recapp facility evaluation report - alberta · 2009. 3. 17. · edmonton - mary butterworth school...
TRANSCRIPT
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM
RECAPP Facility Evaluation Report
Mary Butterworth School
B3205AEdmonton
Edmonton School District No. 7
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 2 of 39
B3205ABuilding Id:
Mary Butterworth SchoolBuilding Name:
EdmontonLocation:16315 - 109 Street Address:
5,752.40Gross Area (sq. m): $12,537,198Replacement Cost:1991Construction Year:
Evaluation Date: May 8 2007
Asset Evolution Incorporated (AEI)Evaluation Company:
Mario PlastinaEvaluator Name:
Mary Butterworth School is a one-storey school with a second floor mechanical room and a total building area is5752.40m2. The original school was built in 1991, however shortly after two 4 classroom additions were added alongthe East elevation in 1992. Two free standing portables are located on site. The one storey school is comprised of several classrooms, a gymnasium , a library, an industrial arts room, homeeconomics room, drama room, science room, computer lab and music room. The 2007 student enrollment is 628 children.
General Summary:
Structural Summary:The foundations consist of cast-in-place concrete grade beams and spread footings. The original building has cast-in-placeconcrete slabs-on-grade with conventional steel reinforcement. The roof comprises of a metal roof deck with steel structuresupported by exterior & interior concrete walls. The structural walls and columns are poured in place concrete. Overall the structural elements are in acceptable condition
Envelope Summary:The exterior cladding consists primarily of brick around the perimeter of the school. The upper portion of the exteriorwalls are clad with prefinished textured stucco panels. The exterior window units are aluminum frame with fixed andawning type units. Metal screens have been fastened to several of the windows for safety concerns. The main entrancedoors are aluminum framed with full glazed panels. The majority of the exterior doors are painted steel doors & frameswith glazed panels. The roof assembly has a combination of a sloped clay tiles and a built-up roof assembly. Skylightsare located throughout several areas in the building. Overall, the envelope of the building is in acceptable condition.
Interior Summary:The main entrance vestibules, corridors, washrooms and change rooms have a ceramic tile floor finish. Carpeting islocated throughout the majority of the classrooms, library, office area and music room. The science rooms, art room andhome economics have a sheet vinyl floor finish. The gymnasium and the computer room have a hardwood floor finish. Theexercise room and student gathering area have a rubber floor finish. The second floor mechanical room has a paint finishon the concrete slab. The majority of the interior walls are painted masonry block walls and gypsum board. The library and general office areahave glazed walls with GWG panels. The interior doors are stained wood doors and/or painted steel doors in hollow metal frames. The majority of theclassroom doors have sidelights with GWG inserts. The majority of the classrooms have a suspended 2'x4' acoustical tile ceiling. A stained wood ceiling is located in themain administrative office area.The structure is painted and exposed in the gymnasium & lunch room. Painted gypsumboard ceilings with a sprayed texture finish is located in the corridors, student gathering area, library, washrooms andchange rooms. Overall, the interior finishes are in good condition.
3.44%5 year Facility Condition Index (FCI):
Facility Details Evaluation Details
Total Maintenance Events Next 5 years: $430,716
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 3 of 39
Mechanical Summary:The building is heated by two gas fired hot water boilers which supply a hot water distribution system which includesfinned tube radiation cabinets, convectors, unit heaters, reheat coils and ceiling mounted radiant heating panels. Aglycol heating loop is heated by a plate and frame type heat exchanger from the hot water heating loop, and the glycolloop supplies the air handling unit heating coils and the fresh air preheat coils. There is one air handling unit in thebuilding which is a mixed air system (air handling unit AS1). The air handling unit is equipped with glycol heating coils,filters, and a circulating water humidification system, although the humidification system is reportedly not used. Themixed air ventilation system has an associated return air fan (FR1). The fresh air supplied to the building by the airhandling unit is balanced by the exhaust air flow from the air handling unit and from approximately 15 sanitary, local andgeneral exhaust fans. Building HVAC actuators and controls are pneumatic, and the control air supply system includes two air compressorsmounted on an air receiver tank, as well as a refrigerated air dryer. There is a Building Management and Control System(BMCS) providing control and monitoring functions for major HVAC equipment (Landis & Gyr Powers System 600). Washroom plumbing fixtures include toilets, lavatories and urinals. There are approximately 18 toilets (16 floor mountedflush valve type and two floor mounted tank type), 16 lavatories (16 counter mounted stainless steel type), and foururinals (two floor mounted flush valve type and two wall mounted flush valve type) in the building. Other plumbing fixturesin the building include drinking fountains (approximately 19), mop sinks (approximately 2), shower stalls (approximately3), and general purpose stainless steel sinks (approximately 35). Two gas fired domestic hot water heaters providedomestic hot water for the building lavatories, sinks and showers. Fire protection for the building consists of automatic sprinklers. In addition, cabinet mounted and wall mounted fireextinguishers are located throughout the facility. No major mechanical equipment or systems require immediate replacement or upgrading. Overall, the buildingmechanical equipment and systems are in acceptable to good condition.
Electrical Summary:Mary Butterworth School is fed with an incoming 120/208V three phase, 4 wire system from an EPCOR padmountedtransformer, located on the school grounds. The main switchboard is rated at 1200A, 120/208V. An MCC has beenprovided for the major mechanical equipment. The wiring in the building is typically standard wiring in conduit. The interior fluorescent lighting fixtures have T-12 lamps and magnetic ballasts. The exit lighting in the original buildingconsists of units with LED lamps. The emergency lighting is fed from emergency lighting battery packs. The exteriorlighting consists of wall mounted H.P.S. fixtures. The building is equipped with a Cerberus Pyrotronics fire alarm system. Detection and end devices include, smoke andheat detectors, bells and pull stations. The various communications and security systems within the school include; an Arrowhead Elite security system thatmonitors motion detectors and a P.A. system interconnected with the Nortel telephone system. A video surveillancesystem, cable TV and data systems are installed within the school. It is recommended, as routine maintenance, that a program for annual examination of major electrical components beinstituted. Maintenance should include thermographic scans for hot spots and power shut down to allow examination ofinterior components for accumulated debris and signs of corrosion. Consideration should be given to upgrading the existing lighting with more energy efficient lighting. Overall the electrical components for Mary Butterworth School are in acceptable to good condition.
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Condition Rating Performance1 - Critical Unsafe, high risk of injury or critical system failure.2 - Poor Does not meet requirements, has significant deficiencies. May have high operating/maintenance costs.
3 - Marginal Meets minimum requirements, has significant deficiencies. May have above average operating maintenance costs.4 - Acceptable Meets present requirements, minor deficiencies. Average operating/maintenance costs.
Rating Guide
5 - Good Meets all present requirements. No deficiencies.6 - Excellent As new/state of the art, meets present and foreseeable requirements.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 4 of 39
A1010 Standard Foundations - 1991 Section*
A1030 Slab on Grade - 1991 Section*
B1010.01 Floor Structural Frame (Building Frame) - 1991 Section*
B1010.02 Structural Interior Walls Supporting Floors (or Roof) - 1991 Section*
B1010.05 Mezzanine Construction - 1991 Section*
B1010.09 Floor Construction Fireproofing - 1991 Section*
B1010.10 Floor Construction Firestopping - 1991 Section*
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
100
100
100
100
100
50
50
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
S1 STRUCTURAL
The foundations consist of cast-in-place concrete grade beams and spread footings.
The building has cast-in-place concrete slabs-on-grade with conventional steel reinforcement.
Concrete structural flat slab supported by poured concrete & concrete block walls
Structural reinforced concrete block walls
Concrete and metal deck over steel structure for suspended floor at mezzanine.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 5 of 39
B1020.01 Roof Structural Frame - 1991 Section*
B1020.06 Roof Construction Fireproofing - 1991 Section*
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
100
50
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Metal roof deck with steel structure supported by exterior & interior concrete walls.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 6 of 39
B2010.01.02.01 Brick Masonry: Ext. Wall Skin - 1991 Section*
B2010.01.05 Exterior Insulation and Finish Systems (EIFS) - 1991 Section*
B2010.01.09 Expansion Control: Exterior Wall Skin - 1991 Section*
B2010.01.11 Joint Sealers (caulking): Ext. Wall - 1991 Section**
5 - Good
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
3 - Marginal
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
75
75
75
20
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace exterior joint sealant
Replace sealant in isolated areas along the eastelevation.
Lifecycle Replacement
Preventative Maintenance
2012
2008
$34,320
$2,288
Unassigned
Low
Some of the sealant has been removed on the east elevation.Concern:
Replace sealant in isolated areas along the east elevation.Recommendation:
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
S2 ENVELOPE
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
MAR-08
The exterior cladding consists primarily of exterior brick.
The upper portion of the exterior walls are clad with prefinished textured stucco panels.
Expansion/control joints are located throughout the cladding assembly.
Sealant is located around all window, door and exterior cladding assemblies.
Deteriorated sealant on east elevation
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 7 of 39
B2010.02.03 Masonry Units: Ext. Wall Const. - 1991 Section*
B2010.03 Exterior Wall Vapor Retarders, Air Barriers, and Insulation - 1991 Section*
B2010.09 Exterior Soffits - 1991 Section*
B2020.01.01.02 Aluminum Windows (Glass & Frame)**
3 - Marginal
4 - Acceptable
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
100
100
50
40
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Repair masonry walls
Replace aluminum windows (approx 60 units)
Repair
Lifecycle Replacement
2008
2031
$28,600
$343,200
Medium
Unassigned
Stress cracked were observed in the Art room and at theentrance F2.
Concern:
A study, prior to the repairs is recommended to determine if thestructural integrity has been compromised.
Recommendation:
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
Interior concrete block construction on the exterior wall assembly.
The exterior soffits above each entrance and around the perimeter of the school have a painted textured exterior gypsumboard finish.
The exterior window units are double glazed aluminum frame with operable awning units above fixed glazed panels
Cracks observed on the inside face of masonry wall in theArt room.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 8 of 39
B2030.01 Exterior Entrance Doors - 1991 Section
B3010.01 Deck Vapor Retarder and Insulation - 1991 Section*
B3010.02 Shingles and Roofing Tiles - 1991 Section
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
0
25
0
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace Exterior Entrance Doors - 25 doors
Repair and replace damaged roof tiles
Replace clay shingle roof tiles
Lifecycle Replacement
Repair
Lifecycle Replacement
2021
2008
2016
$85,800
$2,288
$514,800
Unassigned
Low
Unassigned
Several tiles are damaged in isolated areas throughout the roofConcern:
Replace all damaged clay tiles.Recommendation:
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Type
Year
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
APR-08
The entrance doors are painted steel doors with painted steel frames and GWG inserts . There are approximately a total of25 exterior exit doors throughout the school.
The sloped roof assembly comprises of clay tiles.
Damaged clay tile on sloped roof area.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 9 of 39
B3010.04.01 Built-up Bituminous Roofing (Asphalt & Gravel)**
B3010.04.04 Modified Bituminous Membrane Roofing (SBS)**
B3010.08.02 Metal Gutters and Downspouts - 1991 Section**
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
25
25
30
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace BUR roof assembly
Replace the SBS roof assembly
Replace Metal Gutters
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2016
2016
2021
$171,600
$114,400
$68,640
Unassigned
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Type
Year
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
Updated:
SEP-07
APR-08
APR-08
The upper portion of the school has a built-up bituminous roofing assembly.
The roof above the two pod additions along the east elevation have an SBS roof system.
Gutter & drains are located around the perimeter of the sloped roof areas. The gutters are lined with an SBS assembly.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 10 of 39
B3020.01 Skylights**
3 - MarginalRating
1991Installed
25Design Life
SEP-07Updated
Repair Skylights
Replace skylight assembly.
Repair
Lifecycle Replacement
2008
2016
$28,600
$137,280
Medium
Unassigned
The skylights, as indicated by the school officials still leak inseveral locations. Repairs have been made at the entrances in2005, however the skylights need to be monitored.
Concern:
Monitor and repair leaks at the entrances.Recommendation:
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
MAR-08
APR-08
The skylights are double glazed aluminum frame with fixed glazed panels. Skylights are located at each main entrance,greenhouse, library and in the main student gathering area.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 11 of 39
C1010.01.03 Unit Masonry Assemblies: Partitions -
C1010.01.07 Framed Partitions (Stud) -
C1010.03 Interior Operable Folding Panel Partitions - **
C1010.06 Interior Glazed Partitions and Storefronts - *
C1010.07 Interior Partition Firestopping - *
C1020.01 Interior Swinging Doors (& Hardware) - *
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
5 - Good
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
100
100
30
80
50
40
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace Folding Panel Partitions
Lifecycle Replacement 2021 $22,880 Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
S3 INTERIOR
Event:
Type Year Cost Priority
Updated: APR-08
Interior corridor partitions typically consist of painted masonry block walls.
Interior classroom, washroom stalls & office partitions typically consist of metal framed gypsum board walls.
Folding partitions are located between classrooms 9 & 10 and 5 & 6.
Interior glazed partitions are located in the main vestibules, administration areas, library and exercise room.
The interior swing doors generally consist of solid core painted and/or clear finished wood doors in painted steel frames.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 12 of 39
C1020.03 Interior Fire Doors - *
C1020.04 Interior Sliding and Folding Doors - *
C1030.01 Visual Display Boards - **
C1030.08 Interior Identifying Devices - *
C1030.10 Lockers - **
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
50
25
20
20
30
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace Visual Display Boards
Replace Lockers
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2012
2021
$68,640
$137,280
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
Fire doors are located between the original building and the two wing 1992 additions along the east elevation. The majorityof the doors are rated and labeled.
Interior glazed sliding doors are located in the main office area.
Tackboards and whiteboards are located in each classroom area.
The room number or room name is painted on the interior doors.
Prefinished metal lockers are located throughout the school corridors and change rooms.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 13 of 39
C1030.12 Storage Shelving - *
C1030.14 Toilet, Bath, and Laundry Accessories - *
C2030.01 Ramp Construction*
C2030.02 Ramp Finishes*
C2030.03 Ramp Railings*
C3010.06 Tile Wall Finishes - Ceramic tile**
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
5 - Good
5 - Good
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
30
20
100
30
50
40
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace Ceramic Tile Wall Finishes
Lifecycle Replacement 2031 $91,520 Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Type Year Cost Priority
Updated: APR-08
Clear finish plywood storage shelving throughout the teaching prep areas and storage areas.
The washrooms are equipped with typical washroom accessories: Paper towel dispensers, toilet paper dispensers, hand-soap dispensers, waste bins and mirrors.
The ramps in the student gathering areas are constructed of reinforced concrete.
The ramps in the student gathering area have a carpet floor finish.
The handrail are constructed of tubular steel with a paint finish.
The interior walls in the change rooms have a ceramic tile wall finish. A ceramic glass mosaic wall is located at the mainentrance of the school.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 14 of 39
C3010.09 Acoustical Wall Treatment - **
C3010.11 Interior Wall Painting - *
C3020.01.02 Paint Concrete Floor Finishes*
C3020.02 Tile Floor Finishes - Ceramic tile**
5 - Good
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
5 - Good
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
2005
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
20
15
10
50
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace Acoustical Wall Treatment
Replace Ceramic Tile Floor Finishes - (1500SM)
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2012
2041
$28,600
$183,040
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
Acoustical wall panels are located in the music room.
The interior partitions throughout the school have a paint finish.
Painted concrete floors are located in the mechanical penthouse & custodial rooms.
Ceramic tile flooring is located throughout the corridors, fashion arts, entrance vestibules, washrooms and change rooms.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 15 of 39
C3020.04 Wood Flooring - **
C3020.07 Resilient Flooring - Rubber **
C3020.07 Resilient Flooring - Sheet Vinyl **
C3020.08 Carpet Flooring - 2005**
4 - Acceptable
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
2006
1991
2005
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
30
20
20
15
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace Wood Flooring ( 600SM)
Replace rubber flooring (200SM)
Replace Sheet Vinyl (500SM)
Replace Carpet Flooring - (1000SM)
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2021
2026
2012
2020
$85,800
$34,320
$57,200
$114,400
Unassigned
Unassigned
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Type
Type
Year
Year
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
APR-08
APR-08
Hardwood flooring is located in the gymnasium & in the computer room.
A rubber flooring finish is located in the new exercise room and in the student gathering area.
Sheet Vinyl is located in the Arts room, home economics, science rooms and corridors.
Carpeting is located in the all the classrooms. Carpet was replace in 50% of the classroom areas in 2005.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 16 of 39
C3020.08 Carpet Flooring - Original**
C3030.02 Ceiling Paneling (Wood) - *
C3030.06 Acoustic Ceiling Treatment (Susp.T-Bar) - **
C3030.07 Interior Ceiling Painting - *
3 - Marginal
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
15
60
25
20
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace carpet flooring (1000SM)
Replace Acoustic Ceiling (2500SM)
Failure Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2008
2016
$114,400
$171,600
Low
Unassigned
The carpet has deteriorated in several areas, particularly in hightraffic areas, such as the library and classrooms.
Concern:
Replace carpeting where required.Recommendation:
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
Carpeting is located in the all the classrooms.50% of the carpet is original.
A wood ceiling is located in the office area.
The majority of the ceilings in the classroom areas have a 2'-0"x4'-0"suspended acoustical tile assembly.
All gypsum board ceilings & exposed steel structures have a paint finish.
Deteriorated carpet in classroom area
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 17 of 39
D2010.04 Sinks - **
D2010.05 Showers - **
D2010.08 Drinking Fountains / Coolers - **
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
30
30
35
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace the sinks in the building (approx. 37)
Replace the shower stalls (approx. 3)
Replace the drinking fountains (approx. 19)
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2021
2021
2026
$51,480
$10,296
$22,880
Unassigned
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
S4 MECHANICAL
Event:
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Type
Year
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
APR-08
There are 37 sinks in the building including two mop sinks and 35 general purpose sinks. Typical general purpose sinksinclude single and double bowl stainless steel sinks.
There are three shower stalls in the building, including one in each of the boy's and girl's change rooms and one in one ofthe staff washrooms.
There are 19 drinking fountains in the building. The drinking fountains are typically wall mounted stainless steel units andare not equipped with coolers.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 18 of 39
D2010.10 Washroom Fixtures (WC, Lav, Urnl) - **
D2020.01.01 Pipes and Tubes: Domestic Water - *
D2020.01.02 Valves: Domestic Water - **
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
35
40
40
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace the washroom plumbing fixtures (approx.18 toilets, 16 lavatories and 4 urinals)
Replace the domestic water distribution systemvalves
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2021
2031
$68,640
$57,200
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
Washroom plumbing fixtures include toilets, lavatories and urinals. There are 18 toilets (16 floor mounted flush valve typeand two floor mounted tank type), 16 lavatories (16 counter mounted stainless steel type), and four urinals (two floormounted flush valve type and two wall mounted flush valve type) in the building.
There is one domestic water supply to the building located in the meter room at the northeast corner of the building. Thewater supply is metered (25 mm meter). Water piping in the building is generally copper.
Domestic water system valves include zone isolating valves and fixture isolating valves. The domestic water system valvesare generally brass or steel.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 19 of 39
D2020.01.03 Piping Specialties (Backflow Preventors) - **
D2020.02.02 Plumbing Pumps: Domestic Water - **
3 - Marginal
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
20
20
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Install backflow prevention for the buildingdomestic water supply and isolate the watersupplies to the science room and art room sinkswith local backflow prevention
Replace the backflow prevention device for thefire protection water supply
Replace the domestic hot water circulation pumpP5
Code Upgrade
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2008
2012
2012
$16,016
$13,728
$2,288
Low
Unassigned
Unassigned
There is potential for contamination of the municipal watersupply caused by backflow from the building. In addition, thereis potential for contamination of the building potable waterdistribution system caused by backflow from the science roomor art room sinks.
Concern:
Install a backflow prevention device on the building domesticwater supply. In addition, isolate the domestic water supply tothe science room and art room sinks (approximately ten sinkstotal) and install backflow prevention devices for these isolatedwater supplies.
Recommendation:
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Type
Year
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
Updated:
OCT-07
APR-08
APR-08
There is a backflow prevention device on the fire protection water supply to the building sprinkler system, but no backflowprevention device on the domestic water supply to the building. There does not appear to be any backflow prevention for thewater feeds to the science room or art room sinks.
There is a domestic hot water system circulation pump (P5) which maintains the domestic hot water loop at temperature.This pump is located in the mechanical penthouse.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 20 of 39
D2020.02.06 Domestic Water Heaters - **
D2020.03 Water Supply Insulation: Domestic - *
D2030.01 Waste and Vent Piping - *
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
3 - Marginal
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
20
40
50
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace the two domestic hot water heaters in themechanical penthouse
Investigate and rectify the change room toiletsanitary drainage problem
Lifecycle Replacement
Repair
2012
2008
$18,304
$5,720
Unassigned
Low
Problems have been reported with the sanitary drainage of thetoilets in the change rooms.
Concern:
Investigate the change room toilet sanitary drainage problemand rectify.
Recommendation:
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
Two gas fired domestic hot water heaters located in the mechanical penthouse provide domestic hot water for the buildingsinks, lavatories and showers. The DHW heaters are A.O. Smith model BT251H-860S with an input heating capacity of226,000 Btu/h and a volume of 318 litres each.
Where visible, the domestic water piping is insulated with fiberglass insulation to prevent heat loss and condensation. Theinsulation is protected with a reinforced paper outer cover.
Visible waste and vent piping is generally copper with some ABS plastic. Since the building is primarily on one level, mostof the waste piping is below grade and not visible. Larger diameter waste piping (buried) is probably cast iron.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 21 of 39
D2040.01 Rain Water Drainage Piping Systems - *
D2040.02.04 Roof Drains - *
D3010.02 Gas Supply Systems - *
D3020.02.01 Heating Boilers and Accessories: H.W. - **
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
50
40
60
35
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace the two hot water heating boilers in themechanical penthouse
Lifecycle Replacement 2026 $171,600 Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Type Year Cost Priority
Updated: APR-08
Standard roof drains (approximately 24) are used to provide storm water drainage of the flat roof areas. The storm waterdrainage piping generally appears to be cast iron.
Standard roof drains with metal strainers (approximately 24) are used to collect storm water from the flat roof areas of themain building and the two pods.
The natural gas supply is underground to the building and the gas meter and pressure reducing station are located in themeter room at the northeast corner of the building. From the meter room, gas is supplied to the mechanical penthouse andto the two portables. The natural gas piping is steel.
There are two gas fired heating boilers providing hot water for building heating (B1 and B2). The hot water heating boilersare located in the mechanical penthouse. The hot water boilers are Cleaver Brooks model FLX-700-350 with an inputheating capacity of 3,500,000 Btu/h each.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 22 of 39
D3020.02.02 Chimneys (&Comb. Air): H.W. Boiler - **
D3020.02.03 Water Treatment: H. W. Boiler - *
D3040.01.01 Air Handling Units: Air Distribution - **
D3040.01.02 Fans: Air Distribution (Remote from AHU) - *
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
35
30
30
30
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace the hot water heating boiler commonstack
Replace the building air handling unit AS1 in themechanical penthouse
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2021
2021
$13,728
$320,320
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
The combustion gases from the two hot water boilers discharge through the roof of the mechanical penthouse in a commonstack.
Water treatment for the closed loop hot water heating system consists of manual chemical addition via a chemical potfeeder, as well as side stream cartridge filters.
One air handling unit (AS1) located in the mechanical penthouse provides ventilation for the building. The Haakon Airpakhas a capacity of 50,000 cfm and is equipped with glycol heating coils, filters, and a humidifier.
Air distribution fans for the building other than the air handling unit supply fan include the return air fan associated with airhandling unit AS1. The return air fan (FR1) is an axial type fan. The return air fan for air handling unit AS1 is located in themechanical penthouse.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 23 of 39
D3040.01.04 Ducts: Air Distribution - *
D3040.01.07 Air Outlets & Inlets:Air Distribution - *
D3040.03.01 Hot Water Distribution Systems - **
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
50
30
40
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace the hot water distribution systemincluding the circulation pumps
Lifecycle Replacement 2031 $531,960 Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Type Year Cost Priority
Updated: APR-08
The air distribution ducts include the supply air and return air duct systems for the air handling unit AS1. The duct systemsinclude associated components not specifically listed elsewhere, including duct insulation, turning vanes, dampers, mixingboxes, etc.
Air outlets and inlets include supply air diffusers and return air grilles.
The hot water heating system provides primary building heating via hydronic terminal units including perimeter finned tuberadiation cabinets, force flow convectors, unit heaters, reheat coils, and ceiling radiant panels. The hot water distributionsystem includes all components of the closed loop hot water heating system including piping, valves, piping insulation,piping specialties, circulation pumps, and expansion tanks. There are two main hot water circulation pumps (P1 and P2)located in the mechanical penthouse. The hot water loop expansion tank (TK1) is an atmospheric type tank which islocated in the mechanical penthouse.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 24 of 39
D3040.03.01 Hot Water Distribution Systems - Glycol**
D3040.04.01 Fans: Exhaust - **
D3040.04.03 Ducts: Exhaust - *
D3040.04.05 Air Outlets and Inlets: Exhaust - *
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
40
30
50
30
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace the glycol distribution system includingthe circulation pumps
Replace the building exhaust fans (approx. 15)
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2031
2021
$200,200
$40,040
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
OCT-07
APR-08
The glycol distribution system is used for the air handling unit (AS1) heating coils and for the fresh air preheat coils. Theglycol loop is heated by hot water via a plate and frame type heat exchanger. The glycol distribution system includes allcomponents of the closed loop glycol heating system including piping, valves, piping insulation, piping specialties,circulation pumps, and expansion tanks. There are three glycol circulation pumps, including the air handling unit heatingcoil glycol circulation pumps P3 and P4 and the fresh air preheat coil glycol circulation pump P8, all located in themechanical penthouse. There are two glycol system bladder type expansion tanks (TK2 and TK4), as well as a glycol filltank (TK3), all of which are located in the mechanical penthouse. The glycol distribution system piping is confined to themechanical penthouse where the air handling unit and fresh air preheat coils are located.
There are approximately 15 exhaust fans for the building providing sanitary, local and general ventilation.
Exhaust duct systems include the collection and discharge ducts associated with the 15 building exhaust fans.
Exhaust air inlets include the inlet grilles associated with the exhaust system collection ducts and exhaust air outletsinclude the exhaust system discharge louvres and gooseneck vents, where applicable.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 25 of 39
D3040.05 Heat Exchangers - **
D3050.02 Air Coils - **
D3050.03 Humidifiers - **
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
30
30
25
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace the glycol heat exchanger HX1 located inthe mechanical penthouse
Replace the hot water reheat coils (approx. 40)and the fresh air glycol preheat coils in themechanical penthouse
Replace the humidification system for air handlingunit AS1
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2021
2021
2016
$14,872
$205,920
$11,440
Unassigned
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Type
Year
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
APR-08
There is a plate and frame type heat exchanger (HX1) located in the mechanical penthouse which provides heating for theglycol loop using hot water from the hot water heating system.
The hot water heating system includes duct mounted reheat coils. It is estimated that there are approximately 40 hot waterreheat coils in the building. Air coils also include the fresh air glycol preheat coil in the mechanical penthouse, as this coilis not part of the air handling unit (AS1).
The air handling unit (AS1) is equipped with a circulating water type humidification system utilizing circulating pump P6.The humidification system is not being used.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 26 of 39
D3050.05.01 Convectors**
D3050.05.03 Finned Tube Radiation - **
D3050.05.06 Unit Heaters**
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
40
40
30
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace the wall mounted hot water convectors(approx. 10)
Replace the finned tube radiation cabinets(approx. 335 m)
Replace the hot water unit heaters (approx. 4)
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2031
2031
2021
$34,320
$171,600
$13,728
Unassigned
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Type
Year
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
Updated:
OCT-07
APR-08
OCT-07
There are wall mounted hot water convectors (force flow units) which provide heating at the entrance vestibules and in thecorridors, as well as in some classrooms.
The hot water heating system provides perimeter heating in most areas using finned tube radiation cabinets.
Hot water unit heaters are used for space heating in some locations including the gymnasium and the mechanicalpenthouse.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 27 of 39
D3050.05.08 Radiant Heating (Ceiling & Floor)**
D3060.02.02 Pneumatic Controls**
D3060.02.05 Building Systems Controls (BMCS, EMCS)**
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
2002
Installed
Installed
Installed
35
40
20
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace the ceiling mounted radiant hot waterheating panels
Replace the HVAC system pneumatic controlsincluding the control air supply system
Replace the building management and controlsystem (BMCS)
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2026
2031
2022
$17,160
$102,960
$114,400
Unassigned
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Type
Year
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
Updated:
OCT-07
OCT-07
OCT-07
Ceiling mounted radiant hot water heating panels are used in some locations including the boy's and girl's change rooms.
The building HVAC system controls and actuators are primarily pneumatic. There is a Landis & Gyr Powers System 600Building Management and Control System (BMCS) which provides control and monitoring functions for the main HVACequipment, although the HVAC equipment actuators and room thermostats are pneumatic. The control air supply systemis located in the mechanical penthouse and consists of two air compressors mounted on an air receiver tank with a wallmounted refrigerated air dryer. Pneumatic controls include control valves for the hydronic terminal units, control valves forthe air handling unit glycol heating coils and fresh air preheat coils, and damper actuators for the air handling unit.
The building is equipped with a central Building Management and Control System (Landis & Gyr Powers System 600),which provides control and monitoring functions for the main HVAC equipment, although the HVAC equipment actuators androom thermostats are pneumatic.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 28 of 39
D4010 Sprinklers: Fire Protection - *
D4030.01 Fire Extinguisher, Cabinets and Accessories - *
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
60
30
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
The building is equipped with automatic sprinklers for fire protection. The fire protection water supply to the building is 150mm diameter and is equipped with a backflow prevention device located in the mechanical penthouse. The sprinkler valve is100 mm and is located in the mechanical penthouse.
Wall mounted and cabinet mounted fire extinguishers are located throughout the building.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 29 of 39
D5010.03 Main Electrical Switchboards (Main Distribution)**
D5010.05 Electrical Branch Circuit Panelboards (Secondary Distribution)**
D5010.07.01 Switchboards, Panelboards, and Motor Control Centers**
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
40
30
30
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
APR-08
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace Main Electrical Switchboard
Replace Electrical Branch Circuit Panelboards
Replace Motor Control Centre
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2031
2021
2021
$68,640
$47,008
$14,300
Unassigned
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
S5 ELECTRICAL
Event:
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Type
Year
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
SEP-07
The incoming hydro service to Mary Butterworth School is a 120/208V, 3-phase, 4-wire service from an EPCORpadmounted transformer, located on the school grounds. The EPCOR meter is located in the main electrical room. Themain electrical switchboard is a Federal Pioneer switchboard rated at 1200A, 120/208V, 3-phase, 4-wire. The switchboardhas a 1200A, 12SFSB3 main breaker and a distribution section with fusible switches feeding three branch circuit panels, a600A CDP panel in the mechanical room, MCC #1 and the portables. The main electrical switchboard is original equipmentthat was installed when the school was constructed. There is a 400A spare fusible switch within the switchboard.
The majority of the electrical branch circuit panelboards within the school are original Federal Pioneer panels. Themechanical room CDP panel feeds approximately 6-120/208V panels and the North and South Pods. There are a total ofapproximately 9-120/208V branch circuit panels within the school.
MCC #1 is a 208V, 3 phase, 3-wire MCC located in the mechanical penthouse. The MCC is a 4-section Klockner MoellerSeries 200 motor control centre with approximately 15 starter units.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 30 of 39
D5010.07.02 Motor Starters and Accessories**
D5020.01 Electrical Branch Wiring*
D5020.02.01 Lighting Accessories (Lighting Controls)*
D5020.02.02.01 Interior Incandescent Fixtures*
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
30
50
30
30
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace Individual Motor Starters and Accessories
Lifecycle Replacement 2021 $9,264 Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Type Year Cost Priority
Updated: APR-08
There are some individual motor starters within the building. Most of the individual starters are 120V starter switches forfractional horsepower fans.
The majority of the cabling is standard building wire in EMT conduit. Armoured cable has been provided, in selectedlocations, for final connections to mechanical and miscellaneous equipment.
There are low voltage switches within the school used for lighting control. The GE low voltage relay cabinet is locatedadjacent to the 120/208V lighting panel.
Recessed incandescent lighting fixtures have been installed in the meeting room.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 31 of 39
D5020.02.02.02 Interior Florescent Fixtures**
D5020.02.02.03 Interior Metal Halide Fixture*
D5020.02.03.02 Emergency Lighting Battery Packs**
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
30
30
20
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace Interior Florescent Fixtures
Upgrade T12 fluorescent lighting (Est. 1 fixture/64sq. ft)
Replace Emergency Lighting Battery Packs
Lifecycle Replacement
Energy Efficiency Upgrade
Lifecycle Replacement
2021
2008
2012
$279,508
$171,600
$14,300
Unassigned
Low
Unassigned
The T12 lamps and ballasts are not energy efficient. T12 lampproduction could be discontinued in the future
Concern:
Relamp and reballast existing fluorescent fixtures with T8lamps and electronic ballasts.
Recommendation:
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Type
Year
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
APR-08
The standard lighting fixtures used throughout the school are 1 ft. x 4 ft. or 2 ft. x 4 ft. recessed, fluorescent fixtures. Insome areas a deep cell parabolic lens has been provided for the fixture. The fluorescent fixtures typically have beenprovided with T12 lamps and magnetic ballasts.
Indirect metal halide fixtures mounted on poles and metal halide downlights have been provided in the entrance lobby area.
Emergency lighting battery packs with lexan cube enclosures for the emergency lighting heads have been provided.
Consequences of Deferral:Increased energy costs.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 32 of 39
D5020.02.03.03 Exit Signs*
D5020.03.01.04 Exterior H.P. Sodium Fixtures*
D5020.03.02 Lighting Accessories: Exterior (Lighting Controls)*
D5030.01 Detection and Fire Alarm**
D5030.02.02 Intrusion Detection**
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
2004
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
30
30
30
25
25
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace Fire Alarm System
Replace Security System
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2016
2016
$174,445
$17,957
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
The exit signs within the school are LED type.
The exterior lighting for the school consists of HID wallpack and recessed downlight fixtures. Surface mounted roundfixtures with acrylic lenses are provided in some locations.
A timer and relays have been provided for control of the exterior lighting. An override switch has been provided with thecontrol system.
The fire alarm system is a Cerberus Pyrotronics CPC-3.24/32 system that was installed in 1991. The main fire alarmcontrol panel is located in the general office area. There is a remote annunciator at the main entrance. Fire alarm bells(some with strobes) are located throughout the school. Duct mounted smoke detection has been provided for air handlingsystems.
The security system is an Arrowhead Elite system with the main panel located in the custodian's room. A security systemkeypad has been provided in the custodian's room. PIR motion detectors have been provided throughout the school.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 33 of 39
D5030.02.04 Video Surveillance**
D5030.03 Clock and Program Systems*
D5030.04.01 Telephone Systems*
D5030.04.05 Local Area Network Systems*
D5030.05 Public Address and Music Systems**
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
5 - Good
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
2003
1991
2003
1998
2003
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
25
25
25
15
20
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace Video Surveillance System
Replace Public Address and Music Systems
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2028
2023
$11,440
$21,100
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
3 exterior cameras with weatherproof housings have been installed for the school and there are approximately 7 interiorcameras. The surveillance system equipment is located in the server room.
The majority of the clocks within the school are battery operated. Wall mounted clocks in the school are manufactured byWestclox.
The telephone system is a Nortel system. Norstar telephone handsets are located in the classrooms and selected areassuch as the general office. The main telephone equipment is located in the server room.
The main server is located in room 58. Cat. 5 cables are used for the network wiring within the school. Supernet has beeninstalled in the school.
The public address system is tied into the Nortel telephone system. TOA amplifiers have been provided in the server room.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 34 of 39
D5030.06 Television Systems*
4 - AcceptableRating
1991Installed
20Design Life
SEP-07Updated
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
The cable television equipment is located in the server room. Cable TV outlets are located in selected rooms.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 35 of 39
E1090.04 Residential Equipment - *
E1090.07 Athletic, Recreational, and Therapeutic Equipment - *
E2010.02 Fixed Casework - **
E2010.03.01 Blinds - **
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
10
15
35
30
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace Fixed Casework
Replace Blinds
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2026
2021
$343,200
$68,640
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
S6 EQUIPMENT, FURNISHINGS AND SPECIAL CONSTRUCTION
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
The home economic cooking labs are equipped with refrigerator, stoves, microwaves and several small kitchen appliances.
Basketball hoops and scoreboard are located in the gymnasium. A stair climber, treadmill and other therapeuticaccessories have been re-located in classroom (Rm.15) which has been converted to an exercise room.
Each classroom is equipped with custom wood open faced and/or painted cabinet units. Each science laboratory isequipped with upper wood cabinets, lower cupboards c/w counter-top, open fixed shelving. Most of the other labs, such as;home economics, industrial arts, and music all have fixed storage wood cabinets throughout the room. The library has fixedand moveable wood shelving casework. Glass display cabinets are located in the corridors & entrance area.
Horizontal blinds are between the sealed glazed units.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 36 of 39
E2010.05 Fixed Multiple Seating - **
E2010.06 Fixed Interior Landscaping - *
5 - Good
5 - Good
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
35
10
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Replace Fixed Multiple Seating in corridors
Lifecycle Replacement 2026 $28,600 Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Type Year Cost Priority
Updated: APR-08
Fixed seating is located in the student gathering areas.
Fixed interior planters are located in the main corridors.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 37 of 39
F1010.02.04 Portable and Mobile Buildings - *
3 - MarginalRating
0Installed
30Design Life
SEP-07Updated
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Portable - 181 & 255 - Built in unknown Structure: - Wood frame construction with concrete piles bearing on undisturbed soil. Envelope: - Cladding - A prefinished metal siding with vents is located at the base of the elevation. The exterior skin has a paintedwood siding finish with wood/metal framing construction. - Windows - The exterior windows are aluminum frame fixed and operable awning type windows and exterior metal securityscreens. - Roof Covering - The roofs have an SBS roof assembly. Interior: - Flooring - carpet flooring - Ceiling - 2'x4' Suspended Acoustical tile ceiling - Walls - Painted and /or vinyl covered gypsum board walls with either metal or wood wall construction. - Doors - Fire-rated steel door & frame assembly - Equipment - Whiteboards, tackboards, open wood shelving, wall mounted coat hooks & curtains. - Blinds - vertical plastic blinds Architectural elements within the portables with the exception of the carpet, were found to be in acceptable condition. Mechanical: Portable heating is provided by a gas fired forced air furnace which provides a mixture of fresh air and return air to theconditioned space. Temperature control is independent and is typically provided by an analog or digital electric thermostat.Classroom portables do not have any plumbing. Portables are typically equipped with a fire extinguisher for fire protection.Exterior storm drainage for the portable consists of gutters and downspouts which discharge to grade. Mechanical elements within the portables were found to be in acceptable condition. Electrical: Each portable classroom is provided with a stablock panel (connected to the school electrical distribution system) thatprovides power for the individual classroom. The lighting fixture used within each portable classroom is typically a surfacemounted, T12, fluorescent, wrap-around fixture. Recessed round P.A. speakers, a telephone and a PIR motion detector aretypically provided in each portable classroom. The portables are connected to the school fire alarm system and havepullstations at the exits and heat detectors in the storage and furnace rooms. The electrical elements within the portables were found to be in acceptable condition.
Portable 255
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 38 of 39
F2020.01 Asbestos - *
F2020.04 Mould - *
F2020.09 Other Hazardous Materials - *
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
0
0
0
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace carpeting in 181 & 255
Failure Replacement 2008 $11,440 Low
The carpet flooring is deteriorated and a potential trippinghazard.
Concern:
Replace carpeting in both portables.Recommendation:
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
Event:
Type Year Cost Priority
Updated: APR-08
No asbestos known or reported. An asbestos report by PHH Environmental Ltd. was conducted in November , 2001
No mould known or reported
No hazardous materials known or reported
Deteriorated carpeting in the portables.
Report run on: July 16, 2008 2:52 PM Page 39 of 39
K3020 Indoor Environment
K4010.01 Barrier Free Route: Parking to Entrance - *
K4010.02 Barrier Free Entrances - *
K4010.03 Barrier Free Interior Circulation - *
K4010.04 Barrier Free Washrooms - *
3 - Marginal
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
0
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
0
0
0
0
0
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Install local air conditioning for the computer room(Former Wood Shop)
Indoor Air Quality Upgrade 2008 $9,152 Low
The computer room can get very warm since there is no airconditioning.
Concern:
Install local air conditioning for the computer room.Recommendation:
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (B3205A)
S8 FUNCTIONAL ASSESSMENT
Event:
Type Year Cost Priority
Updated: OCT-07
The computer room does not have any air conditioning.
Barrier free access from the parking area to the main building entrance is provided on the north-west elevation.
An automatic door entrance is provided at the F2 entrance.
Barrier free access is provided to most areas throughout the school.
Barrier free washrooms are provided throughout the school.
Report run on: July 18, 2008 12:20 PM
RECAPP Facility Evaluation Report
Mary Butterworth School
S3205Edmonton
Report run on: July 18, 2008 12:20 PM Page 2 of 7
S3205Building Id:
Mary Butterworth SchoolBuilding Name:
EdmontonLocation:Address:
0.00Gross Area (sq. m): $0Replacement Cost:0Construction Year:
Evaluation Date: June 8 2007
Asset Evolution Incorporated (AEI)Evaluation Company:
Mario PlastinaEvaluator Name:
The site of Mary Butterworth School includes an asphalt paved roadway & parking area accessible from 109th Street atthe west end of the property. Grass, shrubs and trees are located throughout the site. A free standing school signagepanel is located is located along the west end of the site. A poured in place concrete playground area is located at thesouth end of the property. Pedestrian concrete pavers and poured in place concrete walkways are located at the mainentrances and extend along the perimeter of the school. Site drainage east of the school was indicated to be poor. Thegrounds slope towards the school area. Overall the site is in acceptable condition
General Summary:
Structural Summary:
Envelope Summary:
Interior Summary:
Mechanical Summary:
Electrical Summary:
0%5 year Facility Condition Index (FCI):
Facility Details Evaluation Details
Total Maintenance Events Next 5 years: $62,920
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (S3205)
Condition Rating Performance1 - Critical Unsafe, high risk of injury or critical system failure.2 - Poor Does not meet requirements, has significant deficiencies. May have high operating/maintenance costs.
3 - Marginal Meets minimum requirements, has significant deficiencies. May have above average operating maintenance costs.4 - Acceptable Meets present requirements, minor deficiencies. Average operating/maintenance costs.
Rating Guide
5 - Good Meets all present requirements. No deficiencies.6 - Excellent As new/state of the art, meets present and foreseeable requirements.
Report run on: July 18, 2008 12:20 PM Page 3 of 7
G2010.02.02 Flexible Pavement Roadway (Asphalt) - **
G2010.05 Roadway Curbs and Gutters - *
G2020.02.02 Flexible Paving Parking Lots(Asphalt) - **
G2020.05 Parking Lot Curbs and Gutters - *
G2020.06.02 Parking Bumpers - *
4 - Acceptable
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
5 - Good
5 - Good
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
25
25
25
25
25
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace asphalt paved roadway
Replace asphalt paved parking area - 1000SM
Lifecycle Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2016
2016
$22,880
$80,080
Unassigned
Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (S3205)
S7 SITE
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
An asphalt paved roadway to the main parking areas is accessible from 109th Street located at the north-west corner of thesite.
Poured in place & precast concrete curbs are located around the perimeter of the asphalt paved roadway.
The asphalt paved parking area is located at the north end of the property.
Poured in place concrete curbs are located around the perimeter of the parking lot
Painted steel parking bumpers are located throughout the parking area.
Report run on: July 18, 2008 12:20 PM Page 4 of 7
G2020.06.03 Parking Lot Signs - *
G2020.06.04 Pavement Markings - *
G2030.03 Pedestrian Unit Pavers**
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
5 - Good
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
25
25
20
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace concrete pavers
Lifecycle Replacement 2012 $28,600 Unassigned
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (S3205)
Event:
Type Year Cost Priority
Updated: SEP-07
Each parking bumper stall has a reference number.
The parking lots have yellow painted lines identifying the parking spaces.
Pedestrian unit pavers are located in secondary walkways
Report run on: July 18, 2008 12:20 PM Page 5 of 7
G2030.04 Rigid Pedestrian Pavement (Concrete) - **
G2040.03 Athletic and Recreational Surfaces - **
G2040.05 Site and Street Furnishings - *
3 - Marginal
5 - Good
5 - Good
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
25
25
15
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Replace Concrete Walkways
Replace cracked concrete walkwat at entrance F4.
Replace poured concrete playground area.
Lifecycle Replacement
Failure Replacement
Lifecycle Replacement
2016
2008
2016
$171,600
$34,320
$114,400
Unassigned
Medium
Unassigned
The entire concrete walkway at entrance F4 is cracked andcreating a potential safety hazard.
Concern:
Remove and replace concrete walkway at F4.Recommendation:
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (S3205)
Event:
Event:
Event:
Type
Type
Type
Year
Year
Year
Cost
Cost
Cost
Priority
Priority
Priority
Updated:
Updated:
Updated:
APR-08
APR-08
APR-08
Poured in place concrete walkways at the edge of the site lead to all the school entrances.
A poured concrete playground & a sodded football / soccer field with goal posts is located at the south-east end of theproperty.
Bicycle racks are located along the south-west end of the school. Basketball hoops are located adjacent to the asphaltpaved playground along the south elevation of the school. Fixed metal seating is located adjacent to the main entrance.
Settled concrete walkway at entrance F4.
Report run on: July 18, 2008 12:20 PM Page 6 of 7
G2040.06 Exterior Signs - *
G2040.08 Flagpoles - *
G2040.11 Retaining Walls - *
G2050.04 Lawns and Grasses - *
G2050.05 Trees, Plants and Ground Covers - *
G3010.02 Site Domestic Water Distribution - *
G3010.03 Site Fire Protection Water Distribution - *
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
5 - Good
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
25
30
50
15
10
50
50
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
OCT-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
OCT-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (S3205)
Exterior wall-mounted signage is provided on the buildings main entrances. School signage is located on the west wall. Afree-standing signage panel is located at the north-west corner of the site.
A flagpole is located on the west end of the site, adjacent to the main entrance.
Concrete planter retaining walls are located at the south end of the site.
Grassed areas are located along the south, east and west sides of the school.
Mature trees and shrubs are located along the south & west sides of the site.
The building domestic water supply comes from a domestic water main on 109 Street. The domestic water supply to thebuilding enters the meter room at the northeast corner of the building (room 42). The domestic water supply is reported tobe a 75 mm diameter line and the building water meter is 25 mm.
The water supply for the building automatic sprinkler system is independent of the domestic water supply and comes from109 Street. The fire protection water supply is piped to the mechanical penthouse where the sprinkler valve is located.
Report run on: July 18, 2008 12:20 PM Page 7 of 7
G3020.01 Sanitary Sewage Collection - *
G3030.01 Storm Water Collection - *
G3060.01 Gas Distribution - *
G4010.03 Electrical Power Distribution Equipment*
G4010.04 Car Plugs-ins*
G4020.01 Area Lighting*
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
4 - Acceptable
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
Installed
50
50
50
50
25
25
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
Design Life
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
SEP-07
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Updated
Edmonton - Mary Butterworth School (S3205)
It is assumed that the building sanitary sewer discharges to a municipal sanitary sewer on 109 Street.
It is assumed that the building storm sewer discharges to a municipal storm sewer on 109 Street. There are two stormsewer catch basins located in the paved parking area on the north side of the building.
Natural gas is supplied to the building from a gas main on 109 Street. The natural gas supply line runs underground on thenorth side of the building to the meter room at the northeast corner of the building (room 42) where the pressure reducingstation and the gas meter are located.
An EPCOR padmount transformer located on the school grounds provides 120/208V, 3 phase, 4-wire power for the school.
There are a total of 21 rail mounted weatherproof duplex receptacles for car plug-ins.
There are two pole mounted contracline fixtures at the main entrances and three shoebox style HPS, pole mounted fixturesthat illuminate the parking area.