university of illinois at chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to springer’s\scienti c...

18
Playing “Spot the Difference” with Springer Christiane Peters University of Illinois at Chicago CRYPTO 2011 Rump Session

Upload: others

Post on 12-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

Playing “Spot the Difference” with Springer

Christiane Peters

University of Illinois at Chicago

CRYPTO 2011Rump Session

Page 2: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

Recalling “Spot the Difference” games

Source: http://games2rule.com/

Setup:

• Take a document (e.g., a picture).

• Introduce N errors.

• Publish alternate next to the original and tell the player tofind the N differences.

1/13

Page 3: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

“Spot the difference” games for LNCS authors

If you want to play:

• write a paper

• get it accepted at a conference with LNCS proceedings

• send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s “ScientificPublishing Services” (SPS).

• wait for the “final” version of your paper and startcomparing.

Features:

• The number of errors N will be much higher than in anysmall flash game on your smart phone.

• You won’t know N in advance.

• You can play several rounds.

2/13

Page 4: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

“Spot the difference” games for LNCS authors

If you want to play:

• write a paper

• get it accepted at a conference with LNCS proceedings

• send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s “ScientificPublishing Services” (SPS).

• wait for the “final” version of your paper and startcomparing.

Features:

• The number of errors N will be much higher than in anysmall flash game on your smart phone.

• You won’t know N in advance.

• You can play several rounds.

2/13

Page 5: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

Example

• Players: Dan, Tanja, and I.

• Challenge document: article on Smaller decodingexponents: ball-collision decoding

We had the pleasure of playing 3 rounds in which we found 34,14, and 1 errors, respectively.

3/13

Page 6: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

4/13

Round 1: Round 2:

Page 7: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

5/13

Round 1: Round 2:

Page 8: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

6/13

Round 1: Round 2:

Page 9: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

7/13

Round 1: Round 2:

Page 10: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

My favorites (spoiler alert)

8/13

Page 11: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

Renaming conferences

• ASIACRYPT 2009 →• CRYPTO’87 →

Extra fun: try entering “CRYPTO 1987” and “ASIACRYPT 09”on http://www.springerlink.com/ and see if you can findthe proceedings.

9/13

Page 12: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

Reversing the order of authors/editors:

• Cohen, G., Wolfmann, J. (eds.): Coding theory andapplications. →

10/13

Page 13: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

Can introduce more errors by copy/paste-ing the wholebibliography from the submitted PDF and editing it (rather thanusing the submitted LaTeX source code):

• codewords →

11/13

Page 14: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

Can introduce more errors by copy/paste-ing the wholebibliography from the submitted PDF and editing it (rather thanusing the submitted LaTeX source code):

•• codewords →

11/13

Page 15: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

All-time favorite

A bib entry which should look like:

Charpin, P. (ed.): EUROCODE ’94 – Livre des resume –

EUROCODE ’94, Abbaye de la Bussiere sur Ouche,

France, October 1994 (1994); See [16]

Round 1:

Round 2:

12/13

Page 16: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

All-time favorite

A bib entry which should look like:

Charpin, P. (ed.): EUROCODE ’94 – Livre des resume –

EUROCODE ’94, Abbaye de la Bussiere sur Ouche,

France, October 1994 (1994); See [16]

Round 1:

Round 2:

12/13

Page 17: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

All-time favorite

A bib entry which should look like:

Charpin, P. (ed.): EUROCODE ’94 – Livre des resume –

EUROCODE ’94, Abbaye de la Bussiere sur Ouche,

France, October 1994 (1994); See [16]

Round 1:

Round 2:

12/13

Page 18: University of Illinois at Chicago€¦ · send your camera-ready paper to Springer’s\Scienti c Publishing Services"(SPS). wait for the\ nal"version of your paper and start comparing

In conclusion:

• I usually do not play “Spot the Difference” games because Iconsider my time too valuable to do so.

• Sadly Springer’s SPS doesn’t seem to care.

13/13