rocking out at chichen itza
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/2/2019 Rocking Out at Chichen Itza
1/5
P a g e | 1
Robert Laszkiewicz 996064217 Wednesday, February-29-12
GGR360H1S: Culture, History and Landscapes
Assignment 2: Rocking Out at Chichen Itza
Introduction
In 1972 the World Heritage program was started by the General Conference of UNESCO,
which was established to recognize and protect places that are of both cultural and physical
significance (Rossler, 2007, p. 334). The pre-Hispanic city of Chichen Itza is one of these World
Heritage sites located in Mexico. Being one of the greatest Mayan centres, this site has a rich
history with lots of grand architecture. Chichen Itza is one of the most popular archaeological
sites in Mexico, with numerous tourists, tourism plays an important part to both the site and the
local area. In this assignment I will be analyzing a photograph taken at Chichen Itza during a
concert performed by Elton John. Through this analysis I will identify various aspects that is
depicted in this photograph of how tourism plays in World Heritage sites and how it can change
the meaning and cultural significance of these sites.
Landscape Description
This photograph is of the temple El Castillo, a step pyramid, located at Chichen Itza,
during an Elton John concert. This view of the UNESCO World Heritage site is unlike many
other typical photo's of the landscape. This photo is taken at night, with the step pyramid lit up
with many blue lights, with a concert stage in the center that is brightly lit up with white lights,
contrasting with the step pyramid behind it. In the bottom right of the photo you can see the
fringes of the surrounding audiences. In the photo both the pyramid and the concert stage share
-
8/2/2019 Rocking Out at Chichen Itza
2/5
P a g e | 2
the focus, where you cannot help but look at both the stage and the pyramid when trying to focus
on one of them, due to the sharp contrast they provide.
Rocking Out at Chichen Itza
This photograph is an very interesting photo of a World Heritage site, mainly due to the
fact that the World Heritage site is being used as a backdrop to a live concert performance.
Tourism plays an important part to World Heritage sites, many countries strive to put their own
locales onto the list, knowing it will bring national acknowledgement and an increase in tourism.
Having a live concert performed at the World Heritage site of Chichen Itza is just a part of this
tourism, but what else does it mean for the landscape?
When Elton John's performance was announced there were some objections from both
the local community and archaeologists (Gordon, 2010). The price for the concert tickets were
expensive, especially to those of the Mayan population, and the safety of the site was of concern
to archaeologists (Gordon, 2010). The price of the tickets isolated the local community, meaning
that the audience would consist of those from other countries or of the higher elite classes, those
that do not have a cultural tie to the site. Many of the custodians of Chican Itza are those of the
local community (Breglia, 2006, p. 395), where the job quite often runs in the family so current
custodians' great grandparents were part of the original excavation team. While the locals are
tasked with the upkeep of the site, outsiders and those of upper classes get to enjoy the many
events held there.
When first hearing about the Elton John concert at Chichen Itza, my first initial reaction
consisted of "What exactly does Elton John have to do with Chichen Itza?". Elton John has not
been the only person to perform at Chichen Itza, other big name English musicians such as Paul
-
8/2/2019 Rocking Out at Chichen Itza
3/5
P a g e | 3
McCartney and Sarah Brightman have also performed at the location. What cultural ties if any
are there to English music to Chichen Itza? "As integral part of culture, heritage is an essential
element of national representation with the potential to perpetually remind nationals of the
symbolic foundations upon which a sense of belonging is based. (Park, 2010, p. 116)." When a
site becomes a World Heritage site, it is because of its cultural and physical significance it has to
that country and to humanity as a whole. When a concert is performed at Chichen Itza, it isn't
performed because the historical significance of the site plays a part in the performance, just that
it is being used due to its popularity as a World Heritage site. What national representation is
there of Mexico at the Elton John concert? These concerts are an example of how tourism can
take over of a World Heritage site, where the cultural significance of the site and the national
heritage of the site is downplayed in exchange for outside cultures and interests.
Conclusion
This photograph is an example of how landscapes can change to tourism, not only
physically but culturally as well. While this change in landscape is only temporary at times, what
with the concert stages not being permanent, it is just a sign of a future trend. With big plans in
hotel developments near and around Chichen Itza developers are looking to make Chichen Itza
into the new Cancun (ejalbright, 2012). The more that this site becomes nothing more but a
backdrop to concerts and future resorts, the more the cultural and historical significance of the
site gets downplayed. When a site becomes a World Heritage site, it does so because of not only
its importance to the local country, but due to its importance to humanity as a whole. The site
enters the national stage, and at this point is open to other nations and cultures. For in future
concerts and resorts, it will not be the locals or ancestors of the Mayans who originally built this
-
8/2/2019 Rocking Out at Chichen Itza
4/5
P a g e | 4
city, but those of people from other nations and cultures that will be enjoying the view of
Chichen Itza.
Bibliography
Breglia, L. C. (2006). Keeping world heritage in the family: a geneaology of maya labour at
chichen itza.International Journal of Heritage Studies, 11(5), 385-398.
Cleere, H. (1995). Cultural landscapes as world heritage. Conservation and Management of
Archaeological Sites, 1, 63-68.
ejalbright. (2012, February 12).Mega-tourism development at chichen itza nearing reality?.
Retrieved from http://www.americanegypt.com/blog/?p=2300
Gordon, B. (2010, April 3). Elton john concert at chichen itza encounters opposition. Digital
Journal
Park, H. Y. (2010). Heritage tourism emotional journeys into nationhood. Annals of Tourism
Research, 37(1), 116-135.
Rossler, M, (2007). World heritage cultural landscapes: a unesco flagship programme 1992-
2006.Landscape Research, 31(4), 333-353.
-
8/2/2019 Rocking Out at Chichen Itza
5/5
P a g e | 5
Elton John concert at Chichen Itza. Picture found at
http://photo.lejdd.fr/media/images/culture/musique/elton-john-chichen-itza/1995940-1-fre-
FR/Elton-John-Chichen-Itza_pics_809.jpg