“shopper’s stop conference call” - aceanalyser.com call/132638_20080429.pdf · shopper’s...
Post on 15-Feb-2018
217 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
Page 1 of 26
“Shopper’s Stop Conference Call”
MODERATORS: MR. B. S. NAGESH - MANAGING DIRECTOR,
SHOPPER’S STOP LIMITED.
MR. GOVIND SHRIKHANDE – CEO, SHOPPER’S STOP
LIMITED.
MR. NAVALKAR – GROUP CFO, SHOPPER’S STOP
LIMITED.
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 2 of 26
Moderator: Ladies and Gentleman, good evening. I am Rochelle, the moderator, for this conference
call. Welcome to the conference call of Shopper’s Stop Limited, Mr. B S Nagesh is our call
leader for today. For the duration of this presentation all participants’ lines will be in the
listen-only mode. After the presentation, the question and answer session will be conducted
for the participants on this conference call. I would now like to hand the conference over to
Mr. B S Nagesh, thank you and over to you Mr. Nagesh.
B S Nagesh: Thank you Rochelle, good evening everybody. Welcome to our first call of the new
financial year, new financial year, April has begun; I am sitting with new visiting cards, a
new logo, and a new identity. But, I am still sitting with myself; Govind Shrikhande, our
CEO; and Navalkar, our group CFO. So, we are with new excitement and new identity
We are very happy with the way the last quarter has gone on the revenue side. We have
seen the last financial year having performed well on the like-to-like although somewhere
around the 3rd quarter it looked like that like-to-like was slipping, but the business has
really caught on very well, including the new initiatives revenue on our like-to-like basis.
So I think that is a very-very good situation that we are in as of today. We have had very-
very good launch of new identity, new logo, and a lot of changes had been done. We have
posted a slightly edited version of a presentation which I would request my colleagues
Govind Shrikhande to take you through.
We have also had a turnaround in terms of our new initiative Crossword has made profits
at EBITDA level, cash profits, Mother Care has net profits, Mac & Clinique has net profit.
And the three verticals which are still to turnaround are Home Stop, Arcelia, and F&B.
And I think there we are still facing different challenges although Arcelia is looking very
positive, HomeStop is looking positive, F&B there are still challenges, so will share those
challenges as we go forward.
I would also like to inform you that as on 26th of March we have submitted a document for
our rights issue. And therefore, now we are in a period where we are being governed by
the SEBI laws. And therefore in this conference call, till the time our issues closes we will
be constrained by not being able to talk to all our investors, anything more than that what
we have already put in into the document. And therefore please pardon us if we have to say
no to some of your questions or maybe you do not ask us those questions.
I will now hand it over to Mr. Govind Shrikhande to take you through the whole branding,
the significance of it, and how it is going to make a difference to us. Then I also request
him to make the presentation and discuss things with you, Navalkar will join in between to
talk about Crossword’s turnaround as the CEO of Crossword apart from being the group
CFO of the business. And I am here to take up answers to your question, post Govind
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 3 of 26
finishing his presentation. I will hand it over now to Govind. And I will again come back
when the Q&A starts, over to you Govind.
Govind Shrikhande: Good evening friends. I am going to take you through the brand changes that we have done
and the brand philosophy change that we have done. If you can open the first slide on this
logo that we changed, I would start from there. I hope all of you have opened the 1st slide,
it is the new logo, Shopper’s Stop, Start Something New, that is the new thought process
that we have taken. Start Something New is not a line for us, it is a new philosophy. We
believe that we need to change a lot of things within the company as consumers outside
have been changing. So we have embarked on the whole program of touching all the
customer through our new 360 degree experience, cutting across various facets within the
store and outside the store.On the next slide, you can see the consumer in the center and
various touch points that we have tried to reconfigure for our, Start Something New
experience and we will take you through one by one each one of them.
The first one is on the brand positioning, if you look at Shopper’s Stop as a company and
as a department store, when we started off in 1991, we were a contemporary department
store, maintained that position over the years by launching various categories, brands as
well. And over the last two years we had tried to move upward towards bridge to luxury
position in a numbers of stores and you can see that in Juhu, Rajouri, and Malad where we
have launched a number of bridge to luxury brands from Lancome or a MAC or CK Jeans
or French Connection or Tom Hilfiger, all this brands are adding to that, customer’s
experience and aspirations of bridge to luxury. So we are moving up the ladder as for of
customer aspiration is concern. Therefore, we are on top in the positioning of the
department store.
Moving on to the next touch point which is talking about the brand logo and the brand
symbol, brand logo as you know the current, the earlier brand logos that we had which are
the oval shape, talked about our core value such as trust, comfort, and warmth. We needed
something which is much more dynamic we needed something which is progressive and
really portrayed as a thought leader in the department store industry. And that way we
adopted this new logo, and you must have seen various ads on TV, where the oval evolves
into a rectangle through a very good mechanism. And that is what you see the new logo
right now. Along with the new logo we also adopted a new symbol. If you see various
brands have various symbols like a Nike has a swoosh, and the swoosh really means
something to every customer. For our SS as a Shopper’s Stop it also stands as a think
beyond philosophy. So as if you look at this SS logo now, symbol now it tells you about
infinity and it also portrays our positioning which is bridge to luxury. And you will also
find within the store over the next few months lot of products carrying this symbol. You
can now see the applications of the new logo and symbol on our letterhead, envelopes on
our visiting cards then store facades for example, what you are going to see right now is
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 4 of 26
our Bannerghatta Road at Bangalore and you will see the new logo and the facades on all
the stores across India right now.
Moving on the next touch point is about service in the store, last few months we had spent
a lot of time training and upgrading the service standards of all our associates. We also
covered the security and housekeeping in all the stores. And we do believe that customers
will see the difference in the kind of service standards. Next point is uniform. When the
customers enter the store, they interact with associates more and more and the kind of
uniform that we have catered is this moving towards the bridge to luxury positioning,
black and white stripe shirt for both men and women and black and white polka doted saris
for women as well, with the black trouser in a formal area and black jeans in the semi-
formal area which is easily a very-very sophisticated statement for the customer and very
fashionable.
Moving on to the touch point merchandise, as I mention earlier you have already launched
a number of brands across various categories in apparels as well as non-apparels right from
a CK to BOSS in watches to CK, Armani, Gucci in sunglasses. And other brands are
already mentioned in the apparel and cosmetics side too, apart from that we are also
upgrading our exclusive brands like In-Sense which is becoming more glamorous, Push
and Shove which is becoming more cutting edge fashion and Haute Curry which is fusion
brand for us is becoming more tikha and chatpata as well, with these we are dealing about
fashion quotient of the department store will only keep on increasing in future.
In ambience, we have launched for the first time in India a concept called Shopper’s Stop
Radio, similar to FM Radio where you hear radio jockeys, you will now hear radio jockeys
talking in the store, giving you tips on various things right from dressing sense to picking
up the right merchandise for your folk, buying up the right furniture, picking up the right
cuisine along with different kinds of music and the music keeps on changing throughout
the day where in morning you have a soulful music while in the evening the tempo keeps
on increasing and it will also be interspersed with regional topics.
Apart from that we are also changing for example offering taste within every store,
offering a small café or a proper restaurant within it. And you will also find lighting levels
going up and even merchandize being presented in superior fixture and better kind of
wrapping paper as well or gift paper. We will just show you in the next slide and a gift
paper, a new gift paper which is in black and white as well as white and black and for
special occasions you also have it silver on white. We believe this goes very well, very
contemporary and very classy.
And in store design basically we have been increasing the size of a store from 45,000 to
65,000 now moving towards 85,000. And a special feature that we are now offering to our
women customer is day and night lighting in women’s trial room. We believe women are
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 5 of 26
always very careful about the choice of merchandize that they make. And they always
want to check it out, how does a dress look like during day, how does the dress look like in
the night. And we are making it easier for them to make their choice in our trial room. This
is a first time happening in India.
Next to shopping bags - Shopper’s Stop shopping bags are extremely popular world over.
And for the first time we are not only carrying a new logo and symbol on a shopping bag.
We are also offering a limited edition of fashion shopping bags that for this time they are
depicting fashions through the last 30 years and you will be definitely very happy to carry
the shopping bags anywhere around the world.
Moving on to loyalty, we are expanding our loyalty program. These are the redesigned
cards further with the co-branded logo as well and the loyalty program has already crossed
a million and contributing more than 65% of the sales. \
For the associate behavior in order to get a similarity of spirit a similarity of service
standards serving the customer beyond their own deliverables, we have created an anthem
and the anthem is called “Hadh Se Aage”. We have also created a think beyond book
which tells them stories, real stories within Shopper’s Shop where some of our associates
have gone beyond their capabilities and delivered excellent service to our customers. We
believe that weekly initiative will bring together all our associates in order to deliver
exemplary services to customers as well as making them happy everyday, every minute
that they are in the store, making their every visit special.
The next touch point is owning a cause, we believe that environment and environment
awareness is extremely important for a retailer like us. And like our shopping bags are
recyclable we also thought about Life which is our exclusive brand owning up a cause like
Think Green. So the Life merchandise for the summer season with every Life product you
will get a merchandise which is free, which is Neem Seed Pack along with the Life
merchandise and we are targeting to distribute 1.5 Lakh seeds throughout India in the next
90 days time. We kicked off this whole initiative by planting 150 trees at Inorbit Mall and
some of our associates are now going ahead and mending and tending to trees themselves
at their homes as well as the office and we will go on a bigger drive to plant more trees in
future.
Advertising, you will see advertising happening in three stages, the launch of the logo in
the media has already happened, you must have seen the Times of India as well as
Hindustan Times carrying the cover page with the change of logo. As well as lot of TV
advertising which has already broken, as well as logo advertising happening through IPL
matches as well as hoardings. The next level of campaign is going to happen at a brand
campaign and I will show you some of the brand campaign visuals which are going to start
in the print media right now in the next few days’ time. This is the first part of the
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 6 of 26
campaign and as usual the whole campaign is centered around two factors tongue in cheek,
it has lot of fashionable models in it at the same time it is showing a concern about the
whole environment. So, for example this particular ad when you see a great model but the
great model is giving distraction to the poacher and that way we are trying to say “Preserve
Wild Life”, Shopper’s Stop, Start Something New. The next slide for example talks about
giving a toy to a kid to buy a toy, keep him engrossed, and that way “Reduce Noise
Pollution”, Shopper’s Stop, Start Something New. So for us Start Something New is a
philosophy of not only changing logo or symbol, or the shopping bag, or the behavior we
also want all our customers to look at various ways of trying to look at the same thing
differently and start something new. So for example in this particular ad we are saying
“Save Paper” and so on and so forth in this particular saying “Save Water, Conserve
Water” and this ad for example which is one of our favorites “Wear Diamonds, Attract Ex-
Boyfriend, Recycle” Shopper’s Stop, Start Something New. So the whole message in the
print ad campaign is Tongue in Cheek, Start Something New and asking our customer to
really look at things anew, afresh, and really enjoy themselves while shopping.
We have also taken the communication at the store level and we are starting a significant
campaign within the store, where customers can come in and sign in a flash book to Start
Something New. For example giving up smoking could be Start Something New.
We are also putting in communication in other areas like parking, elevators and select
merchandise areas asking the customer to Start Something New. So for example, this is
what you will find in formal footwear area a pair of Nike or Adidas will be kept with the
sign ad saying Run and Start Something New, that is the whole message in this whole
philosophy. So the whole philosophy that I talked about of Start Something New we have
tried to take to all the touch points and you will see the same thing as well in our two film
campaign which will also start getting released in the next few hours and days across
various channels. And they again communicate a similar message of Start Something New.
So that is what I wanted to talk to you on the whole philosophy change.
Now let us run through the whole business overview I will first open the Page #1 of the
Business Overview. At Page 3 Shopper’s Stop opened its 24th store at Kolkata at South
City. We have also opened the second store for Airport Retail in Hyderabad. Crossword
opened its 48th store in Kanhaiya Mall at Bandra and the First Citizen number base crossed
a million and increase of 30% over last year and their contribution to sales for the year was
more then 65%. As Mr. Nagesh mentioned earlier draft letter of offer for right issue has
been file with SEBI on 26th March and our new brand Logo and Emblem was launched on
23rd April by Mr. Shahrukh Khan. Mr. Salil Nair was promoted to the position of COO of
Shopper’s Stop. His brief profile has been giving in the last slide of presentation. Rather
than waiting for the last slide to appear let me talk about Salil, Salil has been working with
us for more then 15 years and he has looked at various positions from the time he has
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 7 of 26
joined. He was a Retail Operation Manager at Bangalore then he move to the Hyderabad
Store and then he became head of operations located at Mumbai. From there on he moved
to the B&M by handling the non-apparel portfolio then the men’s portfolio and then the
whole of buying and merchandizing. After that he also took over the portfolio of store
planning and now as a COO he will handle both buying and merchandizing and operations.
And we believe he will able to give the right impetus to the discipline in operation and
improving the efficiency and productivity along with great service standard for the
customers.
Coming back on awards, I feel extremely proud to tell you about both the awards that we
have won. Both the awards that we have won have come from the World Retail Congress,
the first has been Mr. Nagesh was inducted into the World Retail Hall of Fame. And it s a
very proud moment for us because he is the first Asian as well to be inducted into this Hall
of Fame and it had such celebrities like Sam Walton of Wal-Mart, Charles Walgreen of
Walgreens, and Marvin Traub of Bloomingdales, and Jeff Bezos of Amazon. So, he has
now joined all these big guns in the Hall of Fame, Shopper’s Stop also won the Emerging
Market Retail of the Year in World Retail Congress in the same function. And the other
awards were won by Tesco, H&M and Woolworths at the same time. We also won the
award for the Most Admired Fashion Retail Destination for The Year at IFA.
Moving to the next slide on page#5, our presence is still expanding, Shopper’s Stop today
has 24 stores, Home Stop 3, Mother Care 18 including 9 Shop & Shops, Mac & Clinique
put together 5, 4 Macs and 1 Clinique, F&B has 25 with 13 Shop & Shops. We have two
airports stores. Crossword has the 26th including 10 Shop & Shops and we have 2 Arcelia
total coverage is 16,01,000 square feet. These are all photographs of the new store both for
Kanhaiya Shopping Center at Crossword at Kanhaiya Shopping at Bandra, Linking Road,
which is 3700 square feet. This is the store of MAC at Kemps Corner. Page 8 you can see
the South City Store of Kolkata. It is a beautiful store.
In terms of store area on Page 9 now, the total additions for the year you can see,
Shopper’s Stop 3,50,00 Home Stop 27,629, and Specialty of 53,000. So, total store area as
of 31st March was 1.6 million square feet.
I am now moving on to Page 10 with the key financial highlights of Q4. The sales growth
for Shopper’s Stop Department Stores was 34% all format grew by 38% the like-to-like
sales growth for Shopper’s Stop Department Store is 16% with store greater than 5 years
growth at 6% and the stores less than 5 years going very well at 28%. All formats grew
same store growth at 25%. Sales of square feet on chargeable area for Shopper’s Stop
Department Stores were at 2161 versus 2230 of last year and all formats were at 2080
versus 2120 of last year. Overall customer entry increased by more than 25%.
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 8 of 26
Moving on to Page 11, key financial highlights for the whole of year, sales growth of
Shopper’s Stop Department Store was 28% and all formats was at 34%, like-to-like sales
for growth for Shopper’s Stop Department Store was at 14% with stores greater than 5
years at growth of 6% and store less than 5 years at a growth of 25%. All formats like-to-
like growth was at 20%. Shopper’s Stop Department Stores sales per square feet on
chargeable basis increased from 8810 to 8979 and all formats sales increased from 7973 to
8671. Overall customer entry increased by 28%. I can see the same data in a graphical
format like-to-like sales growth, all formats up by 25% sales per square feet flat in fact it
has degrown. For the whole year like-to-like has grown 20% all formats and all formats
sales per square feet grew by 9% from 7973 to 8671. Operational indicators for Q4
customer entry was up by 25% and conversion ratio is at 26% whereas like-to-like stores
conversion is up by 8%. Transaction size is up by 7% whereas like-to-like transaction size
is up by 9%. ASP is up by 5% like-to-like volume growth for Q4 was 11%.
In terms of the full financial year, customer entry was up by 28% and like-to-like stores
grown by 5% entry. Conversion ratio is down with like-to-like stores degrown by 1% as
the entry was up much higher than normal. We have seen a downward slide in conversion,
whereas the transaction side continued to grow well from 1562 to 1721 a jump of 10% and
like-to-like sales store transaction side grew at 11%. Average selling price grew by 7%
whereas like-to-like volume growth was also 7%.
Moving on to Page 16, the private labels sales mix came down slightly from about 20.6%
to 19.8% whereas the merchandise buying model bought out also came down from 60% to
57% whereas all others have remained almost more or less the same. In terms of
merchandise mix for the full financial year the private label mix was down by 0.5% from
20.6% to 20.1% and the merchandise model again bought out is down from 60% to 58%
others are more or less similar whereas private label sales overall increased by 28% for the
whole year which is inline business top-line growth in sales.
In terms of category wise sales, if you look at Quarter 4, non-apparel continues to be
growing and it has grown from 42.2% to 42.7% and same thing you will also see in the full
financial year from 41.1% to 41.4%. All other categories what you are seeing women share
for example is almost constant and children share has been growing now even for the
quarter as well as for the year. When we look at the revenue mix for the whole year
apparel is down from 58.9% to 58.6% and non-apparel was up from 41.1% to 41.4%
whereas division wise we are now seeing that non-apparels is the highest with 41.4%
followed by menswear at 31.7%, women share has been maintained, and kids share has
actually gone up from 8% to 9.5%. The key drivers in the non-apparel category having
home, leather, watches, jewellery, electronics and personal accessories like sunglasses.
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 9 of 26
Moving on to Page 20, shrinkage in the last quarter was slightly higher than the whole of
the year it moved up from 0.47% to 0.70% but for the whole year we were still able to
maintain at the level of last year. So against the 0.46% of last year we are at 0.47% in this
year which continues to be one of the lowest benchmark.
Page#22 is now the format wise P&L. We have clubbed all the new initiatives like Home
Stop, Crossword, Mother Care, Mac & Clinique, Arcelia, Food & Beverage under the new
initiative. And Shopper’s Stop Departments Store has been shown separately. So when you
see there the revenues 2758 million of Shopper’s Stop and new initiatives is 436 total
contributing to 3195 and against the gross margin in Shopper’s Stop are 29.9, the new
initiatives are at a 32.4, overall at 30.2. But operating expenses in Shopper’s Stop are at
24.5% whereas on the new initiative the expenses are still higher at 44.8, giving overall at
27.2, it leaves the EBITDA of Shopper’s Stop Department Store at 7.4 whereas the new
initiatives are continued to be at a loss at -9.4% and overall Shopper’s Stop Limited
EBITDA at 5.1%. Our finance charges and depreciation have been higher, this year for
both Shopper’s Stop as well as our new initiative, leading to PBT of Shopper’s Stop at a 99
million for Q4, at a percentage 3.6 whereas the new initiative is a loss of 62 million at a -
14.2%, the net Shopper’s Stop Limited PBT is at 37.6 million leaving at 1.2%. This is the
financial summary for Q4 2007-2008 for Shopper’s Stop Limited. Retail turnover up by
38% from 2356 millions to 3261 millions, margin on sale is also up by 35% from 716
million to 965 millions and margin on sale is slightly lower from 30.9 to 30.2 whereas
operating expenses are up from 25.7 to 27.2. As operating profit is almost maintained at
163 millions against 161 million of last year, a 1% jump, so operating profit as a
percentages has drop to 5.1% against 7% of last year, PBT is up from 26 million of last
year to 37 million in this year and PBT is up this year by 186% from a (-22 to19.5 million)
this year.
We move to format wise P&L for the full financial year of 2007-2008, when we look at the
revenue of Shopper’s Stop Department Stores cross the 1000 Crore benchmark this year
which is a significant milestone as far as we are concerned and the new initiatives were at
142 Crores all put together we are at Rs.11,900 millions turnover. Gross margin in
Shopper’s Stop was at 31.8% whereas operating expenses are at 26.4%, leaving a EBITDA
of 6.9% which if you recollect that two years back we are at about 8% EBITDA we are
currently cruising at a 7% and with finance charges at 0.4% and depreciation at 3.2% the
PBT is at a 3.4% at 354 millions on a 10472 millions turnover. The new initiative against
the 1428 million turnover the gross margins is at 33% whereas the operating expenses
continue to be at a slightly higher level of 45.4% leaving a -139 million and the percentage
EBITDA is at -9.7%. Overall Shopper’s Stop Limited is at a turnover of 11900 million
with operating expenses of 28% and margin of 32%, EBITDA of 4.9% and a PBT of 1.2%,
post-depreciation and finance charges of 3.7%. So we notice that as Mr. Nagesh had
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 10 of 26
commented earlier that Shopper’s Stop continues to grow from strength-to-strength and
some of the new initiatives are now turning cash positive.
Coming back to the financial summary of 2007-2008 for the full financial year from an
8995 million we are up by 34% at 12069 million. Margin on sales is up by 37% so from
31.4% to 32%. Operating expenses are also up from 25.6% to 28.7% as well as the
operating profits is now at 586 million against 696 million of last year. Post finance
income, finance expense and depreciation PBT is at 145 million against 487 of last year so
PBT is at 1.2% versus 5.5% of last year and PAT is now at 69 million versus 261 million
of last year.
Page 26, you can see the same representation graphically with turnover, gross cash margin,
EBITDA, and PAT for Q4. On Page 27 you will find that a similar graphical
representation for the full financial year for again sales, cash margins, EBITDA, and PAT.
On Page 28, you will find the operation efficiency indicator as GMROF is up from 677 to
724 for Shopper’s Stop like-to-like department stores, GMROI is down by 10% from
1.01% to 0.91% whereas GMROL is up by 10%.
On Slide #29 you are seeing GMROF down at 9% for Quarter 4 and GMROI is down by
6% and GMROL is up by 11%. Page 30 is for the full financial year. The operational
efficiency GMROF wise we are up by 14%, GMROI we are 3% up, and GMROL we are
6% up and this is for like-to-like department store. And operational efficiency for the full
all stores GMROF is up by 4%, GMROI is up 3%, and GMROL is almost flat. I will now
handover to CB Navalkar: to comment on the Crosswords numbers. Thank you.
CB Navalkar: Thank you Govind. Good afternoon to all of you. Taking you to Slide #33 the Crosswords
financials for the Q4. I must say it has been a good year for Crosswords, with 48 stores and
healthy 17% like-to-like growth we have been able to show a profit after tax for Q4 in the
Crossword Book Stores Limited.
I will run you through the financials. Strictly the financials are not comparable with last
year’s quarter, because we changed the system of royalty with our franchises where earlier
we used to supply merchandised books and music through the franchises, this year it is a
pure royalty arrangement which we have with the franchises so the retail turnover which
shows a drop from 53 million to 22 million is not comparable so I will straight take you
through the profit before tax with all the effects it reached at 5 million for the current
quarter for the Q4 2008 again 4.3 million and after tax which is the MAT which we had to
take for full year. The profit after tax is 4.1 million down from 4.4 million. This in
Crossword Book Stores Limited, let me remind you that Crosswords is franchised all its
own stores operations to Shopper’s Stop Limited .Combined with CBL and Shopper’s
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 11 of 26
Stop, Crossword operations in Shopper’s Stop there is a cash profit which has been
recorded in Q4 and also for the full year.
For the full year financials I will take you to Slide #34. In the full year again the turnover
is down from 403 to 99 million because of the change of the royalty term, but profit before
tax I will take you straight to that, the profit before tax is up from -1.4 million loss last year
to 18.3 million profit and after the MAT tax the profit after tax is 15.9 million against 1.6
million loss for the last year full year.
I will take you through the consolidate financials also taking over Slide #36 consolidate
turnover was at Rs.3.2 billion against last year’s Rs.2.4 billion. Let me remind you the
consolidation includes not only Shopper’s Stop Ltd. but also Crosswords Book Stores Ltd
which is a 100% subsidiary, Hypercity Retail India Ltd. to the extent we have shareholding
at 19%, Gateway Multi Channel Ltd shareholding is 51%, Time Zone Entertainment we
have 45% and Nuance Group is 50% shareholding incidentally Nuance Group, the airport
operations commenced in March for Hyderabad Airport and is scheduled to commence in
May for the Bangalore Airport that is when it will become fully functional for the contract
we have signed in India. The margin on sales this is consolidated with all the formats reads
at 993 million for the quarter against 812, an increase of 22%. The EBITDA is 142 million
against 162 million in last year, the growth of 12%, and it is a 4.4% of the revenue. After
finance charges which have moved from an income which was a 3.9 million of income last
year to 31.6 million of financial charges, and depreciation which after we changed the
method of actually the useful life last year has reduced in Q4 from 151 to 117, the profit
before tax is negative of 6 million against 15.6 million last year. After-tax and minority
interest, the profit after tax is 3.9 million negative against 33.9 million negative last year.
Taking you to Slide #37, the consolidated financial for the full year 2007-2008, the retail
turnover is at 12.2 million a major weightage of Shopper’s Stop Limited, against last year
at 9.2 billion, 31% growth. Margin on sales at 3.9 billion against 2.9 billion last year and
operating profit of 581 million against 717 million, and again financial charges which have
changed from a finance income to finance expense and depreciation which has grown by
146 million after the change of useful life the profit before tax is 72 million, at 0.6% of the
turnover and after-tax and minority interest, the profit after tax is 26.5 million, against last
year’s 41 million. That is 0.2% of the revenue.
That is all. I hand it over back to Govind for this time.
Govind Shrikhande: Thanks friends, so now the whole session is open for any questions.
Moderator: Thank you, sir. Ladies and gentlemen we will now begin the question and answer
interactive session for the conference participants. At this time if you have a question you
may please press “*” and then “1” on your touchtone-enabled telephone keypad. On
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 12 of 26
pressing * and 1 participants will get a chance to present their question on a first in line
basis. To ask a question, please press * and then 1 now. First question is from the line of
Mr. Prakhar Sharma: from CLSA India. Please go ahead.
Prakhar Sharma: Hello sir! Congratulations on the result and the award. I have a couple of questions. I will
just come to them one by one. One, why were other operating incomes in this quarter
particularly high at about 6.6 Crores?
B S Nagesh: This is Nagesh here. Thank you for the compliments. We have a co-branded card which is
a Citibank and in the last year the numbers of co-branded cards that we have got are
substantial, and therefore, we have generated an income from Citibank. Last year it was in
Q3, and this year the income was accrued in Q4.
Prakhar Sharma: Fair enough. And comparing it to last quarter, two costs heads were significantly lower
besides the write-back of power cost. Could you just explain why was this so?
B S Nagesh: Which are the two costs that you are referring to?
Prakhar Sharma: Okay. I just give you. If you see your personnel cost, that was about 17.3 Crores against 21
Crores in 2Q and 21 Crores in 3Q. And this quarter it was a 17.
B S Nagesh: See, one part of the personnel cost will come down to the extent of the provision made for
our performance-linked reward system, so for twelve months we continue to apportion the
performance-linked reward system and the last quarter, we will look at the actual
performance-linked reward disbursement. And to that extent, we adjust in the last quarter. I
mean, that is the only change that has happened, otherwise, in terms of the cost structure,
there is no need of change.
Prakhar Sharma: Does that mean that employee performance was lower than that was budgeted earlier?
Govind Shrikhande: No, the employee performance, see, you budget the employee performance at the total
level, however, the disbursement happens at different, different level.
Prakhar Sharma: Okay. Fair enough, I will take that. So, basically that kind of fluctuation will occur at the
year-end, right, in a sense you know, it comes down steeply from between the two
quarters, but this will be apportioned to the what’s actual at the end of the year?
Govind Shrikhande: Correct.
Prakhar Sharma: Fair enough. And even the selling and distribution which last quarter included that three or
four distribution centers that you had increased capacity, why has the cost come down on a
Q-on-Q basis? Were there one of items last quarter?
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 13 of 26
Govind Shrikhande: I will ask our CFO to answer the question.
Prakhar Sharma: Sure, sure.
CB Navalkar: Yeah, Prakhar, you are talking about last quarter to this quarter?
Prakhar Sharma: Yeah.
CB Navalkar: Because last quarter, you see, we ran a corporate campaign in Q3, but in this quarter, that
is Q4, all we ran was our sale ad, so effectively, our corporate campaign involves a much
larger ad expenditure than our sale campaign does.
Prakhar Sharma: Fair enough. So, should this run rate continue at around 10 Crores, is that a fair
assumption?
CB Navalkar: Once again, as BSN said right at the beginning, this will be futuristic statement, so we
won’t really be able to comment on that.
Prakhar Sharma: Fair enough.
CB Navalkar: Strictly in the retail business we do not compare quarter-to-quarter, I mean last year
because it is quite seasonal. In the Q3 you will have all the festivals, we will have
promotions of a different kind whereas Q4 it will be sale, Q2 it will be a sale so, you know
strictly we compare against last year’s quarter that would break much more better
comparison than Q3.
Prakhar Sharma: Fair enough. And how much of the power cost was written back, the provision that was
made?
CB Navalkar: 2.8 Crores.
Prakhar Sharma: 2.8 Crores. Secondly, the consolidated statement has about 2.2 Crores of the loss before
minority interest, is that because you are doing 51% of Hypercity?
CB Navalkar: Well, it is Gateway.
Prakhar Sharma: That is Gateway loss?
B S Nagesh: Yeah. Primarily that.
Prakhar Sharma: Primarily that. And can I have a brief sense of how the balance sheet as of now looks like?
In the sense how much is debt and fixed assets, and how much interest has been capitalized
during the year?
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 14 of 26
B S Nagesh: Interest capitalized, offline I do not have the figure of interest capitalized.
Prakhar Sharma: Can I have the debt figure as of now? In the standalone entity?
B S Nagesh: About 170 Crores of debt of the 31st March.
Prakhar Sharma: 170 Crores. Fair enough. So, your interest cost will be around 7%-8%, is that the correct
estimate?
B S Nagesh: Yeah, between 9 to 10.5.
Prakhar Sharma: 9 to 10.5.
B S Nagesh: 9.5.
Prakhar Sharma: Fair enough. And secondly, also just on the Slide #28 where you talked about operational
efficiency on a like-to-like basis, why was GMROI down by 10%, sir?
B S Nagesh: The GMROI actually that happened as we have opened stores.
Prakhar Sharma: That is like-to-like number, sir?
B S Nagesh: Actually, the stock for the like-to-like is gone up higher than as compared to the margins,
and that is the reason for the GMROI because again the numerator’s inventory with the as
compared to the margin, and that is the reason.
Govind Shrikhande: The inventory have gone up, Prakhar.
Prakhar Sharma: In the same-stores also?
Govind Shrikhande: Yeah. Actually what has happened is in the last quarter, January went off very well,
February we started seeing the dip in the market, and that was the time when we were
running our sale. And generally as a tradition we run the sale only for a period of two
weeks. We were running up to 17 days, which includes two week-end. This year, the
management took a call to increase the sale period by another one week. So it has two
impacts. One impact is that your inventory that you carried which otherwise you would
send back in the year-end. So, you had a slightly higher inventory at the year-end. And the
second, in that quarter, there would be a slight depression in margin because you would
continue to sell lower cost or more discounted merchandize for a week more than what you
had planned. It has an impact although in a quarter it looks seven days in a quarter it
should not make an impact, it does not make any impact. So we had excess inventory as of
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 15 of 26
the closing for the March year-end which again during the first quarter would get
normalized by either selling or returning stocks wherever you had an option to return.
Prakhar Sharma: Fair enough. Sir, I just thought if I could get two comments from you. One I had visited
the Rajouri Garden Store on a weekend, maybe on a Saturday or Friday, but the number of
customers I could see was slightly lower than I thought of, could you give us a sense of
how the Rajouri which is I think the most expensive retail space as of now, how is that
progresses?
B S Nagesh: See, Rajouri in terms of the revenue is progressing extremely well. Rajouri is bang on
target in terms of the revenue. Rajouri is on target in terms of the way we expect this to
end up during this financial year. You know generally when we keep saying that stores
product breakeven between 4 to 6 quarters, and we would expect Rajouri is to be on the
same line.
Prakhar Sharma: Fair enough. And any thoughts on, is this a kind of slowdown are you seeing at your store
level or among your own consumers, any sign of inflation and other stuff that everyone
else is talking about, are you seeing those kind of sign?
B S. Nagesh: See, in Shopper’s Stop since the whole attempt is to move from premium to bridge to
luxury therefore, our actual average selling prices have been increasing and we have not
seen resistance till the March 31st figure. In Hypercity we notice something which is very
strange for us, although it is positive. The merchandize inflation is at 6.2% which means
basket-to-basket comparison inflation is 6.2, but the customer is buying at a 7.4% inflated
price, which means that the Hypercity customer is buying more inflated products than the
basket inflation. It does not give a sense that you will see a drop in the revenue. But
honestly, the actual talk around the sentimental effect of the inflation has actually caught
up in the media in the last three, four weeks. By the end of probably the month of May also
we will start sensing if there is any slowdown we expect in the quarter, but we are not
seeing slowdown as of now.
Prakhar Sharma: Fair enough. And any idea on the Hypercity, is there anything new besides what we talked
about, you know, or the same summer for the full year, anything that we can share as of
now?
B S. Nagesh: Hypercity, I cannot share about anything which is tomorrow, but as a store, Hypercity has
clocked 147 Crores.
Prakhar Sharma: Fair Enough. And sir, my last question is on, how do you see rentals and real estate
scenarios, lot of deals coming, newspapers have been carrying a lot of articles that real
estate guys are facing some crunch and good inventory could come to you, are you seeing
some kind of signs where…?
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 16 of 26
Govind Shrikhande: We definitely see nervousness in the real estate. From one factor that the real estate
developers who are making us come to their office have started coming to our office. I
think that is the first sign. The second is that I mean, you can sense that the retailers
especially the smaller retailers were paying a rent of 250-300 and looking at a percentage
cost of 26%-27%, not signing property in the same gung ho fashion that they were signing
probably a six-month or a year back. So, we are sensing that the real estate prices will
definitely not go up. In many of the places there could be a 10% to 15% correction, okay,
but it has not become very visible because lot many properties are still not on the finishing
stages. And earlier negotiated prices continue to hold for most of us. And as anchors we
had substantially discounted prices.
Prakhar Sharma: Fair enough. Thank you very much.
Govind Shrikhande: Thank you
Moderator: Thank you, Mr. Sharma. The next question is from the line of Mr. Huzefa Topiwalla from
Morgan Stanley. Please go ahead.
Ms. Divya: Hi, this is Divya from Morgan Stanley. Sir, just a couple of questions. The first one being
I just need to understand how did you actually go about the thought of repositioning the
stores? I mean was there any particular reason for the store positioning at this particular
point of time?
B S Nagesh: See, we do three studies on a regular basis. One is that we do the Mystery Shopper on a
monthly basis every year, we do the customer satisfaction studies, and every year we do a
study called Brand Track. About 2.5 years back doing the Brand Track what we realized
was that as much as customers are trusting us in terms of confidence, trust, dynamism, and
fashionability but what we found was a 18 to 25 age group fashionability quotient was
increasing at a very fast rate. And you would appreciate that our department stores we do
not vertically split a target audience, we have to split it horizontally, so we if we are
positioned at a level, we have to cater to 18 to 45. And we realize that the 18 to 25
although they were shopping with us, but on the fashionability part of this, they were not
associating with us. So, they shopped at Shopper’s Stop, but probably did not carry the
Shopper’s Stop carry bag or did not say hey I shop at Shopper’s Stop although, their
mothers and fathers and parents and brothers and sisters of the higher age would shop with
us. For us, the important thing was in the next 10 years, 15 years, would we remain as a
source catering to the medium age of 29 and 30 all we will be grown by 10 years. And that
was a challenge that we faced two and half years back. So when we went back, we said if
you reposition the store, we will be able to attract 18 to 45 as usual, but we also will be
able to associate with them. So 10 years down the line when these 18 to 25 or 25 to 35 they
will like to shop with us and continue to get associated. Now this is how the whole process
was identified. And then anybody who is a brand for 17 years has an emotional challenge
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 17 of 26
to say how can I change it? And it took us almost about 18 months to research, workout
have Ray & Keshavan as a agency to design and have the total 360 degrees planned,
because it was not just changing the brand or the logo or just let me tell you that what
surprised us was that the association that customer had with our company was with
Shopper’s Stop the brand name and black and white the color and the output in terms of
trust, in terms of dynamism, in terms of customer service was directly related to that name.
That gave us the comfort that even if you change the logo we should still see a positive
movement. Now we are about 6 days down since the time we have changed the logo with a
very-very high impact campaign. And as of now the response is fairly positive.
Ms. Divya: Okay, okay fair enough sir.
B S Nagesh: And of course this takes us up in terms of our positioning from premium to bridge to
luxury and almost every international brand on the cosmetics front in luxury that has got
launched in the country is launched through our doors. So that further substantiates that
even our brand partners are seeing our positioning right in terms of brand as well as the
way we are going forward.
Ms. Divya: Right, just one more questions, regarding our like-to-like sales you have exhibited 16% in
Q4. I just need to know if you could give me a sense of how much of it would be volume
driven and have you taken any substantially price hikes?
B S Nagesh: If you look at the same slide you will actually see that there is a volume growth
percentage. 11% is the like-to-like volume growth and selling price has grown by 5%.
Ms. Divya: Okay, okay fine, fine, fair enough sir. That is perfect, and that is all from me sir.
B S Nagesh: Thank you very much.
Moderator: Thank you. The next question is from the line of Suneeta Sachdev from UBS, please go
ahead.
Suneeta Sachdev: Hi, Nagesh, hi team congratulations.
B S Nagesh: Hi Suneeta.
Suneeta Sachdev: Just one question on Page 15, the conversions ratio for the full year on your like-to-like
stores is down by 1%. What could be the reason for this?
B S Nagesh: Of the conversion going down.
Suneeta Sachdev: Yeah.
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 18 of 26
B S Nagesh: Yeah I think the reasons could be that in the like-to-like stores if you look at the average
transaction size, it has gone up substantially. It is at a 10%. And if you look at our more
than 5 years store they are running at a like-to-like of growth of 5%. So what has happened
is that the older stores which are more than 5 years have actually had customers getting
upgraded. So the transaction size has actually moved up, are you getting me Suneeta? 5%
like-to-like stores sales growth, okay but like-to-like stores transactions size has grown by
11% of Slide#15. So less number of customers have bought much higher baskets. And
anyhow the customer entry for like-to-like stores has come down by 1%, go to slide#14
you will see that the like-to-like stores the customer entry is degrown. So in a situation
where the customer entry de-growth, the business has been able to manage to upgrade the
customer and make them buy more. So operationally the business has become more
efficient in both cases.
Suneeta Sachdev: You know with 65% of your sales coming from your loyalty card holders which is more
than a million. And new stores, you know just been a relatively smaller proportion of your
total stores, this like-to-like sales growth of (-1%) is slightly unnerving.
B S Nagesh: Not sales growth the customer entry is growth…
Suneeta Sachdev: The conversion ratio.
B S Nagesh: You know so conversion is on the number of cash memo which is not in the value. So you
should have to tell that if I get 10 customers who are buying worth Rs.1000 but I have an
option to get 9 customers who buy worth Rs.2000, I will prefer the 9 customer buying
Rs.2000 although I would love to get the last customer….
Suneeta Sachdev: Yeah, Nagesh the only reason I was saying this is basically wanted more bills and wanted
a higher bills side, that is what, that was the only…
B S Nagesh: No we are not getting more bills Suneeta basically, one more things that is happening, in
places which are old, they have had two impacts one is our own cannibalization impact
okay and the second is there is the competition impact.
Suneeta Sachdev: That exactly what I wanted to hear from you.
B S Nagesh: Absolutely.
Suneeta Sachdev: So what is that competition impact and how would you either quantify or qualify it.
B S Nagesh: No, I will quantify and qualify both because I have, I mean in this con-call, I cannot do
future, let me take the past, the last biggest competition in fact we have had it in Bangalore
when we had all our competitors opening, okay and in Pune. And like I had mentioned
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 19 of 26
earlier whenever this competition comes in, in that particular year we lose between minus,
we will go down by -10% to -20% and it takes almost 12 months for the percentages to
come back, because even if they love us if a competition comes up, that quarter 50% go
across to the new store. And we do have to make efforts to get it back and that as far as
competition is concerned, but if you look at our oldest store, wherein all the old stores we
have had our own stores get cannibalizing the store, so that is the one but to that extent 1%
is not real earning but I would not want to lose at 1% also. And I would go by what you are
saying.
Suneeta Sachdev: In terms of new competition coming, this going forward I do not see any competition
increasing in all, I mean your all the more now in 24 locations and all the majors retail
cities you are present in. So I mean is it a little bit unnerving that you know with brand
heritage like yours with you know being a departmental store known as India’s best
departmental store, why should this happen?
B S Nagesh: What has happened?
Puneeta Sachdev: The point I am trying to say is competition should not affect us to this extent.
B S Nagesh: Oh no, not at all, I think it is absolutely unfair if the world’s best retailer tells you that
competition does not impact, I mean in retail competition impacts during the first quarter
and first half and first one year. So we would be fooling ourselves I would not want to say
that, let me tell you wherever competition comes in the same catchments in that quarter or
the next two quarters we will have an impact. Now it is the ability of our organization to be
able to come back in the 3rd Quarter and reach back from the original level, but if it drops
then it means we are not doing well, but be rest assured that here when we say a 1% drop
in customer entry but we see a 11% growth in like-to-like transaction size, it a huge
operation efficiency which means your existing customers are loving you. So I am not too
concerned.
Puneeta Sachdev: Last question on these new businesses where you have not given them separately in terms
of the numbers, any idea on when these really start showing up positively in terms of…
B S Nagesh: Like said the Crossword, Mother Care, Mac & Clinique have perhaps turned positive. I
think we have three businesses Home Stop, Arcelia and F&B our internal projections are
showing that Home Stop and Arcelia we should be able to see a breakeven or a positive.
However in F&B we are likely to struggle.
Puneeta Sachdev: And is there anything that you would like to tell me about the right issue that you all have?
B S Nagesh: We have filed the document and awaiting the procedure to take it’s time.
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 20 of 26
Suneeta Sachdev: And this is entirely for the takeover like Hypercity?
B S Nagesh: Well as for the documentation is the 17 stores that we have shown in the document and
investments in Gateway.
Suneeta Sachdev: Okay sir thanks.
B S Nagesh: Thank you very much.
Moderator: Thank you Ms. Sachdev. The next questions is from the line of Mr. Percy Panthaki from
HSBC, please go ahead.
Percy Panthaki: Hi sir, thanks for teaching us through the brand presentation, I think that was just fantastic,
however, I have a question on the structure of department stores in India as compared to
rest of the world, when you say you are positioning yourself as a luxury department store.
B S Nagesh: No, bridge to luxury, not luxury.
Percy Panthaki: Okay, but department store which is towards the premium and elsewhere in the globe
would probably make a gross profit margin of nearly 40% whereas we are at about 30% to
32%, moreover, we are constrained here because the branded products that we store
basically I believe those brands would want you to sell at the same price as it would be
available in other outlets. So having classified yourself as a premium department store,
how do you see your margins going in the region of EBITDA margins of 12% to 15% as
the other department store players in Asia currently do, how do you see that evolving in
the next 5 to 7 years, does do you think it will happened at all?
B S Nagesh: Okay I am a little constrained to make a statement to say, how things will look in the
future but let me talk about the general question in terms of how department stores around
the world have looked at it. In terms of when you go bridge to luxury or grow from
premium to bridge to luxury, the first thing that it does is it increases the average
transaction size and average selling price. Now I think that is what is very clearly getting
displayed if you look at the last 6 to 7 quarters as to how things have moved on the average
selling price. And therefore although in the market you are seeing like-to-like peer growth
of either competition on many players at the region of 8% to 10% you are seeing us
displaying a 16% like-to-like growth. Although, we have the largest number of stores
which are more than 5 years old compare to competition. And if could take away the stores
which are more than 5 years are like-to-like is running at a high of 25%. So bridge to
luxury is going to definitely increase the average cash per customer and therefore, increase
the average GMROF or the gross margins return on the floor space that will definitely
happen. Now again without commenting on the future if you look at the departments store
business around the world whether you have a gross margin of 45% to 35% the EBITDA
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 21 of 26
ranges in the region of 68% except for businesses of department stores which are older
stores where the property is in the assets and not in the P&L so if you go to many of the
European stores where you see a 12% to 15% of EBITDA that is coming and when you go
and look at their occupation cost you find the occupation cost will be at about 1% to 2%.
So that is the difference, you will see the balance sheet you will find the assets is sitting
and most of them of course have been sitting on very old assets .
Percy Panthaki: Okay but do you think sir that there could be a scenario where an Arrow shirts says that X
price in Shopper’s Stop and Y price in other outlets.
B S Nagesh: In India.
Percy Panthaki; Yes.
B S Nagesh: Under the current MRP rule we will not be able to do it. And we do not expect the MRP
rule to change at least in the 12 to 15 months definitely.
Percy Panthaki: Okay so apart from let us say in the next 2 to 3 years you reach 50 Shopper’s Stop outlets
maybe another 5 or 6 years or let us say on a 10 year view you have reached let us say a
100 outlets but then the growth from the new outlets will definitely slowdown. So what do
you think will support the current multiples of the stock going forward?
B S Nagesh: Okay again I have heard the projections that you have made, but I am not making a
comment, but if I would go by saying that your projections of 100 stores goes right in the
next 10 years’ time, if we just look at the way the pyramid in the middle is growing, and
even at let us say the country growing at 8% and not 9% you see that bulge is the biggest
bulge. So all of us in that department store space or catering to that top-end space will
continue to see the actual pie growing, or for example let me put it slightly in a different
way, when we look at our businesses we still see that 12% to 15% of the Indian customers
are still our target audience and not beyond that. And most of course wherever we are
talking of the top 15% and the top 10 to 12 cities, and there you see that the bulge is
continuing to increase. So even if one talks of a 80 to 100 stores as you were saying for
anybody that pie is not seen as reducing. And the evidence that we have of the last 4 to 5
years is that in the first citizen, which is constant customer, which means you have lot of
like-to-like first citizen customers the average transaction size is increasing, so you had the
same gentleman spending more amount and upgrading himself, so I think that is what is
the direction for the future.
Percy Panthaki: Okay, and in last conference also you said that on FY2010 you would be targeting
EBITDA margin of around 8% anything changed in that.
B S Nagesh: I had to remain silent to indicate to you that I would continue to be silent on this.
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 22 of 26
Percy Panthaki: Okay, okay fine sir, thanks.
B S Nagesh: Thank you.
Moderator: Thank you Mr. Panthaki. Ladies and Gentleman before we take the next question I would
like to reminder you can press * and 1 to ask a questions. The next questions if from the
line of Mr. Ankur Perywal from Religare Securities, please go ahead.
Ankur Perywal: Hello.
B S Nagesh: Hi Ankur.
Ankur Perywal: Yeah, hi, good evening sir.
B S Nagesh: Good evening.
Ankur Perywal: Sir taking on the strategic Slide like you started doing that, you have been focus more on
the departmental stores for now. And we have been expanding in the specialty store as
well. So going ahead how do we plan do we plan to expand more in the apart from the
departmental store format do we plan to expand more in the specialty format or would we
go more in the Hypercity format side?
B S Nagesh: Again please respect my restrain due to the document that we have filed. So I can only tell
you that the current mix is still highly dominated by the department store business, even if
you look at our total business more than 80% to 85% of the business is coming from
Shopper’s Stop. And for references of how we are looking at department store and the
hypermarket and the specialty, I would request you to refer back to our last quarter con-
call and the last to last quarter I think where we will actually put it together for you.
Ankur Perywal: Thank you, thank you.
Moderator: Thank you Mr. Perywal. The next questions is from the line of Ms. Priya Iyer from
Edelweiss, please go ahead. Ms. Iyer your line has been unmuted you can go ahead with
your question.
Priya Iyer: Good evening everybody, I just have one question, in the previous quarter, you know we
had not considered the impact of Time Zone and Hypercity right.
B S Nagesh: Yeah we had considered both the impacts.
Priya Iyer: Both the impacts.
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 23 of 26
B S Nagesh: Yes.
Priya Iyer: As in the consolidated numbers included both the numbers, is it?
B S Nagesh: Yeah very much.
Priya Iyer: Yeah, okay thank you.
Moderator: Thank you Ms. Iyer. The next question is from the line of Mr. Ronak Shachdeva from
Anand Rathi Securities, please go ahead.
Ronak Shachdeva: Yeah good evening everybody.
B S Nagesh: Hi, good evening, Anand.
Ronak Shachdeva: Sir this is Ronak here.
B S Nagesh: Sorry, sorry.
Ronak Shachdeva: Sir I would just like to get a sense of what kind of per square feet revenues are you
generating on the older stores that is, that the store that are more than 5 years old?
B S Nagesh: Okay, actually like this if you look at on the old stores which are more than 5 years they
are still continuing to grow at 5%, and the area has remained the same. I do not think I
have directly here in front of me the sales per square foot, but offhand I can tell you that
there will be larger than the new stores.
Ronak Shachdeva: Yeah I mean, I just try to get a sense is to what kind of you know sales per square feet
could be generated at majority by...
B S Nagesh: No, you know what we will do, is one of us we actually send this across you.
Ronak Shachdeva: That will be great sir.
B S Nagesh: Yeah they will send across you as a mail, okay because if you look at the Shopper’s Stop
department stores on slide#11, it shows about Rs.8900 as you know if you take the square
foot, okay and overall and this must be including the 34% growth that you have seen, but if
you look to like-to-like which is 5%, they would be on a higher side, but we will send you
the figure for that.
Ronak Shachdeva: Yeah sir, the follow-up question on last, I do not know if I am repeating this but the 5%
growth that you are talking about like-to-like in the older stores, is there a reason why it so
less?
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 24 of 26
B S Nagesh: Yeah I mean, this includes Andheri which is 17 years, includes the Bangalore, which is old
and Delhi which is almost 10 years. And I had mention more as a general point that our
experience of the last 17 years shows that stores start showing a decline around the 7th
year.
Ronak Shachdeva: Around the 7th year.
B S Nagesh: From the 7th year, okay and some stores where we had for example, Hyderabad we did a
renovation in the 7th to 8th year and we saw a growth again coming back. Almost like a
rejuvenated curve okay which is done, anyway I got the figure now, let say per square foot
of stores more than 5 years is at about Rs.12,000 per square foot.
Ronak Shachdeva: Rs.12,000 per square foot.
B S Nagesh: They actually are almost 35% to 40% higher than the average.
Ronak Shachdeva: Yeah, alright sir just another question. Sir your private label sales as the percentage of a
total, it was actually come down in this quarter when compared to the Q4 last year. So is
there a reason for that, I mean is there a strategic motivation to go for more branded
product or something or what.
B S Nagesh: I will request Govind to answer this question, please.
Ronak Shachdeva: Yeah.
Govind Shrikhande: There is no strategic reason to downgrade the share of exclusive brands. In fact we would
love to increase the share of exclusive brands.
Ronak Shachdeva: Yeah because of the margin advantage over there.
Govind Shrikhande: But as a position, last two quarter what we have also done is we have increased the kind of
bridge to luxury brands share. We have launched brands like Lancome, we have launched
brands like Tommy Hilfiger in our most stores some earlier and that has caused some
decline in the share of exclusive brands.
Ronak Shachdeva: Right.
Govind Shrikhande: Our endeavors definitely will continue to increase the share of exclusive brands.
Ronak Shachdeva: Alright sir, sir I mean that explains probably a little dip in the gross margin as well.
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 25 of 26
B S Nagesh: If you look at Slide #16 you will actually see that compare to last year Quarter 4, this year
the own what has come down on 50% to 57% however the consignment and the
concession has gone up by 11%, okay some of the bridge to luxury brands that Govind is
talking off, have actually gone into that area.
Ronak Shachdeva: It is the concession area.
B S Nagesh: Right to that concession area.
Ronak Shachdeva: Okay.
B S Nagesh: Okay and therefore you see that kind of a …
Ronak Shachdeva: Alright sir, sir that is it from my side at the moment if there is anything I will probably
comeback, thanks sir.
B S Nagesh: Thank you.
Moderator: Thank you Mr. Shachdeva. Ladies and Gentleman if anyone has a question at this time,
you may press * and then 1 on your touchtone telephone. We have a question from the line
of Ms. Priya Iyer from Edelweiss, please go ahead.
Priya Iyer: Hello Nagesh, I just had a quick question again about how the real estate part of your
business is panning up, as in the retail real estate, you filed the rights document you said to
whatever you can discuss within the per view of that, would be very helpful?
B S Nagesh: As far as the document is concerned, in the document we have sought from our
shareholder’s equity for adding up 17 stores.
Priya Iyer: Okay.
B S Nagesh: The actual number of stores that we had signed and had discussed are available in the Q3
and Q2 con-call discussions.
Priya Iyer: Correct.
B S Nagesh: As far as the real estate is concerned the scenario now I am talking outside of the
document we continue to fetch the rate of an anchor and I had in the last quarter con-call
mentioned saying that although in the last 2 years the average rentals for retail as a
business has gone up by 200% from 150%. Our average rental on signing has not gone up
by more than 10% to 15% I mean this was in the last quarter Q3 if you look at the con call
transcript you will find that there. Okay and some discussions we have put in there, and
Shopper’s Stop Limited April 29, 2008
Page 26 of 26
outside there I cannot comment. However, I feel to us another colleagues question earlier I
have mentioned that there is nervousness in the real estate especially to do with retail and
we believe that although the prices may not soften, but you will see different kinds of
models emerging a lot of real estate players may come at a lower minimum guaranteed
rentals with us or others and look at revenue share so that they can participate with the
growth of the retail business.
Priya Iyer: Okay.
B S Nagesh: And that we are sensing very clearly.
Priya Iyer: Thank you very much.
Moderator: Thank you Ms. Iyer. Ladies and gentlemen if anyone has a question at this time you may
press * and then 1. If anyone has a question you may press * and 1. At this moment there
are no further questions from the participants. I would now like to hand the floor over to
Mr. B S Nagesh for any final remarks.
B S Nagesh: Yeah thank you very much Rochelle, thanks to the ladies and gentlemen, thank you for
being on the con call. We appreciate the time that you take to be on the con call and
discuss as much as we are able to pass information which helps in the retail understanding.
We do learn as much from the kind of questions that you ask. I would also thank Govind
and Navalkar and the team who had been here with us in preparation of the con call and I
would also welcome Mr. Salil Nair who has now been promoted and upgraded as a chief
operating officer and I just want to say that we continue with our tradition of growing
people from within the organization. We would also request that if each of you can just
send a small mail to our Finance or any of us to say that you would like us to plant a tree in
your name, we would love to plant a tree in your name and god save all of us together we
will make the earth more green. Thank you very much and look forward to meeting you
again.
Moderator: Thank you very much Mr. Nagesh, thank you Mr. Shrikhande, and Mr. Navalkar. Ladies
and gentlemen, on behalf of Shopper’s Stop that concludes this conference call. You may
now disconnect your lines. Thank you for connecting to the audio conference service from
Chorus Call and have a pleasant evening.
B S Nagesh: Thank you Rochelle.
top related