tennis court dragging machine
TRANSCRIPT
1
ME30068 – GROUP DESIGN & BUSINESS PROJECT: GROUP REPORT
TENNIS COURT DRAGGING MACHINE
Group 1: Andrew Savage, Harry Davies, Hugh Porter, Luke Ray, Xianqi Yuan
Supervisor: Rod Valentine
ABSTRACT Artificial clay tennis courts require frequent maintenance to ensure the surface is
sufficient for playing. Players are asked to do this after every match by using a net and
dragging it over the court boundaries and the outer area. This is both time consuming
and can be strenuous for older or smaller players. Some players may not be willing to
do this job but may be willing to pay more for their club membership in order to avoid
dragging. This provides us with a business opportunity for a system that does this job
for members. This system can provide a high quality finish and can be more efficient
solution than manual labour, thus saving time. This report aims to present both a
technical and a business case to argue for having an automated tennis court dragging
machine.
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Abstract .................................................................................................................... 1
1 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 4
1.1 Customer Need ................................................................................................ 4
1.2 Market Segmentation ....................................................................................... 4
1.3 Market Opportunity........................................................................................... 5
2 Technical ............................................................................................................... 6
2.1 Product design specification ............................................................................. 6
2.2 Product functions ............................................................................................. 7
2.3 Machine Subsystems Division .......................................................................... 8
2.4 Assembly ......................................................................................................... 9
2.5 Method of Operation and Operating sequence ................................................. 9
2.6 Maintenance .................................................................................................... 9
3 Commercial Strategy ........................................................................................... 10
3.1 The 4Ps of Marketing ..................................................................................... 10
3.2 Market Strategy .............................................................................................. 10
3.3 Pricing Strategy .............................................................................................. 11
3.4 Length of Venture .......................................................................................... 11
3.5 Market Size .................................................................................................... 11
3.6 Capital Investment and Profitability ................................................................ 11
3.7 Potential Market Expansion ............................................................................ 12
3.8 Conclusions ................................................................................................... 12
3.9 Solution Specification Table ........................................................................... 12
Appendices ............................................................................................................. 14
Appendix A - Questions to Lansdowne road tennis club manager .......................... 14
Appendix B - Product design specification .............................................................. 15
Appendix C - Morphological chart ........................................................................... 17
Appendix D - Concept Ideation ............................................................................... 18
Appendix E - Concept Evaluation............................................................................ 24
Appendix F - Control Schematics ............................................................................ 26
Appendix G - Method of Operation .......................................................................... 27
Appendix H - Operating sequence .......................................................................... 27
Appendix I - Intellectual Property ............................................................................ 28
3
Appendix J - Market Segmentation and Identification.............................................. 28
Appendix K - SWOT analysis .................................................................................. 29
Appendix L - PEST analysis .................................................................................... 30
Appendix M - Porter’s Five Forces .......................................................................... 30
Appendix N - Ansoff’s Product Market Growth Strategy Matrix ............................... 31
Appendix O - Product Lifecycle ............................................................................... 32
Appendix P - Similar Products ................................................................................ 33
Appendix Q - Fault Tree Analysis ............................................................................ 34
Appendix R - Cashflow Statement .......................................................................... 35
Appendix S – Table of Courts in Different Countries ............................................... 36
4
1 Introduction There are a growing number of artificial clay tennis courts
being installed across the UK. Artificial clay surfaces
require players to redistribute the particles across the
surface by dragging a net across the court to prolong their
useful life. This is a manual process and needs to be done
regularly, taking several minutes, and so detracts from the
game.
It was perceived that there may be a business case
for an automatic dragging machine to replace manual
dragging. This report details the business case and design of such a machine.
1.1 CUSTOMER NEED Artificial clay courts consist of a dense, Astroturf-like carpet
with a layer of sand-like particles approximately 30mm
thick. The carpet pile wears over time, typically needing
replacing after 5-8 years without regular dragging. [1]
Dragging prevents the carpet pile showing, preventing
excess friction to the surface and extending the life of the
court to 10-12 years. On top of the regular dragging by
players, a tractor must be used fortnightly to decompress
the sand and counter large-scale sand movements
towards the most used areas of play.
Dragging the court gives a more even surface and a better ball bounce. However it
takes time that could be spent playing tennis. Additionally it is a laborious, manual
process, so players would rather not have to do it.
1.2 MARKET SEGMENTATION The potential markets for the machine include
any club with artificial clay courts. These have
been organised by membership fee and modal
members’ age are shown in Figure 3. The
modal members’ age was used to segment the
markets because artificial clay tennis courts
give a less strenuous game, resulting in less
joint and muscle aches. [2] Furthermore tennis
is growing in popularity among the over 50 age
group, [3] so clubs popular with these age groups are
likely to install more artificial clay courts. A high membership fee will also be needed
to pay for the machine, so has also been used to segment the markets. For these
reasons the Leisure and Health Clubs and Private Members’ Clubs have been
selected as the target markets.
Figure 1 – Current dragging product
Figure 2 – Artificial clay carpet
Figure 3 – Market segmentation
5
1.3 MARKET OPPORTUNITY The market opportunity is in the appeal to an artificial clay court owner or prospective
owner, seeking to reduce manual effort, increase dragged surface finish, reduce
dragging time taken and/or extend court life. The people this machine must appeal to
have been identified in Appendix J as tennis and health club members, who ultimately
decide club purchasing decisions.
Porter’s 5 Forces, PEST & SWOT analysis tools, shown in Appendices K, L and M
were used to examine the internal and external factors that will impact the marketability
and success of the product in the marketplace. The key takeaways from this were:
Intellectual property: There are no current IP patents governing clay dragging
machines. This initially offers low barriers to entry for the company, however
also benefits competition. As a new product, applications for any patentable
technology should be filed to create barriers to entry to competition.
Artificial clay court market growth: Due to their playing style and relative
ease of maintenance, artificial clay courts are rapidly growing in popularity.
Artificial clay courts are typically built as replacements for worn Astroturf courts.
This is not surprising since the marginal cost of replacing an Astroturf court with
artificial clay instead of Astroturf is low, and these clubs replacing Astroturf
courts have previously made similar size investments when initially installing
the Astroturf. As a Dragging Machine will be completely dependent on the
success of this surface, its market growth is crucial.
The rising popularity of tennis in the 50+ age group is significant. [4] From
market research at Lansdown Tennis, Squash & Croquet Club in Bath, it
became apparent that artificial clay courts are particularly popular with this
demographic. Additionally, this is the age range which show particular
resistance to the laborious activity of brushing courts. [2]
First mover advantage provides i) strong brand recognition, ii) loyal customers
& iii) more time to develop the product.
A large upfront capital investment will be required to develop this product.
The company’s financials are unknown and as such this may result in the
company having to raise capital.
Bargaining power of customers: Whilst the firm supplies directly to sports
shops and gyms, the end customer is members of tennis and leisure clubs.
These clubs are often “owned” by the members, who have the overall say in
club decisions. As such it is crucial to market to both the clubs and the
members.
New market opportunity: Launching a brand new product into a new market
segment has a high level of associated risk (See Appendix N for Ansoff’s
Matrix). This however offers a large opportunity to widen their customer base
and increase profitability in the long-term.
6
2 TECHNICAL
2.1 PRODUCT DESIGN SPECIFICATION To clarify the demands of the problem statement [5], a product design specification
was created. The demands are below, and the full version is given in Appendix B.
Requirement Importance (W increases 1-3)
Reference
Product description
Redistribute particles to the current standard D Project brief
Redistribute particles better than the current standard
D Project brief
Accommodate court sizes between 60' x 120' and 70' x 130'
D [6]
Suitable for artificial clay court materials D Project brief
Self-powered, battery/mechanical D Project brief
Post and nets to remain in place D Project brief
Performance
Cover the court in 5 minutes D Team
Fully autonomous D Project brief
Maintain even level of particles across the surface
D Project brief
Does not over compact the particles (pressure) D Project brief
Physical characteristics
Small enough to remain on court D Project brief
Must split into components of max weight 35kg D Team
Environment
To be used outdoors D Project brief
Resist court particles D Team
Temperature range -10°C - 35°C D Team
Humidity up to 100% D Team
Resist snow/frost D Team
Safety, legal and other factors
Not obstructive/trip hazard D Team
Comply with noise standards D [7]
Must not infringe on any patents D Team
Product life of 5 years D Team
Table 1 – Design Specification
7
2.2 PRODUCT FUNCTIONS A morphological approach was used, where the problem was split into several
functions, which are described in the table below. Several solutions for each function
were brainstormed and can be seen in the morphological chart in Appendix C. These
were combined to make five full concepts, which were ranked as detailed in Appendix
D. The highest ranked concept was then further developed, giving the chosen
solutions in the following table.
Function Description Chosen solution
Movement The machine needs to move and turn to cover the court, which will vary in size.
A court wide machine with wheels. This means only small turns are needed, simplifying the design.
Route The machine needs some way to know where it is on the court, so that it knows the whole court has been covered and knows where to return to
An infrared laser pointing at one post of the court.
Energy storage
The machine is to be used outside where mains power may not be available. Therefore the machine must store the energy it needs to power itself.
Lawnmower rechargeable battery.
Power input The energy storage device will need to be recharged.
Off the shelf lawnmower battery recharger.
Redistributing particles
The purpose of the machine is to replace the net which is dragged by players. The machine must remove inconsistencies in the sand like surface to give a flat finish.
Flat brushes to even the surface, coupled with a rotating, Archimedes screw shaped brush.
Storage The machine is expected to remain on the court, so will need protection from impacts/weather.
Base station with a garage door style opening.
Dealing with obstacles
The machine must be able to detect obstacles and prevent collisions to prevent damage to itself and people.
Four cameras, each installed at the top corners of each side.
Table 2 – Product Functions
8
In addition to the solutions for the core functions above, the final design has
additional functions, shown in the final concept below:
2.3 MACHINE SUBSYSTEMS DIVISION The machine was divided into five subsystems, for each of the group members to
concentrate on. It was realised that the main issue with the design feasibility was the
thickness of the machine, as this would make it obstruct play. The individual detailed
subassemblies were designed with the objective of minimising the thickness, and
culminated in the following design decisions:
Chassis and systems integration (H. Porter) - The chassis is made up of aluminium
sheet sections in a box shape without a top or base, with securing struts. Drivetrain
and brush components are secured using brackets bolted to this.
Powertrain (A. Savage) - Separate electric motors were used for each of the four
rotating brushes and for each of the two powered wheels. The machine will accelerate
to full speed within 5 seconds and the wheels can be controlled independently to turn
the machine.
Brush system (X. Yuan) - Two types of brushes are used to redistribute the sand,
stationary brushes to give an even surface and four rotating Archimedes’ screw
shaped brushes to push the sand towards the centre. The rotating brush was split into
four sections to prevent the brush sagging as a single brush was very long.
Sensors and guidance system (L. Ray) - A sensor system was required in order to
detect obstacles. The machine had four cameras, at the top corners of each side of
the machine. These cameras detect obstacles and stop the machine if necessary. For
the guidance system an infrared sensor was used. It is pointed to the posts of the
court; if the beam moves out of position then the sensor knows the machine is out of
line and will realign the wheels accordingly.
Figure 1 – Final Concept
9
Base station (H. Davis) - The base station uses a garage door-like mechanism to
open the door using small electromagnets. Durable HDPE is used to protect the
machine and a storage area which protects players’ belongings from the elements.
2.4 ASSEMBLY The machine is to be assembled in two halves in a factory, allowing it to be transported
to the court. The two halves can then be bolted together on court. Since a tractor is
used to maintain the artificial courts, it has been assumed that there is sufficient access
for the two halves.
2.5 METHOD OF OPERATION AND OPERATING SEQUENCE The machine has been designed to be simple to operate with just a button press, as
shown in the method of operation in Appendix G. The operating sequence from the
machine’s point of view is given in Appendix H.
2.6 MAINTENANCE The brushes will need to be cleaned and eventually changed when they get worn out;
this is to maintain the good surface finish produced by the machine. It will also be
ensured that the solar panels are clean so that all the available sunlight will be
absorbed. The torsional spring in the opening door will need to be changed once every
two years as it has a life of 15,000 cycles. Sealed bearings have been selected to
minimise maintenance. The camera lens will also need to be cleaned if there is any
dust on it to ensure maximum visibility; the sensor lens will also need to be cleaned.
10
3 COMMERCIAL STRATEGY
3.1 THE 4PS OF MARKETING From undertaking product lifecycle analysis, shown in Appendix O, it is clear that,
whilst the tennis court market is mature and artificial clay courts and in growth, an
autonomous clay court dragging machine is a completely new undertaking in the
introductory phase. The 4Ps of marketing were developed based on this:
Product: Initially the two models will be launched, a basic model and one with solar
panels. In the future when demand is proven, further customisation, such as
customising the product with logos or extensions to cover more of the run off areas,
can be added.
Price: Risk takers who are keen to be the first to get their hands on the new technology
will pay a premium and thus the price should be set high initially (whilst applying a
“discount”). Later variable pricing can be introduced.
Place: As the first to enter this market, clubs which First mover advantage will come
into play here, where exclusivity can be used to create barriers to entry. The product
is large and thus transportation will be difficult. As such the internet would be an ideal
platform. Scaled models could be used to demonstrate and sales representatives
should physically travel to stores and clubs to spread awareness of the new product
offering.
Promotion: Being an introductory product offering, advertising and promotion should
be very high at first to build awareness. Online advertising, demonstrations and face-
to-face meetings should be used to facilitate this.
3.2 MARKET STRATEGY The market strategy was developed using the 4Ps above and consists of the following
incentives:
First user discount: As the product will be the first of its kind, first time buyers will
tend to be risk takers, relying on the reputation of the company. As a result a discount
or guarantee will need to be offered for such a costly purchase to provide peace of
mind to the purchaser.
Trial period & leasing scheme: Demonstrations of the Court Dragging Machine could
be given to prospective clients along with the option of a trial period for a single
machine. Additionally a rental scheme could be offered allowing clubs to initially rent,
with the option to buy the machine at a reduced price in the future. This will lead to
less resistance from clients who may be apprehensive of making such a large
investment in a new product.
Multiple price strategies: Various pricing options could be given to make the product
as appealing as possible to the client. As this is sold to a variety of different clubs, their
11
needs and demands will vary. As such, offering a variety of specifications would lead
to improved profitability. Options for this would include branding/advertising on the
door flap, custom colour designs (HDPE is very easy to colour) or offering a “green”
option with the top of the box being covered in solar panels to power the system.
3.3 PRICING STRATEGY The reasons for the market opportunity which gave a financial benefit to a club were
used to calculate the machine price. The machine will reduce the amount of time
dragging the court from 4 minutes each hour to 30 seconds, allowing the court to be
used 6% more each hour. Furthermore, since the machine is quick and easy to use,
players who may not usually drag the court are expected to use the machine after
each game. This, combined with the superior finish that the machine gives over the
manual method, are predicted to increase the court life by 3 years, as dragging
increases the court life by 4-5 years. [1] This means the court can be used for 33%
more time, and combines with the 6% to give 39% more value to the court investment.
Based on the market research, detailed in Appendix A, an artificial clay court costs
£25,000 each to install, and making these benefits worth £9800.
Although these assumptions can be taken as generous, they do not include the difficult
to quantify benefits of removing the manual process, making it more enjoyable to play
tennis. For these reasons, the selling price of two machines has been set as £9000,
so £4500 each.
3.4 LENGTH OF VENTURE A venture length of three years was chosen for the design. This gives enough time for
innovation and for the system to be upgraded based on new customer needs. The
updated design can be released onto the market and will greatly increase sales. There
are currently no IPs in the market so it would be key to obtain one for our product, in
order to block potential competitors. By being up to date with customer needs and
wants, new upgrades can be released quickly and will secure our market position.
3.5 MARKET SIZE The UK currently has 23,000 tennis courts of which 21,000 are outdoor. [8] These are
shared between 3,500 clubs giving an average of 6 outdoor courts per club. With the
average life cycle of a tennis court being 17 years [9] and an estimated 25% of worn
outdoor synthetic courts being replaced with artificial clay [10]. Using the assumption
that around 20% of outdoor courts are synthetic this gives an average of 62 artificial
clay courts/year.
It is predicted that the company can supply 15%, 30% and 30% of new installations in
the first, second and third years of launch. Two machines are required per court, giving
sales of 20, 38 and 38 units in each year.
3.6 CAPITAL INVESTMENT AND PROFITABILITY
12
Since the company already manufactures and sells goods to sports shops and gyms,
it has been assumed that the existing machinery and warehousing is suitable and
available for this product. Overheads have been assumed at 20% of the material and
manufacturing costs. This gives a unit profit of £96,960, as shown in Table 7.
Given the number of assumptions made in forecasting profit margin and sales, a
simplified cashflow statement was deemed suitable and is given in Appendix R.
3.7 POTENTIAL MARKET EXPANSION Currently the product is set to be sold solely in the UK. If the product is popular with
clubs nationwide, plans will be implemented to sell the machine abroad (see Appendix
S). [7] Although the Grand Slam tournaments do not use artificial clay courts, many
amateur tournaments do use courts with artificial clay. [10] This would be a good
market to expand into as these matches will want an even surface so will need
dragging even more regularly than at clubs. This would also give good exposure for
the product. A drawback of shipping abroad would be the costs associated with the
size of the machine and import taxes. The machine would need to be sold at a much
higher price to cover these costs, which tennis clubs may not be willing to pay.
The machine could also be expanded into other sports which utilise an artificial clay
surface. Not many well-known sports use artificial clay at the moment however in the
future this may be a possibility. The machine can be implemented to accommodate
for a different sized court or potentially for different surfaces by using a different brush.
3.8 CONCLUSIONS A tennis court dragging machine was developed to meet the needs of clubs with
artificial clay courts. The key features of the product are summarised in the Solution
Specification below. A marketing strategy has been devised to maximise sales and is
expected to produce profits of £96,960 after three years.
3.9 SOLUTION SPECIFICATION TABLE
System Performance
Chassis and systems integration
Drags the entire court in two simple motions, without having the need to turn around.
Powertrain Powerful motors accelerate the machine to top speed in less than 5 seconds.
Brushing mechanism Brushes even out clay surface to a superb finish.
Sensors and guidance system
Infrared sensor detects the alignment of the machine. Motion sensing cameras automatically stop the machine if necessary.
13
Base station Automatically charges machine and also convenient storage for protection from the elements.
Automation The machine operates at the push of a button.
Dragging Speed The machine moves at a speed of 1.5 m/s.
Size and Weight The main machine has dimensions of 380mm x 13,100mm x 420mm and the base station is 451mm x 13,621mm x 571mm. The machine weighs 147.3kg.
Price The machine will cost £4500 for each half.
Table 3 – Solution Specification Table
14
APPENDICES
APPENDIX A - QUESTIONS TO LANSDOWN TENNIS CLUB MANAGER
What are the main issues with dragging? Not had any issues. Might be different come summer as the wetness means sand isn't blowing away.
How long does it take to drag the courts? Each court has two brushes, so it takes around 3-4 minutes, there's a YouTube video to show how
Is dragging always done? Almost always, with many members dragging before, after and during. A tractor is used once a week
How does dragging increase the lifespan/quality of the court? Court lasts 5-8 years without dragging, 10-12 years if dragged. Mustn't have pile on show to prevent wear. What do you think about the future of artificial clay courts? Believes Astroturf courts in the club will be replaced with clay courts as the clay courts are much more used than the Astroturf. Clay courts give some sliding, slower bounce, longer rallies which means more enjoyable games and less aching joints.
15
APPENDIX B - PRODUCT DESIGN SPECIFICATION
Requirement Importance (W increases 1-3)
Reference
Product description
Redistribute particles to the current standard
D Project brief
Redistribute particles better than the current standard
D Project brief
Accommodate court sizes between 60' x 120' and 70' x 130'
D http://www.doittennis.com/buyers-guide/tennis-court-dimensions
Suitable for artificial clay court materials
D Project brief
Self-powered, battery/mechanical D Project brief
Post and nets to remain in place D Project brief
Performance
Cover the court in 5 minutes D Team
Cover the court in 1 minutes W-3 Team
Cover the court in 30 seconds W-2 Team
Cover run-off area in addition to above
W-3 Team
Fully autonomous D Project brief
Easy to operate W-3 Project brief
Return to storage location after dragging
W-2
Maintain even level of particles across the surface
D Project brief
Does not over compact the particles (pressure)
D Project brief
Physical characteristics
Small enough to remain on court D Project brief
Must split into components of max weight 35kg
Team
Economic factors
Target manufacturing cost £3000 D Team
Batch size 200 units over 3 years D Team
Environment
To be used outdoors D Project brief
16
Resist court particles D Team
Temperature range -10°C - 35°C D Team
Humidity up to 100% D Team
Resist snow/frost D Team
Work in light snow/frost W-2 Team
Resist impacts from tennis balls and people
W-3 Team
Safety
Not obstructive/trip hazard D Team
Comply with noise standards D EU Physical Agents (Noise) Directive 2003/10/EC
Legal
Must not infringe any patents D Team
Other factors
Product life of 13 years D Team
Mean time to repair 2 years W-3 Team
Mean time to failure 7 years W-3 Team
Table 4 – Full Design Specification
17
APPENDIX C - MORPHOLOGICAL CHART The functions of the product were listed and methods of completing each function were brainstormed.
The various solutions are shown in the morphological chart. Full concepts were created by tracing paths
through the chart as described in Appendix D.
Mo
ve
me
nt
wheels
tracks flying
legs
rails
Rou
te
line detection
GPS
reference point (net post) camera
En
erg
y
sto
rag
e
battery
mechanical
hybrid
Po
wer
inp
ut
mains
solar
clockwork disposable battery
rechargeable battery
Red
istr
ibu
tin
g p
art
icle
s
Brush
net
rake
blower
vacuum scraper rotating brush
rotating brush archenemies screw
Sto
rag
e
box/hut cover
locked
docking station
Dea
ling
with
ob
sta
cle
s
avoid remove halt ignore
Figure 2 – Morphological Chart
18
APPENDIX D - CONCEPT IDEATION Each group member took a path through the morphological chart in Appendix B and turned it into a concept.
The following full concepts were created, using the majority of the concepts in the morphological chart
Concept
Function
Movement Route Energy Storage Power Input
Redistributing Particles Storage
Dealing with Obstacles
Simple Wheels Reference
point Hybrid Rechargeable
battery Rake and rotating
brush Locks Halts
Square Wheels Line detection Battery Rechargeable
battery Brush Cover Avoids
Flying Flying Camera Battery Rechargeable
battery Net Docking station Avoids
Expensive Tracks Reference
point Battery Rechargeable
battery Brush and vacuum Docking station Halts
Court wide Wheels
Rope route system Battery
Rechargeable battery Brush Hut Halts
Table 5 – Concept Ideation
23
Waterproof Battery Compartment: Rubberised, sealed compartment where flat battery can be removed and replaced with a freshly charged one. Can also
be charged wirelessly by magnetic field (similar to electric toothbrushes) by driving into docking station. Snaps into place (inspiration from rugged &
waterproof GoPro camera)
Audio & Visual Alarms & Pressure Impact Sensor Strip: When Core of rotating brush comes into contact with an obstacle, pressure sensors will activate
siren and flashing light to notify user. Robot will stop.
Rotating Brush: Used to evenly redistribute rubber particles – similar to a hoover brush Can be turned by friction or with a motor
Reference Point Sensor: Located on the underside of the robot – photo sensor to locate the reference point marked on the court
Rugged Wheels/Tyres: Rubberised and hard wearing to maintain grip in wet weather and not slip on the court. Offers suitable ground clearance
Raking Brush & Spring: Raking brush used to smooth out particles and remove tyre tracks behind robot. Similar to raking a bunker. Spring used to apply
downward, even force/pressure to brush to maintain smooth surface.
Simple concept
Figure 7 – Simple Concept
24
APPENDIX E - CONCEPT EVALUATION To determine which of the concepts was most suitable, multiple criteria decision
analysis (MCDA) was used. This objectively ranks concepts against chosen criteria.
The seven standard criteria were defined for the product as follows:
Usability - Simple to operate, Automatic and able to handle varying court sizes.
Quality - Resistance to weather and impacts
Maintainability - Ease and frequency of performing maintenance
Safety - Machine must comply with noise regulations and not be a trip hazard
Durability - Expected lifetime
Manufacturability - Manufacturing cost
Affordability - Market value
Marketability - Appeal to high end clubs/aging clubs
Additionally a storage criteria was used since this was a key aspect of the machine’s
feasibility and was not covered in the other criteria.
Each group member rated how well the concepts would meet the various criteria from
1 (very poorly) to 5 (very well). The average values were taken and multiplied by a
weighting, as shown in the figure below. The weightings are relative and allow the
group to place more importance on critical criteria.
The following table shows that the court wide system was the most feasible solution,
and was selected for further development.
25
Average for concept Weighted Average for concept
Criteria Weighting Simple Square Expensive Flying Court wide Simple Square Expensive Flying Court wide
usability 8 3.5 3.5 4 4.5 3.75 28 28 32 36 30
storability 7 4.25 1.5 4.25 3.5 1.25 29.75 10.5 29.75 24.5 8.75
quality 8 3.75 3.25 3.75 1.5 3.75 30 26 30 12 30
maintainability 7 3 2.75 2 2 3.25 21 19.25 14 14 22.75
safety 8 2.5 2.5 2.5 3.5 3 20 20 20 28 24
durability 5 3 3 3 2.25 3.5 15 15 15 11.25 17.5
manufacturability 5 2.5 3 1.25 2.25 4 12.5 15 6.25 11.25 20
affordability 5 3.25 3.25 3 3.5 4 16.25 16.25 15 17.5 20
marketability 7 3.25 3.5 3.5 4 3.75 22.75 24.5 24.5 28 26.25
Total 195.25 174.5 186.5 182.5 199.25
Proportion 65.1% 58.2% 62.2% 60.8% 66.4%
Table 6 – Concept Weightings
26
APPENDIX F - CONTROL SCHEMATICS
The green boxes represent the door mechanism and activation of the machine.
The blue boxes represent the obstacle detection system.
The orange boxes represent the guidance system.
Figure 8 – Control Scheme
27
APPENDIX G - METHOD OF OPERATION 1. Ensure there are no people or obstacles on the court in the machine’s path.
2. Push button on the base station.
3. The machine will automatically start and the door will open.
4. The machine will travel towards the net, redistributing the artificial clay particles
and leaving an even surface in its wake.
5. Once the machine has reached the tennis court net it will begin to reverse and
drag the court a second time.
6. The machine returns to the storage box and will automatically close the door
once it is inside.
7. The solar panels on the outside of the box will recharge the machine’s battery.
APPENDIX H - OPERATING SEQUENCE 1. Button on box is pressed.
2. Base station door opens.
3. Power is supplied to the wheels and brush. Machine starts moving towards net.
4. The rotating Archimedes screw brush redistributes particles across the court
evenly, so that particles are moved back towards the middle. The stationary
brushes give the court an even surface.
5. The cameras on the machine will detect obstacles on the machine’s route,
stopping the machine before a collision occurs.
6. The infrared sensor will detect the alignment of the machine in relation to the
tennis court posts and the wheels will be readjusted if the machine starts to go
off track.
7. Once the machine has reached the tennis court net the electrical polarity will
be swapped, causing the wheels to reverse and the machine to go back the
same way it came.
8. The machine returns to the base station and as it returns a button is pushed in
the base station which closes the door.
9. The solar panels on the outside of the base station recharge the machine’s
battery whilst inside.
28
APPENDIX I - INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY The escapement patent database yielded no similar machines for the following
searches: artificial clay tennis, synthetic clay tennis, clay tennis sand
Given that the market is small and internet searches did also not show any other
products that drag the court, it was believed that the machine was not infringing on
any intellectual property rights.
APPENDIX J - MARKET SEGMENTATION AND IDENTIFICATION The potential markets for the machine include any club with artificial clay courts. These
have been organised by membership fee and modal members’ age are shown in
Figure 3. The modal members’ age was used to segment the markets because
artificial clay tennis courts give a less strenuous game, resulting in less joint and
muscle aches. [2] Furthermore tennis is growing in popularity among the over 50 age
group, [3] so clubs popular with these age are likely to install more artificial clay courts.
A high membership fee will also be needed to pay for the machine, so has also been
used to segment the markets. For these reasons the Leisure and Health Clubs and
Private Members’ Clubs have been selected as the target markets.
In Private Members’ clubs the club members have the final decision as to whether to
invest in a machine as such decisions are made by member vote. Although members
do not have such explicit control in Health and Leisure clubs, they still influence the
Figure 3 – Market Segmentation
29
club’s purchasing decisions as they are likely to move to rival clubs if they have more
desirable facilities.
Therefore to sell the machine to sports shops and gyms, the company must market
the machine to club members and tennis clubs, so that they demand the machine from
sport shops and gyms. This is visualised in the image below, with the demand flows
in yellow and marketing in blue. The company only needs to make sports shops and
gyms aware of the product, so this is shown dotted.
APPENDIX K - SWOT ANALYSIS
Figure 9 – Sales Flow Chart
Figure 10 – SWOT Analysis
30
APPENDIX L - PEST ANALYSIS
APPENDIX M - PORTER’S FIVE FORCES
Figure 11 – PEST Analysis
Figure 12 – Porter’s Five Forces
33
APPENDIX P - SIMILAR PRODUCTS Market research was done for a variety of similar products; firstly a Zamboni (ice
resurfacing machine) was researched. This process was done by dragging a net (or a
cloth) which is attached to a pole along the ice to resurface it. [11] Currently a net is
used on most clay tennis courts and this is very similar to how a Zamboni operates.
The next reviewed product was the Solar Breeze Pool Cleaner. It is a device which
floats on the water and sucks in debris as it moves using a micro filter; water comes
out of the back of the device. The debris can then be removed like a vacuum cleaner
bag. The robot also has wheels which are used to pivot along the pool wall. [12] This
device is fully autonomous as it automatically knows where to go on the water surface
and when to come out of the water to recharge.
Another similar product is the fully autonomous John Deere automatic lawnmower. Its
range of mobility is restricted by a pre-installed wire which goes around the perimeter
of the garden. It pushes small obstacles out of the way and ignores large ones. [13]
Its mobility is similar to the Solar Breeze in which it knows when it needs to recharge
and knows where it has not cut before.
Another researched machine was the LG HomBot Vacuum Cleaner. It has two
cameras where one scans the floor for mobility and the upper camera scans the ceiling
for navigation. It is designed to only clean where it has not cleaned before and can be
left to hoover for the whole day and will automatically return to charge like the John
Deere. It uses a main brush and also a fan for gathering dirt, also utilising a mop for
finishing. [14] This is very similar to our machine as it utilises a brush and is fully
autonomous.
The most similar product is one which is currently used by many tennis clubs, the
Venus Terrarosa. It is operated manually and is rolled over the court; the method of
movement is the same as a net (which is also currently used). The Venus have blades
which can be set at an exact depth of clay to be removed. The gathered clay is then
broken up and recycled or evenly spread over the court. [15] The main drawback is
that it is not autonomous; it is also expensive at £4260 and weighs 120kg which can
make it difficult for people to operate. [16]
34
APPENDIX Q - FAULT TREE ANALYSIS
Sensor failure:
Laser sensor failure: The machine will go slightly towards or away from the net.
Camera Failure: The machine will not react to obstacles in front or at the back of its
body. Keeping moving may cause collapse failure of the chassis or the brushes.
Figure 15 – Fault Tree Analysis
35
APPENDIX R - CASHFLOW STATEMENT
Cashflow Statement at End of Year 1
Cash receipts from customers £90,000
Cash paid to suppliers and manufacturers and labour costs (51,800)
Overhead cost (18,000)
Net increase in cash
20,200
Cash, beginning of year
0
Cash, end of year
20,200
Cashflow Statement at End of Year 2
Cash receipts from customers £171,000
Cash paid to suppliers and manufacturers and labour costs (98,420)
Overhead cost (34,200)
Net increase in cash
38,380
Cash, beginning of year
20,200
Cash, end of year
58,580
Cashflow Statement at End of Year 3
Cash receipts from customers £171,000
Cash paid to suppliers and Manufacturers and labour costs (98,420)
Overhead cost (34,200)
Net increase in cash
38,380
Cash, beginning of year
58,580
Cash, end of year
£96,960
Table 7 – Cashflow Statement
36
APPENDIX S – TABLE OF COURTS IN DIFFERENT COUNTRIES
Population Players* Clubs Courts Indoor Coaches
USA 313.9m 13.2m 14,226 99,014 11,182 25,000
Germany 81.8m 4m 9,584 48,056 4,898 20,000
France 65.4m 4.1m 8,217 32,387 8,554 9,291
GB&NI 64.3m 4.4m** 2,740 21,506 1,528 15,000***
Italy 60.7m 3.2m 3,000 9,600 1,800 5,000
Spain 47.3m 4.8m 1,226 5,676 57 16,500
Australia 22.3m 2.2m 2,980 15,785 167 1,818
Table 8 – International Tennis Court Data
37
REFERENCES
[1] “QUESTIONS TO LANSDOWN TENNIS CLUB MANAGER", Lansdown Tennis Club, 2016.
[2] R. Valentine, "Tennis Court Dragging Machine Q&A", University of Bath, 2016.
[3] "Sport England: Understanding variations in sports participation", 2010. [Online]. Available: https://www.sportengland.org/media/112596/tennis-case-study-1-.pdf. [Accessed: 07- Mar- 2016].
[4] Department of Mechanical Engineering, "GROUP DESIGN & BUSINESS PROJECT", University of bath, 2016.
[5] "Tennis Court Dimensions - Buyer's Guides DoItTennis", Do It Tennis, 2016. [Online]. Available: http://www.doittennis.com/buyers-guide/tennis-court-dimensions. [Accessed: 07- Mar- 2016].
[6] "Directive 2003/10/EC - noise - Safety and health at work - EU-OSHA", Osha.europa.eu, 2003. [Online]. Available: https://osha.europa.eu/en/legislation/directives/82. [Accessed: 07- Mar- 2016].
[7] D. Ornstein, "Wimbledon 2013: The state of grassroots & elite tennis in Britain", BBC Sport, 2013. [Online]. Available: http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/tennis/22912754. [Accessed: 07- Mar- 2016].
[8] "Cost and Life Cycle – Courts and Surfaces - Learn - Tennis Australia", Tennis Australia, 2016. [Online]. Available: http://www.tennis.com.au/learn/courts-and-surfaces/cost-and-life-cycle. [Accessed: 07- Mar- 2016].
[9] "tiauk.org | The Business of Tennis", Tiauk.org, 2016. [Online]. Available: http://www.tiauk.org/page.asp?node=214&. [Accessed: 07- Mar- 2016].
[10] "Tennis Services UK Limited", Tennisuk.net, 2016. [Online]. Available: http://www.tennisuk.net/TEMS/TourDetail.aspx?tid=307. [Accessed: 07- Mar- 2016].
[11] "My home made ice resurfacer (zamboni)", YouTube, 2016. [Online]. Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=em0uaBWba709. [Accessed: 07- Mar- 2016].
[12] "Solar Breeze: The Robotic Solar-Powered Pool Cleaner Review", YouTube, 2016. [Online]. Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jzWfClbOnIc. [Accessed: 07- Mar- 2016].
[13] "John Deere Tango robot lawnmower- Which? first look", YouTube, 2016. [Online]. Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2MQ-7gnw5co. [Accessed: 07- Mar- 2016].
[14] "LG - LrV5900 Hom-Bot Robot Vacuum Cleaner", YouTube, 2016. [Online]. Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dhIP_1CvrSk. [Accessed: 07- Mar- 2016].
[15] "tennis clay court maintenance", Venus-terrarossa.it, 2016. [Online]. Available: http://www.venus-terrarossa.it/en-clay-court-maintenance.html. [Accessed: 07- Mar- 2016].
[16] "Venus Terrarossa", Bit.ly, 2016. [Online]. Available: http://bit.ly/1QxC6G0. [Accessed: 07- Mar- 2016].