w. frank robinson department of history vanderbilt university · francisco del rosario sánchez....

29
W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY Contours of the Haitian Past; Glimpses of the Future

Upload: others

Post on 08-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

W. FRANK ROBINSON

DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY

VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY

Contours of the Haitian Past; Glimpses of the Future

Page 2: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Struggles of Nationhood1822-1934

Page 3: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Jean Pierre Boyer

Autocratic rule: Boyer was the “true creator of the militaristic regime whose wounds, unhealable, still poison our national organism.”

indemnity and bloated military

1838: 30% of total annual budget for debt

50% for army; <1% on education

Code Rural and forced labor

annexation of Spanish Santo Domingo

revisionism: imperialism and Haiti

victim, perpetrator, or accomplice?

Page 4: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Independence: Juan Pablo Duarte, Ramón Mella, and Francisco del Rosario Sánchez

Page 5: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Haiti and the United States

“Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

trade: lumber and food (meat and flour) for sugar and coffee

refusal of US to recognize Haiti: two-faced policy

“Our policy with regard to Hayti, is plain. We can never acknowledge her independence.”

abolitionists vs. slaveholders – symbol of Haiti

funeral for abolitionist John Brown held in cathedral in Port-au-Prince

President Grant and threat of annexation

Page 6: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

John Brown

Page 7: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Decades of Instability: 1843-1915

James Graham Leyburn summarizes this chaotic era in Haitian history. “Of the twenty-two heads of state between 1843 and 1915, only one served out his prescribed term of office, three died while serving, one was blown up with his palace, one presumably poisoned, one hacked to pieces by a mob, one resigned. The other fourteen were deposed by revolution after incumbencies ranging in length from three months to twelve years.”

Page 8: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Faustin Soulouque (r. 1847-1859)

ex-slave – military officer

ambitious and savvy

nobility = governing coalition

dismissed by foreign critics

wary of annexation by US

failed invasion of Dominican Republican 1855

elaborate court ceremonies

moved against mulatto elites

overthrown by his own generals

Page 9: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Crown of Emperor Faustin I

Page 10: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Six Centimes

Page 11: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Fabre Geffrard

Page 12: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Geffrard

President from 1858-1867

reestablished Haiti as a republic

decreased size of army

returned power to traditional elites

encouraged African Americans to settle in Haiti

new era of Catholic activism

expand access to education

anti-Vodou campaign – concern about image abroad

German merchants and French bankers

exiled in 1867 – continuing cycle of uprisings

Page 13: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Residence of Geffrard

Page 14: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Lysius Salomon

Page 15: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Salomon

Soulouque’s Minister of Finance

“I like coups d’état. You can’t govern without them.”

strategy: “take as much advantage as possible” of a crisis to

justify autocratic rule

restart public education

fix Haiti's financial woes

restore agriculture productivity

improve public administration

modernize Haiti

controversy over reelection – forced into exile

Page 16: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

National Bank of Haiti - 1881

Page 17: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Florvil Hyppolite

Page 18: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Troubles in Haiti 1891

Page 19: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Historic Iron Market

Page 20: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Revolving Door of Power

1911-1915: seven different presidents

United States solidifies its stranglehold on trade and finance

violence: explosion of National Palace and death of Cincinnatus Leconte in 1911

President Vilbrun Guillaume Sam vs. Rosalvo Bobo – July 1915

execution of political prisoners – public outcry

Sam dragged from French legation - torn to pieces by mob

Page 21: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Rise of United States as a Global Power

Page 22: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Roosevelt Corollary

Page 23: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Uncle Sam – School Begins 1899

Page 24: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

White Man’s Burden

Page 25: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

United States Intervention, 1915-1934

Violent Conditions and Temporary Solutions

1. Haitian Guard (Garde d’Haiti)

2. fruits of U.S. presence

3. issues of sovereignty and favoritism

Page 26: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

United States Marines 1915

Page 27: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Les Americains Chassent Les CacosNemours Vincent

Page 28: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Charlemagne Péralte (1886-1919)Haitian nationalist opposed to the US invasion

Page 29: W. FRANK ROBINSON DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY · Francisco del Rosario Sánchez. Haiti and the United States “Haiti and the United States grew up together.”

Good Neighbor?