ir lect ic theories.pptx 2013b
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
1/121
Unit IC
Theories ofInternational
Politics
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
2/121
Theoretical Models of IP
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
3/121
Theoretical Models of IP
1. Positivist:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
4/121
Theoretical Models of IP
1. Positivist:
Empirical/Scientific Approach
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
5/121
Theoretical Models of IP
1. Positivist:
Empirical/Scientific Approach Value-free/non-relativistic
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
6/121
Theoretical Models of IP
2. Post-Positivist:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
7/121
Theoretical Models of IP
2. Post-Positivist:
Normative/ Philosophical
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
8/121
Theoretical Models of IP
2. Post-Positivist:
Normative/ Philosophical Value-based
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
9/121
Theoretical Models of IP
3. Positivist Theories
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
10/121
Theoretical Models of IP
3. Positivist Theories
Realism: Focus on Power of State
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
11/121
Theoretical Models of IP
3. Positivist Theories
Realism: Focus on Power of State Liberalism: Focus on cooperative
relationships between states
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
12/121
Theoretical Models of IP
3. Positivist Theories
Realism: Focus on Power of State Liberalism: Focus on cooperative
relationships between states
Neo-Liberalism: Focus on economic
relationships between States & Non-States
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
13/121
Theoretical Models of IP
4. Post-Positivist Theories
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
14/121
Theoretical Models of IP
4. Post-Positivist Theories
Constructivism: Focus on norms &Actor-identity
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
15/121
Theoretical Models of IP
4. Post-Positivist Theories
Constructivism: Focus on norms &Actor-identity
English School: Focus on shared norms& values
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
16/121
Theoretical Models of IP
4. Post-Positivist Theories
Constructivism: Focus on norms &Actor-identity
English School: Focus on shared norms& values
Marxist/Neo-Marxist: Focus on social
class & economics
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
17/121
Theoretical Models of IP
4. Post-Positivist Theories
Constructivism: Focus on norms &Actor-identity
English School: Focus on shared norms& values
Marxist/Neo-Marxist: Focus on social
class & economics - AKA Radical Model
R li (M il ) Old t
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
18/121
Realist (Mercantile) : Oldest
R li t (M til ) Old t
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
19/121
Realist (Mercantile) : Oldest
1. Conflict between Nations
R li t (M til ) Old t
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
20/121
Realist (Mercantile) : Oldest
The drive to power is a
fundamental aspect of
human nature.
(Thucydides)
1. Conflict between Nations
R li t (M til ) Old t
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
21/121
Realist (Mercantile) : Oldest
2.Mercantilism: Goal ofNational policy is to
maximize State power.
R li t (M til ) Old t
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
22/121
{IG} C
Conflict
{IG}
Resolved by
Power
Realist (Mercantile) : Oldest
3. Structural Realism:
R li t (M til ) Old t
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
23/121
{IG} C
Conflict
{IG}
Resolved by
Power
Realist (Mercantile) : Oldest
Conflict result of Anarchy
= lack of power above
nation states.
3. Structural Realism:
R li t (M til ) Old t
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
24/121
{IG} C
Conflict
{IG}
Resolved by
Power
Realist (Mercantile) : Oldest
Conflict result of Anarchy
= lack of power above
nation states.
3. Structural Realism:
Realist:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
25/121
Realist:
Zero-sum game: Only one can win
4. Assumptions:
Realist:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
26/121
Realist:
Zero-sum game: Only one can win
Competition > Cooperation
4. Assumptions:
Realist:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
27/121
Realist:
4. Assumptions:
Realpolitik: Nationspursue self interest
over collective good
Realist:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
28/121
Realist:
Nations = Rational Actors
Realist:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
29/121
Realist:
Nations = Rational Actors
Goal = Maximize Power and PositiveOutcomes
Realist:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
30/121
Realist:
Nations = Rational Actors
Goal = Maximize Power and PositiveOutcomes
Statism: Focus on the role and power ofindividual states.
Neo Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
31/121
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
Neo Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
32/121
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
1. Anarchy & Self Help
Neo Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
33/121
1. Anarchy & Self Help
National security can onlybe realized through Self-
Help. (Kenneth Waltz, :
Theory of International
Politics):
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
Neo Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
34/121
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
2. SECURITY DILEMMA
Security Dilemma:
Military Preparation togain security leads to
greater international
Insecurity.
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
35/121
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
Security Dilemma:
Military Preparation togain security leads to
greater international
Insecurity.
2. SECURITY DILEMMA
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
36/121
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
Security Dilemma:
Military Preparation togain security leads to
greater international
Insecurity.
2. SECURITY DILEMMA
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
37/121
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
3. Global Ideological Conflict
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
38/121
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
3. Global Ideological Conflict
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
39/121
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
Samuel Huntington: Clash of Civilizations
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
40/121
Neo Realist:Post World War II
Samuel Huntington: Clash of Civilizations
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
41/121
Neo Realist:Post World War II
Samuel Huntington: Clash of Civilizations
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
42/121
Neo Realist:Post World War II
Samuel Huntington: Clash of Civilizations
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
43/121
Neo Realist:Post World War II
Samuel Huntington: Clash of Civilizations
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
44/121
Neo Realist:Post World War II
Samuel Huntington: Clash of Civilizations
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
45/121
Neo Realist:Post World War II
Samuel Huntington: Clash of Civilizations
Neo-Realist:Post World War II
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
46/121
Neo Realist:Post World War II
Samuel Huntington: Clash of Civilizations
Liberal (Idealist):
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
47/121
Liberal (Idealist):
1. IR Goal = Cooperation between Nations
Liberal (Idealist):
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
48/121
Liberal (Idealist):
1. IR Goal = Cooperation between Nations
= Interde endenc
Liberal (Idealist):
2 Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
49/121
Immanuel Kant
1724-1804
Liberal (Idealist): 2. Assumptions
Liberal (Idealist):
2 Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
50/121
Immanuel Kant
1724-1804
ibe al ( dealist):
Cooperation Possible between States
2. Assumptions
Liberal (Idealist):
2 Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
51/121
Immanuel Kant
1724-1804
( ):
Cooperation Possible between States
Liberal States = More cooperative and Peaceful
2. Assumptions
Liberal (Idealist):
2 Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
52/121
( )
Cooperation Possible between States
Liberal States = More cooperative and Peaceful
FDR: Arsenal ofDemocracy
Wilson: Making the World
Safe For Democracy
2. Assumptions
Liberal (Idealist):
2 Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
53/121
Immanuel Kant
1724-1804
( )
Reciprocity Principle:States capable of
foregoing short-term individual gain
for long-term community well-being
2. Assumptions
Liberal (Idealist):
2 Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
54/121
Immanuel Kant
1724-1804
( )
Reciprocity Principle:States capable of
foregoing short-term individual gain
for long-term community well-being
Liberal Institutionalism Trans-National
Institutions To Enforce Reciprocity
2. Assumptions
Liberal (Idealist):
2 Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
55/121
( )
Reciprocity Principle:States capable of
foregoing short-term individual gain
for long-term community well-being
States can develop a
world Federation
Immanuel Kant
1724-1804
Liberal Institutionalism Trans-National
Institutions To Enforce Reciprocity
2. Assumptions
Liberal (Idealist):
2 Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
56/121
( )
Reciprocity Principle:States capable of
foregoing short-term individual gain
for long-term community well-being
States can develop a
world Federation
Liberal Institutionalism Trans-National
Institutions To Enforce Reciprocity
FDR: UNWilson: League of Nations
2. Assumptions
Liberal (Idealist):
2 Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
57/121
( )
Reciprocity Principle:States capable of
foregoing short-term individual gain
for long-term community well-being
States can develop a
world Federation
Immanuel Kant
1724-1804
Trade promotes Peace
Liberal Institutionalism Trans-National
Institutions To Enforce Reciprocity
2. Assumptions
Liberal (Idealist):
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
58/121
3. Cooperation through Free Trade
( )
Liberal (Idealist):
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
59/121
3. Cooperation through Free Trade
( )
International System = Rational,
Independent States
Liberal (Idealist):
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
60/121
3. Cooperation through Free Trade
( )
International System = Rational,
Independent States
Trade = National Self Interest
Liberal (Idealist):
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
61/121
3. Cooperation through Free Trade
( )
International System = Rational,
Independent States
Trade = National Self Interest
Trade = Cooperation = Interdependency
Liberal (Idealist):
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
62/121
( )
Interdependency
3. Cooperation through Free Trade
Liberal (Idealist):
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
63/121
Value Peace > Value of War
Interdependency
3. Cooperation through Free Trade
Liberal (Idealist):
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
64/121
Value Peace > Value of War
US v. Canada
Interdependency
3. Cooperation through Free Trade
Liberal (Idealist):
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
65/121
Value Peace > Value of War
US v. Canada
Interdependency
3. Cooperation through Free Trade
Neo-Liberal: 4. Regime Theory
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
66/121
g y
Neo-Liberal:
4. Regime Theory
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
67/121
International Regimes: Global system of
rules & norms
g y
Neo-Liberal:
4. Regime Theory
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
68/121
International Regimes: Global system of
rules & norms
Established Multi-laterally
g y
Neo-Liberal:
4. Regime Theory
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
69/121
International Regimes: Global system of
rules & norms
Established Multi-laterally
TNGIs (Trans National Governing Institutions)
g y
Constructivism: 1. IR = Social Constrtuction
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
70/121
1. IR Social Constrtuction
Constructivism: 1. IR = Social Constrtuction
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
71/121
Berger & Luckman, Social Construction of Reality (1966)
1. IR Social Constrtuction
Constructivism: 1. IR = Social Constrtuction
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
72/121
Berger & Luckman, Social Construction of Reality (1966)
1. IR Social Constrtuction
Constructivism: IR = Social Constrtuction
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
73/121
IR Social Constrtuction
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
74/121
Constructivism:
1. IR = Social Constrtuction
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
75/121
Alexander Wendt
Anarchy is What StatesMake of It:
the Social Construction ofPower Politics" (1992)
1. IR Social Constrtuction
Constructivism: 2. Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
76/121
Focus on norms & Actor-identity
Constructivism: 2. Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
77/121
Focus on norms & Actor-identity
IR determined by ideas rather than
material forces
Constructivism: 2. Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
78/121
Identities of actors are constructed
by shared/exclusive ideas
Constructivism:
2. Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
79/121
National interest not
pre-existing.
Constructivism: 2. Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
80/121
National interest not
pre-existing.
Product of social value
Constructivism:
2. Assumptions
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
81/121
National interest not
pre-existing.
Product of social value
World Bank &
Poverty
Radical:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
82/121
Radical: 1. Exploitation between Nations
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
83/121
Radical: 1. Exploitation between Nations
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
84/121
Marx:
Radical: 1. Exploitation between Nations
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
85/121
Marx: International Politics =
global extension of class struggle
1. Exploitation between NationsRadical:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
86/121
Marx: International Politics =
global extension of class struggle
1. Exploitation between NationsRadical:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
87/121
Marx: International Politics =
global extension of class struggle
Lenin: Global Class Struggle =
Capitalist states v. Rest
1. Exploitation between NationsRadical:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
88/121
Marx: International Politics =
global extension of class struggle
Lenin: Global Class Struggle =
Capitalist states v. Rest =
Imperialism: Final stage of
Capitalism
Radical:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
89/121
2. Marxist Socialism
Radical:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
90/121
2. Marxist Socialism
Imperialism Caused by Market Saturation
Radical:
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
91/121
2. Marxist Socialism
Imperialism Caused by Market SaturationImperialism = questfor new markets for
goods & capital.
John A. Hobson,Imperialism (1902):
Radical
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
92/121
2. Marxist Socialism
Imperialism Caused by Market Saturation
Imperialism = result of
Domestic monopoly tendencyExported abroad.
V.I. Lenin,
Imperialism, The HighestStage of Capitalism (1916):
Imperialism Caused by Market Saturation
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
93/121
Imperialism Caused by Market Saturation
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
94/121
Imperialism Caused by Market Saturation
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
95/121
Imperialism Caused by Market Saturation
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
96/121
Imperialism Caused by Market Saturation
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
97/121
Radical
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
98/121
2. Marxist Socialism
Imperialism Caused by Market Saturation Inevitable collapse of Global Capitalism
Imperialism Caused by Market Saturation
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
99/121
Imperialism Caused by Market Saturation
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
100/121
Imperialism Caused by Market Saturation
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
101/121
Radical
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
102/121
3. Gramscian Analysis
Radical
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
103/121
3. Gramscian Analysis
Antonio Gramsci, 1920s Italian Communism
Radical
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
104/121
3. Gramscian Analysis
Antonio Gramsci, 1920s Italian Communism Emphasis on cultural & social roles of
hegemony (beyond economic)
Radical
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
105/121
3. Gramscian Analysis
Antonio Gramsci, 1920s Italian Communism Emphasis on cultural & social roles of
hegemony (beyond economic)
Historic Bloc = union of state & culturalpower: e.g. Liberal
Bourgeois Society
Radical
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
106/121
3. Gramscian Analysis
1970s: Development ofTransnational Historic Blocs
Radical
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
107/121
3. Gramscian Analysis
1970s: Development ofTransnational Historic Blocs
Starbucks/MacSociety
Radical 4. World Systems Theory
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
108/121
Radical 4. World Systems Theory
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
109/121
Systems of Globaleconomic/political power
dominates IR
Radical 4. World Systems Theory
I l W ll t i Th I t f
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
110/121
Systems of Globaleconomic/political power
dominates IR
Immanuel Wallerstein: Three Instances of
Hegemony in the History of the CapitalistWorld Economy.
Radical 4. World Systems Theory
I l W ll t i Th I t f
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
111/121
Immanuel Wallerstein: Three Instances of
Hegemony in the History of the CapitalistWorld Economy.
Neo-Radical 5. Post-Colonialism
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
112/121
Neo-Radical 5. Post-Colonialism
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
113/121
Globalization = Exploitation
Neo-Radical: 5. Post-Colonialism
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
114/121
Globalization = Exploitation
Neo-Colonialism: Economic rather than politicalcontrol of poor countries by rich countries
Neo-Radical
5. Post-Colonialism
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
115/121
Globalization = Exploitation
Neo-Colonialism: Economic rather than politicalcontrol of poor countries by rich countries
Dependency Theory: Poor nations poor due to
economic domination by rich nations.
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
116/121
Neo-Radical: Post Colonialism
6 D d (D d i ) Th
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
117/121
6. Dependency (Dependencia) Theory
Raul Prebisch, (1950)EconomicDevelopment of Latin America
History of colonialism =
export & import dependency
Neo-Radical: Post Colonialism
6 D d (D d i ) Th
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
118/121
6. Dependency (Dependencia) Theory
Raul Prebisch, (1950)EconomicDevelopment of Latin America
History of colonialism =
export & import dependency
Same mercantilerelationship withoutpolitical control
Best Paradigm?
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
119/121
Best Paradigm?
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
120/121
Best Paradigm?
-
7/27/2019 IR LECT IC Theories.pptx 2013b
121/121
?