Made in the WorldFrom Trade in Goods to Trade in Tasks

andreas.maurer@wto.org

Boeing Dreamliner 787

Source: Graphic News

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704828104576021142902413796.html

ProcessorsProcessors, €34, 6%, €34, 6%

MemoriesMemories, €15, 3%, €15, 3%

Integr.circuitsIntegr.circuits, €32, 6%, €32, 6%

DisplayDisplay, €22, 4%, €22, 4%

Camera Camera (5 mp), €17, 3%(5 mp), €17, 3%

Other partsOther parts, €59, 11%, €59, 11%

LicensesLicenses, €21, 4%, €21, 4%

Nokia’s Nokia’s operating operating profitprofit, €89, 16%, €89, 16%

Final assembly, €11, 2%

DistributionDistribution, €19, 4%, €19, 4%

Value addedValue addedin Nokia’sin Nokia’sinternalinternalsupportsupportfnsfns, €169, 31%, €169, 31%

(Excl. Operating profit & (Excl. Operating profit & assembly listed below) assembly listed below)

RetailingRetailing, €60, 11%, €60, 11%

Who Captures Value in GlobalSupply Chains?

Case Nokia N95

Source:Jyrki Ali-Yrkkö, Petri Rouvinen, Timo Seppälä & Pekka Ylä-Anttila

ETLA, The Research Institute of the Finnish Economy

Smiley Face (Source: Business Week International online extra, May 16, 2005, Stan Shih on

Taiwan and China)

Higher Added-value and Lower

Replacement

Marketing

Brand

Innovation

DesignR&D

R&D/Innovation Centre

Value Creation

Standardisation

InnovationR&D

Design

AddedValue

Manufacture

Assembly

Logistics

Marketing

Brand

StandardisationValue-added process

Global Logistics Center

Logistics

AssemblyManufacture

7

MIWI website

Trade patterns and global

value chains in East Asia :From Trade in Goods to Trade in Tasks

andreas.maurer@wto.org

Global production chains – Ins and outs

International consumer demand

Export processing zones

Development of infrastructure and technological progress

Lower applied tariffs and trade policy incentives

Outsourcing and offshoring strategies and FDI

Emergence of “Trade in tasks”:

Need for new statistical measures of international trade

Global production chains and world trade

• Dominance of trade in intermediate goods

• Development of intra-firm trade

• Increase of processing trade

Asian economies have relatively low applied tariffs on imports (especially on semi-processed goods)

Source: WTO

Export processing zones account for about 20% of total merchandise exports of developing economies

Sources: ILO & WTO

(2006 or most recent year): economies with EPZs

Asia is the most attractive FDI destination in the developing regions

Source: UNCTAD

(Billions of US$)

… Confirming that:•Asia is the “World manufacturer”•Asian supply chains boost the regional markets•Asian economies present a high degree of industrial specialization

Key facts on Asia trade in intermediate goods …

•Asia’s share in world exports of intermediate goods increases : 35% in 2009•Intra-Asian trade is predominant•Asia imports more intermediate goods than it exports•Intermediate goods traded by Asian economies are more and more sophisticated •More and more concentrated trade on few components

Intermediate goods dominate world non-fuel merchandise exports

Source: UNSD & WTO2009 value

Billi

ons

of U

S$

Towards a new measure of international trade

• Traditional statistics present some biases:– Multi-counting of trade flows in intermediate goods– Difficult attribution of the country of origin of an imported

product

• Measuring trade in value added terms allows:– To circumvent the biases observed with traditional statistics– To take into account the specificity of trade occurring between

the different actors of a production chain

Computers and electronic equipmentexports and their domestic and imported contents

(in billions of $ and percentage)

Source: WTO, based on IDE-JETRO Asian Input-Output tables

United States-China trade balanceTraditional versus VA measure (in billions of US$)

Sources: UN Comtrade Database, IDE-JETRO AIO table and WTO estimates

Summary of the benefits of trade in value added analysis

• A better evaluation of the actual contribution of international trade to an economy

(incl. development, employment, environment)

• To highlight the interdependency of economies, and the counter-productive effects of protectionist measures on economies and enterprises they are supposed to protect

• Better evaluation of the contribution of the services sector on trade

• Conventional trade statistics need complement for analysing value added – data gaps and how can they be closed (TEC, WIOD, OECD/WTO)

http://www.wto.org/english/res_e/statis_e/miwi_e/miwi_e.htm