8/11/2019 THW Make Vaccination Compulsory

1/2

THW make vaccination compulsory

(+)

Themeline:

WHO suggested that for a succesfull protection of the community 95% of children need to have

vaccination. Vaccine represent one of the most succesfull and effective interventions in mdicine.

By vaccination people, society has been able to eradicate numerous disease that caused millions

of death before. WHO decided to try and eradicate polio world wide with vaccination.

UU no 4 tahun 1984...

Limitation:

Those who make vaccination compulsary is government, with the 5 vaccination compulsory such

as Polio, DPT, BCG, Hepatitis B and measles. It should be implemented in developing countrylike Indonesia where the viruses are still endemic, the hygiene is still bad so the risk would be

considerably higher. By compulsorying vaccine, it will protected people from many nkinds of

disease.

Timesplit:

1st : medical

2nd : economical

Arguments:

Medical :

1. If an age group is protected, that result in a better health conditions for the whole society

2. Vaccination can give good body immune, so when people attacked by disease it will not

cause sick. Advanced country like japan, ever stop the vaccination but infact it cause the

highest rate of disease.

3. In Indonesia at 2005 happen the great accident, it is polio, and after confirmed infact they

are never get polio vaccination.

Economical :

1. Commonly used vaccine are cost effective and preventive way of promoting health,

compared to the treatment of acute or chronic disease

2. Immunization for childhood against 7 disease were estimated to save over $ 50 billion /

birth year cohort

3. Produvtivity rates remain high and less money because people are healthier.

8/11/2019 THW Make Vaccination Compulsory

2/2

(-)

Medical point of view:

1st speaker:

1. Vaccine contain mercuri, thimerosol, aluminium, benzetonium klorida and another

dangerous substance that can cause autism and brain disfungtion (Research of american

medical association)

2. Children without vaccination are healthier than children with vaccination

3. Cancer is never found before oblige to get measles vaccination, but after getting for about

200 people get cancer (Cancer research from England)

4. Give solution by using traditional recovery method like honey, olive oil, date

2nd speaker:

1.

Polio cases are increased 50% after getting polio vaccination in 1957 ( United States

Congres)

2. Autism increase between 200-500% in the world after getting vaccination

3. SIDS ( Sudden Infant Death syndrome) increased from 0,55 per 1000 become 12,8 per

2000 and the top of SIDS accident happen in 2-4 months when vaccine is began given to

babies.