noaa workshop on u.s. export controls june 7-9, 2011 – hchb june 28-30, 2011 - seattle
TRANSCRIPT
NOAA Workshop on U.S. Export Controls
June 7-9, 2011 – HCHBJune 28-30, 2011 - Seattle
June 2011 2
U.S. Department of CommerceBureau of Industry and Security
Deemed Export Compliance
Bernard KritzerDirectorOffice of Exporter [email protected]
June 2011 3
Agenda• Export Controls Overview• How to Classify Items on the Commerce Control List• Foreign National Visitor and Guest Access Program• Deemed Exports Overview• NOAA Deemed Export Compliance Program• Exercises• Show how to navigate and use the EAR• Threat Briefing – Office of Export Enforcement• ITAR Overview
June 2011 4
BIS is here to help!
• Outreach Activities• Exporter Counseling• Advisory Opinions• Commodity Classifications• Compliance Strategies
June 2011 5
Need Assistance?
Bureau of Industry and Security Ph. (202) 482-4811Outreach & Educational Services Fax (202) 482-2927
14th St. & Pennsylvania Ave. NWWashington, DC 20230
Western Regional Offices3300 Irvine Avenue, Suite 345 Ph. (949) 660-0144Newport Beach, CA 92660 Fax (949) 660-
9347
96 North 3rd Street, Suite 250 Ph. (408) 291-4212
San Jose, CA 95112 Fax (408) 291-4320
June 2011 6
7June 2011
Bureau of Industry and Security■ Bureau Mission: to advance
U.S. national security, foreign policy, and economic interests
Statutory Authority: Export Administration Act (EAA) of 1979, as amended; International Emergency Economic Powers Act, as amended
Responsibilities: BIS is responsible for implementing and enforcing the Export Administration Regulations (EAR), which regulate the export and reexport of most commercial and dual-use items.
8June 2011
The Threat
■ Dangers of illegal technology transfers are very real:
‑ WMD Proliferation
‑ Weapon Design/Manufacture
‑ Industrial Espionage
■ U.S. economy damaged by illegal technology transfers.
9June 2011
The Threat■ Significance: Both national security and U.S. economy can be seriously damaged by illegal technology transfers.
■ Damage to the economy can include loss of large amounts of proprietary R&D done over many years.
■ Loss of proprietary R&D can result in the establishment and/or enhancement of foreign competitors in leading edge technology sectors.
10June 2011
Origin of the Threat
■ U.S. Intelligence Community has noted: Collection and acquisition activities from
over 56 foreign nations 13 countries assessed to be most aggressive
collectors of U.S. proprietary economic information and critical technologies
Use of clandestine and illegal methods to collect technology
U.S. private sector studies estimate loss in the billions every year
11June 2011
What is being targeted?
Nationally Biotechnology Pharmaceuticals Nanotechnology Quantum Computing Advanced Materials Communications and Encryption Technology Weapons Systems yet unclassified
12June 2011
Methods Used to Target Technology
Unsolicited emails
Front companies
Liaisons with universities that have ties to defense contractors
Recruitment by foreign intelligence services
National laboratories
Compromise of laptop while traveling overseas
Attending/Hosting conferences
Relocating R&D facilities overseas
Circumventing export control laws
Visiting scientific and research delegations
Hacking
Downloading information from your network
13June 2011
Deemed Export Enforcement Facts
■ Since 2004, Export Enforcement has closed over 120 investigations, involving a deemed export. Many of these investigations resulted in action being taken or the issuance of a warning letter.
Since 2004, BIS has issued 19 final orders in 17 investigations involving deemed export violations. This has resulted in over $2 million in fines.
Approximately one-half of the cases involved Voluntary Self- Disclosures (VSDs) and both commodity and technology exports.
Eight cases involved deemed export violations alone.
Most violations involved unauthorized transfers of Category 3 (Electronics) and Category 5 (telecommunications).
14June 2011
Key Compliance Issues Since 2004, a central theme that has been identified in the
course of over 120 investigations of deemed exports has been the poor communications or disconnect between the key compliance actors in the private sector:
1) Export Compliance Personnel
2) Human Resources
3) Hiring Managers There were also issues surrounding foreign visitors and
the need for enhanced compliance training.
This is significant for high technology companies because the investigations identified the fact that many companies maintained effective programs for commodities but that it did not carry over in the area of technology.
15June 2011
Technology Control Plan (TCP)
■ The key to technology export compliance is an effective Technology Control Plan.
■ A TCP should contain the following essential elements:
• Management commitment to export compliance• Physical security plan• Information security plan• Personnel screening procedures• Training and awareness program• Self-evaluation program
■ Meaningful compliance is “win-win” because it protects national security and allows a company to protect its proprietary technical data essential to R&D and bringing new products to market timely.
16June 2011
Key Points for Discussion Successful deemed export compliance
incorporate commodities and technologies.
Successful deemed export compliance also represents management’s commitment to a holistic approach, involving successful interaction between the key stakeholders--export compliance personnel, hiring managers, and human resources.
Rarely have we seen a deemed exporter fail that established and maintained a strong TCP, successful interaction between internal stakeholders, and meaningful annual assessments of its program.
17June 2011
Key Points for Discussion The cost of such compliance is small given
the potential downside loss of millions of dollars of proprietary technology and compromises to national security.
Meaningful deemed export compliance also requires an active partnership between government and all affected stakeholders.
Overview of the Export Administration Regulations
(EAR)
Mr. Douglas BellSenior Export Counselor
Office of Exporter Services
June 2011 19
BIS Mission
• To advance U.S. national security, foreign policy, and economic interests.
– BIS is responsible for implementing and enforcing the Export Administration Regulations (EAR), which regulate the export and reexport of most commercial items.
June 2011 20
How Do We Control Exports?
Statutory Authority
• Export Administration Act (EAA) of 1979, as amended
• International Emergency Economic Powers Act, as amended
June 2011 21
Broad jurisdiction BUT… narrow license requirements
Export Administration Regulations (EAR)
• Implement the Export Administration Act
• Apply to most commercial items
June 2011 22
Where can you find the EAR
• Code of Federal Regulations– 15 CFR 730-774– www.gpoaccess.gov
• Available on-line:– www.bis.doc.gov
• Order from Government Printing Office– 866-512-1800 (toll-free)– www.access.gpo.gov
June 2011 23
Why Do We Control Exports?
• National Security• Foreign Policy
– Anti-terrorism– Crime control– Regional Stability
• Non Proliferation– Nuclear weapons– Chemical/biological weapons– Missiles
June 2011 24
Who Else is Involved in Export Controls?Other Regulatory Agencies
Part 730, Supplement 3
• US Dept. of State - Directorate of Defense Trade Controls (ITAR)
• US Dept. of Treasury - Office of Foreign Assets Control
• US Dept. of Energy
• Nuclear Regulatory Commission
• US Dept. of Commerce – Patent & Trademark Office
• US Department of Interior
• Food and Drug Administration
• U.S. Department of Commerce –records) Bureau of the Census (trade statistics and SEDs/AES
• U.S. Department of Homeland Security – Border and Transportation Security– U.S. Customs Service (works with BIS to ensure compliance)
June 2011 25
Important EAR Terms
• Dual-Use• Item• Export• Reexport• Deemed export/reexport• Commerce Control List (CCL)• Export Control Classification Number (ECCN)
June 2011 26
Dual-use Items
• Items that have both commercial and military or proliferation applications.
• This term is often used informally to describe items that are subject to the EAR.
June 2011 27
What is an item?Part 772
June 2011 28
What is an export?
• An export is a shipment or transmission of items
out of the United States.
June 2011 29
What is a deemed export?
• The release of technology or source code to foreign national in the US is deemed to be an export.
June 2011 30
What is a reexport?
• A reexport is a shipment or transmission of items subject to the EAR from one foreign country to another.
June 2011 31
Technology and Software Exports and Reexports
• Include transfers regardless of the method or media– Consultations– Phone conversations– Instruction– Conferences– Application of knowledge– Visual inspections– Disks, blueprints, hardcopy, etc.– Internet, E-mail, Fax
June 2011 32
Other Important Concepts
• Commerce Control List (“CCL”)
• Export Control Classification Number (“ECCN”)
June 2011 33
What does “Subject to the EAR” mean?§734.2(a)
Items and activities under the regulatory jurisdiction of the EAR– Remember there are other government
agencies that administer export controls
“Subject to EAR” does not mean that a license is automatically required
June 2011 34
What is “Subject to the EAR?”§§734.3-734.5
• Items in the United States
• Some items located outside of the United States
• Activities of U.S. and Foreign Persons
June 2011 35
What is “Subject to the EAR”? Items in the United States
§734.3(a)(1)
• ALL Items in the United States, except: – Publicly available technology & software (excluding
encryption)– Items subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of
another federal department or agency– Literary publications, such as newspapers or
literary works (non-technical in nature)
June 2011 36
What is “Subject to the EAR”? Items Outside the United States
§734.3
• Some items located outside the United States:– U.S.-origin items wherever located– Certain foreign-made items, if:
• The value of the U.S. content exceeds the de minimis percentage
• The foreign-product item is the direct product of U.S. technology or software
June 2011 37
Overview-Summary
• BIS regulates exports, reexports and certain transfers of items subject to the EAR in addition to certain activities of U.S. persons.
• Important terms: Items, export, reexport, deemed export, CCL & ECCN
• First order of business is to determine whether or not your transaction is subject to the EAR.
Classification of Items on the Commerce Control List
Darrell SpiresSenior Electronics Engineer
Office of Nonproliferation and Technology Transfer Controls
June 2011 39
Topics of Discussion
• Determining the Export Control Classification Number (“ECCN”)– The Commerce Control List (“CCL”)
• Self-Classification• Official Commodity Classification Request
– SNAP-R
June 2011 40
Commerce Control List (“CCL”)Part 774, Supplement No. 1
• Contains lists of those items subject to the licensing authority of BIS
• Each entry is called an Export Control Classification Number (“ECCN”)
• Most items are described in terms of their technical parameters
June 2011 41
What does Export Control Classification Number (“ECCN”) tell us?
Part 772
• What items are controlled?• Why BIS controls the item?• Which destinations will require a license?
– Country Chart in Supp. 1 to part 738, • What (if any) list-based license exception
applies?
June 2011 42
The Structure of the ECCN
0 A 018
0 Category
A Product Group
018 Type of Control
June 2011 43
Categories of the Commerce Control List
0 Miscellaneous & Nuclear Materials
1Materials, Chemicals, Microorganisms, and Toxins
2 Materials Processing
3 Electronics
4 Computers
5 Part 1-Telecommunication
5 Part 2- I nformation Security
6 Sensors & Lasers
7 Navigation & Avionics
8 Marine
9 Aerospace & Propulsion
0 A 018
June 2011 44
Product Groups of the Commerce Control List
A Systems, Equipment & Components
B Test, I nspection & Production Equipment
C Materials
D Software
E Technology
0 A 018
June 2011 45
Type of Controls Associated with Entry
0 National Security Reasons
1 Missile Technology Reasons
2 Nuclear Nonproliferation Reasons
3 Chemical & Biological Weapons Reasons
9
Anti-terrorism
Crime Control
Regional Stability
Short Supply
UN SanctionsSurreptitious Listening
0 A 018
June 2011 46
Most of the time related items are grouped in series
Equipment, assemblies
and components
Test, inspection
and production equipment
Software
Technology
Materials
June 2011 47
How to Read an ECCN entry
• Number and Heading• License Requirements
– Reasons For Control• License Exceptions (List-based)• List of Items Controlled
– Units– Related Controls– Related Definitions– Items
June 2011 48
How to Read an ECCN
Heading:
ECCN & Descriptio
n
June 2011 49
How to Read an ECCN
License Requirement
s:
Reasons for Control
June 2011 50
How to Read an ECCN
License Exceptions
:
List-Based
June 2011 51
How to Read an ECCN
List of Items
Controlled:
Units
Related Controls
Related Definitions
Items
June 2011 52
June 2011 53
Technology and Software Classification
• Review Commerce Control List (CCL)• Identify Export Control Classification
Number (ECCN)• In most cases, technology tied
directly to hardware “development”, “production”, or “use”
• Refer to General Technology and Software Notes (Supplement No. 2 to Part 774)
June 2011 54
General Technology Note
The export of “technology” that is “required” for the “development”, “production”, or “use” of items on the Commerce Control List is controlled according to the provisions in each category.
June 2011 55
5A101
5D101
5E101
Technology and Software ECCNs
Telemetry Equipment
Telemetry Software
Telemetry Technology
Product Groups D and E
3A292
3D292
3E292
Digital Oscilloscope
Oscilloscope Software
Oscilloscope Technology
The deemed export rule affects technology and software.
The deemed export rule affects technology and software.
Deemed Export ECCNs
Analog-digital conversion, greater than 1 giga-sample per second, 8 bits or greater resolution, stores 256 or more samples
Production, development or use technology is controlled
June 2011 57
Technology and Software Terms
• Development
• Production
• Use
• Required
June 2011 58
"Development"• "Development" is related to all
stages prior to serial production, such as: design, design research, design analyses, design concepts, assembly and testing of prototypes, pilot production schemes, design data, process of transforming design data into a product, configuration design, integration design, layouts
June 2011 59
"Production"• Means all production stages, such as:
product engineering, manufacture, integration, assembly (mounting), inspection, testing, quality assurance.
June 2011 60
"Use"• Operation, installation (including
on‑site installation), maintenance (checking), repair, overhaul and refurbishing.
June 2011 61
"Required"• As applied to "technology" or
"software", refers to only that portion of "technology" or "software" which is peculiarly responsible for achieving or extending the controlled performance levels, characteristics or functions. Such "required" "technology" or "software" may be shared by different products.
June 2011 62
EAR99 Items• Items that are not specifically listed on the
Commerce Control List yet subject to the EAR, use the designation EAR99 in place of an ECCN.
• This designation may be found at the end of every category of the CCL:
“EAR99 Items subject to the EAR that are notelsewhere specified in this CCL Category or inany other category in the CCL are designated
by the number EAR99.”
June 2011 63
How can you obtain the ECCN of your item?
1. Ask the manufacturer, but verify…
2. Self-classify
• Work with company engineer or someone who knows the item
3. Submit formal classification request to BIS
June 2011 64
An Approach to Self-Classifying Items
• Do an index comparison (good starting point)
You need to understand the functions & characteristics of the item!
June 2011 65
How to Request a Classification File using SNAP-R (or BIS-748-P)
• “Best guess” ECCN• Maximum of six items per request• Item details
– Manufacturer– Model/Part number– Applications– Specifications
• Include detailed technical specifications– Pictorial illustration, e.g. sales brochures
Commodity Jurisdiction Process 22 CFR 120.4(b)
• Determines if items are controlled on the U.S. Munitions List (Department of State) or the Commerce Control List (Department of Commerce)
• Criteria 22 CFR 120.3– Is the item specifically designed, developed, configured,
adapted, or modified for a military application?– Does the tem have a predominant civil application?– Does the item have a performance equivalent to those of an
article or service used for civil application?– Is the item designed for military application and has
significant military or intelligence applicability?
• The CJ application is reviewed by the Departments of Defense, State, and Commerce. Defense and Commerce recommend, State makes the final decision
June 2011 66
June 2011 67
Classification- Summary
Determining an ECCN1. Check with the Manufacturer
2. Work with company engineer/someone who knows the item• CCL is organized in a logical manner • ECCN entries are based on the technical
parameters of an item and contain a wealth of information regarding export controls
3. Submit formal classification request to BIS
Determining License Requirements based on ECCN
and Destination
Darrell SpiresSenior Electronics Engineer
Office of National Security and Technology Transfer Control
June 2011 69
Commerce Country ChartPart 738, Supplement No. 1
• Reasons for Control/Country Chart• If there is:
– “X” in the box indicates a license requirement– No “X” in the box indicates no license
requirement
June 2011 70
Structure Commerce Country ChartWhen the Destination and the Reason for Control Meet, Ask Yourself…
Is there an “X” in the box?
June 2011 71
No License Required
(“NLR”)
• You may use NLR for:– EAR99 items, or– ECCNs where there is no “X” on the Country Chart
under reason(s) for control; and– When the transaction does not require an export
license based on any other licensing requirement (e.g., end-use/user requirements)
June 2011 72
Summary-Determining Licensing Requirements based on ECCN & Destination
• “X” in the box indicates a license requirement
• No “X” in the box indicates no license requirement
License Exceptions
Mr. Douglas BellSenior Export Counselor
Office of Exporter Services
June 2011 74
There is an “X” in the Box…
What do I do?
June 2011 75
Topics of Discussion
• What is a License Exception?
• Restrictions
• List Based License Exceptions
June 2011 76
What is a License Exception?Part 740
An authorization that allows you to export or reexport, under stated conditions, items subject to the EAR that would otherwise require a license.
June 2011 77
When can’t you use a License Exception?
§740.2• Authorization has been suspended or revoked• Export subject to a General Prohibition that is
not eligible for License Exceptions.• Surreptitious Interception Devices • Crime control items to most destinations• Most Missile Technology control items• Embargoed destinations, in most instances
For Full list Refer to §740.2
June 2011 78
The way the EAR sees the world…
Country Groups Supplement 1 to Part 740
Group A: Regime Members
Group B: Less Restricted
Group D: Countries of Concern
Group E: Terrorist Supporting
June 2011 79
Some of the possibleLicense Exceptions…
Availability Based on transaction details - Shipments to US Government employees (GOV)– Civil End Users (CIV)– Repair, Replace or Service Items (RPL)– Technology and Software Restricted (TSR)– Baggage (BAG)
June 2011 80
Shipments to US Government Personnel
§740.11
• Shipments to USG employees either military or civilian
• Items for personal use or official capacity• Also includes agencies of cooperating
governments found in Country Group A:1 and Argentina, Austria, Finland, Hong Kong, Ireland, New Zealand, Singapore, South Korea, Sweden, Switzerland, and Taiwan.
GOV
June 2011 81
CIV Civil End-Users §740.5
• Country Group D:1, except North Korea
• Items that require a license to the ultimate destination for national security reasons only
• Civil end-uses and end-users– No military or proliferation
end-users/uses
June 2011 82
RPL Replacement, Repair and Servicing of Equipment
§740.10
• All Destinations with some restrictions• Commodities• One-for-one replacement of a legally
exported item• Not to be used to stockpile inventory• Servicing of the item can not enhance
capabilities
June 2011 83
TSR Technology & Software Under Restriction
§740.6
• Country Group B
• Technology & software requiring a license to the ultimate destination for national security reasons only
• Prior to use, written assurance required from consignee
June 2011 84
TSR Written Assurance
• Letter, other written communication, licensing agreement, fax
• No written assurance -- No TSR
BAG Baggage §740.14
• Personal Effects
• Household effects
• Tools of the Trade
June 2011 85
TMP Temporary Imports, Exports and Re-exports §740.9
• Exhibitions or Demonstrations
• Tools of the Trade
• Must Return to US within one year
June 2011 86
June 2011 87
Summary-License Exceptions
• Make sure your export requires a license (i.e. there is an “X” in the box), before reviewing the License Exceptions.
• Before going to a specific license exception, make sure there are no restrictions.
• Each exception is unique, make sure you meet all of the criteria.
Douglas BellSenior Export Counselor
Office of Exporter Services
Deemed Exports
June 2011 89
Deemed Exports: Definition
• Release of • technology or source code • that is subject to the EAR • to a foreign national • in the United States (EAR
§ 734.2(b)(2)(ii)). • Release is “deemed” to be an export to foreign national’s home country
June 2011 90
Technology or Source Code Possible Release Methods
• Tours of laboratories
• Research, development, & manufacturing activities
• Foreign students or scholars conducting research
• Hosting a foreign scientist
June 2011 91
Deemed Export Rule Does Not Apply To:
• United States Citizens;• Permanent Resident Aliens (i.e., “Green Card” holders); and• Protected individuals under 8 U.S.C.
1324b(a)(3). Protected individuals include political refugees and political asylum holders.
June 2011 92
Country of Origin(Permanent Residency)
Release of technology to a foreign national of one country, say India, who has obtained permanent residency in another, say the U.K., is treated as if the technology transfer were being made to the U.K. and licensing requirements would be the same as for a British national in the U.K.
If the Indian national becomes a British citizen, transfers of technology would be viewed as transfers to the U.K.
June 2011 93
If an Indian foreign national becomes a citizen of the U.K. but retains Indian citizenship, the most recent citizenship is with the U.K. and releases of technology would be viewed as releases to the U.K.
As a general principle, a foreign national’s most recently obtained citizenship governs the licensing requirement.
Country of Origin(Dual Citizenship)
June 2011 94
Deemed ExportsLicense Requirements
• Is the technology (or source code) subject the EAR?
• Is a license required?
June 2011 95
Technology Not Subject to the EAR
• Publicly available (EAR § 734.7)• Generally accessible to the interested
public• Periodicals, books, print, electronic
other media forms• Libraries (university, public etc)• Released at open conferences
June 2011 96
Technology Not Subject to the EAR
• Product of fundamental research (EAR § 734.8)• Basic and applied research where resulting information is ordinarily published and broadly shared within scientific community
June 2011 97
Technology Not Subject to the EAR
• Educational information (EAR § 734.9)• Released by instruction in catalog courses• Associated teaching laboratories of academic
institutions
• Patent information (EAR § 734.10)• Public information available on patent
application
June 2011 98
Technology Not Subject to the EAR (Cont.)
• Technology subject to the exclusive export licensing jurisdiction of another agency• Directorate of Defense Trade
Controls• Nuclear Regulatory Commission• Department of Energy
June 2011 99
License Exceptions Specifically for Deemed Exports
CIV: Civil End Use (EAR § 740.5)
ECCN 3E002 technology.
Requires Foreign National Review
TSR: Technology and Software Under Restriction (EAR § 740.6)
Applies to technology and software under national security only for country group “B” nationals.
Letter of assurance required
June 2011 100
Deemed Export License Requirements
• Usually Commerce Control List Based• Other license requirements based on
• End use• Embargoed destinations• Entity List
June 2011 101
Deemed Export License Requirements
• Classify the commodity • Second character of ECCN will be A, B or
C• Look for a related software (D) or
technology (E) ECCN usually in the same category
• Most software and technology ECCNs apply to software or technology for “development,” “production,” or “use.”
June 2011 102
BIS - Application Review• Verify classification of technology• Review licensing requirements & license
exceptions based on home country• Assess appropriateness of job description,
responsibility, title • Assess appropriateness of education level
and field to technology & end-use • Determine reasons for control for correct
referrals
June 2011 103
Foreign National Review (FNR)Sections 740.5
• Applicant must submit FNR request before disclosing technology under license exception CIV.
• Request must provide same information on the foreign national as a license application.
• Faster review than license applications
June 2011 104
Deemed Export Contacts
Deemed Exports and Electronics Division
Brian Baker Kurt FranzDirector Senior Export Policy
Analyst202-482-5534 [email protected] [email protected]
Bob JusteSenior Electrical [email protected]