELNET in the digital age. Pakistan Journal of
Library & Information Science, 7, 87-104
Johnson, J. S. (1991). Computerizing information systems in developing
countries: keys to sustainable development. Pakistan Library
Bulletin, 22(3),22-30.
156
Kamath V A (1983). Evaluation of information technology: an overview. IASLIC
Bulletin. 28(4), 178
Kanamadi, Satish & B.D. Kumbar (2007). Impact of information technology
innovations on resources and services of management institute libraries in
Mumbai: a librarian’s approach. Electronic Journal of Academic and
Special Librarianship. 8(1), 9
Jain,M,K,Ed. (1998). From printed bibliographies to online databases: role of
library networks. IN: 50 Years Library and Information Services in India,
Jain, M.K,ed. Delhi: Shipra Publications.
Keralapura, M. (2009). Technology and customer expectation in academic
libraries: a special reference to technical/management libraries in
Karnataka. The International Information and Library Review , 41 (3),
184-195.
Kelapure, Rohit (2003). Scenario- based generation of digital library services. Master of Science Thesis. Virginia Polytechnic Institute. 8-15.
Khan, Najaf Ali (1995). Information technology in the university of Pakistan-
stresses and strains. Pakistan Library Bulletin XXVI (1), 6-11.
Khan, Noor Shed and David Bowden (2005). Community informatics in libraries
in Pakistan: current status, future prospects. New Library World. 106 (
11/12), 532 – 540
Kindiluchi, Amer I. and Iman F. Samarraie (2008). Interaction and impact of
electronic information resources on Qatar University Faculty. Libri.
Vol.58, 281- 293. Available: http://www.librijournal.org/pdf/20084pp281-
293.pdf
157
Kumbargoudar, Praveen Kumar. (1999). Application of artificial intelligence
techniques to library and information science. ILA Bulletin, 34 (3-4), 55-
59
Kuruppu Arachchi, Theja & De Silva (2007). Library automation: strategies for
library human resource management. Journal of the University Librarians,
vol II
Lam, K.T (2001). School library automation. presented at In-Services Training
Course for Teacher-Librarians. Retrieved from:
http://ihome.ust.hk/~lblkt/libauto/libauto.html
Leedy, P. (1993). Practical research: planning and design. New York:
Macmillan, 150-151
Lichtenberg, Jarnes. (2003). Industry explores viability of RFID. Publishers
Weekly, 205(46), 2-3. Retrieved March 7, 2004, from EBSCO Academy
search elite.
Leiner, B.M. (1998). The NCSTRL approach to open architecture for the
confederated digital library. D-Lib Magazine. Retieved from:
www.dlib.org/dlib/december98/ leiner / 12l einer.html
Li, Lili (2009). Emerging Technologies for Academic Libraries in the Digital Age,
Oxford, Chandos. Luambano, p.308
Luambano, I., & Nawe, J. (2004). Internet use by the students of the University of
Dar-us- Salaam. Library Hi Tech News. no. 10, 13-17.
Lynch, C.A.(1998). Identifiers and their role in networked information
158
applications. Feliciter, January 1998, 31-35
Marcum, James W. (2003). Visions: the academic library in 2012. D-Lib
Magazine , 9 (5) , p.2
Malik, Khalid Mahmood (1995). Status of library automation in Pakistan.
Pakistan Library Bulletin(PLB) XXVI (1), 307-328
Malik, Khalid Mahmood and Muhammad Ajmal Khan (2007). ICT training for
LIS professionals in Pakistan: a needs assessment program. Electronic
Library and Information Systems, 41( 4), 418 – 427.
Manujunath, GK and Pujar SM. (2002). Barcoding of library documents:
planning, techniques and tools. Annals of Library and Information
Studies.49 (4), p.119
McQuail, D (2000). McQuail's Mass Communication Theory .4th ed. London:
Sage, 16-34.
Mirza, Muhammad Sajid & Khalid Mahmood. (2009). Web based services in
university libraries: a Pakistani perspective. Library Philosophy and
Practice, p.1. Available at:
http//:www.webpages.uidaho.edu/~mbolin/mirza-mahmood.htm
Mulla, K, R. (2006). E-resources and services in Engineering College Libraries –
a case study. Electronic Journal of Academic and Special Librarianship,
7(1)
Nair, R Raman. (1992). Computer application to library and information services.
New Delhi: Ess Ess Publications, 236-7
159
Nok , Grace. (2006). The challenges of computerizing a university library in
Nigeria: the case of Kashim Ibrahim Library, Ahmadu Bello University,
Zaria. Library Philosophy and Practice. Available at:
http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/~mbolin/nok.htm
Norton, Peter (2006). Introduction to computers. 7th ed. New Delhi, Tata
McGraw Hill Education Private Limited..p.258
Onlude, O.O and O.R Apmama (2010). Effects of information and
communication technology on research and development activities: The
FIIRO Experience. Library Philosophy and Practice. Available :
http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/~mbolin/onilude-apampa.pdf
Parida, B. (2004). Emergence of digital library services in India, Paper to 2nd
International CALIBER-2004,New Delhi, 11-13 February ,2004.
Available at:
http://ir.inflibnet.ac.in/dxml/bitstream/handle/1944/334/04cali
26.pdf?sequence
Praveen Kumar, Mamta Mestri and S Pararmeshwar (2006). Development of
digital libraries in India:socio-economic problems and prospects. A Paper
presented at 4th Convention Planner at Mirozoram University,
Ahmedabad.
Poll, Roswitha (2005). Measuring the impact of new library services. World
Library and Information Congress. 71st IFLA General Conference and
Council “Libraries-A voyage of discovery”. Oslo( Norway), August 14th-
18th 2005.
University Available at: http://archive.ifla.org/1V/ifla71/papers/081e-
poll.pdf
160
Qutab, Saima & Khalid Mahmood (2009). Library web sites in Pakistan: an
analysis of the content. Program: electronic library and information
systems,, 43(4), 430-445.
Ramzan, Muhammad and Singh Diljit (2009). Status of information technology
applications in Pakistani libraries. Electronic Library. 27(4), 573-587
Ranganathan, S.R (1940). Reference service and bibliography. Madras: Madras
Library Association, p.25
Raziuddin, Munawar Sultana (2004). Digital libraries. Pakistan Library and
Information Science Journal (PLISJ). 35 (2).
Rosenberg, D. (1997) University libraries in Africa: a review of their current state
and future potential. vol. I, London: International African Institute.
Riaz, Mohammed (1991). Library automation: an introductory text. Islamabad:
Ebsco Subscription Services, 65-66
Rowley, JE. (1988). Computers for libraries. London: Clive Bingley, p.163
Saeed , Hamid & Muhammad Asghar (2000). Internet use in university libraries
in Pakistan. Online information review,24( 2), 154-160
Said, Amina (2006). Accessing electronic information: a study of Pakistan’s digital library.International Network for the Availability of Scientific Publications (INASP): Oxford, 8-52. Available at: http://www.inasp.info/uploaded/documents/access-info-SAID.pdf
Sambasivan, K. (2000). Investigating library resources: problems and prospects
in the internet age. New Delhi: Ess Ess publications,p186
Shafiullah, Farasat and Stephen A. Roberts (2010). Is ICT infrastructure capable
161
to accommodate standardized library management systems?: case studies
of library automation from public sector universities in Islamabad
(Pakistan). Technology, Policy and Innovation,273-280. Available at:
http://crl.du.ac.in/ical09/papers/index files/ical-44 191 402 1 RV.pdf
Shafiq-ur-rehman, Ch. and Pervaiz Ahmad(2007) Challenges and opportunities
for librarianship in Pakistan. Pakistan Library and Information Science
Journal. 3(38),6-11. Can be retrieved from:
http://eprints.rclis.org/handle/10760/10742#.TzYxp8XuqoU
Shariful Islam, M. and M. Nazmul Islam (2007). Use of ICT in libraries: an
empirical study of selected libraries in Bangladesh. Library Philosophy
and Practice. Available at :http://unllib.unl.edu/LPP/lpp2007.htm
Schmiede, Rudi (2004). Advancing digital libraries in Germany and creating
distributed scientific resources. Telos Digital Libraries Working Group,
vol 4,48-51
Shafiq, Farzana and Khalid Mahmood (2008). Integrated library software: a
survey of Lahore. Library Hi Tech News, vol. 6, 6-13
Shaheen, M., A. (2008). Use of social networks and information seeking
behaviour of students during political crises in Pakistan: a case study. The
International Information & Library Review. vol.40, 142-147.
Shah, S.A., Baig, S.M., & Azra Qureshi (2005). Digital library services and their impact with reference to a developing country: The case of Faculty of Health Sciences Library, Aga Khan University, 2005. In Health Sciences Research Assembly - 2005, Karachi (Pakistan), March 15 - 17,183-183. (published) [Conference Poster].
Sharma , Chetan & Goru Gobind Singh (2009). Use and impact of e-resources at
Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University (India): a case study.
Electronic Journal of Academic and Special Librarianship, v.10(1)
162
Smith, S.J. and Chethan M. (2007). Influence of digital technology on information
users: an analytical study. Pearl: A Journal of Library and Information
Science, 1( 3)
Taylor, Dena. (2005). The literature review: a few tips on conducting it.
[Online].Available at http://www.utoronto.ca/writing/litrev.html(Date
visited: 10.9.2008).
Tiwari, Aravind. (2002). Evaluation of electronic libraries. New Delhi: APH
Publishing.299
Venkata Ramana P and Rao, V Chandrasekhar. (2003).Use of information
technology in central university libraries of India. DESIDOC Bulletin of
Information Technology. 23(2), p.31
Verma, Shivram (2005). Academic library system. New Delhi: Shree Publishers.
Viswanathan, C.G.(1986). Elements of information science and technology.
Lucknow: Printhouse.
Von Cotta, Michael (1989). Automation and academic library structure. Libri,
39(1), 47-63.
Vyas, S.D (1997). Library Automation and Networking in India: problems and
prospects. World Libraries. 8(1). Available at:
http://www.worlib.org/vol08n01/vyas v08n1.shtml
Wijayarathne, Anusha. (2005). Automation of library functions with special
reference to circulation system adopted at the Library of Open University
of Sri Lanka. Journal of the University Librarians Association of Sri
163
Lanka .vol. 9, 21-22
Wilson, Louis R. and Maurice F. Tauber (1964). The University library: the
organisation, administration, and functions of Academic Libraries 2nd ed. , New
York: Columbia University Press, p.25
Young, Heartsill, Ed (1983). ALA Glossary of Library and Information Science,
Chicago,: American Library Association, p.130
Zuberi, Shahnaz. (2007).Digital publishing: a new challenge for library.
Pakistan Library and Information Science Journal, 38 (1).
http://www.answers.com/topic/smart-card-technology
http://www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1G2-3401801216.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_card
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_card#cite_note-16
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_acquisitions
www.hec.gov.pk
http://www.hec.gov.pk/eReforms/DigitalLibrary/Pages/welcome.aspx
http://www.hec.gov.pk/eReforms/PRR/Pages/Default.aspx
http://ihome.ust.hk/~lblkt/libauto/libauto.html automation of library functions
http://www.library.manchester.ac.uk/subjects/eps/ceas/awareness/
http://www.ndltd.org/
164
http://pakistanlibraries.org/about.php#ICT
http://www.sims.berkeley.edu/research/projects/how-much-info/summary.html
http://www.statpak.gov.pk/depts/fbs/statistics/social_statistics/social_statistics.ht
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/camera
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/catalogue Accessed on 04/07/2010
http://www.theislamabad.com/history.html
http://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/digital-technology
http://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/digital/library
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_does_digits_mean
http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/C/computer.html
http://whatis.techtarget.com/definition/0,,sid9_gci212942,00.html
165
SUGGESTION FOR FURTHER STUDIES
This study has opened the door to many other aspects of library modernization.
The following are some of them:
1- Impact of digital technology on library services and resources in the private
sector universities of Pakistan.
2- Studies should be conducted like this in other developing countries of the
world.
3- Comparative analysis of modern library trends in public and private sector
universities.
4- Comparative analysis of modern library practices in Pakistan and other
developing countries of the world.
5- Studies should be conducted to assess the hardware and software requirements
of libraries in the country.
6- Studies should be conducted to frame digital library policy in Pakistan.
7- This study should also be replicated after ten years.
8- Comparative analysis of standard library software in Pakistan and rest of the
world.
166
CONTRIBUTION TO KNOWLEDGE
This study has covered the areas of basic library services, resources,
technology-based infrastructure and the impact of modern
technologies on university libraries. It has reasonably contributed to
the field of librarianship in specific and knowledge in general. This
study will help and guide the modern librarians in a right direction. It
will provide a clear picture of the university libraries to the planners,
educationists, policy makers, higher ups of the universities and
librarians community in the country.
167
APPENDIX-A
QUESTIONNAIRE
DIGITAL TECHNOLOGY AND ITS IMPACT ON LIBRARY AND
INFORMATION SERVICES AND RESOURCES IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR
UNIVERSITIES OF PAKISTAN.
PART I: DEMOGRAPHIC INFORMATION
1- Your name please: ………………………………………………………
1.1 E-mail: ………………………………………………………..
1.2 Telephone ……………………… Cell …………………..
1.3 Designation (BPS) ……………… Gender …………………
1.4 Professional Qualification: ………… Age …………………
2- Name of university ………………………………………………..
2.1 Date of establishment ……………………………………….
2.3 No. of faculties/ departments ………………………………..
2.4 Total no; of affiliated colleges ……………………………….
2.5 Yearly enrolment ……………………………………………
2.6 Name of the university library (if any) ……………………..
2.7 Website of the university/ library …………………………
2.8 Total no: of seminar libraries ……………………………...
3- Training Courses/Seminars/Workshops attended in digital technology
related areas. Please list brief titles, duration and years.
………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………...
.................................................................................................................
168
4- How many users visit your library on a daily basis?
... . ……………………………………………
5- How many users visit your digital library section on a daily basis?
4.1 Faculty members ………………………………………..
4.2 Researchers ………………………………………………
4.3 Students …………………………………………………
4.4 Alumni ………………………………………………….
4.5 Others (Please specify) …………………………………
PART II: INFRASTRUCTURE AND RESOURCES
PHYSICAL FACILITIES
6- Keeping in mind the perfect ambience of a modern library in a University,
please tick (√) your rating on the following scale about physical facilities in your
library.
1. Very Good 2.Good 3. Uncertain 4. Poor 5. Very Poor
Description 2
Furniture/Seating Arrangement
Lighting/Ventilation
Reading Area
Research Cubicles/Cabins
Air Conditioning
Library Building( Safety Aspects)
Printing Facilities/ Soft copy facility
Photocopying Facilities
169
COMPUTER FACILITIES
Please provide the information about the digital technology infrastructure
available in the library.
7- Whether your library is automated? Fully Automated □
Partially Automated □ Not Automated □ If yes,
7.1 Year of starting of library automation: ______________________
7.2 Whether the library management software is a network version? Yes/No
7.3 Whether the management software has online help for users Yes/No
7.4 Whether the management software has OPAC facility? Yes/No
7.5 Whether the management software has Web OPAC facility? Yes/No
7.6 What is the level of library automation? (Please give the following details)
____________________________________________________________
S.No Library functions Automated
___________________________________________________________
1 Acquisition
2 Cataloguing
3 Circulation
4 Serials Control
5 OPAC
6 Annual Stock Verification
7 Budget Control
8 Other (Please specify)
_______________________________________________________________
170
8- Please mention the quantity of hardware and software available in your
library.
Hardware
S.No Nomenclature Available status Quantity
Computer terminals Yes/No
Servers Yes/No
Printers Yes/No
Scanners Yes/No
Bar Code Readers Yes/No
LCD Projectors Yes/No
Digital Camera Yes/No
CDWriters Yes/No
UPS/Generator Yes/No
RF Security System Yes/No
Software
Nomenclature Product Name Quantity
Operating System used in computer terminals
Operating System on servers
Library Management Software
Digital Library Software
Data Bases/Relational databases
Anti Virus software
Anti Plagiarism software
Any other
171
9- Have you created a database of library holdings? Yes □ No □
10- If yes, then please mention whether it covers the following items
S.No Description Status Quantity
1 Books Yes/No
2 Journal back volumes Yes/No
3 Reports Yes/No
4 Dissertations/ Theses Yes/No
5 Manuscripts Yes/No
6 Audio Visual Materials Yes/No
7 CD ROM databases Yes/No
8 Any other Yes/No
9 Total No. of records in the database
LEARNING RESOURCES
11- Present collection (on 01-10-2010)
11.1 Books_________________________
11.2 Research Journals i) Foreign journals _______________
ii) Pakistani journals_______________
Iii) Online/Electronic journals ________
11.3 Back volumes of research journals________________
11.4 Magazines ____________________
11.5 No: of Newspapers ______________
11.6 Manuscripts ___________________
11.7 Theses ______________________
11.8 Dissertation/ Project reports ___________
11.9 Technical reports ____________________
11.10 Non-Book materials
i) Audio cassettes __________
172
ii) Video cassettes __________
CDs ___________________
Slides __________________
Microforms ______________
Transparencies ___________
Software(s) _______________
Databases _______________
11.11 Total collection ________________
11.12 Total collection of the seminar libraries _______
HUMAN RESOURCES
12- Total work force in your library
i) Professional staff ……………………
ii) Para Professional staff ………………
iii) Non-Professional ……………………
iv) Automation & Digitization staff …….
Total workforce: ------------------
13- Please provide number of library staff against each category:
PhD______________ M.Phil___________________
MLIS_____________ BLIS/PG-DLIS ____________
CLI.Sc____________
14- Number of Workshops/ Training Programmes attended in the past five
years by the library staff in the digital technology related area:
i) Professional ……………………………………….
ii) Para-Professional ……………………………………….
iii) Non-Professional ……………………………………….
iv) Total ……………………………………………………
173
15- Do you feel that technology based training programmes have improved the
efficiency of yourself or of your staff? Yes □ No □
Unsure □
16- In your opinion what special qualifications are required for the person in
charge of automation and digitization in a university library?
………………………………………………………………………………
FINANCIAL RESOURCES
17- What are the financial resources of your library?
18- Write down the total budget of the university library for the following
financial years?
19- Write down the total budget for the Automation and Digitization Section of your
Library.
Sources/Grants Please(tick)
HEC/Government
Trust
Donations/Endowments
Overdue Charges, Sale of old newspapers,
Membership charges etc
Any Other (Please specify)
2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10
174
2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09
20- Please provide details of the funds allocated for different library materials:
Library
material
2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10
Books
Journals/
Magazines
Newspapers
A/V material
Microforms
Rare material
Preservation
Automation
&
Digitization
21- Are you satisfied with the budget allocation for your Automation and Digitization
Sections? Yes/No
If not, what is your suggestion (Please tick)
□ Below 10% of the total library budget □ 10-20% □ 21-30%
□ 31-40% □ 41-50% □ 50% and above
□ other
PART III: Networking and information services
22- Please provide details about status of the library& information services
being offered in your library. (Please tick the applicable segment)
1) Book lending ………………………………
175
2) Inter library loan ……………………………
3) Reprographic services ……………………
4) Reference services …………………………
5) Circulation of Accession lists ……………..
6) Routing of periodicals ……………………
7) User education …………………………….
8) Compilation of bibliographies ………….
9) Translation services ……………………….
10) New arrivals’ list. ………………………………
11) Current Awareness Services ………………
12) Selective Dissemination of Information……….
13) Indexing services ……………………………….
14) Abstracting services ……………………………
15) Bulletin Board service …………………………
16) E-mail ……………………………………………
18) Photocopying service …………………………
19) Internet ………………………………
20) Fax …………………………………………
21) Telephone………………………………….
22) Other………………………………………..
23- Does your library have internet connectivity? Yes/No
1. Speed of connection in Kbps/Mbps
2. Since how many years is internet connectivity available
in your library?
□ 10 years or more □ 5-9 years □ 1-4 Years □ less than 1
year □ other
3. Internet services to users are: □ Fee Based □ Free
4. No. of computer terminals having internet connectivity in
your library
176
5. Internet is primarily used for
E-mail FTP Telnet Chating
Phone Book Acquisition e- journals
Online databases(search and research) Fax
______________________________________________________________
24- Does your library provide Online Public Access Catalogue (OPAC)?
Yes/No
If yes, please tick the appropriate box.
1. How many users make use of OPAC every day? (Approx.)
□ 0-50 □ 51-100 □ 101-150 □ 151 or more
2. How many OPAC terminals are installed in library premises?
□ 0-2 □ 3-5 □ 6-7 □ 8 or more
3. Does Faculty/Students have access to library OPAC through
LAN? Yes/No
4. How do you rate the usage of OPAC?
□ Very High □ High □ Uncertain □ Average □ Low
25- 1. Does your library have its own website? Yes/ No
2. What is the extent of library information that is hosted on your website?
(Please tick the appropriate boxes)
□ General Information □ Rules and regulations
□ Staff details □ CAS/ SDI Bulletin
□ OPAC □ other(please specify)
26- Tick the system and rules alongwith edition being used.
1. Name of Classification scheme used ……………………….
Are you satisfied with the classification scheme followed? Yes/ No
If not, what standard would you prefer instead?
………………………………………………………………………
2. Cataloguing rules in practice …………………………………
Are you satisfied with the existing cataloguing rules followed? Yes/No
177
If not, what standard would you prefer instead?
………………………………………………………………………
3. Standards used for assigning keywords:
a) Chain procedure __________
b) Sears’ List of Subject Headings______________
c) LC Subject Headings ______
Are you satisfied with the existing standards for keywords? Yes/No
If not, what standard would you prefer instead?
………………………………………………………………………
27-. Please indicate your opinion on the following:
1. Computer and other equipment in the library are always in good
conditions.
□ Strongly Agree □ Agree □ Uncertain □ Disagree
□ Strongly Disagree
2. Existing library staff is well trained in computers and its applications in
libraries.
□ Strongly Agree □ Agree □ Uncertain □ Disagree
□ Strongly Disagree
28- What are the better methods of keeping library professionals updated?
□ Conferences & Seminars □ Training programmes □ Refresher
courses □ Continued Education Program □ Any other (Pl.specify)
29- Do you feel that technology based information services are better than
manual services? Yes □ No
If yes, in what way technology based information services are better than manual
information services. Please give your opinion about the statements on the
following scale.
178
1. Strongly Agree 2. Agree 3. Uncertain 4. Disagree
5. Strongly Disagree
Sr. No Description 1 3
1 They are accurate
2 They are consistent
3 They can be provided with
lesser time
4 They can occupy lesser space
5 They can be provided round
the clock
6 Can be tailor-made for
specific user needs
30- Do you feel that technology based technical services have a positive impact on
library services and resources
1. Strongly Agree 2. Agree 3. Uncertain 4.Disagree
5. Strongly Disagree
Sr.No Description
1 Acquisition work
2 Cataloguing of documents
3 OPAC
4 Use of E-DDC
5 Digitization of documents
6 Circulation Control
7 Serials Control
8 Information retrieval
9 Stock verification
1
0
Accounting & Management
1 Electronic theft detection system
179
1
31- Comparing technology based information services with that of manual information
services. Please give your opinion about the following statements on the scale given
below:
1. Strongly Agree 2. Agree 3. Uncertain 4. Disagree 5. Strongly Disagree
Sr.No Description 3 4
1 Users prefer to search electronic
resources before they do a manual
search of printed versions
2 Users require orientation to make
the maximum use of technology
based information services
3 Technology based information
services have a positive impact
and thus have improved the image
of the library
4
Library staff is required to
undergo training periodically to
make optimum use of IT
applications in managing library
and information centers
32- Attitude towards application of Digital Technology (DT).Please indicate your
attitude towards the application of Digital Technology in your library.
1. Strongly Agree 2. Agree 3. Uncertain 4. Disagree 5. Strongly Disagree
Sr.No Description 1 2 4
1 DT are to improve the quality of
library services
2 DT applications improve the
180
efficiency of library
3 DT enhances the knowledge and
expertise
4 DT reduces the work load of the
library professionals
5 DT increases regular budgeting
6 DT takes over the traditional way
of information handling in the
library.
33- Does your library provide technology based user education/orientation program for
proper use of library services and resources? □ Yes □ No
1. If yes, how frequently is it provided?
□ In the beginning of the academic year □ when requested
□ In every semester □ Any other (Pl.specify)
2. Who conducts this User Education Program?
□ Librarian □ Assistant Librarian □ Faculty member
□ Any other (Pl.specify) …………………
3. What methods are used to conduct User Education Programmes?
□ Lectures □ Guided Tours □ Seminars
□ Demonstrations □ Printed Guide □ Any other (Pl.specify)
4. What is the duration of User Education Programmes?
□ Half-an-Hour □ One Hour □ One day
□ Two days □ Other
5. Do you feel that User Education Program (UEP) has helped users to
make better use of library services and resources? □ Yes □ No
181
6. Do you feel that UEP has a positive impact on the library services and
resources? □ Yes □ NO
34- We all know that digital resources/ electronic resources can be shared easily with the
establishment of a network system among the university libraries. In the light of this,
please express your opinion about the statement on the following scale.
1. Strongly Agree 2. Agree 3. Uncertain 4. Disagree 5. Strongly Disagree
Sr.No Description 1 2 3 4
1 By forming a network of
university libraries in
Pakistan, we will be able to
enhance resource sharing
2 It will standardize library
services
3 It will build standard
collections
4 The efficiency of human
resources will be improved.
5 Duplication of catalogue
entries will be avoided.
35- (a) Please tick mark the tools used for book selection
□ Publishers’ Catalogues □ Publishers’ circulated E-mails
□ National Bibliography □ Publishers’ Websites □ Book Reviews
□ Other …………….
(b) How do you order for supply of books (Please tick mark?)
□ Through post/ courier □ Telephone □ Online Ordering
□ Fax □ Any other………………………………………..
36- Considering that Publishers’ Websites is as major book selection tool, please give
182
your opinion about the following statements on the following scale.
1. Strongly Agree 2. Agree 3. Uncertain 4. Disagree 5. Strongly Disagree
Sr.NO Description 4
1 It provides full
bibliographical details
2 Price verification can be done
easily
3 E-mail facilitates faster
communication with the
publishers
4 Placing orders through
internet is convenient &
saves a lot of time
5 Speed of delivery of books
for which order is placed
online is better than
conventional methods
37- Comparing advantages of digital/electronic resources over conventional print version,
please give your opinion about the statements on the following scale.
1. Strongly Agree 2. Agree 3. Uncertain 4. Disagree 5. Strongly Disagree
Sr.No Description
1 It is not necessary to retain journal
bound volumes even after the library has
all the back volumes in digital/electronic
form or has access to them from a digital
repository
We can save lot of storage space by
183
2 having resources like Journal back
volumes, Dissertations, Reports in
electronic form
3 It saves substantial amount of money
being spent on maintenance(binding,
cleaning, etc) of books , bound volumes
by having them in electronic/ digital
form
4 It is easy & convenient to conduct a
search on electronic resources
5 Electronic resources are not very
expensive compared to their print
version.
6 It is better to procure an electronic
version of a book/ journal if its price is
equal to or not much higher than print
version
7 In this networked environment,
electronic resources achieve the
objectives of resource sharing in a far
better way than print versions
8 Electronic resources require expensive
infrastructure to disseminate information
contained in them
9 Despite being user friendly, it requires
certain degree of computer knowledge to
get the maximum benefit of these
electronic resources
10 Librarians need to develop in-depth &
rigorous User Education Programs to
184
create awareness among users about
proper utilization of electronic resources.
11 Electronic resources can be updated
easily and immediately in case of online
sources.
12 Copyright is a barrier to electronic
resources
13 As electronic devices are used to operate
electronic resources which are power
dependent, so electricity failure can also
act as a barrier..
38- Any other information/experience that you want to share about the impact of digital
technology on library services and resources?
…………………………………………….
Signature
185
APPENDIX-B
QUESTIONNAIRE
(for the users of the Library/ Information Centre)
DIGITAL TECHNOLOGY AND ITS IMPACT ON LIBRARY SERVICES AND
RESOURCES IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR UNIVERSITIES OF PAKISTAN.
1- Name:
E-mail(optional): Phone/Cell(optional):
Department: Educational Qualification:
Sex(optional): Age(optional):
Field of study/ Teaching: ear/Semester:
2- Type of membership you have in the library
a) Under graduate Student
b) Research Scholar
c) Teacher
3- Why do you visit the library? ( Please tick √ )
To study
To conduct research
To borrow/ return/ renew books
For recreational purposes
Any other (Please specify)…………………………………….
__________________________________________________________
4- Frequency of library visit (Please tick)
__________________________________________________________________
Daily Alternative days Once in three days
Once a week Once a month Occasionally Never
____________________________________________________________
186
5- Average time spent in the library on a visit ( Please tick)
a) Less than 30 minutes
b) Between 30 minutes and two hours
c) Between 2 and 5 hours
d) More than 5 hours
e) Other
6- Are you aware of the following library and information services?
(Please tick√)
Library services Yes No Not sure
Lending/ Circulation
Reading hall
Reference services
Inter library loan
User education
Photocopying
Any other
Information services
Bibliographic Services
Current Awareness Services (CAS)
Selective Dissemination of Information
(SDI)
Indexing/ Abstracting services
Technology based Information services
OPAC
Web based OPAC
E-Journals access
187
Internet
Bulletin Board services
7- How do you rate the quality and quantity of the following traditional
learning resources in your library?
(Please√ the one closest to your choice on the following scale)
1. Very Good 2. Good 3. Uncertain 4. Poor 5. Very Poor
Description
Books
Reference sources
Journals
Project Reports/Dissertations
Govt. Reports
Newspapers/ Business Dailies
8- Do you use any of the following information handling tools/ utilities/
devices/ services/ resources in your library?
___________________________________________________________
No Tools/utilities/devices/services/resources Please tick
___________________________________________________________
USB CD-ROM DVD VCD
Printer Scanner Smart card E-Books
Laptop Computer Telephone Fax E-mail
Bibliographic databases WWW Ftp Telnet
E-Journals
___________________________________________________________
188
9- Do you use online catalogue in your library? Yes/No
If yes, what are the accesses points through which you search?
a) Author b) Title
c) Words in title d) Subject
e) Class number f) Place
g) Publisher h) Series
i) Boolean search j) Truncation
l) Word proximity l) ISBN
10- Did you get any orientation in the use of online catalogue? Yes/No
If not, how did you come to know about searching techniques/strategies
in the online catalogue (Please Tick?)
a) Through trial and error b) By observing others browse
the catalogue
c) From your friends d) Any other (Please specify)
11- Do you get computerized book circulation facilities? Yes/No
If yes, what are the services available? (Please tick)
a) Issue/Return b) Document Reservation
c) Fine Collection d) Enquiry
e) Any other (please specify) ……………………………
12- Do you find the computer based circulation procedure time saving?
Yes/No
13- Do you use internet facility in your library? Yes/No
If yes, Please indicate the services you use in the internet
a) Web browsing b) Email
189
c) Chatting d) Newsgroup
e) Discussion group f) Searching databases
g) Accessing E-books and journals
h) Accessing Reference sources i) Other purposes please specify
14- Please specify the purpose of your internet usage
a) Study/Learning b) Research
c) To collect general information d) Recreational
e) Communication f) Any other (please specify) …
……………………………..
15- Do you receive required information through internet? Yes/No
Do you find internet connection sufficient to meet your requirements?
16- Do you think your skills and expertise are inadequate to use technology
based services and resources? Yes/No
If yes, in which area(s) do you want training?.........................................
17- How do you find user education in technology based resources and
services?
More adequate Adequate Inadequate
18- Do you feel any significant change in speed in your academic/ research
work by using the emerging library technologies? Yes/No
Highly significant Significant Not significant
19- To what extent are you satisfied with the application of digital
technologies in your library?
Very satisfied Satisfied Not satisfied
If you are not satisfied, please specify the reason(s) (please tick)
___________________________________________________________
S.No Reason(s) Tick
190
___________________________________________________________
1. Inadequate IT infrastructure
2. Limited computer literacy
3. Users are not trained for technology
based information services
4 Inadequately trained library professionals in technology
application
5 Inadequate publicity for the technology based services and
resources
6. Discouraging attitude of library professionals towards
their users
7. Rigid ICT use policies implemented by the libraries
8. No provision of this facility
20- Impact of digital technology on the following:
__________________________________________________________________
S.No category Positive impact No Impact Negative impact
__________________________________________________________________
1 Quality of library services
2 Efficiency of the library
3 Status of the library
4 Integration within the organization
5 Enhancement of the knowledge and
expertise
6 Book circulation
7 Use of internet
8 Other (please specify)
21- Do you feel that whenever digital sources are searched, the quality and
quantity of information you get is
□ Better than print version □ Not better than print version
191
□ same as that of print version
22- Library should add more and more of digital sources to its collection.
□ Strongly Agree □ Agree
□ Uncertain □ Disagree
□ Strongly Disagree
23- How do you rate the reference services provided by your library?
□ Very Good □ Good □ Uncertain
□ Poor □ Very Poor
24- Digital technology and its applications have helped libraries in developing
need based Current Awareness Services (CAS).
□ Strongly Agree □ Agree
□ Uncertain □ Disagree □ Strongly Disagree
25- On the whole users are satisfied with the approach of library staff in
providing technology based information services.
□ Strongly Agree □ Agree
□ Uncertain □ Disagree □ Strongly Disagree
26- Please give your suggestions and comments in a para or two,regarding the
impact of digital technology on library services and resources.
………………………………………………………………………………………
27- Your suggestions and comments in a para or two, regarding the impact of
digital technology on library services
………………………………………………………………………………………
Signature
192
APPENDIX-C
INTERVIEW SCHEDULE
(With Chief librarian)
General information
1 Name:
2 Name of the University
3 Phone:
B Impact of digital technology on university library services and resources
Please discuss the impact of DT on the following services and resources
and facilities
Impact of DT on library services
Technical services
Basic services
Information services
Technology based information services
Any other
Impact of DT on library resources
a. Financial resources
b. Human resources
c. Learning resources
d. Physical resources
C What are the major barriers to the application of digital technology in
university Libraries?
D What you suggest for the eradication of these barriers?
E Do you provide carrier advancement facilities to your library
professionals? Please explain.
F Do you provide user education in technology based library services and
resources? Please explain.
G Your comments.
193
APPENDIX-D
Definitions
Digital devices
The devices used for the digitization of documents are referred to as digital
devices. The following are some of the digital equipments used for the
digitization of documents.
Computer
The word “computer” is derived from the word “compute” which means to
compute or calculate. Computer is a machine that takes input in the form of data,
does processing on that data and gives the result. It is a device that accepts
information, processes it for some output . A computer can transmit, store, and
process information. A computer system is a combination of five elements namely
hardware, software, people, procedures and data/information. The basic
characteristics of computers are speed, accuracy, diligence, versatility and power
of remembering. The internal architectural design of computer differs from one
system model to another. However, the basic organization remains the same for
all computer system. The following five units correspond to the five basic
operations performed by all computer systems: input units, storage unit, output
units and control unit. According to the nature of work, computers have three
types: Analog computers, Digital and Hybrid Computers.
The input devices of a computer include Keyboard, Mouse, Trackball, Touchpad,
Track point, Joystick, Scanner, Punch card, Light pen, Optical Character Reader
(OCR), Bar Code Reader (BCR), Magnetic Ink Character Recognition (MICR),
Optical Mark Recognition (OMR), Graphic Tablet or Digitizer, Microphones,
Sound Cards, Digital Cameras, Video Digitizer, Remote Control and Chemical
Detector. The output components of computer comprises of Monitors, Liquid
Crystal Display (LCD), Speakers, Printers, Plotters. Computer Output Microfilm
(COM). Storage devices consist of Magnetic Tape, Magnetic Disk, Floppy Disk,
194
Hard Disk, Zip Drive, Jazz Drive, Super Disk , CD-ROM, CD-R, WORM (Write
Once Read Many), CD-RW, DVD, Magneto-Optical and Fluorescent Disk
Technology.
The basic storage unit in a computer is bit. A bit has a single binary value, either 0
or 1. Eight bits are termed as byte and half a byte is called a nibble. Commonly
used storage unit is byte. Some bigger units of data storage are kilobyte,
megabyte, gigabyte, terabyte, petabyte, exabyte, zettabyte and yottabyte.
The life blood of a computer system is software. Software can generally be
divided into two categories: System software and Application software. Language
processor or Translator can also be treated as a type of software.
Computer has brought a revolution in the history of libraries. It has totally
changed the traditional library system into a modern library system. The invention
of computer has affected all aspects of library procedures. In the early ages of
computer applications to libraries, it was only used for the automation of house
keeping routines in the library. The inception of internet has developed the
concept of virtual or e-library. Now users can get their required information with
a click sitting at home or in the office.
Scanner
The input device that works like a photocopier but digitizes the information into a
computer. Scanners come in both handled and desktop models. Adobe’s
Photoshop and Greenstone Digital Library software are used for processing of
digitized documents. Scanners are widely used in digitization of library
documents.
Digital Camera
Camera is an apparatus used for taking photographs of objects under
consideration. The device that is used to capture images electronically rather than
on film is called digital camera. The image is taken by a group of Charged-
Coupled Devices (CCDs), saved in the RAM of camera, and transferred to a
195
computer for alteration, permanent storage or hard copy. The image can be easily
modified, cropped, combined and enhanced with the help of suitable software.
The photos captured with digital camera can easily be transmitted over internet.
The digital camera is more useful than traditional camera because it is
inexpensive, fast and requires no film processing. Digital camera can be used in
the digitization of library materials.
196
APPENDIX-E
Functions of library automation
K.T Lam (2001) highlighted the main functions of library automation in the
following style:
FIGURE 1: Functions of library automation
197
APPENDIX-F
Emerging Library Technologies
RFlD (Radio Frequency Identification) Technology
With the adoption of barcode technology during the 1970's - 1980's many libraries were
able to streamline workflow within circulation servers. The barcode allowed a quicker and
efficient way to retrieve unique identifier, which assisted libraries to track items. However,
barcodes need to be scanned within a hand held scanner or within 'line of sight
(Lichtenberg: 2003: 14).
The concept of RFlD technology is similar to that of a cellular phone. It is a combination
of radio -frequency-based technology and microchip technology and uses radio waves to
automatically identify people or objects.
Components of an RFlD
Thanuja C. Ranawell (2006) RFlD system consist of main four parts
(1) RFlD tags that are electronically programmed with unique information;
(2) readers or sensors to interrogate the tags
(3) antenna; and
(4) server
RFID has many advantages. It will increase speed of charging and discharging of
documents. Library staff can relieve from repetitive and clerical tasks. It can sort
documents automatically and library staff can shelve documents very easily. There are
portable readers. These portable readers can report the lost, hidden or unordered
documents more easily. RFID tags have greater storage capacity and can hold large
amount of information about a document. Security is a major concern in electronic
environment. RFID has solved this issue without staff interventions through electronic
theft detect system.
RFID technology has few short comings. As far as developing countries like Pakistan is
198
concerned, cost is a major barrier. For implementing and maintaining RFID system, a
substantial amount is needed. A comprehensive RFID system for 100,000 documents with
self charging station, book drop unit and automatic book sorting system ranges from $
100,000 to $ 200,000(Koneru, Indira: 2004:414). Another drawback is that the radio waves
cannot pass through liquid and metals at certain frequencies.
Artificial Intelligence (AI)
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is a subdivision of computer science devoted for creating
computer software and hardware that imitates the human mind. The main goal of AI is to
make computers smarter by creating software that will allow a computer to copy some of
the functions of human brain in selected applications. The major areas of application of AI
are expert system, natural language processing, computer vision, robotics and education.
Kumbargoudar, (1999) described that the application of AI to information and library
work is relatively recent and has been mostly in the expert systems field. Natural language
processing can be used to search relevant information from database, indexing and to
reduce language barriers. Artificial Intelligence is very effective for searching purposes
because it works on pattern matching techniques. AI application usually requires very
powerful computers with fast CPUs and lots of memory. That is why the increased cost
might represent a disadvantage of AI.
Expert system
The biggest use of Artificial Intelligence techniques is in expert systems. An expert system
is an artificial intelligence program incorporating a knowledge based inference system. It
is a highly specialized piece of software that attempts to duplicate the functions of an
expert in some field of expertise. The program acts as an intelligent consultant or advisor.
Expert system has been developed to solve a wide range of problems in domain such as
medicine, mathematics, engineering, geology, computer science, business, law, defense,
education. Expert system offer some of the following advantages (Louis E. Fresnel,
Jr:2000:73):
permit non-expert to do the work of experts
199
improve productivity by increasing work output by improving efficiency
save time in accomplishing a specific objective
simplify some operations
computerize routine clerical work.
Many provisions in the provision of library and information services involve expertise, and
thus provide applications where expert system’s techniques and technology promise to
improve performance (Muhammad Hanifa, K: 2006). An analysis of the literature on the
applications of expert system in LIS yields the following application areas Gibb (1992):
Intelligence interfaces, in particular interfaces for online information retrieval
system
Subject analysis and representation, including classification, indexing and
abstracting services
Information storage and retrieval systems in general
Reference and referral systems
Hypertext and hypermedia
Collection development
Smart card
Smart cards have widespread applications. It can be used for computer security, financial
matters (e.g. ATM, fuel cards, and electronic wallets), health care, access control,
administration, authentication and identification. Application of smart card in library
delivers increased efficiency by providing a means of regularly updating the library’s
inventory and maintaining an accurate control of borrowing records.
200
APPENDIX-G
Online Public Access Catalogue (OPAC)
An OPAC (Online Public Access Catalog) is an online bibliography of a library
collection that is available to the public. OPACs developed as stand-alone online
catalogs, often from VT100 terminals to a mainframe library catalog. With the
arrival of the Internet, most libraries have made their OPAC accessible from a
server to users all over the world. Library materials in the library can be retrieved
through the OPAC. The library documents may be searched by Advanced
Keyword, Simple Keyword, AltaVista Type, Author, Title, Author/Title, Subject,
Call Number, and Journal.
Philip Doty and R. E. Wyllys (2001:14-31) give that OPACs offer numerous
advantages and disadvantages over their card-based predecessors. The major
advantages are:
• Users can perform much faster, the same kinds of searches that card
catalogs facilitate: viz author, title, subject-heading
• Search can also be made through call number, publication date, language,
publisher, series or illustrator
201
APPENDIX-H
Overview of the use of public sector university libraries in Pakistan
Overview of the use of public sector university libraries in Islamabad
S.No University Library Location Librarians
grade
Total
Collection
Total
Human
resources
Status of
Automation
Daily
visits of
users
01 Quaid-e-Azam University
Library
Islamabad 20 1,95,000 40 F.A 500
02 Comsat Institute of
Information Technology
do 19 65,000 20 F.A 1200
03 Federal Urdu University
Library
do 18 19000 06 F.A 480
04 International Islamic
University Library
do 20 200,000 82 F.A 3500
05 Air University Library do 17 15000 08 F.A 700
06 National University of
Modern Languages
Library
do 20 115,000 30 F.A 550
07 Institute of Space
Technology Library
do SPS-8 5636 05 F.A 100
08 Bahria University Library do 17 18558 11 F.A 300
09 Pakistan Institute of
Engineering and Applied
Sciences Library
do SPS-7 35000 12 F.A 700
10 National College of Arts
Library
do 17 7000 05 P.A 75
11 Centre for Applied Studies
in Engineering Library
do 17 15000 06 F.A 230
Note: F.A=Fully Automated P.A= Partially Automated N.A= Not Automated
Overview of the use of public sector university libraries in Punjab
S.No University Library Location Librarians
grade
Total
Collection
Total
Human
resources
Status of
Automation
Daily
visits
users
202
01 Punjab University Library Lahore 20 500,000 123 F.A 900
02 University of Engineering
and Technology Library
do 19 115,000 48 F.A 800
03 Pir Mehr Ali Shah Arid
Agriculture University
Library
Rawalpindi 18 26955 09 P.A 230
04 University of Education
Library
Lahore 19 17,000 04 F.A 60
05 Lahore College for
Women University
Library
do 17 73000 08 P.A 100
06 National School of Public
Policy Library
do 17 55,000 07 F.A 50
07 University of Veterinary
and Animal Sciences
Library
do 17 30,000 21 F.A 250
08 Kinnaird College for
Women University
Library
do 17 18558 07 P.A 500
09 University of Gujrat
Library
Gujrat 17 80,000 05 F.A 900
10 Fathima Jinnah Women
University Library
Rawalpindi 17 35000 07 P.A 450
11 National College of Arts
Library
Lahore 17 33,000 12 F.A 330
12 King Edward Medical
College Library
do 17 41,000 02 N.A 100
13 Islamia University Library Bahawalpur 19 150,000 100 P.A 2000
14 National University of
Science and Technology
Library
Rawalpindi 18 10,000 14 F.A 360
15 University of Health
Sciences Library
Lahore 16 50,000 05 P.A 300
203
16 Govt. College University
Library
Lahore 20 307676 45 F.A 1000
17 Agriculture University
Library
Faisalabad 17 246220 57 F.A 2500
18 University of Engineering
and Technology Library
Taxila 20 55,000 05 P.A 250
Overview of the use of public sector university libraries in Azad Jammu Kashmir &
Northern Areas
S.No University Library Location Librarians
grade
Total
Collection
Total
Human
resources
Status of
Automation
Daily
visits of
users
01 University of Azad
Jammu and Kashmir
Library
Muzafar
Abad
20 50651 08 P.A 260
02 Karrakurrum International
University
Gilgit 18 4000 04 N.A 200
Overview of the use of public sector university libraries in Sindh
S.No University Library Location Librarians
grade
Total
Collection
Total
Human
resources
Status of
Automation
Daily
visits of
users
01 Sindh University Library Jamshoro 18 356,,000 80 F.A 1000
02 Sindh Agriculture
University Library
Tandojam 18 180,000 16 N.A 200
03 Liaqat Universityo of
Health and Medical
Sciences Library
Jamshoro 17 96000 21 P.A 1700
04 Dawood College of
Engineering and
Technology Library
Karachi 17 50,000 12 N.A 100
05 Institute of Business
Administration Library
do 17 54000 22 F.A 200
204
06 Chandka Medical Library Larkana 17 150,000 10 N.A 200
07 Shah Abdul Latif
University Library
Khairpur 18 82000 40 N.A 2000
08 Nadirshaw Edulji
Dinshaw (NED)
University of Engineering
and Technology Library
Karachi 18 15000 10 F.A 1000
09 IBA Library Sukkar 17 20,000 04 P.A 120
10 Karachi University
Library
Karachi 20 350,000 135 F.A 2000
11 Mehran University of
Engineering and
Technology Library
Jamshoro 19 80,000 ---- F.A 700
12 Pakistan Navel Academy Karachi 17 25000 08 F.A 30
Overview of the use of public sector university libraries in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
S.No University Library Location Librarians
grade
Total
Collection
Total
Human
resources
Status of
Automation
Daily
visits of
users
01 Agriculture University
Library
Peshawar 20 110,367 20 F.A 3500
02 Malakand University
Library
Dir 17 14,000 04 N.A 200
03 Frontier Women
University Library
Peshawar 17 5000 03 P.A 100
04 Islamia College University
Library
do 18 90,000 13 P.A 300
05 Khyber Medical
University Library
do 18 42,000 10 P.A 270
06 Bannu University Library Bannu 17 17,000 04 N.A 400
07 University of Engineering
and Technology
Peshawar 18 150,000 14 P.A 270
205
University
08 Institute of Management
Sciences Library
do 17 55000 04 P.A 150
09 Abdul Wali Khan
University Library
Mardan 17 20,000 05 N.A 500
10 Gomal University Library D.I.Khan 18 42500 12 N.A 650
11 Peshawar University
Library
Peshawar 19 161716 35 F.A 200
12 Hazara University Library Mansehra 17 60,000 12 P.A 900
13 Kohat University Library Kohat 17 20,000 06 P.A 500
Overview of the use of public sector university libraries in Balochistan
S.No University Library Location Librarians
grade
Total
Collection
Total
Human
resources
Status of
Automation
Daily
visits of
users
01 University of Balochistan
Library
Quetta 20 200,000 26 P.A 1200
02 Lasbela Agriculture
University Library
Lasbela 17 40,000 04 N.A 200
03 Sardar Bahadur Khan
University Library
Quetta 17 12000 04 P.A 150
04 Balochistan University of
Information Technology
Library
do 17 15000 03 N.A 100
05 Balochistan University of
Engineering and
Technology Library
Khuzdar 18 25000 08 N.A 350