APNIC 22APNIC 22

KRNIC of NIDAKRNIC of NIDA

APNIC Membership FeesAPNIC Membership Fees- KRNIC Review & Comments -- KRNIC Review & Comments -

APNIC Membership FeesAPNIC Membership Fees- KRNIC Review & Comments -- KRNIC Review & Comments -

BackgroundBackgroundBackgroundBackground

Impact on KoreaImpact on KoreaImpact on KoreaImpact on Korea

Situation in KoreaSituation in KoreaSituation in KoreaSituation in Korea

Comments from KRNICComments from KRNICComments from KRNICComments from KRNIC

APNIC 22APNIC 22

APNIC introduced New Fee Structure at APNIC 21APNIC introduced New Fee Structure at APNIC 21 New Fee Structure will introduce 9 membership tiersNew Fee Structure will introduce 9 membership tiers APNIC introduced New Fee Structure at APNIC 21APNIC introduced New Fee Structure at APNIC 21 New Fee Structure will introduce 9 membership tiersNew Fee Structure will introduce 9 membership tiers

BackgroundBackground

Current Fee StructureCurrent Fee Structure New Fee StructureNew Fee Structure

Mem

bersh

ip F

eeM

emb

ership

Fee

TierTier

Extra LargeExtra Large

Very LargeVery Large

LargeLarge

MediumMedium

SmallSmall

Very SmallVery Small

AnnualAnnual

USD 40,000USD 40,000

USD 20,000USD 20,000

USD 10,000USD 10,000

USD 5,000 USD 5,000

USD 2,500 USD 2,500

USD 1,250 USD 1,250

> /10> /10

/10/10

/13/13

/16 /16

/19/19

/22/22

Per A

dd

ress Fee

Per A

dd

ress Fee

Only NIR pays Per Address Fees ! Only NIR pays Per Address Fees !

II

HH

GG

FF

EE

DD

CC

BB

AA

TierTier

USD 92,160USD 92,160

USD 46,080USD 46,080

USD 23,040USD 23,040

USD 11,520USD 11,520

USD 5,760USD 5,760

USD 2,880USD 2,880

USD 1,440USD 1,440

USD 720USD 720

USD 360USD 360

APNIC MemberAPNIC Member NIR MemberNIR Member

To be abolished !To be abolished !

IPv4IPv4 IPv4IPv4

> /10> /10

/10 /10

/12/12

/14/14

/16/16

/18/18

/20/20

/22 /22

/24/24

USD 46,080USD 46,080

USD 23,040USD 23,040

USD 11,520USD 11,520

USD 5,760USD 5,760

USD 2,880USD 2,880

USD 1,440USD 1,440

USD 720USD 720

USD 360USD 360

USD 180USD 180

> /23> /23

/23/23

/26/26

/29 /29

/32/32

/35/35

IPv6IPv6 IPv4IPv4

> /20> /20

/20 /20

/24/24

/28/28

/32/32

/38/38

/40/40

/44 /44

/48/48

APNIC 22APNIC 22

Impact on KoreaImpact on Korea

Before Direct Allocation : USD 92,160 (29,856,256 “ I ” )Before Direct Allocation : USD 92,160 (29,856,256 “ I ” ) After Direct Allocation : USD 238,320After Direct Allocation : USD 238,320 Before Direct Allocation : USD 92,160 (29,856,256 “ I ” )Before Direct Allocation : USD 92,160 (29,856,256 “ I ” ) After Direct Allocation : USD 238,320After Direct Allocation : USD 238,320

A B C D E F G H I

- 2 4 21 27 4 3 3 -

180 360 720 1,440 2,880 5,760 11,520 23,040 46,080

- B C D E F G H I

KRNIC Member

NIR Member

Total

Total

64

-

USD 238,320

“KRNIC have to pay 3 times more than before”

USD 330,480= 92,160(H.A.):Lockup+ 238,320(D.A.)

USD 120,000= 40,000 (M.F):Lockup+ 80,000 (P.A.F.)

APNIC 22APNIC 22

Situation in KoreaSituation in Korea

Legal framework : “the Act on the Internet Address Resources”Legal framework : “the Act on the Internet Address Resources”

Every Korean ISP is the member of KRNIC, and it gets IP through KRNIC

It is impossible to separate KRNIC and its members

IP is regarded as one of the public resources administered by Gov.IP is regarded as one of the public resources administered by Gov.

Local fee structure is centralized under the Act (IP = National resource)

KRNIC’s new year budget should be decided six months before.KRNIC’s new year budget should be decided six months before.

Since the IP fee is controlled by Gov., KR needs more time to implement.

APNIC 22APNIC 22

Comments from KRNICComments from KRNIC

Basically, NIDA understandBasically, NIDA understand

In the future internet governance, APNIC needs to expand its role for AP community.In the future internet governance, APNIC needs to expand its role for AP community.

For APNIC’s future mission, it might need more budget.For APNIC’s future mission, it might need more budget.

However, pre-steps such as more clear explanation should be given to members However, pre-steps such as more clear explanation should be given to members

and more time to understand each other’s situationand more time to understand each other’s situation

““It would be desirable to add more segmented tiers on the current proposalIt would be desirable to add more segmented tiers on the current proposal

covering KRNIC and its members together”covering KRNIC and its members together”

APNIC 22APNIC 22

Q & AQ & A