scholasticism, measure and light in gothic architecturedesignspeculum.com/historyweb/ha2 2.pdf ·...

53
History of Architecture 2 Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecture

Upload: others

Post on 28-Jun-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

History of Architecture 2

Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecture

Page 2: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 3: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

History of Architecture 2

Ecclesiastical Architecture in Medieval Society

Page 4: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

History of Architecture 2

‘Gothic’

originated in present day France

spread to modern day Italy, UK, Spain, Germany, Austria etc

revived in 19c as a ‘style’

Page 5: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

History of Architecture 2

‘Gothic’

anatomy and nomenclature

Page 6: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 7: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 8: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 9: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

History of Architecture 2

‘Gothic’

differences to Romanesque interior

Page 10: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 11: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 12: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

late romanesque sanctuary

Page 13: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 14: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

Capella Palatina, Palermo c 1140 -60~Chartres c.1200compare the nature of the sanctuary

Page 15: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

History of Architecture 2

Perception and appearance of God

iconographic value is reduced

perceiving ‘God’ through His marvels, e.g. light, number, geometry

heightened symbolism of natural phenomena

Page 16: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

History of Architecture 2

early ‘Gothic’

St Denis, 1138 -1144

Page 17: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 18: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

Suger of Saint-Denis , supplicant on a medieval window

Page 19: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

Interior Photo of Saint Denis Church in north Paris

Page 20: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

We remember Abbot Suger because he opened up the heavy Romanesque walls and added stained glass and his use of more efficient vaults at Saint Denis. The pointed, rib vaults were no longer restricted to square compartments. Seven small chapels, called apsidal chapels, radiate around the ambulatory.

Page 21: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

St Denis

Page 22: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 23: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

History of Architecture 2

early ‘Gothic’

Notre Dame, Paris; 1165 - 1200

Page 24: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 25: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

Notre ~Dame

Page 26: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

History of Architecture 2

high ‘Gothic’

Chartres, 1194 -1220

Page 27: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

Cathedral of Chartres, western spires

Page 28: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

Chartres, West End elevation. From G. Dehio and G. von Bezold, Die

Kirchliche Baukunst des Abendlandes, Stuttgart, 1887-1902, plate 407

Page 29: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

Chartres. Floorplan, from G. Dehio and G. von Bezold, Die Kirchliche Baukunst des abendlandes, Stuttgart, 1887-1902, plate 383

Page 30: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

chartres nave

Page 31: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 32: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

Chartres

The center portal is slightly larger. The design of the portal is taken from a Roman triumphal arch. The center portal represents the second coming of Christ with the four Evangelists: the eagle stands for John, the angel for Matthew, the lion for Mark and the bull for Luke, All the figures on the Tympanum are stylized. Figures on the voussoir seem to float

Page 33: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

History of Architecture 2

high ‘Gothic’

Rheims; 1211 - 1260

Page 34: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

Rheims

Page 35: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 36: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 37: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

History of Architecture 2

‘Gothic’

Bourges; 1195 - 1220

Page 38: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 39: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 40: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 41: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 42: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

History of Architecture 2

high ‘Gothic’

Amiens; 1220 - 1247

Page 43: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

AmiensThree architects worked on Amiens. The facade is more elaborate and has more sculptural decorations than Chartres. The tracery in Amiens's rose window is more delicate and the center portal is dramatically larger than Chartres.

Page 44: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

Amiens

Page 45: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

History of Architecture 2

high ‘Gothic’

Beauvais; 1225 - 1272

Page 46: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 47: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

God the Geometer, Manuscript illustration.Clark, Kenneth. Civilization. NY: Harper, 1969. p. 52

The importance of number symbolism was matched by a dedication to geometry. Kenneth Clark points out that ". . . to medieval man geometry was a divine activity . . ."

According to Cowan, churches had been built on geometric principles since early Christian times. Geometry was the basis of all Gothic cathedrals, everything being created from basic relationships. We've seen that the ground plan was always cruciform, the baptism font always octagonal, and the baptistry itself often was, and the circle was everywhere.

This was symbolized in art by God holding a pair of compasses, a common motif in the Middle Ages. The art historian Ernst Gombrich credits a passage from the Old Testament as the inspiration for these portrayals. In Proverbs, Chapter 8 par. 27, Wisdom put forth her voice;

"When he established the heavens I was there: when he set a compass upon the face of the deep:"

Page 48: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 49: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

Walking the labyrinth at Chartres Cathedral (Cathédrale Notre-Dame de Chartres) in Chartres, France

Page 50: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 51: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior

MILAN

Page 52: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior
Page 53: Scholasticism, Measure and Light in Gothic Architecturedesignspeculum.com/Historyweb/HA2 2.pdf · 2009-04-29 · History of Architecture 2 early ‘Gothic’ St Denis, ... Interior