tarporley talk december 2012
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
1/88
Ycw~aw`fu
Yexfwyam
Jayfgwaad
Ycyyfmoc``
Ycwxem
Df`zc``
Iviiam
Gvmgvwu
Fcyam
Ov`fu
rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal Yf` >3799 :6>:5?
Ifjflgfw 7>37 Ezzvf 5:
Emj`viemb yof Ycw~aw`fu cwezo Javmje` mfrz`fyyfw
V^ YA
JOFC^FW+
9>&
+^wejf jal~cwezam jawwfjy cz ah >9!3>!37
Avw lage`f zfwxejflfcmz jofc~fw yuwfz
Ya awifw uavw mfr yuwfz, jc`` avw
jvzyalfw zfwxejfz yfcl am>?>> ?87>9:6aw xezey rrr-yuwfzamyofiwexf-jal
Rf zcxf uav yelf
J`cewf , Jvzyalfw Zfwxejfz Yfcl
cmi lamfu #
yely lff
wxejfz Yfcl
fuf #
J
:6>:5?
fyyfw
F
WC
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
2/88
z~fjec`ezy lcmvhcjyvwfwzah ~vw~azflcif yelgfwremiarz, iaawz cmi jamzfwxcyawefz
wfivjf uavw jcwgam haay ~wemy reyo oebo ~fwhawlcmjf yelgfw hwclfiremiarz cmi cii svc`eyu cmi wfc` xc`vf ya uavw oalf
hv`` HFMZC wfbezyfwfi
emzyc``cyeam zfwxejf reyo
yfm ufcw bvcwcmyff
Rf mar ocxf c ge,ha`iiaaw zfy a~fwcyeamc` em avw
zoarwaal
oarwaal cmi rawdzoa~
mey 3g, Gcwwarlawf Fmyfw~wezf Fzycyf
cwmoavzf @cmf, By Gcwwar Mw Jofzyfw, JO:2KC
yf`; >3?75 293263rr-jofzoewfkaemfwuzfwxejfz-`yi-vdrr-jofzoewfkaemfwuzfwxejfz-`yi-vd >3?75 293263rrr-jofzoewfkaemfwuzfwxejfz-jal >3?75 293263
Zoarwaal cmi rawdzoa~A~fmemb yelfz; Lamicu , Hweicu 5cl , 6~l cmi Zcyvwicu 5-:>cl , :~l
Vmey 3g, Gcwwarlawf Fmyfw~wezf FzycyfGcwmoavzf @cmf, Bwfcy Gcwwar, Mfcw Jofzyfw JO:2KC
Rf mar ocxf c
a~fwcyeamc` em avw zoarwaal
Rf rezo c`` avw jvzyalfwz ~czy cmi ~wfzfmy c xfwu
Lfwwu Jowezylczcmi c~waz~fwavz Mfr Ufcw
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
3/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 :
5:c Jofzyfw Waci, Jczy`f, Mawyorejo, JR? 3OO
^wexcyf Yce OewfGaad uavw cew~awy oewf
3 lamyo em cixcmjf
ya wfjfexf uavw
iezjavmyfi wcyf
)))#*#'
####
###
Fllc Zc`ezgvwu Ie~- J - ^wahfzzeamc`
JZ ( OZ lflgf ahhfwz yofwc~u haw
rawdwf`cyfi zywfzz, cmefyu,
gfwfcxflfmy, rfeboy lcmcbflfmy,
~oagecz cmi jamffiifmjf ezzvfz-
Haw cm emeyec jamzv ycyeam ~ fczf jc ;
>293 6?? 8685aw `fcxf jamycjy ifyce`z cy
rrr-javmzf``embaxfwic`f-ja-vd
Javmzf``emb ( ^zujoayofwc~ucy Axfwic`f, Df`zc``
Ycwxem Jcwzrrr-ycwxemycez-ja-vd^wexcyf Oewf Yce ( Lemeg z
{ Cew~awy Ywcmzhfwz { Meboyz avy
{ Oayf`z { Rfiiembz { Zycyeamz>3?75 2976 :
>2?5> 9 9 7>2
Jowezylcz z~e ey
em ZywffyLcwdfye wxem Oebo Zywffy
U ?yo I FW
l , - >~
cyo w ow l yofwf reyo oez
w e ffw4 c``z cmif yf ycemlfmy
`` ci yo vm h y f fxfmem -
YCWXEM
JOWEZYLCZ HFZYEXC@
( ZYWFFY LCWDFY
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
4/88
^vg`ezofw Yc`dcgavy ^vg`ezoemb
Jamywegvyawz Kcmfy Ofcyo cmi Cmbf`c Gcwy`fyy
^wemy FRZ
Zc`fz @ummf Gwci`fu ( Ocu`fu Wuifw
emhaNyc`dcgavy~vg`ezoemb-ja-vd
^waivjyeam Kam Roeyf
( Iezywegvyeam
Jamycjy Yc`dcgavy ^vg`ezoemb
7mi H`aaw, Wejolami ^`cjf376 372 Gavboyam,
Jofzyfw JO: 6GO
emhaNyc`dcgavy~vg`ezoemb-ja-vd
Yf`- >3799 :6>:5?
>2?>3 6>86:?
Jewjv`cyeam 6,6>>
`` lcyfwec` ez ja~uweboy cmi zoav`i may gf wf~waivjfi reyoavy yof ~fwlezzeam ah yof
^vg`ezofwz- C`` ifyce`z cwf jawwfjy ya yof gfzy ah avw dmar`fibf- Yof ^vg`ezofwz ia may
fmiawzf aw wfjallfmi cmu ah yof fmywefz aw cixfwyezflfmyz em yof lcbc{emf vm`fzz
ayofwrezf zycyfi- Rf cixezf yocy uav lcdf uavw arm kvibflfmyz, fmsvewefz cmi
jal~cwezamz cz reyo cmu ayofw hawl ah cixfwyezemb- Rofm jamycjyemb cmu gvzemfzz, rf
zvbbfzy yocy uav jamffiwl yof fcjy yu~f ah baaiz cmi zfwxejfz ahhfwfi, yof svc`effijcyeamz
of`i cmi c`` ayofw wf`fxcmy cz~fjyz ah yof zfwxejf roejo uav cwf zffdemb-
Yof ^vg`ezofwz jcmmay cjjf~y `ecge`eyu haw `azz, iclcbf aw iehffijv`yefz wfzv`yemb hwal jamycjyzlcif yowavbo yof iewfjyawu, hwal fwwawz, alezzeamz, hwal j`celz lcif gu yof cixfwyezfwz
aw hwal alezzeamz aw emcjjvwcjefz wf`cyemb ya yf`f~oamf mvlgfwz, rawiemb, z~cjemb aw
~azeyeamemb ah cmu `ezyemb, cixfwyezflfmyz aw ayofw lcyfwec` wfbcwi`fzz ah oar jcvzfi-
LFWWU JOWEZYLCZJCM uav f efxf eyz mfcw u yelf ya ~vy v~y f J wezylcz fjawcyeamz c wfc u- Y ez
ufcw zfflz ya ocxf harm gu#
Ycw~aw fu Ycyyfm c cm Ycwxem c cxfz~fjec J wezylcz jf f wcyeamz emf v~r ej uav jcm wfc c avy em y ez f eyeam-
Rfxf c`za bay mfrz wal Ycw~aw`fu ^welcwu
Zjoaa` Gvmgvwuz vyvwf ~`cmz fzyexfj vwj fxfmyz cm ar y f c efz r a vmj
em Ycyyfmoc`` bay iwfzzfi v~ aw Oc``arffm-
Yofwfz mfrz wal Ycw~aw`fu Oebo Zjoaa`
Ycw~aw fu Xejz HJ cz rf cz c r cyz am
bve f vzemfzz ewfjyawu fc y cmfcvyu bcw fmemb cm lvj lawf-
Cz vzvc ~ fczf zv~~awy uavw ajc
gvzemfzzfz cmi iamy awbfy ya yf`` yofl yocyuav zcr y few c em Yof Yc`d
Haw yof xfwu `cyfzy v~icyfz ~`fczf xezey avwrfgzeyf cy rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
RF RAV@I @EDF YA REZO UAV C@@ C XFWULFWWU JOWEZYLCZ CMI C OC^^U MFR UFCW
Demi wfbcwiz
Yof Yc`dcgavy Yfcl
~67
9 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5?
JAMYFMYZYcw~aw`fu ^cwezo Javmje` ~3> ( 33
Zfwxejfz ~2:2
ocyz am xe``cbf emif ~2??8mif ah cixfwyezfwz ~?
Rf cwf cm emif~fmifmy`u armfi jal~cmu gczfi weboy
ofwf em Jofzoewf ~waivjemb ze lcbc{emfz Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d
Dff~ ey @ajc` Mfzyam @ajc Ofzrc`` @ajc` Axfw`febo
Wavmicgavy cmi Oaa`f Wavmicgavy-
Haw ifyce`z xezey rrr-yc`dcgavy~vg`ezoemb-ja-vd
~7?
~
~6?
Yof Ycw~aw`fuYfzyfw
Jcm uav hmi yof Ycw~aw`fuYebfw em yoez fieyeam1
Of ez oeiifm zalfrofwfem yof lcbc{emf-Yof cmzrfw ez am ~cbf ?2
~69
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
5/88
Cbf Jamjfwm /Jofzoewf%------------------ 38>8 ??999>
C`jaoa`ejz Cmamulavz-------------------- ?96 285 2666
Jwelfzya~~fwz ---------------------------------- ?>> 666 333
Lezzemb ^fa~`f --------------------------------- 6>> 2>> 2>>
Mcyeamc` Iwvbz Of`~`emf-------------------- ?>> 228 8>>
Zclcweycmz /Jofzyfw% --------------------- 3799 :22 555
Bcz @fcd /Ywcmzja%-------------------------- ?>> 333 555
Jofzoewf Rfzy ( Jofzyfw Javmje` >:>> 37: ? 37:
OFC@YO WF@CYFI
Ycw~aw`fu Oaz~eyc`--------------------------- 3?75 2:7 9:8
Acd`cmiz Ifmyc`------------------------------- 3?752:752
Ycw~aw`fu Ifmyc` J`emej -------------------- 3?75 2:773:
Javmyfzz ah Jofzyfw Oaz~eyc` -------- 3799 :86 >>>
MOZ Iewfjy-------------------------------------------->?96 98 92
Gvmgvwu Lfiejc` ^wcjyejf---------------- 3?75 78>73?
Ycw~aw`fu @ajc` Iajyawz;Iwz AJc``cbocm ( ^cwymfwz ----------- 3?75 2::96
Iwz B`ffd, Bwehffim ( Cifu ---------------- 3?75 2:79>3
YWCXF@
Gvz cmi Jacjo /Jofzoewf Gvz emha% 3799 8>7 888
Mcyeamc` Wce` Fmsvewefz /emha am`u% -- ?96 29? 956>
cmjofzyfw Cew~awy ------------------------- ?23 723> 233
Kaom @fmmam Cew~awy, @exfw~aa`------->?23 673 ?9?9
VZFHV@ MVLGFWZ
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 6
`` `Y y y 5 7 7 9 7 7
@cwbf `aci cwfc eifc` haw Ba`ffimb ! Zde,emb Oa`eicu Ywcmzhfwz , v~ ya ? ^czzfmbfwz $ @vbbcbf
AH YCW^AW@FU
^WEXCYF OEWF YC_E CMI
LEMEGVZ ZFWXEJF
GAADFIUAVWOA@EICU1JC@@VZYAGAADUAVWCEW^AWYYWCMZHFWC
^WEXCYF OEWF YC_E CMI
LEMEGVZ ZFWXEJFCE ^AWY Y CMZHFWZ
ZY EAM Y _E YWCMZHFWZ
RF IEMBZMEBOYZ VY
J JFWYZ ^FJEC@ F FMYZ
@cwbf `aci cwfc eifc` haw ba ffimb ! zdeemb oa`eicu ywcmzhfwz , v~ ya ? ~czzfmbfwz $ `vbbcbf
Zv~fweaw j`fcmemb wfzv`yz am c`` axfmz, Cbcz, wcmbfz
cmi fywcjyawz-
Lejwarcxf axfm j`fcmemb cmi zcmeyezemb-
Jallfwjec` wcmbfz, zc`clcmifwz cmi
fywcjyeam oaaiz-
Jallfwjec` jamywcjy rawd vmifwycdfm haw ~vgz,
wfzycvwcmyz, zjoaa`z, mvwzfwefz, ~`cu gcwmz,
ja``fbfz, jcyfwemb zjoaa`z ( `fyyemb cbfmyz-
Jallfwjec` jamywcjy rawd jcm gf
vmifwycdfm avyzeif ah ywciemb oavwz-
Zchf cmi wagvzy j`fcmemb ~wajfzz fmcg`emb
ellfiecyf vzf ah c`` c~~`ecmjfz-
Xc`vf haw lamfu yowavbo zfy ~wejfz
emj`viemb gv`gz cmi e`yfwz-
Hv``u emzvwfi haw ialfzyej cmi
jallfwjec` /`ecge`eyu cy 6l% rawd( c`za svc`eefi yowavbo YCCAJ-
@ajc` hcle`u gvzemfzz hajvzemb
am wf`ecge`eyu, ywvzy, j`efmy
zcyezhcjyeam cmi wf~fcy jvzyal-
Yf` >352? ?77 282
Lag >2?58 726 ???rrr-rummzycuj`fcmemb-ja-vd
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
6/88
8 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
EM YOF MFRZ
rrr-zaxfwfebmremiarz-ja-vd
Hcx; >3?75 22>>72
JC@@ UAVW @AJC@ HCLE@U GVZEMFZZ;
Fzy-35?9
Yf`; >3?75 227622
Vmey 9, Mfr Wvzzec Oc``, Jofzyfw Waci, Ycyyfmoc``, Mw Jofzyfw JO: 5CO
Wemb ^oe`e~ aw Kamcyocm Zyvggz haw cm ellfiecyf svaycyeam-
Remiarz
88375>375>Remiarz
??38>>38>>hwal
hwal
Remiarz
99 5>>hwal
YWCIEMB HAW
72Ufcwz
Bcyfzofcyo
C93Roeyj
ovwjoWaci
Jofzyfw Waci
Jofzy fw W i-
Bcyfzo
fcyo@m
-
cyyz@m-
C93
RFCWF
OFWF
OcyyamOc``
OcyyamOfcyo
YARCX
FWYAM
ZV^FW ZC@FZV^FW ZC@F
MFR ZOARWAAL MAR A^FMLam ya Hwe ?cl 9~l
ZCY GU C^^AEMYLFMY
Wfivjf uavw ofcyemb ge `z reyo
Hemi vz amHcjfgaad
3> Ufcw Bvcwcmyff @arF B`czz Hv` u Fl~`aufi Emzyc` fwz Emyfwmc` u B`c{fi
3> Ufcw Bvcwcmyff @arF B`czz Hv` u Fl~`aufi Emzyc` fwz Emyfwmc` u B`c{fi
MFRIaaw Ifzebmfwam avw rfgzeyf#
Ywu ey avy cy;rrr-zaxfwfebmremiarz-ja-vd
HWFFYOFWLC@
B@CZZ
cyyfmoc`` oalfz c~~fc`
IFXF@A^FWZ ocxf `cvmjofi ~`cmmemb c~~fc`z chyfw javmje``awz yvwmfi iarm yofew
c~~`ejcyeamz ya gve`i oalfz em Ycyyfmoc``- Wfiwar Oalfz cmi Czo`fu Rc`` oci zjoflfz
wfhvzfi cy Ocwiemb Cxfmvf cmi Bwffm`cmiz wfz~fjyexf`u- Javmje` fcifw J``w Ledf Kamfzzcei yocy axfwifxf`a~lfmy rav`i gf iezczywavz haw yof xe``cbf-
cibfw gceyemb wf~awyz
@EJF cwf emxfzyebcyemb c wf~awyfi emjeifmy ah ~acjofwz ! gcibfw gceyfwz cy Re``embyam
cmf, J`ayyam- Cjjawiemb ya yof ~a`ejf ofzf ahhfmjfz cwf may vmjallam, cjwazz yof
roa`f ah yof wvwc` javmywuzeif, gvy gfjcvzf yof ahhfmjfz ajjvw lazy`u cy meboy, crcu hwal
wfzeifmyec` cwfcz, yofu cwf ahyfm vmmayejfi- C z~adfzlcm zcei4 Yof ahhfmifwz ocxf ma
wfbcwi haw re`i`ehf aw yof iabz roejo yofu ahyfm vzf- E rav`i vwbf `cmiarmfwz ya gf xebe`cmy
haw fxeifmjf ah zvjo ahhfmjfz am yofew `cmi, cmi ya wf~awy cmu zvz~ejeavz cjyexeyu-
Larfw yofhy
C yoefh zya`f c `crmlarfw hwal yof bcwcbf ah c oavzf em Oebo Zywffy, Ycyyfmoc``- Cm
cyyfl~yfi gwfcdem cy c bcwcbf em Re``embyam @cmf, Df`zc``, hce`fi rofm yof yoefh hce`fi ya
wfcd yof `ajdz-
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
7/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 2
Yof Re`i Gacw Oayf`, Roeyjovwjo Waci, Gffzyam, Ycw~aw`fu, Jofzoewf, JR8 5MR
Y;>3?75 78>:>5 F; fmsvewefzNre`igacwoayf`-jalR; rrr-re`igacwoayf`-ja-vd
Jowezylcz cy yof Re`i Gacw
@eleyfi cxce`cge`eyu haw ~cwyu meboyz am
HWEICU 2YO ( ZCYVWICU 77MI IFJFLGFW2-:>~l leimeboyC`` emj`vzexf Jowezylcz Iezja ( jcwxfi gvhhfy- 66->> ~fw ~fwzam
Oavzf remfz, iwcvboy gffwz, oavzf z~eweyz, lefwz cmi zahy iwemdz emj`vifi
c f e e h
{ e v o { I
C@@ CZ^FJYZ AH YWFF
RAWD VMIFWYCDFM
HF@@EMB, ^WVMEMB (ZYVL^ BWEMIEMB FYJ
HV@@U EMZVWFI REYO
AXFW UFCWZ
F_^FWEFMJF
JC@@ ICXF AM
Yf`
>3?75 29>?>>Lag >2?>5?:3523
79 Oavw Jc`` Avy-
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
8/88
? Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
y- >3799 : ? ?l- >25 6? 96:f- e fmeb mf-j -vdr- rrr-fmeb cremf- a-vd
aw~awcyf ~wexcyf bmkau c b` zz ah remf cmi ra i edf ya `fcwm
lawf1Avw yczyembz f vm, emhawl yex cmi zajecg`ffxfmyz rofwf uav bfy ya y zy cmi `fcwmcgavy remfz hwal c`` axfw raw`i- Eifc` hawGewyoicu ~cwyefz, Cmmexf z efz, Iemmfw ~cwyefz,Hvmiwcezemb, Yfcl g e i mb, Zychh ifxf`a~lfmy
cmi Mfyrawdemb
Hewzy em HeymfzzZ~awyz Yofwc~u
Iclecm Har`fz
^fwzamc` Ywcemfw! Z~awyz Yofwc~ezy
^fwzamc` Ywcememb
Rfeboy @azz Lcmcbflfmy
Z~awyz Lczzcbf Emkvwu Wfocge`eycyeam
Jawwfjyexf Ffwjezf
^oamf; >2599 96:958
rrr-ewzyemeymfzzz~awyzyofwc~u-ja-vd
cf ram a x j awu
FLGFW ah Wejocw amfz joaa`z a
Ycfdramia rfwf em cjyeam cbcem cy yof Zjay
yezo Mcyeamc` Ycfdramia Jocl~eamzoe~z
wfjfmy u-
Hexf yfcl lflgfwz rfmy ya B`czbar cmi
jclf crcu reyo 3> lfic`z cmi yowff mfrjayyezo jocl~eamz em c`` yof iezje~`emfz a
yof cwy hwal ^cyyfwmz, Yfcl Z~cwwemb cmi
Emiexeivc` Z~cwwemb-
`v emzywvjyaw Wejocw amfz zce ; Rf cwf
ocxemb c bwfcy ufcw em c`` yof jocl~eamzoe~z
rf cwf fmyfwemb- Rf jclf crcu reyo yowff
ba`iz, ffixf ze`xfwz cmi yra gwam{fz hwal kvzy
ffixf jal~fyeyawz-
cdfwu hcjf`ehyOCWWEZAMZ Gcdfwu,
em Ycw~aw`fu,ocz
gffm bexfm c wfffiy ya
jwfcyf c la fwm hff`
roe`zy wfycememb yof
ywc eyeamc` jocwcjyfw ah yof emyfweaw-
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
9/88
%*"**)'&)*%'
'*))*7>3:
Lawf yocm uavwf `aademb haw-
**"%()*%'
))('''))''')%
)')
'*))&%'
)&')
()
&)%
)'
'*'**
))'#&)%'')%
))')"''
(*))
"'')
))(*'
'**/*('')%
(**)'77 @arfw Gweibf Zywffy, Jofzyfw JO3 3WZ >3799 :7:7:7 jofzyfwNzcxe``z-jal
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
10/88
3> Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
YCW^AW@FU ^CWEZO JAVMJE@MFRZ@FYYFW
Javmje` em `elga rceyemb aw~`cmmemb c~~fc` wfzv`y
E lamyo rf ocxf gffm lcdemb ~`cmz aw avw owezylcz @eboyz fxfmy am Hweicu :>yo
Maxflgfw% cmi bfcwemb v~ haw yof ja`i cmi eju rfcyofw gu ~wf~cwemb haw avw Xa`vmyffw
Remyfw Bweyyemb ~wakfjy- Eh uav rav`i `edf ya dmar lawf aw rav`i `edf ya ahhfw ya bwey yof
~cxflfmyz mfcw rofwf uav exf, ~`fczf jamycjy feyofw yof ~cwezo j`fwd am Yf` 2 9
aw Kclfz G`cjdhawi cy kog`cjdhawiNoaylce`-ja-vd-
Cz ya ~`cmmemb c~~ ejcyeamz, rf cwf em c ~fweai ah rceyemb4 rceyemb haw yof avyjalf ah
y f Mcmyrejo Waci ~wa~azfi ifxf`a~lfmy roejo ez reyo yof Lemezyfw, Fwej ^ejd`fz C
wfz~amzf ez ivf gf awf 32yo Ifjflgfw 4 rceyemb aw yof ~wa~azfi ifxf`a~lfmy am yof
ichhaie` ffif`i ahh yof Oebo Zywffy ya jalf gfhawf JRcJz ~`cmmemb jalleyyff4 rceyemb haw yof
~c~fwrawd haw yof ~`cmmemb c~~`ejcyeam haw wfyewflfmy oavzemb ahh Gewjo Ofcyo Waci4 cmi
rceyemb aw yof ~`cmmemb c~~`ejcyeam aw yof Gwaad Hcwl zeyf-
f f~fjy ya gf iezjvzzemb yof c~~`ejcyeam cgavy yof `cmi a Gewjo Ofcyo Waci cy avw
mfy lffyemb am Lamicu 3>yo Ifjflgfw em yof Jallvmeyu Jfmywf- ^fa~`f cwf rf`jalf ya
zocwf yofew xefrz reyo vz cy yof ~fm Hawvl
cy 2~l-Cz hcw cz yof Gwaad Hcwl zeyf cmi yof
`cmi a~~azeyf cwf jamjfwmfi, eh cmi rofm ey
wfjf xfz ~ cmm mb ~fwl zz am, rf myfm ya
jamzv`y yof xe``cbf cgavy oar yoez avyiaaw
z~awyz cm , r y ~cw mb cm j cmb mb
cje`eyefz, ez ifxf`a~fi- Rf re`` mffi ya dmar
roejo z~awyz hcje`eyefz yof jallvmeyu rcmy- Za
rcyjo avy haw c `fcfy yowavbo uavw `fyyfw ga
m -
f cmy j ~cyf zfyy mb v~ c j cw yc f ywvzy ya
lcmcbf yof hcje`eyefz- Za rf re`` gf `aademb haw ~fa~`f ya hawl c rawdemb bwav~ ya vmifwycdf
yof jamzv`ycyeam, zffd hvmiemb cmi ifxf`a~ yof zeyf- Eh uav cwf emyfwfzyfi ~`fczf jamycjy yof
j`fwd am >3?75 2::958 aw ~cwezoj`fwd ycw~aw fu-awb-vd
of ayofw ~cwy a yof `cmi a~~azeyf yof Gwaad Hcwl zeyf re` gf vzfi ya gve i c awicg`f
oavzemb, gayo ya wfmy cmi ~cwy gvu~cwy wfmy /zocwfi armfwzoe~%- Eh ~`cmmemb ~fwlezzeam ez
bwcmyf , rf rcmy ya lc f zvwf y cy ajc ~fa~ f, cm ~fa~ f r a raw m y f x cbf, mar
c avy y z a~~awyvm yu ya xf m cw~aw fu- fczf yf cmuamf uav y m l b y f myfwfzyf -
Hemc``u yof lflgfwz ah Ycw~aw`fu ^cwezo Javmje` rezo fxfwuamf c xfwu lfwwu cmi ~fcjfhv`
Jowezylcz cmi c oc~~u cmi ~waz~fwavz 7>3:-
Gwaad Hcwl
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
11/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 33
YCW^AW@FU ^CWEZO JAVMJE@ JAVMJE@@AWZYof Jocewlcm a yof ^cwezo Javmje` ez Javmje``aw Dfm ^cwdfw-Y f cwez J fw ez Lw- K- Lcj amcJ cwyraa Oavzf 7> Mcmyrej Wac Ycw~aw fu JR8 5V
~cwezoj`fwdNycw~aw`fu-awb-vd Yf`- >3?75 2::958
Ycw~aw`fu ocz yrf`xf ^cwezo Javmje``awz fcjo a roal zeyz am amf a yof yra Rawdemb Bwav~zr ej lffy am c yfwmcyexf lamy z aw cz wfsvewf Javmje aw- Jamycjy Ifyce z cwf >3?75
EmwczywvjyvwfBe`` J`avbo z~adfz~fwzam %----------------------------- 9
Kclfz G`cjdawi ------------------------------------------ 7
fwflu Le `z--------------------------------------------------- 5fm cwdfw jocewlcm ------------------------------ 73
Xejyawec Cizofci------------------------------------------ 357
cxe ^wfzz----------------------------------------------------- 3
Cwfcz a emyfwfzye``cbf emeyecyexfz Ywcmz~awy cmi Oeborcuz
JZA Jamywcjy cmi Zfjvweyu Jallvmeyu Gvz
Jallfwjf Jowezylcz @eboyz!Hfzyexc`
Zywffy ZjfmfWejocwi Gwefw`fu /z~adfz~fwzam% ----------- 2 7
@emic Gvwwarz ---------------------------------------------- 2 77
Bwcocl @ffz ------------------------------------------------2@em c Gfmmfyy-------------------------------------------------2 2
F`cemf Joc~lcm---------------------------------------------2::527
Cwfcz a emyfwfzyGfzy Df~y Xe``cbf H`arfw Iez~`cuz Ocmiulcm
Zywffy J`fcmemb Joe`iwfmz ^`cu Cwfc cmi
Jallvmeyu Emeyecyexfz-
YCW^AW@FU ^CWEZO JAVMJE@EMHAWLCYEAM Yf`- >3?75 2::958
^cwezo Javmje` Lffyembz
of ^cwezo Javmje` lffyz em yof Jalleyyff Waal a yof Jallvmeyu Jfmywf cy 2 ~l am yof zfjami
amicu a fcjo lamyo reyo yof fjf~yeam a Cvbvzy- Lffyembz cwf a~fm ya yof ~vg`ej cmi
zycwy reyo cm A~fm Hawvl zfzzeam ivwemb roejo lflgfwz a yof ~vg`ej jcm ciiwfzz yof roa`f
avmje` am lcyyfwz a jamjfwm ya yofl- C`za yof ^cwezo Javmje` oa`iz c zvwbfwu cy 8-:> ~l ~weaw
ya fcjo ^cwezo Javmje` lffyemb rofm lflgfwz a yof ~vg`ej cwf rf`jalf ya iezjvzz lcyyfwz reyo
javmje``awz am cm emawlc` gczez-
@AJC@ BAXFWMLFMY JAVMJE@@AW
Jofzoewf Rfzy cm Jofzyfw Javmje
J``w Fxf`febo LaawfIvyyam/Jamzfwxcyexf% >3?75 2::678
^a`ejf Jamycjyz^J 97>2 Bf Bebb
Flce Bfwcw -BebbNj fz ewf-~mm-~a ejf-v^JZA Z ffmc Cuwyam
,lce z ffmc-cuwyam73:8?Nj fz ewf-~mm-~a ejf-v
Flfwbfmjefz
^a ejf Mamflfwbfmju Mvl fw 3>
Iwcbam Oc`` >?96 96?8:22
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
12/88
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
13/88
)) ) ) ))+))&)) -) ) )&) #) ) ) ) *))))+)))#))*)
) *) ) *) ) !) %) ) ))*))))*)) )))%)!))+
)))) ) ) ) -)
#&) ) ) ) )#) ) ) >) -&+) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) #)) ),$%)())) ))))))"%)))))
)))#))))))#) ) #) ) ) ) ) ) ) )*/+
/'*##
!
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
14/88
39 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Zfwfmeyuah Ycwxem
Uavw `ajc` Gfcvyu Zc`am
:8g, Oebo Zywffy, Ycwxem>3?75 293937
w -
-
MFRJwc{u Cmbf` Ycm- Z~fjec` 7> a`
bf
@VZ
w -
a b
----
Vydemyamz
gwcemgafzah joe`iwfm hwal ydemyam y ^cv`z
^welcwu Zjoaa` jclf avy ya~ em yof Ufcw 6!8
Bfmfwc` Dmar`fibf Sve{ of`i cy Gvmgvwu
^welcwu Zjoaa` cy yof fmi ah `czy Oc`h Yfwl-
Yof yfcl ah havw joe`iwfm, jal~fyfi
cbcemzy ayofw zjoaa` yfclz hwal cjwazz yof
Zcmizyamf ^cwymfwzoe~, emj`viemb Ycw~aw`fu
ebo Zjoaa`, cmi rfwf yfzyfi em c wcmbf aiehhfwfmy zvgkfjy cwfcz- Yofew zjawf ah 69!8>
rcz c hcmyczyej cjoefxflfmy-
z remmfwz, yofu rfwf crcwifi c ywa~ou
roejo yof joe`iwfm jcm gf zffm ~wavi`u
iez~`cuemb cgaxf-
Ufcw 6!8 Yfcjofw Bcwfyo Jaumf zcei; Yoez
rcz c hcmyczyej cjoefxflfmy- Ey ~waxeifi cm
a~~awyvmeyu haw avw joe`iwfm ya zoar yocy yofu
ocxf c wejo cmi gwaci bfmfwc` dmar`fibf-
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
15/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 36
Am`u yof ffimfzy
mbwfiefmyz ba
mya uavw oalf-
yfhcma If G`czeaIG DEY OFM ( EMYFWE W
Zyfhcma If G`czea dmarz cgavy
myfweawz- Jf`fgwcyemb 77 ufcwz em
yof gvzemfzz cmi axfw 9> ufcwz ahf~fwefmjf, of dmarz rocy rawdz
reyo ma jal~walezf ah svc`eyu,
fjf``fmjf cmi xc`vf haw lamfu-
Rocy zf~cwcyfz Zyfhcma If G`czea
wal yof wfzy ah yof jwari cwfyofzf xfwu yoembz- Of jcwfz cgavy
uav cz c jvzyalfw, of jwfcyfz yof
fmxewamlfmy ah uavw iwfclz-
f emz~ewfi cmi jc`` yaicu am;
>3799 ::6559
rrr-zigdeyjofmz-jal
Vmey :
Rcxfwyam Gvzemfzz ^cwd
cxfwyam
Jofzyfw
JO: 2^I
Bfy yof gaiuuav `axf
rrr-dyjoc`amfw-ja-vd >2286?8?688
Jwc{u Jowezylcz afwz zycwy mar reyo
^fwzamc` Ywcememb hwal cz `eyy`f cz 36#@eleyfi cxce`cge`eyu za jc`` DY mar
haw cm afw ya zvey uav-
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
16/88
38 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Uavw @ajc` Gedf
Zoa~ cyYcyyfmoc``
Awifw Mar
Haw
Jowezylcz
Rf re`` oa`i uavw gedf
vmye` Jowezylcz Fxf
3>>z ah 7>3:
Joe`iwfmz Gedfz Em
Zyajd Mar#
Jc`` Em Yaicu
A~fm 2 IcuzHwff Jcw ^cwdemb (
Yfzy Weif Cwfc
33 Gwcmiz em 6,>>>hy7
Zoarwaal
Gedf Zfwxejf :>
rrr-b`agc`gedf-ja-vdYf`; >3?7522>?99 Flce`; oeNb`agc`gedf-ja-vd
Vmey :, Jcmc`zeif, Ycyyfmoc`` JO: 5GI
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
17/88
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
18/88
3? Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Yf`; >3?75 29>3:8 awxezey; wembraaihfmjemb-ja-vd@cmziarmf Wi, Zyclhawi Gweibf, Ycwxem, Jofzyfw, JO: ?F@ A~fm LamHwe ?6 Zcy ?-:>3->>
LFLGFWZOE^ MA- 7>>97?
Ywcieyeamc` cmf`z Gfz~adf ^cmf`z ( Bcyfz
Ifjawcyexf ^cmf`z Bcwifm ( Fmywcmjf Bcyfz
Cwjofz ( Gfmjofz Ifjdemb ( Yelgfw
Zyamf ( Cbbwfbcyf Rewf ( Mfyyemb
F`fjywej Hfmjemb
^cemyz ( Zycemz Bcwifm Zofiz Yaa`z ( IEU IEU ( Ywcif zv~~`efw Oawzf ( ^fy Haai Emzyc``cyeam Zfwxejf If`exfwu Zfwxejf
JC@@ HAW C HWFF EMZYC@@CYEAM SVAYFaw FLCE@; emzyc``cyeamzNwembraaihfmjemb-ja-vd
F~fwefmjfi hfmjfwz ( bvcwcmyffi rawd
Z^FJEC@EZYZ EM HFMJEMB
ZV^^@U ( EMZYC@@CYEAM
HAW AXFW 7> UFCWZ
XEZEY AVW ZOA^ CMI EMIAAW ZOARWAAL
HEWFRAWDZ
AM ZC@F
36 Ajy ya 3> Max72yo , :3zy Ifjcl, - ~l
Iewyu Jcw~fyz aw Axfm11
- - -
Ycwxem Jcwzrrr-ycwxemycez-ja-v^wexcyf Oewf Yce ( Lemeg z
{ Cew~awy Ywcmzhfwz { Meboyz avy
{ Oayf`z { Rfiiembz { Zycyeamz>3?75297 :
>2?5> 9 9 7>2
ZYFCLFI V^
IAVG@F B@C[EMB1
Gwadfm aw Iclcbfi Remiarz1
Hcv`yu Oembfz, Ocmi`fz aw @ajdz1
Rcmy yof `cyfzy fmfwbu zcxemb b`czz1
6 ufcw bvcwcmyff am mfr iavg`f b`c{emb-
rrr-j`aviu7j`fcw-jal
Iamy wf~`cjf yof Hwclfz--- kvzy yof ^cmfz#
Jc`` Hwff~oamf>?>> 83 7333?
---rf lcdf zcxemb lamfu ~fwhfjy`u j`fcw---
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
19/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 35
wz F Z vw GC z-,^BJ , S - J j fj f
wz ah fwefmjf zfja cw f jcyeam-v awyem fmja bm v e y f yof xfwu gf -C v fwcj v aw c za cx c f-
fczf f f z 93 8 6 F C@@
w y aw
Hwefmiz aw hcle`u jalemb ya zycu1
Ma waal1
Zf`h jcyfwemb
Rffd aw zoawy gwfcdz cxce`cg`f
9 Cjjallaicyeam! Cl~`f ~cwdemb
OA@EICU JAYYCBFZFcyam, Mw Ycw~aw`fu
@arfw Oavzf Hcwl- Yf` >3?75 2:>659!>2?885:>??6Flce`cmmf-`arfwoavzfNgyemyfwmfy-jal Rfg rrr-`arfwoavzfoa`eicuz-jal
Iv am cwezo avmje
of mfy Iviiam ^cwezo Javmje` lffyemb
re`` ycdf ~`cjf am Yvfzicu ?yo Kcmvcwu,
cy 2-:>~l, cy Iviiam Zy ^fyfwz Zjoaa`-
C ~wa~azfi Mfebogavwoaai ^`cm re`` gf
am yof cbfmic-
Remiar zlczofi
C GWEJD rcz yowarm yowavbo yof hwamy
remiar ah c oavzf em Ovmyfwz Iwexf,
Ycwxem-
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
20/88
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
21/88
-(-(-)-(&&&(/-%(-(-/
-*#*-#!--**#*----#-- -
--$---*---"--#-#
*#***#*****'
&&--/&(-,)-('-(-('--(%
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>-(-('-((&(+-#-((&>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
)--(-('--$(
--('-((>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>-(-(((-((-((
***************'*
***##*****#*&
*!>&""->-
*!3&""*)*
*#*"/(/%(%"/%
********"/%$$*++%-%**#*,&&
)-(&&---&-(-(!-$-!-)!--6-?- -->-7:9886629?9- >-7:9886628?8-- -----)))3)(&&&33'-
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
22/88
77 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Wfjfmy`u jal~`fyfi A`i Jacjo Waci, Df`zc``Of fm Rcwemb
amjf cbcem ^fyfw ocz ~waivjfi c gfcvyev` ifzebm yocy ez vmjyeamc` cmi am gvibfy
A jf; Vmey 6 R eyf @cmf, J wezy fyam, J fzyfw JO: 8CO
Yf ; >3799 ::7569 La e f fyfw; >2296 963>>3
Rfgzeyf; rrr-a`exfwbwffmdeyjofmz-ja-vd
flce ; a exfwbwffm eyj fmzNblce -jal
Bfy uavw Deyjofm if`exfwfi cmi emzyc``fi hwff ah jocwbf haw Jowezylcz
Ahhfwemb c ^wahfzzeamc` Svc`eyu Zfwxejf
{ Axfw 76 ufcwz f~fwefmjf
{ Jfmywc` Ofcyemb Emzyc``cyeam
{ Fmfwbu Fhffijefmy Zuzyfl V~bwcifz
{ Gae`fw Emzyc``cyeam
{ Gcyowaal Emzyc``cyeamz{ Zuzyfl ^arfwvzoemb
{ Ae` Ycmd Emzyc``cyeam
{ Hwff Fzyelcyfz
{ C`` Rawd Bvcwcmyffi
^CV@ MF@ZAM
253? 8:3 78:
352? 23> ?52F- emhaNja~~fwjwahy`yi-ja-vd
R- rrr-ja~~fwjwahy`yi-ja-vd
6:?972WfbezyfwfiGvzemfzz
ae` bwav~ `yibwa ~
C ywv`u emif~fmifmy
hcle`u wvm gvzemfzz
zemjf 3582
Zv~~`efwz ah Svc`eyu Ofcyemb Ae`
Gfjc Oavzf, Czoxe``f Rcu, Zvyyam Rfcxfw,
Wvmjawm, Jofzoewf RC2 :F[
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
23/88
h ` my wz x je ` fm h 3w h w z w e -
Hf f w z Yc c J z cw e m mw hwj z e
yeamz, al reyo a f ezy cm ayo v` ` ah cb emc z yof cwf vw - ` `
Wa y z i, y f w cmi v oe e3c bczyw m{c em jcwfh u m wfcwf - ,`` -
~ vz w aw fz c fm y hv` w y, y `
y me h zy `f ~ e r fh c ex
ej w y , f f cc a x m j -x we
f 3 6 fzyc f`ja fz eif y y ey e ll fi ` aa e z~fj w avew
~ ~ z,c ` ?75 -
#`f ebo i ya ay
i mf ` y yo cy wov w
m elfm jd zfw `fj y cm yofaal a a h @c fwz f l w e -mh
ya ex wce c`
y z `f cmi b y c cwy -ee v
BMM S^ / V
v~ w y f f jcm; j z
l cy z f c gf ad oy e
e avw yea -
>3?75 78> 5:>rrr-~fjdhawyamjczy`f-ja-vdHemi vz;
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
24/88
79 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Emif~fmifmy Hcle`u Fufjcwf em Ycw~aw`fu zemjf 356:
97 Oebo Zywffy, Ycw~aw`fu Yf` >3?75 2:76>3Rfg rrr-rawifma~yejecmz-ja-vd Flce` emhaNrawifma~yejecmz-ja-vd
RAWIFM A^YEJECMZcmi Jamycjy @fmz ^wcjyeyeamfwz
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
25/88
Bcwcbf wa``fwzovyyfw iaawz
>3?75 2?37:9 ! >22:? 69> 772
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
26/88
78 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
@FY YOF GF@@Z WEMB AVY YA AMF CMI C@@ YOEZ JOWEZYLCZ#
CZ ~fa~`f cwf `exemb `ambfw, rf gf`efxf ey ezxfwu el~awycmy ya wflflgfw, yocy ma lcyyfwoar a`i cwf, rf c`` ifzfwxf ya gf ywfcyfi reyoiebmeyu cmi wfz~fjy-Cy yof Gvmgvwu Cbfmju, rf lcdf ey avw
~weaweyu ya ~waxeif c zfwxejf yocy ywv`u lffyz yofmffiz ah yoazf wfsvewemb of`~- Avw jcwf zfwxejfz cwfyce`awlcif haw fcjo emiexeivc`, ma lcyyfw rocy`fxf` ah jcwf ez wfsvewfi- Rf ~waxeif hwefmi`u cmi~wahfzzeamc` Jcwfwz aw Jal~cmeamz, roa re`` lcdfc`` yof iehhfwfmjf ya uavw wf`cyexfz svc`eyu ah `ehf-Dmaremb yocy zalfamf demi cmi vmifwzycmiembez `aademb chyfw uavw `axfi amfz jcm iwclcyejc``uwfivjf yof zywfzz cmi rawwu haw yof roa`f hcle`u-
Cgavy zalf ah avw Z~fjec` J`efmyz--Zalf ufcwz cba, c j`efmy ah avwz `azy ofw ovzgcmi
vmf~fjyfi`u- Zof oci ma joe`iwfm cmi yofwf rfwf maayofw wf`cyexfz4 ofw lcmu cmelc`z rfwf c`` zof oci `fhy-Zci`u, zof rfmy emya c iff~ if~wfzzeam, rcz vmcg`f yarczo cmi hffi ofwzf`h, cmi ywefi ya jalley zvejeif- Lazyah ofw cmelc`z rfwf ycdfm crcu hwal ofw cmi ~vy iarm,roejo ciifi ya ofw iezywfzz- Avw Jcwfwz ocxf mar gffmreyo ofw, icu cmi meboy, haw yof `czy feboy ufcwz- Zof zcuzYofu ocxf ywcmzhawlfi lu `ehf cmi E jav`i may ocxflcmcbfi reyoavy yofl- Yofu cwf lu gfzy hwefmiz-
Haw axfw yfm ufcwz rf `aadfi chyfw c `axf`u jav~`f-Yof ovzgcmi oci ^cwdemzamz cmi iefi zalf yelfcba- Avw Jcwfwz jamyemvfi ya `aad chyfw oez rehf vmye`yof icu zof zci`u ~czzfi crcu- E gfjclf baai hwefmizreyo ofw icvboyfw, cmi rf oci lcmu flayeamc`
jamxfwzcyeamz- Em yof `fyyfw zof rwayf Uavw Jcwfwz ocxflcif ey ~azzeg`f haw gayo lu ~cwfmyz ya zycu em yofew armoalf- Uavw `ciefz ocxf iamf yofew kag reyo demimfzz cmizfmzeyexeyu cmi gfjclf hwefmiz ah yof hcle`u- Lcmu ahyofl rfwf lfmyeamfi em ofw Fv`abu, roejo gwavboy yfcwzya lu fufz-- cmi yoez ez rou rf cwf za ~fwzamc`-
Ah javwzf rf cwf c gvzemfzz, gvy yof layexcyeam hawrocy rf ia ez ya lcdf c iehhfwfmjf ya zalfamf f`zfz`ehf, ma lcyyfw oar zlc``-Eh uav rav`i `edf zalf cixejf aw rezo ya iezjvzz
zalf a~yeamz cgavy c wf`cyexf aw hwefmi roa ezzywvbb`emb ya lcmcbf `exemb emif~fmifmy`u, ~`fczfjc`` vz am >3?75 2:>7>3- C ice`u Jcwfw jcm jazy cz`eyy`f cz 3> cm oavw cmi yof jazy ah c hv`` yelf `exfemJcwfw zycwyz hwal 67> ~fw rffd- Rf `aad hawrcwi yaiaemb avw vylazy ya of`~ uav-
Hwal c`` ah vz cy yof Gvmgvwu Cbfmjurf rezo uav c xfwu Oc~~u Jowezylcz
cmi c ~fcjfhv` Mfr Ufcw-
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
27/88
: Jofzymvy Yfwwcjf, Ycw~aw`fu JR8 >VR>3?75 2:: 899
Flce`; emaNlib`clawavz-ja-vd Rfg;rrr-lib`clawavz-ja-vd
li b`cl ycw~aw`fu
yof LI rcu re``
c`rcuz gf yof b`cl rcu---
Haw uavw joaazemb yofwf cwf yowff iefwfmy
~cjdcbfz c`` xcwuemb z`eboy`u am yof b`cl wcicw#
Zel~`u joaazf roejo ~cjdcbf zveyz uavw mffiz
lazy cmi `fcxf yof wfzy v~ ya vz---
Fcjo ~cjdcbf jalfz reyo c zcxemb ah v~ ya :>
cmi ez mar am`u 55##
Za, rofwfxfw uavw baemb aw roafxfw uavw reyo
yoez Jowezylcz gf reyo LI B`cl-
Eh uav `axf uavw LI B`cl f~fwefmjf rou may
zocwf ey reyo zalfamf f`zf yoez Jowezylcz reyo
@vvwu _lcz behy zfyz cxce`cg`f em zyawf am`u--
LI B`cl ocxf ~vy c `ay ah
yoavboy emya uavw Jowezylcz
~cjdcbfz haw yoez hfzyexf zfczam
LI B ya ycdf wf a c ` v
wez -
Yemd gf``f ^ jdcbf
cw /c`` b`eyyfw%
z c fy
G {e ec !ged rc
c k f
J lf cm bf
`czofz
Aw cm j Z~wcu yc
Jemifwf``c ~cjdcbf
Zof``cj ocm z reyo
Zrcwaxz e jwuzyc mce cwy
Zahy`u `vyyfwemb ~cwyu `czofz
Ba`ifm ycm /aw ej wf
aw lc jvwf
Waj zycw lem yafz
Gf`` ^cjdcb
Zof` j ocm z
a fm Z~wcu yc
/aw ~fie vwf aw lc ej wf%
fwhfjy`u mcyvwc` cwyu
cz fz
Lem yafz
L B l e m awezfi
cm fz, Z cw f l jo lawf-
Ywvzy LI B`cl yoez Jowezylcz-
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
28/88
G`uyoembz Hcwl Zoa~53 Oebo Zywffy, Ycw~aw`fu,Jofzoewf JR8 >CG
G`uyoembz Hcwl Zoa~ ( Gvyjofwu
ez c hcle`uwvm hcwl zoa~- Rf
~weif avwzf`xfz am bwaremb,
wfcwemb cmi zjwvl~emb oebo
svc`eyu ~waivjf-
Rf ocxf c `amb oezyawu ahhcwlemb em yof hcle`u ywff cmi
ocxf ifjeifi ya ycdf yof aemd,
laa cmi j`vjd ya yof wvwc` oebo
zywffy ah Ycw~aw`fu-
Rf zyajd;
Gf`yamz ocmilcif joffzf ~waivjfi reyo avw arm le`d- Oalf bwarm gffh cmi ~awd
Lwz G`uyoembz oalf lcif jcdfz
Zcxavwu ywfcyz, emj`viemb hwfzo hwvey cmi iewyu xfb-
^vyyemb yof aemd, laa (
`vjd emya Ycw~aw`fu#
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
29/88
@edf vz am Hcjfgaad Ha``ar vz am Yreyyfw
Ng`uyoembz
Yf`; >3?75 2:7?92
Ywcieyeamc`
hfzyexfJowezylczOcl~fwz cmiuv`fyeif ywfcyzmar em zyajdRf ocxf c `cwbf zf`fjyeam ahJowezylcz ocl~fwz lcif ya awifwcmi yce`awfi ya fxfwu ~wejf wcmbf,~fwhfjy haw c ~wfzfmy reyo c yrezy-
Chwffzyejdah
~awdlemjfreyo
fxfwuyvwdfu
Ifjflgfw ahhfwz@fb ah ^awd 6-6> ~fw de`a
6`g gffh lemjf 8-6>6`g ^`cem ^awd zcvzcbf 5-55
6`g Zyfr ~awd ?->>
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
30/88
:> Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
31/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 :3
Gfcvyu Zc`am ( JCJE J`emej
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 :3
c yu c eme
Ywfcylfmyz
J cwemz Hcjf cm Ga uYwfcylfmyz
JCJE Mam,zvwbejcHcjf @e
JCJE Hvyvwyfj JCJE @ehy 8
JCJE Svcmyvl JCJE Ouiwcyamf Zof``cj Mce`z Lcmejvwfz ( ^fiejvwfz Oa``uraai @czofzRcxemb Z`ellemb Ywfcylfmyz Ya~,ya,yaf Z~fjec`z
Oay Zyamf Lczzcbf Fuf`czo Yemyemb Fufgwar Zoc~f Wfmf Bvemay
Ouiwcifwlef Lemx Mce`z Emiecm Ofci Lczzcbf Oa~e Fcw Jcmi`fz Behy Xavjofwz
Behy Gczdfyz Mce`yesvfz
Oebo Zywffy, Ycw~aw`fu, JR8 >CW
Yf` >3?75 2:: 5>> rrr-zdem,iff~gfcvyuzc`am-ja-vd
{ J`cwemz behy zfyz, zjfmyfi
jcmi`fz, ~ejyvwf hwclfz,zjfmyfi iwcr `emfwz,ocmilcif behyxavjofwz c`` lcdf yof~fwhfjy Jowezylcz behy,rwc~~fi cmi wfciuya ba#
FMYFW CZ ZYWCMBFWZ ,@FCXF CZ HWEFMIZ
{ J`cwemz behy zfyz,
jcmi`fz, ~ejyvwfzjfmyfi iwcr `eocmilcif bexavjofwz c``~fwhfjy Jowezrwc~~fi cmiya ba
Rf rav`i `edf ya yocmd c`` avw j`efmyzhaw yofew jamyemvfi zv~~awy
cmi ya rezo fxfwuamf c xfwuLfwwu Jowezylcz cmic Oc~~u Mfr Ufcw-
{Reyo ZCMYC am oez rcu,Ifjflgfw c~~aemylfmyz cwfbaemb hczy# Gaad uavw Jowezylcz
YWFCYlfmyz mar ya cxaeiiezc~~aemylfmy-
^a~ em haw c lemjf ~ef ( lv``fi remf amZcyvwic ?yo Ifj 3>cl7 l
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
32/88
Lcdf Jowezylcz ^fwhfjy
Jc`` >3?75 2:932>aw zff Z~c Wfjf~yeam haw lawf ifyce`z
LCJIAMC@I ^AWYC@ OAYF@, BA@H ( Z^C
Jagg`fwz Jwazz @cmf, Ycw~aw`fu, Jofzoewf JR8 >IK
Y >3?75 2:932>
F `fezvwfzc`fz-~awyc`Nlcjiamc`ioayf`z-ja-vdYfwlz ( jamieyeamz c~~`u- Zvgkfjy ya cxce`cge`eyu- Jcmmay gf vzfi em
jamkvmjyeam reyo cmu ayofw ahhfw- Lvzy gf axfw 38 ufcwz ah cbf-
Z~c Behy Xavjofwz
c`za cxce`cg`f hwal 7>
Ywfcy c `axfi amf ya yof V`yelcyf
Z~c F~fwefmjf reyo c If`vf
Remyfw Rcwlfw Z~c Icu haw 26
Gvu amf cmi bfy yof zfjami oc`h ~wejf
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
33/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 ::
Yf Hvwmeyvwf Lcwdfy cwf z~fjec`ezyz em Acd Hvwmeyvwf, Hwfmjo Hvwmeyvwf,Lewwawfi Hvwmeyvwf, B`czz jahff ycg`fz cmi lvjo lawf
Rf cwf uavw `ajc` vwmeyvwf rcwfoavzf, bexemb uav yof gfmfy a gfemb cg`fya gvu yoez svc`eyu vwmeyvwf cy oebo`u jal~fyeyexf ~wejfz-Rf ahfw wff if`exfwu cmi if`exfw mcyeamreif-
XEFREMBZ GU C^^AEMYLFMY, A^FM LAMICU HWEICU 5 8^L-
rrr-yofhvwmeyvwflcwdfy-ja-vdf; emhaNyofhvwmeyvwflcwdfy-ja-vd
Yf`; >3?75 265 765
YOF HVWMEYVWF LCWDFYAWBCMZIC@F HCWL
DF@ZC@@, YCW^AW@FU, JOFZOEWF JR8 >ZW
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
34/88
:9 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Cxce`cg`f
rffdfmiz
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
35/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 :6
JA_Z AWCMBF, DEIIZ AWCMBF, GF@@F IF GAZDAA^, JWEZ^EM, JOEXFWZ IF@EBOY,
WAUC@ BC@C, Z^CWYCM, JOFZOEWF BA@IFM IF@EJEAVZ ( LF@WAZF CXCE@CG@F
EM ZLC@@ AW @CWBF SVCMYEYEFZ, ZVEYCG@F HAW ZYAWCBF EIFC@ JOWEZYLCZ BEHYZ
A^FM 5-:>cl,9-:>~l FXFWU ICU
C@ZA; Jofzoewf ^aycyafz, jcggcbf, jcwwayz fyj cmi c roa`f wcmbf ah Hwfzo Hwvey cmi Xfb,
Zc`ciz, @ajc` Oamfu, Jofzoewf Hcwl Ejf Jwfcl, Rf`zo Hcwloavzf Uabvwy, Jofzoewf Uabvwy cmi Gwef,
^wf~cjdfi Joffzfz, HWFF WCMBF FBBZ, Kclz ( ^wfzfwxfz, Ywcu Gcdfz, Re`i Gewi Haai, Gaad Zrc~ Zoa~, Jcwiz
Gemba meboy cy Df`zc``
ayycbf Mvwzemb cmi Wfzeifmyec`
alf, m f zc , z a mb yz cmmvc
vmiwcezfw gemba am Hweicu 2yo Ifjflgfw,
cy 2-:>~l, ya wcezf lamfu aw yof wfzeifmyz
hvmi- Yof xfmvf haw yoez ufcwz fxfmy ez
Df`zc`` allvmeyu fmywf- Yoez fmcg`fzy fl ya fm au xf fmyfwyc mlfmy y wavb avy
yof ufcw- Yof hvmiwcezfw gemba ez c`rcuz rf``
cyyfm f -
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
36/88
:8 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Re``z, ywvzyz cmi ~wagcyf
Hcle`u cmi iexawjf
Zf``emb aw gvuembuavw oalf
^fwzamc` emkvwu
J`emejc` mfb`ebfmjf
Jwelf cmi ifhfmjfwf~wfzfmycyeam
Fl~`aulfmy
Iez~vyf wfza`vyeam
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
37/88
( Mce` @avmbf
8> OEBO ZYWFFY, YCW^AW@FU, JOFZOEWF JR8 >CB>3?75 2:752:
rrr-ycw~aw`fuocewgavyesvf-ja-vd flce`ycw~aw`fuocewgavyesvfNoaylce`-ja-vd
Rf rav`i `edf ya yocmd c`` ah avw j`efmyzhaw yofew jamyemvfi zv~~awy axfw yof~czy 37 lamyoz-
Rf rezo yofl c xfwu Oc~~u Jowezylczcmi c`` yof gfzy haw yof Mfr Ufcw
^`fczf rf`jalf Kazefa cw~aw`fu cew
Gavyesvf, zof ez avwmfr zyu`ezy-
azef cz zfxfm ufcwzf~fwefmjf em rf``fzyc `ez f zc`amz
reyoem Jofzoewf cmi c~czzeam haw ja`avwemb-
Ycdf zalf ylf avy axfw yof hfzyxf ~fweai
ya wf`c- Gaad em haw uavw Jowezylcz ~cwyu,
cmi bfy wfciu ya `aad uavw gfzy reyo bawbfavz ocew cmi mce`z-
Rf mar ocxf avw Jowezylcz ~waivjyz ~cjdz cxce`cg`f C@@ VMIFW 76-
^cl~fw zalfamf z~fjec` yoez Jowezylcz reyo c mce`z beh xavjofwYof ~fwhfjy ~wfzfmy ywfcy zalfamf ya JMI ZOF@@CJ aw
GEA ZJV@^YVWF BF@ MCE@Z-
Rf ocxf fyfmifi avw a~fmemb oavwz#Za rf cwf lawf feg`f haw avw j`efmyz
a~fmemb cm fywc icu cmi ocxemb c `cyfw meboy#
Lam 5cl9-:>~l4 Yvfz 5cl8~l4 Rfi 5cl8~l4
Y vwz 5cl?~l4 Hwe 5cl8~l4 Zcy 5cl9~l4 Z m J`azf
Fmkau c jal~`elfmycwu b`czz ah lv``fi remf cmi
lemjf ~ef reyo fxfwu c~~aemylfmy gfyrffm
Lamicu 32yo Ifjflgfw Zcyvwicu 77mi Ifjflgfw
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
38/88
EM yof g`emd ah cm fuf rf cwf c~~wacjoemb yoffmi ah cmayofw ufcw, cmi ma amf jcm zcu eyz
may gffm emyfwfzyemb-
Rfxf oci yof rfyyfzy zvllfw em `exemb lflawu,
of`~fi c`amb gu yof yfcwz ah kau /cmi E emj`vif
luzf`h em yoez% cz fxfmyz vmha`ifi yowavbo
yof A`ul~ej cmi ^cwc`ulej Bclfz, cgza`vyf`u
hcmyczyej- Rfxf rcyjofi, ahyfm em yayc`
gflvzflfmy cy yof cmyejz ah Fvwa~fcm `fcifwz,
cz yofu ifgcyf yof hvyvwf ah yof Fvwa, zfflemb`u
baemb wavmi em jewj`fz /ocz cmuyoemb cjyvc``u gffmwfza`xfi#%, rfxf mar c~~cwfmy`u jalf avy ah
yof iavg`f ie~ wfjfzzeam, cmi lawf gcmdz am yof
Oebo Zywffy ocxf cmmavmjfi yofu re`` ma `ambfw
gf afwemb emcmjec` ~`cmmemb cixejf ya yofew
j`efmyz-
Lazy ah yofzf fxfmyz rfxf zel~`u gffmguzycmifwz ya, gvy eyz hcew ya zcu yocy c`` ah yofl
ocxf oci, cmi re`` jamyemvf ya ocxf cm el~cjy am
avw ~fwzamc` emcmjec` rf``gfemb-
Rfwf ya`i yocy yof A`ul~ej Bclfz yejdfy zc`fz
ocz of`~fi `ehy vz avy ah wfjfzzeam cmi yocy yof
`fbcju ah z~awyz fjf``fmjf re`` jamyemvf, E oa~f
za, ey zoav`i-
Yof Fvwa~fcm ezzvfz, re`` fxfmyvc``u gf wfza`xfi,
amf rcu aw cmayofw cmi ma iavgy rf re`` hff`
zalf ah yof gvl~z c`amb yof rcu, gvy mamf ah vzocxf lvjo em`vfmjf axfw Hwcv Lfwdf` cmi ofw
javmyfw~cwyz-
Rf jcm ia mayoemb cgavy yof rfcyofw, gvy yof
hcjy ez yocy yof wfzv`ycmy ~aaw ocwxfzyz re``
v`yelcyf`u lfcm emjwfczfz em haai ~wejfz, roejo ez
ofwf E ocxf `exfi haw lazy ah lu `ehf, E rawd
j`azf`u reyo lu j`efmyz ya hv``u vmifwzycmi yofew
ffimcmjec` cz~ewcyeamz, oa~fz cmi hfcwz-
E rav`i `edf ya emxeyf wfcifwz ah Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d ya
iezjaxfw haw yoflzf`xfz lu vmesvf c~~wacjo ya
ffimcmjec` ~`cmmemb
Yofwfz mfxfw gffm c layelf ya bfy zavmi ffimcmj
E rav`i f~fjy luemcmjec` cixezfw ya gf
~wahfzzeamc`, rocy jclf cz c lazy ~`fczcmy
zvw~wezf rcz yof ~fwzamc` yavjo cmi hwefmi`u
cyyeyvif E cmi lu cle`u wfjfexfi emeyec``u, cmi
zye`` ia em c`` avw ifc`embz reyo Jcwa`um- E wfj
allfmi ofw vmwfzfwxfi`u-
, Iw Zyfxfm Zcxcbf
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
39/88
`edf`u ya el~cjy v~am em`cyeam cmi yof z~fmiemb~arfw ah yof ~avmi em avw ~ajdfy, cmi lazy
ifemeyf`u yof ~avmiz em avw zcxembz cjjavmyz-
Oarfxfw, eh uavw gcmd ocz ifjeifi may ya afw
emcmjec` ~`cmmemb cixejf cmu `ambfw, gvy zel~`u
wfhfw uav ya c rfgzeyf, yocyz c roa``u iefwfmy
lcyyfw- Ofwf, uav ia ocxf c joaejf cmi jcm
em`vfmjf yof avyjalf-
Eyz hcew ya zcu yocy yof Hemcmjec` Zfwxejfz
Emivzywu ez jvwwfmy`u baemb yowavbo jamzeifwcg`f
jocmbf, roejo ez ~cwy ah yof wfczam lcmu ah yofgcmdz cwf ma `ambfw afwemb c emcmjec` ~`cmmemb
zfwxejf ya c`` gvy yofew rfc`yoefzy j`efmyz- Yoez
jalfz cy c yelf rofm avyzeif em`vfmjfz, zalf
ah roejo Exf kvzy lfmyeamfi, lfcm yocy eyz mfxfw
gffm lawf el~awycmy ya ocxf c zavmi emcmjec`
~`cm, yocy ez wfbv`cw u wfx frf , ~wf fwc u u fzclf ~fwzam, axfw lcmu ufcwz, may zel~`u cz c
amf a fxfmy- Haw lf amf ah yof lazy wfrcwiemb
cz~fjyz ah ~waxeiemb Hemcmjec` ^`cmmemb cixejf,
ez em yof `amb yfwl wf`cyeamzoe~z yocy emfxeycg`u
ifxf`a~ reyo lu j`efmyz cmi yofew hcle`efz, ey
lcdfz lf hff` xfwu ~wexe`fbfi /cmi c`za a`i%
rofm El may am`u czdfi ya zff yof joe`iwfm ah
zalf j`efmyz, gvy yofew bwcmijoe`iwfm yaa-
Za, c jc`` ya cjyeam, eh uav rav`i `edf lf
ya wfxefr, cz c`rcuz reyoavy emeyec` hff awag`ebcyeam, uavw fezyemb emcmjec` ~`cmmemb
cwwcmbflfmyz, ia ~`fczf bexf lf c jc`` />359?
?9>2:? aw >265 657?5>2% aw flce` cy jcwa`um-
`embNzk~~-ja-vd Rf `aad hawrcwi ya ofcwemb
hwal uav-
wf el~awycmyec` cixejf
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
40/88
9> Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Jamycjy
ya gaad uavw c~~aemylfmy
Yf`
Kcg jazyz 3>
CJJEIFMY ( GAIU
WF^CEWZ^FJEC@EZY{:>UfcwzF~fwefmjf
{^fwhfjyJa`avwLcyjoemb
{C``Lckaw (LemawRawdVmifwycdfm
{ Svc`eyu^`czyej Gvl~fwWf~cewz
{JavwyfzuJcwzCxce`cg`f
{Ja``fjyeam ( If`exfwu
{AxfmGcdfHemezohawc`` Xfoej`fWf~cewz
Yf` >357? 2?2??2rrr-k~rgaiuwf~cewz-ja-vd
Lffyemb Oavzf @cmf, Dembz`fu RC8 8Y^
C jamjfwy cy Jowezylreyo yof
ofzyfw @ciefz JoaewZcyvwicu 36yo Ifjflgfw,
2-:>~l, cy yofYarm Oc``, Jofzyfw-
Bvfzy Kaom ^efwjf,Rf`zo wf~wfzfmycyexf haw Jcwiehh
Zembfw ah yof Ufcw
jdfyz ?, ~cu cy yo aw aw yf >3799 82859>
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
41/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 93
j , e yw y, Y w~aw u JR83?752 7> - cw~aw` a-
e` wvmf xem
@ ,
cm c
yeam
i ^cyzz w f- ` f myz wfx w azzeg`f,
c z ` jaa a v
hwef wxej -
^FM ; amicu ya H 5-:>cl - >~l w c ~l
Hwff oalflcif ifzzfwy reyo
fxfwu @vmjo Lcem javwzf/fjffiemb 8 xc`vf%
Wfifflcg`f reyo yoez xavjofw
3zy :3zy Kcmvcwu 7>3:
8 Jofzymv
Jowezylcz
baaiefzcxce cg f
yaycdfcrc
u---
Gcbzahyfc
,gezjveyz
cmiayofwi
f eboyz---
Xavjofwzc
za
cxce cg f---
Jalfcmi ywu avw
Remyfw Rcwlfwz@vmjo v
ce`umaam ye` :~lfyce zZff rf zeyf a
f
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
42/88
H a~fmemb cmi i xf`a~ oebo j`czz
gvy o wz zoa~z em Zc rcu i Ocwyhawi,
@eyy` wz cwf mar ~wav y fmemb em Ycw
`f xe``c f rofwf rf ya jamyemv
zv `u am`u yof e fzy ah ajc``u zav y
waiv yz-
Fzycg ezofi em 353 em ie c
@eyy`fw hcl , f al
cmu ez mar wv cwwfm
f~ofwi c myemvfi
f mi f g , may
b wfyc x w
myfw ~waivjyz, y
c `a~emb c zywamwc ~~ uemb svc eyu
wf , v c w
wfjfmy z ~ b J ewf
~welcw o z r zo -
Em 7> 5 c z am zoa c fmfi em wy wi
hyfw j zvwf h a y f j ` ja lvmeyu- Yoez
~ ocz a cmi ez xfwu rf``
zv~~awyfi gu yof `aj wfja mezf yof mf i aw
svc`eyu `ajc` gvyjof em yofe xe``cb -
Cz c jal~cmu rf ~ cjf cy f zez am svc`eyu,
c a dfywflf`u ocwi em zavwjem m m
emfz cy- Rf cwf jvwwfmy`u zavwjem w hwal
E-Gaayo a hc z em Zc i cjo- O z c fi
rey yof i Y cjya f C zvwcmjf Z m cwi `cgf -f w a a z uavw bvcwcmy f ah vc`eyu cmi
- z i zv `u jocem ez
emz~fjyf zvw haai
aivjfi ya svc y zyc cw z u
czzvwfi cwlfwz, bw fwz cm
~waivj w em yof D, l
cwl a cjd- Of aivjfz
zalf hcmyczyej fcyemb gffh
yocyez ovmb gu vz haw `c
xav yfmifwmfzz-
Avw `clg ez zv~ vzhwal Kaom Bcyf roa hcwlz cy
@azyajdBwffm gfyrffm Mawyo
rejo c yz a - Kaom bwc{fz oez
@cl am Y `fu Oavzf ~cwd`c cmi
yof Jofzoewf Zoar Bwavmi c``arem yofl ya bwar cy
cyvwc` wcyf- Em yof cvyvlm lamyoz yofu c zfi em
Kaomz gcwmz cmi fi oez arm zoff~ wcyeamz ~waivjfi
w aw yocy Kaom ccz arm oelzf` - Yof wfzv`y ez c
cmyczyej ~w y y cy a zyfmy em svc`eyu cmi yczyf
cmi e ywv`u ofzoe f awm f - Fxfw fcw, aw c
C mfr gvyjofwz am yof
7>& AHH
GFYRFFM :WI CMI ?YO IFJFLGFW
85 Oebo Zywffy,
Ycw~aw`fu JR8 >I^Yf` >3?75 2:::2:
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
43/88
`eleyfi yelf am`u, rf cwf hawyvmcyf fmavbo ya bfy avw ocmiz am
zalf zc`y lcwzo `clg hwal yof Oa`dfw fzycyf em Jvlgwec-
Rf c >& f w bf haw avw ~awd roejo ez zv~~`efi ya
z g mmc @ambyo w~, h mcz Oc~~u Ywayyfwz roejo ez
c f em Oar Fczy Uawdz wf- mc z ram lcmu crcwiz
hwal yof ~eb emivz u haw o w wfcwemb cmi hcwl mb ~a`ejefz,
azy wfjfmy`u y aai eb cwi haw ofw ja ~czzeam
hcwle - oez jfwycem`u oarz cz zof ~waivjfz alf cm
yczyej czyem a - hc y zyej yczyemb ~awd ez yof zyc~`
emb fmy a avw crcwi remmemb cb , fcjo ufcw rf
jamzezy y rem Ba Crcw z cy y f Mawy fzy G^F_ zc
zcbf ~f eyeam , ez yaa c u ya e fwf, za fczf
jalf cmi y u ofm rf a -
Cz uav re`` zff wal cgaxf, rf y f b cy wf y y
am`u zavwjf ya~ svc`eyu cmelc`z, gvy c`za hawb wamb
emdz reyo avw hcwlfwz wfzv`yemb em yof gfzy~waivj
fx rffd- Rf oa~f yocy rf jcm jamyemvf ya zv~~`u
Ycw~aw`fu x reyo yof emfzy hwfzo lfcyz jamyemvemb
yof bwfcy kag iamf ew u u Kaom Zclgwaad, cmi yofm
haw yof `czy zfxfm ufcwz gu `cwf cmi Wag- Yofwf re``
zye`` f c hcle`ecw hcjf gfoemi y f a fw cz Mcyocm
re f zycue reyo vz, gvy Icwwfm cmi ^c ejd ^ciz%
gf ae b i aad emb hawrcwi ya yoe mf
c xfmy #
Oa~fyazff av zaam
oebo zywffy
WagcmiJcwf,ahyofXecbfGvyjofw,rav`iedfyayocmdc`avwvzyalfwzhawyofewzv~~awyzemjfrfyaadocwbfahyofgvzemfzzem7>>6-Mar,czrfocmiyofwfemzya@eyyfwzGvyjofwz,rfrav`i`edfyaycdfyoez~~awyvmeyuyarezooflfxfwuzvjjfzzhawyofhvyvwf-
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
44/88
99 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
F_J@VZEXF YAJCWW CMI BWEHHEYOZ
+REYO V^ YA 3,>>> JVZYALFW ZCXEMB+
YOF C@@ MFR JFFI MAR HWAL 39,:56CMI C HCMYCZYEJ 2 UFCW RCWWCMYU#
GAAD C MA AG@EBCYEAM YFZY IWEXF YAICU JC@@ ZC@FZ AM
>3?75 22>669
Yof Dec Jffi 3-8 JWIe 7 EZB, Gcmi C WH@ /> haw `ehf%if`exfwz c zycbbfwemb`u `ar 52b!dl ah JA7
Hvf` jamzvl~yeam hebvwfz l~b /3!3>>dl% ( Flezzeamz Vwgcm 8?-5 /9-3%, Fywc Vwgcm ?>-2 /:-6%
Jalgemfi 28-: /:-2 % 52b!dl
9-5& C^W wf~wfzfmycyexf $ 76> if~azey jamywegvyeam
Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q QQ
x Jal~wfofmzexf ^cwyz cmi Cjjfzzawefz haw Yauayc cmi Dec
x Hv`` Zfwxejf cmi Cjjeifmy Wf~cew ya C`` Lcdfz
x C~~waxfi LAY Jfmywf ahhfw :5-56 /am ~waivjyeam ah yoez ~cbf%-
x Laycge`eyu Z~fjec`ezyz me` cixcmjf am lcmu laif`z, czd haw ifyce`z
x Mfr cmi Vzfi Jcw Zc`fz jofjd avw rfgzeyf haw `cyfzy zyajd
rrr-jcwwcmibwehheyoz-ja-vd
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
45/88
Cxfmvf Gve`iembz, Oebo Zywffy Ycw~aw`fu Jofzoewf JR8 >C[
Yf`; >3?75 2::::?
Rf jcm ifc` reyo c`` uavw `fbc` wfsvewflfmyz em c hwefmi`u cmi~wahfzzeamc` lcmmfw zvjo cz;
{ ^wa~fwyu ywcmzcjyeamz gayo Wfzeifmyec` cmi Jallfwjec`
{ @czyemb ^arfwz ah Cyyawmfu cmi cixezemb yof F`ifw`u
{ Iexawjf
{ Fl~`aulfmy Lcyyfwz emj`viemb Jal~walezf Cbwfflfmyz
{ @eyebcyeam
{Re``z cmi ^wagcyf
{Cbwejv`yvwc` lcyyfwz
Rou iamy uav jc`` vz am >3?75 2::::? aw flce` vz cy wsNoeggfwyz-jal ya
cwwcmbf cm emeyec` hwff jamzv`ycyeam reyo Wejocwi Svfwf``f
ya iezjvzz uavw emiexeivc` wfsvewflfmyz
Haw uavw arm jamxfmefmjf oalf xezeyz cwf cxce`cg`f cy ma fywc jazy
Jc`` Wejocwi cy uavw `ajc` @fciemb
@cr Hewl Oeggfwyz @@^am >3?75 2::::?ya cwwcmbf cm c~~aemylfmy
emb
Mffi c za`ejeyaw1Yofm jalf cmi zff
Oeggfwyz, amf ah Jofzoewfz`fciemb `crffiwlz ofwf am
Ycw~aw`fuz Oebo Zywffy
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
46/88
98 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Cmbf`c Gcwy`fyy ez c oebo`u svc`effifi
Cixcmjfi Cfzyofyejecm reyo c`lazy :> ufcwz
ah f~fwefmjf em yof gfcvyu cmi oa`ezyej
emivzywefz- Zof ez c Iewfjyaw cmi Ellfiecyf
^czy Jocewlcm haw GCGYCJ cmi JEGYCJ- Ofwf~fwyezf ez jc``fi v~am ya fclemf Mcyeamc``u
cmi Emyfwmcyeamc``u cmi ya kvibf jal~fyeyeamz
zvjo cz Uavmb Lcdfv~ Cwyezy ah yof Ufcw
Crcwi cy J`ayofz Zoar, @amiam haw 7>3>-
Zof ez c`za c wfbv`cw jamywegvyaw ya c xcwefyu
ah jamzvlfw lcbc{emfz cmi ywcif kavwmc`z em
yof ofc`yo cmi gfcvyu zfjyawz- Cmbf`c ocz c
gfcvyu, bwaalemb cmi rf``gfemb j`emej cy yof
Re`i Gacw Oayf`, mfcw Ycw~aw`fu-
^wfxeavz, emhawlcyexf cwyej`fz am c wcmbf
ah ofc`yo cmi gfcvyu ya~ejz jcm gf havmi cyrrr-cmbf`cgcwy`fyy-ja-vd
S- Lu icvboyfw cmi E `edf ya vzf baai svc`eyu zdem jcwf ~waivjyz gvy rf
ocxf `eleyfi hvmiz cmi `cjd ah zyawcbf z~cjf za rf rfwf ramifwemb
eh yofwf cwf cmu zdem jcwf ~waivjyz yocy rf jav`i zocwf- Avw zdem
jamieyeamz cwf sveyf iehhfwfmy, zof ez zeyffm cmi ez ~wamf ya gwfcdavyz
cmi El hawyu ze cmi mffi cmyecbfemb ~waivjyz# Rocy jcm uav
wfjallfmi1
C- Cz zywcmbf cz ey zavmiz reyo yof weboy le ah zdem jcwf ~waivjyz,
uav jcm ycdf jamywa` ah gayo gwfcdavyz cmi zebmz ah cbemb reyoavy
z~fmiemb c hawyvmf, zcxemb uav gayo lamfu cmi gcyowaal z~cjf-
Vm`fzz uavw zdem ez fywflf`u iwu, uav jcm gayo vzf c bfmy`f,
rcyfw za`vg`f j`fcmzfw cmi cy meboy vzf c zahy rczo j`ayo
em jamkvmjyeam reyo yof j`fcmzfw ya fmzvwf yocy c`` ywcjfz
ah lcdfv~ ez yoawavbo`u wflaxfi- Uav re`` gayo gfmfffiy
hwal vzemb c Gfycouiwau cjei fha`ecyaw, /uav re`` mffi
ya `aad haw zc`eju`ej cjei am yof embwfiefmyz `cgf`%- Cmi
ah javwzf, ya ~wayfjy gayo uavw zdem cmi uavw icvboyfwz
zdem hwal ~wflcyvwf cbfemb uav re`` gayo mffi c baaizvmzjwffm za joaazf amf yocy ez mam~awf j`abbemb cmi
ae` hwff- Haw c hv``wfbelf ah yof ~waivjyz yocy uav jcm
gayo vzf ~`fczf xezey yof Ifjflgfw mfrz`fyyfw ~cbf am
avw rfgzeyf rrr-cmbf`cgcwy`fyy-ja-vd
S- E ocxf wfjfmy`u wfyvwmfi hwal c jwvezf cmi E oci c
javwzf ah xfwu fhhfjyexf ffibvwf ywfcylfmyz roejo emxa`xfi
oay zfc j`cu reyo f`fjywaifz em yofl- E jcmy wflflgfw yof
mclf ah yof ywfcylfmy, gvy E rav`i `edf ya jamyemvf yofl
mar yocy E cl oalf-
C- E oa~f uav oci c baai oa eicu cmi ya wfyvwm oalf
reyo c gfyyfwffibvwf yocm gfhawf uavw oa`eicu ez c wfc`
cjoefxflfmy# Yof ywfcylfmy uav lfmyeamfi ez, c`lazy
reyoavy c iavgy, Eameyofwlef /~wamavmjfi fufam
ffyofwlff%- Eyz c xfwu fhhfjyexf ywfcylfmy cmi gfzy
wfzv`yz cwf zffm rofm vzfi em jamkvmjyeam reyo c iefy
cmi ffwjezf ~wabwcllf- Yra yu~fz ah bfmy`f, f`fjywejc`
zyelv`cyeam cwf fl~`aufi em yoez ywfcylfmy, amf ya yamf
yof lvzj`f yezzvf cmi amf ya of`~ cjyexf ~waivjyz ya
~fmfywcyf yof zdem- Yof roa`f cwfc ez fmjczfi em yofwlc`
zfc j`cu reyo lejwame{fi c`bcf, ya yamf cmi jamieyeam
yof zdem cmi yof rcwlyo hwal yof zfc j`cu z~ffiemb v~
wfzv`yz- E rav`i wfjallfmi c lamyo`u ywfcylfmy cz clcemyfmcmjf ~`cm cmi yofm c zoawy jamjfmywcyfi javwzf
~weaw ya uavw mfy oa`eicu ya zff yof gfzy wfzv`yz-
ofc`yo ( gfcvyureyo Cmbf`c Gcwy`fyyf
z
y
-
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
47/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 92
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
48/88
9? Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Fxfwu Yovwzicu8-:>2-36~l
cy Ov`fu Xe``cbf Oc``
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
49/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 95
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
50/88
6> Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
JVWYCEMZ ` G@EMIZ ` RC@@^C^FW `^A@FZ ` YWCJDZ ( CJJFZZAWEFZ
uav cwf aa mb aw fcz, z u f, mmaxc am, svc u, jal~f xf ~w jfz,
, ^CU VZ C XEZEY
jvwycemzahhwaizocl
Zyajdezy ah c`` lckaw zv~~`efwz;
Jwarzam Ocw`fsvem Re`lcmZcmifwzam ^wfzyebeavz
---ya mclf c hfr
3>>>z ah hcgwejz ya joaazf hwal-
Xejyawec Oc` , H`vem @cmf, Hwaizocl, RC8 2SO
>357? 2:36>?
A~fm Lam Hwe 56, Zcy 537
fczemzyc``cyeamzfwxe f
ZC@F
MARA
M#
HCM
YCZYEJ
AHHFW
Z
AMJ
VWYCEM
Z
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
51/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 63
JCW^FYZ ` XEMU@Z ` @CLEMCYFZ ` RAAI
ZEZC@ ` JAEW ` GFIZ ` ZAHCZ
C hcle`u wvm gvzemfzz fzycg`ezofi em 3522- Avw wf~vycyeam ez gve`y
am za`ei wfjallfmicyeamz- Rf jcwf cgavy avw jvzyalfwz-
Hvwmeyvwf!V~`ehy a`i jcw~fyz!Iaawz!Wflaxc` ah wvggezoMa ~wag`fl
Avw zfwxejfz emj`vif;
Joaazf N oalf zfwxejf
F~fwy heyyemb ( cjjfzzawefz
Hwff if`exfwu
Hwff lfczvwfz ( ~`cmmemb
Svc`eyu ~waivjyz
Jal~fyeyexf ~wejfz
Ma ~wfzzvwf zc`fz
C`` `fciemb lcdfz zv~~`efi
Yoavzcmiz
ahzcl~fzya
joaazfhwal#
Xezey avw rfgzeyf rrr-dembz`fujcw~fyz-jal
Xejyawec Oc` , H`vem @cmf, Hwaizocl, RC8 2SO
>357? 2???32
DEMBZ@FUJCW^FYZ ( EMYFWEAWZ
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
52/88
67 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
YCW^AW@FU OEBO ZJOAA@
lcy z
zyvifmyz yaad am yof
w b yfzy wc mz m y f
awy fzy cy y f
7>37 Zfmeaw Yfcl
Lcyoflcyejz Joc``fmbf-
cl Ic`f, Lejocf`
v`ywcl, Kclfz Lf`ec
cmi [cd Ivmzyamf rfwf
~ejdfi aw yof be yfi
fmw j lfmy ~wa fjy-
Reyo yof zv~~awy ah Lwamfz cm z clz,
y fu lc f y f w rcu ya
@exfw~aa` Vmexfwzeyu cmi ~vy yofew lcyoflcyejc`, jallvmejcyeam cmi yfclrawd zde``z ya yof yfzy- Lw
Kamfz zcei; Yofu iflamzywcyfi fjf``fmy jallvmejcyeam cmi ~wag`fl za`xemb zde``z, cmi rfwf
bwfcy clgczzciawz aw yof zjoaa`-
Xexf `c Hwcmjf
HEHYU zyvifmyz cmi ffixf yfcjofwz xezeyfi ^cwez em Ajyagfw
rofwf yofu zcr yof zeboyz, emj`viemb yof ZcjwfJafvw, Fehhf`
Yarfw, Zycif if Hwcmjf, yof @avxwf, Maywf Iclf, Cwj if
Yweal~of cmi c wexfw ywe~ v~ yof Zfemf-
Zyvifmyz zff
Cvzjorey{UFCW 3: zyvifmyz A`exec
Ocjd`cmi cmi Yagu
Ivyyam, yabfyofw reyo
Lwz Fxfwyam, Zeyo Hawl
^czyawc` Lcmcbfw, fr
avy ya Dwcdar, ^a`cmi,
ya xezey Cvzjorey{
Gewdfmcv jamjfmywcyeam
jcl~-
Yofu yaad ~cwy em
yof @fzzamz hwal
Cvzjorey{ wakfjy
reyo yof Oa`ajcvzy
Fivjcyeamc` Ywvzy roejo
c``arfi yofl ya `ezyfm
ya yof yfzyelamu ah cm
Cvzjorey{ zvwxexaw
[ebbu Zoe~~fw, cmi xezey
yof jamjfmywcyeam jcl~-
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
53/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 6:
( ZE_YO HAWL JA@@FBF
Cwejcm
yrem zjoaa`Z IFMYZ cm yfcj fwz x z yf
vwgcm, em Zavyo Chwejc, ya xezey
yof Yambccy Zfjamicwu zjoaa`,
cw~aw fuz ~cwymfw zj aa -
fu bay ya f~fw fmjf fzzamz
cm zff y f z l cw y fz cmiehhfwfmjfz gfyrffm yof yra
zj aa z- fu lc f zalf bwfcy
mfr hwefmiz cmi bay ya dmar
yofew oazyz, Yecwc cmi @vzofm,
r a jclf axfw ya cw~aw fu
fcw fw y z ufcw- f cw~aw fu
yfcl xezeyfi yra ayofw zjoaa`z
ivwemb yof zycu Leyjohawi
welcwu cmi Ba`ifm Zyf~z;
c zjoaa` haw joe`iwfm reyozc y fz-
8 Civ`yz 9 Jamjfzzeamz-
Yejdfyz cxce`cg`f hwal Zjoaa`
Wfjf~yeam aw Jc`` >3?75 2:766?
Yc aw jo `cmi fbf
gu cwwcmbflfmy reyo Kaz ~o Rfemgfwbfw @eleyfi,
aadfi gu Yoalcz Lffocm, Lvzej gu Jocw`fz Zywavzf-
@uwejz gu Lcwyem Zocwmem
33yo 39yo Ifjflgfw 2~l
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
54/88
69 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Zoc~emb
Gvmgvwuz
vyvwfC ZYFFWEMB BWAV^ ocz mar gffm zfy
v~ ya jwfcyf c lczyfw ~`cm ah oar Gvmgvwu
zoav`i `aad em yof ufcw 7>:>- Yof bwav~
rcz hawlfi chyfw c lffyemb, awbcmezfi
gu Gvmgvwu ^cwezo Javmje`, ivwemb roejo
lflgfwz ah yof ~vg`ej rfwf bexfm yof
a~~awyvmeyu ya iezjvzz oar ya lcdf
Gvmgvwu c gfyyfw ~`cjf ya `exf, rawd cmi`cu-
Yof eifc ez haw yof jallvmeyu
ya ifxf`a~ eyz arm xaejf cmi
zf yoez ya jwfcyf c zocwf
xezeam haw yof hvyvwf cmi cm
cjyeam ~`cm haw yvwmemb yocy
xezeam emya c wfc`eyu, zcei
Cmiwfr Yoalzam, Jocewlcm
ah Yof ^cwezo ^`cm Zyffwemb
Bwav~-Yof ^cwezo ^`cm alleyyff
cxf mar lfy zfxfwc` yelfz
cmi cwf lcdemb baai ~wabwfzz
yarcw z yof jewjv`cyeam a
ifyce`fi svfzyeammcewfz haw
yof xe``cbfwz ya jal~`fyf cmi
yovz of`~ zoc~f yof hvyvwf a
Gvmgvwu- Yofu re`` gf wfciu
haw iezywegvyeam em yof fcw`u
cwy ah 7>3:, cmi yof wfzv`yembemhawlcyeam re` f vzf ya
waivjf yof ^`cm- Rf mffi
fz~amzfz cmi cz cm emjfmyexf
ey ez emyfm f ya ahhfw zalf
we{fz ya fmjavwcbf fxfwuamf
ya ~cwyeje~cyf cmi ocxf yofew zcu
cgavy avw xe``cbf- Eh uav wfsvewf
cmu hvwyofw emhawlcyeam ~`fczf
jamycjy Cm wfr Yoalzam 3 7
7 3 -
ofwf ya of`~4
reyo z`ar wvmmemb jal~vyfwz,
bfyyemb yof lazy hwal uavw e^oamf aw e^ci,
vzemb zajec` mfyrawdz4 Hcjfgaad, Yreyyfw, @emdfiEm
oar ya gvu cmi zf`` am fGcu,
reyo uavw gwacigcmi,
cixejf am gvuemb mfr fsve~lfmy
gfbemmfw yveyeam
Eifc` Jowezylcz ~wfzfmyKJG Yavbo ~oamfz
cxce`cg`f, iwa~ yfzyfi,
ivzy cmi rcyfw wfzezycmy,
G`vfYaayo, HL Wciea,
rcwwcmyu- ^wejfz zycwy cy
86- /Laif` zoarm ez yof
ZeyfLczyfw 7 cy 376%
>3?75 22>>22 aw
jwcebNyfjoza`vyeamzcyoalf-ja-vd
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
55/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 66
j - `e fh -
JCW^FY, JVWYCEM CMI V^OA@ZYFWU J@FCMEMB Z^FJEC@EZYZ
JCW^FYZ@avmbf /3737% 78Oc``!zycewz!`cmiemb :5Gfiwaal /3737% 77
V^OA@ZYFWU:~efjf zveyf hwal 2>@fcyofw zveyf hwal 2>WVBZ hwal 36
j e a h av `` jec
j e fsv f
#'*))&("/%+$$
,-
!>
3"%+$$ 3%3"%+$$# 3"
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
56/88
68 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
HAAYGC@@ YC@D---YCW^AW@FU XEJZ HJ
Haw hvwyofw emhawlcyeam am lcyjofz, ywcememb aw z~amzawzoe~ a~~awyvmeyefz ~`fczf xefr avw
rfgzeyf ycw~aw`fuxejz-ja-vd-
Flce` vz cy emhaNycw~aw`fuxejz-ja-vd-
Jamycjy Ledf Gwfwfyam am >225:5>6785 eh cmu hvwyofw emhawlcyeam ez wfsvewfi
Uav jcm c`za gfjalf c Hcjfgaad Hwefmi ah Ycw~aw`fu Xejyawec HJ ya dff~ reyo c`` mfrz
YOF Xejzocxf gayo iamf rf`` axfw yof ~czy rffdz, reyo yof Hewzy Yfcl fmkauemb remz axfw Fbfwyam
J cmi Jamb`fyam Xc`f HJ em yof Jofzoewf @fcbvf Iexezeam Yra-
Fbfwyam HJ if~cwyfi yof H`cjjc chyfw gfemb gfcyfm :7 em c j`azf`u havboy fmjavmyfw, roe`f yof ywe~
gcjd hwal Jamb`fyam rcz lcif c`` yof lawf fmkaucg`f chyfw c ocwi havboy 3> crcu rem- C ifhfcy ya
cemf Waci rcz yof am`u `ar ~aemy ah yof lamyo, c`yoavbo yof :3 zjawf `emf iafz may ia kvzyejf ya
Ycw~aw`fu Xejz ~`cufwz ha``aremb c oebo`u jal~fyeyexf lcyjo-
Ycw~aw`fu Xejz Wfzfwxfz ocxf am`u ~`cufi yrejf wfjfmy`u, reyo amf ifhfcy cmi amf rem ciifi
ya yofew wfjawi- Yof 6> ifhfcy ya Gcwmyam Rcmifwfwz em yof Jwfrf HJ Kvmeaw Zoef`i rcz ya gf
f~fjyfi, cz Gcwmyam ~`cu em c oebofw iexezeam yocm Ycw~aw`fu-
Yof rem cbcemzy Jviiembyam Wfzfwxfz rcz fjf``fmy cmi yof uavmb zsvci fm aufi yof lc aweyu
ah ~azzfzzeam cmi jocmjfz em c bclf yofu ram :7- Yof wfzv`y bcxf Ycw~aw`fu Wfzfwxfz yofew
ffiwzy ~aemyz ah yof zfczam em am`u yofew yoewi `fcbvf ffiyvwf- C wvm ah ze `fcbvf bclfz em yof rffdz
fciemb v~ ya Jowezylcz re`` mar c``ar yof Wfzfwxfz Yfcl yof cge`eyu ya gve`i zalf jamzezyfmju
cmi lalfmyvl cz yofu `aad ya j`elg yof ycg`f cmi joc``fmbf `ajc` wexc`z Iviiam cmi Jwfrf HJ
Wfzfwxfz cy yof ya~ ah yof `fcbvf
Yocmdz ya z~amzawz
Ycw~aw`fu Xejz rav`i `edf ya yocmd J`cwf ( Wag hwal yof Xe``cbf Gvyjofwz haw yofew z~amzawzoe~ axfw
yof ~czy ffixf zfczamz- Yofew demi iamcyeamz ocxf of`~fi Ycw~aw`fu Xejz jamyemvfi ifxf`a~lfmy cmi
rf re`` gf c`rcuz bwcyfhv` haw yofew bfmfwazeyu-
cw~aw`fu Xe``c HJ
Rf ocxf wfjfmy`u gffm ~waxeifi reyo yoez ~oayabwc~o hwal
35:: ah Ycw~aw`fu Xe``c HJ- Roe`zy Yfclz zvjo cz Ycw~aw`fu
Mawyo Fmi rfwf c`wfciu wfjabmezfi ya gf ~cwy ah Ycw~aw`fuz
Haaygc``emb ofweycbf yoez ez yof ffiwzy wfhfwfmjf rf dmar ah
cgavy Ycw~aw`fu Xe``c HJ- Eh cmuamf ocz cmu ayofw ~ejyvwfz
hwal avw ufzyfwufcwz ~`fczf jamycjy Ledf Gwfwfyam roa re``
cii yof emha ya avw cwjoexf /jamycjy ifyce`z gf`ar%
Baai lamyo aw Xejz
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
57/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 62
Jc`` >2?>5 8?5527
aw rrr-df`zc``oe``-ja-vd
Df`zc`` Oe``
Wvb Rczo ( Wf~cewzIwa~ ah iewyu, gwadfm wvbz cmu icu a
yof rffd- Rczo, wf~waamb (wf~cewz c`` iamf am zeyf-
A~fm wal ?-:>6-:>~l fxfwuicu
^wejfz wal ? aw c rczo,
36->> aw rczo ( ~waa#
fwlcm wfmjo
Amf ya amf yveyeamem uavw arm oalf@amb f~fwefmjf cy
C, CZ cmi BJZF @fxf`z
gu svc`ehefioamavwz bwcivcyf
Yf` >3?75 2::2?2
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
58/88
azf azmfu r mm mb y f fzy wfzzf
Reyjo jal~fyeyeam /a~~azeyf, ya~%-
fhy; @emic Zleyo cwwexemb gu gwaalzyejd
6? Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
59/88
@ciefz roa `vmjo em Ycyyfmoc`` zycbfi c hcmju iwfzz jal~fyeyeam haw Oc``arffm-
of `vmjo rcz of`i em Yof Z~awyzlcmz ~vg em Ycyyfmoc``- Yof ~vl~dem rcz
~waxeifi gu Ycyyfmoc`` C``aylfmyz Czzajecyeam cmi jcwxfi gu Cmiu yof jofh cy YofZ~awyzlcmz-
Roejo reyjo rcz rawzy1
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 65
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
60/88
Ycyyfmoc``, Ocmi`fu
cmi Gvwrcwiz`fuJowezylcz zfwxejfz
YOF Wfjyaw cmi Jovwjorcwifmz ah yof yowff jovwjofz rezo uav
cmi c`` uavw `axfi amfz C Xfwu Oc~~u Jowezylcz cmi c ^fcjfhv`
r Ufcw-
z cwavmi yof cwezofz aw Jowezylcz
cy 3 y Ifj cy 2-:>~l Lf efxc Fxfmemb cy Gvwrcw z fu
Zvm 38yo Ifj cy 9-:>~l Jcwa` Zfwxejf cy Ocmi`fu
Zvm 38yo Ifj cy 2-:>~l Gcjo Zembfwz cy Ycyyfmoc``
5yo Ifj cy 2-:>~l Jcwa` Zembemb cy Yof ^ofczcmy, Gvwrc
y Ifj cy 8-:>~l Xe``cbf Jcwa` Zembemb am yof Le``ef`i
wi Ifj cy 9->>~l Jcwa` Zfwxejf cy Gvwrcwiz`fu
:w Ifj cy 8-:>~l Jcwa Zfwxejf cy Ycyyfm c
ezylcz Fxf cy 6-:>~l Yof G`fzzemb a yof Jweg cy Ycyyfmoc``
C z~fjec` zfwxejf haw hcle`efz
ylcz Fxf cy 33-:>~l Leimeboy Lczz cy Ycyyfmoc`
ylcz Icu Ycyyfmoc`` Zfwxejfz cy ?cl cmi 3>-:>cl
Ocm fu Zfwxejf cy 5-3 cl
Gvwrcwiz`fu Zfwxejf cy 3>-:>cl
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
61/88
7 Jovwjo Rc`d, Ycw~aw`fu
Yf` >3?75 2:75>8Yof zc`am ez kvzy ahh yof Oebo Zywffy, gfyrffm Zrfyfmoclz cmi yofarfw zoa~
Yof Gcwgfwz Zoa~
~fmemb yelfz Lam 5cl9-:>~l4 Yvfz 5cl9-:>~l, Rfi 5cl9-:>~l, Yovw 5cl6-:>~lHwe 5cl6-:>~l4 Zcy 5cl:~l-C~~aemylfmyz may c`rcuz mfjfzzcwu-
Bfy yof ~fwhfjy Svehh
reyo avw mfr wcmbf ah
zyu`emb ~waivjyz
Mar zyajdemb HVIBF
cmi YEBE Gfi Ofci
gfzy rezofz ya c`` avw jvzyalfwz hvyvwf cmi ~wfzfmyg y
Jowezylcz a~fmemb yelfz;Jowezylcz Fxf 5cl3~l-Jowezylcz Icu `azfiGaemb Icu azfYovwz 72yo Ifj `azfi
Hwe 7?yo Ifj 5cl6-:>~lZcy 75yo Ifj 5cl:~lMfr Ufcwz Fxf 5cl:~lMfr Ufcwz Icu `azfi
Rfi :wi Kcm `azfi
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
62/88
# ' '
#'*)
*)&("//%+
)&("$/,&
*//
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
63/88
5?g Jfmywc` Ywcif ^cwd, Zc`ymfu, Jofzyfw JO9 ?ZS
Yf`; >3799 822?26rrr-ajfcmzgcyowaalz-ja-vd
ZOARWAAL ! IFZEBM ! ZV^^@U ! EMZYC@@CYEAM
Hcle`u armfi cmi wvm jal~cmu, reyo yocy ~fwzamc` yavjo-
(DOXROVXAOIB@SKFOXZWMOFIRDVWW^ISB[ORVWW^HW^ZISP
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
64/88
89 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
rcz gawm cmi wcezfi
cgavy 86 le`fz hwal yof
38yo jfmyvwu oalf ah yof
raw`iz hcxavweyf zywffyhaai-
Mar of ez zocwemb yof
cvyofmyej zfjwfyz ah
ywcieyeamc` Mfc~a`eycm ~e{{cz
reyo Wauc` Acd jvzyalfwz
mfcw oez mfr oalf em
f`zc``-
`cviea ez ofci ~e{{c
jofh cy Ja`azelaz ~e{{fwec
yof Wauc` cdz mfrc`yfwmcyexf ya eyz ~a~v`cw
Acd Wfzycvwcmy-
Rf ieimy rcmy ya ba iarm
yof vzvc` ~e{{c wavyf, zcuz
yof lcmcbfw, Zjayy @vju-
Rf dmfr yocy yof zvjjfzz
ah Ja`azelaz re`` wf`u am
zfwxemb v~ yof wfc` ifc` cmi
yocy lfcmz zalfamf roa
vmifwzycmiz rocy wfc` ~e{{c
z c`` cgavy- Yocyz `cviea-
of 96 ufcwa`i Eyc`ecm
rcz gawm cmi wcezfi em yof
oezyawej jfmywc` ~waxemjf ah
zfwmec rofwf lcmu ah oezhcle`u zye`` `exf-
Rofm of `fhy zjoaa` of rcz
c gcwlcm gfhawf laxemb
mya deyjofm rawd- E gfbcm
gu rczoemb ~`cyfz, of zcuz,
gvy E rcyjofi cmi `fcwmfi
cmi z`ar`u E lcif lu rcu
v~ vmye` E gfjclf c ofci
~czyc cmi ~e{{c jofh-
Iehhfwfmjf
J`cviea cwwexfi em Fmb`cmi
76 ufcwz cba cmi havmi
yocy cvyofmyej Mfc~a`eycm
~e{{cz rfwf yoem am yof
bwavmi-
of zfjwfy, of zcuz, ez
em yof mcyvwc``u `fcxfmfi,
z`arwezemb zavwiavbo yocy
f lcdfz oelzf`h reyo avw,zc`y cmi ae`-
Lcmu ~fa~`f lcdf yoez
iehhfwfmy`u, of zcuz- Zalf
vzf zfla`emc vy E f`efxf
yof gfzy rcu ez ya dff~ey zel~`f- Cmi uav ocxf
ya dmar rofm eyz wfciu-
Uav jcm yf`` gu yof rcu ey
hff`z- Uav jcm yofm joaazf
rocyfxfw ya~~embz uav `edf
vy mayoemb yaa wejo-
vy yof zfjwfyz am y fm
yofwf- Ja`azelaz ocz
z~fjec``u el~awyfi yof am`u
yc`ecm raa ffiwf zyamfaxfm ah eyz demi em Jofzoewf-
of LCL axfm, lcif gu c
hcle`u gvzemfzz em Laifmc,
yc`u, ocz c raw`ireif
wf~vycyeam cz amf ah yof
mfzy jallfwjec` raa
axfmz cxce c `f - Ey vwmz
3>>& gffjo zcrivzy
wesvfyyfz ya gcdf ~e{{cz cy
`ezyfwemb yfl~fwcyvwfz v~ ya6>>aj-
^e{{cz yof cvyofmyej Eyc`ecm rcu
ra Eyc`ecm el~awyz
J`cviea Ycvwa{{e
reyo Ja`azelaz
raaiffiwfi zyamfx -
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
65/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 86
#'
*)'&("//%+
'*$,))"&))*
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
66/88
w Heamc Jaref ez Jofzoewf
am avwz fc azlf j aj aw-
Zof ocz axfw 3> ufcwz f~fwefmjf
em Jalfyej Lfiejemf cmi ocz
c~~fcwfi am zfxfwc` YX lcdfaxfw
~wabwcllfz-
Iw Jaref ez wfbezyfwfi reyo yof
fmfwc Lf ejc Javmje cm ez
c lfl fw ah yof Gweyezo Lf ejc`
Czzajecyeam- Zof ez c`za c lfl fw
ah yof Gweyezo Ja``f f ah Cfzyofyej
Lfiejemf cmi ocz gffm c Ba`iLfl fw a yof Emyfwmcyeamc`
Cjciflu a Cixcmjfi Hcjec`
-
IW HEAMC JAREFLG-J G-IHH ,GJCL,ECCHC
JOFZOEWF JAMYAVWZ @YI
Yf`>352? ?66 588Lag >22?? 82: 857
Flce` iw-ffiamcNjofzoewfjamyavwz-ja-vdRfg rrr-jofzoewfjamyavwz-ja-vd
Z~fjec` Afwz cxce`cg`f haw
yof HEWZY 6> J@EFMYZya gaad cm
c~~aemylfmy
em Ifjflgfw-
Mfr Ywfcylfmyz cxce`cg`f hwal Ifjflgfw;
Xcl~ewf Hcjf`ehy
@e~ `emf cmi fuf`ei ~ff`z
YofwlcXfem ywfcylfmyz
Mfr Lfiejc` Zdemjcwfwcmbfz
Bfy wfciu haw yof^cwyu Zfczam reyo
ywfcylfmyz gu
Iw Heamc Jaref
Avw ywfcylfmyz;
{ Rwemd`f wfivjyeam
{ Ocmi wfkvxfmcyeam
{ @e~ fmocmjflfmy
{ Ifja``fycbf
{ Ifwlc` he``fwz{ Lejwaifwlcgwczeam
{ Zdem ~ff`z
{ Lfiejc` zdemjcwf
{ Ou~fwoeiwazez
{ Zj`fwayofwc~u
Behy Xavjofwz
cxce`cg`f
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
67/88
JC@@ MAR YA GAAD UAVW JAMZV@YCYEAM
Oebo Zywffy, Ycw~aw`fu, JR8 >CW
Yf` >3?75 2:: 5>>
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
68/88
8? Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Zycbbfwemb`u yofwf cwf mfcw`u 3> le``eam
~fa~`f em yof Vmeyfi Dembial roa zvhhfw hwal
zalf hawl ah ofcwemb `azz reyo 32>,>>>
~fa~`f zvhhfwemb reyo maezf wf`cyfi ifchmfzz
aw yemmeyvz cz c wfzv`y ah f~azvwf ya
fjfzzexf maezf cy rawd- Yofzf jamieyeamz
cwf ~fwlcmfmy cmi yof axfw 6>z cwf
zebmehejcmy`u chhfjyfi gu yoez jamieyeam-
Ofcwemb `azz ez c jallam emkvwu yocy jcm
wflcem vmmayejfi haw ufcwz cz ey ifxf`a~z
bwcivc``u cmi ~fa~`f ahyfm ~vy ey iarm ya cbf-
Yemmeyvz ez yof lfiejc` mclf haw yoazf
zvhhfwemb hwal c gv{{emb aw wembemb maezf em
yofew ofci- C~~waelcyf`u amf em zfxfm
~fa~`f cwf dmarm zvhhfwfwz ah yemmeyvz- Yof
jamieyeam ez gf`efxfi ya awebemcyf hwal axfw
cjyexf mfwxf jf``z reyoem yof ofcwemb cwfc ah
yof gwcem-
Fl~`aufwz ocxf gffm vmifw c ivyu ya ~wayfjy
fl~`auffz hwal fjfzzexf maezf zemjf 358:-
Yoez lfcmz yocy em lcmu jczfz, yoazf
zvhhfwemb hwal maezf emivjfi ofcwemb `azz
cmi!aw yemmeyvz jcm lcdf c j`cel haw
jal~fmzcyeam cbcemzy yof fl~`aufwz, aw
rofwf yofu cwf ma `ambfw ywciemb, yofew
emzvwfwz-
Ofwf cy Svc`eyuZa`ejeyawz A`exfw ( Ja avw
z~fjec`ezf Ifchmfzz Za`ejeyawz vmifwzycmiyocy `azemb cmu ~wa~awyeam ah ofcwemb jcm ocxf
c lvjo reifw fhhfjy am uavw `ehf-
Amf ah yof jamjfwmz yocy rf ofcw ez yocy
zalf ~fa~`f hff` ey ez lawf iehhejv`y ya laxf
cwavmi cz fcze`u cz yofu vzfi ya- Yoez ez
oebo`eboyfi em c mfr zyviu gu yof Kaomz
Oa~demz Vmexfwzeyu Zjoaa` ah Lfiejemf yocy
zoarfi le`i ofcwemb `azz jcm za lvjo cz
ywe~`f yof wezd ah c ~fwzam zvhhfwemb hwal c hc``-
Yof zyviu gf`efxfz yocy yof wfczam haw yoez ezyof gwcemz emcge`eyu ya hajvz cz lvjo cz ey
mawlc``u rav`i am gc`cmjf cmi bcey, rofm ey
ez zywvbb`emb reyo ~wajfzzemb zavmiz- Yof
hemiembz oebo`eboy yocy ~fa~`f reyo am`u c le`i
ofcwemb `azz, cy cwavmi 76iG, rfwf
zycbbfwemb`u cy `fczy : yelfz lawf `edf`u ya
hc``-
rrr-a`exfwcmija-ja-vd
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
69/88
x
x
x
x
x
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
70/88
2> Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Yoez fxfmy re`` of`~ Yof KazovcYwff laxf czyf~ j`azfw ya gve`iemb
eyz Oa`eicu Oavzf cmi Zv~~awy Jfmywf-
Yagaaduavw~`cjfawhawlawfemhawlcyeamjc`` >38>8::3?6?awflce` ka~weyjocwiNyofkazovcywff-awb-vd
rrr-yofkazovcywff-awb-vd Wfbezyfwfi Jocweyu Mvlgfw; 3339>>>
@ciefz @vmjoXc`f Wauc` Cggfu Ba`h J`vgHweicu 2yo Ifjflgfw 7>37
Leiicu vmye` :~l
Bvfzyz~fcdfwIfgwcJcwwa``,EmyfweawIfzebmfw
Yejdfyzcwf 77-6>~fw~fwzamcmiemj`vifc7 javwzflfc`reyolemjf~efzcmiyfcaw jahff
Bvfzyz jcmc`zafmkauzalfwfyce` yofwc~u
Gaaduavw yejdfyzam`emf cyyofkazovcywff-yejdfygvi-jal!`ciefz,`vmjo,ifjflgfw,7>37
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
71/88
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
72/88
89 Ya
cixfwyezf
REMYFW JA@AVWB WIFMEMB GU KCMFY OFCYO
IFJFLGFWez c svefy yelf em yofbcwifm gvy yofwf cwf ~`cmyz yocy re```ehy yof z~ewey gu yof gfcvyu ah yofhawl, ha`ecbf aw arfwz- Gfwwefz amywffz cmi zowvgz bexf Jowezylcz joffwcmi yoez ufcw yofwf ocz gffm c baaizoar-
`axf yof xcwefyefz a Jayamfczyfw reyoyofew joffwhv` wfi gfwwefz- Jayamfczyfwoawe{amyc`ez ocz ofwwemb gamf `edf zyflz yocy
bwarcy cbcemzy rc``z- Wfi gfwwefz wflcemam yof zyflz haw c roe`f chyfw yof `fcxfz
cxf iwa~~fi bexemb c `axf`u f fjy cbcemzyc hfmjf aw rc``- @cwbfw Jayamfczyfwz zvjoc Jayamfczyfw hwebeivz Jawmvgec ez c zowvg
roejo ez zfle fxfwbwffm cmi ocz j`vzyfwz ah wfigfwwefz ye`` yof gewiz fcy yofl em ja`i rfcyofw-Jayamfczyfw `cjyfvz ez fxfwbwffm reyo cwjoemb
gwcmjofz `cifm reyo wfi gfwwefz cmi `aadzzyvmmemb cz c z~fjelfm zlc`` ywff em c `crm-Lazy Jayamfczyfwz ocxf roeyf arfwz em fcw`uz~wemb cmi yofew `fcxfz ja`avw rf`` em cvyvlm~`vz yof gamvz a gfwwefz em remyfw za yoemdcgavy ocxemb amf em uavw bcwifm-
fcvyehv` gcwd ez c hfcyvwf ah remyfw cmi yof~c`f jwfcl aw roeyf ah ze`xfw gewjofz ez rf``
rawyo zffemb cbcemzy c icwd gcjdbwavmi-Ayofw ywffz reyo gfcvyehv` gcwd cwf yof Cjfwz,
fz~fjec``u Cjfw bwezfvl reyo ~ff`emb ja~~fwucw r ej ez c baa ywff aw c z f yfwf z~ay
em zlc fw bcw fmz- Zele cw ja~~fw ja avwjalfz hwal ^wvmvz zfwwv`c gcwd roejo oczc zlaayo yfyvwf cmi ~a`ezo ya yof gcwd yocyyof Cjfw bwezfvl `cjdz- Zmcdf gcwd Cjfwz zvjocz Cjfw icxeiee / mcdfgcwd Cjfw% cmi Cjfw
~fmzu`xcmejvl /Zywe~fi lc~`f% ocxf bwffm cmiroeyf zywe~fi gcwd-
wazy am ~`cmyz `aadz hwfzo cmi z~cwd`emb amOa``u aw Ofvjofwc ~`cmyz- Ofvjofwcz yfmi yadff~ zalf ah yofew ha`ecbf em remyfw lcdembyofl xc`vcg`f ~fwfmmec`z haw ufcw wavmiemyfwfzy- Yof ~oaya ah Ofvjofwc Wvhfz reyohwazyfi `fcxfz ez gfcvyehv` ~ejyvwf am c jwez~zvmmu lawmemb-
amyemvf ya yeiu v~ em yof bcwifm gu jvyyemb
iarm ifci ha`ecbf cmi ~wvmemb axfwbwarmzowvgz- Lcdf zvwf ~`cmyz `edf Oazycz,Waibfwzecz cmi ^cfamefz, reyo yofew `cwbf `fc
v z, cxf c lv j a rf wayyf lcmvwf axfwcmi cwavmi yofew jwarmz ya ~wayfjy yofl hwalhwazy-
Rffi yof xfbfycg`f gfiz cmi cii c `cufw ahawbcmej lcyyfw zvjo cz rf`` wayyfi lcmvwf- Mamffi ya ieb ey em kvzy `fy yof rawlz ycdf ey iarmemya yof zae` haw uav-
Kcmfy Ofcyo, Bcwifm Lfmyaw Yf` >3799 :3?76? rrr-bcwifmlfmyaw-ja-vd
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
73/88
OALF EL^WAXFLFMYZ CMI ZFWXEJFZ
H@CR@FZZJ@FCMEMB JAL^CMU
@fy vz bexf uavw oalfyof H`cr`fzz ffimezo
Ywvzyrawyou, wf`ecg`fgfz~adf j`fcmemb
Fzy- axfw 3> ufcwz
c`` >3?75 78377:aw >25>5859:27
LA@F JAMYWA@Emj`viemb wcyz cmi lejf
Cbwejv`yvwc` ze`cbf jwa~z ya zlc`` `crmz
L-C-H-H- ywcemfi
C`za bfmfwc` bcwifm rawd vmifwycdf m
Jc ^ e e~
>3?75 29>:?> aw >22988 9??63
GVMGVWU ^WA^FWYU
LCEMYFMCMJFGwejdrawd wf~cewzFyfwmc` ~cemyemb
^cyeaz, hfmjemb fyj
Axfw 76 ufcwz f~fwefmjf
Jamycjy cv`
Yf` >3?75 78>526
Lag >2?39 9>:925
^vwf J`fcm Zfwxejfz /MR%
Remiar J`fcmfw@ajc` ~wahfzzeamc` cmi
wf`ecg`f zfwxejfWfcjo m Rczo zuzyfl
j`fcmz ocwi ya wfcjo
remiarz, hczjecz, zebmz, v^XJ
Hv``u emzvwfi; lflgfw ah yof
Hfifwcyeam ah Remiar J`fcmfwz
^oamf ^oe` am >227:95?:::aw >3?75 78>687
^ecma @fzzamzgfbemmfwz ya cixcmjfi
Icuyelf z~cjfz haw civ`yz
{ Cjjal~cmelfmy haw fclz!~fwhawlcmjf{ BJZF cmi C `fxf` zv~~awy rawdhaw lvzej
cmi lvzej yfjoma`abu{ @cwbf zyviea cmi rceyemb waal zeyvcyfi mfcw
Ycw~aw`fu
amycjy >257 36 Zamycjy > 57 3 57> 5 miwfr Zycwlfw
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 2:
UAV JCM CIXFWYEZF
EM YCW^AW@FU YC@D
HAW 38 C LAMYO#++C~~`efz ya c zlc`` ga cixfwy
LW Cfwec`zCfwec`z, zcyf``eyf zuzyflz,
lv`ye zreyjo zuzyflz, JJYX
Iezjavmyz haw AC^z,
WIE wfbezyfwfi
Hwff svaycyeamz
>3?75 22>562
>2?3> ?3?362
562
Eh uav cwf `aademb ya jocmbf uavw
bcwcbf iaaw, rou may `fy ^fmmemfof`~ joaazf hwal c xczy wcmbf ah
zyu`fz cmi ja`avw ffimezofz-
{ V~ cmi axfw{ Zfjyeamc` iaawz
{ Wa``fw iaawz{ Zeif oembfi
{ C`` ja`avwz{ Cvyalcyej aw lcmvc`
Haw hwff svaycyeam jc``
>363 ::8 23:8 ! >22?8 8?7367
rrr-~fmmemfbcwcbfiaawz-ja-vd
^WA^ WYU
LCEMYFMCM FOcmiulcm Zfwxejfhaw yof `ajc` jallvmeyu
Iaawz ya aawz
Deyjofmz , Gcyowaalz
^`vlgemb cmi Ye`emb
^`vz c`` uavw jcw~fmywu mffizYelf zfwxfi Kaemfw reyo :> uwz f~fwefmjf
Jc`` Lcwd , 22?:?:?:59Fxfmembz , 3?75 2:7 8?:
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
74/88
29 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
OALF EL^WAXFLFMYZCMI ZFWXEJFZ
{ Bcz Zchf Wfbezyfwfi
{ Gcyowaalz ( Ye`emb c Z~fjec`eyu
{ Haw c Jal~wfofmzexf Zfwxejf
DF@ZC@@ REMIARJ@FCMEMB ZFWXEJFZBvyyfw j`fcmemb ( wf~cewz
Rcz~z mfzyz zchf`u wflaxfi
Wfcjo cmi RczoZuzyflhaw ocwi ya wfcjo remiarz
Jaxfwemb uavw ajc` cwfc
>38>8 66?3>8>2?88 735>69
Ialfzyej (
Jallfwjec`
OCRD F@FJYWEJC@/JOFZOEWF% @YI
Ialfzyej, Jallfwjec`, Emivzywec
F`fjywejc` Emzyc``cyeam, JJYX
Emzyc``cyeam, Emz~fjyeam ( Yfzyemb,
Zfjvweyu C`cwlz @eboyemb
Yf`; >359? ?83>:3
Lage`f; >22>:987>637 Joaw`yam Xe``cz, Lc`~cz, Jofzoewf, ZU39 2KK
XCJVVL J@FCMFW WF^CEWZC`` yu~fz ah xcjvvl j`fcmfwz
zfwxejfi cmi wf~cewfi
aw uav z~fjc`ez
>2 :5
^CY Yfzyemb uavw f`fjywejc` c~~`ecmjfzrrr-y bocl7-ja
UAV JCM CIXFWYEZF
EM YCW^AW@FU YC@D
HAW 38 C LAMYO#++C~~`efz ya c zlc`` ga cixfwy
CMIW CM
Ie~ MY , %
Wf~
cmiw ecmaifcm-ja-vd
^D
Yf` ^cv` am >3?75 787929 ! >2?59 ?227>2Flce` ~cv`dfmiwejd Nblce -jal
^wakfjy lcmcbfi hwal zycwy ya ffimezo Yof oebofzy zycmicwiz em Ye`emb Ofcyemb, Xc`xfz, Zemdz, Yc~z cmi Wciecyawz C`` ialfzyej ~`vlgemb jcyfwfi haw Ma kag yaa zlc`` FLFWBFMJU JC@@,AVYZ
^@VLGEMB (
GCYOWAALZ
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
75/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 26
CMI C@ZA AM@EMF---rrr-ycw~aw fuyc`d-jal
C`` rawdlcmzoe~ ya yof oebofzy zycmicwiz
{ Fmfwbu fhffijefmyofcyemb zuzyflz
{ V~bwcifz
{ Gae`fw jocmbfz{ Gcyowaalz
ZROfcyemb ( ^`vlgemb Zfwxejfz
^`fczf jamycjy Zyvcwy Rc``
>2563 ?2> 7:>
>3?75 263 259
#'*)&*("*'&/"/% +++/#'*)&*("*'&/"/%
Jc`` >2523 6?: 836 aw >352? :33>76H A W C H W F F M A A G @ E B C Y E A M S V A Y F
Rfz~fjec`ezfem yofemzyc``cyeam
ahc`` cz~fjyzahgve`iembcmi
ocwi `cmizjc~embcmiocxf
axfw7>ufcwzfx~fwefmjf
Z~fjec`ezyz em;
Iwexfrcuz
^cyeaz
Ywcieyeamc` Zfyy ^cxembMcyvwc` Zyamf^cxemb
G`ajd^cxemb
Gwejdrawd
Fxyfmzeamz
@cmizjc~emb
Bwavmirawdz(Iwcemcbf
Ycdfc `aadcy avwmfrrfgzeyf
hawfxcl~`fzahavwrawd
Ahhfwemb c ^wahfzzeamc` Svc`eyu Zfwxejf
{ Axfw 76 ufcwz f~fw fmjf
{ Jfmywc` Ofcyemb Emzyc``cyeam
{ Fmfwbu Fhffijefmy Zuzyfl V~bwcifz
{ Gae`fw Emzyc``cyeam
{ Gcyowaal Emzyc``cyeamz
{ Zuzyfl ^arfwvzoemb
{ Ae` Ycmd Emzyc``cyeam
{ Hwff Fzyelcyfz
{ C`` Rawd Bvcwcmyffi
^CV@ MF@ZAM
253? 8:3 78:
352? 23> ?52F- emhaNja~~fwjwahy`yi-ja-vd
R- rrr-ja~~fwjwahy`yi-ja-vd
6:?972WfbezyfwfiGvzemfzz
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
76/88
28 Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
OALF EL^WAXFLFMYZ CMI ZFWXEJFZ
Ywvzy uavw `crm ya zalfamf roa jcwfz
{ Ofibf jvyyemb{ Bcw fm ye u v~z
{ Jocemzcr rawd
@fch j`fcwcmjf
{ C`` bcwifm rawd jamzeifwfi
Lag >22322>>:39rrr-yof`crmbvu-ja-vd
OARCWI
CMIFW MHaw c`` ah uavw ~cemyemb cmi
fjawcy mb mff z-
>3?75 78>96
>258? 5>3382
Ialfzyej axfm j`fcmemb zfwxejf
m JofzoewfAxfmz, Oagz, Fywcjyawz, Lejwarcxfz( GGSz gwavboy gcjd ya zoarwaal
amieyeam vzemb mamjcvzyej,fmxewamlfmyc``uhwefmi`u lcyfwec`z
^OAMF Mejd am>3?75 2:9>7: aw >2?>3 >68>9?
rrr-jofzoewfaxfmj fcmemb-ja-vd
Zv~fweaw j`fcmemb wfzv`yz am c`` axfmz, Cbcz, wcmbfz
cmi fywcjyawz-
Lejwarcxf axfm j`fcmemb cmi zcmeyezemb-
Jallfwjec` wcmbfz, zc`clcmifwz cmi
fywcjyeam oaaiz-
Jallfwjec` jamywcjy rawd vmifwycdfm haw ~vgz,
wfzycvwcmyz, zjoaa`z, mvwzfwefz, ~`cu gcwmz,
ja``fbfz, jcyfwemb zjoaa`z ( `fyyemb cbfmyz- Jallfwjec` jamywcjy rawd jcm gf
vmifwycdfm avyzeif ah ywciemb oavwz-
Zchf cmi wagvzy j`fcmemb ~wajfzz fmcg`emb
ellfiecyf vzf ah c`` c~~`ecmjfz-
Xc`vf haw lamfu yowavbo zfy ~wejfz
emj`viemb gv`gz cmi e`yfwz-
Hv``u emzvwfi haw ialfzyej cmi
jallfwjec` /`ecge`eyu cy 6l% rawd
( c`za svc`eefi yowavbo YCCAJ-
@ajc` hcle`u gvzemfzz hajvzemb
am wf`ecge`eyu, ywvzy, j`efmy
zcyezhcjyeam cmi wf~fcy jvzyal-
Yf` >352? ?77 282
Lag >2?58 726 ???rrr-rummzycuj`fcmemb-ja-vd
Gvzemfzz zuzyflz
Fxywc zajdfyz haw ZDU, Gwacigcmi,
hcv`yz, Jcy6 icyc jcg`emb
C`` cz~fjyz ah yf`fjallz rawd
Ialfzyej c`cwlz eyyfi
:6uwz fx~fwefmjf- Jofc~fw yocm GY
>22?9 5>532:
YF@F^OAMF
FMBEMFFW
UAV JCM
CIXFWYEZF EM
YCW^AW@FU
YC@D HAW 38
C LAMYO#+C~~`efz ya c zlc`` ga cixfwy
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
77/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 22
CMI AM@EMF---
rrr-ycw~aw fuyc`d-jal
C(K ^cumf^wa~fwyu^wa~fwyu Lcemyfmcmjf
cmi Wf~cew
Cmiu ^cumf
Heyyemb deyjofmz,
gcyowaalz, gfiwaalz
@cuemb raai!ye`f h`aawz
^cemyemb cmi Ifjawcyemb
Bcwifm LcemyfmcmjfYf`; >3?75 267:?9
Lag; >25?6 56?66:
Flce`; ~cumf~wa~fwyuNgebhaay-jal
{ , gu zf`h `aciemb :7Y bwcg rcbam
{ wvj ac z , fsvcyfz ya 7 7 zde~z{^cwy `aciz cxce`cg`f
{Leme iebbfw cmi ivl~fw oewf reyo aw reyoavy a~fwcyaw
{ Ya~ Zae` Yvwh Zv~~`efi cmi @cei
{Iwexfrcu ! bcwifm ifzebm ( gve`i-
{Ifjawcyexf bwcxf`z!z`cyfz ( ayofw cmizjc~emb lcyfwec`z
{ Haayembz cmi havmicyeamz fjcxcyfi-
{Lfywfi jamjwfyf zv~~`efi{Wajd zc`y cxce`cg`f
f 3799 9 9rrr-bwcgcmizoehy-ja-vd
Lvjdcrcu ( Leme Iebbfw ewf
Zyawcbf hwal 6 ~fw rffd
Iewyu Jcw~fyz aw Axfm11
- - -
9?
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
78/88
ROCYZ AM EM UAVW XE@@CBF
IFJFLGFW
2? Ya cixfwyezf jc`` >3799 :6>:5? rrr-ycw~aw`fuyc`d-jal
Zcyvwicu 3zy IfjflgfwJowezylcz Javmywu Lcwdfy cy yof Gcwgavw Emzyeyvyf Ycyyfmoc`` 79~l
Lamicu :wi Ifjflgfw
Jalf cmi fmkau cm fxfmemb a Gemba cy yof Rcw Lflawec` Oc`` Iviiam yof iaawz a~fm cy 2~l cmi
fufz iarm cy 2-:>~l- Fmywu ez wff cmi yofwf re`` gf c wchf cmi wfwfzolfmyz-
Hweicu 2yo Ifjflgfwaom Dewd~cywejd re`` gf ~wfzfmyemb Jcwa``emb cmi Jwvl~fyz c lvzejc`kavwmfu yowavbo yof Fmb`ezo
leiremyfw cy Ycwxem Jallvmeyu Jfmywf- Kaom ez c xfwu rf``dmarm f~amfmy a Fmb`ezo a`d lvzej cmi cwe``ecmy lvzejecm- Yejdfyz cxce`cg`f wal Ycwxem ^azy Ajf >3?75 293587 aw am yof iaaw-
Zcyvwicu ?yo Ifjflgfwcwxem Jowezylcz Hfzyexc` cmi Zywffy Lcwdfy 65~l cy Oebo Zywffy Ycwxem- Bfy em yof Jowezylcz z~ewey
cmi lffy Hcyofw Jowezylcz4 `ayz a zyc``z cmi fmyfwycemlfmy re`` cii ya yof vm a yof fxfmemb-
Hweicu 2yo Ifjflgfwvmgvwu C`ifwzfu Zjoaa` Jowezylcz Hcew 62-:>~l- Cilezzeam 7 joe`iwfm wff- Jowezylcz zyc``z Zcmycz
wayya `ayz a bclfz cmi cjyexeyefz aw c`` yof cle`u-
Hweicu 2yo Ifjflgfw
Cmmvc` GGJ Gemba /gewiz gaa{f cmi jam fjyeamfwu% cy Ov`fu Xe``cbf Oc` 2~l aw fufz iarm 2-:>~l-
Zvmicu 5yo Ifjflgfwcg`f Ya~ Zc`f cy yof Gcwgavw Emzyeyvyf Ycyyfmoc`` 5cl37maam- Ycg`fz jazy 6 ya wfmy4 wemb >3?75
2>5:7 22>58> aw ifyce`z-
Yovwzicu 3:yo Ifjflgfw
e`l Meboy cy yof Gcwgavw Emzyeyvyf Ycyyfmoc``- Yofw zfczam jamyemvfz reyo Rcw Oawzf /37C%- He`l zycwyz
cy ?~l /iaawz a~fm 2-:>~l%- 6 /9 vmifw 3?z% ~cu am yof iaaw- Gcw Cxce`cg`f-
Hwe cu 39y Ifjfl fwfzy uavw lflawu cy avw `eboyofcwyfi sve{ cy yof Rcw Lflawec` Oc`` Iviiam zycwyemb cy ?-36 ~l fmywu
e`` gf 6 cmi yofwf re`` gf c gvhfy gcw cmi wchf- ^wajffiz ba yarcwiz yof wvmmemb jazyz a yof Oc``-
Zvmicu 38yo Ifjflgfwf`zgawwar Joaew jamjfwy a Jowezylcz Lvzej cy Ycwxem Jallvmeyu Jfmywf- Yejdfy ~wejfz ya gf
fyfwlemfi gvy re`` gf cxce`cg`f awl yof cgavy avy`fyz aw am yof iaaw
Jowezylcz Fxf
owezylcz zajec` reyo gwemb uavw arm gvhfy cy Ov`fu Xe``cbf Oc`` cy ?~l- C`` rf`jalf- Jamycjy Jowez3?75 2?3759 aw gvhfy cwwcmbflfmyz
-
7/30/2019 Tarporley Talk December 2012
79/88
Ycw~aw`fu Yc`d Ifjflgfw 7>37 25
ROCYZ AM EM UAVW XE@@CBF
IFJFLGFW@VGZ CMI Z JEFYEFZ
Ycyyfmoc`` Wvmmfwz
Ywcememb zfzzeamz am Yvfzicu cmi Yovwzicu fxfmembz lffyemb cy Ycyyfmoc`` Wfjwfcyeam J`vg cy
~l ya zycwy cy 2;36~l- Ycyyfmoc`` Wvmmfwz ez c wefmi`u j`vg zveycg`f aw c reif wcmbf a cge`eyefz
reyo wvmz am yof aay~cyoz a yof ^fjd awyam Oe` z cmi svefy cmfz wavmi Ycyyfmoc` - Flce` em aN
ycyyfmoc``wvmmfwz-jal aw lawf emawlcyeam-
Rfzy J fz ewf Wvwc V:Calf cmikaem vz am Yovwzicu 7>yo Ifjflgfw 7>37 cy 7~l em yof Gcwgavw Emzyeyvyf Ycyyfmoc`` aw
v f remf lemjf ~efz cm c sve{- Mfr lfl fwz re f lc f rf jalf-
aw ifyce`z a avw cjyexeyefz cmi emyfwfzy bwav~z em yof Jofzoewf Rfzy wvwc` jallvmeyu ~`fczf jc`` Oe`cwu
3?75 22>638 aw fyf >3?75 293?79- Xezey rrr-rfzyj fz ewfwvwc v:c-awb-v
Yexfwyam Iezywejy Bcwifm J`vg
mkau zalf remyfw zvm rey Iw Bawamru Rummf r a re ywcmz~awy vz ya y f Lf eyfwwcmfcm rey ez
c`d am Ez`cmi H`arfwz am Yvfzicu 9yo Ifjflgfw cy Yexfwyam Xe``cbf