Adam Edwards and Vanessa Hill

Sept 2014

Information Literacy SkillsLondon Health Libraries

Welcome

09.30-10.00 Refreshments

10:00-10:45 What makes a bad workshop?

10:45-11:00 Break

11:00-13:00 The Winner takes it all

13:00-14:00 Lunch

14:00-15:45 Create a game

15:45-16:00 Questions

16:00 Close

What makes a bad workshop?

http://www.flickr.com/photos/webtreatsetc/4869256777/

Solutions

Enhancing the quality and impact of Library Workshops

Adam Edwards and Vanessa Hill June 2014

The winner takes it all

Knowing me, knowing you

• Issues

• Collaboration

• Inspiration

• Solutions

• Impact

SOS

• Not embedded

• Inconsistent provision

• Repetitive

• Bad timing

• Information skills

• Teaching methods

Librarians and teaching

• Relevance• Too much• Tools based• Didactic• Uninspiring• Subject• Teaching skills

http://www.flickr.com/photos/vicchi/4079403111/

Gimme, Gimme, Gimme

•Answers

•Facts

•References

•Reporting back

•Easy option

•Fear

Librarians reinforce this!

http://www.flickr.com/photos/nottsexminer/6270679714/

ArrivalTeaching qualifications:

• PGCertHE @ MDX• Teaching Fellowships• FHEA• TESOL

Benefits:• Equivalent• Learning together• Language• Respect• Understanding

Björn Again

• Less is more

• Cloning

• Discussion

• Learning by doing

• Learners, not the taught

• Gameshttp://advedupsyfall09.wikispaces.com/Sara+Woodard

The name of the game

• Fun

• Quick

• Simple

• Easy

• Need or objective

Adapted from Susan Boyle, Lilac 2011

I have a dream

Move from

“ …lifting and transporting textual substance from one location, the library, to another, their teacher’s briefcases.”

To

“…searching, analyzing, evaluating, synthesizing, selecting, rejecting…”

Kleine 1987

Super Troupers

• School plan

• Mapping

• Structure

• Menu

Greatest Hits

• Thinking about resources

• Keywords

• Searching

• Evaluation

Example of coursework marking criteria

10% Introduction

15% Overview

30% Critical analysis

15% Discussion

10% Conclusion

10% Referencing

10% Quality etc

Maximum marks for a well referenced and accurate description of [subject] using suitable references

Maximum of 10 marks for a list of references which is both relevant, and correctly given in Harvard style

Maximum of 10 marks for quality, style of writing and presentation

Thinking about resources

BooksWhat are they:

A written or printed work of fiction or fact.

May be electronic.

Good for:

Clear overview.

Not so good for:

Up to date information.

JournalWhat are they:

A regular publication containing articles on a particular academic subject.

Presents new research.

Good for:

Latest research, critically reviewed by experts.

Not so good for:

Broad overview of a subject.

Web page

What are they:

An information resource which can be easily created by anyone on any topic.

Electronic.

Good for:

Very up to date information.

Not so good for:

Accurate and reliable information.

NewspaperWhat are they:

A regular publication containing current events, informative articles, diverse features and advertising.

May be electronic.

Good for:

Daily information.

Not so good for:

Balanced and well researched information.

Popular (trade) journalWhat are they:

A regular publication containing new products plus information for a business sector.

Good for:

Latest product news.

Not so good for:

Detailed and objective reports.

Find out moreMyUniHub > MyStudy > MyLibrary > Library Subject Guides

http://libguides.mdx.ac.uk/EIS

Thinking about keywords

http://www.flickr.com/photos/rossjamesparker/89414788/

The real thing

http://www.flickr.com/photos/sidelong/300188454/

Your first piece of coursework for CCM2426 will be based on the Cornish Villages 4G trial.

• Keywords

• Alternative keywords

• More specific keywords

• Related subjects

Finding resourcesmyUniHub > My Study > My Library > Summon

Select Summon and search for information for your project

Google vs Summon

http://www.flickr.com/photos/ennuiislife/3450743002/

Google

• Familiar and easy to use

• Finds too much information

• Fast results

• Access from any computer

• Access to some books and journals

• Designed to sell you things

• Search results sponsored

• Searches for info from any source

• Pay for academic information

Summon

• Easy to use

• Finds lots of academic info

• Fast results

• Access from any computer

• Access to lots of books and journals

• Designed to find you information

• Search results by relevance

• Searches quality resources

• Free access to full text

Evaluating information

Evaluating information

Imagine you are writing an essay on ‘Network Security’.

Have a look at the 4 items that you have been given and consider the following:

• Which items are the most relevant to your essay?

• Which items would be no use?

• Which item has the most academic authority?

• Which items might have bias?

• Which item is the most current?

• Authority

• Relevance

• Intent

• Objectivity

• Currency

Evaluating information

How are books arranged in the library?

004.19 PRE

Books are arranged…..

Co

mp

uti

ng

Des

ign

De

sig

n

Des

ign

An

imal

s

An

imal

s

An

imal

s

Co

mp

uti

ng

Co

mp

uti

ng

His

tory

His

tory

History

004.19 ABE 004.19 CR0 004.19 PRE

Take a chance on me

Marks Attendees Non-attendees

Commonest mark 65% 50%

Highest mark 90% 75%

Lowest mark 40% 40%

Bibliography commonest mark

7/10 5/10

• Survey of CCM2426 students

• 66 attendees, 22 non-attendees

“If you put me to the test, if you let me try………”

Search tools used Attendees Non-attendees

Google 68% 63%

Wikipedia 38% 27%

Summon 68% 40%

Library catalogue 30% 59%

Evaluation criteria Attendees Non-attendees

Current 89% 59%

Relevant 76% 59%

Academic authority 67% 41%

Easy to read 24% 45%

On and on and on

• Develop activities

• Improve attendance

• Revalidation

• Moodle

• DProf

The winner takes it all

• Successful collaboration

• Changes have worked

• Teaching is more fun

• Impact…

...Library training gets you better marks!

When all is said and done• Boyle, S. (2011) Using games to enhance information literacy

sessions, Presented at LILAC 2011. http://www.slideshare.net/infolit_group/boyle-using-games-to-enchance-information-literacy

• Kleine, M. (1987), What is it we do when we write articles like this one-Or how can we get students to join us?, Writing Instructor 6, 151.

• Markless, S., (2010), Teaching information literacy in HE: What? Where? How?, presented at King’s College London, 9/12/10. [Notes taken at the event.]

http://bit.ly/GamesMDX

http://www.flickr.com/photos/naturalturn/3264726560/

Mamma Mia it’s……………

Create a game• Reflect on our games

• Think about games you know

• Brainstorm ideas

• Create game (1 hour)

• Complete form

• Prepare presentation (15 mins)

• 5 min presentation

Adapted from Susan Boyle, Lilac 2011

http://www.flickr.com/photos/ajourneyroundmyskull/4788590225/

Adam Edwardsa.edwards@mdx.ac.uk

Vanessa Hillv.hill@mdx.ac.uk