itulip.com - itulip, inc © 2007 itulip, inc. the contrary market view of the markets predicting...
TRANSCRIPT
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
iTulip, Inc.iTulip, Inc.
The Contrary Market View of the Markets
Predicting your economic future since 1998
The Contrary Market View of the Markets
Predicting your economic future since 1998
Eric JanszenFounder and PresidentiTulip, Inc.
iTulip.com
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
iTulip, Inc.iTulip, Inc. All information provided "as is" for
informational purposes only, not intended for trading purposes or advice. Nothing appearing in this presentation should be considered a recommendation to buy or to sell any security or related financial instrument. iTulip, Inc. is not liable for any informational errors, incompleteness, or delays, or for any actions taken in reliance on information contained herein. See full disclaimer here: http://www.itulip.com/GeneralDisclaimer.htm
All information provided "as is" for informational purposes only, not intended for trading purposes or advice. Nothing appearing in this presentation should be considered a recommendation to buy or to sell any security or related financial instrument. iTulip, Inc. is not liable for any informational errors, incompleteness, or delays, or for any actions taken in reliance on information contained herein. See full disclaimer here: http://www.itulip.com/GeneralDisclaimer.htm
iTulip.com
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
HistoryHistory
Founded: 1998Visitors: 7,000,000
Members: 2,200
Economic and Financial MarketsMacro Trends
Founded: 1998Visitors: 7,000,000
Members: 2,200
Economic and Financial MarketsMacro Trends
Bill Griffeth, CNBC
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
What is iTulip?What is iTulip?
March 2006: “ iTulip.com, which was restarted this week after a three-year hiatus, does not hesitate to claim credit for accurately predicting that the bubble would pop. It even got the timing right."
March 2006: “ iTulip.com, which was restarted this week after a three-year hiatus, does not hesitate to claim credit for accurately predicting that the bubble would pop. It even got the timing right."
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
What is iTulip?What is iTulip?
May 2007 "A typical down cycle [for residential real estate] is five to seven years," says Eric Janszen, co-author of America's Bubble Economy: Profit When It Pops (Wiley, 2006), one of a recent crop of bubble books and far from the gloomiest and doomiest.”
May 2007 "A typical down cycle [for residential real estate] is five to seven years," says Eric Janszen, co-author of America's Bubble Economy: Profit When It Pops (Wiley, 2006), one of a recent crop of bubble books and far from the gloomiest and doomiest.”
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
Other iTulip FirstsOther iTulip Firsts
Housing BubbleAugust 2002: “Yes. It’s a Housing bubble.”January 2004: “Will end by seizing up.”January 2005: “Will Last 10+ Years.”June 2005: “It’s a top.”All-Assets-Up Global Credit Bubble June 2006: “All assets positively correlated, driven by excess global liquidity.”
Housing BubbleAugust 2002: “Yes. It’s a Housing bubble.”January 2004: “Will end by seizing up.”January 2005: “Will Last 10+ Years.”June 2005: “It’s a top.”All-Assets-Up Global Credit Bubble June 2006: “All assets positively correlated, driven by excess global liquidity.”
Money Matters
Finance
Award
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
The ModelThe Model
Ka-Poom Theory of Bubble CyclesDeveloped for Osborn Capital, LLC in 1999 to time stock sales, re-investment of proceedsApplicationSpring 2000: Exit tech stocks and purchase US Treasury Bonds
Sell Cisco @ $68, buy 10 year Treasuries 6.51%
Summer 2001: Purchase Precious Metals
Buy gold @ $270, silver $4.25, platinum $452
Ka-Poom Theory of Bubble CyclesDeveloped for Osborn Capital, LLC in 1999 to time stock sales, re-investment of proceedsApplicationSpring 2000: Exit tech stocks and purchase US Treasury Bonds
Sell Cisco @ $68, buy 10 year Treasuries 6.51%
Summer 2001: Purchase Precious Metals
Buy gold @ $270, silver $4.25, platinum $452
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
Ka-Poom Theory V1.0 (1999)
Ka-Poom Theory V1.0 (1999)
US Foreign and domestic debt repudation1. Bubble formation2. Bubble collapse and disinflation3. Domestic reflation to protect the
economy (rate cuts, tax cuts, dollar depreciation)
4. Repatriation of dollar denominated assets
5. Global central bank cooperation to support the US dollar fails
6. Declining dollar, high inflation, rising interest rates, slowing economy
7. Go to Step 3
US Foreign and domestic debt repudation1. Bubble formation2. Bubble collapse and disinflation3. Domestic reflation to protect the
economy (rate cuts, tax cuts, dollar depreciation)
4. Repatriation of dollar denominated assets
5. Global central bank cooperation to support the US dollar fails
6. Declining dollar, high inflation, rising interest rates, slowing economy
7. Go to Step 3
Monetize Debt
Inflation
Expectations of Future Inflation
Consume Now
Buy on Credit
Insufficient Domestic Savings
Classic vicious circle inflation driven by currency depreciation
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
Ka-Poom Theory V1.0 (1999)
Ka-Poom Theory V1.0 (1999)
1999 Prediction 2000: Crash followed by negative
wealth effect disinflation 2001: Fed will aggressively cut rates
to prevent a Japanese 1990s deflation CPI inflation bottoms ~ 0% Q3 2001
1999 Prediction 2000: Crash followed by negative
wealth effect disinflation 2001: Fed will aggressively cut rates
to prevent a Japanese 1990s deflation CPI inflation bottoms ~ 0% Q3 2001
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
Ka-Poom Theory V1.0 (1999)
Ka-Poom Theory V1.0 (1999)
What actually happened? 2000: Q2 crash followed by disinflation 2001: Fed did not permit the CPI inflation to
turn negative (no deflation… well, not much) CPI inflation bottomed @ -1.3% September 2001
What actually happened? 2000: Q2 crash followed by disinflation 2001: Fed did not permit the CPI inflation to
turn negative (no deflation… well, not much) CPI inflation bottomed @ -1.3% September 2001
Ka-Poom Actuals vs Forecast
-2%
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
11/18/9903/21/0001/04/0103/20/0105/17/0108/22/0110/03/0112/13/0101/09/0306/30/0409/21/0412/14/0403/22/0506/30/0509/20/05
Fed Funds CPI
Disinflation
Reflation
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
Ka-Poom TheoryKa-Poom Theory
1999 Prediction (cont’d) 2001: Dollar depreciation part of reflation
policy 2003 -4: Foreign private investors repatriate
dollars Inflation peaks at 20%
1999 Prediction (cont’d) 2001: Dollar depreciation part of reflation
policy 2003 -4: Foreign private investors repatriate
dollars Inflation peaks at 20%
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
CPI-U Inflation - 1978 to 2008
800%
27%100%
300%
0%
200%
400%
600%
800%
1000%
1978 1988 1998 2008
Non-Traded Traded Total
Ka-Poom Theory V1.0 (1999)
Ka-Poom Theory V1.0 (1999)
What we did not expect1. Housing bubble
Kept economy going, so no rapid exit by foreign investors
2. Price-insensitive purchasers of US debt (Oil exporters, China, UK)
Filled in for private investors
3. “China factor” influence on traded goods prices and CPI accounting
Inflation “contained”
What we did not expect1. Housing bubble
Kept economy going, so no rapid exit by foreign investors
2. Price-insensitive purchasers of US debt (Oil exporters, China, UK)
Filled in for private investors
3. “China factor” influence on traded goods prices and CPI accounting
Inflation “contained” EducationHealthcare
Insurance
Consumer Electronics
CPI
Monetary
Inflation
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
Ka-Poom Theory V2.0 (2004)
Ka-Poom Theory V2.0 (2004)
Ka-Poom disinflation-reflation cycle
1. Bubble formation2. Bubble collapse and disinflation3. Domestic reflation policies for
economic recovery4. Cooperative currency
depreciation props up US dollar5. Go to Step 1
Ka-Poom disinflation-reflation cycle
1. Bubble formation2. Bubble collapse and disinflation3. Domestic reflation policies for
economic recovery4. Cooperative currency
depreciation props up US dollar5. Go to Step 1
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
Ka-Poom Theory (either case)
Ka-Poom Theory (either case)
What happens in gold terms? What happens in gold terms?
US Dollar Depreciation
Global Depreciation
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
Now What?Now What?
Reversion to the Mean Triggered by random event No one knows what or when The usual suspects
War or terrorist attack Revelation of fraud (GSEs) Name your pin
Reversion to the Mean Triggered by random event No one knows what or when The usual suspects
War or terrorist attack Revelation of fraud (GSEs) Name your pin
There is a bubble in everything… all asset classes… globally.” - Jeremy Grantham, April 2007
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
Then What?Then What?Disinflation Phase - Risk Adjustments Within asset classes
From most risky to least Among asset classes
Purchasing power vs yield Liquidity vs value
Among geographies Local vs remote Lowest economic and political risk
Disinflation Phase - Risk Adjustments Within asset classes
From most risky to least Among asset classes
Purchasing power vs yield Liquidity vs value
Among geographies Local vs remote Lowest economic and political risk
0
2,0004,000
6,000
8,000
10,00012,000
14,000
1st 2ndQtr
3rdQtr
4thQtr
5thQtr
6thQtr
7thQtr
8thQtr
9thQtr
10thQtr
Stocks Bonds Gold
Crisis
CrisisCrisis
Crisis
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
What happens to gold?What happens to gold?
Previous asset price reversion periods Capital flight to political safety
Dollar rises, gold falls US Government policy fights disinflation
Rate cuts, gov’t spending, $ depreciation
Coordinated global central bank policy But unlike the 2001 version…
Previous asset price reversion periods Capital flight to political safety
Dollar rises, gold falls US Government policy fights disinflation
Rate cuts, gov’t spending, $ depreciation
Coordinated global central bank policy But unlike the 2001 version…
Reflation
5.25%
4.25%
3.25%
2.25%
5%
3%
6%
0.00%
1.00%
2.00%
3.00%
4.00%
5.00%
6.00%
7.00%
1st Qtr 2nd Qtr 3rd Qtr 4th Qtr
Fed Funds RateDeficit % GDP
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
After Disinflation?After Disinflation?
What’s different this time? Not in 2001 “Kansas” anymore Oil is at $60 not $20 Global inflation is high not low US is at war not “peace” US running huge fiscal deficit vs surplus Dollar is weak not strong Euro has never been stress-tested
What’s different this time? Not in 2001 “Kansas” anymore Oil is at $60 not $20 Global inflation is high not low US is at war not “peace” US running huge fiscal deficit vs surplus Dollar is weak not strong Euro has never been stress-tested
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
Two Ka-Poom ScenariosTwo Ka-Poom Scenarios
#1: The Last Ka-Poom: Reflation Fails
US-centric currency crisis 1997/1998 style currency crisis,
except in major currencies Dissolution of global monetary
system Sound far fetched? Greenspan
was nervous enough last time to propose…
#1: The Last Ka-Poom: Reflation Fails
US-centric currency crisis 1997/1998 style currency crisis,
except in major currencies Dissolution of global monetary
system Sound far fetched? Greenspan
was nervous enough last time to propose…
Senator Paul Sarbanes: "... is it your intention that the report of this hearing should be that Greenspan recommends a return to the gold standard!?"
Greenspan: "I've been recommending that for years, there's nothing new about that. It would probably mean there is only one vote in the FOMC [Federal Open Market Committee] for that, but it is mine."
- Senate Committee Hearing, Sept. 1997
Crisis
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
Two Ka-Poom ScenariosTwo Ka-Poom Scenarios
#2: New Ka-Poom Cycle: Relfation Succeeds
The Next Bubble Developed by markets Encouraged by government tax
and monetary policy Alternative Energy and
Infrastructure
#2: New Ka-Poom Cycle: Relfation Succeeds
The Next Bubble Developed by markets Encouraged by government tax
and monetary policy Alternative Energy and
Infrastructure
“We are too dependent on imported oil from troubled parts of the world, so the question was, how would we craft something that would give us energy security as soon as possible? … we had presentations from terrific scientists on progress that's been made in technology and a number of alternative sources of energy — everything from solar to wind to energy to batteries and clean coal.
-Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson Feb. 2007
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
How to Make an Asset Bubble
How to Make an Asset Bubble
Five Steps1. Start with an asset that was already inflating
before the last bubble collapsed (e.g., Housing during the stock market bubble)
2. Talk it up (e.g., “Ownership Society”)3. Create tax incentives (e.g., 1997 Tax Relief Act)4. Deregulate or don’t regulate (e.g., creative
mortgage products, such as liar loans, cite the benefits of “free markets” and “innovation”)
5. Add money(Also, take credit for “booming economy”)
Five Steps1. Start with an asset that was already inflating
before the last bubble collapsed (e.g., Housing during the stock market bubble)
2. Talk it up (e.g., “Ownership Society”)3. Create tax incentives (e.g., 1997 Tax Relief Act)4. Deregulate or don’t regulate (e.g., creative
mortgage products, such as liar loans, cite the benefits of “free markets” and “innovation”)
5. Add money(Also, take credit for “booming economy”)
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
The Tea LeavesThe Tea LeavesHard Assets: The Fourth Currency1. Disinflation period when gold
declines 25%+ during rush to liquidity (ala Feb. 2007 and Spring 2006)
2. If continues, asymmetric economic impact causes unexpected change in pricing relationships (outside “model”)
3. Hits currency and credit derivatives
4. Capital seeks safety from chaos while global central banks cope
Hard Assets: The Fourth Currency1. Disinflation period when gold
declines 25%+ during rush to liquidity (ala Feb. 2007 and Spring 2006)
2. If continues, asymmetric economic impact causes unexpected change in pricing relationships (outside “model”)
3. Hits currency and credit derivatives
4. Capital seeks safety from chaos while global central banks cope
iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007iTulip.com - iTulip, Inc © 2007
iTulip SelectiTulip Select
Specialist Interviews:Jim RogersMartin MayerDr. Jamie GalbraithJames Scurlock
Specialist Interviews:Jim RogersMartin MayerDr. Jamie GalbraithJames Scurlock
iTulip.com
CommentariesBook ReviewsPortfolio
ModelingShadowFed
CommentariesBook ReviewsPortfolio
ModelingShadowFed
http://www.itulip.com
The Investment Thesis for the Next Cycle