raidho c1.1 loudspeakersraidho.dk/wp-content/uploads/raidhoc11_audiobeat.pdfwith the original. of...

9
Raidho C1.1 Loudspeakers by Roy Gregory, January 7, 2012 © www.theaudiobeat.com nce upon a time, there was a little speaker with big ambitions. It had an aluminum baffle and a boat-backed cabinet, and its manufacturer made some serious claims about their revolutionary drivers and materials, their in-house production, their advanced mounting, and the quality of their crossovers. In fact, if all the claims were true, the speaker should be capable of a near-magical performance. It would also be very, very expensive, but not as costly as you might assume, because the speaker I’m describing is probably not the one you are thinking of. The speaker I have in mind is the Raidho C1, a compact, two-way stand-mount from Denmark, exquisite of form, impressive of function and genuinely revolutionary when it came to hardware: no off-the-shelf or “modified” tweeter or reconed bass unit; instead, it used real in-house-designed and -built drivers and components, and real clean-sheet engineering solutions. The C1 was about as far from a “me-too” product as it’s possible to get. The Raidho story actually starts with a driver -- a planar-magnetic high-frequency unit, sometimes (erroneously and confusingly) referred to as a ribbon. In my lexicon, a ribbon has an entirely conductive moving element, with signal going in one end and out of the other. The Raidho unit used a thin aluminum trace etched onto a mylar diaphragm, creating a continuous sheet. Magnets are placed either side of the driver membrane and behind its center. This construction, with signal passing down one side of the membrane and up the other, means that the electrical load represents something akin to a conventional voice coil, but flattened, with a nominal 7-ohm impedance -- in marked contrast to many ribbons that either exhibit 1 O

Upload: others

Post on 15-Feb-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Raidho C1.1 Loudspeakersraidho.dk/wp-content/uploads/RaidhoC11_audiobeat.pdfwith the original. Of course, having the C1s on hand allows direct comparison between the two, but let’s

RaidhoC1.1 Loudspeakers

by Roy Gregory, January 7, 2012 © www.theaudiobeat.com

nceuponatime,therewasalittlespeaker withbigambitions.Ithadanaluminumbaffle andaboat-backedcabinet,anditsmanufacturermadesomeseriousclaimsabouttheirrevolutionarydriversandmaterials,theirin-houseproduction,theiradvancedmounting,andthequalityoftheircrossovers.Infact,ifalltheclaimsweretrue,thespeakershouldbecapableofanear-magicalperformance.Itwouldalsobevery,veryexpensive,butnotascostlyasyoumightassume,becausethespeakerI’mdescribingisprobablynottheoneyouarethinkingof.ThespeakerIhaveinmindistheRaidhoC1,acompact,two-waystand-mountfromDenmark,exquisiteofform,impressiveoffunctionandgenuinelyrevolutionarywhenitcametohardware:nooff-the-shelfor“modified”tweeterorreconedbassunit;instead,itusedrealin-house-designedand-builtdriversand

components,andrealclean-sheetengineeringsolutions.TheC1wasaboutasfarfroma“me-too”productasit’spossibletoget.

TheRaidhostoryactuallystartswithadriver--aplanar-magnetichigh-frequencyunit,sometimes

(erroneouslyandconfusingly)referredtoasaribbon.Inmylexicon,aribbonhasanentirelyconductivemovingelement,withsignalgoinginoneendandoutoftheother.TheRaidhounitusedathinaluminumtraceetchedontoamylardiaphragm,creatingacontinuoussheet.Magnetsareplacedeithersideofthedrivermembraneandbehinditscenter.Thisconstruction,withsignalpassingdownonesideofthemembraneanduptheother,meansthattheelectricalloadrepresentssomethingakintoaconventionalvoicecoil,butflattened,withanominal7-ohmimpedance--inmarkedcontrasttomanyribbonsthateitherexhibit

1

O

Page 2: Raidho C1.1 Loudspeakersraidho.dk/wp-content/uploads/RaidhoC11_audiobeat.pdfwith the original. Of course, having the C1s on hand allows direct comparison between the two, but let’s

cripplinglysevereimpedancecharacteristicstothedrivingamplifieroremployatransformertoovercomethem.

Notthatdefinitionsreallymatter.Whatmattersisperformance,andinthisregardtheRaidhounitwasspectacularlygood--butalsoproblematic.Soquickandclean,itwashardtointegrateproperlywithconventional,dynamicmidrangeorbassdrivers.Eventhefastestavailableunitswerestrugglingtokeepup,resultinginarangeofhybridloudspeakersthathadphenomenalperformancepotentialbutwerealmostunworkablycriticalwhenitcametoplacementandsystemmatching;justalittleextraweightinthewrongplace,whetheritcamefrompositioningorthedrivingsystem,andthewholethingfellapart.ThoseXSeriesspeakersweretheclassichi-ficonundrum:whentheyweregoodtheywerevery,verygood,butwhentheywerebad,theysoundedbroken.

TheC1wasthefirstofRaidho’snext-generationloudspeakers,anditwasaimedatsolvingtheproblemsexperiencedwiththeXSeriesmodels.Anotherhybridplanar-magnetic/dynamicdesignbuiltaroundtheoriginaltweeter,thistimeitwasbasedonamid-bassdriverbuiltentirelyin-house.Ofcourse,manymanufacturersstatethattheirdriversare“unique,”“custom”or“modified.”Whatthatgenerallymeansisthattheyhavecollaboratedwithadrivermanufacturertoadaptanexistingunitordevelopanewonefromthemanufacturer’sexistingkitofparts.Theresultmayindeedbeunique--butitisalsogenerallyprettyconventional.

There’snothing--andIdomeannothing--conventionalaboutthemid-bassunitthatRaidhodevelopedforthe

C1.Facedwiththechallengeofcreatingadriverthatcouldmatchthespeedofresponseanddynamicrangeoftheirtweeter,they

quicklyrealizedthatextrememeasureswerenecessary.Let’sstartwiththeconeasanexample.

Ratherthanrelyingonanexistingpartormaterial,theysetouttodeveloptheirown.AninnovativeproductionprocesswasemployedtocreatewhatRaidhorefertoas

a“deepceramiccoated”coneforthebassdriver.Mostceramicconesarehomogenousstructures,themostfamiliarbeingAccuton’swhite-bowldiaphragms.Theseareabout500micronsthickandundoubtedlystiffandlight.Theissuewiththemispreventingthemfromringing,whichaccountsinpartforthevariouscutoutsorholes

withwhichtheyaredecorated.TheRaidhodriveradoptsadifferentapproach:100-micronceramic“skins”beingformedonthesurfaceofathinaluminumstructure,leavingametalcore.Thatcreatesasandwichconewiththick,lightceramiclayersoneithersideofathinaluminumcenter.Theaimistoproduceaconestructurethatisaslightandstiffasconventionalceramiccones,butoffersfarbetterself-damping.

Buttheinnovationdidn’tstopthere.Conventional

dynamicdriversarebuiltontoachassisthatisthenattachedtothecabinetbybolts,clampsorsomeotherfixing.TheRaidhodrivereliminatedthechassisentirely,alongwithanymechanicaldiscontinuitiesorenergylossthatresultedfromitsfixingtothebaffle.Instead,theconesurroundattacheddirectlytothecontouredaluminumbaffle,thebasketstructurebeingreplacedbyamotormountedonaringthatwasscreweddirectlyintothebackofthebafflebyaseriesofstand-offs.Themotoritselfusedanarrayofneodymiummagnetsinapush-pullarrangement,theshortvoicecoilbeingmassively

2

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

Page 3: Raidho C1.1 Loudspeakersraidho.dk/wp-content/uploads/RaidhoC11_audiobeat.pdfwith the original. Of course, having the C1s on hand allows direct comparison between the two, but let’s

overhung.Theformerwasfullyventedtofurtheraiddynamicsandavoidthermalcompression.Thewholeunitwasamodelofelegantengineeringanduttersimplicity,dedicatedtothesinglegoalofcreatingthefastestpossibledriverbyeliminatingmechanicalcompromise,storedorreflectedenergyandcompression.Itisbothanimpressiveandextremesolution,anunequivocalresponsetotheparticularlydemandingquestionpresentedintheformofRaidho’sownplanar-magnetictweeter.TheC1’sbassdriverwasthatanswer--andaprettycomprehensiveoneatthat.

Thehigh-frequencyunitwasalsobuiltdirectlyontotherearofthecontouredbaffle,ensuringaccurateinterfacingbetweenthedrivermembraneitselfandtheshallowflarethatloadedit,avitalconsiderationinachievingconsistentresults.TheXSerieshadusedamoldedpolymerelementtoloadthetweeter,butmadethemistakeofusingasimplepushfittolocateit.Variationsintheprecisealignmentofthedriverandthethroatoftheflare,aswellasthedistancebetweenthetwo,producedclearlyaudibleirregularitiesinresponse.Theanswerwastointegratethetwoelementsbyeliminatingtheexistingfaceplateandconstructingthedriverdirectlyontotherearoftheflaredbaffle--whichalsohappenedtocreateapleasingcontinuitywiththeconstructionofthemid-bassdriver.

Thetwodriversweremarriedbyasimplecrossoverconstructedfromhand-builtinductorsandcapacitorsmanufacturedspecificallytoaRaidhodesign,usingpreciselyspecifiedelementsandmaterials.Thediminutivecabinetwasnarrowanddeep,withcurvedwallsandarear-facingreflexport,carefullyflaredandintegralwiththecontouredspine.Thehigh-glossburlwalnutfinishwasimmaculate,andthecompanyalsosuppliedastrikinglyelegantstand,withalightweight,sprungconstructionandresonancecontrolinterfacestopandbottom.

Allinallitwasastunningproduct:innovativeandvisuallyelegant,itsoundedmightyimpressivetoo.Butbestofall,itcostratherlessthanhalfthepriceofsomeotheroptions--speakersthatattractedconsiderablymoreattentiondespitebeingarguablylessaccomplishedanddefinitelylessfullyengineered.Thoseintheknowsimplysmiled,satbackandenjoyedthemusic,whileRaidhoworkedondevelopinglargersystemsandthedriverstopopulatethem.

IreviewedtheC1sseveralyearsago,andthey’vebeenaconstantpresencesince,eitherinoneofmysystemsorontheendofChrisThomas’s

setup.Theirdynamicandmusicalcoherence,theirtransparencyandsensitivitytothenuancesof

techniqueandexpressionhavemadethemaninvaluabletool,acrystal-clearwindowontosystemperformance.Atthesametime,theirrevealingcharacterhasmadethemademandingreviewpartnerandadraconiantask-masterwhenitcomestosystemsetupandstateoftune.NothinggetspasttheC1s,musicallyorinhi-fiterms.

Whichbringsusfinally,tothenewC1.1,thelatestincarnationofthischallengingandrewardingcompactspeaker.Outwardlyvirtuallyidenticaltotheoriginal,theupdatedmodeldrawsinpartonexperienceandtechnologydevelopedforthoselargerspeakersystems,particularlytheimposingC4floorstander.Aswellaschangesandrefinementsinthedrivers,therehavealsobeenanumberofimprovementsintheotherhardwarecomponents,whichmightseemalmostinsignificantyetcollectivelyhaveaprofoundeffect.

Themostobviouschangeistothehigh-frequencydiaphragm.Theoriginalemployedincrediblythinconductivealuminumtraces,etchedinaclassic“prisonbars”patterninathinfoilbondedtoamylarmembrane.Therevisedtweeteremploysthesamemagnetstructure,butnowtheconductivetracesconstituteaninterlocking,almostherringbonepattern.Raidhoclaimthatthisimprovesthelinearityandconsistencyoftheribbon/diaphragm’smotion,helpingpreventbowingorripplingunderdrive.Giventhewidthoftheradiatingareaandthelateralspacingofthemagnets(oneoneachside,oneinthemiddle),Icancertainlyunderstandthatthismighthavebeenanissue

3

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

Page 4: Raidho C1.1 Loudspeakersraidho.dk/wp-content/uploads/RaidhoC11_audiobeat.pdfwith the original. Of course, having the C1s on hand allows direct comparison between the two, but let’s

withtheoriginal.Ofcourse,havingtheC1sonhandallowsdirectcomparisonbetweenthetwo,butlet’snotgetaheadofourselves.

Changestothemid-bassdriverareconfinedtothemotorassembly,andmorespecificallythevoicecoilandformer.Theoriginalversionemployedanaluminumformerandthishasnowbeenchangedtoazero-hysteresistitaniumpart,whilethevoicecoilnowusesadouble-layerwindingthatisclaimedtoreducethedriver’sinductanceby50%.Onceagain,directcomparisonsarebothinstructiveandconclusive.

Thecabinetstructureremainsunchanged,thealuminumbaffleplatesstillneatlymatedtothebeautifullylacquered1”-thickHDFcarcass.Asifthesmall-paneldimensionsandcurvedsidewallsaren’tstiffenough,therearethreeinternalhorizontalbracesandanotherverticalone.Despiteitsdiminutivedimensions,thisisonesolidandsubstantiallittlebox.Itisstillavailableintheoriginalburlwalnutfinish,butnowalsocomesinhigh-glossblackorwhite,thelatterbeingparticularlyattractive--atleasttomyeyesandinthecontextofourdistinctlymoderninteriordécor.

Theothervisiblechangeistotherearterminals,whicharenowRaidho’sowndesign,inplaceofthepreviousWBTs.Thesearelow-mass,dimensionallytuneditemsthatmightnotlookparticularlyimpressivebutsoundamazing.Orrather,theydon’t;theyjustletyouhearhowmuchimpactmostotherterminalshaveonthesignalthatpassesthroughthem.Internally,thewiringhasbeenupgraded,nowincorporatingNordostOdinaswellasthepreviousValhallaconductors--suitablyclassypartnersforthehand-craftedcomponentryemployedinthecrossover.

Thesumtotalofthesechangesmightnotseemthat significant,moreatweakingthanafundamental redesign,butletmebeabsolutelyclearaboutthis:sonically,theC1.1isawholenewballgame.Aspreviouslymentioned,havingtheC1in-houseasalong-termreferencealloweddirectcomparisonbetweenoldmodelandnew--anditwasn’tpretty.Facetoface,thenewspeakergoesdeeperwithconsiderablymorepurpose.Bassnoteshavegreaterpresenceandenergy,betterpitchdefinitionandshape.Musichasgreaterimpact,bothphysicallyandemotionally.

Impact--it’saninterestingterm,andparticularlysowhenitcomestotheC1.1.Therearetwoelements

thatmatterwhenitcomestoimpact:weightandspeed.Somethingheavytravellingatmoderatespeedcanhavealotlesseffectthansomethinglighterbuttravellinganawfullot

faster.Justthinkballistics.Asix-gunfiresaheavyslugthat’salmosthalfaninchindiameter.AnM16firesathinner,longerroundthat’slessthanquarterofaninchindiameterandmaybeathirdasheavy--butittravelsalotfaster,andasaresult,despitebeingsmallerandlighter,it’salotmorelethal.Justaskthepeopleonthereceivingend.

Inthesameway,thephysicsofsmalldriversinsmallcabinetsmeanthatsmallspeakerssimplydon’tgothatlow--atleastnotunlesstheyresorttomass-loadeddriversorothertrickery.Whichtakesusstraightbacktobulletsandslowandheavyversuslightandfast.Overtheyears,differentdesignershavetrieddifferentapproachestofakingitwhenitcomestocoaxingorchestralclimaxesoutofsmallspeakers:varyingdegreesof“voicing,”ABRs,isobaricbassloadingandcountlessotherapproachesIeitherhaven’theardaboutorhavesimplyforgotten.Fewifanyofthemactuallydeliveraconvincingimpressionoftherealthing,atleastnotwithoutsimplydumpingtheprobleminsomeoneelse’slap--normallythepersondesigningthepoweramp.

Soifrealisticweightisdarnednearimpossibletoachieve,howaboutaconvincingsenseofimpact?It’stheroadlesstraveled,atleastintermsofspeakerdesign,butit’sthepathchosenbyRaidho.WhattheC1.1sdoisdelivercleanbassinformationaslowastheycan--andtheydosoextremelyquickly.Thosebassnotesmightnotgothatdeep,althoughthesecond-generationdriverwithitstitaniumvoice-coilformercertainlyseemstohelpinthisregard,butboyaretheyfast.Theresultisplentyofimpactbutwithoutanyofthe“padding”sooftenaddedontothebottomendoflittlespeakerstomakethemseemlargerthantheyare.

Theresultingclaritycleansupthemidbassandbringscolorandseparationtothemidrange.Andmusicallythechangesarenolessprofound.PlaytherecentJurowski/LPOrecordingofHonegger’sPastorale D’Ete(CD[LPO0058])andtheC1.1sdeliveradramaticallymoretransparent,spaciousandspatiallyfocusedpictureoftheorchestra.Tonalseparationissignificantlybetter,woodwinds,hornsandcellieasilypickedastheyplayinconcert.That’spartlydowntotheextrasubstance

4

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

T

Page 5: Raidho C1.1 Loudspeakersraidho.dk/wp-content/uploads/RaidhoC11_audiobeat.pdfwith the original. Of course, having the C1s on hand allows direct comparison between the two, but let’s

throughthemids--butIsuspectitalsoreflectsanincreasedsenseofbodyandcolorfromthetweeter.However,it’snotjusttheeasewithwhicheachinstrumentcanbeidentified;itspurposeandcontributionsimplymakemoresense.Theshapeandstructureoftheworkismoreapparentandtheplayingmoreaccomplished.TheC1.1sbringaneasyfluiditytothemusic,anaturalebbandflowthatbreatheslifeintotheperformance.

MoveontoAmyMacdonald’sThis Is The Life[MelodramaticRecords173212-4]andallthesamebenefitsareapparent,thenewerspeakereasilysortingoutwhatisaless-than-wonderfulmodernrecordingandinjectingamuch-neededsenseofpaceandintent.Theguitarthatdrivesthetitletrackhasrealattackandonceagainthealbumasawholehasapurposefulmomentumthatengagesanddrawsthelistenerin.Theshiftsindensitythataresuchapartofthisdisc,thewaysomanyofthetracksbuildfrombasicfolkarrangementstoalmostanthemicproportionsplaceaheavyburdenonthesystem’sdynamicenvelope,aloadthat’sreadilyencompassedbytheC1.1s’enthusiasticresponse.Somuchsoinfactthattheuseofcompressiontofilloutthemusic’sdensityandcreatethefeelingofloudnessisclearlyrevealed,therecordingneverpushingthespeakers’dynamicrangealltheway--despitethemusicaldemands.Wheremostspeakersarealltoogladtoacceptalittlejudicioushelpwhenitcomestolouderpassages,thesesmallRaidhoshaveareal“bringiton”attitude.It’salmostasifthey’resaying,“Wedon’tcompressthemusic--whyshouldyou?”

5

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

Ifyoureadthe introductory blog that preceded this series of speaker reviews,you’llseemeadvancethetheorythatsmallspeakersdidn’t

reallyhittheirstrideuntildesignersrecognizedthecentralimportanceofdynamiccoherence

andexpressiontotheirabilitytoconvincemusically.TheC1.1goesmuch,muchfurtherthanthat;dynamiccoherencemightwellbedescribedasitsraison d’etre.It’swhat,incombinationwithitstactile,unimpededbassperformance,makesthisspeakersoastonishinglyexpressiveandcommunicative--andwhatallowsittospeak(despiteitsdiminutivedimensions)withavoiceofsuchmusicalauthority.Andlet’sfaceit,ifyoucan’thavebandwidth,thenauthorityisdefinitelythenextbestthing!

Takethebassclarityandpresence,theuseable,meaningfuloutputthatgoeslowerthanyouexpect,withoutslowingorslurring,aswellasthoseunfettereddynamics,andwhat

yougetisaspeakerthatdeliversnotjusttremendousresolutionanddynamicdiscrimination,butasenseoftonalshadingandsubtlythatnormallyescapesspeakersofthisilk,wherecolorandresolutiontendtobeeither/orqualities.Don’tgetmewrong--aspeakerlikeCrystalCable’sArabesqueMinihasawiderandrichertonalpaletteandbetterharmonicdefinitionthantheC1.1,butifyouexpecttheRaidhotosoundanemic,youareinforaverypleasantsurprise.Leanitmaybe,butgutlessitain’t.Instead,itleansonthefronthalfofnotes,which,alongwithitsrhythmicallyarticulate,sure-footedpresentationandsuddenleadingedges,is

Page 6: Raidho C1.1 Loudspeakersraidho.dk/wp-content/uploads/RaidhoC11_audiobeat.pdfwith the original. Of course, having the C1s on hand allows direct comparison between the two, but let’s

whatimbuesmusicwitharealsenseofpurposeandtheplayingwithprecision.

IusedtheC1.1switharangeofamps,butmainlytheVTLMB-450IIIs,theIconAudioStereo60and,perhapsmostimpressivelyofall,theRowland625.ThisisnoAvalonIndraorCoincidentPureReferenceExtreme,speakersthatstandsofarapartfromthemusicthatwhatyouhearisdominatedbytheamp.ThetonaltailoringimposedbytheRaidhoissubtle,butit’sthere,andit’senoughtogivethespeakeranidentifiablecharacter--definedbyitsquicknessandasoundthat’scleanwithouteverbeingsterile.ButwhereasmostspeakerswillleaveyouthinkingthattheRowlandamphasslightlyunderstateddynamics,perhapsalackofabsolutedynamicrange,theRaidhosrevealthatactuallyit’sthoseotherspeakersimposingthelimitation.TheunexaggerateddynamicenvelopedeliveredbytheRowlandampisgivenfullscope,allowingitseasy,unobstructedclarityfullrein.ComparingtherecentBoxstarre-releaseofJanisIan’sBetween The LinesLP[Boxstar88697691871]tomyoriginalpressing[CBS33394]isacaseinpoint.Usingthetried-and-trustedtesttrack“AtSeventeen,”theC1.1/625combinationclearlyrevealsthenaturalfluidityandphrasingintheperformance,aswellasawealthofdetail,easilyseparatingthemultipleguitarsandthechorushorns.Italsoidentifiesthepeculiartonalityofthetromboniumaswellasrevealingtheslightlossofimmediacyandabsoluteclarityonthereissue.

Lestyouthinkthatsoftnesscomesfromamporspeaker,notonlyisitabsentfromtheoriginalpressing,it’sabsentonmanyotherstoo.TheArgenta/YepesConcierto de AranjuezLP[AlhambraSCLL14000]isaperfectexample.Thisisoneofthegreatclassicalrecordings,whereaperformanceofrealmajestyiscapturedinsoundthattrulydoesitjustice.ItsmagicalblendofmusicalbrillianceandspatialcoherencerevealsboththeC1.1s’strengthsandcharacter.Thetransparencyandseamlessspaceofthisrecordingareclearlyapparent,thesoloistperfectlycentered,hisinstrumentpresentedwithrealimmediacyandpresence.Thesoundstageisbroad,butwhilsttheinstrumentsarebothlayeredandpreciselylocated,itlackstheobvioussenseof(slightlyexaggerated)depthyougenerallyhearfromthisdisc,anartifactofthesimple,minimalistmicrophonetechnique.Thespeakers’widestanceandclaritycreateanexpansivesoundspace

withpreciselyarrangedandlocatedinstruments,buttheydon’tdefinetheacousticasawhole,withclearlydiscernable

boundaries.Listenfordepthinthesoundstageandit’sthere;itjustisn’tobviouslytherebecause

youaren’thearingthesidewall,therearwallorthesenseofproportionbetweenthem.

However,whatisreally,reallyimpressiveisthesheerintensityofYepes’playing,hisattack,hisshapingofnotesandphrases.Theopeningpassageofthesecondmovementisalessoninthatstrangealchemythatsomehowseamlesslycombinesdelicacyandpower,poiseandanalmostabandonedcascadeofnotes.ItunderlinesnotjustYepes’ability,butthegripandauthorityoftheC1.1whenproperlydriven.Ifasystemisawholethat’sgreaterthanthesumofitspartsthentheC1.1/625setupdefinitelyqualifies,whichisdoublyimpressivegiventhequalityoftheindividualelements.ThrowRowland’sAerisDACintotheequationandthingsreallystarttocook.Drivingthe625directlyfromtheDAC’soutputbringsadramaticimprovementindynamicrange,transparencyandtemporalintegrity,ascomparedtotheWadiaS7ialone.ThesparseopeningofMartinStephenson’s“LeftUsToBurn”(fromBoat To Bolivia[Kitchenware/Sony88697145962],withitsdeepbassintro,tomtomsandpercussion,takesonanewpurposeandpace,thetimingandweightofhandonskinmoreapparent,theblacknessofthebackgrounddeeperandmorevelvety.Theinstrumentsstepawayfromthespeakers,thevoices,leadandbacking,aremorefocused,morenaturalandeasiertoseparate.Suddenly,theperformanceiscrisper,tighterandjustplainbetter.

What’sthatgottodowiththespeakers?Afterall,it’stheDACthatwaschanged.Sure--butitwasthespeakersthatletyouhearthedifferencethattheDACmade,andjusthowbigthatdifferencewas.InthesamewaythattheC1.1sdon’tcompressdynamics,theydon’tcompresssystemdifferenceseither,allowingthemusicasmuchpresenceandauthority,intelligibilityandimpactastheequipmentcandeliver.Onething’sforsure:withtheRaidhosyou’llneverbeleftwondering.

IftheC1.1s’raison d’etreisuncompresseddynamicdelivery,theotherareainwhichtheytrulyexcelistemporalandspatialintegrity.Eachinstrumentorvoice

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

6

Page 7: Raidho C1.1 Loudspeakersraidho.dk/wp-content/uploads/RaidhoC11_audiobeat.pdfwith the original. Of course, having the C1s on hand allows direct comparison between the two, but let’s

7

ispreciselylocatedinspace(assumingthattheinformationisencodedintherecording),itscontributionstimedtoperfection(assumingthatthedrivingsystemiscapableofachievingthat).This“aplaceforeverythingandeverythinginitsplace”senseoforganizationiscrucialtotheincredibleintelligibilitythesespeakersbringtorecordedmusic.Theymakeitmucheasiertosortoutormakesenseofthemusicandthesystemasawhole--notjustwhat’shappening,butwhyaswell.Sowhenmusicianshitanotetogether,they really do,addingjusttherightweightoremphasistothemusic.Thesolidityoftuttis,whetherbrassorpercussion,givesarealisticallysuddenimpactandexplosivequalitythatescapesallbutthebestspeakers,whilethemusicians’placementinthemusicalschemeofthingsgivesthemusicjusttherightimpetus,whetherit’sagentleprodorafull-onorchestralclimax.

Takentogether,thesequalitiesofunclutteredclarity,dynamicrangeandresolution,spatialandtemporalintegrityandtheoverallsenseoforganizationandintelligibilitytheybringcreateaspeakerthat’scapableofsingularlyimpressivemusicalfeats.Theyalsocreateaspeakerthatsoundsdistinctive--anddistinctlydifferenttomostotherspeakers,withthatwidestanceandabsenceofaddedweighttopadoutthebottomend,muddleitandslowitdown.Thequestionpotentialownersneedtoaskiswhetherdifferentmeansbetter,andwhatthatmeansforthemusicthey’llplay.

Let’stakeNouvelleVague’sinspiredcoveroftheUltravoxclassic“FadeToGrey”fromBande A’Part[PerfectKissPFG079]asanexample.QuiteapartfromthewholenotionofreproducingthisNewRomanticmilestonewithsolofemale-voiceandaccordionaccompaniment,itpresentssystemswithamusicalchallengeofquiteanotherkind.Behindthesimpleinstrumentation,MarcCollincreatesacomplexsyntheticsoundscape,asparselypopulatedmetrostationthatthenitselftransmogrifies.

TheC1.1spresentthecoreelementswithalmostpristineclarity.Truetotype,thevoiceisalittlehollow,moremouththanchest,the

accordionlackingalittleharmonictexture,almostmakingitsoundsynthesizedratherthan

liketherealthing.Behindthem,thecollageofquick,hurriedstepsareclearlylocatedinspace,

eachindividualscurryingleftorrightandpreciselyangledacrossthesoundstage.Butwhatisalmostspookyistheimmediatelyidentifiableechooffootstepsintunnels,thesenseofthetubeextendingbeyondthem.Thehollownessinthevoicefitsrightin,alongwiththerushingwindoftrainsandalltheotherincidentalnoises.Whenthespokenvoiceoverstarts,mostsystemssimplysubmergeitinthegeneralwashofsound.TheC1.1spickitoutandseparateitwithalmoststartlingclarity,addinganotherlayertothecool,greyemptinessoftherecording.

Allofwhichisprettyimpressive;butit’swhathappensnextthatreallysetstheC1.1sapart.Thesoundscapeslowlychangestoatropicalbeach,metallicknocksandchimestosteeldrums,rushingtrainstowavesontheshore,theslightlythreateningisolationtoareassuringcalm.Asithappensthetonalpaletteshiftscompletely,fromcold,dull,monotonegreystowarm,bright,goldenyellows.It’sapieceofstudioartifice,apartytrick,butonethat’smusicallynolessimportantforallthat.Infact,it’sthisshiftinperspectivethatinformstheperformanceandaddssomuchmoretotheoriginal--andwithoutwhichitbecomeslittlemorethanacurio.I’veneverheardthatshiftsoclearly,orhearditpresentedsoeffectively,asIdidontheC1.1s.TheRaidhosdon’tjusttellyouwhat’shappened;youalsounderstandwhy.Thisabilitytograsptheessentialsenseofaperformanceis,inmyexperience,unprecedented.It’srootedintheclaritywithwhichthespeakerpresentstheelements

inthemusicandtherelationshipsbetweenthem,anditmakestheRaidhoC1.1amusicalcommunicatorparexcellence.

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

Page 8: Raidho C1.1 Loudspeakersraidho.dk/wp-content/uploads/RaidhoC11_audiobeat.pdfwith the original. Of course, having the C1s on hand allows direct comparison between the two, but let’s

8

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

heC1.1scannotcreateareplicaof theoriginalperformance--andintruth, theydon’teventry.Insteadtheyconcentrateonthesenseofthemusicratherthanthefact.It’satime-honoredapproachthatprobablydatesfromthedesignoftheLinnKann--butI’veneverhearditdonesowell.Itmightsacrificeapalpablesenseoftheenclosedacousticspace,thesheerharmonicbeautyandcomplexityofinstruments,butthat’slessofanissueifyoudon’tdependonacousticrecordingsforthemajorityofyourlistening,andmanydon’t.Butwhateveryoulistento,thepurposeandintentintheplayingwillrarelyhavebeenpresentedsoclearly--ordrivenhomequitesoeffectively.Itdoesn’tnecessarilymakeforacomfortablelisteningexperience,butthentoomuchhi-fispendsfartoomuchtimetryingtobemusicallypolite,evencuddly.WhenShostakovichwrotehis13thSymphony,namedforthepogromatBabiYar,doyouthinkhemeantittobeeasylistening?TheRaidhossucceedinencompassingthefullrangeofmusicalexpression,fromtheguiltypleasure

andalmostjauntylightnessofNouvelleVague’sversionoftheBuzzcocks’“EverFallenInLove”tothesomberpathosoftheLeningradSymphony.

Thisemotionalrangeisoneofthelastgreatfrontiersinhi-fi--andtheC1.1sbreaknewground.Atatimewhensystemsingeneralandloudspeakersinparticularseemtoplaythingseversafer,optingforflatfrequencyresponse,resolutionorsomeothertechnicalparameter,attheexpenseofmusicalexpressionandinvolvement,theC1.1sareawelcomebreathoffreshair.Thechallengetheyrepresentforlistenerscomesintheformofaquestion,“Doyouwanttoplayitsafeorareyoufeelingadventurous;doyouwantmusictoconfirmwhatyoualreadyknoworbecomeavoyageofdiscovery?”Thinkcarefully,becausethewronganswerwillgenerallyproveexpensive--evenifitmighthaveseemedlikethe“safe”solutionatthetime.

Ifit’sadventureyouwant(orneed),looknofurtherthantheC1.1s.Believeme,they’lltakeyouonquiteatrip!

Price:$15,000perpairinblackorwhitefinish,$17,000perpairinburlwalnutfinish.Raidhospeakerstandscost$3000perpair.

Warranty: Fiveyearspartsandlabor.

RaidhoAcousticsc/oDantaxRadioA/S,Bransagervej15,9490Pandrup,Denmark+4598247677

www.raidho.dk

Care and feedingTheC1swereremarkablytolerantofsystemandsetup,especiallyaftertheexperienceofthepreviousrange.Theyneededtobeplacedwellawayfromwalls,wellapartandslightlytoedin.Theyweren’tparticularlyhardtodrive,buttheyplacedaheavypremiumonthecoherenceofthesystemdoingthedrivingaswellasitsstateoftuning.Decentsupportsandacoherentcableloomwereprettymuchde rigueuriftheC1.1sweren’tgoingtotellyoualltooclearlyaboutdiscontinuitiesintheenergyspectrumofyoursystem.Beyondthat,adecentsourceandastraight-

lineapproachwereallthatwererequiredtoachieveexcellentresults.

TheC1.1sarealmostbutnotquiteaseasytofeed.System-wise,theyneedexactlythesamecareandattentionastheC-1s;startmixingandmatchingcablesandthey’lltellyoujusthowdumbanideathatis.Thegoodnewsisthateverytimeyouimprovethequalityoreffectivenessofyoursysteminfrastructure,whetherthat’sthesurfacessupportingyourelectronics,what’scouplingthemtogetheroranew,cleangroundforyourACsupply,theRaidhoswilltellyouallaboutitloudandclear.

Theyalsolikethesamewidestanceastheiroldersiblings,workingbestwhenplacedonespeaker’swidth(orabout15”)outsidethenormformylisteningroom.Theyalsoliketobetoedinfarmore,pointingdirectlyatthelistener,andarefarlessforgivingwhenitcomestofront-walldistance.I’mguessingthatit’sthedeeperbassfromthereviseddriver,butyoureallyneedtogettheirfront/backpositioningspoton.Inthisregard,thematchingstandsmakelifeeasy.Unchangedfromtheoriginals,theyoffercup-and-cone-typevibrationcontrolattopandbottom,alongwitha

T

Page 9: Raidho C1.1 Loudspeakersraidho.dk/wp-content/uploads/RaidhoC11_audiobeat.pdfwith the original. Of course, having the C1s on hand allows direct comparison between the two, but let’s

9

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

carefullyshapedandtunedlightweightconstructiontohelpdissipateunwantedenergy.Distinctlydifferent,theyarealsoextremelyeffective.I’vetriedtheRaidhospeakersonother,moreconventionalstandsandtheperformancesuffersmarkedly.Twoaspectsofthestands’designcontributetoeasingsetup:theirlightweightandthefactthattheconicalfeetonwhichtheystandhavebroad,roundednosesthatareeasytoshiftonjustaboutanysurface,sosmalladjustmentsinangleordistanceareeasilyachieved.

Whichbringsmetomyonerealbug-bearwiththeRaidhostand.Thosefeetarenotadjustable!Andtherearefourofthem!Foraspeakerthatisthisthoroughlyengineeredthisseemslikeamassiveoversight--andonethatisnowbeingrepeated.Notonlydoesitmeanyoucan’tgetthespeakerspreciselylevel,oneofthefeetwillalmostcertainlybeunloadedandlefttorattle.Comeonguys,getwiththeprogram;aretrofittablefootthatincorporatesthesamevibrationcontrolaswellaslevelingneedstobeapriority.Giventhefocusandprecisionwithwhichthesespeakerspresentsoundsources,Icanonlywonderwhatwouldhappenifyoucouldgetthemperfectlyplantedandverticaltoboot.What’sreallyfrustratingisthatthestandsaresoessentialtothespeakers’performance.Otherwiseyoucouldjustgowithadifferentoption.-Roy Gregory

Associated Equipment

Analog:VPIClassic3+turntablewithVPIJMW12”andTri-PlanarMkVIIUIItonearms;LyraTitan,Skala,DorianandDorianMonocartridges;ClearaudioGoldfingerStatementandvandenHulCondorcartridges;Connoisseur4.2andCoincidentSpeakerTechnologyStatementphonostages.

Digital:WadiaS7iCDplayer,dCSPaganinithree-boxdigitalfront-end,JeffRowlandAerisdigital-to-analogconverter.

Preamplifiers:Connoisseur4.2,VTLTL-7.5SeriesIIIandCoincidentSpeakerTechnologyStatementlinestages.Power amplifiers:JeffRowland625stereoamp,BerningQuadratureZ,VTLMB-450SignatureSeriesIII,JadisJA-30andJA-120,andCoincidentSpeakerTechnologyM300BFrankensteinMkIImonoblocks.

Integrated amplifier:IconAudioStereo60Signature.

Speakers:CoincidentSpeakerTechnologyPureReferenceExtreme,FocalChorus807VandStellaUtopiaEM,SonusFaberCremona,SpendorSA1andA6.

Cables:NordostOdinthroughoutthesystem,fromACsockettospeakerterminals.

PowerdistributionwasviaQuantumQRTQB8swithamixofQX2andQX4powerpurifiersandQV2ACharmonizers.

Supports:RacksarefiniteelementeHD-04MasterReferenceracksandampstandsalongwitha26”-wideStillpointsESS.Theseareusedwithequipmentcouplersthroughout,eitherStillpontsorNordostSortKones.CablesareelevatedonAyreMyrtlewoodblocks.

Accessories:FeickertprotractorandAestetixcartridgedemagnetizer,aprecisionspiritlevelandlaser,areallylongtapemeasure,andplentyofmaskingtape.AlsoextensiveuseoftheFurutechanti-staticanddemagnetizingdevicesandtheVPIHW27Typhoonrecord-cleaningmachine.