national assembly of pakistan · national assembly of pakistan assembly debates thursday, the 19th...

National Assembly of Pakistan

Assembly Debates Thursday, the 19th of June, 2014.

The National Assembly of Pakistan met in the National Assembly Hall (Parliament House), Islamabad, at 10:35 a.m. of the clock in the morning. Mr. Speaker,

(Sardar Ayaz Sadiq) in the Chair.

Recitation From The Holy Qura�an

'( )* +,-. )/ 0123 4 56 7 (896 : ;<=:,>- ? @AB )- C 9* D(1 E)FG

]IJ6 A9;:: ,= K* L1 M=N>

- ? ); OPQ= .R IS '( T67 )U OV )* ,;K WG,XY )FG Z -BB LR, 3[* ,;.9* )FG B1( \-K;: ,;.9* )FGE )]C ^3_ `( M=Na -b,J= ?( )

- C D b5V(1 )* )U OV b,= K-:, 3[-C M=NWc dPX ?

); N 3_ B B(R’ 6f,;Kgh B1( di,[j 5* `( ,k l7 mRE I= . 2; n>6? )FG -b( )U OV )* 56 7 '( o* ,-pB ); OFG ,XY M=NWc B1( q Wr1 ;s,6 t

-? )- C ,X . M=NWc)V (1E[

,a1 ,-K=Nvw D( -0x6 KV E -M=N6Kyz(

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: |-R5|}~( �'(,�6 . ~ -M�j � -M��= N�3[V( E�@= ��67~�9V( �@��6 C �'( -M� yA�9~V( �@= ��7�9~V(E leave

applications.

2

LEAVE OF ABSENCE

Mr. Ali Muhammad Khan, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 16th May and 6th June, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.) Mr. Speaker: Sardar Ashiq Hussain Gopang, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 16th and 17th June, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.) Mr. Speaker: Malik Iqbal Mehdi Khan, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave from 2nd to 19th June, 2014, due to illness. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.) Mr. Speaker: Mr. Muhammad Riaz Malik, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave from 10th to 17th June, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.)

3

Mr. Speaker: Syed Ayaz Ali Shah Sherazi, MNA, has requested for 6th, 13th and 14th June, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.) Mr. Speaker: Nawabzada Mazher Ali, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave from 5th to 16th May and 3rd to 16th June, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.) Mr. Speaker: Mir Munawar Ali Talpur, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 16th and 17th June, 2014, due to illness. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted.)

Mr. Speaker: Minister for Finance to move Demand No.62. Interior Ministry )V )FG B EM=NWc Minister Sahib Demand No.62 moveE)]�=�* Leader of the Opposition ;s,6 . ,-.9* ); OFG ,XY EM=NWc

�=K/ �=K3/B5-7 L, 3_ 6�7,p B 8�= KV � ( ¡R E -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C(

4

�U.,£ 6s-97 �x;K-7()�=K/ �=K

3/B5-7 �JA( L, 3_:( 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ )P]�h `( -2= nX¤ ,k `,[7( )FG IS (896 : @Wr( T

-C-96 : `( U1,W c M=Na ¥XY ,W cB )FG 8�6 g6? ,k -M3 ¢= N_ ,;.5WG )FG

,= . 8�6 g6? ,;.5WG )FG I= . ;�¦6? @Wr( event ,;.5WG )FG q§( q6 Ky§( ,k T67 M=Na mB,_ ©,_ )* -b(-2= nªfix )¬O* )

; C ,6Y M=NWcE M=Na (B56 O6gh = .( ;s,6 . ,-.9* ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS 1R -bR )®>? 56 7 I°±(1 (5WG B1( `( 9X : ;�j5{Y o* �d² )/ q³6 ? I= . ;s,6 . o* qU �´ IS

M=NJWr ;�¦6? `5¢µ( (5WG )FG B1( `( )/ ¡896 : q W c(,-. ,= K* o´5WG I= . ¶X g· lUCD,-. ¸5V

M=NWc oU ¹5* ¥Wc(,-. ¸5V M=NWc 56 7 `( @�± o* ;s,k97 9* )* )¢¬C ( ;s,°±(1 (�= KX: 9*

)FG B M=NWcE 6�67 IS ;�j5{Y 5* `( ;<º1 -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na q- �;N 6Y q³6 ? ¥»= O

8N=KV5X C -24B5µ M=NWc -b,;K¢*,X . )* +(5} M=NWc -b( 5* = .( ¶; ?,_ ,-K WGB )¬OFG ,XY = .( 8�=O®X . +B,¼ 9X : ,-K WGB )¬OFG ,XY 56 7 ;�j5{Y )

- C ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ )* �x-Y -M3 ¢= C9X : ( 0123 4 ,= K* )FG B1( `( M=Na

,-K=N½= C ;�j5{Y 5* ;�¦6? 8sB5X N_ q³6 ? q¨a )FG IS ¡B,_ b5= O8 :B,X . )- C ¥a 9* ;�j5{Y

5* 8sB5X N_ ¡R )FGE 5; C `( -b,= KjBR = .( ,[= C( I°±(1 5WG ,-.,6Y L1 q³6 ? B5WGD )* B�-.( IS B5WGD M=Na I= . I°±(1 5WG B1( L1 q³6 ? simple q§ = .( ;s,6 . T67 5* �= ., 3_ = .( -bxX . )* ;�g;? -M

U :(-9= :8R ,= K* ,=K´ IS ¾ 6�¿ 1R )]�6? ,6Y 9* -b( )* 56 7 barricades )P

; ? -b( 5* ,-.,À8 ?( IÁ-.5= O* Xs ( )/ B1( @Wr )/ q�-C5* -2= nX¤ qX�PX A o

U ¹5WG )FGE q§( +x_( R,6 . ( M=Na Xs ( ¶{= .R M=NÂ B5WGD M=Na ¶{= .R M=NÂ qXA(9* M=Na ¶{= .R M=NÂ 2W c IÃ6Y Xs ( M=NÀQ= .R IS barricades )ÄÂ )

U C 5WG M=NWcE oU ¹5* I- . o

U ¹5* Å-g3§ q

- �X:( q8 �Æ= N_ )* ;�g;? barricades )

; C ,ÇV M=NWcE M=Na I= . q³6 ? ,;.,;K6: b5®XY IS 2W c,È ¡BR,½V( )

- C mB,JWr )- C ,a -B M=Na q³6 ? = .( ;�¦6? (896 : event ,= K* B1( m896 : +(B (

)/ ,= K*E I= . -¾ =?B,;. )FG `( 5* Xs ( x8KP6 A M= N>- ? ); O{_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ IS 6�67 L1 x»-C

b,W c1 )/ 5; C 6s,6 t-�X: o* ;�j5{Y )

- C ¡896 : M=Nv= K6N_ ); N_ (B M=Na ©(8R 9* b5´5V 5* o- ¹,X . q³6 ? ,= .xX . B1( )V 5PX A q³6 ? )

U C xÀ· B1( -b( 5* ); O®¬K{ÉR )U O´ IS U1,6Y +x_( R,6 . (

5

,6Y 9* ,-KX:( +,k 9* )* EU1,À·R b,W c1 9X : I= . ¡B,_ M=:-2= nX¤ M=NU.5WGE 9Äa @Wr )

- C )- O¯: ( `(57 M=N>

- ? )U C 5P·E @Wr )- O¯: ( `(57 M=Na ); OFG B )

U C 5WG q- �X:( q§,= K/ Xf5Ê ¶6 gË§ 5*

)- Oj ,_ ); OP·B )U C 5WG past practice 5* )- Oj ,_ ); OP·B )

U C 5WG political reconciliation5* )- Oj ,_ ); OP·B )

U C 5WG X�3/B 8�= KV o* b5; O=:(�W c 5* )- Oj ,_ ); OP·B )

U C 5WG m896 : 26 np )* ¶; ?,_ @Wr )

- C `( 5* ¥=.8R ,= K* B1( m896 : +(B ( )* ¶; ?,_ -b( 5* TXC(1 9* ,= .RE o

U ¹5* ,[= C( event create M=N>- ? )

- C 5WG ,= .R IS T67 )/ ^va M=Na = .( qU �

-: ¡dÌ;C(di( (�= KX: 5WGE 9Äa )P]�h ¶6 gË§ M=Na M=N>- ? ,;. ( IS `( -b,= KjBR 6�67

`( ;�j5{Y 5* ;sB12- Í )FG = .( )¢¬C ( ©57,a o* b,>6A ¥JQa B5² 9X : -b( 2W c I½6 O² 9{¼ o* ;<=:,JA ¥p,Y 5WG )¢¬C ( ;�3¢WGR b1R9´ �x-Y)*E ;�j5{Y R5-7 = .( ;�3¢WGR

¡R9´ 9* mR = .( )8 C 5PX A )/ barricades M=NWc ¾ 6�¿ 1R )]�6? )

- C ,8K WG 9X : IS -b( 5* ,= .,8K WG ,6Y ,W cB )FG 5; C `( )* �°6 C 56 7 (5WG q³6 ?( L, 3_ R5y�h 6�7,p Xs ( 5*

M=NU.,;K6: )´ IS L1 b,W c1 )/ 5WG 9* )

U C ( M= NWc IS ,= K* ©,t;?B5¿ o

U ¹5WG )FGE ,6 K=:dÎ;C

80’ 90b5´5V 5* bullets qÐÂ oU ¹5WG )FG )- O

;N]Y qË- A -B M=NWcE b1 8�-.8R )/ 5; C -M=N

;.1R qË- A -B M=NWcE I= . ;s,6 . o* qU �´ B1( b,>=? ;. )P]�h q

3§5-7 oU ¹5WG IS 5®XY Ñ= OX7 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p )

- C 6�67 I= . I>· ,= .R )FG IS M=Na R5-7 ¥-.5= O6:9

8 : 56 7 @U ?,£ (5WG )FG M=Na `(

)* `,X . xXY bU1,6Y ,ÒE q�* B 8�= KV )- C ,>· IS `( 5* �qÌÓ

;N_( mR 9* ,-.,6Y )¬OFG ,XYE M=Na -b( b1-2= nX¤ M=Na M=N>

- ? ,-.89X : ,;K WG,XYE M=Na 8�- OU:(5X C \-.B5{_ M=N>- ? ,-.9* ,;K WG,XYE M=Na

B 8�= KV � ( ¡R -M3 ¢= C -B5X C( B1( = .( ;�},J6 A ,k Iª-R B(R Å

-g3§ o* ;�=O3N=K7 )/ ,;K¦·

b5WG IS 6s,-K67 (� -Y ,;K-:,6Y )FG IS Xs ( )/ LR,= .-B M=NJWr q�= C9*5y=?8R -9= :-dÔ )FGE @Wr

Xs ( o* -b( o8 ¹5PX A o

8 ¹5PX A b5; C,6 . 9X : b5= O* ;<=:,JA ); C 9* M=NWc `( o* I6 Y1 ,= K* )FGE

,= K* @Wr B(�;K±( M=Na )P8 �¬N6. M=NWcE M=NJWr I= . B(�;K±( )¬OFG ,XY ,= . q§9* )¬OFG ,XYE M=N>

- ?E M=NJWr `( ^va M=Na ;<=:B5¦Ë6A )¬OFG ,XY B1( ¡B5¦Ë6A )®Õ¬Oµ )¬OFG ,XY IS Xs ( ¡B5¦Ë6A )®Õ¬Oµ M=:9*

6

B1( )¢¬C ( ;sD,Y (�= KX: I- . M=:9* IS ¡B,JWr `( ;<=:B5¦Ë6A 5* -b,ÕÖ-C 5WG T67 ;<=:B5¦Ë6A

o* d²,-Y B,½ÆV(1-R q¨w 58 OP6 ? ); O-g;? B(R 9X : ×89X 7 )U O´E 28 n=K

8NS8R )* ¶; ?,_ oU ¹5* 8�- Oy=?9Ä= .(

M=N>- ? ,= K* IS M=N>· +5± I= . I- . )P]�Ë§ IS -b(�;K/,= K/ ©R-96 : 5WG 9* ^À6 A )

; C ,6Y M=NWc B1( B8R )

; C ,6Y M=NWcE )]C 58 OP6 ?d Ø�-C 5* R56 71,6 . `( )* IS ,>· ,= K´ IS M=NJ

;? @ØÙ}(9= : -B1 )

; C ,-K6: M=NWc @

; ? qU �6:R ¶8 �=N6. U1,6YE b,W c1 ;�j U1,6Y ¡B,J;? o´�-. -B 5* Ld�-7 )FGE `( )

- C ,>· IS M=Na 9´( M=N>

- ? qU �´ 5; C ;<=:B5¦Ë6A )/ b5´5V ,k -M=N½= C ¶8 ?( )U C ,6Y ,ÒE `( ;<=:B5¦Ë6A

)* )¬OV @Wr )- C ,= K* ¶X g· M=N>

- ? ,= .5P· )FGE @Wr 5; C `( ;<=:B5¦Ë6A 5* )- C ,X t6? )¬OV )*

B(8R 6�7,p Xs ( )* ¶; ?,_ m8dP· M=NWc B1( @Wr 2W c ;<º1 2W c +�£ 9X : Xs ( )/ 1R +�£ )´ ( ,6Y )FG B M=NWc IS ;<=:B5¦Ë6A )* 9X :1( o

U ¹5* I- .,>6? 9* )* 6�3/ -b5-7 I- . B,a

mRE oU ¹5* ;<=:B5¦Ë6A 5* @

; �-7 I- . 9* mR oU ¹5* -b( 5* I- .,>6? )®a IS I= . ¥Wc(,-.

¸5V M=NWcE -b(�;K/,= K/ M=N>- ? xXY ); O{_ `( ^va 5*E b5

- C(�;K/,= K/ o* capability M=N>- ? )FG IS L1 xXY M=NÁ_E 6�67 IS `( ^va M=Na ¶X g·,-K;N 6Y (5WG )FG L1 b5

- C(�;K/,= K/ )- C ,= K* )FGE `( )]C q

- �=NU. ( ^va 5* -M=NU. ( q³6 ? b5

- C(�;K/,= K/ )- C ,= .R )FGE @Wr )

- C ,= .R )FG `( 8�- Oy=�VB,X . )

- C ,= .R )FGE I= . ¸5V )- C ,>6? 8�-.5Ú8R )FG B M=NWc B1( Xs ( ,= K*

9* )FG B M=NWcE = .( qÙ®-w )* 9X :1( = .( qÙ®

-wE M=Na q- �X:( ;<=:B5¦Ë6A )* )¬OV 1B ,W cB

b5WGE M=Na `( ;<=:B5¦Ë6A )* )¬OV 1B ,W cB b5WG T67 )* )¬OV @Wr )- C m8B5*

)U C ,À·E T67 )* )¬OV @Wr )

- C b,= K¢-C,ÀX ? M=Nv= KP6 AE T67 )* )¬OV @Wr b5®= K67 M=Na

)U O´E T67 )* )¬OV mB,JWr )¯�6? b53 ¢= N 3_ )* )P¯�=�X: ); O-g=�X7 )FG BE )

8 C 5PX A )8 C 5PX A 1 -B,6 .

); C xW c )

U C 5WG ¡B,JWr �d² )- OÚ 896 : o* 3T3Ê5* o* 9Äa @Wr )

- C )- O¯: ( Xs ( 5* Û6 O -¿ ); C 9* )

U C 5WG )- O¯: ( )8 C 5PX A )¯�6? )/ LR,= .

-B )- O¯: ( +5ÜÓj `( )¯�6? o* ¡B,= KX: b5- g=�X7 )/ 8�WG 9* @Wr )

- C q- �X:( ;<=:B5¦Ë6A 5* )®Ò ,= .,ÇVE `( ;<=:B5¦Ë6A 5* 9´( Xs ( o*

`( q W c(,-. o* I6 Y1 )/ Xs ( o* inefficiency o* I6 Y1 )/ Xs ( )* -b(

7

¥Wc(,-. bureaucrats o* I6 Y1 )/ 9´( Xs ( dPX ? L1 ); C 9* M=NWc IS )- O;: ( ¸5V )

- C dh )* �°6 C dPX ? Xs ( ); O¦· M=NWc IS I= . -M¢7 ¡BR,£ `( 5* ,;K-:,6Y q³6 ? M=Na M=N>

- ? b5WG B1( -M=N

;. B(-2W c 56 7 -M*B,k M=NWc -b( )* 9X :1( Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( B ( 6fBR 9* ); O¬: R M=NWcE 6s,-K67

9{= KXN_! q§ q§ oX¹ 1( -b5* )FG 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ �= ., 3_ Xs ( 5* @¨w 5WG 9Äa `( -b(5= C( 5* @¨w M=N>

- ? 5WG ,Ò IS q§ q§ oX¹ 1( ,k oU ¹,À6 ? @=?( oX¹ m( )FG Xs ( ,k 56 7 b,= Kj

-B,6 K¦3§ Ñ= C2

3 4 )- C q

- �X:( 8�=N_ ¡8B5PX A B1( `( q§ q§ 5X C 1( )* oU ¹,À6 ? 5* ¡RE @Wr

,= K* M=NÀ6 �Ë§

IS I= . L1 ¸5V M=NWc B1( 5®Ò -b(5®>X?E Xs ( R5-7 B(8R 6�7,p `( -2= nX¤ 5* M=NÀQ= .R (B(� -Y ’ Xs ( ,-K=N½= C = .( )¢¬C ( -b,[

-C( M=NWc -M6 7 5* `,[7( ,;.5WG )FG 9Äa Xs ( B56 O6gh 5WG )

; C ,6Y b5WG )´ IS ,= K* b19* B1( ,=K* b5¦· M=Na b5´5V M=Na 5; C M=N>- ? I>·

,;K{_ �= ., 3_ Xs ( q- �X:( o

- ¹1B�-.( \-K8N=Kj M=Na ); O¦· b5WGE 5®Ò -b(5®>X? Xf,-. ,W cB )FG T=C( oX¹ `( 5* )®Ò ,ÇV ,W cB )FGE I= . 6¾

8?5µ )FGEdPX ? ,k5* D5* o* M=Nv;.56 C )V 9* ( ,W cB

)FG IS 5= OX: @; ? ¸5VE I= . ,= K* )FGE dPX ? -M=N

;. B(-2W c b5´5V )* 9X :1( -M67 5* Xs ( )- C

(B,a )FG B1( ,6Y 9* M=NÀQ= .R L1 LB(R( T67 5* Xs ( )- C b,= KV5´ M=:B,aE )P]�h L1 9{¼

q³6 ? M=N>- ?E M=Na q§( -b(5= C( M=Na b,= Kj 6�7,p 6�67 `( -b(5= C( M=Na )

U C ( `( )/ )®>? )- O¯: ( -B5= C28 n-.( M=Na ,>· IS ¶X g· ¸5V )¢¬C ( M=NWc 56 7 `( ;�j5{Y )* �x-Y q�= C(

conspiracy 9* )FG B M=NWc IS I= . ¶X 7 )- O¬N>h M=Na )®¯Y M=NU.,6YE L1 ); OFG ,XY M=NWc IS

¡BR,½V(2W c,È 5* q�* )Î¬C d² )/ M=NS1B B1( m9;:( 5; C ,[= C( (1,ÉR M=NÂ56 C IS T6 C L1 @; � -7 5WG )

U C ,6YE 6s,-K67 b5= OU:(89V )/ oU ¹5* -2= nX¤ @

; � -7 M=N>- ? o

; ¹5WGE oU ¹(89V )/ B1( q; �Ú896 :

)FGE -b(�;K/,= K/ 5; C ,;K WG,XY q Wr I= . )FG IS b,= KU:(89V b5WG ¡2= nª ;s,6 . d Ø�

-C )U C ( B1(

M=Na ¶X g· 9* ,W cB b5WGE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ 6�67 I= . ;sD,Y b5WG ’ M=Na )- C = .( -bR )®>?

,>· IS 8B5PX A 1R `( ¡BR,½V(2W c,È 5* )- C 9*B1( 1R )¢®]Y `( 5*E `R )¢®]Y m9* 56 7

q³6 ? )FG ,XY )¢®]Y m9*E Xs ( 8K=:9*5y=?8R M=NWc ¶8 �=N6. M=NU.,6Y 56 7 ;s,6 . 9* ,;. )FGE ,= K*

8

;sB12- Í ¡89X : q³; ? IS 2)]�6? L1 ,-.¥Wc( ¸5V 56 7 ,-. ¥Wc( 2= n 3[j M=NWc Xs ( )* ¶; ?,_

M=NWc -M6 7 ,k R5-7 terrorist b5´5V )* ¶; ?,_ -b( ,k IÞ6 C(B )FGE 56 7 ); OFG ,XY M=NWc IS I= . 56 7 b,= Kj -B(5

- C Ñ= C23 4 )

- C bold step ,= KV )FG B1( 56 7 +�£ ,= .,À8 ?( )FG B1( I- .

(� -Y o* ;�=O3N=K7 )/ `( q; �3¢* 5* mB,-K* 9X : )V 9* )

- C ,6Y ,k +�£ ,= .,À8 ?( )FGE `(

5* q�* )Î¬C d² )/ 3B,;.56 N_ m9*E M=N>- ?( b5´5V Xs ( o* b5Æ¿ M=Na )P

8 �¬N6. )U C 5WG b5´5V )

- C I= . +,k (19* 9* -b( -b,6 KV,È o* R�a o* )FG B1( I- . IS Xs ( o* R�a o* )FGE dPX ? Xs ( 5* ); O¦· M=NWc IS -M=N

;. B(-2W c b5´5V )* 9X :1( Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( B ( 6fBR

9* 1R B1( I= . q�-C5* dPX ? Xs ( o* ¥

-.5= O6:98 : 5WG o´E )P]�h 5; C dPX ? ;<=:B5¦Ë6A ,k `(

8�- Oy=�VB,X . ,k B1( `( ^va )* b5´5V o* -b( b5= O-:,6 .dº ,k B5Ü

; C ,;. ( )FG IS `( I6 Y1 )/ (2= nª I= . -b,;K¢*,X . ,-K6:E ¥k Xs ( 5* q�* mB,JWr MNA )

- C ,>· IS Xs ( @ØÙ}(�U.,£ )* b5j�£ )* )¯�=�

-: )P8 �¬N6. M=NWcE T67 )

- C )- O¯: ( b5j�£ 9X : ¥XY 9* ¡B5X C o´�-. -B M=Na I= . -b,;K¢*,X . ,-K6: 9* M=NJWr ,= .RE ,= K* mB,JWr )¯�6? 6f ( @Wr )/ ,[

-C5* -b,;K¢*,X . M=NÃ

-.,a )´E @Wr -b( 5* ,[-C5* -b,;K¢*,X . M=:R )´ T* @�± ,k 6f ( I= . ¡B,JWr

Iª-R ¡B(R )FG I- . IS b5- C(dËQY o* Iª-R ¡B(R )FGE M=Na 6f ( q³6 ? ,;K¦· b5WG B1( (896 :

¾-ß(1 B5² ,;K¦·9X : b5WG IS M=Na Xs ( 9X : o

U ¹5* �= KÖ-O; : M=N>

- ? 9* ,W cBà M=Na Xs ( )* �x-Y oU ¹5* ;s,6 . M=N>

- ? 9* ,W cBà ¡2= nª oVR 3TWG(5-7 )FG IS (B(� -Y )- O¯: ( ¶; ?,_ )¢¬C ( 2= n 3[j M=NÀ·Bà )¢¬C ( ¸5V M=NÀ·B IS 56 7 Xs ( 5* ¾ =�g

ß ;�y§ M=Na )V M=NvXY B1( Xs ( `( ^va M=Na o

- ¹(dËQY X¾-?,X . ©,_ ,k `R ©,_ M=:9*à9Äa ;<=:B5¦Ë6A o* ¡2; nÀX A )* )�=�

-: M=:9*E @Wr Xs ( )* ¶; ?,_ b5WG )´ 9Äa I= . M=:-2= nX¤ Xs ( 5* M=N>

- ? o- ¹9* )¬OFG ,XY IS `(

@�± )/ Xs ( -b( b5´5V 5* = .( ;<º,È 3T-g6? )FG B M=NWc 56 7 ¸5V ); OFG ,XY M=NWc IS

`( ^va M=Na ;<=:B5¦Ë6A I- . 5WGE@Wr Xs ( 5* ;<º,È 3T-g6? )FG B M=NWcà@Wr Xs ( ,k ¶; ?,_

mR )FG B M=NWcà @Wr Xs ( )* ¶; ?,_ -b1,°;C 9* )FG B M=NWcE IÁ-.5= O* Xs ( )- C ;<=:B5¦Ë6A

9

)* )¬OV b,= K-:,6 .dº M=:Rà ^va )/ 2W c,6 . )U O´ B1( Xs ( )/ LR,= .

-B -b5* M=N>- ? ,;K-:,6Y IS

6�67 b,= Kj 6�7,p `( ^va )/ 2W c,6 . )U O´ 5; C )- O;NS ¸5V )P

; ? 56 7 b,= Kj 6�7,p )* ¶; ?,_ b,>=? 9X : m8dP· )P

; ?à )- O;NS ¸5V )P

; ? 56 7 b,= Kj 6�7,p 5* 8B5PX A 9* ¸,À6 ? )U O´ )P

; ? B1( d Ø�-C M=N>

- ? ); C ( )P

; ?E I= . L1 ¸5V M=NWc B1( dPX ? d Ø�-C M=N>

- ? M=NU. ( )´E 9Äa

b,= Kj 6�7,p I= . ;<=:B5¦Ë6A 5WG o´ 5; C Xs ( q Wr @ØÙ}(9= : -B1 b5WG )´ B1( M=Na q³6 ? 9ÚR(

-M3 ¢= C -B5X C( B 8�= KV b5WG ,ÒE I= . ;<=:B5¦Ë6A 5WG o´ 5; C b,>=? )* ¸5V b,W c1 M=N

U.,6Y )´E 9Äa I= . ;<=:B5¦Ë6A 5WG o´ 5; C -b,;K¢*,X . 5WG ,ÒEM=Na dPX ? = .( I6 K

;:dh I= . ,;K¦· b5WG IS I= . ;<=:B5¦Ë6Aà q�= C9*5y=?8R q Wr `( ^va o* ;<

- :,J-ß )FGà `( ^va o* o

U ¹5* ;<=:dh ( ;<- :,J-ß M=N>

- ?à oU ¹5* 28 n=K

8NS8R ;<- :,J-ß M=N>

- ? mR ,;K{_E ;<=:B5¦Ë6A B1( ;<=:dh ( M=Na ( 8B5P; ? ,_ Zdi )FG IS 9´( ;<=:B5¦Ë6A B�-.()* ¡8B5P; ? )/ q³6 ? ;<=:dh ( o* 8s1xa 9* 1R 5; C dPX ? ;<=:B5¦Ë6A ;<=:dh ( ,k IÕ7 -M6 : o

; ¹,6Y )FGE `( )¬OV `( ;<=:dh ( ,k IÕ7 `( ;<=:B5¦Ë6A M=Na I- . M=NÂ(8Rà `( -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na Xs ( �2Í )®Õ¬Oµ )¢¬C ( M=:9* IS 56 7

-b,;K¢*,X . )* +(5} Xs ( 5* ,-KX:( qÎ= OÖ7 B 8�= KV @=�®[;C M=:9*E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: ,-.(B 9= :5- O; : 6�7,p 3 B(-9´ )FG IS ¥k q³6 ? ;s,6 . oU ¹5WG q§(

subject 9X : B1( b5Ê9X : q³6 ? B1( 2W c ¥»= O8N=KV5X C o

8 ¹B,X . )- C `( 9X : ;s,6 . 9* oV )FGE

B 8�= KV � ( (R -M3 ¢= C -B5X C( ,k prerogative )FG M=Na -b( 5* b1R ,Ò `( )* L1xw

M=Na mR M=N>- ? ,;K{_EM=Na )

- C T-C-96 : )´ ( ,-.xXY E)FG I= . M=N>

- ? 5WG ,;K{_ IS 2W c ¥»= O8N=KV5X C o

8 ¹B,X . ;s,6 . m9* B1( dPX ? `( ,k 2W c B 8�= KV 9* ( ;s,6 . ,-.9* E)FG ,XY ,-.(B 9=:5- O; : 6�7,p

,-.(B 9= :5- O; : -M=N[7 : I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 E9{= KXN_ M=Na �= K

3/B5-7 L, 3_ 6�7,p ,k ;�¦6? B5{ 3[j M=NWc IS b5¦- ?( )

- C ;<=:B5¦Ë6A )* l®°;Oj )- O¯: ( 56 7 ;s,6 .

-�6Y M=NWc B1( 56 7 o8 ¹B,X .

)* ;s,6 .-�6Y M=NWc ,= . o

8 ¹B,X . o* struggle )FG 5; C `( ,k b5¦- ?( )- C LR,w( ,= K* ()FG

10

B1 b,>=? B,6 . B,6 . ,;.5WG ,;K WGB )FGE -M{= KV I= . q³6 ? m2= nª ©,= K-7 M=Na M=N>

- ? ,-KV5P6 ? )¬OFG ,XY IS ¡B,JWr q³6 ? `( ;<=:B5¦Ë6A )* )¬OV ;�¦6? q6�yz struggle )FG B1( `( )* )¬OV @Wr )

- C )¢¬C ( )¢¬C ( +,k )¬O* M=NWc 56 7 I= . )®À�X? ©,_ ); O-: ,6Y M=NWc ,= . `( )/

)®>? mB,JWr -b( )* ¶; ?,_ )�]C (B )FG B M=NWc B1( 98 :B,XY � ( q�=C9*5y=?8R 9X : sign )¬O*E I= . = .( dÌ/ @Wr )

- C ,À8 �*( )² ,= K* B1( `( M=Na oU ¹5* ^3_ M=N>

- ? )FG IS -b( o* b,= K

-:,6 .dº B1( ¡B,JWr struggle B1( ¡B,JWr b,= K-:,6 .dº q³6 ? q�* )/ @· M=N>

- ? )FG I= . = .( ¡28 n[WG E)FG -M{= KV `( I°±(1 9X : 6�6 7 ¥k T

-C,-Kµ 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )

- C ¥k = .( ¥=KÜÆ

;C )/ -b,= K6: ,= .R B1( b,>=? 9X : q�= NÂ,X . 8�- Oy8 �=N8K/ mR ¡R 5; C dPX ? `( )*

�°6 C M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS I= . q³6 ? ;<=:B5¦Ë6A ,k IÕ7 )FG IS M=NJWr M=N>· I- . M=N>· âB ,-.,6Y )¬OFG ,XYE = .( I°±(1 (5WG )FG B1( ;�¦6? â,-K/5¢µ( I°±(1 )FG B1( (2= nª ©,= K

-7 )FG IS @U ?(9X : 28 n[

-Na )- C q³6 ? T

8C5- C ,= KV )FG B1( b5¦- ?( )

- C condemn ,= K* )FG B1( b,>=? Ù1,W c M=Nacondemn ,= K* E)FG mB,_ o

U ¹,6 .5¿ Ù1,W c almost 2W c = .( )- C

condemn ,= K* )FG B1( resolution `,X . o* )FGEÑ= OX7 28 n[-Na 6s,6 t

-�X: )- C `(

9X : ;�- g§ @�± ,k -M3 ¢{= .( ,= KV )FGà ;�- g§ @�± o* ¥k 8�- O6N=K* \-K8N=Kj 9* )* ;�- g§

@�± )* )®Õ¬Oµ )¬O* M=NWc B1( `( 9X : follow up 5WG ,W cB )FGE (2= nª ©,= K-7 )FG

IS 6s( M=NJWr `( -2= nX¤ 9X : âB ,-.,6Y )¬OFG ,XYE 5WG ,;K{_ )FG IS L, 3_ 6�7,p )- C T67

RBR )* ¶; ?,_ ;s,6 . o* )FG IS oU ¹5* hidden hands 5WG ); O{_ M=NWcà 5{_( @Wr

rule out M=N>- ? )

; C 9*E -M{= KV @Wr )- C )P

8 �*( ¥a 9* I- .(96 :�a )Î¬C d² )/ ); O®¯Y )U C 5WG

-b( 5* q³6 ? )]C 6s,½-C ,-.9* )FG B1( `( )* )¬OV M=NJWr patience o* ;sB12- Í

)FG I- . IS @Wr `( fd² ,k = .( B1( @�± o* ;s,6 . 9* )* )]C q- �=N XY )V M=N

U. ( B1( 2W c �d² )/ )

U C ,6 t6? I= . ,>· )U C ,6Y IS ãD )* l6C,Þj 56 7 q³6 ? Iv[®_ 5WG ,Ò `( 5*

handle ,= K* )U C ,6Y ,Ò B1( `( ,k 56 7 q³6 ? 8<V -BB )

U C ( ,Ò 5; C '(ã, 3[

-C( �oV,°;C Ù1,W c

11

)* )- Oj ,_ @Wr M=NÀ·B )É `( 9X : 56 7responsibility fix 5WG o´ 5; C `( 9X : 9´( -M

3 ¢{= .( I- . (5WGà B1( dPX ? M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS )- C ( )V (1 b5

- CR M=Na @U ?(9X : 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p ItËz I6 . ItËz -b( )* ¶; ?,_ in touch q³6 ? M=NWc b,W c1B1( )/ ¡B,_ M=N

8.5X CB )V M=NWc)FG B B1( )

- C ( )V (1 = .( 1R b5- CR M=Na q�= C( M=:-2= nX¤ q³6 ? 9* )FG Bà �= ., 3_

mB,JWr U1,W c M=Na )P8 �¬N6. )

U C 5WG mB,_ ;�/1R -MU NJÙj 5WG M=N

U.,6YE M=Na I= . -b( 5* q8 �-:B,Ò )/ ,;K¦· b5WGE`( )¬OV I= . ,-K¦· IS �2Í ;<=:B5¦Ë6A ,k -b( 5* 1BR )FG B1( M=NJWr M=N>

- ? )FG (2= nª ©,= K-7 )FG IS I= . o

; ¹R,= .-B )FGà M=NJWr q³6 ? `,[7( )FGE Xs (

)- C 5; C X¾

-?,X . ©,_ ;�j5{Y o*à¥»V,6 . )P¯A ( )Î¬C d² )/ Xs ( à)- C 56 7 political side

q³; ? governance o* ;s,6 . M=: 8B5PX A B1( qº,6 . ;sxa,°j 5* M=: 8B5PX A M=Na `( ;<º1

;s,6 . M=N>- ? ,;.9* -M{= KV b,>6A 9X : political side q³

; ? Xs ( ;<=:,>- ? 3 5-7 o6¹5®_( )/ )´ ( ); OÚ 896 : )FG B B1( @Wr Xs ( )* ¶; ?,_ m8dP· )FG BE -M{= KV 6f ( M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS q³6 ?( ;�j5{Y 5* = .( ©,_ (5WG )FG B1( ;�j5{Y )- O¯: ( m 8�-K6g=?( 9X : +,k 9* q WrB )FGà ;�j5{Y ¡2; n>6? o* �d² ,6Y q WrB )FGà ¡B,_ ,=K

-:R M=Na = .( ,ÀX A( +,-. (�= KX: (5WG )FGE M=Na Xs ( -M=N½= C5* )/ ,;K¦· b5WG IS ,= K

-:R ,k 2W c ^va 6s( ¡B,JWr �d² ¶{= .R ,W cB IS)FG -b( o* positive direction)FGE -M{= KV M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS 9´( `( @�± o* M=N

3_ -B,_ b5WG o´ 5; C -b( 5* q³6 ? ¥a 9* +,k,-. ,-.,-K6: )FGE `( )¬OV IS L1 M=NJWr qº9;: ,;.9* (5WG M=N>

- ? ¶{= .R ); O{_à )FG ,XY L1 q�* �d² )/ q³6 ? 3 -B,_ 5WGà )FG ,XY 2W c,6 . )/ 5WG ,= . B�-.( )/ 5WGE (2= nª ©,= K

-7 )FG IS @Wr 6�/ )P8 �*( b5WG )É

I= . ;s,6 . ;�/BR )FG IS @Wr 6f ( 9ÚR( )P8 �¬N6. M=NWc B1( ¥k Xs ( I= . ); O¦· )P

; ? IS Xs ( 9ÚR( M=NWc Xs ( ¥k 9ÚR( b5WG )É @Wr ); O¦· M=NWc IS L, 3_ R5y�h 6�7,p M=NWc B1(

mB,_ M=NWcà ¥k 9ÚR( b5WG )É`( )¬OV IS 9´( I= . process )®¯Y ,Ò B1( M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS I= . ,-K¦·à q6�yz ;s,6 . 5WG )

U C ,6Y o´ M=Na @; � -7 ,-.9* ,;K WG,XY b5WGE -M{= KV

12

+1�-th L, 3_ R5y�h q3 �= Cdº 6�7,p )P8 �¬N6. )

U C 5WG M=NWcà = .( �d² I= . ,-K¦· IS @Wr ;<=:B5¦Ë6A )* qh,Y M=NWc B1( ¡241R �d² `( @�± )* ;sD,Y (�= KX: ,-.9*à M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS

;<=:B5¦Ë6A o* oU ¹5* ;�j� -Y M=N>

- ? )FGE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: Kindly wind up M=:9*E ,-.(B 9= :5- O; : -M=N[7 : `( M=Na @Wr 6�/ 5* IÕ7 ,-KV(8R )FG B1( 6�/ 5* )´ (

¥a 9* )´ ( ,-KÚ896 : )FG B1( `( 5* ¥J�;? B1( ¡B,6 .R96 : )/ T67 fd² )®À�X? X¾

-?,X . ©,_ @Wr )´ ( )V 9* )®¯Y M=NWc B1( -b( b1B(R( 5* ä56 O-Üj ()FG ,-.9* B1 @Wr )

- C -b,;K¢*,X . o* qº9;: ,kà -b,;K¢*,X . o* oV,t

3§5-7 ,kà -b,;K¢*,X . )* B,£1 ,k ( 8�-K6g=?( @Wr )- C ¥JQa ,-.9*

E)FG ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E

Mr. Speaker: Item No. 5. Discussion and voting on demand for grants in respect of voted expenditure other than charged expenditure. Now we will take up the Ministry of Interior and Narcotics for Cut Motions.

M=Na )- C Xs ( o* o

8 ¹B,X . 5* @U ?,8 . mR ,= .R ,À; ? B1( -b( ,k Ñ±5j ,= K ( ,À; ? every

we cannot, Leader of the Opposition,kprerogative ,;.5WG )FG that I give +1�-th 6�7,p -2= nvX .à dPX ? (2= nª ( 8�-K6g=?( LB )

U C ,6Y ,ÒE¥k ¾ 6�¿ `R )]�6? )/ )V 9* ;s(B LB,= K´ )]�6? ;. )P

8 �¬N6. M=NWcE B 8�= KV � ( (R -M3 ¢= C -B5X C(E

�=K/ �=K

3/B5-7 �JA( L, 3_: M=Na )- C 56 7 ;s,6 . o*à)P]�h 5; C patience o* ;s,6 .

o* ,6Y q WrB )FG IS patience ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XYà m2= nª oU ¹,À6 ? M=NWc m2= nª )

- C (9X : q³; ?,_

13

)FG B M=NWcà M=Na )- C o

U ¹5* q�= C( ;s,6 . M=N>- ? o*àM=Na )

- C ;�j5{Y o* ;s,6 . o* B1( `( )* �°6 C LB�-KX: 8�- Oj 9=:dÎ

;C M=:9* )´ 5; C dPX ? R5y�h -b,-Y ,= . L,3_ R5y�h b5= O* M=N>- ? M=NÂ56 C )´E Xs ( 9´( )- O¯: ( 9= : -B1 5* â1B ); O¬: R 5; C qå±(1 M=:9= :dÎ

;C1R I- . M=N;.5WGE

6s( Xs ( R5-7 = .( æ±5j mR ); O¬: R M=NWc B1( L1 6s(56 7 )- O¬: R )* )¬OV m8dP· 5WG ); C ,6Y M=NWcE M=Na )

- C 5; C ;�j5{Y o* R5-7 ;<V,k1 o* B1( b,>=? 9X : (8dP· 5WG ,= K´E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: M=Na = .( 8�- Oj )* �°6 Cà B(8R 6�7,p )- OFG B M=:R )P]�h 9* )- O¬NÂ M=:RE = .( = .( 8�- Oj )* �°6 C M=Na )

- C = KU:,a �-K6: 9* ,-K=:R )FG B1( -2= nvX . ¡2= nª

;�/(5-7BR )FG IS ¥k q³6 ? 8�6 g6? M=:9= :dÎ;C o

U ¹5WG M=NWc B1( relevant ministry o* �-KX7 M=:9= :dÎ

;C oU ¹5WG M=NWcà T67 fd² I[= Nç

-C L, 3_ I6 K7,p )- C B1( b5= O±,6 . )

- C o* M=NÀ; ?

to the point relevant and factsE 6f ( 9´( Interior )FG 5; C we will talk about Interior, we will not talk about the entire budget that has been taking place and I will not allow

more than three or four minutes. l�g§( B(8R E 6�7,p

6s,-K67 �J�h Z,t§( B(8R : 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E M=Na �2Í ¥6K=:9-: (

B 8�= KV � ( (R -M3 ¢= C -B5X C( 5* I= . assure ,-.9* ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS basically m2= nª

\= KV5* ,-.(B 9= :5- O; : 6�7,p actually b5¦- ?( )- C endorse ,= K* )FG 56 7 b5¦- ?(

)- C ,>· )FG B1( B 8�= KV � ( (R -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C( 5* appreciate ,= K* )FG B1( -b( o* efforts 5*E M=Na 3 B(-9´ I= . b19* ,Ò IS IÁ-.5X 7 Interior q Wr xÒ( )FG B1( M=Na

8<* -M3/5j q³6 ? M=NWc B1( -b( 8<* -M

3/5j M=Na 9= :B,½;C q³6 ? b5WG o´ B1( Xs ( `( 9X :

14

;s,6 . 9* M=NÂà @· -B( @· T-C-96 : q³6 ? ¶; ?,_ E)®¯Y 24 (2= nª ©,= K

-7 IS)FG 1R -BB 8�= KV 5* 1R 1R 8�- Oj mR M=:RE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: +1�-th L, 3_ R5y�h q3 �= Cdº E 6�7,p

+1�-th L, 3_ R5y�h -M=N[7 q3 �= Cdº : 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! B 8�= KV � ( (R -M3 ¢= C -B5X C( )

- C 6f ( 56 7 B5WGD ,k â,-K/5¢µ( It

-?,_ )FG `( ,k I;K{-. ,= .,À8 ?( T67B1( )]C -�6Y ,k b5¦- ?( )

- C B,> Øè( ,= K* M=Na `( o* �=K

U:,; . ,;.9* b5WG B1( ,-.(B 9= :5- O; : 6�7,p )- C 6s(56 7 ,= .R L1 q³6 ? (896 :

©5ÖÓj 6s(56 7 ,À; ? B1( M=Na `( 6s(56 7 5* q³6 ? M=N>- ? ,-.x8KP6 A b5WG,XY ,ÒE 6s,-K67

9{= KXN_ !@Wr b,>=? ;�6 O3Na Xf5Ê )V 9* )P8 �¬N6. M=NWc B1( @Wr ); OFG ,XY M=NWc Iva,°j )P]�¨_à Iva,°j

(89Ä6 . )FGE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! M=Na `( )¬OV -édÔ 9* ,W cB b5WG IS M=Na ¥k R5-7 ©,;KXN[WG ,= K´ B1( M=Na -M=N½7(5V )/ xaà M=Na )

- C qË- A -B b5´5V 5* ,ÀQ= .R B1( M=Na `( U1,W c 5*

0xÈ( ,-.9* ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS 83 ¸5V M=NWc -M6 7 5* bullet injuries M=NÀ; ?à mB,JWr

); C 5WG )

U C 5WG b,W c1 9X : -M= N;. ;s(5j( B1( 5WG M=N

UK´à LB,= K´ deaths 5WG qU �´ M=NWc B1( 1R -M=N;.(5-7 M=NWcE ¥k q³6 ? T=NÂ,; . 8B( )8 O

-NÀê )- C B-9´ )* R56 71,6 . ,;KX:,= . M=N>

- ? T=N;KPX A )8 O

-NÀê )- C B-9´ )* R56 71,6 . M=Na I= . -édÔ ,-.9* b5WG,;K WG,XY IS )¢¬C ( -Å= Cdh )P

; ? -M6 7 )* @�6 7 M=Na 8�®6 . q³6 ?( ;. R56 75j M=NÀ

; ?E They were seven in critical conditions. This is the situation now. 6s( ,= K*,-.9* )FG ë ,-.9* I= .

)FG IS ;sxa,°j 5* ,-.,À6 �¨_ )FGE q; �®6Y 9X : ¥=K;: M=N>

- ? E,-K*8dPX A ¸ ( qÐÂ )FG ( 5* ,-.,À6 �6? )FG `( 5* ,-.,k8dP6 ? M=N>

- ? )FGE `( )]C -�6Y M=Na)/ ;s,6 . ,W cB9* b5WGE `( )* )U OV M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS ;�j5{Y M=Na ¶X g· ¸5V M=NWc 56 7 ¡�-Ky

3 �-C(R )/ )´ ( ,-KÚ896 :

); OFG ,XY M=NWc B1( ¶X g· ¸5V M=NWc 56 7 I6 .96 g;?,-. B,k M=NWcE -b(R,-. ;�/1R M=NWcE ;s1,>· )FG IS

15

-b(R,-. ;�/1R )/ ,-.(R -My3§R 2; n>6? )FGE L1 -b(R,-. ;�/1R 56 7 Û®-w I;K/(B ,À·R )FG B

M=NWcà -b( )/ 6s,-K;N 6Y( )U O]g=�* B1( 56 7 ;�6 O3Na Xf5Ê ,k B,> Øè( )FG B9* M=NWc `( Xf5Ê 5* )´ ( M=N

U.,É896 :E ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ I= . IS)FG 56 7 ,= K´5WG `( 9X : 5; C `5¢µ( q Wr ,= K* ,;K{_,6Y )FG B1( -M=N½7(5V )/ ;<=:-då;C q Wr o* q; �{_,6Y )FG 1( 56 7B injured M=NWc -b( o*

;�gß o6¹,= . o* ,wR o* q; �{_,6Y )FGà ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ I= . o´5WG ;�j5{Y 6s,6 t-�X: )/à

Xs ( o* ;�²,_1 )/ Xs ( @Wr( -M*B M=NWc `( ;�j5{Y )* B(8R 6�7,pE ;sxa,°j 5* ( 8�-KP8 ? )U O]g=�*E Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( B ( 56 7 o8 ¹,k qU �´ )FGà T67 M=Na 6s,-K67 Iªxw 2W c,È ¡BR,½V( )*

)8 O¬N]. 5* R-dh,-. ,= K* ,= K´ )FG 56 7 ^va M=Na M=N>- ? ,À; ?E -M

3 ¢{= .( )* 1R )8 O-NÀê �°6 C L1 8�-K=NÂ

,;.9* )FGE L1 -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na R56 75j M=N>- ? )FG `( 9X : Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( B ( )¢¬NS 8s,k ¡RE LB,= K´ IÂ,_ )¯�6? 5* Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( B ( M=Na T* )- C R-dh,-. ,= .R9* B1( b5= O* R-dh,-. ,= .R9*E 5

- C L,a o* qX�6? B1( )Ú 8B56 C b5´5V 5* ¥k ;<V(�w M=Na 3T=NX. ,= K* ,= K´à -M= N

;.(5-7 5* 3T=NX. ,= K* ,= K´à I= . ,= K* ,= K* ,W cB,6Y )FGE ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ o´5WG ;�j5{Y 6s,6 t

-�X: )/ IS 9´( ;sxa,°j 5* ,-.,À6 �¨_ ); OFG ,XY M=NWc B1( Xs ( R5-7 I>· M=NWc)FG B ,;K{_5WG )FG o

U ¹5* ,[= C( 2ì-O} 5WG 56 7

;sxa,°j 5* ,-. 8B,Ç6 C ,;K WG,XY à5WG @Wr ;sxa,°j 5* M=N>- ? ,-. 8B,Ç6 C ); OFG ,XYE )¢¬N]Y L, 3_ 6�7,p )

- C ,>· @Wr )

- C IvÕ=Oµ ,= K* )FG IS @Wr )- C q

- �=NU. ( I;K/(B B,= K;N -Y( )FG ,-.9*à = .9g

;? �,Õ- C( ,k

IvÕ=Oµ )FG IS @Wr )- C -M=N

U. ( B1( ¡B5¦Ë6A ); N_ (B 9X : ,-K®XY )FGE B1( extra constitutional ); N_ (B 5* adopt M=N>

- ? ,-.9*E I= . (896 : = .( q�= NÂ,X . -b,= K6: )FG 56 7 M=Na mR ,W cB b5WG `( 5* 9´( 9{= KV @Wr )

- C ,-K®XY )FG 5; C ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ o´5WG `( Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( B ( 5* withdraw ,= K* )U C ,6YE 56 7 -M=N

;. B(-2W c b5´5V 9X : )FGE I= . Z( -�a )FGà I= . -b5

- C,£ )* ¶; ?,_ Z( -�a )FG T67 M=Na -M=N;. B(-2W c b5´5V 5* R-dh,-.

); O¬: R9* M=NWcE -M=N;. B( -2W c ¸5V q�* )

- C )- O´ M=NWc ë q�* )- C )

- C ,X tíX? M=NWcà -M=N;. B(-2W c

m2îXA oU ¹5* -b,X tíX? ,;K{_ )FGE `( ,k 6�®Þj )FG IS T67 5* 5WG,XY 9ÚR 5VE (B(� -Y I= .

16

Xs ( )* R,çj M=Na M=N>- ? )FGE qi B5ÆV( ¡2= nª I- .,6 .R5j 3 B(-9´ )FG IS `( Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( B ( 5* withdraw ,= K* )

U C ,6Yà L1 )]C q- �Ój Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( B ( )FGà 5- ÓV Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( B (

)FGE ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ I= . )FG IS 56 7 ¥3[= C8R56 7 -M

3 ¢= NJ· )FGà `( 9X : 56 7 = .( l=Cdi )FG L1 +�w R,J;�}( ,k B,> Øè( ,»X 79* )FGE L1 I>· ,W cB )FG IS `( ¥

3[= C8R56 7 -M3 ¢= NJ· )*

)- Oj ,_ @Wr 3T=NX. M=N>- ? )Ä-. 5WGE ;�j5{Y 6s,6 t

-�X: )- C T=N

;. T=N;. ¶*D )¯C 1B ,k I-p1,°j

)- O¬: R ,k -bxw( ,= K* )FGE L1 ); O¦· M=NWc IS @Wr I-p1,°j M=N>- ? M=NÂ )É @Wr -b5-7 )*

9´(R5Ê M=N>- ? M=NWcE@Wr )- O¯: ( -b5-7 ,k (R5Ê M=N>

- ? M=:9* )É 9´( I= . ¥3[= C8R56 7 -M

3 ¢= NJ· -M6 : ,;.,6Y )FGE B1( `( M=Na Xs ( )* ¡B,k24 -M=Na -Bxa ,6Y 9* 3T=NX. )

; C ,6Y5WG M=NWc B1( )- O¯: ( -b,= K6: �-K6NJ¨£ ); O¬: R(9* M=NWcà L1 )]C q

- �Ój ,Ò5WGE (� -Y (B -b( )* ¶; ?,_ M=NÀ8 �=N6.E

-b( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶8 �=N6. 9* oU ¹5* I;K/(B M=NÂ,»-C IÁ-.5= O* Xs ( )* ¥

3[= C8R56 7 -M3 ¢= NJ· o*

8sB5X CB )U C ,6Y (à I¼d�{= . 8sB5X CB 5* -b5* )

- C ,a ,Ò ë `( 5* -b5* @=�®[;C m9* ,ÒE

`( 9X : q³6 ? Xs ( 5* d Ø�-C o

- ¹,3. o- ¹9* )¬OFG ,XYE B1( -b( -b(2ïµ( )/ M=NXt6? b5¦- �67 )

- C I= . Û®-w I;K/(B ,= .,À·RE ¡2= nª 0xÈ( )* l6C,Þj 56 7 I½6 C,_ o

U ¹ ( q6A )P; ?à b5¦- ?( )

- C ,>· IS I= . -M

3 ¢{= .( ;�j 19*à `( )/ -b,ÕÖ-C ,Ò5WGà `( 5* ¥=.�6 K

;: )* 9* Z,;K3¢j (2= nÀQ_ 5* ,= .,ÇV E,=K´ ¡2= nª 0xÈ( )* l6C,Þj 2- n 3[y· B5WGD )

- C æ- Oj ,= K* ,>· I= . ;�j 19*à -M{=KV I- .

)- C ,6Y -b5* )P

; ? L1 ¸5V 56 7 B(2Í( ); C 9* )FG BE L1 -b5* )/ ¶; ?,W c )P

; ?à L1 ;�j5{Y )* )¢

-C 5* B,»®W c( )P; ?à L1 )¢

-C 5* -b(�;K/,= K/ )P; ? -M6 7 o* Xf5Ê 2= n

-ð q§,= K/ )FGà L1 )¢-C 5* ¡B,k24 -M=Na -Bxa )P

; ? b5¦- �67 )- C I= . R� 3[

;C ,= .(9*E B1( 6s,6 t-�X: M=Na = .( q�= C(

;�3¢WGR ¡R9´àT=NÂ5X C o* ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ o* ©,3Kj @U ?,£ o* IS q

- �j IÂ(5- C(896 7 -M6 : ,= KÉ

6�/ 5* bullet 9X :1( )* )Ü7 M=Na M=NWcà m2îXA B1( o; ¹,ÀX A )* )Ü7 M=Na M=NWcE

6s,-K67 D(1 ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ )FG Please intervene B1( `( )®a ,°j 5* ( 8�-KP8 ?

)U O]g=�*E -b( 5* engage )U O]g=�*E 9´( L1 )* 8dP6 ? )U C 5WG M=NWc 5; C ;�- Oj )U O]g=�*E @Wr -B1B

17

M=N>- ? )

; C 9* ë @Wr )/ ¸5V ); O8 : 58 C M=NWcà @Wr q§,= K/ ¸5V M=NWc mB,JWr 98:11 -é(B,-.

); C ,6Y5WG M=NWc @Wr )

; C ,6Y M=NWc -b( 5* ); C ,-Kj M=NWc -b( o* ;�- Oj )

; C 9* M=NWc B1( ¸5V -b,a )

; C ,6Y M=NWcE I= .1B change )U O]g=�*E I= . ,-.(B (ã,-K3:ñ')¢¬N]Y b5´5V )* ;s,-.,= K6: �-K6: M=NU.(19*E I= . 56 7 2W c,6 . m8dP· 9*5WG 9= :dÎ

;C ); C 9* M=NWc -b(R,-. ã(B -B1à -b( )* I-Kj 5*

+,ÇV )U O]g=?R I= . Xs ( )* R,çj M=Na )FGE I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: I= .9{

3_ R5y�h -b,-Y oU ¹-9{XY(E

6s,-K67 R5y�h -b,-Y o

U ¹-9{XY( : 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ )P]�h Xs ( o* I6 Y5; C )¬OFG ,XYE é,-Y Xs (

o* you belong to Lahore B1( )- O¯: ( 9= : -B1 -b,6 K7,p o*E 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ M=Na ¥»V,6 . qU �

-: ;s,6 . b19* ,ÒE (89ÄÀ6 A I= . M=N>- ? )FG IS T* )

- C ;<=:B5¦Ë6A )* )U OV LR,= .-B

o- ¹,6 .dº ¡RE L�-. -B R,6 . b5

- C1R )- C b,= K

-:,6 .dº M=:Rà @¨[j \= KV )- C q³6 ? B1( -9®X K=NX. o

8 ¹B,X . )- C q³6 ?E IvUK¢j I= . )FG IS 5WGD M=NaB = .( ;�¦6? â,-.d�

-7 I°±(1 (5WG )FGE oU ¹5* q³6 ?

-b,[-C( `( I°±(1 o* ;<=:,JA M=N>

- ? ,;K{_9* including Shabaz Sharif = .( Û®-w I°±(1 (5WG 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ It must be condemned o

- ¹,[-C( M=N

-.,6Y æU C,-p o

U ¹5WG M=NWcE q³6 ?( `( ,k solution ,= K* )FG ë 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ Shabaz is a party. Xs ( o* )P]�h I6 Y5

; C )¬OFG ,XY B1( ã(B -B1 -b,6 K7,p o* q³6 ?E -B,6 K¦3§ o* ;�j5{Y o

8 ¹B,X . )FG 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E o

- ¹,[-C( M=N

-.,6Y æU C,-p o

U ¹5WG M=NWc 5; C ¡2= nª qU �-: -9= :56 g

;? )FGE @6 .(9X : I= . )FG IS We must find the culprits. 56 7 Iª-R (R )FG B 56 7 q³6 ? )FG ( ){_ )U OV )¢¬N]Y q3 �= Cdº 6�7,p )FG B,adi M=NWc IS -b( 5* `( -M

3 ¢= NJ· 9X : -é(2; nð( )FGE ¡2= nª request I= . )FG through you and to the Cabinet to Nawaz Sharif ¡2= nª -b( )/ request )FG IS He should involve

18

Supreme Court in it. @=?2X n_ 8sB5* 5* = .( @=?di ,= .R )U C ,6Y IS Xs ( M=NJWr

= .( ,[= C( -M3 ¢= NJ· ,-K6: 9* M=:R 56 7 `R -bR )* B�-.( Iª-R b1B(R o* qó�-., 3[

-C m9*EWhoever is responsible, he must be punished

according to law. This is the solution.oU ¹5* (241R solution

M=N>- ? )FGE b,= Kj -B(5

- C Ñ= C23 4 interfere M=:9* @=?2X n_ 8sB5* )* -96 g6A )* )- O¦·

9X : = .( -M3 ¢= NJ· M=N

U.,-K6: `( -M3 ¢= NJ· 5* I= . o

8 ¹5= C8R M=:R IS M=NJWr Iª-R -b(B(R mR M=:RE whoever is responsible `( 5* (-24 M=:RE That is the only

solution. Thank you very much.

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: q6A @=�/5V(�6 K} 6�7,pE 6s,-K67 @=�/5V(�6 K} : I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E M=Na )- C b5Ê9X : q³6 ? I= . ;s,6 . qí·

q³; ? IS = .( I°±(1 ,= K´5WG `( )* �°6 C M=NJWr ,= K* ,-.9* )FG as a E ;�j5{Y 9´( @Wr �= .-dh ^J

-? ); OV (8R M=NWcB )´E �= .-dh irritate ); C 9* M=NWcB )´ b5´5V 5*à 5; C

I= . ¥U.,[j ;�j5{Y )U OV )* q³6 ? )PA ( M=N>- ? )Ä-. 5WG B1( ^va )* )U OV q³6 ? )PA ( M=N>

- ? )Ä-. 5WGE = .( I°±(1 ,= K´5WGà M=N

;.R,>3§ M=NUK´5WGà LB,= K´ ¸5V `( M=Na �= K¦

3§ )U O´ 5WG B1( 83 ¸5V q³6 ?( ;. ©,;KXN[WG M=Na R56 75j M=NWc 56 7 injured M=NWcE 5; C -b( )* `,X . )

- C ,6Y o* )

U C ,6 t6? @Wr �= .-dh M=N>- ?( `( ;s,6 . 9X : IÕ

- } DR )FG B M=NWc IS Xs ( ,k L(96 :24 ,= . Xs ( )* -M=N

;. B(-2W c ¸5V 3s5®a M=NWc 5; C M=Na I= . 5; C ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS ¡B5µ B5² 9X : @U ?(9X : 28 n[

-Na 5* `( dPê 9X : ,-.,6Y )¬OFG ,XY ,À; ? IS I= . )¢¬NS ,= K´5WGà T* )- C ,= K*à T* )

- C o; ¹R,= .

-B o*à M=Na ¡9U:(5{-.( ,;.(9* b5WGà M=Na `( )®UK¢j ,k ¥Y ,;KV,»-C b5WGà )U C ,6 t6? `(

)* @Wr (241R I;K/(B )V )FG B M=NWcE 6s( mB,JWr `,X . 2W c -2= nX¤ o8 ¹ ¡1 )* )å¬C B-R

19

R56 75j )FGE photos R56 75j M=NWcE ¾ =�gß B1( Û®-w R56 75j )FG 6�/ ¶{= .R )FG B M=NWc

b,>=? oU ¹5* IX t6? ,= . +5ÜÓj M=N>

- ? )FGà Xs ( )* )- O¯: ( ¸5V q³6 ? ¶{= .R )FG B )Ä-. 5WG IS ,= K* (5WGà )¢¬NS (5WG B1( T* )

- C ,= K* B1( )- O;NS )8 O

-NÀê (5WGE `( )* �°6 C M=NJWr oU ¹5*

¥Y ,-KV,»-C )¬OFG ,XY q§,= K/ 9X :B5²à I- .B1 M=NJWr -b,ÕÖ-C ,Ò5WGà M=Na qí=? ,-K¦· L,XY ,W cB ,À; ? IS

I= . o; ¹R,= .

-B )FGE I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: I= .9{

3_E IvÕ=Oµ I= . (5WG )FG ¡B39= :98 : B1( -M3 ¢= C -B5X C( )* -b,= KjBR IS

8R5µ o8 ¹B5= O{= K/ 9X : 1R -B9{= KXN_ X¾

-?,X . X¾-?,X . 8�- Oj ;s,6 . M=:9* )´E q6A B(8R 6�7,pE

9=: -B1 )

U C (96 : I- .(-9-7) 6s,-K67 �J�h l�g§( B(8R(: 24 ¥»V,6 . B12- Í most

welcome I= . understanding )FG -M{= KV 6s( -M=N;. b5= C28 n[

-Na o* disposal )* �°6 Cà (B-R ( 8B5P; ? ,_ ;<º1 `( 5* mR M=:RE ¥k q³6 ? b5¦- ?( )

- C ,= .,adi ,À; ? B1( -b( 5* R,= . ,Ò5WG IS 8�- OU:(5X C 8sU1 ( (5WG IS -bB,¼ Tµ ( )* ¸5V M=N>

- ? M=NWcE M=Na ,= K´ M=Na )

- C -b( 5* ,= .(5®6 . àb,>=? 6f ( M=Na )- C q§( B8RB ( )/ 56 7 L, 3_

6�7,p )/ )² (5WG ,À; ? ¥kà 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ IS )®>? Interior `( )* �°6 C Petroleum and Natural Resources and then Water and

Power ¥»V,6 . `( )* �°6 C M=:9* )´E ¥»V,6 . Xs ( )* ¶; ?,_ understanding qí=? )FG qí=? ,Ò5WGE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: q6A B 8�= KV � ( ¡R -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C(E

20

�= K/ �=K3/B5-7 �JA( L, 3_: 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ I= . )² (5WG ,À; ? IS ¥k @Wr )

- C -bB,¼ q�= NÂ,X . oV B1( naturally 56 7 alphabet M=Na o

; ¹ ( )FG dPX ? 8R5µ ,;. ( )FG 5; C @Wr )

- C ,>· ,À; ? IS 8R5µ )* 8<* -M3/5j @Wr @

; � -7 M=NWc); O¬NÂ9* dPX ? 1R 9=:B,½;C qÐ-.5WGà I= . )² ,= K´5WG ,À; ?E 6s( `( Ñ= C( o* I6 Y1 )/ Foreign o* )

U C ,6 t6? 6s( )U C ,6Y ( ,Ò

dPX ? 8R5µ `( )* �°6 C “Interior” oU ¹ ( ,Ò proper M=NvXY I= . I½= Cd² B,= K

;N -Y( M=:9*E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: M=Na move ,;.9* b5WG Minister for Finance to

move demand No. 80. Mr. Mohammad Ishaq Dar: I beg to move that a

sum not exceeding Rs. 3,235,048,000 be granted to the Federal Government to meet expenditure during the year ending 30th June, 2015 in respect of NATIONAL FOOD SECURITY AND RESEARCH DIVISION (Demand No. 80).

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: q6A ¡241R demand q³6 ? )V M=NÂ Minister for Finance to move demand No. 128.

Mr. Mohammad Ishaq Dar: I beg to move that a

sum not exceeding Rs. 1,071,300,000 be granted to the

21

Federal Government to meet expenditure during the year ending 30th June, 2015 in respect of DEVELOPMENT EXPENDITURE OF NATIONAL FOOD SECURITY AND RESEARCH DIVISION (Demand No. 128).

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: q6A 6s(5

- C Ñ/5= C B5X OV,; . 6�7,p

6s(5- C Ñ/5= C B5X OV,; . : Thank you Mr. Speaker! 24 I= .

honourable Minister 6�7,p )- C 56 7 figure o* ;s,w12

3 4 o* )FG IS Food Security )* )U OV 3.235 billion rupees )P· B )U O´ M=NWc Food Security )* )U OV q¨>X? -2= nX¤ 5; C I= . )FG IS `( 5* ,6 KV,- w 2= n

-ð ¡B12- Í ,À6 �Ë§ ,=K´ )FG IS )®À�X? ©,_ it was 3.237 `( ©,_ )®À�X? ©,_ )/ q³6 ? `( 5* @· ,= .R9* ,=K´ )FG = .( 5; C `( 5* @· ,= .R9* ,= K´ )FG B1( (241R I= .

)- O¯7 5Ê o* -2= nX¤ )FG IS -b,;K¢*,X . o* 70% population is in rural areas and lives on agriculture B1( -b,;K¢*,X . mB5X C )* B�-.( )- O

;N]Y q³6 ? sensitive Xs ( )* L1 M=NWc M=:-2= nX¤ price index o* L1

agriculture )/ qWr o; ¹5WG = .( �d² 5; C agriculture )* 9X :1( I= .

23 ï= C9X : D(8R ,6Y ,W cB )FG IS Xs ( )- C ,= .

8�-.( )/ import 0123 4 9* ¡R B1()FG b,>=? 9X : Xs ( )

- C m241R -M=N-.(5± )P· B M=NWc B1( ,= .

8�-.( )/ q³6 ? 56 7import q³·B qU �´ )FG 24 L1 I= . import q³·B )FG IS 56 7 -b( 5* q-ßdh M=Na )

U C ( ,Ò L1 M=N6t=�P6

? )´ B1( @Wr -b( )/ L1 M=:-2= nX¤ M=NÂ )´ B1( b,>=? )/ 56 7 q³6 ? oU ¹5*

)U C ,6Y ,Ò L1 -b( )* 9X :1( )FG IS -b( b1-2= nX¤ 5* L1 ©56 O± M=:9* )´ ,= . M=N>

- ?

22

©56 O± M=:9* )´ 24 I= . )- O;: ( `5¢µ( o* ;s,6 . )FG ,>6A b ;. agriculture ,k l®°;C )FG 24 ( Xs )

- C mB5X C U1,W c 5* ,ÀQ= .R ,Ò5WG agriculture )* 9X :1( Xs ( 5* q�* ;�},J6 A M=Na ;�/,= K/ d Ø�

-C M=N>- ? o

U ¹ ( o´ Xs ( 5* oU ¹5* politics d Ø�

-C M=N>- ? o

U ¹ ( o´ 24 9´( Xs ( M=NÀQ= .R )´ agriculture)* )U OV oX¹ @=?( ¥=.( -M=:( 5WG -b,;K¢*,X . -9®X K=NX. o

8 ¹B,X . 5WGà= .9g;? �,Õ

- C( 5WG B1( q- �;N 6Y q³6 ? M=N

;K},J6 A M=NWc `( `U1,W c )* B�-.( 6�/ `( matter )* B�-.( ); O

-g=�X7 M=NWc -b( ,k = .( q Wr purpose )FG 24 IS -b,;K¢*,X . o* economy ,k backbone

agriculture )FG B1( L1 backbone 56 7 agriculture )FG IS `( 5* 9´( ignore and neglect ,= K* )

U C ,6Y ,Ò 5; C `( )/ I= . ,Ò5WG IS (B,JWr -b,;K¢*,X .

¡R,Õ; O±( qº9;: M=N>- ? )

U C ,X .9* ,ÒE M=Na `( M=Na = .( o8 ¹5PX A q§ ©,3Kj -édÔ

b1R9* 24 B1( I am lucky IS 6f ( 28 n[-Na T

-C,-Kµ q³6 ? )P8 �¬N6. )

U C 5WG M=NWc IS -B28 nÁ=.98 : )* 9X :1( 5; C subsidy ¡R qU �´ )FG subsidy 5; C M=N>

- ? ¡R qU �´ )FG -M{= KV úû �Õ=Oµ )/ úü �Õ=Oµ ;. L1 )V )

U C ( M=NWc sales tax 5* 56 7 )®>? úû �Õ=Oµ ,À; ? -M{= KV ( ` )* implements B1( `( )* 56 7

spare partsM=NWc `( )* 9X :1( M=N>- ? B1( `( )* 9X :1( o

8 ¹5= C8R ,É896 : ¡R qU �´ )FG The result is IS B,»;N 3_,k 5; C o

U ¹5* L�U.,¼ M=N>- ? (5WGE M=Na )- O¯: ( �2Í

T-C,-Kµ 28 n[

-Na o* 3 5´ B( -B5´ = .( -2= nX¤ b19* ,Ò IS 24 agriculture M=Na = .( I6 K

;:dh -b,;K¢*,X . )* B�-.( -b,;K¢*,X . -9®X K=NX. o8 ¹B,X . o* ;�j5{Y M=Na 1996 M=Na the

agriculture growth was 11.7% B1( L1 56 7 11.7% ,À; ? 24 `( o* = .( q Wr 1 I6 Y q³

; ? ,= K* I6 Y1 q³; ? IS b,>=? 9X : = .( -B28 nÁ=.98 : o* @=�{_ o

U ¹D qU �´ q³; ?

B1( ); N[/ 28 nÁ=.98 : -B )U O¬: R )U O´ )P; ? 56 7 28 nÁ=.98 : 8�=O*B,a M=Na o

U ¹,É8R ¶*D ,k ,À; ? L1 B,»;N 3_,k 5* ×89= :8R ¶*D M=Na ¥a ,W cB ,À; ? The result is -b( 28 nÁ=.98 : -B o* I6 Y1

23

)/ I= . Xs ( ,k 56 7 agriculture growth )FG 5Ê ,É896 : B1( `( )* �°6 C qi,k B1( varieties q³6 ? M=N

U. ( M=NÀ; ? T67 o* I6 Y1 )/ -b,;K¢*,X . ,k agriculture

growth (5WG2; n>6? B1( 6f ( ,= K* )FG 6f ( L1 figures 5; C M=N>- ? -M{= KV @Wr dPX ?

negative M=Na )®¯Y )U O´ IÁ-.D,Y `( ;<º1 q³6 ? negative )/ 0123 4 ,= K* ,À; ? 56 7 11.7% growth IX . )U O´ )P

; ?E `( ;<º1 q³6 ? 9´( Xs ( 5PQ= .R )´ 5; C M=Na )

- C = .( 8sB,XY ,= .,-K6: )FG I= . -b,;K¢*,X . )* agriculture )* main crops ,k )¢¬N]Y rice )FG wheat)FG sugarcane )FG cotton )FG

T67 )* 9X :1( (B,JWr growth ,;. ( )FG 24 @Wr )- C growth show ,= K* )FG

2.1% IS I= . agriculture ,k growth `( ©,_E 56 7 )®À�X? ©,_ )/ 5; C @· )FG -M{= KV `( ©,_ I= . ,= .,À·R ,= K´ )FGE24 `( M=Na = .( -2= nX¤ M= Na �2Í -MWG-R -M=N3[-C ,-.(9* b5WG,XY ,Ò 3 B(-9´ b19* ,Ò -b( o* ;�j� -Y M=Na -édÔ b5P·B ,Ò IS I= . ¶X g·56 7 Xs ( )

- C ,= .,;K6: )FG m2= nª `,X . ýüüþEüû )/ )V )* ýüú�Eú� ;. ,k (B5X C 8sB,XY )FG 24 `( M=NaE `( 5* 9´( Xs ( (B-R 5PQ= .R

I= . M=Na Xs ( )* `,X . 8B5PX A b1R ,Ò = .( oX¹,k I= . (B5X C `U1,W c )V ,;K{_ )FG I= . figures m2= nª M=N>

- ? M=NWc I= . figures Economic Survey )*figures M=NWc 9´( I= . Xs ( (B5X C 5PQ= .R )´ 5; C by and large qWr1

growth q WrB )FG )¢¬N]Y rice )FG 6.8 q³6 ?( 6.7 )¢¬N]Y wheat)FG ýüúüEúú M=Na 25.2% q³

; ? `( ©,_ q³6 ? 25.2%)FG B1( ýüüþEüû M=Na wheat 56 7 )FG 21.2% q³

; ? T67 )/ I= . qó896 : -M{= KV)FG I= . Xs ( ýüüþEüû )/ )V )* ýüú�Eú� ;. � ©,_ ,k 9´( Xs (

population growth 5* `( M=Na add19* 5; C 24 where is the agriculture growth? According to the survey IÁ-.D,Y the

24

population growth is more than 2% -M{= KV M=Na qí- ?( ,kfigure ,;K=NÂ b5WG 1.7%. 1.7% q³6 ? 9´( )FG 5; C 24 this comes to about

16% to 17% rather 18%. 9´( 18% Xs ( -b( -2= nX¤ b1 5* figures M=Na add19* 5; C 24 the growth is in negative not in positive. 5; C `( )* )U OV 6s( `( M=Na �-KX7 M=:-2= nX¤ 24 M=Na 3 (B-9´ b19* ,Ò ;�¦6?

¡B12- Í M=NWcE Main thing, of course, research )FG 6s( research )* 9X :1( 56 7 q³6 ? ¶X g· ,= K* ,W cB,6Y )FG 5; C `( M=Na �2Í I= . ,-KPQ= .R

)¬OFG ,XY IS research M=Na ,= .8�-.( )* crops ,k aggregate average

,= K* )FG (B,JWr aggregate average ,= K* )FG What is the reason? b,>· M=NWc mB,JWr certified seeds b,>· M=NWc mB,JWr L1 seeds 56 7

mB,JWr 5* mB,JWr B,»;N 3_,k 5* 2; n>6? production M=:RE24 L1 seeds q³6 ? research )/ mB5X C M=N>

- ? ¥»-C )FG B 24 L1 M=:-2= nX¤ q

- �;N 6Y q³6 ? M=NWc L1 56 7 research M=Na ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XY 56 7 full time research o* body o

- ¹5WG )¬OFG ,XY 24 L1 `( M=Na M=N>

- ? )FG B1( the result is IS @Wr )- C q³6 ?56 7 6s(

,= .R )FG 8�6 g6? `( M=Na @Wr )- C 9*-R ,= K* )FG Mackenzie ,k IS

Mackenzie 5* ýüýþ ã M=Na @Wr )V M=NU. ( )´ B1( ýüýþã M=Na `(

)/ @Wr development o* budget 8�6 g6? M=NU.(5- O6: )´E 6s( 24 b,>·

Mackenzie b,>· -b,;K¢*,X .à b,>· -b,;K¢*,X . ,k culture b,>· Mackenzie ,k culture b,>· o* ¡B,JWr ;sB5¿ ©,Yà b,>· Mackenzie o* ;sB5¿

©,Y 24 M=NJWr 5; C mB,JWr )- O¯: ( ©,Y IX . )¬OFG ,XY,-K®XY B1( `( ©,Y IX . M=NJWr I= . ,-KPQ= .R )¬OFG ,XY IS mB,JWr )U OV ¡B12- Í ,= K* )FGE24 6�/ )/ )®>? o

- ¹,X . is the most important thing. M=Na qº,6 . b1-2= nX¤ M=Na M=N>

- ? bU1,6Y ,Ò `( M=Na bU1,6Y

25

,Ò IS qU �* b5Ê96 : B1( b5Ê96 : )/ -M/ )FG B M=NWc rather decades )/ -M/ )FG B M=NWc IS lining of water course B1( `( )* �°6 C lining of

the canals and even the lining of the rivers 5; C I= . `( M=Na oU ¹5* T=C9´(9X : d Ø�

-C M=N>- ? ( q WrB )FGE 56 7 water courses M=NWc `( M=Na q�*

�Y ;. 5; C lining oU ¹5WG )FG -M{= KV `( M=Na I= . lining M=N>

- ? oU ¹5WG )FGE 5; C

`( o* I6 Y1 )/ ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ I= . 5WG o´ IS lining )* 9X :1( I6 Y5; C ¡R )

U C ,6YE 5; C `( ©,_ Xs ( 5PQ= .R )´ 5; C fertilizer o* as far as my

knowledge goes L1 offtake M=N>- ? )FG 56 7 offtake (5WG ,;.9* E,À; ?

what is the reason Sir IÁ-.5= O* ,-K; :( ,Ç-O¦h 5WG ,= K´ )FG fertilizer IS B,»;N 3_,k LB,X t=�6: afford q Wr M=N>

- ? 9* ,;K{_ IS L1 `( ;�y=�± M=Na L1 )V 9* B1( L1 ©,Jå

;N_( m9*E 6s( M=NJWr I= . ,-KPQ= .R )U OFG ,XYE @Wr 8�= .98 : ,= .

8�-.( )* ¶; ?,_ ); C 9*

M=NWcà -M=N-.(5± -b,;K¢*,X . )* ¶; ?,_à 24 M=Na,= .

8�-.( 56 7 subsidies M=NWc Sir they are over a trillion Indian Rupees. -M{= KV b,>=? 9X : -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na

subsidies 56 7 )®>? M=NÀ; ? `( )/ @· B1( 56 7 q³6 ?( )FG `( )/ @· B1( dPX ?

q- �X:( q-ßdh )* l6C,Þj I= . ¸5V `( )

; C ,À8 ?(5* ); OFG B M=NWcà ); C x6 . ); OFG B M=NWcE ¡2= nª

3 B(-9´ 5WG o´ IS )U C (96 : o

- ¹,6 .2îh M=NJWr L1 facilities ¡R M=NU.,6Y 56 7 -b,;K/1�-K WG

)* `,X . M=NWcE 9´( M=NJWr o- ¹,X . M=Na L1 facilities b5WGà fertilizer M=Na L1

facilities b5WGE fertilizer o* ;�y=�± 5* Xs ( 5PQ= .R IÁ-.D,Y India Rupee is over Rupee’s double -M{= KV dPX ? q³6 ? b,W c1 ,k fertilizer 9´(

M=Na)¯C 1B 5PQ= .R )´ 5; C @· )FG B1( (B,JWr fertiliser `( )/ LR,= .-B )FGEthe

result is IS mB,JWr b,W c ¡B,JWr 56 7 production )FG L1 ×896 : M=N>- ? o

; ¹,X . B1( `( ,k I6 t=�

;N-. ,= K* 5WG ,W cB )FGE I6 t=�;N-. I= . 5WG ,W cB )FG IS I= . q³6 ? 0xÈ( )FG

26

¡2= nª ¥6K=:9-: ( T-C,-Kµ 28 n[

-Na )/ IS 24 6s( 6�67 B,»;N 3_,k I= . ¶{= .R ,W cB )FG IS M=Na q- �X:( agriculture M=Na ¶X g· M=N>

- ? ,X . ,W cB Eb5WG 24 22 million hectares M=NWc q 8.58 C -b,;K¢*,X . `,X .à m896 : M=N>

- ? M=NWc 24E`( 22 million hectares M=Na )/ Sir on record 3 million hectares have gone to

the urban population. q- �;N 6Y M=N

-K=Na -B B1( agriculture )* 2î3§ )* R9´RB( o

; ¹5WG M=NÀ; ? b,>6A b,= .

-26 n_ o; ¹5WG M=NÀ

; ?à b,>6A `( @�± o* M=:-2= nX¤ o; ¹5WG M=NÀ

; ? 56 7 b5´5V )* `,X . M=N

U.,6Y B1( b,W c1 9X : L1 ¸5V M=NÂE L1 6s(organization o; ¹5WG ,6Y q WrB )FGE L1 `( M=Na invest )

; C 9* ,6Y M=NWc)FG B B1( L1 ); O¦· M=NWc IS agriculture M=Na ¶X g· M=N>

- ? )FGE 5; C 3 B(-9´ 5WG o´ I= . 3 million hectares 56 7 M=N

-K=Na -B urbanization M=Na ,6Y q WrB M=NWc B1( q XY qU �´ M=NWcE 24 B1( q³6 ? M=N

U.,6Y Eo´ 5; C `( )/ 2; n>6? I= . )FG IS agriculture )* )U OV 5X 75Ê B1( agriculture qWr Xs ( 5* )V )* )

U C ( ,ÒE M=Na Xs ( 5* bU1,;K6: IS 56 7 ¥U.,8K¢{= K

8 : 5* facilities ¡R qU �´ M=NWc )P]�h oU ¹5* -é(2; nð( M=N>

- ? 24 M=Na 3 5-7 b5WG q

- �;N 6Y q³6 ? facilities Eb5WG -M{= KV agriculture 5* neglect B1(ignore I- . E19* )P]�h R,= . )FG IS 1994 M=Na q8 �X:8R 9-:B5´ 8�=O8N_ ^-K=N6. � (

-b,;K¢*,X . `( )* minutes q³6 ? R56 75j b5WG )´ T67 )- C ,>· ,À; ? in one of

the meetings IS Madam Prime Minister, 260 billion dollars we have given to textile unfortunately, still the

result is this. 5; C 24 6�67 b,W c1 mR )FG Bà 24 9ÚR( mR 9* 5PQ= .R5; Cà B,»;N 3_,k 5* mR 9* 5; C 5PQ= .R B1( Xs ( ,k 56 7 B,»;N 3_,k )FG 97 percent B,»;N 3_,k )

8 C 5PX A B,»;N 3_,k M=NWcE �2Í -M=N;. 8�- N_9X : m896 : B,»;N 3_,k M=NWcE L1 )

8 C 5PX A B,»;N 3_,k q Wr M=NWc 56 7 `( -b,;K¢*,X . 5* xXY B )FG M=NWcE -b( 5* 9´( 9´( I= . M=:-2= nX¤ ¥a

27

M=NU.,6Yà 2; n>6? )Î¬C d² )/ ¥a M=N

U.,6Y 5; C M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS -b,;K¢*,X . = .( ©,t3§5-7

^va )- O]: ,Ò B1( 6�6 7 ;. @Wr q- �X:( agriculture 5* neglect )

; C 9* M=NWcB 6<

; : ;. ¡B,JWr ¶X g· oU ¹,ÀX A( M=N>

- ? 5WG o´ b,>6A ;. economy o* -2= nX¤ )FGE qº,6 . B1( detail M=Na M=Na LR,= .

-B M=N>- ? ,;.,6Y b5WG qí=? 3 B(-9´ ,;.9* b5WG

EI= .9{3_

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: I= .9{

3_ q6A +1�-th L, 3_ R5y�h q3 �= Cdº 6�7,pE

+1�-th L, 3_ R5y�h -M=N[7 q3 �= Cdº : I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 E9{= KXN_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! mB,JWr

9=: -B1 I- .(-9-7 )

- C )- O¯: ( 8�6 g6? 9=:dÎ;C M=NaE B(8R 6�7,p M=Na Xs ( o* I6 Y5

; C ,k 6<V,È b5WGE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! mB,JWr 9= : -B1 I- .(-9

-7 )- C q

- �X:( 8�6 g6? 9=:dÎ;C M=Na -é(2; nð( ,= K* IS

56 7(B,JWr qÔB -B 28 nÁ=K/ )FG `( o* growth 6�/,-Kj M=N>- ? 5WG q WrB B1( dPX ? b5¦- ?(

)- C -é(2; nð( =K*, IS `( ©,_ 56 7 2013-14 ,k 56 7 b5¦- ?( )

- Ceconomic survey 3T=NX. ,= K* ¡B,JWr 56 7 agriculture growth q³

; ? L1 1R I= .B, 3[}( = .( �Õ=Oµ q³

; ?E q- �Ó= C IS )®À�X? ©,_ 56 7 1R I= .B, 3[}( ¶8 ? ( �Õ=Oµ ,À; ? `( )/ q³6 ? @·

q³; ?E q

- �Ó= C IS 56 7 )®À�X? X¾-?,X . ©,_ 56 7 -9®X K=NX. o

8 ¹B,X . o* 8�- Oy- ?B5´ q³

; ? T67 o* average -M=N

;. 8�- N_9X : q³; ? `( )/ q³6 ? @· Eq³

; ? 5; C ¾-ß(1 ,= K* (5WGà ¾

-ß(1 I= . (5WG IS agriculture sector M=Na o

U ¹5* IvUK¢j )FG B1( `( )®UK¢j o* I6 Y1 )/ 6f ( ¡B,JWr growth stagnate 9* q WrB L Em x>X? I;K{-. (2= nª )FGE26 nJ

-? 1Rà Agriculture Minister b,>=? Ñ= C23 ï

;C ,adi M=NWc M=Na -b( ,k +(2; n¤( ,;.9* b5WG B1( )¦]�h -M=N½= C )FG IS I= . ;�}(B -B o* ¡2; n>6? )* mB,6 . M=Na ); O¯7 5Ê q³6 ? M=NWc B1( ¶X g· ,-.9* q³6 ? ); OFG ,XY M=NWcE M=Na 8R5µ o

8 ¹B5{= K/ o* \-. 8�-K=N8K/ q8 �=NJ· ,k 26 nJh b5WGE

28

¡B,JWr ¥JQa -b(�= KU:,; . 5* ¥p,Y )FGE @Wr M=NWc,XY )´ IS I= . 6s,= Kj,k b5WG B1( -b( o*

o6¹,= Kj,k M=Na B,»;N 3_,k o* o6¹,= Kj,k )FGE 6s,-K67 D(1! M=N>- ?( ¡B,JWr 8sB5X N_ E)U OFG ,XY ¡B,JWr

8sB5X N_ `( )U OV )U OFG ,XY IS I= . I6 Y5; C )

- C (5VR M=Na 6s,= Kj,k 5WG M=NU.,6Y IS qÔB -B I6 KÓ

3/ 56 7 )FG L1 `( ;�3¢= N°j ,k @Wr( I6 KÓ

3/ )FGE qË; �¢±�6 . )/ ¡B,JWr ;s,t=�679

;: M=Na ;�}B -B 5* L1 ¾ =�679

;: M=N>- ? ¡R ,6Y q WrB 56 7 ¡R o

- ¹,6Y )U OFG ,XY B1( M=Na Xs ( )/ 56 7 -b(26 nJh `( �d² Ñ= C23 ï

;C ,adi M=NWc B1( 56 7 -b(26 nJh `( �d² Ñ= C23 ï;C ,adi M=NWcà

q§,= K/ b5; Og¨Õj )/ æ�± d Ø�-C Xs ( R,= . )U OP·B IS ;<=:23 nS( Xs ( `( -b(5= C( M=Na

qí=?R +(5} )* b58 C11 )/ b,>=? )U C ( )P

8 �¬N6. M=NWcE `( ,k B,»;N 3_ )- Cà `( ;<=:23 nS(à

m5- C �Õ=Oµ )

8 C 5PX A ,k B,»;N 3_ )- C 8s11 mR 9* Xs ( 5* b,>=? ,6 t=�P6 ? )FG B1( 6f (

L1 b56 C -B oV,Y ,k B,» 3/ )FGE 6f ( L1 q; �/�Ã-K; : ,k B,» 3/ )FGE `( o* ¡R,= K-N6. ;s,W c56 71

M=NWcE `( M=Na ,-K¦· IS `( ;�j5{Y ,k B5Ü± )FGE M=N>- ?à I= . ¥[®[

;C )/ +�w I6 Y5; C

,k B,» 3/ )FG I= . 28 nÁ=K/ B1( `( 28 nÁ=K/ 9X : 6�6 7 ;. @Wr `( 5* focus ;�/BR M=N>- ? M=:9* )´ 5; C 6s,-K67 D(1! @Wr -b,;K¢*,X . 5* 56 7 q

3§,°j qº9;: ,-K=:R ); OFG ,XY M=NWc L1 M=N>- ? mR M=N

U.,X . E)´ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! T-C,-Kµ 28 n[

-Na )- C q

- �X:( 9= :dÎ;C M=Na ,>· IS ¡B,JWr

56 7 economic strategy )FG L1 export led growth o* ¡B,JWr ;�yQY q¨w )FGE ;�/BR )FGE 9´( Xs ( o* export led growth o*strategy )FG 5; C `( )* )U OV ;�}(B -B `( o* backbone )FGE b5= O*à Xs ( o* ;�Ó-O¿ )FG ,= K*à Xs ( )

- C `( 8�6 g6? M=Na ;�¦6? )/ incentives )U C R

industrial output 5* large scale manufacture sector o* growth 5* )

- C ,É896 : )* )U OVE 6s( -édi )U O]g=�* L1 6s,= Kj,k 5WG ,;.,6Y )FGà Xs ( )* ^va M=Na investments ( o

; ¹,6Y M=NWcà )U O-: textile units install 5WG

); C ,6Y M=NWcà -b( 5* `,X K* )U OFG ,XYE B1( Xs ( 6f ( ¶{= .R )FG B M=NWc IS ¡B,JWr 56 7

29

installed capacity )FG `( 5* 56 7 q8 �PX ? B,kBR )FGà 56 7 `,X K* B,kBR )FG B1( 56 7 ¡B,JWr -M

3 ¢*8R19X : )FG `( M=Na imbalance ( ,»X 7 )FGE M=NJWr 6f ( imports ,k (B,>§ ,-K=NÂ 89X : ,W cB )FGE�q; �7 IS -b,;K/1�-K WG )/ @Wr I>· )FG B M=NWc IS

things oU ¹(5Ä-Kj M=N

U.,6YE 5; C ;�}(B -B o* Xs ( o* 56 7 growth )FG L1 Xs ( o* ¡B5X C economic strategy 56 7 )FG `( ,k B,Õg

-?( `( 9X : )FGE 6s,-K67 D(1! q§( fd² Xs ( )* oil seed production )FGE Oilseeds M=Na Xs ( q³6 ? = .( qÔB -B ^va )

- C 5WG )* )² ,-. Xs ( b56 CB( )¯C 1B Xf9-7 )

; C 9* M=NWc edible oil 5* 8sB5X Oj( )

- C 9* M=Naà 6s( `( o* ;sB12- Í M=N>- ? )FGE -b,;K¢*,X .

R5-7 ¥=KÆ* 5WG ,;K{_ )FGE -b,;K¢*,X . o* -M=Na -B M=Na -b,;K¢*,X . )* B,»;N 3_,k M=Na I= . ;�=O7xp R56 75j )FG IS -b,;K¢*,X . 5* R5-7 ¥=KÆ* 9* ){_E -M{= KV `( B,»;N 3_,k o* Ivp57 o

U ¹(-di( M=N>- ? o* o

; ¹,6Yà `( B,»;N 3_,k 5* L1 policy framework M=N>- ? ,= .R ,;.,6Y T67

)* B�-.( ); OFG B )U C 5WG L1 -b,;K¢*,X . R5-7 ¥=KÆ* 9* E){_ 6s,-K67 D(1! )®À�X? b5

- CR Xs ( )- C ,ÀQ= .R `( -b(5= C( M=Na B1( ;s(B,6 K

-7( M=Na M=:26 n-¤ M=NXKPX A IS q³6 �* 98 :,J

8? o* ;�y=�± -b,J§ ( 5* 5PX A q WrB )FG B1( q³6 �* 5V ( o* ;�y=�± ;�3/5´ )/ LR,= .

-B ×896 : qU �´ )FGE�ÕÖj )- O¦· ,k )FG price fluctuationà I= . price fluctuation b5= O* ( q WrB )FGE I= . price fluctuation `( )U OV ( q WrB )FG IS agriculture

marketing ,k 56 7 Xs ( ,k mechanism ,À; ? L1 @WrBR @Wr96 : 5WG ,= K´ )FGE 5; C 6f ( `( ,k -b(�½µ )FGEB1( 56 7 ^v6 KX: 28 nÁ=K/ ,À; ? L1 6f ( 56 7 purchase ,;.9* ,À; ? L1 8�=O*B,a )/ ¥»

-C ,»X 7 )FGE B1( 56 7 private structures )- C (

)P; ?à 56 7 private sector )

- C `( 5* replace ,-.9* ,À; ? L1 organised )Î¬C d² )/ 5WG M=N>

- ? ,»/E ,;K6g=�;N-. q³6 �* LR,= .

-B5V (à ¸5V5; C rotate 9* )FG B M=NWc B1( q³6 �* 5V ( o* ;�y=�± q

- �;:( ×896 : qU �´ IS 5{X . ( -b,;K/1�-K WG ,k (B,>§

30

,-K=NÂ ,;.89X : )FGE q³6 �* 98 :,J8? )- O;: ( IS -M=Na -B IX . M=NWcmdPQ6 . B1( q³6 �* 98 :,J

8? )- O;: ( @· IS -b( 5* )- OPQ= .R 5* q³6 ? -b,[

-C( `9;: ); C ,6Y M=NWcE B1( ); O¦· M=NWc IS M=Na,= .

8�-K WG 98 :,J8? ,k

©,Jå;N_( @· 9* E1R 6s,-K67 D(1! q§( fd² -b,;K¢*,X . `( +�w qí6A5; C )* R56 71,6 . ,= K

-:R ,k fifth largest producer )FG of milk production. B1( -b,;K¢*,X . ,k 56 7 ,8 .5PX A B,»;N 3_,k )FG `( o* security `( ,k B(�a1B(Rà `( ,k ,-K=N 6Yà `( ,k ,-.dhà `( o* T

-CB53 ¢-C( q

- �XNJ· 56 7 )FG L1 )U C ,Ò )FG L1 T

-N=KP6 ? )FG 56 7 ,;KV,X . )FG ×R1R ,;KXg=�6: )FG -MPQa ,;K

-N6. )FG )¯�6? 5* ,;KV,X . )FG B1( 56 7 5; OV,¼ ,;.5WG )FG 8�=OX: 8s,k )* M=NaB( -B,6 . X¾ =�6: 9* )* )- O¯: ( dPê ,k LB(-9´ ,;.9* )FGE 6�67 B(�= K

-:,À; ? 5* ;s53ÊB q- �=:R

o; ¹89X : )FG )

8 C 5P6 A )h �½j o* 5; C L1 T-N=KP6 ? ,k (R5Ê ,;.9* )FGE B1( 6�67 q�*

B(�v= KÜg;? 5* 3 5- 7 ,-.9* ,;.5WG )FG B1( q�* ¡8R T=C( oX¹ 5* q-ß(B ,-.9* ,;.5WG )FG 5; C

T-N=KP6 ? ×R1R )- O¬N¯. )* )U OV L1 3T=NX. ,;.9* )FG q

- �X:( -b,6Y )- C ,X t6? )* )U OVà q

- �Ó= C IS ×R1R mB,JWr )

8 C 5PX A B,»;N 3_,k B1( ;�3/5´ mB,JWr )8 C 5PX A B,»;N 3_,k o* = .( @Wr( -2= nX¤

)FGE -M{= KV Xs ( M=NÀQ= .R IS 6f ( q³6 ? mB,JWr ×R1R ,k ;�¦6? (896 : IÕ7 8�=O*B,a M=Na )- C ( )/ )®>? æ

U C,-p 5WG ,;.,6Y )FGE `( 5* L1 chillers M=N>- ? M=NWcà L1 market

mechanism 6f ( q³6 ? M=N>- ? )FGE ( 6f q³6 ? -b,;K¢*,X . ,k ¥ÀX ? `( o* ;�¦6?

¡896 : percentage 56 7 -b,;K¢*,X . )* ¥ÀX ? o* )FG )FG ,XY I8 KU :5* ,k 6�=N_ )FG )FG ,XY m2= nª -b,;K®a ,k + ( )FG )FG ,XY ,ÉR5´24 ,k 5- O=NS )FG )FG ,XY dPQ_ B1( 2= n

-¤ B5X C o* B56 g³· )FGà L1 ;�y=�± ¥p,Y M=N>

- ? 9* o; ¹,X .E b5= O* IS mB,JWr `,X . L1

food processing industry 5* @Wr )- C -01di M=N>

- ? ,= .RE @Wr )- C

incentivize M=N>- ? ,= K* IS @Wr )

- C food process industry 5* -01di M=N>- ? ,= .Rà @Wr )

- C incentivise M=N>- ? ,= K* IS @Wr food processing

industry 5* M=NU.,É896 : B1( ,É896 : 9* @Wr q

- �X:( ( ` o* shelf life ,É896 :

31

M=NÁ_E I= . ¡B,JWr ;�}(B -B o* ;s,t=�679;: EM=NWc I= . M=Na ;�=OÆ= O* `( )U OV 3T=NX. 9*

b5WG,W cB IS 6�67 ;. Xs ( )- Oj ,_)* I= . ;sB5¿ ©,Y M=N>- ? )

U C ( o´à 6�67 ;. Xs ( -MWG-R)* M=Na I3[Ö

-C 3TÖ-C M=N>

- ? ,Ò5WGà Xs ( ;�yQY q¨JÔ ;�/BR M=N>- ? ,-K6: M=N

U.,X . )É 6s,-K67 D(1! 6s( M=Na ;�=O-: ,-.(5VR b5WG,;K WG,XY 9=: -B1 I- .(-9

-7 )/ IS ;�=Oy Wr( ,= K* E)FG Xs ( R5-7 acknowledge 9* )FG M=NWc IS ¡B,JWr qh5

- C,k( ,k T=NU.,6 . )/

T=N6.5X 7 �Õ=Oµ q6A ¡8R oX¹ ;�}(B -B )/ ,;. ( )FGE I= . `( o* significance )FGE @Wr R5-7 I>· M=NWc)FG B ISEE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: q6A B8RB ( -b( ¡R Ù1,W cE kindly Ñ= C23 ï;C EM=NÀ·Blow

your voices.

+1�-th L, 3_ R5y�h -M=N[7 q3 �= Cdº: Thank you Sir. @Wr R5-7 I>· M=NWc)FG B IS 6f ( q³6 ? (B,JWr 56 7 B,Ò -B1B )FGà `( o* ;<=:23 nS( ;�}(B -B )/ ^v[

-Na E)FG Major employer today, even today in Pakistan is the

agriculture sector. Xs ( admit M=NWc); C 9* IS Xs ( )* ^va o*

;<=:23 nS( ¡R,6 . ( b5; C,>=?R M=Na @=�Öj à)FG L1 ¥6. IÞ/(1 ,= . x6 . IÞ/(1 ;�}(B -B )/ ^v[

-Na )FGE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! 9´( ^va o* ;<=:23 nS( ¡R,6 . ( o* purchasing power @· )

U C ,6Y5WG o´ 5; C ;�3¢= N°j ,k I= K¦X?slow 5WG )U C ,6Y ,ÒE 6�67 ^va o*

;<=:23 nS( ¡R,6 . ( o* purchasing power M=Na I¼,-p( 5WG ,Ò 5; C ;�3¢= N°j ,k

I= K¦X? ’ )¢¬N]Y B(8R 6�7,p M=NWc); OFG ,XY ’ `( o- ¹(1B )´ ()/ )Ú 896 : ,Ò T67 o

- ¹(1B )/ I= . M=NWc); OFG ,XY IS ;�3¢= N°j ,k I= K¦X? )´ ( )Ú 896 :E L1 )¢¬NS ,Ò5WGà L1 )¢¬NS -M{Jh )FGà L1 q³6 �

;: -M{Jh 5WG ,;K{_ )FG IS 6�67 ;�}(B -B o* �d² ¾ =�gß I6 Y5

; C ¡R )U C ,6Y oÉ

32

6s,-K67 D(1! 9= : -B1 I- .(-9

-7 R5-7 q- �X:( 9= :dÎ

;C M=Na I>· M=NWc){¯Yà 8�6 g6? o* 9= :dÎ;C I ØÞ7xa

M=:9* IS 6f ( -b,;K¢*,X . o* ÑÜ- C ¡R,6 . ( L1 )FG 56 7 ;<6:d-Ô o* 2= nÁÂ )�=�

-:)* o´�-. -B 2ï6 C 9* q WrB (B1()FG ` ÑÜ

- C ¡R,6 . ( ;<=:23 nS( b,>· q; � WGB `(à)FG ÑÜ- C

¡R,6 . ( o* ;<=:23 nS( -b,;K¢*,X . ;s,>=?R)* M=Na q; � WGB à)FG -b,;K¢*,X . ,k -b,[* )FGà -b,;K¢*,X . ,k ¡B,W c à)FG -b,;K¢*,X . ,k B(�-K=Na -B à)FG -b,;K¢*,X . ,k B,»;N 3_,k 6s,-K67E)FG D(1! 9´( @Wr

)- C 6s( `( 5* ;<6:d-Ô o* 2= nÁÂ )/ 9X :1( 9*)V ,-. ( )FG 5; C Xs ( )]C 2= n

ØÞ-C

@Q-.( 8sB5X N_ +(9´19X : = .( targeted subsidy mR )FG B M=NWc -M{= KV that

is not the ultimate solution. That is a temporary stopgap arrangement Mr. Speaker. That is a targeted subsidy for a limited time. Ultimately the economy has to grow. Ultimately the purchasing power of the farmer has to

grow so that people are uplifted out of poverty line. Mr. Speaker, China has done that. China has uplifted millions of its rural poor out of poverty and that is through incentivising Chinese agriculture.

6s,-K67 D(1! M=Na = .( B1( 28 nÁ=K/ -édÔ ,-.9* b5WG,;K WG,XYE ;�j5{Y o* `( ;<º1 ;s,t=�679

;: M=Na )FG IS ,Ç= Oj T8NÁ=K6719X :’ 128 n=Kj T6 C ’ 128 n=Kj -M=:9

8 : ’ -M{= KV b5= O*à IS b5= C2î3§ 5* -MÓyÙj ,-.9* )FG -M{= KV M=Na `( U1,W c ` 5* ,-.,;K6: b5WG,;K WG,XY IS Xs ( o* ;�}(B -B o* q�= NÂ,X . I= . q WrB 56 7 6f ( 5; CE)FG 56 7 rural to urban migration

33

)FGà`( 5* Xs ( stop M=N>- ? 9* M=N

U.,X . )´ B1( 6f ( ¡896 : ¡-2= n;. )/ rural to urban migration 5WG q WrB )FGE 6�67 rural urban migration `(

¡-2= n;. )/ q; �Ú896 : )FG 5; C 6s,-K67 D(1 dPX ? b12î3§ M=Na slums M=NWc); O-N].à dPX ?

b12î3§ M=Na @U ?(9* ,;. ( )FGà dPX ? b12î3§ M=Na )

; C 89X :)* (8R M=NWcà dPX ? ); OP]? )Ä-. ,a M=NWc)

; C ,6Y B1( dPX ? = .( ¡dÌ;C(di( ,k @z,w (�= KX: ,;.5WG )FG’ b5= O* IS ¸5V q3§,°j

\-K;: oV,Y )/ q- �X:( o´�-. -B M=Na -b2= n6¤( M=NWc)

; C ,6Y5WGà L1 = .( I;K/(B 3 x;. )- C 9* o*

3T3Ê5* M=NWc)

; C 9*E

6s,-K67 D(1! M=Na -édÔ ,-.9* b5WG,XY ,Ò IS (B,JWr current status ,= K* )FGE and I will wind up Mr. Speaker.

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: ok.

Makhdoom Shah Mehmood Hussain Qureshi: And all my points Mr. Speaker, are points which are for constructive planning for the Government in the days ahead, in the years ahead, of their economic

management. 6s,-K67 Xs ( )P8 �¬N6. M= NWcà M=Na 2W c MNA )/ 6�²,-th b5WG

)FG ,XY `( ,k l®°;C -b5

- C )/à )FG ,XY `( ,k l®°;C -9®X K=NX. o

8 ¹B,X . )/ )FGà `( l®°;C,k

= .9g;? �,Õ

- C( )/à`( ,k l®°;C ;�},J6 A qhx_( )/ )FGà `( ,k l®°

;C )Z( \= KV )/ )FGà M=Na 2W c MNA )/ 6�²,-th b5WG B1( b5WG,;K¦· IS U1,;K6: )- O¯: ( )Î®Y )* B,»;N 3_,k )/ ¶X 75X C 9* `( -b(5= C( 5* U1,;K6: IS IS 6f ( L1 )®>? )/ LR,= .

-B

34

qÐ-K;: `5¢gh 9* ,W cB à)FG L1 )®>¯? )/ LR,= .

-B (89{6Y (5WG 5¢gh ` 9* ,W cB à)FG b5= O* ’ `( ,k 56 7 margin of profit )FGà ;�}(B -B æµ,-Kj 3T

-g6? M=N>- ? ,W cBà b5= O* M=N>

- ? ,W cBà `( )U OV M=N>

- ? ,W cB IS )®À�X? �-KX7 b5V,_ M=Na ’ = .( ©,_ M=Na M=N>- ?à )®À¯�X?

qU �* b5V,_ M=Na Xs ( o* 56 7 ;�}(B -B ¥-Y(�a)* M=NWc T67 5* Xs ( agricultural

inputs M=NWc); O¦·à -b( o* M=N;Ky=�± ×896 : qU �´ M=NWcà -b,J§ ( 5* 5PX A q WrB M=NWc B1( 56 7

`( o* output )FG 56 7 `( o* commodity )FGà`( o* ;�y=�± M=Na international factors inclusiveà `( M=Na L1 increase o

U ¹ (E 8<V -BB I= . )FG IS `( ,k margin of profit 89{_ ,= K´ B1()FG ;�}(B -B æµ,-Kj 3T

-g6? I6 KÓ3/ M=N>

- ? E,W cB

6s,-K67 D(1! M=Na 6f ( -édÔ ,-.9* b5WG,XY ,Ò IS ;�}(B -B )* )U OV = .( ;�¦6? constraining factor 56 7 à)FG Xs ( ,k B5Ü± M=N>

- ? )FGE @Wr 6�/ qh5± +96 gh M=NWcE q¨ÀX �X? qU �* b5= OU:,W cR )/ @Wr )

- C storage )U OV )* 1�-K6: ;�¢6 C M=N>- ? ,= K*

and today Mr. Speaker on the Floor of the House, I am putting myself on record that the main constraining factors in agricultural growth in Pakistan is the water scarcity. Pakistan in the 1950 was a water affluent country. And today Pakistan, in 2014, is a water scarce country. Now, if there is no water, there is no

agriculture. That is the primary input of agriculture. B1( )P]�h I= . `5¢µ( )/ ,-K¦· ,8 .9X : )FG IS M=N

;Kj5{Y o; ¹ ( q WrB M=NWc M=N

;Kj5{Y o; ¹,6Y q WrB àM=NWc

oU ¹5* )U O

-: storage o* ;s,6 . M=N>- ? qQ_5WGà o

U ¹5* ,= K-: storage M=N>

- ? -M6 :

35

,»/ B1( 6f ( B,»;N 3_,k 6s5= O8 : ¥=.1 ,k ¥6. M=N>- ? mR ,;K{_à q6 t6? ,k �2= n8. ,-K´R ,= K´5WG

à)FG L1 -9= :8R © o* ;�y=�± M=N>- ? ,»X 7 ,;K{_E`( ¶; ?,W c)* )/ L1 M=:-2= nX¤ ¥»

-C qQXY M=NWcE 6f ( -b,;K¢*,X . o* ;�}(B -B M=Na ’ M=Na I= . q³6 ? without any fear of

contradiction I>· ,W cB b5WG IS land is not the constraining factor. -M=Na -B 6f ( q³6 ? mB,JWr `,X . qi,k )FG 56 7 ¡B,JWragriculturable

)FGà 56 7 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( B�-.()* oU ¹D ,6Y q; �{_ E)FG 6f ( ;�}(B -B M=Na 8s1,kB )FG 5; C o

- ¹,X . o* 8s1,kB E)FG 6f ( ;�}(B -B M=Na 8s1,kB )FG 5; C -2= n[= NÂ,X . o* 8s1,kB )FG T67 o* I6 Y1 )/ (B,JWr B,»;N 3_,k (5WG(89{6Y E)FG

Xf2ï= CB o* ;s,6 . B5X OV,; . 6�7,p ¶6 gh )/ )®>? 9* M=NWc){¯Y IS ¡B,JWr Xf2ï= CB ,k -b(�½µ E)FG mB,JWr extension department ,k L -B,-K67 ¥»

-C ,»X 7 6�67E)FG )/ I= . b56 C5¿ 5* ¥½

;O-Na (5WG )FGà I= . )®>? -9*dh M=Na ,À; ? 6s( b56 C5¿ `,X .)* ,= K´ B1( b56 C5¿ )

- C L1 I6 Y5; C M=N>

- ? ¡RE I= . �= .5- C dËº 6�7,p )P

8 �¬N6. M=NWcà -b( �Â(1)* )

- C ¡B,_ dËÔ ;�}(B -B o* ¡B(�_,X . o*à Chamber of Agriculture )* 2= nUKX7 -M=Na ×�-K/ )P

; ?E M=NU.,;K6: IS ×�-K/ M=Na Xs ( 5*

extension department oU ¹,À·R ,;K=:R à)FG b,>=? mB,_ qó�-K/ à)P

8 �¬N6. M=NU.,;K6: IS -b,;K¢X75®6 . M=Na o

U ¹5* Xs ( 5* agriculture extension department o

U ¹,À·R ,;K=:R à)FG M=NU.,;K6: 26 n=K

-7 L(5- g-?5; O-gX? b5V(1 5* o

U ¹5* Xs ( 5* b,W c1 extension department o

U ¹,À·R )FG ,;K=:Rà M=N>- ? ’ -B,-K67 L ¥»

-C ,= K´ à)FG Xf2ï= CB ,k L -B,-K67 ¥»

-C ,= K´ à)FG extension ,k L -B,-K67 ¥»-C ,= K´ )FG B1( q³6 �

;: 6f ( o* ;�}(B -B o* I= . ;<V,Y E)FG

36

6s,-K67 D(1! ¡9-7 ( I;K{-. I= . )FG IS ;�j5{Y ;�¦6? ;�®6 tÔ M=Na )FG IS @Wr

)- C -b,;K/1�-K WG ¶; ?,_)* ;sB,6 t

;? o- ¹9* )FGà )U O]g=�*à regional trade o

- ¹,É896 : )FGà )¬OU : ,É896 :à -M{= KV M=Na 6f ( 8RB,»= CB 9X : ,-.D b5WG,;K WG,XY IS IS ,;K/1�-K WG -b ¶; ?,_)* 9´( Xs ( )- C qÔB -B `,-K67( o* ;sB,6 t

;? 0123 4 o* -b( ;sD,Y M=Na 5; C -b,;K¢*,X . ,k B,»;N 3_,kEE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: q6AE

+1�-th L, 3_ R5y�h -M=N[7 q3 �= Cdº: -b,;K¢*,X .5; C ,k B,»;N 3_,kà ×�-K/ ,kà 6s,6 t

-�X: ,kà I�(1 9X : B1( 2W c 2î3§ M=Naà L 8B,k1( M=Naà ,;K®a -b M=Na )

- C 9ÚR ,ÒmRà 6f,6 t;�7( m9* ,Òà

b5= O* ’ I= . M=N>- ? IS L1 ¥Ò,X . )FGà I= . M=N>

- ? IS L1 ;�/,= K/ 9* ,W cB )FGà `( )U OV IS -b,;K/1�-K WG o* ;�}(B -B B1( -b,;K¢*,X . o* ;�}(B -B M=Na R,= K

-N6. ¡ Zdi I= . IS)FG -b,;K/1�-K WG o* ;�}(B -B 5* billions, and I would like the

honourable Finance Minister to look at the Indian budget, to see the amount of subsidy provide to the

Indian farmer.

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: = KP8 ? )FG q6AE

+1�-th L, 3_ R5y�h -M=N[7 q3 �= Cdº: Sir last point. 6s( 9´( I= . -b,;K/1�-K WG

5* ¡ 8�[6 N_ mR ,W cB )FG B1( -b,;K/1�-K WG M=Na T=NU.,6 . `,-K67( q�= C( M=NWcT6 7E 5* Xs (

)- C 8sB5X N_ T

UC(9X : +-9-:,»= Oj )* B�-.( )U C D )

U C 5WG M=NWcE -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na )U C (5Ê +�-K´

)* ¶X 7 )/ ;s,_ -M= Nva -M8 : )* o

U ¹5* q³6 ? T-N6Y q�= C( M=N>

- ? )FG T67 5* Xs (

37

8sB5X N_ TUC(9X : +-9-:,»= Oj ,-K´ ){¯Y M=NWc APCOM L -B,-K67 ¥»

-C ,= K´ `( ;<º1 L -B,-K67 ¥»-C ,= KÉ expansion L -B,-K67 ¥»

-C ,= KÉ 5; C -b( ;sD,Y M=Na 9´( -b,;K/1�-K WG )/ Xs ( qÔB -B `,-K67( o* 8�= .9

8 : M=NÂ5P· )´ 5; C M=Na I>· ,W cB b5WG IS 6s,6 t-�X: ,k B,»;N 3_,k ¥»V,6 .

IÃWc(1 9X : 5WG ,ÒE 6s,6 t-�X: ,k B,»;N 3_,k 6f,6 t

;�7( 9* m ,ÒE M=Na -M=Na2U n=KX7 � ( ¡R -BdhB,¼ q§5¢= C( -M

3 ¢= C( I>· ,W cB b5WG M=Na b5- C,[* )* = .( m�-KU:,J

-? )* B5² 9X : I>· ,W cB b5WGE 9´( ,[= C( (5WG 5; C @Wr 6f ( I>· )FG B M=NWc B1( 6f,6 t

;�7( M=:9* )É ¡2= nª 3 B-9´ I= . )FG IS ©2- n6¤ -9®= K/ T{=K

8 : ,ÇV )¬C R M=NWcE B5X OV,; . 6�7,p Xs ( L(5´ M=NWcE -9®X K=NX. o8 ¹B,X . o* \-K8N=Kj q³

; ? o- ¹x= K´ 6�7,p @

ØÙ}(9= : -B1 )P; ? Xs ( M=NaB1()

- C )- C B1( �= .5

- C 6�7,p Xs ( L(5´ M=NWc @Wr )

- C 6<; : q³6 ? ,= .,À

8 ?( ,À; ? B1( -9®X K=NX. o8 ¹B,X . 5* M=Na )

- C ,>· ,À; ? IS (B(� -Y qÔB -B `,-K67( 9X : input ;�j )¬C ,ÇVE ©2- n6¤ ¥=K/ T{=K

8 : ;�j )¬C ,ÇV B,» 3/,k dh )

U C ,6Y ,ÒE 16�Õ=Oµ b5¦- ?( )- C ,ÇV ,= .R 17�Õ=Oµ Xs ( )

- C 9* ,= .RE 6f ( 56 7 qÔB -B ¥

-Y(�a M=NWc L1 B,»;N 3_,k o* ;s5± �= .9-7 )/ 2W c,6 . qQXY5WG M=NWc please

revisit, please rethink, M=N>- ? 5; C ;�}(B -B M=N>

- ? 5WG ,Ò 5; C -b,[* M=N>- ?

,Ò5WGE -b,[* ©,t3§5-7 M=N>

- ? 5WG ,Ò 5; C -b,;K¢*,X . ©,t

3§5-7 M=N>- ? 5WG ,;K{_E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: I= .9{

3_E 28 n[-Na B,¼ ¥

-K3¢= N-. 8R5µ o

8 ¹B5= O{= K/E

9=: -B1 )U C (96 : ¥

-K3¢= N-. 8R5µ o

8 ¹B5{= K/) 6s,-K67 B�-K{_ ;s,= K7 -b,-Y -M/56 C:( �@��6 C �'( -M� yA�9~V( �@= ��7�9~V(E 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p 6�/ )/ )®>? 5; C M=Na 6s(5

- C Ñ/5= C B5X OV,; . 6�7,p ,k B1( +1�-th 6�7,p ,k B1( `( )* L1xw 56 7 -b(5= C( M=Na mB,JWr ;�/1R M=NWc b5¦- �67 )

- C I3[= NJWr ;�}(B -B )/ l®°;Oj )- O¯: ( concern ,k B,> Øè( ,= K* )FGE B1(

,°;O±1 ,;KÓ±5µ L1 `( )®[®_ M=Na IÞ6 C(B q³6 ? ); OP·B M=NWc B1( -b( ,k I= .9{3_ q³6 ? (R( ,;.9*

38

b5WG B1( -b( 5* -M=N½= C ,-.DR ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS 56 7 q³6 ? -b( o* input `( )®a ,°j M=Na 5WG o´ '(, 3[

-C( in letter and spirit @Wr 3T3Ê5* M=:9* )´ IS -b( o* 56 7

input )FG `( 5* q- �X:( q�= NÂ,X . ,k IÕ7 EM=N

U.,-K6: `( M=Na oU ¹5* ^3_ M=N>

- ? )FG IS agriculture is a mainstay of Pakistan’s economy, B1( ^va

M=Na T67 fd² ,>· ,= K´ )FG IS 67 8�- N_9X : � ( (R -M3 ¢= NÂ5X C,X . `( )* ¶; ?,_

involve )FG with 45% of the labour force, 56 7 `( )* ¶; ?,_ ^v[

-Na )FG B1( M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS `( ;�j5{Y ,k 56 7 6�/ )/ (896 : T*5µ )FG B1( 56 7 ¡B,JWr q�= NÂ,X . ,k IÕ7 )FG IS @Wr )

- C 2W c ;<V,Y M=Na ;�}(B -B 5* æµ,-Kj 3T-g6?

,-.,-K6: )FGE @Wr �2Í B1( �2Í q�* = .( 8�- OU:(5X C )* 9X :1( @Wr `( )* 9X :1( ;�- Ogh 9* )FG B M=NWc B1( ¡B,JWr ¡B5X C 3T

3Ê5* I= . )FG IS @Wr 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( 5* profitable M=N

U.,-K6:E `( ©,_ T67 ¶; ?19´ ,k 9*-R ,= K* ,= K´E `( M=Na oU ¹5* ^3_

M=N>- ? IS 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( o* ¶; ?19´ @· q WrB -M{= KV 9´( Xs ( 56 7important crops M=NWc

-b,;K¢*,X . o* -b( o* �d² M=NÀQ= .R 5; C '(�J�z( wheat )* B�-.( 4.4 8�-N_9X : o* ¶; ?19´ o

U ¹5WG )FGE 9´53Ê -M=NS )* B�-.( 4 8�- N_9X : )/ 9X :1( ¶; ?19´ oU ¹5WG )FGE T

UC(B )* B�-.( 22.8 8�- N_9X : o* ¶; ?19´ o

U ¹5WG )FG B1( maize )* B�-.( 7.3 8�- N_9X : o* ¶; ?19´ o

U ¹5WG )FGE 56 7 ¶; ?19´ overall @· oU ¹5WG )FG L1 main ¡B,JWr -M

8 :,k o* crop q³

; ?E +1�-th 6�7,p q³6 ? ); O-: ,6Y M=NWc B1( 6s(5

- C Ñ/5= C 6�7,p q³6 ? ); O-: ,6Y M=NWc

IS `( ;<º1 56 7 -M8 :,k o* crop )FG L1 ¥

-K3¢= N-. 8R5µ o

8 ¹B5= O{= K/ )* `,X . M=N>- ?

)FG B1( I= . `( ;<º1 ¡28 n[-Na � ( ¥U.,8K¢{= K

8 : )* `,X . )FGE T67 )* )¬OV already @Wr )

- C ¡28 n[-Na � ( T

-C,-Kµ 5* q³6 ? 8�¢=C5{= .B o* oU ¹5WG )FG B1( M=Na

-M=N½= C ,-.DR ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS '(, 3[-C( �oV,°;C 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ o* q�= NÂ,X . )FG B1( M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS 56 7 weak points M=NWc `( ;<º1 M=NWc @Wr 3T

3Ê5* M=:9* )´ IS `( )*

39

B�-.( ¡2; n>6? M=NU.DE `( ;<º1 56 7 6�/ )/ weaker sector )FG `( 5* M=Na

admit ,;.9* b5WG L1 mB,JWr 8�= K/ ,k 28 nÁ=K/ )FGE @Wr )- C 8�= K/ )* 9X :1( = .(

8<i(B8R ¥6. 2014 ©B 8�= Kµ 8�- O6N=K* )/ approve (19* 9* ¥-K3¢= N-. q6 Ky§( M=Na

(56 g=�P6 ? ,= .R )FGE b,>=? M=Na ©R q- �{ 3_ M=N>

- ? ,-.9* ,;K WG,XY é,-Y B5² 9X : M=Na )- O¯: ( +2; nth M=N

U.,_ �=K3/B5-7 L, 3_ 6�7,p o* IS I= . ¥6. 2007M=Na q³6 ? I= . ¥6. 8�- O6N=K*

)/ approve (19* 9* q6 Ky§( )* B�-.( ,6 t=�P6 ? ,À; ? 56 7 IS X¾-?,X . ©,_ )* �°6 C 6�67

@Wr ¸5V TXC(1 )U C ( M= NWc 5; C L1 q§( )/ )Î¬C d² L1 M=NJWr TXC(1 ¥a ,= K´ E)FG M=Na

;sB -�°j L(5-7 �2Í 8RB,»= CB )* )¬OV X¾-?,X . ©,_ )* �°6 C L1 ¥6. dPX ? )/ 8�- O6N=K* )/

approve (19* 9* q³6 ?( 8�- Oy=�VB,X . B�-.()* 3T=NX. ,= K* )FGE M=Na -M= N½= C ,-.DR ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS I= . ¥6. 6�67 b,>=? 8�- Oy=�VB,X . )/ `,X . 5WG )

U C ,6Y ,Ò 5; C '(, 3[

-C( 56 7 (B,JWr 8�= K/ 28 nÁ=K/ `()FG M=Na ¡2; n>6? )

U C ( oÉ `( )* L1xw 56 7 patent rights ,k ¥6. )FG T67 o* I6 Y1 )/ b,>=? 9X : ;�}(B -B )* B�-.( 8�- Oy

8 �¢= C5- C( M=N>

- ? o; ¹5WG 5; C L1 q³6 ?

@U ?(9X : 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p )/ approve (19* 9* `( M=Na q³6 ? @Wr )- C 8�- O6N=K* )*

)- Oj ,_ 3T=NX. ,-.5WG )FG B1( 8�- O6N=K* )- C 3T=NX. )

- C 5WG o* ¡B5 Ø�-Oj mR ¡R )FGE '(, 3[

-C( )- C ( oV(1 next Cabinet meeting M=Na patent rights ,k ¥6.

q³6 ? @Wr approve (19* 9* dPX ? 8�- Oy=�VB,X . 5* M=N6t=�P6? )É `( )/ 56 7

concerns M=NWc ¡B,JWr 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( q8 �-:5= Oy· )* B1( I= . ¥6. `,X . )

- C 5WG )* �°6 C M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS specially T67 ;s,6 . )* 9X :1( q Wr�-., 3[

-C o* qU �´ -M8 :,k

l®°;Oj)*E '(, 3[

-C( )- C ( )V (1 b5V,_ )* B�-.( q =.�6 K

;: )U C ( oÉ b,>=? 9X : 56 7

main IvUK¢j )FG IS b1B,»;N 3_,k 5* ¾ =�gß 8�= K/ M=N>

- ? ,;K®a `( o* qË Wr(di '(, 3[-C( `(

¥6. )* `,X . )- C 5WG )* �°6 C '(, 3[

-C( `( o* qË Wr(di 5WG )U C ,6Y oÉ `( )* L1xw

= .( ¥6. Establishment of National Food Safety, Animal

40

and Plant Health Regulatory Authority ,k q³6 ? )FG B1( L1 q³6 ? @Wr )- C B,= K

; : 9* ,= KV )FG B1( I-K=N6.,k )* `,X . `( ;<º1 R56 75j )FG b,W c1 9X :E `( )/ -b,;K¢*,X . o* 8sB5X Oj( B1( 8sB5X N[{= .( M=NWc 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( 28 nÁ=K/ )* B�-.( M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG '(, 3[

-C( `( )* B�-.( ¡2; n>6? )U C ( oÉ b,>=? 9X : o

- ¹,X . o* ;s,6 . o* qU �É 6s(5- C

6�7,p )- C q³6 ? ;s,6 . o* `( M=Na o

U ¹5* ^3_ M=N>- ? IS o

- ¹,X . )* 2= n-°6 C ;�}(B -B -M{Jh

M=N>- ? )FGE 56 7 5; C m896 : -dË=?8R M=NWc 56 7 m896 : )]C 5Ü- Oj M=NWc -b( 9X : 5; C naturally

`( ©5= OV )* 9X :1( 6�67 ;. 6�/ ¸5V lÆ;Oj I- . b5WG `( ;<º1 ;. ¶X g· M=N>

- ? 5WG ,;K{_E M=Na 8RB,»= CB )* 9X :1( I= . ;s,6 . ,-.D ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS ×�-K/ ;�j5{Y 5* M=Na )- C 98 :(1 -24B5* o* ¡2; n>6? )* )¬OV ,= K

-: +(9´19X : )- C xXY )¬OV )* -b( 5* ,>· B1( `(

)* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ = .( (241R +(9´19X : 56 7 IS q Wr5*R1B )* l®°;Oj ,À; ? T67 ,k

province of Sindh ,k q³6 ? (896 : L�U.,¼ ,-.5WG ,À; ?E ×�-K/ ;�j5{Y )- C L1 TXC(1

9* ,= .R IS @Wr `( M=Na interested M=N>- ? M=NWc B1( @Wr ,-KX:( +(9´19X : R5-7 M=N

U.xXY )É IÁ-.D,Y 56 7 98 :(1 -24B5* ,k 56 7 +(9´19X : )FG This is on record IS 56 7 -2= n¼ -b1 56 7 )®>? xXY ,À; ? Xs ( )

- C R5-7 admit ,= K* )FG IS `( )/ qi,k L�U.,¼ M=NJWr ,X t

-�¦X? E)FG 5; C `( ;<º1 ;sB12- Í `( dh( o* IS )¢¬C ( -dh(9´19X : 5* @Wr 0123 4 M=:9* 56 7B1( `( ;<º1 Å

UC,½-C 56 7 mB,JWr irrigation system)* B�-.( M=NWc

T67 M=Na 6s,6 t-�X: )* B�-.( q³6 ? -9V,-K* B�-.()* M=NWc B1( 56 7 (B,JWr ` 8�-.( ,k @

8 �¢/ )FG `( )* B�-.( q³6 ? M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG ;�¦6? 3T

UC,6 t-�´ )FG IS -b( )* 9X :1( +,k ,= K*

)U C ,6Y B1( `( )* )¬OV M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS ×�-K/ 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ 5* `( 9X :1()* qß5Ü-7

B5² 9X : I6 Y5; C q

- �=:R )¬OFG ,XYE b,>=? 9X : ;�}(B -B )* )¬OV -M6 7 ;s,a(�£( ,k -bxw( ,= K* )FG B1( M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG Ñ= OX7 28 n[

-Na � ( 6s,6 t-�X: ,k q³6 ? M=Na (896 : B5{ 3[j b5WG `( )®[®_

M=Na �= K/ �=K3/B5-7 L, 3_ 6�7,p ,k �=K/ �= .5

- C dËº 6�7,p ,k B1( `( )* L1xw �_(

41

dËÔ 6�7,p ,k �Y)]C B(-9´9{ 3_ b5WG IS b5¦- ?( )- C `( )®a ,°j M=Na ¡B,JWr B5X CdP6 ?

8sB5X N_ o* )FG B1( )- O¯: ( )- O¯: ( 56 7 relevant provinces M=NWc -b( )/ ;s,6 . o* )FGE @Wr LR5X 7 -M=Nv6 . )¯C 1B o* `( ;<º1subsidy phosphastic B1(

potash )* B-9U:x= K8 :di M=Na T

-C,-Kµ 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )

- C -bxw( ,= K* M=NaE)FG ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS '(ã, 3[

-C( �oV,°;C `( ,k (896 : L�U.,¼ 5WG ,Ò B1( ,-K=N½= C `( @ºB 5* `( )/ q³6 ? LR,= .-B

,-KÚ896 : ()¬OFG ,XY B1 '(ã, 3[-C( �oV,°;C 9´( Xs ( o* 8sB5X N_ ¥a, 3_ o

U ¹5WG 5; C '(ã, 3[-C( �oV,°;C `(

M=Na �= .-dh q³6 ? I¼,-p( M=:9* E)´ -B28 nÁ=.98 : )* mB,6 . M=Na ;s,6 . o* qU �´ IS -B28 nÁ=.98 : o* ;�y=�± o

U ¹,É896 : EqU �´ IÁ-.D,Y I= . mB,_ ;sxa,°j 9´( Xs ( m 8�-KP8 ? ©R )* ¶; ?,_

M=N XY5Ê 5; C Xs ( o* q¨ÀX �X? ;�j5{Y )- C L�W c,°j ,= K* ,À; ? IS q¨>X? ¡B5- O67 )/ `( o*

M=N;Ky=�± ×896 : M=N

U.,6Y E)´ 5; C `( 5* q³6 ? Xs ( )- C ,ÀQ= .R IS = .( negative

trend ,À; ? production of tractors )* B1(9X :1( `( 9X : q³6 ? T-C,-Kµ 28 n[

-Na )- C o

- ¹,6 .2îh o* B1( -B28 nÁ=.98 : )* 9X :1( M=NJWr ;<=:,wB ¡R E)FG ×�-K/ )* 56 7 mB,JWr B,»;N 3_,k M=NWc 5; C IÁ-.5X 7 b,W c1 9X : `1Bx= K6: 28 nÁ=.98 : LR,= .

-B ©,Jå;N_( ,;.5WG )FG B1( M=Na )

- C categorically 56 7 8�- O6N=K* o* \-K8N=Kj q³

; ? 5; C `( M=Na `( ;s,6 . ,k B,> Øè( ,= K* IS 9´( qº,6 . -B28 nÁ=.98 : o* ;�y=�± @· o

; ¹5WG )FG B1( `1Bx= K6: o* @· M=N>- ? o

; ¹5WG 5; C `( ,k q³6 ? ,ÀX A( +,-°= OX: M=N>

- ? )U C ,6Y T67E,Ò ()* 9X :1 T

-C,-Kµ 28 n[-Na )

- C ¡896 : ©,J· o- ¹,6 .2îh B1(

b5¦- ?( )- C `( )* 9X :1( q³6 ? 7 �Õ=Oµ o

8 ¹5= C8R @· )- C 9* ,k -bxw( E,= K* b,>=? 9X :

b5= C-26 n_ o* ;s,6 . qi,k oU ¹5WG )FG B1( ¡B,JWr = .( -B-dåj -M*B -M6 7 ,k l®°

; C ×�-K/ )* ¶; ?,_ )FG L1 L�w,£,6 . b,>=? 9X : -B,= KX: B1( 98 :,J

8? )- O¯: ( ¶; ?,_ )V 9* EM=NU. ( -b( ,k l®°

;C q³6 ? = .( agriculture family )* ¶; ?,_ )FG B1( )P]�h ¶{= .R 9* ¡896 : ;s2= n¤ oU ¹5WG IS I= . b5

- C1R M=:-2= nX¤ ×�-K/ o*crops M=NWc B1( `( -2= nX¤ ,k Xs ( 5* B12- Í L -B(�-.( ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XY IS cost of production )* L1xw = .( -2= nX¤ Xs ( B12- Í -MWG-R

42

M=Na M=NWcB IS 6s( -M3 ¢= NÁ=K-:5= Oy· )* )¯A 9

-7 qi,k LR,= .-B 5WG )U O´ EM=NWc 5; C `( -2= nX¤ 5*

M=NJWr d Ø�-C�a ,-KP·B )¬OFG ,XY IÁ-.5= O* -b( b5

- C1R b1-2= nX¤ 9X : -B,= KX: 98:,J8?B1( )* 9X :1( IS `(

5* @Wr 8sB5X N[{= .( I- . )- C 9* EM=:R mB,JWr T

-C,-Kµ 28 n[-Na )* @¨w M=Na I= . ;s,6 . )FG

IS M=Na )- C b,W c1 9X : I= . ,>· IS IÁ-.5X 7 I= . ×�-K/ o* crop )FG 5; C q�* ;sB5¿ M=Na

q³6 ? @Wr 8sB5X N[{= .( 9X : ¡�-K6:,X . M=N>- ? M=N

U.,ÇV )´ 5; C `( )®[®_ M=Na @Wr )- C (B5X C

8�-K=N8K/ ,= KV B1( @Wr )- C `( 9X : 8sB5X N[{= .( o* ;s -B,6Y( E¡R 5; C M=Na Xs ( 5* -M=N½= C ,-.DR

,;K WG,XY b5WG IS 56 7 q³6 ? 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( ,k Iva,°j )FG )FG ,XY ×�-K/ ,k )FGà )FG ,XY -b,;K¢X 75®6 . ,k )FGà )FG ,XY )* oX¹ )* ,k )FG ,= . 6s,6 t

-�X: ,k )FG 5; C '(ã, 3[-C( �oV,°;C M=Na Xs ( 5*

-M=N½= C ,-.DR b5WG,;K WG,XY IS I= . �2Í = .( qhR ( ,k Iva,°j M=N>- ? E)FG +1�-th L, 3_ R5y�h

6�7,p )- C ¥»V,6 . ¾ =�g

ß ;s,6 . o* IS 56 7 ¡B,JWr q8 �=NJ· )FG `( M=Na )®>? -bR 6�67 `x6Y( (5WG 5; C 6�/ b5´5V )

- C ,>· IS `( q8 �=NJ· )* B�-.( q�* @�± o* oU ¹5*

-M3 ¢= C -B5X C( M=N>

- ? 5WG o´ IÁv6 . 2W c qhR ( 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( )* )¬OV ,-K;N 6Y q³6 ? contribute 9* ){_ ,Ò L1 m9* 5; CE,Ò M=Na `( -9= :56 g

;? 5* @Qv= .1 ,;.9* b5WG B1( M=Na -b( 5* -M=N½= C ,-.DR ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS '(ã, 3[

-C( �oV,°;C @Wr `( )®[®_ M=Na ¡B5X C 3T3Ê5* M=:9* E)´

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: = KP

8 ? )FGE

6s,-K67 B�-K{_ ;s,= K7 -b,-Y -M/56 C : 24 ¡�v6Y )FGE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: Kindly wind up 9* EM=NÂ

6s,-K67 B�-K{_ ;s,= K7 -b,-Y -M/56 C : I= .9{3_E

43

28 nS(8R L�= Kyíi ( -Bdh : I= . ;�¦6? @Wr( Iva,°j E)FG `( 9X : -b( 5* )- OV 56 C EM=:R

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: b5¦- ?( )

- C ;s,6 . 9* oV E)FG 28 n[-Na 6�7,p Xs ( )

- C ;s,6 . 9* oV E)FG ;s,6 . 5; C `( 9X : ¶X 7 )8 O

-NÀê q³6 ? 5WG q; �{_ )FGE Xs ( )- C ;s,6 . 9* oV

E)FG 8�-KU :(1 Xs( EM=:9*

6s,-K67 B�-K{_ ;s,= K7 -b,-Y -M/56 C : M=Na ;�=O3Nt6? B,»;N 3_,k )- C 5WG )* ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG

IS o- ¹,X . )* 2= n

-°6 C oU ¹5* (B(-9´ M=N>

- ? E)FG 6s5= O8 : -9®= .1 )* 9X :1( = .( ¾-ß(1 B5² 9X :

8�- Oy- ?B5´ � ( 6s,6 t

-�X: )- C = .( ¡ 8�[6 N_ @Wr(di o* E)FG T67 9X :1()* mB5X C ©,_

)* )¬OV b5¦- ?( )- C 10 )¯C 1B 34 )¢¬N¯. )* 9X :1( `( 5* cap ,= K* B1( @Wr

3T3Ê5* 9* )FG B M=NWc IS `( @=�{_ 5* )´ ( q³6 ? EM=N

U.,É896 : 8�- Oy- ?B5´ � ( -b,;K¢X 75®6 .

q³6 ? `( )* B�-.( ¡ 8�[6 N_ mR q WrB )FGE 6�67 I= . devolution 5WG ,= K´ )FG B1( M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS provinces 5* q³6 ? `( M=Na )´ ( ,-. ( E)¬OFG ,XY 2W c )]C 5¿ o* q- �X:( T{a,-K*( M=NWcE 6s( M=Na b5¦· IS 6s5= O8 : ,k M=Na ,;K-:,6Y b5WG IS ,-K;N 6Y (896 : 6s5= O8 : ¥=.1 ,k impact 6s,6 t

-�X: M=Na ,;. ( )FG 5; C ×�-K/ M=Na )- O;: ( 6s5= O8 : ¥=.1 M=N>- ?

-M{= KVEM=NWc M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS ×�-K/ 5* q³6 ? `( )®[®_ M=Na q�= C( @=�{_ o- ¹,-K6: )¬OFG ,XY

T67 )/ -b( )* B,»;N 3_,k 5* L�U.,¼ E)¯�-�¦X? b,>=? 9X : +1�-th 6�7,p

)- Cprocessing o* ;s,6 . o* 5; C `( )®[®_ M=Na = .( © -B5X C9X : q³

; ? IS �2Í -b(9{a )* )¬OV B1( ;�ÄvÒ -b,;K¢

;Nv6 . B1( ,8 .,¼ )* à)¬OV `( 5* @Wr )- C mB5X C

-b,;K¢X 75®6 . )* )¬OV ,= .(9* B1( 56 7 q³6 ? processing 8s1di B1(dates )* 6s,[7 )/ 56 7 q³6 ? ¡28 n_ 8�-.( -b,;K¢X 75®6 . mB5X C )* àB�-.( ;�ÄvÒ -b,;K¢

;Nv6 . )* B�-.( B1( `(

44

)* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ ,8 .,¼ )* 56 7 -B,= .9= :( b5WG )´ -b( 5* q¨ 3[= NXK/ ;<=:,wB ¡R )U C ,6Y Eo´

-M=:9´ -24U1,W c )* )¬OV 8�- Oy- ?B5´ )

- C `( I°µR ¡896 : o- ¹,6 .2îh o* B1( -M=:9´ -24U1,W c )*

9X :1( 8�- Oy- ?B5´ )

- C = .( ;<=:,wB ,k -bxw( ,= K* )FG B1( +,J;? 56 7 -2ï{= K

8 : M=NWc 56 7 -M=:9´ -24U1,W c )* )®[®_ M=Na M=NWc L1 b5¦- ?( )

- C +,J;? withdraw )¬O* (EM=NWc `

M=Na oU ¹5* ^3_ M=N>

- ? IS)FG 6s(5- C Ñ/5= C B5X OV,; . 6�7,p ;�}(B -B )* )¬OV ,-KX:( (896 :

©1B (R( ); C 9* )FG B q³6 ?(EM=NWc b5¦- ?( )

- C agriculture machinery ,k q³6 ? ,>· IS `( )* 9X :1( ;<=:,wB o

- ¹5WG )¬OFG ,XYàM=Na -b( )* ¶; ?,_ ¥»V,6 . lÆ;Oj Eb5WG -M{= KV

M=Na )- O¯: ( ¶; ?,_ = .( notification ,= .D b5WG IS 2006 M=Na -b( +,J;? b1-2= nX¤

)* 9X :1( M=Na )- C 19=: -B o

8 ¹5= C8R oU ¹(9* Eq³

; ? q; �y�±�6 . )/ `( ;<º1 Xs ( o* `( 9X : L,Ç-C M=N>

- ? ¡89X : B1( 2009-10 M=Na Xs ( )- C dPX ? `( )* 9X :1( ¡B,_ M=:-2= nX¤ ,ÇV

¡R EM=NWc 5; C o- ¹,6 .2îh ,= K* M=:9* IS 6�67 Xs ( `( �d² q³6 ? M=NÀ

8 �=N6. 5; C o- ¹,6 .2îh 9*

)* `( ;<º1 q³6 ? ¶X g· ©,= K-7 ,À·B àM=:9* �2Í I= . M=N>

- ? )FG IS �2Í `( �d² ¶8 �=N6. 9* Xs ( -b( b1-2= nX¤ ,k )

; C 9* EM=NWc Xs ( )- C ,>· 5WG ,Ò -M{= KV `( ;<º1 9´(

�= .5- C dËº 6�7,p Xs ( ,k ¶; ?,_ ); O¬: R 5; C (2= nª ©,= K

-7 )FG IS oU ¹5* I6 Y1 M=N>

- ? q³; ? IS

L1 I= . M=:-2= nX¤ withdraw I- . ); C 9*E©,Y2î6 ? M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS `( o* ¡896 :

;sB12- Í )FG B1( M=Na )- C already T

-C,-Kµ 28 n[-Na )/ ;�/(5-7BR o* )FG IS ¶8 ? (

�Õ=Oµ ¡B,JWr +�-K´ æU C,-p 5WG o

; ¹,6Y )FG because mB,JWr `,X . `( fd² o* ¡2- n=K

3¢j `( ;<º1 available M=N>- ? )FGE 5; C @Wr `( )* )¬OV 3T

3Ê5* )FG B9* M=NWc IS �= .-dh q�= C( ¡2- n=K

3¢j 56 7 IS -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na M=N>- ? q; �

-N6. `( )* )¬OV T-C,-Kµ 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p )/ B5X CdP6 ? ;�/(5-7BR o* o

U ¹5WG )FG IS L1 o- ¹,6 .2îh M=:9* B1( -b( ¡2- n=K

3¢j 9X :1()* 56 7 -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na M=N>

- ? àq; �-N6. `( )* 9X :1( 56 7 2009 M=Na -2= n8.5= C8R Xs ( )

- C oU ¹,ÇV M=NÀ

; ? -b( 5* withdraw 9* ,= KV )U C ,6YE b,>=? 9X : oX¹ T=C( ¡8R oX¹ o* ;s,6 .

45

o* qU �´ IS ;�}(B -B )* )¬OV 56 7 8�6 g6? )FG L1 (896 : @· )FGà `( M=Na oU ¹5* ^3_

M=N>- ? )FG IS devolution )/ )®>? ,6 K=:dÎ

;C `( ¡28 n[-Na ,k 8�6 g6? ,À; ? That

was 24 billion. B1( 6�67 M=Na `( ;<º1 ,= . ( b5WG 5; C `( ,k �2Í 8�6 g6? 2; nÀX �X? 8B19* )¯C 1B ,À; ? B1( T67 5* b5¦- ?( )

- C = .( -M=Nv6 . )¯C 1B )* 9X :1( ,= .,É896 : )FG

B1( I= . ¡B,_ M=:-2= nX¤ oU ¹,6 .5¿ 8�6 g6? B�-.()* reflect o

- ¹5WG )¬OFG ,XY Eq³; ? -M{= KV M=Na

m896 : RBR )* ¶; ?,_ I= . ;s,6 . ,;.9* b5WG oU ¹,6 .5¿ 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ )- C )- O¯: ( 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( ,k 56 7

8�6 g6? )FG `( )* B�-.( b5¦- ?( )- C I¼,-p( M=N>

- ? ,= K* E)FG `( I°µR 6s,6 t-�X: )*

8�6 g6? )* B�-.( '(�J�z( b5¦- ?( )- C o

- ¹,6 .2îh o* B1( @Wr b,= Kj 6�7,p 5* B1( qº,6 . 56 7 -b( o* @=�

8 : )FG T-C,-Kµ 28 n[

-Na )* )å¬C B-R `( ;s,6 . 9X : ¥U.,£ )- C 9* M=Na 6s,= Kj,k 5WG

)U O´ M=NWc B1( b5¦- ?( )- C `( I°µR 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( ,k 8�6 g6? )FG `( 5* ,= .,É

896 : E)FG M=Na Xs ( )/ ;�/(5-7BR b19* ,Ò IS ×�-K/ )* B�-.( q³6 ? Xs ( o

- ¹,6 .2îh M=:9* B1( ×�-K/ ,k 56 7 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( 8�6 g6? à)FG )* oX¹ )* ,k 56 7 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( 8�6 g6? )FG 5; C +1�-th 6�7,p

o- ¹,6 .2îh 9* )* `( )* B�-.( 3T

3Ê5* M=:9* B1( I¼,-p( M=:9* because 56 7 T=N6.5X 7 -M=Nv6 . ,k oX¹ T=C( ¡8R oX¹ ;�}(B -B ,k mB,JWr ,À; ? `( 5* definitely

devolution )* �°6 C b,W c1 9X : reflect ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XYEM=Na = .( I°µR dPX ? +,J;?

-b(5= C( )* b5; N_1R -M= N½= C ,-.DR ,;K WG,XY b5WG B1( b,>6A ;. ,= .8�-.( )* ¶; ?,_ 8�= .9

8 : ,k Iva,°j )FG 5; C @Wr ¥»V,6 . )- O¯: ( B,»;N 3_,k b5= OU:,À6 ? )* ¶; ?,_ M=NWc B1( o

U ¹5* q³6 ? ,[= C( IvÕ=Oµ T67 M=Na ¡B,JWr q8 �

-:5= Oy· 5* b1B,»;N 3_,k 5* q�* @�± ,k @6 .(9X : 5WG ,Ò 5; C @Wr 2W c

;<V,Y M=Na )- O¯: ( B,»;N 3_,k )* ¶; ?,_ m8dP· b5WG )´ B1( 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( ,k ¶; ?,_ M=:R à)´ M=Na Xs ( 5* -M=N½= C ,-.DR ,;K WG,XY b5WGE `( )®[®_ M=Na `dh,k 28 n[

-Na )* ¶; ?,_ ¡B,JWr ;s,6 . ;�=OX7 5WG q WrB )FG B1( `( )* 9X :1( (B,JWr = .( ¥XK¢

-C9X : 8�-K=N8K/ )FG T67 9X :

46

@Wr '(ã, 3[-C( �oV,°;C @

U ?,£ M=NWcB E)´ M=Na M=N>- ?( Øä,çV( )* ¶; ?,_ I= .9{

3_ (R( ,;.9* b5WG B1( Xs ( o* 8sB5X N_ ,k B5X CdP6 ? I= .9{

3_ (R( ,;.9* b5WGE DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON DEMAND FOR GRANTS

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: 1R M=NWc -B 8�-.,J= ?8R -M6 7 )* 9X :1( 8s11 ,-.9* )FG 5; CMay I take

up Demand No. 80. The question is that Demand No.80, as moved, may be granted.

(The demand was granted.)

Mr. Speaker: The question is that Demand 128, as moved, may be granted. (The demand was granted.)

Mr. Speaker: Minister for Finance to move Demand

No.69.

Mr. Mohammad Ishaq Dar: Sir, I beg to move that

a sum not exceeding Rs.2,815,172,000 be granted to

the Federal Government to meet expenditure during the

47

year ending 30th June, 2015 in respect of OTHER

EXPENDITURE OF INTERIOR DIVISION. (Demand

No.69).

Mr. Speaker: There are five Cut Motions on

Deamnd No.69. Rai Hasan Nawaz Khan.

Rai Hassan Nawaz Khan: Cut Motion No. 132. Sir,

I beg to move that the demand under the head Other

Expenditure of Interior Division” (page No.1293) be

reduced to Rs. 100/- (To discuss the failure of

Government to ensure merit in the FIA where hundreds

of persons were appointed on deputation on political

basis).

Mr. Speaker: Minister concerned do you oppose it?

Mr. Muhammad Baligh-ur-Rehman: I oppose it.

48

Mr. Speaker: Ms Shahida Rehmani .

Ms. Shahida Rehmani : Cut Motion No. 133 . Sir, I beg to move that the demand under the head Other Expenditure of Interior Division “ (page No. 1293 be reduced to Re.1/- (To discuss the failure of government to make a comprehensive/ clear strategy regarding placement of Afghan refugees).

Mr. Speaker: Minister concern do you oppose it?


Mr. Speaker: Ms. Aisha Syed Sahiba.

Ms. Aisha Syed: Cut Motion No. 134. Sir, I beg to move that the demand under the head Interior Division ( page No. 1293) be reduced by Rs.100/-(To discuss the failure of Government to make the identity card system transparent for the public).

49

Mr. Speaker: Minister concerned, do you oppose it?


Mr. Speaker: The remaining Cut Motions are clubbed together and treated as moved.

Mr. Speaker: Minister for Finance to move demand

No.70.

Mr. Mohammad Ishaq Dar: Sir, I beg to move that a sum not exceeding Rs.1,675,184,000 be granted to the Federal Government to meet expenditure during the year ending 30th June, 2015 in respect of NARCOTICS CONTROL DIVISION (Demand No.70)

Mr. Speaker: There are 13 Cut Motions on Demand No.70. Sheikh Rashid Ahmed.

Sheikh Rashid Ahmed: Cut Motion No. 136. Sir, I beg to move that the demand under the head “

50

Narcotics Control Division” (page No.1323) be reduced to Re.1/-( To discuss the failure of Government to control and ban narcotics substance and take steps to formulate a comprehensive strategy to control, ban and rehabilitate the addicts and create narcotics free environment in the country at par international standard). Thank you Mr. Speaker.



Mr. Speaker: Dr. Azra Fazal Pechuho.

Dr. Azra Fazal Pechuho: Sir, Cut Motion No. 147.

Sir, I beg to move that the demand under the head

Narcotics Control Division( Page No. 1324) be reduced

to Rs.100/- (To discuss the failure of government to

control widespread use of illegal drugs in the country).


51

Mr. Mohammad Baligh-ur-Rehman: I oppose it.

Mr. Speaker: Mr. Mohammad Rehan Hashmi.

Mr. Mohammad Rehan Hashmi: Cut Motion No. 143.

Sir, I beg to move that the demand under the head

Narcotics Control Division ( Page No. 1323) be reduced

to Rs.100/-( To discuss the failure of Government to

improve performance of Anti Narcotics Force in view of

making Pakistan a drug free State).

Mr. Speaker: Minister concerned do you oppose it?.


Mr. Speaker: The remaining Cut Motions are

clubbed together and treated as moved.


No. 124.

52


a sum not exceeding Rs.3,855,190,000 be granted to

the Federal Government to meet expenditure during the

year ending 30th June, 2015 in respect of

DEVELOPMENT EXPENDITURE OF INTERIOR

DIVISION (Demand No.124).

Mr. Speaker: There are five Cut Motion in Demand

No.124. Rai Hasan Nawaz Khan.

Rai Hasan Nawaz Khan: Cut Motion No.149. Sir, I

beg to move that the demand under the head

Development Expenditure of Interior Division (page

No.2269) be reduced to Rs. 100/-(To Discuss the failure

of Government to provide health facilities to the people

of rural areas within the jurisdiction of the Ministry of

Interior due to lack of coordination.

53

Mr. Speaker: Minister concern do you oppose it?


Mr. Speaker: Ms. Shazia Mari.

Ms Shazia Mari: Cut Motion No.150. Sir, I beg to

move that the demand under the head Development

Expenditure of Interior Division ( page No.2469) be

reduced to Rs.100/-( To discuss the failure of

Government to provide security to people and at

sensitive locations like Karachi International Airport and

F-8 session court in Islamabad.

Mr. Speaker: Minister concern do you oppose it?.


Mr. Speaker: The remaining Cut Motions are

clubbed together and treated as moved.

54


No.125.


a sum not exceeding Rs.324,300,000 be granted to the

Federal Government to meet expenditure during the year

ending 30th June, 2015 in respect of DEVELOPMENT

EXPENDITURE OF NARCOTICS CONTROL DIVISION

(Demand No.125).

Mr. Speaker: There is only one Cut Motion in

Demand No. 125.. Sheikh Rashid Ahmed.

Sheikh Rashid Ahmed: Cut Motion No.153. Sir, I beg to

move that the demand under the head “Development

Expenditure of Narcotics Division” (page No.2433) be

reduced to Rs.100/- (To discuss the failure of

55

Government to rehabilitate people addicted to different

narcotics substances). Thank you



6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: )P]�h kindly +,-. mR )U O]g=?R B1( M=Na request b19* ,Ò IS I= . 8�6 g6? 8�=O6N=.8R M=N>

- ? )FGE let us focus on Interior itself and short to the point. And I am sure T67 fd² ¥k ;�¦6? q³X A( 9= :B,½;C

oU ¹5WG M=NÀ

; ?E I;KÆÄ3_ o

- ¹,J6 A I6 K7,pE

Iª2; nth I;KÆÄ3_ o

- ¹,J6 A : I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! Ministry of Interior b,>6A

;. (2= nª ©,= K-7 )FG IS Ministry of Interior ;�j5{Y B1( ^va o* = .(

×89= :B o* ¡ 8�W c o* ;�=O3N=K7 q; �P·B )FGE -M{= KV `( ;<º1 mB,JWr ^va )* 56 7 ;sD,Y M=NWc B1( 56 7 law and order o* situation @Wr face 9* M=NWc)FG B ,-K=N½= C I= . = .( o

U ¹5* = .( ,= . 1R -bR o* ;s,6 . M= N>- ? )FGE -M{= KV ¶X g· ¡B,JWr q; �¢/ o* I6 Y1

)/ q W c(,-. o* I6 Y1 )/à Û®-w q�= NÂ,X . o* I6 Y1 )/ I= . ^va q³6 ?( q³6 ? ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ )* ;�¦6? q Wr B1 -B b1B53Ê1 IX . )FGE `( law and order )* 6s(9

-7 ;sB5¿ ©,Y o* I6 Y1 )/ `( ;<º1 -b,;K¢*,X . o* 56 7 index table )FG `( M=Na (B,JWr

rank 105 9X : )FG B1( I= . out of 183 ^Â,Jh 56 7 M=NWc -b( M=Na (B,JWr I= . rank 105 IX . ( ,W cB )FGE Law and order situation o* I6 Y1 )/ 56 7

investment 2W c,6 . )* ^Â,Jh )* )/ M=NJWr q- �®a )U OFG ,XY q³

; ? 56 7 -b,;K¢*,X . l7,k

56

,;K-N6. )FG L1 investment âB qU �´ )FG B1( L1 M=N>

- ? ( q WrB )FGE = .( estimate )* l6C,Þj 40 per cent business 56 7 )FG L1 qXA(9* o*

56 7 activity )FG L1law and order o* I6 Y1 )/ @; �-7 5WG qQXY )FGE 6s,-K67

D(1 ,k -édi ,;K-N6. )FG IS L1 b,>6A IX . majority 5* protect m9* b,Wc1 IX . minorities ,k q³6 ? ©,= K

-7 ,À·B )U C ,6YE -M{= KV mB,JWr ^va M=Na minorities ,k

,-K;:( (896 : 53 ¢= C( 5WG ,;.,6Y )FGE q³6 �* L1 kidnap 5WG ); C ,6Y M=NWc q³6 �* L1 mB,a

); C ,6Y M=NWc q³6 �* -b( )* B�-Kj )

U C x6Y ); C ,6Y M=NWc q³6 �* -b( )* ,6Y9´ dPê )

U C x6Y ); C ,6Y M=NWc q³6 �* -b( IX . b,W c1 IX . blast ,;.5WG )FG b,>6A b1B(-2W c 5; C M=N>

- ? b19* b5¦· o´ -M{= KV ;�¦6? q§ R(�°;C M=Na innocent ¡2î3§ mB,a )

; C ,6Y M=NWcE ,-K=N½= C Xs ( )* @

U ?(9X : 28 n[-Na )

- C q³6 ? ¥k b5Ê9X : b,>=? m8dP· 5WG )* 8�- Oy8 �=N8K/ ¡R IS

`( ^va )* T8CB5*à -9V5{_à -B8R1Bà T

8N=K*B,aà b,>=? ;. IS 56 7 Xs ( o* ;sR,6 K} M=NWc,Ò M=NWc )FG ,XY L1 M=NWc�6Y,[j )FG ,XY L1 )/ B�a b5WG )FG ,XY L1 I6 Y9´ dPê b5WG )FG ,XY L1 B�-Kj 5WGà L1 q³6 ? Xs ( )* Øä5Ægh M=N>

- ? M=NWcEB1( I= . `5¢µ( )/ )P]�h ,-K¦· 89X : ,W cB )FG IS b,>=? ;. Xs ( )* T

8CB5X C9U:( q³6 ? Øä5Ægh M=N>- ? EM=NWc `( ^va M=Na

,= K*Interior Ministry )- C b5ÊB�a )* reforms )

U C (19* M=NWcà ,= K* ;<º5Ê( )- O;N]Y q³6 ? `B(�a `( ^va M=Na R56 75j M=NWc ,= K* L1 registered M=NWcE M=Na

q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS oU ¹5* q³6 ? I_B�a mB5X C ©5= OV ;. 8R28 n[6 7B M=N>

- ? )FGE -b(,= K* o* 56 7 activity o

; ¹5WG )FG 56 7 -b( ,k T6 N=K®_ b,W c1 9X : ,= . ( )FG ,= K* `( IX . Ministry of Interior ,k check and balance )FGE L1

foreigners 56 7 illegally `( ^va M=Na ); OFG B M=NWcà oU ¹5* 8RB,»= CB )FGE Xs ( 9´(

q�* ^va M=Na ); C ,6Y M=NWcà 9´( Xs ( q§189X : ^va ,= .

8�-.( o* ;s,6 . 9* M=NÂE 9´( Xs ( b,W c1 )

; C ,6Y M=NWc 5; C Xs ( 5* -M=N;. 2î3§ tick )

- C 9* ); C 89X : M=NWc IS q�* q³6 ? -M=N

;.

57

b12î3§ M=Na Xs ( M=NU.,6YE -M{= KV `( ^va M=Na `( ;<º1 ,a96 : )V (1 q³6 ? LB )FG B

M=NWcà -MX g=�X7 q³6 ? LB M=NWc)FG Bà oV,Ç-O6: q³6 ? LB )FG B M=NWcà -b,-°µ( q³6 ? LB )FG B M=NWcE -M{= KV m896 : `5¢µ( )P]�h)/ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! I= . ,-K¦· ,;.89X : )FG IS -b( ,k U¡5* q³6 ? 8RB,»= CB

mB,JWr `,X . Øä5Ægh M=N>- ? )FGE mB,JWr `,X . ,= .

8�= Kj )* 56 7 -2- n_9X : M=NWcà 56 7 8�¢®-.96 7 M=NWc 56 7 `( ^va o* ;�j� -Y )

; C 9* M=NWcà -M6 7 )* )U OV ,>· ,;.,6Y )FG IS I= . q³6 ? = .( -b5; N_ M=NWcà -b( )*persons 5* ¡RBR)]C )/ (B,a ,6Y ,W cB )FGEb,>=?)P]�h

`5¢µ( )/ ,-K¦· 89X : ,W cB )FG IS `( ;<º1 `( ;�j5{Y M=Na I- . 5; C -bB,¼ 28 n[

-Na M=NWc B1( I- . q Wr Interior Minister M=NWcE Interior Minister ,-K;:( crucial

times ¥XY ,W cB )FG `( ;�j5{Y IX .à 5®XY 9= :R ,= . ( ;�/BR à,= . ( 6�67 @Wr q§,= K/ b5; O},J6 A )

- C Xs ( 5* = .( mandate ,= .R ;�3¢WGR b1R9´ )/ ;s,6 . )- C 9* )*

)U OVà @Wr )- C q³6 ? dialogue o* q�= NÂ,X . B,= K

; : o* q³; ?E @Wr )

- C Xs ( 5* ¡di 8�-K=NWc ,= .R IS Xs ( free hand o* q�= NÂ,X . B,= K

;N -Y( 19*E L1 dialogue o* q�= NÂ,X . sabotage 5WG qU �´E`( -b(5= C( 5* M=N>

- ? R,J;�}( M=Na ,= KV ,= K´E political parties 5* M=N>

- ? R,J;�}( M=Na ,= KV ,= K´ -M{= KV 6�67 @U ?(9X : 28 n[

-Na b,>=?)- C (

2X n=KX:)* ,É89X : B1( ,>· IS @Wr `( ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ �x-Y)* `( ;<º1 q- �X:( â,X .

6f(5µ( ¶; ?,_)* M=NWcm8dP· B1( -M3 ¢= C9X : ( ,k 6�67 B8RB ( ,= . ( 5; C @Wr )

- C ,-Kj( ,-K±�p 9* Xs ()* 5* = K6NÂ ,>· IS q6A M=N>

- ? `( ^va o* ;�=Oyz,_ -9= :-dÔ E)FG

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: = KP8 ? E)FG

Iª2; nth I;KÆÄ

3_ o- ¹,J6 A: b5= O* IS `( ;<º1 mB,JWr ^va o* ;�=Oyz,_ md�-7

M=NWcE

58

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: ¥»V,6 . = KP8 ?E Thank you q6A = K

U:,a M=NÂ5P·à 8�-KU :(1 Xs( )U O]g=�V9*E Iª2; nth I;KÆÄ

3_ o- ¹,J6 A: 6s,-K67 D(1! M=Na �2Í = .( ;s,6 . b19*E mB5X C ^va

5* 8B5PX A )* �2Í +x_( R,6 . ( o* ;s,6 . b19* o´ IS +x_( R,6 . ( 2= nU.2= n8K-:( 28 n[

-Na o* â,-. )¯�=�

-:)* )FGE +x_( R,6 . ( o* = .( �6 t�j )/ = .( ¡5V5j 6�7,p o8 ¹ ¡1

IX . T=C9X : T-CdÌ-C,k 9* )* M=NWc); O¦· IS `( ;<º1 +x_( R,6 . ( M=Na X¾

-?,X . 5Ê M=N;.B5}

R5-7 3T* B,= K; : 5WG qQXY M=NWcE ¶6 gË§ M=Na M=N>

- ? ,;. ( IS 2= nU.2= n8K-:( 28 n[

-Na ¡ b,>· )FG IS = .( ¡B,k24 2ï=N¼ ( o

8 ¹ ¡1 ¥-K=N XY IX . ¶8 �=N6. )* I= . T=C9X : T

-CdÌ-C,k ,;.9* )FGE

,= K* `( 5* l7 )FGà ,= K* `( 5* = KX7 ,= K* ,= K´à,= K* `( )/ ¶X 75X C ¶X gê oU ¹5WG ë

T67 ^va M=Na T=N

;K-N=K; : b,= K¢

-N6t=?( +,k 9* q WrB b5WG -M{= KV `( ,k L(96 :24 9=: -B1 Iv -Y(R (5WG -M{= KV 9=: -B1 Iv -Y(R I- . ( ` -b(5= C( M=Na R56 75j M=NWc B1( I- . q Wr M=N>· L1 M=NJWr d Ø�

-C ,W cB ( )FG 5; C dPX ? `( ^va B1( `( +5± ,k '( qWr ØÛµ,Y E)FG I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: -¾ =�

3/ �= K3/B �JA( 6�7,p )

- C request o* E)FG b5¦- ?( )- C ,-.,6Y )FG 5; C M=NWc); O¦· IS = .( 8�- Oj M=Na ;s,6 . 9* )* dPX ? ¥»

-C bU1,6Y ,ÒEL1 8�=OV 5WG M=NWc)FG BE

-¾ =�3/ �= K

3/B �JA( : 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! )¢¬C 1 Xs ( = KP8 ? q Wr I>· M=NWc)FG BE 9´( M=Na

= .( 8�- Oj b19* ,= . = .( I8 K-NÀê b19* ,= . )- O: ( o

U ¹,À6 ? �= K3/B5-7 L, 3_ 6�7,p o* fd²

)Ú 8B,_ -M=N;. )8 O

-NÀê b19*à Zdi 5; C ¶X g· M=N>- ? ,-.89X : E)FG

59

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: (5Ê -M=N;. )8 O

-NÀêE

-¾ =�3/ �= K

3/B �JA( : )P]�h b,J§ R,= . )FGà ¡9®= K´ I= . M=N>- ? q³

; ?E 6�67 B,½ÆV(1-R q¨w 58 OP6 ? 6�7,p )

- C ,>· IS +x_( R,6 . ( M=Na b1B(-2W c M=NvçUC(B q¨»

-C M=NWcE 6f ( b,>=? ,-.D5j ¥

-Õµ -b,JA9V( 6�7,p M=N>- ? M=NWcà -b( q�*)* ¸B-96 : )

- C ,ÀX A5X C IS 6s,-K67 Xs ( b,>· )P

; ?à Xs ( o* ¡28 n[-Na b,>· q³

; ? 6�67 q- �;:( B(-2W c Z(dÔ q�= N6Ky=?( M=Na )/

M=Nv»-CE 5Ê 56 7 `( ^va M=Na ;sxa,°j M=NWcà 3 ,k 6f ( 2= nU.2= n8K

-:( 28 n[-Na b,>=?

); C 5WGE q

- å= O®6 K; : ;�},J6 A b5V(1 )/ 5; C )P]�h )¢¬C 1 q Wr ¡896 : ;�6 Ogh E)FG I= . 8�=O8N_

28 n[-Na M=NWc)FG BE Xs ( 8�- Oj)

- C q Wr �-KX7 )- O¬: R M=NWcE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! `( ^va M=Na )- O

;N]Y q-ßdh âx6 . )U C ,-K6: )U O´à q

- �;N 6Y q-ßdh joint investigation o

U ¹,-K6: qU �´ M=NWcà 6f ( ;. oU ¹5* 6s,= Kj,k M=N>

- ? M=NU.5WGEM=Na

= .( ); OÆFG o* ;s,6 . 9´(Eb5WG,;.9* Xs ( 5* -b( B8RB ( ,adi M=:R E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: q6A U1,W c -b( B8RB ( q Wr )FGE -¾ =�3/ �= K

3/B �JA( : `( ); OÆFG 6f ( )* -bREEE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: �2Í ,-.(B 6�7,p ©56 C M=NWc)FG BE

-¾ =�3/ �= K

3/B �JA( : ,-.(B 6�7,p o* 2= n-¤ )FGE ,-.(B 6�7,p 5* 9U:,¼ 8�=KÄ= .96 : o*

fd² -b( 5* B,XY X¾-?,X . �,°j M=NWcE

60

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: ,-.(B 6�7,p -¾ =�

3/ �= K3/B 6�7,p )

- C Xs ( 9X :1()* comment ,= K* )FGE -b( 5* I;KX: q Wr M=N>

- ?E

-¾ =�3/ �= K

3/B �JA( : 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! ¥k = .( 26 n-¤ ¡R qU �´ ’ M=Na )

- C q³X A( 26 n-¤ q Wr ¡R )FGE Xs ( o* attention b5WG,;K WG,XYE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: ,-.(B 6�7,p L1 qi,k 9= :R )/ Xs ( o* attention )- O¬NÂ o* 3T

3Ê5* EM=NWc)FG B9*

-¾ =�3/ �= K

3/B �JA( : 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! ¥k LB,= K´ ,= . ¶8 ? ( R(di( ¥;K±)* M=Na = .( ¡BR,½V(2W c,È 6�7,p )* )8 O¬N]. 5* B1( -M=N

;. B(-2W c b5´5V �x-Y)* Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( B ( 6fBR

o* qU �´à 6f ( L1 Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( B ( TXC(1 qU �´5WGE ¥k b,>=? o* = .( 26 nJh IX . IvJA (5WGà

`( ^va M=Na 6�=O6gÔ ;s,6 . 56 7E)FG )®>? oU ¹(�;K6:( T=NÂ5X C 8sB5X CB 56 7 E)FG 6s,-K67

9{= KXN_ ! M=Na `( -b(5= C( M=Na ,-K¦· b5WG,;K WG,XY IS I= . police competent qWr M=N>- ? )FG determine, committed, emotional ;�3¢WGR b1R9´ ¶; ?,_)*

)- O8NJ-? )* )U OVEB -�°j ;s ¶; ?,_)* ’`( ^va M=Na Xs ( narcotics o* ;s,6 . 9*

M=NWc)FG Bà `( ^va M=Na Xs ( oU ¹ ( ¡8R 8RB,k ’ 56 7 T

-N[UCD ,k It¨_( = .(à)FG ©,_

,= K´5WG )FGà 6s( ¡B�W c5X 7 B,3K-: 6�7,p b,>=? ); C 5WG 5; C M=Na -édÔ ,;.9*E )P]�h q³X A(

fd² R,= . )FG IS ¡B�W c5X 7 B,3K-: 6�7,p +57dh)* �Â(1 ,>· ); C 9* )P

; ? IS -¾ =�3/ �= K

3/B ¶6 gh )/ = .( qÙ®

-w qU �´5WG IS T67 )8 O¬N]. 5* M=Na )- C 6f5µ M=Na ,-K6g=�P6 ? ,À; ?à`( 5*

61

M=Na )- C ;�/,= K/ M=Na 6¾ =�P6

? ,= .R B1( T67 5* ;�/,= K/ M=Na ,-K6g=�P6 ? ,À; ? `( 5* 6f5µ M=Na 6¾ =�P6

? ,= .RE 8�- O-N=K8Nç= OV ©2- n6¤ B,-t;�µ( 5* '( ;�- O67 6�=OÜ

- C m9*E

6s( IvUK¢j ,= K* )FG IS @Wr )- C = .( = .( ©,_ )* T

-N[UCD

M=NWc)U C 5WG)

U C RE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! qí=? IvÕ=Oµ M=N>- ? 5WG ,W cB )FG IS mB,JWr license

legal M=NWc ,= . illegal M=NWcE -M6 7 )* illegal EM=NWc 6s,-K67 T67 `,X .)* -M´ )FG L1 5; C L(19X : M=N>

- ? 9* ,W cBE m2= nª ¶; ?,_ M=NU. ( E T67 @�± ,k It¨_( )¬OFG ,XY

5WGE -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na 6�/ )/ q; �¢/ -2= nX¤ State Minister for Interior is that arms M=NWcE I= . LBR 2= n6K

-7 -M6 : E)FG ,»X 7 6s(2î§ ¶8 ?5´ -M6 : M=NWc){¯Y B1( ¡2î3§ )Î®Y ’ o

U ¹5* dPê ,[= C( M=N>- ? )FG IS T67 `,X .)* It¨_( M=N>

- ? )FG ( B1 @Wr )]C �5±1 M=NWc 56 7 Xs ( 5* 1B q³

8 �X7 -B M=NWc); OPQÂ IS IvÕ=Oµ M=:9* IS mB,JWr license legal ,= . illegal M=NWcE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! 6�67 \-. 8�v6 . q; �®6Y )FG q�* 2î3§ M=Na ’ ¶6 gË§ M=NÂ IS @Wr( mB(R( ,k xX KPê (B,_ ¥6Y ,= K´ E)FG 6�67 \-. 8�v6 . M=Na ¸ ( qÐÂE q§( fd² B5WGD M=Na

¸ ( )ÄÂà q§( fd² qXA(9* M=Na ¸ ( )ÄÂE Obviously, Xs ( I= . ¶6 gË§ M=NÂ IS ;�¦6? 896 :m 8RB,»= CB ,k ,= K

;N_ `,-. 5WG ,= K´ E)FG 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! 8sB5X N_,X . IX . M=NU. (E)- O; : (

q¨°6 7 8sB5X N_,X . M=NWc IS ,= K-:R o* b5®= K67 M=Na ’ M=Na Overseas Minister

à,À; ? M=Na )- C = .( ^va 5* = KX7 ,= K*à( ` M=Na T=N

U.,6 . 5Ê ¸5V o- ¹,-°µ( ’ -b,;K¢*,X .

)* 8sB5X N_,X . IX . ¥=K67 M=Na )P; ?Eo

U ¹5* ,[= C( T=N_19X : ’ `R )�Ì¿ ,ÇV )* ’ 2; n>6? IS)FG 6s( 5Ê )¬O* M=NWcEo

U ¹ ( ¡8R 8RB,k T67 m�-K6: )- C q¨°6 7 ,-K=NÂ 5WGà M=Na Xs ( 5*

-M=N½= C )/ I>· b5WG,;K{_ IS q¨°6 7 B1( q¨p( M=Na -B1 ;sB( Iv -Y(R Zdi M=N>- ? 89{X . q; �{_

62

B1( I- . I= . )- O;: (competent ¸5V M=NWc B1( I= . L�-K6: (89{X . ,;.,6Y )FGE ,= K* Xs ( )- C

b,= K8 :B5= O{= K/ o

U ¹,ÇV oU ¹5WG M=NWcE L1 mB,XY)]C -b5µ o* 8

- ? (89X : (5WGE -b( )]C b1B,XY )* `,X . ¡28 n=K6: M=N>- ? )FG B1( LB,À8 ?(

LB,À8 ?( )8 O-NÀê o

8 ¹5= C8R mR )FG B M=NWcà Levies `,X .)* oU ¹5* ¥ç

UC(B q Wr M=N>- ?

à)FG 5- C ,= . ¶8 ? ( B(-2W c m�-K6: M=NWcE ¥k M=Na )

- C = .( )8 C ,¼ )V (1 o

U ¹,À6 ? 5* ,>· IS B,= . L1 Levies )* ,= K* ;sD,Y M=NWcà`( ,>·)

- C ,>· 9´ 9000 Levies )FG T=N

;K-N=KX: `,X .)* M=Nvç

UC(B M=NWc qº,6 . X¾-?,X . B(-2W c )¢¬C 1 q Wr ’ I= .

o8 ¹5Ê ,k I- .,a -B )FGE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! = .( ;<º1 ,À; ? IS ,-pB b1B,k )/ ¸5V ); C B8R )P

; ? B1( 6f ( T=C( oX¹ mB-9´ 5; C ¸5V L(19X : M=N>

- ? ); C 9* IS T=C( oX¹ )FG ,= . ¡8R o

U ¹ ( q6A )FG ,= . ,= K* E)FGTotal situation change 5WG qU �´ )FGE 6s,-K67 q³6 ?( I;KÆÄ

3_ o6¹ o6¹ )- C ;�¦6? q³X A( ;s,6 . o* IS -b( I;KX:5* q Wr M=N>

- ? IS -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na -b5* ,W cB ( E)FG M=Na q§( )- O¬N>h o* ¡B,_ b126 n

-¤ 9X : ;s,6 . b19* ,ÒE 6�67 L1 @; �-7 5WG M=N

UK´ M=Na @; � -7

9* b1R ,ÒE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: )P]�h �2Í Xs ( o* 8<U :x¼ o* 9{¼ )FGà Xs ( 8�=OV I- . 5WG M=NU.,6YE

-¾ =�3/ �= K

3/B �JA( : I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! +x_( R,6 . ( M=Na (�°;CD R

M=N;.B5} ¡89{X . M=N

UK´E9´( )]C 5¿ M=Na ¡89{X . M=N;.,6Y 5; C M=Na discuss I- . ,;.9* IS

oU ¹,6 .5¿ IvUK¢j ,= K´5WG B1()FG -b( b5; CB5} )/ ,ÀX A5X C IS Xs ( ,k passport, entry,

63

exit b5¦- ?( )- C ,>· IS o

U ¹5* M=N>- ?àB1( -b( `,X .)* )/ 56 7 -b5µ 8�¢V q¨»

-C )FGà L1 q

- �;:( â,-Kµ5-7 )FG IS L1 q Wr,6 K

; : 2= nÀX ? mRE M=N>- ? M=Na q�= C( ;s,6 . M=N>

- ? 9* ,;K{_E 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! `( ^va M=Na narcotics )* mB,6 . M=Na I= . ,>· IS)FG ,W cB,6Y

-b,;K¢*,X . ;�¦6? ¡896 : ¡ 8�-Kj E)FG ¡2= nª different opinion )FG IS -b,;K¢*,X . ,= K-:R )* consumer M=Na ;�¦6? )´ ( xXY ,= K´ M=NaE)FG `( 9X : believe M=N>

- ? ,;.9* I= . @Wr q

- �;:( narcotics export 9* M=NWc)FG BEoU ¹5* shipment ,= .

oU ¹xX K/ 5WGà -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na )- O;: ( ¡B8RU1,X . (�= KX: 5WG ){¯Y M=NWc IS -b( )U OV )* )P]�h ¡ 8�-KXNÂ1(B M=Na = .( ¥8.5WG ,-.,-K6: (89X : I- .B1 L1 q

- �;:( genius M=N;.,6 . M=NWc)

; C 9*à ©D q =.57 )´ ()* B1( B8R ,;KÄÂ )FG IS ,= K

-: ,8K* I- . ¥À· B1()U C ,6Y T=NÂ5X C )V (1 q³6 ? )

; C B8R M=NWc B1( ¶; ?,W c 8B56 7 M=NWc)

; C ,6Y5WGm8dP·)*EoU ¹5* ¡B8RU1,X . )

- C ,À; ? M=Na ,;.,6Y )FG 5; C T=C( X¾ =?( 1( `( 5* `( o* q-ßdh ,k ,-.,À· ,;.xÀ· E)FG )

- C ,À; ? B�-.()* `( 5* B8RU1,X . ,= K¦h ,= K* ,;.,6Y )FGE9´( B8RU1,X . I- . 5WG @=�µ( o* oV5´ mR ,;K=:R )FGE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! b5; OV(�w o* ;sB5¿ ©,Y ’ `( ^va M=Na T=NÂ,;K*( @Wr( T=NS )U C 5WGàT=NÂ,;K*( M=Na )/ T=N

;K-N=K; : +-9®a 96 :¡ 5WG ){¯Y M=NWcE`( M=Na )¢¬C ( +-9®a M=NWc

8<=:2= nª IX . IvJA )- C 9* )V (1 q³6 ?E Xs ( ¥=K67 M=Na M=N

U.,6Yà (� -Y I- . m9*à visit IX . M=NU.,6Yà Xs ( ;�j5{Y M=Na àM=NWc M=Na I= . M=N>

- ? ,;K¦· IS q�* T=NS M=Na M=NU.,6YE,-K;N 6Y ,ÀX A(

,-.,À· I= . +-9®a ,À· M=NWc)FG BEB,8K/5= OU :,¼ )* b5®8.5WG )/ 56 7 ;�3¢WGR b19´ ,k ,-.,À· (

,W cB )FG `( ,k 5; C +,w qhR ( B5Ü

; C q Wr M=N>- ? ,;.9*E qhR ( ,;K¦· )FG IS `( )/ 2; n>6?

)FG IS M=Na ¥=K67 xXY bU1,6YE @U ?,8 . 9X : )

U C ,XY q; �®a )FGE q6 t6? q³6 ? M=N>- ? o

; ¹,6Y -b( 5* ,;KX: )FG IS q6 t6? q6�=�P6

? 5; C ;sD,Y â,-.d�-7 b5WG )´E 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ `( ^va M=Na o

U ¹5* qhR ( ;sR,>3§ M=N>

- ? mR ,W cB �5-7 ,k @z,w I= . )FGE

64

) ;�® -Y(�a(

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: -B,= .( 6�7,p Xs ( -M=N;. -bR )* �°6 C )

U C ( M=NWc B1( disturb 9* )FG B M=NWcE q6A ;s,6 . )¬O]g=�*E o

- ¹,6 .2îh 9* )* 8�-KU :(1 Xs( )¬O]g=�*E -¾ =�3/ �= K

3/B �JA(: OK sir 6�67 Xs ( qÎ= OÖ7 8�WG(9{[j ,k ¡2= nª �d² B,> Øè( M=:9* )´ M=Na ¶8 �=N6. M=N

U.,6Y )´E I= . -M¢7 T67 \-.B M=Na q³6 ? 5WG b,>6A q³6 ? 5WGE L1 ¥Wc( ©R )* )¬OV I= .,a24 ;s,= K7 ,;.5WG )FGE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ M=Na ;s,6 . 9* ,W cB ,À; ? B1( -édÔ 9* ,W cB ,À; ? IS I= . 8�®6 . �19X : b,= .

8B,Ò B1( ¥k q³6 ? M=Na )

- C ©,3Kj Xs ( 5* ¡8B5P; ? q§ ¡R )FG b5¦- �67 )- C +,w 6<=:d-Ô

qhR ( o* 8�®6 . �19X : b,= .8B,Ò o

U ¹,-K6: M=NWc -b( 5* B�-.( mR ,= .R )FGE -M3 ¢X C9* -b(

o* ¡28 n[-Na )* B�-.( )FG -b( ,k 2ïµ( )FGE 9´( `R LB�-KX: ¶*D )¯C 1B o* ¥k5V 5WG q WrB )FG M=NÀQ= .R I°= N 3_ 5* B,a )FG B b5WG M=NÀQ= .R 2W c `( qhR ( 5* 8<´B,8 . 9®k

)- C B,a )* )¬OV B,= K

; : M=NWc T67 o* \-K{= .96 : -B5= O-: q; �

-N6. 5WGE T67 o* \-K{= .96 : -B5= O-:

M=N>- ? q; �

-N6. 5; C `( M=Na L1 oV5´ o* ;�y=�± q Wr æU C,-p M=N>

- ? ,-.9* ); OFG ,XYE L1 ); O¦· M=NWc I= . ©5-Üµ +,k )FGE q; �Æj R5y�h )

- C `( -b(5= C( M=Na 58 OP6 ? 6�7,p 5* ,>· IS B1( 58 OP6 ? 6�7,p )

- C ,>· IS M=NÀQ= .R ,= .8�= Kj M=Na q

- �;NS 6¾ =?B5* q; �®a )FG q; �Æj R5y�h 6�7,pE q; �Æj R5y�h 6�7,p )

- C ,>· b,W c `( )* )¬OV ,-.dh ä23 4 )FGE Xs ( ;<=:-då;C M=:9* )´ Xs ( `5¢µ( ,k B,> Øè( M=:9* )´E 9´( 8<=:5= OU :(9X : -M

3 ¢{= K/ M=Na -M6 7 )* `,X . (896 : I= .,a24 M=N>

- ? )FG 9´( locally 8�®6 . �19X : ¡8B,Ò (5- O6: ); O¬NÂ M= NWc 5; C Xs ( 5*

65

,= K* Ñ= O®»;C )FGE Xs ( 5* ,= K* @6 .(9X : )FGE ¸5V b,W c1 )/ 8�-K{= K/ 8�-K=NWc ( hIÁ=.d )/ 9ÚR( 9ÚR( )/ D )FG B M=NWcE Xs ( q�* 5* T

-N[UCD )- O¬: R )* )¬OV )- O;: ( m9-g

-? ); C 9*

M=NWcE o´R9*B,k Xs ( o* ,= K* )FG ë 56 7 T=NS (5WG )FG 6s,-K67 +x_( R,6 . ( ,k M=Na mB5X C ^va o* ;s,6 . M=N>

- ? ,;.9*E )- O;: ( ¸5V dh ); C ,6Y M=NWc �°6 C M=Na ); O¦· M=NWc

q�-N6t=?( )V (1 IS @Wr )

- C Xs ( 5* )®>? q Wr 0xÈ( mR ¡R q³; ?E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ I= . coast guards B1( \-K®Çy§ o* ;s,6 . )

; C 9* M=NWcE `( ^va M=Na T

-C,-Kµ 28 n[-Na b,>=? R56 75j M=N>

- ? )FG (2= nª I= . -M=N½= C )FG IS -M=Nv6 . 9V(8R o* \-K®Çy§ o

; ¹5WG )FG M=Na -M=Nva M=N>- ? I>· ,W cB b5WGE @Wr b5

- C(�;K/,= K/ 5* ( 9* +,-.�6 . 9* ); O¬: R M=NWcE b,>=? m1 ( ,k (1 ( q Wr (89Ä6 . (5WG )FGE 2W c (896 : qhR ( under

invoice ,;.(5Ä-Kj )FGE 2W c (896 : qhR ( )¢¬C ( ); N_ (B 3 x;. ,;.9* )FG T67 )/ @8 �¢*

)/ ^a ,»j 5WGE Coast guards M=Na 56 7 qhR ( ,ÇV (5WG )FG `R )/ LB�-KX: ©,_ )/ coast guards M=Na ,ÇV (5WG )FG o

U ¹5* `( 5* )- C ,8K WG D(1 qWr M=N>

- ? )FGE M=Na )

- C ;�j5{Y )/ ¥=KX:( o* )FG oU ¹5* L�-K6: q Wr b5= O* I- . 5WG coast

guards M=Na `( o* -M=N;. ©,_ )/ LR,= .

-B b,W c1 `124 M=N>- ? o

- ¹5WG )¬OFG ,XY ^3[= N6. L1 q�* m896 : qhR ( ,k q Wr ,8K=N6. b5= O* I- . E5WG T67 qhR ( )* -M= N

;. )- O¬N>h coast guards M=Na \Â )U O´ M=NWc L1 5; C )

- C 5Ê o* -b,k 9X : \Â )U O´ M=NWcE 6�/ 5* ,;KX: )FG IS coast guards o* -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na ©,t

;?B5¿ ,= K* )FGE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! `( ^va M=Na ¥U. ( 9X : m2= nª o

U ¹,À6 ? `( -bR I>· )FG B )P; ? = .( -bR M=Na

b1 8B19* )¯C 1B o* M=Na b5P·D M=N>- ? I>· ,W cB b1 8B19* )¯C 1B ,k )FG xX KPê ¥U. ( M=NaE

`( ^va M=Na b1 8B19* )¯C 1B )* ;sxa,°j M=NWc under invoicing )*E `(

66

^va M=Na b,>· )U O´ q6A Xs ( )- C scanners )

U C ,ÇV )P; ?E )- O;: ( m896 : 56 7 ¡96 g6?

)* â98 : ); C ( M=NWcE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: -¾ =�

3/ 6�7,p o- ¹,6 .2îh 9* )* Xs( 8�-KU :(1 )¬O]g=�*E

Shaikh Rashid Ahmed: Thank you very much Sir.

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: L-2- nª -M¢7 I6 K7,pE

Iª2; nth L-2- nª -M¢7 : I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E 6s,-K67 M=Na9{= KXN_ q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS `( ;<º1 2W c o

- ¹,;K¢*,X . )- O¯: ( Xs ( 5* 2= n-ð Øä5Ægh ¶6 gË§ ,W cB )FGE )FG ,XY L1 qXA(9* M=Na 5WG

)FG ,XY L1 B5WGD M=Na 5WG )FG ,XY L1 M=NaB1, 3[X C )FG I8 KU:5*,= . M=Na ,= . -b,;K¢*,X . )* q�* q³6 ? M=Na)Ü7 5WG L1 )- O¯: ( Xs ( 5* Øä5Ægh2= n

-ð ¶6 gË§ ,W cB E)FG M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(R o* Iª-R b,= .B(R B1( -Å

UC(di `( )V (57 )/ `( +5± -MyÙj5* M=N>- ? 9* q WrB

M=NWcE I= . +5± ¶{= .R q WrB )FG IS I= . ¡28 n[-Na 56 7 )FG L1 = .( ¥=Kµ o

; ¹5WG oU ¹5WG

¡28 n[-Na d Ø�

-C ( q WrB )FGE M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS `( ¡28 n[-Na )* B�-.( 56 7 -2= n[

-N6t=?( 56 7 T8N-Ky8 ?B,X K=:

8R ( )FG B M=NWc 56 7 I= KV,Y @Wr )- C ;s,°±(1 )PQ¬.R M=NWc `( M=Na -b( )*

-b,=KjBR coordination q³6 ? M=N>- ? d Ø�

-C ( q WrBE q =K8N-.( T

-N6Y o* 5WG )FG ,XY T=NÂ5X C 5WG m241R)FG ,XY mB(R( b5WG 56 7 `( ¡28 n[

-Na )* )¯�=�-: ( )FG B M=NWc -b( )* B�-.(

coordination nil )FG )FG ,XY L1 qXA(9* 8sB5X C2U n=.( ,k Iva,°j 5WGE qXA(9* 8sB5X C2U n=.( ,k Iva,°j I= . ,À

; ? IS oU ¹5* q³6 ? IJQth responsibility )- O¬NÂ )* )¬OV

B,= K; : M=N>

- ? E,À; ? `( o* o8 ¹B5= O{= K/ ,k Iva,°j �°6 C M=Na T=NÂ5X C b,W c1 o

U ¹ ( B1( dPX ? `( )*

67

�°6 C @Wr )- C b,W c1 -B96 g

-�=:B 5* ); C ( (5WG ,ÀQ= .RE -M{= KV responsibility T*

o* q³; ? I= . b5´5V 5* M=N>

- ?,;KX: ¥XY ,W cB IS T* o* responsibility )FGE M=Na q; �P6 �Ë

§ b5WG 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ I= . 56 7 )

U C 5WG); OÚ 896 : o8 ¹B5{= K/ lapses M=NWc I= .

`( ¡28 n[-Na o* o´R9*B,k d Ø�

-C ( q WrB )FGE ¡B,_ +5± `( I6 Y1 )/ ¶6 gË§ q WrB )FG B1( L1 )- O¯: ( Xs ( 5* 2= n

-ð Øä5Ægh ); OP]�Ë§ M=NWcE M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS internal security 56 7 )FG `( ^va o* `( o* Iª-R ¡B(R 9= :28 n-.( ¡28 n[

-Na 9X : o; ¹ ( )FGE

`( ¡28 n[-Na 5* qh,Ç-O WG b1R,= K

-N6. 9X : +,k )¬OFG ,XY,-.9*E 9´( I= . qh,Ç-O WG ¡R,= K-N6. 9X : +,k

M=N>- ? M=:9* )´ 5; C ;sD,Y M=Na q; �P6 �Ë

§ b5WG internally B1( )

; C 89Ä6 . )®¯Y M=NU.,6Y

)´E 6�/ )/ )®>¯? 5; C M=Na ¡28 n[-Na )V (57)* )/ I= . b5¦· o´ IS `( B�-.()*

q³6 ?)- O;N]Y T

8N-Ky8 ?B,8K=:8R )

; C ( M=NWc -b( ,k structural reforms o* �d² ,-.,6Y ;�¦6? ¡B12- Í )FGE `( 5* restructure ,-.9* ;�¦6? ¡B12- Í E)FG and unless

and until @Wr -b( T8N-Ky8 ?B,X K=:

8R 5* 56 7 -b( )* )¯�=�-: )

; C ( M=NWc -b( 5* restructure M=N>

- ? M=:9* )´ M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG I- . coordination 5WG q; �{_ )FG I- . q Wr improvement 5WG q; �{_ )FG B1( I- . q Wr `( ^va )* ¡2î3§ )- O¯: ( Xs ( 5* Øä5Ægh ¶6 gË§ M=NÁ_ )´E 6�/ )/ )®>? 5; C M=Na Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( )* )V (57 )/ b5¦· o´ IS Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( ’ T67 fd² m896 : m896 : ,Ç= Oj -M3 ¢X C9*

-9V 8�-K{= K/ M=NWc -b( -9V 8�-K=NÁ_ o* ¡9U:(5{-.( )* )¬OV M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( m(

5* = .( 8<- :di -M

U :D q�-N6t=?( )

- C ,-K6: o* ;sB12- Í )FG B1( -b( )* 56 7 -b(2ïµ ( -M6 7 o* ;s2î3§ doubtful )FG ,= . M=Na q; �P6 �Ë

§ b5WG IS non competent 56 7

¸5V b,W c1 )P8 �¬N6. )

U C 5WG M=NWc -b( 5* replace 9* )* competent b5´5V 5* `( )ËQth M=Na M=N

U.,À8 �=N6. B1( -b( 5* �= .�6Y b5V5¿( 9X : ;�=O6:9;: ¡R )U C ,6Y B1( dPX ? -b(

68

5* `( 8�- Oy8 ?B,X K=:

8R M=Na ,= .,À8 �=N6. )

U C ,6YE M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( m()* -B 8�-Kµ

q³6 ? increase o- ¹5WG )¬OFG ,XY IS,;. 56 7 properly illegal immigrants `(

^va M=Na LB )FG B M=NWc -b( 5* deport 9* M=NÁ_ IÁ-.5= O* I= . IJQth 56 7 )FG )U C ,6 t6?

`( IS illegal immigrants 5* deport m9*E I= . `( L�U.,¼)/ ,;.,À8 ?( )FG -b( illegal immigrants )/ )¢¬N¯. ,;K=NÂ )FG B1( -b( b5´5V 5* `( ^va M=Na )- OFG B )¬OV )* space ,;K=:R )FGE M=Na5

; C q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS `( 5* restructure ,-.9* ;�¦6? ¡BB12- Í )FG B1( competent ¸5V )

- C ,ÇV ¡B12- Í M=NWc B1( -b( )* -B 8�-Kµ increase IS,;.)¬OFG ,XY)

- C 9* L1 -b( b5´5V 5* deport 9* M=NÁ_E (241R 56 7 secret fund for counter terrorism -b( )* `,X . R56 75j )

; C 5WG M=NWcE M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS )U C ,6 t6? `( )* I= . -B 8�-Kµ )Ìg

;? ÑU C,t;? 9X :

©,Jå;N_( )¬O* M=N

U.,6Y 56 7 normally )- O-N_ M=Na ,;. ( )FG IS I= . )Ìg

;? ÑU C,t;? M=Na mR

)¬C R ); C ,6Y M=NWc B1( -b( ,k o

U ¹5* 8RB,»= CB ,= . transparency 56 7 secret funds M=NWc -b( o* M=N>

- ? o; ¹5WGE M=Na q; �P6 �Ë

§ b5WG IS I= . -B 8�-Kµ 56 7 M=NWc I= . law

enforcement institutions )* infrastructure )* )¬OV ©,Jå;N_(

)- C 5WG )¬OFG ,XYE )

U C ,6 t6? `( )* IÂ -b( 5* )Ìg;? ÑU C,t

;? M=Na Xs ( `( 5* ©,Jå;N_(

M=:9*E 56 7 human trafficking )FG I= . q³6 ? (896 : 53 ¢= C( `( ;<º1 -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na R56 75j )FGE `( 9X : q³6 ? -M

3 ¢{= .( ,-K=NÂ )¬OFG ,XY B1( facilitate ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XY IS I= . human trafficking 5* 128 n-K* © 9* M=NÁ_ B1( `( )* )¬OV 56 7 M=Na

q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG -B 8�-Kµ -b( 5* )¬C R ); C ,6Y M=NWc L1 M=Na q; �P6 �Ë

§ b5WG 93:5j )Î¬C d² )/

©,Jå;N_( M=:9*E ¡2ï=N

;. ;s,6 . 56 7 M=Na -édÔ ,-.9* ; � WG,XYq b5WG IS (B,-. B1( (BR,-. 5* M=Na q; �P6 �Ë

§ b5WG IS `( o* o´R9*B,k 2; n>6? o

- ¹9* ;�¦6? ¡B12- Í )FG IÁ-.5= O* (B,-. B1( (BR,-. )* `,X . -b( ,k 8RB,»= CB updated ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XY B1( `( 5*

69

updated )- C 9* )* )¬OV biometric system ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XY (BR,-. 5*E `(

@8 �¢/ )* ;�g;? 56 7 illegal sims -dË§ M=NWc T67 )/ @

U ?(9* 5* ©128 n-K* ,-.9* ;�¦6? ¥»

3¢j 5WG ,W cB )FGE -b( @U ?(9* 5* ©128 n-K* ,-.9* ;�¦6? ¥»

3¢j 5WG ,W cB )FG 5; C -b( @U ?(9* 5* ©128 n-K* )

- C 9* M=Na o- ¹,_ ( 5WG q; �{_ )FG B1( `( )* )¬OV M=Na q; �PË6�

§ b5WG

IS B1( q³6 ? extra measures 56 7 )¬OV ,6Y ); O{_ M=NWc -b( 5* )¬OV ,-.,6Y )¬OFG ,XYE M=Na q; �P6 �Ë

§ b5WG IS Xs ( 8�- Oy=�VB,X . o* o

8 ¹B5{= K/ 9X : LB,6 .1R )/ I6 Y5; C mR )FG B M=NWc

B1( `( 5* ©,°µ )- C ,-K6: o* 3T

3Ê5* 9* )FG B M=NWc 5; C M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS 56 7 qº,6 . -B,= .9= :( M=NWc 56 7 M=N

;.B,JÔ M=NWc B1( 56 7 specially airports M=NWc -b( @Wr( ;s,a,½j o* q³6 ? o

8 ¹B5{= K/ 5* LB,6 .1R ,-KPQ= .R )¬OFG ,XY IS b,W c1 9X : ,= K* b,= K�®- w M=NWc B1( ,= K* b,= .B1-dË·

M=NWcà )U C ,6 t6? `( )* IS @Wr -M

3 ¢= NJ· ,-K6: M=:RE M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS `( 5* internally department 5* ,-KPQ= .R )¬OFG ,XY IS L1 b,>· qÙ®

-w B1( ,Þ-7 9X : M=NWcE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! M=Na ¡9

-7 ( ;s,6 . b19* o´ IS M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS B8RB,6 . o8 ¹B5{= K/

Ñ= C( q§ ,k +,k )FGE -M{= KV unfortunately I= . +,k Ñ= C( q§ ,k )FG B1( Ñ= C( q§ 5* b12î3§ )* B�-.( q

- �Ó= C ¡B,JWr main cities )* B�-.( -b( )/ +,k ,= KV ,6Y ,W cB )FG B1( diplomats o* o

8 ¹B5{= K/ 9X : ¡1 oU ¹ ( -2= nX. o* o

8 ¹B5{= K/ 9X : B1( @Wr( ;s,a,½j o* o

8 ¹B5{= K/ 9X : -b( 5* ,= .,ÇV )FG ,= K´E M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS -b( o* job description I= . M=N>

- ? )FGà -b( o* job description I= . )FG IS I= . B8RB,6 . o* o

8 ¹B5{= K/ )* )¬OV 8�/5X C oU ¹,-K6: qU �´ )FGà M=Na q; �P6 �Ë

§ b5WG IS -b( 5* TXC(1 b,W c1

9X : ,-K6g=�P6 ? )¬OFG ,XY ,;. IS I= . ,-KX:( +,k b,W c1 9X : 2; n>6? B5² 9X : 9* ); O{_ M=NWcE ¡9-7 ( ;s,6 . I= .

IS I think, I would suggest that more coordination is required between the departments that come under this

70

Ministry. B1( ¡241R ;s,6 . I= . IS -b( 5* latest training q- �=:R ;�¦6?

¡B12- Í )FG é,-Y B5² 9X : T=NÂ5X C 5* B1( last M=Na b5¦· o´EEEE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: Xs ( q³; ?5X 7 I°µR last I>· q WrB M=NWcE

Iª2; nth L-2- nª -M¢7 : IS Xs ( -b( )* -dhB ( 5* update M=:9*à 28 n[j 9{= KXN_

updated arms )- C 5WG )¬OFG ,XYE terrorists )* `,X . B1( )¢¬C ( 56 7 ¸5V M=NWc

-b( )* `,X . LR,= .-B updated arms )

; C 5WG M=NWc B1( 56 7 ¡B,JWr T=NÂ5X C )FG -b( )* `,X . L1 -dhB ( M=NWc 56 7 IS ); O®¯Y q³6 ? M=N>

- ? M=NWcà L1 = .( T=NX.53 Ê )* B5² 9X : d Ø�-C

); C ( M=NWcE ;sB -�°j )* ¶; ?,_ B5WGD M=Na qi,k updated arms )P

; ? 56 7 IS ©,Jå

;N_( )U C 5WG M=NWcE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: I= .9{

3_E�6Y,_ �JA( �= K/à 6�7,p Ñ¿ ( -M=N-K¢7 E 6�7,p

�=K/ Ñ¿ ( -M=N

-K¢7 : I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E 6s,-K67 D(1 ! 56 7 mB,JWr `,X .

2= nU.2= n8K-:( )* )V (57 )/ I= . ¡28 n[

-Na )FG `( M=NaFIA, NADRA, NARA, Narcotics, Passports, Customs, Coast Guards I= . +,J

;? M=:-2= nX¤ M=NWc B1( ãD 8�-K=:( B8RB ( -b( o* Iª-R ¡B(R )FGE 9´( ;sB( -B1 I6 YB, -Y B1( T

-C,¼ )* �°6 C ,ÀQ= .R )

U C ,6Y 5; C I= . 6�/ )/ @Wr( ¡2- n=K3¢j )FGE ãD 8�-K=:( B8RB ( o* ©,t

;?B5¿ +,J;? 9;:

mB,JWr )- Oj ,_ )FG IS ¥k q³6 ? ,-K; :( (896 : I°±(1 3T=NX. ,= . ( ¡B,JWr MNA L2W c,È Ñ¿ ( )* )V (57 B1()/ `( )* L1xw 56 7 ¥[®[j ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ )* ;s,°±(1 3T=NX. )FG B ( M=NWcE @Wr )

- C `( M=Na 56 7 q; �=NU.(1B I½= Cd² `( M=Na ©,Jå

;N_( ,= K* )FG 5; C q§( q; �=NU.(1B

71

B5² )Î¬C d² )/ 6f ( q³6 ? q- �X:( -24B5µ 5* ©,Jå

;N_( 9* )FG B M=NWc é,-Y B5² 9X : 56 7 para military forces M=NWc -b( 5* @Wr q§( q; �=N

U.(1B )Î¬C d² )/ ©,Jå;N_( 9*

)FG B M=NWcE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! M=NJWr qi,-p( \-. 8�-Kµ )* ¶; ?,_ T=NÂ5X C )* +, ØÞ-C 5* b56 C5¿

)* ¶; ?,_ ¥a 9* 2; n>6? ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XY ,À; ? B1( -b( 5* professionally 2; n>6? ); C 9*à -b( 5* \-K

-N=.98 : )

; C (9*à -b( 5* well equipped ); C 9* B1( @Wr )

- C `( )/ LR,= .

-B 8�6 g6? -b,;K¢X 75®6 . M=Na B1( ×�-K/ M=Na 6¾ =�P6? 9* Xf9

-7 9* )FG B EM=NWc b,>6A b,>6A 9X : q³6 ? @Wr )

- C -b( para military forces 5* 6¾ =�P6? 9* Xf9

-7 9* )FG B M=NWc b,W c1 9X : ;sD,Y 2; n>6? )

- C 5WG o* )U C ,6 t6? -bR -b�6 . 6s(9

-7 ); C 5WG ,6Y )FG B M=NWc 56 7

ãD 8�-K=:( B8RB ( o* ©,t;?B5¿ )FGE ¡241R �d² Narcotics )* )V (57 )/

0xÈ( I= . )FG IS `( ;<º1 Narcotics M=Na T=NU.,6 . -b(2ïµ( 5* 2= n

-°6 C q�* 8s2= nª )* b,= K±9

;: mR ¡R qU �´ M=NWc B1( = .( 28 n=KV B1( notification 9X : T=NU.,6 . -b(2ïµ( 5* 2= n

-°6 C q�* 8s2= nª 9X : qº9;: mR ¡R qU �´E (B,JWr IvUK¢j 6�/ )/ (896 : qí=? 5; C )FG IS 6�6 7 @Wr q

- �X:( �-K¢X C B1( �-K¢X C,-. o* R,= K-N6. 9X : 2= n

-°6 C 8s2= nª )* b5´5V 5* b,= K±9

;: mR 9* -b( b1B(R( M=Na )V 9* ); C ( M=NWcà T6 7 o* 6�/ )/

¡896 : ©,3Kj mB,JWr `,X . Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( m( ,k LB(R( )FGE Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( ,k LB(R( I;K 3/-9´ qU �* )¿ dÔ )/ 56 7 ©,t

;?B5¿ )FG 5; C `( M=Na Xs ( M=NÀQ= .R IS Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( m(

o* o´R9*B,k 5; C B1R o* ;s,6 . )FGà m896 : m896 : high profile )¢¬C ( M=NWc IS T67 M=Na Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( )- C M=N

3[ 3/5* 0123 4 M=NS B1( b,W c1 9X : 56 7 -b( )* -b(2ïµ( ;s,-K=N°

;C )P; ?à M=Na dPX ? b5¦· ,Ò IS qU �* )¢¬C ( ¸5V 6f ( `( -b5= C( M= Na )P

8 �¬N6. )U C 5WG

M=NWc -b( )* ¸5Và -b( )* relatives B1( -b( )* I;K 3/B B(R 2= n-°6 C 8s2= nª )*

72

;s,-K=N°;C M=NWcE qU �* q�= C( b58 N_5X C 9X : )P

8 �¬N6. )U C 5WG ¸5V -b( )* I;K 3/B B(R B1( -b( )*

¸5Và Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( m( 5; C ;s,½®°

;C B1( I;K 3/B b5= CB(R ,k = .( ,[= C( LB(R( -M6 : ,= K´ )FG IS b,>6A 9X : b5´5V 5* `( )¬OV ,6 t=�P6 ? ,;.,6Y )FG IS L1 -bR B1( ;s(B M=Na q

- �X:( b,= K±9;:

M=:9* B1( -b( 5* -b( -2ï= NS )/ oU ¹5* 6�®Þj M=N>

- ? )FG T67 o* 6�/ )/ ¡896 : ©,3Kj -b,;K¢*,X . )* L1 mB,_ -2ï= NS M=NWc T67 M=Na -M

3 ¢X C9* )/ )V 9* 8s5V B,a )/ )V 9* 6f ( m896 : m896 : high profile cases M=NWc B1( Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( o* oU ¹5* q³6 ? o´R9*B,k M=N>

- ? )FGE b,W c M=Na ,-K; :( B12- Í b5¦· ,Ò IS ¶X g· 8�- Oy

8 ?B,X K=:8R )¢¬C ( M=NWc ©,3Kj )* B5² 9X :

8sB5X N_,X . ,k 8�- Oy8 ?B,X K=:

8R )FG IS T67 )- C ¶X g· o´R9*B,k o

U ¹,À·R B1( )®À�X? b5- CR 56 7

)®À�X? b5V,_ M=Na 56 7 @6 .(9X : )P; ? `( M=Na o

U ¹5* ¡2; n>6? )V 9* )U C ( M=NWc B1( `(

)- C +,k ,= K*E b,W c ,-K; :( B12- Í )FG IS 8sB5X N_,X . )* )¬OV q¨ÀX �X? 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ M=Na = .( announcement o

U ¹5WG q³; ? B1( L1 q³

; ? `R ©,_ )* )¬OV IS 8sB5X N_,X . = .( +,w qhR ( 5* `R ©,_ )* )¬OV ,= .R )

U C ,6Y ,Ò T67 5* LR56 75j 8�- Oy- ?B5´ )

- C â1B ,= .R ,À; ?E ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ )FG IS L1 +,w qhR ( )* )¬OV 56 7 8sB5X N_,X . )

- C ,-K6: o* `( o* duration )FG `( 5* X¾

-?,X . ©,_ )/ ,É896 : 9* `R ©,_ ,= K* )U C ,6Y 56 7 q¨ÀX �X?

8�- Oy- ?B5´ )

- C announce E,À; ?,= K* `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ @

8 �¢* ,k 56 7 LB(R( )FG `( o* ©,t;?B5¿ I= . IS)FG @

8 �¢* `( ;<º1 2; n 3[= N6. b56 C5¿ )* B�-.( Ñ= C( o6¹ B ( ,k +,k 9* ,W cB )FGE L1 ,6Y 9* ©,a 5* ,;K*1B )FG B1( `( o* R,= K

-N6. 9X : L1 -M3 ¢{= KV5* 0123 4 9* ,;K=:R )FG B1( q

- �;N 6Y `( ;<º1 @

8 �¢* M=Na -M3 ¢X C9* 5WG q WrB )FG 5; C I= . -b,;K¢*,X . )* ¸5V m896 : )P¯A ( )Î¬C d² )/

73

); O-: ,6Y EM=NWc Narcotics M=Na q³6 ? same q§( fd² )FG IS `( ;<º1

-b,;K¢*,X . Narcotics M=Na = .( ;�¦6? ¡896 : ¡ 8�-Kj -M6 : ,»X 7 )FG B1( ¡B5X C ,= K-:R

M=Na 9U:xX K/ o* ;�=O3N=K7 )/ narcotics o* -b,;K¢*,X . B1( -b,;K¢*,X . ,k I= . LB(R( )- O* 1B M=Na +,k,-. )FG B1( ¡B5X C ,= K

-:R M=Na oU ¹xX K/ ,= K* ,6Y ,W cB )FG B1( 6�/ )/ ¡896 : ;s,6 . I= .

IS)FG -b,;K¢*,X . ,k oU ¹5* I£xwà o

U ¹5* ;s,>=?R ,= . oU ¹5* bU1,Ò ,[= C( M=N>

- ? )FG IS b,>6A 9X : o- ¹,_ ( )/ I= . narcotics M=N>

- ? )¯�-�¦X? B1( I= . LB(R( o6¹,= Kj,k )/ ,-KX:( +,k 9* E){_

(BR,-. o* q³6 ? -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C ¶X g· reputation 2; n>6? B12- Í )FG -M{= KV `( M=Na q³6 ? ¡2; n>6? o* ;sB12- Í E)FG M=Na Xs ( 5* 9

-7 ( M=Na 8�/5* 8RB,Ò )V (57)* )/ b5¦· ,Ò IS ¥»V,6 . ¾ =�g

ß 8�/5* 8RB,Ò ,k +,k ,= K* ,;.5WG )FGà +,k I= . ,;.5WG )FG IS M=N>· )/ b5- Oj B1( b5- O8 : o* R(�°;C M=Na narcotics B1( 9Ä= .R M=:-2= nX¤ ¥»

-C o; ¹,6Y M=NWc B1(

`( )* �°6 C ¡8B5P; ? q§ B(�½j M=Na `( 5* (189{X . ,= .R ,;.,6Y )FG B1( 8�/5* 8RB,Ò @=�®k ,;.9* )FG IS 8�/5* 8RB,Ò `( 9X : B5X CdP6 ? )Î¬C d² )/ +,k 9* ,W cB )FGE ¡B�-Ky§ R1�Y M=Na Xs ( M=NÀQ= .R IS 56 7 ,W c1 b 9X : \-K®Çy§ 5WG q WrB )FG 56 7 M=:-2= nX¤ 5WG q WrB M=NWc `( M=Na o

U ¹5* q³6 ? \-K*B1 d Ø�-C M=N>

- ? q WrB (E ( -�>z ãD 8�-K=:( B8RB ( )/ )V 9* I= . +,J;?

mB(R( -M6 7 o* I= . ©,t;?B5¿ )FGE é,-Y B5² 9X : M=Na q³6 ?( -b( -b(2ïµ( o* Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( M=Na B1( Narcotics M=Na 56 7 2= n

-°6 C 8s2= nª )* b,= K±9;: o* qU �´ M=NWc 5; C M=Na

`( )* )V (57 )/ 3 B(-9´ b19* ,Ò IS `( 5* ,ÀQ= .R )U C ,6Y B1( `( 9X : 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ oU ¹(1B,k Em9*

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: I3[

UC,w �= K/ I6 K7,pE

74

Iª2; nth I3[UC,w �= K/ : I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 E9{= KXN_ ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(R 56 7 IS = .( @Wr( ;sB( -B1 )FG 5; C M=Na q; �

-7,-K 3/ 8RB,k )* )V (57 )/ ;s,6 . b19* o´ IS q; �-7,-K 3/ 8RB,k ,k 56 7

ã(96 7( 5WG ,W cB )FG `( M=Na = .( 5; C ¥6.8R q; �-7,-K 3/ 8RB,k ,k ã(96 7( )FG B1( = .( q; �

-7,-K 3/ 8RB,k M=Na 56 7 oV5yåj q§ qÙ®

-w q³6 ? o; ¹,6Y ( )FG 5; C ¥6.8R q; �

-7,-K 3/ 8RB,k ,k ã(96 7( ¶X g· 5; C ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ o* I6 Y1 )/ 5WG ,W cB )FG B1( ¶X g· )ËQth o* technical b,= K�®

- w EM=NWc `( M=Na L1 -M=N

;.(5-7 56 7 b1dPê M=Na q³8 �=N6. o

U ¹5WG M=NWc )- O¯: ( b5X g6? )* ¶; ?,_ B1( -b( -M=N;.(5-7 )* q³6 ? ¥6.8R q; �

-7,-K 3/ 8RB,k ); C 5WG M=NWc B1( -b( b5= CB,X t=�6: 5* ,;KX: M=N>

- ? E,;.5WGB1( -b( )* ¥6.8R ¥6.8R q; �

-7,-K 3/ 8RB,k ¥XY )FG B ); C 5WG M=NWcE 5; C `( M=Na ;�¦6? ;sB12- Í

)FG `( ;s,6 . o* IS +(5} )U C ,6 t6? `( )* IS -b( 5* ;<V5¦§ )®aà L1 ¥[®[j

;sx»3¢j ,k ,-Kj,_ )FG B9* M=NWcE B1( IJQth oV5yåj q§ qÙ®-w 9X : `R `R B(-2W c ,k I- .,a96 7

= .( 6<=:d-Ô 9X : T67 o* I- .,W c,a @Q-.( q³6 ? `R B(-2W c )¯C 1B M=N>

- ? )FGE -b( 9X : `R `R B(-2W c )* )

- C ,a96 7 \Â )FG B M=NWcE 5; C `( M=Na ¡2; n>6? )- C D o* ;sB12- Í )FGE

q§( fd² +x_( R,6 . ( o* o

8 ¹B5= O{= K/ )* )V (57 )/à I= . +x_( IÁ-.5X 7R,6 . ( I¼x-tz(B(R )FG B1( +x_( R,6 . ( ,k -Mj( 1 -b,a( mB5X C ^va 9X : 93:( -B(�-.( ,;.5WG )FGE

mB5X C ^va M=Na -Mj( 1 -b,a( o* ;<V,Y �6 . )/ 9;:�6 . o; ¹5WG q WrB,6Y )FGE `( o*

¡896 : ;s,W c56 71 56 7 mB,JWr o8 ¹B5= O{= K/ mB(R( M=NWc -b( ,k TXC ( M=Na o

U ¹5* coordination M=N>

- ?E -b( `,X .)* �= .�6Y It¨_( M=N>- ?à -b( o* \-K

-N=.98 : M=N>

- ? oU ¹5WGà

-b( o* qºx -Y( ;�=O6:9;: M=N>- ? ào

U ¹5WG mB,JWr mB5X C ^va 5* M=: 8B5PX Aà +x_( R,6 . ( )* 56 7 o

8 ¹B5= O{= K/ B(R( m M=NWc -b( o* �6 . qºx -Y( o* �Y )FGE

75

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ T67 fd² B5WGD ,k I°±(1 (5WG IS T=NÂ5X C )* b5P; ?,W c )- O;NS ¸5V

mB,a )U O´ 5; C (B,JWr (-24 )- O¬: R ,k oU ¹5* +, ØÞ

-C ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XYE mB,JWr b,W c LR,= .-B )/

LR,= .-B suspend ,= .R9* ,;.,6Y )FG 56 7 -M=N

;. )- O¬N>h o* q8 �PX A ,-Kj 9* dPX ? TXC(1 ); C ,6Y (

M=NWcE 5; C oU ¹5* (-24 o

- ¹5WG )¬OFG ,XY IS,;. example )- O]: B1( L�-KU: ( IJQth �,p ){_ 5WGE `( fd² `( M=Na 56 7 ;�¦6? ¡896 : o6¹(9

-7 )FG L1 q§,= K/ b,= K;:dP6 ?à \-K8N_5X C B1(

-2- n 3_5j19X :à ¥Wc(,-. ¸5V )´ ( )FG B ( M=NWcà ¥Wc(,-. b5´5V 5* o; ¹dP6 ? ,= K* ,W cB,6Y )FG `( ,k

q³6 ? ©,= K-7 ,-KP·B ,Ò5WGE B1( L1 IJQth 56 7 ¡B,JWr ;� Ø²,ç7 )U OV )*à +(5} 5* ØÛÆg

;? )U OV )* )FG L1 b1B5X 7à bU15*(8R )* ¶; ?,_ xa )FG B1( +,J

;? b5= O;N=K*8R M=Na L1 R5-7 3s5®a M=NWcE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ 8sB5X N_,X . )* )V (57 )/ qi,k ;s,6 . qQXY5WG )FGE -M{= KV 56 7

mB,JWr -b12= n6. ^va -M=N3[j ¥6K=:( 8�= .B 8sB5X N_,X . ); O®a M=NWc L1 ;�¦6? m8B5P; ? )/ Xf9

-7 o* I6 Y1 )/ mB,JWr b5

- C,-t;?B,ç/ )* )´ ( M=N

-KU :D qÐÂ q; � WGB M=NWc 56 7 ^va ,k image 2W c,6 . )* b5{va M=Na ;�¦6? 6s(9

-7 q WrB9* )FGE = .( -M=N3[j ¥6K=:( 8�= .B

8sB5X N_,X . )- O¬: R )U OV )* = .( -M=N3[j o

; ¹5WG )FG B1( 56 7 b,W c1 9X : +,k )- C 9* )V (1 ¸5V

); C 5WG M=NWc L1 qU �* -bR ;. )

- C ,-t;?B,ç/ ,k 9{XY )

; C ,ÇV M=NWc B1( ¡896 : ;�6 O=NÕj M=Na ); C 5WG M=NWcE

)ñ -b(-R(2î Øè(

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: q6A I3[UC,w �= K/ I6 K7,pE

76

Iª2; nth I3[UC,w �= K/ : 5; C M=NJWr `( 9X : B5- } ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XY IS b5= O* -M=N

3[j ¥6K=:( 8�= .B 8sB5X N_,X . )

- C ,-K6: oV(1 -M=N3[j @Wr ,= K¦h M=N>

- ? ); C ,X .9*E `( fd² mB5X C ^va

M=Na 8sB5X N_,X . )- C ,-K6: ,k 56 7 +, ØÞ

-C )FG L1 = .( fd² )/ ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XYE L�-.,J�X C b5±xw )* )U OV \Â( +, ØÞ

-C )FGE `( fd² -M6 7 )* 8sB5X N_,X . )P· B )U C 5WG M=NWc -b( 5* q³6 ?

,ÀQ= .R )U C ,6YE `( fd² ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ )* )V (57 )/ ;s,6 . b19* o´ `( )* 56 7

root cause M=NWc 6�67 ;. @Wr L1 address M=N>- ? M=:9* )´ 5; C ;�3¢WGR

¡R9´ )* )Ë; ? , -Y M=Na M=NJWr o

U ¹5* o6¹,= Kj,k �= ., 3_ I- . ¥a ){_E `( M=Na = .( -2= nX¤ 56 7 2= n-ð qQva ¶; ?,W c 3s5®a )FG `( 5* ,k1B )

U C ,6Yà I= . ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(R B1( ;sB( -B1 I6 YB, -Y b5- C1R o* Iª-R ¡B(R )FGE )`( æ±5j 9X : 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ )

- C q§9* ;sB(�p oV, -Y o* B1( 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ �-K¢j ;sB(�p 9X : -M{J

;�j )U C 5WG(

Iª2; nth I3[

UC,w �= K/ : B1( `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ ¡B,JWr 56 7 qU �-: ¥[

-C )´ ( q WrB ( )FG -b( )U OV )* B,Ò -B1B M=N>

- ? )FG law and order o* situation q�= C( )FG ^va M=Na +,J

;? mB(R( failure o* �d² )FG B,6Y M=NWc B1( mB,JWr b5- C(56 7 5* 1B

B,Ò -B M=N>- ? ¥a ,W cBE 5

; C -b( )* B,Ò -B1B )U OV )* M=NJWr 6�/,-Kj ;s,a(�£( )- C 9* )Ä-. 5WGE

@=�®°;C ,k 56 7 IÕ7 8�6 g6? M=Na ,À·B ,= K´ )FG L1 I- . )

- C 5WG )* 96 :(96 : )FGE 9´( mB,JWr )¯�6? B1( mB,JWr -b(56 7 @=�®°

;C ¥p,Y M=N>- ? 9*M=: o´ 5; C L1 b,>· �12ìj o´5WG B1(

L1 ,= K* m9* oÉ `( fd² â(B5-7 )FGà oU ¹,Ç-O¦h -B196 : -B1B q; �Ú896 : q WrB,6Y )FGà )U O

-: )U O-:

T{= K8 : ,k ã(96 7( ,W cB5WG )FGE ¡ 8�[6 N_ @· )/ @· o

; ¹5WG q WrB,6Y M=NWc 5; C +(5} ,= K* M=:9* )´ T* �d² M=N

U.,6Y )É ;�gß )* )V (57 )/ ¸5V dh )FG B M=NWcà -M{= KV 8�6 g6? M=Na ;�gß )* )U OV o

U ¹5* é,-Y @ºB M=N>- ? q³·B qU �É mB,JWr 56 7 ¡B,k24 ©,;KXN[WG

77

M=NWc b,W c1 q³6 ? oU ¹5* ,[= C( +, ØÞ;O

-:( M=N>- ? ,;.5WGà IS 6<=:d-Ô 9*,6Y b,W c1 ;�gß o* 6�/,-Kj

;<V5¦§ ¥p,Y ){_ 9*E 9´( L1 ¡B1R-dh ,;.9* )FG 5; C L1 9*,6Y 8<=:5= OU :(9X : b128 nS(8R 5* T=N¼ mR ,= . )- O¯: ( b5X g6? )* 8�=OX: o* ¸ ( )

U C ,6 t6?E `( )V (57 )/ 56 7 ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ ×896 : q WrB )FG 9´( @Wr root cause `( )* address M=N>

- ? M=:9* )´ 5; C m2= nª ©,= K

-7 M=Na I;K/(5- g-?(� -Y -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na -Mj( M=N>

- ? ,;K{_ (E '( @Wr 6�/ 5* -Mj( mRE `( fd² @Wr ); OPQ= .R M=NWc IS 56 7 ¡B,JWr L2W c,È -M¦6? 9X : IvJA (5WG 5; C o

U ¹5* q³6 ? Øä5Ægh M=N>

- ? )FG B ,ÒE B1( oU ¹5* dPê `( ( )/ M=N>

- ? )¯�6? E,Ò 5; C M=NJWr B12- Í L1 +,J;? 2Í,-K} 56 7 `( ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ M=Na 3s5®a M=NWc B1( L1 ;sD,Y 56 7 m�-K6: 5* ;�3¢WGR

R9´ ); O¬: R,-K6: M=NWc L1 M=NJWr address )- C 9* )Ä-. 5WGE ,8 .,¼ )* )V (57 )/ q³6 ?

M=NJWr ,-KPQ= .R ,Ò5WGE q³6 ?( 56 7 IDPs )FG B ( M=NWc -b( q³6 ?,k ©,= K-7 ,-KP·B ,Ò5WGE I= .9{

3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: I= .9{3_ �6Y,_ �JA( 6�7,pE

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E ãD 8�-K=:( B8RB ( 9X : ;s,6 . )FG B9* M=NWc 8�- Oy=�VB,X . )* +,J

;? -M=NS(B(à B1( ;�¦6? I= .9{3_ IS Xs ( )

- C )P]�h æ±5j ,= .RE -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na `( ;<º1 56 7 ©,t

;?B5¿ ¥XY q WrB )FGE L1 q�* )/ qQÉ8R qX�PX A M=N>- ?

)FGE ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(R = .( ;�¦6? @Wr( ¡28 n[-Na )FG B1( I= . q�* q³6 ? ^va )* B�-.( I= .

¡28 n[-Na foundation base o* ;�=O3N=K7 q; �P·B )FG B1( `( o* Iª-R ¡B(R

m2= nª ©,= K-7 M=Na 6�/ )/ ×896 : 9* )FGE -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na I;K 3/ -�� qi,k IpdÔ )/ R5-7

3T* )®JA )FG B5WG M=NWcE qXA(9* )* ;sD,Y X¾U?5Ê q³6 �* -b ( ,= .R9* ,;.,6Y )FG q³6 �* � (

,= .R9* ,;.,6Y )FGà )®À· +,w b,W c1 9X : I;KP6 ? ¡B5-7 q WrB5WG )FGE b,W c1 9X : )®À· +,w ã(5- }( ,= K* ,;.,6Y )FG 8�-.,J= ?8RB1( o* o

; ¹,6Y )FG B1( ,= K-:R 5* I= . I;KX: )FGà -b,;K¢*,X . o* -2= n8.B,À; ?( 5* q³6 ?

78

I; KX: )FGE ¡28 n[-Na Iv -Y(R 5* q³6 ? I;KX: )FG IS qXA(9* M=Na )¢¬C ( )¢¬C ( T

8N-KU :(5X C M=NWc b,>6A T=NÂ5X C M=N>

- ? q; �{_,6YE b,>6A 96 g-�=:B -B )* B,»®W c( q³6 ? M=N>

- ? ); O{_,6YE b,W c1 9X : -b( ;�3¢WGR b1R9´ o* q

- �X:( M=N;KV(�w q; �ÄÂ M=NWc B1( b,W c1 9X : ¶8 �=N6. 9* q�* )* )U OV q³6 ? L1

o´�-. -B ,k -0(9X7 )- C ,À6 �6? ,k B8RB ( ); OV ,»-C M=NWcE q�* )* q³6 ? ã(5- }( )

- C 9* ,k B8RB ( ); OV ,»-C M=NWcE I;K 3/ -�� b5

- CR 6s,6 t-�X: M=Na L2W c,È Ñ¿ ( q6A,6 . ,k I°±(1 (5WGE `( fd²

B1, 3[X C M=Na )U C ( -B1B ;s,°±(1 )

; C 5WG ); OFG B M=NWcà b5´5V 5* ,8 .5V ,W cB,6Y )FGE b5´5V 5* (B,a ,W cB,6Y )FGE 6s,6 t

-�X: M=Na I;K 3/ -�� -B1B 56 7 L2W c,È Ñ¿ ( q6A,6 . ,k 56 7 I°±(1 (5WGE -b( )/ ,ÀX A5X C ,= K´ IS Xs ( ,k +,-. L2W c,È Ñ¿ ( )FGE b5¦- ?( )

- C ,>· b,W cE 5; C 56 7 1R 98 :5j -9®»= O

U :,_ 9X : B(5Ê B,XY ¸5V )U C ( )P

; ? b5¦- ?( )- C ,>· IS @Wr Xs ( 5* oV5´ ,-.B,a

); OFG ,XY M=NWcE b5¦- ?( )- C ,>· 1RB,a b5¦- ?( )

- C B,XY b,=KV5´ `( -b5; C, -Y 5* EM=:B,a mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . o* q§,= K/ b5; O},J6 A 5* I= . -é(2; nð( )FG q§,= K/ q6� WG -�a b5; O},J6 A 5* IS qXA(9* )* ;sD,Y ;�¦6? 6s(9

-7 M=NWc M=Na ,-KPX A5X C b5WG,XY ,Ò I6 Y(5-7 �°/ l=OµB 6�7,p

)/à M=Na ,-KPX A5X C b5WG,XY ,Ò I6 Y(5-7 �°/ l=OµB 6�7,p )/ IS L2W c,È Ñ¿ ( 56 79X : I°±(1

(5WG `( )* B,6 . m M=Na -b( o* ,= K* )U C (B )FG ,= K* 2W c,6 . desk 9X : ,6Y )*

M=NU.,;K6: )´ IS 6s,6 t

-�X: )* 6f ( ;sD,Y )¢¬C ( M=NWc IS b,W c1 9X : b5- O67BR b5´5V 5* T=NÂ5X C o* L 8�-K

- } ¡R9´ M=Na B,a ,= .R ,;.,6Y )FG b,W c1 9X : 5®Ò 8<6: )¢¬N]Y militant 56 7 IS \= KVñ@¨[j) -b ()* militant Xs19´ )* ¸5V I= .EM=NWc ¥À· +,w T=NÂ5X C )* ¶; ?,_

,6Y 9* 2W c,È ¡BR,½V( 6�7,p )* ¡-9*dh Tµ ( M=Na IvJA ); C 9* M=NWc M=Na ,-KPX A5X C ,;K WG,XY

b5WG IS ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(R b,>=? b,>· 9X : )FG b,>· 9X : )FG b,>=? 9X : (B -B1 ;s EIv -Y(R 9-7 ( Xs ( )

- C ,-K; :( 8�-Kµ b5= O* ,À·B -b( E9X : M=Na = .( ;s,6 . b5¦· ,ÒEEE 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A No interference please. �6Y,_ �JA( 6�7,pE �6Y,_ �JA( 6�7,pBrief, to the point Xs ( ;s,6 . 9* )U O]g=�VE

79

)`( æ±5j 9X : ;�¦6? )/ -B-dåj -M=NS(B( 8�- OU:(5X C � ( B8RB ( 9X : m8dP· )U O´ 5WG(

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: `( IX . observation I- . M=:R -2= nvX .E

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : M=Na @ØÙ}(9= : -B1 6�7,p 5* b5V56 C ,ÒE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: b,=Kj -b,-Kyz(�6 K} 6�7,p Xs ( M=NÀ

8 �=N6. -2= nvX .E Ñ= C23 ï; C

M=NÀ·BE

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : M=Na 6�67 ;.àI= . 6�67 ;. M=Nato the point,;.9* b5WG

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: �6Y,_ Xs ( to the point.

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : M=Na to the point b19* ,Ò -b( 5* M=N

U.,À8 �=N6.E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: No, no. -b( 5* M=N>- ?EL1 Xs ( 2U n=KX7 5*

addressM=:9*

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : qU �P6 ? 5P8 �=N6. B,= .E (Interruption)

80

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: �6Y,_ 6�7,p 2U n=KX7 5*

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : ;�3/(R96 : E19* mB,JWr �U.,£ 5* b,W c1 ,À·B (5WG )FG I6 Y(5-7

�°/ l=OµB )- CE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: �6Y,_ 6�7,p Xs ( 2U n=KX7 5* addressM=:9*

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : ,= K* @Wr )

- C Xs ( 5* ¶8 �=N6. )* (96 : ,>·E (Interruption)

Mr. Deputy Speaker: No cross talk.

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : M=Na I>· I= . ,W cB b5WG Xs ( )/

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Xs ( 2U n=KX7 5* address M=:9*

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : M=Na Xs ( )/ ;s,6 . 9* ,W cB b5WG

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: M=N>

- ? controversial ;s,6 . Xs ( I- . M=:9* no, to the point.

81

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : IS 2W c,6 . desk 9X : ,6Y 9* mB,JWr �U.,£ 9X : -b,[7( q3§5j(di ,k+(-9V( ,ÇV ,W cB )FG EI= . )`( æ±5j 9X : ;�¦6? )/ -B-dåj -M=NS(B( 8�- OU:(5X C � ( B8RB ( 9X : m8dP· )U O´ 5WG(

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Ñ= C23 ï

;C M=NÀ·B �6 .,w 2= n3_ q¨w 6�7,pE

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : 6�67 ;. I6 Y(5

-7 �°/ l=OµB 6�7,p )¢¬N]Y ¸5V R56 75j M=NWc \= KVñ@¨[j) -b (5* q�* )* 2W c,6 . )* -My

3§R o* ;sB12- Í M=N>- ? )FGEqi,k M=NWc I6 Y(5

-7 �°/ l=OµBE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: 6�67 M=Na Xs ( 5* I>· ,W cB b5WG

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : 9

-7 (

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: M=N>- ? M=N>

- ? Xs ( controversial ;s,6 . )FG B9* M=NWc

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : M=Na ( ,W cB b5WG M=Na ,W cB ( b5WG

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Xs ( Interior IX . to the point ;s,6 . M=:9*cut motion IX . ;s,6 . M=:9* q6A

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : M=NaInterior IX . ;s,6 . ,;.9* b5WG `( )* L1xwE

82

(Interruption) 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Xs ( Ñ= C23 ï

;C M=NÀ·BE 6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : `( )* L1xw 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ( Xs 5* æ±5j M=:R )´ �6 .,w 2= n

3_ q¨w 6�7,p M=NÀ8 �=N6.

q6AE 6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : Xs ( Narcotics E5* M=Na Narcotics IX . ;s,6 . ,;.9*

b5WGE 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A 6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : 5X C mB -b,;K¢*,X . )* B�-.(E 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Xs ( 5* æ±5j M=:R )´ �6 .,w 2= n

3_ q¨w 6�7,p Ñ= C23 ï;C

M=NÀ·B q6AE 6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . )* B�-.(à ,= K

-:REE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A �6 .,w 2= n3_ q¨w Point of Personal

Explanation = KU:,a M=NÂ5P· q6AE q6A I= . `( fd² M=N>

- ? )®Y E,Ò (Interruption)

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Xs ( `( fd² issues ); O

-N]. M=NWc )`( æ±5j 9X : ;�¦6? )/ -B-dåj -M=NS(B( 8�- OU:(5X C � ( B8RB ( 9X : m8dP· )U O´ 5WG(

83

9=: -B1 ;�{vJh )U C (96 : o

- ¹,X . 1 q6 t6?) ¡B�W c5X 7 �6 .,w 2= n3_ q¨w(: ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 E9{= KXN_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ M=Na -b( )/ ;�/(5-7BR b19* IS q

- �X:( 9= :B,½;C M=:9* 8�6 g6? )/ related o

U ¹5* q- �X:( -9= :1,6 t

;? M=:R

Mr. Deputy Speaker: Order in the House.

¡B�W c5X 7 �6 .,w 2= n3_ q¨w : I= . M=Na -b( )/ ;�/(5-7BR b19* ,Ò IS q

- �X:( -b,6 .-B

¡�-K6: M=:9* B1( L 8�-K- } ¡R9´ M=N>

- ? M=:9*E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: = KP8 ? )FG

¡B�W c5X 7 �6 .,w 2= n

3_ q¨w : @Wr ); OFG ,XY M=NWc IS 8�6 g6? IX . ;s,6 . M=:9* 8�6 g6? q Wr IX . 9= :dÎ

;C o* )U C ,6Y q�* o* B(R9* q3 �* ¥»V,6 . M=N>

- ? o- ¹9* )¬OFG ,XY b,>=? IX .E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: = KP

8 ? )FG

¡B�W c5X 7 �6 .,w 2= n3_ q¨w : 2= nª ¡ Xs ( )/ ;�/(5-71BR o´5WG IS b5¦- ?( )

- C q�* 5* o

8 ¹B,X . 5* I- ., 3[-C )

- C ,-K6: o* 3T3Ê5* o* 5; C ;s,6 . dPX ? ;�¦6? B1R ;. )

U C ,6Y o´E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: = KP

8 ? )FG Thank you. ,= K ( Xs ( ,kE

84

¡B�W c5X 7 �6 .,w 2= n3_ q¨w : M=Na Xs ( )/ ;�/(5-7BR b19* ,Ò IS -b( 5*

M=N>· IS q- �X:( parameters IX . )FG B B1( q

- �X:( 6<=: -�>; ? M=Na EM=NWcB discipline M=Na LB )* ;s,6 . M=:9*

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: �6Y,_ 6�7,p Xs ( 3 5j, -Y b5WG q6A

¡B�W c5X 7 �6 .,w 2= n

3_ q¨w : Discipline M=Na LB )* ;s,6 . M=:9*E @Wr -b( o* -9= :1,6 t

;? 5* M=N-.,a )´E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: = KP

8 ? )FG Xs ( ,k )¢¬C 1 ,;K-N6. M=N>

- ? )FG point of personal explanation.

¡B�W c5X 7 �6 .,w 2= n

3_ q¨w : -M{= KV oU ¹5* +(-9V( q

3§(9;:à oU ¹5* L 8�-K

- } ¡R9´ o* qU �´ 5; CEEE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A �6Y,_ �JA( 6�7,pE q6A �6Y,_ �JA(

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_E ;�¦6? I= .9{3_

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: �6Y,_ �JA( 6�7,p B1( Xs ( )* )- O

;N]Y colleagues M=NWcE M=N>

- ? M=N>- ? I= . I½= Cd² b5¦- ?( )

- C point of personal explanationE,>·

85

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : M=NÀQ= .R M=Na law and order IX . ;s,6 . 9* b5WG,W cBE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A �6Y,_ �JA( 6�7,pE

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: M=N>- ? M=N>

- ? ¡2= nª ;s,6 . M=N-K/E �6Y,_ 6�7,p ¡2= nª ;s,6 .

M=N-K/

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : q6A

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: 2= nª ¡ +,J

;? 26 nJh )/ 3 B(-9´ )FG IS I= . `U1,W c )FG `( )* decorum ,k Xs ( ©,= K

-7 M=NÀ·BE�6Y,_ 6�7,p Xs ( )- C 6�67 2U n=KX7 I>·

q WrB )FG IS Xs ( q- �X:( Cut Motions IX . ;s,6 . M=:9*E Ñ= C23 ï

;C M=NÀ·BE

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : m2= nª ©,= K-7 M=NaE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Xs ( Ñ= C23 ï

;C M=NÀ·BE

86

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : -b( 5* M=NU.,À8 �=N6.E -b( )/ LR,= .

-B IÕ- } M=NJWr ,;. ( E)FG

-b( )/ LR,= .-B IÕ

- } -2= n;. (B,JWr E)FG (B,JWr IÕ- } ;�¦6? -2= n;. )FGE -b( 5* M=NÂ56 C IS

-b,[-C( )- O]: -b,[

-C(E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A q- �X:( q

- �X:( b58 O=N_ IX . Ñ= C23 ï;C M=NÀ·BE �6Y,_ �JA( Xs (

¡B,6Y M=NÀ·B q6A

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : m2= nª ©,= K-7 M=Na -b( 5* M=N

U.,À8 �=N6.E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Xs ( ¡B,6Y M=NÀ·B q6AE

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: �6Y,_ 6�7,p Xs ( wind up )U O]g=�*Eq6A

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : m2= nª ©,= K

-7 M=Na q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p 2= n3_�6 .,w q¨w

6�7,p 5* )¬OFG ,XY IS )Î¬C d² )/ EM=NÀ8 �=N6.

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: �6Y,_ 6�7,p Xs ( I- . L1 9* M=: Xs ( q

- �X:( ;s,6 . M=:9* q6A

87

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : @Wr ;s,6 . )FG B9* M=NWcE M=NÀQ= .R @U ?,8 . 5; C )¢¬C 1 kill9*

,= .R (2= nªE @U ?,8 . kill ,= .R9* @Wr o

U ¹5* q- �X:( ;s,6 . )

; C 9*E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A Xs ( @U ?,8 . æ

U C,-p 9* )FG B M=NWc ,-KX:(E Xs ( q- �X:( ;s,6 .

M=:9* q6AE q6A �6Y,_ 6�7,pE 6�/ 26 nJh -2= nvX . Ñ= C23 ï;C M=NÀ·B q6AE

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : M=Na q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ 6�7,pà M=Na I= . I>· ,W cB ,À; ? IS

6�67 ;. I6 Y(5-7 �°/ l=OµB )¢¬N]Y ¸5V M=NWc @¨[j \= KV 5* q�* 2W c,6 . )* -My

3§R o* ;sB12- Í M=N>

- ? )FGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: �6Y,_ 6�7,p Xs ( q�*

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : -b( o* ;�j5{Y )- C (9´ )* )U OV I6 Y(5

-7 �°/ l=OµB )¢¬N]Y ¸5V qi,k EM=NWc

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: �6Y,_ 6�7,p Xs ( B,6 . B,6 . -b( ,k +,-. )V )FG B M=NWc M=Na

Xs ( ,k = KU:,a dPX ? �-K6: b19* ,ÒE

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : M=Na )´ ( ,6Y ,W cB b5WGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Xs ( )- O¯: ( -M=N;. 8�- Oj M=Na try to conclude q

- �X:(

88

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : `( )* L1xw Narcotics )* )V (57 )/ ;s,6 . b19* M=Na

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: -M=N

;. 8�- Oj )/ Xs ( 6�/ 26 nJh )/ 3 B(-9´ )FG IS

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : b,W c ¥»V,6 .

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: IS -M=N;. 8�- Oj M=Na B,XY 8�- Oj M=Na to the point q

- �X:( ;s,6 . ¥JQa M=:9*E = KP

8 ? )FGE

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : `( )* L1xw Narcotics )* )V (57 )/ ;s,6 . b19* ,Ò

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: B1( personal q�* IX . Xs ( q

- �X:(observation I- . EM=:R E = KP

8 ?

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : EM=N>- ?EM=N>

- ? m2= nª 5; C �U.,£ 5* b5¦- ?( )- C (96 : ,>·

@Wr )- C q�* �U.,£ 5* (96 : M=N>

- ? ,>· )FG b5¦- ?( )- C mB,JWr �U.,£ 5* (96 : ,>·

)FG -M{= KV ¡B,JWr �U.,£ o* ;�=O6:9;: I= . M=N>- ? )FG @Wr q�* ,J

-� WGB 5* (96 : M=N>·E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: B,XY 8�- Oj )* B�-.( àB�-.( �6Y,_ 6�7,p Xs ( ;s,6 . EM=N-K/

�6Y,_ 6�7,p Xs ( 3 5j, -Y E5WGB

89

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : q6A q6A

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: B,XY 8�- Oj )* �-.( B Xs ( +,J

;? 26 nJh )/ 3 B(-9´ )FG IS L1 to the point ;s,6 . EM=:9* Xs ( )/ M=Na )

- C 2U n=KX7 )- C request q³6 ?

o* IS Xs ( observationI- . M=:R q�* IX . personal ;s,6 . ;�j M=:9* to the point, Cut MotionIX . Xs ( ;s,6 . M=:9* q6A ¡B,6Y EM=NÀ·B -M=N

;. 8�- Oj Xs ( q

- �X:( wind up M=:9* q6A

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : m2= nª ©,= K-7 M=Na q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ 6�7,pà �6 .,w 2= n

3_ q¨w )- C I= . D56 C )FG

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: qU �P6 ? Xs ( M=: 8B5PX AE Xs ( q

- �X:( ;s,6 . M=:9*E

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : M=Na 82X nÀ; ? b1B,a ,Òà 82X nÀ

; ? b1B,a E,Ò

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: `( 5* M=: 8B5PX A Xs ( q- �X:( ;s,6 . M=:9* q6A

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : `( L1xw)* Narcotics )* )V (57 )/ M=Na ;s,6 .

b19* ,Ò IS mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . )* àB�-.( mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . )* B�-.( IÃ 6Y IÃ 6Y 9X : Forces )* ¸5V m8dP· M=NWc IÃ6Y IÃ6Y 9X : -M{= KV B5X C m -b,;K¢*,X . )* B�-.( ;s,= K

3¢-Na 6 . q WrB )FG mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . )* àB�-.( mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . )* B�-.( @Wr `(

90

q6 Ky§( )*à -M=NS(B( q6 Ky§( \À; ? )U O´ M=NWc request9* 9* )* IS qU �P6 ? mB,JWr licenses 56 7 )¬OU: R )

U C 5WG M=NWc L1 mR M=:R E Xs ( -M{= KV `( 9X : ¡�-K6:,X . ,ÇV E¡R -M{=KV mB5X C ,X . -b,;K¢* )* B�-.( B5X C m -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na 2= n

-°6 C o- ¹5- C,£

It¨_( o* ¥=.B ¥=KX: )FG 2= n-ð o

- ¹5- C,£ It¨_( o* mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na ¥=.B ¥=KX: )FG

@Wr I= . ©(5Ê ,-.9* ); OFG ,XY M=NWc 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p IS 9-7 ( ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(R

b,>=? 9X : b,>· M=NWcà 6s,6 t-�X: )* )å± (1 M=Na ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(R b,>· EM=NWc L2W c,È q6A,6 .

9X : IvJA (5WG ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(R b,>· M=NWc Anti Narcotics 5* )V M=NÂ ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(R b,>· M=NWc `( )* L1xw 9´( Xs ( (BR,-. o* -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C M=NÂ 56 7 ¡B,JWr research )FG q

- �;N 6Y (BR,-. )* )/ )V (57 IS mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . )* B�-.( 56 7 ( -b,-°µ IDPs -b,;K¢*,X . )* B�-.( )

U C ( M=NWc -b( 6�/ 5* �-KX7 )¢¬N¯. )V 9* -b( )* NIC mR )U O¬: R )U O´ M=NWc -b( 5* -b,;K¢*,X . o* nationality mR ¡R qU �´ E)FG q- �Ó= C -b,;K¢*,X . )* B�-.( nationality ,-K=NÂ ,-K; :( -b,_ ( )FG IS = .( B(-2W c )¯C 1B )* B�-.( nationality ¥a o

; ¹,6Y )FG mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . )* B�-.(E (2= nª ©(5Ê I= . )FG IS ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(R b,>=? 9X : b,>· M=NWc M=NÀQ= .R q�* 9X : q³6 ? criticize ,-.9*

;�¦6? -b,_ ( ,;.5WG )FG -M{= KV ¡B,JWr �= KÖ-O; : )

U C (96 : fxp( )FG (B,JWr �= KÖ-O; : )

- C 9* ,k ¡R,= K

-N6. �ÕÖj b,>=? 9X : I= . )FG IS @Wr ;�j5{Y o* fxp( ,-.9* ); OFG ,XY M=NWc IS -M6 7 b56 OÓ

3/ )* B�-.( 56 7 56 7 qË· )FG -b( 5* (B5X C EM=:9* M=Na )- C -M6 7 -M6 7

;s,°±(1 ,k 9*-R ,= K* )FG L1 ,;K¢*,X . -b M=Na )U C 5WG )FG I- . 5®Ò 8<6: -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na )FG

EI- . 8<6:5®Ò \= KVñ@¨[j) -b (,k militant wing ,k in-charge )FG ,-. B1( ,= K-:R

M=NJWr q; �¦· q³; ?à ,= K

-:R M=NJWr q; �¦· q³; ?

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_:No cross talk please. q6A

91

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : IS @=?( 5= O* @=?( )* `,X . militant wing )FG -M{= KV

6f ( ,= K-:R )

- C ;<6:,3. ,= .R9* -b,;K¢*,X . )* ,= .8�= Kj )

- C ¶{= .R ,= KV IS 9´( militant wing q�* )* `,X . )FG 5; C L1 \= KVñ@¨[j) -b (,kmilitant )FGE

9´( q�* )* `,X . )FG B1( `( ,kin-charge 5®Ò 8<6: )FG T67 5* 2= n3_

6s,6 t-�X: ,>· ,;.,6Y )FGà 2= n

3_ 5WGD Bà 2= n3_ 6s,6 t

-�X: ,>· ,;.,6Y )FGE 5; C I= . ,= K* )FG I= . ,= K* I½= Cd² )FGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: M=N>

- ? �6Y,_ 6�7,p Xs ( )* LB,6 . 8�- Oj )U O´ 5WG M=NWc q6Awind up 9* M=: 1R 8�- Oj M=Na wind up M=:9*Eq6A

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : q6A �M=Na ,;.9* b5WGE M=Na `( )* L1xw M=Na wind

up,;.9* b5WGE `( )* L1xw )`( æ±5j 9X : ;�¦6? )/ -B-dåj -M=NS(B( 8�- OU:(5X C � ( B8RB ( 9X : m8dP· )U O´ 5WG(

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Ñ= C23 ï

;C M=NÀ·BE q6A

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : 28 nS(8R 6�7,pà `( )* L1xw 28 nS(8R 6�7,pE 28 n[-Na

¡ q¨a o´ Xs ( 5* `( I°µRE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: �6Y,_ 6�7,p Xs ( dPX ? personal observation mR )FG B M=NWcE

92

6s,-K67 �6Y,_ �JA( : b,W c `( )* L1xw (BR,-. ,k 9*-R @Wr )

- C 9* E,= .R @Wr )

- C Narcotics,k 9*-R ,= .RE 2; n>6? I= . )FG IS ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(R )* )U OV 56 7 demand ,À·B )FG `( M=Na cut )

U C ,ÇV )P]�h 5; C 8�- Oy- ?B5´ ,ÇV ,W cB E)FG ;�¦6?

I= .9{3_

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: 6s,-K67 -b,Jå-C +x_( -¾ =�

3/ 6�7,pE -b,Jå-C 6�7,p to the

point B1( brief q6AE

6s,-K67 -b,Jå-C +x_( -¾ =�

3/: 24 ;�¦6? I= .9{3_ IS Xs ( )

- C )- O;: ( @Wr( 8�=O{6 t6�/ )* 9X :1( ;s,6 . )

- C 9* ,k æ±5j ,= .RE ;s,6 . I= . )FG IS = .( ©,_ ,6 K=:dÎ;C `( ;�j5{Y

5* )- C 5WG 5* ,= . ( )FGEb,>=? IX . @Wr M=NÀQ= .R 5; C )i ,-p( )

; C 5WG ,6Y )FG B M=NWcE ñ@¨[j

\= KV) -b (,k B53 ¢-Na ,À; ? terrorism, loadshedding à¡B,Ò -B12= n6. unemploymentà `( M=Na qË· 5WG o´E -M{= KV 9´( Xs ( 6f ( ;sD,Y M=NÀQ= .R 5; C

)®À�X? = .( ©,_ M=Na @Wr b,>· )¯�-�¦X? M=NWcE= .( ©,_ M=Na I= . ¡B,_ M=:-2= n X¤ ×896 : )*

9Ú�S )/ 9Ú�S q XY qU �´ M=NWcE 24 M=NJWr I= . ,-KPQ= .R )FG IS `( ;<º1 -b,;K¢*,X . @Wr( -M=:9

;: -2= nX¤ )FGE M=Na 6f ( b,>=? IX . 9=:dÎ;C 9* ,W cB b5WG B1( ¡2= nª q

- �;:( dËÔ M=N>- ?

)- O;N]Y b,>=? IX . b5´5V )* experience M=NWc 56 7 T=NXtX? T=NXtX? T=N

;. T=N;. ©,_

)/ )P8 �¬N6. )

U C 5WG B1( 56 7 26 nJh 8�{=KV( 5WG )* ( M=NWc)FG BE 24 (2= nª )- O¦· ,k B1( o8 ¹5PX A

;s,6 . )- C 9* ,k �ÕÖj I= . )FG IS 9´( q³6 ?( q³6 ? I= . non-serious Z( -�a ,;K®XY

)FG B ,Ò 5; C @Wr `( ^va 5* )´ ( )¢¬NS )V )* M=N

U.,6Y )´E 24 (� -Y )* )�/ (1 6s( 5; C M=NJWr serious ,-.5WG m89X : ,ÒE 6s( 5; C M=NJWr I= . ,-KX75Ê m89X : ,Ò IS I= . ^va 5WG ,Ò 5

; C I= . 8�6 g6? q³6 ? 5WG ,Ò B1( @Wr b,>=? IX . q³6 ? M=NÀ8 �=N6. )´ B1( I= . ^va

93

q³6 ? )´ ( )®¯Y ,ÒE across the board )P8 �¬N6. M=NWcE )- O;: ( m896 : m896 : @Wr(

;s,°±(1 ); C 5WG M=NWc -M{= KV ¶6 gË§ M=Na M=N>

- ? ,;. ( IS mB,JWr 9U:2= n8K-:( 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p b,>· M=NWcE M=N

U. ( M=NÀ8 �=N6. B1( +5± )* )- Oj ,_ ;s,6 . M=:9*E

= .( ;s,6 . Xs ( 5* bU1,;K6: IS 6�67 Xs ( ,k �U.,£à o

U ¹5* q³6 ? B 8�= KV 6�67 q- �X:(

+(5} )/ 8s5P6 A ,-KV56 C 0123 4 9* mR ,Ò 5; C I= . ^va @

; � -7 5WG )U C ,6Y ,ÒEIÁ-.5= O* 6f (

dPX ? @Wr `( 3�g6? M=Na ¥XY m89X : M=NWcE ;s(B ,k I°±(1 ,;.5WG )FG 9U:2= n8K-:( 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p M=N>

- ? ¶6 gË§ o; ¹ ( IS 9Ú�S M=NWcE @

U ?(9X : 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )

; C ( M=NWc 5; C 9U:2= n8K-:(

28 n[-Na M=N>

- ? ); C (E ,-K;:( (896 : -M

3 ¢= C9X : ( ¥XY ,W cB )FGE q³6 ?( q³6 ? L1 ¶6 gË§ M=Na M=N>- ? (

)FG B 6�67EM=NWc ,[= C( oU ¹5* I°±(1 ,;.5WG )FG 5; C ¸5V ¥=K WG1 2U n=KX7 9X : q³6 ? )

; C ( EM=NWc ( )* ^va )* ;sD,Y 5* ); OPQ= .R M=NWcE b,>=? IX . 5

; C = .( , 3_,J;? ,-K6: (5WG )FGE 24 M=Na

= .( o8 ¹5PX A q§ ;s,6 . ,-KPX A5X C ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS b5Ê9X : ,k 56 7 I°±(1 (5WG T67 )* B�-.(

)- O;: ( b5´5V 5* )]C I6 Y1 T=NÂ5X C )- C �= K¦

3§ E,= .R9* -M=N;. B(-2W c b5´5V )* �x-Yà (B-R

;s,6 . B5- } )/ M=N-K/ IS -M=N

;. B(-2W c b5´5V )* �x-Y Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( B ( o

; ¹5WG )FGE B1( 6f ( )/ ¶X g· ©,_ )®>¯? 6�67 = .( �-B56 7 o

- ¹5V,k )* B�-.( -M=N;. B(-2W c ¸5V ( )*

b5´5V )* b1dPê 5* ); C x6Y M=NWc 5; C Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( B ( b5- O;NS IX . o; ¹5WG )FGE 24 I= .

-Bd² ¥JÔà `( -Bd² ¥JÔ )/ 5; C ;�j5{Y M=N>- ? ¥XY q; �{_E 6�67 ;. = .( -b,[

-C( 5* -b5{_ M=N>

- ? 5WG ,ÒE 24 @Wr )- O¯: ( b1dPê )/ ¥»-C 9* 2W c,6 . )®¯Y )U O´ M=NWcE 24

investment b,>· )/ )U C ( o´à unemployment Xs ( b,>· )/ @

; �-7 M=:9*E¡B,_ M=:-2= nX¤ M=: 8B5PX AE M=NJWr ¥p( -2= nX¤ q; �PQ= .R )FG IS 9U:2= n8K

-:( IX . ,= K* +,k ,-.9* )FGEb,>6A à 6<=:d-Ô 6<=:d-Ô 9;: ,;.5WG ,6Y ,W cB )FGE 24 8�6 g6? -M6 : ,= K* B ,W c )FGE 2= nª ¡ request @

U ?(9X : 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )/ ,= K* )FGE M=Na q6�yz ;s,6 . M=N>

- ? b19*

94

,Ò IS L1 M=NÀQ= .RE -b( 5* = .( 6<=:d-Ô +(5} ,k 8�6 g6? ,-.,-K6: m89X : ,ÒE L1 `( q§9* 9X : )P

8 �¬N6. )U C 5WG M=NWc b,>6A ¡B,JWr Iª2; nth q³6 ? q³

8 �=N6. M=NÀ; ?E L1 `( q§9* 9X :

M=NWc b,>6A q¨ÀX �X? B,6 . mB,JWr 9=: -B1 @ØÙ}( q³6 ? )P

; ?E -M{= KV @Wr )- C q³6 �* q�* )* X¾ =�6:

M=Naà `( X¾-�=N6. ,= . `( X¾

-�=N6. M=Na TXC ( M=Na Zdi M=N>- ? `5¢gh ,= K*E -b( 5* q³6 ? -B 8�-Kµ

)U C R )U O´à -b( 5* q³6 ? 2= n

ØÞ-O=N6. @Q-.( 8sB5X N_ )* -B 8�-Kµ )

U C R )U OÉ5®XY q6A 1 8B5PX A M=NJWr I;KX: )FG IS Xs ( ×�-K/ 5* ¶X g· M=N>

- ? 1R )É I;KX: )FG 26 n=K-7 L(5- g

-?5; O-gX? b5V(1 5*à -M{= KV (� -Y )* )U OV -b( +5ÜÓj 5V b5´ 5* 5; C ¶X g· mR E1R -b( 5* 5; C ¶{= .R E5V 24 I= . elected ¸5V M=NWcE 24 = .( = .( L�-K6: elect 5WG 9* ,= . ( )FGE = .( L�-K6:à -M{=KV -b( )/ q³6 �* ,ÀX A5X C ,= K´ )FG IS Xs ( )* )º xw M=Na ,= K* IvUK¢j )FG

6<=:d-Ô ,= K* I>· M=NWc)FG B B1( ;sD,Y 9Ú�S ,6Y )FG B M=NWcE -b( 5* +B5* (B5X C )- C 9* B1(

I= . ^[=C8R )- C ,6 t6? )* )U OV ¶*B ,= .R )FGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: -b,Jå

-C 6�7,p 8�-KU :(1 Xs( M=:9*Einterior)/relevant ;s,6 . M=:9*E

6s,-K67 -b,Jå-C +x_( -¾ =�

3/: 24 ;s,6 . M=N-K/ IS 2W c )º xw M=Na ;�3¢WGR R9´ R56 75j

EM=NWcminorities ,k ©,= K-7 M=N>

- ? ,À·B ,6Y ,W cB )FGE b5´5V )* b5±xw M=Na I;KX: M=N>- ?

,= K* ,= K* (5WG ,6Y ,W cB )FGE I= . elected¸5V q Wr 5; C ( )* M=NU.,;K6: )É24 (� -Y )*

)U OV 9-7 ( M=Na M=Na ,;K¦· b5WG IS 9U:2= n8K

-:( )* B�-.( b,>=? IX . NISP L2= n-ð1 56 7 o

U ¹,-K6: )FG `( 5* ä56 O-Üj B1( ;<º,È B1 M=:9* IS,;. ^va q³X A( fd² )´ ( )®¯YE IÁ-.5= O*

investment o* 2W c -2= nX¤ ¥U.,£ )FGEB1( 9-7 ( M=Na (B-R @

U ?(9X : 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )/

= .( B1( q³6 ? -édÔ )FG B1( M=Na = .( ,8 .5PX A ,_ I°±(1 bU1,;K6: B1( `( )* �°6 C

95

;s,6 . b19* ,ÒE 24 M=Na -b( )* = .( MNA )/ xaE `( )- C ,>· (B-R B1 -B

)/ ¶; ?,W c U1xaE M=Na )- C ,>· IS b5= O* `( )

- C ,>· 6f ( @Wr -B(5- C Ñ= C2

3 4 )/ ¥a 9* )U C ( EM=NWc ¡9

-7 ( ;s,6 . 9* )* @; �-7 9* ,W cB 24Eb5WG )P]�h I= . M= N>

- ? ¶6 gË§ oU ¹ ( IS

`( mB,X t=�6: 5®Ò o* ;s,6 . )- C 9* M=Na -b( 5* b5= O* -é(2; nð( 5WG ,W cB )FGE I= . b5= O*

B53Ê ,X th )FG B M=NWc IS 5®Ò ( ,= K´E B1( = .( mB,JWr )- C (9X : 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p M=NWc 56 7 `( ,k nickname q³6 ? ); O

-: ,6Y M=NWcE ); O¦· M=NWc ***)FG ,= . I= . )FG L1 )FGE5; C (� -Y )* )U OV seriousness M=N

U.,-KX:(E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A )U C (B -M¢7 -B(5

- C 6�7,pE I= .***B1( Xs ( 56 7,k ØÛÆV )FG 5{_( expunge )

; C 9* M=NWcE ***)@Qt6? 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ Øä,çV( o

U ¹(1BB,k )/ � -�Y )U O¬NS )U O´(

)U C (B -M¢7 -B(5

- C -b,-Y : I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 E9{= KXN_ 6s,-K67 D(1! IJQth Iv -Y(R M=Na

¡R,= K-N6. Iª-R ¡B(R b,>6A ^va M=Na -Mj( 1 -b,a( )FG `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ ;�¦6?

mB,_ B1( q = .-R mB(R( q³6 ? `( )* ;�g;? M=NWcE 6�/ )/ )®>? M=Na (BR,-. o* ;s,6 . b19* ,ÒE (BR,-. )* 6f ( 56 7 ;sD,Y M=NWcE (BR,-. )* )®>? -M=Na2U n=KX7 5* b5¦- ?( )

- C ,8K WG ,= .R B1( ;s(B )* -M=N

;. )]�6? `( )* )- C ,8K WG ,k -M

3 ¢= NÁç= O8 :5- C ¡B,6Y ,= K* ,= K´E 2= n

-¤ I= . -b( ,-KX:(,k B,= K

;N -Y( )FGà -b( o* ÛUC(23 4 9X : L1 (B5X C M=N>

- ? ,;.9;:( ,À; ?E IÁ-.D,Y L1 (896 :

,ÀX A( +,k 9* ,W cB (BR,-. M=Na ¡2; n>6? )- C D )* )U OVà -M{= KV `5¢µ( )FG IS 6f ( ;.

)U O-: -M=Na2U n=KX7 o* appointment M=N>

- ? o*E (BR,-. 2= n-°6 C -M=Na2U n=KX7 )FG B1( b,W c1

;sD,Y I= . )FG 56 7 q-ßdh 2= n-ð qQva ,-KX:( q; �

-7,-K 3/ 8RB,k ,-.(5- O6: )FG ,XY `( )* )U OV (BR,-.

)* m-B(1BR )®À· M=NWcE 9´( +,w o- ¹,;K¢*,X . ¡2î3§ ,-KX:( 8RB,k )

- C (5- O6: )* )U OV ,;.,6Y )FG

96

5; C )/ ( ){É R )- C ,À· )

; C 89X : M=NWc B1( `( )/ B,6 . B,6 . 9{XY )U C (5ÄÂ )

; C ,6Y M=NWc B1( o8 ¹5PX A o

8 ¹5PX A `( M=Na M=N8.1,kB oV(8R o

; ¹,6Y M=NWcE q§( fd² 8sB5X N_,X . Tµ ( o* ;s,6 . )FGE )®À�X? ©,_ m2= nª = .( o

U ¹,À6 ? q¨w �J�h -b,-Y )

- C 9= : -B1 Iv -Y(R o* o´R56 75j M=Na ;s,6 . o* IS 8sB5X N_,X . Tµ ( )* 2W c,6 . 56 7 8�- O6g=?( ,= Kµ,a )FG `( ,k IJ

;?, -Y ,-.5WG )U OFG ,XYE 56 7 IS oU ¹5* L�-K6: q³6 ? 8sB5X N_,X .

)- C (5- O6: )* )U OV ,;.,6Y )FG 5; C 8�- O6g=?( `( 5* 2= nÀê ); O¬NÂ M=NWc B1( 6�67 ;. L1 -b( )/ â ,»j M=N>

- ? ,;.9* `( )* 8sB5X N_,X . M=Na M=N8.1,kB o

; ¹,6 t=�V(8R M=NWcE 5; C 9=: -B1

Iv -Y(R 6�7,p )- C ¡896 : -M=N½= C o

- ¹,W cR oU ¹(9* q³

; ? `( B5®¼ 9X : IS I= . ;�¦6? q³X A( b5¦- ?( )

- C ;s,6 . o* )FGà ¡896 : q³X A( q Wr�-., 3[-C o* )FGE @Wr `( )®[®_ M=Na (896 :

;�/R96 : -B +,k 9* M=NWc)FG B B1( Xs ( Zdi M=NÀQ= .R )É -M{= KV 6f ( = .( ©,_ 5WG ,= K´ )FG L1 8�- O6g=?( ,= Kµ,a q§( fd² )- O¯: ( +,k M=Na +9´24 ¥JÔ )FGE 6s,-K67 D(1! +x_( R,6 . ( qº,¼1 à,= .9= :( b,>=? 9X : q³6 ? ¥k5V 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ )* -M3 ¢{= KV( M=N>

- ? )U C (19* )U O´ 56 7

;sB( -B1 q¨-Y(R o* Iª-R ¡B(R q³

; ?E 6s,6 t-�X: M=Na 5; C b5¦- ?( )

- C M=N>- ? )

- C (19* -b( 5* )- O¯: ( ;sD,Y ,k @¨w )FGE`( )U OV I= . 6s,6 t

-�X: M=Na 5; C M=N>- ? M=N

U.(19* )É -M{= KV 9´( qº,¼1 M=Na,= .9= :( ¥k5V 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ )* -M3 ¢{= KV( 5WG )

; C ,6Y 5; C I= . qº,6 . b56 C5¿ )* )U OV = .( ©,3Kj @

U ?,£ o; ¹5WGE -M{= KV I= . +,k q³6 ? b5¦- ?( )

- C M=N>- ? ,= K* B1( I- . (2= nª ©,= K

-7 )FG IS ×�-K/ B1( 6s,6 t

-�X: M=Na B1( qº,¼1 M=Na,= .9= :( -M3 ¢{= KV( )

- C (9* ,k -b( ,k oU ¹5* +(9´19X :

)FGE T{8.5*B,-. )* mB,6 . M=Na -édÔ b19* ,Ò IS 56 7Anti Narcotics

Force )FG B1( `( 5* ©128 n-K* )- C 9* o* Iª-R ¡B(R ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(R o* )FGE M=Na

B5WGD o* ;s,6 . b19* ,ÒE 6f ( B5WGD M=Na qÎ= Cdi( ^Â,Jh )* ;�¦6? mB,_ L19´ `( B,6 .1B,k M=Na 3s5®a M=NWc B1( L1 +,w b5*824 9X : )

U C 5WGm8dP· d Ø�-C )

; C ( M=NWc B1( `(

97

)* L1xw T67 fd² -¾ =�3/ �= K

3/B 6�7,p )- C ;s,6 . o* IS ¸5V B1( ^va R5-7 q³6 ?

q- �;:( LR,= .

-Bconsume 9* )FG B M=NWc T{8.5*B,-. IS mB,JWr )- O¯: ( ¸5V )- O;: ( LR,= .

-B addict 5WG )FG B M=NWc IÁ-.5= O* +,w availability)FG B1( o

U ¹5* `( IX . 8�- Oy- ?B5´ o*

�d² )/ 8s1,kB M=N>- ? )FG T67 o* I6 Y1 )/ ¡B,JWr -b(56 75

- C ¥[-C L,6 K

; : 5WG q WrB )FGE -M{= KV (B,JWr Narcotics department `( )®[®_ M=Na o

U ¹5* ,-KX:( B(R9* M=N>- ?(R( 9* ,W cB )FGE q§( fd² Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( o* ;s,6 . )FGE FIA high profile cases M=NWc56 7 -b( 5* ,;KPQ= .R )FG B1( @

8 �¢* B1( @Q-.( T{=K

8 : )* -2ï= NS EM=NWc -M{=KV `( M=Na deputation IX . )- O;: ( R(di( 5* o

; ¹dP6 ? ,= K* ,= K´ )FGE q¨ÀX �X? b5; Oj5{Y M=Na q³6 ? B1( -b( )* )®À�X? B(1R( M=Na q³6 ? IS 56 7 -Mj �-K¢X C B1( ); O¬N>XA -b(2ïµ( M=NWc 56 7 ); OP]�Ë§ M=NWc IS ( -b )* )®>? 8�- Oy

8 ?B,X K=:8R M=Na -b( o* o

U ¹,J· M=Na oU ¹5* qË· )FG B1( -b( 5* o

U ¹5* )®UK¢j -M6 : )FG B M=NWc 5; C L1 approach); C 9* M=NWc

B1( deputation 9X : Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( m( M=Na )

; C ( M=NWcEB1( ;�¦6? mB,_ -b(2ïµ( 5* M=Na ,;K-:,6Y b5WG IS 56 7 ,>z,_ ©,_ )/ deputation 9X : Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( M=Na 56 75j R M=NWc -M{= KV -b( ,k q�X C(1 )* )U OV o

U ¹5* LR(B( M=N>- ?E 5; C `( )U OV M= Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG

IS Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( m( 5* 9´( Xs ( )

- C qå±(1 = .( effective department )* B5² 9X :à = .( q�

-N6t=?( )* B5² 9X : -b( +,k)/ ,-K=NÂ )FG 5; C `( )* )- O¯: ( 56 7 -b(2ïµ( M=NWc -b( 5* 8s5j19X : ,-.9* )U OFG ,XYà -b( o* Ivp57 o

U ¹(-di( o- ¹9* )U OFG ,XY B1( -ÅÓ6 C

56 7 deputation 9X : q3§B,ç/ )

U C D )U O´ M=NWc -b( )/ (B,»8OPX A ,-K®a )U OFG ,XYE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ;�¦6? I= .9{3_ Eq6A

98

)U C (B -M¢7 -B(5

- C b,-Y: M=Na9-7 ( -Mj( 1 -b,a( o* ;s,6 . b19* ,ÒE 6s,-K67 D(1!

qXA(9* ,k I°±(1 (5WG (896 :56 7 â,-K/5¢µ( I°±(1 ,À; ?E -M{= KV `( )å± (1 M=Na ¡B,JWr b5- C1R

b5; Oj5{Y ,k 56 7 I= .1B ,À; ? q- �Ó= C blame gameà L1 I>· )FG B )P

; ? 8sB5X C9U:( o* Iª-R ¡B(R -b( o* B1( L1 I>· )FG B )P

; ? 8sB5X C9U:( o* Iª-R ¡B(R -b( o* )FGE M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS I= . blame game M=N>

- ? o- ¹5WG )U OFG ,XY IÁv6 . q

- �X:( q- �X:( Iª-R ¡B(R ¡B5X C

o- ¹9* )U OFG ,XYE 5; C 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! q

- �X:( 9=:dÎ;C @

; � -7 )- C 9* )/ )®>? M=Na B5WGD )* )å± (1

o* ;s,6 . b19* ,ÒE B5WGD M=Na 56 7 ;<=:96 :96 : o* qU �´ )FG `( 9X : M=Na I= . ,-K¦· ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS

@¨ØÈ dPX ? @¨

ØÈ )FG ,;KÚ896 : )FG 5; C 8�j ,;.,6Y )FG -b5-7 dPX ? -b5-7 )FG ,;K¦6? )FG 5; C @6 A ,;.,6Y )FG

I= . (� -Y ,k �5-7 M=:9*E I= . (� -Y )* 2îº 5* -B(1 ( )- O¬: R oV(1 ;s,6 . )FGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A I= .9{

3_ q6AE

)U C (B -M¢7 -B(5

- C -b,-Y : = .( 8�-K{= K/ mR M=:R )P]�h @; � -7 9* ,W cB Eb5WG -b5-7

l7,-. q³6 �* ,Ç= OU :(Bb M=N>- ? ,;.,6YE 9´( Xs ( o

U ¹5* Å-g3§à o

U ¹5* 2W c,È ¡BR,½V( 5WG oU ¹5*

5WGà9´( `( ;s,=.dØ�-C)* )/ Xs ( 5* �x;K

-7( 5; C)FG `( o* -B(1 ( )- C ,6 .R ,k I½= Cd²

I= . M=N>- ? )FG IS Xs ( IvJA B1 ( 5WG M=N

U.,6Y B1( ;s(B )* oU ¹,É 8B ( )]�6? barrier

)- C ,À8 ?( M=N

U.,6YE `R )8 O-NÀê ;. I- .,= K

3¢71 R� 3[3¢;C 5WG ,;. )FG B B1( Xs ( M=N>· IS M=NJWr

5; C I;KX: q Wr M=N>- ? ,À; ? IS I= . 6<* ,= K´5WGE

99

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E

)

U C (B -M¢7 -B(5- C -b,-Y: 6s,-K67 D(1! 5®Ò 8<6: o* ;�=Oy Wr( M=N>

- ? )FGà ;�=Oy Wr( `( ;s,6 . o* )FG IS `( )P¯�=�X:)* -b5* q§ ;<º,È q³

; ? IS L1 5®Ò 8<6: )- Oj ,_)* T=NÂ5X C qÐ= KP6 ? q6 . q

- �6: q WrB B1( 5®Ò 8<6: b,=.8B,Ò L,6 K

; : 9* ,;. ,W cBE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E 6s,-K67 -b,[7( -b,JA9V( E 6�7,pTo the

point and brief please.

6s,-K67 -b,[7( -M� yA9V( ¡B(-dh: 24 I= .9{3_ IS Xs ( )

- C )P]�h )- OV 56 C ,k æ±5j ,= .RE24 M=Na to the point ;s,6 . b19* ,ÒE 6f ( mB,JWr ^vamB5X C 5* ;�3¢WGR

¡R9´ )- C 8�=OXNÂ M=Na B)V ,À· E)FG mB,JWr ^va 5* -M=N

;. ¡896 : b1-2= nX¤ ,k ,-Kj,_ )FGà security, economy, energy and inflation 24 M=Na Xs ( )/ -édÔ ,-.9* ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS 6�67 ;. Xs ( )* ^va ;sD,Y)* = KP

8 ? M=N>- ? b5WG

)´à 6�67 ;. Xs ( )* ^va o* o8 ¹B5= O{= K/ 2; n>6? M=N>

- ? o´5WGà I= . 6�/ M=:-2= nX¤ TXC ( M=Na inter linked Xs ( )- O

;N]Y q-ßdh @=?8R M=:R,-K6:à Xs ( ^va)* M=Na crisis M=NWcB )´E Xs ( )* ^va M=Na o

U ¹5* I[= NX. M=N>- ? )

U C ( ,ÒE 24 ©,Y I= .5; C

)FG IS ,-K;:( @Wr( -M3 ¢= C9X : ( ¥XY ,W cB )FG B1( @

U ?(9X : 28 n[-Na 6�7,p -b,;K¢{6Y,; . )U O´ )

U C 5WG M=NWcE m896 : `5¢µ( )/ ,-K¦· ,;.89X : )FG B1( ¥k TXC(1 )

U C ( M=NWcE Ñ= OX7 � ( qhB ( �,8K/ ,k 2W c,6 . ,k 5

8 C B ,À; ?à 6�67 -b( 5* I;KX: xXY IS ,-K;:( @Wr( -M3 ¢= C9X : ( ¥XY ,W cB )FG

5; C b5¦- ?( ()- C ,-KX: (B5µ tour cancel 9* ,= .REL1 `( ^va M=Na R56 75j E)FG B

100

2= nU.2= n8K-:( 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p 5; C -b(5= C( M=Na ); C ( q Wr M=N>

- ?E I= . 5; C 8�- Oy- ?B5´ o*

seriousness )FG IS 8�- Oy- ?B5´ q

- �;NS serious E)FG

Xs ( o* minorities IX . )®JA 5WG M=NWc)FG BEmB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na minorities -b( )]C b1B,XY ,k ,= K* B5Ü± )FGE Xs ( b56 O=:d- Ô 5* 5; C 8B5PX A M=:Rà Xs ( -M=:2= n8K

-NJ= �VB,X .)* Øä5Ægh M=N>- ? M=NWcE ¡B,JWr = .( ¥6K=:9-: ( 26 nJh IX . IvJA 5WG à( 6s,6 t

-�X: q6 Ky§( )* = .( 26 nJh 98 :5j m1 )/ ã(5- }( )U O´ 5WGà -b,;K¢X 75®6 . )* = .(sitting MPA 5* �=K¦

3§ 9* ,= .R ,= KÉI= . 6�/ 2= nU.2= n8K-:( ¡28 n[

-Na ,k +,k )FG IS ^va )* ;sD,Y 5* )PQ¬.RE ,-K;:( `5¢µ( â,-. I°±(1 qXA(9* M=Na (5WGE mB,JWr Ñ= OX7 28 n[

-Na ;s(B 5* b,W c1 -M=N

;. )]�6? X¾-�¦X? )U OÉ 2= nU.2= n8K

-:( 28 n[-Na 5* I= . I;KX: q Wr M=N>

- ?à T-Nç= C8R 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p ,k o

U ¹5* -b,= K6: ;. M=N>- ? ,= . (à ©B 8�=Kµ -B28 n[

-Na o* �d² )/ -b( o* ;sR,= K} )- C 9* o

U ¹5* M=N>- ? ,= KÉ mB,JWr 2= nUKX7 -M=Na ©1x6 . 58 OP6 ? 6�7,p -b( o* ;sR,= K} )U OV )*

)U O´à¡B,JWr ¡B5X C ×�-K/ I-K=N6.,k -b( o* ;sR,= K} )U OV )* qU �É m896 : `5¢µ( )/ ,-K¦· ,;.89X : IS 56 7 ^va ;sD,Y)* M=NWcE

24 ¶X g· IpdÔ )®>? B�-K{_ qh,-. = .( Å-g3§ )

- C ’�= ., 3_ L1 q³6 ? 5®Ò 8<6: ,k oU ¹5* I;K 3/B B(R ,À; ? ,= . ,= K* ,À; ?à ¶8 ? ( )8 O

-NÀê ;. `( )- C mB5X C +x_( R,6 . ( 5*

©,J-Ô9= : ,= .,-K6: (5WG ,À; ?E24 m896 : `5¢µ( )/ ,-K¦· ,;.89X : )FG IS qXA(9* M=Na -M

3 ¢= C9X : ( ¥XY ,W cB )FGà Xs ( )

- C 6s,6 t-�X: -B96 g

-�=:B 5* q =K WG 28 nX.,k -B )* )V M=NWc)U C Rà �-K/ ×

-B96 g-�=:B )* )U OV Xs ( 5* q =K WG -B28 nX.,k ,= . b,=.

8B,Ò )V )* )- O¬: R )* )U OV I[= NX. M=N>- ? E)FG m896 : `5¢µ( )/ ,-K¦· ,;.89X : )FG IS ¡B,JWr ×�-K/ 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ )- O¯: ( own IX . ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ ,k IJ

;?, -Y 9* q WrB )FGE 24 Xs ( )/ `5¢µ( )/ ,-K¦· ,;.89X : )FGà

101

mB,JWr = .( ¥6K=:9-: ( 26 nJh 6�7,p)U C (B )

- C ,>· ,À; ? IS mB,JWr ^va M=Na )- O;: ( foreigners +5Pê M=NWc)FG B IS -M6 7 ,k o

U ¹5* I;KX: q³6 ? M=N>- ? )FG IS T* �ÕÖj )/

-b,;K¢*,X . M=Na )U C ( 5WGà ,= K* )

- C 9* )U C ( 5WGE q³6 ?( ¶; ?B,-. -b,;K/9= : -B1 M=Na 56 7 -M

3 ¢= C9X : ( ¥XY ,W cB )FGà Xs ( )

- C IDPs )* )U OV ,= K* ,XY5Ê E)FG ¥6K=:9-: ( @U ?(9X : 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p )U C ( B1( = .( ¥6K=:9-: ( 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p ,k +,-. )V ,= KV IS L1 ,À6 �-N_ © M=NÂ )´E

`( M=Na displaced q³6 ? b5WG )´à 24 IDPs M=Na o

U ¹5* B1 -�°j ¸5V q³6 ? b5WG )´E -b( ,k -b,_9X : ©,Y -b5* ,Ò5WGà ,6Y -b()* ,k ©,Y -b5* )P¯A 5X C ,ÒE M=Na 9

-7 ( M=Na ;s,6 . ,-.9* b5WG,XY ,Ò IS 56 7 State terrorism Punjab Government o* �d² )/ o

U ¹5WG )FGE -bR m8B,>=?R ¶8 ? ( b5´5V 5* �=K¦3§ 9*

,= .R ,= K´ ’ LB,= K´ ’¡B5Êà `( )* T=NÂ5X C�°6 C ©,;KXN[WG M=Na qU �´ )FG -B28 nS(8R 5* `B5µ )

- C 9* )U OV )* IS,;. 8sB5X CB ¥=.�6 K;: 9* -b()* )* )- O¯: ( l7 M=Na o* E)

U C ,6Y o8 ¹ ¡1 6¾ =�

8 :5µ M=Na ); OPQ= .R )FG B IS 6�67 6s,6 t-�X: T=NÂ5X C -b( 9X :1()* -M

3 ¢= C9X : ( 9* q WrB q³

; ?à b,= .B5X 7 q³6 ? 9* q WrB q³; ?à Xs,3_ )/ -b,a,_ ¡B5X 7 9* q WrB q³

; ?à 56 7 ` o* -b,kR )/ 3T=NS ¡B5X 7 9* q WrB q³

; ?à I= . 5; C 6s,6 t

-�X: 8�- Oy- ?B5´ ,k ©,Y E)FG

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_E

6s,-K67 -b,[7( � yA9V( -M ¡B(-dh: M=NJWr M=NWc); O¦· IS Sindh Government serious M=N>

- ? 24E)FG ¡B,JWr 8�- Oy- ?B5´ ;�¦6? serious à)FG ¥»V,6 . ¾ =�g

ß +,k 9* q WrB )FGE

102

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 -b,[7( � yA9V( -M ¡B(-dh: 24 = .( E 8�- Oj 2= nU.2= n8K

-:( 28 n[-Na 6�7,p 5; C

); C ( q Wr M=N>

- ?E (� -Y )�/ (1)* 56 7 ,-K;:( I[= NX. advertisement )* )U OV Xf9-7 9* M=NWc)FG Bà ¶X g· )¢¬N¯. -b( )* )U OV q³6 ? ¶*B M=NÂ IS L1 `U1,W c M=Na

M=NU. (E I= .9{

3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E -B26 nJh )/ 3 B(-9´ )FG IS speech)

; C 9* )U C 5WG `( 5* interrupt I- . M=:9*à )®>? ¶{Â mR)* ,= .R M=:9*E +x-w B124 -b,-Y

E 6�7,p

6s,-K67 +x-w B124 -b,-Y: �@��6 C �'( -M� yA�9~V( �@= ��7�9~V(E I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E

;�{vJh R(R(� -Y oU ¹,>; �

-:( â -B,-. B1R )/ B-9´ q WrB )FG B1( ^va 5* )]C B,J3§ o

- ¹1B�-.( B1( o

- ¹12= n6. 23 ï= C9X : ,k ,-Kj,_ ,-.9* 89X : ,W cB E)FG 6f ( ¡B,JWr I- . 5; C o; ¹,= .d

Ø�-C M=:�Y24 Øä5Ægh M=NWc B1( I- . q Wr ,= Kµ(d

-å6 7oU ¹ M=:�Y24E L1 )º xw M=N>

- �67 ,8 .,¼ ,>· ,;.,6Y )FGà L1 M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS 6�/ )/ 896 : × 6�gh)* -M²1 )P

; ?à ¾ =�gß -b,J¨[j )P

; ?à ¾ =�gß

o- ¹,;K¢*,X . )P

; ?Eb5¦- ?( )- C -b,;K¢*,X . o* ã,½6 C B1( q; �jx_ o* \-K67 ¡89V B1( -M=:R +x_(

o* q³6 ? ã,½6 C 1(B q; �jx_ o* \-K67 ¡89VE 6f ( M=NJWr TXC ( M=Na ;�/R 1 -b,6 K=:9´ 9* ,= .R ,= K´ 6f (E)FG -b( I£xw ;s,6Y M=Na ©R,6 . I;K/(5

- g-? @Wr -M

3 ¢= C9X : ( 9* M=NWc)FG BE ;�3¢WGR b1R9´ ¶; ?,_)* ¶; ?,_ )]C L,-K´ o

- ¹,[-C( M=N

-.,6Y q³6 ? æU C,-p 5WG q WrB M=NWc B1( M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§

b5WG IS ¡B5X C +5± = .( 6s(d� -¿( )* @z,w M=Na )FGà ¶*R B1( 6¾-?B M=Na x;K6Na

)FGE

103

q§( fd² 9´( -b,;K¢X 75®6 . 5* ,ÀQ= .R )U C ,6Y 5; C L1 q³6 ? ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ ,k B,» 3/ )FGE

b,W c1 q³6 ? o´�t=�®w �-K¢X C M=NJ= �Ø�-O; : ;�¦6? LR,= .

-B active M=NWcà ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ M=Na 3s5®a M=NWcE mB,JWr -BB8RB,6 . IX . mB,JWr I= .,[y Wr ^Â,Jh M=Na 8�=O®Õ

- C5± @U ?,£ )¬O*

M=NWc)U O´à -M6 7 oU ¹5*,k q§,= K/ -B(56 7 M=N>

- ? ,;K-N6.E b,W c1 9X : -b,;K¢*,X . o

- ¹1B�-.()* ;sxa,°j M=Na 56 7 ¸5V ;�® -Y(�a M=NWc)

; C 9*àM=N>- ?( I= .,a24 q³6 ? @Wr(di ,= K* ,;.,6Y M=N>

- ?(à)FG \-K-N=.98 : q³6 ?

¡R o; ¹,6Y à)FG M=N>

- ?( It¨_( q³6 ? ,= K¦h ,;.,6Y,= K* -b,;K¢*,X .E)FG B�-.()* q�* )/ @Wr -.B -�I- .( M=NWc); O¬NÂà q�* )/ I- .(d�µ ); O¬NÂ M=NWcà q�* @Wr)/ = KP6 ? ); OÄ-.,a M=NWcà)- O¯: ( foreign

reserves )- C ,É896 : )¬OV )* ×89= :8R -M=Nv6 . -B9V(8R )U OV M=NWc)

; C ,6Y B1( `( o* ;s,W c56 71 q³6 ? M=N>

- ? oU ¹,;K6: M=N

;.,6YE I6 Y1 �,p 2W c, ØÈ )FG IS 56 7 ¶X g· ,;K=:R )FG `( )* ¶X g· ;s,6 KV,Þj q³6 ? M=NWc)

; C 5WGEq�* o* proxy war Pakistan )* B�-.( ¡89V q WrB,6Y E)FG

-b,;KÆ;C +,½j)* 9X : )]C L,-K´ -b,J¨[j -M=:9

U:( -B 5* �=K¦3§ ,= K* )FG ,; .,6YE 6s,-K67

9{= KXN_ ! I= . x>X? I°±(1 M=N>- ? E)FG mB5X C ^va B�-.()* = .( @=�¢Ö

;C ,k ¥JÔ 0123 4 9* ,= .R ,= K´ )FGE I= . 5

; C ^va 5; C D IÂ( D( ' +,-.)* )/ ¥p,Y ,= K* ,= K´ -M{= KV `( )* �p,½j mB5X C M=N>

- ? ){_ 5WGà @Wr = .( +5± M=N>- ? -M6 : E){_ M=NJWr = .( +5±

)- O-N]. M=N>

- ? ,= .R ,= K´E LR5X 7 ;�¢´( (B,JWr +5= C ¡R( -B ( )FG LB�-KX: ;�¢´( -b,;K/1�-K WG ,k +5= C ¡R( -B ( )FGE = .( -bR -b,;K/1�-K WG o

8 ¹)* ¡1 IX . = .( L9*( -�a ,À; ?à = .( comparison 3T=NX. ,= K* ,W cB,6Y ,À; ? 5; C -b,;K/1�-K WG )* q�* compare )

- C q�* o- ¹,;K/1�-K WG X�

3/B 8�= KV )/ ;s,6 . o* IS 6f ( 14 ;�¢´( 5* -b,;K¢*,X . R( -B ( (5WG )FG B1( 15 ;�¢´( 5* -b,;K/1�-K WG B1( 6f ( -b,;K¢*,X . b,>· (8dP· )FG B1( -b,;K/1�-K WG b,>· (8dP· )FGE q§,= K/ ;�=OÜ

- g3§ )

- C >·)* ,T* -b,;K¢*,X . o* ;s,6 . ); C 9* 5WG 56 7 +x_( )* +,-. 9X :

104

¥p,Y ,= K* ,= K´ ,À; ? b,W c1 6f ( oU ¹5* -b,J¨[j M=N>

- ? )FGE b,W c1 6f ( ¡�-K6:5= CR M=NWc b,W c1 ¡5®= .96 : M=NWc b,W c1 I°= N 3_ M=NWc B1( mB,_ TXC ( M=Na ;�/R 1 -b,6 K=:9´ M=NWc = .(

m241R ,k xÒ 8s,k 9* M=NWc)FG BE b,W c1 6f ( oU ¹5* �6 t�j Øä5Ægh M=N>

- ? oU ¹5* +,a( L,ÒB,6 .

Øä5Ægh M=N>- ?E o

U ¹5* ã,= KV1( +(9*( o* L,ÒBR Øä5Ægh M=N>- ? o

U ¹5* â5X 7 B5X 7(,W c B( -B,6 . Øä5Ægh M=N>

- ? oU ¹5* ,6Y9´ Øä5Ægh M=N>

- ?E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A 8�-KU :(1 Xs( )¬O]g=�*E

6s,-K67 +x-w -b,-YB124: M=Na 8�-KU :(1 Xs( ,;.9* b5WG )P]�h 8�6 g6? M=Na q³6 ? 9=:dÎ;C

M=N>- ? )

- C 9* ¡R qU �É 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ 56 7 M=Na ;s,6 . ,-.9* ,;K WG,XY b5WG L1 relevant )FGE m2= nª o

U ¹,À6 ? R5y�h -b,-Y oU ¹-9{XY( 6f ( Ù1,W c M=Na R56 75j M=N>

- ? B1( I3[= NJWr M=Na -b( ,k ©R )/ +(2; n¤( ,;.9* b5WG B1( m896 : B5- } )/ -b( o* ;s,6 . ,;.9* b5WGE b5¦- ?(

)- C I3[= NJWr ¶*R )* ¶; ?,_ ;<=:B5¦Ë6A 5* b,>· b,>· )/ -b,ÕÖ

-C ,;.5WG )FG )¢¬NS -b,ÕÖ

-C ,;.5WG )FG B1( ;<=:B5¦Ë6A )* �x-Y -b5* +,k ,;.9* )FGE 6s( q³6 ? L1 ); O¦· M=NWc IS ;<=:B5¦Ë6A md�-7 M=Na )FGE ,-K=N½= C L1 = KP

8 ? ); O¦· b5WG )´ -M{= KV M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS ;<=:B5¦Ë6A )/ LR,= .

-B -b,;K¢*,X . md�-7 M=Na )FG ;�=O-:,;K¢*,X . md�-7 M=Na )FG B1( ¡B,JWr )

- C ( oV(1 M=Nv[-C md�-7 M=Na M=NWc -b(B1( ,k ¥6KÖ

;N[j 3 1�-th 5WG ,»X 7 )FGE b5¦- ?( )

- C ,>· IS ;<=:B5¦Ë6A 5* )- C ,X t6? )* )¬OV ’ M=Na b5¦· ,Ò ;<=:B5¦Ë6A )

- C ,X t6? )* )¬OV M=N>

- ? -b,;K¢*,X . 5* )- C ,X t6? )* )¬OV `( +5± 5* )

- C ,X t6? )* )¬OV )¬OU : ( ISSL M=NÀQ= .R Z(dÔ B�-.()* ,= K* 5WG ,W cB )FGE Z(dÔ o* division ,k IvÕ=Oµ 5WG ,»X 7 )FGE -M=N

;. b5Ü7 M=Na Z(dÔ 5* ,8K-:,6 . )U C ,6Y ,ÒE xÒ( I- ., 3[

-C -b5* 5WG ,Ò (B,JWr I= .,[y Wr 5WG ,Ò -b5*B1( 5WG ,ÒE @Wr b5WG )É M=NJWr TXC ( M=Na ;�/R 1 b,6 K=:9´ ,= K* ,6Y ,W cB

105

)FGE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ M=Na I= . ,-K¦· L,XY ,W cB b5WG IS @· )/ @· )¢¬N]Y @U ?(9X : 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p Ñ= C23 ï

;C )U C D q³X A( ;s,6 .E 26 nJ

;�/ M=Na m( oX¹ q§ oU ¹5WGE +,J

;? ¥»= O8N=KV5X C -2= n8.B,X . )

- C M=N>- ?( 8<=: 8�-K=Na ,= .RE -M

3 ¢= C9X : ( M=Na M=NU.,6Y ;s(9*( -�a M=:9*E ;s(9*( -�a )

U C 5WG 6s,= Kj,k b5= O* M=N>- ? )

U C 5WG ,= K* hurdles M=NÀ; ?E -M{= KV @· )/ @· @

U ?(9X : 28 n[-Na 5* U1,W c M=Na ( 9*

`( Ù1,W c 5* R,J;�}( M=Na ,-K=NÂ )¬OFG ,XY ,À; ?E `( m( oX¹ q§ 5* R,J;�}( M=Na M=N>- ? ,= KV

Ù1,W c 5* R,J;�}( M=Na M=N>- ? ,= KVE (B,JWr I6 .5¿ )* oX¹ )* 56 7 frontline

province )FGE b1B(-2W c M=N-.,6Y b,W c1 æ

U C,-p 5WG qQXY M=NWc -b( o* -2= n8.9X :(9X : -b( o* M=:R(�=K

U :,6Y L,6 K; : 5WG qQXY M=NWcE B,J

3�= N6. )¯�6? @=�;N=. 5WG ){¯Y M=NWcE B,J

3�= N6. M=N-K¦6? ¡B,JWr L5= O6:

5WG qQXY M=NWcE -b( o* 6�- g;�-Na ;sR,= K± 5* R,J;�}( M=Na M=N>

- ? ,= KV ,= KÉ

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E I= . 8�6 g6? 9=:dÎ

;C M=N>- ? )FGE ¶8 ? ( 8�- Oj 5WG )U O´

M=NWc 1R 8�- Oj M=Na 8�-KU :(1 Xs( M=:9*E

6s,-K67 +x-w -b,-YB124: M=Na q- �X:( ;s(-R o* ;s,6 . M=N>

- ? 9* ,W cB E M=Na q- �X:(

o8 ¹B,X . o* ;s,6 . M=N>

- ? 9* ,W cB )- O¯: ( -b(�-., -Y o* ;s,6 . M=N>- ? 9* ,W cB )

- C ( b5V(1 b5®[-C

o* ã,½6 C B1( `( )* ¥6KÖ;N[j o* ;s,6 . 9* ,W cB b5WGE `( )¬OV Xs ( ¡2= nª ;s,6 .

B5- } )/ M=N-K/E M=Na ,-K¦· L,XY ,W cB b5WG = .( -9= :56 g

;? q³; ? m2= nª o

U ¹,À6 ? R5y�h -b,-Y oU ¹-9{XY( 6�7,p o* IS = KP

8 ? )FG 8�- OU:(56 7 -M3 ¢= N_ ,-.5WG E)¬OFG ,XY +,J

;? 6�- g;�-Na b1�-KU:,J

-? 5* = .( IÃ6Y ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XYE b5

- C(dËQY 5* 96 7( ;s ,k L2W c, ØÞj ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XYE `( +5± )* )´ ( X¾§ ,-KV56 C )¬OFG ,XY 8s5P6 A )/ 6s,-K;N 6Y( ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XYE

106

+5± 5* ,-.,;K6: )¬OFG ,XY IS root cause ,= K* )FG `( +,J;? terrorism

,kE `( )* )P¯�=�X: -b5* M=NWc IS 109 -M=Nv6 . 9V(8R o* bleeding 5WG qQXY )FG `( 6<=:d-Ô +5± o*E `( )* )P¯�=�X: )¢

-C 5* 2Í,-K} M=NWc 56 7 -b,;K¢*,X . 5* destabilize ,-.9* ); OFG ,XY M=NWc disintegrate ,-.9* ); OFG ,XY M=NWcE -b,;K¢*,X . )* B�-.( I- ., -Y qÐ-K67 ,-.(9* ); OFG ,XY M=NWcE q

- �/ I°= N 3_ 9* )* b5= OU:,À6 ? 5* b5= OU:,À6 ? )/ ,-.(89V ); OFG ,XY M=NWcE 3 -B,_ )* )P¯�=�X: ,= K*E (2= nª ,-K; :( �ÕÖj )FGE @· )/ @· b5

- C(dËQY 5* ;s96 7 ,k L2W c, ØÞj ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XY `U1,W c )* B�-.( ,-. ( )¬OFG ,XY B1( ( 9* +5± 5* R,J;�}( M=Na ,-K=NÂ )¬OFG ,XY B1( +5± 5* ,-.,;K6: )¬OFG ,XYE `( M=Na o

U ¹5* ^3_ M=N>- ? 9´( ¡8dPê 9X : )

- C 5X C 1R M=NWc L1 abnormal 5WG ,Ò 56 7 )¦· ,Ò (B ;s )* )

- C 5X C 1R M=NWcE @Wr -M6 7 b53Ê -B,_ ,k B,» 3/ M=NWc @Wr )- O¯: ( b5= OU:,[y Wr o* b53Ê -B,_ ,k B,» 3/ M=NWcE -M6 7 ,k @Wr +R )

; C dP6 ? M=NWc -b( o* b53Ê -B,_ ,k B,» 3/ M=NWcE M=N>

- �67 @Wr most favorite I6 YBR )- O¬: R o* ;s,6 . ); C 9* M=NWc -b( o* b53Ê -B,_ ,k B,» 3/ M=NWc B1( b5

- C(dËQY 5* ( 9* `( 9X : ;s,6 . o- ¹9*

)¬OFG ,XY B1( )- O;NS )

U C 5WG M=NWc ;s,°±(1E 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ )¢¬C ( ;sD,Y M=Na insurgency )/ @Wr B-9´ )FG B M=NWcE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: `( 5* conclude M=:9* within one minute.

6s,-K67 +x-w -b,-YB124: ( 8B5P; ? ,_ Ivp57 (�= KX: M=:9*E 8�6 g6? `,X . 5WG )

U C ,6Y ,ÒE +,J;? 9;: Xs ( 5* ;s,wdh M=Nva oE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_E

107

6s,-K67 +x-w -b,-YB124: B1,X . )U C (56 g

-?( M=:9* )´ 6�/ ¶X g· 5WG ,Ò -M{= KV -b,;K¢*,X . 5WG ,Ò 5

; C 6�/ ¶X g· 5WG ,ÒE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ¡2= nª ¡B5X C ;s,6 . M=N-K/E 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_

M=NÀQ= .R oU ¹5* q³6 ? ^va o* 1R ;sB( -B1 6�/ )/ @Wr( o

; ¹5WG M=NWc ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(R B1( ;sB( -B1 I6 YB, -YE seriousness 6f ( o* ;�j5{Y I- . )P]�h o

U ¹5* 9= : -B1 I6 YB, -Y d Ø�-C (

,W cB )FG B1( I- . q Wr )P]�h oU ¹5* Iv -Y(R9= : -B1 d Ø�

-C ( ,W cB )FGE oU ¹,>; �

-:( ;sB -�°j )* ¶; ?,_ m2= nª )¬OV ¥6.,£ +(2; n¤( )FGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: M=N>

- ? M=N>- ?E Xs ( 2U n=KX7 5* T=CB 8�= .( M=:9*E -b,-Y 6�7,p I= .

personal observation I- . M=:RE Xs ( = .( 8�- Oj M=Na 8�-KU :(1 Xs( M=:9*E Eq6A

6s,-K67 +x-w -b,-YB124: Xs ( )- O¯: ( b5= OU:,À6 ? 5* M=N>· IS )P]�h interrupt I- .

M=:9*E 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! m( oX¹ q§ )* �°6 C terrorism oU ¹5WGE +x_( R,6 . ( )*

B�-.( terrorism oU ¹5WGE ¡B,JWr 8<*28 n_8R T

8CB5* )* B�-.( terrorism oU ¹5WGE

L,-K´)]C xk1 o* M=N-.,6Y M=N

UKÉ 6¾ 6A -b,6 K7,p o* M=N-.,6Y M=N

UKÉ +x_( R,6 . ( o* ¡-26 n_ ¡ 8�-Kj M=Na terrorism o

U ¹5WGE I8 KU:5* M=Na terrorism oU ¹5WG -b,;KÆ

;C M=Na terrorism o

U ¹5WG 6�/ )/ ×896 : 9* qXA(9* M=Na terrorism oU ¹5WGE -b,;K¢*,X .

¥-K3¢= N-.28 n-.( 8sB5X C2U n=.( 9X : terrorism o

U ¹5WGE b,>· q³; ? ;sB( -B1 Iv -Y(RE b,>· )P

; ? 9=: -B1 Iv -Y(RE ;s(B LB,= K´ )]�6? -M

3 ¢= C9X : ( 0123 4 ,;.5WG )FG m241R -bR ( 9* statement ¡R o

; ¹,6Y )FGE -M3 ¢= C9X : ( )

- C 5X C 1R )]�6? @; � -7 5WG ,= KÉ 9=: -B1 Iv -Y(R

m2ï=N;. -B1B Ù1,W c M=Na ( 9* statement ); O¬: R M=NWc B1( M=N>

- ?( ( 8�-.5Ú8R ,;.,6Y )FG

108

B1( -b( )* )P¯�=�X: -0(B5Ê b,_B M=:-2= nX¤ M=NU.,ÇV o

; ¹,6Y M=NWc IS 5PQ= .R 9=: -B1 Iv -Y(R b,>· )FGE 8�-.5Ú8R 9* U1D B1( M=N>

- ?( qXA(9* 56 g=�P6 ?E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ;�¦6? I= .9{3_ B124 -b,-Y 6�7,pE,= .9

3: oU ¹5; O67 I6 K7,pE

Iª2; nth ,= .9

3: oU ¹5; O67 : I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E 24 L1 )- OV 56 C M=:R )´ 5; C ;s,6 . b19* Eo´

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: to the point ;s,6 . M=:9* relevant M=:9* 8�6 g6? M=:9= :dÎ

;C M=N>- ? M=NWc q6AE

Iª2; nth ,= .93: o

U ¹5; O67 : 6f ( @Wr 56 7 b,>=? )P8 �¬N6. M= NWc B1( T67 05-¿5j 9X : T{_8R

9* )FG B M=NWc L1 )FG ¡28 n[-Na � ( 9= :2= n8K

-:(E 9Äa `5¢µ( )* ¶; ?,_ ,-K¦· 89X : ,W cB )FG IS 28 n[-Na 6�7,p 5; C R56 75j q Wr M=N>

- ? M=NWc IÁv6 . mB5X C -M3 ¢= N_ M=Na L1 M=N>

- ? )U C ( M=NWcE

T67 05-¿5j 9X : ;s,6 . 9* )FG B M=NWc B1( L1 b,>=? R56 75j M=N>- ? M=NWcE m896 : `5¢µ(

)* ¶; ?,_ ,-K¦· 89X : ,W cB )FGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Minister of State M=NWcE mB,_ )P8 �¬N6. M=NWcE

Iª2; nth ,= .9

3: oU ¹5; O67 : ©B 8�= Kµ 28 n[

-Na o* M=Na ;s,6 . 9* q WrB b5WGE28 n[-Na � (

8�=O8N_ o* M=Na ;s,6 . M=N>- ? 9* q WrBE ©B 8�= Kµ 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p 5; C = .( L, 3[-N>3§ M=NWc B1(

)- O¯: ( ¥th M=Na )P8 �¬N6. )

U C 5WG M=NWc B1( -b( 5* \-KÆ= C96 : ¥a o; ¹,6Y )FG B1( L1 T=C9X :

T-CdÌ-C,k 9* )* `( 5* @

; �-7 9* ); O¬: R M=NWc IS q6A I= . 5WG ,= K´E qXA(9* 8sB5X C2U n=.( ,k

109

Xs ( I°±(1 ¶{= .R M=NÂE qXA(9* 8sB5X C2U n=.( 9X : 56 7 I°±(1 (5WG 28 n[-Na 6�7,p ¥»V,6 . q Wr

6<U :,- w )P

; ? 24)8 O-NÀê )* �°6 C L1 8sB5X C2U n=.( 9X : )U O´ M=NWc B1( lounge M=Na )P

8 �¬N6. M=NWc = .( T=C9X : T

-CdÌ-C,k o* B1( TXC(1 )®¯Y )

U C (E 6�67 IS mB,JWr Ñ= OX7 28 n[-Na

6�7,p ;s(B 1R )]�6? )/ )V 9* B1( 6�67 ;. 8sB5X C2U n=.( 5* ¾ 6�¿ 2U n=K®k M=N>- ? ,= K*

L1 b,W c1 R56 75j )P; ?E `( )* R56 71,6 . M=Na -9®-K=N XY 5* B1( ,= .

8�= Kj 5* ,= K* b5¦· B1( I= . )- O¦· )ÄÂ IS q§ @=?( 6�7,p 5; C b,W c1 R56 75j q Wr M=N>

- ? )P; ?E 6�6 7 IS q§ @=?(

6�7,p b,Wc1 R56 75j )P; ? B1( +,J

;? o* o- ¹(9Ä-. q³6 ? 9* )FG B )P

; ?E 8sB5X C2U n=.( ,k 56 7 I°±(1 )FG ¥p( M=Na L1 ¡28 n[

-Na � ( 9= :2= n8K-:( M=Na q Wr ,;. ( )FGE �2Í -M=Na -B )]C 5¿

o* o; ¹5WG )FG -M{= KV 8sB5X C2U n=.( ¡28 n[

-Na � ( 9= :2= n8K-:( M=Na ,;. ( )FG B1( ¡28 n[

-Na � ( T-Nç= C8R )* `,X . ,;.5WG )FGE b,W c1 56 7 6�/ )/ (896 : It

-?,_ (5WG L1 8�Â5* 6¾ =?B58 N_ ,kE

8�Â5* 6¾ =?B58 N_ M=Na IÁ-.5X 7 b,W c1 9X : equipment M=N>

- ? )P; ? ©5Ê ¡5= C( -M

3 ¢= C( )* `,X . T67 o* I6 Y1 )/ I= . ¸ ( o*8dP6 ?E 9´( -b( )* `,X . foam ,;.5WGE o

- ¹,X . o* IÃ6Y 9´( foam ©,Jå

;N_( ,= K* ,;.,6Y 5; C (2= nª ©,= K-7 )FG ,-K; :( (896 : I= . It

-?,_ I- . ,;.5WGE 6s( M=Na 9= :2= n8K

-:( ¡28 n[-Na M=Na B8R,6 . o

8 ¹B5{= K/ -24B5µ o* �d² o; ¹ ( b5WGE B8R,6 . o

8 ¹B5{= K/ -24B5µ Coastguards L1 ¾ =�g

ß )Î¬C d² )/ +,k M=N>- ? )FG B T67 o* I6 Y1 )/

\-K®Çy§ 5WG q WrB )FGE é,-Y B5² 9X : ×�-K/ M=NaE M=Na ×�-K/ o* ;s,6 . b19* o´ It¨_( q³6 ? M=N>

- ?( B8R,6 . )/ ,;. ( )FG B1( o- ¹(9= :( ¥=K

;: q³6 ? M=N>- ?( ,6 .B

8R )/ ,;. ( )FGE ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ 5WG o´ IS `( 9X : ¶X g· -b,>=?R M=:R B1( `( 5* ä56 O-Üj )

- C ,-K6: o* 3T3Ê5*

M=:9*E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ : I= .9{3_E

110

Iª2; nth ,= .93: o

U ¹5; O67 : Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( m( )* )¬OV ( 8B5P; ? ,_ )- OV 56 C M=:Rà Xs ( 5; C

q³6 ?( )/ I= .9{3_ I>· M=NWc)FG B T

8N-KU :(5X C 5; C M=NWc1 9X : m89X : M=NWcEÑ= C( oU ¹ ( m( M=Na

8sB5X N_,X . ,k IvUK¢j ,;.5WG B1()FG 8�- O67B( 8sB5X N_,X . T67 5* -M=N;. )/ B,XY -B1B M=Na ,-K®a

)¬OFG ,XY L1 ,6 K=:dÎ;C `R LB,6 . -B1B M=Na ,;K®a )FGE 5; C Xs ( I= . M=N

U.,;K6: IS 56 7 `( normal procedure M=Na 8sB5X N_,X . )

; C ,6Y b5WG )´ 5; C L1 )- O;NS @

U ?,8 . M=Na b5´5V 5* ); O®a b5WG )´ B1( b5´5V 5* b,W c1 9X : `( -2= nX¤ )* )¬OV ){É R )

- C ,À· ); C 89X : M=NWcE 5; C o

- ¹,6 .2îh)U C (96 : Xs ( `( 9X : q³6 ? o

U ¹5* -b,>=?R M=:R B1( 8sB5X N_,X . 5* ;<º1 9X : )- O¬: R o* ;sR,w M=NÂ(8RE (BR,-. ,k I= . ©,Y )FG IS -b( )* `,X . 2= n

-ð qQva b,>=? 9X : ); OFG B M=NWc 5; C -b( ,k (B5X C 8RB,»= CB M=N>

- ? )FGE 9´( )FG q³6 ? 5; C M=NJWr M=N>- ?

,;KX: IÁ-.5= O* b5¦- ?( )- C `( 5* -MX :1( M=N>

- ? ,= K* E)FG T67 o* I6 Y1 )/ terrorism -bR -b�6 . ×896 : )FG ,W cBE

¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ 5WG o´ IS `( o* �d² q³6 ? -b,>=?R ,= .R )

U C ,6Y B1( 2= n-ð b5= O{va

)* ÑU C(5* )- O;N]Y q³6 ? M=NWc `( 5* collect ,= K* )

U C ,6YE -M=Na2U n=KX7 (BR,-. q³6 ?( ;. M=N>- ? ,= KV ,= K´ )FG IÁ6K67 `( 5* ¶X 7 )- O¬N>h 5WG )U O´ M=NWcE (2= nª ©,= K

-7 )FG IS `( )/ 2; n>6? ,À; ? IS q Wr1 -M=Na2U n=KX7 (BR,-. +,k ,;.9*E @· -B( @· 2W c,6 . )/ q³6 ? L1 T

-C-96 : D ,W cB ,À; ? B1( -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na q³6 ? ,ÀX A( q Wr +,k 9* ,W cB ,À; ?E )

- C ,6Y,-. `( 5* b5= O* ,= .,8K WG ,= K´ B1( ,>· I= . ,;.,6Y )FG IS L1 8s8R ( M=N>

- ? )- C 9* ,;K=:R E,À; ? 6s( 5; C 8s8R ( 5WG ,= K´ 5WG ,Ò B1(

6s( 5; C M=NJWr ,-K; :( qWr ,;K6: M=:R IS `( -M=Na2U n=KX7 o* ,= K* b,= K�®- w M=NÀ

; ? T67 o* I6 Y1 )/ `( 5* ,= .,8K WG ,= K´E I= .9{

3_E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: 28 n[-Na � ( 8�=O8N_ B,¼ 2= nU.2= n8K

-:( �J�h -æ= O®6 . -M� yA9V( E 6�7,p

111

6s,-K67 �J�h -æ= O®6 . -M� yA9V( : �@��6 C �'( -M� yA�9~V( �@= ��7�9~V(E I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 E9{= KXN_ 6f ( 2= nU.2= n8K

-:( )* 8<* -M3/5j 9X : ;�¦6? ¥=KÜÆ

;C )/ Ñ®;K-gh -M3 ¢= C -B5X C( b5= O8 :B,X . )

- C ,-KX:( B,> Øè( ©,=K

-7 ,= .,adi )FGE M=Na 3T3Ê5* b19* ,Ò IS briefly to the point 56 7

T8N-KU :(5X C b,>=? 9X : raise )¬O* )U O´ M=NWc -b( ,k 6s(56 7 b1R B1( (2= nª �ÕÖj o

U ¹5* q§,= K/ 9= :dÎ

;C ,-.9* M=N>- ? )FGE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! I;KÆÄ

3_ o- ¹,J6 A I6 K7,p )

- C q- �X:( 9= :dÎ

;C )/ -B,- w ( ,= K* ,À; ? B1( `( ;<º1 �= ., 3_ L1 X¾

-�V 9* q WrB b5WG o´à L1 d Ø�-C M=N>

- ? M=NWcB (E b5¦- ?( )

- C qXA(9* )* )V (57 )/ ;s,6 . o* B1( ,>· IS qXA(9* M=Na T=NÂ,XY �Õ=Oµ B,6 .1B,k �-K6: 5WG ,»X 7 )FG B1( ;sD,Y = KP

8 ? M=N>- ? M=NWcE M=Na -b( )/ ;sB -�°j )*

¶; ?,_ �x;K-7( b19* ,Ò IS qXA(9* )* B�-.( 56 7 q³6 ? ;sD,Y M=NWc I= . o

U ¹5* ,= K-: Iv[®_

M=N>- ? ,À; ? B1( M=NJWr I= . I3[= NJWr -MWG-R M=Na ,-KP·B )¬OFG ,XY IS ãD 8�-K=:( B8RB ( )]C 5¿ o* Iª-R

¡B(R )FGE Having said so, Prime Minister )- C I= . ¾

-ß(1 ,= K* ,À; ? IS @Wr -b( ;sD,Y )/ l®°

;CD B1( L�t=�®w M=N>- ? LB E); O{_ Ñ®;K-gh -9= :1,6 t

;? M=Na ;�¦6? q§ b5¦Ð6Y )/ I= . q³6 ? pressurize ,= K´,= K* B1( 3T

3Ê5* o* qU �´ IS oU ¹5* B1( I;K/(B

,-K=NÂ )¬OFG ,XY ,;. IS b,W c1 )* ;sD,Y ©128 n-K* )¬O* M=NU.,6YE -M{= KV @

U ?(9X : 28 n[-Na )

- C q- �X:(

8�- O6N=K* \-K8N=Kj qXA(9* M=Na x6 . 9*à +,J;? 8�- O6N=K* 5* )V ,6Y 9* B1( b,W c1 9X :

extend M=NS q- �X:( ¡B5X C help o

U ¹,6 .5¿ ;�j5{Y 5* B1( I= . 56 7 ¡B5X C = .9g;? q³

; ? B1( ¡B5X C 3T

3Ê5* q³; ? IS ;sD,Y 5* ©128 n-K* ,= K* 5; C)

U C ,6Y -M8 NXK=NS Ñ= OX7 28 n[

-Na ×�-K/ 5* q Wr ,= .,-K6: IS q

- �=NU. ( B1( o- ¹5- C,£ )-¿ ,½;C M=NWc `( ,k +(2; n¤( ,-.9* `( ;�j5{Y o* Iª-R

¡B(R )FG B1( oX¹ @=?( ¥=.( o* 8�- Oy- ?B5´ `( -2= nX¤ 5* ;�¦6? LR,= .

-B ;�=Oy Wr( q; �=:R )FGE

112

`( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ 56 7 q³6 ? b,W c1 9X : requirements oU ¹ ( B1( b,= Ky·

3T=NX. o* M=NUK´ 5; C -b( b5= Oy· M=Na = .( ;�¦6? ¡896 : b,= Ky· mB,JWr )- O¯: ( -M=N

-.(5± M=Na M=NÀ; ?E -b( -M=N

-.(5± 5* 2= n-°6 C o

U ¹5* ;<º1 æU C,-p )¬O* o

U ¹,6 .5¿ ;�j5{Y B1( `( o* ;sB1, 3[j M=Na @=?( 5= O* @=?( )* 9-:B5´ q³6 ? ¥a, 3_ )P

; ?à `( ;sB1, 3[j M=Na law enforcing agencies 56 7 Z,¼1 )

- C ×�-K/ ;�j5{Y o* ;�/(5-7BR -b()/ 5* ¡R o

U ¹5WG M=NÀ; ?E `( q8 �=NJ· 5* �W c(

-B �a,Y 6�7,p )- C 8�= K WG ,= K* B1( o

U ¹5* @U ?,8 . æ

U C,-p )¬O* 2= n

-°6 C qXA(9* )* ;sD,Y 5* )- Oj ,_ ); OP·B )U C 5WG B1( mB5X C ^va )* ;sD,Y 5*

)- Oj ,_ ); OP·B )U C 5WG -M=N

;. )U O-: -M=N

-.(5± 5* 9ÚR( )V 9* )U C ( T67 M=Na Protection

of Pakistan Ordinance, 2014 ,À; ? B1( `( M=Na Anti Terrorism Act o* amendment )* mB,6 . M=Na -M=N

-.(5± )P; ? B1( )P]�h `5¢µ( )* ¶; ?,_

,-K¦· ,;.89X : )FG IS @Wr )- C -b( b5

- C(5= C( M=Na qi,k ;<º1 ,=KVE -M{= KV ,ÀX A( )FG IS `( 9X : ä,= K

;NY( o* B1( â5- C ^vX . `( o* ;�/BR o* B1( 1R -M=N

-.(5± `,X . 5WG )U O´ M=NWc B1( qº,6 . )

- C 5WG )V (1 M=NWcE M=Na dPX ? original ;s,6 . 9X : ,W cB ( b5WG IS 6�67 )/ @U ?(9X : 28 n[

-Na )- C b,W c1 9X : ownership oV )FG B1( b,W c1 9X : I= . Iv[®_ 0123 4 ,= K*

)FG Interior Minister qU �* I°µR b,W c1 9X : ,6Y ){¯Y M=NWc b,W c1 9X :consultations ,k Iv[®_ 0123 4 (5WG )FGE

6s,-K67 D(1 ! ;�j5{Y ×�-K/ R5-7 `( ;s,6 . ,k �(2; nð( 9* qQXY )FG IS @

U ?(96 7 M=Na qË· o

U ¹ ( )FGE,W c1b )* 56 7 figures )¬C R )U O´ M=NWc 5; C `( M=Na ,= .,;K6: ,= K´ )FG stated crimes M=NWc `( M=Na qË· )FGE b,>6A ;. B,6 .1B,k ,k l®°

;C )FG 5; C I= . q³6 ? Xs ( 5* ,= .,;K6: ,6Y ,»X 7 )FG IS mB5X C ^va M=Na 56 7 `( = .( ©,_ M=Na

2; n>6? governance oU ¹5WG )FG `( )]�=�

;N-.)* M=Na 56 7 B,6 .1B,k 8R28 n[6 7B)U O-: 5WG )FG B

113

M=NWc 5; C -b( o* R(�°;C 8RB,»= CB LR,= .-B )FGEI= . q³6 ? ,= .,;K6: ,6Y ,»X 7 )FG IS large scale manufacturing index )FG L1 q¨>X? I°µR X¾

-?,X . �Õ=Oµ )/ qó896 : )FG )®À�X? X¾-?,X .à ;s,_ b5V,_ M=Na B1( I= . 6�/ ¡2; n>6? o* ;�jxw M=NWcE I;KÆÄ

3_ o- ¹,J6 A I6 K7,p )

- C minorities o* ;s,6 . o* 56 7 IS ¥»V,6 . ¾ =�g

ß )FG B1( `( 5* protect ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XY B1( ;�j5{Y `( 9X : I6 Y5

; C 9* q WrB )FGà ;sR,6 K} M=NU.,Ò B1( +,J

;? installations -b( 9X : I6 Y5

; C 9* q WrB )FGE I= . oU ¹5* qU �

-: -2= nX¤ M=N>- ? )FG 56 7

-b,;K¢*,X . M=Na oU ¹5WG )FGE 6f ( 56 7 incidents -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na 5WG )FG B M=NWc `( o*

¡89* ;�¦6? o- ¹(9X : q; �®a )FGE Ñ®;K-gh M=N

;.,6 . o* M=NUK´ IS 56 7 `( )* ¥p( l

UC,½7 M=NWc -b( o* �d² ,-.,6Y )¬OFG ,XY B1( b5ÊB�a )* )V (57 )/ b,>=? 9X : ;s,6 . o* qU �´E 56 7 @Wr )

- C National Internal Security Policy ¡R )FG 9U:2= n8K-:( ¡28 n[

-Na )- C 3T

3Ê5* 9* )* �-KX7 L,a o* ¥=K®£ ;s�a M=Na B1( `( ;�j5{Y 5* T67 fd² 5= C5= CB ,= K*à ¥6K=:9-: ( @

U ?(9X : 28 n[-Na )

- C `( 5* 8�- O6N=K* M=Na 5= C5= CB ,=K* B1( I-K=N6.,k )- C `( o*

¡B5 Ø�-Oj ¡Rà M=Na,= K-:R M=NÂ,3Kj @· q; �®a M=NWc IS )- O;: ( @· )¿ dÔ M=Na National

Internal Security Policy ,k ¥JQa ,= K* ,-.,6Y B1( `( 5* 3T=NX. ,-.9* I= . = .( ;�¦6? ¡896 : o6¹,= Kj,k )FGEI= . = .( ;�¦6? comprehensive policy )FGE I= .

National Internal Security Policy 56 7 b5ÊB�a o* 6s,6 . o* qU �´ `( )* mB,6 . M=Na qí6? IÈ,Y( o

; ¹9* )FG IS ,= K* frame work 5WG ,Ò B1( T* fd² `( 5* ,ÀQ= .R )

U C ,6Y ,Ò B1( q�* q³6 ? fd² o* ,>; �-:( ¡�-K¢X C )FG ,XY L1 q�* q³6 ? 28 nÁ=K/

M=Na 5WG L1 ¥6.,£ ©56 O± M=N>- ? )FGE b,>=? 9X : 2= n

-ð b5= O{va o* ;s,6 . o* qU �´ 5; C 2= n-ð

qQva 56 7 `( ^va M=Na ); OFG B M=NWc `( )* mB,6 . M=Na q¨>X? I°µRperhaps (B,-. 56 7 ISNational Alien Registration Authority )FG `( 5* activate ,= K* ,= K´E qXA(9* M=Na b,>6A 9X : I= . ;<=:,» 3/ LR,= .

-B q³; ? b,W c1 9X : ,6 K=:dÎ

;C = .( ¶*D )*

114

6<=:dº b5´5V 5* 8R28 n[6 7B ,= K´,= K*E B(R,-. B1( (B,-. o* TXC ( M=Na coordination oU ¹(9* qU �´ B1( -b( )* biometrics )¬OV )U O´ 56 7 IS = .( oV,3Kj +�£ )FGE q³6 ?( M=NJWr -M

3 ¢= C28 n[6 7B M=Na ¥JQa activate )- C 9* M=Na qi,k ;<º1 )V ,ÒE -M{= KV `(

,k activate )¬O* ,-.,6Y q Wr `( ;s,6 . ,k ;s56 O3: )FG IS ¡B,JWr d Ø�

-C -b( ;sxa,°j M=Na )FGE

mB,JWr ;�¦6? )/ b5; N_1R )

- C Ñ®;K-gh events )* )V (57 )/ 9=: -B1 Iv -Y(R o* qË· 5* `5¢gh ,= K* )FG B1( M=Na -b( ,k I= .9{

3_ (R( ,;.9* Eb5WG -M{= KV M=Na -b( 5* I= . ,-K¦· ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS 9=: -B1 Iv -Y(R +,k 9* )FG B M=NWcà o

8 ¹ ¡1 9X : d Ø�-C ,-. ( ,= . ,= .

8�= Kj 9X : d Ø�

-C ,-. ( ,= . d Ø�-C )

; C ( ,-K WGB �ÕÖj M=N>- ? )FGE +,k 5WG ,W cB )FGà +,k d Ø�

-C ,W cB ( )FG B1( `( )* 6¾

U?,;K-: '(�J�z( d Ø�-C )FG B ( M=NWcE -¾ =�

3/ �= K3/B 6�7,p )

- C ;�¦6? q§ M=N;.,6 .

It¨_( T-N[UCD )* mB,6 . M=Na EM=NS It¨_( T

-N[UCD )* mB,6 . M=Na 56 7 ¶X g· q³6 ? L1(5WG

6�/ )* )- Oj ,_ )FGE )®À�X? X¾-?,X . b5V,_ M=Na b,W c1 -M

3 ¢X C9*9X : o* 56 7 M=N-.,;K/(R @ºB

M=NU.5WG B1( `( )* �°6 C 8RB,»= CB ,= .x6Y ,= K´ I= . q³6 ? -b ( (R 8RB,»= CB )FGE 6s( mB,JWr )¬OV 1R q Wr ); N_ (B )P

; ? IS )- O;N]Y q³6 ? T

-N[UCD M=N

U. (à 6s,-K67 D(1! It¨_( T-N[UCD = .( ;�¦6?

q Wr @Wr( @Wr( document E)FG q�* q³6 ? ,= K-:R )* ^va M=Na `( )]C -æ= CBR

)Î¬C d² )/ It¨_( T-N[UCD M=N>

- ? ,= .R ,;.,6Y T67 fd² )®À�X? X¾-?,X . b5V,_ M=Na ,8K-:,6 . ,= K´E�= ., 3_

@Wr -M=:28 n-Ky=�VB,X . ,ÀX A(5* ,ÇV E5WG `( )* L1xw �2Í -M=:28 n-Ky=�VB,X . q Wr M=N>- ? mB5X C

^va M=Na T67 fd² ,8K-:,6 . ,= K´E 6s( mB,JWr `,X . 1R q Wr ); N_ (B )P; ?à = .( I= . IS

M=NÀQ-. ( �-K6: 9* M=NÂ B1( 56 7 8RB,»= CB x6Y (5WG B1()FG 56 7 q³6 ? Å

-g3§ mB,JWr `,X . oX¹,k

)V 9* )U C (à )FG ,XY L1 q¨°6 7 5WG ,= . q¨p( 5WG `( 5* 2= n

-°6 Cverification )´ ( renew 9* M=:R B1( (241R I;K/(B 56 7 IS ¥»

3¢j I;K/(B ,À; ? B1( 56 7 ¾ =�gß I;K/(B ,À; ?

115

@Wr )- C q Wr1 ,-KX7 )FG IS @Wr make sure M=:9* )´ IS -b( o*

verification E5WG 9´( oU ¹5* ¥»

3¢j 5WG @Wr b,>=? 9X : 2- Í,Y M=NWc M=NJWr M=NU.,;K6:à

)P]�h M=NU.,;K6:à M=Na Xs ( ¡B5X C help b19* ,Ò -M{= KV I= . verification ,k

process 56 7 )FG I= . ,-KX:( due course )V ,Ò ã, 3[-C( (E' 6s,-K67 D(1

8sB5X N_,X . B1( CNIC o* q¨°6 7 o* ;s,6 . o* qU �´E ¡B,JWr 8�- Oy- ?B5´ 8s2= nª 9X :

-M=N½= C q; �P·B )FGE 8s2= nª 9X : q Wr -b( b5yQth M=Na )P¯A ( -B2ï= N¼ ( )U C ,ÇV )U O´ M=NWcE

¡B,JWr 3T3Ê5* )FG IS @Wr �-K´ 5* b5yQth )/ �,p M=:9*E ¡B,JWr 3T

3Ê5* )FG IS ¡2; n>6? M=N

U.D B1( �J�z( (ñ'9´( oU ¹5* q�= C( b,= K6:(9

-7 M=NÀ; ? q³6 ? 5; C -b( 5* @

; �-7 ,= K* ,= K´ )FG ,= . @· ,= K* ,= K´ )FGE = .( B,6 . dPX ? -¾ =�

3/ �= K3/B 6�7,p )

- C q- �X:( b5; C,6 . M=Na

b,>6A Ñ®;K-gh ;�¦6? )/ oU ¹,6 .5¿ ;sxa,°j T{_8R )¬O* b,W c1 9X : ¶X g· -M=N

;.(5-7 )* m89{X . )- C ,6Y ,k 9*-R ,= K*à M=Na `( M=Na -b( 5* �2Í ,-K;:( ,-K¦· b5WG,XY ,Ò IS 9´( I= . ;�j5{Y q³; ? 5; C -M=N

;.(5- 7 ¡89{X . M=NUK´à 56 7 Û®-w b5j,k M=Na 3s5®a M=NÀ

; ? B1( 2= n-ð qQva M=NÀ

; ?à 9´( ;�j5{Y ,-KX:( +,k I- . q WrB9* o

; ¹5WG ,= . I½6 C,_ ;s,= .(1B 56 7 ¥XY q WrB M=NÀ; ? 5; C �= ., 3_ q³6 �*

q³6 ? I= . -2= nX¤ )- Oj ,_ I- . o; ¹ (E

-K67, 6s D(1 L-2- nª I6 K7,p )

- C lack of intelligence coordination o* ;s,6 . o*à ;�¦6? @Wr( ;s,6 . )FG B1( exactly qí=? -2= nX¤ )FG 56 7 National

Internal Security Policy M=Na ¡896 : ;�7,-p1 )* ¶; ?,_ -b,= K6: o* qU �´ )FGE @Wr ); OFG ,XY M=NWc IS mB,_ -b,;K¢*,X . o* 56 7 33 b,=K¢

-N6t=?( +,k q WrB9* M=NWc L1 = .( coordination centre M=Na +,k M=:9*E 9´( ,8 .,¼ M=Na o

U ¹5* chatter ¡89{X . o; ¹,6Y )FG B1( qXA(9* l®°

;Oj)* )FG 5; C ¡B5µ 5² 9X :B b,W c1 convey o- ¹5WG )¬OFG ,XYE

9´( oU ¹5* ^va )* q�* B1( )Ü7 M=Na ¶X g· )FG ,= . internationally q�*

116

= .( q�-N6t=?( 5* q; �®a )FG 5; C I½®°;Oj q�

-N6t=?( B1( b5yQth 5* q- �®a )¬OFG ,XYE `( )* )U OV

internal security policy M=Na (B5X C ©,-Y1� -Y ¥=KÜÆ;C )/ -b,= K6: ,= .R9* ,=K´

)FG B1( `( 9X : +,k 0123 4 )FGE 6s,-K67 D(1 = .( 8�- OU:(5X CB1( L-2- nª I6 K7,p )- C

T{_8R ); C 9* )

U C 5WG b5= C2î3§ 5* mB,6 . M=Na ,= .,;K6: IS ¡2î3§ )- O¯: ( Xs ( 5* Øä5Ægh M=N>- ?

); OP]�Ë§E qí=? I6 Y1 )FG IS ;�j5{Y )- C VIP guards b,>6A )V ,k )3 ¢¬N

3_ oV(1 b5= C 8B,Ò o* )¢¬N]Y -¾ =�

3/ �= K3/B 6�7,p )

- C ,>· IS ;s -B,6Y( ¡R )U C ,6Yà b,>=? 9X : ,>· ,= K´

IS 8�®6 . �19X : b5= C 8B,Ò o* ;s -B,6Y( )U C ,6 t=?RE M=N>

- ? 6s,-K67 D(1 qí=? b,= .8B,Ò 6�67 Û®-w

b5P; ?,W c M=Na o; ¹,6Y M=NWc 5; C -b( ,k Û®-w ©,Jå

;N_( ,;.5WG )FGE @Wr 9X : ;�¦6? U1,6 .R )FGE ;�¦6? )¢¬C ()/ VIPs ,k 56 7 m896 : ¡1,Y )P

; ? )®À�X? B(1R( M=Na )- O¯: ( VIP squads 5* )´ ( B1( )P¯�=�X: )- OP·B M=Naà )¢]7 L1 ;� Ø²,ç7 )/ LR,= .

-B )- O¯: ( status symbol )* B5² 9X : ©,Jå

;N_( ); C 9* )P

; ?E @Wr )- C -b( +,J

;? ;sB12- Íx6 . -2= n8.B5= O{= K/ 5* @

; �-7 ,= K* )FG -b( troops 5* unprecedented )Î¬C d² )/ TXC(1 q

- �X:( 5*824 b B1( -B8R1B 9X : D(8R )FG IS,;. L1 8<=:28 n_ o8 ¹B5= O{= K/ B1( +(5} o*

o8 ¹B5= O{= K/ 5* 2; n>6? )

U C ,-K6: B1( @Wr q§( direction M=Na )FG B,6Y M=NWcE @Wr ¡1 oU ¹ (

oX¹ o8 ¹B5= O{= K/ 9X : M=N>

- ? +(5} o* o8 ¹B5= O{= K/ 9X : -M=N½= C ); OP·B M=NWc B1( `( )U OV )* 3T

3Ê5* )FG B9* EM=NWc L-2- nª I6 K7,p o* `( ;s,6 . )/ q³6 ? M=Na Z,ç;C( ,;.9* b5WG IS Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( M=Na q³X A( ;s2î3§ )* ¸5V )

- C 5WG )¬OFG ,XYE Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( m( ,= K* 2W c )ËQth M=Na q³X A(

;s2î3§ )* ¸5V )- C 5WG )¬OFG ,XYE

b,>=? 9X : 9´( ¡B,JWr 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ oU ¹ ( 5; C b5¦- ?( )

- C 6�¢7 l6C,_ +,J;?

8�- Oy8 ?B,X K=:

8R -B 8�= K WG 5* q- �X:( q-ßdh M=Na )

- C D o* )U C ,6 t6? ,ÀQ= .R IS 9´( Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( M=Na q³X A( ;s2î3§ )* ¥a,Y R(di( +,k )FG B9* )P

; ? 5; C -b( 5* continue ,= K*E Ñ®;K-gh

117

8�- Oy8 ?B,X K=:

8R M=Na 56 7 q³X A( 2î3§ ;s )* ¸5V )P; ?E -b( 5* 9{= KV )

U C ( 6f ( q³6 ? �J�z( (ñ'mB,JWr 56 7 -B 8�= K WG M=NWc )FG ,XY L1 Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( )* b5WG )FG ,XY (BR,-. )* b5WGà )FG ,XY 8sB5X N_,X . )* b5WG )FG ,XY Interior Ministry )* b5WG )FG ,XY ¡241R

b5= C28 n[-Na )*à 3T

3Ê5* o* q WrB,6Y )FG IS q³X A( ;s2î3§ )* -b(2ïµ( 5* )´ ( ,= .D )U C ,6YE 8s2= nª prevail ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XY B1( ;sxa,°j 2; n>6? )¬OFG ,XY)

- C 5WGE Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( m(

M=Na q¨>X? I°µR internal vigilance unit 5* strong ,= K* ,= K´ )FG ( ` 8<- :5= C M=Na ;�¦6? q§ internal ¡2; n>6? )

U C D M=NWcE Ñ= C( oU ¹ ( m( M=Na q¨>X? I°µR

oV,k b182= nÀ6 ? 5* (-24 ¡R qU �´ )FG b5¦- �67 )- C human trafficking )

; C 9* )U C 5WG -b,;K¢*,X . )/ ¶X g· ¸5V q 8.( )]�=�P6 ? )P

; ? ,= . q�* B1( ^va )]�=�P6 ? )P; ?E -b( 5* b,W c1

)/ (89{X . ,= K´à B1( -b( 1-2= nX¤ b ,k ;�/R96 : -B T8C5- C ,= KV ,W cB,6Y )FG B1( `( o* -¾ =�6: q

- �* o* q WrB,6Y )FGE b,>6A 9X : Ñ®;K-gh -b(26 nJhà M=Na +,-. M=N>

- ? b5V ,Ò IÁ-.5= O* ;<º1 @· )FG I= . ,>· IS Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( M=Na Û®-w deputations 5* ,-K*B )¬OFG ,XYE ¥»V,6 . I= . ¾ =�gß I>· M=NWc)FG B B1( M=Na Xs ( 5* ,;.,;K6: b5WG 6s,-K67 D(1 IS I= . q³6 ? ¥»V,6 . ¾ =�g

ß I>· )FG B M=NWc IS influential ¸5V +,J

;? b5; O±1 )/ )- O¯: ( )- O: ( b5´5V o* \-K8N_5X C )

; C (19* )P; ?E 6�67 ¡B,JWr 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ oU ¹ ( )FG q§,X tX? ¸5V Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( M=Na deputation 9X : +,k )FG B9* )P

; ? -M6 7 ,k experience -M6 7 ,k relevant expertise ¥»V,6 . Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( )/ ;�Î6 C,Þj M=N>- ? q; �P·B Eq³

; ? @Wr )- C -b( M=Na )/ ¶8 ?,_ b5´5V o* deputation @

; �-7 )* 9* TXC(1 ,6 t=�P6 ? )FG B1( �= .-dh b5´5V 5* 9{= KV M=N>

- ? )U C ( B1( 9´( 9{= KV M=N

U. ( )´ 5; C 8s2= nª 9X : 9{= KV M=NU. (

)´ q�* o* 3 B,ç/ 9X : M=N>- ? 9{= KV M=N

U. ( )´E 8s9{= K/ 8�-Kµ )* mB,6 . M=Na q³6 ? b5¦- ?( )

- C ¥»V,6 . ¾ =�gß ,>·E @Wr 8s9{= K/ 8�-Kµ )* Û®-w ©,Jå

;N_( 9X : -M=N½= C M=N>- ? ); OP·BE

T67 fd² I½6 C,_ ;s,= .(1B M=NWcBà b1B,6 K-7( M=Na ,;. ( ,W cB 8s9{= K/ 8�-Kµ )* 8<=:5= OU :(9X :

118

©,Jå;N_( )

; C 5WG )FG BE B1( 8<=:5= OU :(9X : M=N;.5}R o

; ¹5WG M=NWcBà b1dPê )* ;s,6Y(9-7( )

; C 5WG )FG BE 6f ( �J�z( (ñ' 8s9{= K/ 8�-Kµ 9X : 56 7 ©128 n-K* `( 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ )- C ,= K* )FGE ,;K¢*,X . -b

o* -¾ =?B,;. M=Na L1 unprecedented )FGE Illegal sims o* ;s,6 . o* L-2- nª I6 K7,p )

- C ;�¦6? ¾ =�gß ;s,6 . o*E M=Na b,>=? 9X : q =K

8 : -b5µ b5= O-NXKy· ,k q³6 ? I= .9{

3_ (R( ,;.9* b5WG b5¦- �67 )

- C 2U n=.2= n8K-:( ¡28 n[

-Na )* ¶; ?,_ B5X CdP6 ? -b1,°;C ,= K* 6s,-K67 D(1 6.32 million sims ¶8 N_9;:(5Ê ¶*D M=NJ§ -M6 7 ,k 8RB,»= CB M=N>

- ? ,À; ? L1 âx6 . o* qU �´ M=NWc B1( `( )* )U OV ;�¦6? LR,= .

-B @U ?,8 . )¬OFG ,XY ,À; ?E �J�z( (ñ 'I= . ;�¦6? ¡896 :

o6¹,= Kj,k )FGE `( )* L1xw @Wr )

- C cellular mobile operators, CMOs 5* �-K6:,X . ,= .,-K6:à IS L1 biometrics )¬OV 2= n

-°6 C qU �-: M=NJ§ 53 ¢= C( I- . M=:9*à I= . TÊ(9X :

0123 4 )FG ,»X 75WG B1( ã, 3[-C( (ñ')- O¯: ( due time M=Na complete ,Ò5WGE 6s(

)- O;N]Y q³6 ? franchises M=NWc cellular operators o* L1 +,J

;? biometrics )¬OV 2= n

-°6 C 53 ¢= C( M=N>- ? M=NWcB9*E B1( qº,6 . TXC, 3_ 9X : q³6 ? , 3[

-C( (ãñ'= .( certain time period -b( 5* ,= .R ,= K´ )FG `( M=Na L1 q³6 ? `( -2= nX¤ 5*

ensure M=:9* )´ B1( @Wr = .( transparency o* �d² )´ ( M=NÉ896 : )´E B8RB,6 . o

8 ¹B5= O{= K/ 5* 2; n>6? ,= K* ,W cB,6Y )FGE \-K-N=.98 : )U OV )* T=NÂ5X C -24B5µ 9X : +,k

,= K* ,W cB,6Y )FGE o*9;: B1( m241R ^Â,Jh ;s,6 .)/ q WrB5WG )FGE 6s,-K67 D(1 8sB5X N_,X . M=Na ¡2; n>6? o* ;s,6 . Ñ¿ ( -M=N

-K¢7 6�7,p )- C o*à ;�¦6? q§ b,= .2

; n>6? oU ¹5WG M=NWc

6�67 I= . 8�- Oy- ?B5´ o

U ¹ ( q³; ? 5; C `( ;<º1 Xs ( 5* I;KX: )FG IS `( ;<º1 q§( ¶*D

8sB5X N_,X . pending )P; ?E 6¾A ¡28 n[

-Na o* )U C ,6 t6? b,>=? ¸5V L2W c, ØÞj )

; C 9* )P; ? IS

b5´5V ,k 6¾A )U OV )* +,-. ¥»-C ,= . ( )FG -M{= KV 8sB5X N_,X . M=N>

- ? ¥a )FG BE 8sB5X N_,X .

119

)* )V (57 )/ 3.9 million �J�z( (ñ' 8sB5X N_,X . `( = .( ©,_ M=Na 53 ¢= C( )¬O* )U O´ M=NWc B1( 6�/ in time 53 ¢= C( )¬O* )U O´ M=NWcE @Wr )

- C ordinary passport ,k @

U ?,8 . LB,6 . -bR )/ @· )* 9* `R -bR ,k ,= .R9* )FGE Urgent passport ,k +,k X¾

-?,X . -bR )/ @· )* 9* B,XY -bR ,=.R9* )FG B1( b,>=? 56 7 I6 KV,Þj ,= K* ,= K´ IS `R ©,_ ,k 8sB5X N_,X . 5; C (�J�z(ñ' 5{_( @Wr continue ,= K* )FGE `( 5* L�w,£,6 . ,= .R9* )FG 6s( `R ©,_ ,k 8sB5X N_,X . ,-K=NÂ -M{Jh )FGE 2î6? ©,Y ;<º1 o* qË· )FG M=Na Xs ( 5* -édÔ b19* IS T{

8.,kB,-. )* )V (57 )/ ;�¦6? )/ -b(26 nJh )

- C ;s,6 . o* M=Na `( )* mB,6 . M=Na ( 8B5P; ? ,_ Xs ( 5* bU1,;K6: ,ÒE T{8.,kB,-. M=Na I= . 93:,; . Û®-w )FG IS -b,;K¢*,X . ,k B,J

3§ ,=K-:R M=Na I;K/(5

- g-?(� -Y )¢¬C ( ^Â,Jh

M=Na ,;.5WG )FG b,>6A 9X : ;�3/,k o* o; ¹,6Y b5WG IÁv6 . United Nations Office

on Drugs and Crimes 56 7 )FG UNODC `( )* l6C,Þj `( )- C

-b,;K¢*,X . 5* poppy cultivation free country )®À�X? -M=N;. ©,_ )/

declare ,= K* (5WG )FGE `( ©,_ q³6 ? ¡896 : record ceases M=NWc 56 7 Û6 O -¿ o* M=N

UK´E IvUK¢j b,W c1 9X : ,;. ( )FG IS mB,JWr I= .,[y Wr ^va M=Na 2007ã M=Na poppy cultivation @· q³

; ? 6f ( ;�¦6? LR,= .-B ×896 : qQXY )FG b5P·D 89{= .( qU �´5WG

)FGE 5; C mB,JWr ^va M=Na `( )* �x-Y 2; n>6? +,k ,W cB5WG )FG B1( (ã, 3[-C(ñ'`( 9X :

I6 Y5; C )FG B o´E

6s,-K67 D(1 M=Na Xs ( )/ -édÔ b19* ,ÒEB1( `( -b(5= C( )/ Xs ( )*

)å¬C B-R I= . -édÔ b19* ,Ò IS ãD 8�-K=:( B8RB ( oU ¹,6 .5¿ IvUK¢j )FGE Z,¼1 o* 3T

3Ê5* )FG IS +,J

;? b56 C5¿ 5* facilitate M=:9* @Wr -b( o* help M=:9* b,>6A ;. ){_ 5WGE `( )®a ,°j M=Na 56 7 q³6 ? o

U ¹,6 .5¿ b5; Oj5{tz(B(R M=Na ;sxa,°j ); C 5WG M=NWcà I= .

120

;s,6 . = KP8 ? )FG IS @Wr -b( )/ l®°

;CD M=N>- ? LB ); O{_E b,>=? 9X : 6f ( ;�¦6? LR,= .

-B echo (5WGE B5WGD )* 1R -bR )* ;s,°±(1 ,kà ,= . -b( reactions ,k 56 7 mB,JWr ¶X g· b5= OP

; ?,_ o* �d² q³6 ?)/ )U C (E M=Na I= . -édÔ b19* IS,Ò L1 o

U ¹,6 .5¿ Iva,°j )FG `( )* )U OV o

U ¹,6 .5¿ ;�j5{Y )- C -M=N½= C o

- ¹,W cR oU ¹(9* )FG IS L1 q�* q³6 ?

culprit 5* spare M=N>- ? M=:9* )´ B1( ¡B,JWr o

8 ¹B,X . oX¹ @=?( ¥=.( -M=:( q�* q³6 ? fd² )* militant wing M=Na involved M=N>

- ? )FGE I- . q Wr qXA(9* M=Na B1( I- . q Wr ^va )* q�* )Ü7 EM=Na I= . ;s,6 . ¥»V,6 . )² L� 3_ )FG B1( `(

)V (57 )/ ^va M=Na �J�z( (ñ'overall ¡2; n>6? )FG I= . stand alone 56 7 ;s,°±(1 M=NWc -M6 7 )* )P¯�=�X: b53Ê -B,_ o* 56 C q³6 ? q; �{_5WG )FG o

U ¹5* B1( ;�®ç- } q³6 ?

q; �{_5WG )FGE 56 7 q³6 ? ;sxa,°j M=NWc )¢¬N]Y q Wr I= . )- Oj ,_ M=NU. ( )´ M=NJWr -M=N½= C )FG IS

`( )* mB,6 . M=Na 56 7 q³6 ? oU ¹(1BB,k o* )

U C ,6Y o´ `( 9X : -b,-K=NJè( ,k B,> Øè( m9* o´ (ã, 3[

-C(E' ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_E

Mr. Deputy Speaker: Demand No. 62. The question is that the Cut Motions as moved on Demand No. 62, be adopted. (Consequently Cut Motions were rejected.)

Mr. Deputy Speaker: Now, I put Demand No. 62

to the House. The question is that Demand No. 62, as moved be granted.

121

(Consequently the Demand was granted.)



to the House. The question is that Demand No. 63, as moved be granted. (Consequently the Demand was granted.)


Mr. Deputy Speaker: Now, I put Demand No. 64 to the House. The question is that Demand No. 64, as moved be granted.

122

(Consequently the Demand was granted.) Mr. Deputy Speaker: Demand No. 65. The question

is that the Cut Motions as moved on Demand No. 65, be adopted. (Consequently Cut Motions were rejected.)

Mr. Deputy Speaker: Now, I put Demand No. 65 to the House. The question is that Demand No. 65, as moved be granted. (Consequently the Demand was granted.)



123

Mr. Deputy Speaker: Demand No. 67. The question





124




Mr. Deputy Speaker: Demand No. 70. The question




125




Mr. Deputy Speaker: Demand No. 125. The

question is that the Cut Motion as moved on Demand No. 125, be adopted. (Consequently Cut Motions were rejected.)



126

Mr. Deputy Speaker: The Proceedings of the

House are suspended for Zohr Prayers for 30 minutes.

(Proceedings of the House were suspended for Zohar Prayers for 30 minutes)

6s,-K67 B,= .2î

3§ ¡�=.di ( : = KP8 ? )FG M=Na 8�-KU :(1 Xs( ,;.9* b5WGE -M{= KV = .(

28 n[-Na L1 violate 9* )FG B M=NWc -9V1B 5*à L1 ¥U.,8K¢{= K

8 : 28 n[-Na)* M=NWcE L1 6�67

m2= nª )Î®Y M=Na M=NU.,6Y )´ B1( m2= nª rights 5* violate M=:9* )´à I= .

= .( B,= .2î3§ ¡�=.di ( )* rights violate M=N>

- ? 5WG )FG B I= . mB5X C -b(5= C( )* rights violate 5WG )FG B M=NWcESuch initiative will be discarded

at all levels. For heaven sake, sanity to prevails. Prime Minister and the concerned Minister should take a

serious notice of this. I= . b,>· ,k Z( -�a )FG IS 6�67 = .( elected MNA 5* o

U ¹,6 . `,X . ); C 9* M=NWcE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: I= .9{

3_E= KU:,a )U OV 5P·E

6s,-K67 2î3§ B,= . ¡�=.di ( : M=Na = .( 8�- Oj M=Na conclude ,;.9*

b5WGE= .( B1( -2= nX¤ most important, right person for the right

127

job. -M6 7 )* exit control list M=Na +,-. M=NWcà 56 7 qualify q Wr M=N>- ?

9* )FG B M=NWc 8�/5X C )* )U OV L1 MDs )- O]: )P8 �¬N6. M=NWcE For heaven

sake positive approach is the need of the hour. B1( é,-Y 9* 56 7 m2= nª 9= : -B1 �5¿5j 6�7,p M=NWc -b( 5* '( )

- C = .( responsibility ¡R )FG he comes from a very respectable family. -b( 5*à é,-Y 9* \-KV1B o

8 ¹B,X . 5* -b( )¢¬N]Y b5´5V 5* strengthen ,-.9* )FGE `( )/ ¥»= O8N=KV5X C -2= n8.B,X . M=Na coordination )Ú 896 : o´ B1( ¥»= O

8N=KV5X C 9X g¨k ä56 O-Üj 5WG ,Ò 5; C result oriented approach will become the order the

day. Thank you so much.

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: I= .9{3_E 28 nS(8R I[= Nç

-C L, 3_ I6 K7,pE

28 nS(8R I[= Nç-C L, 3_ : I= .9{

3_ 9{= KXN_ 6�7,pE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! -b,;K¢*,X . )* )U OV ,>· ,;.,6Y )FG IS @Wr ;�¦6? 6<=:d-Ô ^va EM=NWc -M{= KV 9´( @Wr )- O¯: ( o

; ¹B�£ ¥U.,_1 5* M=NÀQ= .R 5; C M=Na q; �P6 �Ë

§ b5WG IS @Wr 2= nª( -M=:9

;: ^va M=NWc B1( ;�¦6? ¶*R ,;.5WG )FG 6�67 = .( �d² )- O¯: ( ¥U.,_1 ); OPQ= .R M=NWc B1( q

- �X:( -9= :28 n[-Na o* b,= K¢= NÂ,X . ); OPQ= .R EM=NWc

M=Na B1( ¡B,JWr o8 ¹B,X . )

- C @=�V128 nX. ¡28 n[-Na 9X : qU �* cuts )

U C ,ÇV M=NWc B1( ¡R,= K-N6.

cuts `( )®UK¢j 9X : M=NWc IS @Wr )- C o

U ¹5* æj,6Y q�= NÂ,X . M=N>- ? o

U ¹,-K6: IS @Wr )- O;: ( o; ¹B�£ ¥U.,_1 )* R56 71,6 . @Wr `( ^va M=Na energy shortages 56 7 M=NWc -b( M=Na qË· M=N>

- ? 9* ){_E 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! ¡B,JWr specific Cut Motion T67 IX . M=Na ;s,6 . b19* o´ L1 Cut Motion 26 nJ

-? 31 )FG B1( `( M=Na @Wr )- C

�= KÖ-O; : o* )FG ¡28 n[

-Na 9X : IS ¡28 n[-Na ¥=Kµ q WrB )FG ©5*dP; ? 5* utilize )

- C 9* M=Na

128

B1( ©5*dP; ? 56 7 IS M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS -b,;K¢*,X . o* 6f ( o* I- . �2Í energy requirements 5; C = .( ;s,6 . )FGE I think Pakistan’s economy

and national security 9´( -b( 1R b5®UK¢j 5* ¥Y ,-.9* )FG 5; C the answer is Thar Coal.

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! M=Na ¶X g· ,8 .5PX A ,_ Xs ( 5* IS,-Y b1R o´ IS -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na )- O

;NS ¥U.,_1 M=NWc coal )* B1( coal 5* ,= K

-:R M=Na dP6 ? M=Na black gold ,>· ,;.,6Y )FGE ,=K

-:R dP6 ? M=Na o6¹d-åj ^Â,Jh 18th and 19th century M=Na 9´( b5¦- ?( )

- C industrialise ,= K* 5; C L1 coal as energy base use 9* )* b5¦- ?( )

- C industrialise ,= K*E Pakistan has the sixth largest coal resources in the world. mB,JWr = .( 5Ê q§( 6sB(

-M8 : T67)FG M=Na 6�/ )/ LR,= .

-B ©5*dP; ? M=Na B(-2W c5- C square kilometer o*

q-ß(B( 9X : I= . Iv= K/1 ,= .,X . ,;.,6Y )FGE B1( `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ �2Í I= . M=N>- ? )FG IS

mB,JWr `,X .coal )FG we have enormous resources of shell gas. CIA = .( (B5X C I= .-96 g

;? o; ¹9* )FG ,= K

-:R dP6 ? M=Na ¥U.,_1 ,k B1( b5¦- ?( )- C

I= .-96 g;? ,= K* )FG IS Pakistan has one of the largest resources of

shell oil and gas. B1( L1 q³6 ? Xs ( )* `,X . lower Indus Basin M=Na )FGE B1( `( )* `,X . 56 7 recoverable shell oil )FG L1 5

- C -M=Nv6 . ©2= n6. of shell oil 56 7 )FG L1 recoverable 5WG ,;K{_ )FG B1( `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ 202 trillion cubic feet of gas is available. 6s(

;s2= n¤ `( ;s,6 . o* )FG IS we are sitting, 180 million people are sitting on these resources, and we are not able to

129

utilize them. @Wr B,XY 6sB( 9V(8R I- .D,_ we are losing FORES, why? Because we are importing very expensive fuel B1(

L1 56 7 q³6 ? oil rich countries M=NWc -b( 5* `( ,k L�U.,¼ )FG `( 6<=:d-Ô ^va 5* `( ,k L�U.,¼ M=N>

- ? )FGE B1( `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ ;s2= n¤ o* ;s,6 . )FG IS ,6 K=:dÎ

;C 1R 5Ê 6sB( -M8 : )* coal )* 9X :1( I= . ^va ,À8 �=N6. (5WG )FGE -M{= KV -M=N

;. 5Ê -M=Nva 9V(8R 56 7 )FG @Wr 2W c ©,_ Xf9

-7 ); C 9* M=NWc to import coal. South

Africa )/ coalà ,= K3¢= N-.1 8�-.( )/ coal 9ÚR( 9ÚR( )/ coalà -M{= KV )- O¯: (

^va ,k 56 7 coal )FG `( )* )U OV ,= K* 9* )FG B M=NWcE M=Na 9=: -B1 6�7,p )P8 �¬N6.

)U C 5WG M=NWc -b( )/ I= . ,-KPX A5X C b5WG,XY o´ q

- �X:( statement M=Na M=:RE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! = .( 8�- Oj M=Na I= . ;�j5{Y oU ¹ (à X¾

-?,X . 5Ê 6sB( @Wr )- C IPPs

)* )V (57 9* )U C REB1( @Wr )

- C ©5*dP; ? )* )U OV ,= K* ,À·B )FGà = .( 6sB( q³6 ? M=N>- ? ,À·BEB1( 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! dP; ? ©5* M=Na ¾

-ß(1 9* b1R IS it is not about Sindh. Thar Coal is Pakistan’s national security and

economy ,k answer )FG ©5*dP; ?E 5; C it is a national resource. @Wr M=N>

- ? -¾ =�X7 )FG B IS ×�-K/ 5* L�U.,¼ 5WG ,ÒE `( ^va 5* L�U.,¼ 5WG ,Ò IÁ-.5= O* Xs ( ¶{= .R M=NÂ 6s( 6�/ IÃ6Y `( ,k ( 8�-KÄ= KX:19X : ¥XY ,W cB )FG IS I= . = .( polluted fuel )FGE Xs ( -M=N XY 5* ¶{= .R M=NÂ IS -M=N XY o* q§(

�Õ=Oµenergy requirements coal answer )FGà ,= K®= .28 n_ ( 80 percent of their energies coming from coal.à ,= .

8�-.( 50 percent of energy is coming from coal.à XsB5= C (B5X C average

30 to 40 percent is coming from coal. USA, more than

130

50 percent is coming from coal. And do you know IS -b,;K¢*,X . ,k ,-K;NSpercent energy requirement coal meet ,;.9* )FGE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! You will all be shocked. I myself was

shocked. One percent. One percent of our energy resources is being used by coal. T67 )* @Wr9X :1( = .( 5Ê q§(

6sB( -M8 : )* 9X :1( )P

8 �¬N6. )U C 5WG M=NWcEWe should use 9´( Xs ( 5* fiscal

deficit ,-.,É896 : )FG 5; C ,É896 : )U O]g=?Rà 5Ê 6sB( )/ ,É896 : )U O]g=?REwe will allow you, but use it for Thar coal. Use it to build

infrastructure there, because tomorrow Xs ( 5* `( ,k L�U.,¼ 5WG ,ÒE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! I understand and I acknowledge IS q¨ÀX �X? ;�j5{Y B1( `( ;�j5{Y )

- C and I will just conclude by just one or two statements. ¶X g· positive steps )U OV M=NWc coal o*

extraction M=NaE -M{= KV 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! It’s a bit late. 80s M=Na 6�67 �=K¦3§

Iª2; nth B1( ¡B,JWr -9®X K=NX. o8 ¹B,X . o* q¨>X? ;�j5{Y q³

; ? and subsequent ;�j5{Y M=Na Chinese interest ,À; ? ©5*dP; ? M=Na B1( `( ;<º1 X¾

-?,X . )¯C 1B )* �2= n8. )/ they had agreed but again because of political

reasons, I don’t want to go into point scoring but 6�67 ¡241R ;�j5{Y o

U ¹ ( 5; C 6�/ M=:-2= nX¤ b5¦- ?( )- C @

; � -7 9* M=:RE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! `( ;<º1 o* 56 7 q�= NÂ,X . )FG what we have done is IS initially 56 7 q¨ÀX �X? 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ )- C tariff announce ,= K* ,À; ? B1( `( M=Na rate of

return 56 7 announce ,= K* ,À; ? on equity that was about 20

131

percent. Now we have gone and increased the rate of return to more than 30 percent. I want to ask the

Minister why have we done that. b5= O* @Wr )- C `( mB5X C )�

-7 M=Naà @Wr )

- Ccoal imports 9X : B1( 56 7 imported coal plants b5WG )´ `( IX . @Wr )

- C ,É896 : ,É89X 7 )* returns )U C R M=NWcE Why? I want

an answer because I have concerns. Not just that, what we have done is, we have downgraded our quality requirements, which means that what we want to do

M=NJWr I;KX: )FG IS -2= n-KU :,XY 56 7 M=NWc L1 invest M=:9* )´à q³X A( ;s,6 . )FG (B,JWr

;�/1R ^va )FG invest m9*E

-M{= KV 56 7 ÛUC(23 4 M=NWc 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! ¶X g· ¡B,;K-ghR5

-7 B1( sovereign country o* fd² ¶X g· 5; C ÛUC(2

3 4 M=NÀ·BEWe have removed our qualifications on the quality of the plants which means that if China is commissioning 1.5 plant a month, they can easily come and dump it in Pakistan. At hardly any

cost. That is wrong Mr. Speaker ¶X g· ÛUC(23 4 Xs ( M=NÀ·BE @Wr )

- C oU ¹5* quality o* ÛUC(2

3 4 M=N>- ? M=NÀ·B B1( = .( B1( ;s,6 . IS ;s,_ B(-2W c 8s(1,Ç= Oj

o* coal o* M=NJ= �{_ upcountry q³·B oU ¹5WG M=NWcà `( o* ,= K* logic

)FGE Xs ( o* q�= NÂ,X . I= . q; �¦· )FG clearly IS 1R IÃ6Y Xs ( coal fire plants M=NU.,-K6:E 9´( 5; C Xs ( indigenous coal IX . ,-K6: )FG B M=NWc 5; C `( m2= n

-¤-R )* ¶; ?,_ M=N

U.,-K6: IS Xs ( o*transport costs I- . b5WGE -M{= KV 9´( Xs (

132

imported coal 9X : ,-K6: )FG B M=NWc 5; C B�-Ky§ )* `,X . à(B(� -Y IÁ-.5= O* b,W c1 )U C (

,Ò (B,_E 6s( @Wr )- C = .( B(-2W c ¥=Kj B1Rà M=Na ,-.,6Y M=N>

- ? q; � WG,XY `( M=Na provincial issues, not a provincial issue, it is a national issue. Why are we making coal fire plants up country Mr. Speaker. And this is one of the reasons why we want to put a Cut Motion because this policy is not

going to help.

67 6s,-K q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A = KU:,a )U OV 5P· q6AE

28 nS(8R I[= Nç-C L, 3_ : B1( `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ ¡9

-7 ( 8�- OU:(5X C I= . )FG IS 56 7 -M=NU. ( ,;K¦· )FG IS natural resources 56 7 I6 .5¿ ,;K=:R )FG `( 5* first

right ,-.5WG )U OFG ,XYE 6s( 56 7 q³6 ? gas producing areas M=NWcà T8NS28 n_8R

M=NWc ,= . )]C 5¿ M=NWcà kindly at least policy making ,= . 9ÚR( q- �;N 6Y q³6 ?

T=N� b,=K-NXKy· M=NWcà oX¹ oX¹ ¥=.( )FGà 1( q6A ¡8R q§ ¥=.( )FGà -b( M=Na -b( b56 C5¿ 5* IÕ7 M=:R 5; C M=NJWr I;KX: 5; C )®Y IS gas concessions o* q�= NÂ,X .

,= K* )FGE I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: I= .9{

3_ q6A 6s,-K67 @=�/5V(�6 K} 6�7,pE@U ?,8 . ,k (B-R ©,= K

-7 q³·B B1( 58 C ¡R 8�- OU:(5X C ;s,6 . EM=:9*

133

6s,-K67 @=�/5V(�6 K} : I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! ^va M=Na 56 7 m241R ¸5V suffer

); C 9* M=NWc T67 o* I6 Y1 )/ ^va o

U ¹,Ç-O¦h ,k B,» 3/ ,;.5WG )FGE M=NJWr @=�V128 nX. 9X : base ,-.9* ,;.89X : )FGE 6�/ )/ @6 .(9X : mB,JWr ^va M=Na seriousness I- . )- C 5WG o* I6 Y1 )/ ,[= N 6Y IS q³6 ?( 9*-R ¡2= nª -M¦6? )

- C ,= K* IS @Wr q§( o* oU ¹,W cR

)/ )®U. 5* 9X : +,k 9* )FG B M=NWc -M{=KV q�* q³6 ? 8�- Oy- ?B5´ M=Na ( )* )FG ,XY L1

×�-K/ o* 8�- Oy- ?B5´ o

U ¹ ( 5WG ,= . 6s,6 t-�X: o*à `( 5* T=C2= n_ M=N>

- ? ,= KVE ,= K-:R o* q³6 ?(

©,3Kj ¡R qU �´E M=Na ,-.(2W cR M=N>- ? ,;K WG,XY -M{=KV ,= K

-:R M=Na `( ,k ©,Jå;N_( B5X CdP6 ? 5WG ,W cB

)FG B1( q6A9-:( `( )/ ¥p,Y o* q WrB,6Y )FGE -M{= KV mB,JWr àb,W c = .( q³X A( ;s,6 .

)FG IS b5- C1R b5= O8 :B,X . )

- C ¥a 9* b,W c1 q; �-g;? 5; C ,ÇV ¡R -M{= KV 8�6 g6? ,= . ( 5; C `( 9X :

-B 8�-Kµ d Ø�-C M=N>

- ? )U C ( IS `( 9X : o

U ¹5* seriousness oU ¹,À·R qU �´ E5WG 5; C 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p M=NWc)P

8 �¬N6. �U., 3_ ¶X g· �= .-dh ¡2; n>6? )V M=NU. (E -M{= KV T6 C M=Na qí=? b5¦· ,Ò IS

`( IX . T=C2= n_ )- C 5WG o* ;sB12- Í )FGE ©128 nX. o* M=N

;Ky=�± mB,JWr b,W c ,[= N 6Y IS q³6 ?( I= KV,Y b5

- CR M=Na q³6 ? oU ¹,W c896 : M=N

UK´E ¶X g· @· q³6 ? o; ¹,6Y5WG M=NWc B1( ¶X g· ×896 : q³6 ?

o; ¹,6Y M=NWc I= . ;<º1 )* ¶; ?,_ )FGE -M{= KV 5WG I= . ,W cB )FG IS ,=K

-:R M=Na M=N;Ky=�± @·

5WG o; ¹,6Y M=NWc -M{=KV @Wr q-ß,a o* b5; Oy=�± 5* xa 9* @Wr -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na q

- �X:( M=N;Ky=�± ,É896 :

); O¬: R M=NWcE 6s( `( 5* )

- C ,É896 : )/ �2Í I= . M=N>- ? ,;.5WG IS oV, -Y ©128 nX. ×896 : E,= K´ -M{= KV

`( )/ dÌ/ +,w qhR ( ,= . +,w ¡8B,Ò ,= . +,w 8sB5X N[-C(98 : ,= . +,w 56 7 `( 9X : dÌ/

o; ¹9* M=NWc M=:-2= nX¤ L1 qÐ-K¦h 5WG o

; ¹,6Y M=NWc T67 ,k ¶6 756 C +,w qhR ( 9X : ,;.89X : )FGE `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ -b(9= :( T=N� X<

U :,X . -MU :D o* q³6 ? ;�¦6? ;s,6 . o

U ¹5WG B1( qU �* I°µR I= . 53 ¢= C( qU �* b5= O®6 Ky§( )/ xXY ,W cB ( E)FG �23 ïj B1R)* )/ ( ` M=Na ¡-2= n;. o

U ¹ ( B1( qi,k �Y ;. `( IX . +,k 5WG ,»X 7 )FG B1( M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS ¥JQa 5WG ,»X 7 )FG

134

-M{= KV ¶X g· ^Â,Jh o* intervention )/ I= . IvUK¢j ,kB (5WG )FGE L1 ^Â,Jh )- O¯: ( m�U.,¼ )U OV )* 5; C L1 +,J

;? +,k `( ^va )/ q³6 ? 9* )FG B M=NWc B1( @Wr )/ q³6 ? ¥p,Y 9* -M=NWc)FG B -M{= KV 6�67 @Wr q�* +,k o* �d² M=NWc); OÚ 896 : 5; C b,W c1

sanctions o* M=N;.,6 . o

; ¹,6Y ( M=NWc b,W c1 ¥U.,[j o* M=N;.,6 . o

; ¹,6Y ( M=NWcE M=Na qí=? b5¦· ,Ò IS ^va)

- O¯: ( R,çj)* )U OV )* M=N XY5Ê B1( @�6 C '( M=:9*E+5± )- C ;�¦6?

suffer 9* ,= KVà ;�¦6? ¥»3¢j ¶{= .R EoV 6s( M=NJWr M=N>

- ?( b,= K-:,_ ( q

- �=:R M=N=K WG,XY B1( `( +,k 5* )´ ( ,É896 : M=N

U. IS,;. @Wr q- �X:( q6A9

-:(à q- �X:( R,À·à ,-KX:( 8�=Oy=�/ 56 7 `(

)/ 93:,;Kj 5WG )FG B M=NWcà`( )/ 56 7 ,Ç-O¦h oU ¹ ×896 : q WrB )FGàR,À· o* ¡B56 C qÐ-K¦h 5WG

qU �´ )FGà M=NJWr ¡ 8�[6 N_ q- �=:R 89X : q WrB )FGE I= . +,J

;? M=:-2= nX¤ M=NWc 56 7 mB,JWr ^va ¶; ?,_)* EM=NWc M=Na qí=? b5¦· ,Ò IS `( 56 7 q

- �;N 6Y ¡�v6Y -M{Jh 5WG ){_E

dPX ? mB,JWr b,W c T-Cdi ¥U. ( )/ q6 t6? o

U ¹,-K6: ,6Y q WrB )FGE9´( @Wr ©5* )/ L�U.,¼ ,À8 ?( M=NÂ 5; C dPX ? M=NJWr T

-Cdi ¥U. ( o* M=NJWr B12- Í ;s M=N>- ? )FGà I= .

qÐ-K¦h q6 t6? E)FG `( ¶; ?,_)* ¶; ?,_ R56 75j ;<º1 M=Na ¥=.( oX¹ q6A B1( ¥=.( -M=:( q6A o* ;s,6 . 5WG q WrB E)FG ¥=.( oX¹ q6A b,W cmB,JWr 2ï= Na )FG -M{= KV ¥=.( -M=:( q6A )* @Wr q³6 ?( -M

3 ¢= N8K/ ,-K6: )FG B M=NWc B1( ^Â,Jh )/ ;s,6 . 9* M=NWc)FG BE M=Na qí=? b5¦· ,Ò IS @Wr LR,= .

-B ;�y=�± M=Na )V M=NWc)FG Bà ¥=.( -M=:( q6A o* ;�y=�± 5* @· ,= K* )U C ,6Y

IS,;. +,w qhR ( o* 6�67 ;s5± �= .9-7 `( ;. )¯�

-�¦X? 5; C L1 o- ¹,_ ( )/ `( T=N�

5* �= .9-7 E){_

`( ¶; ?,_)* ¶; ?,_ q-ß,a M=Na q¨ÀX �X? ;�j5{Y M=Na -M=N6. ,ÇV 5WG ,À; ?(E ;�¦6? ¡B,_ T=N� )V (57)* )/ 56 7 @Wr license issue )FG B9* )P

; ? -M{= KV `( R56 71,6 .)*

135

q³6 ? X¾-?,X . 5Ê M=Nv

U.,¼ ©,Jå;N_( M=N

U.5WGà -b( X¾-?,X . 5Ê b5®U.,¼ IX . approval ¡R àqU �´

L1 T=NS ,-K6: B1( `( IX . q8 �=NJ· q- �6: B1( `( o* T

8CB5X CB q³6 ? R56 75j àM=NWc -M{= KV q³6 ?( ;. `( 9X : o

U ¹5* implementation M=N>- ? o

U ¹5WGE dPX ? 9´( I= . +,J;?

M=:-2= nX¤ R56 75j M=NWc B1( I= . +,J;? ¥U.,[j R56 75j M=NWc 5; C dPX ? @=�V128 n=KX: 5* ,-KX75Ê )¬OFG ,XY IS

@Wr ,-K; :( -B 8�-Kµ b,>·)* )V M=NU.,6Y )´E

`( ¶; ?,_)* @Wr )- O¯: ( q Wr -b( b1B(R( o* 56 7 mB(R( -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na ¡896 : ¥»

3¢j )/ oU ¹5* æµ,-Kj ,J· M=NWc)FG BE -b( M=Na = .( LB(R( I= . q³6 ? )FG IS 1( q6A

¡8R q§ ¥=.(à oX¹ oX¹ ¥=.( B1( @=�V128 n=KX: mB(R()*’ -b( 5* @Wr )- O¯g=�6: ,6Y )FG B M=NWc 5; C dPX ? ¡B,JWr o´R9*B,k b,>· q XY qU �´ IS = .( ,[= C( LB(R( 56 7 ¥XY ,W cB )FG B1(

B5; O±,È )FGà`( 5* @Wr )- O¯g=�6: ,6Y M=NWc)FG B 5; C `( ,k 6�®Þj )FG IS @=�V128 n=KX: ¡28 n[-Na

)]C B,k à)FG -b( 5* dPX ? �= .-dh 8�-Kµ -B I- . )U C R M=N

U.,6Y 5; C 2; n>6? ,Ò5WGE `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ T=N� ¡B5X 7 )* ¥U.,[jà 56 7 q§ -M=:( q6A o* ¥»

3/ M=Na ,= . 5®= .dPê T=N� 56 7 ¡B5X 7 o* o

; ¹,6Y )FGà`( o* ¥»3/ M=Na @Wr +,k 9* M=NWc)FG BE M=Na b5WG,;K-:,a IS

6s,6 t-�X: M=Na ¶X g· ¸5V m89{X . )U O´ -M{= KV -b( 5* q³6 ?( ;. o

U ¹5* M=N>- ? I;KX: IS (5WG ,= K* ’

(-24 oU ¹5WGà -b( )/ ¡B5{= .B o* qU �´ ,= . M=N>

- ? o* qU �´ B1( ;�¦6? mB,_ TXNJX ? 6f ( q³6 ? )¢¬C ( M=NWc IS 56 7 T=N� ¡B5X 7 9* )FG B M=NWc q§ -M=:( q6A o* ¥»

3/ M=Na ,= . q- �X:( b5= C28 nÁ=Kµ o* ¥»

3/ M=NaE 5; C `( 9X : ,= K* oU ¹(1BB,k o* qU �´E 0123 4 M=Na 5; C ,= K*

,= K´ IS @Wr ;�¦6? Å®-th M=NWc -M{= KV `( )* �°6 C dPX ? @Wr 3 5j, -Y 5WG 9* ¶8 �=N6. E)U O´

`( ¶; ?,_)* Hydro Carbon Development Institute )FGE I= . 8s5= O

8N=K8N[-C( +,J

;? ;s,= KV57,a @=�V128 n=KX:B1( 5* refine ,;.9* )FGE I= . LB(R( q³6 ?

136

+,k M=N>- ? 9* ,W cBà q

- �X:( Iª-R ¡B(R ¡B5X C M=N>- ? 9* ,W cB )FGà @=�V128 n=KX: M=Na q³6 ? 8s1xa

B1()FG q§ -M=:( q6A M=Na q³6 ? 8s1xa 9* )* `( 5* ,= .xXY ,6Y E)FG ,W cB M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS 56 7 mB(R( +,k M=N>

- ? 9* )FG B M=NWcà q- �X:( Iª-R ¡B(R ¡B5X C M=N>

- ? 9* M=NWc)FG Bà -b( 9X : 8<* ,= .,ÇV E)

U C ,6Y ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_E 26 nS(2= n3_ -b,-Y E 6�7,p

6s,-K67 2= n

3_ 26 nS( -b,-Y: I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R E 6�7,p9{= KXN_ m2= nª 1R 8<* -M

3/5j )P; ? B1( L1 æ®

-p 2= n-.56 C o* T=N� o

U ¹xX K/ mB,6 .)* M=Na )P; ?E 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R

6�7,p9{= KXN_ M=Na )- C L2; n_ 26 nJ

;�/ 2013 M=Na q6 Ky§( B5®¼ IX . = .( R(RB(dº 15j o* q³

; ? B1( `( ;<º1 -¾ =�3/ 6s,;Kµ ( 6�7,p R56 75j à)P

; ? T67 )- C `( 5*

oppose M=N>- ? ,= K* ,À; ? B1( mB5X C `U1,W c )

- C `( 5* unanimously ,= K* E,À; ? `( 9X : M=Na 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 6�7,p9{= KXN_ Xs ( ,kà 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p B1( mB5X C `U1,W c ,k I= .9{

3_ (R( b5WG,;.9* IS b5¦- ?( )- C I= . R(RB(dº unanimously o* q³

; ?E 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 6�7,p9{= KXN_ `( �°6 C)* `( ;sB( -B1 o* Iª-R ¡B(R q³

; ? under Rule 169 sub rule 2 )* ;�g;? ;sB( -B1 �-K6:,X . q³

; ? IS `( R(RB(dº IX . ¶X 7 )- O¬N>h B�-.()* o

U ¹5* oU ¹(1BB,k o

; ¹9*E`( q6 Ky§( 8<=:98 :9{= K/ o* �d² )/ 28 n=KV -B q³6 ? )U O´à reminders q³6 ? )U O´à 9Äa `( ;sB( -B1 )

- C `( R(RB(dº ,k oU ¹5*

6s(56 7 M=N>- ? ,= .RE dPX ? 04-04-2014 5* M=Na )

- C `( I6 Y1 )/ privilege motion move ,= K* IS `( -B-dåj -b(5= C( o* ’ ¡2= nª M=N>

- ?à `( -B-dåj -b(5= C( ,k Z,½g;�/(

137

f196 gh 5WG ,»X 7 )FG b5= O* IS I= . 2= n-.56 C 5* T=N� o

U ¹xX K/ )- C 9* o* 56 7 R(RB(dº

q³; ?à`( mB5X C -b(5= C( -B-dåj )

- C `( R(RB(dº o* ¡B5 Ø�-Oj ¡R q³; ?E 6s,-K67 D(1! `(

Iv[®_ M=Na’ `( B( -B1 ;s )- C o

U ¹5* oU ¹(1BB,k M=N>

- ? o*E M=Na 56 7 2= n-.56 C æ®

-p)* mB,6 .)* M=Na ;s,6 . 9* b5WG,W cB B1( 2= n

-.56 C RB()* R9´ )- O;N]Y q³6 ? 0x-p( M=NWcà ;s(5Ê

)FGà o6¹(5¿ )FGà D,a 8�-K* q�-N6t=?( )FGà 9U:5V 9= :R B1()FG `( ¶; ?,_)* -b(Rdh æ®

-p )FGà -b( B,_m 0x-p( M=Na o

U ¹5Ê T=N� à)FG �2Í æ®-p 2= n

-.56 C M=Na oU ¹5Ê T=N� @Wr(di

M=N>- ? o* qU �´ )FGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 6�7,p9{= KXN_! æ®

-p 2= n-.56 C )* q; �y=�± ;sxÇ-O67 5*,6 .5

8 C o* I6 Y1 )/ Virginia tobacco o* ¡B,= K

;: M=Na ¥»V,6 . @; � -7 M=NWc)FG B5WGE `( Iv[®_ M=Na

`( 5*,6 .58 C )/à `( Virginia )/à `( ¥Õµ )/ ¡-9*dh ;�j5{Y 5* -9U:,[{= .( o8 ¹5= C8R o* �a M=Na b56 CB( )¯C 1B o* -b�a ( q WrB ( )FG B1( b,>=? IX . q6A9

-:( -2ïUC(9* ^va

M=Na ;�¦6? LR,= .-B B1()FG q6A9

-:( -2ïUC(9* o* I6 Y1 )/ b,>=? IX . @Wr 3T

3Ê5* 9* M=NWc)FG B IS ,= K

-: @=?8R M=NU.,-K6: ,= . 56 7 LR56 75j @=?8R )FGà`( M=Na q8 �¢= NXK* M=N

U.,É896 :E `(5; C )U OV )* M=Na = .( proposal ’ b,>=? 9X : 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p )P8 �¬N6. M=NWc)

U C 5WGE M=Na )- C 56 7

R(RB(dº 15j o* )FGà9´( æ®-p 2= n

-.56 C 5* T=N� @Wr(di o* qU �´ 5; C b,W c1 IX . mB,JWr q; �y=�± ;sxÇ-O67 56 7 IS `( 5*,6 Ky

; ? o* ¥Õµ o* I6 Y1 )/ ¥»V,6 . @; � -7 5WG M=NWc){YE9´( b,W c1 IX .

oU ¹5Ê T=N� o* I6 Y1 )/ LB,6 .1R mB,JWr q; �y=�± ;sxÇ-O67 ¥Ò( M=NWc); O{_ 5; C q§( xÇ-O67 ;s o* I6 Y1 )/ mB,JWr x= K6:9

;: @=?8R o* o´�-. -B �= .-dh ×896 : q; �{_ E)FG

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E

138

6s,-K67 2= n3_ 26 nS( -b,-Y: 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p = .( 1R 8�- OjE `(

Iv[®_ M=Na -M=NU. ( )* ¥»= O

8 :B ( ,k IÂ(57 q³6 ? mR ,W cB b5WGEmB,JWr x= K6:9;: @=?8R o*

o´�-. -B �= .-dh ×896 : q; �{_ )FG b5= O* IS b,W c1 9X : ;sxÇ-O67 I- . )- C 5WG o* I6 Y1 )/à 2= n

-.56 C ,k o

- ¹,X . T67 fd² x= K6:9;: @=?8R M=Na ¥

-Y(R 5WG ,;K{_ à)FG )- O¯: ( ¶; ?,_ silting o; ¹,6Y

)FGE 9´( ;�j5{Y `( Iv[®_ M=Na I= . o- ¹,6 .2îh m9* IS b,W c1 9X : o

U ¹5Ê T=N� @Wr(di m9* 5; C b,W c1 x= K6:9

;: @=?8R o´�-. -B ×896 : q; �{_ E)FG `( ¶; ?,_)* ¶; ?,_ M=Na -M=N

U. ( ¥»= O8 :B ()* 178 ,k IÂ(57 q³6 ? mR b5WG,W cBE

o; ¹B�£ T=N� o* ;s,=.B12

- Í o* ¾ =�679;: ‘‘T67 )]C 5¿ M=Na o

; ¹B�£ T=N� ,k 24 IJ3�X 7

æ±(1 5WGà `( )Ë3 �¯7 )/ ;s,= .B12

- Í ¡B5X C )* )- C 9* )®[®_ M=Na @Wr b5= C�-K6:,X . B1(

Iª-R b5= C(R æ6 C,; .)* M=NWcà 56 7 +5= C 9X : -B,- w ( -�¼,-. b5WGà -b,;K¢*,X . 9Ä= .R)* b5Ü7 9X : ¾ =�679;:

¥p,Y o´5WG ’’E 6s,-K67 D(1! `( -M=NU. ( )* ¥»= O

8 :B ( 178 )* mB,6 . M=Na ’ 56 7 b,>=? IX . 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p )P8 �¬N6. M=NWcE M=Na ,;K-:,a b5WG IS T=N� o* shortage )FGE

9Äa `( R(RB(dº ,k `,X . ,-KP·B `( ;sB( -B1 5* E)¬OFG ,XY M=Na I= . I>· b5WG,W cB IS 9´( qå±(1 Xs ( `,X .)* T=N� o* qË· )FGà M=Na I= . b5WG,;K-:,a IS mB5X C ^va M=Na T=N� o* qË· E)FG

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_E

6s,-K67 2= n3_ 26 nS( -b,-Y: 9´( Xs ( )U O

-: -M3 ¢{= K-NS ,-K=:R M=NWc); OFG ,XY 5; C `( R(RB(dº

o* q- � 3/1B M=NaEE

139

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? = KU:,aEI= .9{

3_ M=NÂ5P·E

6s,-K67 2= n3_ 26 nS( -b,-Y: -M=N

U. ( ¥»= O8 :B ()*178 )* ;�g;? `( M=Na mB,JWr

)]C 5¿ ,kà mB,JWr )å® -p ,k l7 ,;K-N6. )FG ISEmB,JWrEEEE )å® -p 5* ¡R )

U C ,6YE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 2= n

3_ 26 nS( -b,-Y: M=Na = .( I°µR Xs ( )/ B1( 28 n[-Na )/EE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: 2= n

-.56 C o* T=N� IX . B,XY I°µR 5WG ,= K´ E)FG

6s,-K67 2= n3_ 26 nS( -b,-Y: B5®¼ 9X : M=NJWr assurance M=:R IS (B,JWr ¾ =�679

;: b1R,= K

-N6. 9X : T=N� ,k IvUK¢j ¥Y 5WG ,ÒE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E28 nS(8R -b(dËÔ 8K -7 E 6�7,p

28 nS(8R -b(dËÔ 8K -7: I= .9{

3_ q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_E |-R5|}~( �'(,�6 . ~ -M�j � -M��= N�3[V( E�@=��67~�9V( �@��6 C

�'( -M� yA�9~V( E�@= ��7�9~V( q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p M=Na 9= :dÎ;C M=N>

- ? b19* ,Ò B1( m2= nª X¾-?,X .

T8N-KU :(5X C M=NWc `( 9X : q

- � 3/1B b5V(8R ,ÒE 28 n[-Na 6�7,p q³6 ? R56 75j M=NWc B1( o

- ¹,J= �VB,X . ¡98:9{= K/ 6�7,p q³6 ? M=NWc B1( -b( o* ;�7,-p1 6�®È b19* ,ÒE M=Na )

- C q- �X:( 8�6 g6?

o* 9=:dÎ;C M=Na Gas Infrastructure Development Cess 9X : ;s,6 . o* q³; ? IS -b( b56 C5¿ M=Na -M6 7 b5±xw T=N� produce 5WG q WrB )FGE T

-C,-Kµ ¥6.

140

M=Na Xs ( )- C ¥a, 3_ ,= K* IS `( 9X : Xs ( Cess ,ÇV )FG B M=NWcE B(8R 6�7,p )

- C )®À�X? b5

- CR ’ `( 9X : 8<* ,ÇV B1( R5-7 q Wr `( M=Na T8N=.B @· )¬O*E )P]�h I= . ¶6 gË§

M=N>- ? o

; ¹ ( IS ¥»= O8 :B ( 158’161B1( 162I= . ,;K¦· )FG IS T67 )]C 5¿ M=Na 56 7 q³6 ? resources b5WG L1 `( )]C 5¿ ,k x>X? l7 )FGE 5; C q�* )]C 5¿ )* l7 9X :

Xs ( Cess )¢¬NS ,ÇV ); O{_ M=NWc `( o* ;�7,-p1 o* )U C ,6YE )P]�h I= . ,= .,;K6: )

U C ,6Y IS oU ¹5* 8�{= .( ,[= C( )FG `( )®[®_ M=Na o

U ¹5* T-N-K=:8RB ( ,= .D ,=K´ )FGE ¥p( M=Na 5; C I= .

,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XY IS 9´( Xs ( T-C,-Kµ ¥6. M=Na `( 5* IÕ7 )

; C ,-K6: M=NWc 5; C Xs ( 5* U1,W c M=Na two-third majority )* 1dP; ? `( 5* ,-.D m89X : ,ÒE 5

; C )¢¬NS Xs ( = .( )]C 5¿ ,k l7 ,-K=NÂ ); OFG ,XY M=NWcE é,-Y 9* M=Na )* oX¹ )* o* ;s,6 . b19* ,Ò IS b,W c1 9X : 56 7 T=N� produce 5WG q WrB )FG IS `( 9X : @Wr 3T

3Ê5* 9* )FG B M=NWc IS ¡B,JWr 56 7 -9= :28 n_ 8�-.( M=NWc `( o* revival 5WGE ¡B,Ò -B12= n6. ,k (96 : ©,Y )FG B1( qí=? �Y(1 I;K/(B )FG T67 )* )å¬C B-R @Wr )- O¯: ( B,Ò -B12= n6. b5

- C(56 75- C 5* b,W c1 9X :

B,Ò -B1B DR ); O{_ M=NWcE M=Na ;�7,-p1 b5WG,XY ,Ò 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )/E

¡241R -2= nX¤ 56 7 unidentified gas thefts M=NWc 56 7gas losses 5WG

)FG B M=NWc (9´1( )* -9V1B )* l6C,Þj consumers 9X : `( ,k ¶6 756 C ,;. ( )FG L1 �2Í 4.5 8�- N_9X : consumer )/ ©5¿1 ,= K* ,;.,6Y )FGE q³6 ?( I= . )- OPQ= .R M=Na ( ,W cB )FG IS ;�j5{Y 3T

3Ê5* 9* q WrB )FG IS 9�Õ=Oµ ;. `( f23 4 5* )V )U C ,6YE

5; C I= . = .( ;�¦6? ¡896 : o; ¹R,= .

-B 5WG o´ B1( ;�¦6? (896 : ¶6 756 C consumer 9X : m89X : ,ÒE `( o* ;�7,-p1 q³6 ? M=Na ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS ¡28 n[

-Na )P]�h mR B1( `( U1,W c 5* mRE ¡2ï=N

;. ;s,6 . L(5- g-?5; O-gX?26 n=K

-7 )* 8<*28 n_8R â9* M=Na T=N� o* ¡B5X 7 5WG q WrB )FG T67 )* )®[®_ M=Na L(5- g

-?5; O-gX?26 n=K-7 o* ;�j5{Y ’ 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p B1( `( o*

141

¡28 n[-Na )

- C = .( \-K8N=Kj o* q³; ? T67 M=Na )P]�h q³6 ? )- OP

8 �=N6. ,k æ±5j xaE `( M=Na I= . ;s,6 . )² o

U ¹5WG q³; ? IS 7 6sB( I- .D,_ -b,ÕÖ

-C `( ¡B5X 7 o* I6 Y1 )/ 56 7 )FG ,W cB `( )* )¬OV ©B 8�= Kµ 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ L(5- g-?5; O-gX?26 n=K

-7 8�- Oy- ?B5´ B1( (9´1( ¥a 9* 6.6 6sB( )¯C 1B

`( 9X : M=NU.,ÇV )´E 56 7 ¡B5X 7 5WG q WrB )FG `( 5* legalize )

- C 9* )* )¬OV L(5- g-?5; O-gX?26 n=K

-7 o* ;�j5{Y ¥JQa B,= K; : )FGE Xs ( 5* 58 O=:28 n[

-Na 8�= .( 8sB5X N_ )- O¬: R )* )¬OV B,= K; : )FG B1( -M

3 ¢{-K* 56 7 consumer 5* legalize )- C 9* )¬OV q³6 ?

L(5- g-?5; O-gX?26 n=K

-7 o* ;�j5{Y B,= K; : )FGE M=Na I= . ,-K-:,6Y ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS `( 9X : +,k 6<*

0123 4 ,= K* )U C ,6Y ,ÒE `( )/ 7 6sB( )¯C 1B I- .D,_ -b,ÕÖ

-C 5WG ,W cB )FGE q³; ?5X 7 -2= nX¤

8s,W c5* )/ 6s,6 t-�X: o* �d² q¨Ò 9Ä6Y = .( I£xw )FG b,>6A 24 X¾

-?( o* -M=Na -M3 ¢= NJ�

-C(98 : -MU :D oV(8R ,6Y q WrB )FG T67 )* )¬OV 1400 -M=Nva )¯C 1B Å;O-gh )¬O* )U O´

M=NWcE -M=NU. ( o* f1B l6C,Þj)* q�* q³6 ? )º xw )/ b,>6A )/ T=N� produce

o; ¹5WG 5WG ,= . o

U ¹5* q³6 ? ,[= C( resource 5WG 5; C `( I£xw ,k x>X? l7 ,;K-N6. )FG IS

`( )* 56 7 source M=NWc `( )* 5 5®k 28 n=Kj )*radius M=Na )®>? -M3 ¢{-K*

b5´5V 5* )¬C R M=NU.,6YE `( 9X : +,k 0123 4 )FG b,W c1 )* )º xw 5* -M

3 ¢{= K-NS M=N>

- ? )¬C R ,6Y )FG B M=NWcE `(5; C )* )¬OV ¡2= nª 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p )/ ;�7,-p1 B,kBR )FGE ¡9-7 ( -2= nX¤ `( @§5j M=Na q³6 ? b5= Oj9´ M=Na T=N� o* 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ q³6 ?( q³6 ? ¡B,6Y )FG Ñ®;K-gh b5±xw M=NaE -b,-ÕjB ,k I-K=N>h ( ,W cB )FG B1( 23 nS( -b,-ÕjB M=Na ¡9g§ B1(

¡B,Þµ( ,k ;<º1 ,;. ( )FG 5; C T=N� o* 8R5V \-. 8�= K3/ o* o

; ¹,6Y )FGE 5V 23 ï= C9X : ,k q³6 ? IvUK¢j Ñ®;K-gh b5±xw )/ ( ,W cB )FG B1( é,-Y B5² 9X : m2= nª )Î®Y )/E 5; C ¡2= nª 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )/ 3 B(-9´ )FG IS `( o* �d² I6 Y5

; C ¡R )U C ,6Y B1(

immediately ¶X g· ;s,a,»7( )¬C R M=NU.,6Y IS,;. �-KU: ( )

- C ( )V (1 -b,-ÕjB Ñ= C23 4

M=Na T=N� 8R5V \-. 8�= K3/ B1( 5V 23 ï= C9X : )/ ,X t6? ,6Y E){_ Xs ( ,k ;�¦6? ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_E

142

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: B(R24 ©,J· -b,-Y \-.,XY 6�7,pE

B(R24 ©,J· -b,-Y \-.,XY: o

- ¹,6 .2îh 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ 6�7,pE (2= nª l®°;C 8<*28 n_8R

-M=:�6 . )/ )FG b,>6A )/ 6�/ )/ LR,= .-B ¥=K

;: ,;K®»-C )FG 1( B T=N� q³6 ? b,W c1 )/

LR,= .-B B(�½j M=Na q; �®»

-C )FGE b,W c1 9X : 1980)* 6<=:dº ¥=K;: ,-K®»

-C 0123 4 (5WG B1( )®>? b,W c1 9X : Union Texas B1( `( )* �°6 C British Petroleum 6s( I-KU:,XY -2= n-KXNJ· UEP )FG 56 7 ¥=K

;: q; �V,»-C )FGE 9Äa `5¢µ( )* ¶; ?,_ ,-K¦· I= . ,;.89X : )FG IS b,W c1 9X : q³6 ? ;sD,Y `( )Î¬C d² )/ M=NWc IS b,W c1 )* ¥k5V 56 7 ¸5V M=NWc -b( 5* -96 :,6Y ¥»V,6 . M=N>

- ? ); O¬: RE -b( 5* o8 ¹5PX A 56 7 IÁ=KP

8 ? b5= CB(R M=Na ¥a, 3_ M=N>- ? )

; C 9*E `( )Î¬C d² )/ ;sD,Y (�= KX: )

; C 5WG M=NWc IS T67 )Î¬C d² )/ -b,;K¢X75®6 . M=Na oU ¹5Ê )*

)º xw M=Na T=N� 5; C q¨a 9Äa `( )º xw M=Na T=N� M=N>- ? )FGE `( )Î¬C d² )/

-M=:�6 . M=Na ¥=K;: B1( T=N� 5; C ,;K®»

-C )FG 9Äa 6�/ )/ LR,= .-B -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na ;<6:d-Ô q³6 ?

q Wr1 9X : )FGE ;<6:d-Ô o* 2= nÁÂ )* )¯�=�-: L1 ¸5V o´�-. -B 2ï6 C )FG B M=NWcE b,W c1 9X :

q³6 ? qí=? ,;.5WG )FG IS 56 7 -b(2ïµ ( )®>? )/ )ÄÂ )U C 5WG M=NWc 56 7 British

Petroleum M=Na ,= . Union Texas M=Na )ÄÂ )U C 5WG )P

; ? L1 q³6 ?( ;. M=NWcE I½= Cd² I= . ,;.5WG )FG IS 56 7 b,W c1 ,k road block ,;.9* )FG ,= . o

U ¹5* ;sx»3¢j (�= KX: ,;.9* )FG `( 5* = .( 1R -96 :,6Y mR 9* `( ,k I-Kj �-K6: 9* ); O¬NÂ M=NWcE 9Äa 8s2= nª 9X : 6f ( ;. ¶X g· q³6 ? M=N>

- ? 5WG ,W cBE m2= nª ©,= K-7 M=Na 56 7 o

U ¹5Ê T=N� )* )º xw M=Na ;sD,Y (�= KX: )

U C 5WG )P; ?E -M=:�6 . 5* q³6 ? `( )Î¬C d² )/ b,W c1 9X : ,= KV ,6Y ,W cB )FGE 5; C

`( )Î¬C d² )/ I- . b5WGE b,W c1 9X : ); O¦· M=NWc IS qU �P6 ? -b( )* `,X . skill M=N>- ?

skill -b5* mR ,Ò I= . 8�- Oy- ?B5´ o* Iª-R ¡B(R )FG B1( L1 -b( 5* \-K

-N=.98 : mR

143

B1( -b( b5´5V 5* -96 :,6Y ¡R M=NU.,6YE (241R I= . )FG IS b,W c1 9X : 56 7 mB,JWr )¯�6?

M=NWc `( 6<=:d-Ô æ®-p )* -b( 5* 2W c,6 . X�

3/9V,»/ ¡R )U C ,6Y IS,;. L1 `( ¥6.,£ 5WG

M=NÁ_ IS L1 -b( ¥=K;: B1( T=N� b5= O

-NXKy· M=Na -96 :,6Y 8�-.5Ú8R M=NÁ_E ¡2= nª I= . 3 B(-9´ )FGE `( )* �°6 C 56 7 production bonus )FG `( 9X : q³6 ? q³6 ?( ;. o

U ¹5* decision M=N>

- ? )FGE 6f ( ¡2= nª 28 n[-Na 6�7,p ©,J· 6�7,p )/ ;s,£xa q³6 ? o

U ¹5WG q³; ? B1( M=Na )

- C qí=? 3 B(-9´ o* q³; ? IS b,W c1 9X : mB,JWr )

8 C 5PX A )8 C 5PX A bU1,Ò

M=NWc 56 7 -b( -B,= .9= :( M=Na M=NWc b,>6A )/ T=N� q; �®»-C )FG -b( -B,= .9= :( 5* T=N� o*

;<V5¦§ @Wr(di o* )U C ,6YE¡896 : o

- ¹,6 .2îhE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: I= .9{3_E �=K/ Ñ¿ ( -M=N

-K¢7E �=K/ Ñ¿ ( -M=N

-K¢7: q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p ,[= C( ^va 56 7 ©9X g=�-: -24B5¢= CB )/ (dP6 ?

(89X : )FG B1( ¡896 : q; �y�±�6 . o* ;s,6 . I= . )FG IS @· `( ^va M=Na b,>6A 9X : mB,JWr `,X . di(1 B(�½j M=Na ¥U. ( ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XY T=N� o

- ¹5WG )¬OFG ,XYE @Wr ©28 n-K=N_ ,= K3¢= C( B1(

-b(9= :( 1 9Ä= .R ^Â,Jh )/ T=N� X<U :,X . -M

U :D )- C ,ÀX �6? B1( 9Ä= .R ;s(�Wc,°j o* �d² ,6Y

)FG B M=NWcE I6 Y1 ,= K* )FGE I6 Y1 I= . )FG IS @Wr )- C Xf2ï= CB ,k +,k @

; �-7 9* ,= .R )FGE `( mB5X C tenure M=Na 56 7 = .( ©,_ (B-9´ )FG B1( `( )* )®>? )* X¾

-?,X . ©,_ M=Na q³6 ? 9´( ¶{= .R M=NÂ 5; C Xs ( )

- C oU ¹5* )U O

-: wells M=N>- ? mR5P·E Xf2ï= CB

,k +,k M=N>- ? ,= K*E ©128 n=KX: B1( T=N� o* ;<i,= .BR qU �

-: M=N>- ? o* B1( `( ^va M=Na

b,>6A q- �;:( di(1 B(�½j M=Na ¥U. ( T=N� ©5* +,J

;? M=:-2= nX¤ R56 75j M=NWcE Xs ( q- �X:( 56 7

qh,k,-. q³; ? 56 7 58 O=:28 n[

-Na 8�= .( )* )V (57 )/ q³; ? B1( 56 7 Xs ( o* \-K-:xX . )* )V (57

)/ q³; ?E

144

M=Na m896 : `5¢µ( )* ¶; ?,_ ,;K¦· b5WG IS M=Na 6�67 `( 8�6 g6? 5* ¶{= .R ,W cB ,À; ? 5; C \-K-:xX . )* 9X :1( 56 7 ¡B,JWr ;sB( -B1 \-K-:xX . B1( 8�- OyX�®= .18R `( )

- C Ñ®;K-gh b5¦Ð6Y 9X : )- O¯: ( b5±xw M=Na )- O¯: ( b5Ö®Y M=Na M=N>· 9X : \-K¢*,6 . @6 A )

- C ,-K6: )* )¬OV M=N>· 8· ¥-K3¢= N-. @=�´ )* )¬OV M=N>· q�* -2= nX¤ )*

)¬OV b56 CB( )¯C 1B ¶*B )¬C R M=NWc -M{= KV 9´( Xs ( )U O-: wells )

; C R5P· Xf2ï= CB ); C 9*

5; C qU �-: -2= n-KXNJ· M=N

;. ( 5; C Xs ( 5* ¥U. ( q³6 ? ,;K®a B1( T=N� q³6 ? q; �®aE ¡241R �d² T=N� o* 6¾ =�

8 :B, 3_ o* ,>; �-:( M=NÀQ= .R IS ¡B5X C ¡B5X C ;s(B ¸5V q

- �X:( b5= C 8B,Ò 5* b5- OU:D M=Na )

; C ,ÇV M=NWc T=N� ); C (1dP6 ? M=NWc B1( ¾ 6�¿ dPX ? L1 -2ïµ ( )

; C ,6Y M=NWcE L1 b5= C 8B,Ò 56 7)V (1 ¾ 6�¿ b5X g6? 5* ©5{_ )

- C ,6Y )V (1 L1 ¡B5X C ;s(B 5* ,;K´,6Y )FGE 6<=:d-Ô qhR ( q

- �X:( ¡8B,Ò M=Na 1R 5Ê )¯C 1B )- C ,X t6? )* )¬OV ¡B5X C ;s(B ,;K´,6Y )FGE 6f (

©,t;?B5¿ I= . )FG IS b1B,XY b56 C5¿ o* -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C ¶{= .R M=NÂ 5; C ^v6 KX: 8sB5X N[-C(98 :

b5*824 9X : @· o; ¹5WG ,6Y q WrB E)FG 8s5= OU:(9X : b,=.

8B,Ò q; �Ú896 : ,6Y q WrB EM=NWc q- �Ó= C = .(

I½6 O² ,[= C( )FG 56 7afford 9* ,;K{_ )FG L1 ¡8B,Ò �= .9-7 ,W cB )FG B1( ^v6 KX: 8sB5X N[

-C(98 : @=�V128 nX. o* I6 Y1 à)/ @=�V128 nX. o* M=Na Xs ( 5* ;sB5¿ ©,Y U1,;K6: IS ,= K* )FG = .( ©,_ M=Na T=N

UK; : )¯C 1B )* 6<=:dº ;s,_ I°µR @=�V28 nX. o* M=N;Ky=�± o

U ¹,É896 : M=NUK´ B1(

¶8 ? ( )¯C 1B )/ )V 9* 5- C )¯C 1B ;. @· o* EM=N

UK´ T=NUK; : )¯C 1B M=N

;Ky=�± ,É896 : 9* ¶8 ? ( )¯C 1B @· 9* ¡R M=N

UK´ 5; C 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ I= . ¡896 : 6�=O6gÔ ©,t;?B5¿ E)FG T=N�

)* +,J;? ¥

3_dË· B1( ¥=.28 n_ 8�-.( -M3 ¢{-K* 9X : ¡�-K6:,X . EM=NWc 6s( T67 ^va M=Na

¥=.28 n_ 8�-.( T=N� -M3 ¢{-K* 9X : = .( ©,_ )/ ¡�-K6:,X . 5WG 5; C b,W c1 9X : q�

-C5* b,= .28 n_ 8�-.(

M=NÃÂ EM=NUK´ 56 7 o

- ¹(9X : b,= .28 n_ 8�-.( M=NWc L1 q³6 ? �-K6: 5WG q WrB M=NWc B1( I= . Xs ( ,k q�= NÂ,X .

o* I6 Y1 )/ 5WG ,W cB E)FG 9´( Xs ( o* ¡28 n[-Na o* q�= NÂ,X . 2; n>6? o

; ¹5WG B1( @· @U ?,8 .

145

M=Na I= . q�= NÂ,X . à); C ,-K6: )U O

-: T=N� -M3 ¢{-K* b5= C28 n_ 8�-.( 5* ); O¬: R qU �

-: b,= .28 n_ 8�-.( =N

;KÄÂM B1( 6s,6Y Xs ( 5*provide M=N

;.5WG B1( Xs ( o* qh5- C,k( 2; n>6? Eo

; ¹5WG

-M{= KV 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ `( �d² oU ¹5* I6 Y5

; C M=N>- ? E)FG ¥=K

;: ¡8B5X 7 ,k IvUK¢j qXA(9* )/ )V 9* dÌ Ø�j ×89´ ;. ¶{= .R M=NÂ IS ¥=K

;: o* )]C ,>; �-:( ¡8B5X 7 )FG B1( m896 :

m896 : ¥=K;: B5X 7 6f ( 6sB( q; �X: 5WG )U O´ EM=NWc 9Äa 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ o* `( �d² oU ¹5* I6 Y5

; C M=N>- ? E)FG ¡241R �d² -9= :2- nU.,ç= CB o* à©,t

;?B5¿ -b,;K¢*,X . )* T67 )]C 5¿ M=Na q³6 ? )®¯Y M=N

U.,6Y o- ¹(9= :( ©128 nX. ¥Çy§ 5WG ,W cB )FG B1( `( o* ¥=K/ )®À· +,w 5WG q WrB )FG

B1( oU ¹5* q³6 ? )- OP¯A5X C M=N>

- ?D(1 )FG IS Xs ( o* 56 7 q- �X:( ¡28 n_ 8�-.( )FG T67 )Î¬C d²

)/ ©128 nX. o* ;�=Oy Wr( o- ¹5WG )¬OFG ,XY L1 -9= :2- nU.,ç= CB +,k )

- C 9* )* R56 71,6 . q³6 ? `( o* L1 -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C M=N>- ? E)FG 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ !M=Na 3 B(-9´ b19* ,Ò IS 9

-7 ( L1 q�-C5*

;s,W c56 71 M=NWc IS @=�V128 nX. ¡28 n[-Na T67 5* `( ;<º1 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ 5* ,J· 9* ,-K=:R à)¬OFG ,XY T67 )* `,X . ¥U. ( 8�-K=:( T=N� )¢¬N]Y àmB(R( o

U ¹5Ê -bB�_ B1( -bBRB,-. )¢¬N]Y mB(R( M=NWc B1( `( 5* ,J· 9* ,-K=:R )¬OFG ,XY B1( L1 ,;K¦· )FG IS M=NJWr 8�-Kµ ,= K¦h )¬O* M=N

U.,6YE I= . ¡896 : q; �y�±�6 . o* ;s,6 . )FG B1( M=Na 3 B(-9´ b19* ,Ò IS @=�V128 nX. ¡28 n[

-Na M=Na L1 8�- Oy

8 ?B,X K=:8R T67 5* ¡B,»6 g

-? M=Na )V ,= .,6Y ,6Y ,W cB )FG B1( L1 q³6 ?( 8<i(9X : M=Na à)FG 5; C `( 5* q³6 ? -b( +,J

;? b1-2= nX¤ )/ ,k1B E)U C ,6Y EI= .9{

3_

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ : �=K3¢y6A q; �/R E 6�7,p

6s,-K67 �= K

3¢y6A �JA( q; �/R : I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 E9{= KXN_ 3 B(-9´ )FG IS 8�6 g6? 9X : 3�g6?

5WG q WrB )FGE IÁ-.5= O* -b(dËQY M=NWc q- �-:,a 5; C b5¦- ?( )

- C M=N>- ? E)FG IÁ-.5= O* ;�j5{Y I>·

146

q WrB )FG IS 56 7 8�6 g6? @Wr )- C ,= .,-K6: )FG L1 ;�/BR )FG B1( `( 9X : 3�g6? 5; C dPX ?

3�g6? q Wr )FG B1( q- �-:,a 5; C -b( o* E)FG q Wr1 ©,3Kj )FG IS ¥Ç

-O67 M=Na B5j ,XY,-. 5; C T* )

- C 3 B(-9´E,ÀQ= .R )FG IS @=�V128 nX. ¡28 n[-Na 9X : ;�¦6? Xf9

-7 )FG B ( M=NWc B1( `( )* m896 : )¯A 9X 7 q³6 ? q; �y�±�6 .EM=NWc )FG IS 56 7 mB(R( æµ,-Kj 3Tg6? M=NWc @Wr `( 9X : q³6 ? 96 g

-� -7 xXY )FG B EM=NWc @Wr )- C `( 8�6 g6? M=Na ¾

-ß(1 I>· ,= .R )FG IS 1( q6A ¡8R q§ ¥=.( 5* q³6 ? M=NXt=�6: E)´ ,-K=N½= C ^va 5* X¾ =�6: 9* q Wr @Wr )

- C 8�6 g6? ,-.,-K6: )FG ¡dP; ? àq6A B5µ q6A qX�=�6: B1( 8�6 g6? à,-K6: mB,JWr o

U ¹5* T{=K8 : ,k M=N>

- ? E,;KX: q§( @=�V128 nX. 9X : 9´( Xs ( T{=K

8 : ¶{= .R M=NÂ IS ,-K;NS (896 : T{=K8 : ,ÇV )FG B M=NWc B1( )P]�h `5¢µ( ,;.5WG

)FG IS dÌ Ø�j ×89´ M=Na â,X . 6sdÔ ¡2- nU.,ç= CB E)FG )P]�h R,= . )FG IS -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na 56 7 ¥=K

;: @Wr )- O¯: ( b5´5V 5* mR )FG B )P; ?

`( ;<º1 L1 q§,À8 ?(àq§,;K/ )¯C 1B 28 n=KV ,À; ? B1( NATO5* 56 7 oU ¹xX K/ )* )¬OV ,6Y ,W cB

,À; ? L1 LR5X 7 )¯C 1B 28 n=KV E,À; ? @Wr -M{= .dh( -24B5µ 5* mR )FG B )P; ? 56 7 mB,JWr

b5- C,J¨[j 5* ¥;K± 9* ,W cB ,À; ? B1( -b,J¨[j -b( 5* m( o

8 ¹ Ñ= C( B1( q6A oX¹ B5µ ,k ¥=K;: mR ,W cB ,À; ? B1( q³6 ?( 5; C ã, 3_,a '( M=N>· X¾

-�¦X? ,= K´ E)FG 5; C ,-K=N½= C `( 9X : mB(R( M=NWc B1( `( 9X : -b5* ¸5V EM=NWc 2U n=K

-N=K6g-?( )P

8 �¬N6. M=NWcà àT8N=.9*1B5= O6: ¡98 :9{= K/ )P

8 �¬N6. M=NWc B1( Xs ( ¶{= .R M=NÂ IS = .( @=?( ¡8R q6A1( ¡8R q§ ¥=.( o* L(5- g

-�; : ,6 K=:dÎ;C I- .,W c,a

;. = NT ¶*D )¯C 1B )/ 9X :1( E)FG IÁ-.5= O* M=Na \-. 8�-K=N8K/ q8 �=NJ· 26 nJh,k q³6 ? ,W cB b5WG B1( @Wr )- C = .( I°µR qÙ®

-w )/ ©(5Ê 9* ,= .R ,À; ? B1( -b( o* ;s,w(dh M=NÀQ= .R IS = .( q6A @=?( LR5X 7 ¶*D )¯C 1B L(5- g

-�; : ,;K=NÂ )FG B1( 9´( L1 M=:5¦z5Ê B5®¼ 9X : ,À8 �=N6. )FG B1( )�=�-:

)U C ( 5; C `( ,k q³6 ? L1 o

8 ¹ àm( ¡8R m( ©5¿1 )FG ,; .9*E M=Na ,;K¦· b5WG IS @Wr -M=NS(B( 5; C -b( ×89X : ¸5V M=NWc B1( @Wr 5; C -b( )* )P¯�=�X: àM=NWc M=NJWr oV5V Xs,X . )- O¬: R

147

)V (1 I= . m896 : m896 : -B2ï= N¼ ( EM=NWc 6�67 mB(R( L,6 K; : )

; C 5WG M=NWc 5; C q�* )- C ¶; ?,W c

D(8RE )P]�h ;s,a5®°j q; �®a M=NWc IS q�=�g=? -b,-Y )- C 303 -B2ï= N¼ ( 9X : -M

3 ¢{= .( ,= K* B1( �= K¦3§

B,½ÆV(1-R q¨w 58 OP6 ? )- C 1500 T

8N=.9*1B5= O6: 9X : ¶; ?,W c àD(8R 9Äa oU ¹5* ¥=K67 M=Na M=N>

- ? ,= K´ B1( L1 �2Í �d²96 : 6f (E)

U C 5WG ;. q�* @ØÙ}(9= : -B1 5* ;s(96 7 M=N>

- ? oU ¹5WG IS L1 q�*

m96 : )- Ô dh 5* ¶; ?,W c àM=NÂ(8R -b(�;K/,= K/ q³6 ? ¥=K67 M=Na )U O´ B1( @Wr q³6 �* q�* o* ;s,6 .

); C 9* EM=NWc 9Äa `( fd² 56 7 mB,JWr mB(R( L,6 K

; : 5WG )FG B M=NWcE -b(9= :( ,k 53 ¢= C( ¶{= .R M=NÂà 6f ( IÁ=.dh( -b(9= :( )/ q; �/1R ,ÇV ,W cB à)FG ¥k I= K

-:,È96 : )- C ;sB,ç/ I- ., -Y D5P· )FG

B1( 6f ( L1 `( )* ¶; ?,_ I- .(B,= . ,ÇV ,W cB )FG B1( mB,JWr 9X :1( -M=N6. E)FG )P]�h `5¢µ( (5WG b,>=? 9X : 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p )P8 �¬N6. M=NWc B1( -b( )* -M=N

;. I°µR M=Na )- C -b,= K6: )Ú 89X : IS

¥-K3¢= N-.28 n-.( IvUK¢jà qU �P6 ? @¨[j ^va )FGà @Wr -b( )/ T=N� M=N>

- ? �= .9-7 ); O{_E 6f (

b5; N_1R )- C ©(5Ê ,= K* )FG B1( M=Na = .( B1R-dh ,k ,8K=N6. b5WGà+x_( R,6 . ( 56 7 ¥8KXN=K*

)FG Xs ( ¶{= .R M=NÂ IS `( ¡8R â5X 7 M=Na ¶X 7 28 n=Kj5®k B1R-dh m89X : M=NWc B1( q�* 6s,6 .B( ,= K

;N -Y(B 5* 9{¼ M=N>- ? )FGE q³6 �* ¡98:9{= K/ @=�V128 nX. )

U C ,6Y B1( ¥=K;: )

U C (5V8R ,= . T=N� o* -M

U :D M=Na (8dP· 5WGE `( ,k 5; C B5= OU :(B8R )

U C ,6Y ,Ò B1( L1 ¡1 ¡1 oU ¹ ( oX¹

b1dË· M=Na ,À8 �=N6. 5WG ,Ò B1( 8�= .9´ T=NU.,6 . )* ©5*58 C19X : q; �y�±�6 .àM=NÀQ= .R )FG IS @Wr

= .( ,È5² o- ¹,>· M=NWc B1( @Wr -b(�;K/,= K/ b5Ä-.5´ o* fd² B1( b5Ú�-.( o* fd² -b(

)* )P¯�=�X: ); O®¯Y EM=NWc m2= nª )º xw M=Na )®À�X? B1R M=Na -B 8�-Kµ )®a B1( b,W c1 9X : 5Ê �Õ=Oµ +,k 5WG ,»X 7 )FG B1( 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p )- C q³6 ? ,>· IS b,W c1 9X : o

U ¹5* +,½;O-:( M=N>

- ? 5WG E,Ò ,-K=N½= C ,k5ÚR )FG IS = .( MNA q�* 28 n=Kj o* 3 B,ç/ M=N>

- ? 9* ,;K{_à +,½;O-:(

o* 5; C �Y B-9´ qU �´ E)FG M=Na �2Í 1R 8�- Oj b5V ,Ò B1( Xs ( o* ;�=Oj5ÜÓj 9X : q³6 ? )P]�h `9;: ,;. ( )FG B1( q³6 �* q³6 �* æ±5j ,;K®a E)FG

148

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ : Xs ( )- C = .( 8�- Oj æ

U C,-p 9* ,= .R )FG B1( = .( 8�- Oj M=Na 8�-KU :(1 Xs( 9* M=:RE

6s,-K67 �= K3¢y6A �JA( q; �/R : 1R 8�- Oj mR EM=:R 5; C b,>=? 9X : @Wr T{=K

8 : ); C ,ÇV

,6Y )FG B M=NWcE 9´( @=�V128 nX. ;s,w5- OÜj 9X : M=NÀQ= .R 56 7 @Wr )

- C q6A T=C( o8 ¹ )

U C ,ÇV M=NWcE M=Na ,;K¦· b5WG IS I= . �,Õ

- C( )* b5V5¿( )* l6C,Þj M=N>- ? )FGEq6A T=C( o

8 ¹ )- C ,ÇV ,k I½= Cd² I= . )FG IS )®>? 56 7 efficient process )FG `( 5* )

; C ,ÇV M=NWc B1( dPX ? `( 9X : @=�V128 nX. 8�- OyX�®= .5= C8R ¡5= OV o

U ¹,ÇV o; ¹,6Y )FG B1( dPX ? `( M=Na ¥U. (

b5= O-NXKy· ,k 56 7 -M6 7B,a )FG `( M=Na L1 ¥a, 3_ ,= K* ,;.,6Y )FG B1( dPX ? -b( +,J

;? b5; Oy=�± 5* æy6A 9* )* `( 9X : q6A T=C( o

8 ¹ T{= K8 : ,;K

-N6. E)FG ,-K; :( ¥6.8R T{= K8 : \Â ,W cB ()FG

B1 `( 9X : o- ¹,3.d

Ø�-C o- ¹5WG )¬OFG ,XY B1( -b( 5* q³6 ? ,-KPQ= .R )¬OFG ,XY IS +,w qhR ( )* ¶; ?,_

@Wr ,= K* 9* )FG B EM=NWc ©128 nX. o* b5; Oy=�± M=Na @Wr 6f ( ;. `( ,k oU ¹5*

properI½= Cd² M=N>- ? ,-K6: E){_ IÁ-.5= O* ,-K; :( (896 : T{= K

8 : )FG B1( I= . T{= K8 : 6<=:d-Ô 9X : ,;.89X :

`(à)FG 5* @Wr q§ -M=:( q6A M=N>- ? mR E)FG B T=N� )* )¬OV IÁ=.dh( 8s1,kB ,-K6:

)FG (5WG B1( @Wr IÁ-.5X 7 B,;K-ghR5-7 M=N>

- ? M=NWc B1( R( -B ( ;�/,= .B M=N>- ? M=NWcà @Wr q

- �X:( I6 YB, -Y q�= NÂ,X .à @=�V128 nX. àq�= NÂ,X . Iv -Y(R q�= NÂ,X . -b( b5´5V )/ ); O¬NÂ M=NWc 56 7 +x_( -My

3§R M=N;.5±

EM=NWc @Wr I= . ); O¦· M=NWc IS @Wr q- �X:( b,= K¢= NÂ,X . M=N

U.,-K6: B1( 28 n[-Na -b,6 K7,p M=NÀ

8 �=N6. B1( `( ^va ,k 56 7 +,w qhR ( )FG 56 7 ,[X C I½6 O² )FG L1 m5

- C,X tX? �Õ=Oµ 6<=:d-Ô I½6 O² )FG B1( @Wr q�* ¡2; n>6? o* �d² -b( 6�/ 5* )V EM=N

U.,6Y ¡9-7 ( ;s,6 . M=Na b19* ,Ò B1( 28 n[

-Na -b,6 K7,p )P8 �¬N6. )

U C 5WG M=NWc IS ¥=K;: ¡8B5X 7

)* )¬OV 5*B,X . -MU :D )/ TXNvk )ÄÂ -M6 7(B àB5X C dÌ Ø�j ×89´ B1( dPX ? q³X A,a )* o*

149

-MU :D o

; ¹,6Y )FG LB5X C5- g=�3/ E ;. q

- �;:( ¥=K;: 5X 7B¡ o

; ¹5WG )FG B1( `( M=Na -b( o* o8 ¹B5{= K/ )* ¸5V B1( m896 : m896 : ¸5V 5®a 3s M=NWc B1( -b( 9X : -2ï= NS )

U C ,-K6: )U O´ EM=NWc b,W c1 9X : Ñ= C( o

U ¹ ( m( )* ¸5V 3s5®a @8 �¢*àM=NWc )* ¸5V 3s5®a M=NWc B1( M=Na

,;K¦· b5WG IS -b( o* Iª-R ¡B(R q; �-N6. )FG B1( o

U ¹5* q³6 ? )U C ( B1( `( 9X : -M

3 ¢{= .( )V B1( bB56 CB( )¯C 1B ,k ¥=K

;: ¡B5X 7 ,;.5WG E)FG IÁ-.5= O* 5*B,X . M=Na T=NÂ,XY �Õ=Oµ 2U n=K3/ M=NWc

B1( -b( )* 2ï=N¼ ( 28 n[-Na o* q³6 ? M=N>

- ? ); O-N_ IÁ-.5= O* q6�¦

Øè56 C( -é(B,-. 5WG )U C ,6Y ,Ò B1(

56 7 ¶X g· ); C 9* EM=NWcB 6<=:d-Ô b5´5V 5* ,À·B B1( B,XY 5Ê b5´5V 5* b,W c1 )/ ©,»-C ,= .R

,= K´ B1( -b( ,k oU ¹5* -b5

- C,£ M=N>- ? E)FG ¸5V b,W c1 9X : ¥6Y )

; C ,6Y M=NWc 5; C oU ¹5* ¡( 1(

o6¹ oU ¹ ( B1( o

U ¹5* -b,;K¢*,X . ,k -b5- C,£ 5´D M=N>

- ? ,;.5WG B1( L1 -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na )P8 �¬N6. )

U C 5WG EM=NWc 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! (B(� -Y 1( q6A ¡8R q§ ¥=.( 9X : @¨

ØÈ I- . ,= K* à)U C ,6Y oX¹ T=C( 1(

q³6 ? )P¯A ( mB(R( M=NWc B1( -b( M=Na -M3 ¢X C9* 5* q³6 ? ,k1B E)

U C ,6Y -2ï{= K8 :56 7 o* B,adP6 ?

)FG @· -B( @· `( 6<=:d-Ô 5* +5® ØÞj 5* `( ,k l7 ,= .R E)U C ,6Y @Wr I= . 56 7 ); O¦· M=NWc

IS 6sx½-C( ,W cB ( )FGào

U ¹5* 6sx½-C( M=N>

- ? E)FG 6f ( q³6 ? @Wr 6<=:d-Ô 5* l7 M=:Rà +5® ØÞjàB1R-dh )Î]O² 5* M=Na5

; C ,;K¦· b5WG IS ;�j5{Y 5* oU ¹5* Ld�-7 M=N>

- ? E)FG 6�67 @Wr b56 O=:d- Ô 9X : @¨

ØÈ M=:9* )´ 5; C dPX ? 6sx½-C( )

U C ( dPX ?,Ò oU ¹5* M=N>

- ? â1B ){_ I= .9{3_E,ÒE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: EI= .9{

3_ Xs ( 56 7 comments pass ); C 9* M=NWc `( M=Na (B-R

ä,= K;NY( ,;.96 : EM=:9* = .( 5; C Xs ( )

- C ,>· IS -M=NS(B( -b( ×89X :à - O¯: () mB,6 . M=Na o; ¹(-R

)U C (B L�-K6: ,;K=:R )FG 6�/ -M=NS(B( )* mB,6 . M=Na M=N>

- ? mR 26 nJ-?E,;K{_ 2 `9;:

Xs ( U1,W c )/ 2W c,6 . ,= K* M=:9*E¥°V �-KX7 E 6�7,p

150

6s,-K67 ¥°V qíä�-KX7 : I= .9{3_ +2; nth 9{= KXN_ E 6�7,p oX¹ @=?( ¥=.( -M=:( o*

8�- Oy- ?B5´ 6�67 )/ o

U ¹ ( )FG 6<; : )/ I= . ;s,6 . o

; ¹9* )FG IS backward areasM=Nadevelopment o

U ¹(9* )U C ,6Y oÉ I;K 3/ -�� X¾

-?,X . ¶X 7 ©,_ )/ dËÔ 8s5* B1( 9*B,X .dP

; ? o* I= . 8�-.,J= ?8R q WrB )FG IS b,W c1 9X : T=N� ,kprovision,=.R )U C ,6YE X¾

-?,X . ¶X 7 ©,_ )/ b,W c1 2W c9X : ©,_ 2- n=K6: ); OÄÂ )P

; ?à b,W c1 ;s,6 K=:dÎ;C o

; ¹5WG M=NÀ; ? IS bx¼

6�7,p )- C 8s5*dËÔ )U OV )* B1( 9*B,X .dP

; ? )* )U OV T=N� ,k 8�{=K67(9X : B5 Ø�-Oj ,= KV(19* )FGE -M{= KV 6f ( ;. b,W c1 9X : on ground ¶X g· M=N>

- ? ,»/5WGE last budget M=Na )- C B1( `( )º xw )/ l®°

;C )- OP·B )V (1 qº,6 . -M=:28 n-K=NJ= �VB,X . )- C I= . 8�-.,J= ?8R o* q³

; ? IS b,W c1 9X : o

U ¹5Ê T=N� ,k provision ,= .R )U C ,6YE IÁ-.5= O* mB5X C ×�-K/ M=Na I= .

�2Í 1R 8<*28 n_8R 98 :B(5* 8�= K WG M=NWc = .( dËÔ 8s5* B1( = .( q³8 �j b,>6A 9X : T=N�

M=N>- ? )FGE �=Kj( )FG IS 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ `( 9X : oU ¹5* I- . o

U ¹5* positive response m9* oÉ 6s,-K67 D(1 ©5*dP; ? )* mB,6 . M=Na 2W c ;<º1 ;s,6 . o

; ¹5WG )FGE I;K 3/ -�� X¾-?,X . ¶X 7 ©,_ )/ ©5*dP; ? 9X : o

U ¹5* +,k M=N>- ? (5WGE `( )U OV M= N>

- ? ,W cB5WG IS L1 ×�-K/ )/ l®°

;C ,;KP·B )FG B1( b,W c1 )/ oU ¹5* d²,-Y L(5-7 L�U.,¼ -b( 5* M=N>

- ? E,Ò5WG oU ¹5* q§,= K/ L�U.,¼ M=N>

- ? ,Ò5WGE `( )U OV `( 5* d Ø�-C -B(�-.( ,= K* ,W cB,6Y )FG B1( `( M=Na

interesting ;s,6 . I= . )FG IS ©5*dP; ? 56 7 `( ^va )* )U OV B1( I6 .5¿ ×�-K/ )* )U OV ;�¦6? ¡B12- Í )FG b,W c1 9X : dP; ? )* b5´5V )U OV )* q³6 ? 5{_( explore,-.9* ;�¦6? ¡B12- Í )FG -M{= KV b,W c1 -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C I= . IS)FG b,W c1 9X : ©5*dP; ? 8�{= K67(9X : )U OV )* q- �;N 6Y q³6 ? land acquire o* qU �´ )FG b,W c1 )/ 56 7 ¸5V displaced )

U C 5WG M=NWcà b,W c1 )* 56 7villagers displaced )

U C 5WG M=NWc -b( )* )U OV 8�- Oy- ?B5´ )

- C oU ¹5* q³6 ? compensationq³6 ?( ;. M=N>

- ? ,= .R B1( b,W c1 )* ¸5V `( 9X : 6f,6 t;�7(

)FG B9* M=NWc B1( b,W c1 9X : 56 7 employment¡R q WrB,6Y )FG `( M=Na q³6 ? qh,½j

151

b5´5V 5* ¥JQa B5² 9X : d Ø�-C -B(�-.( ,= K* ,W cB,6Y )FGE 6s,-K67 D(1 under 18th

Amendment 56 7 50% share 56 7Natural resources 9X : ,Ò5WG L1provinces ,k ,Ò5WGE Ñ®;K-ghprovinces )/ I= . -B 8�-.,J= ?8R q WrB ( M= NWc IS 56 7 `( o*management )FG natural resources o* 56 7 q³6 ? ¡28 n[

-Na 5WG `( M=Na = .( ,[= C( +B5µ ,= .,-K6: )

U C ,6Y T67 M=Na provinces o* q³6 ? o´�-KU:,J-? 5WG B1( L1

)- O¯: (resources )* mB,6 . M=Na R5-7 ;s,6 . M=NÁ_9*E 6s,-K67 o- ¹(9= :( ¥U. ( 56 7 ¥Çy§

9*5WG -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na ,;. ( )FG `( o* ;�¦6? ¡896 : B(�½j )FG B1( ( ` )/ qU �* ;s,3.R,Y q³6 ? )- Oj ,_ )

U C ( M=NWcE -b( ;s,3.R,Y )* R56 71,6 . B1( q6 Ky§( M=Na qU �* B,6 . `( )®UK¢j 9X : ;s,6 . )

- C 5WG )* R56 71,6 . 6f ( ;. `( 9X : oU ¹5* d²,-Y L(5-7 -M

3 ¢{= .( M=N>- ? ,= KV ,= K´E `(

M=Na m896 : m896 : +,-. )- Oj ,_ )FG B ( M=NWc 56 7 I= . \-K®Çy§ )FG B9* ); C 5WG M=NWc 5; C 3 B(-9´

)FG IS \-K®Çy§ 5* ,k1B )U C ,6Y B1( 56 7 q³6 ? `( M=Na 3s5®a M=NWcà )

8 C 5PX A -b(2ïµ( )/ 9{= KV m896 : m896 : b5´5V ;. -b( 5*expose ,= K* )

U C ,6Y 56 7 q³6 ? `( 2= n-ð o

- ¹5- C,£

B,6 .1B,k M=Na 3s5®a M=NWcE ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: I= .9{

3_E �=K/ +x-w �qÌ�Üj L, 3_ 6�7,pE �=K/ +x-w �qÌ�Üj L, 3_ :I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ Xs ( ,k I= .9{3_ IS Xs ( )

- C )P]�h æ±5j ,= .R IS M=Na `( ¡28 n[

-Na 9X : )- O¯: ( ;sD,= K-7 ,k B,> Øè( b19* B1( M=Na �= Kj(

,;KP·B b5WG )* mB,JWr qº,¼1 9= : -B1 56 7 `( ;<º1 R56 75j M=NWc m896 : B5- } )/ -M/ )FG B àM=NWc L1 ¡B,JWr ¶X g· -9= :1,6 t

;? M=NWc -b( 5* M=N-K/ )´ q³6 ? B1( `( 9X : ¥JÔ q³6 ?

M=:9* )´E `( )U OV IS T67 fd² ;�j5{Y ;<º1 -b(26 nJh)* -b()* )/ ;s,°±5; C

M=NWc `( fd² -M3 ¢= C -B5X C( )* q³6 ? -b( )/ ;s,°±5

; C M=NWcE `( fd² LB,À8 ?( 8B19*

152

o- ¹,;K¢*,X . +(5} )* q³6 ? -b( )/ ;s,°±5

; C M=NWcE @Wr �= Kj( ); OP·B M=NWc IS I= . ¶X g· ¡2; n>6? o* �d² )V M=N

U.,6Y )É¡2= nª ¶X g· -9= :1,6 t;? M=NWcà q¨>X? -9= :56 g

;? I= . )FG IS ×�-K/ ,6 K=:dÎ;C

70% T=N� ,;K=:R )FG mB5X C ^va 5* B1( `( ;<º1 56 7 X<U :,X . -M

U :D M=Na M=NJ= �{_ M=NWc -b( 5* �-K6: ,= .R9* ,= K´ )FGE 56 7 M=NJ= �{_ M=NÀ

; ? -b(26 nJh o* q¨ÀX �X? 8�- Oy- ?B5´ o*à

-b( 5* b5¦- ?( )- C ¥»V,6 . �-K6: ,= K* (5WG )FGE 3 B(-9´ )FG IS `( fd² I- . ,= K* )

U C ,6Y T67 fd² o

U ¹5Ê 5* ,= K* ,= KÉ oU ¹5Ê o* T=N� )/ (B5X C -b,;K¢*,X . �= KÆ

;N[j ,;.5WG -M{= KV)FG oU ¹5Ê 2î3§ M=Na T=N� M=N>

- ? )FGE 5; C `( fd² I- . 5WG IS 2; n_ �Õ=Oµ )- O¬: R b5V(1 5* q³6 ? +19gh ,= .R9* )

U C ,6YE `( M=Na 3 B(-9´ )FG IS = .( B1( -9= :56 g;? )FG IS b,>6A )/

qU �-: T=N� q; �®»

-C )FG b,W c1 IvÕ=Oµ ,= K* ,= K´ )FG IS X¾-?,X . ¥=Kj )* area M=Na 56 7 q³6 ?

bU1,Ò M=NWc -b( 5* T=N� ¡R )U C ,6Y o´ `( 9X : q³6 ? ¥JÔ M=N>

- ? ,= K* ,W cB,6YE 5; C kindly @Wr �= Kj( ); OP·B M=NWc IS 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p `( 9X : q³6 ? ¶X g· B5- } M=:9* )É 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ m241R 1R )ËQth M=NWc `( ¡28 n[

-Na M=Na OGDCL B1(PPL 56 7 ISOGDCL 95 billion ,k æµ,-Kj ,;K=:R )FG -M6 7 5* I= . privatize )

- C 9* ,k Xf5Ê )FG B M=NWcE `( 9X : -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C( lÆ;Oj )FG ¡B,_ b,= K

8 :B,X . lÆ;Oj M=NWc IS @Wr `( 5*

¥»V,6 . oppose M=:9* )´ b,>6A ;. ,-.,6Y (89X : M=NU.,6Y )É B1( @Wr I= .

profitable -2= nX¤ 5* @Wr privatize M=N>- ? )

- C 5WG M=:R )´ , 3[-C( '(E `( fd²

PPL 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ 48 billion profit L1 q³6 ? æµ,-Kj mR ,W cB )FGE `( ,k q³6 ? b5¦- ?( )

- C LR(B( ,= K* (5WG )FGE 56 7 )]C 18R M=NWc )®>¯? -b( 5* privatize M=:9* B1( dPX ? 56 7 profit)V (1 M=NWc -b( o* �d² �°6 C M=Na M=N XY5ÊE 5; C kindly @Wr `( 9X : q³6 ? æ±5; C ); OP·B M=NWc IS 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p `( 9X : q³6 ? ¶X g· q- � 3/1B M=NÂ(8R )É

153

`( M=Na ¡241R 3 B(-9´ I= . )FG IS I= . �= C(q M=:-2= nX¤ M=NWc -M67 5* CCI M=Na T{_8R ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XY B1( I= . CCI M=Na T{_8R (5WG )FGE B1( 8RB,»= CB 9X : )FGà minuted )FG IS Ñ= OX7 28 n[

-Na ×�-K/ )- C ( ` 9X : decent note ,= .R )FG IS -b( 5*

privatize I- . ,= K* )U C ,6YE 5; C o

- ¹,6 .2îh )* 9* `( 9X : q³6 ? ¶X g· B5- } EM=:9* b1B,XY b56 C5¿ 5* ¶; ?,_ 9{= KV M=NvXY �2Í = .( )]C 5¿ o* I- . M=N XY5ÊE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ¡241R 3 B(-9´ I= . IS)FG q§ -M=:( q6A ,k @Wr ,a5yÔ ); O

-N_ M=NWc IS T=N� B 8�-K®_ 8�PX ? ,= KÉ `( )U OV )* q³6 ?( ;. o

U ¹5* q�= NÂ,X . M=N>- ? o

U ¹ ( IS -b( )* )U OV oU ¹5* safety

rules )- C 5WG )¬OFG ,XY regulations )

- C 5WG )¬OFG ,XY IS -b( 5*maintain ,= K* )U C ,6YE

-b( o* maintenance qh -BD o* )U C ,6Y `( 9X : o

U ¹5* I- . oU ¹5*guidance o

- ¹5WG )¬OFG ,XY ©B 8�= Kµ 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ o* �d² )/ B1( I= . é,-Y 5² 9X :B ^v6 KX: 8sB5X N[-C(98 : M=Na

©,Jå;N_( ,;.5WG )FGE b5¢6 C M=Na q³6 ? )

; C 5WG M=NWc m896 : B 8�-K=Nv_à B1( ); O-N_ M=NWc IS L1

T=N� B 8�-K®_ 8�PX ? ,= K´ B1( M=N;Ky=�± M=N

-.,6Y æU C,-p M=N

UK´5WGE 6s( M=Na ¡9-7 ( 3 B(-9´ b19*

,Ò IS -b(9= :( X

- ? E)P· B B1( 56 7 @Wr )- C ,-K/ )FGif it is

true ISone million dollar per day Xs ( 9X : I- .,a96 7 ,Ò5WG 9´( Xs ( -b(9= :( X- ? 9{= KV M=N

U.,6Y )É 5; C M=NJWr 56 7 8�6 g6? M=Na d Ø�-C ,= . (

)FG 5; C `( )U OV )* b5¦- ?( )- C o

U ¹5* \-. 8�-Kµ M=N>- ? q³·BE

b,>6A ;. LNG sector ,k l®°

;C )FG `( )* l®°;Oj q³6 ? M=N

;.,6 . q WrB5WG M=NWc IS 8sB5X C @§,£ 9X : ¥

-K=Na98 : ,-.,ÇV L,XY )FG B M=NWcà because M=Na -M=Na2U n=KX7 q³6 ? b5WG 8sB5X C \-KXN 3_ 8�-K=:( q8 �=NJ· ,kE `( )/ M=NJWr ¶X g· briefings qä M=NWc IS `( 9X : ¶X g· )´ ( ×896 : )FG B M=NWcà -M{= KV `( 9X : q³6 ? @Wr ,-K

-N_ M=NWc,XY )´ IS ,= K* ,-.9* L,XY

154

)FG B M=NWc because Xs ( 5* I;KX: )FG IS energy )* )- O;NS crisis M=NWcE

hopefully28 n[-Na 6�7,p 2X n_( ¶X g· q

- � 3/1B M=NÂ(8R )´ B1( M=NJWr ¶X g· M=NU.,;K6: )´

I= .9{3_E

PRAYER FOR THE HEALTH RECOVERY OF MS TAHIRA ASIF, MNA

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: I= .9{

3_ q6A -¾ =�3/ fxp -M=:�Â( 6�7,pE

-¾ =�3/ fxp -M=:�Â( : I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ 6�/ )/ )®>? 5; C M=Na Xs ( )*Û/5; C

)/ `( -b(5= C( )* B�-.( )U C ,wR ;�gß )U OV )* b5¦· ,Ò ¡B,JWr MNA L2W c,È q6A,6 .

)* )U OVà -b( o* ;<V,Y ;�¦6? q Wr critical o; ¹5WG q WrB,6Y )FG B1( (ñ'�oV,°;C -b( 5*

;�gß mRà T67 fd² situation )FG `( ;<º1 -b( o* BP 30B1( 40 9X : ¥XY ,W cB )FGE 5; C M=Na ,wR )* )U OV b5¦· E,Ò

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: 2= nX. ;s,-K¢7 6�7,p ,wR M=N

U.,adi L2W c,È Ñ¿ ( I6 K7,p )* )U OVE (ñ'M=N>

- ?( ;�gß mRE )`( æ±5j 9X : ,wR o* qU �´(

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A -¾ =�

3/ fxp -M=:�Â( 6�7,pE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A -¾ =�3/ fxp -M=:�Â( 6�7,p

155

DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON Cut Motion/DEMAND GOR GRANTS AND Cut Motion

-¾ =�3/ fxp -M=:�Â( : ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_ 9{= KXN_ 6�7,pE ;�¦6? q Wr @Wr( ¡28 n[-Na )FG

T67 IX . Cut Motions @Wr )- C )

U C ,ÇV M=NWc B1( I= . = .( q�= C( ¡28 n[-Na )FG

6�67petroleum products )* 9X :1( prices ,k I¼,-p( ,;.5WG )FG 5; C ¡B5X C +(5} 9X : ¶6 756 C ,;.89X : )FG = .( = .( -2= nX¤ o* price ×896 : o

; ¹,6Y )FG B1( @Wr I= . ); OP]�Ë§ M=NWc IS )®>? q³6 ? `( )/ )®>? q³6 ? `( -b(5= C( )* B�-.( ¡896 : M=:-2= nX¤ M=N>· qU �´ IS T67 M=Na = .( regulatory authority q³6 ? o

U ¹,-K6: qU �´ q³; ? IÁv6 . )FG

q³6 ? q³6 ?(E 5; C 6�67 q³6 ? I= . I¼,-p( ,Ò5WG price )* B�-.( 5; C -b(5= C( 5* 8�- Oy=�VB,X . 5* 56 7 )FG on board ,= KV )

U C ,6Y ,Ò -b( 5* confidence M=Na ,= KV )U C ,6Y

,Ò ( ` )* �°6 C prices M=Na I¼,-p( ,Ò5WG B1( 2W c )- O¬N>h o* end)* 9X :1( 6�67 -M=N;. B,XY -bR LB M=N

U.,6Y )´ )- O¬N>h o* -¾ =?B,;. M=Na dPX ? `( )* �°6 C 56 7 )FG TUC(9X :

,k I¼,-p( ,Ò5WG -M{= KV 6s( I= . ,;.5WG I= . )FG IS M=NJWr I;KX: q Wr M=N>- ? ,;KÄÂ ;s(B,6 K

-7( )/ I;KX: ,;KÄÂ )FG ,= . o

8 ¹ ¡1 )/ ,= .8�= Kj )/ I;KX: ,;KÄÂ )FG IS 6s( I= . ú� �Õ=Oµ

×896 : qU �´ )FG 6s( LB�-KX: 8�- N_9X : ×896 : qU �´ )FG B1( `( ;<º1 56 7 )FG -M3 ¢= C -B5X C

;�¦6? q Wr 6s(9-7 )FG B1( @Wr I= . ); OP]�Ë§ )FG IS `( ;<º1 o

U ¹5* q�= C( qh5± q�= NÂ,X . o

U ¹D )U C ,6Y T67 )* 9X :1( = .( I= .5

; C )FG IS 56 7 mB,JWr `,X . already 56 7 9U:, -Y-R M=NWc IÁ-.5= O* M=Na )®À¯�X? o

- ¹,J= �VB,X . ©,_ )* B�-.( M=Na )- C = .( ©(5Ê

,= K* ,À; ? 5; C mB,JWr 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )

- C ,>· ,À; ? IS 6s( mB,JWr `,X . 56 7 1)FG L úû ©,_ )* 9U:, -Y-R LB )U O´ M=NWc 5; C 6s( I= . )¬OU : ,;K6: IS 9´( úû ©,_ )*

156

9U:, -Y-R Xs ( )* `,X . R56 75j M=NWc 5; C )´ ( future )* B�-.( short term B1( long term o* -b( o* ,= K* q�

-C5* planning ¡R qU �´ )FG IS T67 )* 9X :1( M=NJWr I;KX: )ÄÂ IS `( short termI= . )FG B1( long term I= . )FG IÁ-.5= O* M=NJWr )´ ( o* �d² 6�67 M=N

U.,6Y )´ 5; C mB,JWr `,X . = .( short )* ¶; ?,_ long term q³6 ? ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XY ordinary energy )U OV )* ;�¦6? mB,_ +,k 56 7 )FG L1 )¬O* )U O´ )¢¬N]Y ©5*dP; ? )* )U OV ;s,6 . o

U ¹5WG )FG IS `( 5* 56 7 )FG utilize ,= K* )

U C ,6Y q§( )Î¬C d² )/ qXA(9* )* L,ÒB�-K6: )* 9X :1( coastal areas B�-.()* = .( nuclear plant 56 7 )FG L1 `( o* breaking

ceremony oU ¹5WG )FG T67 M=Na @

U ?(9X : 28 n[-Na 6�7,p R5-7 q³6 ? Ñ= C23 ï

;C )V )U O´ )P; ? 5; C M=Na I= . ,-KPX A5X C b5WG,XY ,Ò IS I= . 56 7 )FG 2= n

-°6 C on board )¬OV )U C 5WG

M=NJWr L1 )¢¬NS L1 b5¦- ?( )- C 56 7 )FG L1 b,W c1 IX . f,;K;N¼( ,= .R9* IÁ-.5= O* `( )*

;s(93:( 56 7 M=NWc ¡B5X C qXA(9* IX . M=:89X : )´ IÁ-.5= O* `( o* 56 7 radiation M=NWc L1 ,6 K=:dÎ

;C 56 7 M=NWc M= NJWr �üE�ü 28 n=Kj5®k ;�3/(R96 : o- ¹9* ¡89X : o´ 5; C L1 56 7 )FG

mB,JWr `,X . = .( ;s,= KV57,a ,k 56 7 )FG L1 = .( 53 ¢= C( )FG 5; C `( )* )U OV b5¦- ?( )

- C 5* ,[-C 6�®Þj I= . IS project `( IX . ¡B,6Y 9* ,= .R )FG ,[

-C5* 8�{=K67(9X : ,k -bxw( ,= .R9* )FG IÁ-.5= O* I= . 5

; C M=Na )- C ,-K/ )FG IS = .( China

o* q- �XNJ· )FG B1( China )* )3 ¢Ö

-C )* 6s,[7 )/ ,= K* ,= K´ )FG -.,XY( B1( `( M=Na = .( -M=Na -B q³6 ? acquire qU �´5WG )FG -M{= KV I= . -2= nX¤ clear M=N>

- ? )FG q³6 ?( ;.E 5; C B1( b,W c1 IX . 56 7 )FG 6�67 -M=Na -Bacquire qU �´5WG )FG 5; C `( ,k

6�®Þj )FG IS Xs ( )- C 8�6 g6? q³6 ? `( )* B�-.( ¶*B ,= .R )FG 6�67 8�6 g6?

¶*B ,= .R )FG 5; C `( 5* ¡B5µ B5² IX . I= . ,= .,;K6: )U C ,6Y `( -b(5= C( )* B�-.( IS

L1 project 56 7 )FG )- O;NS ,k )FG B1( )¢¬NS ,W cB5WG )FG B1( qXA(9* o* ¡R,6 . ( )*

157

)U OV L1 pollution ( ` )* )U OV 56 7 ;sxa,°j M=NU. ( )´ `( )* )U OV L1

,= K* 9* )FG B M=NWc I= . 56 7 )FG `( ;<º1 ¥=K;: B1( T=N� 28 nÁ=K/ ,k 56 7

governance o* ;<V,Y )FG `( M=Na ;�¦6? q Wr q�= C( -M3 ¢= C -B5X C )FG IS b,>6A 9X :

T67 fd² qXA(9* )* B�-.( ,;.5WG )FG IS 56 7 ×�-K/ ,k 6�/ )/ (896 : I6 .5¿ )FG B1( b,>=? )/ ( Xs = .( income 56 7 )FG L1 generate o

; ¹5WG )FG B1( `( generation )* B�-.( 70% 56 7 )FG @Wr IÕ7 mR )FG B )

; C 5WG M=NWc -M{= KV M=NJWr 56 7 )FG L1 56 7 M=:-2= nX¤ q; �®a M=NWc 1 L Xs ( 6�/ 5* I;KX: )FG `( M=Na ;�¦6? 3�g6? qQXY5WG )FG q§( fd² M=Na b5¦· ,Ò IS -b,;K¢X 75®6 . 56 7 )FG I6 .5¿ = .( ,[= C( I6 .5¿ )FG b,>6A )/ @Wr T=N� 5; C ); O¬NÂ M=NWc -M{= KV -b( +(5} )* )U OV

-b,;K¢X 75®6 . )* +(5} )* )U OV ,= . -b,;K¢X 75®6 . )* B�-.( 56 7 T=N� )FG L1 T=N� M=N>- ?

)FG 6�/ )* dPê b1 IX . `( )* )U OV M=NÀQ= .R IS 6�67 )]C 5¿ )/ 56 7 -2= nX¤ Xs ( )V )FG B M=NWc @· @· -B( L1 )]C 5¿ )* B�-.( 5; C +(5} 5* L1 relief ,-K®a )¬OFG ,XY dPX ? )´ ( L1 )]C 5¿ M=NvXYE q§( fd² 56 7 T=N� )* ;sxa,°j M=NWc q³6 ?( = .(

mB,JWr oU ¹,À6 ? )

- C q³6 ? ,>· `( )U OV )* IS I= . ¡896 : b5= C 8B,Ò ,k 6s( I= . q³6 ? Xs ( = .( q�= NÂ,X . ,-K6: ); O{_ M=NWc IS üüEúýüü ,= . úþüü q§ q§ )* )U OV -M{= KV I= . )FG IS 6�67 I= . Xs ( q³6 ?( )®À�X? b5

- CR qU �* ;s,3.R,Y )U C 5WG T67 M=Na b5V5{_

)* )¯�6? q³6 ? mB,XY)]C 56 7 M=NWc L1 �=K¦3§ )U O´ 5WG B1( ¡241R IÃ6Y qU �* IÃ6Y

-2ï6 C M=Na I3 .R,Y )U C 5WG 5; C I= . q³6 ? ¡896 : q

- �;N 6Y q³6 ? 56 7 ¡896 : b,= .8B,Ò M=NWc `( )*

B�-.( 5; C ¡B5µ B5² 9X :B @; � -7 9* ,-K=:R )¬OFG ,XY IS,;. I= . IS I= . 56 7 T=N� o* 56 7 6f (

¥k b1dPê )* B�-.( ;s(x»3¢j M=NWc L1 ;sx»3¢j @; � -7 b5WGE industry zone o*

;s,6 . b19* ,Ò m2= nª )Î®Y M=Na central KarachiqXA(9* )* B�-.( North Karachi, New Karachi, Federal B, Area,kindustrial area

158

,; . ( )FG B5X C (E `( industries )* B�-.( M=Na ¥[®[j I>· ,»X 7 b5WG -b( b5´5V 5* IS I= . 56 7 )FG b,W c1 9X : ¥[®[j \-. 8�= K

3/8R5V o; ¹5WG )FG T=N� o* B1(

Sunday 5; C ¥»V,6 . q Wr 6- ? )V ); O{_,6Y M=NJWr economy 5*

B5X N_ 8s )- C 9* )* )U OV industry zone 5* 5; C ¥»V,6 . L1 m9* ¶; ?,_

¶; ?,_ mB,JWr M=NÀQ= .R water problem B1( I= . ¡B,_ problem ¥XY q WrB M=NWc `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ 56 7 IS T=N� @Wr ); O¦· )P

; ? ¡B,JWr T=N� @Wr T=N� M=Na R5-7 ¥=KÆ* M=NWc @Wr T=N� M=Na ;�¦6? )P¯A ( M=NWc -M{= KV I= . IS 6s( T=N� M=Na I= . 5WG ,W cB )FG IS I- . 5

; C @Wr industry 5* mR ){_ M=NWc B1( I- . b1dPê 5* mR ){_ M=NWc 5; C `( )* )U OV 56 7 )FG o

U ¹5* ¡B5µ = .( q�= C( q�= NÂ,X . oU ¹,-K6: )

U C ,6YE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A wind up )U O]g=�*E -¾ =�3/ fxp -M=:�Â( : `( )* L1xw LPG quota ,k 56 7 )FG L1 fair

formula M=N>- ? )FG B,»;O-N°¿ fertilizer q§ -M=:( q6A power commercial B1( 5®= .dPê 56 7 M=NWc28 nÁ=K/ mB,_ `( M=Na 56 7 )FG

problem)FG -b(9= :( -b,;K¢*,X . T=N� X<U :,X . -M

U :D I6 .5Ü- Oj = .( 2= nÈ, -Y @ºB 56 7

)FG �2Í )- C 9* )* R56 71,6 . q³6 ? L1 cold storage M=Na (89X : (5WG )FGE

à -b,;K¢-NJ·9;: à -b,;K¢

-C,-°µ( à -b,;K¢*,X . ,= .8�-.( T=N� X

- ? 5WG ,W cB oU ¹5* ;�y§ M=N>

- ? )FG 2W c -2= nX¤ ad hoc b1R,-K=N6. xXY9X :

159

)FG B @· @· -B( `( 5* = .( planning )* ;�g;? 9´( M=NU.,6Y ( 5; C M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§

b5WG IS L1 -2= nX¤ q³X A( -2= nX¤ )FGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{3_

-¾ =�3/ fxp -M=:�Â( : `( M=Na = .( 56 7 ¥=K

;: B1( T=N� )* 3 x;. )* )U OV 56 7 license issue )¬O* )

; C ,6Y M=NWc `( M=Na ¡B,À6 ? ;s53ÊB ¥XY q WrB )FG -M3 ¢X C9* )FG `( 5* M=NÀQ= .R IS I= . T* fd² )/ @Wr @

; � -7 ); O{_9* M=NWc mB,JWr M=NÀQ= .R `( ;<º1 (B,JWr ,6 K=:dÎ

;C �üü 6sdP· )¯C 1B ,k 8�6 g6?56 7 )FG 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ET6 C = .( 8�-K{= K/E �ü 6sdP· )¯C 1B )* 8�6 g6? M=Na @Wr ú� 6sdP· )¯C 1B 56 7 )FG b5-¿dº M=Na �2Í B9* )FG M=NWc ;s,_ 6s9* (B,JWr 56 7 )FG L1 0,¼R M=Na xXY )

U C ,6Y ,Ò ¥k 8�6 g6? ,k þü �Õ=Oµ 56 7 )FG L1 b,>=? IX . @; � -7 5WG ,;.,6Y )FG

ýü 6sdP· LB )U O´ M=NWc 56 7 @Wr +(5} )* )U OV M=NJWr )- C 9* M=NWc 56 7 +(5} )*

)U OVE 9´( `( M=Na )/ q³6 ? 9´( 25% 56 7 )FG L1 9´( `( M=Na M=N>- ? M=NÀ·B

)´ 5; C L1 xXY )FG -M3 ¢X C9* )* 9X :1(E5; C I= . (B

-R ,_ M=NÀQ= .R IS `( 5* @Wr T* fd² )/ 2; n>6? ;�3¢= N°j o* �d² ); O{_,6Y M=NWcEI= .9{

3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: I= .9{3_E I= .

-B, 3_ ¡dh I6 K7,p q6A

Iª2; nth I= .-B, 3_ ¡dh : 24 petroleum and natural resources

)* mB,6 . M=Na b,>=? IX . Cut Motions )U C ( M=NWc T67 M=Na -b,;K¢*,X . -9®X K=NX.

B,X . o8 ¹ o* 6<

- :,6Y )/ 56 7 qh5yÔ B5² 9X : ,ÀQ= .R ,= K´ )FG IS T=N� provideM=N>- ?

160

o* B,6Y q Wr b5; C,>=?R M=Na B1( `( )V (57 )/ m2= nª 9Ä= .R 26 nJh -b( 56 7 q³; ?,_ M=NWc

b5¦- ?( )- C q³6 ? ;s,6 . o* 1( B `( )* L1xw 24 hiring�� ,k 53 ¢= C( )FG 56 7

¥k5V ¸5V M=NWc young¸5V M=NWc -b( 5* T=N� -2= n-KXNJ· hire M=N>- ? o

; ¹9* Ñ®;K-gh b5±xw M=Na ,;K¢*,X . -b qß5Ü

-7)* B5² 9X : ×�-K/ B1( -b,;K¢X 75®6 . M=Na 24 q�= C( 6s,[7 )/ dPX ? ©5*dP; ? IX . 56 7 +,k ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XY IÁ-.5= O* L1 energy solution )FG

-b,;K¢*,X . ,kE L1 q³6 ? M=N>- ? 5WG ,W cB B1( 24 production 5* increase)

- C 9* o* ;s,6 . o* qU �´ 5; C I= . = .( L-9U:,6Y )FG mB,_ Cut Motions ,k 24 (2= nª l®°;C 8dPÐ-.,_ )/ )FG (2= nª o

U ¹,6 . ( bU1,Ò 8dPÐ-.,_ M=Na )FG M=Na )- C -M

3 ¢{= KV( q³6 ? 8dPÐ-.,_ )/ (89V B1( (ñ'�oV,°;C o* o

- ¹,6 .2îh 1( B o8 ¹B,X . o* -b1,°;C o* I6 Y1 )/ 6f ( M=Na

Xs ( )* )- Oj ,_ b5WGE24 q- �=N½= C B5² 9X : @Wr 6�67 )- O¯: ( )Î®Y M=Na q³6 ? )

; C ,6Y M=NWc `( -b(5= C( M=Na q³6 ? ;s,6 . )

; C 9* M=NWc 5; C @Wr ); O¦· M=NWc IS resource B,JWr m `,X . )FG @Wr ×�-K/ )V (57)* )/ q³6 ? ); O¦· M=NWc q³

; ?,_ -b,;K¢X 75®6 . )* )V (57 )/ q³6 ? ); O¦· b5WG )´ 26 n=K

-7 (5- g-?5; O-gX? 6s,6 t

-�X: 56 7 I6 .5¿ T67 M=Na ,-KX:( potential ,;KP·B )FG 5; C 24 ×�-K/ M=Na @Wr ;s,6 . )

; C 9* M=NWc IS q6A �ü �Õ=Oµ T=N� mB,JWr `,X . )FG B1( +5ÜÓj ¸5V )

; C 5WG M=NWc 24 mB,JWr5; C bU1,Ò M=Na q�* )

- C ¶X 75X C ,= KV IS -M¦6? 6�67 �ü �Õ=Oµ T=N� ×�-K/ )* `,X . )FG 5; C ,= K* I6 Y1 )FG IS

mB,JWr bU1,Ò M=Na T=N� M=N>- ? )FG 245; C I= . = .( ,[= C( ©(5Ê )FG T67 ,k

6s(56 7 M=NJWr 5; C I;KX: )FG IS Article 158 )* R56 71,6 . @Wr )- C qh5±

interest M=Na +,k ,-.9* B1()FG @Wr qh5± interest M=Na ); C 9* -M{= KV -b(

b5; C,>=?R M=Na R56 75j b5´5V 5* I= . -b,-K=NJè( 3T-g6? M=N>

- ? q; �ÄÂ ;s,6 . IÁ-.5= O* \-.�= K

3/8R5V ,k q³6 ? -b( 9X : ¶6 756 C )FG 9´( 5; C T=N� o; ¹5WG �= ., 3_5

; C T=N� 9X : generator )V 9* B1( L1 ,-KX:( +,k ); O¬NÂ9*E b,>6A T=N� )FG b,W c1 T=N�

161

)*generators9X : ¸5V q6 t6? o* 56 7 IvUK¢j )FG )®UK¢j 5* ¥Y )FG B9* M=NWc \-. 8�= K

3/8R5V )/ B,XY1R ¸5V ¶X g· relief ¥p,Y ); C 9* M=NWc -M{= KV otherwise 5; C

©128 n=KX: ,= . ©-9= :8R )* 5; C )- O;: ( )¢¬N¯. M=N>- ? )FG -b( b56 O=:d- Ô )* `,X .E 24 q§(

)U OV I= . ;�¦6? (896 : 53 ¢= C( M=NJWr d Ø�-C ,;. ( )FG B1( b,>6A ;. productiono* ;s,6 .

)FG IÁ-.5= O* daily basis IX . = .( 8sB,XY )FG ,; . ( -M{= KV ¶X g· -B1B ¥6K± ,k = .( 8sB,XY )FG 56 7 total production )FG L1 ,6 K=:dÎ

;C �ýüü @=?( @=?( q§ Ñ= C( )FG 6s( 24 `( ,k 9´( break up M=NÀQ= .R -b,;K¢X 75®6 .5

; C ,k ,6 K=:dÎ;C ,;K

-N6. )FG 566 MMCF contribution )FG `( �ýüü M=Na B1( consume L1

,;.9* )FG ��ü 24 (5- g-?5; O-gX?26 n=K

-7 ,k )FG ��ú )FG I= . \Â \À6 ? )FG 24 ,6 K=:dÎ

;C I= . 9X :1( )¯�=�-: q; �{_5WG )FG figure B1( 271 consume,;.9* )FG 24

×�-K/ contribute,;.9* )FG 2664 MMCF B1( 24 L1 `( 5* ,;K®a )FG 1200, Sir consumption 1600 o* )FGE q§(24 )/ )Î¬C d² = .( (B,JWr

I6 .5¿ )FG 6s,6 t-�X: 24 L1 produce ,;.9* )FGE 189 MMCF B1( -b( ,;K®a5* )FG 1038 MMCFE I= . = .( idea mR q WrB b5WG M=NaE I= . q�= C( academic M=N

;.,6 . M=NWc -M6 7 9X : q³6 ? M=NJWr B5- } ,-.9* )U OFG ,XYE B1( `( ;s,6 . 5* q³6 ? appreciate ,-.9* )U OFG ,XY IS R56 71,6 . +,J

;? contributions )* @Wr 8R1B b5; N_B 9X : M=N>

- ? ); O®»-Cà 8B5; C 8B5PX ? M=N>

- ? ); C 9*à )¢®]Y

`5®6Y M=N>- ? )

; C 9* )- O¯: ( l7 )* )U OV 56 7 (B,JWr -9U:,6Y l7 )FGà @Wr B, 3[;N-.( M=N>- ?

); C x= KPX ?E

162

24 6f ( ;s,6 .56 7 5WG q WrB )FG L1 -b( 8<* -2- n 3_5j )* )V (57 )/ `( )U OV ¡B12- Í q³

; ? IÁ-.5= O* ¶X g· q�= C( b,= K¢= NÂ,X . 8�- Oy- ?B5´ )* )- Oj ,_ M=N

U. ( T67 9X : M=NJWr -é(2; nð( )FGE 24 @Wr IÁ-.5= O* -b,;K¢*,X . -9®X K=NX. o

8 ¹B,X . )* B1R M=Na = .( T=N� q�= NÂ,X . oU ¹ ( T67 M=Na tight gas q¨>X? I6 K

;:dh `( 9X : q³6 ? q�= NÂ,X . incorporate o* qU �´ B1( M=N

;Ky=�± ^3_)]C set o* qU �´ b5WG 24à 56 7 q³6 ? M=N;Ky=�± àM=NÀ

; ? -M{= KV I= . 5; C 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ ,k +,k )FG IS b5; Oy=�± 5* review q³6 ? m9* B1( 56 7 LR56 75j 6�7,p ©,Y )FG `( )* -M=Nw l6C,Þj production ,k )

- C ,É896 : ,k 56 7 ¥JÔ )FG `( 5* ¡B,6Y )P· BE 24 ¡B,JWr local ENPs M=NWcE 6s( low BTU ,;.5WG )FG 5; C -b( 5* 6f ( 9V(8R ,;K®a )FGlow BTUE T67 M=Na -M6 :,k o

U ¹(8R 8�= KU :,[*1( o* B(�½j ;�¦6? LR,= .

-B o; ¹5WG )FGE 5; C -b( 5* dPX ? = .( Ñ= O®= .B B5²)* 9X : ¶8 ? ( 9V(8R ,;K®a )FGE -M{= KV 56 7 ¥aB,-. )FG 56 7 900 BTU )FG ,= . 1000 BTU )FGà -b( 5* ¶X 7 ,;K®a9V(8R )FGE 6s( 9´( Xs ( ¶X 7 9V(8R ); O¬: R M=NWc = .( ¥k5V q

- �XNJ· 5* gas production )* )U OV 5; C I= . incentive M=N>

- ? )FG B1( q§( IÃ6Y Xs ( d�± o* d Ø�-C )

; C ( 8B1R M=NWc 56 7 LB,À8 ?( 9V(8R ,;K=:R )FGE 9´( @Wr )/ qÙ®

-w oU ¹5WG 5; C �2Í B,XY ,= . X¾

-?,X . 9V(8R 5; C Xs ( ,k I¼,-p( )FGE @Wr )

- C 5; C `( 5* LB,6 . L2= n;. 9X : 8B5PX A ,= .R 5WG E,Ò -M{= KV LB,À8 ?( 9V(8R )- C 5WG )*

�°6 C q³6 ? consider ,-.9*à M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG IS I= . oU ¹5* ;<

- :,W c-R o* ;�jxw M=N>

- ? )FGE q§( IÃ6Y -b,;K/1�-K WG )FGE M=Na M=N>

- ? -b( o* M=NÂ,3Kj ,-K=:R q; � WG,XY IÁ-.5= O* M=Na )- O¯: ( Xs ( 5* -M=:2; n>6? ^va q; �P6 �Ë

§ b5WGE -M{= KV IÁ-.5= O* )¢¬C ( ;s,a(�£( L1 )

; C 9* M=NWc T67 )/ 2W c, ØÈ ,;.5WG )FG IS -b( IX . ^v6 KX: 23 ï= C9X : )FGEL1 `R 9V(8R 5* q³6 ? ,Ç-O¦h ); OP]�Ë§ M=NWc d�± )/ B1( @Wr ,Ç-O¦h M=N>

- ? ); OP]�Ë§E 5; C `( fd² o* M=N;.,6 . M=NWc 56 7 )- Oj ,_ o

; ¹ ( M=NWc B1( `( )/ M=Na M=N>

- ? b5¦· o´ IS oU ¹5* 28 n[

-Na B(�-K=Na -B (8dP· 5WG )* )P]�h )- O¯: ( B1R ,= . )

- C x¼ B1R )U C (5- O´E 9´( q�* )/ o

U ¹5* q³6 ? q Wr,;.5* oU ¹5WG )FG 5; C I= . ^va (B,JWr

163

)FG productionq- �Ú896 : )FG 5; C -b,;K¢*,X . o* q

- �Ú896 : )FGà b5´5V o* Ñ= O®= .B ,-K®a )FG 5; C -b,;K¢*,X . )* b5´5V 5* ,-K®a )FG So, let\s put our differences

aside and let’s think in the greater interest of this country and gas is a resource, it is required.

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: I= .9{

3_E

Iª2; nth I= .-B, 3_ ¡dh : 1R -M=N

;. 8�- Oj recommendations ×89X : b5V 24E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: = .( 8�- Oj M=Na )U O¬: 9*E

Iª2; nth I= .-B, 3_ ¡dh : 24 `( )* L1xw 6f ( q Wr o* 26 n

-¤ )FG IS (9´1( o* ¶X g· disagreements M=NWc over the issuance of license for the

LNG terminal at Port Qasim 24 M=Na b5WG,XY o´ IS 8�- Oy- ?B5´ `( 9X :

;�7,-p1 m9* IÁ-.5= O* = .( sole company )* )V (57 )/ ;s,6 . ( q WrB )FG `( M=Na o

U ¹5* competition d Ø�-C M=NJWr M=N>

- ? 5; CE,= . ( ,= K* process M=N>- ? ,= K*

B1( ,[= C( M=N>- ? )FG 5; C dPX ? (9´1( 5* b5= O* -é(2; nð( )FG B1( (9´1( )* ©1B 5* dPX ?

Xs ( M=NÀQ= .RE `( )* L1xw M=Na Á-.5= O*I b,>=? R56 75j M=NWc 28 n[-Na 6�7,p q³6 ?E = .(

5; C T=N� q�= NÂ,X . M=Na ,ÀQ= .R )U C ,6Y IS shale gas o* provision 9X : q³6 ?

+,k 5WG ,;K{_ )FG IS M=N>- ?DGPC ,k 56 7 ©1B )FG `( 9X : o

- ¹,3.dØ�-C M=:9*E (B(� -Y

Xs ( )* `,X . 172(3) R56 75j )FGE b56 C5¿ 5* Xs ( ¶; ?,_ M=N>- ? )V 9* ¥XY )FG B

M=NWc We are supposed to work in light of 172(3) that is

164

the amendment in 18th Constitutional amendment, `( 9X : q³6 ?( ;. +,k M=N>

- ? 5WG ,W cB )FGE @Wr dPX ? I>· )FG B M=NWc IS 6f,6 t;�7( M=N>

- ? M=:9* )´ R,= . B12- Í M=N

U.DR )´E `( )* �°6 C M=Na ;s,6 . b19* o´ IÁ-.5= O* energy solution dP; ? )FG B1( dP; ? ©5* 56 7 175 billion tons ,k = .( 8�{= K67(9X :

)FG `( o* transmission lines 9X : d², -Y L(5-7 @ºB M=N>- ? q³·B qU �´ )FGE M=Na

qí=? ,6 t;�V( b19* o´ IS T=NXtX? 6sB( o* I= . @ºB )FG ¥8.58 Cà 9´( B1( ¶X g· M=N>

- ? 5; C @· -B( @· X¾

-?,X . 5Ê -M=Nva ¶*B M=NÂ B1( IÁ-.5X 7 b,>=? 9X : T-C,-Kµ 28 n[

-Na )- C block

allocation o* ;s,6 . o* )FG page 74 of PSDP 6s,6 t-�X: 5* M=N>

- ? ¡R IÁ-.5= O* 6s,6 t

-�X: )* 2W c 8�{= K67(9X : 9X : sufficient allocation M=NWcE5; C Xs ( )- C

block M=Na M=N>- ? ,À·BE -M{= KV M=NJWr Xs ( )

- C ¶8 ? ( -M=Nva block ,= .R )FGE Xs ( (B(� -Y `( block 5* )V M=NÂ IÁ-.5= O* I= . block M=N>· q³6 ? ©,Jå

;N_( 5WG ,;.,6Y )FGE -M{= KV 9´( Xs ( Å;O-gh 9* M=:R )´ b5y=�{_ 9X : B1( I= . ¶8 ? ( -M=Nva 9´( Xs ( ¡B,JWr

b5y=�{_ 9X : Å;O-gh 9* M=:R B1( sufficient allocation M=NJWr mR M=:R 5; C dPX ? `( ,k -B(56 7 M=N>

- ? d Ø�-C ,;. (E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: I= .9{

3_ q6AE

Iª2; nth I= .-B, 3_ ¡dh : 1R M=N

;.,6 . B1(E 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: © -B5X C19X : M=:RE

Iª2; nth I= .

-B, 3_ ¡dh : qí=? © -B5X C19X : )FG E24

165

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q¨ç= C96 : M=:RE Ms. Shazia Mari: These are proposals, PSDP page

74; Block allocation for Sindh, Balochistan and KPK, the money should be allocated to projects.

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A 56 7 q; � WGB M=NWc L1 M=:RE

Iª2; nth I= .

-B, 3_ ¡dh : M=Na I= . I>· q WrB q³; ?E `( )* L1xw M=Na = .( I°µR

dPX ? b5¦· o´ IS -M3 ¢*8R19X : IX . M=NJWr B5- } ,-.9* )U OFG ,XY B1( 56 7 5 kilometer

radius o* ;s,6 . )FG 24 o6¹56 C T=N� 8�v= Kµ 56 7 )FG L1 M=Na8dPÐ-.,_ )FGEB1( M=Na

Xs ( 5* I= . m5}R )/ q; �¦· b5WG IS = .( ×89= :8R )* 28 n=Kj5®k radius )* 56 7 ;s,>=?R M=NWc -b( M=Na q³6 ? T=N� M=N>

- ? )FG So, this is not being implemented, although it is also a Supreme Court

order. 6f ( 9´( @Wr b,>=? m8dP· 5WG 9* ;s,6 . 9* )FG B M=NWc 5; C mB53 ¢j )- O¬: R )* )U OV 9* )FG B M=NWcà @Wr 8<

- :(8R )- O-N_ )* )U OV M=N>

- ? ); C 9*E B(� -Y ( mB,JWr b1B53 ¢j

5* M=NÀ6 �Ë§

E @Wr 9´( T=NXtX? ©,_ ); C 5WG 5; C ;�¦6? q³X A( M=N

;.,6 . ); C 9*E -M{= KV 9´( Xs (

)- C ¶X g· ¶{= K/ ,= KV )FG T=NXtX? b5V,_ M=Na 5; C ¡B,JWr R�a )U O]g=�*E ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E �W c, 3_ ,-Y ,£ -b q§,6 K} 6�7,p 28 n[

-Na B,¼ @=�V128 nX.E

166

6s,-K67 �W c, 3_ -b,£, -Y q§,6 K} : I= .9{3_ Eq6A M=Na -B-dåj -b(26 nJh ,k B5{ 3[j b5WG IS

b5¦- ?( )- C ¡896 : ;�- Ogh )* ¶; ?,_ ;�¦6? q§ -9= :1,6 t

;? q³6 ? M=:R )U C (B ,k B,> Øè( q³6 ? ,= K*

)FG B1( M=Na 3T3Ê5* b19* ,Ò IS )- O

;N]Y ;s,6 .(56 7 q³6 ? ¥a M=NÁ_ L1 -b( )* )- Oj ,_ ¶*B )

U C R M=NU.,6YE M=Na �-KX7 l

UC,½7 B12- Í b5P·B ,Ò IS `( ¡28 n[-Na )

- C �2Í m5

- C 8B19* )Ä-. ,a)¯C 1B M=NWcE T67 M=Na )/ X¾-?,X . 8B19* o* capital allocation

q³6 ? )FG B1( I= . L1 ¡28 n[-Na )FG 56 7 b189{-K=N_ 6sB( I= KX:1B ,J· 9* ;�j5{Y 5* q; �=:R

)FGE 5; C `( )U OV 9´( `( o* 6�/,-Kj )/ M=NÀQ= .R 5; C ;�¦6? @· @ºB `( M=Na q³·B qU �´ )FGE Xs ( �2Í federal constabulary 5* M=NÀQ= .R 5; C ,6 K=:dÎ

;C ×89= :8R 6sB( )¯C 1B o* @ºB -b( )* )U OV Å;O-gh o* qU �´ )FGE5; C ¡896 : oV5yåj @ºB I= .

¡28 n[-Na Xf9

-7 o; ¹9* )FGE b,>=? 9X : 56 7 M=N

;.,6 . M=NU.5WG M=Na ¥=KÜÆ

;C )/ -b( ,k 6s(56 7 B12- Í mR b1R ,ÒE -M{=KV �-KX7 )¢¬C ( -B53 ¢= C( M=NWc 56 7 m896 : @Wr( àM=NWc qh5± ;�=O}5

- C )* M=NWc B1( `( M=Na = .( ¥»= O

8 :B (158 )FG T67 ,k ;�¦6? )/ R(di( )- C 9*-R

,= K* B1( (2= nª ©,= K-7 )FG IS `( +B5µ 9X : q³6 ? 1( q§B q§ o

U ¹ ( M=Na q³6 ? 8�=O6N=.8R ,-.5WG ¡B12- Í )FG IS ¥»= O

8 :B ( 158 ,k ZxÈ( )¢¬NS 5WG ,ÒEIÁ-.5= O* 2= nª ¡ )U C (B `( M=Na

I= . )FG IS 6�67 I= . ¥»= O8 :B ( ,= .,-K6: ,= K´ 5; C original Article )FG

Constitution ,kà `( ;<º1 framer )* -MWG-R M=Na ;s,6 . ¶X g· B1( q³; ?à 6s(

;sD,Y m896 : ©�6 . ){Y M=NWc intent ,= K* q³; ? framers 5* b5¦- �67 )

- C Constitution ,= .,-K6: IS ,= K* `( )* ;sxa,°j M=NWcE IÁ-.5X 7 9´( @Wr non-

priority usage M=Na T=N� ©,Jå;N_( 9* )* qQva -b,ÕÖ

-C M=:R9* T67 )/ -b,;K¢*,X . 5* -b,ÕÖ

-C 5WGà 2W c ¡2î3§ ,k -b,ÕÖ-C 5WGà `( ,k 9

3:( 2W c ¡2î3§ 9X : m89X : 5; C M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG I= . 6�/,-Kj ;s,6 . M=N>

- ? )FGE `( fd² Xs ( 6f ( ¶{= .R M=NÂ IS ^va M=Na B1,X . 5* ¡B5X C T=N� M=N>

- ? ¥a q WrBà fertilizer )* ;�¦6? )/ 8<- :xX . �-K6: M=NWcà

167

¡28 n_ 8�-.( �-K6: )FGà -M{= KV @Wr �-KX7 56 7 producing )]C 5¿ M=NWc b,W c1 9X : @Wr q§ -M=:( q6A 5* T=N� @Wr(di 9* )FG B M=NWcE 5; C ,= K* I= . optimal utilization )FG T=N� o*à IÁ-.5= O* q§( T=N� )/ 9´( B1,X . )- O]: o* 5; C L1 +,J

;? b56 C5¿ )* +(5} ©,Jå

;N_( M=:9* )É 9´( fertilizer )- O]: ,Ò 5; C +,J

;? b56 C5¿ )* +(5} ©,Jå;N_(

M=:9* )É¡28 n_ 8�-.( )®¯Y o´à ^va M=Na oV,t3§5-7 o

U ¹ ( o´à GDP growth 5WG oÉ `( ,k 9

3:( +,J;? b56 C5¿ )* +(5} 9X : m89X : ,ÒE`( )U OV ;sB12- Í `( ;s,6 . o* )FG

IS I= . ¡896 : @Wr( resources o* optimal utilization o* )U C ,6Y B1(

¥»= O8 :B (158 )* ;�g;? LB 9* o* )

U C ,6YE `( M=Na (B-R B1R q3 �= C�-.( )/ )- O¯7 5Ê o* ;sB12- Í )FG B1( qQva R,çj 5* )- Oj ,_ ¶*B 9* )- O¯7 5Ê o* ;sB12- Í )FGE 5; C `( )* mB,6 . M=Na )´ ( M=Na 9*-R 9* b1R ,ÒE b,>=? 9X : -B2- n 3[= CB5X CB,k ,k 9*-R ,= K* ,= KÉ @Wr 3T3Ê5* 9* )FG B M=NWc IS 8s2= nª 9X : -M=:2; n>6? ¸5V b5- N 3[= CB5X CB,k M=Na )

U C D M=NU.,6YE -M{=KV

56 7 ;�j5{Y o* L(5- g-�; : ,k ¥=K{_ )FG `( 9X : Xs ( 5* L1 ¸5V M=N>

- ? ); O®aE b,>=? 1( q6A ¡8R q§ ,k 9*-R ,= K* ,= K´ IS = .( 5Ê 6sB( )¯C 1B ,k æµ,-Kj q; �=:R )FGE 5; C = .( 5Ê 6sB( )¯C 1B ,k æµ,-Kj 56 7 )FG `( M=Na 1R ¶*D D(1 Ñ= OX7 58 O{= .-9Ä= .( +,k M=N>

- ? m9* ,ÒE T67 5* 2W c,6 . b1 8B19* o* L(5- g

-�; : ¥a q WrB 5WG L1 ( 9* )¢¬C ( b1(BR( 5* M=N>- ?

M=NU.xXY )É 5; C `( )U OV ;sB12- Í `( ;s,6 . o* o

; ¹5WG )FG IS Xs ( market based pricing 56 7 )FG L1 mR M=NÁ_ IS,;. I= . ¸5V ( 9* qU �* 5Ê 6sB( ,k

L�U.,¼ 9* )* -b( b1B(R( 5* ä56 O-Üj ,-K6: M=NÁ_E I= . fund 56 7 drain I- . b5WGà I= . job create 9* M=NÁ_ B1( GDP growth mR M=NÁ_E `( )U OV @Wr )

- C q�* I;K 3/B B(R 5* M=N>

- ? ,= .,ÇVE @Wr )- C b5; N_1R 5* M=N>

- ? ,= .,ÇVE @Wr )- C q�* 5* 56 7 ¥Wc(

M=N>- ? ,À; ? `( 5* 89{X . M=N>

- ? )U C DE @Wr 3T

3Ê5* 9* )FG B M=NWc IS ¡2; n>6? ¸5V 56 7 M=NWc L1 -b( b1�>Ô 9X : ;s,-K=N°

;C )U O* M=NU.,6Y IS,;. Iª-R ¡B(R )/ I= . ¸5V +,k 9* M=NÁ_E

168

m2= nª = .( oU ¹,À6 ? q

- �X:( @=�{_ o* inauguration o* ;s,6 . o*E -dË=�{_ o* inauguration ,k ©5¿( qí=? )FG IS 56 7 qh,½j MNA )FG T67 )

- C @=�{_ 5* identify ,= K* )FG q§( ,k l7 ,;K

-N6. )FG IS @=�{_ 5* inaugurate m9*E -M{= KV q; �y�±�6 . )/ ¶X g· M=NJ= �{_ q�= C( M=NWc 56 7 q-ß,a M=Na q�* B1( )

- C identify M=NS B1( L1 M=NJ= �{_ 6f ( implement 5WG q WrB M=NWcà -b( )* -B 8�-Kµ q³6 ? q-ß,a M=Na ,= K¦h )U O* )U O´E5; C = .( ethical ,= . moral responsibility ¡B,JWr I= . )FG IS T67 Å

-g3§ )

- C L1 @=�{_ oU ¹(19* q³

; ? �U., 3_ I= . l7 q§( ,k ,;K-N6. )FG IS `( @=�{_ 5*

inaugurate 9* ){_E5; C ¡8B5P; ? `( M=Na ©R M=Na (B-R ;�Ó/1 (�= KX: M=:9*E oU ¹5*

q�= C( ;s,6 . M=N>- ? )FGE q6A Å

-g3§ )

- C ;�- Ogh o* @=�{_ 5* ,= .,-K6: `( ,k l7 ,;K-N6. )FG

)FG ,XY T67 o8 ¹B,X . )/ L1 q-ßdh 5WGE

) ;�® -Y(�a( 6s,-K67 �W c, 3_ -b,£, -Y q§,6 K} : Xs ( )

- C ;s,6 . 9* oV )FGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Ñ= C23 ï;C M=NÀ·B Xs ( ¶8 �=N6. M=N

U.,6YE q6A = KP8 ? )FGE Xs (

¡B,6Y M=NÀ·BE I= .8B, 3_ ¡dh 6�7,p Ñ= C23 ï

;C M=NÀ·BE28 n[-Na 6�7,p 6s(56 7 mR )FG B

M=NWc `( )* �°6 C Xs ( q- �X:( ;s,6 . M=N>·E 2î3§ B,= . 6�7,p Ñ= C23 ï

;C EM=NÀ·B

6s,-K67 �W c, 3_ -b,£, -Y q§,6 K} : ( 8B5P; ? ,_ (B-R -M/ M=NÂ M=Na )- C o

U ¹5* Û®-w ;s,6 . M=N>- ? o*E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Xs ( ;�® -Y(�a I- . M=:9* Ñ= C23 ï

;C M=NÀ·BE Xs ( ¡B,6Y M=NÀ·BE

169

6s,-K67 �W c, 3_ -b,£, -Y q§,6 K} : (B-R ©R xÀ· 9* )*à Xs ( )- C '(ã, 3_,a X¾

-?,X . ©,_ ;�j5{Y 9* oV E)FG 5*dP; ? © o* 2W c Å

-g3§ )

- C b,>=? 9X : ;s,6 . o*E 2W c Å-g3§

,;K¦· )FG IS 5*dP; ? © ©5*dP; ?E )P]�h q³6 ? q6 Ky§( M=Na T=NU.,À8 ?( ©,_ M=NWc)U O´ 5WG

dP; ? 5* © o* ;s,6 . -M/ q³6 ?(EM=NWc)FG B ;. = .( T-C1( I- . ©5* x»-C )FG I- . q6 t6?

q- �6: (E)FG ` )* -b5* Iª-R B(R M=NWcà M=Na `( �d² M=N>

- ? ,-.,6Y ,;K WG,XY -M{= KV lUC,½7

5* B12- Í )- Oj ,_ ,-KP·B )¬OFG ,XYE 6f ( Thar Coal Project provincial responsibility E)FG 9´( -b( 5* Z,¼1 )/ R�a )¬OFG ,XY B1( Ñ= OX7 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p ×�-K/ 5* q³6 ? qU �* +B5µ IX . ,>· IS Xs ( ¡B,JWr5* ¥JQa 8sB5X N_ ¥p,Y )FGà Xs ( @Wr )/ ,= K* M=NWc); OFG ,XY @Wr `( )U OV )* 2- Í,Y M=NWcE@Wr I= . q³6 ? Xf5Ê M=NWc)FG B IS b,W c1 9X : ©B 8�=Kµ 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ = .( âx6 . )V 9* `( 5* develop )- C 9* o* 3T

3Ê5* m9*E9´( `( L1xw)* q³6 ? Thar Coal Development M=Na q³6 ? o

U ¹5* B1( R�a )¬OFG ,XYà o

U ¹5* `( M=Na IÕ7 )- OV (8R o* ;s,6 . à5WG oU ¹5* resources o*

;s,6 . 5WG 5; C '(ã, 3[-C( ©B 8�= Kµ 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ `( M=Na ,-KX:( B5X C ( B(R9* (R( m9* o´E IÁ-.D,Y I= . ¾

-ß(1 ;�Î=OÖ7 IS)FG18th Amendment )* �°6 C I= . +,J;? 9;: ¥U.,[j

b56 C5¿ o* ;�=O{va M=NWcE

M=Na I= . B12- Í 3 B(-9´ b19* IS,Ò 6s,6 t-�X: )

- C 18th Amendment M=Na ;�¦6? (896 : B(R9* (R( ,= K* IS +,J

;? 56 7 qQva ¥U.,[j )P; ?à ;s,= K

-:�°j M=NÀ; ?à L1 b56 C5¿

)V (57)* 9* ¡R Uo´ M=NWcEImported coal plants o* ;s,6 . oU ¹5WGE

Imported coal plants 56 7 M=NWc q; �¢±�6 . )/ ’ b5= O* IS qh,½j coal develop M=N>

- ? 5WG à( coal plants specifically = .( certain goal 9X : )

U C ,-K6: M=NWc); C ,6YE`( ,k 9*-R `( )* �°6 C 56 7 98 :(1 B1,X .

8�-K=:( o* ¡28 n[-Na

170

)U C ( o´ L1 B12- Í 9* M=:R E)´ ;sB12- Í `( ;s,6 . o* )FG IS ¥6KÖ

;N[j M=Na = .( 2; n>6? q�= NÂ,X . )U OV )* @· ;�y=�± q6 t6? )U OV )* ¡B12- Í )FG IS ©5*dP; ? 5*

develop 9* )* q§( 9X : q6 t6? oU ¹,-K6: )

U C ,6Y -M{= KV interim period M=Na Xs ( `,X .)* q; �¢/ q6 t6? ,k o

U ¹5* B1( -M3 ¢X C ( M=N>

- ? B1()FG Xs ( imported coal o* �d² ¶{= .R )FG B M=NWc 56 7 IS M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS q; �¢±�6 . )FGE9´( q-ß,a M=Na

5*dP; ? © 5* develop ,= K* ,= K´ ,;.5WG 5; C �= ., 3_ 6f ( I= . ;sx»3¢j 3T=NX. I- . o; ¹ (E

b,>6A ;. integrated policy o* ;s,6 . )FG IS integrated policy 5WGEI= . q¨>X? ;�j5{Y )FG T67 )

- C -2ï= NÂ,X . 9X : +,k ,= K* )FG 1( B �J�z( ' q¨>X? I°µR -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na 2007 M=Na policyq

- �6:à implement M=N>- ? o

U ¹5WGà 2009 o* q

- �6:à implement M=N>- ? o

U ¹5WGà2012 o* q- �6:à implement M=N>

- ? oU ¹5WGE @Wr )

- C x>X? +,k I= . ,= K* IS `( q�= NÂ,X . 5* implement ,= K* B1( 6f ( �J�z( ' ^va = .()* q�= NÂ,X . R56 75j T67)FG M=Na q�* 5* ^3_ I6 K

3/ M=N>- ? )FGà

oU ¹5* -M

3 ¢X C9* M=N>- ? )FG IS 56 7 b,>=? 9X : investment m9* ,Òà `( 5* -b5*

q§ ;�y=�± )®a o´ b5= O* IS 6�/ )/ ¡896 : -M3 ¢X C9* I= . q³

; ? IS investor ,;. ( `(à,À; ? 5* I= . M=N>

- ? I;KX: ,;.5WG ,À; ? IS M=Na 9´( ¥=K;: ,= . T=N� discover b19*

,Ò 5; C )P]�h -b5* q§ q�= NÂ,X . ;�g;?)* TUC(9X : )®a o´E q§( 5* manipulate

9* )* -M3 ¢X C9* o* o

; ¹,6Y q³; ?E 5; C 6f ( �J�z( ' L1 I;K/(B �-K6: 9* ,= .R ,= K´ à)FG

Merit and transparency 5* -01di ,= .R ,= K´ )FG B1( ;�¦6? q§ -2= n[= NÂ,X . ’ ¥=.( oX¹ q6Aà ¥=.( oX¹ q6A Xs ( )V M=NÂà poor man’s fuel ,;.,6Y ,À; ?à qU �* 8<* -M

3/5j ¥=.( oX¹ q6A )* )V (57 )/ M=NÀ; ?E -b,;K¢*,X . )* )®À�X? LB,6 . ©,_ M=Na

q¨>X? I°µR I= . (5WG IS @Wr )- C market mechanism M=Na

171

intervention9* )* ¥=.( oX¹ q6A TUC(9X : 5* decrease ,= K* B1( L1

TUC(9X : 56 7 winter M=Na T=N6KPX A 5Ê I= KX:1B o

- ¹5WG )¬OFG ,XY q³; ?àT=N

-.( 5Ê \Â)* \À6 ? q WrB B1( 6f ( LB,= K´ 5Ê )* \Â \À6 ? )FG B1( '(ã, 3[

-C( q§( ©5= OV ¡B,JWr 3T3Ê5*

)FG IS `( 5* 8�=OV5Ä= .B 9* )* `( ©5= OV 9X : ,À·B )U C ,6Y IS,;. = .( ¡896 : R(�°;C )*

consumers 56 7 ¥=.( oX¹ q6A ©,Jå;N_( )

; C 9* M=NWcà L1 `( )/ �=KÆ;N[j

M=NÁ_5WGE

-b(9= :( X=? q³6 ? B1( Ñ®;K-gh +B5µ 9X : `( ,k 9*-R ,= K* )FG

IS = .( L�W c,°j 2009 M=Na (5WGà 2013 ;. `( IX . oU ¹5* �a (B�vJÔ I- . 5WG ,»/ B1(

`( o* ¡R,= K-N6. I6 Y1 I= . )FG IS international sanctions ,k `( X<

U :,X . -MU :D

9X : ZxÈ( ,;.5WG E)FG @Wr )- C Iranian Government 5* engage ,= K* )FG

B1( @Wr )- C ¶X g· ); N_ (B )V ,»-C M=NWc M=NJWrB1( ¡B5X C �= Kj( )FG IS @Wr `( X- ?)V (1 M=NWc -M{= KV -b(

¥Y)* 3 x;. )U O* M=NWc)FG B,6YE M=Na )- C )®>¯? 9*-R ,= K* B,XY ,_© -9®X K=NX. o

8 ¹B,X . ;�j5{Y M=Na q WrB B1( = .( X¾

-?( X- ? E)FG @Wr 3T

3Ê5* 9* M=NWc)FG Bà -2ïUC(9X : 5* incentivize q³6 ? ,= K* ,= K´à

Shell Gas o* q�= NÂ,X . q³6 ? o´)U C ,6Y ( 56 7 �= .-dh T

UC(9X : 5* incentivize m9*

172

o´ -M{= KV short term M=Na Xs ( ,k solution 56 7 )FGà L1 �2Í B1( �2Í ¥=.( -M=:( q6A )FG b5= O* IS 56 7 TAPI Pipeline )FG L1 ,-K=N½= C ,-KX:( ;<º1 )V o´E¥=.( -M=:( q6A 2006 )/ 3T

3Ê5* 5WG q WrB à)FG I3[= NJWr ¥=Kµ 5WG B1( 6f ( �J�z( ' q¨>X? I°µR )FG IS LNG Terminal 56 7 )FGà`( IÁ=KP

8 ?,k = .( mB5X C transparent )Î¬C d² )/ 5WG )FG ,»X 7EAnd Internationally

competitive prices 9X : q�* 5* ^3_ I6 K3/ 5WGE 2W c -B1B B,6 K

-7( M=Na negative M=:26 n

-¤ q; �XNÀX A M=NWcE`( o* ¡R,= K-N6. I6 Y1 )FG IS `( ^va M=Na

= .( (896 : ¥U. ( ,= Kµ,a R56 75j )FG 56 7 M=N>- ? ,;K WG,XY IS ^va M=Na ¥=.( -M=:( q6A B1()

U C ( )Ä-K¦h B1( polluting oil 5* replace b1 8B19*Em9* I= KX:1B ,= .,ÇVà @Wr M=NWc); O

-: ,6Y IS T* )

- C )¢¬N¯. )U OVà @Wr ); O-: ,6Y M=NWc IS -b5* ¸5V `( )P¯�=�X:)* M=NWc -M{= KV @Wr )

- C -b( ,k Iv6 .,½j ,= K*E 6s( �J�z( ' LNG Terminal \Â ,W cB E)FG q�* 5* `( o* T

UC(9X : IX . I6 K3/ )FGà @Wr 2W c ;<º1 2- Í,Y M=NWcE Transparent )Î¬C d² )/ ,= K*

,= K´ B1( )P]�h ¡B5X C �= Kj( )FG IS `( ©,_ 9-7 ()* )/ )®>? q¨>X? q6A9

-:( -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na )U C ,6Y ( o´E

¥=.( -M=:( q6A TUC(9X : o* b,>=? ¡896 : M=N

;.,6 . o* o; ¹,6Y M=NWcE¥=.( -M=:( q6A T

UC(9X : )* -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C( M=Na b189{-K=N_ 8s2X n[{= .( R56 75j M=NWcEM=Na )- C +,J

;? -M3 ¢= C -B5X C( 5* Û-7 q³6 ?

)PQÂ M=NWcE @Wr )- C 8�=O*B,a M=Na = .( tender float 9* ,= .R E)FG 56 7 q³6 ?

IÕ7 ,-K=NÂ )FG ,;K WG,XYà q�* `,X .)* ¶8 ? ( o* ¥=.( -M=:( q6A )FGà q�* )* `,X . `R o* ¥=.( -M=:( q6A à)FG 5Ê @�6 C '( ’ IÕ7 M=NÂ B1( ¥=.( -M=:( q6A ^va 5* ,= K¦h M=:9*E @Wr )

- C open tender 9* ,= .R )FG B1( T67 `,X .)* q³6 ? R56 75j )FGà -M3 ¢= C -B5X C( M=Na 5WGà 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ M=Na 5WGà 8�- Oy- ?B5´ )/ 2W c,6 . 5WGà B 8�= .9

8 : 5WGà 56 7 q³6 ? 5WGà

173

¥=.( -M=:( q6A -b,;K¢*,X . 5* ); N[/ b5j(R ,= K¦h Em9* 2= n-ð Iª-R I- .(B(R b5; C,6 . )/

I3[= NJWr -b,ÕÖ-C ,;.5WG )FGà L�U.,¼ M=N>

- ? 5WG ,;.E 56 7 ;s(2- ì7 b,W c1 28 n[-Na M=NWc)FG Bà L1

)P8 �¬N6. M=NWc -b( )/ ¶X 75X C M=NÂ IS ;sx»3¢j,= K* M=NWcE Ñ®;K-gh @�± o* M=N

;.,6 . )- C 9* )/

I= . IvUK¢j ¥Y M=N>- ? 5WG ,ÒE

@Wr )

- C d�± )/ government to government basis 9X : negotiated ;s,6 . 0123 4 o* o

U ¹5WG )FGEq³6 ?( ;. oU ¹5* T

UC(9X : o* ;s,6 . d�± )/ M=N>

- ? oU ¹5WGEM=Na `( U1,W c )* B5®¼ 9X : b5WG,;K¦· B1( mB5X C Z53 C1 )/ b5WG,;K¦·E

I= . 56 7 6f ( L2; n_à LB,À8 ?(à T=N-.( o* ;s,6 . M=NWc)

; C 9*à 6f ( LNG Market M=Na limited quantities )FGE `( M=NJWr)U OV 2= n

-ð Iª-R ¡B(R )/ ,-KXg6? B1()¬OFG ,XY 6�67 price negotiation o´5WGà L1 q³6 ? +(5} )- Oj ,_)* )

U C ,6Y ( o´ -M{= KV ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ = .( competitive bid process )FGà`( o* -2ï

UC(9X : q³6 ? Xs ( ()- Oj ,_)* )

U C ,6Y o´à )®>? I= . comparison 5WG ){_ IS market price )FG ,= K* B1( negotiated price ,= K* `(E)FG B�-.()* ;�¦6? )/ factors

M=NWc); C 5WGà ;�¦6? )/ parameters M=NWc)

; C 5WGE 56 7 ;s(2- ì7 `( ¡28 n[-Na M=Na

M=NWc)FG B L1 M=NWc); OP]�Ë§ B1( '(ã, 3[

-C( q§( l6C,Þj)* `( )®a ,°j 5* q³6 ? ¥Y )U C ,6Y,= K*

E,Ò

m2= nª oU ¹,À6 ? )

- C 2= n-.56 C )/ T=N� ,k 9*-R ,= K*E 2= n

-.56 C M=Na )P]�h `( 53 ¢= C( )* specifics ,k ’ IÁ-.5X 7 = .( )U O

-: 8�{= K6719X : 9X : -M=N6. ,ÇV 5WG ( ,À; ?E 6s( @Wr )- C ¡dË§ 15j o* )FG B1( -M=N6. 8�WG ,Ò)

U C ,6Y B1( b5V5¿( l6C,Þj)* 56 7 @ºB ©B 8�= Kµ 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ ,= K¦h m9* o´ ,= . oU ¹,6 .5¿ ;�j5{Y m9* o´à`( M=Na o

U ¹5Ê -bBRB,-. IÕ7

174

,-KX:( IÕ7 )V (8R o´ B1( 2= n-.56 C 5* q³6 ? -b,;K¢*,X . )* 9Ä= .R b5±xw o* fd² B12- Í

¥a )U C ,6Y o´E

= .( ¥

-p,¼ 26 nJh 26 n=K-7 L(5- g

-?5; O-gX? )/ ’ b5¦- ?( )- C X¾

-?,X . T8N-KU :(5X C ,k 9*-R ,= K*E

,-K=N½= C b5¦- ?( )- C m896 : @Wr( T

8N-KU :(5X C ,k 9*-R ,= K* E)FG GIDC = .(GIDC Act )FG 56 7 q¨ÀX �X? 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ M=Na `,X . 5WG (à `( )* ;�g;? GIDC ,k ZxÈ( ,= K* ,;.,6Y )FG B1( collect o

; ¹5WG B1(E)FG `( m896 :)* specific uses M=NWc T67 B�-.()* UFG control à)FG q

- �Ó= C Unaccounted for Gas ,k ©128 n-K* )FGà TAPI Pipelines )FGà -b(9= :( T=N� X<

U :,X . -MU :D )FGà `(

@�± )* m896 :56 7 )]C 5Ü- Oj M=NWcà -b( )* )U OV GIDC 5* ©,Jå;N_( ,= K* ,;.,6Y )FGE

9´( GIDC Act ×89X : M=NÂ 5; C `( B�-.()* I= . +,J;? M=N

;.,6 . R56 75j M=NWcE

56 7 UFG increase )FGà,-K=N½= C ;�¦6? (896 : IvUK¢j )FGEUFG increase `( ;<º1 `R �Õ= Oµ ;. X¾

-�¦X? ,»X 7 )FG B1( ¡B,JWr 3T3Ê5* )FG IS `( @· ,= K*

)U C ,6Y B1( M=NJWr �=Kj( )FG IS ,p5Ü

-7 UFG ,k oU ¹5Ê -bRB,-. M=Na ,6 K=:dÎ

;C 2.5�Õ=Oµ q; �y�±�6 . )/ ¡B5X 7 5WG ,W cB )FGE @Wr )* oX¹ )* )/ ¥a 9* `( 5* ¥Y )- C 9* 3T

3Ê5* 9* )FG B M=NWc B1( )P]�h ¡B5X C �= Kj( )FG IS @Wr `( 5* ¥Y )- C 9* M=Na

B12- Í 6s,= Kj,k b5WG )´E 56 7 producing -B,= .9= :( M=NWc -b( 5* l7 )FG IS T=N� -b( 5* )®a B1( ¡B,JWr ¡B5X C 3T

3Ê5* )FG IS X¾-?,X . 5®k 28 n=Kj ,k 56 7 I£xw )FG `( 5*

T=N� ,= K¦h o* )U C ,6Y IS,;. T67 )º xw )/ T=N� q; �®a )FG `( )* ¸5V q³6 ? `(

)* �U.(5µ M=Na ¥a, 3_ 5WG M=NÁ_E I= . ¥»V,6 . ¾-ß(1 )FG `( M=Na o

U ¹5* 1R )U C (B M=N>

- ? M=NWcE T=N� 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ o* ;s,6 . )FGE

175

q; �y�±�6 . )/ M=Na )

- C )®>? ,>· IS T=N� o* 8�-.,J= ?8R ,6 K=:dÎ;C6 -M=Nv6 . 6 .5= O* 8�=Oµ qi -bR

TUC(9* 9* qQXY )FGE -M

3 ¢*8R19X : 56 7 )FG L1 4 -M=Nv6 . )* 6<=:dº )FG 5; C `( )¬OV I= . ;�¦6? (896 : mismatch )FG T67 5* @Wr ¥Y 9* )FG B M=NWc LNG import )/ -M{= KV 6�67 ;. I= . ¥U.,[j ¥Y M=N>

- ? ); C 5WG I= . gap )FG B ,Ò B1( 8R5V

\-. 8�= K3/ 5* resort 9* )* `( gas 5* (B5X C ,= K* ,;.,6Y )FGE M=Na b,>=? 9X : I= . 9*-R B12- Í 9* b1R IS I= . q¨>X? ;�j5{Y )FG B1( m2= nª o

U ¹,À6 ? )- C b,>=? ¡896 :

Iª-R2= n-ð I- .(BR ;s,6 . o* IS 9´( MNA 28 n=Kj q³6 ? I- . ,ÇV ){_ 5; C ,= K* M=:9* )É

MNA ,k +,k 28 n=Kj ,-.(5ÄÂ M=N>- ? )FG B1( I= . o

U ¹5Ê -bRB,-. ,k +,k )FGE @Wr )- C

8s2= nª o* R,= K-N6. 9X : T67 Å

-g3§ )

- C )®>? ;�/(5-7BR ¡R `( ,k 28 n=Kj 6f ( )®>? \Â ,W cB )FGE '(�J�z( 2004o* M=N

;K/(5-7BR q³; ? 6f ( mB5X C o

U ¹5Ê -bRB,-. 8�=O-: âB1 9X : 2011o* b5; N_(5-7BR )* 9X :1( 28 n=Kj \Â )FG B M=NWc 2= n

-°6 C q�* 3 B,ç/ )* 2= n-°6 C q�*

28 n[-Na o* priority )

U C ,ÇV 2= n-°6 C q�* MNA 5* \-K;: )¬O*E b1dPê )/ x6 . 9*

b5´5V )* 28 n=Kj )U C ,ÇV ,6Y )FG B M=NWcE `( )¬OV 3 B(-9´ I= . )FG IS (B-R ©R ©5P· 9*

;s,6 . M=:9*E ,-K=N½= C b5*B,X . M=Na -M3 ¢X C9* )FG B1( '(, 3[

-C( -b( 8<X:9* b5´5V 9X : ¶; ?,W c D(8R )U C ,6Y ,Ò B1( +,-. Xs ( )* )- Oj ,_ '(, 3[

-C( ( M=NU.,6Y )É 5WG ,;K{_ )FG q�* 5* Ñ= O®»

;C q³6 ? 5WGE -M

3 ¢= C-9U :,8 .5= OU :(9X : o* ;s,6 . o

U ¹5WG OGDC and PPL I= . b5- C1R m896 :

profitable mB(R( M=NWc B1( -b( o* management 5* transfer M=N>- ? ,= K* ,6Y ,W cBE management 5* ¥=K/ M=N>

- ? ,= K* ,6Y ,W cBE -b( )* )®>? q³6 ? 2U n=K3/ 8�=O*B,a M=Na )

U C D )U O´ )P; ?E 6f ( q³6 ? �= .-dh )

8 C 5PX A chunks 56 7 M=NWc 5�Õ=Oµ )Ú 8B,_ ;s,_ �Õ=Oµ B1( 10�Õ=Oµ ;. -b( )* -B2U n=K

3/ 8�=O*B,a M=Na )U C D ,6Y )FG B

M=NWcE ( ` )/ 56 7 @ºB )U C ( o´ L1 ^va )* R,çj )* )¬OV ©,Jå

;N_( 5WG oÉ I= .

176

56 7 mdå-C b,>=? �-K®6 . )¬O* ); C ,6Y M=NWc 5; C `( )V (57 )/ -M

3 ¢= C-9U :,8 .5= OU :(9X : o* 9{¼ I- .

M=:9*E '(, 3[-C( 56 7 q³6 ? I½= Cd² )FG (896 : transparent 5WG ,ÒE Xs ( )* )- Oj ,_

5WG ,Ò B1( ^va )* R,çj M=Na 5WG ,ÒE M=Na I= . 3 B(-9´ B12- Í 9* b1R b,>=? '(�J�z( highest level of oil production -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na )FG = .( ¶*D ©2= n6. 9X :

X¾-�¦X? ,»X 7 )FGE highest numbers of wells in the history of

Pakistan `( ©,_ )* B�-.( approve )¬O* )U O´ B1( '(, 3[-C( `( 5* ,= .,É

896 : )U C ,6Y ,ÒE `( )¬OV Xs ( ¥»V,6 . `( 9{¼ M=Na I- . M=NWcB IS ;�j5{Y `( )®[®_ M=Na +,k M=N>

- ? 9* q WrBE ;�j5{Y 56 7 9* q WrB )FG L1 '(, 3[-C( Xs ( )* )- Oj ,_ )FG B1(

`( )* ;s(93:( q³6 ? Xs ( ;. M=NXt-�¦X? )É '(�J�z( transparent )Î¬C d² )/

2W c -2= nX¤ ,k 6s(56 7 )- O¬: R )* )¬OV 2- Í,Y M=NWcE oU ¹5* `( M=Na 1R )

U C (B M=N>- ? M=NWc 6f (

`( 5* @=�®[;C ,= K* ,;.,6Y )FG ^va )* B�-.( q³6 ? B1( ^va )* 2W c,6 . q³6 ?E 6f ( '(�J�z(

-M3 ¢X C9* ¡di 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na R56 75j )FG B1( `( 5* -M=N6. qh(5±D( ¾Ù/ 9X : q³6 ? @=�®[

;C ,= K* ,= K´ )FGE Shell gas ,k 9*-R (5WGE )P]�h q3§5-7 ;�¦6? o

; ¹5WG 9´( )®À�X? X¾-?,X . ©,_ ¶X g· +,k ,=K* ,;.,6YE 6f ( @Wr `( 5* )V 9* )´ ( ); OÚ 896 :E Shell gas �-KX7 b5

- CR ,= . �-KX7 b5; OÆWG ,k TÊ(9X : M=N>- ? )FGE I= . b5V,_ B1( b123 ï} 9X : Û=Ogh I= .

Iva,°j )FGE IÁ=.dh( = .( �Y(1 ^va )FG T67 )- C shell gas M=Na o6¹,= Kj,k ¥p,Y

o* )FGE -b( 5* 35©,_ )ÄÂ B1( X¾-?,X . ¶*D )/ LR,= .

-B wells drill )¬O* )U OÉ -b,;K¢*,X . o* ¡B5X C -¾ =?B,;. M=Na = .( B(-2W c wells drill )

U C 5WG M=NWcE `( 5* ,-K;:( -b,_ ( solution I- . ,À6 �Ë§ )

U C ,6Y -M{= KV @Wr `( 9X : +,k 9* )FG B M=NWc B1( ¡R,= K-N6.

;s,6 . I= . )FG IS `( )* )¬OV q�= NÂ,X . q- �=:R m89X : o´ IS 56 7 shell gas 9X : +,k

m9* ,Ò `( 5* Xs ( ,= K* TUC(9X : M=:R )É M=Na -b(5= C( )* )¬OV B12- Í b5¦· ,Ò

IS 6f ( -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na 56 7 shell gas o* 8�- OyX�®= .18R )FG I= . (B,JWr I-K=NJ-�;? )FG IS

177

Xs ( 109V(8R )/ @· TUC(9X : 9X : Xs ( X�®= .18R M=N>

- ? 9* ); O{_E 56 7 LNG 10 dollars 8sB5X Oj( ,-.9* ); OFG ,XY M=NWc 5; C -b( )* )¬OV +,-°= OX: )FG IS �W c, 3_ `( M=Na

¶X g· ;sD,»3¢j b5WG -M{=KV ©,Y2î6 ? @Wr fully open M=NWcE q�* )* `,X . oU ¹5* B1(

@=�{_ 5WG @Wr `( )* )¬OV q³6 ? 2- Í,Y M=NWcE M=:5ÚB,À8 ?( @=�j9;: )* �°6 C = .( model agreement B,= K

;: ,-.9* ,À; ? b56 C5¿ 5* q³6 ? IÕ7 ,-K=:R ,À; ? `( TÊ(9X : M=Na ;�¦6? q§ ;sx»3¢j M=NÀ

; ?E +,J;? b56 C5¿ o* q

- �X:( )U C (B q³

; ?E `( )U C (B ,k

+(2; n¤( ,= K* ,= K´ `( )U C (B )/ input oV qU �´ B1( 6f ( +,J

;? q- �=NU. ( )-¿ ,½;C mB5X C

9* )* = .( model agreement B,= K;: ,= K* ,=K´ `( 9X : +,J

;? b56 C5¿ 5* Z,ç;C( )FG B1( 43T

8N-Ky=?9Ä= .( b1B,XY b56 C5¿ )* B�-.( -MU :,_ 9* )¬C R )U O´ M=NWcE I= .

;�¦6? ¡896 : o6¹,= Kj,k )FG 56 7 )- O;: ( @· )¿ dÔ M=Na �= ., 3_ -M{Jh I- . o; ¹5WGE -M{= KV '(�J�z( I= .

q³6 ? ¥JQa 9* ,=KV ,= K´ )FG B1( 6f ( M=NJWr �= Kj( )FG IS `( )/ �= .-dh drilling 5WG o´ B1( ^va o* 56 7 ¥=K

;: B1( T=N� o* -M3 ¢*8R19X : `()FG M=Na )]C L,-KX: I¼,-p( 5WG E,Ò

5; C ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ I= . )FG IS 56 7 8<* -M3/5j )¬O* )U O´ M=NWc M=Na )

- C )®>? ,>· IS ;�¦6? @· @ºB I= . ¡28 n[

-Na ;�j5{Y )/ q; �=NÂ )FG B1( ( ` )/ ;�¦6? LR,= .-B @ºB

TXC(1 q; �=:R )FG 5; C 8<* -M3/5j TXC(1 oV)V M=N

U.,6YE ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_E The question is that the Cut Motion as moved…..

) ;�® -Y(�a(

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ¡2= nª ;s,6 . M=N-K/ I= .

-B, 3_ ¡dh I6 K7,pE I= . 56 7 -M=NU. ( )*

¥»= O8 :B ( o*clarification )FG I= . 9V5Ä= .B -M

3 ¢= N_ M=Na M=:9* )´ 8�6 g6? 9X : ;s,6 . 5WG

178

q WrB )FGE The question is that Cut Motions as moved on demand No. 84 �=K/ �=K

3/B5-7 �JA( EL,3_ �=K/ �=K

3/B5-7 �JA( L, 3_: I= . q³X A( ;s,6 . )FG IS 9´( oU ¹5* q�= C( ;s,6 . o

U ¹5WG )FG B1( 26 nJh 9´( clarification \-.,a ,W cB )FG 5; C `( M=Na = .( 8�- Oj )/ ,= K* Zdi ,;.89X : )FGE ;s,6 . q³X A( 5WG )

U C ,6Y o´ -b( o* �d² )/ ,ÀX A( 6¾�= Na xXY )U C ,6Y ,ÒE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: 2U n=KX7 )

- C I>· ,= .R )FG )®>? 6�67 28 n[-Na 6�7,p 9= :dÎ

;C 9* )FG B )P

; ?E 9V5Ä= .B `x6Y( M=Na 9* M=NÂE q6A I= .-B, 3_ ¡dh I6 K7,pE

Iª2; nth I= .

-B, 3_ ¡dh: IÁ-.5= O* 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )

- C ,>· `( 5* M=NÀQ= .R LB,6 .1R `( 5* revisit M=:9*E L1 = .( right )FG (B,JWr Constitutional Xs ( q³6 ?

L(5- g-?5; O-gX?26 n=K

-7 )/ belong ); C 9* M=NWc Xs ( ,k q³6 ? 8<U :(B )FG @Wr 6�/ ,k 8<U :(B

)FG B1( 6s,6 t-�X: ,k q³6 ? )FGE M=Na 5; C q; �¦· b5WG ,ÀX A( )FG resources M=Na

rich 5WG IS,;. @Wr rights exercise 9* M=NÁ_E 24 = .( 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )

- C ;s,6 . o* (2= nª ©,= K

-7 )FGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: 8�-KU :(1 Xs( 9= :dÎ;C )* �°6 C Xs ( rebut M=N>

- ? 9* q; �{_E

Iª2; nth I= .-B, 3_ ¡dh: 24 I= . GIDC act )FG L1 8s5* 9* )FG B )P

; ?E and GIDC )* 8�{= .( M=Na USG )* )¬OV o

U ¹5* envision M=N>- ? ,= K*

,= K´ ,À; ? I[= NX.E -M6 7 b1-2= nX¤ )* )¬OV envision ,= K* ,= K´ ,À; ? the cess shall

179

be utilized for and in connection with infrastructure development of Iran, Pakistan pipeline project, Turkmistan Afghanistan Pakistan India TAPI pipeline

project, LNG 5; C I= . UFG M=N>· q³6 ? )FG b5¦- ?( )- C ,>· )FGE and

they should not come. ,= . 5; C L1 8�{= .( 5* ×89X : M=NÂ B1( (B,JWr I= . ,-p,½;C

)FG 24E = KP8 ? )FG I= . 8�{= .( `( ;<º1 ,= . ( 6<

; : q³6 ? Û®-w ,À; ? B1( `( ;<º1 q³6 ? proper `( 9X : +,k ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XY ,À; ?E -M{=KV = .( ©,_ ¡B,JWr 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ M=Na ,W cB B1( `( 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ )* )¬OV æ±5j )FG IS `( GIDC 5* as per article 171 of the Constitution b56 C5¿ M=Na 56 7 T=N� )* 9Ä= .R

M=NJWr benefits ¥a )FG B M=NWc royalty 5WG ,= . FED 5WG `( )* l6C,Þj M=NJWr I= . mR ,= .R )

U C ,6YE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: I= .9{3_E Z,t§( B(8R 6�7,pE

6s,-K67 �J�h Z,t§( B(8R: ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ I= . 5WG o´ IS @Wr 2W c -2= nX¤ )* 9X :1( `( `U1,W c M=Na 8�6 g6? )* )V (57 )/ qU �

-: traditions @U ?,£ I- . M=:9*E mB,JWr `,X . @

U ?,8 . )FGE Xs ( = .( -bR B1( extra ¶8 �=N6. M=NU.,6Y

1R -bR ¶8 �=N6. M=NU.,6YE 6s( I= . = .( @Wr )

- C ,= K-: 6f(1B ©(8R )FG B M=NWcE )®>? 8<*

-M3/5j 9X : -M=N

;. )/ B,XY 8�- Oj )/ LR,= .-B 8RB,»= CB ©,»-C 9* ¶{= .R M=NÂ q�* )

- C ;s,6 . M=N>- ? o*E 17’17 8�- Oj ;s,6 . 5WG q WrB )FG = .( = .( 8<* -M

3/5j 9X : M=NvXY most welcomeE 6s( `( ,k 6s(56 7 28 n[

-Na ,k +,k )FG `( 9X : 8�=O6N=.8R 5; C I- . M=:9*E ¶{Â M=NÂ `( )* 9X :1( ©(5Ê )V M=N

U. ( `( 9X : �°6 C M=Na -M3 ¢{_8R 9* M=NÂE )¢¬N]Y q³6 ?

180

M=:9* (� -Y )* )¬OV I= . budgetary process )FG `( 5* ,= K-: I- . \-.B

mR M=:R IS L�-KU: ( Xs ( 5* q³6 ? ;�¦6? Ñ= O®»;C 5WG 6�67 I= . 8�6 g6? LB,6 .1R q³6 �* 3T=NX.

,-.5WG 5WG 5; CE ;�¦6? I= .9{3_

Mr. Deputy Speaker: The question is that the Cut

Motions as moved on Demand No. 84, be adopted. (Consequently Cut Motions were rejected).




Mr. Deputy Speaker: The question is that the Cut Motions as moved on Demand No. 86, be adopted. (Consequently Cut Motions were rejected).

181




Motions as moved on Demand No. 130, be adopted. (Consequently Cut Motions were rejected).




Motions as moved on Demand No. 143, be adopted. (Consequently the Demand was granted.)

182


6s(5

- C Ñ/5= C B5X OV,; . : Prime Minister of Pakistan )/ )U C (96 :

o- ¹,6 .2îh Finance Minister I= . ¡2= nª ,6 t

;�V( b,W c1 )U C ,X t

-�¦X? ú� -b56 7 5* ×�-K/ ,k representative 56 7 ,À; ? L1 retire(5WG Chief Minister

(Sindh) o*, ×�-K/ )* Chief Minister o* summary Prime Minister 6�7,p )* `,X . X¾

-�¦X? qU �´ )FG -M=N;. ©,_ o* extension)*

)U OV 24 L1 extension q¨a M=N>- ? )FG The result is today IRSA is

without a representative of the province of Sindh. 6f ( ×�-K/ ,k o

U ¹5* representative Sir, unfortunately IRSA M=Na M=N>- ? )FG

)U C (96 : o

- ¹,6 .2îh 56 7 summary b,W c1 )/ oU ¹ ( )FG )

U C (96 : o- ¹,6 .2îh Prime

Minister Sahib )/ M=N>· IS )®>? `( )* 9X :1( I6 Y5; C mR )* `( 5*

©,»-C 9* M=:R 1( B `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ I= . 3 B(-9´ q³6 ? b5P·B ,Ò L1 I= . 3 B(-9´ b5P·B ,Ò IS Federal Member I3[= NJWr ×�-K/ )/ ,;.5WG )FG IÁ-.5= O*lower

riparian ×�-K/ )FG B1( I= . IvÕ=Oµ ,[= NS q³6 ? qhR ( oU ¹5* 5WG ,-K;NS q³6 ? `( )

- C ¶X g· ,= K* 5WG -M{= KV 9´( o

U ¹5* Û®-w qhR ( q³6 ? q³X A( ;s,6 . ,;.9* )FG 5; C `( o* q³6 ? ;� Ø²,ç7 o

- ¹9* )¬OFG ,XYE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E

183

6s(5- C Ñ/5= C B5X OV,; . : I= . ©2- n6¤ -9= :19X : �23 ïj )* B1R M=Na article )*

throughI= . (5WG ,À; ? B1( 56 7 (5WG )FG Federal Member, because Sindh is a lower riparian, ©B 8�= Kµ 26 nJh 56 7 )FG L1 �-K/ × 5* ,-K®a

E)¬OFG ,XY Thank you Sir.

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ;�¦6? EI= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 -b,J¨_ Xf5®6 . 6�7,p

6s,-K67 �J�h -b,J¨_ Xf5®6 .: ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_ 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p|-R5|}~(E �'(,�6 . ~ -M�j � -M��= N�3[V(

E�@= ��67~�9V( �@��6 C �'( -M� yA�9~V( �@= ��7�9~V(E q- �X:( `( speech ,k -B,- w ( = .( då 3/ )/ ,-.9*

b5WG,XY ,Ò

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Time M=N>- ? )FG B,XY T

8N-Kj M=Na Xs ( )- C ;s,6 .

o- ¹9* )FG q6A Xs ( Cut Motion IX . ;s,6 . M=:9*E

6s,-K67 �J�h -b,J¨_ Xf5®6 .: 9{ 3_ )FG 24 Xs ( )- C = .( 8�- Oj )

- C ,É896 : ,= .RE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: Cut Motion IX . ;s,6 . M=:9* q6AE

6s,-K67 �J�h -b,J¨_ Xf5®6 .: = .( 8�- Oj ,É896 : ,= .RE L�w1 ,= K* )FG m2= nª 6s56 Ogh )

- C M=:5X g-?,X . -bR ,k

q�* )/ -M/ ,= KV ,Ò5WG I= . ,= K-:R B,XY -bR o* )FG

184

I- . b(5X g-?,X . -bR )

U C ( ,Ò I- . q6 t6? oU ¹ ( o´ `( )* L1xw 24 ;�j5{Y 6�67 ;�j5{Y M=Na

M=N>- ? o

U ¹ ( q³; ? 5; C B53 ¢

-Na M=Na )¢®]Y M=Na meeting M=Na ,= .8�= Kj IX . = K

U:,a q³6 ? m8B5; C )U O´ 6�®Þj L1 x= K

3/56 7 -MX : q³6 ? ,= .,À·R ,= K´ -M=N;. )- O¬N>h ,k L�w1 ,= K* ,= K´

û )¬O-N>h ,k L�w1 ,= K* ,= K´ ×89= :8R ©,_ ,k L�w1 ,= K* ,= K´ 1R ©,_ ,k L�w1 ,= K* ,=K´ -M=N;. ©,_ ,k L�w1 ,= K* ,= K´ B1( I= . q³6 ? ,>· IS q6A I= .9´( I- . 5WG )- O;: ( 8�= .2= nX. M=Na 5; C

(2= nª +,-. ©�6 . E,-K=:R 2= n-¤ @Wr )

- C 5; C ¶X g· M=N>- ? ,>· +(5} 2; n>6? q; �

-:,6Y )FG -M{= KV \-. 8�= K

3/8R5V @· )- C 5WG )* )

U C ,6 t6? B1( ×896 : EqU �´ `( )* L1xw 24 Xs ( )- C

,ÀQ= .R IS mB5X C ^va M=Na q6 t6? o* qË· ,k ,-Kj,_ )FG 6�67ýüü M=Na -9®X K=NX. o8 ¹B,X .

o* ;�j5{Y oU ¹ ( 5; C ¸(B ,X .D( ,= K´ IS q6A �23 ïj 6�7,p ,k B1R ,-K;:( )]C B,k

B1R ,À; ? IS -b,;K¢*,X . IX . @¨ØÈ 9* )* )®¯Y )U O´ \-. 8�= K

3/8R5V ×896 : qU �´ bx¼ ,= K´5WG @Wr I= . M=:9* )´ mB,JWr `( ;<º1 )* 56 7 9= : -B1 o

- ¹,X . q6 t6?1 )P; ? 56 7 �°6 C M=Na

@ØÙ}(9= : -B1 q³6 ? )- O]: b5¦- ?( )

- C q³6 ? L�w1 ,= K* -M{= KV L1 L�w1 ,= K* 56 7 ,¼1 )U C ,6Y5WG

6s( I= . ;�j5{Y oU ¹ ( `( )

- C q³6 ? L�w1 ,= K* -M{= KV 6s( ;. 5; C ,¼1 M=N>- ? (5WG

)®À�X? 8�6 g6? ,À; ? 8�6 g6?(241R )FG `( q6 Ky§( ,k `( ;�j5{Y ,k -M{= KV oU ¹5* d²,-Y L(5-7

3T=NX. ;<iB M=N>- ? `()FG )* L1xw 6�/ )/ (896 : IvUK¢j mB5X C ^va M=Na 2W c

©,_ floods ); C ( M= NWc 6sx=K/ ,;. ( )FG B1( I;KX: )FG mB5X C 5* ^va

5- C(dËQY b 6�/5* 5* I= . I;KX: )FG IS 6sx=K/ -M* -M* b5±xw )/ -9´ B )* ,;. ( )FG `( ^va M=Na � 3_( ;sB12- Í )FG construction of dams o* ISdams 2= nJå

;C )¬O* M=NU.,6Y 56 7 ú�þü ,= . ûü )* o

U ¹,W cR )* �°6 C `( ^va M=Na 2= nJå

;C q Wr M=N>- ? E)

U C 5WG @Wr I= . M= N>- ? ); O¦· IS Xs ( m896 : 896 : m @=?8R

M=NU.,-K6: @Wr I= . ); O¦· M=NWc IS -M6 7 b5±xw )/ 6sx=K/ )

; C B-9´ )U C 5WG ,;. ( )FG

Xs ( b,W c1 )/ )8 C 5PX A )

8 C 5PX A @=?8R 2= nJå;C M=:9* o

- ¹,X . ,k L2= n-¤-R M=:9* IS,;. `( )/

185

@Wr q6 t6? o* B(1(�= KX: M=Na I¼,-p( M=NÁ_9*E -M{= KV `( 8�6 g6? M=Na M=NJWr oU ¹5* q³6 ?

,[= C( I6 .5Ü- Oj ;�j5{Y ;<º1 o* 6<

- :,6Y )/ d Ø�-C M=N>

- ? ,W cB ( ¡B,JWr �=KÖ-O; : 5*

fxp( )* B5² 9X : ,= KV )U C ,6Y �=KÖ

-O; : )U C (96 : �= KÖ

-O; : I- . ,= KV )U C ,6Y IÁ-.5= O* -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C( ,k +,k )FG ;�j5{Y 5* L1 M=:-2= nX¤ M=N

U.,;K6: 56 7 �= ., 3_ L1 oversight 9* )* )´ ( ×896 : E)U O´ `( )* L1xw qXA(9* L1 2î3§ )FG ^va -b,;K¢*,X . ,k T67 5* ;�3¢= N°j o* I3_ ¸B ,>· ,;.,6Y )FG qXA(9* Xs ( 5* �ü 8�- N_9X : )/ LR,= .

-B revenue ,;K=:R )FG ×�-K/ Xs ( 5* T=N� ,;K=:R -M{= KV)FG I= . ,= K* ;s,6 . o

U ¹5WG IS @Wr 5; C Xs ( 5* )- O¬: R )V (1 M=NWc B1( Xs ( )

- C 56 7 M=NJWr 56 7 �þü Mega Watt q6 t6? 56 7 ( 8�X .(1 )/ ¡R q³

; ? L1 q³6 ? mB,JWr 9= : -B1 ;�{vJh +,-. M=N>- ? b5V ,Ò b5¦- ?( )

- C TXC(1 )V oV 5; C o

- ¹,6 .2îh 9* )* �þü Mega Watt 56 7 q6 t6? qXA(9* 5* ¡R ,6Y q WrB q³; ?

56 7 IS ;�¦6? qWr @· )FG `( 5* ©,t6? ,= K* B1()U C ,6Y `( 8�6 g6? M=Na ¥a, 3_ ,= K*

E)U C ,6Y `( )* L1xw R,6 . (B�= K7 M=Na q³6 ? Electric )* -B53 ¢= C( M=NWc q6 t6?B1( )* -B53 ¢= C( M=NWc 6�®Þj \-. 8�= K

3/8R5V ×�-K/ M=Na q�= C(5; C 9* ¡R qU �´ )FG )* oX¹ )* M=Na q�= C( ¡R9* qU �´ )FG -b,;K¢X 75®6 . ,k 5; C ©,Y q Wr M=N>

- ? M=NÀX A5X C IS �= ., 3_ L1 ^va -b,;K¢*,X . IÕ7,k q Wr M=N>

- ? E)FG B mB,JWr 9=: -B1 ;�{vJh �5¿5j )- C -M6 7 ,k L5®6Y 6f (

@Wr )- C `( q6 Ky§( M=Na ,ÀQ= .R �=., 3_ q Wr o

U ¹5* ,[= C( Å-g3§ 5WG )* oX¹ M=Na ×�-K/

M=Na -b,;K¢X 75®6 . M=Na T67 5* b5¦- ?( )- C q 6 t6? B5X 7 I- . ,>· E5WG �= ., 3_ q Wr o

U ¹5* ,[= C( -B-dåj -M*B 5WG ,= . -B-dåj qhR ( 5WG mB( m2= nª o

U ¹,À6 ? IS Xs ( R5-7 q Wr q- �;:( ,_B,X .

5WG Xs ( ); O¦· 5WG IS q6A M=Na úûü -9´ )* -b,»j M=Na ,;K WGB b5WG úú B(-2W c ,k ¥6. ,;K=:R b5WG ,= K* Xs ( )* dPê M=Na m( q§ M=N>

- ? E,;K®XY

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{3_

186

6s,-K67 �J�h -b,J¨_ Xf5®6 .: ,= K* Xs ( )* M=NadPê 6¾ =?di M=N>

- ? ,;K®XYE q³6 ?( 5; C ;s,w12

3 4 M=NWc 24

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A þ 8�- Oj )U O´ 5WG EM=NWc wind up M=:9*Eq6A

6s,-K67 �J�h -b,J¨_ Xf5®6 .: qU �P6 ? b,>· )U C 5WG M=NWc 24 o

U ¹,É 8B( 8�- Oj )U C 5WG

×89= :8R 8�- Oj qº,6 . M=NWc

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: @U ?,8 . ,-KX:( æ

U C,-p 9* )FG B M=NWc

6s,-K67 �J�h -b,J¨_ Xf5®6 .: `( )* L1xw 24 Xs ( M=NÀQ= .R mB,JWr q§189X : ^Â,Jh )

- C ^va -b,;K¢*,X . o* ;�j5{Y 5* q¨ÀX �X? ;�j5{Y 5* q³6 ? `( ;�j5{Y 5* q³6 ? ); N[/ b5j(R IX . q6 t6? ,= K¦h )

- C 9* ,k ,>· -M{= KV ,= K* I6 Y1 )FG IS @Wr -b( )/ q6 t6? M=N>- ? )V )FG B M=NWc `( )]C 5Ü- Oj 5* q³6 ? q

- �X:( `( M=Na ;s,3_B(-9´ M=Na ¥a, 3_ ,= K* E)

U C ,6Y `( )* L1xw qXA(9* M=Na 56 7 = .( Karachi Electric Supply Corporation (5WG o

; ¹9* q³; ? T67 )/ �23 ïj )* B1R M=Na

privatize9* ,= .R ,= K´ 6s( `( )- C ,-KX:( +,-. q Wr ©�6 . ,= .R q�* B1( )

- C 5; C ,-KX:( +,-. M=N>

- ? ED�6 . `( )- C ,-KX:( +,-. ©�6 . ,= .R K-Electric ,= .R9* 6s,-K67 L1

^v6 KX: q- �XNJ· 56 7 +(5} 5* relief)

- C ,X t-�¦X? )* )U OV facilitate)

- C 9* )* )U OV q³; ? L1 )- O¯: ( Xs ( 5* facilitate 9* q WrB )FG ú Eú )8 O

-NÀê o* \-. 8�= K3/8R5V 56 7

187

ú�üú ã ,k ,= . û ,k 56 7 Electric law L1 )FG (B,JWr 56 7 Electric -b5- C,£

)FGE )ñ -b(-R(2ì}(

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: -b,J¨_ Xf5®6 . 6�7,p = .( 8�- Oj M=Na 8�-KU :(1 Xs( )U O]g=�*E

6s,-K67 �J�h -b,J¨_ -b,-Y Xf5®6 .: 24 Xs ( M=NÀQ= .R IS qXA(9* M=Na 28 n=Kj \-. 8�= .B

5* 5; C @; � -7 q Wr 9* ,= .R ,= K´ )FGE IÁv6 . 28 n=Kj )

- C 5WG ,k 5; C L�U.,¼ q Wr M=N>- ? )FGE

over billing q- �;:( 5WG qU �´ IS)FG T6 C L1 L,XY )FG B M=NWc IS )- O¯: ( mB(R( 5*

,-K;N 6Y q³6 ? �U.,¼ L mR M=NÁ_ M=:REB1( b,>6A IX . qXA(9* M=Na m5- C �Õ=Oµ \-K®6 . )FGà

-b( 5* q³6 ? theft ,k ¥6. ,-K6: )* ,= .R ,6Y ,W cB )FGE 5; C ¡B,JWr Xs ( )/ 3 B(-9´ )FG IS b,>6A 9X : recovery losses M=NWc q Wr M=N>

- ? b,W c1 IX . 5; C 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ )- C 9*

o* oU ¹5* l�

-Oj q; �-N6. M=N>

- ? )FGE `( )* L1xw ¡28 n_ 8�-.( 5* 56 7 8R5V ,= .R ,6Y ,W cB )FG L1 q³6 ? @· ,= K* ,6Y ,W cB )FG B1( qXA(9* M=Na 56 7 ¡28 n_ 8�-.( )FG `( o* = .( �-K6: )

- C 5WG o* I6 Y1 I= . q³6 ? )FG IS 56 7 8R5V )FG `( 5* @· ,= K* ,6Y ,W cB )FG B1( `( IX . q³6 ?

over billing B1( excess billing o* ,6Y q WrB )FGE 24 Xs ( M=NÀQ= .R IS qXA(9* )* ¶; ?,_ q Wr o

- ¹( 8�� ,k I£xw -b,;K¢X 75®6 . M=Na 56 7 ,;KÄÂ )FG ¶; ?,_à b,W c1 B5WGD 5* 5; C q6 t6? ¡R ,6Y q WrB )FGà ¥Õ=Oµ R,6 . ( 5* 5; C ¡R ,6Y q WrB )FGE ,= K* I6 Y1 )FG IS b,>6A IX . qXA(9* )* ¶; ?,_ o

- ¹( 8�� ,k 56 7 = .( 8R9´ -M3 ¢= N8K/ ,= .,-K6: ,6Y ,W cB )FGà q6 t6? ,k 8<

- :xX . ,= .,ÇV ,6Y ,W cB )FGE 9´( b,W c1 )/ ¡8B5P; ? q§ ;s(2= n

-¤ ¶6 gË§ )* qXA(9* 5* q³6 ? q6 t6? mR ¡R )

U C ,6Y 56 7 IS `( ,k l7 )FG 5; C @Wr -B(5- C Ñ= C2

3 4 6�7,p )* ;�¦6? B(-9´9{ 3_ b5WG )´E

188

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E q6A �= .5

- C dËº 6�7,pE ;s,_ 8�- Oj 5WG )U O´ M=NWcE�= .5

- C dËº 6�7,p ;s,6 . ¡B,6Y M=NÀ·BEM=N>- ? 8<* -M

3/5j M=Na ¡dÔ, 3_1då3/ M=N>

- ? o; ¹5WGE �= .5

- C dËº 6�7,p 0123 4 M=:9*E

�=K/ �= .5- C dËº : L1 B53Ê )

; C ,X th M=NWcB )´ Xs ( 1R 8�- Oj mR M=:R ,= K* Zdi ,;.89X : )FGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: B,XY X¾-?,X . ;s,_ 8�- Oj )

U C R M=NWc L1 2U n=KX7 5* q³6 ? -M3 ¢{= .9U:(8R

)/ ,-.xXY ); OFG ,XY M=NWcE q6A �= .5- C dËº 6�7,p Xs ( ;s,6 . M=:9*E

) ;�® -Y(�a(

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: �=.5- C dËº 6�7,p Xs ( ¡B,6Y M=NÀ·BE

�=K/ �= .5

- C dËº : @�6 C '( -M� yA9V( @=�79V(E )¢¬N]Y M=Na 0123 4 9* ,W cB ,À; ? B1( )P]�h dPX ? m2= nª ;�/1R Z,t§( B(8R 6�7,p )

- C @QY ,= K* IS Xs ( (B-R âB M=NU.,6YE 5; C

3 B(-9´ I= . )FG IS `( ;<º1 -b,;K¢*,X . )* 9´( +,w q�* q³6 ? qhR ( M=NÀX A5X C)/ 5; C 6�/ )/ (896 : IvUK¢j 5; C L1 ,= . 5

; C )¦· ,Ò oU ¹,Ç-O¦h ,= . )¦· ,Ò 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/à (2= nª ©,= K-7

)FG I= . universal )FGàacross the board )FGà +,J;? b56 C5¿ M=Na )FGà

;s,>=?R M=Na q³6 ? )FG b12î3§ M=Na q³6 ? )FGE`( Øä,tz )/ (2= nª ©,= K-7 )FG IS ,-K;N 6Y

`( subject IX . 8�- Oy- ?B5´ 5* T*5µ ,-KP·B )U OFG ,XY )P

; ? )®À�X? mB5X C ©,_ M=Naà `( 8�6 g6? M=Na B1( `( )/ )´ (E 9´( +(5} )/ M=NÀX A5X C )´ 5; C 6s(56 7 qí=? )®a ,Ò IS M=N>

- ? ¶X g· q³6 ? M=N>- ? (5WGE IÁ-.5= O* 6f ( q³6 ? 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ LB,6 . LB,6 . )8 O-NÀê on

189

the average 5WG q WrB )FGE ¶X g· b5±xw M=Na LB,À8 ?( o; ¹5WG )FGà ¶X g· b5±xw M=Na

LR5X 7 o; ¹5WG )FGà ¶X g· 5WG ,;K{_ )FG o

U ¹5* 3 5-7 ;�y�± )FG -M6 7 M=Na ¶8 ? ( o* o; ¹5WG

)FGE -M{= KV I= . across the board )FGà I= . +,J;? b56 C5¿ M=Na )FGà I= . 12î3§ b

b5; C,>=?R b5- C1R M=Na )FGE ¶X g· @Wr )

- C 9´( LR,= .-B âB,X . ,-.9* (5WG 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ 5*à 5; C @Wr -b( b5±xw 5* high loss area declare 9* )* @Wr -b( 5* M=NWc); O¦· IS -b( 5* ¥»V,6 . q Wr q6 t6? )- O¬: R o* ;sB12- Í M=N>

- ? )FGE

unfortunately 9´( @Wr 8�- Oy- ?B5´ o* social responsibility M=NÀQ= .R

5; C `( Øä,tz )/ I= . ;�¦6? q Wr Û®-w q�= NÂ,X . )FGEIÁ-.5= O* `( M=Na 56 7 ¥6. ,;K=:R )FG L1 q³6 ? (B,a ,;.,6Y )FG B1( 56 7 M=N>

- ? ,;K=:R )FG L1 q³6 ? (B,a ,;.,6Y )FGEoU ¹5*

discrimination M=N>- ? o

; ¹5WG IS 8�- Oy- ?B5´à mB5X C )* mB5X C 9´( 8R9´ Xs ( �-K6:

9* M=:R ,= . mB5X C )* -BB 8�= Kµ �-K6: 9* M=:R 5; C qí=? ¸5V 5WG ,Ò IS b5´5V ,k incentive 56 7 )FG L1 @

; � -7 5WG )U C ,6Y ,ÒE 24 @Wr b5

- C1R b5- O=N;. -B 8�= KU :,_ )/ `(

)®UK¢j 5* M=NWc); OPQ= .RE )®>? 5; C 9´( @Wr generation 5* M=NÀQ= .R 56 7 IS 6�/ )/ L,= .-B

T*5µ M=Na q³6 ? ,;K WGB )FG B1( (2= nª ©,= K-7 )FG IS ¶X g· ;sB12- Í )/ LR,= .

-B T*5µ M=Na ,;K WGB )FG IS generation q³6 ?( ;. plans 5; C m896 : )

; C 5WG M=NWcà )- O¯: ( plans 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ ;�¦6? m896 : m896 : o; ¹,-K6: )FGEMoU sign )

; C 5WG M=NWcà )®À¯�X? B1R M=Naà mB,JWr B1R M=Na q³6 ? )

U C 5WG )P; ?à 6s( q³6 ? )

U C 5WG M=NWcà ñI-KU :,XY)/ ¥=.8R 5WG q WrB )FGà ñ I-KU :,XY)/ b,= K

-NXKy· ( q WrB M=NWc L2= n-ð1 EL2= n

-ð1 -M{= KV on ground ,= K* )FGE `( -bR T

-C,-Kµ o* 6�67 ;s,6 . 5WG q WrB q³; ? 5; C 6<

; : q³6 ? M=Na )- C qí=? ,>· ,À; ? IS

b,W c = .( ¡�-K-: B5X C ,k @Wr B12- Í ); O¬NÂ M=NWc )- O¯: ( 9X :1( IS b,>=? unusual delay (5WG 56 7 IS M=N>

- ? ,-.5WG )U OFG ,XYE -M{= KV `( )* L1xw qº,6 . 56 7 -M=N;. B(-2W c 1R

190

5Ê 8s(1,Ç= Oj add )U C 5WG `( )

- C ,a -B M=Naà -M{=KV ( ` )/ q³6 ? impact M=N>- ? (5WGE

R,= . )U OP·B 28 n[j 9{= KXN_! IS impact L1 M=N>- ? (5WG IS @Wr I= . I>· M=NÁ_ IS 8R5V

\-. 8�= K3/ 5* @Wr )

- C R( -B ( 9* ,= .R )FGE5; C b,>=? 6�67 @Wr )- C q³6 ?( )]C 5Ü- Oj )

U C ,ÇV M=N>- ? M=NWcE 1R o* inauguration B12- Íà 1 8�� 747 o* ,= . Xf( 58 C o* 9´(

Xs ( )- C 9* ¡R 56 7 IS @Wr )

- C )U C ,ÇV )P

; ? B1( 6s( rotation IX . L1 ( )FG B M=NWc 5; C `( ,k q³6 ? 56 7 impact)

U C ( ,Ò ,= . Xs ( )* 56 7 coal fired power plants M=NWcE 6s( Xs ( ©(5= O WG,_ M=Na '(ã, 3_,a ,ÇV )FG B M=NWcE b,>· port b,>· coal m9;:( ,Òà b,>· ;. )

U C ( o´ `( o* edit costà 2W c, ØÈ )FG IS qí=? consumer pay m9* ,ÒE 56 7 conversion q³

; ? coal ,k L�U.,¼ )- C ,À8 ?( o*

IS q6A I= . ,;K¢/ fuel 5WG ,Ò T-Cdi ¥U. ( )/à 6s( @Wr `( 5* transportation

cost M=Na loose 9* )* `( ,k L1 advantage q³6 ? @; � -7 9* )FG B M=NWcE

@Wr b12î3§ )* 6<=:dº -M=:9;: coal fired power plants ,ÇV )FG B M=NWc 5; C

environmental \Â( IvUK¢j )- O¯: ( )®Ò M=Na ©(8R M=NWc)FG B B1( 56 7 (B,JWr existing resource )FGà 56 7 indigenous coal ,k dP; ? M=Naà `( 5* @Wr

infrastructure )* )- O¬: R )U OV B,= K; : M=N>

- ?E transmission line 5* oU ¹ lay

)- C 9* )* )U OV @Wr )

- C q- �X:( PSDP M=Na o

U ¹5* ,[= C( 8�{= K67(9X : M=N>- ? ,À·B T67

M=Na incentive )®a foreign investors 5* ,= . domestic investors5* IS L1 b,W c1 M=N

U.,6Y B1( b,W c1 ,6Y )* B1( B1,X . T8N-.xX . M=N

U.,ÇV IS,;. `( o* evacuation 5WG ){_E evacuation ¡B5X C fd² )/ to be honest with you 56 7 existing power plant 56 7 inaugurate 5WG ){¯Y M=NWc -b(

o* fully M=N>- ? o

U ¹5WG ,= . 56 7 )- C ( )V (1 @ =K

-: @¨>6A L2= n-ð1 -b( o* q³6 ?

evacuation ,k q³6 ?( ;. ¡B5X C fd² )/ +, ØÞ;O-:( M=N>

- ? (5WG )FGE -M{= KV L1

191

across the board @Wr = .( m241R 5* blame ); O¬: R M=NWcB )´ `( M=Naà -M{= KV IvUK¢j I= . )FG IS q6 t6? )

U C ( o´ B1( q6 t6? q�* )* dPê ;. )¯�-�¦X? o´ q³6 �

;:5; C ,6Y )* @Wr I= . I>· M=NÁ_ )´ IS @Wr 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ 5* ¶X g· �Y ;. @; � -7 9* ); O{_

M=NWcE -M{= KV 56 7 q¨p( IvUK¢j )FG M=Na T67 ;s,6 . IX . emphasize,-.9* ,;K WG,XY b5WG L1 I= . )FG IS Xs ( generation add q³6 ? )

; C 9* M=NU.,6YE 9´( Xs ( ,k ,;K* M=:5- O*

M=Na (89X : )FGà9´( Xs ( )- C line losses B1(collections q

- �X:( = KP8 ? M=N>

- ? M=NS 5; C dPX ? ,»X C ( I= . IvUK¢j ¥»V,6 . ¥Y M=N>

- ? 5WG ,ÒE Xs ( o* ¡B5X 7 M=NWc1 o; ¹5WG )FG B )FG ,XY

L1line losses )* +,-. )/ 5WGà )FG ,XY L1 receivables )* +,-. IX . 5WG IS q¨°6 7 ¥6. 9´( )

U C R )U O¬: R B1( `( M=Na Xs ( )- C receivable ,ÀQÂ IS,= .R @Wr )

- C I= . q6 t6? actually qX�=�6: )FG IÁ6K67 Xs ( )

- C b,W c1 M=N>- ? qX�=�6: q�* B1( 5* qX�=�6:

o; ¹5WG )FGE 5; C L1 (B,_ ,k (B,_ ,k 56 7 counting )FG 6�67 ;. @Wr `( ,k ©,= K-7 M=N>

- ? M=NÀ·B )´à 6�67 ;. IS b,W c1 IX . @Wr governance 5* = KP8 ?

M=N>- ? M=:9* )´à b,W c1 6�67 ;. professionalism@Wr M=N

U.D )´ 5; C M=NJWr `( 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ )/ q³6 �* q³6 ? ;s,6 t-? M=N>

- ? )®a ){_ o´E I= . ;�¦6? ¡B12- Í )FGE b,>=? IX . 56 7approachqWrB )FG unfortunately mB,JWr ;�/1R M=NWcà )U O´ ( M=NWc �6 .,w q³6 ?à IS q�* 5* oV,Ò )- O¬: R )/ IvUK¢j ¥Y M=N>

- ? ,;.5WGà q�* 5* B5X 7 )- O¦· )/ IvUK¢j ¥Y M=N>

- ? ,;.5WGE M=Na )- C R5-7 -b( )/ q³6 ? I= . 3�g6? o* )FG IS 9´( Xs (

total losses = .(LESCO )* M=NÀQ= .R 5; C L1 Xs ( )* +,J;? qº,6 . 56 7 ×�-K/

M=Na ,= . -b,;K¢X 75®6 . M=Na 56 7 DISCOS M=NWc `( )/ LR,= .-B losses M=NWcE -M{= KV

oV,Ò b,W c1 o; ¹89X : )FGE 5; C `( fd² )/ )®UK¢j ¥Y M=N>

- ? 5WG )´E Xs ( 5* cooperation )U OFG ,XY provincial governments o* 5; C Xs ( -b( 5* on

board )V )* 5WG,-K®XY ,Òà Xs ( 5* I- . �2Í -b( )/ bills receive )- C 9*

192

M=NWc -M{= KV 5{X . ( -b( o* R�a )V )* Xs ( 5* b5´5V )/ q³6 ? bill receive )- C 9* EM=NWc 5; C `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ -b( b5±xw M=Na q³6 ? 56 7 T

8NÁ=K67(9X : )- OÄÂ M=NWcE= .( 5; C encourage ,= K* )

U C ,6YE @Wr )- C 18th amendment M=Na I= .

possibilities M=NÀ·B IS provincial governments 56 7 M=NWc L1 R5-7 )- O¯: ( power plants M=N

U.,ÇVE 6s( L1 6�67 M=NU.,ÇV 5; C -b( 5* encourage ,= K*

)U C ,6YE L1 9´( advise M=:R 5; C -b( o* b,>=? (2X n=K

-: )/ q³6 ? B1( -b( )* )- O¯: ( intuitions )/ ©,3Kj )* B5² 9X : wind power )FGà 5; C ×�-K/ )* `,X . 9´(

`( ,k = .( resource R56 75j )FG 56 7 IS 6�/ )/ LR,= .-B developed )FG

5; C ×�-K/ 5* `( 5* )´ ( )- C ,É896 : o* 6�=O

- }9;: ¡R )U C ,6YE -b( 5* incentives ,= K*

)U C ,6YE )

U C ,6 t6? `( )* IS -b( 5* dis-incentive b,W c1 IX . ,= .R )U C ,6YE q§( fd²

)/ -b,;K¢X 75®6 . M=Na 9V5Ê B1,X . o* q- �;N 6Y potential )FG L1 �U., 3_

6s,6 t

-�X: )/ q³6 ? LR,= .-B 5WGE5; C M=NJWr `( IX . concentrate ,-.9* )U OFG ,XY B1(

b56 C5¿ 5* B1( oU ¹,6 .5¿ T

8N-Ky- ?B5´ 5* `( mB,_ process M=Na involve ,-.9*

)U OFG ,XYE `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ @Wr56 7 conversiono* ;s,6 . 9* )FG B M=NWc cheaper fuels )* )U OV IS T

-Cdi ¥U. ( 6�/ )/ ,Ç-O¦h )FG @Wr T=N� IX . M=NU.,6Y ,= .

)®U. 5* IX . EM=NU.,6Y T=N� )* )U OV q³6 ? M=Na 3 B(-9´ qí=? b19* ,Ò IS 5®XY (� -Y (� -Y 9*

)* = .( x>X? ¥-K=Na98 : ¥=.( -M=:( q6A ,k award (5WG )FGE )®À�X? B1R M=Na q³6 ? @Wr

`( T8N-KU :(5X C ;. ( ){¯Y )P

; ? IS L1 @=?2X n_ 8sB5* M=Na xXY ,= K´ B1( (B,_ Iva,°j derail ,= K´5WGE 6s( dPX ? `( 8�- OU:(5X C 9X : )

- C ( )* )U OV M=NJWr ,6 K=:dÎ;C X¾

-?,X . ©,_ \Â M=NWc)U O´ B1( `( X¾

-?,X . ©,_ M=Na 56 7 56 CB( b )¯C 1B ,k IÁv6 . 9V(8R -B ,k loss (5WG `(à)FG ,k q³6 ? q�* I- . q�* )

- C 6s,[7 B12- Í ,-.,»X 7 ,Ò5WGE 6s( L1 ,= K ( )FG

193

5; C `( )U OV )* q³6 ? M=NJWr I= . ;s,a, ØÞ;O-:( )

- C 9* M=N=K WG,XY IS B1,X . T8N-.xX . b,W c1 M=NÃÂ

b,>6A I= . resource R56 75j E)FG 6�67 ;. Xs ( o* transmission lines M=NÃÂ B1( = .( alternate backbone M=N

U.,-K6: )´ 56 7 IS northern parts of the countryM=Na `( T=N� 5* )* )V )

U C ,6Y ,ÒE Xs ( B1,X . T8N-.xX .

M=NU.,ÇV B1( `( ¶; ?,_)* transmission lines M=N

U.,ÇV 56 7 IS power �2Í north south 5* M=N>

- ? IÁv6 . south north q³6 ? )V )- C ,6Y)* ;s,a, ØÞ;O

-:( m9*E L1 �2Í qXA(9* +,k)* M=N>

- ? )U C ( IÁv6 . mB5X C ^va +,k)* )

U C ( ,ÒE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! ( ` L1xw)* q³6 ? @Wr I= . ¶{= .R M=NWc)FG B IS M=NJWr hydle projects M=Na q

- �;N 6Y �Y ;. T*5µ ,-KP·B )¬OFG ,XYE b,W c I= . ;�/BR )FG IS @Wr 5Ê(R o* q³6 ? ;s,6 . 9* M=NWc)FG Bà @Wr , 3_,À6 ? o* q³6 ? ;s,6 . 9* )FG B M=NWc B1( `(

)U OV )* @Wr M=NWc); O¦·E ,3_,À6 ? o* land acquisition )- O;: ( )¿ dÔ )/ ¥XY q WrB )FGà = .( -2= n¼ (5WG (241R -2= n¼ (5WG -M{= KV 6�6 7 ;. @Wr `( IX . actual

contracts award 9* )´ ()* )- OÚ 896 : o* ;s,6 . M=N>- ? M=:9* )´ 6<

; : ;. I= . Iva,°j 9ÚR( ©5´ ,;Kj5Pê )FG B ,Òà¥k24 M=Na ,;Kj5Pê ,Ò)FG BE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A 8�-KU :(1 Xs( E)U O]g=�*

�=K/ �= .5- C dËº: M=NJWr )¬OFG ,XY IS @Wr next phase IX . q³6 ? +,k ,-.9*

0123 4 M=:9* B1( ( ` )* )U O¬NÂ 2W c, ØÈ )FG IS M=NJWr resources b5WG)- OP·B )´E ,3_,À6 ? ,[= C( 8�{=K6719X : )FG 56 7 2Í � Xs ( 5* q6 t6? M=N>

- ? ,;K=:Rà L1 Xs ( ^va)* )* 56 7 water reservoirs `(àM=NWc 5* q³6 ? expand ,;.9* )FGà Xs ( x= K6:9

;:)*

194

o* life 5* extend E)FG ,;.9* I= . 5; C Xs ( o* = .( life line )FGE -b,;K¢*,X . )*

)- O;N]Y q³6 ? possible projects M=NWcE @Wr ¥k q³6 ? qí=? I>· )P

; ? )FG B IS oU ¹,À6 ?

Xs ( oU ¹,W c -9= :1 IX . 5; C emphasize 9* M=NWc)FG Bà Xs ( 128 n=Kj -2ï6 C IX .

emphasize 9* M=NWc)FG Bà Xs ( o* priority I= . o- ¹5WG M=N=K WG,XY IS @Wr )- O¯: (

hydle projects 5* 6�/ )/ )´ ( -MU :D M=Na M=NÀ·B B1( 56 7 water

projects M=NWcà -b( 5* )´ ( M=NÀ·BE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E

�=K/ �= .5

- C dËº: q§( IX . Xs ( o* ¡B,_ qh5- C,k( q

- �-N6. E)FGSir, in conclusion M=Na ¶{= .R ,W cB b5WG IS you are getting impassion,

in conclusion I will sayq- �;N 6Y ;sB12- Í )FG M=NJWr emphasis)- O¬: R o*

`( 28 nÁ=K/ IX . ’ )- O;N]Y resources M=NJWr transfer )

- C 9* o* ;sB12- Í )FGà )- O;: ( @Wr )

- C M=N>- ? )U O*E`( 6s,[7 )/ M=NJWr ¥»V,6 . B(8R 6�7,p )/ B1( `(

8�- Oy- ?B5´ )/ q³6 ? ;<=:,» 3/ )FG B o´ IS You need to divert more

resources to this sector in order that this country may progress further.

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_E2= n3_ 26 nS( -b,-Y E 6�7,p

195

6s,-K67 2= n3_ 26 nS( -b,-Y: I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R E9{= KXN_ 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p! 8�-.,J= ?8R 26 nJ

-? 101 IX . m2= nª qi,k Cut Motions M=NWcE 9´( @U ?,8 . @· )FG 5; C

M=Na `( 5* read 9* )*EE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A conclusion ,;K6: M=:RE

6s,-K67 2= n3_ 26 nS( -b,-Y: 8<* -M

3/5j 26 nJ-? 11 56 7 )FGà L1 æ®

-p 2= n-.56 C M=Na

= .( q6 t6? ,k hydel division à)FG 1R hydel sub-division M=NWcà5; C `( M=Na �,8K/ o* qË· )FGEM=Na 8�-.,J= ?8R b5WG,;.9* IS b,W c1 �,8K/ o* qË· ¡B5X C o* )U C ,6Y B1( `( ¶; ?,_)* ¶; ?,_ b,W c1 )* qh,½j b5´5V 5* o

; ¹dP6 ? ,= K* `(E)U C ,6Y

¶; ?,_)* 8<* -M3/5j 26 nJ

-? 12 à)FG b,W c1 IX . (B,JWr = .( district headquarter hospital )FGà9´( `( )* )U OV \Â( B 8�= Kµ @

U ?,£ ,= K* )U C ,6Y b5= O*

IS 8�= K3/8R5V \-. o* I6 Y1 )/à b,W c1 IX . LR,= .

-B 8�= K3/8R5V \-. q WrB5WG T=N

U.,6 .E)FG T=NUK; :

)8 O-NÀê 8�= K

3/8R5V \-. q WrB5WG 5; C)FG 9´( -b( 5-Ü= Cdh b )* )U OV \Â( B 8�= Kµ @U ?,£ ,= K*

5; C)U C ,6Y -b( b5-Ü= Cdh )* ¶; ?,_ = .( qQ= K

-: ,k + ,Ò5WGE

`( ¶; ?,_)* IvJX A B1( �-K*5´ 56 7)* B 8�= Kµ M=NWcà @· voltage B1( tripping o* I6 Y1 )/ q6�yz M=N

-KU :D M=NWcE9´( `( )U OV )* \Â( B 8�= Kµ @U ?,£ ,= K*

)U C ,6Yà `( fd² (B,JWr = .( I£xw )FG b,>6A IX . ¥6.B,a qi,k,k deposit à)FG 9U:, -Y-R M=NWc B1( b,W c1 2= n

-.56 C )* ¥6.B,a ;<=:,>- ? �q¨w( q8 �V(5* M=NWc)* B1( b,W c1 oU ¹ -BBD,_ 8B56 7

M=Na ¥6.B,a qi,k)* )- C , -YB,k )ÄÂ M=NWc)

U C 5WGE 5; C b,W c1 B 8�= Kµ)* qi,k overloaded M=NWcE`( )* voltage ,k IvUK¢j )FGE132 8�= .9´ -M

3 ¢= N8K/ )* L1xw ¥Y M=N>- ? 5WG

196

,;K{_ E)FG M=Na 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )/ �-.,J= ?8R b5WG,;.9* IS b,W c1 o

U ¹ -BBD,_ 8B56 7 )* )U OV 123 KV -M

3 ¢= N8K/ 8�= .9´ )U OV )* 9´( oU ¹5* �-K6: ;�¢6 C ,= K* )

U C ,6Y 5; C I= . -b( b5´5V )U OV )* IÁv6 . )ËQth )U OV )* ’ 56 7 technical losses ,;.5WG )FGà L1 B1( )Î¬C d² )/ ©128 n-K* M=N>

- ? 5WG ,;K{_ )FGà b,W c15; C IX . 9´( -M6 : )

U C ,6Y 5; C o- ¹,6 .2îh o´5WGE

`( ¶; ?,_)* IvJX A ( ¡ -B,a ,k qi,k I£xw )FGà -b( qi,k)* consumer

M=NWcE9´( b,W c1 IX . = .( sub-division@U ?,£ ,= K* )

U C ,6YE `( fd² ¥k5V Xs, 3[*B1 ’@Wr )/ L2î3§5

- C qi,k -b(à)FG B1R dhB,ç¢-C(98 : -B o* ;�jdh )U OV )*à -b( ,k ¥=K

;: ,k IX Y9-7 ,;.5WG )FGà ©5= Oµ ,k 56 7 IX Y9

-7 ,;.5WG )FG 5; C qi,k LR,= .-B ,;.5WG E)FG b,W c1 -b(

`,X .)* )- O;: ( )¢¬N¯. )- O; : ( )¢¬N¯. M=N>- ? )

; C 5WG M=NWc b5= O* IS ¡R,6 . ( scattered E)FG = .( = .( B 8�= Kµ 120 ;. 28 n=Kj5®k ,6 Kyz ,;.5WG à)FG b,W c1 9X : 6�67 8�v¼ ,;. ( )FGE ¡B,JWr �6 . q; �y�± I= . )FG IS ¡2î3§ b5±xw B1( o

; ¹,>=?R b5±xw ¶; ?,_)* = .( ,[= N 6Y â5®_ M=NWc)

; C 9* 5; C b,W c1 9X : 9´( qh,½j B5² 9X : ¥k5V Xs, 3[*B1 @U ?,£ o* )

U C ,6Y 5; C 56 7 ¥=K

;: ,k IX Y9-7 )FGà `( o* ( 8�X .(1 5* ;�Xg6? )

U C ,6Y5WG o´E

`( ¶; ?,_)* ¶; ?,_ -b23 n=.18R B1( sub-divisionM=Na b5= C 8B,Ò o* qË· 9´(E)FG b5= C 8B,Ò o* qË· ¡B5X C o* )

U C ,6YE b,>=? IX . ¡B,JWr recovery 100% )FG B1( losses ¥»V,6 . M=N>

- ? M=NWcE 8�=K3/8R5V \-. mB,6 .)* M=Na 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p 8�=O8N_,= . 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p 6�67 q³6 ? ); OP8 ?( M=NWc 5; C I= . M=NWc); O¦· b,>6A IX . losses I- .

b5WGà b,>6A 9X : recovery 100% 5WGE M=Na -b( 5* assure b5WG,;.9* IS b,W c1 2= n

-.56 C M=Na hydel division q³6 ? M=NWcà b5- C1R sub-division q³6 ? M=NWcE

197

b,W c1 IX . I- . ¡B5X 7 o; ¹5WG )FGE M=Na -b( )/ ;�/(5-7BR b5WG,;.9* IS b,W c1 9X :

8�= K3/8R5V \-. I- . o* E)

U C ,6Y

`( ¶; ?,_)* ¶; ?,_ mB,JWr LR,= .-B 9;: feeder over loaded M=NWcE d-åX 7

-B ¡ )FGà �-K*5´ )FGà9´( `( M=Na bifurcation o* )U C ,6Y 5; C )ËQth R,çj)*

M=Na q³6 ? `(E)FG fd² mB,JWr LR,= .-B -BdhB,ç¢

-C(98 : q³6 ? over loaded M=NWc b5= O* IS 2008 )/ )V 9* mB,JWr 5{[= NX. ,k PC-I planning M=Na 5WG(89X : ,À; ?(E Xs ( o* b53 ¢ 3/5* o* I6 Y1 )/à mB,JWr -M

8 NXK=NS B�ç¿ 6�7,p o*’ b,>=? IX . q6 Ky§( B5®¼ 9X : q³6 ? @Wr )

- C ;s,6 . o*Eq³6 ?( L1 PC-I 5WG ,»X 7 b,W c1à)FG IX . -B 8�-Kµ M=NWc){¯Y (E 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p M=Na Xs ( Û/5

; C)* )/ 28 n[-Na 6�7,p B1( 8�=O8N_

28 n[-Na 6�7,p )/ I= . ;�/(5-7BR b5WG,;.9* IS X¾

-?,X . ©,_ b,W c1 9X : augmentation ,k o

U ¹5* +,k M=N>- ? (5WG E)FG transformer overload

M=NWcE b,W c1 IX . additional transformer M=NU.,ÇV M=N

U.,6YE 56 7 B1-dË· transformer àM=NWc -b( o* IÃ6Y high capacity )* M=N

U.,ÇV M=NU.,6YE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: 8�-KU :(1 Xs( E)U O]g=�*

6s,-K67 2= n

3_ 26 nS( -b,-Y: q6A q6AEB1( `( fd² qi,k ¡R,6 . ( q 6 t6? )/ +19gh )FGE `( Iv[®_ M=Na M=Na -édÔ b5WG,;.9* IS 56 7 )º xw æ®

-p 2= n-.56 C )* q6 t6?

+19gh)/ M=NWcà -b( 5* ¡B5µ B5² 9X : q6 t6? @Wr(di o* )U C ,6Y B1( q6 t6? o* 56 7 (1B,-.

8�= K3/8R5V \-. 0123 4 o

U ¹5WG )FG 5; C M=Na Xs ( Û/5; C)* )/ 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p )/ I= . ;�/(5-7BR b5WG,;.9*à �6 .,w 2= n

3_ q¨w 6�7,p )P8 �¬N6. M=NWcà M=Na -b( 5* q³6 ? ;�/(5-7BR

198

b5WG,;.9* IS b,W c1 IX . 56 7 losses q6 t6? o* 8�= K3/8R5V \-. o* I6 Y1 )/’b,W c1 IX . ¥6.B,a

b5- C, -YB,k)* M=Na 56 7 1R-dh M=NWcà -b( ¥6.B,a )* b5

- C, -YB,k -b,»V,a)* 8�= K3/8R5V \-.

o* I6 Y1 )/ 93:,;Kj 5WG M=NWc)FG BE M=Na ;�/(5-7BR b5WG,;.9* IS b,W c1 IX . 8�= K3/8R5V

\-. ¥»V,6 . I- . o* )U C ,6Y b5= O* IS b,W c1 IX . 8�= K

3/8R5V \-. ,-.9* ( 8�X .(1 R,çj)* M=Na q³6 ? M=N>

- ? )FG +(5} )* R,çj M=Na M=N>- ? E)FG M=Na ;�/(5-7BR b19* ,Ò IS

b,W c1 9X : 8�= K3/8R5V \-. 5* I- . ,= K* E)

U C ,6Y

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: 28 nS(8R -M=:2îh Z( -BB 58 OP6 ? I6 K7,pE

28 nS(8R -M=:2îh Z( -BB 58 OP6 ?: I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E M=Na b,>=? 9X : mB,JWr

former 98 :(1 8�-K=:( B1,X . )* 28 n[-Na �= .5

- C dËº 6�7,p )- C ;�¦6? q Wr @Wr(

technicalities M=NÀ; ? `( 9X : ;s,6 . o* B1( mB,JWr `( ;<º1 )* 56 7 9= : -B1 M=NWc

b5¦- ?( )- C ,-K/E M=Na q

- �X:( o8 ¹5PX A q§ = .( opinion ,-K=:R b5WG,XY o´ `( M=Na I= .

)FG IS )®À�X? -M3 ¢{= KV( M=Na [j@ \= KV ) -b( ,k = .( q Wr slogan ,À; ? T67 o* I6 Y1

)/ 6f ( L1 `( U1,W c M=Na majority M=Na )P8 �¬N6. M=NWc B1( L1 slogan q Wr1 ,À; ? IS

L1 +5± 5* q6 t6? provide M=:9* )´E 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! b5¦- ?( )- C ;�¦6? ¡B,_

M=N-t=?B,;. M=:RE M=Na R,= . ,-.DR b5WG,XY o I6 Y(B -9= :19X : �23 4( 6�7,p )

- C -¾ =?B,;. ¡R q³; ? `( )* �°6 C L1 m896 : )

U C ,;KPX �X? )P; ? -M{= KV )P]�h ,;KÄÂ )FG IS q³6 ?( IS 56 7 mB,JWr

9=: -B1 M=NWc -b( 5* q³6 ? q- �X:( M=N

-t=?B,;. TXC(1 q- �=NÂ M=:89X : o´ 56 7 b5¦- ?( )

- C ¡R M=NÀ; ?E

(B,JWr ¥-K3¢= N-. 8R9´ suffer 9* ,W cB )FG heavy losses and technical

lossesE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ q6A9-:( ,= . q6 t6? q�* q³6 ? ^va o* qº9;: )* )¬OV 9´(

sufficient )FG 5; C q8 �-:B,Ò )FG IS L1 ^va B12- Í qº9;: m9* ,ÒE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_

199

= .(international analyses )FG T67 M=Na ,= .,;K6: ,= K´ )FG IS `( ¡�p )* m241R )Ü7 M=Na ¥=K

;: B1( T=N� )* reservoirs @; �-7 5WG M=N

U.,6Y )´E 6s( mB,JWr `,X . ,= K* solution )FG IS ¥U. ( 8�-K=:( T=N� )* 56 7 reserves M=NWc L1

9´( `( current century M=Na @; � -7 )

; C 5WG M=NWc 5; C mB,JWr `,X . alternate ,= K* M=NWcE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ I= . m2= nª `,X . research paper)FG 56 7 M=Na )

- C 8�=O-:28 n-.( )/ D,»-C )FGE L1 M=Na ( 8B5P; ? ,_ Xs ( )* ¶; ?,_ 2U n=K

3/ ,-.9* q; � WG,XY b5WGE `( M=Na ,= .,;K6: ,= K´ )FG IS 929 -M=Nv6 . -M

8 : coal reserves available M=NWc 56 7 IS ,= K

-:R ,k T=NÂ,XY �Õ=Oµ IÕ7 )FGE -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na 185 -M=Nv6 . -M8 : ©5* )FG 56 7 IS ,=K

-:R )* m2ï=N

;. ^va 9X : ,;. ( )FG T67 o* 9´( Xs ( comparison I= . M=:9* IS 9´( -b(9= :( B1( ¡R5Ó/ 6sdÔ )* ¥=K

;: 5* 9´( xa M=:R 5; C -b( )* 56 7reservesM=NWc 5; C `( )* 96 :(96 : mB,JWr `,X . ©5* R56 75j )FGE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! (B,JWr ^va ¥=K

;: )- C �= .9

-7 9X : q- �X:( ;�¦6? LR,= .

-B q�-C9* Xf9

-7 ,;.9* )FGE ,= K-:R M=Na 56 7 qº9;: 9=:-9X : ^Â,Jh

M=NWc -b( M=Na 9´( @Wr -b(9=:( 5* M=NÀQ= .R -b(9=:( largest ¥=K;: produce ,;.9* )FG

,= K-:R M=Na B1( `( ,k q³6 ? 56 7 75 8�- N_9X : q6A9

-:( ,k source ©5* )FGE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! ,= K

-:R M=Na T=N� )/ 9´( q 6 t6? produce o* o; ¹,6Y )FG 5; C L1 �2Í 19�Õ=Oµ

)FG B1( -b,;K¢*,X . 45 8�- N_9X : T=N� Xf9-7 ,;.9* )FG q6A9

-:( produce )- C 9* M=NaE

mB,JWr `,X . q6A9-:( generate o* o

; ¹,6Y )FG 1B 8�= KU :,W c )/ B1( L1 ,= K

-:R M=Na 16�Õ=Oµ `( 2U n=K

3/,k )FG B1( -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na 3.32U n=K3/ )FGE mB,JWr `,X . ,= K

-:R M=Na IÁ=.dh( q- �j96 7

I-KU:,XY ,= .8�-.( 5= C )* I= .93, 75, 55 percentage energy produce

200

); C 9* M=NWc ©5* )/ B1( -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na b,>6A 9X : L2= n

-¤-R )FG ©5* ,k b,W c1 9X : produce I- . )

- C 5WG )* 96 :(96 : )FGE

b,>=? 9X : ;s,6 . o* mB,JWr ¥6K=:9-: ( 28 n[-Na @=�V128 n=KX: )

- C IS ©5* ×�-K/ o* o8 ¹B,À; ?( )FG B1( L1 -b( 5* Xf9

-7 ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XYE ,= K* 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ (5WG wind ,= K* L1 q³6 ? q�* )]C 5¿ o* o

8 ¹B,À; ?( )FG ,= K* L1 q³6 ? )]C 5¿ ;. �-K6:,X . )FG IS L1 wind ,k 56 7 source )FG T6 7 )/ @Wrenergy produce )

; C 9* M=NWcE b56 C5¿ 5* M=:5ÚB,À8 ?( @=�j9;: M=Na mR ¡R )FGE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ 9´( qå±(1 M=NJWr q6A9

-:( ,k IvUK¢j ¥Y ,-.9* )FG 5; C M=NJWr broad aspect M=Na ,-.9* m89X : ,ÒE 9´( Xs ( M=NÀQ= .R 5; C 8�-K=:1 56 7 )FG ,= K

-:R M=Na q- �j96 7 5= C T=C( m( B1( -M=NXK/( 18000 MW)FG 7000

MW )/ LR,= .-B produce 9* )FG B M=NWcE mB,JWr ^va M=Na '( �oV,°;C )

- C ;�¦6? LR,= .-B M=N

;Kyå-C ¡R M=NWcE 9´( Xs ( )- O¯: ( ^va )* b1B,XY �d² M=NÀQ= .R 5; C `( M=Na Xs ( 5* coastal areas of Karachi I8 K¦³

8 ? ’ o- ¹(5= O67 B1( Balochistan

)* coastal areas B1( -bRB,-. -B,= .9= :( B1( 2= nJ3�* )* Xs ( 5* ;�¦6? mB,_

)¢¬C ( )º xw d Ø�-C M=N

U. ( )´ b,>6A 9X : @Wr ¸5V wind energy )* 1dP; ? )- O¯: ( ^va 5* energy crisis)/ ©,»-C ); O{_ M=NWcE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ 6�/ )/ @Wr( ;s,6 . IS environment o* pollution `( )/ M=N>

- ? 5WG o´E @Wr 9V5Ê o* ;s,6 . M=:9* B1( 9´( @Wr 9V5Ê oV(1 Xf5Ê 9X : M=N

U.,6Y 5; C I= . cheapest B1( 6�/ )/ @Wr( source of energy )FG 56 7 @Wr )- O¯: ( ^va M=Na produce 9* ); O{_ M=NWcE

T67 ,k @Wr q; �y�±�6 . )/ L�U.,¼ M=N>- ? )V )FG B -M{= KV q¨ÀX �X? 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ )- C 2= n6KXNJ³6 AM=Na

I= . 8�{= K6719X : ,ÇV 9* ( 8B5P; ? ;�¦6? initiative ,= KVE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! b,>=? 9X : -b( +,J;?

;sxa,°j ’ IÁ-.5= O* 6�67 98 :(1 8�-K=:( B1,X . ¡28 n[-Na o* ;s,6 . o

; ¹ ( )FG 5; C = .( +R )/

201

IÕ- } B1( oV,Ò Xf5®Ò B1( ;�¦6? )/ -B53 ¢= C( )

; C ( M=NWc `( ,k �2Í = .( qWr solution )FG IS M=NJWr alternate o* �d² ,-.,6Y m89X : ,Ò IS,;. @Wr )- O¯: ( +(5}

5* `( Ñ= O®»;C B1( ;sD,»3¢j )/ ©,»-C M=NÁ_E (241R 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ M=Na b,>=? 9X : I= .

,-K¦· b5WG,XY o´ IS `( PSDP M=Na )P]�h = .( q³6 ? q�= C( @=�{_ d Ø�-C M=N>

- ? oU ¹ ( 56 7

wind 9X : 9V5Ê 9X : ©5* 9X : 5WGE oU ¹5* ,[= C( 8�{= K6719X : d Ø�

-C M=N>- ? ,= . ( even IS in

approved q³6 ? )P]�h d Ø�-C M=N>

- ? ,= . ( )FG IS @Wr )- C `( �d² ,XY5Ê )FG ,= .

,-KX75Ê 0123 4 ,= K* )FGE )]C 2= nØÞ-C 58 OP6 ? �= K¦

3§ I6 K7,p )- C 56 7 )- O¯: ( B1R M=Na

56 7heavy investment o* q³; ? IPP o* �a M=Na 6f ( L1 Iv= K/1 )FG IS 6f ( 56 7

mB,JWr ^va M=Na q 6 t6? ¥XY q WrB )FG q§( )/ @Wr -Å= Oµ 6s,= . 5WG )FG B M=NWcE `( )* L1xw 56 7 8�6 g6? M=Na ¡ 8�[6 N_ @

; �-7 o* qU �´ )FGE I= . ;�¦6? (896 : I= Kyz( )FG B1( = .( 5; C @Wr q

- �X:( +5± 5* q6 t6? M=N>- ? mR )FG B M=NWc B1( b56 O=:d- Ô )* 9X :1( )/

¡ 8�[6 N_ ,k ¶6 756 C ,8K WG ,= .R )FG T67 o* I6 Y1 )/ -b( 5* q6 t6? expensive )®a o´E `( )* L1xw 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ Xs ( ,k I= .9{

3_ (R( ,-.9* b5WG,XY o´ B1( 3T3Ê5* I= . b19* o´

IS 28 n[-Na 6�7,p 5* M=Na `( �d² ¥U.,a 9* b5{_ IS `( 8�6 g6? M=Na alternate

energy q6A9-:( o* �d² o

U ¹5* I- . oU ¹5* ,[= C( initiative M=NÂ T67 )/ ^va ,k

L�U.,¼ 5WG ){_E I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: 6s,-K67 ¥°V �-KX7 6�7,pE

6s,-K67 ¥°V �-KX7q³z,a: I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E 8<* -M3/5j 26 nJ

-?66)FG to this Cut Motion I want to make a focus, water accord 1991

56 7 b1B,XY b56 C5¿ )* -b,= KjBR (5WG `( 9X : letter and spirit

202

implementation�� M=N>- ? 5WG q WrB )FGE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ 6�67 water o* ;s,6 . o

; ¹ ( )FG 5; C 23 nS( I= . ;s,6 . o

; ¹ ( )FG IS ,= .8�-.( )

- C (B,JWr o- ¹,X . â1B ,= KV )FG -M{= KV 56 7 o

- ¹,X . M=NJWr available )FG `( M=Na ×�-K/ 5* (B5X C share M=N>

- ? ¥a ,W cB )FG T67 o* ×�-K/ 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ I3[= NJWr ;<=:,» 3/ o; ¹9* q; � WGB )FG B1( 56 7 ×�-K/ M=Na o

- ¹,X . ,;KXg-�¦X? )FG

`( o* distribution M=Na q³6 ? ;�¦6? LR,= .-B @6 .(9X : M=NWcE é,-Y B5² 9X : `(

accord�� M=Na 56 7downstream ¡98:5* 6f(2= n6. ,k 56 7 9*-R ,= K* ,= K´ )FG L1 10 -M=Nva 28 nÁ=.( 8�=Oµ ,k ,À; ?E 9Äa 10 -M=Nva 28 nÁ=.( 8�=Oµ annually water

downstream ¡98:5* 6f(2= n6. release M=N>- ? ,= K* ,6Y ,W cB )FGE T67 )/ ×�-K/

o* -M=Na -B erode 5WG q WrB )FG sea erode 9* ,W cB )FGE recently 9´( o8 ¹

¡1 B1( ;s(B,6 K-7( M=NÀQ= .R 5; C `( o* I6 Y1 )/ o

- ¹,X . )* )¯�=�-: ( )U O´ M=NWc q§( sea

erosion )* I6 Y1 )/E ×�-K/ o* 5P·D 28 nÁ=.( -M=Na -B sea erosion M=Na ,6Y q WrB )FGE ¡98:5* 6f(2= n6. 10 -M=Nva 28 nÁ=.( 8�=Oµ o

- ¹,X . 56 7 `(accord ,k IÕ7 )FG `( 5* q- �=N½= C ,= .,-K6: )

U C ,6YE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! (2= nª l®°;C dËÔ 8s5* )/ )FG B1( dËÔ 8sB5* 5{[= NWc

M=Na ,;. ( )FGE M=Na )- C last time= .( question q6 Ky§( M=Na ,= K* ,À; ? B1( ,>·

,À; ? IS b,W c1 9X : q6 t6? )* 6¾8�V1 @· )

; C ( M=NWcE complaining = .( question ,À; ? `( 9X : ,= .,;K6: ,= K´ IS -M

3 ¢= NJ�-C(98 : -M

U :D q6�yz )- C 5WG o* I6 Y1 )/ b,W c1 9X : 6¾

8�V1 @· ); C ( M=NWcE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ 56 7 b,W c1 )* consumers M=NWc L1 payment 56 7 ); C 9* M=NWc ¥6. 56 7 pay )

; C 9* M=NWc = .( 5; C )¢¬C 1 q Wr 78 8�- N_9X : ×896 : )- C ,6Y o*

I6 Y1 )/ ¥6. ¥6.8R 5WG )U O´ M=NWc -M{= KV 56 7 quality of the electricity -b( 5* provide o* ,6Y q WrB )FG L1 ;�¦6? low )FGE M=Na ,;K¦· 5{[= NWc M=Na dËÔ 8s5* L1

q8 �/ )FG 56 7 6�/ LR,= .-B recovery )V (1 b12î3§ M=Na L1 2î3§ ¥a, 3_ )FGE

= .( 5; C `( )* voltages = KP8 ? 9* )¬C R M=N

U.,6Y B1( b,W c1 9X : 56 7 I= K-:(B1R )FG

203

8R5V 8�= K3/ -.\ ,k L1 q³6 ? ;�¦6? LR,= .

-B )FG `( 5* @· )/ @· ,= K* )U C ,6YE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_

B,X .dP; ? M=Na )- O¬N¯. )* o

- ¹,X . ,k ;�¦6? (896 : IvUK¢j )FG `( o* = .( I6 Y1 electrification I- . ,-.5WG q³6 ? )FGE o

- ¹,X . o* I6 Y1 )/ b,Wc1 9X : ;�¦6? -b, 3[= C9X : )FGE @· )/ @· b,W c1 9X : electrification )¬O* M=N

U.,6Y -b( )* villages electrify )¬O* M=N

U.,6Y IS,;. `( -b()/ +(5} ,k L�U.,¼ 5WG ){_E ¡9-7 ( point which I

want to make IS -dË=?8R ,k ;�¦6? (896 : 9*-R (5WG )FG `( 8�6 g6? M=NaE dP; ? (B,JWr desert ,k ,= .9= :( )FG B1( b,W c1 9X : rainwater æy6A )

- C 9* )* )¬OV 9Ä-K-: 9*B,X .

o* 8�= KU :,_ 9X : B1( 56 7 mountainous side )FG `( 9X : @=?8R -M6 : ); O{_ M=NWcE 5; C

`( ,k oU ¹5* `( M=Na 9*-R M=N>

- ? )FG IÁ-.5= O* I= . ;�¦6? backward ,= .9= :( )FG `( M=Na -dË=?8R )

- C ,-K6: )* )¬OV m124 )U C (9* M=N

U.,6Y B1( -dË=?8R ,k provision q³6 ? ,À·B )U C ,6YE ;�¦6? ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: �= K/ +x-w �qÌ�Üj L, 3_ 6�7,pE

�=K/ +x-w qÌ�Üj L, 3_ : I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 E9{= KXN_ 24 3 B(-9´ I= . )FG IS `( 8�6 g6?

M=Na I= . ¡896 : @Wr( ¡28 n[-Na )FG B1( = .( ¡B,k24 -M*B ;�® -Y(�a )

- C 9* o* ¡B5X C ¡B5X C 3T3Ê5* 9* ,W cB )FGE24 = .( 8�- OU:(5X C )FG IS 56 7 o

U ¹ ( oX¹ -2= nX. M= NWc `( 9X : 56 7 sovereign guarantees M=NWcà I= . qU �

-: 26 n-¤ o

U ¹ ( )FG B1( `( 9X : I6 Y(5-7

6�7,p o* I6 Y5; C q³6 ? M=NWc,XY )´ B1( 6s(56 7 q³6 ? M=NWc,XY )´ IS -b(

o*sovereign guarantees b5¦- ?( )- C TXC(1 9* oV M=NWcà b5¦- ?( )

- C oU ¹(5Ä-Kj M=NWc 56 7 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ o* M=NWcE 6s( q- �;:( â -B,-. ;<V,Y M=Na T* fd² `( 5*

face M=:9* )´ IS q³6 �* q³6 ? I= . M=N>- ? (5WG B1( ( ` ;<º1 sovereign

204

guarantees 8sB5* M=Na ,6Y 9*à IÁv6 . M=Na `( Xs19´ ,k +,-. q³6 ? )V b5V IS ã, 3[-Na Xs19´ -M6 7 )* B,XY 8�{=K67(9X : M=NWc b5¦- ?( )

- C TXC(1 oU ¹x6 . M=NWcE

24 (241R (2= nª = .( @Wr( 8�- OU:(5X C )FG T67 9X : M=Na 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p o* I6 Y5; C

q³6 ? b5WG,XY ,Ò IS 9®k24 8<=:8R = .( ©,_ )* �°6 C ,6 K=:dÎ;C -M=N

;. 5Ê -M= Nv6 . 9X : ,»X 7 ( )FG B1( mB,JWr T

-C,-Kµ 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )

- C I= . ,= .,adi )FG IS -b( )* 56 7 receivables M=NWc L1 ,6 K=:dÎ

;C )Ú 8B,_ -M=N;. 5Ê -M=Nv6 . M=NWc B1( I= . ); O¦· M=NWc IS @Wr

-b( receivables )/ -b( o* payments 9* M=NÂ )´E M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS I= . q

- �;:( @Wr( B1( alarming situation )FG IS I= . receivables M=N>- ?

5WG ); O{_E Xs ( I= . ); OP]�Ë§ M=NWc IS 5{[= NU. ( q- �;:( ¡B5{= .B m9* ,Ò dh5= C-2- nS )/ B1( dPX ?

Xs ( `( 8<´B,8 . 9X : X¾-�¦X? M=NÁ_ )´ 5; C I= . M=N>

- ? 5WG ,;K{_ B1( I- . q Wr (5WG )FGE o- ¹,6 .2îh 9* )* `( 5* ,ÀQ= .R )

U C ,6Y B1( 9´( Xs ( )* `,X . -b( 5* )- O¬: R )* )¬OV )¢¬N¯. I- . b5WG )´ 56 7 Xs ( ,k circular debt )FG 5; C Xs ( T* fd² M=:9* E)´ `( ;<º1 Xs ( o* alarming situation )FG L1 LB,6 . )/ IÂ5Ê )8 O

-NÀê \-. 8�= K

3/8R5V ¥XY q WrB )FGE`( M=Na 3 B(-9´ I= . )FG IS mB,JWr 8�- Oy- ?B5´ o* �d²

)/ m896 : @=�®k ); C ( M=NWc IS b5¦- ?( )

- C 56 7 8R9´ M=Na 8�= .( ,= K* )FGE`( M=Na M=Na 9=: -B1 6�7,p )/ ;�7,-p1 b5WG,XY ,Ò IS o

- ¹,6 .2îh 9* )* `( 9X : q- � 3/1B M=NÂ(8R B1(

M=NJWr )- C ,À6 �Ë§ o* 3T

3Ê5* M=:9* IS b5¦- ?( )- C 8R9´ M=Na ©5= Oµ )* )¢¬N¯. mR 9*

= .( 1R )- O¬N>h ;. `( o* -M3 ¢= N-.96 7 5* LR,= .

-B )V )U O´ M=NWc B1( `( 5* @=�®k 9* )FG B M=NWc IS @Wr )

- C 8R9´ M=Na qU �-: 8�= .( o* )FGE `( ;<º1 Xs ( M=NÀQ= .R IS `(

;<º1 56 7 -b( )* )¢¬N¯. )P; ? L1 `( )- O¬N>h )* �°6 C (5WG M=Na 8B( )U O´ B1( L1 ©5= Oµ q³6 ?

xXY ,= K´ B1( `( ;<º1 -b( o* -M3 ¢= N-.96 7 b,W c1 M=N>

- ?9X : )FGà q§( )¬OV \-. 8�= K3/8R5V qó896 :

205

oU ¹5WG )FGE`( 9X : q³6 ? @Wr M=NWc,XY )´ IS 9= : -B1 6�7,p M=NJWr M=N

U.,;K6: IS L�-KU: ( b5¦- ?( )- C ,= K* It

U?D ¥JÔ ,= .,-K6: )FGE ¡241R ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ I= . )FG B1( M=Na 8�- Oy- ?B5´ )/

humble 3 B(-9´ b19* ,Ò IS o- ¹,6 .2îh 9* )* 56 7 8�{=K67(9X : -9®X K=NX. o

8 ¹B,X . o* 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ )- C )

U C ,ÇV 5; C @· -B( @· -b( 8�{=K67(9X : ,k 5; C M=NJWr 8s 8�= .9* M=:RE Xs ( `(

,k q³6 ? @Wr )/ )V ); O¬NÂ M=NWc IS ¡B,JWr 8�- Oy- ?B5´ )

- C ¶X g· ,= K* q Wr M=N>- ? B1( (B,_

¶X g· Xs ( )- C ,= K* )FG 56 7 = .( ©,_ M=Na ,= K

-: 8R9´ M=Na 8�= .( ,= K* )FGE 5; C o- ¹,6 .2îh 9*

)* Xs ( LB,6 .1R q- �X:( ¡dË=�j 5* 3T=CdÌ= CB M=:9* IS 56 7 Xf1( 58 C )FG L1 8�{=K67(9X : -9®X K=NX.

o8 ¹B,X . )* )

- C ,a -B M=Na B1(,= . ( 1 8�� 747 q³6 ? mB,JWr -9®X K=NX. o8 ¹B,X . )* )

- C ,a -B M=Na ,= . ( )FGE = .( ¶8 ? ( 5Ê 8s(1,Ç= Oj ,k )FG B1( = .( X¾

-?,X . 5Ê 8s(1,Ç= Oj ,k )FGE 5; C 24 @· )/ @· (B,JWr 8s 8�= .9* 5; C I- . ,= KV )

U C ,6YE ¡241R 3 B(-9´ I= . )FG IS M=NJWr LB,= K´ ©,_ 5WG )U O´ M=NWc �6 .,w 2= n

3_ q¨w 6�7,p )/ `( q6 Ky§( M=Naon the floor of the House interact )

; C 9* )U C 5WG as a colleague 5; C @Wr -b( )/

3 B(-9´ I= . ); C 9* M=NWc IS 6�67 Xs ( 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ M=Na )U C ( M=NWc 5; C (B-R m 8�-KP

8 ? M=NWcB B1( )- O

-N_ ,k LR,a LR,= .-B M=NÀ·Bà I= . ¡2= nª humble request )FGE

) ;�® -Y(�a( 6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ : Intruption I- . M=:9*E

�=K/ +x-w qÌ�Üj L, 3_ : @· )/ @· `( q6 Ky§( ,k ©57,a ( 8B5P; ? ( 8�-KP8 ? )FG B B1(

Xs ( I= . X¾-?,X . ©,_ ¥JQa M=:9* B1( @Wr ;<=:B5¦Ë6A )* l7 M=Na M= NWc B1( Xs ( 5*

8<=: 8�-K=Na xa )FG B1( `( 8<=: 8�-K=Na 5* (B-R m2= nÉR )/ M=NU.xXYà Xs ( o* B1( 8�- Oy=�VB,X .

o* ¡2; n>6? )* )¬OV )FGE

206

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ : �=K

-N 6Y 26 nS( -b,-Y E 6�7,p

6s,-K67 �= K-N 6Y 26 nS( : Ivp57 M=:9* q¨>X? I°µR (8dP· b5WG ;�3/(R96 : 5; C M=:9*E �@��6 C

�'( -M� yA�9~V( �@= ��7�9~V(E I= .9{3_ q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ 6�7,pE 9{ 3_ )FG IS = .( ©,_ )* �°6 C )P]�h

`,[7( (5WG IS M=Na q³6 ? `( 8�- Oy=�VB,X . ,k 26 nJh b5WGE ¶X g· Xs ( o* o- ¹,6 .2îh q³

; ? B1( ¶X g· o

8 ¹B,X . o* o- ¹,6 .2îh q³

; ?E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ : Xs ( )* q§189X : q³6 ?( q³6 ? `( 9X : 3 5-7 M=N>- ? M=NWcE

;s,6 . M=:9*E

6s,-K67 �= K-N 6Y 26 nS( : 24 ^va M=Na 6f ( ¥k ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ )* �°6 C 6�/ )/

m896 : -2ïUC(9* )/ B-9´ )FG B M=NWc 5; C L1 \-. 8�= K

3/8R5V ,k IvUK¢j )FGà L1 q6 t6? ,k IvUK¢j )FGE 24 `( M=Na LR56 75j ;�j5{Y 5* RB5j +(-9V( M=N>

- ? (2î³8 ? ); O{_à IÁ-.5= O* q-ß,a M=Na

T=N6. T=N;. ©,_ M=Na ;�j5{Y o* priority M=Na I= . M=N>

- ? ,À; ?E T67 o* I6 Y1 )/ 6f ( @Wr `( Ñ= O®»

;C )/ B-9´ )FG B M=NWcE24 @Wr q³6 ? ); O-: ,6Y M=NWc B1( M=NJWr q³6 ? ,;KX:

IS)FG 56 7 qË· )FG L1 = .( ©,_ ,= . 1R ©,_ M=Na ¡B5X C M=N>- ? 5WG Eq; �{_ -M{= KV 24

;�j5{Y o* `( = .( ©,_ o* o´R9*B,k )/ `( o* priority = KX7 9* ); O{_ M=NWcE@Wr I= . ¶{= .R ); O{_ M=NWc IS L1 q

- �;NS T=C2= n_ )FGEM=Na24 8�- Oy=�VB,X . M=Na I= . ;s,6 . ,;K¦· b5WG IS mB,JWr `,X . = .( 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p M=NWcà = .( 8�=O8N_ 28 n[-Na 6�7,p M=NWc

B1( = .( B-9U:(1 8�= .( 6�7,p M=NWcE -M{= KV b5- O=N;. 5* I= . æ±5j M=N>- ? ,;K®a B1( b5- O=N;. )*

`,X . ,-K; :( @U ?,8 . M=N>

- ? ,;.5WG IS \-. 8�-K=N8K/ q8 �=NJ· M= Na M=NU. (E 24 ¡B,JWr -b( )/ ¡RB�JWr

207

)FG B1( @Wr )- O¯: ( )®UK¢j ,k ¥Y ); OFG ,XY M=NWc B1( 9´( b5- O=N;. )/ M=N>- ? ¥À6 �

-N_ q; �{_ 5; C oU ¹5* q8 �X:8R 28 n[

-Na 9* )V -M{= KV (� -Y )* )¬OV I= . q6 t6? ,k IvUK¢j ¥Y 9* EmR 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! ^va M=Na B1( q³6 ? ;�¦6? )/ ¥U.,[j M=NWc -M{= KV 6f ( ¥k )®À�X? ¶X 7 b5- O=N>h )/ I= . ;s,6 . ¥XY q WrB )FG T67 fd² -B,6 K¦

3§ Ñ= C23 4 6�7,p )

- C +,-. )- OV �6 . ,k ,>· 5; C (B,_ -bR I= . 3�g6? o

; ¹5WG )FG B1( I= . 3�g6? o; ¹5WG )FG IS `( ,k +,-. ,= K* ,À·B )

U C ,6Y B1( b5´5V 5* B1( q³6 ? 3B5= OÆ

-O* ,= K* ,=K´E 24 M=NJWr `,[7( )FG B1( 56 7 ;sx»3¢j M=NWc B1( M=NJWr ;�j5{Y o* ;sx»3¢j ,k q³6 ? `,[7( )FGE -M{= KV q-ß,a M=Na @Wr I= . ); O

-N_ )U C (

M=NWc IS @8 �¢/ M=Na T=N

U.,6 . B(-2W c 8s(1,Ç= Oj o* 3TUC,6 t-�´ )FGà -M{=KV -M

3 ¢X C9* o* ;�j5{Y o* I6 Y1 )/ ,= . q¨ÀX �X? ;�j5{Y 9X : I= . ¸5V ;s,a(-9V( ,ÇV )FG B )P

; ? IS -b( o* I6 Y1 )/ @8 �¢/

¡B5X C fd² )/ q6 t6? 5*produce M=N>- ? 9* ,;K{_E 24 @Wr 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p B1( ;�j5{Y )/ I= . ©(5Ê ,-KPX A5X C ); OFG ,XY M=NWc IS 9´( LB,6 . B(-2W c o* capacity )FG 5; C dPX ? 6f ( ¥k @Wr T67 Ñ= O®»

;C )/ B-9´ )FG B M=NWc `( o* ;s,W c56 71 ,= K* M=NWcE 24 = .( �d² 5; C q6 t6? o* \-. 8�= K

3/8R5V mB,_ ^va M=Na )FGE -M{= KV 24 )* oX¹ )* )* = .,À; ?,_

¡ -B,= K;Na( â5®_ ,= K* ,;.,6Y )FGE mB,JWr ¶8 ?,_ �Õ=Oµ B 8�= Kµ 8R5VB11( M=NWcàmB,JWr `,X tX? �Õ=Oµ

dhB,ç¢-C(98 : -B5VB11( M=NWcàmB,JWr 8R9´ 8R5VB11( M=NWcà ¡B,JWr -M

3 ¢= NJ�-C(98 : -M

U :D b1-9= :9Ä-.( )* )- C ,a -B o* )FGE 24 @Wr 9X : +(-9V( ,= .,ÇV ,;.,6Y )FG IS @Wr )* oX¹ )* )V (1 B5X 7 M=NWcà )* oX¹ )* )V (1 q 6 t6? ¡B5X 7 )

; C 9* M=NWcE 24 9´( oU ¹5* @=?( oX¹ m( 6�7,p q�*

)* `,X . q�* 5* )- C (8dPX A )U O´ )P

; ? 5; C I= . 8�=O8N_ 28 n[-Na 6�7,p B,6 . B,6 . T=C9X :

T-CdÌ-C,k )

; C 9* M=NWcE 24 = .( ©,_ 5WG ,= K´ )FG M=Na = .( -MU :D -M= Na )/ )V 9*

q6 t6? )* 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )/à 8�=O8N_ 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p )/à 5{[= NX. )* Ñ= OX7 )/à ( 8�X .(1 )* -M=Na2U n=KX7 )/ = .( = .( m�-K6: )/ `R `R I°µR xa 24Eb5WG M=Na R5-7 B5X 7 M=N>- ? 5WGàm2= nª ,= .9= :( M=Na ¡B5X 7 M=N>

- ? E)FG M=Na24 )- C I= . 6¾

-�®= KX7 ,À; ?,= .R ( 8�X .(1 `U1,W c

208

M=Na \-. 8�-K=N8K/ q8 �=NJ· o* \-K8N=Kj M=Na IS Xs ( 56 7 B,J3§1R(�w( )

; C ,;K6: M=NWc B1( Xs ( 56 7 ); O¦· M=NWcàM=Na mB,_ )* oX¹ )* o* Iª-R ¡B(R M=N>

- ? ,;K=NÂ -M{= KV 24 M=Na )- O¯: ( -M6 g=?B o* M=Na ¶X 7 Districts o* Iª-R ¡B(R ,;K=NÂ b5WGà 9´( I= .figures 56 7 Xs ( ,;K6: )FG B M=NWc 9´( I= . ¾ =�g

ß )FG 5; C M=Na `( -b(5= C( 5* B1( Xs ( 6�/ 5* L(5´ ,;.9* b5WG IS M=Na resign 9* b1R ,Ò I- .B1 8�=O8N_ 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p resign 9* M=:R )´E 24 )P]�h 5{[= NX. Ñ= OX7 )* `,X . ,6 t=�P6 ? ,;.,6Y )FG B1( 6�67 M=Na b,W c1 ,;.,6Y b5WG 5; C )P]�h ,= .,;K6: ,;.,6Y )FG IS I= . ¡B5X 7 o* I6 Y1 )/ M=N>

- ? )FG I= . -MU :D -24D `( )¬OV )FG

IS (B,JWr @8 �¢/ ,-.(9X : )FGà mB,JWr @

8 �¢/ o* capacity M=N>- ? )FG IS L1 @

8 �¢/ 5* xXY ){_E 24 M=NJWr dhB,ç¢

-C(98 : M=N>- ? ); O®aà 24 M=Na )

- C 5; C 8sB,8K/ M=N>- ? ,= K* B1( Xs (

)- C -M

8 N6. ,6 .R ,= .R E)FG ¶X g· 5; C ;�3/(R96 : àM=:9* 1R -M=N;. 8�- Oj B1( ;�3/(R96 : EM=:9*

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_ : Xs ( 8�6 g6? 9X : M=N>

- ? 8<* -M3/5j 9X : ©56 C )FG B M=NWcE

-2= nvX . = .( 8�- Oj M=Na 8�-KU :(1 Xs( EM=:9*

6s,-K67 �= K-N 6Y 26 nS( :24 1R -M=N

;. 8�- Ojà 24 mB,JWr ¶; ?,_ I= . @¨ØÈ b5= O* ,;.5WG

)FGà @Wr -b1,6 . )¢¬N¯. qi 8<- :5= C q 6 t6? (�= KX: )

; C 9* M=NWcE 24 9´( 6s,6 t-�X: M=Na T=N6.5X 7

)¯C 1B M=Na q; �-N6. )FG 5; C (2= nª ,= K* B5Ü± )FG IS )* oX¹ )* )* b5´5V 5* LB,À8 ?(

)¯C 1B 9X : q6 t6? o; ¹,6Y E)FG 24 Xs ( ¥=K

;: T67 8<=:B 9X : ); O¯g=�6: M=NWc )P]�h )* oX¹ )* M=Na ¶X 7 )¯C 1B LR,= .

-B M=Na ,;K®a )FG IÁ-.5= O* M=Na transportation ,k (R( b5WG,;.9*àq-ß,a M=Na I= . M=N>

- ? E,À; ? M=Na transportation ,k ¶X 7 )¯C 1B LR,= .-B (R(

,;.9* b5WG B1( M=Na q- �X:( q6 t6? = .( )¯C 1B T=N

;. )¢¬N¯. M=Na (�= KX: ,;.9* b5WG -M{= KV Xs ( )P]�h ,= K* incentive ); O¬: R M=NWc ë 24 m2= nª 2W c dPê M=Na 28 n=KV5Ä= .B ,;.5WG )FG @Wr

209

q6 t6? q³6 ? M=N>- ? x6Y ); O{_E mB,JWr feeder M=NWc 5; C @Wr 9X : 5; C ¥k5V ;�¦6? LR,= .

-B 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ )FGE 24 transmission line 6s,6 t-�X: M=Na ¥=.�6 K

;: o; ¹5WG )FG -M{=KV

KPK M=Na M=N>- ? o

; ¹5WGE 24 @Wr 6�67 PSDP M=Na ;s,6 . ); C 9* M=NWc 5; C M=NJWr

); O¦· M=NWc IS PSDP M=Na Xs ( )* )U OV @=?8R ,-K6: ); O¬: R M=NWc 5; C 24 KPK )V (1 5; C I3[= NJWr ); O]: 18R M=NWc -M{= KV q6 t6? 6s,6 t

-�X: 5* q; �®a )FGE 24 M=NJWr B(5= CR )/ b5= O* ,= .,ÇV ,W cB,6Y )FGE @Wr 6f ( q³6 ? q

- �X:( q6 t6? q- �X:( ;sB12- Í )/ LR,= .

-B (�= KX: ); C 9* M=NWc -M{= KV

¡B,JWr d² � \-. 8�= K3/8R5V 6s,6 t

-�X: )/ LR,= .-B )FGE 24 m2= nª )- O¯: ( 8<*28 n_8R M=Na

-M=N;. q6 t6? dPê M=NWcà @Wr q

- �X:( q6 t6? (�= KX: ); C 9* M=NWc -M{=KV 24 L2; n_ L2; n_ B1( LB,À8 ?(

LB,À8 ?( )8 O-NÀê \-. 8�= K

3/8R5V )FGE 24 I= . ,= K* @¨ØÈ )FGE M=NJWr B(5= CR )/ I- . ,= .,ÇV )

U C ,6Yà M=NJWr B56 O6gh I- . ,= K* )

U C ,6Yà I= . 5; C Xs ( M=N

;.dÌ-C ,É896 : )FG B M=NWcE (� -Y )U OV )* @Wr q³6 ?

6�gh -M²1 M=NWc Xs ( q³6 ? 6�gh -M²1 M=NWc 5; C Xs ( `( fd² o* q�= NÂ,X . b5= O* ); C ,-KX:(

M=NWcE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 �= K

-N 6Y 26 nS( : 24 = .( ©,_ �°6 C q³6 ? Xs ( M=NJWr 1R 8�- Oj )* )U OV ;�3/(R96 : M=N>

- ? ); O{_9*E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: dPX ? Xs ( 5* 9V5Ä= .B -M3 ¢= N_ M=Na LR,= .

-B @U ?,8 . M=:R )´E q6A

Iª2; nth @ =K6: -M=N-K¢7 I6 K7,pE

210

Iª2; nth @ =K6: -M=N-K¢7 : I= .9{

3_ 9{= KXN_ 6�7,pE ;�¦6? ,XY9X 7 ,À; ? IS 8R5V \-. 8�= K3/ @

; � -7 )U C ,6Y5WG o´à L1 L�w1 5; C (B5X C I- . ,»/5WG -M{= KV 6s( -b,-ÕjB ,k I-K=N>h ,W cB ( )FG B1( ¡2= nª ;�j5{Y )/ ;�/(5-7BR )FG IS L1 +(5} 5* ¶; ?,W c )* )PQ

-KX: 5; C b5´5V 5* )Ìg;? )*

9X :B5² (5P6 �6? M=:R IS,;. b5´5V ,k ¶X g· 5; C (B(-9´ )U C ,6Y5WGE ^va M=Na o

U ¹,-.(5; C )* -b(9g6?

o* ;�¦6? ¡896 : I6 Y1 ;�j5{Y o* b,= K¢= NÂ,X . M=NWcE IÁ-.5= O* = .( 5; C qQ-.( long term policy M=N>

- ? )FGE ¡241R mB(R( M=Na q- �;:( -M

3 ¢X C9* )FGà ¡2ï=N;. power

generation B1( oU ¹xX K/ M=Na b,= Kj,

-Y M=NWc B1( )Ä-K¦h æU C(B-R )/ o

U ¹,-.(5; C (�= KX: ,-.9* I= .

6�/ M=:-2= nX¤ ¥a 9* -b(9g6? (�= KX: q WrB9* M=NWc B1( 6<=:d-Ô (B,a ,W cB,6Y )FGE IÁ-.5= O* m896 : b5´5V )* `,X . 5; C -B28 n=.2- n6¤ àM=NWc 6�/ ¶X g· )FGE L1 5; C afford ); O¬NÂ9* M=NWc -M{= KV 6<=:d-Ô M=N>

- ? E); O{_9* ^va M=Na oU ¹,-.(5

; C )* 9U:, -Y-R o* oU ¹5* qË· M=N>

- ?E -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na (� -Y )

- C energy resources ;�¦6? (�= KX: )¬O* M=NWc ;�¦6? )¬C R M=NWc -M{= KV @Wr `( 5* ¡B(�-.,J= ?( )/ explore M=N>

- ? E); C 9*

= .( ¥

-K3¢= N-.28 n-.( m124 )* l6C,Þj )®Ò ( -M=N

;. b5V,_ M=Na -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na 9= : -B -M=Na -B )- O¬N¯. )* o

- ¹,X . )* 9U:, -Y-R @· )FG B5WG M=NWcà IÁv6 . @; � -7 M=N

U.,6Y5WG )É -M{= KV ;�j5{Y )

- C )- O¬N¯. )* o- ¹,X . )* ¥U.,[j 5* ¥Y )

- C 9* )* )U OV ¡B12- Í ;s,a(�£( 9X : oU ¹5* L�= K6g

-�/ 3T3Ê5* M=N>

- ? o*E x3Kj o- ¹,X . 5* Øä5Ægh )

- C 9* ,kà o- ¹,X . æ

U C,-p )- C 5WG )/

)- C ,X t6? )U OV )* B1( (2ï= N

;. o- ¹,X . 5* L�-K´ )

- C 5WG )/ )- C ,X t6? )U OV )*à `( )U OV )* = .(

L�w,£,6 . æj,6Y q�= NÂ,X . )² M=:9* IÁ-.5= O* I= . ;�¦6? ¡B12- Í -2= nX¤ )FGEdPX ? I= . `()¢¬NS o* 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ M=:9* )É +(5} 5* M=N>· )´ IS 6s( o- ¹,X . I- . 5= OX:à = .( `xÒ 5= OX:à

dPX ? ,ÉR ( `xÒ 5= OX:à dPX ? +(5} b,>· )U C ,6Y o´ L1 5; C )¢¬C 1 q Wr dh )

U C ,6Y oÉ b5y=?8R o* qh,Ç-O WG b1R,= K

-N6. 9X : -M3 ¢*28 n[

-NS EM=:9* IS,;. `( o* cost I- . )Ú 896 : B1( 56 7

211

mB,JWr RB�JWr ^Â,Jh M=NWc 56 7 M=NJWr )- O;: ( ÑU C,t;? ); O]g=�P6 ? M=NWcà L1 q

- �;:( @ºB M=NJWr o; ¹ ( )FGà L1 q6A9

-:( T¢UC(9* B1R )

- C 9* )U OV )* ;�j5{Y b5= O* M=N>- ? ©,Jå

;N_( Eo; ¹9*

©5*dP; ? M=Na oU ¹,-.(5

; C )* q; �y=�± 9U:, -Y-R M=NWcE `( 5* M=NJWr B1( L1 ;<º1 o* ;sB12- Í q³6 ? M=NWc `( 5* @Wr b5= O* ©,Jå

;N_( M=N>- ? )

; C 9*E dP; ? ©5* ×�-K/ ,k M=N>- ? -b,;K¢*,X .

,k q³6 ? I3 .,3.( )FGE T67 )/ `,X tX? B(-2W c 8s(1,Ç= Oj q6 t6? @Wr(di o* q; �{_,6Y )FGE B1( L1 ,= K-:R ,k ,8KPX A (896 : reservoir )FG ©5* ,k B1( M=NJWr )¬OFG ,XY IS @Wr `( 9X : ;�¦6? I6 Y5; C M=:R B1( `( 9X : +,k M=:9*E B1( 9´( M=NJWr -b12= n6. ^va )/ q³6 ? R(�a( o*

;sB12- Í )FG 5; C @Wr -b( )* )U OV law and order situation ,k ©,= K-7

M=NÀ·B B1( -b( 5* M=NU.x6 . B1( `( 8�{=K67(9X : 9X : +,k M=:9* IÁ-.5= O* `( )/ ¡B,JWr

oU ¹,-.(5

; C ;�¦6? 2; n>6? q; �{_5WG )FG B1( T67 6s( -�w )/ ,= K-:R B-9´ q WrB )FG L1 6s( -�w )/

¡B,JWr ;�X g6? q; �{_5WG )FGE I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: 6s56 Ogh @z,w 6�7,pE

6s,-K67 6s56 Ogh @z,w : I= .9{

3_ 24 Xs ( )- C æ±5j ,= .RE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ Xs ( 5*

I;KX: )FG IS ¡B5X C ,= K-:R M=Na 6s( ¡9

-7 ( \-K67 o- ¹,X . 9X : )FG 5; C ¡2= nª Xs ( )/ 3 B(-9´

)FG IS qXA(9* M=Na 56 7 qU �-: -M

U :D oV(8R q WrB,6Y )FG K4 )* +,-. 9X : 5; C (B(� -Y `( M=Na 8<

- :1( )* I-Kj M=Na L9= : -Bà q- �Ó= C T=N6. 8B19* )¯C 1B )P· B )U O´ M=NWcE M=Na b5WG,;KP6 �Ë§

IS `( 5* �2Í ducking )* )U OV ©,Jå;N_( ,= K* )

U C ,6Y ,Ò `( )* �°6 C dPX ? (ñ'q Wr ØÛµ,Y )FGE ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ I= . )FG IS ×�-K/ M=Na ,= K* mB5X C ^va M=Na o

- ¹,X . o* ;�®£ )FGE ( -�>z ×�-K/ M=Na reservoirs )

U C ,-K6: M=NU.,6Y IS,;. o

- ¹,X . 6�67 L2= n-¤-R

,Ò5WG 5; C `( )/ o- ¹,X . )* mB,6 . M=Na ;sx»3¢j M=Na qË· )

U C ( o´E B1( ¡2= nª Xs (

212

)/ I= . q³6 ? ã,6 t;�V( )FG IS I= . 56 7 9{-K=N

8. ,= Kµ,a B1( hydrants 5* ¡B5µ B5² 9X : @; � -7

,= K* )U C ,6Y IS,;. `( )/ o

- ¹,X . )* ¥U.,[j )- OÚ 896 : o* )U C ,6 t6? @· b5WGE ¡2= nª Xs ( )/

I= . q³6 ? 3 B(-9´ )FG IS q¨ÀX �X? ;�j5{Y M=Na 56 7 @=?( 5= O* @=?( )* ¸5V b,>=? mB,JWr m�-KU:,J

-? )P; ?à mB,JWr )Î®Y )/ q³6 ?à b5¦- ?( )

- C o- ¹,X . )* m896 : 8�=O{6Y(9X : 56 7 ,6 K=:dÎ

;C 98 8B19* ,= . = .( 6sB( ,k ,À; ? L1 8�{=K67(9X : oX¹ @=?( 6�7,p )/ approve ,= .(9* ,À; ?E ¡2= nª 3 B(-9´ )FG IS `( 9X : d Ø�

-C o- ¹,3. o* )

U C ,6Y B1( `( 8�-Kµ 5* qi B5ÆV( -2= nv= .B ,= K* )

U C ,6Y IS,;. mB,JWr )Î®Y M=Na o- ¹,X . )* ;sxa,°j ;�/BR M=NÁ_5WGE

b,>6A ;. 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ ,k l®°;C )FG mB5X C ^va M=Na \-. 8�= K

3/5V M=Na qË· o* )U C ,6 t6? I¼,-p( (5WGE ¡2= nª I= . q³6 ? 3 B(-9´ )FG IS ,[= N 6Y IS �U.,£ = .9g

;? �,ÞV( -M=N[7 oU ¹,À6 ? )

- C )®>¯? q³6 ? ,>· B1( 6s( q³6 ? ,>· IS 9V5Ê q6A9-:( B1( 8�-.1 q6A9

-:( 9X : ¡ 8�[6 N_ ¡R )U C ,6Y B1( `( 9X : LR,= .

-B I6 Y5; C ¡R )

U C ,6Y IS,;. q 6 t6? o* ;sx»3¢j M=Na qË· æ±(1 5WG B1( T67 fd² )Î¬C d² )/ K Electric )

- C +(5} 9X : �U.( -B ¥6. ,k ¶6 756 C D(8R )FGà average bill )* ,-. + 9X : `( ¡B5µ B5² 9X : -M

3 ¢{= .( ,= KV )U C ,6YE 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p L1 5; C +(5} B5X 7 d Ø�

-C o; ¹ ( )FG -M{= KV M=Na I= . bU1,;K6: IS 56 7 6<=:d-Ô ¸5Và -M6 7 )* dPê

,k ,>z5X 7 ,-.x6Y ¥»3¢j )FG -b( )* b1dPê )* ¥6. 6�67 T=N6. B(-2W c B1( LB�-KX: B(-2W c

)¯C 1B )Ä-. 5WG 5; C `( ¡B5X 7 ,k Iª-R B(R -b5* ,Ò5WGE `( ¡B5X 7 ,k L(96 :24 -b5* )FG )P]�h )

U C ,6Y,;K6:E `( )U OV +(5} 5* B5X 7 )- O¦· )V (1 )®>¯? q- �X:( 5

- C,6 K=:9´ M=Na M=NÁ-.,À6 A 56 7B1(

¸5V `( -b(5= C( M=Na )P8 �¬N6. M=NWc 56 7 q; �j5{Y ©5= OV 9X : ¸5V M=NWc -b( 5* I- .,= Kj ¡1B B,= K

;N -Y( ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XY IS qí=? +(5} )FG 56 7 -b( 5* b5

- C(5= C( M=Na o; ¹,X t-�¦X? )FG B1( qí=? +(5} )FG

56 7 -b( 5* -M=Na -B 9X : )U C (9´ o´E -M{= KV ¡2= nª Xs ( )/ ;�/(5-7BR )FG B1( `( -b(5= C(

)/ ;�/(5-7BR )FG IS ×�-K/ 56 7 2; n_ )/ 2; nÀX �X? �Õ=Oµ 5= O-:5= CB )- O¬: R D(1 )FG B1( 6�67

213

Xs ( qXA(9* 5* -b,;K¢*,X . ,k q3§,°j 6�7 ); O¦· M=NWc 5; C ¡2= nª Xs ( )/ 3 B(-9´ )FG IS

b,W c1 )* ;sxa,°j 9X : q³6 ? d Ø�-C o

- ¹,3. o* )U C ,6Y B1( M=Na o

8 ¹5PX A q§ ;s,6 . I>· 9* q- �X:(

5Ä;KÆ´ ,k +,;K;N -Y( b19* ,Ò IS b,>6A 9X : ;�¦6? ¡B,_ b,= Kj19gh M=NWcà o- ¹,X . q6 t6? o*

\-. 8�= K3/8R5V o*à 5; C M=Na 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p )/ 3 B(-9´ b19* ,Ò IS +(5} )* mB,6 . M=Na I= . slang language ©,Jå

;N_( I- . M=:9* ¡B5X 7 ,kE `( )/ ;sxa,°j M=NÉ896 : )´E M=Na -b( )U OV )* = .( då 3/ b5¦· ,ÒE IS

@Wr )

- C )P· B M=N>- ? M=NWc )¯�· m8dPê o

- ¹,X . M=Na m( �U.,£ ,Ò5WG (2= n;. LB, 3_( B1( R5* M=:89X : )´ o

- ¹,X . M=Na

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E 2= nª B5- Oj q¨w B5X OV,; . 6�7,pE

Mir Munawar Ali Talpur: Mr. Speaker thank you

very much for giving me some time to speak on this Cut Motion which is very important relating to energy crisis in our country and water. 24 M=Na = .( då 3/ ,;KÚ89X : b5WGE

o- ¹,X . 6s ( o* ;s,6 . )

; C 9* 5WG ©R )- C x6Y o* ;s,6 . )

; C 9* 5WG @Wr )

- C ¶X 7 -bR )/ I-Kj M=N>- ? ,= .5ÚR Xs ( )

- C ,>- ? o* ;s,6 . ); C 9* 5WG

Sir, Pakistan is very poor country of the world. But Sir

Pakistan is very rich in population. (896 : `5¢µ( (5WG 24 ,-K¦· 5; C M=N>- ?

214

)¬OFG ,XY 56 7 ¶X g· 5®Ò 8<6: )- C ,= K* 6f ( `( 5* 56 7 `( o* (-24 q¨a )FG 24

b,>=? 9X : IvUK¢j 5; C o- ¹,X . ,k ¥XY ,W cB )FG

2= nª B5- Oj q¨w B5X OV,8 . : (896 : `5¢µ( (5WG 24 ,-K¦· 5; C M=N>

- ? )¬OFG ,XY 56 7 ¶X g· 5®Ò 8<6: )

- C ,= K* 6f ( `( 5* 56 7 `( o* (-24 q¨a )FG 24 b,>=? 9X : IvUK¢j 5; C o- ¹,X . ,k ¥XY ,W cB )FG B1( q6 t6? ,k ¥XY ,W cB )FG ;�¦6? m896 : -b(9g6? M=NWc b,>=? 24

last year o* ADP M=Na )¢¬N¯. )P· B )U O´ )P; ? 58 billion `( 5* @·

9* )* 42 billion 9* ,= .R ,= K´ )FG IÁ6K67 ;�j5{Y ;<º1 m896 :)- C m896 : -bxw(

)¬O* M=NWc �ü page o* 9=:dÎ;C M=Na m896 : m896 : @=?8R )

- C ,-K6: o* ;s,6 . o* qU �´ )FG m896 : m896 : reservoirs )

- C ,-K6: o* ;s,6 . o* qU �´ )FG ¡896 : ¡896 : ©,-K=NS )

- C ,-K6: o* ;s,6 . o* qU �´ )FG 24E ¡896 : q³X A( ;s,6 . 24)FG M=Na 24 6f ( = .( article ×89X : ,W cB ,À; ? `( M=Na (5WG,ÀQÂ ,À; ? I= . ,= .

8�-.( might turn our Azad Kashmir into desert which is very alarming Sir.

Xs ( o* 56 7 q³6 ? basin treaties oU ¹5WG M=NWc before and after partition. Indus Basin Treaties o

U ¹5WG M=NWc Xs ( )* 56 7 q³6 ? M=NWc L1 ,= .

8�-.( o* �d² M=NWc not in Pakistan `( I6 Y1 )/ Xs ( )- C �

rivers 56 7 M=NWc treaty 9* )* ( Xs )- C mR q³6 ? )U O¬: R )P

; ? ,= .8�-.( 5*

so you have Sir cut down on your ADP B1( I= . 24 M=Na Xs ( 5* bU1,;K6: IS ×�-K/ )* B�-.( (B,JWr 26 nJh ,_B( M=Na 26 nJh M=N>

- ? )FG ¡896 : `5¢µ( o* ;s,6 . )FG ×�-K/ M=Na 24 internationally )

U C ,= .BR ×�-K/ 56 7 )FG L1 ,;.5Ê )FG Arabian Sea )* B�-.( B1( internationally )

U C ,= .BR ×�-K/ )* 9X :1( 6�/ )/ LR,= .

-B right I6 .5¿ ×�-K/ ,k )FGE M=N>- ? IS q�* B1( )]C 5¿

215

,kE -M{= KV )U C ,= .BR ×�-K/ mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . 5* o

- ¹,X . )FG ,;K=:R 24 mB,JWr b,W c 6�/ )/ (896 : problem )FG IJ

3�X 7 @¨>6A link q; �¦6? )FG q³6 ?( I>6? q WrB )FG 6�67 IS mB,JWr b,W c ;�¦6? ¡896 : shortage )FG o

- ¹,X . o* ¥=.9X :( qU �j )/ )V 9* B,JWr m 8<*28 n_8R dËÔ 8s5* B5X C2= nª é,-Y -M=:�6 . 8<*28 n_8R B1( q³6 ? ;�¦6? B,_ m IÀ8 �P

8 ? 8<*8248R L2= n-ð1 56 7 ¡98:5* 6f(2= n6. 9X : situation M=NWc b,W c1 o

- ¹,X .9X : o* �= .� 3_ ;�®£ )FG )®À�X? b5- O=N>h )/ B1( ;�j5{Y q³6 ?( ;. `( IX . ¶X g· M=N>

- ? q WrB9* )FG )P]�h (896 : `5¢µ( (5WG 24 -b,£, -Y q§,6 K} 6�7,p )

- C b,>=? 9X : q- �X:(

statement ¡R q³6 ?( L1 M=N>- ? )P

8 �¬N6. )U C 5WG -b( ,k @=�V128 n=KX: ,k xXY ,= K´

;<º1 L1 )®Y )U O´ M=NWc -M{= KV 6�67 b5¦- ?( )- C ,>· )FG IS m2= nª -b,k ; ?^À

)U O´ M=NWc ©5*dP; ? o* ;s,6 . -M/ -M/ 9*E 24 ©5*dP; ? mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . ,k L1 )FG dP; ? ©5* 56 7 )FG it is going to generate lot of electricity B1( I= . -b,;K¢*,X . mB5X C ,k I= .,a24 )FG Xs ( )* -b,k \À; ? )U O´ M=NWc Xs ( 9*B,X .dP

; ? )®¯Y M=NU.,6Y Xs ( ,6Y 9* M=NÀQ= .R b,W c1 9X : Xs ( M=NÀQ= .R IS - O

;NS) +,k 5WG ( )FG ,-K;NS infrastructures )- O]: M=NWc 8R1B )- O]: M=NWc ); N_ (B )- O]: M=NWc and our

members have requested today that they need 20 billion for that project. But if you cannot give 20 billion in these circumstances which Shah Sahib has just mentioned

circular 56 7 q³6 ? Xs ( ,k deficit )FG 5; C at least Sir be kind Prime Minister of Pakistan 6�7,p 56 7 `( ;<º1 2W c,6 . ^va M=Na M=NWc

B58 C 9* )FG B M=NWc and at least should give 5 billion for transmission lines from Matyarit to Thar. Sir we are having shortages in our canal Nawab Yusuf Talpur

216

Sahib has just mentioned, our honourable members here. I= . 13 to 18 percent )FG 24 canals )* B�-.( canals

)* B�-.( 24 I= . q³6 ? ¡896 : alarming situation )FG ×�-K/ )* B�-.( 24E24 M=Na mB,JWr 56 7 ;�/1R mB,JWr -b,;K¢X 75®6 . 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p )P8 �¬N6. )

U C 5WG M=NWc )P¯A (m896 : M=NWc he is very nice person. B1( I= . I3[= NJWr +(-9V( )

; C ,ÇV M=NWc IS MNAs o* I6 Y1 )/ @=?( oX¹ -9= :( o* I6 Y1 )/ ×�-K/ M=Na ¸5V ¥6. M=N>- ? mR )FG B M=NWc I think he should correct his policy B1( 56 7

q³6 ? leakages L2= n-ð1 M=NWc transmissions lines )* B�-.( ( 8�X .(1 )*

B�-.( M=NWc he is young, he should work on that and try to ¥6. L2= n

-ð1 56 7 M=NWc 28 n=Kj )¢¬N]Y T=N� 56 7 )FG 24 T=N� M=Na q- �;:( ;<=:,» 3/

M=N>- ? )FG -b,;K¢*,X . M=Naà T=N� )* 28 n=Kj -B 56 7 M=NWc -b( M=Na q

- �;:( LR,= .-B ;<=:,» 3/

M=N>- ? )FG ( 8�X .(1 mB,JWr q¨w2= n

3_ 6�7,p -M{= KV ( 8�X .(1 o* ;sB12- Í ;s,= .,» 3/ M=NWc Xs ( ( -b 5* ¥6. L2= n

-ð1 ;�/BR M=NU.(9* you have got, every

department has got people, we should make our department work. )- O

;N]Y q³6 ? departments M=NWc -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na 24 )¬OFG ,XY L1 irrigation 5WG )¬OFG ,XY L1 agriculture )¬OFG ,XY5WG L1 o

U ¹5* q³6 ? department 5WG and we make sure that people )- O

;N]Y q³6 ? M=NWc 24 -b( )* 56 7 linemen M=NWc supervisors M=NWc L1 6�/ 24 +,k M=:9* B1( 6<=:d-Ô b5´5V )* 9X :1( 24 (� -Y (B 6<=:d-Ô b5´5V b5- O=NÁ[j )* 9X :1( 56 7 ¥6. )FG q Wr1 ,-. ( )¬OFG ,XY I- . IS = .( )PQ

-KX: B1( = .( 6�®6 . )FG 56 7 IS ýü B(-2W c ,= . �ü )¯C 1BB(-2W c ,-. ( )¬OFG ,XYE5; C 24 I= . ¡B,_ M=N

;.,6 . M=NWc )- O¦· 5* 5; C 24 ;�¦6? ¶X g· )FG -M{= KV time limited )FG and we are supposed to talk only

217

on this Cut Motion 5; C M=Na q§( )* 9X :1( )- O¯: ( Xs ( 5* b5WG,;KP·B RBOD is very important project in Sindh Sir. `( )* 9X :1(

q³6 ? oU ¹5* +,k M=N>

- ? ,W cB5WG (5WG 28 n[-Na 6�7,p L1 dPX ? �-K6: ,= K´5WG B1( Xs ( o

- ¹,6 .2îh 9* )* RBOD 5* M=NÀQ= .R IS ,-K;NS 5WG ( ,-K;NS -b,;K¢*,X . ,k I[= NX. Xf9

-7 (5WG )FG ¡2W c, ØÈ ;s,6 . )FG b,W c1 q³6 ? 1 L I[= NX. q³6 ? 8�ÂB1 ^-K6: B1( o

U ¹ ( @=?( Ñ= C( loan ,k ,Ò5WGE 5; C ¥k b,>=? Islamic banks loans ,k I= . ;s,6 . o

U ¹5WG )FG )- O¯: ( T-C,-Kµ 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p m896 : o; ¹,6 .-�6Y q³6 ? )U O´ 5WG b,W c1 mB,JWr = .( ;�/1R -b (dº)

- C â,X . o* q¨>X? ;sB5Ê qó89X : B1( `( ,k (B5X C IJ6 A9

;: q³6 ? (89X : IS (R5Ê ,-K;NS 56 7 6s(9-7

-2= nX¤ )FG (R5Ê o* ;�- OÓV 56 7 )FG -M{= KV M=NJWr (896 : `5¢µ( )FG IS @Wr 0123 4 )/ q Wr I= .IMF B1( world bank M=Na T

-NÀX ? )U O´ B1( `( ,k B5Ü± B,JWr ( M=N>- ? )FG q�* q³6 ? democratic Government ,k M=N>

- ? )FG `( )- C ,a -B

M=Na ¥3_B,a bU1D ,k B5Ü± )FG IS -M6 7 b5´5V )

- C I= . conditional ties -b,a M=NÂ I= .B1( (R5Ê )* loan 6�67 )/ -b,;K¢*,X . ,-K6: )FG -b( b5´5V )

- Cthey started taking from that time. thank you very much.

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_ q6AE Iª2; nth I[= Nç-C ;<=:,-K} (ñ'I6 K7,p

Iª2; nth I[= Nç

-C ;<=:,-K} (ñ' 8K-7 : �@��6 C �'( -M� yA�9~V( �@= ��7�9~V(E )FG 9{ 3_ )- OV 56 C ,k æ±5j xa ¡896 : 9= :R )/ B, ØÞ;O

-:( 9* q WrB q³; ? q6AE M=Na q6A water accord

1991 9X :1()* M=Na ;s,6 . b19* o´ @Wr -b,;K¢-C,-°µ( )* bU1,= .BR )* @=?8R o* ;s,6 .

); C 9* M=NWc @Wr ,= .

8�-.( o* -dË=?8R o* ;s,6 . ); C 9* M=NWc -M{= KV 56 7 mB,JWr ^va )* B�-.(

= .( problem )FG B1( `( )* 9X :1( ¡B,JWr ;�j5{Y �= ., 3_ R =KÚ -b, M=N>- ? mR

218

q WrB T67 )* 9X :1( 1R I°µR drift ,»X 7 ( )FG B1( L1 )FG q6A water accord (B,JWr 56 7 Xs ( 5* I;KX: )FG ý� �Õ=Oµ (B,JWr GDP 56 7 )FG L1 agriculture ,k )FG B1( �ü �Õ=Oµ ¡B,JWr population b5; C,>=?R M=Na q; � WGB )FG B1( L1

B,»;N 3_,k M=NWc `( ;<º1 mB,JWr B,»;N 3_,k b1 5* I- . o- ¹,X . ¾ =�g

ß ¥a ,W cB )FG I- . -b( )* `,X . q6 t6? )FG IS L1 motors xXY M=NÁ_E 5; C B,»;N 3_,k ;�¦6? mB,_ 56 7

)8 C 5PX A B,»;N 3_,k M=NWc L1 8B5PX A 8B5PX A )* 2î3§ o* �d² b5¦- ?( )

- C -fB ,= .R9* )FG `( )* )U OV q6A M=Na Xs ( )/ ;�/(5-7BR b19* o´ IS 2010M=Na 56 7 m89ÄÀ6 A

)U C 5WG 1R b56 C5¿ )* X¾ =�6: M=NaE )¢¬C ( ;sxa,°j 5* ¥Y ,= K* )

U C ,6Y ¡�v6Y )/ �v6Y B1( `( )* L1xw 56 7 M=Na I= . b5¦· ,Ò IS q§( drift o* I6 Y1 )/ 56 7 M=NJWr

-b,ÕÖ-C 5WG ,W cB )FG 5; C L1 I= . )FG IS @Wr bU1,= .BR IX .reservoirs M=N>

- ? ,-K6: ,X . )FG B M=NWc river waters )* 9X :1( B1( I- . @Wr hydro power projects ,-K6: ,X . )FG B M=NWcE I= . b5

- C1R ¥U.,[j ,k = .( ;�¦6? (896 : (B,JWr ¥Y ,;K{_5WG )FG 9´( @Wr CCI )* 56 7 water accord )FG 1991 ,k `( )* 9X :1( ¡B5X C fd² ¥JÔ �a (BR M=NÂ9* ;�¦6?5; C (896 : IvUK¢j o

- ¹1B�-.( ^va ,k = .( ¥Y )U C ,6Y5WG ,Ò

¡241R ;s,6 . ¡B,JWr o; ¹,6Y ( )FG transmission B1( 56 7 wastage of

electricity )FG `( M=Na 56 7 (B,JWr transmission ,k 56 7 distribution losses )FG `( o* ;�¦6? ¡896 : I6 Y1 = .( )FG -.,Å± M=:B,;. B1( ¡241R ¡B,JWr56 7 I= . )FG transformers 56 7 M=NWc 6�67 I= . ;�jdh )

- C 5WG ; C ,6Y) M=NWc

5; C -b( )* 9X :1( Å±,-. copper ,;.5WG )FG T67 o* I6 Y1 )/ L1 B,6 . B,6 . 6s(9-7

); C 5WG M=NWc L1 B,6 . B,6 . repair )* )U OV )

; C ( M=NWc B1( +(5} 5* ;�¦6? Ñ= O®»;C

o; ¹5WG )FG 5; C `( )* 9X :1( 9´( 28 n[

-Na ¡ look in M=:9* IS 56 7 purchasing 5WG q WrB )FG -b( o* `( M=Na electricity companies

219

M=Na L1 ,=K* material 56 7 )FG quality ,k ©,Jå;N_( q WrB9* )FG ,= . M=N>

- ?E `( )* �°6 C (2= nª (2ï= N

;. 8�- OU:(5X C 56 7 )FG L1 )FG special incentives to domestic consumers )FGE ¡2= nª ;�/(5-7BR ;�j5{Y )/ 5WG o´ IS @Wr

)- C b5{va )/ )-¿ dº )U OV )

U C 5WG M=NWc `( )* 56 79X :1( R5Ê )FGE `( )* qÐ= KU:(R(

,k 56 7 ¶6 756 C )FG L1 Xs ( b56 O=:d- Ô IX . I- . M=NÂ(8R B1( `( o* proper distribution M=:9* B1( targeted subsidy to utility to poor 5* ,k1B

)U C ,6YE I= . = .( ;�/(5-7BR 5WG o´ ¡2= nª B1( `( )* �°6 C M=Na ;�/(5-7BR b19* o´ IS 56 7 ¡B,JWr -9= :28 n[

-Na M=NWc 9´( I= . )- O¯: ( m8B5P; ? ;s,6Y(9-7( @· 9* M=:R B1( I= .

;s,6Y(9-7( 56 7 M=NWc ( M=NJ§ ©,3Kj )* B5² 9X : M=Na -b( b1-2= nX¤ o* ;s,6 . b19* o´ IS T67 M=Na traveling )FG transportation )FG communication )FG gifts, entertainments M=NWc -b( b1-2= nX¤ 5* reduce ,= K* )

U C ,6Y B1( pro-furnace oil policy 5* 8B5PX A ,= .R )

U C ,6YE o- ¹( 8�� q³6 ?( = .( ,= K

-: 8�{= K67(9X : 8sB,8K/ 5WG ,W cB )FG B1( M=Na q³6 ? T

-Cdi ¥U. ( ,k )FGE `( M=Na5* advice b19* o´ IS `( -2= nvX . `( 5* Xs ( T=N� IX . ,= . ©5* IX . convert M=:9* IÁ-.5= O* I= . q³6 ?

;�¦6? expansive )FGE `( )* �°6 C (2= nª 56 7 ¡9-7 ( )FG L1 )FG IPPs )*

9X :1( M=Na ;s,6 . ,-.9* q; � WG,XY b5WGE 2= nª ¡ ;�j5{Y )/ ;�/(5-7BR )FG IS -2= nvX . Xs ( ¸5V `( )* 9X :1( 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ 8<V,ç= C8R I- . m9* sovereign guarantee 5* I= . = .( ;�¦6? m2= nª ©,= K

-7 M=Na unjust -2= nX¤ )FG B1( NTDC must pay up to date payments. Government has to pay 15% return to the total investment of IPPs annually under the

sovereign guarantees. B1,X . -B245= C8R19X : 56 7 M=NWcàb5´5V )* ¶; ?,_ 56 7 -b( ,k ,À; ?(5WG L�W c,°j 9´( `( )* l6C,Þj I= . M=NvXY 5; C ¡B,JWr 8<=:5= OU :(9X : b,= K

-NXKy· 56 7 M=NWc I= .

220

)- O¯: ( +,k ¾ =�gß fd² )/ 9* M=NÁ_ )´ B1( 56 7 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ ,k ,À; ? tariff, the government should rationalize the tariff determination and

cooperate with NEPRA. 9´( Xs ( (2X n=K-: )* ¶; ?,_ ,-KX:( +,k ¾ =�g

ß M=NU.xXY

B1( -b( )* )- O¦· 9X : Xs ( M=NvXY 5; C m2= nª ©,= K-7 M=Na ;�¦6? mB,_ ¥U.,[j Xs ( )*

q§( M=Na ¥Y 5WG M=NU.,6Y )´ B1( `( ;<º1 M=NÀQ= .R IS ¡B,JWr 56 7 circular debt

Xs ( I>· )FG B )P; ? IS @· 5WG qU �´ )FG `( ;<º1 -M=N

;. 5Ê -M=Nv6 . IX . qU � ( )FGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ;�¦6? I= .9{3_ q6AE

Iª2; nth I[= Nç

-C ;<=:,-K} '( -b,-Y 8K -7 : 5; C -b( b1-2= nX¤ 5* M=NÀQ= .R B1( = .( (2= nª ¡9

-7 ( LB53 ¢j I= . )FG q- �X:( ;�j5{Y )* )U OV B1( ¡B,_ b5; Oj5{Y )* )U OV IS 9´(

@Wr q- �X:( BR,XY 5* ¶{= .R )* U1,X . M=N

U.x= KPX ? )´ 5; C M=NJWr ©5{ 3[* M=N>- ? ,-.89{X . m89X : ,ÒE

I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ;�¦6? I= .9{3_ q6AE �J�h 9=: -�-. 5= OPÐ6 . 6�7,pE @=�79V(�6 K}

¥=K-71�-Kj 6�7,p Xs ( 5* 8�- OU:(5X C � ( B8RB ( M=:R )´ I= . @

; � -7 9* M=NÂ ){_ ( �°6 CEq6A @=�79V(�6 K} ¥=K

-71�-Kj 6�7,p ,k = KU:,a M=NÂ5P·E2ì;O

-gh 8�- OU:(5X C � ( B8RB ( M=:9*E

6s,-K67 @=�79V(�6 K} ¥=K-71�-Kj : �@��6 C �'( -M� yA�9~V( �@= ��7�9~V(E 6s,-K67 D(1! M=Na Xs ( ,k

B5{ 3[j b5WG IS Xs ( )- C )P]�h æ±5j ,= .RE T67 fd² I= . mB,JWr @Wr( )®Õ¬Oµ q§,= K/

q3§,°j `( )* )U OV +, ØÞ;O

-:( )FG 5; C `( M=Na 6�67 8�- OU:(5X C � ( B8RB ( ,= . ( )FG 5; C ,k1B M=N>

- ?E 6s,-K67 D(1! I= . �,Õ- C( M=N>

- ? )FGE ;sB5¿2î6? Xs ( o* ¡896 : o- ¹,6 .2îhE

221

6s,-K67 D(1! ©(5Ê I= . )FG IS mB,JWr +2; nth ;�/1R M=N>· )´ IS ,= K* ;s,6 . mB,JWr ;�/1R )

U C D M=NWcE -édÔ I= . )FG IS M=Na (896 : +(2; n¤( ,;.9* b5WG +,J;? q§,= K/ ¡B5¦Ë6A

b5´5V ,kEI= . )¢¬C ( ;sD,Y )U C ,-K6: )U O´ M=NWc IS )- O¯: ( l7 )* )U OVà M=Na 5; C l7 o*

;s,6 . q³6 ? )- O¯: ( `,X . ¶*B ,;K=NÂ b5WG IS M=NvXY )®]. ,½j M=Na (B,JWr ;�/1R -9= :-dÔ )FG -b,[

-C( )FG -M²1 B(R )FGE 5; C `( )U OV @Wr q- �X:( ;s,6 . 9* ); O¬NÂ M=NWcE B1( b,>=?

m8dP· 5WG 9* 23 nS( mB,JWr ;�/1R ); O¦· M=NWc IS L1 o- ¹,X . L1 ,= .BR B1( L1 2î- ? ©,-K=NS

56 7 )FG I= . ¡B,JWr )FGEB1( oU ¹5* `( 9X : 3�g6? I- . 9* Em q³6 ?( m2= nª ;�/1R

+2; nth B5X OV,; . 6�7,p )- C I= . LdÎµ ©,Jå

;N_( ,= K* IS à` 8�-.( -M=N_,6 .( I= . B,JWr ( )FGà b5= OÚ�-K/ ,k )FG B1( q�* ,k M=N>

- ? )FG IS oU ¹5* ;s,6 . m9*E 5; C 6s( )P]�h (B56 O6gh

I= . ,-K¦· (89X : IS ,[= C( M=N>- ? )FGEM=Na ,-K; :( I>· b1R IS b,>6A q³6 ? ;s,6 . 5WG @· -B( @·

mB,JWr Z5Ö7 o* I= . ;s,6 . M=:9*E @Wr b,>=? Xs ( )/ 8�¢=C5{= .B ); C 9* M=NWc IS

b,>=? q³6 ? ;s,6 . 5WGà M=Na ã, 3[-C( '( �oV,°;C B(�°6 C,; . b5WG in fact, IS b,>6A q³6 ?

-M=N_,6 .( ` 8�-.(,= . )FG b,W c1 +dº(dº )/ ); O®»-C )

U C 5WG qXA(9* ;.à 6�/ ¸5V ); O-: ,6Y M=NWc

IS `( M=Na 6�/ (896 :)/ IÕ7 -b5; O-gX? ,k )FGà 6�/ )/ (896 : IÕ7 1991,k 56 7 accord )FG 1991 M=Na +x_( R,6 . ( M=Na I= . accord Û-g;�/R (5WG B1( q§( -bR

@Wr 8�- Oy=�VB,X . )* 26 nJh )- O]: B1( `( -bR 8RB,k( 9X : IvÕ=Oµ (5WGE

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: ¥=K-71�-Kj 6�7,p L�-KU: ( L1 ©,= K

-7 M=NÀ·B )´E Xs ( ,k 8�- OU:(5X C ,= K ( )FGE Ñ= C23 ï

;C M=NÀ·B ¡896 : o- ¹,6 .2îhE= K

U:,a )U OV 5P· q6AE

6s,-K67 @=�79V(�6 K} ¥=K-71�-Kj: IÕ7 b5

- C5; O-gX? ,k q³6 ? )FG -M{= KV -b( 5* ,-K;NS T{=K8 :

)/ q³6 ? ,;K®a )FG L1 oU ¹5* 1R -M=N

;. B(-2W c )FGE

222

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A I= .9{3_E I= . dPX ? 9V5Ä= .B -M

3 ¢= N_ M=Na `( 9X : ;s,6 . M=:9* )´E Xs ( Ñ= C23 ï

;C M=NÀ·BE

6s,-K67 @=�79V(�6 K} ¥=K-71�-Kj: 5; C 6s,-K67 D(1! I= . -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C )FG IS Xs ( o- ¹,6 .2îh

M=:9*E

6s,-K67 q8 �X:8R 9{= KXN_: q6A ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E q6A �J�h 9= : -�-. 5= OPÐ6 . 6�7,pE

6s,-K67 �JA(9= : -�-. 5= OPÐ6 . : �@��6 C �'( -M� yA�9~V( �@=��7�9~V(E 28 n[j 9{= KXN_! 6f ( @Wr

Water and Power Cut Motions IX . ;s,6 . 9* )FG B M=NWcE b,>=? ,ÀQ= .R )U C ,6Y 5; C T=N

;KPX A �Õ=Oµ q6 t6? 56 7 (�= KX: o; ¹5WG )FG L1 T=N� 9X : o

; ¹5WG )FG B1( T=N;K6:

8�- N_9X : 56 7 o; ¹5WG )FG L1 ¥U. ( 9X : o

; ¹5WG )FG 6�67 IS 29% hydel o; ¹5WG B1()FG

-M=N;. 8�- N_9X : 2= nUK®k5= O

-: IX . o; ¹5WG )FG B1( 6�/ )/ LR,= .

-B q6 t6?56 7 (�X K=: o; ¹5WG )FG L1 -b(

b1-2= nX¤ )/ o; ¹5WG )FGà -b( mB,JWr sources )/ o

; ¹5WG )FG 56 7 6�/ )/ LR,= .-B

)Ä-K¦h M=NWc B1( Xs ( 5* I;KX: )FG IS )¢¬N]Y q³6 ?( ,À6 ? ,>· ,= K´ IS T=N� )* 56 7 9U:, -Y-R M=NWc @· )

; C 5WG B,6Y )FG M=NWc mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na B1( ¥U. ( 5; C Xs ( )/ I; KX: )FG IS -b,J§ ( )/ M=N

;.,6 . 9* ,W cB )FG B1( L1 ,-K;NS ,Ç-O¦h )FGE 6�67 IS M=NJWr B12- Í ;s q³; ?

IS @Wr hydel IX . B1( `( )* L1xw @Wr 2U n=K®k5= O-: IX . `( 5* M=:9* 56 7 -M=N

;. 8�- N_9X : )FGE M=NJWr @· )/ @· 2U n=K®k5= O

-: IX . LR,= .-B )/ LR,= .

-B ,-.,6Y )U OFG ,XY B1( hydel IX . ,-.,6Y )U OFG ,XYE

`( )* L1xw 28 n[j 9{= KXN_! 1993 B1( 1996 )* )- C ,a -B M=Na IPPs

)/ 56 7 )U C 5WG Iª2; nth 2= n

ØÞ-O=N6. 58 OP6 ? I6 K7,p )- C -b( )/ m�Wc,°j )U O* B1( `(

223

8�- Oy- ?B5´ M=Na IPPs 5; C `( )

- C ,a -B M=Na L1 )U C 5WGE Iª2; nth 2= n

ØÞ-O=N6. 58 OP6 ? )* B1R M=Na m�Wc,°j )

U C 5WG B1( -b( o* ;s,w123 4 M=N

U.5WGE 9Äa 6�67 ¡B,JWr ;�j5{Y -M=N;. ©,_

)* �°6 C @; � -7 9* ¡R qU �´ -b,;K¢*,X . @¨[j \= KV ) -b( o

U ¹ ( 5; C 56 7 -b( )* ¶; ?,_ b5¦- ?( )- C 23 ï7 ,= K* L1 ¡B,_ ,= K

-:R 5* I;KX: )FG B1( M=NJWr q³6 ? I;KX: )FG IS -b( )* ¶; ?,_ ,= K* ,= K* â5®_ ,= K* ,= K´E `( ,k I= . (5WG IS I- . -b( o* ;�j5{Y M=Na I- . ©2- n6¤ -9= :19X :

�23 ïj o* ;�j5{Y M=Na oU ¹5* IPPs ,= . o

U ¹5* q�= C( q- �XNJ· 2W c,6 .56 7 56 7 q6 t6? (�= KX: o

; ¹9* 5WG L1 -b,;K¢*,X . )

U C (E `( )/ I= . (5WG IS T67 )- C ,a -B M=Na )P]�h R,= . )FG IS

6s,-K67 -B(5- C Ñ= C2

3 4 6�7,p @U ?(9X : 28 n[

-Na )- O]: 5; C b5¦- ?( )- C ,>· ,À; ? IS @Wr -b,;K/1�-K WG

5* q6 t6? )- O¬: R )* )U OV B,= K; : M=NWcE IÁ-.D,Y L1 -b( )* M=N>

- ? )P; ? IÁv6 . mB,JWr -9®X K=NX.

o8 ¹B,X . )* B1R M=Na B,= K

; : )U O* )]C 5Ü- Oj)U C 5WG )P

; ? 56 7 `( ;<º1 -b( o* ;�j5{Y M=Na -M

3 ¢= NJ· )U C 5WGE `( )* �°6 C 56 7 -b( ,k 23 ï7 (5WG `( )* �°6 C I- . -b( )* B1R

M=Na )U C ( I- . -9= :19X : �23 ïj )* B1R M=Na )

U C (EdPX ? 6�67 ¡B,JWr ;�j5{Y oU ¹ ( 2008

M=Na -9®X K=NX. o8 ¹B,X . o

U ¹ ( 5; C @Wr b,>6A ); C ,6Y )P

; ? 5; C -ÅÓ6 C ¡B,6 K-7( m�-KU:,J

-? ,= . ¶X g· )¢¬C ( @z,k T=C5

- C (B,JWr ,ÀX �=�X: ); C 9* )P

; ? B1( @Wr T67 )/ L�Wc,°j ); C 9* )P

; ? m241R -bR suo-moto ,;.,6Y ( ,À; ?E l6C,_ Ñ= OX7 T

8N[6 7 6�7,p mB,JWr )P¯�=�X: )¢¬C ( ); Oj 5Pê )P

; ? IS oU ¹5* q�= C( ;s,6 . )

U C ( T67 IX . suo-moto )V EM=NÁ_ I= . `( )U OV 3 5-7 6�=OÜ

- C M=NWc IS Ñ= OX7 T8N[6 7 I6 Y(5

-7 6�7,p R5-7 ,6Y )* 8sB5* M=Na ); OP8 �=N6. )P

; ? B1( L1 I= . M=N>- ? ); O¯7 5Ê )P

; ? IS ,= K* ( ` )/ -b,;K¢*,X . o* qh,-.�6 . 5WG ,= K* LB,6 .1R 6�67 ¡B,JWr ;�j5{Y )

U C ( o´ ,= K* I= . ¸5V mB,JWr `,X . M=NU. ( )´ 6�6 7

@Wr -b( 5* \-K;:,-K; :( 9* M=NWc)FG BE I6 .5Ü- Oj 0123 4 q Wr M=N>

- ? ,;.5WG ,À; ? B1( -b( IX . -M3 ¢X C9*

,k +(-9V( \Â ,;.,6Y ,À; ?E q³6 ?( 56 7 q³6 ? `( ;<º1 ;<V,Y )FGà l6C,_ Ñ= OX7 T8N[6 7

6�7,p M=N>- ? M=NWc B1( I= . )¯�6? )

U C 5WG M=NWc IS = .( q³6 ? -b( )* �x-Y suo

224

moto M=N>- ? E,= . ( I= . 3 5-7 q6�=NÕ

- C -b( o* q- �X:( )FG IÁ-.5= O* L1 5; C -b( )* )- O¯: (

m�-K6: )P; ? Ñ= OX7 T

8N[6 7 6�7,pE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! ¡2= nª request )FG IS , 3_,À6 ? @=?8R IX . LR,= .

-B @ºB ·B ³q )U C ,6Y IÁ-.5= O* , 3_,À6 ? @=?8R )/ o

- ¹,X . )* )U OV mB,JWr 9U:, -Y-R M=Na I¼,-p( 5WG ,Ò B1( `( )* L1xw @Wr © 8�= K

U :,W c q 6 t6? LR,= .-B (�=KX: 9* ); O{_ M=NWc T67

)/ ¡B,JWr ;�3¢= N°j ¡B,JWr 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( 5* B1( ¡B,JWr ¡241R ;�3¢= N°j B1( ¡B,JWr ¡28 n_ 8�-.( 5* L�U.,¼ 5WG ,ÒE98 :5j m1 ,= . I= . 56 7 128 n=Kj T6 C 0123 4 qU �´ M=NWc I= .

productive M=N>- ? M=NWcE 128 n=Kj M=N[6 C 56 7 M=NWc L1 2W c, ØÈ )FG b5´5V )* )U OV

¡8B5P; ? ;�¦6? +,k o; ¹ ( M=NWcE 9Äa -b( M=Na )/ o

U ¹5* q³6 ? Xs ( 5* productivity d Ø�-C

M=N>- ? )

U C ( o´ B1( `( )/ oU ¹5* L�U.,¼ M=N>

- ? 5WGE 5; C M=Na ,;K¦· b5WG IS L1 )¢¬N¯. 56 7 b5¦- ?( )

- C 128 n=Kj b5¢6 C )* )U OV )P· B M=NWc L1 q³6 ? , 3_,À6 ? @=?8R )* )U OV )U C R

M=NU.,6Y IS,;. `( )]C 5Ü- Oj 5* LR,= .

-B ,= .R )U C ,6YE b,>=? ;�¦6? ¡896 : ;s,6 . o* o

; ¹,6Y )FG IS 98 :5j m1 @Wr ,-K6: )FG B M=NWc qXA(9* B5WGD )* )U OVà 28 n[j 9{= KXN_! L�U.,¼ T* 5* 5WG ,ÒE 56 7 B5WGD )* ¸5V b5WG )´ 56 7 b,W c1 )/ )

; C ( M=NWcE I= . ,-K-N6. 5; C qXA(9*)®>? )/

)U OFG ,XY ,À; ? B5WGD )* )U OV ,= . )´ ( ,-.,6Y )U OFG ,XY ,À; ?E 9Äa ,>· ,;.,6Y )FG IS I= . ×�-K/ ,k I6 .5Ü

- Oj )FGE 5; C 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! I= . ×�-K/ ,k I6 .5Ü- Oj M=N>

- ? )FG I= . mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . ,k )FG B1( 6s,6 t

-�X: ,k )FGE IÁ-.5= O* b,W c1 o* 56 7 ^ç=C98 : o

; ¹ ( )FG L1 6s,6 t-�X: M=Na o

; ¹,6Y )FGE @Wr 5; C o

8 ¹5PX A o8 ¹5PX A b5*824 )/ )®¯Y )

; C ,6Y M=NWc )- O¯: ( )- O¯: ( M=NJ�5±xw B1( @Wr 5; C 98 :5j m1 ©,Jå

;N_( ); C 9* q³6 ? M=N>

- ? M=NWc b,W c1 )* 56 7 ¥k5V ¸5V EM=NWc `( )* L1xw 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p! ;�¦6? mB,_ T

8N-Ky8 ?B,X K=:

8R )* -B 8�= K WG BdÎj M=N>- ? )U O* )U O´

M=NWcE 56 7 ad hocism IX . +,k ,= .xXY ,Ò)U C ,6Y 5; C 2W c, ØÈ )FG `( fd² )/ `(

M=Na oU ¹5* Zdi M=N>

- ? )U C ( ¡2= nªE,Ò ;�/(5-7BR )FG IS Ñ®;K-gh -B 8�= K WG BdÎj )U O*

M=NU.,6YE

225

),- ./01 23 4 567895: 2;< 93=> ?@2A B6C-DE 23 4 8F;GBH1 I

JK 0LM(

9{= KXN_ 6�7,p ! ,=K

-:R M=Na B1( -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na B1( ;�¦6? mB,_ b5´5V )/ Xs ( )®a M=NWc 56 7 ); O¦· M=NWc IS b,>6A b,>6A Xs ( )* JENCOS M=NWcà )¢¬N]Y +,6Y 1B53Ê à)FG 1 8�� )FG ,= . m241R M=NWcà b,W c1 @Wr 9V5Ê q6A9

-:( -M3 ¢= N8K/)* ,ÇV M=NWc); O{_ 56 7 -bR

)* @U ?,8 . )®Y B1( ;s(B 5* q6 t6? 56 7 ¥U. ( ,= . T=N� IX . q; �®XY )FGE -b( )/ Xs (

9* -b()* 5* 9V5Ê q6A9-:( IX . dÌ¢

-C(98 : M=:9* IS,;. ¥U. ( B1( T=N� )* Xf9-7 5*

@· ,= K* `(E)U C ,6Y q6A5V,-K{= K

8 : 5* q³6 ? ,ÀQ= .R E)U C ,6Y

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: Thank you.

6s,-K67 -. -�9= : �JA( 5= OPÐ6 .: 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p ! 6�/ )/ LR,= .

-B b,>=? line losses àM=NWc)

; C 5WG B1( technical losses M=NWc); C 5WGE56 7 M=N

-KU :D ;�¦6? o- ¹(9X :

M=NWc B1( -b( M=Na 56 7 q6 t6? 6s(9-7 o

; ¹5WG )FG B1( 56 7 ¡B5X 7 ,k 2ì-O} )FG B1( line

losses 5* @· ,= K* )U C ,6Y B1( qU �

-: M=N-KU :D o

U ¹,ÇV M=NU.,6Y ,;. IS q6 t6? ,k losses @·

5WGE I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: �= K/ @=�/1 -M=N[7 E 6�7,p

6s,-K67 @=�/1 -M=N[7 : 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! Cut Motions, Water and

Power IX . Iv[®_ ¥XY ,W cB E)FG M=Na (2ì;O-gh �2Í I= . qí=? ,-K¦· b5WG,XY ,ÒE M=Na

�2Í -M=N;. 8�- Oj M=Na q

- �X:( ;s,6 . ¥JQa ,-.9* b5WG,XY ,Ò b5= O* IS )P]�h I;KX: )FG IS

226

Cut Motions 9X :1()* 8�- Oy- ?B5´ o* �d² )/ ,= K* 6s(56 7 ,-. ( E)FG M=Na = .(

)U C (B ,-K=:R B12- Í ,-K=:R b5WG,XY ,ÒE @Wr )- O

;N]Y q³6 ? b,>=? R56 75j M=NWcà @Wr R,= K-N6. ¡ B5²

9X : 6�/ )/ )®>? -b,[-C( M=NWc B1( dPX ? -b,J¨[j M=NWcE 24 9´( ;s,6 . M=:9* 5; C LR,= .

-B 2; n>6? ,Ò5WGE T67 fd² ,Ç-O¦h o

U ¹ ,k Iv[®_ ¥XY ,W cB )FGE M=Na (2ì;O-gh qí=? ,-K¦· b5WG,XY

,Ò IS @Wr 6�/ q³6 ?)- O;N]Y ¸5V R56 75j M=NWcà @Wr �2Í B1( �2Í X¾

-?,X . 8�- Oj )U OV )* ,-KX:( 6s,[;NY( M=:9* IS @Wr ,= K* +(5} B5² 9X : +(5} 5* ¶X g· mR )FG B M=NWcE9´( @Wr +(5} 5* )- O¬: R M=Na +,k,-. M=NWc 5; C @· )/ @· ;s(B M=Na ¶8 �=N6. 9* )- O¯: ( 2= nJ

-ß )- C 8B5P6 �

-�P6 A o* 3T3Ê5* B12- Í M=:9*E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! `( )* ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ M=Na I= . ,-K¦· b5WG,XY ,Ò IS o

U ¹,Ç-O¦h T67 fd² ×896 : q WrB à)FG T67 fd² 98:(1 8�-K=:( B1,X . o* ¡28 n[

-Na �-.()* )¢¬N¯.B )P· B )U O´ 6s(EM=NWc 5; C ,[= C( )FG ,;KÄÂ IS I- . @Wr 5*dP; ? © )* )å¬C B-R q6 t6? ,-.,-K6: M=NWc); OFG ,XY I- . @Wr q�y

3§ oU ¹,-.(5

; C )å¬C B-R)* q6 t6? ,-.,-K6: ); OFG ,XY EM=NWc (B(� -Y '( )/ ,wR M=:9* IS '( �oV,°;C o

- ¹,J§ ( B5² 9X : q 6 t6? -b,;K¢*,X . 5* mR mR IS,;. -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na q6 t6? ¥XY E){_ 56 7 mB,JWr 98 :(1 8�-K=:( B1,X . )* 28 n[

-Na ;s(2- ì7 M=NWcà ;�- Ogh 9* àM=NWc)FG B -b( )/ q³6 ? qí=? ;�/(5-7BR b19* IS,Ò )- O¯: ( )ËQth M= Na qß5Ü

-7 B5² 9X : I6 Y5; C ¡R )

U C ,6YE -M6 7 -2= n-KXNJ· IX . -M=N6. ,ÇV (5WG )FGà ,= K* L1 -BdhB,ç¢

-C(98 : -2= n-KXNJ· )V q WrB M=NWcE -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na )- O;N]Y DISCOS àM=NWc ,= K* -b( b1B(R( -B 8�= K WG)* -b5* q§ -2= n-KXNJ· dhB,ç¢

-C(98 :)* )V M=NWc)FG Bà ,= K* L1 2; n>6? dhB,ç¢

-C(98 : M=NWc ,= . M=N>- ? 24EM=NWc 9´( L1 200 )* ¡1 ,k

dhB,ç¢-C(98 : )FG 5; C ,= K* 200 )* ¡1 )* dhB,ç¢

-C(98 : B�-.()* 56 7 -M=N;.coils

o; ¹5WG M=NWcàT* coils B�-.()* ,= K* L1 q8 �V(5* ¶*B M=NWc)FG BE I= . = KX7 8�-K=:( T

-Nv= K6: ,k I½= Cd² ,k B 6f (E)FG I6 Y(5

-7 6�7,p q³6 ? M=NWc)P8 �¬N6. B1( �6 .,w 2= n

3_ oU ¹,À6 ? q³6 ?

227

Ñ= C23 ï;C EM=NWc); OP·B M=Na b5WG,XY ,Ò IS 3T

3Ê5* M=:9* IS 6�67 @Wr )¢®]Y b5Ê5®6Y M=Na ;s,6 . 9* M=NWc)

; C 5; C `( ;<º1 5; C I= . M=:-2= nX¤ q³X A( q; �ÄÂ M=NWc -M{= KV 6s( @Wr )�6? M=N>- ? )FG Bà 6s( @Wr mature 5WG M=NWc)U O´à @Wr 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ B�-.()* M=NWcà @Wr qh5± q6 Ky§( -M*B)* M=NWcà @Wr 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ xXY M=NWc)FG BE

24 LB,À8 ?( )/ T=N6. 8B19* o* +(5} o* M=NWc,Ç-C `( ¥-K3¢= N-. q6 Ky§( IX . qÐÂ

oU ¹5WG àM=NWc -b( -B-dåj b5´5V 9X :1()* qÐÂ o

U ¹5WG M=NWc IS I= . mB,_ -B-dåj oU ¹,À6 ? B1(

M=N-K¦6? +(5} 5* ,= K* mR q Wr)FG BEM=Na dPX ? I= . ;�/(5-7BR b19* ,Ò IS @Wr 6�/ L(5-7 L1 28 n[

-Na 5WGà MNA 5WGà L1 T67 I½®Y 6s,-t;�-:( )/ 6�

- g;�-Na 5WG )* b,>=?

Ñ= C23 ï;C ,adi M=NWcà ,= K* L1 +(5} 5* ¶X g· mR M=NWc)FG B B1( 9´( M=N>

- ? mR )FG B 5; C dPX ? ,-KX:( 6s,[;NY( -b,[

-C( 5* R5-7 ,-.9* E)U OFG ,XY ;�¦6? I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: I= .9{

3_ q6AE �=K3¢y6A q; �/R E 6�7,p

6s,-K67 �= K

3¢y6A �JA( q; �/R: �@��6 C �'( -M� yA�9~V( �@= ��7�9~V(E I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E2ì;O

-gh B(-9´ 3 )FG IS D,k -0,6 . @=?8R 5; C M=N>

- ? -M6 : ,»/ b5= O* IS ×�-K/ q³6 ? -é(B,-. )FGà -b,;K¢X 75®6 . q³6 ? B1( 26 n=K

-7 L(5- g-?5; O-gX? q³6 ?E9Äa M=Na 2010 o* �d² bU1,6Y ,Ò 6�67 = .(

;�¦6? (896 : -b,¼5² ,= . (à LR5X 7 ¶*D ^_5= O* o- ¹,X . B1( b,= K WG,6 K

; : ,;.9* ,;.9*à ×�-K/ q³6 ? ,= K´à o6¹5- O67 6s,6 t

-�X: q³6 ? ,= K´ B1( 26 n=K-7 L(5- g

-?5; O-gX? 0x -p()* q³6 ? )U O´à @Wr )/ )- C ;�3/(R96 :

,= K* B1( b56 O=:d- Ô o* b53ÊD IX . -M3 ¢6 7 q³6 ? )

U C ,-Kj B1( -b( o* b1R(�a( )* )¯A 9X 7 q³6 ? )®¯Yà q³6 ?( ;. L1 6sx=K/ M=N>

- ? ED5P6 ? 6f ( q³6 ? @Wr ;sB12- Í )FG IS @Wr T-Cdi IX .

M=NU.,6Yà @Wr )®U. 5* IX . M=N

U.,6YE mB,JWr `,X . '( o* o- ¹,6 .2îh )/ o

- ¹,X . )FGà I= . q- �;:(

228

¡896 : ;�yå-C )FG IS T67 5* @Wr R5-7 æ

U C,-p 9* M=NWc)FG BE9´( ,ÀQ= .R )U C ,6Y 5; C

mB,JWr dÌ Ø�j ,-K=NS © B1( ¡8R oX¹ ^-KV’ LB�-KX: ¶*D ¡R,6 . ( `( @=�/ ,k B,» 3/ E)FG 9Äa �6 . q; �y�± )/ q¨ÀX �X? 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ )- C 3T

3Ê5* ào* I6 .5Ü- Oj ,;K®XY ,= K´à `( )* )U OV o

U ¹5* 9X :(9X : )¢¬N¯. M=N>

- ? ,-KP·B ;K WG,XY,E ;�j5{Y `( )º xw 5* ’56 7 qÔB -B I£xw )FGà 56 7 qÔB -B æ®-p à)FG `( IX . o

U ¹5* +,k M=N>- ? ,-.9* ); OFG ,XYE 3200 ,Ç= Oj 8s(1 q6 t6? ¥adP; ? B1,X .

)/ dÌ Ø�j ×89´ mR )FG ,W cBE9Äa b,W c1 2W c -B )FGà T-Cdi ¥U. ( ,;K®XY )FG T67 )/

serious ,=.B,J= �6: b q; �®= KPX ? M=NWcE b,W c1 dÌ Ø�j ×89´ M=Na q Wr )®U. 5* ,k ¥adP; ? B1,X . ,= .,ÇV ,6Y ,W cB E)FG b5- O=N;. ¥adP; ? )* -b,= KjBR ’ 56 7 IJQth ;s,= Ky§5j o* 56 7 28 n-.(

¥-K3¢= N-. 8sB5X CB o

U ¹ ( )FGà`( M=Na mB,JWr LB�-KX: ¶*D ¸5V ¥6Y M=NWc); O{_E@Wr M=NWc); O¦· IS ;�j5{Y )

U C ,-K6:à ,ÀX A( +,k )FG -M{= KV `( 5* ¡8B,>X? )º xw M=Na E)U C ,-K6:

= .( ¡B,k24 IÃ 6Y )FGà -B(BRB1R b5±xw M=Na )

U C ,-K6: 9Äa ¡R,6 . ( 5* -R¾ 6? I- . M=:9*Eb,>6A 9X : 3200 ,Ç= Oj 8s(1 q6 t6? )FG b,W c1 2200 )8 O

-NÀê 8�= K3/8R5V \-. )FGE

,-K=N½= C -M=N;. )]C 5¿ B1( ,8 .,¼ 5* ¥a, 3_ M=:9*à o

U ¹5* b,W c1 28 n=Kj M=N>- ? )FG B1( qi,k IÃ6Y

IX . ’ b5= O* IS L�-.,J�X C M=NWc)º xwà 6<=:d-Ô M=NWc)º xwàb,W c1 q6 t6? )* ¥6. mR q³6 ? M=NWc)FG BE @· -B( @· b56 CB( T

8N-.5= C losses)* )å¬C B-R’q³6 �* 28 n[-Na 6�7,p )/ M=Na

b5WG,;K¦· IS M=NU. ( M=Na Xs ( 5* ,-.,À·R b5WG,;K WG,XYE`( 5* ;s,= K

;:(-R )/ L�t=�®w 5WG 9* M=NÀQ= .R IS 28 n=Kj B 8�= .B 6 . ,;.,À8 ?( )FGE)/ ( I;KX: )FG IS I= . B(�-K=Na -B `(à)FG 5* 8B5PX A )* 2W c 6<=:d-Ô )* B,XY 5Ê X¾

-?,X . B1( LB,6 . 5Ê qi,-p()* T8N-.5= C ©(8R )*

b56 O=:d- Ô )* `,X tX? `,X tX? B(-2W c ¥6. M=NWc); C (E 6f ( T=NÂ5X C q³6 ? -b( dPê)* ¥

-Y(R o; ¹5WG

¥6.E)FG q³6 ? mR M=NWc)FG B B1( ¥=KV-R q³6 ? B5WG )FG M=NWcàdhB,ç¢-C(98 : ,;K®6Y 5; C)FG

`,X tX? `,X tX? B(-2W c ¸5V ,À8 �*( M=NWc); C 9* B1( L1 Line Superintendent )V

229

,;.,6Y )FGà T=C( ¡8R 1( 5* M=NWc); O¬: Rà `( IX . LB�-KX: B(-2W c Xf9-7 ,Ò5WGELB�-KX: -bR L1

dhB,ç¢-C(98 : ,;K®XY B1()FG dPX ? ¥6Y dPX ?E)FG ,; .,6Y )- O

;N]Y -b( )* 8�= .9´ -M3 ¢= N8K/ '(àM=NWc m9*

q6 t6? ¡B5X C )U C ,6Y5WGà @Wr �= Kj( M=NWc); OP·B 9Äa 8R9´ -M

3 ¢= N8K/ M=Na q8 �¢= NXK* q³6 ? M=N>- ? à)FG

-b( )U OV )* b5¦- ?( )- C o

U ¹5* b,W c1 9X :(9X : +,k M=N>- ? ,= K*E

6s,-K67 D(1! `( IX . ;sB12- Í )FG IS ;�j5{Y Å®-th 5WG )* +(5} mB,6 .)*

M=Na )¯A 5ÊE Xs ( M=NÀQ= .R IS @Wr ,= .8�-.( )/ q; �/1R 9* EM=NWc)FG B L1 )

U C ,= .BR ¥6.,k 5* ,-K*1B )FG ,;K WG,XYà L1 q¨À· ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ 9* ,W cB mB,JWrE)FG 9= : -B1 @

ØÙ}( 6�7,p q³6 ? )U O´ B1( '(ã, 3_,a ¡R5j B,k24 5* )®a M=NWcE9Äa -b( 5* M=N>· IS )®>? b5¦- ?( )

- C mB,JWr -M=N

;. ,= .BR �-K6: )¬O* 6s( L1 q¨À· ;�3¢WGR ¡R9´ 9* )* b,W c1 b5¦- ?( -2ïµ ( )V 5P· M=NWc B1( -b,;K¢*,X . 5* 96 g

-�6: ,-.9* ,;K WG,XY )FGE I= . (896 : serious IvUK¢j )FG `( 9X : 9´( ;�j5{Y Å®-th 5WG 9* )P

8 �¬N6. ’ M=Na 6f ( q³6 ? ,;K¦· b5WG IS ;�j5{Y q6 t6? ¡B5X C 9* q; �=:R q; �¢/ q6 t6? q; �=:RE I- . 6f ( q�* ¡BR,£ 6�7,p ,k �5-7 ,;.5WG B1( I- . q�* B1( ,k �5-7 ,;.5WGE q; �y�±�6 . )/ -b( )* ¶; ?,_ o

U ¹5* )¢¬C ( 2= n 3[j M=NWc -M3 ¢= C -B5X C( M=Na )P

; ?E -b( 6�/5* b5; N_1R ,k ,;KX: ,À; ?E @Wr R5-7 L�-Kj2

3 4 )P; ? -9®X K=NX. o

8 ¹B,X . )* IS B,= . qå±(1 I= . 6sx½

-C( )V 9* M=NU. ( )´E -b( )* 56 7 m5}R M=NWc -b( o* 56 7 M=N

;.,6 . M=NWc I= . (B,_ ¶X g·E 6�67 q Wr I= . B(�;K±( M=Na )

U C ( M=NWc L1 mB,_ )]C 5Ü- Oj X�X7 5WG )U O´ M=NWc B1( X�P8 ? 5WG )U O´ M=NWcE ¡�-K-: B5X C 8�{= K6719X : ,À; ? `( )* )¬OV I-KU :,XY )/ 56 7 -b,a,_ ,= . ( -b( )* 9®U.(56 C )

U C ( L1 M=N>- ? ¥XY ){_E q

- �;:( ¡896 : -M3 ¢X C9* o

U ¹5WG )FG ,-K=N½= C I= . +5± ,-KPX A5X C q; � WG,XY )FG 56 7 8<X:9* )FG )FG ,XY I½6 C,_ B1R M=Na )FG )FG ,XY LR56 75j B1R M=Na M=NWc -b( 5* q�

-C,ÀX ? q- �ÄÂ )¬OFG ,XYE 9´( -b( b5´5V 5* q�

-C,ÀX ? ,= .,ÇV ,;.,6Y 5; C -b,;K¢*,X . -b( ;sD,Y M=Na I- . ,;.5WGE T67 M=Na B,XY @§5j q³6 ? M=NWc T67 -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na ¥=K

;: q³6 ?

230

T=N� q³6 ? )FG o- ¹,X . q³6 ? )FG -M{= KV q; �y�±�6 . ¡B,JWr qÎ

UCD,-. )FG T67 o* I6 Y1 )/ I= . ^va B1( +5± ’ `( ^va ,k 98�Õ=Oµ 6<=:d-Ô B1R-dh suffer 9* ,W cB )FGE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ M=Na ,;K¦· b5WG (B(� -Y = .( m241R )* 8�- OU:(5X C \-.B5{_ o* )

U C ,6 t6? oU ¹(89V

m89ÄÀ6 A )* )U C ,6 t6? ’ L1 B5X 7 )FG L1 5*(8R )FG M=Na ,;K¦· b5WG +,JA M=Na @Wr

mB,_ )Ä-K-: M=NWcE 9´( @Wr ( 8B5P; ? )/ q³6 ? ;sD,Y 2; n>6? 9* ){_ 5; C I= . ;<º1 o* ;sB12- Í )FG IS Å®-th 5WG 9* `( ^va )* mB,6 . M=Na M=N XY5ÊE dPX ? ;<=:B5¦Ë6A

)* �x-Y 3 -B,_ o* ;s,6 . o; ¹5WG )FG bx¼ ,;.5WG )FGE 3 B(-9´ qí=? )FG IS M=Na ,;K¦·

b5WG IS `( +5± )* ¶; ?,_ Z( -�a ;�¦6? 5WG ,»X 7 )FGE @· )/ @· M=NJWr -dË=?8R )- C ,-K6:

)¬OFG ,XYE , 3_,À6 ? 9X : q³6 ? )¢¬N¯. )P· B M=NWcE ©5-Üµ b5j,k o* )U C ,6 t6? 6<=:d-Ô 5* q; �¢/ q6 t6?

M=:RE 22)¯C 1B 8<- :5= C q6 t6? ;�j5{Y �= .9

-7 q WrB )FG furnace ;�¦6? ,Ç-O¦h )FGE M=Na ,;K¦· b5WG q; �¢/ q6 t6? @Wr (�= KX: M=:9* )´ 5; C ^va M=Na oV,t

3§5-7 )U C ( o´E @Wr ,= K

-:R 5* q³6 ? q6 t6? mR ); O{_ M=NWc IvU.5* mB,JWr `,X . )FGE @· )/ @· mB,JWr 8<*

-M3/5j 5* ;s,= K

;:(-R 9X : I- . M=NU.,6Y @· )/ @· ¥a, 3_ ,= K* )

U C ,6Y B1( ¡B,JWr 5Ä;KÆ´ 5* q³6 ? ¥a, 3_ ©,Y ,= .,-K6: )

U C ,6YE ¡896 : o- ¹,6 .2îhE '( E ØÛµ,Y

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: B,;K¢V(�6 K} o

- ¹,X t6?E dP· 6�7,p q³6 ? M=N>- ? M=NWcE ,ÀX A( = KP

8 ? )FGE L�W c, 3_ o6¹ o6¹ = .( 8�- Oj ;s,6 . 9* M=NÂ -2= nvX . q6�yz I- . )¬O]g=�* ñ -b(-R(5WG )

U C ,6YE dPX ? dPê M=N>- ? ,6Y M=NÁ_ )´ Xs ( ¸5VE

Iª2; nth L�W c, 3_ o- ¹,JAB: I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E 24 M=Na ;s,6 . b19* o´ 8<* -M3/5j 26 nJ

-?123T67 M=Naloadshedding, energy crises, over billing B1( q6 t6? ¡B5X 7 )* )V (57 )/ ;�j5{Y o* qh,k,-. )* 9X :1( M=Na ;s,6 . ,-.9* q; � WG,XY

231

b5WGE T67 o* I6 Y1 )/ M=Na q; �P6 �Ë§

b5WG Xs ( ¸5V 8<U :(B 8�= KU :,_ 9X : )P

8 �¬N6. M=NWcE qí=? L1 -B53 ¢= C( )P

; ? T67 )* 9X :1( Xs ( )- C ;�/,= K/ o* B1( Xs ( )* -M

3 ¢{= KV( M=Na m�w1 )¬O*E B1( )®À�X? X¾

-?,X . ©,_ ¡B,JWr ;�j5{Y )* )P¯�=�X: qí=? )ÄÂ )FG B IS I= . qÔ5- OÜj -b(9g6? ,À; ?E -M{= KV Xs ( I= . M=NÀQ= .R IS mB,JWr B1R M=Na 6�67 X¾

-?,X . )/ ¶X 7 )¯C 1B qi 8<- :5= C @Wr 8B5PX A 9* )U O´ )P

; ? 5; C 6s( L1 17)/ 18)¯C 1B qi 8<- :5= C X¾

-�¦X? ,»X 7 )FGE `( )Î¬C d² )/ ,6 K=:dÎ

;C 75 8�- N_9X : I¼,-p( (5WG B1( 8R5V \-. 8�= K3/ M=Na q³6 ? ,-K; :( q Wr I¼,-p(

(5WGE ×�-K/ )* B�-.( o- ¹,X . ,k ;�¦6? (896 : TÊ(9* )FG B�-Ky§ b5- O=Na -B 5* 6s(9

-7 ,;.9* ,6Y ,W cB )FGE -M=:�6 . )/ )V 9* I8 KP

8 ? B1( q 8K=NS B�-K6: o* M=N-K=Na -B B�-Ky§ R96 : o

; ¹5WG ,6Y q WrB M=NWcE (2= nª l®°

;C IÁ-.5X 7 qXA(9* )/ )FGE qXA(9* M=Na `( ;<º1 -M=:9;:�6 . 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ 5WG q WrB )FGE 2W c )º xw M=Na )Ú 8B,_ ;s,_ )/ ¶8 ? ( )8 O

-NÀê 8R5V \-. 8�= K3/ o

; ¹5WG )FG -M{= KV `( )* L1xw q³6 ? -M= N

;. )/ B,XY )8 O-NÀê ¶X 7 )8 O

-NÀê 8R5V \-. 8�= K3/ o

; ¹5WG )FGE B1( q- �;:(

q; �y�±�6 . )FG IS 56 7 K electric )FG = KP8 ? )FG +,-. 5; C b5¦- ?( )

- C ©�6 . ,= KV )FG L1 ©,k ;. attend M=N>

- ? ); C 9*E I- . q Wr M=NJWr ,;KX: IS M=NJWr ,-K®a T* )/

)FG @Wr ;s,6 . T* )/ M=:9*EE -MU :D -24D L1 q³6 ? +(5} )* 9X :1( )FGE b,W c1 9X :

90 8�- N_9X : payment ¡R ,6Y q WrB )FGK electric )* ãD )* l6C,Þj 70 8�- N_9X : b,>6A 9X : payment o* )

U C ,6Y b,W c1 9X : 8R5V \-. 8�= K3/ M=N>

- ? 5WG o´E -M{= KV M=Na T67 ,= .9= :( M=Na q; � WGB b5WG b,W c1 ,6 K=:dÎ

;C 90 8�- N_9X : payment o* o; ¹,6Y

)FG `( )* R56 71,6 . \-. 8�= K3/8R5V ¶8 ? ( )/ `R )8 O

-NÀê )FGE +(5} 5* I- . 5; C o

- ¹,X . ¥a ,W cB )FG B1( qXA(9* = .( ¥

3[= N-.28 n-.( q8 �/ )FGE b,W c1 o* ¡R,6 . ( b1 8B19* M=Na )FGE qXA(9* o* +(5} o

- ¹,X . o* �-.56 C �-.56 C 5* `9;: )FG B M=NWcE b,W c1 K4 I6 .5Ü- Oj 56 7 qXA(9* )*

+(5} 5* )- C ,X t

-�¦X? )* )¬OV ,= K* E,À; ? 6f ( `( )* )¬OV M=NÀQ= .R IS 8�6 g6? )* B�-.( `( M=Na ,= K* @ºB q³·B )FGE @· )/ @· Xs ( qXA(9* )* )¬OV o

U ¹5* ,Ç= Oj 8�{=K6719X :

232

); O¬: RE `( 8�6 g6? )* B�-.( qXA(9* 5* 8R5V \-. 8�= K3/ B1( o

- ¹,X . `( ;<º1 6�67 IS -b,-ÕjB ( ,W cB )FG B1( -b56 7 o

U ¹D56 7 ,k I-K=N>h )FG B1( qXA(9* )* +(5} o- ¹,X . o* �-.56 C

�-.56 C 5* `9;: )FG B M=NWcE q6 t6? )* )¬OV `9;: )FG B M=NWc (B(� -Y K electric 5* +,ÇV M=:RE L1 T* fd² Xs ( )

- C -9U:,8 .5= OU :(9X : ,= K* )FG -M{= KV `( )* �°6 C L1 ¥»V,6 . q Wr

)¯C ( )/ 2W c,6 . 5WG )U O´ M=NWcE L1 q�* o* oU ¹5* ;s,6 . M=N>

- ? ); O-N_E 2W c )º xw M=Na

8R5V \-. 8�= K3/ 6f1dÔ 9X : )FGE M=Na 28 n[

-Na 6�7,p 5* q³6 ? b5¦· o´ IS 6f ( '( �oV,°;C )- C 6f ( Xs ( 5* = .( ;s-dÔ ¡R )FG @· )/ @· `( 5* maintain M=NÀ·B )- O¯: ( B�-.( ;�3/(R96 : M=NÀ·BE Xs ( 5* (B-R q§ b,>=? )/ ;s,6 . o* o

; ¹,6Y )FG 5; C Xs ( oU ¹,>; �

-:( ,6 K=:-B,-. â5®_ )

; C 9* M=NWcE ,[= C( I- . M=:9* '( �oV,°;C ;s-dÔ ,;K=:R )FG B1( q Wr1 TXC(1 )V ,;K=NÂ )FGE (� -Y )* )¬OV )- O¯: ( b5= C1B M=Na 6¾

-�=N XY M=:9* 9´( '( )- C Xs (

5* = .( æ±5j ,= .R )FGE T67 )* 9X :1( Xs ( )- C -M

3 ¢{= KV( campaign )* -b(B1R L�w1 ,= K* ,À; ? IS @Wr 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ 9X : 56 C,£ M=NU.,X . )É @Wr energy crisis )/

M=Nv»-C )É dP; ?transmission line )* )¬OV 56 7 25 -M=Nv6 . ,k I6 .5Ü

- Oj )FG `( M=Na Xs ( )

- C 100 -M= Nva )P· B M=NWcE @· )/ @· `( M=Na Xs ( 5 -M=Nv6 . 5; C ¶*B ); O{_ M=NWcE Xs ( T6 C128 n=Kj 9X : 40 -M=Nv6 . ¶*B ); O{_E Xs ( ,k -M

3 ¢{= KV( B53 ¢-Na ,k x>X? IÕ7

q6A9-:( TÊ(9* ,À; ? T67 )* 9X :1( Xs ( )

- C = .( ;�j5{Y oU ¹(9´ B1( q

- �X:( ;�j5{Y oU ¹,-K6:E I= . I- . M=N XY5Ê IS 6f ( +(5} 5* Xs ( )

- C �5±1)]C ,-K6: ,= KV ¥k dPX ? Xs ( o* ¡B,6 . )FGE M=NJWr 5; C �= Kj( q³

; ? IS `( 8�6 g6? B�-.( q6A9-:( )* )V (57 )/ L1 L1

)]C 5Ü- Oj M=NÀ·B )´ IS @Wr `( ©,_ energy crisis )/ 2W c,6 . ¥»-C M=N

U.,6Y )É = .( ©,_ ;�¦6? ,;.5WG )FG second year d Ø�

-C M=N>- ? ( ,W cBE Xs ( )

- C ¡896 : ¡B,= K

3/5WG )/ -b,;K¢*,X . 8�- OyX�®= .18R 8�-Kµ 56 7 IS 1R -M=Nv6 . ,k )FG `( M=Na Xs ( )- C

.5 -M=Nv6 . ¥a, 3_ 9* ,= .R -M{= KV +(5} 5* M=N>- ? I;KX: ExXY +(5} 5* ); OP]�Ë§ ); OP]�Ë§ ¶6 gË§ M=Na

233

)U C ( ,Ò IÁ-.5= O* q

- �;:( ¡B,= K3/5WG )/ I= . 8�6 g6? B,= K

; : ,= K* ,= K´ )FG IS 6�67 ;. I= . M=NÀ6 �Ë§

)´ 6<

; : ;. +(5} ,k (96 : ©,Y 5WG ,»X 7 5WG ,ÒE I= .9{3_E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: 28 n[

-Na B,¼ 98 :(1 8�-K=:( B1,X . I6 Y(5-7 Ñ¿ ( 6�7,pE

I6 Y(5-7 �J�h Ñ¿ (: I= .9{

3_ 6s,-K67 E9{= KXN_ M=Na ¡B5X C 3T3Ê5* b19* ,Ò IS m2= nª

b5= OU:,À6 ? )- C b5- O¦6? )

- C 56 7 q³6 ? ;s,-p(2; nð( )U C ,À8 ?( M=NWc -b( 6�/ ,k ¡B,6 . ¡B,6 .

6s(56 7 mR b5{_E I- . mR ,»/ 5; C M=Na q³6 ? q§( ©,Y M=Na b5WG q�* ;<º1 L1 ¶6 gh )/ 6s(56 7 q6�®È 9* ); O{_ M=NWcE ;�¦6? )/ 05-¿5j M=NWc ;�¦6? )/ m2= nª b5; N_1R )- C I= . IvUK¢j ,= .,À

8 ?( )FGE IS q6A o- ¹,X . (896 : æ

U C,-p ,;.5WG )FG B1( B�-Ky§ M=Na xXY ,;.,6Y )FGE reservoirs L1 (B,JWr = .( (896 : ,-.(9X : IvUK¢j )FGE D,k -0,6 . ;s,¼x;K

-7( o* I6 Y1 )/ I- . -M6 : ,»/E ¡B,JWr ;�j5{Y )

- C , 3_,À6 ?2= nª,= .R 9X : we started work honestly B1( `( ©,_ land acquisition )* )¬OV @Wr )

- C maximum amount allocate o* E)FG B1( I= . @=?8R 56 7 )FG T67 )* ¶; ?,_ reservoir

q³6 ? 5WG ,ÒE I= . M=NJWr 9´( )- O¯: ( ¥U.,_1 )/ q³6 ? ,-.,-K6: m89X : 5; C '(, 3[-C( �oV,°;C I= . B12- Í

)- O]: ,Ò B1( 56 7 ;<=:,» 3/ )FG o- ¹,X . æ

U C,-p )- C 5WG o* L1 '(, 3[

-C( ¡896 : �Y ;. `( @=?8R )* reservoir )/ @

; �-7 5WG )U C ,6Y Eo´ I- . �2Í I= . reservoir o

- ¹,X . Øä5Ægh m9* ,Ò IÁv6 . downstream B,XY m896 : m896 : © 8�= K

U :,W c T8NÁ=K6719X : 56 7 M=NWc 56 7run

of the river b5WG )´ -b( 5* I= . © 8�= KU :,W c q 6 t6? (�= KX: )

- C 9* M=Na -b1,°j ;<6:,3. 5WG ,ÒE T67 M=Na 5Ê(R )FG q6�

-?56 C )FG ,À; ? 8s5* )FG B1( `( )* �°6 C x= K6:9;: o* o´�-. -B

M=Na 35©,_ ,k I¼,-p( 5WG ,ÒE IÁ-.5= O* sedimentation x=K6:9;: M=Na @· 5WG )

U C ,6Y o´E m2= nª ;�¦6? )/ b5; N_1R )

- C ©5*dP; ? )* l®°;Oj ;�¦6? )/ b5; N_1R )

- C

234

;s,6 . o* )FGE R5-7 qWr m2= nª oU ¹,À6 ? M=NWc B5X OV,; . 6�7,p b5¦- ?( )

- C `( ;s,6 . ,k �(2; nð( q³6 ? ,= K* IS b,W c1 9X : 9X gQ= .28 n_(dÌ

-C( -M6 : ,W cB )FGE = .( IpdÔ -B(BR )/ @Wr I= . ;s,6 . )- O

-N_ ( )FG B )P; ? -M{= KV 6s( I= . Iva,°j ×�-K/ ;�j5{Y )* `,X . )FGE ©B 8�= Kµ

;�j5{Y )- C ×�-K/ ;�j5{Y )

- C 19Ä-K=:( )- C B1( = .( q

- �U:,XY q- �XNJ· )FG Sinohydro

b5- O67 )- C ¥a 9* I= . 8�{=K6719X : b,W c1 9X : 8sB,8K/ ,= K* )FG 56 7mine mouth

9X :mining q³6 ? 5WG o´ B1( ¶; ?,_ B1,X . 8<- :xX . q³6 ? b,W c1 9X : )ÄÂ ,ÒE B1( b,>=? 9X :

m2= nª oU ¹,À6 ? 6s(5

- C B5X OV,; . 6�7,p )- C 9*-R ,= K* IS b,>=? 9X : -M

3 ¢= NJ�-C(98 : -M

U :D ¡B,= K8Na

oV(1 mB,JWr -bxX . M=Na )FGE M=Na b,>=? 9X : explain ,-.9* b5WG,XY ,Ò IS @Wr -M3 ¢= NJ�

-C(98 : -MU :D o* q�= NÂ,X . IPP mode M=Na ,-.(5

- O6: ); OFG ,XY M=NWcE IÁ-.5= O* ;�¦6? q§ state owned -2- n=K

U :,XY q- �XNJ· b,>=? 9X : B1,X . 8<

- :xX . ,ÇV q WrB M=NWc 5; C L1 ,6 K=:dÎ;C B,XY

)/ X¾-?,X . -M=Nv6 . 9V(8R -M

3 ¢= NJ�-C(98 : -M

U :D M=Na q³6 ? invest M=:9* Eo´ -M3 ¢= NJ�

-C(98 : -MU :D M=Na

¶; ?U1,_à¶; ?B,-. q³6 ? )FG B1( ¶; ?B,-.à ¶; ?U1,_ q³6 ? )FGE 56 7 © 8�= KU :,W c 8�{= K67(9X : mB,JWr ¶; ?B,-.

M=Na `( ;<º1 proposed q³6 ? M=NWc ,= . under construction M=NWc -b( o* q6 t6? ¶; ?U1,_ 5* )V )

- C ,6Y )* )¬OV -M3 ¢= NJ�

-C(98 : -2- nU.D )- O]: o´ B1( o- ¹( 8�� B1( 1B53 ¢j,6Y B1(

dP; ? M=Na 8�{= K67(9X : ©5* 9X : M=NÃÂ )´ -b( o* -M3 ¢= NJ�

-C(98 : -MU :D ¶; ?U1,_ ¶; ?B,-. 56 7 )FGà I= .

,6 K=:dÎ;C )Ú 8B,_ ¶X 7 ;s,_ M=Nv6 . 9V(8R `( 9X : invest b5WG )´E T67 fd² M=NJWr `(

;<º1 massive interest receive 5WG )FG ,W cBà sentiment (896 : ,ÀX A( )FG IS ¸5V b,>=? 9X :à sentiment I= . IS)FG IPP mode 9X : -M

3 ¢= NJ�-C(98 : -M

U :D oU ¹,ÇV

M=NU.,6Yà T67 )/ = .( 5; C I= . L�U.,¼ 5WG ,Ò IS 8�=O8N_ 5* q

- �X:( T-Nv= K6: 8�=N 3_ )* 9X :1(

debt ,-.,À8 ?( M=N>- ? m89X : ,Ò B1( ¡241R ;s,6 . I= . )FG IS @Wr )

- C wheeling 9* ¡R )FG o

U ¹5* q³6 ? -b( -M3 ¢= NJ�

-C(98 : -2- nU.D 5* ©,Jå;N_( 9* )* q6 t6? = .( ^va )/

m241R )- C 5* ;. )V ,6Y ,;K{_ )FGEm2= nª qXA(9* )* b5; N_1R )

- C q6 t6? o*

235

;<=:,» 3/ o* )FGE b,W c1 9X : qXA(9* â28 nÁ=KV( oU ¹xX K/ q

- �XNJ· )FG T67 ,k ,= K-: +,-. 6s( K-

Electric )FG `( 5* )Ú 8B,_ ¶X 7 5Ê 8s(1,Ç= Oj q6 t6? q; �®a )FGE `( )* �°6 C I= . +,J;? ;sxa,°j )* ¡( T=C( q§ )* B1( qXA(9* )* 5WG )

; C ,6Y M=NWcE @Wr -b( 5* = .(fixed q6 t6? ¥

-K3¢= N-. 8R9´ )/ mR )FG B M=NWcE `( )* L1xw 9´( b,W c1 9X :

\-. 8�= K3/8R5V o

; ¹5WG )FG ,= . oU ¹5* B1( ;sxa,°j )

; C 5WG M=NWc 5; C I= . )* ¡( T=C( q§ o* ¡R,= K

-N6. B5² 9X : Iª-R ¡B(R )FGE -M{= KV IÁ-.5= O* ;�j5{Y T=N6KPX A �Õ=Oµ o* q³6 ?( q³6 ? 2U n=K3/

B 8�Â5WG )FG B1( @Wr ¡28 n[-Na � ( 98 :(1 8�-K=:( B1,X . )

- C IvUK¢j )* ¡( T=C( q§ )* ¶; ?,_ ,= .,À8 ?( (5WG )FG IS R56 71,6 . `( ;s,6 . )* IS = .( ©B 8�= Kµ ;�j5{Y Xs ( 5* q6 t6? mR q WrB )FG B1( dPX ? q³6 ? ;<=:,» 3/ 6f ( ¶8 ? ( 5

- C ©,_ o* -M3 ¢= C-9U :,8 .5= O

U :(9X : )* �°6 Cà IÁv6 . 1R -M3 ¢= C-9U :,8 .5= O

U :(9X : oU ¹5WGE = .( -M

3 ¢= C-9U :,8 .5= OU :(9X : ¡28 nva ;�j5{Y )* -b(B1R o

U ¹5WG 6�67 I= . q¨>X? I°µR qQ6 . B1( `( )* �°6 C ¡241R -M

3 ¢= C-9U:,8 .5= OU :(9X : T67 )* l®°

;Oj ;�¦6? )/ ;sD(5Ê b5WG L1 )®À�X? B1R M=Na -9®X K=NX. o

8 ¹B,X . )* B1R M=Na ¡241R transaction oU ¹5WGE

©,Y2î6 ? qXA(9* )* +(5} o* Iª-R ¡B(R q³6 ? qº,¼1 ;�j5{Y 9X : �U.,w o; ¹5WG E)FG IÁ-.5= O*

I= . transaction 56 7 )FG -M3 ¢= C-9U:,8 .5= O

U :(9X : o*à M=Na oU ¹5; O67 6�7,p o* ;�j� -Y M=Na

-édÔ b19* ,Ò IS ¡2= nª ;s,6 . -M/ M=NÂEEE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: -B,6 tÔ( 6�7,p kindly disturb 5WG )FG B M=NWc Xs ( b5´5V o* -B(1 ( q WrB ( )FGE

I6 Y(5-7 �J�h Ñ¿ ( : I= . 8�= K

U :,_ 53Ê (B-R �-K6: (9* M=:RE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: M=Na ,;.(9* b5WGE

236

I6 Y(5-7 �J�h Ñ¿ ( : M=Na 3T

3Ê5* 9* ,W cB b5WG IS )- O;N]Y q³6 ? ;sD(5Ê )

U C ,À8 ?( )U O´ M=NWc 5; C -b( ,k 6s(56 7 q

- �X:( l=Oµ5; C B1( ;s,£1( )FG `( )* l6C,Þj mR b5{_E qXA(9* ,k )®UK¢j 9X : @Wr )

- C )®>? )/ qWr K-Electric )* ¶; ?,_ ,= .,À8 ?( (5WG )FG

,;. IS qXA(9* )* b5´5V o* Ñ= OV,»;C M=NWc -b( ,k IÂ( -B( ,= K* ,6Y E){_ M=Na dP; ? 9X : dPX ? bU1 ( ,Òà ¡B,JWr I= . ;�¦6? massive effort )FG IS I= . )®Ò ( 1R -M=N

;. ©,_ M=Na dP; ? M=Na mining q³6 ? = .( m896 : )

- C ,J= �X: 9X : 8sB,8K/ 5WG )U C ,6Y B1( `( )* ¶; ?,_

56 7 mine M=:9* L1 ¶; ?,_ B1,X . 8<- :xX . q³6 ? M=N

U.,ÇVE I= . = .( ,[= C( IvUK¢j )FG B1( I= . qh5± I3 .,3.( )FG B1( )¢¬N]Y IS m2= nª b5= OU:,À6 ? )

- C ,>· I= .B1( ¥»V,6 . ¾ =�gß ,>· IS mB,JWr

`,X . 56 7 reservoirs M=NWc ,= . cold reserves M=NWc I= . = .( qh5± I3 .,3.( M=NWc B1( `( )/ �=KÆ

;N[j ,-.5WG mB,_ -b,;K¢*,X . ,k l7 )FGE -M{= KV `( M=Na lead ×�-K/ 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ 5* q- �=NÂ m89X : o´ B1( qº,¼1 ;�j5{Y '(ã, 3[

-C( �oV,°;C B5X CdP6 ? )Î¬C d² )/ -b( )* `( effort M=Na ¡8dP· 5WG o´Eb,>=? 9X : = .( misunderstanding )FGà (B,JWr 6�67 energy mix massively change (5WG m5

- C o* oU ¹,W cR M=NaàM=Na

;�=O-: 9X : ^3_ ,k B,> Øè( M=N>- ? 9* ,W cBà -9®X K=NX. o

8 ¹B,X . )* )- C ,a -B M=Na 56 7 o

U ¹ ( oX¹ -2= nX. )ÄÂ 1993 )/ )V 9* 1996 ;. L1 mB,_ )* mB,_ o

U ¹ ( oX¹ -2= nX. ¥=K;: 9X : )ÄÂE

¥=K;: `( ;<º1 ,;K¢/ ,À; ? B1( ¥=K

;: 9X : ,ÇV )¬C R )U O´E L1 contemporary situation M=Na = .( = KP

8 ? q�= NÂ,X . -M{= KVàq³; ? long term M=Na I= . q�= NÂ,X . mB,JWr

)¬OV -b,ÕÖ-C LR ;<6:,3. o

U ¹5WGà¥=K;: ,Ç-O¦h (5WGà ¥=K

;: o* transportation qÐ-K¦h 5WG qU �´ B1( ¡B,_ M=:-2= nX¤ qÐ-K¦h 5WG qU �´ M=NWc B1( `( )/ (B,JWr 56 7 q6A9

-:( T{a ,À; ? L1 ,-K;:( 58 OÄ= K-: 5WG ,= K´ IS `( ,k L -B,= Ky

- A )®À�X? `R LB,6 . ©,_ )/ @Wr ;�ÄÀ6 ? )FG B M=NWcE `( )¬OV I= . effort coal o* �d² B1( mainly hydel o* �d²à © 8�= K

U:,W c )* `(

237

;<º1 8�{=K67(9X : 56 7 9=: -B 2= nJå;C M=NWc ,= . 56 7 proposed M=NWc L1 R( -B ( dË=�

3¢* M=Na q³6 ? M=NWcà )* oX¹ )* M=Na q³6 ? M=NWcà ;�ÄvÒ -b,;K¢

;Nv6 . B1( -bBRB,-. -B,= .9= :( M=Na 8�{=K67(9X : M=NWc B1( (B,JWr )]C B,J

3§ potential E)FG -b( M=Na ;�¦6? b5Ê 9X : `( ;<º1 +,k ¡B,6Y )FG x3Kj @ =K

-: @¨>6A )FG L1 2= nJå;C )* ¡9

-7 ( ¥Y(dh M=Na )FG B1( ,6 K=:dÎ;C 5

- C 5Ê 8s(1,Ç= Oj q6 t6? `( )/ ¥p,Y 5WG o´à T=C( )* 1B 8�= K

U :,W c )FG `( ,k financial close ,6 K=:dÎ

;C ¥JQa 5WG ,»X 7 )FGà L1 q³6 ? 2017 )* 9-7 ( ;. ,= . 2018 )*

0123 4 M=Na 5- C 5Ê )* 6<=:dº q6 t6? ,-K=:R 0123 4 9* M=:R E)´ `( fd² mB,JWr

-b,;K¢WG5* )* ,= .9= :( M=Na -M=N;. B,XY 5Ê 5Êà m5

- C m5- C 8s(1,Ç= Oj )* M=NWcE`( fd²

©(2; nX¤ M=Na M=NWc B1( q³6 ?( R( -B ( 2= nJ3�* 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ M=Na -M=N;. B,XY -M

3 ¢*5V -9U:,8 .B1 8�= .( 5WG q WrB M=NWc B1( ¡B,_ ¥a 9* o

U ¹5* = .( B(-2W c 8s(1,Ç= Oj L1 q³6 ? )- O]: Eo´ -M{= KV 6�/ )/ ¡896 : -M

3 ¢= C 8�= .( x= K6:9;: B5µ B1( x= K6:9

;: 5= OU :,¼ o* 5WG o´ L1 ,6 K=:dÎ;C T=N

U.,À8 ?( 5Ê 8s(1,Ç= Oj o* q6 t6? '(ã, 3[

-C( �oV,°;C 2018 )* ¥U.(1( M=Na mB,JWr 8R9´ M=Na )U C ,6Y ( oÉx= K6:9

;: B5µ 56 7 )FG L1 LR5X 7 5Ê ¶X g· ,k )FG B1( x= K6:9

;: 5= OU :,¼ q³6 ? LR5X 7 5Ê ¶X g· ,k 8�{=K67(9X : )FG B1( L1 8�{=K67(9X : )- O;: ( )Ä-K¦h q³6 ? M=N>

- ? M=NWc IÁ-.5= O*already infrastructure b,W c1 9X : R56 75j )FGàdisplacement b5´5V o* ;�¦6? @· )FGE5; C I= . 1R 8�{=K67(9X : M=NJWr

T=NU.,À8 ?( 5Ê 8s(1,Ç= Oj M=:R )É qXA(9* )* ¥Y,_ 9X : b,>6A 9X : (B,JWr nuclear

plant ,À; ? b,W c1 9X : T=NU.,6 . 5Ê 8s(1,Ç= Oj )* nuclear power plant ,-K=NU.,XY o*

R�a )/ @Wr ,ÇV )FG B M=NWcà L1 -b5V )FG `( )¬OV 8�6 g6? M=Na Xs ( 5* d Ø�-C M=N>

- ? )U C (

,ÒE IÁv6 . `( )* �°6 C T;N=K; : 5Ê ,k B1( ,ÇV M=NWc)FG B L1 IPP mode M=Na M=N

U.,ÇV )´ B1( �2= n8. `( ,k 56 7 q³6 ? decide 5WG ,Ò `( )* 6s,[7 )/ L1 M=N

U.,ÇV )´ L1 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ � ( -b,;K¢*,X . o* liability M=N>- ? 5WG oÉm2= nª b5; N_1R )

- C ¡B5X 7 o* q³6 ? ;s,6 . o*à line losses o* ;s,6 . o*àb,>=? 9X : ¡�-K-: B5X C o* B,6 . B,6 . ;s,6 .

238

oU ¹5WG )FG B1( M=Na `( ,k 9*-R ,-.9* b5WG,;K WG,XYà M=Na `( M=Na petitioner ,À; ?E`5¢µ( o* ;s,6 . )FG IS M=NJWr o

U ¹5* +(-9V( M=N>- ? ,-.,ÇV ,;K WG,XYà ¡B,JWr ;�j5{Y 9X : q³6 ? +(-9V( )ÄÂ

M=NWc IS `( o* price jack up o* qU �´ )FG B1( L1 price jack up )- C 9*

M=Na oU ¹5* )®¯KPê M=NWcE q�

-C2X n[-C(98 : ¥

-K3¢= N-.28 n-.( )

- C (B,JWr 8s8R ( ,= K* B1( `( )* �°6 C 1R -M=N;. B1( -2= n[

-N6t=?( )- C (B,JWr 8s8R ( ,= K* B1( 56 7 price jack up o

U ¹5WG )FG L1 b5¦- ?( )- C justified B(dº ¡RE -M{= KV 6�67 M=Na petitioner ,-K6: ¡�-K-: B5X C 8�{= K67(9X : M=Naà `R 8B19* )¯C 1B o* ;s53ÊB )* )¬OV I= . 1R ©,_à (2= nª o

U ¹,À6 ? �=.5- C dËº ,À8 �=N6. (5WG

)FG he will bear me outà `R 8B19* )¯C 1B o* ;s53Ê1B )* )¬OVà ¡28 n[-Na

� ( 98 :(1 8�-K=:( B1,X . ,k B5Ü± M=N>- ? ,À; ? ¡28 n[

-Na � ( ãD ,k B5Ü± ,À; ? b,>6A 9X : I= . ¥U.,¼ ¡89X : o

U ¹5WG Eq³; ? = .( 5Ê L2= n;. 6sB( )¯C 1B I- .D,_ -b,ÕÖ

-C (5WG )FG I= . 8�{= K67(9X : ¥=.9X :( 2011 M=Na 8sB,8K/ ,-.5WG ,À; ? Am I right? B1( I= . 26 nJ§R 2014 M=Na 8sB,8K/ 5WG ,ÒE I- .D,_ -b,ÕÖ

-C 56 7 @=?2X n_ 8sB5* M=Na ¡2= nª figures accept M=NU.5WG L1 = .( 5Ê L2= n;. 6sB( )¯C 1B Xs ( o* qh5

- C,k( 5* -b,ÕÖ-C (5WG because

of absence of 450 MW from the national gridE b5¦- �67 )- C

`R 8B19* )¯C 1B ;s53ÊB qÐ-.,a q³; ? L1 )

; C ,-.�-.R dPX ? )FG B M=NWcàI= . q³6 ? M=N-.,a )´à B5®¼

9X : M=N>- ? M=N

-.,a )´ o´�t=�®w M=Na I= . q³6 ? M=N-.,a )´ T67 )

- C )¢¬N¯. )Ä-. ,a )P; ?E 5; C I= .

©,Y ,W cB )FG -M3 ¢X C9* ,kàM=NvXY +,-. ,= K* ,-K=NÂ )FGàmB,_ )- OP]�Ë§ )V (1 M=NWc f B(�À6 �Ë§

¸5V b,>=? 9X : )P8 �¬N6. )

U C 5WG M=NWcE 6s( -ÅÓ6 C ¸5V ); O¦· M=NWc IS @Wr )- C IÂ(5

- C(96 75´ o* T=N� `( 5* o

U ¹xX K/ 9* ¡R )FG ¡�-K-: B5X C 5*à ¥=K;: 9X : ¥XY ,W cB )FGà qÐ-K¦h q6 t6? 5WG

o´ B1( 6�67 T=N� )U C ,6Y ( o´ 5; C `( 5* T=N� 9X : convert 9* ,= .R )

U C ,6Y ,Òà dPX ? `( o* q6 t6? ,k 8<=:B mB�£ @· 5WG )

U C ,6Y ,ÒE m2= nª b5= OU:,À6 ? )- C IvÒ ,= K* )FG IS

b,>6A 9X : losses ); C 5WG M=NWc b,W c1 9X : @Wr q6 t6? �-K6: 9* ); O¬: R M=NWc IÁ-.D,Y b,W c1 9X :

239

)P¯A ( ¸5V q³6 ? ); OFG B M= NWcE I= . ;s,6 . -b( o* ;�/BR )FG IS 9´( -édi M=:9* 2; n_ �Õ=Oµ M=N>· 9X : lossesM=NWc ,= . q§( �Õ=Oµ losses M=NWc b,W c1 9X :à LB�-KX: �Õ=Oµà ,= . T=N6. ,= . T=N

;. �Õ=Oµ ¸5V )¢¬C ( q³6 ? M=NWc 56 7 q6 t6? ,k ¥6. (R( ); C 9* M=NWcà @Wr q6 t6?

6�67 �-K6: ); C 9* M=NWc 5; C L1 ¸5V q³6 ? penalize )

; C 5WG M=NWcà -M{= KV I= . `5¢µ( o* ;s,6 . )FG @Wr `( 5* avoid M=N>

- ? ); O{_9* `( o* I6 Y1 I= . )FG IS 6�67 T=N;.

�Õ=Oµ ¸5V 56 7 q6 t6? ,k ¥6. (R( ); C 9* M=NWcà 2; n_ �Õ=Oµ (R( M=N>

- ? ); C 9*à M=Na q�*

particular situation ,= . location o* ;s,6 . M=N>- ? ,W cB9*E 5; C = .( social

pressure build up ,Ò5WG -b( b1B5X 7 9X : 56 7 q6 t6? ,k ¥6. (R( M=N>- ? )

; C 9* B1( -b( ,-. -b,Ò�-KÚR )* 9X :1( 56 7 q6 t6? ¥6. (R( M= N>

- ? ); C 9* IS Xs ( )* )P¯�=�X: I= . T=NXtX?

,= . T=N;. �Õ=Oµ ¡R,6 . ( L1 q³6 ? penalize q WrB5WG )FG I= . = .( internal

pressure b,W c1 9X : build up )U C ,6Y5WG E,Ò B1( (241R KPK M=Na

successfully I= . 8R,a © ¥XY ,W cB )FG -M=N

;. B,XY -BB 8�= Kµ 9X : ,= . X¾-?,X . ¶X 7 -BB 8�= Kµ 9X :E

IS @Wr )- C source out )¬C R9* -BB 8�= Kµ IS,;. -b( )* losses 56 7 M=NWc L1 9´(

q§( �Õ=Oµ M=NWc ,= . 2; n_ �Õ=Oµ M=NWc L1 @· 9*5WG ,X tX? ` 9X: )U O´ ( ¶X g· ¶8 ?,_ 9X : )U O´ ( B1( 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ 5* b,W c1 )/ 5= O-:5= CB -B LR,= .

-B ,-K®a 0123 4 )U O´ 5WG M=NWcE B1( I= . q6 t6? �-K6: )- C 9* oV(1 56 7 q�= NÂ,X . )FG `( )/ q³6 ? M=Na KPK ,k example Xs ( 5* b1R ,Ò IS b,W c1 )/ M=NJWr 5= O

-:5= CB q³6 ? LR,= .-B collect (5WG )FG )®À�X? = .( 1R -M=N

;. )- O¬N>h M=Na B1( ¶; ?,_ b,W c1 q6 t6? o* consumption q³6 ? 56 7 q6 t6? æ

U C,-p q WrB5WG q³; ? L1 q³6 ?

@· oU ¹5WG )FG B1( M=NJWr q6 t6? o* availability 8R9´ M=Na LR,= .

-B oU ¹5WG )FGE m2= nª

-b,;K¢X 75®6 . )* b5= OU:,À6 ? )- C 9*-R ,= K* )FGE @Wr )

- C 1R(R B(� -Õ-7 -M

3 ¢y�-C(98 : -M

U :D 56 7 )FG L1 -M

3 ¢y· ¡R9* )FGE oU ¹D56 7 M=Na ¡8R q6A -b,-Yà o

U ¹D(B5V q³6 ? -M3 ¢y· )

U C ,6Y5WG o´E `( ;<º1 LB�-KX: 5Ê 8s(1,Ç= Oj 56 7 )FG L1 mB,JWr qXA5®6 . b5= OU:,À6 ? o* ¥8.58 C

240

requirement )FGE @Wr -b( 5* �2Í ¶X 7 5Ê mR M=NWc)FG B B1( `( o* I6 Y1 �2Í I= . )FG IS -b( ,k @

8 �¢/ ¶X 7 5Ê )Ú 8B,_ ¶X 7 5Ê )/ LR,= .-B q 6 t6? ,À8 ?( q Wr M=N>

- ? ,;K{_E -b( 1R -M

3 ¢y�-C(98 : -2- nU.Dà T67 M=Na = .( -M

3 ¢y· qU �´5WG )FG ¡241R T=N;K*( o

U ¹D56 7 ;. -M

3 ¢y· )U C ,6Y5WG oÉ -b( 5* q

- �;N 6Y -b( o* requirement )FG L1 ¡B5X C q6 t6? @Wr ,= K¦h M=NÁ_9* )É M=Na b,>=? 9X : = .( ;s,6 . -édÔ ,;.9* b5®XYE `( ;<º1 56 7

requirement )FG o*5- C 5

- C DISCOS o*à 9´( L1 @Wr ¡B5X C M=NWc,XY,-.9* 5; C M=NJWr T=N

-.( B(-2W c 8s(1,Ç= Oj o* q6 t6? )¬OFG ,XYE @Wr 6f ( LR5X 7 B(-2W c 8s(1,Ç= Oj q6 t6? produce )FG B9* M=NWcà )®À�X? ©,_ @Wr )

- C oU ¹D56 7 M=Na IÂ5Ê B(-2W c X¾

-?,X . 5Ê 8s(1,Ç= Oj q6 t6? (�= KX: o* 56 7 8RB,»= CB ,À; ? -b,;K¢*,X . o* -¾ =?B,;. M=NaE -b,;K¢*,X . )* @

8 �¢/ )- C q³6 �* q

- �;:( q6 t6? (�= KX: M=N>

- ? o*E -M{=KV M=Na b,>=? 9X : I= . q³6 ? ,;.,;K6: b5®XY Ù1,W c o*information )* )U OV IS `( )/ LR,= .

-B 9´( @Wr q6 t6? produce M=:9* B1( @8 �¢/ 5* ,-K=:R M=NWc,XY

5; C I= . ,-K=:R ;�¦6? (896 : ^_B ,Ò5WGE (B,JWr @8 �¢/ q

- �; :( L�= K/56 C ;<V,Y M=Na )FG IS L1 `( 5* ,À8 ?( M=N>

- ? ){_ E,Ò `( ;<º1 mB,JWr `,X . ¥-K3¢= N-.28 n-.( 8�ÂB1 ^-K=N6. )FG ,= .

m241R 56 7 ^-K=N6. M=NWc -M=N3[= C( 8�- OyX�®= .5= C8R ^-K=N6. )FG ,= . âx_( 8�- OyX�®= .5= C8R ^-K=N6.

)FG -b( o* �d² )/ M=NJWr loansM=NWc 56 7 )®Ò ( 1R -M=N;. ©,_ M=Na 56 7 (B,JWr

L�= K/56 C @8 �¢/ )FG -M

3 ¢y�-C(98 : ,k `( 5* Xs( 8�= .9´ ,= K* ){_ ,6Y E,Ò )U O

-: 8R9´ M=N-K6:

)É -BdhB,ç¢-C(98 : )U O

-: M=NÃÂ )É 56 7 LR56 75j ;sD,Y M=NWc x3Kj M=N>· 9X : 1R 5Ê T=N6. )FG b,W c1 9X : X¾

-?,X . 5Ê ,Ò5WG b,>6A X¾-?,X . 5Ê )FG b,W c1 ¶8 ? ( 5Ê ,Ò5WG 5; C I= . (B,_

-M3 ¢y�-C(98 : -M

U :D simultaneously M=NJWr I= . effort ,-.9* m89X : ,Ò T67 M=Na (B,JWr distribution ,k , ØÞ

-C + q³6 ? = KP8 ? 5WGà -M

3 ¢y�-C(98 : ,k +, ØÞ

-C q³6 ? = KP8 ? 5WG

¶; ?,_ -M3 ¢= C2- n6¤ q³6 ? ¡B,JWr increase 5WGE `( ;<º1 56 7 @Wr effort )FG B9* M=NWcà

M=Na M=N>- ? ,;K¦· IS L1 mB,_ )* mB,_ effort I= .,X . ¥=KyQ

;. ;. X¾-�¦X? M=N

U.,6Y )´

241

X¾-?,X . ©,_ )* +,;K;N -Y( 9X : 6�67 @Wr LB,6 .1R -M

3 ¢{= KV( M=Na M=NU.,6Y )É B1( M=Na b,>=?

9X : ¾ =�g�; C ,-.9* b5WG,XY ,Ò IS M=Na B1()

- C m2= nª oU ¹,À6 ? �6 .,w 2= n

3_ q¨w 56 7 m2= nª M=NU.,6 . �d² ,À8 �=N6. )FG @Wr )

- C q³6 �* -¾ =?B,;. M=N>- ? ¡R IS bx¼ -¾ =?B,;. 5* 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ @; � -7 )

U C ,6Y5WG oÉ \-. 8�= K3/8R5V ,k @

; � -7 ,-.5WG = .( ¥»3¢j +,k )FG ¥6KÖ

;N[j 6<=:dº M=NaE `( M=Na @

U ?,8 . )ÄÂ ,Ò -M{= KV @Wr q- �;:( B12- Í �=Kj( DR ); O{_ M=NWc (ñ')* ¥

-Õµ 1 +9* )/ IS \-. 8�= K

3/8R5V I;K¢WG ( I;K¢WG ( `( ^va M=Na @· o´5WG B1( �-KX7 b5V,_ M=Na @Wr `( ©5= OV 9X : X¾

-�¦X? M=NU.,6Y )´ b,>6A @Wr I= . I>· M=NÁ_ )´ IS 6s( I= . \-. 8�= K

3/8R5V @; �-7

)- C 5WG )* ¥»V,6 . 6<=:dº qX�

-�¦X? ( )FGE M=Na b,>=? 9X : = .( comparison ,-.9* b5WG,XY ,Ò qU �j )* )- O¬N>h M=Na Xs ( `( 5*compare M=:9* 2013ã )* qU �j )* )- O¬N>h )* ¶; ?,_ 5; C -M=N

;. )8 O-NÀê 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ on average mB,_ -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na @· )FGE ¶; ?,_ ¶; ?,_ M=Na Xs ( 5* ,-.,;K6: ,;K WG,XY b5WG IS )®À�X? ©,_ -b( b5

- CR M=Na -b,;K¢*,X . )* ©5² 1 -édÔ M=Na b1B1R-dh )

- C M=NÂ,; .82W c o* oU ¹5WG M=NÀ

; ?E ¡B,JWr ¡28 n_ 8�-.( �-K6: qQXY5WG q³

; ?E ¥Õ=Oµ R,6 . ( M=Naà qXA(9* M=Naà -b,;K®a M=Naà B1, 3[X C M=Naà -b1�� M=Naà 8s5{Â,= K/ M=Naà 96 75ÍÂ(5

- C( M=Naà +,J;? ¡28 n_ 8�-.( �-K6:E ¸5V bU1,Ò )/ )

; C ( )P; ? ¡B1R-dh )U OV )*à

5Ê ×89= :8R 5Ê )¯C 1B I= .(9* Xf9-7 )* 9*à (B,_ -bR B, ØÞ;O

-:( M=Na ,À8 �=N6. ); C 9* )P

; ? IS q6 t6? )U C ( o´à ¡28 nÁ=Kµ )®¯Y o´ B1( M=NJWr ¡8B,>=?R )®a oÉ (ñ ')* ¥

-Õµ )/ 96 :5; O*( 2013ã )/ ¡28 n_ 8�-.( 5* q6 t6? ¡B5X C ¥a q WrB )FGE `( ;<º1 q³6 ? 1R M=N

8KÆ3/ ¥XY

q WrB M=NWcE `( ;<º1 q³6 ? 5- C 5

- C )8 O-NÀê o* 1R M=N

8KÆ3/ ¡28 n_ 8�-.( xXY q WrB )FGE q§( I6 Y1

)/ (B,JWr \-.9X gQ= Kµ5- O=Na 28 nÁ=K/ 13.1 �Õ=Oµ growth show ,»/9* )FGE¡B,JWr 56 7 growth o

U ¹5WG )FG qh5- C,k( M=Naà L1 q§( I6 Y1 )/ o

U ¹5WG )FG IS ¡28 n_ 8�-.( 5* uninterrupted q6 t6? qä )FG B1( 96 :5; O*( )/ XfB,a ;. T=N6.5X 7 )8 O

-NÀê q6 t6? qä )FGE 6s( 9´( @Wr )

- C X¾ =�6: M=Na @· ,= K* )FG 5; C = .( 8�Ì3/ @· ,= K* )FGà -M{= KV 96 :5; O*(

242

)/ XfB,a ;. uninterrupted q6 t6? mB,_ -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na ¡28 n_ 8�-.( 5* qä )FGE b,>6A M=NJWr \-. 8�= K

3/8R5V o* I6 Y1 )/ oV,Ò ¡R o; ¹,6Y )FG b,W c1 9X : @· -B( @· I= . q³6 ?

acknowledge ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XY IS ¶X 7 )- O¬N>h @Wr )- C )- O¯: ( Xs ( 5* b5´5V o*

b5= OV,Ò )/ Øä5Ægh ,À·B )FGE I= . achievements )FG 56 7 @Wr )- C = .( ©,_

M=Na o* M=NWcE M=Na I= . M=N>- ? I>· ,W cB IS `( ,k o

U ¹5* ;�¦6? (896 : 8s 8�= .9* @Wr claim )FG B9* M=NWc -M{= KV @Wr )

- C ¾ =�gß ;�y§ o* �d² +�£ B12- Í )

U C ,À8 ?( M=NWcE T=NU.,6 .

B(-2W c 8s(1,Ç= Oj )U OV )* `( ;<º1 I-KU:,XY invest ,W cB9* )FGà I= . T=NU.,6 . B(-2W c

8s(1,Ç= Oj `( )/ ¥8.58 C X¾-?,X . )/ ;s,_ ©,_ M=Na q6 t6? o* -M

3 ¢= C2- n6¤ M=Na I¼,-p( ,Ò5WG -b,;K¢*,X . M=NaE I= . `( )/ L1xw )FG 56 7 mB,JWr )- O¯: ( ¥U.,_1 M=NWc -M6 7 5* )

U C 196 : 9*D @Wr q6 t6? M=Na I¼,-p( M=:9* )É `( M=Na à© 8�= K

U :,W c 2= nvk5= O-:à 9V5Ê B1( 8�-.1 B1,X .

L2= n-ð1 ¥a, 3_ M=NWc `( fd² B1( æ

U C(B-R M=NWc )¢¬N]Y ©5* )* T8NÁ=K67(9X : @Wr M=N

U.,ÇV )´à I= . I-KU :,XY o* R�a )/ M=N

U.,ÇV )É 5; C I= . `( )* L1xw )Ä-. 5WGEM=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG B1( M=Na assure ,;K{_9* b5WG )- O¯: ( b5= OU:,À6 ? B1( b5- O¦6? 5* `( `�½j -b(5= C( 5* IS L�-KU: ( �-KX7 b5V,_ )* B�-.(à -M=N

;. B,XY ©,_ M=Na @Wr m896 : R,J;�}( )/ I>· M=NÁ_ )´ IS -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na 8R5V \-. 8�= K

3/ -¾ =?B,;. ,k IÕ7 -M6 : )U C ,6Y o´ B1( \-. 8�= K

3/8R5V ¥6KÖ;N[j

6<=:dº M=Na @; � -7 )

U C ,6Y5WG oÉ situation 56 7 )FG L1 `( @�± o* )FGE -M{= KV M=Na b,>=? 9X : = .( B1( ;s,6 . ,-K¦· b5WG,XY ,ÒE M=Na ¶X g· -B9Ä¼ ,-.,;K6: 5WG,XY b ,Ò IS `( ;<º1 56 7 mB,JWr receivables M=NWc Ñ®;K-gh b56 C5¿ )/à 6s,6 t

-�X: 8�- Oy- ?B5´ )/

@Wr )- C 4.67 -M=Nv6 . ,-K=NÂ )FGà 56 7 �= Kj( )FG IS T=N

;. -b56 7 ;. (R( )U C ,6Y5WG ,ÒE

9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( ¡ 8�[6 N_ M=Na -b( )/ @Wr )- C 3.65 -M=Nv6 . ,-K=NÂ )FGE¥8.58 C 8.32 6sB(

)¯C 1B -b( )/ ,-K=NÂ )FGE KPK ;�j5{Y )/ @Wr )- C 1.94 6sB( )¯C 1B ,-K=NÂ

)FG B1( 9X g¨»= C9Ä= .( ¡ 8�[6 N_ M=Na = .( ¡896 : minor q§ -b( o* amount )FG 1R

243

6sB( I= KX:1B ¥8.58 C b5¦- ?( )- C (B,JWr (R( ,-.9* )FGE B1( M=NJWr �= Kj( )FG IS T=N

;. -b56 7 )/ )®>? )®>? L1 (R( )

U C ,6Y5WG ,ÒE ×�-K/ 8�- Oy- ?B5´ )

- C M=NJWr 54.55 6sB( )¯C 1B ,-K=:R M=NWcE -b,;K¢X75®6 . 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ )- C (B,JWr 5.55 6sB( I= KX:1B ,-K=:R )FGE I= . M=Na 8<

- :9* o* ;s,6 . ,W cB9* b5WGE 5; C I= . ¥8.58 C debt 56 7 8�- Oy

- ?B5´ )* `( ;<º1 receivables M=NWc current L1 75.9 6sB( I= KX:1B )FGE `( M=Na 56 7 )

- C (9X : receivables M=NWc L1 M=Na ¥a, 3_ M=N>

- ? ,W cB9*E `( M=Na R( -B ( 2= nJ3�* )* q³6 ? M=NWc

-b,;K¢X 75®6 . )* 56 7 6s5= O8 : b5®= .1 )* )¢¬N¯. M=NWc L1 q³6 ? M=NWcE ×�-K/ )* `( )* L1xw q³6 ? M=NWc B1( @Wr ¡B5X C 3T

3Ê5* )FG B9* M=NWc IS I= . 56 7 )¢¬N¯. M=NWc I= . reconcile M=NU.,6Y5WGE 9´( o

U ¹5* dispute )FG b56 C5¿ M=Na B1( Z,¼1 M=Na -b( numbers 9X : 5; C q�* fd² reconcile M=N

U.,6Y5WGE 9´( Z,¼1 5* oU ¹5* hit q

- �=NÂ o; ¹89X : )FG ,= .

Z,¼1 5* I= . ¶6 756 C ,-.,À8 ?( ,;.89X : )FG 5; C = .( I°µR I= . mB,JWr )- C (9X : 6s,[7 6s,;K* ¥8K=N_

M=NU.,6Y5WG B1( `( )* �°6 C ,= K

-: 6s,[7 6s,;K* 8sB,8K/ 5WG T67 M=Na oU ¹5* ambiguity

I- . 5WGE oU ¹5* claim, counter claims I- . b5WGE M=Na = KP

8 ? I>· ,W cB b5WG �= .5- C dËº 6�7,p o

U ¹5* Û®-w ;s,6 . 5; C M=N>- ? I>· ,W cBE I= . M=Na 8<

- :9* ,;K6: ,W cB b5WG M=Na )

- C ,>· L1 8<- :9* ,;K6: ,W cB b5WG I= . M=NÀQ= .R 1R `( )* 9X :1( details M=Na

I- . M=NU.,6Y dPX ? (B-R ¡8B5P; ? q§ 6s( Xs ( M= N>· )´ IS M=Naà M=Na mB,_ b56 C5¿ o* ;s,6 . 9* ,W cB b5WG I= .5

; C ;�¦6? (896 : figure )FG I= . dispute ¥XY ,W cB )FG SEPCO B1( `( )* ¶; ?,_ B1( ( ` M=Na B1( q³6 ? )FG x3Kj @Wr )

- C qº,¼1 ;�j5{Y )

- C Karachi Water Boardo* guarantee ¡R oU ¹5WG )FG

Karachi Electric Supply Company 56 7 )FG ýý 6sB( )¯C 1B @Wr )/ L1 claim o

; ¹9* )FG Karachi Electric Supply Company )- C

þû 6sB( )¯C 1B 56 7 )FG Sui Southern ,-K=:R,k )FG T67 M=Na ý 6sB(

244

)¯C 1B ¥p( )FG qº,6 . (R5Ê )FG L1 I- . ¥p( ); O¬: R M=NWc I- . (R5Ê ); O¬: R M=NWcE Xs ( ¸5V m2= nª o

U ¹,À6 ? b,>=? IX . qXA(9* )* )P8 �¬N6. )

U C 5WG M=NWc Xs ( -b( 5* M=N>·à¶X g· M=N>· 5; C (2= nª 6�®Þj )FG o

U ¹5* figure 56 7 )FG = .( common 56 7 )FG = .( 3 x;. o

- ¹9* )¬OFG ,XY Z,¼1 -b(5* +,J;? receivables and payables

)* 9X :1( IS,;. M= NJWr I;KX: \Â )U C ,6Ywhere do the Federal

Government stands? B1( ,>· b IX . 56 7 )FG )]C 5¿ Û®-w )FG b,>·,= . IX . Z,¼1 Û®-w )FG I= . reconciliation 56 7 )FG I= . qh5± R,çj M=Na )FG IS I= .

reconciliation 5WG )U C ,6YE `( M=Na Z,¼19´( 5* 56 7 )FG -b,ÕÖ

-C q³6 ? ,-.,À8 ?( ,;.89X : )FG 5; C M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS Z,¼1 5* -b,ÕÖ

-C ,À8 ?( ,-K=NÂ )¬OFG ,XY for the sake of austerity IS,;. I= . L�-KU: ( 56 7 )FG 6s,[7 6s,;K* 56 7 )FG (B,JWr ;�/BR )FG BE M=Na

)- C I= . ,-.,;K6: 5; C M=N>

- ? ,;K WG,XY ,À; ? -M{= KV dPX ? q³6 ? M=Na )- C ,>· 5®XYE ,;K6: q Wr M=:RE

m2= nª = .( oU ¹,À6 ? )

- C b,>=? )/ ,= .,À8 ?( ,À; ? b,W c L, 3_ q6A Xs ( )

- C ,À8 ?( ,= . ,À; ?

sovereign guarantees D(1 I= . IPPs M=Narecall o* q³; ? sovereign

guarantees56 7 M=NWc )®À�X? B1R ;�j5{Y o* q³6 ?( b5¦- ?( )- C recall M=N>

- ? o* they have not yet claimed the guarantees B1( 56 7 @Wr )- C sovereign guarantees 56 7 PPA @Wr ); O¬: R M=NWc Power

Generation Companies 5* IPPs 5* 56 7 @Wr ); O¬: R M=NWc PPA itself is a sovereign guarantees. We undertake to buy

purchase power from them. 5; C 9´( L1 pile up )U C ,6Y5WG

payment = .( ,k �Y ;. 5; C (2= nª ©,= K-7 )FG = .( date )* �°6 C 56 7

)FG it becomes legally incumbent upon them that they should recall the guarantee. Am I right Shah Gee?

245

q³6 ?( ;. M=N>- ? o

U ¹5WGà q³6 ?( ;. M=N>- ? o

U ¹5WG -M{= KV )®À¯�X? )- C ,a -B M=Na M=N

U.5WG M=NÀ; ?E

@=?2X n_ 8sB5* M=Na )U O´ )P; ? @Wr `( situation 5* avert )FG B9* M=NWc @Wr )

- C ,6 K=:dÎ

;C ú� 6sB( )C 1B ¥k M=NJWr xa )FG B1( ý� 6sB( I= KX:1B M=NJWr ýþ 5* ¥a )

U C ,6Y ,Ò @Wr `( M=Na oX¹ T=C( 1( 5* q³6 ? payment 9* )FG B M=NWc )®>¯? @Wr defaulter PSO )* M=NWc `( 5* q³6 ?payment M=:9* )´ B1(

IPPs5* q³6 ?payment M=:9* )´ IS,;. L1 default M=Na I- . M=NU.,6Y `( M=Na

(B,JWr ,-KX:( interest )FG 9´( b5¦- ?( oU ¹5*)

- C mB,JWr ¶; ?,_ 56 7 q³6 ? o- ¹5- C,£ +,k

); O{_9* M=NWc L19´( ,= K* 5; C -b,-ÕjB )- C ( D(1 )FG 5; C mB,JWr )U OV ¡896 : ¥»

3¢jà+5± )* )U OV q³6 ? o´5WG -M{= KV Iª-R ¡B(R 5; C ;�j5{Y o* o´5WG q§( )U OV @Wr `(

situation 5* avert )FG B9* M=NWc M=Na L, 3_ 6�7,p 5* I= .à = .( 5; C I= . -9®X K=NX. o8 ¹B,X . M=Na L, 3_ ;�¦6? M=NWc 5; C I= .à L, 3_ q6A M= Na �= .dh b5WG Xs ( ,kE L1 M=Na -M=N½= C ,;.DR b5WG IS I= . sovereign guarantees 56 7 )FG recall M=N>

- ? b5WG o´ B1( `( )/ )®>? )®>? 56 7 )FG 56 7 outstanding 56 7 )FG partially @· @· -B( 56 7 )FG B12- Í settle 9* ,= .R )

U C ,6Y ,Ò IPPs )* ¶; ?,_E Circular debt ,k IvUK¢j 56 7 )FG L1 = .( genuine IvUK¢j )FG @Wr )

- C Ñ®;K-gh sources )/ ,-.(9X :56 7 circular debt ,À; ? L1 clear ,= K* � ü `( M=Na q³6 ?( q³6 ? ý� 6sB( 56 7 )FG qº,6 . )FG T67 o* settlement q³6 ?( ;. M=N>

- ? qQ_5WG -M{= KV I= . LB,6 .1R 56 7 )FG I= . �üü o* figure b,>=? IX . o

U ¹,;K6: qU �´ q³; ? �üü

M=N>- ? )FG �üü )/ @· )FG ýûüEýûþ)* 6<=:dº I= . ,;K

-N6. )FG -M{= KV I= . = .( problem )FG which is there, we cannot deny it. It is

there and we accept that problem is there. ý þ 6sB( I= KX:1B 56 7 subsidy M=NJWr q¨a )FG ýþü q³

; ? �þB1( b5¦- ?( )- C ,= .R )FG

246

ý þ 6sB( )¯C 1B M=NJWr subsidy q¨a )FG `( R56 71,6 .)* ýü� 6sB( )C 1B ,k differential 56 7 )FG R56 75j )FG 56 7 circular debt o* ;sB5¿ M=Na 56 7 )FG it is staring at us 56 7 L1 deficit 56 7 )FG I= . = .( q�= C(

situation )FG 56 7 âB q; �{_ )FG ¡B5X 7 )/E 9´( L1 ¡B5X 7 �-K6: )U C ,6Y5WG 56 7

technical losses M=NWc L1 �-K6: M=NU.,6Y5WG I= . -b,Ò�-K WG,-. 56 7 M=NWc I= . M=N>·they

disappear in the thin air I= . @Wr Xf5Ê ); O{_ 3TWG(5-7 qWr ); O{_9* M=NWc E,-. 6�67 culture (B,JWr 56 7 )FG L1 6s(9

-7,-K; :( ,= K´5WG 5WG -M{= KV solution 56 7 )FG `( M=Na = .( q Wr solution )FG IS (B,JWr distribution system (B,JWr

generation ¡B,JWr 56 7 )FG transmission q- �;N 6Y q³6 ? LR,= .

-B @Wrprivatize ); O{_9* M=NWc M=NJWr privatize o

- ¹9* )¬OFG ,XY b,>=? IX . M=Na ,-K¦· b5WG,XY ,Ò IS I= . privatization ,k process 56 7 )FG I= . o

U ¹5* ¡B,JWr invention M=N>

- ? )FG @Wr )- C I= . �ú M=Na start ,= K* IÁv6 .dispute )

; C 9* M=NWc m2= nª o

U ¹,À6 ? -9®X K=NX. o8 ¹B,X . )V (1 IS M=N>

- ? b5¦- ?( )- C ã M=Na start

,= K* M=NvXY T67 )- C q³6 ? start ,= K* But, it was pursued by the

successive governments. m2= nª oU ¹,À6 ? M=Na q³6 ? B�-.( (5WG �= .5

- C dËº 6�7,p q³6 ? B�-.( )

U C 5WG privatization 56 7 `( ;<º1 -M=Na2U n=KX7 M=NWc M=Na ,wR ,;.9* b5WG L1 B�-.( I- . b5WG 5; C L1 @Wr )

- C oX¹ o8 ¹ q§ ¥=.( o* privatization

56 7 )FG b5¦- ?( )- C start o* úý 8�- N_9X : 56 7 )FG Morgan Stanley

)- C ,X t=�6: )FG -b( )* behalf IX . ,X t=�6: and it was a successful

privatization 56 7 úý I= .B, 3[}( ¶X g· percent o* q³; ? m896 : )P¯A ( )¢¬N¯.

)®a q- �Ó= C Eúü ©,_ )* �°6 C 6�67 PTCL qX�=�6: L1 -b( o* price5* `( ;<º1 q³6 ? `( )

- Cjustify ,= K* It was very

247

successful transaction. KEPCO o* b5¦- ?( )- C transaction o*

6f ( KEPCO privatized )FG KEPCO is another successful transaction. `( )U OV I= . ,-K¦· IS L, 3_ 6�7,p m2= nª 2= nX. M=NWc �= K

3/B5-7 L, 3_ 6�7,p I= . -ÅÓ6 C ;s,£1( M=NÁÉ896 : M=NS82

3 4 ); C B,a M=NWc IS I= . )

U C ,6Y5WG ,Ò L1 5WG )U C ,6Y ,Ò bx¼ 5WG )

U C ,6Y ,Ò -M{= KV privatization -b( )* manifesto ,k ,= . ¡241R b5= O8 :B,X . )* manifesto ,k ,-K;:( IÕ7 )FG ,-K;N 6Y m,JWr

manifesto ,k IÕ7 )FG B1( I= . ,-K;N 6Y q³6 ? B,k24 )* hold )/ ,= . B,k24 )* `( )/ ¥»

-C )* private sector M=Na xXY )U C ,6Y regulator ,W c1

b IX . )P8 �¬N6. )

U C 5WG M=NWc b,= .28 n[-Na q³

8 �=N6. oU ¹5WG M=NWc M=N

;Kj5{Y q³8 �=N6. o

U ¹5WG M=NWc they can watch the situation so that I= . out of control I- .

b5WG regulators `( )U OV appoint )¬O* )U C 5WG M=NWc I= . �Y(1 I½= Cd² )FG

`( -2= nX¤ 5* ©128 n-K* )- C 9* ,k I= . mB(R( ;�j5{Y o* ¥=.5g

;? M=Na B M=NWc )´ -M3 ¢X C9* @

; � -7 M=N>- ? o´5WG I= . mB(R( ;�j5{Y o* ¥=.5g

;? M=Na M=NWcB )´ ¡B5X 7 M=N>- ?

@; � -7 o´5WG technical losses @

; �-7 M=N>- ? b5WG )´ transmission

losses @; �-7 M=N>

- ? b5WG )´E I= . �2Í B1( �2Í I½= Cd² 56 7 )FG ,= . dPX ? I= . )FG IS I= . 56 7 B(8R 6�7,p b,>=? IX . )P

8 �¬N6. )U C 5WG M=NWc he will bear me

out. IS I= . 8�¢V )FG 56 7 I= . CCI )- C approve o* o

U ¹5WG )FG T67 5* @Wr pursue 9* )FG B M=NWc ýüúý M=Na I= . -9®X K=NX. o

8 ¹B,X . o* ;�j5{Y )- C q Wr I= .

8�¢V approve o* oU ¹5WG q³

; ? @Wr )- C I= . 8�¢V 56 7 )FG L1 inventM=N>

- ? o*E Xs ( b5´5V )

- C I= . approve o* q³; ?Eo

U ¹,À6 ? a, -b ,= .,6Y 19* I- . 6f (E We are pursuing the same agenda, which has been pursued by

successive governments since 1991. 5; C `( )U OV oU ¹5* qU �

-:

248

-2= nX¤ M=N>- ? )FG �2Í 56 7 )FG L1 \-.B ¡ -B,6 . )* )U OV `( @�± o* M=N

;.,6 . ,-.9* 56 7 )FG L1 ,ÀX A( M=N>

- ? ,;KÄÂEM=Na M=Na ¡2= nª ;�/(5-7BR )FG I= . ,-K; :( I- . M=:9*E 5; C I= . M=Na ñ -b(-R()

- C 5WG oV(1 )FG LR,= .-B M=Na 56 7 )FG @

U ?,8 . M=N>- ? ,;K WG,XY,-K=NÂ M=Na )

- C 3T3Ê5* o* )FG IS m2= nª b5= OU:,À6 ? )* b5- O¦6? )* )- O

;N]Y q³6 ? -B53 ¢= C( )P; ? L1

mB,_ )* mB,_ addressb19* B1( M=Na 9´( oU ¹5* LB ,= K´ )FG 5; C (2= nª

-b,6 K=:9´ 2- Í,Y )FG �°6 C M=Na 89{X . M=NÂ M=Na dPX ? 6s(56 7 mR b1R ,ÒE5; C b,W cE b,W cE

L1 ,_B( 26 nJh,k 56 7 )FG L1 retire )FG ,= K´5WG I= . (2= nª ©,= K-7 )FG úþ5* L, 3_ q6AE

B5X OV,; . 6�7,p T* -bREI= . q³6 ? retire (5WG )FG M=NJWr oU ¹ ( o

U ¹5WG M=NWc -b( o* instructions IS L1 -b( 5* q§( 5* L1 )´ ( `( o* `124 ,-KÚ896 : ); OFG ,XY

M=NWc M=Na ¥k I;KX: b5V9* ,Ò offhand M=Na ¶X g· M=N>- ? I>· ,;K{_ -M{= KV -b( ,k @QY

56 7 )FG L1 b5PQ-. (24 IX . 9´( L1 q§( 5* continue ,-.(19* ); OFG ,XY M=NWc M=Na ¶{= .R b5V ,Ò o

U ¹5*9´( -M- }�£ M=N>

- ? )FG 5; C ×�-K/ ;�j5{Y ,k 56 7 )FG L1 @QY )FG `(5; C IX . ã, 3[

-C( (ñ'�oV,°;C ¥=Kyå;C o* )

U C ,6Y o´ M=Na )- CE q6AE I= . TXC ( M=Na Xs (

@; �-7 M=:9*EI= . M=Na qí- ?( -9´ ;s,3_B( )* ¶; ?,_ M=Na )

- C 3T3Ê5* o* )FG IS M=Na

)- O¯: ( b5= OU:,À6 ? 5* 56 7 )FG -MU NJÙj b5{_9* 9´( M=N>

- ? -M=NJÙj ,»/9* 5; C `( )* )U OV qi,°j b5WG,;KÄ-.,a 3T

3Ê5* b19* ,Ò I= . = .( ©,_ M=Naproblem M=N>- ? ¥Y

q; �{_5WG I= . 1R ©,_ M=Na q³6 ? �= ., 3_ I- . 5WG E){_ -M{= KV = .( ©,_ M=Na @Wr )- C

progress B12- Í show o* )FGE ¡B,JWr economy M=Na 56 7 results )U C ( M=NWcà `( M=Na B(8R 6�7,p o* effort )FG he is leading a

finance team from the front. -M{= KV `( M=Na 8R5V \-. 8�= K3/ M=Na 56 7

qË· oU ¹ ( )FG ,= . ¡28 n_ 8�-.( 5* 56 7 uninterrupted q6 t6? q¨a )FG `( ,k ;�¦6? (896 : ¶; ?,W c )FGà `( o* ;�¦6? ¡896 : contribution )FGE B1( ¡B,JWr 3T

3Ê5* 5WG o´

249

IS ¡28 n_ 8�-.( ,k I= K¦X? q§( fd² ,;K®XY )FG BE IS,;. b5´5V employment )®aà ¸5V unemployed I- . Eb5WG qh9´ I>§ ,-K=NÂ -b,_ ( )FG -M{= KV â5P6 ? ,-K¦§ ;�¦6? ¥»

3¢j E)FG 5; C I= . LR56 75j ;sD,Y M=NWc 56 7 M=Na )

- C explain 9* )U C R EM=NWc M=Na q§(

)* ¶; ?,_ q Wr 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p Xs ( ,k 9{ 3_ B(-9´ b5WGE M=Na )- C 3T

3Ê5* o* )FG �= Kj( )FG IS m2= nª b5; N_1R o* 56 7 queries M=NWc L1 satisfy b5WG o´E ;�¦6? ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: q6A I= .9{

3_E

Mr. Speaker: Demand No. 101. The question is that the Cut Motions, as moved, on Demand No. 101 be adopted. (Consequently the Cut Motion were rejected). Mr. Speaker: Now, I put Demand No. 101 to the House. The question is that Demand No. 101, as moved, be granted. (Consequently the Demand was granted).

250

Mr. Speaker: Demand No. 135. The question is that the Cut Motions, as moved, on Demand No. 135 be adopted. (Consequently the Cut Motion were rejected). Mr. Speaker: Now, I put Demand No. 135 to the House. The question is that Demand No. 135, as moved, be granted. (Consequently the Demand was granted).

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: 8R5´ =.¥ 6�7,p Xs ( 5* M=Na ,;K=:R q³6 ?( I= . -M3/5j 15j )

- C 9* )* �°6 CE �W c(

-B �a,Y E 6�7,p q6A M=Na ,;K=:R b5WG -M3/5j )* �°6 Cà ñ -b(-R(,k ;<º1 5WG

,W cB )FGEM=N>- ? )®>? motion move 5WG o´E Xs ( �°6 C M=Na 9* M=NÁ_ )´E

MOTION REG: CONSTITUTION OF A PARLIAMENTARY COMMITTEE TO EVALUATE SHORTCOMINGS OF PREVIOUS ELECTIONS AND MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ELECTORAL REFORMS FOR FREE, FAIR AND TRANSPARENT ELECTIONS

251

Mr. Zahid Hamid: Thank you Mr. Speaker. I seek your permission under the proviso to sub rule(3) of rule 158 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the National Assembly, 2007 for moving this Motion under rule 244(B). and I am happy to say that the Motion enjoys a broad consensus of all the representatives of political parties, of ten political parties, who are present in this House today: i.e. the Pakistan People’s Party Parliamentarians, the Pakistan Tehrik-e-Insaaf, the Motahidda Qaumi Movement, Jamaat-e-Islami, Jameeat-e-Ulama-e-Islam (Fazlur Rehman Group), Pakhtunkhwa Milli Awami Party, Pakistan Muslim League (Zia), Pakistan Muslim League (Functional), National People’s Party and the Pakistan Muslim League Nawaz. And the Motion is as follows:

In pursuance of the Prime Minister’s letter dated 10th June, 214, calling upon the Speaker to constitute a Parliamentary Committee, subject to approval of the House, to evaluate shortcomings of previous elections and make recommendations for electoral reforms to

252

ensure that elections are held in a free, fair and transparent manner, this House under Rule 244(B) of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the National Assembly, 2007, authorizes the Speaker, National Assembly, in consultation with the Chairman Senate and Leaders of the Parliamentary Parties in the House, to constitute the said Committee comprising members from all the Parliamentary Parties in proportion to their representation in the Parliament. The Speaker may replace any member of the Committee on request of the Leader of the Parliamentary Party concerned.

2. The scope of work of the Committee will include, but not be limited to, making recommendations in respect of electoral reforms, required to ensure free, fair and transparent elections, including adoption of the latest technology, available for holding elections, alongwith draft legislation, including Constitutional Amendments, if required for this purpose.

253

3. Quorum to constitute a sitting of Parliamentary Committee for Electoral Reforms shall be one fourth of the total membership. 4. The Committee may make rules for regulating its procedure. 5. The Committee shall present its report to the Parliament within three months from the date of the notification of the Committee. Thank you Mr. Speaker.

Mr. Speaker: Now I put the Motion to the House. The question is that the Motion as moved be adopted. (Consequently the Motion is adopted unanimously.)

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: ¥=.8R5´ 6�7,p ;�/(5-7BR 9* )FG B )P; ? M=Na -b( 5* mR b1RE L1

,-.,;K6: L,XY )FG B )P; ?E �=K

3/B ¥=.8R5´ 6�7,pE

POINTS OF ORDER

254

6s,-K67 �= K3/9V(�6 K} ¥=.8R5´: ;�¦6? I= .9{

3_ 9{= KXN_ 6�7,pE b5Ê9X : B5WGD M=Na = .( I°±(1 (5WGà o

- ¹,[-C( M=N

-.,6Y æU C,-p M=N

U.5WGà ;�¦6? )/ qË- A -B )

U C 5WGà T=NÂ5X C ,k B(R9* q³6 ? d Ø�-C ,= . (à

q�* B1( Å-g3§ ,k B(R9* q³6 ? d Ø�

-C ,= . (à `( o* qÐ;K¢6 C(1 q³6 ? d Ø�-C o

U ¹ (E `( M=Na @Wr )- C b,>=? ¸,À6 ? 8B1R q³6 ? ào* T=C9X : T

-CdÌ-C,k M=Na ;s,6 . q³6 ? o*E B1( @Wr )

- C delegation q³6 ? ,6 t=�P6 ? 6f,>- �j -b (dÎV( M=NaE `( delegation M=Na ¥a, 3_ M=NÀ

; ? L2W c,È Ñ¿ ( ¡B,JWr @=?( -M=:( m(à Ñ¿ ( -M= N

-K¢7à @=?( -M=:( m(à -¾ =�3/ fxp -M=:�Â(

B1( I6 Y(5-7 ¥=K¦§ B5Ü- OjE

)ñ -b(-R( 6sd-åj( 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: q6A �= K

3/B ¥=.8R5´ 6�7,pE 6s,-K67 �= K

3/9V(�6 K} ¥=.8R5´: 6f,>- �j -b (dÎV( M=Na -b,;K¢*,X . qh(5} = .9g;? )*

b5- O*B,k 5* �=K¦3§ ,= K* ,= K* ,= K´ 5; C `( )* �°6 C @Wr )

- C b,>=? )/ delegation 6 t=�P6 ?, mB,JWr MNAs ,kE Iª2; nth ¡B,JWr MNA L2W c,È Ñ¿ ( I6 K7,pà Ñ¿ ( à -M= N

-K¢7 -¾ =�3/ fxp -M=:�Â(à I6 Y(5

-7 ¥=K¦§ B5Ü- Ojà I= . ¸5V b,W c1 )U O´ It;?,¼ qó89X :à `( )* �°6 C L1

¥8KXN_,W c )U O´E 56 7 ¥8KXN_,W c M=Na I= . b,W c1 IX . ¶{= .R )FG B )P; ?à ,6Y )FG B )P

; ?à 5; C ¶X g· â5{ 3[j R(di( -b( )* ,X . ` )

U C ( Ñ¿ ( -M=N-K¢7 )* o

U ¹,À6 ? )* `,X . B1( b5; O*97 o* B1( ¥»

3/ o* I6 Y1 L1 )/ â5{ 3[j \Â )FG B )P; ?E b5¦- ?( )

- C ,>· )´ ( 1R 8RB(1 Xs ( B1( ¶{= .R 5VE -b( o* q8 �PX A T7 +,k o

U ¹ ( B1( -b( 5* b5¦- ?( )- C ,>· IS

b,W c @Wr ); C ( M=NWc B1( I= . R5-7 b,W c1 )/ ¥»

-C )U O´ B1( )´ ( 1R 8RB(1 M=N>- ? )PQ¬.RE I= .

5; C `( ;s(B ,k I°±(1 ,;.,;K6: Eb5WG `( )* �°6 C M=Na ¥k ¾ 6�¿ 5* IÁ-.5= O* L1 )®>? +(9´19X : -b( ,k I= . ,À

; ? IS ¥k ¾ 6�¿ 5* I= . -M=N¼�;. M=:9* )´E -M{= KV b5; C(B ;s(B -M=N¼�;. 9* 5; C (2= nª +(9´19X : -M6 : ,»X 7 ,À; ?E M=Na b,W c1 ,X t

-�¦X? b5WG B5WGD M=Na = .( )]�6? B1( 1R )]�6? (B,JWr ;<º1 ,À; ?

255

6f,>- �j -b (dÎV( àM=Na B,> Øè( ;<=:-9= :-då;C q³6 ? ,-.9* ,À; ? B1( -b( )* b5P·R IX . 5¢µ( ` q³6 ? ,-.9* ,À; ? B1( )/ ( ;s,°±(1 I- . b5WG `( )* )U OV ;s,6 . q³6 ? o

- ¹9* q³; ?E M=Na b,W c1

,= K´ b5WG b,W c1 qh(5} = .9g;? )* M=Na2; n¼R B1( 6f,>- �j -b (dÎV( )* 2; n¼R M=NaE Z,ç;C(

)/ m2= nª b,W c1 ); C ,6Y )

U C 5WG PTI )* ;�ÎÆ3/ R5y�h q³6 ? R56 75j )P; ?E b,W c1 It

;?,¼ qó89X :à ;s,6 . ;�=OX7 q³6 ?( 5WG q WrB q³

; ?à 5; C = .( oU ¹5* M=N>

- ?( ,k L�-K6: ,= . -b5* L�-K6: ,À; ?à ¥U.,6 .5j )V )* ,= . ( IS L2W c,È Ñ¿ ( X .I = K

8 :( (5WG )FGE 5; C M=Na )- C ,>· IS L1

5; C ¡B,JWr MNA M=NWcE dPX ? @Wr b,W c1 )/ )®»-CE -b( )* b,= Kj ,k 26 nJ

-? ( 8�-.5Ú8Rà -b( )* b,= Kj )* 26 nJ

-? )- C 8�-.5Ú8R )* �°6 C Ñ¿ ( 5* -b5µ ,= K* 5; C b5¦- ?( )

- C ,k IS @Wr -¾ =�

3/ �= .-B ¥8KXN_,W c ,6Y )FG B M=NWcE @Wr )

- C b,W c1 )/ ¡8B,Ò oU ¹,J³êà Z,ç;C( )/

b5- C1R b,= .

8B,Òà ¶; ?,_ M=Na T-N=KV56 Oy=?( q³6 ? q³

; ? B1( ¡B,JWr q³6 ? ¶; ?,_ oU ¹ (E 6�67 9X g=?28 n_

)/ D,»-C ,= K´ 5; C ,[= C( \Â ,W cB ,À; ? IS -b5-7 q Wr -b5-7 )FG B1( 9´ ,W cB )FG ¥[®[jE -b( o* q8 �=N6. q³

; ? B1( -b( ,k B5= OU :(B8R ,À; ?E 5; C ,ÀX A5X C M=Na )- C -b( )/ IS @Wr -b5j

8�=O*B,a )* 6<=:dº )/ `,X . 5WG )FG B )P; ? = .(E 5; C )®>? = .( 8s1di )V (1

qó89= :B )´ ( oU ¹ ( 5; C M=NJWr ¡8B,Ò I;K¢WG ( o

- ¹9* ¡89X :E ¡8B,Ò 6�67 I;K¢WG ( o* 5; C q�* m�-K6: )

- C L -B(1BR X¾-�=NÀ· )* ©5P· ,= KV B1( D56 Cà o6¹,6 t

-�X: M=Na `( )- C ;s,6 . o*à I-Kj

9X : )8 C ,É8R )Ú �-K6: )

U C 5WG )P; ? IS 5

; C L2W c,È Ñ¿ ( )FGE `( )- C ,>· IS b,W cà 5; C

L1 D56 C IS M=Na M=N>Ë; ? oV5´ B,a b1R ,ÒE L1 ã, 3_,a '( BR,>6? -b5; C, -Y àM=NWc ¡896 : 8�Â56 C

M=NWcE L1 `( ;<º1 q³6 ? M=N>- ? M=:B8RE IÁ-.D,Y ¥U.,6 .5j 9´( ¥

3[= NXK/ ,;.5WG 9{X K=N_ 6�7,p! b5¦- ?( )

- C b,= .8B5X 7 q³6 ? q

- �¦X? oU ¹5WG M=NÀ

; ?E)´ ( 3T=C8R 8RB56 C 9X : ¥U.,6 .5j q³6 ? (89X : (5WG ,À; ?E -b( o* q8 �=N6. ¶; ?,W c)* M=Na -M=N

;. ¥U.,6 .5j )P; ?à -b( )* B5= OU:(B8R `,X .)* = .( ¥U.,6 .5j

,À; ?à -b( o* 6�=O67 M=Na )¢¬N¯. m89X : )U C 5WG )P

; ? b5= O* \-KX:, 3_ )- C 9* q¨»

-C oU ¹5WG q³

; ? B1( `( �°6 C)* b5¦- ?( )

- C +x_( R,6 . ( ,-. ( ,À; ?E

256

M=Na -b(2= n¤ `( ;<º1 (5WG 6�67 ,= .8�= Kj M=Na I;KX: M=N>

- ? T* )V (57 )/à q�* B5= OU:(B8R )V (57)* )/à q³6 �* q¨J= �µ )* )/ )V (57 B1( q³6 �* T=NÂ5X C æ

U C(B-R)* )/E 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_! @Wr 6�/ qXA(9* M=Na )- OFG B M=NWc)V (1à B5WGD M=Na )- OFG B M=NWc)V (1à 6�/ IÃ6Y mobile snatch M=NWc)

; C 5WGE q�* )- Cmobile snatch 5*

)8 C ,É8R ×�-.,6 . )* M=N>

- ? ,ÀQ= .R ,Ò5WG IS ¥U.,6 .5j oU ¹5* ,8 .,É8R Ú �-.,6 .) M=N>

- ? ,;.5WGEI-Kj 9X : (82X nS ,É�-.,6 . (5WG ,À; ? B1( �2Í M=NÀQ

-. ( d Ø�-C q WrB ( M=NÀ

; ? B1( Iª2; nth )/ ,ÀX A5X C IS 5; C

2W c,È Ñ¿ ( )FGà( ` )- C D56 C IS b,W c ’`( )* ,>· IS M=Na )P]�

;? oV5´ b1B,a ,Òà)P]�h oV5´ )

- C B,a ,6 t=�P6 ? ,= K´ `(E)FG ,>·)- C IS B,a )* ,À·RE

9{= KXN_ 6�7,p ! `( )

- C b,= KV5´ M=:B,aE = .( oV5´ b,>=? M=NÃÂà 56 7 arteries o

; ¹5WG M=NWcà 56 7 oU ¹,6 . `,X . M=Na +,k o

; ¹ ( M=NWcà damage 5WG )* hip o* =K

U:,_ 8� M=NUK´à ¡241R oV5´ qÐÂ 5; C I- .,3Kj 5* o

; ¹ 8B,ÀX ? oU ¹5WG q¨»

-CE`( �°6 C)* -M

3 ¢= C9X : ( (5WGE b128 nS(8R o* @=�8 : 5* M=Na 6f(9

-7 -M=N[g;? 3T=NX. b5WG,;.9* IS

)- O;: ( )P¯A ( b128 nS(8R o* @=�8 : M=Na )

- C mB5X C -b,;K¢*,X . M=Na M=N>· M=N>- ? q³Q= .R b5¦- �67

)- C ,-K; :( +,k B1(,= K* qå±(1 q³6 ?( ;. L1 ¸,6Y M=NWc)FG BE M=Na b,W c1 )/ ,= . ( b5WG IS B1( )P]�h �-K=N-. ,k I6 K®

- w )FG -M{= KV L1 -B28 nS(8R o* @=�8 : q³6 ?( ;. R56 75j à)FG ,ÉR ( I8 K

-NÀê 8�¢=CB o

; ¹9* )FG B1( dPX ? o; ¹,6Y ( E)FG 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p -b( o* ;�=OÓ6 O² ’ -b5-7 o*

¶8 N[-N=KX: M=Nv

;.56 C drain out oU ¹5WG M=NWcE`( )* �°6 C -b( ,k -M

3 ¢= C9X : ( (5WGà -M3 ¢= C9X : (

)- C 5WG �°6 C)* 6�67 o

U ¹ ( q§ 5= C M=Na )V ,= .,6Y ,= K´E 8�v6 . q�* ,k q³6 ? ,;. ( )FG 5; C body `( 5* absorb M=N>

- ? 9* q WrB q³; ?à clotting 0123 4 5WG qU �´ )FGà

clotting 0123 4 oU ¹5WG 5; C ;s(B )* -M=N

;. )]�6? oU ¹5* M=N>· )/ o

U ¹(1R oU ¹(5Ä-Kj

qU �´ B1( L�w,£,6 . -B28 nS(8R )- C -b�-KV -b5µ ,= K*à IÁ=.dh( -b5µ ,= K* IS b,W c1 9X : Xs (

257

b,W c)* qí=? (1R ©,Jå;N_( o

; ¹5WG )FGE ;s(B 5* ¥»= C 8�= Kj B58 N_ (5®À· )* b128 nS(8R )- C L1 (1R provide o

U ¹(19*E`( �°6 C)* clotting 5; C âB qU �´à 2; n>6? qU �´5WG 6�®Þj L1 )´ ( damage M=N>

- ? 9* q WrB -M{= KV -b( ,k o6¹ oX¹ 50à45 IX . ,À; ?E ;s(B 5* )Ú 8B,_ -M=N

;. )]�6? 30à25 5WG ,= K´ ,À; ? B1( I= . ¡896 : â,-.d�-7

;sB5¿ ©,Y q³; ? B1( ¾ 6�¿ ;s,_ )]�6? '( )

- C oU ¹5* L-96 gåj 9* )* ,= .,À·R IS

50à55 B1( 60 )* 6<=:dº ,X t-�¦X? B1( b5¦- ?( )

- C M=NÀQ-. ( M=NÂ5P·à -b( b,= Kj)*

)- Oj ,_ )P; ? 5; C -b( 5* b5PQ-. ( )/ 6s(56 7 ,= .RE q8 �=N6. qU �´ B1( @Wr ¸5V )U O´E`( )*

`R 8�- Oj �°6 C L1 dPX ? o´R5- O- } o* ;<V,Y M=Na q XY M=N

UK´ B1( `( ;<º1 -b( ,k o6¹ oX¹ 40à45 -b,=KjBR)* ,À; ? ’ 6�67 M=Na )

- C X¾-?,X . )8 O

-NÀê )®>? B5WGD ( 8B5PX A E)FG

9{= KXN_ 6�7,p ! (2= nª I6 KV,Þj I= . )FG IS ¡B,JWr -b5; C, -Y MNA ,XY)- C B I°µR

;�j5{Y 6s,6 t-�X: 5* o

8 ¹B5= O{= K/ )U OV )* 28 n=KV -B )PQÂ M=NWc -b( B,XY b5- O=N>h M=Na ’ 1R I°µR ¶6 gh )/ L9* -�;. q³6 ? 9* qQXY M=NÀ

; ?EB,XY I°µR 6�67 -B28 n=KV )PQÂ 5; C ;�j5{Y 6s,6 t-�X: 5*

`,[7( ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XY ,À; ? ’ M=Na �2Í `( )U OV M=N>- ? IS criticize 9* b5WG,W cB IS

-b,;K¢*,X . @¨[j \= KV) -b5- C( à)FG q�* q³6 ? o

U ¹,6 .5¿ ;�j5{Y 5* 9´( MNA ,= . @=?( oX¹ m( 28 n=KV ,;KPQÂ )FG IS )P]�h )/ )- O¯: ( +,-. )/ self defence )* )U OV It¨_( )¬OFG ,XY 5; C -b( 5* provide ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XYà facilitate ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XYE )´ ( ,= K* ,;KPQÂ )FG IS )P]�h security threats M=NWcE 5; C ( ` )* security

threats 5* ,ÀQ= .R )U C ,6Yà ,X t

-?,6Y )U C ,6Y B1( `( 5* security provide o*

)U C ,6YE `( 5* security provide M=N>

- ? o* qU �´ B1( I= . I3 .R,Y ,J-?1B (5WGE

258

9{= KXN_ 6�7,p ! ¥k ;s(B 5* ¶X g· rumours 3 R9´ 9* )FG B )P; ? IS

M=Na 2W c,6 . b5®»-C ,Ò 5; C )P]�h 8�WG ,= K* )

U C ,6Y ,ÒE Xs ( o* o- ¹,6 .2îhà 9{= KXN_ 26 nJ= �X7 -B

b5- C1R o* ’ Xs ( b5´5V )

- C facilitate ,= K*E )P]�h B5WGD )/ )V )* +x_( R,6 . ( ;. T=NÂ5X C 8RB,Ò ,= K¦h ,= K* ,= K´à )P¯�=�X: ¥U.,6 .5j q XYE M=Na b5WG,;K¦· IS 9´( o

U ¹5* qhR ( ;�/(5-7BR ,;.9* )FGà9´( `( o* -b,6Y 56 7 d�-7 L à)FG @Wr 6�/ b5

- C,[-C( o* -b,6Y

o* ;�y=�± 96 :(96 : )FG ,XYE)FG = .( �p,£ ,k ,8K=N6. 5WG ,= . )FG ,XY 9= : -B1 ,k ,8K=N6. à5WG M=Na ,;KP6 �Ë§ b5WG IS -b,[

-C( o* -b,6Y o* ;�y=�± = .( )FG b5= O* IS b,a Xs,6 . 5* q Wr1 RBR ,;.5WG ,-K;N 6Y)FG 2= nª( qhR ( 5* ,;.5WG B1()FG ,-K;N 6Y 6<=:d-Ô qhR ( 5* ,;.5WG E)FG )8 O¬N]. 6�/

M=NWc); C 5WG)P]�

-?,_)*à b,= K8N=K6: 6�/ o* q³6 �

-?,_ o; ¹5WG M=NWcE

9{= KXN_ 6�7,p! 9´( o

U ¹5* request 5; C)FG ,; .9* `( o* request 5* entertain ,= K* E)

U C ,6Y M=Na `( -b(5= C( mB,_)* 26 nJh )/ b5WG,;K¦· IS 9´( request o* qU �´ B1()FG ;�j5{Y ;<º1 )/ b5WG,;K¦· IS Xs ( ¡9U:(5{-.( EM=N

U.(9* Iª2; nth 2W c,È Ñ¿ ( o* request b,W c1 9X : q³

; ? ,= . M=N>- ? q³

; ?E`( ,k IvÕ=Oµ Xs ( M=:9*à Xs ( qWr o* o

8 ¹B,X . o* ;�j5{Y E)FG 9{= KXN_ 6�7,p 9´( security provide o* o

; ¹,6Y 5; C �= ., 3_ I= . I°±(1 I- . ,;.5WGà o´�-. -B ;s5j '( ¶; ?,W c)* M=Na à)FG æÆ-C -b,ÕÖ

-C )]C ^3_ '( ¶; ?,W c)* M=Na )FG -M{= KV '( q³6 ?)- C 5; C ,>· )FG’ q6�

-: @=?9* �)

- C ,= .,adi )FG IS )®>? 8<- :1( 5* 5Ú�-.,6 . dPX ? ¥k5; C 19*E M=NJWr5

; C qè,= K

;NY( 2= n6.(�;. )®>? o- ¹9* M=N=K WG,XY IS,;. )¢¬C ( ;s,°±(1 ,J

-?1B I- . b5WGE

9{= KXN_ 6�7,p ! ;s(B 5* B,6 . B,6 . m2= nª `,X . àT=NÂ5X C q§ q§ oX¹ 1(à T=C( X¾ =?( 1( )FG B ( )P

; ? IS Xs ( 5®»-C 5; C ;�¦6? ¥À6 �-N_ )U O®»

-C)* ,Òà Xs ( 5®»-C )´ 5; C

259

;�¦6? ¶X g· 5WG ,;K{_ )FGE M=Na )- C ,>· IS 56 7 ¶X g· ,-.5WG ,Ò5WGà 5WG )

U C ,6Y ,ÒE )P]�h = .( ItËz 9X :1( M=N>

- ? ,Ò)®aà = .( ItËz @· M=N>- ? )®a ,Òà (2= nª -b,J= ?( B1( L�= KÖ} E)FG

I am not Molvi Mullah -M{= KV 6sB )- C ¡2= nª o´�-. -B q

- �;N 6Y q³QÂ à)FG )P]�h = .( ¥X. LR,= .

-B M=N>- ? )®a B1( = .( ¥X. @· M=N>

- ? )®a ,ÒE )P]�h �5-7 M=N>- ?

,À; ?à o- ¹, 3[= C9X : M=N>

- ? q³; ? -M{= KV 56 7 b,W c1 B5WGD o* ¡8dP· q³

; ?à¡B,JWr o8 ¹B,X . )* q³6 ?

¶X g· ¸5V )P; ?à L1 m896 : �5-7 LR -B )P

; ? B1( )P]�h 89{X . 89{X . ); OV 56 C)* )P; ? IS ¥=.8R5´

oU ¹,À6 ? 2= n

-°6 C o8 ¹B5= O{= K/ I- .)* ,-.,6YE M=Na b5WG,;K¦· IS 9´( b5¦- ?( )

- C request ¡R q³; ? 5; C @· -B( @· request 5* 5; C entertain ,= K* ,;.,6YE

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: q6A = KP

8 ? E)FG

6s,-K67 �= K3/9V(�6 K} ¥=.8R5´: M=Na b5WG,;K¦· IS `( ;<º1 -b( 5* ,wR o*

;sB12- Í E)FG 2W c 26 nJh )- O¯: ( dPê M=Na )- O¯: ( ¡5= O6: b5X g6? )U OV )* ,wR ,;.9* à)FG )- O¯: ( -M=:�Â(1 V )*)U O ,wR )FG ,; .9* 5; C -b( o* ;�gß va,kI )U OV )* ,wR m9*E L1 `( ;<º1 ;�¦6? Ñ= O®»

;C M=Na )FG B1( ;�¦6? critical condition M=Na )FGE -b( )* b5®;.,£ 5* q³6 ? B,;Kµ9´ ,= K* ;�j5{YE)

U C ,6Y 6s,6 t-�X: `( IX . +,k m9*E 56 7 T=NÂ5X C

o* 8sB5X CB )FGà56 7 T=NÂ5X C q- �X:( -b,6Y )

- C (8dPX A )U OV )* o; ¹9* )FG IS `( )

- C ¥U.,6 .5j -M=NÀX A E,=KV 24 ( ` )/ ¥U.,6 .5j -M=NÀX A ,= KV ,;.5WGà +,-. ¶X 75X C (B,a)* ,= K´ à)FG ¥U.,6 .5j ,-K

-N=KPX A ,;.5WG 5; C ¥U.,6 .5j ,Ç-C,a ,;.,6Yà )¢¬N¯. )Ä-. ,a ); C ,6Y -M{= KV ,[= C( ¶X g· M=N>

- ? ;�¦6?E(5WG I= .9{

3_ 9{= KXN_ E 6�7,p

260

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: ¡2= nª ;s(B 5* = .( )]�6? Administrator )/ ¡9-7 ( ;s,6 . o

U ¹5WG q³; ?E¾ 6�¿ ¶8 ? ( )]�6? q³6 ? Administrator )/ ;s,6 . o

U ¹5WGà 6f ( 2îX?1R 5* ×89= :8R )]�6? q³6 ? ;s,6 . o

U ¹5WG q³; ?E @�6 7 M=Na ¶8 ? ( M=Nv

;.56 C M=N=K WG,XY o; ¹5WG M=NWc

9Äa ,6 K=:dÎ;C T=NÂ,;K

-NX. )/ LR,= .-B \Â qQXY M=NWcà 56 7 )P]�h ¡9

-7 ( 26 n-¤ q¨a q³

; ?E @Wr 6�/ o* ,wR )FG IS '( �oV,°;C -b( 5* ;�gß mRE

6s,-K67 �= K3/9V(�6 K} ¥=.8R5´: M=Na Xs ( ,k I= .9{

3_ b5WG,;.9* IS Xs ( )- C ¡896 :

3T3Ê5* o*E

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: M=N>- ? (2= nª I= .9{

3_ o*)- C 9*(R( ;sB12- Í M=N>

- ? E)FG I= . ¡2= nª Iª-R ¡B(R E)FG +1�-th L, 3_ R5y�h q3 �= Cdº E 6�7,p

+1�-th L, 3_ R5y�h -M=N[7 q3 �= Cdº: I= .9{3_ 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_E 6s,-K67 9{= K=NXK/! 56 7 ¥=.8R5´

6�7,p )- C ,= .,adi )FGàM=NJWr 6�/ 5* ¡B5X C ¡B5X C ¡RB�JWr )FG B1( @Wr `( )å± (1

o* ;�j -�a M=NWc); C 9*à `5¢µ((896 : â,-. I°±(1 E)FG ¡B,JWr \= KV5* M=NWcà `( U1,W c o*

26 nJh M=NWc B1( -b( ¶; ?,_)* I= . RBR â,-. I°±(1 3T=NX. ,= . ( @WrE)FG 6�/ ,wR 5´ M=NWc IS '( oV,°;C -b(�� 5* ;�gß va,kI ,Þ} )

U C ,adi B1( -b( o* dËÔ -B(BR )U C ,adi B1( L1 ;�gß

6s,= . 5WG o* TXC(1 q6 Ky§( M=Na q- �X:( ;s,a� -Y 24 +,6 t

-?( M=:RE 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! 6f ( M=Na Xs ( 5* = .( Iª-R ¡B(R ’9=: -B1 @

ØÙ}( )- C Û-7 ,ÀQÂ B1( `( Û-7 o* 9X :R,= K

-N6. ;�j5{Y B1( -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C( )- C B 8�= KV � ( ¡R -M

3 ¢= C -B5X C( o* q Wr(96 :24 M=Na ;sB1, 3[j o* B1( qU �* ¡B,JWr M=N

;K¢3¢-C M=N

U.5WGE -b( b5; N[3¢-C ,k �ÕÖj I= . ,À

; ? IS ;�6 O3Na )Î¬C d² )/ )´ ( )U C ,É896 :E`( ^va o* -¾ =?B,;. `( ;s,6 . o* L(5´ )FG IS mB,JWr ^va )*

261

;s,6 .,-t;�-:( 9X : I= KV(5Ê -b, 3[

-C ,;KÄÂ ,W cB à)FG �,ç3/ M=N>- ? )

; C 5WG B,W cE)FG B )- C D(1

-é(2; nð( ,;.9* ,W cB B1()FG )- O;N¬K67 )V (1 9X : �= KÖ

-O; : o; ¹5WG q WrB E)FG 2; n_ )* �°6 C )- O

;N]Y ;s,6 .,

-t;�-:( )

U C ( M=NWcà @· 1 3T=N6. q�= C( ;sB5¿ ©,Y q WrB E)FG

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! Xs ( 5* R,= . )FG IS = .9g;? �,Õ

- C( 2= nUKX7)* -M=Na -b(dËÔ -b,-Y 6�7,p )

- C q- �X:( q¨>X? 9= :dÎ

;C M=Na q§( )]C -�6Y ,k B,> Øè( ,= K* ,À; ? B1( ,>· ,À; ? IS M=NJWr )´ ( ,-KÚ896 : )¬OFG ,XYE ,-.,a IS 2013 )* ;s,6 .,

-t;�-:( 9X : M=NJWr serious

reservations M=NWcE @Wr ); OP]�§ IS L1 �,ç 3/ I- . )P; ?à @Wr ); OP]�Ë§ M=NWc

mandate ,= .(9X 7 ,= K´ -M{= KV )´ ( M=NWc); OÚ 896 : B1( `( )U OV )* Xs ( )- C q³6 ? = .(

,ÀX A( role play )- C 9* o* 3T

3Ê5* Eo* 6s,-K67 9{= KXN_ ! Xs ( )- C ,ÀQ= .R IS

mB5X C -b(5= C( )- C Xs ( ¶; ?,_)* -b1,°;C ,= K* )FG B1( @Wr `( -2= nX¤ ,k �(2; nð( M=:9*

)´ B1( M=NJWr oU ¹5* ^3_ M=N>

- ? IS 9= : -B1 @ØÙ}( )

- C = .( = K-: )]C -�6Y 5*

)- Oj ,_ ); OP·B )U C 5WG `( -2= nX¤ ,À·B)´ ( )FGà`( -b(5= C( )* )- Oj ,_ ,À·B @WrE)FG Xs (

o* guidance M=Na )´ ( ,-KÚ896 : M=NWc,XY )´ B1( ,;KÓ±(1 ;s,Yxp( M=NWc,XY )´E T* @�± o* ;s,Yxp( M=NWc,XY )´ IS I3[= NJWr )* )¬OV `( ^va M=Na ,[= C( +, ØÞ

-C �B,°;Oj (19* ,=.R )

U C ,6Y IS -b,;K¢*,X . )* ;s,6 .,-t;�-:( 9X : L�-KU: ( I= KV(5Ê -b, 3[

-C oU ¹5* )

- C ,À8 ?( o* ;s96 7 I- . m9* T67 )/ ;<=:B5¦Ë6A 5* ;�j,½;N_( ®a) o´E B,6 . B,6 . I= . I3_� -Y ,;K WGB )FG IS o

U ¹5* 6�3/ -b5-7 5WG ,Ò o

U ¹5* derail m9* ,ÒE oU ¹5* derail M=N>

- ? 9* ,;K{_ 6�67 +5± lÆ

;Oj 5WG o´ B1( 6�67 `( Z,ç;C(9X : 5WG )U C ,6YE �,ç 3/ ;s,6 .,

-t;�-:( o* I6 Y1

)/ I= . ;�j5{Y q- �6: )FG B1( dPX ? 6�/ )- O¯: ( ;<º1 ,k B, ØÞ;O

-:( M=:9* )´ B1( ¡B5X C 8�- Oy=�VB,X . q

- �X:( +98 : ¥JQa m9* o´ B1( = .( smooth transition 5WG o´

262

from a political government to an elected, another elected political government.

6s( ( ){_ )¬OV mB,JWr `189X : M=Na -b,;K/1�-K WG M=Na ©,3Kj @

U ?,£ 5WG qQXY )FG IS b5¦- ?( )

- C )- O¯: ( -M3 ¢{= KV( -M

3 ¢= NJ· 5* ,-K;:( ä56 O-Üj B1( ,-K; :( R5-7 B,;K-gh 9* ,= .R )FG IS L1 ^va )* @

ØÙ}(9= : -B1 5* m2î8 �* M=Na (8dP· 9* ,;K{_ )FGE L1 q�* 9= : -B1 5* = KX7 9* ,;K{_ )FGE@

ØÙ}(9= : -B1 9´( q =K WG 28 nX.,k ,k ©,Jå;N_( 9* ,;K{_ )FG 5; C L1 `( o* 3T

-C -B24 9* ,;K{_ )FGE 24 M=NJWr `( @�± ,k -M

3 ¢{= KV( -M3 ¢= NJ· )¬OFG ,XYE M=NJWr I= . -M

3 ¢{= KV( -M3 ¢= NJ·

M=N>- ? )¬OFG ,XY 56 7 6f ( -M

3 ¢{= KV( -M3 ¢= NJ· -b,;K¢*,X . ,k M=NJWr o

U ¹,À·R mR ,W cB )FGE I= . (89Ä-KV I= . D5V 6f,;Kgh -M

3 ¢{= KV( -M3 ¢= NJ· M=NJWr M=N>

- ? )¬OFG ,XY B1( `( 9X : +�w R,J;�}( ,k B,> Øè( 9* ){¯Y M=NWcE 6s,-K67 D(1 M=NJWr )¢¬C ( -M=N

-.(5± )¬OFG ,XY IS oU ¹5* 9´( 89´ 896 : ,-.9* )FG ,XY

q³6 ? 5; C -b5- C,£ `( 5* ;s -B,6Y( I- . mRE M=NJWr ,[= C( b(9Ä-. 8�=N_ Xs( )¬OFG ,XY 56 7

�2Í �-KX7 b5´5V )* b5P; ?,W c M=Na I- . )®¬KP·E = .( ,[= C( b(9Ä-. 8�=N_ Xs( 5WG T67 M=Na 6�/ 5* R,J;�}( 5WG IS I= . �,ç3/ -M

3 ¢{= KV( )- C (9* o* `( M=Na ;�=O®W c( )FGE 6f (

;�¦6? )/ ¸5V 56 7 M=:5ÚB,À8 ?( @=�j9;: M=Na ¥a, 3_ )P; ? 56 7 6f ( `( ;s,6 . 9X : lÆ

;Oj oU ¹,À·R

mR M=NWcB M=NWc b(9Ä-. 8�=N_ Xs( 9X : = K-: q; �=N

-. )/ I= . IvÕ=Oµ ,= K* ,= K´ `( 9X : I= KV(5Ê -b, 3[

-C ¶8 ?( )FG B M=NWcE -96 g6A o* o; ¹,-K=N°

;C ,k 56 7 = K-: q; �=N

-. )/ IvÕ=Oµ ,= K* ,= K´E 6f ( -96 g6A o* o

; ¹,-K=N°;C 9X : 56 7 -b(26 nJh q8 �=NJ· M=NWc �= .5

- C dËº 6�7,p Ñ= C23 ï;C ,adi M=NWcE

6f ( `( 5* revisit 9* )FG B M=NWcE 6s,-K67 D(1 M=Na q- �X:( ;s,6 . @

; � -7 ,;.9* b5WG -B,J-?

,k ;<º1 )FGE T67 spirit )/ `( -2= nX¤ 5* )´ ( )- C ,É896 : o* 3T

3Ê5* o* )FG '(, 3[

-C( Xs ( M=NJWr ;�6 O3Na M=NU.,X . )´E M=NJWr = .( I3_� -Y )FG B1( I= . M=Na 8RB,»= CB ,-.(9*

,;K WG,XY b5WG B 8�= KV � ( ¡R -M3 ¢= C -B5X C( Ñ= C23 ï

;C ,adi M=NWc B1( M=Na 26 nJ= �X7 M=Na I>· ,»X 7 b5WG

263

IS `( 5* delaying tactics )* B5² 9X : I- . ©,Jå;N_( ,= K* )

U C ,6YE -M=N;. )- O¬N>h

o* ;�®>h ¡R qU �´ )FG `( q8 �=NJ· 5* B1( -M=N;. )- O¬N>h )* B�-.( M=NJWr -bR ;s(B = .(

9* )* ;�=O-: q; �=N-. )/ `( +,k 5* ¥JQa ,-.9* )¬OFG ,XYE I= . I- . 5WG IS @Wr )®¬K7

b5- C,>6? o* 8B ( ); O¬NÂ )

U C 5WG -b( -M=N;. b5- O=N>h 5* -M=N

;. ©,_ M=Na ¥=.�6 K;: 9* M=:RE

6s,-K67 D(1 -M=N;. )- O¬N>h 6�67 ¥JQa 5WG M=N

U.,6Y 5; C `( q8 �=NJ· ,k 8<=: 8�-K=Na @; � -7 5WG ,-.,6Y

)¬OFG ,XY B1( Xs ( o* ;�j� -Y M=Na 2- Í,Y ,-.5WG )¬OFG ,XYE 9´( -M=N;. )- O¬N>h M=Na q

- �X:( q8 �=NJ· ,-KX:( +,k ¥JQa M=N>

- ? 9* q; �{_ 5; C q8 �=NJ· q- �X:( ;<=:R,¼( 5P· qQXY o

; ¹5WGE I= . -2= nX¤ 8RB,»= CB o* )U C ,6Y IS within three months @Wr ¥a 9* `( +,k 5* )´ ( M=N

U.,É896 : B1( Z,ç;C( )

U C (B )/ @=�j(9;: M=:9* B1( 9´( -M=NU. ( M=Na @=�j9;: o

- ¹9* o; ¹89X : )FG 5; C M=NJWr

-M=NU. ( M=Na q³6 ? @=�j9;: o

- ¹9* )¬OFG ,XYE For free, fair, transparent, credible elections in Pakistan. Thank you, Sir.

6s,-K67 9{= KXN_: +1�-th 6�7,p `( M=Na = .( clause add o* qU �´ q³

; ? IS -M=N;. )- O¬N>h )* �°6 C another one month extendable 56 7 M=Na )

- C oppose ,= K* ,À; ? IS M=N>

- ?E -M=N;. )- O¬N>h ,k 6�®Þj )FG -M=N

;. )- O¬N>h M=Na o* )U C ,6YE

IÁv6 . M=Na )- O¯: ( 2U n-K=N_ \= KV5* )/ B1( ¡B,_ ¥»= O8N=KV5X C -2= n8.B,X . )/ 8�¢=C5{= .B b19* ,Ò

¥k )¢¬N]Y q Wr (B,JWr -M3 ¢= N_ conclude ,;.5WG )FGE ;<º1 I- . æ

U C,-p M=:9* ¥k q Wr \-K8N=Kj 9* )* +,-. )V M=NÂ 56 7 56 7 o

- ¹,J= �VB,X . o8 ¹B,X . )* -BB 8�= KV M=NWc -M6 7 5*include

,-.9* )FG ,= K* @8 �¢/ ,-.,-K6: )FGE M=Na 8�¢=C5{= .B b19* ,Ò Xs ( 5* circular q³6 ? 9*

M=:R )´E )¢¬N]Y q Wr adjourn 5WG ,Ò -M3 ¢= N_ (B,JWr B1( 6�/ o

8 ¹B,X . )* B 8�= KV 9´( ( M=NU.,6Y )´ m2= nª -B26 nJ= �X7 M=Na B1( @Wr dPX ? = .( \-K8N=Kj 9* )* conclude 9* M=NÂ )´ ;<º1 æ

U C,-p )¬O* 2= n-°6 CE EI= .9{

3_

264

The House is adjourned to meet again on Friday, the 20th June, 2014, at 10.00 a.m. (The House was adjourned to meet again on Friday, the 20th June, 2014, at 10:00 a.m.)

national assembly of pakistan · national assembly of pakistan assembly debates thursday, the 19th...

Documents