seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
1/208
101 378
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
2/208
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
3/208
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
4/208
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
5/208
PROCLAIM LIBERTY
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
6/208
ALSO by GILBERT SELDESOn Related Subjects
Your Money and Your LifeMainlandThe Years of the LocustAgainst RevolutionThe Stammering CenturyThe Seven Living ArtsThe United States and the War
(London, 1917)
This is America(Moving- Picture)AND
The Movies Come From AmericaThe Movies and the TalkiesThe Future of DrinkingThe Wings of the EagleLysistrata (A Modern Version)
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
7/208
71 7r* r n /T/ W/:.-2. I U (;*'% v;t:: t
L I B E RTY
By
GILBERT SELDES
Proclaim liberty throughout the land unto all theinhabitants thereof; it shall be a jubilee unto them. . .
Leviticus xxv, 10,
THE GREYSTONE PRESSNEW YORK
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
8/208
PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICABY* TEtE WILLIAM BYRD PRESS, INC.
RICHMOND, VIRGINIA
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
9/208
To TECE CHILDRENwho will haveto live in the world
we are making
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
10/208
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
11/208
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Thanks are given to the Macmillan Company for their
permission to quote several paragraphs from Arthur Koestler'sDarkness at Noon in my first chapter. The Grand Strategyby H. A. Sargeaunt and Geoffrey West, referred to in chaptertwo, is published by Thomas Y. Crowell Co.
G.S.
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
12/208
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
13/208
Contents
PAGE
CHAPTER i TOTAL VICTORY 13
CHAPTER ii STRATEGY FOR THECITIZEN 29
CHAPTER m UNITED . . . . ? 44
CHAPTER iv THE STRATEGY OFTRUTH 61
CHAPTER v THE FORGOTTENDOCUMENT 77
CHAPTER vi THE POPULATION OFTHESE STATES 92
CHAPTER vii ADDRESS TO EUROPE 111
CHAPTER vni THE SCIENCE OFSHORT WAVE 119
CHAPTER ix DEFINITION OF AMERICA 129
CHAPTER x POPULARITY ANDPOLITICS 156
CHAPTER xi THE TOOLS OFDEMOCRACY 163
CHAPTER xn DEMOCRATIC CONTROL 170
CHAPTER xni THE LIBERTY BELL 199
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
14/208
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
15/208
PROCLAIM LIBERTY
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
16/208
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
17/208
CHAPTER I
Total Victory
THE PERIL WE ARE IN TODAY IS THIS :For the first time since we became a nation, a power exists
strong enough to destroy us.
This book is about the strength we have to destroy ourenemies where it lies, what hinders it, how we can use it.It is not about munitions, but about men and women; itdeals with the unity we have to create, the victory we haveto win; it deals with the character of America, what it has
been and is and will be. And since character is destiny, this
bookis about the
destinyof America.
The next few pages are in the nature of counter-propaganda.With the best of motives, and the worst results, Americans
for months after December 7, 1941, said that Pearl Harbor
was a costly blessing because it united all Americans and
made us understand why the war was inevitable. A fifty-milebus trip outside of New York perhaps even a subway 'ride
within its borders would have proved both of these state-ments blandly and dangerously false. American unity could
not be made in Japan; like most other imports from that
country, it was a cheap imitation, lasting a short time, and
costly in the long run ; and recognition of the nature of the
war can never come as the result of anything but a realistic
analysis of our own purposes as well as those of our enemies.
What follows is, obviously, the work of a citizen, not a
specialist. For some twenty years I have observed the sources
of American unity and dispersion; during the past fifteen
years my stake in the future of American liberty has beenthe most important thing in my life, as it is the most impor-tant thing in the life of anyone whose children will live in
the world we are now creating. I am therefore not writing
13
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
18/208
14 PROCLAIM LIBERTY
frivolously, or merely to testify to my devotion; I am writingto persuade -to uncover sources of strength which others
may have overlooked, to create new weapons, to stir new
thoughts. If I thought the war for freedom could be won by
writing lies, I would write lies. I am afraid the war will belost if we do not face the truth, so I write what I believe to
be true about America about its past and present and future,
meaning its history and character and destiny but mostly
about the present, with only a glance at our forgotten past,and a dedaration of faith in the future which is, I hope, the
inevitable result of our victory.
We know the name and character of our enemy theAxis ; but after months of war we are not entirely convinced
that it intends to destroy us because we do not see why ithas to destroy us. Destroy; not defeat. The desperate war
we are fighting is still taken as a gigantic maneuvre ; obviouslythe Axis wants to win battles and dictate peace terms .
We still use these phrases of 1918, unaware that the purposeof Axis war is not defeat of an enemy, but destruction of his
national life. We have seen it happen in France and Polandand Norway and Holland; but we cannot imagine that the
Nazis intend actually to appoint a German Governor Generalover the Mississippi Valley, a Gauleiter in the New Englandprovinces, and forbid us to read newspapers, go to the movies
or drink coffee; we cannot believe that the Axis intends to
destroy the character of America, annihilating the liberties
our ancestors fought for, and the level of comfort which wecherished so scrupulously in later generations. In momentsof pure speculation, when we wonder what would happen at
worst , we think of a humiliating defeat on land and sea,bombardment of our cities, surrender and a peace confer-
ence at which we and Britain agree to pay indemnities ; per-haps, until we pay off, German and Japanese soldiers wouldbe quartered in our houses, police our streets ; but we assume
that after the shooting war was over, they would not ravishour women.
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
19/208
TOTAL VICTORY IS
Victory (Axis Model)
All this is the war of 1918. In 1942 the purpose of Axis
victory is the destruction of the American system, the anni-
hilation of the financial and industrial power of the United
States, the reduction of this country to an inferior positionin the world and the enslavement of the American people by
depriving them of their liberty and of their wealth. The actual
physical slaveryof the American
peopleand the deliberate
taking over of our factories and farms and houses and motor
cars and radios are both implied in an Axis victory; the
enslavement is automatic, the robbery of our wealth will de-
pend on Axis economic strategy: if we can produce more
for them by remaining in technical possession of our factories,
they will let us keep them.
We cannot believe this is so because we see no reason forit. Our intentions toward the German and Italian people arenot to enslave and impoverish ; on the contrary, we think ofthe defeat of their leaders as the beginning of liberty. We donot intend to make Venice a tributary city, nor Essen a fac-
tory town run by American government officials. We maypolice the
streets ofBerlin
untila democratic government
proves its strength by punishing the SS and the Gestapo,until the broken prisoners of Dachau return in whatever
triumph they can still enjoy. But our basic purpose is still to
defeat the armed forces of the Axis and to insure ourselves
against another war by the creation of free governmentseverywhere.
(Neither the American people nor their leaders have be-
lieved that a responsible peaceable government can be erected
now in Japan. Toward the Japanese our unclarified inten-tions are simple : annihilation of the power, to such an extent
that it cannot rise again as a military or a commercial rival.
The average citizen would probably be glad to hand over to
the Chinese the job of governing Japan.)Fortunately, the purposes of any war alter as the war goes
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
20/208
16 PROCLAIM LIBERTY
on; as we fight we discover the reasons for fighting and the
intensity of our effort, the cost of victory, the danger of de-
feat, all compel us to think desperately about the kind of
peace for which we are fighting. The vengeful articles of the
treaty of Versailles were written after the Armistice by
politicians; the constructive ones were created during the
war, and it is quite possible that they would have been ac-
cepted by Americans if the United States had fought longer
and therefore thought longer about them.We shall probably have time to think out a good peace in
this war. But we will not create peace of any kind unless weknow why an Axis peace means annihilation for us ; and why,at the risk of defeat in the field and revolution at home, the
Axis powers had to go to war on the United States.
Ifwe impose our moral
ideasupon
thefuture,
the attack
on Pearl Harbor will stand as the infamous immediate cause
of the war; by Axis standards, Pearl Harbor was the final
incident of one series of events, the first incident of another,all having the same purpose, the destruction of American
democracy which, so long as it endured, undermined the
strength of the totalitarian powers.
Why? Why are Hitler and Mussolini and To jo insecureif we survive? Why were we in danger so long as they werevictorious ? The answer lies in the character of the two groupsof nations ; in all great tragedy, the reason has to be found in
the character of those involved; the war is tragic, in noble
proportions, and we have to know the character of our enemy,the character of our own people, too, to understand why it wasinevitable and how we will win.
Our character, molded by our past, upholds or betrays usin our present crisis, and so creates our future. That is the
sense in which character is Destiny.We know everything hateful about our enemies ; long be-
fore the warbegan we knew the treachery of the Japanese
military caste, the jackal aggression of Mussolini, the brutal-
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
21/208
TOTAL VICTORY 17
ity and falseness of Hitler ; and the enthusiastic subservience
of millions of people to each of these leaders.
But these things do not explain why we are a danger to the
Axis, and the Axis to us.
Historic Necessity4
The profound necessity underlying this war rises from
the nature of fascism : it is a combination of forces and ideas ;
the forces are new, but the basic ideas have occurred at least
once before in history, as the Feudal Order. Democracy de-
stroyed Feudalism ; and Feudalism, returning in a new formas Fascism, must destroy democracy or go down in the at-
tempt ; the New Order and the New World cannot exist side
by side, because they are both expanding forces ; they have
touched one another andonly
one will survive.We might
blindly let the new despotism live although it is the most ex-
pansive and dynamic force since 1776; but it cannot let us live.
We could co-exist with Czarism because it was a shrinkingforce ; or with British Imperialism because its peak of expan-
sion was actually reached before ours began. We could nothave lived side by side with Trotskyite Communism becauseit was as aggressive as the exploding racialism of the German
Nazis.
As it happened, Stalin, not Trotsky, took over from Lenin ;Socialism in one country supplanted the permanent revolu-
tion . Stalin made a sort of peace with all the world; he
called off his dogs of propaganda; he allowed German Com-
munism to be beaten to death in concentration camps; and,as Trotsky might have said, the historical obligation to
destroy capitalist-democracy was undertaken not by the
bearded old Marxian enemies of Capital, but by Capital'sown young sadists, the Storm Troopers, called in by the
frightened bankers and manufacturers of Italy and Germany.
Thatis
why,since
1932,realist democrats have known that
the enemy had to be Hitler, not Stalin. It was not a choice
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
22/208
18 PROCLAIM LIBERTY
between ideologies ; it was a choice between degrees of expan-sion. Moreover, Stalin himself recognized the explosive force
of fascism in Germany and shrank within his own borders ; hewithdrew factories to the Urals, he dispersed his units of
force as far from the German border as he could. By doingso, he became the ideal ally of all those powers whom Hitler's
expanding pressure was discommoding. The relatively static
democratic nations of Europe, the shrinking semi-socialist
states like France and Austria, werebruised
bycontact
withHitler ; presently they were absorbed because the Nazi geo-
graphy demanded a continent for a military base.
The destruction of America was a geographical necessity,for Hitler ; and something more. Geographically, the United
States lies between Hitler's enemies, England and Russia ; weare not accustomed to the thought, but the fact is that we area transatlantic base for England's fleet; so long as we are
undefeated, the fleet remains a threat to Germany. Look atthe other side : we are a potential transpacific base for Russia ;our fleet can supply the Soviets and China ; Russia can retreat
toward Siberian ports and join us. So we dominate the twonorthern oceans, and with Russia, the Arctic as well. That is
the geographic reason for Hitler's attack on us.The moral reason is greater than the strategic reason : the
history of the United States must be destroyed, its future
must turn black and bitter ; because fasci-feudalism, the new
order, cannot rest firmly on its foundations until Democracyperishes from the earth.
So long as a Democracy (with a comparatively high stand-ard of living) survives, the propaganda of fascism must fail ;the essence of that propaganda is that democratic nations
cannot combine liberty and security. In order to have security,
says Hitler, you must give up will and want, freedom ofaction and utterance ; you must be disciplined and orderedbecause the modern world is too complex to allow for thewill of the individual.
The democracies insist that the richcomplexity of the world was created by democratic freedom
-
8/13/2019 seldes-proclaim liberty.pdf
23/208
TOTAL VICTORY 19
and that production, distribution, security and progress have
not yet outstripped the capacity of man, so that there is roomfor the private life, the undisciplined, even the un-social. Theessential democratic belief in progress is not a foolish
optimism, it is basic belief in the desirability of change; and
we, democratic people, believe that the critical unregimentedindividual must have some leeway so that progress will be
made. The terror of change in which dictators live is shown
in their constant appeal to permanence; we know that theonly thing permanent in life is change; when change ceases,life ceases. It does not surprise us that the logic of fascism
ends in death.
So long as the democratic nations achieve change without
revolution, and prosperity without regimentation, the Nazi
states are in danger. In a few generations they may indoc-trinate their people to love poverty and ignorance, to fear
independence ; for fascism, the next twenty years are critical.
Unless we, the democratic people, are destroyed now, the
fascist adults of 1940 to 1960 will still know that freedomand wealth co-exist in this world and are better than slavery.
So much which is enough was true even before the dec-
laration of war ; since then the nazi-fascists must prove thatdemocracies cannot defend themselves, cannot sacrifice com-
fort, cannot invent and produce engines of war, cannot win
victories. And we are equally compelled, for our own safety,to destroy the principle which tries to destroy us. The alter-
native to victory over America is therefore not defeat or
an inconclusive truce. The alternative is annihilation for the
fascist regime and death for hundreds of thousands of nazi
party men. They will be liquidated because when they are
defeated they will no longer have a function to perform ; theii
only function is the organization of victory.
The fascist powers are expanding and are situated so that
with their subordinates, they can control the world. And th