the new ethnographers using observational research to inform new product design and development
TRANSCRIPT
About Me
Almost 20 years as a marketing manager B.A. in Cultural Anthropology M.B.A. in Marketing Working on Ph.D. in Marketing (minor in
design) research focuses on how institutional, functional
(subcultural) and/or microcultural discourses, practices and experiences influence firm
innovation particular interest in the use of ethnography in
new product development and design
Wilner 2008
2
The Study’s Context
The marketing concept says that to achieve competitive advantage and strong performance, firms should identify and satisfy customer needs and wants better than their competitors (cf. Kotler, 1999; Kirca et al. 2005).
Of course, accurately identifying those needs and wants in the course of new product design and development (NPDD) is easier said than done.
Wilner 2008
3
The Study’s Context
Traditional market research methods to gather information about consumers: self-report surveys, focus groups, analysis of historic purchase data, etc.
These methods have benefits in identifying some consumption habits or patterns, but are less useful for uncovering unrecognized, unarticulated or future desires
Deshpandé (1983) offers a useful distinction between research methods that are appropriate for verification versus those that are more useful for discovery.
Wilner 2008
4
Ethnography
Ethnography, from the Greek, ethnos = people; graph= writing is a discovery-based research method borrowed from cultural anthropology utilized by both marketing scholars (cf. Belk, ed. 1991) as well as practitioners (cf. Jordan, 2003; Ante 2006, Khermouch 2001, Mariampolski 2006).
Ethnography is generally understood as a descriptive account (usually written) of a society or culture. This account is produced after the researcher has spent time among the group of interest (naturalistic context), engaged in an activity known as fieldwork.
Wilner 2008
5
Ethnography
Traditionally, ethnographies covered a “natural cycle” (usually a year) to see how societies and their activities changed throughout the period
Engaging with informants (participant-observation) was considered at the heart of ethnography, complemented by interviews of informants
Researcher-as-instrument Interpretive perspective What people do vs. what they say they do
Wilner 2008
6
Many Types of Ethnography
According to Mariampolsky (2006) these include:
Observed product usage in private settings Structured usage Contextual usability Cultural studies Day-in-the-life Accompanied purchase Guerrilla/blitzkrieg ethnography Observed purchase or mystery shopping
Wilner 2008
7
Types of Ethnography
These types vary along multiple dimensions, including:
Context: private vs. public Specific product vs. category vs. use
constellation How structured the interaction is Amount of interaction (participation) with
consumers How evident the presence of the researcher is Duration of study Number (and “types”) of informants
Wilner 2008
8
Types of Ethnography
Other variables: Use of informant interviews Use of auto-driving (elicitation techniques) Informant checks Triangulation with other researchers,
methods Composition of research team Outputs
Written Report? Video? Recommendations? Designs?
Wilner 2008
9
For Example…
Grab a pen and paper and pair up with someone beside you. Take turns describing the experience of using a laundromat If you have used a laundromat, when was it? Why did you need to wash there? Did you go with anyone? How often did you go? What were the challenges? What would have made the experience easier?
Wilner 2008
10
For example…
Now, work with your partner again and consider: What did you see? What didn’t you see? How is it different than you remembered? What you add to your list of challenges? What would you add to your
recommendations? What is doing laundry in a laundromat?
Wilner 2008
12
Cultural Knowledge
Cost: Each washer in a laundromat generally takes $1–5 in quarters, depending on its size, and
each dryer typically takes one quarter per 6–8 minutes. Some laundromats now have washers and
dryers that accept prepaid laundry cards instead of quarters.…Cost of drop-off laundry\
service: usually, laundromats charge by the pound... A typical load of laundry weighs 10–25
pounds, costing anywhere from $7.50 to $25.00. Supplies: Take the following items with you: Your
laundry in a basket or laundry bag; detergent ; fabric softener; A roll of quarters… The washers
and dryers at laundromats are similar to machines designed for homes..but laundromat facilities
are also different in several ways. Washers and dryers require quarters (or prepaid cards) to
operate. Many washers and dryers have larger capacities than at home machines. Machines may
not be as well-maintained or cleaned as you’d like. Compartments for detergents and fabric
softeners are located atop the washer. Washers typically tumble rather than agitate…Remember
that you’re sharing washers and dryers—leaving your laundry in the machine too long is not only
harmful to your clothes but also inconsiderate to others. Never leave laundry unattended.
Because most laundromat washers are front-load models, remember that they don’t require as
much detergent as a top loader.
Wilner 2008
13
The Role of the Senses
“This is simply the freshest, cleanest
Scent imaginable. We don’t know
If anyone can tell us why, but this
May be the most comforting,comfortable scent in the
[DemeterFragrance] Library.”
Wilner 2008
14
Fun and Sociality
At a music festival [in the Netherlands]…jeans brand Wrangler
offered festival goers a much needed service: laundry. And at 18
meters wide and 9 meters high, the Wrangler Laundromat was
hard to miss. People dropped off their mud-encrusted laundry
and were sent a text message the moment it was ready. No spare
change of clothes? Wrangler came up with a generous solution to
that problem, too: they handed out black overalls to anyone who
used the laundromat. [This is] an exercise in experiential
marketing, aimed at surprising and delighting consumers in a way
that magazine ads or TV spots usually can’t.
Wilner 2008
15
Doing Laundry as Clean SlateDeclaring laundry bankruptcy If you’re someone with a mountain of laundry
who is having a problem getting your laundry situation under control, I think
that the laundromat bankruptcy plan is a good plan to follow. Go once to the
laundromat, get all of your clothes washed, and then get started on your new
laundry routine at home with a clean slate… you can do your laundry
yourself, or you can use the Fluff-N Fold service that most laundromats offer...
There is something simple and wonderful about using the laundromat as your
first step in getting on track with a home laundry routine. Also, if you don’t
have a washer and dryer in your home and don’t already use it, you may want
To consider using the services of your local Fluff-N-Fold. You may find that the
expense of the service is less than the amount you value the time you could
spend doing something else.
Wilner 2008
16
Reflections on Exercise
Everyday processes are complex They have both material and social meaning Missing out on part of the story might mean
missing out on an NPD opportunity Looking for one thing, you might find
another A priori assumptions can get in the way Lived experience is powerful Ethnography is only as good a tool as the
people who use it.Wilner 2008
17
Ethnography and NPD
Product design has long been consumer-centered Human factors analysis Ergonomics Participative Design
Although instances of corporate ethnography date back more than 70 years, the method wasn’t used extensively in commercial applications until the development of interactive software in the 1980s (Wasson 2000).
Ethnography has become popular in product design because it “fills a void in the research data” (Jordan 2003 p. 77).
Wilner 2008
18
Ethnography and NPD
The few marketing articles that mention both product development and ethnographic methods do so only indirectly (cf. Arnould and Wallendorf 1994, Agafonoff 2006; Elliott and Jankel-Elliot 2003); design is rarely explicitly addressed.
There is literature on the use of observational research for NPDD in the management literature and NPD literature, but very little theorizing about design and ethnography (for exceptions, see. Rappaport and Rayport, 1997; Rosenthal and Capper 2006)
Wilner 2008
19
Ethnography and NPD
Globalization, market fragmentation and increased competition have increased pressure on firms to innovate faster, with products that resonate with both existing and prospective customers
Ethnography has consequently been embraced as a research method by firms’ marketing, R&D, and design units. The hope is that its techniques will bring an understanding of consumers’ lived experiences, and therefore enable the creation of more relevant, marketable and successful products
Wilner 2008
20
Research Questions
1. Why do firms engage in ethnographic inquiry, particularly in the context of new product development and design?
2. What strategic value do they believe the methodology brings to NPDD?
3. What roles do marketers, designers, engineers and/or qualitative researchers play and how to they intersect/interact?
4. Who in the firm manages and/or interprets the findings?
Wilner 2008
21
Ethnography and NPD
Ethnography, then, is seen as a unique lens for “seeing” the consumer
Hundreds of major firms purport to you it as one research method for NP (or service) D
Is it a fad? Does it work? Under what conditions?
Do you need to hire anthropologists? Design ethnographers? Marketing consultants?
Wilner 2008
22
Research Program
Phase One: reviewing the rhetoric surrounding theuse of ethnography in NPDD (i.e.: looking at whatProponents of the method say about it)
Phase Two: conducting on-site observation to see what
transpires and how it compares to assumptions
Phase Three: Gleaning best practices for NPDD
Wilner 2008
23
Phase One Data Sources
Books on ethnography written for marketing managers;
Media reports on firm use of the method Blogs on design, innovation, and applied
anthropology that discuss the ethnographic method in NPD
Ethnographic consultants’ marketing materials (often just one of a suite of market research methods offered)
Design associations’ materials Conference proceedings (e.g. EPIC (Ethnographic
Praxis in Industry Conference), DUX (Designing for User Experience)
Wilner 2008
24
Preliminary Findings
Ethnography = X-Ray Vision can uncover current design
flaws e.g. the smell of clean
laundry (Abrams 2000)
Wilner 2008
25
Preliminary Findings
Ethnography = Horse Whispering can get into consumers’ minds;
figure out what they’re not saying e.g. seniors at Best Western
hotels (Khermouch 2001)
Wilner 2008
26
Preliminary Findings
Ethnography = Dream Interpretation
can reveal brand or product associations that consumers aren’t consciously aware of
e.g. technology use in the home (Elliott and Jankel-Elliot 2003)
Wilner 2008
27
Preliminary Findings
Ethnography = MuseWill stimulate ideation for breakthrough products
e.g. Herman Miller’s Resolve Office System (Deasy et al. 2001)
find new consumer markets or categories for existing products (Jordan 2003)
Wilner 2008
28
Next Phase
Interviewing corporate stakeholders about the role of ethnography in new product design and development (including marketers, designers, ethnographers, consultants)
Observing firms’ qualitative research efforts and considering how the product design and development process is impacted
I would welcome your feedback and appreciate your participation in the study
Wilner 2008
29
Thank You!
Contact information:
Sarah WilnerSchulich School of BusinessYork University, [email protected]
Wilner 2008
30