outlines of a world coming into existence-pervasive computing and the ethics of forgetting-martin...

16
1 Introduction `` In the course of human (and non human) history, it is rare enough for a significant new regime of recording the past to develop.'' Bowker (2003, page 28) Bowker points to the invention of writing and the printing press as the only two new regimes of recording the past in the last millennium; we posit here that pervasive computing and the concept of life-logs are set to become the third. Pervasive comput- ing, as defined by Galloway (2004, pages 384 ^ 385), ``seeks to embed computers into our everyday lives in such ways as to render them invisible and allow them to be taken for granted.'' Pervasive computing aims to augment all aspects of life and activities by seeking to add value through the addition of computing power to everyday objects, rendering them `smart' to some degree, yet also mundane and routine. A life-log is conceived as a form of pervasive computing consisting of a unified digital record of the totality of an individual's experiences, captured multimodally through digital sensors and stored permanently as a personal multimedia archive. The aim of life-log devel- opers is that they will provide a record of the past that includes every action, every event, every conversation, every material expression of an individual's life; all events will be accessible at a future date because a life-log will be a searchable and recallable archive (see van Dijck, 2005). Such life-logs will constitute new, pervasive, sociospatial archives, because inherent in their construction will be a locational record; it will detail everywhere an individual has been. Such a conception is fuelled by several factors: firstly, the rollout and adoption of technologies that systematically measure many aspects of social and economic life (eg electronic payment, utility usage, material and information traffic flows, surveil- lance); secondly, the recognition that digital storage capacity is growing exponentially at the same time, that cost and physical size are falling, and that digital sensors are becoming smaller and more autonomous; and lastly, the fact that there are a number `Outlines of a world coming into existence': pervasive computing and the ethics of forgetting Martin Dodge Geography, School of Environment and Development, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9PL, England; e-mail: [email protected] Rob Kitchin NIRSA and the Department of Geography, National University of Ireland, Maynooth, County Kildare, Ireland; e-mail: [email protected] Received 18 February 2005; in revised form 26 July 2006; published online 9 March 2007 Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 2007, volume 34, pages 431 ^ 445 Abstract. In this paper we examine the potential of pervasive computing to create widespread sousveillance, which will complement surveillance, through the development of life-logs ösociospatial archives that document every action, every event, every conversation, and every material expression of an individual's life. Reflecting on emerging technologies, life-log projects, and artistic critiques of sousveillance, we explore the potential social, political, and ethical implications of machines that never forget. We suggest, given that life-logs have the potential to convert exterior generated oligopti- cons to an interior panopticon, that an ethics of forgetting needs to be developed and built into the development of life-logging technologies. Rather than seeing forgetting as a weakness or a fallibility, we argue that it is an emancipatory process that will free pervasive computing from burdensome and pernicious disciplinary effects. DOI:10.1068/b32041t

Upload: dieg0u

Post on 06-Feb-2016

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Outlines of a world coming into existence

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

! "#$%&'()$*&#!!!" #$% &'()*% '+ $(,-" .-"/ "'" $(,-"0 $1*#')23 1# 1* )-)% %"'(4$ +') - *14"1+1&-"#"%5 )%41,% '+ )%&')/1"4 #$% 6-*# #' /%7%8'69:: ;'5<%) .=>>?3 6-4% =@0

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

O(&$ - &'"&%6#1'" 1* +(%88%/ C2 *%7%)-8 +-&#')*P +1)*#823 #$% )'88'(# -"/ -/'6#1'" '+#%&$"'8'41%* #$-# *2*#%,-#1&-882 ,%-*()% ,-"2 -*6%&#* '+ *'&1-8 -"/ %&'"',1& 81+%.%4 %8%&#)'"1& 6-2,%"#3 (#181#2 (*-4%3 ,-#%)1-8 -"/ 1"+'),-#1'" #)-++1& +8'5*3 *()7%18B8-"&%0A *%&'"/823 #$% )%&'4"1#1'" #$-# /141#-8 *#')-4% &-6-&1#2 1* 4)'51"4 %L6'"%"#1-882-# #$% *-,% #1,%3 #$-# &'*# -"/ 6$2*1&-8 *1Q% -)% +-881"43 -"/ #$-# /141#-8 *%"*')* -)%C%&',1"4 *,-88%) -"/ ,')% -(#'"','(*A -"/ 8-*#823 #$% +-&# #$-# #$%)% -)% - "(,C%)

!"#$%&'() *+ , -*.%/ 0*1&'2 &'$* (3&)$('0(45 6(.7,)&7(0*16#$&'2 ,'/ $8( ($8&0) *+ +*.2($$&'2

9,.$&' :*/2(E%'4)-6$23 O&$''8 '+ R"71)'",%"# -"/ N%7%8'6,%"#3 S"17%)*1#2 '+ T-"&$%*#%)3 UL+')/ V'-/3T-"&$%*#%) TW? XDY3 R"48-"/A %B,-18P ,9/'/4%Z,-"&$%*#%)9-&9(<;*< =&$08&'[!VOK -"/ #$% N%6-)#,%"# '+ E%'4)-6$23 [-#1'"-8 S"17%)*1#2 '+ !)%8-"/3 T-2"''#$3 \'("#2]18/-)%3 !)%8-"/A %B,-18P )'C9<1#&$1"Z"(1,91%V%&%17%/ W@ ^%C)(-)2 =>>HA 1" )%71*%/ +'), =_ `(82 =>>_A 6(C81*$%/ '"81"% X T-)&$ =>>a

'()%*"(+,(! #(- .$#((%(/ 01 .$#((%(/ #(- 2,3%/( =>>a3 7'8(,% ?F3 6-4%* F?W G FFH

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

!"#$%&'%&()*+,-&.%/

Page 2: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

'+ &'"#%,6')-)2 %L6%)1,%"#* #$-# *%%< #' 1"#%4)-#% &-6#()%/ /-#- 51#$1" 6)'#'#26%81+%B8'441"4 *2*#%,*3 5$1&$ -)% +1)1"4 /%7%8'6%)*: 1,-41"-#1'"* .%4 `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`%"*%"3 &1#%/ 1" ;%&<%)3 WXH=09.W0 M' /-#%3 )%&')/1"4 )%41,%* $-7% 4%"%)-#%/&-6#- +)', -" I%L#%)1'): 6'*1#1'"3 4%"%)-882 #$)'(4$ '"% /1,%"*1'" -"/ $%8/ C2 -"')4-"1*-#1'" 5$1&$ 1* %L#%)"-8 #' -" 1"/171/(-8 -"/ 5$1&$ #$%2 /' "'# &'"#)'8.%43 #$%2 &'"*#1#(#% *()7%188-"&%09 K 81+%B8'4 5188 4%"%)-#% &-6#- +)', -" I1"#%)1'):.') +1)*#B6%)*'"0 6%)*6%&#17%3 +)', 5$1&$ #$% 1"/171/(-8 5-#&$%* #$%,*%87%* #$)'(4$1"#1,-#% #%&$"'8'41%* .1%3 #%&$"'8'41%* 1" *%)71&% #' #$% 1"/171/(-8b%43 6$'"%*3 &-)35%-)-C8% &',6(#1"403 51#$ #$% &-6#- 6''8%/ 1"#' - ("1+1%/3 ,(8#1,%/1- -)&$17% 5$1&$#$%2 &'"#)'8 c%43 1# &'"*#1#(#%* 3"43),%$$#(7,b*'(*7%188-"&% C%1"4 #$% 1"#%)"-8 &'("#%) #'%L#%)"-8 *()7%188-"&% .T-"" %# -83 =>>?0d9

!" #$1* 6-6%) 5% %L-,1"% #$% 6'#%"#1-8 %++%&#* -"/ %#$1&* 1" - *$1+# +)', *()7%188-"&%#' *'(*7%188-"&% #$)'(4$ #$% /%7%8'6,%"# '+ 6%)7-*17% &',6(#1"43 -"/ 1" 6-)#1&(8-)#$% "'#1'" '+ 81+%B8'441"49 !" #$% +'88'51"4 *%&#1'" 5% '(#81"% %L1*#1"4 +'),* '+%L#%)1') &-6#- -"/ #$%1) (*%*9 e% #$%" %L-,1"% #$% 6'#%"#1-8 '+ 81+%B8'4* #' 6%)+'),*'6$1*#1&-#%/ 3"7%"38#!%#$ *'(*7%188-"&% -"/ #$% +'),* '+ 1"#%)1') &-6#- 1# 1* -"#1&16-#%/#$%2 5188 &-6#()%9 O%&#1'" F %L68')%* #$% "-#()% '+ ,%,')2 51#$1" - 81+%B8'4 -"/ )-1*%*%#$1&-8 f(%*#1'"* &'"&%)"1"4 #$%1) (*% -"/ /%7%8'6,%"#9 !" #$% 6%"(8#1,-#% *%&#1'" 5%,-<% #$% &-*% +') -" %#$1&* '+ +')4%##1"4 -"/ 188(*#)-#% $'5 *(&$ -" %#$1&* 5'(8/ C%,'C181*%/3 C%+')% /)-51"4 *',% &'"&8(*1'"*9 U() -"-82#1&-8 6%)*6%&#17% 1* "%&%**-)182*6%&(8-#17% 417%" #$% %,%)4%"# "-#()% '+ 6%)7-*17% #%&$"'8'41%*3 C(# /)-51"4 '" &())%"#%,61)1&-8 ,-#%)1-8* 5% +'88'5 M$)1+#:* .=>>F3 6-4% H@?0 )%&%"# 8%-/ 1" #)21"4 II#' &-6#()%#$% '(#81"%* '+ - 5')8/ J(*# &',1"4 1"#' %L1*#%"&%3 '"% 5$1&$ 1* C-*%/ '" &'"#1"('(*&-8&(8-#1'" -# %-&$ -"/ %7%)2 6'1"# -8'"4 %-&$ -"/ %7%)2 81"% '+ ,'7%,%"#9::

U() -1, #$%" 1* #' #$1"< #$)'(4$ 8"33%5$, %7%"#(-81#1%* -"/ "%5 *'&1'*6-#1-8 6)'&%**%*-"/ '(#&',%* #$)'(4$ #$% (*% '+ #$% +)-4,%"#-)2 /1*&()*17% -"/ ,-#%)1-8 %71/%"&%&'"&%)"1"4 6%)7-*17% &',6(#1"4 -"/ 81+%B8'441"4 %,%)41"4 -# #$% #1,% '+ 5)1#1"49 !# 1*#' *6%&(8-#% -" 1,-41"-#17% 4%'4)-6$2 '+ #$% +(#()% #$-# ,-2 ') ,-2 "'# &',% #' 6-**A #'%L68')% *',% 1"1#1-8 &'"&%6#(-8 #''8* #$-# ,14$# C% (*%+(8 1" #$1* 6)'J%&#A -"/ #' *#-)##' )-1*% -"/ #$1"< #$)'(4$ *',% C)'-/%) *'&1-83 6'81#1&-83 -"/ %#$1&-8 f(%*#1'"* 51#$)%*6%&# #' 6%)7-*17% &',6(#1"43 81+%B8'441"43 -"/ #$%1) %++%&#*9 U() -1, 1* "'# #' /%#-18%L#%"*17%82 #$% ,%&$-"1&* -"/ +'), '+ #$% #%&$"1&-8 *2*#%,* C%1"4 &'"&%17%/ ') /%7%8'6%/3') 5$1&$ ,14$# %,%)4% 1" #$% +(#()%9 V-#$%)3 5% +'&(* '" #$% 1,681&-#1'"* '+ *(&$ *2*#%,*-"/ 6'#%"#1-8 &'("#%),%-*()%* *$'(8/ #$%2 C%&',% -* 51/%*6)%-/ -* /%7%8'6%)* $'6%9

0 1(%23*44.#)35 63#3%.$*#6 37$3%*&% ).8$.T-"2 %7%)2/-2 -&#171#1%* 1" 6(C81& *6-&%*3 1"/171/(-8 ,'C181#1%*3 -"/ 6%)*'"-8 1"#%)B-&#1'"* -)% "'5 C%1"4 *"4!%(,$& -"/ #4!"+#!%7#$$& &-6#()%/ -"/ )%&')/%/9 O(&$ &-6#()%1* #$% '(#&',% '+ 6)'&%**%* -"/ 6)-&#1&%* '+ *()7%188-"&%3 51#$ #$% 4)'5#$ 1" *()7%188-"##%&$"'8'41%* )%*(8#1"4 1" - /-182 /%8(4% '+ &-6#- #$-# -)% 1"&)%-*1"482 C%1"4 <%6#36)'&%**%/3 )%5')<%/3 &1)&(8-#%/3 -"/ 3&3!,+#!%7#$$& %L68'1#%/ C2 - )-"4% '+ 1"*#1#(#1'"*

.W0 `%"*%" .&1#%/ 1" ;%&<%)3 WXH=3 6-4% =a@0 *#-#%* #$-# II1# 1* -" ("+')#("-#% -&&1/%"# '+ $1*#')2 #$-# #$%#%), /-#(, 999 )-#$%) #$-" &-6#(, 999 *$'(8/ $-7% &',% #' *2,C'81*% #$% ("1#B6$%"',%"'" 1" *&1%"&%9'̂) *&1%"&% /%-8*3 "'# 51#$ I#$-# 5$1&$ $-* C%%" 417%": C2 "-#()% #' #$% *&1%"#1*#3 C(# 51#$ I#$-# 5$1&$

$-* C%%" #-<%": ') *%8%&#%/ +)', "-#()% C2 #$% *&1%"#1*# 1" -&&')/-"&% 51#$ $1* 6()6'*%9::

F?= T N'/4%3 V ]1#&$1"

Page 3: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

-"/ &')6')-#1'"*3 '*#%"*1C82 51#$ #$% 4'-8 '+ C%##%) ,-"-4%,%"# '+ #$%1) '6%)-#1'"*.,-<1"4 #$%, ,')% %++1&1%"#3 ,')% 6)'+1#-C8%3 ,')% *%&()%3 *-+%)3 -"/ *' '"09 O(&$*()7%188-"&% 1* C%1"4 /1)%&#%/ -# -88 -*6%&#* '+ /-182 81+%3 1"&8(/1"4 5')<1"43 &'"*(,1"43&',,("1&-#1"43 -"/ )%&)%-#1'"3 #' &)%-#% - 6'5%)+(8 I&-6#- *$-/'5: .N'/4% -"/]1#&$1"3 =>>HA -8*' *%% ;'4-)/3 WXX_A \8-)<%3 WXXFA N%8%(Q%3 WXX=A Y2'"3 =>>?09

M$% 5')<68-&%3 51#$ 1#* ("%f(-8 6'5%) )%8-#1'"*3 $-* 8'"4 C%%" - *1#% 5$%)%6%'68%*: -&#171#1%* -)% 1"#%"*%82 5-#&$%/ -"/ )%&')/%/9 M$% 1"&)%-*1"4 (*% '+ *'+#5-)%1" ,-"2 5')<1"4 6)-&#1&%* $-* ,%-"# #$-# ,')% -"/ ,')% &-6#- '" 5')<%)* -)% C%1"44%"%)-#%/9 O(&$ &-6#- -)% '+#%" C%1"4 (*%/ #' ,'"1#') -"/ #' %7-8(-#% *#-++ 6%)+'),B-"&% -"/ #' 6)'71/% /1++%)%"#1-8 )%5-)/* -"/ 6("1*$,%"#* +') 1"/171/(-8 5')<%)*.%4 ;-883 =>>?A T-)L3 WXXX09 M261&-8 ,%-"* '+ &-6#- 4%"%)-#1'" 1"&8(/% #$% (*% '+ &'/%*') *516% &-)/* #' #)-&< %,68'2%% ,'7%,%"# #$)'(4$ - 5')<68-&% -"/ #$% 8'441"4 '+#$% (*% '+ &',6(#%) *2*#%,* .%4 <%2*#)'<% &'("#*0 -"/ #%8%6$'"%*9

R7%)2/-2 ,'C181#1%* -)% *1,18-)82 C%1"4 ,'"1#')%/ -"/ )%&')/%/ 1"#' &-6#- *$-/'5*9M)-7%88%)*3 '" - 7-)1%#2 '+ ,'/%* '+ #)-"*6')#3 -)% )%"/%)%/ 1/%"#1+1-C8% -"/ #)-&<-C8%-&)'** #$%1) J'()"%2* C2 *,-)#&-)/ #1&<%#1"4 *2*#%,* .%4 #$% U2*#%) &-)/ '" #$% Y'"/'"S"/%)4)'("/03 *(CJ%&#%/ #' 7%)1+1&-#1'" -# *%&()1#2 *&)%%"1"4 6'1"#*3 -"/ '+#%" 'C*%)7%/C2 C8-"<%# \\Mg &'7%)-4% -# #$% #%),1"(* -"/ 1"&)%-*1"482 '"C'-)/ .%4 C(*%* 1"Y'"/'"09 K1) #)-7%8 1* #$% -)&$%#26-8 %L-,68%3 5$%)% #$% 6'**1C181#2 +') -"'"2,'(*,'C181#2 $-* C%%" %++%&#17%82 %81,1"-#%/ .*%% K/%23 =>>FA N'/4% -"/ ]1#&$1"3 =>>F09h'5%7%)3 1# 1* "'# J(*# ,-** #)-"*6')#-#1'" #$-# 1* *()7%2%/A )'-/* -)% 1"&)%-*1"482 Q'"%*'+ 6%)*'"-81*%/ &-6#- 4%"%)-#1'" #$)'(4$ #$% 1/%"#1+1&-#1'" -"/ #)-&<1"4 '+ 7%$1&8%*9M$1* 1* %"-C8%/ #$)'(4$ '"C'-)/ 8'&-#1'"-8 /%71&%* .%4 1"B&-) "-714-#1'" *2*#%,*0 -"/-8*' )'-/*1/% *%"*') *2*#%,* .*(&$ -* Y'"/'":* &'"4%*#1'" &$-)41"4 *&$%,%3 5$1&$#)-&<* -88 7%$1&8%* %"#%)1"4 -"/ 8%-71"4 #$% &%"#)% '+ #$% &1#23 #$)'(4$ #$% (*% '+ -"%#5')< '+ &-,%)-* 51#$ -(#',-#1& "(,C%)B68-#%B)%&'4"1#1'" &-6-C181#209 S"/%) 6)%B#%L#* '+ %++1&1%"&2 -"/ &'"4%*#1'" )%/(&#1'"3 *-+%#2 -"/ *%&()1#23 -"/ )%7%"(% )%&'7%)23 1#$-* C%%" $26'#$%*1*%/ #$-# 1" - +%5 2%-)* 1# 5188 "'# C% 6'**1C8% #' 8%4-882 /)17% 51#$'(##$% +(88 J'()"%2 C%1"4 )%41*#%)%/ 1"#' - &-6#- *$-/'5 .*%% N'/4% -"/ ]1#&$1"3 =>>H09

\',6%#1#1'"3 -"/ #$% /)17% +') %7%) 4)%-#%) %++1&1%"&2 -"/ 6)'+1#-C181#23 1" #$%6)'71*1'" '+ )%#-18 4''/* -"/ *%)71&%* C2 8-)4% &')6')-#1'"* $-* -8*' ,%-"# %7%),')% &-6#- 4%"%)-#%/ '" /',%*#1& &'"*(,6#1'" -&#171#1%*9 O$'661"4 6-##%)"* -)%"'5 %-*182 +'8/%/ 1"#' 1"/171/(-8*: &-6#- *$-/'5* C2 )%#-18%)* %-4%) #' %L#)-&# ,-LB1,(, *6%"/1"4 +)', %L1*#1"4 &(*#',%)* -"/ #' 61"6'1"# 81<%82 "%5 I6)'*6%&#*:9 M$1* 1*+-&181#-#%/ C2 #$% 1/%"#1+1&-#1'" -"/ #)-&<1"4 '+ *$'66%)* '7%) #1,% #$)'(4$ 8'2-8#2&-)/*3 +)%f(%"# &(*#',%) &'/%*3 -"/ %8%&#)'"1& 6-2,%"#b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c1"*#-"# &)%/1# /%&1*1'"*3 &$%-6%) )-#%*3 -"/ *' '" .*%% T&\(88-4$3 =>>F0d3C(# 5$1&$ -8*' 1,6-&#* ("%f(-882 '" I*(C'6#1,-8: &'"*(,%)* 5$' 6-2 ,(&$ ,')% ')-)% -(#',-#1&-882 /%#%),1"%/ #' C% #'' )1*<2 -"/ -)% %L&8(/%/9 \-6#- '" &'"*(,6#1'"#)-"*-&#1'"* -)% -8*' C%1"4 &-8&(8-#%/ I-* 1# $-66%"*:3 -* C-"<* 5-#&$ '(# +') 6'#%"#1-882+)-(/(8%"# %7%"#*9 h%)%3 #$% /%#%&#1'" '+ +)-(/ 1* 6)%,1*%/ '" -84')1#$,* #$-# 5-#&$ +')#)-"*-&#1'"* I'(# '+ <%%61"4: 51#$ - ,'/%8 '+ - 6%)*'":* I"'),-8: C%$-71'() /%#%),1"%/

M$% %#$1&* '+ +')4%##1"4 F??

Page 4: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

C2 #$% &-6#- *$-/'59 E%'4)-6$1& I"'),-81#2:b*$'661"4 1" 68-&%* #$-# +1# 2'(),'/%8b1* '"% '+ #$% <%2 &)1#%)1-3 -8'"4 51#$ )%#-18%) #26%3 #1,% '+ /-23 &'*# '+ 1#%,3+)%f(%"&23 -"/ *%f(%"&% '+ 6()&$-*%* .%4 M188 -"/ h-"/3 =>>?09

!# 1* "'# '"82 #$% )-5 *1Q% -"/ %L#%"# '+ *()7%188-"&% #$-# $-7% &$-"4%/ 1" #$% 8-*#+%5 2%-)*3 C(# -8*' #$% %,%)4%"&% '+ "%5 &-8&(8-#17% 6)-&#1&%*9 \-6#- *$-/'5* -)%1"&)%-*1"482 C%1"4 81"<%/ #'4%#$%)3 6)'&%**%/3 I,1"%/:3 -"/ -"-82*%/ 1" &',C1"-#1'"3'+#%" 1" )%-8 #1,%3 51#$ #$% 4'-8 '+ 1/%"#1+21"4 6)%/1&#17% 6-##%)"* -# #$% 1"/171/(-8 8%7%81" #%),* '+ $'5 6%'68% -)% 5')<1"43 #)-7%881"43 &'"*(,1"43 &',,("1&-#1"43 -"/ *' '"9\-6#- *$-/'5* -)% C%1"4 (*%/ #' ,-<% #4!"+#!,- J(/4,%"#* -C'(# 1"/171/(-8*3 %"-&#B1"4 1"&)%-*1"482 *'6$1*#1&-#%/ )-"<1"4* -"/ &8-**1+1&-#1'"* -8'"4 -L%* '+ 6'5%) #$-#,%%# #$% "%%/* -"/ -4%"/- '+ #$% 1"*#1#(#1'" &'"#)'881"4 #$% *$-/'53 )-#$%) #$-" #$%1"/171/(-8 .*%% E)-$-, -"/ e''/3 =>>?A Y1-"'* -"/ N'(48-*3 =>>>09 RL#%)1') &-6#-#$%" -)% #$% I+(%8: +') +1"%B4)-1"%/ /1++%)%"#1-#1'" -"/ *'&1-8 *')#1"4 .Y2'"3 =>>?09 O(&$*')#1"4 1* '+#%" "'# I+%8#: /1)%&#82 ') 1* 6%)&%17%/ -* - C%"%+1# .%4 +-*#%)3 %-*1%) *%)71&%+)', - &',6-"2A C%1"4 '++%)%/ - 6%)< *(&$ -* /1*&'("#* ') (64)-/%*0 -"/ #$(*5%8&',%/9 M$%*% -(#',-#%/ )%*6'"*%*3 -* M$)1+# -"/ ^)%"&$ .=>>=0 "'#%3 6)'/(&%6-)#1&(8-) -"/ "%5 *'&1'*6-#1-8 +'),-#1'"*9

M$-# *-1/3 ,-"2 -&#171#1%* -"/ *6-&%* *#188 %*&-6% #$% )%-&$ '+ #$1* )%41,% '+)%&')/1"49 K* K,1" -"/ M$)1+# .=>>=3 6-4% W=@3 '() %,6$-*1*0 )%,1"/ (*3 II#$%"%#5')<* '+ &'"#)'8 #$-# *"-<% #$%1) 5-2 #$)'(4$ &1#1%* -)% "%&%**-)182 "$%/"8!%73 "'#6-"'6#1&P #$%2 /' "'# +1# #'4%#$%)9 M$%2 5188 6)'/(&% 7-)1'(* *6-&%* -"/ #1,%*3 C(# #$%2&-""'# +188 '(# #$% 5$'8% *6-&% '+ #$% &1#2b1" 6-)# C%&-(*% #$%2 &-""'# )%-&$ %7%)2B5$%)%3 1" 6-)# C%&-(*% #$%2 #$%)%+')% &-""'# <"'5 -88 *6-&%* -"/ #1,%*3 -"/ 1" 6-)#C%&-(*% ,-"2 "%5 *6-&%* -"/ #1,%* )%,-1" #' C% 1"7%"#%/9:: M$% "%L# f(%*#1'"3 #$%"3 1*#' 5$-# /%4)%% 5188 6%)7-*17% &',6(#1"43 '6%)-#1"4 +)', -" I1"#%)1'): 6%)*6%&#17%36)'/(&% - 7%)2 /1++%)%"# 5-2 '+ <"'51"4 #$% $1*#')2 '+ 1"/171/(-8* -"/ &1#1%* C2 #-<1"4-" '66'*1#% 7-"#-4% '+ 71%51"4P "'# #'6B/'5"3 C(# +)', #$% 1"*1/%3 8''<1"4 '(#i

9 1&(-23*44.#)35 63#3%.$*#6 *#$3%*&% ).8$. $:%&(6: 4*;3<4&6-!!M$% T2Y1+%;1#* *2*#%, 1* /%*14"%/ #' *#')% -"/ ,-"-4% - 81+%#1,%:* 5')#$ '+,),*&!9%(/b-# 8%-*# %7%)2#$1"4 #$-# &-" C% /141#1*%/9::

E%,,%88 %# -8 .=>>?3 ')141"-8 %,6$-*1*0

RL#%)1') &-6#- #$-# )%"/%) 6%'68%:* 817%* #)-"*6-)%"# #' "4!3%-, ')4-"1*-#1'"* -)% "'56-)#1-882 C%1"4 &',68%,%"#%/ C2 1"#%)1') &-6#-b#$% 6%)*'"-8 /'&(,%"#-#1'" '+ 817%*-* #$%2 ("+'8/3 -" 1"#%)"-882 3,$:;8*"-47,- -(#'C1'4)-6$1&-8 *'(*7%188-"&% .*%% T-""%# -83 =>>?09 h%)%3 &-6#- '" 1"/171/(-8 (*-4% -)% #4!"+#!%7#$$& C%1"4 4%"%)-#%/ C2,-#%)1-8 'CJ%&#* (*%/ '" -" %7%)2/-2 C-*1* C2 -" 1"/171/(-83 *(&$ -* - 6$'"%3 -&',6(#%)3 - #%8%71*1'"3 - &-)3 %#& .5$%"3 5$%)%3 $'5 8'"4 (*%/3 C(# -8*' &'"#%"#b5$-# 5-* /'"%3 5-* &$'*%"3 5-* *-1/3 %#&09 !" -//1#1'"3 #$% -6681&-#1'" '+ 6%)7-*17%&',6(#1"4 #' I/(,C: 'CJ%&#* .81<% +1#"%** %f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b#$% &'"*&1'(* *%8+ &)%-#1'" -"/ 6(C81& *$-)1"4 '+*'(*7%188-"&%3 +') %L-,68%3 #$)'(4$ C8'441"4 -"/ 5%C&-,*9

.=0 O&'6'6$181- 1* #$% 68%-*()% 1" 8''<1"4 -"/ 1" C%1"4 8''<%/ -#9

F?F T N'/4%3 V ]1#&$1"

Page 5: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

K# 6)%*%"#3 $'5%7%)3 #$%*% &-6#- -)% 6-#&$2 1" "-#()% .1" #%),* '+ 5$-# 1* -&#(-882&-6#()%/03 -)% "'# &'"#1"('(*82 &'88%&#%/ .)-#$%)3 &-6#- -)% 4%"%)-#%/ '"82 /()1"4(*%03 -"/ 1"/171/(-8 *#)%-,* '+ &-6#- -)% "'# C%1"4 -,-84-,-#%/ 1"#' - *1"48%3("1+1%/ 81+%B8'49 T')%'7%)3 *',% 6)%*%"# &-6#()% #%&$"'8'41%* -)% 4%"%)-882 *#188 %L#%)B"-882 &'"#)'88%/ -"/ ,'"1#')%/ 'CJ%&#* -"/ 1"+)-*#)(&#()%*b#$%2 -)% #$1)/B6%)*'"#%&$"'8'41%* .#$-# &)%-#% C1'4)-6$1%*0 #$-# $-7% +1)*#B6%)*'" 6'#%"#1-8 .#' &)%-#%-(#'C1'4)-6$1%*0A &'"&%6#(-882 #$% &-,%)-* -)% 6'1"#%/ -# #$% 6%)*'"3 )-#$%) #$-"6'1"#%/ C2 #$% 6%)*'"9

U"% '+ #$% -1,* '+ *',% 6%)7-*17% &',6(#1"4 %"#$(*1-*#* 1* #' &)%-#% - ("1+1%/3-(#'C1'4)-6$1&-8 .+1)*#B6%)*'"0 81+%B8'4 +') %-&$ 1"/171/(-8 #$)'(4$ /141#-8 #%&$"'8'41%*#$-# -)% -85-2* '"3 5$1&$ &',,("1&-#% 51#$ %-&$ '#$%) 51#$'(# $(,-" 1"*#)(&#1'" ')1"#%)7%"#1'"3 -"/ 5$1&$ -)% *' 6%)7-*17% #$-# #$%2 &'7%) -88 -*6%&#* '+ $(,-" -&#171#2-"/ C%&',% *' C-"-8 -* #' C% *%%,1"482 1"71*1C8%b#' &)%-#% - ,%-"* #' 6%)*'"-882*#')% -88 '+ '"%:* -&#171#1%* #$)'(4$'(# - 81+%#1,% 51#$1" - *1"48% -)&$17% .\KVDR3=>>F09 M$% 6)'*6%&# 1* '+ &-6#()1"4 -"/ *#')1"4 ,),*&!9%(/ 5% *%% -"/ $%-)bII#$%#'#-81#2 '+ 1"+'),-#1'" #$-# +8'5* #$)'(4$ - $(,-" 81+%:: .`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

=*6(%3 !/ K &'"&%6#(-8 ,'/%8 '+ ,%/1- &-6#()% '+ #$% <&>%:,0%!3 *2*#%,* .*'()&%P E%,,%88%# -83 =>>?09

M$% %#$1&* '+ +')4%##1"4 F?H

Page 6: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

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f(%"&2 1/%"#1+1&-#1'"0 #%&$"'8'41%*3 ,-<1"4#$%, 1"*#-"#82 8'&-#-C8% '" /%,-"/9 O(&$ )1&$ &-6#- 5188 $-7% #$% %++%&# '+ '6%"1"4 (6"%5 #1,% G *6-&% f(%)1%* #$-# 5%)% 6)%71'(*82 1,6'**1C8%9 ^') %L-,68%3 1# 5188 C%6'**1C8% #' <"'5 %7%)2 )'(#% %7%) #-<%"3 #$% 8'&-#1'" '+ %7%)2 6%)*'"-8 1#%, 51#$1"- *%"*') +1%8/ -"/ #$% $1*#')2 '+ #$-# 'CJ%&# -"/ 1#* )%8-#1'"* #' '#$%) 'CJ%&#*3 -"/ #')%&-88 %7%)2 68-&% 1" 5$1&$ -" -&#171#2 5-* ("/%)#-<%"9 K* "'#%/ C%8'53 #$%)% 5188 -8*'C% #$% 6'#%"#1-8 %++%&# '+ &)%-#1"4 - ,'C18% 6-"'6#1&'" .-* '66'*%/ #' - 6-)#1-8'814'6#1&'"09

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c*2*#%,-#1*1"4 -"/ *14"1+1&-"#82 /%%6%"1"4C'/182 6%)+'),-"&% ,'"1#')1"4 )%41,%* &',,'" 1" #'/-2:* *'&1%#2 .*%% O&$((),-"3=>>F0d9

F?_ T N'/4%3 V ]1#&$1"

Page 7: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

O14"1+1&-"# 6)'4)%** 1* 6)%*%"#82 C%1"4 ,-/% 51#$1" #$% &',6(#%) *&1%"&% &',,("1#21" %L68')1"4 81+%B8'441"49.?0 ^') %L-,68%3 O("18 g%,()13 - )%*%-)&$%) -# #$% T!M T%/1-Y-C 1* /%7%8'61"4 - 6%)*'"-81*%/ *'("/ 8'441"4 *2*#%, &-88%/ I?9#! ?#3 @ !9%(A%(/: #$-#-)&$17%* -88 '+ -" 1"/171/(-8:* &'"7%)*-#1'"* -"/ 6)'71/%* ,%-"* #' (*%+(882 *%-)&$ #$%7%)C-#1, #)-"*&)16#* 71- 71*(-8 1"#%)+-&%*9.F0 V%*%-)&$%)* -# T1&)'*'+# V%*%-)&$ Y-C 1"\-,C)1/4% -)% /%7%8'61"4 B,(3,C#+3 - /%71&% 5$1&$ -(#',-#1&-882 #-<%* 6$'#'4)-6$*'+ - 6%)*'":* %"71)'",%"# 1" )%*6'"*% #' &$-"41"4 &'"/1#1'"* .*(&$ -* C'/2 ,'#1'"3814$# 8%7%8*3 #%,6%)-#()%0 .e1881-,* -"/ e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

=*6(%3 0/ M$% %L6%)1,%"#-8 1"#%)+-&% #' #$% 6$'#'4)-6$1& 8'4 6)'/(&%/ C2 #$% B,(3,C#+ 6)'#'#26%.*'()&%P e1881-,* -"/ e''/3 =>>F09

.?0 ^') '#$%)71%5* *%% [-&< .=>>H03 7-" N1J&< .=>>H03 -"/ e%)<$'7%" .=>>F09 M$% 6)'&%%/1"4* '+ #$%\KVDR .=>>F0 -"/ D%)7-*17%>F .=>>F0 &'"+%)%"&%* 6)'71/% - 4''/ *-,68% '+ )%*%-)&$ 1" #$1* -)%-9.F0 O%% 0//1$**222'23+'43567'46/'358*!9348:6*226/*226/;<93:9632'0/4=9

M$% %#$1&* '+ +')4%##1"4 F?a

Page 8: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

> ?*6*$.4 @3@&%*3-!!K )%&')/ 1+ 1# 1* #' C% (*%+(8 999 ,(*# C% &'"#1"('(*82 %L#%"/%/3 1# ,(*# C% *#')%/3-"/ -C'7% -88 1# ,(*# C% &'"*(8#%/9:: ;(*$ .WXFH0

!!M$%e%*#%)" #)-/1#1'" '+ ,%,')2 *1"&% #$% V%"-1**-"&% $-* C%%" +'("/%/ (6'" #$%-**(,6#1'" #$-# ,-#%)1-8 'CJ%&#*3 5$%#$%) "-#()-8 ') -)#1+1&1-83 &-" #7! #3 #(#$"/4,3'+ $(,-" ,%,')29:: ^')#2 .WXXX3 6-4% =3 '() %,6$-*1*0

K* ^')#2 /%#-18*3 -)#%+-&#* $-7% 8'"4 C%%" )%&'4"1*%/ -* -"-8'4(%* ') +'18* +') ,%,')29!" #$% &-*% '+ -)&$17%*b*(&$ -* /1-)1%* ') 6$'#' -8C(,*b#$%2 )%&')/ %7%"#*3 6%'68%3-"/ 68-&%* -* *"-6*$'#* 1" #1,% -"/ *6-&%9 ^') 6%'68% 5$' <"'5 #$% 1"/171/(-8* 1" #$%-)&$17%3 &'"#%L# 6)'71/%* %,'#1'"-8 &'""%&#1'"* -"/ +()#$%) ,%-"1"43 C(# +') '#$%)*#$% -)&$17% *1,682 6)'71/%* - +-&#(-8 -&&'("#9 h%)%3 #$%)% 1* - /1*#1"&#1'" C%#5%%" 5$-#5% 5'(8/ &-88 #$1" ,%,')2 -"/ #$1&< ,%,')29 M$1" ,%,')2 1* +-&#(-8 -"/ %-*182+'),-81*%/ 51#$1" - ,%/1- -* #%L#(-8 ') "(,%)1& )%&')/*3 *'("/3 1,-4%3 %#&A 1# 1*&-6#-b*%8%&#%/ +-&#* &-6#()%/ +)', #$% *(, '+ -88 ,-#%)1-8 /-#-9 M$1&< ,%,')21* %,C%//%/3 %,'#1'"-83 &'"#%L# )1&$3 1,,-#%)1-8b1# 1* )%,%,C)-"&%* #$-# &'"*#1#(#%5$' - 6%)*'" 1* -"/ 1# 6)'71/%* - *%"*% '+ *%8+9 M$1&< ,%,')1%* -)% ,(&$ ,')% #$-"7-)1'(* *#)-"/* '+ #$1" ,%,')2 #1%/ #'4%#$%)3 #$%2 $-7% %,'#1'"-8 -"/ &'"#%L#(-8/%6#$ #$-# 1* ,')% #$-" #$% *(, '+ 1#* 6-)#*9

N1-)1%* &-" 6)'71/% *',% )%*'"-"&%* '+ #$1&< ,%,')1%*3 C(# -)#%+-&#* *(&$ -*,'C18% #%8%6$'"%* -"/ %,%)41"4 5%-)-C8% &',6(#1"4 &-" -# C%*# 6)'71/% '"82 $1"#*3-* #$% ,-#%)1-8 #$%2 )%&')/ -"/ *#')% 1* 8-)4%82 '"% /1,%"*1'"-8 -"/ 8-&<* #$% 1"#%)B6)%#-#1'"3 ,%-"1"43 -"/ %,'#17% 1"#%)&'""%&#1'"* #$-# - $(,-" ,1"/ 5'(8/ -//9 ^')%L-,68%3 - 71*#- *#')%/ 51#$1" - 81+%B8'4 1* *1,682 - 71%5 '+ - 68-&%b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b#$% +-&#(-8 /%#-18* '+ %7%)2/-2 81+%3 6)'71/1"4 - 8171"4-)&$17% '+ #$% ,1"(#1-% '+ 1"#%)-&#1'"*3 #)-"*-&#1'"*3 -"/ ,'C181#1%*9

M$-# *-1/3 81+%B8'4* &8%-)82 $-7% *14"1+1&-"# 1,681&-#1'"* +') #$% )%&')/1"4 '+ #$%6)%*%"#3 -"/ #$(* $'5 #$% 6-*# 1* *,7#$$,- -* '66'*%/ #' )%,%,C%)%/9 !" #%),* '+5$-# 1* &-6#()%/ #$%)% 1* - f(-81#-#17% *$1+# 1" #$% 4)-"(8-)1#2 .*6-&% G #1,% )%*'8(#1'"'+ &-6#-0 -"/ +1/%81#2 '+ )%&')/1"4 ,%/1-3 -"/ #$(* #$% f(-81#2 '+ #$% &-6#- $%8/3 -"/-8*' 1" &',68%,%"#-)1#1%* C%#5%%" ,%/1- 5$1&$ &)%-#% ,(8#1/1,%"*1'"-8 -)&$17%* .#$%*-,% %7%"#* &-6#()%/ C2 /1++%)%"# #%&$"'8'41%* -"/ *(C*%f(%"#82 81"<%/ #'4%#$%)09 M$1*1* -&&',6-"1%/ C2 - f(-"#1#-#17% *$1+# 1" #%),* '+ #$% 7'8(,% '+ 6%)*'"-8 &-6#-&-6#()%/3 "'# *1,682 -* - +("&#1'" '+ )%*'8(#1'" .- $14$%) )%*'8(#1'" 61&#()% )%f(1)%*,')% *#')-4%03 C(# 1" #%),* '+ #$% +)%f(%"&2 '+ &-6#- 4%"%)-#%/ .#$% "(,C%) '+ +)-,%*6%) *%&'"/3 #$% "(,C%) '+ -&#171#1%* )%&')/%/3 #$% (*% '+ ,(8#168% ,%/1-*3 %#&0 -"/ #$%,'C181#2 '+ &-6#()% .&-6#- -)% 4%"%)-#%/ +)', /%71&%* &-))1%/ ') 5')" C2 #$% 6%)*'"3"'# +1L%/ 8'&-#1'"* *(&$ -* KMT* -"/ *()7%188-"&% &-,%)-*09 !" *$')#3 &-6#- -)%C%&',1"4 &'"#1"('(* -&)'** #1,% -"/ *6-&%3 +8'51"4 1"#' #$% 81+%B8'4 %++')#8%**82 -* -"-#()-8 6-)# '+ #$% 6%)+'),-"&% '+ /-182 81+% .*%% N'/4% -"/ ]1#&$1"3 =>>H09

e$18% #$%*% #%&$"'8'41&-8 *$1+#* $-7% #$% 6'#%"#1-8 #' 6)'71/% )1&$ -(#'C1'4)-6$1&-8"-))-#17%* #$-# -)% '+ 6'#%"#1-8 (*% -"/ 7-8(% #' #$% 1"/171/(-8 81+%B8'4%%3 -88'51"4 #$%)%68-21"4 '+ 81+% %7%"#* .-* *(6%)1') /1-)1%*3 1"#%)-&#17% 6$'#'4)-6$ -8C(,*3 -"/ 81+%81"%,'71%*3 +') %L-,68%03 #$%2 )-1*% C)'-/%) *'&1-8 -"/ 6'81#1&-8 f(%*#1'"*9 !" 6-)#1&(8-)3

F?@ T N'/4%3 V ]1#&$1"

Page 9: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

#$%)% -)% f(%*#1'"* &'"&%)"1"4 5$' '5"* 81+%B8'44%/ &-6#-3 $'5 #$%2 &-" C% (*%/3 -"/#$% 81,1#* #' 5$-# 1* &-6#()%/9

!" )%8-#1'" #' '5"%)*$163 5$18% #$% &-6#- 51#$1" - 81+%B8'4 -)% -(#'C1'4)-6$1&-83-"/ 5188 C% $%8/ C2 #$% 1"/171/(-83 #$%)% -)% f(%*#1'"* &'"&%)"1"4 -&&%** -"/ &'"#)'89^') %L-,68%3 5$' $-* )14$#* #' -&&%** '#$%) #$-" #$% &)%-#')i M' 5$-# %L#%"# &-" #$%,-#%)1-8 C% *%f(%*#%)%/ +') 8%4-8 &-*%* -"/ 5$-# 1* #$% 8%4-8 *#-#(* '+ *(&$ ,-#%)1-8iN' &-6#- #-<% '" #$% *-,% *#-#(* -* C1'8'41&-8 ,%,')1%*i U) -)% #$%2 *%%" -* +"*,'CJ%&#17% -"/ #)(%i e$-# $-66%"* 5$%" #$%)% 1* - /1*&)%6-"&2 C%#5%%" #$% *#-#%,%"#* '+1"/171/(-8* -"/ #$% 81+%B8'4:* &-6#-i K)% #$%)% -"2 '#$%) #$1)/ 6-)#1%* #$-# &-" $-7%-&&%**3 *(&$ -* 4'7%)",%"# *%&()1#2 -4%"&1%* ') %,68'2%)*i e'(8/ -&&%** C2 #$1)/6-)#1%* .1"&8(/1"4 8%4-8 (*%0 C% )%*#)1&#17% ') "'")%*#)1&#17% .%4 5188 -88 &-6#- C% -7-18-C8%') '"82 *%8%&#%/ 6')#1'"*3 %1#$%) C2 /-#% ') ,%/1-0i e'(8/ '#$%) 6%'68% &-6#()%/ C2 #$%81+%B8'4 $-7% &8-1,* #' -&&%** #' 1#* &'"#%"#* .*(&$ -* - 6-)#"%) ') +)1%"/* ') 5')<&'88%-4(%*0i e$-# $-66%"* #' #$% 81+%B8'4 -# /%-#$i .H0 K)% #$%)% 1"$%)1#-"&% )14$#* -"/*' '"i e$' $-* &'"#)'8 '+ - &$18/:* 81+%B8'4i e188 81+%B8'4* C% 7'8("#-)2 ') 5188 6)%**()%') ,-"/-#')2 ,%-*()%* C2 *#-#% -"/ &-61#-8 +')&% 6%'68% #' -/'6# #$%,i

!+ 81+%B8'4* -)% -&&%**1C8% #' #$1)/ 6-)#1%*3 1" 5$-#%7%) +'),3 #$%" *(&$ -&&%** '6%"*(6 #$% 6'#%"#1-8 +') 1"7-*17% 6)'+181"43 *'&1-8 *')#1"43 -"/ 6%)"1&1'(* /1*&1681"1"4%++%&#*9 .M$% 81+%B8'4 5'(8/ C% 1" ,-"2 )%*6%&#* - ,-)<%#%):* /)%-,3 %"-C81"4 #$%, #'I4%# 1"*1/% #$% 81+%: '+ - &'"*(,%) #' -" ("6)%&%/%"#%/ /%4)%%90 ^') %L-,68%3 #$%)% 1* #$%'66')#("1#2 #' ,'"1#') 81+%*#28%3 51#$ #$% 81+%B8'4 6)'71/1"4 C-*%81"% &-6#- #$-# ("/%)B61" *%)71&%* *(&$ -* $%-8#$ -"/ &-) 1"*()-"&% c-* %"71*-4%/ 1" O#%)81"4:* .WXXa0 "'7%8D"$& E%*,d9 Y1+%B8'4 &-6#- &'(8/ %L#%"/ *'&1-8 *')#1"4 6)-&#1&%*3 -88'51"4 +') 6)%+%)%"B#1-8 #)%-#,%"# '+ &(*#',%)* -"/ &81%"#* #$-# ,-L1,1*%* 6)'+1#*3 ,-1"#-1"* #$% *#-#(* f('3-"/ 6%"-81*%* #$'*% #$-# +1# &%)#-1" 6)'+18%* .E-"/23 WXX?A Y2'"3 =>>?09 T')%'7%)3 #$%)%1* #$% 6'#%"#1-8 +') 1"/1*&)%#1'"*3 6%)7%)*1'"*3 -"/ ,1"') 1"+)-&#1'"* '+ #$% 8-5 #' C%1/%"#1+1%/ -"/ 6%"-81*%/3 #$(* %"&'()-41"4 ,')% )14')'(*3 *%8+B/1*&1681"1"4 C%$-71'()31" #()" %"&'()-41"4 -" (8#)-&'"*%)7-#17% *'&1%#2 .*%% -8*' ;8-"&$%##% -"/ `'$"*'"3 =>>=09e$%" %7%)2 -&#1'" 1* )%&')/%/ +') 6%)6%#(1#23 1" - *%%,1"482 'CJ%&#17% ,-""%)3 -"/ #$%)% 1*- 81<%81$''/ #$-# #$% &'"*%f(%"&%* 5188 C% )%-81*%/3 #$%" ;%"#$-,:* D-"'6#1&'" C%&',%*+(882 )%-81*%/9 M$1* 1* 6-)#1&(8-)82 #$% &-*% 1+ 81+%B8'4* -)% 1"#%)81"<%/ #' &)%-#% &'88%&#17%6)'+18%*9

M$% 71*1'" +') 81+%B8'4* 1* #$-# #$%2 5188 &-6#()% -88 6'**1C8% &-6#-3 *#')1"4 1#+')%7%)9 !# 1* "'# &8%-)3 $'5%7%)3 #' 5$-# %L#%"# - 81+%B8'4 5188 C% %/1#-C8%3 1+ -# -889O$'(8/ - 81+%B8'4 C% %/1#-C8% 81<% - /1-)2 ') 6$'#'4)-6$i O$'(8/ 6')#1'"* C% '6%"#' *%8%&#17%3 6%),-"%"# %)-*1"4i U) J(*# /%8%#1'" +)', 71%53 C(# 51#$ #$% 6)'*6%&# '+)%&'7%)2i ^()#$%)3 *$'(8/ #$%*% -&#* '+ %)-*1"4 ') /%8%#1"4 #$%,*%87%* C% 51#"%**%/-"/ )%,%,C%)%/ C2 #$% 81+%B8'4i K)% #$%)% %7%"#* -"/ -&#1'"* #$-# *$'(8/ C% %L&8(/%/+)', &-6#()%3 ') -# 8%-*# *$'(8/ #$%)% C% -" '6#1'" #' *(*6%"/ )%&')/1"4i \-" 2'(6)%** 6-(*% '" #$% 81+%B8'4i e'(8/ -" -&# '+ /%8%#1'" ') *(*6%"*1'" 1#*%8+ C% &'"B*1/%)%/ - *14" '+ 4(18# 1+ #$% 81+%B8'4 5%)% #' C% (*%/ 1" 8-5i N' #$% ,("/-"1#1%* '+ 81+%)%-882 "%%/ #' C% &-6#()%/ +') 6%)6%#(1#23 *(&$ -* &8%-"1"4 #$% $'(*%3 5-8<1"4 #$%/'43 ') 821"4 '" - C%-&$i K* U*&-) e18/% *#-#%/ IIU"% *$'(8/ -C*')C #$% &'8'()'+ 81+%3 C(# '"% *$'(8/ "%7%) )%,%,C%) 1#* /%#-18*9 N%#-18* -)% -85-2* 7(84-):: .WX@@36-4% @>09 !" -//1#1'"3 #' 5$-# %L#%"# 5188 1# C% 6'**1C8% #' /(6% #$% 8'43 #' ("*%##8% #$%-(#$%"#1&1#2 '+ #$% )%&')/9

M$% /%4)-/-#1'" '+ C1'8'41&-8 ,%,')2 ') &'4"1#17% /1*')/%)* -)% #)-(,-#1& %L6%B)1%"&%*3 -* #$% %71/%"&% +)', +'),* '+ /%,%"#1- -"/ ,%"#-8 188"%** 188(*#)-#%9 O' 5$-#

.H0 M$1* 1**(% '+ -&&%** -"/ '5"%)*$16 '+ 6%)*'"-8 /141#-8 )%&')/* -+#%) /%-#$ 1* -8)%-/2 &-(*1"4&'"&%)"3 *%% O%81"4' .=>>F09

M$% %#$1&* '+ +')4%##1"4 F?X

Page 10: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

5'(8/ C% #$% 1,6-&# '+ -&&1/%"#-8 ') /%81C%)-#% /-,-4% ') -8#%)-#1'" #$)'(4$ #$%68-"#1"4 '+ +-8*% I,%,')1%*: #' #$% 81+%B8'4i T')%'7%)3 &'(8/ #$% 81+%B8'4 C% *#'8%" -"/(*%/3 6%)$-6* 1" #$% *-,% 5-2 -* *#'8%" 6-**6')#* ') 1/%"#1#2 &-)/*i e$-# 5'(8/ C%#$% &'"*%f(%"&%* +') #$% 6%)*'" 5$'*% 81+%B8'4 5-* *#'8%"3 C'#$ %,'#1'"-882 -"/,-#%)1-882i

O',% f(%*#1'"* -C'(# #$% I)%-81#2: '+ #)21"4 #' 817% 1" - 81+%B8'44%/ 5')8/ -)% *#-)#1"4#' C% #$'(4$# #$)'(4$ -"/ f(%*#1'"%/ C2 #$% 5')< '+ /141#-8 -)#1*#*9 ^') %L-,68%3 Y(&2]1,C%883 #$)'(4$ $%) 5%C*1#% .0//1$**222'=8>?@64+3=='><40 II! ,%-*()% #$%)%+')% ! -,::$-* ("/%)#-<%" - f(-"#1#-#17% 6%)*'"-8 -(/1#b5$1&$ 1"&8(/%* - *#'&< ,-)<%# *#28%%7-8(-#1'" &-88%/ >@F3 II- 5%%<82 1"/%L #$-# #)-&<%/ c$%)d 6%)+'),-"&% C%#5%%" =>>= G >?C2 ,%-*()1"4 +1"-"&1-83 %,'#1'"-83 *'&1-8 -"/ %"71)'",%"#-8 +-&#')*9:: T(8#1,%/1- -)#1*#R881% h-))1*'":* 6)'J%&#* 1"&8(/% G"$- C#*- H-),(!4*,33 - 8'441"4 '+ -88 $%) 6(C81&#)-"*6')# J'()"%2* +') - 2%-)3 -"/ #$% '#! II 6)'J%&#3 5$%)% %7%)2#$1"4 *$% -#% +')#$% 2%-) -+#%) $%) =="/ C1)#$/-2 5-* 6$'#'4)-6$%/3 8'44%/3 -"/ /1*68-2%/ '"81"% .0//1$**222'3==6307::6A<B'><409 K ,')% 4%"%)-81*%/ f(%*#1'"1"4 '+ #$% %L&%**%* '+ &'"*(,%)1*#&(8#()% 5-* #$% +'&(* '+ H$$;C"(J4+%(/K7"+ .0//1$**222'7==;><BA846BC'><403 - I81+%B8'441"4:#26% 6)'J%&# C2 -)#1*# O#%6$-"1%3 1" 5$1&$ *$% &',6)%$%"*17%82 )%&')/%/ -88 $%) 6()&$-*%*1" =>>W9 K #'#-8 '+ SO ja?HFX9WF .%L&8(/1"4 "%5 $',%0 +') =H@_ /1++%)%"# 1#%,* -"/ *%)71&%*5-* *6%"#3 -88 &-#-8'4(%/ '"81"% 51#$ /%*&)16#1'"*3 6$'#'4)-6$*3 /-#%3 #1,%3 8'&-#1'"3 -"/-,'("#9 Y-*#823 K8C%)#' ^)14':* 5')< 1" I71*(-8B*#-#1*#1&*: f(%*#1'"* $(,-":* C-"-8 /%6%"/B%"&% '" #%&$"'8'42 #$)'(4$ - 7%)2 %L-&#1"4 #26% '+ 8'441"4 .+14()% ?09 M$% 6)'J%&# 1*II-" '"4'1"4 %L6%)1,%"# &'"*1*#1"4 '+ 6$'#'4)-6$1"4 %-&$ #1,% ,2 )14$# $-"/ (*%* -"'CJ%&# 1" ')/%) #' &)%-#% ,2 -(#'C1'4)-6$2 +') *%8+B)%+8%&#1'" -"/ %"+')&1"4 ,2 1/%"#1#2::. )̂14'3 =>>F3 6-4% H=09

=*6(%3 9/ K *,-88 6-)# '+ K8C%)#' ^)14':* -(#'C1'4)-6$2 6)'J%&#3 - ,-"(-882 6)'/(&%/ 6-)#1-8I81+%B8'4: '+ -88 $1* 1"#%)-&#1'"* 51#$ %7%)2/-2 'CJ%&#* .*'()&%P 0//1$**222'65'C8'A3*!7=+3:/<*09

FF> T N'/4%3 V ]1#&$1"

Page 11: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

A B:3 3$:*)- &; ;&%63$$*#6 *# .# .63 &; 83%2.-*23 )&@8($*#6!!T(&$ +')4%##1"4 #()"* '(# #' C% ,')% C%"%+1# #$-" C%)%-7%,%"#3 - ,%)&2 )-#$%)#$-" ,-8-/29 M' +')4%# 1* -* %**%"#1-8 -* #' <%%6 #$1"4* 1" ,1"/3 +') "' 1"/171/(-8 ')&'88%&#171#2 &-" -++')/ #' )%,%,C%) %7%)2#$1"49:: Y'5%"#$-8 .WXXX3 6-4% L10

e1#$ )%*6%&# #' #$% /%7%8'6,%"# '+ *'(*7%188-"#3 81+%B8'441"4 #%&$"'8'41%*3 -"/ #$%/1*&'()*%* (*%/ #' *(66')# *(&$ /%7%8'6,%"#3 #$% /18%,,-* 5%3 -"/ #$% -)#1*# 6)'J%&#*/%*&)1C%/ -C'7%3 )-1*% -)% *#)-#%41&-882 -7'1/%/ C2 ,-"2 #%&$"'8'41*#* C%&-(*% #$%2$14$814$# /1++1&(8# %#$1&-8 f(%*#1'"* &'"&%)"1"4 %7%"#* -"/ -&#1'"* #$-# 5%)% 6)%71'(*82%1#$%) 6)17-#% ') /1*6-)-#%82 &-6#()%/ -&)'** ,%/1- -"/ ')4-"1*-#1'"* -"/ 5$1&$ 5%)%*(C*%f(%"#82 /1++1&(8# #' *#1#&$ #'4%#$%) 1"#' - &'$%)%"#3 ("1+1%/ 5$'8% .*%% ;-""'"3=>>_09 h%)% 5% *(44%*# #$-# *(&$ /18%,,-* -"/ f(%*#1'"* ,14$# C% #-&<8%/ #$)'(4$ -"%#$1&* '+ +')4%##1"49 !" *' /'1"43 5% 5-"# #' 68-2 /%718:* -/7'&-#% #' #$% /)17% #' &)%-#%#%&$"'8'41%* #$-# I*#')% -"/ ,-"-4% - 81+%#1,%:* 5')#$ '+ %7%)2#$1"4: C2 *(44%*#1"4 #$-#,%,')2 *$'(8/ -85-2* C% &',68%,%"#%/ C2 +')4%##1"49 e% #$(* 6'*1# #$-# +')4%##1"4 1*"'# - 5%-<"%** ') - +-881C181#23 C(# 1* -" %,-"&16-#')2 6)'&%** #$-# 5188 +)%% 81+%B8'441"4+)', C()/%"*',% -"/ 6%)"1&1'(* /1*&1681"-)2 %++%&#*A -* [1%#Q*&$% *(44%*#*3 +')4%##1"45188 *-7% $(,-"* +)', $1*#')2 .V-,-/-"'71&3 =>>W09

h(,-" ,%,')2 1* +-881C8% -"/ /'%* "'# &'"*#1#(#% - 6%)+%&# C1'8'41&-8 81+%B8'49D%'68% +')4%#9 O&$-&#%) .=>>W0 /%#-18* *1L +'),* '+ +')4%##1"43 #$)%% &'"&%)"%/ 51#$8'** -"/ #$)%% 51#$ %))')9._0 Y'**BC-*%/ +')4%##1"4 &'"*1*#* '+ #)-"*1%"&% .#$% 8'** '+,%,')2 '7%) #1,%03 -C*%"#,1"/%/"%** .#$% 8'** '+ ,%,')2 /(% #' /1*#)-&#%/"%** -# #$%#1,% #$% ,%,')2 )%8-#%* #'03 -"/ C8'&<1"4 .#$% #%,6')-)2 1"-C181#2 #' )%,%,C%)b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b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

D%)$-6*3 1" #$% 6)'&%** '+ /%*14"1"4 -"/ 1,68%,%"#1"4 81+%B8'441"43 +')4%##1"4*$'(8/ C% -" 1"#%4)-8 6-)# '+ -"2 *2*#%,9 M$1*3 5% +%%8 *$'(8/ $-66%" +)', #$% C'##',(6 -"/ *$'(8/ C% - &')% +%-#()% '+ #$% 81+%B8'43 )-#$%) #$-" +)', #$% #'6 /'5"3 5$%)%1"

._0 O&$-&#%) "'#%* '"% '#$%) 6)'C8%, 51#$ ,%,')2b6%)*1*#%"&%3 #$% )%&-881"4 '+ %7%"#* #$-# 5'(8/)-#$%) C% +')4'##%"9

M$% %#$1&* '+ +')4%##1"4 FFW

Page 12: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

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`(*# -* - 6%)*'" 5'(8/ *1,682 *#-)# #' +')4%# 6-)#* '+ #$% J'()"%23 *' #$%81+%B8'4 5'(8/ 4)-/(-882 /%4)-/% #$% 6)%&1*1'" '+ #$% )%&')/ 51#$ #1,%9 KC*%"#,1"/%/B"%** &'(8/ C% %"*()%/ #$)'(4$ /1*#)-&#%/"%** C%1"4 C(18# 1"#' #$% *%"*1"4 #%&$"'8'41%*'+ &-6#- 4%"%)-#1'"9 M$% 8'4 5'(8/ )%&')/ #$% 5$'8% J'()"%23 C(# ,1** '(# &%)#-1"61%&%* '+ &-6#-3 C%&-(*% - )%&')/1"4 ,%/1(, 5-* *51#&$%/ '++ ') 5-* /1)%&#%/ -# *',%B#$1"4 %8*%9 ;8'&<1"4 5'(8/ C% 1"&')6')-#%/ -# #$% #1,% #$% 81+%B8'4 5-* C%1"4 f(%)1%/9K# '#$%) #1,%*3 #$% f(%)2 5'(8/ C% -"*5%)%/ 51#$ "' 6)'C8%,*9 T1*-##)1C(#1'" &'(8/C% -&$1%7%/ C2 #$% *6%&1+1& ,1*)%&')/1"4 '+ 6-)# '+ -" %7%"#3 C(# "'# #$% 5$'8% %7%"#9^') %L-,68%3 6-)# '+ - J'()"%2 5'(8/ C% *#(-"+$& ,1*-##)1C(#%/ .%43 $-71"4 - &'++%% 1"O#-)C(&<* )-#$%) #$-" \-++%k [%)'03 C(# #$% '7%)-88 J'()"%2 1" #%),* '+ #)-7%881"4 +)',K #' ; 5'(8/ C% &'))%&#9 !" '#$%) 5')/*3 ,1*-##)1C(#1'" 1* ,%-"1"4+(8 1" #$% )%8-#1'"*'+ #1,%3 *6-&%3 -"/ &'"#%L#9 !# 1* "'# #$% -//1"4 '+ +-8*% ,%,')1%*3 C(# )-#$%) #$%I#5%-<1"4: '+ - 6-*# %7%"#9 O(44%*#1C181#2 5'(8/ &'"*1*# '+ #$% 68-(*1C8% )%*&)16#1"4 '+7,*!#%( %7%"#* -+#%) - 6-)#1&(8-) #1,%9 h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

C =*#.4 $:&(6:$-

!!;(# +') #$'*% +1)*# -++%&#1'"*3M$'*% *$-/'52 )%&'88%&#1'"*3e$1&$3 C% #$%2 5$-# #$%2 ,-23K)% 2%# #$% +'("#-1"B814$# '+ -88 '+ '() /-23K)% 2%# - ,-*#%)B814$# '+ -88 '() *%%1"49:: e1881-, e')/*5')#$

L-,1 @(!%+#!%"(3 ": @++"*!#$%!& :*"+ M,7"$$,7!%"(3 ": '#*$& C9%$-9""- .W@>a0

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

FF= T N'/4%3 V ]1#&$1"

Page 13: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

,%,')1%* - +-&#(-8 )%&')/ '+ %7%"#*b#$% I,-*#%)B814$# '+ -88 *%%1"4:b,14$# C%&',% -)%-81#29

O(&$ - I,-*#%)B814$#: -)&$17% $-* ,-"2 6'#%"#1-8 *'&1-83 6'81#1&-83 -"/ %#$1&-8 1,681B&-#1'"* 51#$ )%4-)/* #' #$% )%4(8-#1'" '+ %7%)2/-2 81+%3 &$-"41"4 #$% &'"/1#1'"* #$)'(4$5$1&$ 81+% ("+'8/*9 M$'(4$ 1# 1* 6'#%"#1-882 %,6'5%)1"4 +') 1"/171/(-8*3 -# 1#* 8'41&-8%L#)%,% 1"/171/(-8* ,-2 &',% #' 817% 1" - +(882 6-"'6#1& *'&1%#2 51#$ 1"#%)"-8 *'(*7%18B8-"&% )%+8%&#%/ 1"#' %L#%)"-8 *()7%188-"&%9 e$%#$%) *(&$ - *1#(-#1'" &',%* #' 6-** '"82#1,% 5188 #%883 C(# 1# 1* 1,6')#-"#3 5% C%81%7%3 #' #$1"< #$)'(4$ #$% 1,681&-#1'"* '+ %7%)B6)%*%"# 81+%B8'441"4 -* *(&$ #%&$"'8'41%* C%41" #' %,%)4%9 M' &'("#%) #$% 6'#%"#1-8826%)"1&1'(* %++%&#* '+ 6%)7-*17% &',6(#1"4 5% $-7% *(44%*#%/ #$% /%7%8'6,%"# '+ -"%#$1&* '+ +')4%##1"4 #$-# 1* ,-#%)1-81*%/ #$)'(4$ #$% I8'** '+ ,%,')2: 1" - 81+%B8'49e$18%C(18/1"4 +-881C181#2 1"#' #$% *2*#%, *%%,1"482 ("/%),1"%* 81+%B8'441"43 1# *%%,* #' (*#$% '"82 5-2 #' %"*()% #$-# $(,-"* &-" +')4%#3 &-" )%5')< #$%1) 6-*#3 &-" -&$1%7%- 6)'4)%**17% 6'81#1&* C-*%/ (6'" /%C-#% -"/ "%4'#1-#1'"3 -"/ &-" %"*()% #$-# #'#-81B#-)1-" /1*&1681"1"4 /'%* "'# '&&()9 K +-881C8% 81+%B8'43 ("/%)61""%/ C2 -" %#$1&* '++')4%##1"4b-" %#$1&* #$-# 5')<* -# C'#$ ,1&)' .1"/171/(-8P C%1"4 -C8% #' 817% 51#$2'()*%8+0 -"/ ,-&)' .&'88%&#17%P C%1"4 -C8% #' 817% 1" - *'&1%#20 *&-8%*.a0b-88'5* $(,-"*#' C% +-881C8%3 #' %7'87% #$%1) *'&1-8 1/%"#1#1%*3 #' 817% 51#$ #$%1) &'"*&1%"&%3 #' /%-8 51#$I#$%1) /%,'"*:3 #' ,'7% '" +)', #$%1) 6-*# -"/ C(18/ "%5 817%*3 #' )%&'"&18% #$%1) '5"6-)-/'L%* -"/ &'"#)-/1&#1'"*3 -"/ #' C% 6-)# '+ *'&1%#29 Y1+%B8'4*3 -* #%&$"'8'41*#* -)%*%%,1"482 &'"&%171"4 #$%,3 -)% ("+')4171"4 '+ ,1*#-<%* C%&-(*% '+ #$%1) (C1f(1#'(*-"/ ,%)&18%** ,%,')2 .E-88'5-23 =>>?0A +')4%##1"4 -88'5* +')4171"49 e1#$'(# +-881C181#281+%B8'4* ,14$# "%7%) $-66%" C%&-(*% 6%'68% 5188 '66'*% #$%1) /%7%8'6,%"#9 !" #$-#*%"*%3 +')4%##1"4 ,-2 C% -" %**%"#1-8 1"4)%/1%"# #' 6%)7-*17% &',6(#1"49

D3;3%3#)3-K/%2D3 =>>F3IIO()7%188-"&% -# #$% -1)6')#P *()7%1881"4,'C181#2l,'C181*1"4 *()7%188-"&%::'()%*"(+,(!

#(- .$#((%(/ H 9C W?_H G W?@>K,1" K3 M$)1+# [3 =>>= C%!%,31 M,;%+#/%(%(/ !9, N*5#( .D'81#2 D)%**3 \-,C)1/4%0;-88 ]3 =>>?3 II\-#%4')1Q1"4 #$% 5')<%)*P %8%&#)'"1& *()7%188-"&% -"/ *'&1-8 ')/%)1"4 1" #$% &-88

&%"#%)*::3 1" B4*),%$$#(7, #3 B"7%#$ B"*!%(/1 .*%)#7&O M%3A #(- 2%/%!#$ 2%37*%+%(#!%"(R/9 N Y2'" .V'(#8%/4%3 Y'"/'"0 66 =>W G ==H

;-""'" Y3 =>>_3 II^')4%##1"4 -* - +%-#()%3 "'# - C(4P #$% /(-81#2 '+ ,%,')2 -"/ 1,681&-#1'"* +')(C1f(1#'(* &',6(#1"4:: C"2,3%/( 0 ? G WH

;%&<%) h3 WXH=3 IIO&1%"&%3 &(8#()%3 -"/ *'&1%#2::.9%$"3"89& ": B7%,(7, !E =a? G =@a;8-"&$%##% `B 3̂ `'$"*'" N E3 =>>=3 IIN-#- )%#%"#1'" -"/ #$% 6-"'6#1& *'&1%#2P #$% *'&1-8 C%"%+1#*

'+ +')4%#+(8"%**:: P9, @(:"*+#!%"( B"7%,!& !F ?? G FH;'4-)/ e3 WXX_ P9, B%+4$#!%"( ": B4*),%$$#(7,1 D&8,*7"(!*"$ %( P,$,+#!%7 B"7%,!%,3 .T!M D)%**3

\-,C)1/4%3 TK0;'5<%) E \3 =>>?3 IIM$% 6-*# -"/ #$% !"#%)"%#:: BBMC @!,+3 #(- @334,3 > =@ G ?>3

0//1$**222'AA:>'<:C*1:<C:74A*18+=6>7/6<BA 356/<:A*18+=6>7/6<BA*6/34A*<B=6B3.;.*+<2@3:;17A/'15D;(*$g3 WXFH3 IIK* 5% ,-2 #$1"<:: P9, H!$#(!%7 <"(!9$& `(82 !GC W>W G W>@3

0//1$**222'/037/=7B/6>'><4*8B+<8B5*D=7A0+@A*><418/3:*+8A0D'0/4\KVDR3 =>>F E%*3! HC<Q"*A39"8 "( C"(!%(4"43 H*79%)#$ #(- M,!*%,)#$ ": .,*3"(#$

'=8,*%,(7,3 WH U&#'C%)3 [%5m')<3 0//1$**:3A37:>0'46>:<A<D/'><4*EFGHI-&&.\8-)<% V3 WXXF3 IIM$% /141#-8 6%)*'"- -"/ 1#* -6681&-#1'" #' /-#- *()7%188-"&%:: P9, @(:"*+#!%"(

B"7%,!& !H aa G X=N%8%(Q% E3 WXX=3 IID'*#*&)16# '" #$% *'&1%#1%* '+ &'"#)'8::L7!"5,* AE ? G aN'/4% T3 ]1#&$1" V3 =>>F3 II^821"4 #$)'(4$ &'/%l*6-&%P #$% )%-8 71)#(-81#2 '+ -1) #)-7%8::

'()%*"(+,(! #(- .$#((%(/ H 9C WXH G =WWN'/4% T3 ]1#&$1" V3 =>>H3 II\'/%* '+ 81+%P 1/%"#1+1&-#1'" &'/%* -"/ #$% ,-&$1"%B)%-/-C8% 5')8/::

'()%*"(+,(! #(- .$#((%(/ 21 B"7%,!& #(- B8#7, 09 @HW G @@W

.a0 O%% -8*' ;8-"&$%##% -"/ `'$"*'":* .=>>=0 -"-82*1* '" #$% 1,6')#-"&% '+ 1"*#1#(#1'"-8 +')4%#+(8"%**#' *'&1%#-8 5%88BC%1"49

M$% %#$1&* '+ +')4%##1"4 FF?

Page 14: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

^1#Q41CC'" K3 V%1#%) R3 =>>?3 II IT%,')1%* +') 81+%:P ,-"-41"4 1"+'),-#1'" '7%) - $(,-" 81+%#1,%::NRC"+84!%(/ M,3,#*79 C"++%!!,, G*#(- C9#$$,(/, .*"8"3#$ == T-23 0//1$**222'B3A>'7>'8@*3A6*393B/A*J:7B5 E07==3BC3A*1:<1<A7=A*K34<:63A'15D

^')#2 K3 WXXX3 II!"#)'/(&#1'"::3 1" P9, H*! ": E"*/,!!%(/ R/* K ^')#23 O ](n &$8%) .;%)43 UL+')/066 W G W@

^)14' K3 =>>F3 IIO#')1"43 1"/%L1"4 -"/ )%#)1%71"4 ,2 -(#'C1'4)-6$2::3 1" .*"7,,-%(/3 ": .,*)#3%),ISST Q"*A39"8 "( <,+"*& #(- B9#*%(/ ": '=8,*%,(7,3 => K6)183g1%""-3 66 H= G H_30//1$**222'66'6A/'6'@?</<;8'7>'L1*!A846*13:97A693&.

E-88'5-2 K3 =>>?3 IIM'5-)/* #$% +')4%##1"4 ,-&$1"%:: .4*3, >%8 B64#*, U#? 5%C8'43 Wa N%&%,C%)30//1$**222'18:A3=61AM87:3L72'<:C*-&&, %- &% +=<CC3: 7:>0693A'101

E-88'5-2 K3 =>>F3 II!"#1,-#1'"* '+ %7%)2/-2 81+%P (C1f(1#'(* &',6(#1"4 -"/ #$% &1#2:: C4$!4*#$B!4-%,3 !F ?@F G F>@

E-"/2 U h3 WXX? P9, .#("8!%7 B"*!1 H ."$%!%7#$ '7"("+& ": .,*3"(#$ @(:"*+#!%"( .e%*#71%5 D)%**3;'(8/%)3 \U0

E%,,%88 3̀ Y(%/%) V3 ;%88 E3 =>>?3 IIM$% T2Y1+%;1#* Y1+%#1,% O#')%::3 1" .*"7,,-%(/3 ": HC<B@G<< ISSV Q"*A39"8 "( '=8,*%,(!%#$ P,$,8*,3,(7, W'P. ISSVX a ['7%,C%)3 ;%)<%8%230//1$**222':3A37:>0'46>:<A<D/'><4*!NJ3443==*18+A*IOH-&&,'15D

E)-$-, O3e''/ N3 =>>?3 IIN141#1*1"4 *()7%188-"&%P &-#%4')1*-#1'"3 *6-&% -"/ 1"%f(-81#2:: C*%!%7#$B"7%#$ ."$%7& 09 ==a G =F@

`'$"*'" O3 =>>?3 IIU++8'-/1"4 2'() ,%,')1%*:: P9, Y,?Z"*A P%+,3 WF N%&%,C%)3 6-4% @H30//1$**222'B?/643A'><4*-&&,*%-*%.*47C7P6B3*%."QQR"F!#SJ'0/4=

Y%2*$'" K3 M$)1+# [3 WXXX3 IIY1*#* &',% -817%P %8%&#)'"1& *2*#%,* '+ <"'58%/4% -"/ #$% )1*% '+&)%/1#B*&')1"4 1" )%#-18 C-"<1"4:: '7"("+& #(- B"7%,!& 0F F?F G F__

Y1-"'* T3 N'(48-* T3 =>>>3 IIN-"4%)1Q-#1'" -"/ #$% %"/ '+ /%71-"&%P #$% 1"*#1#(#1'"-8%"71)'",%"#:: 0*%!%39 U"4*(#$ ": C*%+%("$"/& >H =_W G =a@

Y'5%"#$-8 N3 WXXX3 IID)%+-&%::3 1" P9, H*! ": E"*/,!!%(/ R/* K ^')#23 O ](n &$8%) .;%)43 UL+')/066 L1 G L111

Y2'" N3 =>>?3 IIO()7%188-"&% -* *'&1-8 *')#1"4P &',6(#%) &'/%* -"/ ,'C18% C'/1%*::3 1" B4*),%$$#(7,#3 B"7%#$ B"*!%(/1 .*%)#7&O M%3A #(- 2%/%!#$ 2%37*%+%(#!%"( R/9 N Y2'" .V'(#8%/4%3 Y'"/'"066 W? G ?>

T&\(88-4$ N3 =>>F3 IIN-#-C-*% "-#1'"P #$% (6*1/% '+ IQ%)' 6)17-&2: ::M,#3"(<#/#[%(, _9>F3 =_ G ?H30//1$**222':37A<B'><4*L8B3;-&&.*4>>8==7C0'15D

T-"" O3 ['8-" 3̀e%88,-" ;3 =>>?3 IIO'(*7%188-"&%P 1"7%"#1"4 -"/ (*1"4 5%-)-C8% &',6(#1"4/%71&%* +') /-#- &'88%&#1'" 1" *()7%188-"&% %"71)'",%"#*:: B4*),%$$#(7, #(- B"7%,!& ! ??W G ?HH

T-)L EM3WXXX3IIT%-*()1"4 %7%)2#$1"4 #$-# ,'7%*P #$% "%5 *()7%188-"&% -# 5')<::3 1"P9,Q"*A8$#7,#(- 2,)%#(7, V%*%-)&$ 1" #$% O'&1'8'42 '+ e')<3 7'8(,% @3 R/* ! O1,6*'"3 V O1,6*'".`K! D)%**3 E)%%"51&$3 \M0 66 W_H G W@X

[-&< 3̂ =>>H3 IIY1+%8'441"4P &-6#()1"4 %7%)2 ,',%"# '+ 2'() 81+%:: @'''<4$!%+,-%# `-"(-)2 GT-)&$3F G a

D%)7-*17%>F3 =>>F .*"7,,-%(/3 ": .,*)#3%), ISST Q"*A39"8 "( <,+"*& #(- B9#*%(/ ": '=8,*%,(7,3=> K6)183g1%""-3 0//1$**222'66'6A/'6'@?</<;8'7>'L1*!A846*13:97A69&.

V-,-/-"'71& D3 =>>W3 II^)', $-("#1"4 #' #)-(,-P [1%#Q*&$%:* -&#17% +')4%##1"4 -"/ ;8-"&$'#:*5)1#1"4 '+ #$% /1*-*#%)::."3!+"-,*( C4$!4*, !! 0//1$**48A3'L08'358*L<8:B7=A*14>*9&%%*%%'-:74757B<96>'0/4=

O&$-&#%) N Y3 =>>WP9, B,),( B%(3 ": <,+"*&1 D"? !9, <%(- E"*/,!3 #(- M,+,+5,*3 .h'(4$#'"T1++81"3 ;'*#'"3 TK0

O&$'+1%8/ 3̀ =>>F3 IIh'5 #' *-7% 2'() 81+%:: P9, G4#*-%#( WX K(4(*#3 0//1$**222'C87:567B'><'8@*1:6B/*&T,)U)T.VVUV,U;%%&),WT&&'0/4=

O&$((),-" [3 =>>F3 IIN-#-C-*%* -"/ C'/1%*P - &2C')4 (6/-#%:: '()%*"(+,(! #(- .$#((%(/ H 9CW??a G W?F>

O%81"4' 3̀ =>>F3 IIe$'*% /-#- 1* 1#3 -"25-2i:: P9, Y,?Z"*A P%+,3 ? `("%3 0//1$**222'B?/643A'><4*-&&.*&(*&,*/3>0B<=<C?*>6:>86/A*&,57/7'0/4=

O#%)81"4 ;3 WXXa D"$& E%*, .E'88-"&Q3 Y'"/'"0M$)1+# [3 =>>F3 IIT'7%,%"#B*6-&%P #$% &$-"41"4 /',-1" '+ #$1"<1"4 )%*(8#1"4 +)', #$% /%7%8'6,%"#

'+ "%5 <1"/* '+ *6-#1-8 -5-)%"%**:: '7"("+& #(- B"7%,!& 99 H@= G _>FM$)1+# [3 ^)%"&$ O3 =>>=3 IIM$% -(#',-#1& 6)'/(&#1'" '+ *6-&%:: P*#(3#7!%"(3 ": !9, @(3!%!4!, ":

0*%!%39 G,"/*#89,*3O Y,? B,*%,3 0G ?>X G ??HM188 V3 h-"/ N3 =>>?3 II;%$-71')-8 ,'/%8* '+ &)%/1# &-)/ (*-4%:: U"4*(#$ ": H88$%,- B!#!%3!%73 9H

W=>W G W==>

FFF T N'/4%3 V ]1#&$1"

Page 15: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

M51*# 3̀ =>>F3 II I;8-&< C'L:&-, +') #'#-8 )%&-88::00CY,?3L($%(,WH `("%3 0//1$**222'B32A'++>'><'8@*%*06*/3>0B<=<C?*,WVWU)%'A/4

7-" N1J&< 3̀ =>>H3 II^)', *$'%C'L #' 6%)+'),-#17% -4%"#P #$% &',6(#%) -* 6%)*'"-8 ,%,')2,-&$1"%::Y,? <,-%# #(- B"7%,!& G ?WW G ??=

e%)<$'7%" D3 =>>F '=8,*%,(7, <#79%(,31 C#8!4*%(/ #(- M,!*%,)%(/ .,*3"(#$ C"(!,(! RB&'"#%"#V%6')# X3 K\M%[3 K(4(*#3 0//1$**222'7>/3B'B3/

e18/% U3 WX@@ P9, .%7!4*, ": 2"*%#( G*#& .e e [')#'"3 [%5 m')<03 ')141"-882 6(C81*$%/ W@XWe-)/3 Y'&< o \'93 Y'"/'"

e1881-,* Y3e''/ ]3 =>>F3 IIO%"*%\-,P K 6$'#'4)-6$1& ,%,')2 +') %7%)2'"%::<%7*"3":! M,3,#*79C#+5*%-/,L8,(2#& X `("%3 0//1$**222':3A37:>0'46>:<A<D/'><4*02A?A/34A*X3BA3E74"93:9632*18+=6>'11A

e')/*5')#$e3 W@>a L-,1 @(!%+#!%"(3 ": @++"*!#$%!& :*"+ M,7"$$,7!%"(3 ": '#*$& C9%$-9""-0//1$**36:'=6+:7:?'8/<:<B/<'>7*:1<*56A1=7?*1<34-,U-'0/4=

p =>>a - D1'" 6(C81&-#1'" 6)1"#%/ 1" E)%-# ;)1#-1"

M$% %#$1&* '+ +')4%##1"4 FFH

Page 16: Outlines of a World Coming Into Existence-Pervasive Computing and the Ethics of Forgetting-Martin Dodge e Rob Kitchin

!"#$%&%"#' "( )'*+ !"#$ %&'#()* +%, -* ./01)/%.*. 2&/+ '"* 345 0*-$#'* 2/& 6*&$/1%) &*$*%&("-, +*+-*&$ /2 $7-$(&#-#18 /&8%1#$%'#/1$9 !"#$ 5:; +%, 1/' -* 6)%(*. /1 %1, 0*-$#'* </& /'"*&/1)#1* .#$'&#-7'#/1 $,$'*+= 0#'"/7' 6*&+#$$#/1 /2 '"* 67-)#$"*&9