professional development programme coastal infrastructure … · nearshore breakwater structure...

57
The University of the West Indies Organization of American States PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME: COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE A COURSE IN COASTAL DEFENSE SYSTEMS I CHAPTER 11 STRUCTURAL DESIGN By DAVE BASCO, PhD Professor, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering And Director, the Coastal Engineering Centre, Old Dominion University Norfolk, VA Organized by Department of Civil Engineering, The University of the West Indies, in conjunction with Old Dominion University, Norfolk, VA, USA and Coastal Engineering Research Centre, US Army, Corps of Engineers, Vicksburg, MS, USA. St. Lucia, West Indies, July 18-21, 2001

Upload: trinhcong

Post on 03-May-2018

214 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

The University of the West Indies Organization of

American States

PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME:

COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE

A COURSE IN

COASTAL DEFENSE SYSTEMS I

CHAPTER 11

STRUCTURAL DESIGN

By DAVE BASCO, PhD Professor, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

And Director, the Coastal Engineering Centre, Old Dominion University

Norfolk, VA

Organized by Department of Civil Engineering, The University of the West Indies, in conjunction with Old Dominion University, Norfolk, VA, USA and Coastal Engineering Research Centre, US Army, Corps of Engineers, Vicksburg, MS, USA.

St. Lucia, West Indies, July 18-21, 2001

Page 2: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

STRUCTURAL DESIGN OFSTRUCTURAL DESIGN OF

David R. Basco, Ph.D, P.E.Director, The Coastal Engineering Center Old Dominion University,Norfolk, Virginia

USA 23529 [email protected]

Page 3: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

COURSE ORGANIZATIONCOURSE ORGANIZATION• Course 2.1: Design of Coastal Structures I

- Stability of loose-material structures (breakwaters and revetments)

- Case studies: Introduction, Example Problems VI-7

• Course 2.2: Design of Coastal Structures II- Design philosophy; probabilistic design methods- Role of damage in coastal structure design- Cross-sectional design (breakwaters/revetments)- Balanced design prinicples- Case study

• Course 4: Design of Marine Structures- Seawalls and bulkheads- Beaches- Example problems VI-7 Armor Layer Stability

Page 4: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Steven A. Hughes. Ph.D., P.E.Coastal and Hydraulics Laboratory

US Army Engineer Research and Development Center

David R. Basco. Ph.D., P.E.Coastal Engineering Center

Old Dominion University

Page 5: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Overview of Armor Layer StabilityRubble-Mound Trunk and Head StabilityRiprap and Toe StabilityCross-Section DesignExample Problems

CEM Chapter VI-5-3 (Author: Hans F. Burcharth)CEM Chapter VI-7 (Author: David R. Basco)

Based on:

Page 6: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Movement of armor units• Rocking• Displacement from layer• Sliding of layer• Settlement of layer

Not armor unit breakage

Page 7: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Parameter Stability Equation

Page 8: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Sea State Variables• Wave height• Wave length• Wave steepness• Wave angle• Wave Asymmetry• Spectrum shape• Water depth• Water density

Structure Variables• Armor layer slope• Freeboard• Armor density• Armor gradation• Armor weight• Armor shape• Packing density• Layer thickness• Porosity of layers

Page 9: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Page 10: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Page 11: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Classified by:• Type of armor unit• Water depth• Superstructure• Dynamic• Crest elevation

• Non-overtopped• Low-crested• Submerged

• Based on small-scale physical models• Testing of designs is recommended• Always test unusual designs

Model Testing

Page 12: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Page 13: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Overview of Armor Layer StabilityRubble-Mound Trunk and Head StabilityRiprap and Toe StabilityCross-Section DesignExample Problems

CEM Chapter VI-5-3 (Author: Hans F. Burcharth)CEM Chapter VI-7 (Author: David R. Basco)

Based on:

Page 14: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Design Guidance for These Situations

Page 15: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Hudson’s Equation

Page 16: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Page 17: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Page 18: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Page 19: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Page 20: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Page 21: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Page 22: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

where

Page 23: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Overview of Armor Layer StabilityRubble-Mound Trunk and Head StabilityRiprap and Toe StabilityCross-Section DesignExample Problems

CEM Chapter VI-5-3 (Author: Hans F. Burcharth)CEM Chapter VI-7 (Author: David R. Basco)

Based on:

Page 24: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Gradation Range:

with

Page 25: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Design guidance for:• Sloping trunk and head• Vertical trunk and head

Toe berms…• Support main armor layer• Prevent damage by scour

Page 26: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Page 27: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Overview of Armor Layer StabilityRubble-Mound Trunk and Head StabilityRiprap and Toe StabilityCross-Section DesignExample Problems

CEM Chapter VI-5-3 (Author: Hans F. Burcharth)CEM Chapter VI-7 (Author: David R. Basco)

Based on:

Page 28: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

One Side Exposed to Waves

Page 29: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Both Sides Exposed to Waves

Page 30: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Geometric Design Aspects• Crest elevation and width• Concrete cap• Armor layer thickness• Primary layer bottom elevation• Toe berm• Structure head• Lee-side armor• Underlayers• Bedding/filter layer• Scour protection

Preliminary Design Phases

1. Structure geometry2. Evaluate construction

technique3. Evaluate design materials

Page 31: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Crest width:

Armor layer thickness:

Riprap layer thickness:

(whichever is greatest)

Page 32: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Overview of Armor Layer StabilityRubble-Mound Trunk and Head StabilityRiprap and Toe StabilityCross-Section DesignExample Problems

CEM Chapter VI-5-3 (Author: Hans F. Burcharth)CEM Chapter VI-7 (Author: David R. Basco)

Based on:

Page 33: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

� Revetment StructureSame as runup and overtopping exmplThe CBBT Island Case Study

� Nearshore Breakwater StructureChesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MDCape Henry-Fort Story,VA

� Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Page 34: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC
Page 35: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

• Impermeable Revetment• Non-overtopping Waves• Armor Stone

Page 36: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Page 37: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC
Page 38: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC
Page 39: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

CBBT original design

Page 40: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

• October 31,1991 Northeaster• The Great “Halloween Storm” of 1991• The Perfect Storm (Junger,1997)• The Storm of the Century (movie)

Page 41: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC
Page 42: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC
Page 43: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

• The design wave height• The evolution of design waves• Impermeable revetments• Non-overtopping waves

Page 44: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

• Table VI-6-4 Hudson formula• Table VI-6-5 Van der Meer (plunging)• Table VI-6-6 Van der Meer (surging)

Page 45: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

• (a)Damage Curve Relations for VI-7-10• (b)Damage Curve Relations for VI-7-11

Page 46: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

Coastal Engineering Practice CommitteeCEM Preview

Page 47: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC
Page 48: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC
Page 49: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC
Page 50: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

• Nearshore breakwaters• Permeable• Submerged

Page 51: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC
Page 52: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC
Page 53: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC
Page 54: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC
Page 55: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC
Page 56: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

SUMMARY: ARMORSUMMARY: ARMOR--LAYER STABILITYLAYER STABILITY

1. Hudson (1974) SPM (1984)1. Hudson (1974) SPM (1984)•• Limited applicabilityLimited applicability

-- ONLY permeable structuresONLY permeable structures-- ONLY nonONLY non--overtopping wave conditionsovertopping wave conditions

•• Factors not consideredFactors not considered-- Wave period, Wave period, TTpp

-- Variable structure permeability, PVariable structure permeability, P-- Damage level, SDamage level, S-- Storm duration (number of waves), tStorm duration (number of waves), tdd

Page 57: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME COASTAL INFRASTRUCTURE … · Nearshore Breakwater Structure Chesapeake Bay –Bay Ridge,MD Cape Henry-Fort Story,VA Jetty Structure Oregon Inlet,NC

SUMMARY: ARMORSUMMARY: ARMOR--LAYER STABILITYLAYER STABILITY

2. CEM (2000)2. CEM (2000)•• No limitationsNo limitations

-- Includes wave overtopping and Includes wave overtopping and submerged submerged condtionscondtions

-- Includes Includes TTpp, P, S and t, P, S and tdd factorsfactors•• Methods easy for EXCELMethods easy for EXCEL•• Includes partial safety factors for designIncludes partial safety factors for design

Use CEM (2000) methods to estimate armorUse CEM (2000) methods to estimate armor--layer stability.layer stability.