packetvideo vs. spotify
TRANSCRIPT
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
� ��������� ���������������������
��������������������������������� �������!"#"!$%&��' �(!$)�*+,!��('�������-���.!"#/(!$)012$33"4,32"/'%(4����5"6"3��'��3#"!7(3 *+,!��('�������-���75"6"3,3#"!7(3012$33"4,32"/'%(4����8!$75(98"!��'��,58":7�*+,!��('�������-���%8!$74,58":7012$33"4,32"/'%(4�� �(258��$)2"!(,��5!""5 ���58 �/((!�(7 �3)"/"7 ��,/$.(!3$,������;�����"/"98(3"< *���- ���;�����,%7$4$/"< *���- ���;����
�55(!3"=7�.(!��/,$35$..���>����?� �� �� ���� �
�����?��������?��������� ���� �������?�������� ������� ����
���>����?� �� �� ���� � ,�?"/,:,!"%(!9(!,5$(3
�/,$35$..
6'
�� ���@��������' ,�?"/,:,!" %(!9(!,5$(3 �� ���@�������? ,��3$5"#�>$3)#(4%(!9(!,5$(3 �,3#��� ���@������ � �@����� ,��2A"4B(2!) %(!9(!,5$(3
?"."3#,357'
������ '� CCCCCCCCCCCCC
� ������� � ���������������������
?����?�� ��D��@������
�������
�/,$35$..� �,%&"5�$#"(� �(!9(!,5$(3 *E�,%&"5�$#"(E-� .(!� $57� %(49/,$35� ,),$375� ?"."3#,357
�9(5$.=� ���� �3%' *E�9(5$.= ���E-F� �9(5$.=� �$4$5"#� *E�9(5$.=� �>E- ,3#� �9(5$.=� �"%83(/()=�
����� *E�9(5$.=��2AE-�*,// %(//"%5$6"/=�E?"."3#,357E- 8"!"B=�#"4,3#7�,�G2!=�5!$,/�,3#�,//")"7�,7�
.(//(:7<
'11CV1659 WMcIEG
Case 3:11-cv-01659-IEG -WMC Document 1 Filed 07/27/11 Page 1 of 11
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
;�;� ��������� ���������������������
�� �������������������
�' �8$7��(2!5�8,7� G2!$7#$%5$(3�(6"!� 58"�72BG"%5�4,55"!�(. 58$7�,%5$(3�23#"!����'�'�'�
HH �����,3#����*,-'
�' �"32"�$7�"75,B/$78"#�$3�58$7�G2#$%$,/�#$75!$%5�92!72,35�5(����'�'�' HH ���*B- �*%- �
*#- ,3#� ����*B-'� � ?"."3#,357� 8,6"� %(44$55"#� ,%57� (.� $3.!$3)"4"35� $3� 58$7� G2#$%$,/� #$75!$%5F� ,3#�
?"."3#,357��9(5$.=��>�,3#��9(5$.=��2A ,!"�,/$"3�%(49,3$"7'
��� ����������������
�' �8$7� $7� ,� %$6$/� ,%5$(3� .(!� $3.!$3)"4"35�(.��3$5"#� �5,5"7��,5"35��(' � ��� ��� *58"�
E�,5"35;$3;�2$5E (!�EI�����,5"35E-' �8$7�,%5$(3�$7�B,7"#�29(3�58"��,5"35��,:7�(.�58"��3$5"#��5,5"7 �
����'�'�'�H���� "5�7"1'
�� ����
�' �/,$35$..� �,%&"5�$#"(� �(!9(!,5$(3� *E�,%&"5�$#"(E-� $7� ,� %(!9(!,5$(3� (!),3$J"#�
23#"!� 58"� /,:7�(.� 58"�75,5"�(.�?"/,:,!" 8,6$3)� $57�9!$3%$9,/�9/,%"�(.�B27$3"77�,5��������%$"3%"�
�"35"!�?!$6" ��,3�?$")( ��������'
�' 3�$3.(!4,5$(3�,3#�B"/$". �?"."3#,35��9(5$.=���� $7�$3%(!9(!,5"#�23#"!�58"�/,:7�
(.�58"�75,5"�(. ?"/,:,!" �8,6$3)�$57�9!$3%$9,/�9/,%"�(.�B27$3"77�,5����58��6"32" ��2$5"����� ���58�
�/((! � �":� @(!& � �@� �����'� � 3� $3.(!4,5$(3� ,3#� B"/$". � �9(5$.=� 9!(#2%57� ,%%27"#� (.�
$3.!$3)"4"35�$3�58$7��(49/,$35�,!"�,3#�8,6"�B""3�(.."!"#�.(!�7,/" �7(/# �,3#�$49(!5"#�B=��9(5$.=�
��� $3�58$7�,3#�(58"!�G2#$%$,/�#$75!$%57'
�' 3�$3.(!4,5$(3�,3#�B"/$". �?"."3#,35��9(5$.=��>�$7�$3%(!9(!,5"#�23#"!�58"�/,:7�(.�
58"��3$5"#�>$3)#(4 �8,6$3)� $57�9!$3%$9,/�9/,%"�(.�B27$3"77�,5��(/#"3��(27" �����!",5��2/5"3"=�
�5!""5 � �(3#(3� K��� �� � �3$5"#� >$3)#(4'� � 3� $3.(!4,5$(3� ,3#� B"/$". � �9(5$.=� �>�
4,32.,%52!"7 #$75!$B25"7 � ,3#� $49(!57 58"� 9!(#2%57� ,//")"#� 5(� $3.!$3)"� 8"!"$3 $3� 58$7� ,3#� (58"!�
G2#$%$,/�#$75!$%57'
�' 3�$3.(!4,5$(3�,3#�B"/$". �?"."3#,35��9(5$.=��2A $7�$3%(!9(!,5"#�23#"!�58"�/,:7�(.�
�2A"4B(2!) � 8,6$3)� $57� 9!$3%$9,/� 9/,%"� (.� B27$3"77� ,5� �6"32"� �,!$";�8"!"7"� �� � �����
�2A"4B(2!) ��2A"4B(2!)'�� 3�$3.(!4,5$(3�,3#�B"/$". �9(5$.=��2A 4,32.,%52!"7 �#$75!$B25"7 �,3#�
$49(!57 58"�9!(#2%57�,//")"#�5(�$3.!$3)"�8"!"$3 $3�58$7�,3#�(58"!�G2#$%$,/�#$75!$%57'
Case 3:11-cv-01659-IEG -WMC Document 1 Filed 07/27/11 Page 2 of 11
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
;�;� ��������� ���������������������
' �9(3� $3.(!4,5$(3� ,3#� B"/$". � ,5� ,//� !"/"6,35� 5$4"7� 4"35$(3"#� $3� 58$7� �(49/,$35 �
?"."3#,357 � ,3#� ",%8� (.� 58"4 � :"!"� 58"� ,)"357� (.� ",%8� (58"! � ,3#� $3� #($3)� 58"� 58$3)7� ,//")"#�
8"!"$3 �",%8�:,7�,%5$3)�:$58$3�58"�7%(9"�,3#�%(2!7"�(.�$57�,)"3%=�,3#�,258(!$5=�,3#�:,7�72BG"%5�5(�
,3#�23#"!�58"�729"!6$7$(3�(.�$57�%(;#"."3#,357�,7�%(;%(379$!,5(!7'
' 3� $3.(!4,5$(3� ,3#� B"/$". � ?"."3#,357� ,!"� 72BG"%5� 5(� 58$7� �(2!5I7� 9"!7(3,/�
G2!$7#$%5$(3�B"%,27"�58"=�8,6"�%(3#2%5"#�,3#�#(�%(3#2%5�B27$3"77�:$58$3�58$7�#$75!$%5'� ?"."3#,357 �
$3%/2#$3)� 58!(2)8� $35"!4"#$,!$"7 *$3%/2#$3) � #$75!$B25(!7 � !"5,$/"!7 � 9,!53"!7 � 72B7$#$,!$"7� ,3#�
(58"!7- �4,&" �4,32.,%52!" �78$9 �#$75!$B25" �(.."!� .(!�7,/" �7"// �,#6"!5$7" �,3#�27"� 58"$!�9!(#2%57�
,3#� 7"!6$%"7� $3� 58"� �3$5"#� �5,5"7 � $3%/2#$3)� 58$7� #$75!$%5 � 58!(2)8� :8$%8� 58"=� #"!$6" 72B75,35$,/�
!"6"32"'� � �"!7(3,/� G2!$7#$%5$(3� "A$757� 79"%$.$%,//=� (6"!� ?"."3#,357� B"%,27"� (.� 58"$!� $3.!$3)$3)�
%(3#2%5�:$58$3�,3#�#$!"%5"#�,5�%$5$J"37�$3�58$7�#$75!$%5 �$3%/2#$3)�B=�6$!52"�(.�,5�/",75�58"$!�:"B7$5"�
*:::'79(5$.='%(4-�58,5�,%5$6"/=�!",%8"7�(25�5(�%$5$J"37�$3�58"��(258"!3�?$75!$%5�(.��,/$.(!3$,�,3#�
(.."!7�?"."3#,357I� $3.!$3)$3)�9!(#2%57'� ��8"7"� $3.!$3)$3)�9!(#2%57�8,6"�B""3�,3#�%(35$32"� 5(�B"�
27"#�$3�58$7�#$75!$%5'��?"."3#,357�8,6"�%(44$55"#�9,5"35�$3.!$3)"4"35�:$58$3�58$7�#$75!$%5'��
����� ������������������ ��������������
��' �(23#"#� $3� � � �,%&"5�$#"(� $7� ,� �,3� ?$")(;B,7"#� %(49,3=� 58,5� 9!(#2%"7�
7(.5:,!"� 58,5�,//(:7� 58"�27"!� 5(�"3G(=�:$!"/"77�427$%�,3#�6$#"('� �,%&"5�$#"(�(.."!7�"6"!=58$3)�
.!(4� B!(:7$3)� .(! � !"%(44"3#,5$(3� (. � ,3#� #$7%(6"!=� (.� 427$%� ,3#� 6$#"( � 5(� 58"� 92!%8,7" �
9/,=B,%&� ,3#� 78,!$3)� (.� 427$%� ,3#� 6$#"('� �8"� %(49,3=I7� 7(.5:,!"� 7299(!57� ,//� 4,G(!� 4"#$,�
.(!4,57 B!(,#%,75�75,3#,!#7 �8(4"�3"5:(!&$3)�9!(5(%(/7 �(9"!,5$3)�7=75"47�,3#�8,3#7"57L4(B$/"�
98(3"7'� �,%&"5�$#"(I7 %275(4"!7� $3%/2#"� 4(B$/"� (9"!,5(!7� 72%8� ,7� �"!$J(3� K$!"/"77 � ����
?(�(�(� ,3#� !,3)" � 8,3#7"5� 4,32.,%52!"!7 � ,3#� %(3724"!� "/"%5!(3$%7� %(49,3$"7'�
�,%&"5�$#"(M7� 7(.5:,!"� $7�%2!!"35/=�"4B"##"#� $3�4(!"� 58,3���� 4$//$(3�#"6$%"7�:(!/#:$#"�,3#�
4(!"�58,3���� #$.."!"35�9!(#2%57'
��' �,%&"5�$#"(I7� 7(.5:,!"� 9!(#2%57� .(!4� 58"� .(23#,5$(3� .(!� ,2#$"3%";$35"!,%5$6"�
4"#$,� "A9"!$"3%"7� 58,5� )$6"� %(3724"!7� 58"� .!""#(4� 5(� "3G(=� 42/5$4"#$,� %(35"35� 8(:"6"! �
:8"3"6"!�,3#�:8"!"6"!�58"=�:,35'�
Case 3:11-cv-01659-IEG -WMC Document 1 Filed 07/27/11 Page 3 of 11
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
;�;� ��������� ���������������������
��' ?"."3#,357 (.."! ,� 427$%� 75!",4$3)� 7"!6$%"� %,//"# �9(5$.= � .(23#� ,5�
:::'79(5$.='%(4'� �8"� �9(5$.=� 7"!6$%"� 9!(6$#"7� 75!",4$3)� (.� 7"/"%5"#� 427$%� .!(4� ,� !,3)"� (.�
!"%(!#� /,B"/7� *����� �(3= �K,!3"! ��3$6"!7,/ ����-'� �8"��9(5$.=�7"!6$%"�"3,B/"7�27"!7� 5(�,%%"77�
427$%�,6,$/,B/"�58!(2)8�58"�7"!6$%"'���9"%$.$%,//= �58"��9(5$.=�7"!6"!7�"3,B/"�27"!7�5(�B!(:7"�B= �
.(!�"A,49/" �,!5$75 �,/B24 �!"%(!#�/,B"/ �)"3!"�(!�9/,=/$75'��8"�7"!6$%"�$7�9!"7"35/=�(3/=�,6,$/,B/"�$3�
58"��3$5"#��5,5"7 � ,3#� $3� %"!5,$3� %(235!$"7�(.��2!(9"'� �8"� 7=75"4� $7� %2!!"35/=� ,%%"77$B/"�27$3)�
#$.."!"35�%(4925"!�7(.5:,!"�(9"!,5$3)�7=75"47�,3#�4(B$/"�(9"!,5$3)�7=75"47'�
��' 3�D23"�� ��� �58"��3$5"#��5,5"7��,5"35�,3#��!,#"4,!&� ..$%"�*E���� E-�$772"#�
58"�I�����,5"35�5(��(/.�+!2))"!�.(!�8$7 $36"35$(3�"35$5/"#�E?"6$%"�.(!�58"�?$75!$B25$(3�(.��27$%�$3�
?$)$5,/��(!4'E �,%&"5�$#"( $7� 58"�"A%/27$6"�,3#�%2!!"35�(:3"!�(.�,//� !$)85 � 5$5/" �,3#�$35"!"75� $3�
,3#�5(�58"�I�����,5"35 �$3%/2#$3)�58"�!$)85�5(�B!$3)�58$7�72$5�.(!�$3G23%5$6"�!"/$".�,3#�#,4,)"7'��
������
��� ��������� � �����������������������
��' �,!,)!,987���58!(2)8 �� ,!"�$3%(!9(!,5"#�B=�!"."!"3%"�,7�$.�75,5"#�.2//=�8"!"$3'
��' �8"�I�����,5"35�$7�6,/$#�,3#�"3.(!%",B/"'�
��' �5� /",75� ,7� ",!/=� ,7��,=��� ����� �:8"3��,%&"5�$#"(�B!(2)85� 58"� I���� �,5"35� 5(�
?"."3#,357I�,55"35$(3 �?"."3#,357�8,6"�8,#�,%52,/�&3(:/"#)"�(.�B(58��,%&"5�$#"(I7�!$)857�$3�58"�
I�����,5"35�,3#�58"�#"5,$/7�(.�?"."3#,357I�$3.!$3)"4"35�(.�58"� I�����,5"35'� ��"6"!58"/"77 ��9(5$.=�
����8,7 (.."!"#�.(!�7,/" �7(/# �,3#�$49(!5"# 9!(#2%57�,3#L(!�7"!6$%"7�%(3.$)2!"#�5(�$3.!$3)"�58"�
I�����,5"35 �,3#�$375!2%5"#�,3#�"3%(2!,)"#�(58"!7�5(�27"�58"�I�����,5"35�$3�,3�$3.!$3)$3)�4,33"!'
��' K$58�&3(:/"#)"�(.�58"�I�����,5"35 �,3#�$35"35�5(�"3%(2!,)"�(58"!7�5(�9"!.(!4�,%57�
58,5� �9(5$.=� ���� &3":� $3.!$3)"#� 58"� I��� �,5"35 � �9(5$.=� ���� 8,7� $3.!$3)"#� ,3#� $7 %2!!"35/=�
$3.!$3)$3)� 58"� I�����,5"35�B=�4,&$3) �27$3) � 7"//$3) �(.."!$3)� .(!� 7,/" � ,3#L(!� $49(!5$3)� $35(� 58"�
�3$5"#��5,5"7 �:$58(25�,258(!$5= �9!(#2%57�(!�7"!6$%"7�58,5�,!"�%(6"!"#�B=�(3"�(!�4(!"�%/,$47�(.�
58"� I���� �,5"35 � $3%/2#$3)� %/,$4� � � $3%/2#$3)� B25� 3(5� /$4$5"#� 5(� ?"."3#,357I� $3.!$3)$3)� 427$%�
75!",4$3)�7=75"4�,3#�7"!6$%"7 �$3%/2#$3)�.(!�58"$!��9(5$.=�7=75"4�,3#�7"!6$%"'
Case 3:11-cv-01659-IEG -WMC Document 1 Filed 07/27/11 Page 4 of 11
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
;�;� ��������� ���������������������
�' K$58� &3(:/"#)"� (.� 58"� I���� �,5"35 � �9(5$.=� ���� 8,6" %(35!$B25"#� 5(� ,3#L(!�
$3#2%"# �,3#�:$//�%(35$32"� 5(�%(35!$B25"� 5(�,3#L(!� $3#2%"� 58"� $3.!$3)"4"35�(.� 58"� I�����,5"35�B=�
(58"!7�$3�58$7�?$75!$%5�,3#�"/7":8"!"�$3�58"��3$5"#��5,5"7 �B=�7"//$3) �(.."!$3)�.(!�7,/" �,#6"!5$7$3) �
/",7$3) �(.."!$3)� 5(� /",7" � $375!2%5$3)� ,3#L(!� $49(!5$3)� $35(� 58"��3$5"#��5,5"7 �:$58(25� ,258(!$5= �
:$58� 58"�#$!"%5� $3.!$3)"4"35�B"$3)�,%%(49/$78"#�B=�"3#�27"!7�(.�,5� /",75� 58"� .(!")($3)�9!(#2%57�
,3#L(!�7"!6$%"7'�
�' �9(5$.=� ���� $7� 3(5� /$%"37"#� (!� (58"!:$7"� ,258(!$J"#� B=� �,%&"5�$#"(� 5(� 9!,%5$%" �
%(35!$B25(!$/=�9!,%5$%"�,3#L(!�$3#2%"�58$!#�9,!5$"7�5(�9!,%5$%"�58"�%/,$47�(.�58"�I�����,5"35'�
��' +=� !",7(3� (.� �9(5$.=� ���I7� $3.!$3)$3)� ,%5$6$5$"7 � �,%&"5�$#"(� 8,7� 72.."!"# � ,3#�
:$//�%(35$32"�5(�72.."! �72B75,35$,/�#,4,)"7�$3�,3�,4(235�5(�B"�9!(6"3�,5�5!$,/ �B25�$3�3(�"6"35�/"77�
58,3�,�!",7(3,B/"�!(=,/5='
��' �9(5$.=����I7�%(35$32$3)�,%57�(.�$3.!$3)"4"35�,!"�$!!"9,!,B/=�8,!4$3)�,3#�%,27$3)�
#,4,)"�5(��,%&"5�$#"( �.(!�:8$%8��,%&"5�$#"(�8,7�3(�,#"12,5"�!"4"#=�,5�/,: �,3#�:$//�%(35$32"�
5(�72.."!�72%8� $!!"9,!,B/"� $3G2!=�23/"77�?"."3#,357I�%(35$32$3)�,%57�(.� $3.!$3)"4"35�,!"�"3G($3"#�
B=�58"��(2!5'���8"�8,!#78$97�58,5�:(2/#�B"�$49(7"#�B=�,3�$3G23%5$(3�,!"�/"77�58,3�58(7"�.,%"#�B=�
�,%&"5�$#"(�78(2/#�,3�$3G23%5$(3�3(5�$772"'���8"�92B/$%�$35"!"75�:(2/#�B"�7"!6"#�B=�$772,3%"�(.�,3�
$3G23%5$(3'
��' �9(5$.=����I7�$3.!$3)"4"35�(.�58"�I�����,5"35�8,7�B""3�,3#�%(35$32"7�5(�B"�:$//.2/�
,3#�#"/$B"!,5" �G275$.=$3)�,�5!"B/$3)�(.�#,4,)"7�23#"!�����'�'�'�H���'��
��' �9(5$.=� ���I7� $3.!$3)"4"35� (.� 58"� I���� �,5"35� $7� "A%"95$(3,/� ,3#� "35$5/"7�
�,%&"5�$#"(�5(�,55(!3"=7I�.""7�,3#�%(757�$3%2!!"#�$3�9!(7"%25$3)�58$7�,%5$(3�23#"!�����'�'�'�H���'
������
��� ��������� � �� �������������������
��' �,!,)!,987���58!(2)8��� ,!"�$3%(!9(!,5"#�B=�!"."!"3%"�,7�$.�75,5"#�.2//=�8"!"$3'
��' �8"�I�����,5"35�$7�6,/$#�,3#�"3.(!%",B/"'�
��' �5� /",75� ,7� ",!/=� ,7��,=��� ����� �:8"3��,%&"5�$#"(�B!(2)85� 58"� I���� �,5"35� 5(�
?"."3#,357I�,55"35$(3 �?"."3#,357�8,6"�8,#�,%52,/�&3(:/"#)"�(.�B(58��,%&"5�$#"(I7�!$)857�$3�58"�
I�����,5"35�,3#�58"�#"5,$/7�(.�?"."3#,357I�$3.!$3)"4"35�(.�58"� I�����,5"35'� ��"6"!58"/"77 ��9(5$.=�
Case 3:11-cv-01659-IEG -WMC Document 1 Filed 07/27/11 Page 5 of 11
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
;�;� ��������� ���������������������
�>�8,7�#$75!$B25"#�,3#�$49(!5"#�9!(#2%57�,3#L(!�7"!6$%"7�%(3.$)2!"#�5(�$3.!$3)"�58"� I�����,5"35 �
,3#�$375!2%5"#�,3#�"3%(2!,)"#�(58"!7�5(�27"�58"�I�����,5"35�$3�,3�$3.!$3)$3)�4,33"!'
��' K$58�&3(:/"#)"�(.�58"�I�����,5"35 �,3#�$35"35�5(�"3%(2!,)"�(58"!7�5(�9"!.(!4�,%57�
58,5� �9(5$.=� �>� &3":� $3.!$3)"#� 58"� I��� �,5"35 � �9(5$.=� �>� 8,7� $3.!$3)"#� ,3#� $7� %2!!"35/=�
$3.!$3)$3)� 58"� I�����,5"35�B=�4,&$3) �27$3) � 7"//$3) �(.."!$3)� .(!� 7,/" � ,3#L(!� $49(!5$3)� $35(� 58"�
�3$5"#��5,5"7 �:$58(25�,258(!$5= �9!(#2%57�(!�7"!6$%"7�58,5�,!"�%(6"!"#�B=�(3"�(!�4(!"�%/,$47�(.�
58"� I���� �,5"35 � $3%/2#$3)� %/,$4� � � $3%/2#$3)� B25� 3(5� /$4$5"#� 5(� ?"."3#,357I� $3.!$3)$3)� 427$%�
75!",4$3)�7=75"4�,3#�7"!6$%"7 �$3%/2#$3)�58"$!��9(5$.=�7=75"4�,3#�7"!6$%"'
�' K$58�&3(:/"#)"�(.�58"�I�����,5"35 ��9(5$.=��>�8,6"�%(35!$B25"#�5(�,3#L(!�$3#2%"# �
,3#�:$//�%(35$32"�5(�%(35!$B25"�5(�,3#L(!� $3#2%"� 58"�$3.!$3)"4"35�(.� 58"� I�����,5"35�B=�(58"!7� $3�
58$7�?$75!$%5�,3#�"/7":8"!"�$3�58"��3$5"#��5,5"7 �B=�7"//$3) �(.."!$3)�.(!�7,/" �,#6"!5$7$3) �/",7$3) �
(.."!$3)� 5(� /",7" � $375!2%5$3)�,3#L(!� $49(!5$3)� $35(� 58"��3$5"#��5,5"7 �:$58(25�,258(!$5= �:$58� 58"
#$!"%5� $3.!$3)"4"35� B"$3)� ,%%(49/$78"#� B=� "3#� 27"!7� (.� ,5� /",75� 58"� .(!")($3)� 9!(#2%57� ,3#L(!�
7"!6$%"7'�
�' �9(5$.=� �>� $7� 3(5� /$%"37"#� (!� (58"!:$7"� ,258(!$J"#� B=� �,%&"5�$#"(� 5(� 9!,%5$%" �
%(35!$B25(!$/=�9!,%5$%"�,3#L(!�$3#2%"�58$!#�9,!5$"7�5(�9!,%5$%"�58"�%/,$47�(.�58"�I�����,5"35'�
��' +=�!",7(3�(.��9(5$.=��>I7�$3.!$3)$3)�,%5$6$5$"7 ��,%&"5�$#"(�8,7�72.."!"# �,3#�:$//�
%(35$32"�5(�72.."! �72B75,35$,/�#,4,)"7�$3�,3�,4(235�5(�B"�9!(6"3�,5�5!$,/ �B25�$3�3(�"6"35�/"77�58,3�
,�!",7(3,B/"�!(=,/5='
��' �9(5$.=��>I7�%(35$32$3) ,%57�(.� $3.!$3)"4"35�,!"�$!!"9,!,B/=�8,!4$3)�,3#�%,27$3)�
#,4,)"�5(��,%&"5�$#"( �.(!�:8$%8��,%&"5�$#"(�8,7�3(�,#"12,5"�!"4"#=�,5�/,: �,3#�:$//�%(35$32"�
5(�72.."!�72%8� $!!"9,!,B/"� $3G2!=�23/"77�?"."3#,357I�%(35$32$3)�,%57�(.� $3.!$3)"4"35�,!"�"3G($3"#�
B=�58" �(2!5'���8"�8,!#78$97�58,5�:(2/#�B"�$49(7"#�B=�,3�$3G23%5$(3�,!"�/"77�58,3�58(7"�.,%"#�B=�
�,%&"5�$#"(�78(2/#�,3�$3G23%5$(3�3(5�$772"'���8"�92B/$%�$35"!"75�:(2/#�B"�7"!6"#�B=�$772,3%"�(.�,3�
$3G23%5$(3'
��' �9(5$.=��>I7� $3.!$3)"4"35�(.� 58"� I�����,5"35�8,7�B""3�,3#�%(35$32"7�5(�B"�:$//.2/�
,3#�#"/$B"!,5" �G275$.=$3)�,�5!"B/$3)�(.�#,4,)"7�23#"!�����'�'�'�H���'��
Case 3:11-cv-01659-IEG -WMC Document 1 Filed 07/27/11 Page 6 of 11
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
;�;� ��������� ���������������������
��' �9(5$.=� �>I7� $3.!$3)"4"35� (.� 58"� I���� �,5"35� $7� "A%"95$(3,/� ,3#� "35$5/"7�
�,%&"5�$#"(�5(�,55(!3"=7I�.""7�,3#�%(757�$3%2!!"#�$3�9!(7"%25$3)�58$7�,%5$(3�23#"!�����'�'�'�H���'
������
��� ��������� � ���������� ������������
��' �,!,)!,987���58!(2)8��� ,!"�$3%(!9(!,5"#�B=�!"."!"3%"�,7�$.�75,5"#�.2//=�8"!"$3'
��' �8"�I�����,5"35�$7�6,/$#�,3#�"3.(!%",B/"'�
��' �5� /",75� ,7� ",!/=� ,7��,=��� ����� �:8"3��,%&"5�$#"(�B!(2)85� 58"� I���� �,5"35� 5(�
?"."3#,357I�,55"35$(3 �?"."3#,357�8,6"�8,#�,%52,/�&3(:/"#)"�(.�B(58��,%&"5�$#"(I7�!$)857�$3�58"�
I�����,5"35�,3#�58"�#"5,$/7�(.�?"."3#,357I�$3.!$3)"4"35�(.�58"� I�����,5"35'� ��"6"!58"/"77 ��9(5$.=�
�2A 8,7�#$75!$B25"#�,3#�$49(!5"#�9!(#2%57�,3#L(!�7"!6$%"7�%(3.$)2!"#�5(�$3.!$3)"�58"� I�����,5"35 �
,3#�$375!2%5"#�,3#�"3%(2!,)"#�(58"!7�5(�27"�58"�I�����,5"35�$3�,3�$3.!$3)$3)�4,33"!'
��' K$58�&3(:/"#)"�(.�58"�I�����,5"35 �,3#�$35"35�5(�"3%(2!,)"�(58"!7�5(�9"!.(!4�,%57�
58,5� �9(5$.=� �2A &3":� $3.!$3)"#� 58"� I��� �,5"35 � �9(5$.=� �2A 8,7� $3.!$3)"#� ,3#� $7� %2!!"35/=�
$3.!$3)$3)� 58"� I�����,5"35�B=�4,&$3) �27$3) � 7"//$3) �(.."!$3)� .(!� 7,/" � ,3#L(!� $49(!5$3)� $35(� 58"�
�3$5"#��5,5"7 �:$58(25�,258(!$5= �9!(#2%57�(!�7"!6$%"7�58,5�,!"�%(6"!"#�B=�(3"�(!�4(!"�%/,$47�(.�
58"� I���� �,5"35 � $3%/2#$3)� %/,$4� � � $3%/2#$3)� B25� 3(5� /$4$5"#� 5(� ?"."3#,357I� $3.!$3)$3)� 427$%�
75!",4$3)�7=75"4�,3#�7"!6$%"7 �$3%/2#$3)�58"$!��9(5$.=�7=75"4�,3#�7"!6$%"'
�' K$58� &3(:/"#)"� (.� 58"� I���� �,5"35 � �9(5$.=� �2A 8,6"� %(35!$B25"#� 5(� ,3#L(!�
$3#2%"# �,3#�:$//�%(35$32"� 5(�%(35!$B25"� 5(�,3#L(!� $3#2%"� 58"� $3.!$3)"4"35�(.� 58"� I�����,5"35�B=�
(58"!7�$3�58$7�?$75!$%5�,3#�"/7":8"!"�$3�58"��3$5"#��5,5"7 �B=�7"//$3) �(.."!$3)�.(!�7,/" �,#6"!5$7$3) �
/",7$3) �(.."!$3)� 5(� /",7" � $375!2%5$3)� ,3#L(!� $49(!5$3)� $35(� 58"��3$5"#��5,5"7 �:$58(25� ,258(!$5= �
:$58� 58"�#$!"%5� $3.!$3)"4"35�B"$3)�,%%(49/$78"#�B=�"3#�27"!7�(.�,5� /",75� 58"� .(!")($3)�9!(#2%57�
,3#L(!�7"!6$%"7'�
�' �9(5$.=� �2A $7� 3(5� /$%"37"#� (!� (58"!:$7"� ,258(!$J"#� B=� �,%&"5�$#"(� 5(� 9!,%5$%" �
%(35!$B25(!$/=�9!,%5$%"�,3#L(!�$3#2%"�58$!#�9,!5$"7�5(�9!,%5$%"�58"�%/,$47�(.�58"�I�����,5"35'�
��' +=�!",7(3�(.��9(5$.=��2AI7�$3.!$3)$3)�,%5$6$5$"7 ��,%&"5�$#"(�8,7�72.."!"# �,3#�:$//�
%(35$32"�5(�72.."! �72B75,35$,/�#,4,)"7�$3�,3�,4(235�5(�B"�9!(6"3�,5�5!$,/ �B25�$3�3(�"6"35�/"77�58,3�
,�!",7(3,B/"�!(=,/5='
Case 3:11-cv-01659-IEG -WMC Document 1 Filed 07/27/11 Page 7 of 11
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
;;� ��������� ���������������������
��' �9(5$.=��2AI7�%(35$32$3)�,%57�(.�$3.!$3)"4"35�,!"�$!!"9,!,B/=�8,!4$3)�,3#�%,27$3)�
#,4,)"�5(��,%&"5�$#"( �.(!�:8$%8��,%&"5�$#"(�8,7�3(�,#"12,5"�!"4"#=�,5�/,: �,3#�:$//�%(35$32"�
5(�72.."!�72%8� $!!"9,!,B/"� $3G2!=�23/"77�?"."3#,357I�%(35$32$3) ,%57�(.� $3.!$3)"4"35�,!"�"3G($3"#�
B=�58"��(2!5'���8"�8,!#78$97�58,5�:(2/#�B"�$49(7"#�B=�,3�$3G23%5$(3�,!"�/"77�58,3�58(7"�.,%"#�B=�
�,%&"5�$#"(�78(2/#�,3�$3G23%5$(3�3(5�$772"'���8"�92B/$%�$35"!"75�:(2/#�B"�7"!6"#�B=�$772,3%"�(.�,3�
$3G23%5$(3'
��' �9(5$.=��2AI7 $3.!$3)"4"35�(.�58"� I�����,5"35�8,7�B""3�,3#�%(35$32"7�5(�B"�:$//.2/�
,3#�#"/$B"!,5" �G275$.=$3)�,�5!"B/$3)�(.�#,4,)"7�23#"!�����'�'�'�H���'��
��' �9(5$.=� �2AI7� $3.!$3)"4"35� (.� 58"� I���� �,5"35� $7� "A%"95$(3,/� ,3#� "35$5/"7�
�,%&"5�$#"(�5(�,55(!3"=7I�.""7�,3#�%(757�$3%2!!"#�$3�9!(7"%25$3)�58$7�,%5$(3�23#"!�����'�'�'�H���'
��� !��"����!�!"
K����� �� ��,%&"5�$#"(�!"79"%5.2//=�!"12"757�58"�.(//(:$3)�!"/$".<
�' �� G2#)4"35� 8(/#$3)� 58"� ?"."3#,357� /$,B/"� .(!� $3.!$3)"4"35� (.� 58"� �,5"35;$3;�2$5�
,77"!5"#�,),$375�58"4F
+' �� 9"!4,3"35� $3G23%5$(3� 92!72,35� 5(� ��� �'�'�'� H� ��� ,),$375� ?"."3#,357 � 58"$!�
(..$%"!7 �,)"357 �"49/(=""7 �,55(!3"=7 �9,!"35�,3#�72B7$#$,!=�%(!9(!,5$(37 �,77$)37�,3#�72%%"77(!7�
$3� $35"!"75 � ,3#� ,//� (58"!7� ,%5$3)� $3� %(3%"!5� (!� 9,!5$%$9,5$(3� :$58� 58"4 � "3G($3$3)� 58"4� .!(4�
%(35$32"#� ,%57� (.� $3.!$3)"4"35� (.� 58"� �,5"35;$3;�2$5� ,77"!5"#� ,),$375� 58"4 � 5(� 58"� "A5"35� 58(7"�
9,5"357�8,6"�3(5�="5�"A9$!"#F�
�' �3� ,%%(235$3)� (.� #,4,)"7� !"72/5$3)� .!(4� 58"� ?"."3#,357I $3.!$3)"4"35� (.� 58"�
�,5"35;$3;�2$5�,77"!5"#�,),$375�58"4 �5()"58"!�:$58�9!";G2#)4"35�,3#�9(75;G2#)4"35�$35"!"75F
?' ��G2#)4"35�8(/#$3)�58,5�58"�?"."3#,357I $3.!$3)"4"35�$7�:$//.2/ �,3#�,�5!"B/$3)�(.�
#,4,)"7�92!72,35�5(�����'�'�'�H���F
Case 3:11-cv-01659-IEG -WMC Document 1 Filed 07/27/11 Page 8 of 11
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
;;� ��������� ���������������������
�' ��G2#)4"35�8(/#$3)�58$7��%5$(3�5(�B"�,3�"A%"95$(3,/�%,7" �,3#�,3�,:,!#�5(��/,$35$..
�,%&"5�$#"(�.(!�$57�,55(!3"=7I .""7�,3#�%(757�92!72,35�5(��� �'�'�'�H���F ,3#
�' �2%8�(58"!�,3#�.2!58"!�!"/$".�,7�58$7��(2!5�#""47�G275�,3#�9!(9"!'
?���?<��D2/=��� ����� �"79"%5.2//=�72B4$55"# �
�������������������������������� ���
+=< ������������������� ���8!$7��,58":7�55(!3"=7�.(!��/,$35$..���>����?� �� �� ���� �
Case 3:11-cv-01659-IEG -WMC Document 1 Filed 07/27/11 Page 9 of 11
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
;��;� ��������� ���������������������
D��@�������?����?�?
�,%&"5�$#"(��(!9(!,5$(3�#"4,3#7�,�5!$,/�B=�G2!=�(3�,//�$772"7�5!$,B/"�(.�!$)85�B=�,�G2!='
?���?<��D2/=��� ����� ����������������������� ��������� ���
+=< ������������������ ���8!$7��,58":7�55(!3"=7�.(!��/,$35$..���>����?� �� �� ���� �
Case 3:11-cv-01659-IEG -WMC Document 1 Filed 07/27/11 Page 10 of 11
Federal Question
JS 44 (Rev. 12/07) CIVIL COVER SHEETThe JS 44 civil cover sheet and the information contained herein neither replace nor supplement the filing and service of pleadings or other papers as required by law, except asprovided by local rules of court. This form, approved by the Judicial Conference of the United States in September 1974, is required for the use of the Clerk of Court for thepurpose of initiating the civil docket sheet.
I. (a) PLAINTIFFS
(b) County of Residence of First Listed Plaintiff(EXCEPT IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASES)
DEFENDANTS
County of Residence of First Listed Defendant(IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASES ONLY)
NOTE: IN LAND CONDEMNATION CASES, USE THE LOCATION OF THELAND INVOLVED.
(c) Attorney’s (Firm Name, Address, and Telephone Number) Attorneys (If Known)
II. BASIS OF JURISDICTION
1Plaintiff
2Defendant
3(U.S. Government Not a Party)
4(Indicate Citizenship of Parties in Item III)
III. CITIZENSHIP OF PRINCIPAL PARTIES(For Diversity Cases Only)
(Place an “X” in One Box for Plaintiffand One Box for Defendant)
PTF DEF PTF DEF
Citizen of This State 1 1
Citizen of Another State 2 2
Citizen or Subject of aForeign Country
3 3
Incorporated or Principal Place 4 4of Business In This State
Incorporated and Principal Placeof Business In Another State
5 5
Foreign Nation 6 6
VII. CHECK IF THIS IS A CLASS ACTIONUNDER F.R.C.P. 23
DEMAND $ CHECK YES only if demanded in complaint:JURY DEMAND: Yes No
VI.
Cite the U.S. Civil Statute under which you are filing (Do not cite jurisdictional statutes unless diversity):
CONTRACT TORTS
110 Insurance120 Marine130 Miller Act140 Negotiable Instrument150 Recovery of Overpayment
& Enforcement of Judgment151 Medicare Act152 Recovery of Defaulted
Student Loans
153 Recovery of Overpaymentof Veteran's Benefits
160 Stockholders' Suits190 Other Contract195 Contract Product Liability
REAL PROPERTY
210 Land Condemnation
220 Foreclosure
230 Rent Lease & Ejectment
240 Torts to Land
245 Tort Product Liability
290 All Other Real Property
PERSONAL INJURY310 Airplane315 Airplane Product
Liability320 Assault, Libel &
330 Federal Employers'Liability
340 Marine
345 Marine ProductLiability
350 Motor Vehicle355 Motor Vehicle
Product Liability360 Other Personal
CIVIL RIGHTS441 Voting442 Employment443 Housing/
444 Welfare
440 Other Civil Rights
PRISONER PETITIONS
510Motion to VacateSentence
Habeas Corpus:530General535Death Penalty540Mandamus & other
550Civil Rights
PERSONAL INJURY
362 Personal Injury -Med. Malpractice
365 Personal Injury -Product Liability
368 Asbestos PersonalInjury Product
PERSONAL PROPERTY370 Other Fraud
371 Truth in Lending
380 Other PersonalProperty Damage
385 Property Damage
Product Liability
FORFEITURE/PENALTY
610 Agriculture620 Other Food & Drug625 Drug Related Seizure
of Property 2 1 USC 88 1630 Liquor Laws640 R.R. & Truck650 Airline Regs.660 Occupational
Safety/Health690 Other
LABOR
710 Fair Labor StandardsAct
720 Labor/Mgmt. Relations730 Labor/Mgmt. Reporting
& Disclosure Act740 Railway Labor Act790 Other Labor Litigation791 Empl. Ret. Inc.
Security Act
BANKRUPTCY
422 Appeal 28 USC 158
423 Withdrawal
PROPERTY RIGHTS
820 Copyrights
830 Patent
840 Trademark
SOCIAL SECURITY
861 HIA (1395ff)
862 Black Lung (923)
863 DIWC/DIWW
864 SSID Title XVI
865 RSI (405(g))
FEDERAL TAX SUITS
870 Taxes (U.S. Plaintiffor Defendant)
871 IRS - Third Party26 USC 7609
OTHER STATUTES
400 State Reapportionment410 Antitrust430 Banks and Banking
Commerce460 Deportation470 Racketeer Influencedand Corrupt Organizations
810 Selective Service850 Securities/Commodities/
Exchange875 Customer Challenge
12 USC 3410
891 Agricultural Acts892 Economic Stabilization
Act893 Environmental Matters894 Energy Allocation Act895 Freedom of Information
Act900 Appeal of Fee
Determination UnderEqual Access to Justice
950 Constitutionality ofState Statutes
890 Other Statutory Actions
VIII.
555Prison Condition
(Place an “X” in One Box Only)
CAUSE OF ACTION
REQUESTED IN
RELATED CASE(S)
28 USC 157 450
COMPLAINT:
DATE SIGNATURE OF ATTORNEY OF RECORD
Slander
(See instructions):
CSDJS44
Franchise196
Amer. w/Disabilities -
Amer. w/Disabilities -
Consumer CreditCable/Sat TV
445
446
480490
NATURE OF SUITIV. (Place an “X” in One Box Only)
V.OriginalProceeding
Removed fromState Court
Remanded fromAppellate Court
Reinstated orReopened another district
Transferred from
(specify)
MultidistrictLitigation
Judge fromMagistrateJudgment
ORIGIN (Place an “X” in One Box Only)1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Brief description of cause:
JUDGE DOCKET NUMBER
FOR OFFICE USE ONLYRECEIPT # AMOUNT APPLYING IFP JUDGE MAG. JUDGE
Accommodations
Employment
Other
Injury
Liability
IMMIGRATIONNaturalization Application
Habcas Corpus -Alien Detainee
462
463
465 Other ImmigrationActions
Appeal to District
IF ANY
PACKETVIDEO CORPORATION, a Delaware corporation
San Diego
Christopher A. Mathews (SBN 144021)Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP865 South Figueroa Street, 10th FloorLos Angeles, CA 90017(213) 443-3000
SPOTIFY USA INC., a Delaware corporation, SPOTIFY LIMITED, a United Kingdom corporation, and SPOTIFY TECHNOLOGY SARL, a Luxembourg corporation,
NY/San Diego
x
x
x
35 USC 1 et seq.
Patent infringement.
x
July 27, 2011 /s/ Christopher A. Mathews
(SEE INSTRUCTIONS ON THE REVERSE OF THE FORM.)
U.S. Government
U.S. Government Diversity
(Excl. Veterans)
(405(g))
'11CV1659 WMcIEG
Case 3:11-cv-01659-IEG -WMC Document 1 Filed 07/27/11 Page 11 of 11