i 1. i final work plan dover, new hampshire september … · dover, new hampshire . september 8 ......
TRANSCRIPT
i 1 I
FINAL WORK PLAN
DOVER MUNICIPAL LANDFILL FEASIBILITY STUDY
DOVER NEW HAMPSHIRE
SEPTEMBER 8 1989
PREPARED IQR
EPA REGION BOSTON MASSACHUSETIS
PREPARED BY
hmH_ M ~ A S S 0 C I A T E S I N C ENG INEERS ENV IRONME NTAL CONSU LTANTS ~PLANNERS
HMM Ref No 2512-1HAZ2767
September I 1989
Paul Marchessault (HSN-CANS) Environmental Protection A1ency 90 Canal Street Bolton MA 02203
Dear Paul
Eac- pleue find three ccplea of the Final Feutblllty Worl Plan which II aubmltted In acccrdlnce with paralflph 40 of the Admlnlltratlve Onlet Thll Worl Plan wu developed followlnl the auJdollnol In the Interim Final Guidance for RIIFS (9111) and Is buatl an Information available u of the date or aubmlttal or the Worl Plan
~t to revtew of thiJ document by EPA HNM will mate luelf available to dliCUII a project tcbedule for future activities cwa the project Should you have any queadona pleue do not -Itate to call
S~ly
Richard C Cote
RCCmnl
196 bker Avetwe bull Concont bull MliBolldMMtlt bull 01 742 bull (5081 1714000 bull FAX (5081 )11middot268 Thrtt h Kuhlt Plfk Ommiddote bull BecifO+d bull Ntbulllt H~ml)lohlll bull tl310 bull l fgtlllth~ ~- 101U bull FAX 11gt111 11gt1gtmiddot-l b-4
TABbull EOF COfiPNIS
fa~lt
10 INTRODUCTION 1-1
11 Backaround 1-112 Site Location 1-113 Site History 1-3
20 SCOPE OP WORK 2-1
21 RIJPS Procea 22 Sltopo of Walt
2-1
2-5221 Toot Imiddot
Toot2 ~222 2-5 223 TootJ - 2-5
=-~-ObJoctivallld 224 Toot4- 2-6B-Riat~22$ Toot5 2-7 ~ofRemoclial 226 Toot6- 2-1 227 Toot7- 2-1IDilial of- shy228 Toot Imiddot ==~ 2-9
~llmtobility SIUdia229 Toot9 2-10=yoloof~ 2210 2-11TootiO bull ~ofDn1t PS Repon2211 Toot II - Filial PS Report 2-15 2212 Tllll2 2-15 ~ Doaip of Selected Rnedill Altenwiva
2213 Tootl3 2-18~rllldCoordinllion2214 Tllll4 2-18c-aRelabonosupporr 2-19
ATTACIIMINr
A - Adminiattllive Order middot Sope of Walt
Y
10 NJROQUCTION
11 BACKGROUND
HMM Associates lnc (HMM) has prepared this Draft Feasibility Study (fS) Work Plan
ror the Dover Municipal Landfill to conform to applicable guidance under the Comprehensive
Environmental Response Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA) and the National Oil and
Huardow SubstanCeS ContinJency Plan (NCP) and more current EPA guidance implemented
under the Superfund Amendments and Reauthorization Act of 1986 (SARA) specificaUy the
Interim final Guidance for Conduttinc Remedial lnvestiauions and Feasibility Studies Under
CllRCLA dated Aupt 1988 (OSWER Dimtivo 935-301 ) HMM developed this Draft FS
Wort Plan with the undenlllldinJ tlw EPA seeks to ime the December 1988 Draft
Remediol lnveotilotim Repon the Manb 1989 Risk Aloe- the resulll of the field
llemenll Srudy (Manb 31 1989 Wort Plm) md the Peuibility Srudy (PS)componenll of this
projoltl in conformmce with the ltamnt tedtnical _dt lei fonb by EPA In this woy the
raul lleltold of Deciaion (ROD) will reflect the cumndy _m to selelttion of
the moot_ site remedy
12 SIIIOCADQN
The Drmr Municipol Llndftll iJ I _ w- c1ilpolal uu located in the -est
ltOmet of Dcmr New ll_w the - of the Dover a and Madbury
town lines The site aboWD iD Piampua 1-1 iss~ four miiN wettmiddot norlbweat ampom the tenter
of the City of Dcmr bull 431230 nonb lllirude md 705730 well IOfllitude (USOS 1978)
The landfill iJ about onemiddotbolf mile IOUIII of the Dcmr city produlttion well (Colderwood) which
is loeaed in an uca tailed _ Hoppen approximllely 00 feet west of the Cochelto River
and -tme-lthinl of I mile nonb of Molleso a- and the Bellamy (Porumouth) Reservoir
Wetlando southwell of the laadfill it fnlm the reoervoir The landfill is bordetocl by
Tolend Rood md 0 Hill Road on the oonh by Tolend Rood on the ltIll md by private
property m die southelll and IOUIII The weatem portion of the site borden boch the
Mldbwy-Dover line lnd private property The eu1 point of the landfill site is 11 the intersection
ofTolend Road and Glen HillRochester Nect Rod The site is located in 1 rural au althouamph
land Ilona the eut side ofTolend-Rochester Neck Roads hu been subdivided for buildinamplots
2512HAZ-2732 1-1
LOCA110N OP DOVER lANDIIUSITII
DOVBRNH
13 SITE USTQRY
The Dover Municipal Landfill beaan active operation in 1960 or 1961 and continued until
1979 at which time diJposal operacions ceased ln the course of faciliry operltion the landfill
received solid waste macerials comprised of domeStic and industrial sludges leuher tanninc and
shoe wute products oraanic solvents wute oil and munidpampl solid wute Closure of the site
consistinJ of a cover oper11ion consuu~ion of a surface waterJ1uchate drainqe channel and 0
P O site access control wu completed in 1980 Olt 3m
The proximity of two major municipal water supply sources the Calderwood WeU (City ~ z ~ 3of Dover) and the BeUamy Reservoir (City of Ponsmoulh) prompted Dover city officials and VC ~z
repla1ory penonnel to initiate a poundwater monitorina proaram in 1977 follow ina site ~ ~
closure lhe monitorina proanm wu expmded to include aeveral residential wella Laboratory H lt P 11111)1lt1 of w11er collec1ed from raideatillwe1111ocaoed on Tolencl Rood t Olen Hill mr
Rod revealed that m p some of the wdlt were conlllninlampecl primarily with vo~ile OfJIIlk r n z
_ Baecl on public hoal1b concema woci- wilh lhe exiltinJ nl pocential 0 0 - of - public t privooe middot- 1Upply _ lhe Dover Municipol LlndfU 0 ~ wu nabd n1 ploced on the EPAs Nlliollll Priori) Lill
In occonllnlte wilh lhe _of lhe Nllional C-mency Pl111 a Remedial Action
- Plan (RAMP) wu -- f0lt 1be oite in 1913 The RAMP iDcluded a _
ocopo of MrVicel for romodlol oct1on activldoa bull the olio t called fOlt complollon of
a RaDocllolJmaliilllionPeaoibllity Shldy
In order to ptweed with the RaDocllol lnapionPeuibillly Shldy of the Dover
Municipal Landfill tbe s- of New H w- $apply t PoUutloll C-1
Commlulon (NHWSPCC) executed a _nve - wid the IPA Thio _ment enablocl EPA to _n fundi fOlt invatilllion of lhe obe in accordance wid lbe
Comprehensive Enviroamontal R- c_ion t Liability Act of 1910 (CERCLA)
for RemodiallnveaticllionPeuibllity Study aaivitieo
23 I2HAZ-2732 1-3
20 SCOPE OF WORK AND SCHEQWE
21 RIFS PRQCESS
Thi3 wort plan for the Dover Landfill feasibility Study (FS) was based on the scope ofwork oudined in the Administrative Order for the Feasibility Study (See Anactunent A as
0~0
updated in accordance with EPAs Interim Final Guidance for Conductins Remedial Oltlnvestisatioru and Feasibility Studies Thi3 tpproach meets all the mandates of SARA in order middotz- for NHJDES and EPA to develop 1ft eteeptable Record of Decision (ROD The new provisions ~3VC~zunder SARA havifta the peltelt impact on the IUIFS proceaa are the Clunup Standards These ~sundardt create a bulluona llatutory preference for remediea dw are hiafdy rdiable and provide ~~ lt ~ lona-tenn proceaion In addition to the requimnent that remedies be both cott-eftective and ~mr
pngtlteclive of shy heollb llld lbe environment oeleltlion of a mnedial llfiacll mull abo rconaldor lbe followinl Uclelineo n z ~
0 0 0~
rrA JRfaonco for mnedial aotionl thai ~oy tre-t that pe-y llld
aipilkoally -lbe volame tollicity or mobility of hazanloul Rlbouncapoll- aad contalllitwa u lbeir prialtipal-
Avo- of ofampilo -pot~ aad ~ - _ wllen otherpnaicalgtle _lecbDol01ioa availlble
The need to - lbe ue of pe~ aoludOftl md altemllive treamenttedtaotopea or - tOCOVery oocmolopu IIIII lbem to lbe muimwn
pnaicoble
Althoqb the new proriliona of CERCLA have reaulted in aonw modificatioru to theIUIPS procea lbe buic componenu of lhe procesa remain inUMt The Rl continues to serve uthe mechaniam for collectlaa dMa for aile and wute chlncterizalion and for conduclinatteMabilily teltina u neceaauy to evalubull the performance and cOlt of the treatmentteehaoloaies lnd 1upport lhe deaip of selected remedies The PS continues to serve u themedlaniJm for lbe devel-t saeeninJ IIIII detailed evoluotion of potemiol mediolaltemarivea
~12JHAZ2732 2-1
This work plan follows the Interim Final Guidance for Conduttinl Remedial
lnvestisltions and Feuibility Studies Under CERCLA (OSWER Directive 93553-01) which
varies rrom older romws in that the current RIFS process is much more interactive with the Rl
beins divided into two phases and the FS in1o three phases Some of the Rl and FS phases run
concurrently and the objeclives of the laner phases of the R1 are tailored to meet specific FS
data needs Exhibit 2-1 depicts the new process
It is important to note that because portions of tbe RI and FS are conducted concurrently
data collected in tbe Rl will influence the development of remedial alternatives in the FS which
in rum affects the dau needl and scope of treatability studiea and additional fteld investiJations
Two conceptS are ueful to understand the new phued IUIPS proceaa Pint data can be
collected in severalalqes with initial data collection efforts usually beina limited to deve1opinamp
a pnera1 undmllnclint of the aile AI die site is better cbancterized sublequent data colleclion
cfforu c be foculed 10 fill Ill wcm 11p1 in he diU Second lhil phued un1
__idemiflcllloaofkeydolaaeodlueadyinlhe_ll_iblero_
lhll dill collectioa is alwaya direcled toward providina infOIIDIIion relevanr to bullaecuon of a
remedial aetioa In this way die overall aile charwcerirMicm effort cm be continually acopecl to
minimize he oolloclion of-dolallld muimizo dolo qualily
Colleclion of llldiiiOIIIIdD 1111 commenced wilb a Field llemeftl Sllldy whidl il aimed
II clotinl - in die -- t for die Rlllld tilt- (RA) Wbile a basic plaD
of operaion 1111 - delopod t cleacribed in a Field - Wost Plan he clala
oolleclion prooou will conlinuo 10 be _mro he dolo aeodl of die PS
Upon ltltgtqgt1e1ion of he Field llemeftla Sllldy lhe new- will be evalualed wilh IOipOCI
10 die dD IIIII coadaailtn of die Rlllllll RA and a delcrmilwion made 11 10 he neceaally of
bini porliona ofeilbor - middot The Dover Manicipal Landfill PS will incorponlte he foUowm lalks subjeclro EPA
approval
TASK 1 Scoojns pftbc FS
Adminillralive Order Data Oaps
Field Elemenl SIUdy Wort PIUI
Draft Feuibilily SIUdy Wost PIUI
TASK 2 Sjtc CbepmriprjM
bull Field SIUdy Elemenu Repon
2middot2
u~============J _mz~
~~S2-l
shy
I I
~ I I
TASK 3 DeyclQIDCot gf Rcspons Qbjectiycs NMi Respow Actiqps Pinal Pcuibility Study Work Plan
Letter repon with sugsested tcchnolosies for consideralion and discussion of
Applicable or Relev111t and Appropriate Requitemenu (ARARs)
TASK 4 Baseline Risk AmnDfDt
Sununuy of Existing Baseline Risk Assessment specifically the identification
of sensitive recepton and remedial clean-up objectives whith may be modifed
based on the tonclusions of the Field Elemenu Study Completion of this tuk
would be tontincent upon Field Element Study dltl and EPA ipprOVal
TASK RcmcdiallnycMitbulliqn Rcpoa Summary of lWatinl Draft R1 Report speltifiltally the contaminant fate IUid
U1n1p011 Ulelllnenl which may be updlled bued on tbe conclusiona of the
Field llemonts Study Such on updlte would be campewl upon BPA _II
TASK 6 Dcycl- gf Altmperiyg
Briltfinl to pmeat pellmitwy _ objoctma ond criteria
Letter_ cliaataainl pellmitwy - objoctigta ond criteriaLetter_ Olllliaiac tomedilllloomarivea clnelopocl
TASK 7 lnitjal Sgwginf of Altmneriva
TASK 8 trmllbjljrv SDMjca (Optional)
Benchsclleshybull T~Wmihy Studiel
TASK 9 Qaailcd ANIYia of Rmbulljnjnr Altrmlljyg
Summary table and narntive description of ldvamqes and disadvan111eS of
eaeh allemllive
TASK 10 PrciJamprJtjoogfDqft PS Repon
TASK II Final PS Rcpon
TASK 12 Pmjmjnary DesjroofSclcctod Rrmt4ja] Ahcmatiyc
(Developed after ROD Siplinamp)
2112HAZ-2732 2-4
TASK 13 MwpmmtandCoordjnlljon
TASK 14 Cmrunynjty RclatjgM Sygpon
22 SCOPE OF WORK
This section discusses current EPA FS guidance as it applies to the FS tasks and amplifies
the scope and HMMs approach to the tub
221 Tuk 1 bull Scgpina of the FS
The Dover Municipal Landfill Rl lq)OR was prepared in IICCordance with the NCP and
prevlilina JUiltlonce undolt CERCLA HMM will updl1e the site _ infomwion
preiOIIIOdln the Remediallnvatiaation Report Agt - previowly the FS procetJ under SARA (ond Ill other new ampderol reaulationl)
hu become more -ive willgt 1he remedial endpoira belri fottorecl inlo 1he invettiaative
pngtCOII from 1he projoltt planninl- duouch1he mnoinder of 1he invellipdCOI
Tbr pwpooe of Tlllt I will be to dovolop a wor1t plan IWinamp IMgtw tpeeifiC diu llpl are to
be 8llecl Tbeae diu - lndude - outliDed in 1he Admirlilualve Order bull u u 1he oddidonll dlla requlrementl 11111 have dovolopod duoup 1he review of 1he Remedial
fnvestiaatiCOI (Rl) (Docomber 1981) ond lUolt -t(RA) (Mardi 1988) Tbr field wort
will be conc1ucted u put of 1he Site Cbancterizltioo (TIIIt 2)
Tbeae efforu have reoulted In the clovelopment of 1he Field 11ement Study Wort PlOD
docamatlinl1he JCopiq - Uld pmenq orwicipoted future wb It olao tervet II I
voluable tool fw uailrgtirtlmpooaiblliliea ond eatabliohini 1he projoltt t tchedule
222 Tuk 2 middot Sifl aizbullion
The exiltifta Rl report delcribea tbe fe1d investiallive work conducted to eWe by previous
inveatiaators The dlta and concluaiona presented in the Rl and RA reports form the buis for
lhe cwrmt understandinc of site conditions
Based on HMMs review of the Rl and RA repons and in liaht of current SARA guidance
Uld anticipated remecliol _ options data saps 10 be lldclreoaed duoup funlrer freld
investiJarion wete outlined in Task 1 field Element Study Wort Pllll
2512HAZ-2732 2-5
I I
- I I
Upon completion ofTuk I through onaoina cUcussions wilh the EPA and NH DES he
new database will be reviewed relative to the interpretaJion and conclusions of the previous Rl
and RA repons Specific attention will focus on the contaminant fate and transport model of the
Rl repon as well as the identification of sensitive receptors and the remedial objective(s) and
criteria developed in the Risk Assessment This updated Site Characterization will be presented
in a Draft Field Element Study Report submined to EPA and NH DES for review
223 Tuk 3 - Dcyelgpncm gf RcapoOR Obicctjycs and Rcsponsc Actions
General response actions that miampht be taken at a site are initially deftned during scoping
and are refmed throusflout the PS process u a better undentandina of site conditions is aained FoUowinamp completion of the site characterization and reduction and interpre111ion of the
resul11111 data HMM in conjwxtion with EPA and NH DES will re-evaluate the e~oisting
rapo- objectives opplicable technoloJieo ond ARARs for lhe Dever Municipal Landfill The
results of this uaesamem will be uted to revile and fanalize thiJ Draft Peuibility Study Wort
Plaa ThiJ evaluation will detormiDe whether new infOIDIIlion lllhmd durinamp the Sile
Chlraclerizllion would result in moclificatioaa to responae objectives and criteria for eath
COftlarninaled medium Pwthamore each response technoiOIY orilinaiJy identified would be
re-cvallllled for ita opplicability 10 site conditions ond odditioaal rechnoloJieo would be
idenlilled for lilnher c-idenltion u wunnoecl Finally the idenlifled ARARs would be
re-cuminocl to eruwe t1w they opplicable to the reviled raponse objeetiveo ond
tecbDoloPet New EPA pidance relative to ARARJ is in development IDd is avai1able in drift
form (Relerence Review Dnft CERCLA C-lilnce With Other Laws Mtnual OSWER
Direcrive 92341~1 (May 6 1981)) ond pidance is also anilable in the EPA Re1ion I
S~al Riolt Alletlmenr Oaidance for the Supetfund Propam
The responae objectivea techaolotiea and ARARs lhll evolve from thiJ process will
serve u lhe buil for initillinamp dilcualionJ reaardinc more specific upecu of remedial response such u site-speciamp delft--up aoals If an ARAR is delermined to be protective of the human
health or the eavizonmenr it will be used to establish the acceptable exposure level If an
ARAR is not proceaive of the population or environmem does not exist for 1he specific
chemical or pathways of concem or does not apply because multiple contaminants may be
posina a cumulative risk acceptable exposure leveb will be identifted through the risk
usesament process The Supcrfwxl Puhljc Health Enluarjoo Manual provides additional details
on establishinamp acceptable exposure levels when no ARARs exist
2112HAZ-2732 2-6
This reevalUillon process will result in the preparaalon of a Pinal Peuibility Srudy Work
Plan which will outline what refmements if any would be required in the development and
evalualion process of remedial alternatives
224 Task 4- Bwlinc RN Assuqcnr
A3 the Site Characterization nean completion the resultutt data wiU be evaluated in
conjunction with data from the existinc Baseline Risk Assessment The objective of this
useumem will be a determination of the nanue and sipiftcanee of the risk posed to public
health welfan or the environment by the contaminlnta preaenc The Bueline Riak Aueument
is euemially an useumem of the riat usociated with the No-Action alternative (ie the
prellld futuJe rilt in tbe oboence of my odditional mpo111lt lltliou)
Tho Bueline Riallt --r metilodoiOSY obould be bued on lbe moot cumnt-shyocoepoed by tbe US Em-Il r-aioa Aptyeny u publilbed in lbe ledenl Repoer
(49FIU27 et teq) IDd in lbl fiaa1 s Ppbljs Health Pxeluim Mnbull (US BPA
~1-16-060 Ootobor 1916) llld lbe s- of New llamplbile o Riallt --r Oftlce
Oaldellnu 110 IIJo -lded in lbe lleJlon I Sllflll-1 Riallt --r Ouldaxe for lbe
s__ Propm Tbe publicbeallb riltc- obou1d _--
fillY pt bull ideMification of tboee individual~ or JIVUPI wbo 11e 11
rilt of _ via inbololion iopllion clinlct COIIIICI or olber _ of
_ Tbla -Ia buedupon idonliflcolion ofeltJ1011110 pGwamp)l
bued on ealadq cilia IIIII - cilia fngtm lbe Silo Cbarw1eriuoion llld conalderl
f_ mecblalomo for lbe COIIIIminlaao of concern
Iqaisicy bullmiddot=-=middot a compuilon of contaminant concentrationlll the titc with
COIItllniDID-apecific ARARJ to determine acceptable concentnlions for each
rnecliam of ccoem for tbe conwninants of concern
Rid Oypstcrizerigp m inlepation of fmdinamps ampom the expn~UR usessment
and toxicity asaeument to determine the potential for ldvene health or
environmentampl effecu for each exposure scenario
2$12JHAZ2732 2-7
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
HMM Ref No 2512-1HAZ2767
September I 1989
Paul Marchessault (HSN-CANS) Environmental Protection A1ency 90 Canal Street Bolton MA 02203
Dear Paul
Eac- pleue find three ccplea of the Final Feutblllty Worl Plan which II aubmltted In acccrdlnce with paralflph 40 of the Admlnlltratlve Onlet Thll Worl Plan wu developed followlnl the auJdollnol In the Interim Final Guidance for RIIFS (9111) and Is buatl an Information available u of the date or aubmlttal or the Worl Plan
~t to revtew of thiJ document by EPA HNM will mate luelf available to dliCUII a project tcbedule for future activities cwa the project Should you have any queadona pleue do not -Itate to call
S~ly
Richard C Cote
RCCmnl
196 bker Avetwe bull Concont bull MliBolldMMtlt bull 01 742 bull (5081 1714000 bull FAX (5081 )11middot268 Thrtt h Kuhlt Plfk Ommiddote bull BecifO+d bull Ntbulllt H~ml)lohlll bull tl310 bull l fgtlllth~ ~- 101U bull FAX 11gt111 11gt1gtmiddot-l b-4
TABbull EOF COfiPNIS
fa~lt
10 INTRODUCTION 1-1
11 Backaround 1-112 Site Location 1-113 Site History 1-3
20 SCOPE OP WORK 2-1
21 RIJPS Procea 22 Sltopo of Walt
2-1
2-5221 Toot Imiddot
Toot2 ~222 2-5 223 TootJ - 2-5
=-~-ObJoctivallld 224 Toot4- 2-6B-Riat~22$ Toot5 2-7 ~ofRemoclial 226 Toot6- 2-1 227 Toot7- 2-1IDilial of- shy228 Toot Imiddot ==~ 2-9
~llmtobility SIUdia229 Toot9 2-10=yoloof~ 2210 2-11TootiO bull ~ofDn1t PS Repon2211 Toot II - Filial PS Report 2-15 2212 Tllll2 2-15 ~ Doaip of Selected Rnedill Altenwiva
2213 Tootl3 2-18~rllldCoordinllion2214 Tllll4 2-18c-aRelabonosupporr 2-19
ATTACIIMINr
A - Adminiattllive Order middot Sope of Walt
Y
10 NJROQUCTION
11 BACKGROUND
HMM Associates lnc (HMM) has prepared this Draft Feasibility Study (fS) Work Plan
ror the Dover Municipal Landfill to conform to applicable guidance under the Comprehensive
Environmental Response Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA) and the National Oil and
Huardow SubstanCeS ContinJency Plan (NCP) and more current EPA guidance implemented
under the Superfund Amendments and Reauthorization Act of 1986 (SARA) specificaUy the
Interim final Guidance for Conduttinc Remedial lnvestiauions and Feasibility Studies Under
CllRCLA dated Aupt 1988 (OSWER Dimtivo 935-301 ) HMM developed this Draft FS
Wort Plan with the undenlllldinJ tlw EPA seeks to ime the December 1988 Draft
Remediol lnveotilotim Repon the Manb 1989 Risk Aloe- the resulll of the field
llemenll Srudy (Manb 31 1989 Wort Plm) md the Peuibility Srudy (PS)componenll of this
projoltl in conformmce with the ltamnt tedtnical _dt lei fonb by EPA In this woy the
raul lleltold of Deciaion (ROD) will reflect the cumndy _m to selelttion of
the moot_ site remedy
12 SIIIOCADQN
The Drmr Municipol Llndftll iJ I _ w- c1ilpolal uu located in the -est
ltOmet of Dcmr New ll_w the - of the Dover a and Madbury
town lines The site aboWD iD Piampua 1-1 iss~ four miiN wettmiddot norlbweat ampom the tenter
of the City of Dcmr bull 431230 nonb lllirude md 705730 well IOfllitude (USOS 1978)
The landfill iJ about onemiddotbolf mile IOUIII of the Dcmr city produlttion well (Colderwood) which
is loeaed in an uca tailed _ Hoppen approximllely 00 feet west of the Cochelto River
and -tme-lthinl of I mile nonb of Molleso a- and the Bellamy (Porumouth) Reservoir
Wetlando southwell of the laadfill it fnlm the reoervoir The landfill is bordetocl by
Tolend Rood md 0 Hill Road on the oonh by Tolend Rood on the ltIll md by private
property m die southelll and IOUIII The weatem portion of the site borden boch the
Mldbwy-Dover line lnd private property The eu1 point of the landfill site is 11 the intersection
ofTolend Road and Glen HillRochester Nect Rod The site is located in 1 rural au althouamph
land Ilona the eut side ofTolend-Rochester Neck Roads hu been subdivided for buildinamplots
2512HAZ-2732 1-1
LOCA110N OP DOVER lANDIIUSITII
DOVBRNH
13 SITE USTQRY
The Dover Municipal Landfill beaan active operation in 1960 or 1961 and continued until
1979 at which time diJposal operacions ceased ln the course of faciliry operltion the landfill
received solid waste macerials comprised of domeStic and industrial sludges leuher tanninc and
shoe wute products oraanic solvents wute oil and munidpampl solid wute Closure of the site
consistinJ of a cover oper11ion consuu~ion of a surface waterJ1uchate drainqe channel and 0
P O site access control wu completed in 1980 Olt 3m
The proximity of two major municipal water supply sources the Calderwood WeU (City ~ z ~ 3of Dover) and the BeUamy Reservoir (City of Ponsmoulh) prompted Dover city officials and VC ~z
repla1ory penonnel to initiate a poundwater monitorina proaram in 1977 follow ina site ~ ~
closure lhe monitorina proanm wu expmded to include aeveral residential wella Laboratory H lt P 11111)1lt1 of w11er collec1ed from raideatillwe1111ocaoed on Tolencl Rood t Olen Hill mr
Rod revealed that m p some of the wdlt were conlllninlampecl primarily with vo~ile OfJIIlk r n z
_ Baecl on public hoal1b concema woci- wilh lhe exiltinJ nl pocential 0 0 - of - public t privooe middot- 1Upply _ lhe Dover Municipol LlndfU 0 ~ wu nabd n1 ploced on the EPAs Nlliollll Priori) Lill
In occonllnlte wilh lhe _of lhe Nllional C-mency Pl111 a Remedial Action
- Plan (RAMP) wu -- f0lt 1be oite in 1913 The RAMP iDcluded a _
ocopo of MrVicel for romodlol oct1on activldoa bull the olio t called fOlt complollon of
a RaDocllolJmaliilllionPeaoibllity Shldy
In order to ptweed with the RaDocllol lnapionPeuibillly Shldy of the Dover
Municipal Landfill tbe s- of New H w- $apply t PoUutloll C-1
Commlulon (NHWSPCC) executed a _nve - wid the IPA Thio _ment enablocl EPA to _n fundi fOlt invatilllion of lhe obe in accordance wid lbe
Comprehensive Enviroamontal R- c_ion t Liability Act of 1910 (CERCLA)
for RemodiallnveaticllionPeuibllity Study aaivitieo
23 I2HAZ-2732 1-3
20 SCOPE OF WORK AND SCHEQWE
21 RIFS PRQCESS
Thi3 wort plan for the Dover Landfill feasibility Study (FS) was based on the scope ofwork oudined in the Administrative Order for the Feasibility Study (See Anactunent A as
0~0
updated in accordance with EPAs Interim Final Guidance for Conductins Remedial Oltlnvestisatioru and Feasibility Studies Thi3 tpproach meets all the mandates of SARA in order middotz- for NHJDES and EPA to develop 1ft eteeptable Record of Decision (ROD The new provisions ~3VC~zunder SARA havifta the peltelt impact on the IUIFS proceaa are the Clunup Standards These ~sundardt create a bulluona llatutory preference for remediea dw are hiafdy rdiable and provide ~~ lt ~ lona-tenn proceaion In addition to the requimnent that remedies be both cott-eftective and ~mr
pngtlteclive of shy heollb llld lbe environment oeleltlion of a mnedial llfiacll mull abo rconaldor lbe followinl Uclelineo n z ~
0 0 0~
rrA JRfaonco for mnedial aotionl thai ~oy tre-t that pe-y llld
aipilkoally -lbe volame tollicity or mobility of hazanloul Rlbouncapoll- aad contalllitwa u lbeir prialtipal-
Avo- of ofampilo -pot~ aad ~ - _ wllen otherpnaicalgtle _lecbDol01ioa availlble
The need to - lbe ue of pe~ aoludOftl md altemllive treamenttedtaotopea or - tOCOVery oocmolopu IIIII lbem to lbe muimwn
pnaicoble
Althoqb the new proriliona of CERCLA have reaulted in aonw modificatioru to theIUIPS procea lbe buic componenu of lhe procesa remain inUMt The Rl continues to serve uthe mechaniam for collectlaa dMa for aile and wute chlncterizalion and for conduclinatteMabilily teltina u neceaauy to evalubull the performance and cOlt of the treatmentteehaoloaies lnd 1upport lhe deaip of selected remedies The PS continues to serve u themedlaniJm for lbe devel-t saeeninJ IIIII detailed evoluotion of potemiol mediolaltemarivea
~12JHAZ2732 2-1
This work plan follows the Interim Final Guidance for Conduttinl Remedial
lnvestisltions and Feuibility Studies Under CERCLA (OSWER Directive 93553-01) which
varies rrom older romws in that the current RIFS process is much more interactive with the Rl
beins divided into two phases and the FS in1o three phases Some of the Rl and FS phases run
concurrently and the objeclives of the laner phases of the R1 are tailored to meet specific FS
data needs Exhibit 2-1 depicts the new process
It is important to note that because portions of tbe RI and FS are conducted concurrently
data collected in tbe Rl will influence the development of remedial alternatives in the FS which
in rum affects the dau needl and scope of treatability studiea and additional fteld investiJations
Two conceptS are ueful to understand the new phued IUIPS proceaa Pint data can be
collected in severalalqes with initial data collection efforts usually beina limited to deve1opinamp
a pnera1 undmllnclint of the aile AI die site is better cbancterized sublequent data colleclion
cfforu c be foculed 10 fill Ill wcm 11p1 in he diU Second lhil phued un1
__idemiflcllloaofkeydolaaeodlueadyinlhe_ll_iblero_
lhll dill collectioa is alwaya direcled toward providina infOIIDIIion relevanr to bullaecuon of a
remedial aetioa In this way die overall aile charwcerirMicm effort cm be continually acopecl to
minimize he oolloclion of-dolallld muimizo dolo qualily
Colleclion of llldiiiOIIIIdD 1111 commenced wilb a Field llemeftl Sllldy whidl il aimed
II clotinl - in die -- t for die Rlllld tilt- (RA) Wbile a basic plaD
of operaion 1111 - delopod t cleacribed in a Field - Wost Plan he clala
oolleclion prooou will conlinuo 10 be _mro he dolo aeodl of die PS
Upon ltltgtqgt1e1ion of he Field llemeftla Sllldy lhe new- will be evalualed wilh IOipOCI
10 die dD IIIII coadaailtn of die Rlllllll RA and a delcrmilwion made 11 10 he neceaally of
bini porliona ofeilbor - middot The Dover Manicipal Landfill PS will incorponlte he foUowm lalks subjeclro EPA
approval
TASK 1 Scoojns pftbc FS
Adminillralive Order Data Oaps
Field Elemenl SIUdy Wort PIUI
Draft Feuibilily SIUdy Wost PIUI
TASK 2 Sjtc CbepmriprjM
bull Field SIUdy Elemenu Repon
2middot2
u~============J _mz~
~~S2-l
shy
I I
~ I I
TASK 3 DeyclQIDCot gf Rcspons Qbjectiycs NMi Respow Actiqps Pinal Pcuibility Study Work Plan
Letter repon with sugsested tcchnolosies for consideralion and discussion of
Applicable or Relev111t and Appropriate Requitemenu (ARARs)
TASK 4 Baseline Risk AmnDfDt
Sununuy of Existing Baseline Risk Assessment specifically the identification
of sensitive recepton and remedial clean-up objectives whith may be modifed
based on the tonclusions of the Field Elemenu Study Completion of this tuk
would be tontincent upon Field Element Study dltl and EPA ipprOVal
TASK RcmcdiallnycMitbulliqn Rcpoa Summary of lWatinl Draft R1 Report speltifiltally the contaminant fate IUid
U1n1p011 Ulelllnenl which may be updlled bued on tbe conclusiona of the
Field llemonts Study Such on updlte would be campewl upon BPA _II
TASK 6 Dcycl- gf Altmperiyg
Briltfinl to pmeat pellmitwy _ objoctma ond criteria
Letter_ cliaataainl pellmitwy - objoctigta ond criteriaLetter_ Olllliaiac tomedilllloomarivea clnelopocl
TASK 7 lnitjal Sgwginf of Altmneriva
TASK 8 trmllbjljrv SDMjca (Optional)
Benchsclleshybull T~Wmihy Studiel
TASK 9 Qaailcd ANIYia of Rmbulljnjnr Altrmlljyg
Summary table and narntive description of ldvamqes and disadvan111eS of
eaeh allemllive
TASK 10 PrciJamprJtjoogfDqft PS Repon
TASK II Final PS Rcpon
TASK 12 Pmjmjnary DesjroofSclcctod Rrmt4ja] Ahcmatiyc
(Developed after ROD Siplinamp)
2112HAZ-2732 2-4
TASK 13 MwpmmtandCoordjnlljon
TASK 14 Cmrunynjty RclatjgM Sygpon
22 SCOPE OF WORK
This section discusses current EPA FS guidance as it applies to the FS tasks and amplifies
the scope and HMMs approach to the tub
221 Tuk 1 bull Scgpina of the FS
The Dover Municipal Landfill Rl lq)OR was prepared in IICCordance with the NCP and
prevlilina JUiltlonce undolt CERCLA HMM will updl1e the site _ infomwion
preiOIIIOdln the Remediallnvatiaation Report Agt - previowly the FS procetJ under SARA (ond Ill other new ampderol reaulationl)
hu become more -ive willgt 1he remedial endpoira belri fottorecl inlo 1he invettiaative
pngtCOII from 1he projoltt planninl- duouch1he mnoinder of 1he invellipdCOI
Tbr pwpooe of Tlllt I will be to dovolop a wor1t plan IWinamp IMgtw tpeeifiC diu llpl are to
be 8llecl Tbeae diu - lndude - outliDed in 1he Admirlilualve Order bull u u 1he oddidonll dlla requlrementl 11111 have dovolopod duoup 1he review of 1he Remedial
fnvestiaatiCOI (Rl) (Docomber 1981) ond lUolt -t(RA) (Mardi 1988) Tbr field wort
will be conc1ucted u put of 1he Site Cbancterizltioo (TIIIt 2)
Tbeae efforu have reoulted In the clovelopment of 1he Field 11ement Study Wort PlOD
docamatlinl1he JCopiq - Uld pmenq orwicipoted future wb It olao tervet II I
voluable tool fw uailrgtirtlmpooaiblliliea ond eatabliohini 1he projoltt t tchedule
222 Tuk 2 middot Sifl aizbullion
The exiltifta Rl report delcribea tbe fe1d investiallive work conducted to eWe by previous
inveatiaators The dlta and concluaiona presented in the Rl and RA reports form the buis for
lhe cwrmt understandinc of site conditions
Based on HMMs review of the Rl and RA repons and in liaht of current SARA guidance
Uld anticipated remecliol _ options data saps 10 be lldclreoaed duoup funlrer freld
investiJarion wete outlined in Task 1 field Element Study Wort Pllll
2512HAZ-2732 2-5
I I
- I I
Upon completion ofTuk I through onaoina cUcussions wilh the EPA and NH DES he
new database will be reviewed relative to the interpretaJion and conclusions of the previous Rl
and RA repons Specific attention will focus on the contaminant fate and transport model of the
Rl repon as well as the identification of sensitive receptors and the remedial objective(s) and
criteria developed in the Risk Assessment This updated Site Characterization will be presented
in a Draft Field Element Study Report submined to EPA and NH DES for review
223 Tuk 3 - Dcyelgpncm gf RcapoOR Obicctjycs and Rcsponsc Actions
General response actions that miampht be taken at a site are initially deftned during scoping
and are refmed throusflout the PS process u a better undentandina of site conditions is aained FoUowinamp completion of the site characterization and reduction and interpre111ion of the
resul11111 data HMM in conjwxtion with EPA and NH DES will re-evaluate the e~oisting
rapo- objectives opplicable technoloJieo ond ARARs for lhe Dever Municipal Landfill The
results of this uaesamem will be uted to revile and fanalize thiJ Draft Peuibility Study Wort
Plaa ThiJ evaluation will detormiDe whether new infOIDIIlion lllhmd durinamp the Sile
Chlraclerizllion would result in moclificatioaa to responae objectives and criteria for eath
COftlarninaled medium Pwthamore each response technoiOIY orilinaiJy identified would be
re-cvallllled for ita opplicability 10 site conditions ond odditioaal rechnoloJieo would be
idenlilled for lilnher c-idenltion u wunnoecl Finally the idenlifled ARARs would be
re-cuminocl to eruwe t1w they opplicable to the reviled raponse objeetiveo ond
tecbDoloPet New EPA pidance relative to ARARJ is in development IDd is avai1able in drift
form (Relerence Review Dnft CERCLA C-lilnce With Other Laws Mtnual OSWER
Direcrive 92341~1 (May 6 1981)) ond pidance is also anilable in the EPA Re1ion I
S~al Riolt Alletlmenr Oaidance for the Supetfund Propam
The responae objectivea techaolotiea and ARARs lhll evolve from thiJ process will
serve u lhe buil for initillinamp dilcualionJ reaardinc more specific upecu of remedial response such u site-speciamp delft--up aoals If an ARAR is delermined to be protective of the human
health or the eavizonmenr it will be used to establish the acceptable exposure level If an
ARAR is not proceaive of the population or environmem does not exist for 1he specific
chemical or pathways of concem or does not apply because multiple contaminants may be
posina a cumulative risk acceptable exposure leveb will be identifted through the risk
usesament process The Supcrfwxl Puhljc Health Enluarjoo Manual provides additional details
on establishinamp acceptable exposure levels when no ARARs exist
2112HAZ-2732 2-6
This reevalUillon process will result in the preparaalon of a Pinal Peuibility Srudy Work
Plan which will outline what refmements if any would be required in the development and
evalualion process of remedial alternatives
224 Task 4- Bwlinc RN Assuqcnr
A3 the Site Characterization nean completion the resultutt data wiU be evaluated in
conjunction with data from the existinc Baseline Risk Assessment The objective of this
useumem will be a determination of the nanue and sipiftcanee of the risk posed to public
health welfan or the environment by the contaminlnta preaenc The Bueline Riak Aueument
is euemially an useumem of the riat usociated with the No-Action alternative (ie the
prellld futuJe rilt in tbe oboence of my odditional mpo111lt lltliou)
Tho Bueline Riallt --r metilodoiOSY obould be bued on lbe moot cumnt-shyocoepoed by tbe US Em-Il r-aioa Aptyeny u publilbed in lbe ledenl Repoer
(49FIU27 et teq) IDd in lbl fiaa1 s Ppbljs Health Pxeluim Mnbull (US BPA
~1-16-060 Ootobor 1916) llld lbe s- of New llamplbile o Riallt --r Oftlce
Oaldellnu 110 IIJo -lded in lbe lleJlon I Sllflll-1 Riallt --r Ouldaxe for lbe
s__ Propm Tbe publicbeallb riltc- obou1d _--
fillY pt bull ideMification of tboee individual~ or JIVUPI wbo 11e 11
rilt of _ via inbololion iopllion clinlct COIIIICI or olber _ of
_ Tbla -Ia buedupon idonliflcolion ofeltJ1011110 pGwamp)l
bued on ealadq cilia IIIII - cilia fngtm lbe Silo Cbarw1eriuoion llld conalderl
f_ mecblalomo for lbe COIIIIminlaao of concern
Iqaisicy bullmiddot=-=middot a compuilon of contaminant concentrationlll the titc with
COIItllniDID-apecific ARARJ to determine acceptable concentnlions for each
rnecliam of ccoem for tbe conwninants of concern
Rid Oypstcrizerigp m inlepation of fmdinamps ampom the expn~UR usessment
and toxicity asaeument to determine the potential for ldvene health or
environmentampl effecu for each exposure scenario
2$12JHAZ2732 2-7
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
TABbull EOF COfiPNIS
fa~lt
10 INTRODUCTION 1-1
11 Backaround 1-112 Site Location 1-113 Site History 1-3
20 SCOPE OP WORK 2-1
21 RIJPS Procea 22 Sltopo of Walt
2-1
2-5221 Toot Imiddot
Toot2 ~222 2-5 223 TootJ - 2-5
=-~-ObJoctivallld 224 Toot4- 2-6B-Riat~22$ Toot5 2-7 ~ofRemoclial 226 Toot6- 2-1 227 Toot7- 2-1IDilial of- shy228 Toot Imiddot ==~ 2-9
~llmtobility SIUdia229 Toot9 2-10=yoloof~ 2210 2-11TootiO bull ~ofDn1t PS Repon2211 Toot II - Filial PS Report 2-15 2212 Tllll2 2-15 ~ Doaip of Selected Rnedill Altenwiva
2213 Tootl3 2-18~rllldCoordinllion2214 Tllll4 2-18c-aRelabonosupporr 2-19
ATTACIIMINr
A - Adminiattllive Order middot Sope of Walt
Y
10 NJROQUCTION
11 BACKGROUND
HMM Associates lnc (HMM) has prepared this Draft Feasibility Study (fS) Work Plan
ror the Dover Municipal Landfill to conform to applicable guidance under the Comprehensive
Environmental Response Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA) and the National Oil and
Huardow SubstanCeS ContinJency Plan (NCP) and more current EPA guidance implemented
under the Superfund Amendments and Reauthorization Act of 1986 (SARA) specificaUy the
Interim final Guidance for Conduttinc Remedial lnvestiauions and Feasibility Studies Under
CllRCLA dated Aupt 1988 (OSWER Dimtivo 935-301 ) HMM developed this Draft FS
Wort Plan with the undenlllldinJ tlw EPA seeks to ime the December 1988 Draft
Remediol lnveotilotim Repon the Manb 1989 Risk Aloe- the resulll of the field
llemenll Srudy (Manb 31 1989 Wort Plm) md the Peuibility Srudy (PS)componenll of this
projoltl in conformmce with the ltamnt tedtnical _dt lei fonb by EPA In this woy the
raul lleltold of Deciaion (ROD) will reflect the cumndy _m to selelttion of
the moot_ site remedy
12 SIIIOCADQN
The Drmr Municipol Llndftll iJ I _ w- c1ilpolal uu located in the -est
ltOmet of Dcmr New ll_w the - of the Dover a and Madbury
town lines The site aboWD iD Piampua 1-1 iss~ four miiN wettmiddot norlbweat ampom the tenter
of the City of Dcmr bull 431230 nonb lllirude md 705730 well IOfllitude (USOS 1978)
The landfill iJ about onemiddotbolf mile IOUIII of the Dcmr city produlttion well (Colderwood) which
is loeaed in an uca tailed _ Hoppen approximllely 00 feet west of the Cochelto River
and -tme-lthinl of I mile nonb of Molleso a- and the Bellamy (Porumouth) Reservoir
Wetlando southwell of the laadfill it fnlm the reoervoir The landfill is bordetocl by
Tolend Rood md 0 Hill Road on the oonh by Tolend Rood on the ltIll md by private
property m die southelll and IOUIII The weatem portion of the site borden boch the
Mldbwy-Dover line lnd private property The eu1 point of the landfill site is 11 the intersection
ofTolend Road and Glen HillRochester Nect Rod The site is located in 1 rural au althouamph
land Ilona the eut side ofTolend-Rochester Neck Roads hu been subdivided for buildinamplots
2512HAZ-2732 1-1
LOCA110N OP DOVER lANDIIUSITII
DOVBRNH
13 SITE USTQRY
The Dover Municipal Landfill beaan active operation in 1960 or 1961 and continued until
1979 at which time diJposal operacions ceased ln the course of faciliry operltion the landfill
received solid waste macerials comprised of domeStic and industrial sludges leuher tanninc and
shoe wute products oraanic solvents wute oil and munidpampl solid wute Closure of the site
consistinJ of a cover oper11ion consuu~ion of a surface waterJ1uchate drainqe channel and 0
P O site access control wu completed in 1980 Olt 3m
The proximity of two major municipal water supply sources the Calderwood WeU (City ~ z ~ 3of Dover) and the BeUamy Reservoir (City of Ponsmoulh) prompted Dover city officials and VC ~z
repla1ory penonnel to initiate a poundwater monitorina proaram in 1977 follow ina site ~ ~
closure lhe monitorina proanm wu expmded to include aeveral residential wella Laboratory H lt P 11111)1lt1 of w11er collec1ed from raideatillwe1111ocaoed on Tolencl Rood t Olen Hill mr
Rod revealed that m p some of the wdlt were conlllninlampecl primarily with vo~ile OfJIIlk r n z
_ Baecl on public hoal1b concema woci- wilh lhe exiltinJ nl pocential 0 0 - of - public t privooe middot- 1Upply _ lhe Dover Municipol LlndfU 0 ~ wu nabd n1 ploced on the EPAs Nlliollll Priori) Lill
In occonllnlte wilh lhe _of lhe Nllional C-mency Pl111 a Remedial Action
- Plan (RAMP) wu -- f0lt 1be oite in 1913 The RAMP iDcluded a _
ocopo of MrVicel for romodlol oct1on activldoa bull the olio t called fOlt complollon of
a RaDocllolJmaliilllionPeaoibllity Shldy
In order to ptweed with the RaDocllol lnapionPeuibillly Shldy of the Dover
Municipal Landfill tbe s- of New H w- $apply t PoUutloll C-1
Commlulon (NHWSPCC) executed a _nve - wid the IPA Thio _ment enablocl EPA to _n fundi fOlt invatilllion of lhe obe in accordance wid lbe
Comprehensive Enviroamontal R- c_ion t Liability Act of 1910 (CERCLA)
for RemodiallnveaticllionPeuibllity Study aaivitieo
23 I2HAZ-2732 1-3
20 SCOPE OF WORK AND SCHEQWE
21 RIFS PRQCESS
Thi3 wort plan for the Dover Landfill feasibility Study (FS) was based on the scope ofwork oudined in the Administrative Order for the Feasibility Study (See Anactunent A as
0~0
updated in accordance with EPAs Interim Final Guidance for Conductins Remedial Oltlnvestisatioru and Feasibility Studies Thi3 tpproach meets all the mandates of SARA in order middotz- for NHJDES and EPA to develop 1ft eteeptable Record of Decision (ROD The new provisions ~3VC~zunder SARA havifta the peltelt impact on the IUIFS proceaa are the Clunup Standards These ~sundardt create a bulluona llatutory preference for remediea dw are hiafdy rdiable and provide ~~ lt ~ lona-tenn proceaion In addition to the requimnent that remedies be both cott-eftective and ~mr
pngtlteclive of shy heollb llld lbe environment oeleltlion of a mnedial llfiacll mull abo rconaldor lbe followinl Uclelineo n z ~
0 0 0~
rrA JRfaonco for mnedial aotionl thai ~oy tre-t that pe-y llld
aipilkoally -lbe volame tollicity or mobility of hazanloul Rlbouncapoll- aad contalllitwa u lbeir prialtipal-
Avo- of ofampilo -pot~ aad ~ - _ wllen otherpnaicalgtle _lecbDol01ioa availlble
The need to - lbe ue of pe~ aoludOftl md altemllive treamenttedtaotopea or - tOCOVery oocmolopu IIIII lbem to lbe muimwn
pnaicoble
Althoqb the new proriliona of CERCLA have reaulted in aonw modificatioru to theIUIPS procea lbe buic componenu of lhe procesa remain inUMt The Rl continues to serve uthe mechaniam for collectlaa dMa for aile and wute chlncterizalion and for conduclinatteMabilily teltina u neceaauy to evalubull the performance and cOlt of the treatmentteehaoloaies lnd 1upport lhe deaip of selected remedies The PS continues to serve u themedlaniJm for lbe devel-t saeeninJ IIIII detailed evoluotion of potemiol mediolaltemarivea
~12JHAZ2732 2-1
This work plan follows the Interim Final Guidance for Conduttinl Remedial
lnvestisltions and Feuibility Studies Under CERCLA (OSWER Directive 93553-01) which
varies rrom older romws in that the current RIFS process is much more interactive with the Rl
beins divided into two phases and the FS in1o three phases Some of the Rl and FS phases run
concurrently and the objeclives of the laner phases of the R1 are tailored to meet specific FS
data needs Exhibit 2-1 depicts the new process
It is important to note that because portions of tbe RI and FS are conducted concurrently
data collected in tbe Rl will influence the development of remedial alternatives in the FS which
in rum affects the dau needl and scope of treatability studiea and additional fteld investiJations
Two conceptS are ueful to understand the new phued IUIPS proceaa Pint data can be
collected in severalalqes with initial data collection efforts usually beina limited to deve1opinamp
a pnera1 undmllnclint of the aile AI die site is better cbancterized sublequent data colleclion
cfforu c be foculed 10 fill Ill wcm 11p1 in he diU Second lhil phued un1
__idemiflcllloaofkeydolaaeodlueadyinlhe_ll_iblero_
lhll dill collectioa is alwaya direcled toward providina infOIIDIIion relevanr to bullaecuon of a
remedial aetioa In this way die overall aile charwcerirMicm effort cm be continually acopecl to
minimize he oolloclion of-dolallld muimizo dolo qualily
Colleclion of llldiiiOIIIIdD 1111 commenced wilb a Field llemeftl Sllldy whidl il aimed
II clotinl - in die -- t for die Rlllld tilt- (RA) Wbile a basic plaD
of operaion 1111 - delopod t cleacribed in a Field - Wost Plan he clala
oolleclion prooou will conlinuo 10 be _mro he dolo aeodl of die PS
Upon ltltgtqgt1e1ion of he Field llemeftla Sllldy lhe new- will be evalualed wilh IOipOCI
10 die dD IIIII coadaailtn of die Rlllllll RA and a delcrmilwion made 11 10 he neceaally of
bini porliona ofeilbor - middot The Dover Manicipal Landfill PS will incorponlte he foUowm lalks subjeclro EPA
approval
TASK 1 Scoojns pftbc FS
Adminillralive Order Data Oaps
Field Elemenl SIUdy Wort PIUI
Draft Feuibilily SIUdy Wost PIUI
TASK 2 Sjtc CbepmriprjM
bull Field SIUdy Elemenu Repon
2middot2
u~============J _mz~
~~S2-l
shy
I I
~ I I
TASK 3 DeyclQIDCot gf Rcspons Qbjectiycs NMi Respow Actiqps Pinal Pcuibility Study Work Plan
Letter repon with sugsested tcchnolosies for consideralion and discussion of
Applicable or Relev111t and Appropriate Requitemenu (ARARs)
TASK 4 Baseline Risk AmnDfDt
Sununuy of Existing Baseline Risk Assessment specifically the identification
of sensitive recepton and remedial clean-up objectives whith may be modifed
based on the tonclusions of the Field Elemenu Study Completion of this tuk
would be tontincent upon Field Element Study dltl and EPA ipprOVal
TASK RcmcdiallnycMitbulliqn Rcpoa Summary of lWatinl Draft R1 Report speltifiltally the contaminant fate IUid
U1n1p011 Ulelllnenl which may be updlled bued on tbe conclusiona of the
Field llemonts Study Such on updlte would be campewl upon BPA _II
TASK 6 Dcycl- gf Altmperiyg
Briltfinl to pmeat pellmitwy _ objoctma ond criteria
Letter_ cliaataainl pellmitwy - objoctigta ond criteriaLetter_ Olllliaiac tomedilllloomarivea clnelopocl
TASK 7 lnitjal Sgwginf of Altmneriva
TASK 8 trmllbjljrv SDMjca (Optional)
Benchsclleshybull T~Wmihy Studiel
TASK 9 Qaailcd ANIYia of Rmbulljnjnr Altrmlljyg
Summary table and narntive description of ldvamqes and disadvan111eS of
eaeh allemllive
TASK 10 PrciJamprJtjoogfDqft PS Repon
TASK II Final PS Rcpon
TASK 12 Pmjmjnary DesjroofSclcctod Rrmt4ja] Ahcmatiyc
(Developed after ROD Siplinamp)
2112HAZ-2732 2-4
TASK 13 MwpmmtandCoordjnlljon
TASK 14 Cmrunynjty RclatjgM Sygpon
22 SCOPE OF WORK
This section discusses current EPA FS guidance as it applies to the FS tasks and amplifies
the scope and HMMs approach to the tub
221 Tuk 1 bull Scgpina of the FS
The Dover Municipal Landfill Rl lq)OR was prepared in IICCordance with the NCP and
prevlilina JUiltlonce undolt CERCLA HMM will updl1e the site _ infomwion
preiOIIIOdln the Remediallnvatiaation Report Agt - previowly the FS procetJ under SARA (ond Ill other new ampderol reaulationl)
hu become more -ive willgt 1he remedial endpoira belri fottorecl inlo 1he invettiaative
pngtCOII from 1he projoltt planninl- duouch1he mnoinder of 1he invellipdCOI
Tbr pwpooe of Tlllt I will be to dovolop a wor1t plan IWinamp IMgtw tpeeifiC diu llpl are to
be 8llecl Tbeae diu - lndude - outliDed in 1he Admirlilualve Order bull u u 1he oddidonll dlla requlrementl 11111 have dovolopod duoup 1he review of 1he Remedial
fnvestiaatiCOI (Rl) (Docomber 1981) ond lUolt -t(RA) (Mardi 1988) Tbr field wort
will be conc1ucted u put of 1he Site Cbancterizltioo (TIIIt 2)
Tbeae efforu have reoulted In the clovelopment of 1he Field 11ement Study Wort PlOD
docamatlinl1he JCopiq - Uld pmenq orwicipoted future wb It olao tervet II I
voluable tool fw uailrgtirtlmpooaiblliliea ond eatabliohini 1he projoltt t tchedule
222 Tuk 2 middot Sifl aizbullion
The exiltifta Rl report delcribea tbe fe1d investiallive work conducted to eWe by previous
inveatiaators The dlta and concluaiona presented in the Rl and RA reports form the buis for
lhe cwrmt understandinc of site conditions
Based on HMMs review of the Rl and RA repons and in liaht of current SARA guidance
Uld anticipated remecliol _ options data saps 10 be lldclreoaed duoup funlrer freld
investiJarion wete outlined in Task 1 field Element Study Wort Pllll
2512HAZ-2732 2-5
I I
- I I
Upon completion ofTuk I through onaoina cUcussions wilh the EPA and NH DES he
new database will be reviewed relative to the interpretaJion and conclusions of the previous Rl
and RA repons Specific attention will focus on the contaminant fate and transport model of the
Rl repon as well as the identification of sensitive receptors and the remedial objective(s) and
criteria developed in the Risk Assessment This updated Site Characterization will be presented
in a Draft Field Element Study Report submined to EPA and NH DES for review
223 Tuk 3 - Dcyelgpncm gf RcapoOR Obicctjycs and Rcsponsc Actions
General response actions that miampht be taken at a site are initially deftned during scoping
and are refmed throusflout the PS process u a better undentandina of site conditions is aained FoUowinamp completion of the site characterization and reduction and interpre111ion of the
resul11111 data HMM in conjwxtion with EPA and NH DES will re-evaluate the e~oisting
rapo- objectives opplicable technoloJieo ond ARARs for lhe Dever Municipal Landfill The
results of this uaesamem will be uted to revile and fanalize thiJ Draft Peuibility Study Wort
Plaa ThiJ evaluation will detormiDe whether new infOIDIIlion lllhmd durinamp the Sile
Chlraclerizllion would result in moclificatioaa to responae objectives and criteria for eath
COftlarninaled medium Pwthamore each response technoiOIY orilinaiJy identified would be
re-cvallllled for ita opplicability 10 site conditions ond odditioaal rechnoloJieo would be
idenlilled for lilnher c-idenltion u wunnoecl Finally the idenlifled ARARs would be
re-cuminocl to eruwe t1w they opplicable to the reviled raponse objeetiveo ond
tecbDoloPet New EPA pidance relative to ARARJ is in development IDd is avai1able in drift
form (Relerence Review Dnft CERCLA C-lilnce With Other Laws Mtnual OSWER
Direcrive 92341~1 (May 6 1981)) ond pidance is also anilable in the EPA Re1ion I
S~al Riolt Alletlmenr Oaidance for the Supetfund Propam
The responae objectivea techaolotiea and ARARs lhll evolve from thiJ process will
serve u lhe buil for initillinamp dilcualionJ reaardinc more specific upecu of remedial response such u site-speciamp delft--up aoals If an ARAR is delermined to be protective of the human
health or the eavizonmenr it will be used to establish the acceptable exposure level If an
ARAR is not proceaive of the population or environmem does not exist for 1he specific
chemical or pathways of concem or does not apply because multiple contaminants may be
posina a cumulative risk acceptable exposure leveb will be identifted through the risk
usesament process The Supcrfwxl Puhljc Health Enluarjoo Manual provides additional details
on establishinamp acceptable exposure levels when no ARARs exist
2112HAZ-2732 2-6
This reevalUillon process will result in the preparaalon of a Pinal Peuibility Srudy Work
Plan which will outline what refmements if any would be required in the development and
evalualion process of remedial alternatives
224 Task 4- Bwlinc RN Assuqcnr
A3 the Site Characterization nean completion the resultutt data wiU be evaluated in
conjunction with data from the existinc Baseline Risk Assessment The objective of this
useumem will be a determination of the nanue and sipiftcanee of the risk posed to public
health welfan or the environment by the contaminlnta preaenc The Bueline Riak Aueument
is euemially an useumem of the riat usociated with the No-Action alternative (ie the
prellld futuJe rilt in tbe oboence of my odditional mpo111lt lltliou)
Tho Bueline Riallt --r metilodoiOSY obould be bued on lbe moot cumnt-shyocoepoed by tbe US Em-Il r-aioa Aptyeny u publilbed in lbe ledenl Repoer
(49FIU27 et teq) IDd in lbl fiaa1 s Ppbljs Health Pxeluim Mnbull (US BPA
~1-16-060 Ootobor 1916) llld lbe s- of New llamplbile o Riallt --r Oftlce
Oaldellnu 110 IIJo -lded in lbe lleJlon I Sllflll-1 Riallt --r Ouldaxe for lbe
s__ Propm Tbe publicbeallb riltc- obou1d _--
fillY pt bull ideMification of tboee individual~ or JIVUPI wbo 11e 11
rilt of _ via inbololion iopllion clinlct COIIIICI or olber _ of
_ Tbla -Ia buedupon idonliflcolion ofeltJ1011110 pGwamp)l
bued on ealadq cilia IIIII - cilia fngtm lbe Silo Cbarw1eriuoion llld conalderl
f_ mecblalomo for lbe COIIIIminlaao of concern
Iqaisicy bullmiddot=-=middot a compuilon of contaminant concentrationlll the titc with
COIItllniDID-apecific ARARJ to determine acceptable concentnlions for each
rnecliam of ccoem for tbe conwninants of concern
Rid Oypstcrizerigp m inlepation of fmdinamps ampom the expn~UR usessment
and toxicity asaeument to determine the potential for ldvene health or
environmentampl effecu for each exposure scenario
2$12JHAZ2732 2-7
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
10 NJROQUCTION
11 BACKGROUND
HMM Associates lnc (HMM) has prepared this Draft Feasibility Study (fS) Work Plan
ror the Dover Municipal Landfill to conform to applicable guidance under the Comprehensive
Environmental Response Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA) and the National Oil and
Huardow SubstanCeS ContinJency Plan (NCP) and more current EPA guidance implemented
under the Superfund Amendments and Reauthorization Act of 1986 (SARA) specificaUy the
Interim final Guidance for Conduttinc Remedial lnvestiauions and Feasibility Studies Under
CllRCLA dated Aupt 1988 (OSWER Dimtivo 935-301 ) HMM developed this Draft FS
Wort Plan with the undenlllldinJ tlw EPA seeks to ime the December 1988 Draft
Remediol lnveotilotim Repon the Manb 1989 Risk Aloe- the resulll of the field
llemenll Srudy (Manb 31 1989 Wort Plm) md the Peuibility Srudy (PS)componenll of this
projoltl in conformmce with the ltamnt tedtnical _dt lei fonb by EPA In this woy the
raul lleltold of Deciaion (ROD) will reflect the cumndy _m to selelttion of
the moot_ site remedy
12 SIIIOCADQN
The Drmr Municipol Llndftll iJ I _ w- c1ilpolal uu located in the -est
ltOmet of Dcmr New ll_w the - of the Dover a and Madbury
town lines The site aboWD iD Piampua 1-1 iss~ four miiN wettmiddot norlbweat ampom the tenter
of the City of Dcmr bull 431230 nonb lllirude md 705730 well IOfllitude (USOS 1978)
The landfill iJ about onemiddotbolf mile IOUIII of the Dcmr city produlttion well (Colderwood) which
is loeaed in an uca tailed _ Hoppen approximllely 00 feet west of the Cochelto River
and -tme-lthinl of I mile nonb of Molleso a- and the Bellamy (Porumouth) Reservoir
Wetlando southwell of the laadfill it fnlm the reoervoir The landfill is bordetocl by
Tolend Rood md 0 Hill Road on the oonh by Tolend Rood on the ltIll md by private
property m die southelll and IOUIII The weatem portion of the site borden boch the
Mldbwy-Dover line lnd private property The eu1 point of the landfill site is 11 the intersection
ofTolend Road and Glen HillRochester Nect Rod The site is located in 1 rural au althouamph
land Ilona the eut side ofTolend-Rochester Neck Roads hu been subdivided for buildinamplots
2512HAZ-2732 1-1
LOCA110N OP DOVER lANDIIUSITII
DOVBRNH
13 SITE USTQRY
The Dover Municipal Landfill beaan active operation in 1960 or 1961 and continued until
1979 at which time diJposal operacions ceased ln the course of faciliry operltion the landfill
received solid waste macerials comprised of domeStic and industrial sludges leuher tanninc and
shoe wute products oraanic solvents wute oil and munidpampl solid wute Closure of the site
consistinJ of a cover oper11ion consuu~ion of a surface waterJ1uchate drainqe channel and 0
P O site access control wu completed in 1980 Olt 3m
The proximity of two major municipal water supply sources the Calderwood WeU (City ~ z ~ 3of Dover) and the BeUamy Reservoir (City of Ponsmoulh) prompted Dover city officials and VC ~z
repla1ory penonnel to initiate a poundwater monitorina proaram in 1977 follow ina site ~ ~
closure lhe monitorina proanm wu expmded to include aeveral residential wella Laboratory H lt P 11111)1lt1 of w11er collec1ed from raideatillwe1111ocaoed on Tolencl Rood t Olen Hill mr
Rod revealed that m p some of the wdlt were conlllninlampecl primarily with vo~ile OfJIIlk r n z
_ Baecl on public hoal1b concema woci- wilh lhe exiltinJ nl pocential 0 0 - of - public t privooe middot- 1Upply _ lhe Dover Municipol LlndfU 0 ~ wu nabd n1 ploced on the EPAs Nlliollll Priori) Lill
In occonllnlte wilh lhe _of lhe Nllional C-mency Pl111 a Remedial Action
- Plan (RAMP) wu -- f0lt 1be oite in 1913 The RAMP iDcluded a _
ocopo of MrVicel for romodlol oct1on activldoa bull the olio t called fOlt complollon of
a RaDocllolJmaliilllionPeaoibllity Shldy
In order to ptweed with the RaDocllol lnapionPeuibillly Shldy of the Dover
Municipal Landfill tbe s- of New H w- $apply t PoUutloll C-1
Commlulon (NHWSPCC) executed a _nve - wid the IPA Thio _ment enablocl EPA to _n fundi fOlt invatilllion of lhe obe in accordance wid lbe
Comprehensive Enviroamontal R- c_ion t Liability Act of 1910 (CERCLA)
for RemodiallnveaticllionPeuibllity Study aaivitieo
23 I2HAZ-2732 1-3
20 SCOPE OF WORK AND SCHEQWE
21 RIFS PRQCESS
Thi3 wort plan for the Dover Landfill feasibility Study (FS) was based on the scope ofwork oudined in the Administrative Order for the Feasibility Study (See Anactunent A as
0~0
updated in accordance with EPAs Interim Final Guidance for Conductins Remedial Oltlnvestisatioru and Feasibility Studies Thi3 tpproach meets all the mandates of SARA in order middotz- for NHJDES and EPA to develop 1ft eteeptable Record of Decision (ROD The new provisions ~3VC~zunder SARA havifta the peltelt impact on the IUIFS proceaa are the Clunup Standards These ~sundardt create a bulluona llatutory preference for remediea dw are hiafdy rdiable and provide ~~ lt ~ lona-tenn proceaion In addition to the requimnent that remedies be both cott-eftective and ~mr
pngtlteclive of shy heollb llld lbe environment oeleltlion of a mnedial llfiacll mull abo rconaldor lbe followinl Uclelineo n z ~
0 0 0~
rrA JRfaonco for mnedial aotionl thai ~oy tre-t that pe-y llld
aipilkoally -lbe volame tollicity or mobility of hazanloul Rlbouncapoll- aad contalllitwa u lbeir prialtipal-
Avo- of ofampilo -pot~ aad ~ - _ wllen otherpnaicalgtle _lecbDol01ioa availlble
The need to - lbe ue of pe~ aoludOftl md altemllive treamenttedtaotopea or - tOCOVery oocmolopu IIIII lbem to lbe muimwn
pnaicoble
Althoqb the new proriliona of CERCLA have reaulted in aonw modificatioru to theIUIPS procea lbe buic componenu of lhe procesa remain inUMt The Rl continues to serve uthe mechaniam for collectlaa dMa for aile and wute chlncterizalion and for conduclinatteMabilily teltina u neceaauy to evalubull the performance and cOlt of the treatmentteehaoloaies lnd 1upport lhe deaip of selected remedies The PS continues to serve u themedlaniJm for lbe devel-t saeeninJ IIIII detailed evoluotion of potemiol mediolaltemarivea
~12JHAZ2732 2-1
This work plan follows the Interim Final Guidance for Conduttinl Remedial
lnvestisltions and Feuibility Studies Under CERCLA (OSWER Directive 93553-01) which
varies rrom older romws in that the current RIFS process is much more interactive with the Rl
beins divided into two phases and the FS in1o three phases Some of the Rl and FS phases run
concurrently and the objeclives of the laner phases of the R1 are tailored to meet specific FS
data needs Exhibit 2-1 depicts the new process
It is important to note that because portions of tbe RI and FS are conducted concurrently
data collected in tbe Rl will influence the development of remedial alternatives in the FS which
in rum affects the dau needl and scope of treatability studiea and additional fteld investiJations
Two conceptS are ueful to understand the new phued IUIPS proceaa Pint data can be
collected in severalalqes with initial data collection efforts usually beina limited to deve1opinamp
a pnera1 undmllnclint of the aile AI die site is better cbancterized sublequent data colleclion
cfforu c be foculed 10 fill Ill wcm 11p1 in he diU Second lhil phued un1
__idemiflcllloaofkeydolaaeodlueadyinlhe_ll_iblero_
lhll dill collectioa is alwaya direcled toward providina infOIIDIIion relevanr to bullaecuon of a
remedial aetioa In this way die overall aile charwcerirMicm effort cm be continually acopecl to
minimize he oolloclion of-dolallld muimizo dolo qualily
Colleclion of llldiiiOIIIIdD 1111 commenced wilb a Field llemeftl Sllldy whidl il aimed
II clotinl - in die -- t for die Rlllld tilt- (RA) Wbile a basic plaD
of operaion 1111 - delopod t cleacribed in a Field - Wost Plan he clala
oolleclion prooou will conlinuo 10 be _mro he dolo aeodl of die PS
Upon ltltgtqgt1e1ion of he Field llemeftla Sllldy lhe new- will be evalualed wilh IOipOCI
10 die dD IIIII coadaailtn of die Rlllllll RA and a delcrmilwion made 11 10 he neceaally of
bini porliona ofeilbor - middot The Dover Manicipal Landfill PS will incorponlte he foUowm lalks subjeclro EPA
approval
TASK 1 Scoojns pftbc FS
Adminillralive Order Data Oaps
Field Elemenl SIUdy Wort PIUI
Draft Feuibilily SIUdy Wost PIUI
TASK 2 Sjtc CbepmriprjM
bull Field SIUdy Elemenu Repon
2middot2
u~============J _mz~
~~S2-l
shy
I I
~ I I
TASK 3 DeyclQIDCot gf Rcspons Qbjectiycs NMi Respow Actiqps Pinal Pcuibility Study Work Plan
Letter repon with sugsested tcchnolosies for consideralion and discussion of
Applicable or Relev111t and Appropriate Requitemenu (ARARs)
TASK 4 Baseline Risk AmnDfDt
Sununuy of Existing Baseline Risk Assessment specifically the identification
of sensitive recepton and remedial clean-up objectives whith may be modifed
based on the tonclusions of the Field Elemenu Study Completion of this tuk
would be tontincent upon Field Element Study dltl and EPA ipprOVal
TASK RcmcdiallnycMitbulliqn Rcpoa Summary of lWatinl Draft R1 Report speltifiltally the contaminant fate IUid
U1n1p011 Ulelllnenl which may be updlled bued on tbe conclusiona of the
Field llemonts Study Such on updlte would be campewl upon BPA _II
TASK 6 Dcycl- gf Altmperiyg
Briltfinl to pmeat pellmitwy _ objoctma ond criteria
Letter_ cliaataainl pellmitwy - objoctigta ond criteriaLetter_ Olllliaiac tomedilllloomarivea clnelopocl
TASK 7 lnitjal Sgwginf of Altmneriva
TASK 8 trmllbjljrv SDMjca (Optional)
Benchsclleshybull T~Wmihy Studiel
TASK 9 Qaailcd ANIYia of Rmbulljnjnr Altrmlljyg
Summary table and narntive description of ldvamqes and disadvan111eS of
eaeh allemllive
TASK 10 PrciJamprJtjoogfDqft PS Repon
TASK II Final PS Rcpon
TASK 12 Pmjmjnary DesjroofSclcctod Rrmt4ja] Ahcmatiyc
(Developed after ROD Siplinamp)
2112HAZ-2732 2-4
TASK 13 MwpmmtandCoordjnlljon
TASK 14 Cmrunynjty RclatjgM Sygpon
22 SCOPE OF WORK
This section discusses current EPA FS guidance as it applies to the FS tasks and amplifies
the scope and HMMs approach to the tub
221 Tuk 1 bull Scgpina of the FS
The Dover Municipal Landfill Rl lq)OR was prepared in IICCordance with the NCP and
prevlilina JUiltlonce undolt CERCLA HMM will updl1e the site _ infomwion
preiOIIIOdln the Remediallnvatiaation Report Agt - previowly the FS procetJ under SARA (ond Ill other new ampderol reaulationl)
hu become more -ive willgt 1he remedial endpoira belri fottorecl inlo 1he invettiaative
pngtCOII from 1he projoltt planninl- duouch1he mnoinder of 1he invellipdCOI
Tbr pwpooe of Tlllt I will be to dovolop a wor1t plan IWinamp IMgtw tpeeifiC diu llpl are to
be 8llecl Tbeae diu - lndude - outliDed in 1he Admirlilualve Order bull u u 1he oddidonll dlla requlrementl 11111 have dovolopod duoup 1he review of 1he Remedial
fnvestiaatiCOI (Rl) (Docomber 1981) ond lUolt -t(RA) (Mardi 1988) Tbr field wort
will be conc1ucted u put of 1he Site Cbancterizltioo (TIIIt 2)
Tbeae efforu have reoulted In the clovelopment of 1he Field 11ement Study Wort PlOD
docamatlinl1he JCopiq - Uld pmenq orwicipoted future wb It olao tervet II I
voluable tool fw uailrgtirtlmpooaiblliliea ond eatabliohini 1he projoltt t tchedule
222 Tuk 2 middot Sifl aizbullion
The exiltifta Rl report delcribea tbe fe1d investiallive work conducted to eWe by previous
inveatiaators The dlta and concluaiona presented in the Rl and RA reports form the buis for
lhe cwrmt understandinc of site conditions
Based on HMMs review of the Rl and RA repons and in liaht of current SARA guidance
Uld anticipated remecliol _ options data saps 10 be lldclreoaed duoup funlrer freld
investiJarion wete outlined in Task 1 field Element Study Wort Pllll
2512HAZ-2732 2-5
I I
- I I
Upon completion ofTuk I through onaoina cUcussions wilh the EPA and NH DES he
new database will be reviewed relative to the interpretaJion and conclusions of the previous Rl
and RA repons Specific attention will focus on the contaminant fate and transport model of the
Rl repon as well as the identification of sensitive receptors and the remedial objective(s) and
criteria developed in the Risk Assessment This updated Site Characterization will be presented
in a Draft Field Element Study Report submined to EPA and NH DES for review
223 Tuk 3 - Dcyelgpncm gf RcapoOR Obicctjycs and Rcsponsc Actions
General response actions that miampht be taken at a site are initially deftned during scoping
and are refmed throusflout the PS process u a better undentandina of site conditions is aained FoUowinamp completion of the site characterization and reduction and interpre111ion of the
resul11111 data HMM in conjwxtion with EPA and NH DES will re-evaluate the e~oisting
rapo- objectives opplicable technoloJieo ond ARARs for lhe Dever Municipal Landfill The
results of this uaesamem will be uted to revile and fanalize thiJ Draft Peuibility Study Wort
Plaa ThiJ evaluation will detormiDe whether new infOIDIIlion lllhmd durinamp the Sile
Chlraclerizllion would result in moclificatioaa to responae objectives and criteria for eath
COftlarninaled medium Pwthamore each response technoiOIY orilinaiJy identified would be
re-cvallllled for ita opplicability 10 site conditions ond odditioaal rechnoloJieo would be
idenlilled for lilnher c-idenltion u wunnoecl Finally the idenlifled ARARs would be
re-cuminocl to eruwe t1w they opplicable to the reviled raponse objeetiveo ond
tecbDoloPet New EPA pidance relative to ARARJ is in development IDd is avai1able in drift
form (Relerence Review Dnft CERCLA C-lilnce With Other Laws Mtnual OSWER
Direcrive 92341~1 (May 6 1981)) ond pidance is also anilable in the EPA Re1ion I
S~al Riolt Alletlmenr Oaidance for the Supetfund Propam
The responae objectivea techaolotiea and ARARs lhll evolve from thiJ process will
serve u lhe buil for initillinamp dilcualionJ reaardinc more specific upecu of remedial response such u site-speciamp delft--up aoals If an ARAR is delermined to be protective of the human
health or the eavizonmenr it will be used to establish the acceptable exposure level If an
ARAR is not proceaive of the population or environmem does not exist for 1he specific
chemical or pathways of concem or does not apply because multiple contaminants may be
posina a cumulative risk acceptable exposure leveb will be identifted through the risk
usesament process The Supcrfwxl Puhljc Health Enluarjoo Manual provides additional details
on establishinamp acceptable exposure levels when no ARARs exist
2112HAZ-2732 2-6
This reevalUillon process will result in the preparaalon of a Pinal Peuibility Srudy Work
Plan which will outline what refmements if any would be required in the development and
evalualion process of remedial alternatives
224 Task 4- Bwlinc RN Assuqcnr
A3 the Site Characterization nean completion the resultutt data wiU be evaluated in
conjunction with data from the existinc Baseline Risk Assessment The objective of this
useumem will be a determination of the nanue and sipiftcanee of the risk posed to public
health welfan or the environment by the contaminlnta preaenc The Bueline Riak Aueument
is euemially an useumem of the riat usociated with the No-Action alternative (ie the
prellld futuJe rilt in tbe oboence of my odditional mpo111lt lltliou)
Tho Bueline Riallt --r metilodoiOSY obould be bued on lbe moot cumnt-shyocoepoed by tbe US Em-Il r-aioa Aptyeny u publilbed in lbe ledenl Repoer
(49FIU27 et teq) IDd in lbl fiaa1 s Ppbljs Health Pxeluim Mnbull (US BPA
~1-16-060 Ootobor 1916) llld lbe s- of New llamplbile o Riallt --r Oftlce
Oaldellnu 110 IIJo -lded in lbe lleJlon I Sllflll-1 Riallt --r Ouldaxe for lbe
s__ Propm Tbe publicbeallb riltc- obou1d _--
fillY pt bull ideMification of tboee individual~ or JIVUPI wbo 11e 11
rilt of _ via inbololion iopllion clinlct COIIIICI or olber _ of
_ Tbla -Ia buedupon idonliflcolion ofeltJ1011110 pGwamp)l
bued on ealadq cilia IIIII - cilia fngtm lbe Silo Cbarw1eriuoion llld conalderl
f_ mecblalomo for lbe COIIIIminlaao of concern
Iqaisicy bullmiddot=-=middot a compuilon of contaminant concentrationlll the titc with
COIItllniDID-apecific ARARJ to determine acceptable concentnlions for each
rnecliam of ccoem for tbe conwninants of concern
Rid Oypstcrizerigp m inlepation of fmdinamps ampom the expn~UR usessment
and toxicity asaeument to determine the potential for ldvene health or
environmentampl effecu for each exposure scenario
2$12JHAZ2732 2-7
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
LOCA110N OP DOVER lANDIIUSITII
DOVBRNH
13 SITE USTQRY
The Dover Municipal Landfill beaan active operation in 1960 or 1961 and continued until
1979 at which time diJposal operacions ceased ln the course of faciliry operltion the landfill
received solid waste macerials comprised of domeStic and industrial sludges leuher tanninc and
shoe wute products oraanic solvents wute oil and munidpampl solid wute Closure of the site
consistinJ of a cover oper11ion consuu~ion of a surface waterJ1uchate drainqe channel and 0
P O site access control wu completed in 1980 Olt 3m
The proximity of two major municipal water supply sources the Calderwood WeU (City ~ z ~ 3of Dover) and the BeUamy Reservoir (City of Ponsmoulh) prompted Dover city officials and VC ~z
repla1ory penonnel to initiate a poundwater monitorina proaram in 1977 follow ina site ~ ~
closure lhe monitorina proanm wu expmded to include aeveral residential wella Laboratory H lt P 11111)1lt1 of w11er collec1ed from raideatillwe1111ocaoed on Tolencl Rood t Olen Hill mr
Rod revealed that m p some of the wdlt were conlllninlampecl primarily with vo~ile OfJIIlk r n z
_ Baecl on public hoal1b concema woci- wilh lhe exiltinJ nl pocential 0 0 - of - public t privooe middot- 1Upply _ lhe Dover Municipol LlndfU 0 ~ wu nabd n1 ploced on the EPAs Nlliollll Priori) Lill
In occonllnlte wilh lhe _of lhe Nllional C-mency Pl111 a Remedial Action
- Plan (RAMP) wu -- f0lt 1be oite in 1913 The RAMP iDcluded a _
ocopo of MrVicel for romodlol oct1on activldoa bull the olio t called fOlt complollon of
a RaDocllolJmaliilllionPeaoibllity Shldy
In order to ptweed with the RaDocllol lnapionPeuibillly Shldy of the Dover
Municipal Landfill tbe s- of New H w- $apply t PoUutloll C-1
Commlulon (NHWSPCC) executed a _nve - wid the IPA Thio _ment enablocl EPA to _n fundi fOlt invatilllion of lhe obe in accordance wid lbe
Comprehensive Enviroamontal R- c_ion t Liability Act of 1910 (CERCLA)
for RemodiallnveaticllionPeuibllity Study aaivitieo
23 I2HAZ-2732 1-3
20 SCOPE OF WORK AND SCHEQWE
21 RIFS PRQCESS
Thi3 wort plan for the Dover Landfill feasibility Study (FS) was based on the scope ofwork oudined in the Administrative Order for the Feasibility Study (See Anactunent A as
0~0
updated in accordance with EPAs Interim Final Guidance for Conductins Remedial Oltlnvestisatioru and Feasibility Studies Thi3 tpproach meets all the mandates of SARA in order middotz- for NHJDES and EPA to develop 1ft eteeptable Record of Decision (ROD The new provisions ~3VC~zunder SARA havifta the peltelt impact on the IUIFS proceaa are the Clunup Standards These ~sundardt create a bulluona llatutory preference for remediea dw are hiafdy rdiable and provide ~~ lt ~ lona-tenn proceaion In addition to the requimnent that remedies be both cott-eftective and ~mr
pngtlteclive of shy heollb llld lbe environment oeleltlion of a mnedial llfiacll mull abo rconaldor lbe followinl Uclelineo n z ~
0 0 0~
rrA JRfaonco for mnedial aotionl thai ~oy tre-t that pe-y llld
aipilkoally -lbe volame tollicity or mobility of hazanloul Rlbouncapoll- aad contalllitwa u lbeir prialtipal-
Avo- of ofampilo -pot~ aad ~ - _ wllen otherpnaicalgtle _lecbDol01ioa availlble
The need to - lbe ue of pe~ aoludOftl md altemllive treamenttedtaotopea or - tOCOVery oocmolopu IIIII lbem to lbe muimwn
pnaicoble
Althoqb the new proriliona of CERCLA have reaulted in aonw modificatioru to theIUIPS procea lbe buic componenu of lhe procesa remain inUMt The Rl continues to serve uthe mechaniam for collectlaa dMa for aile and wute chlncterizalion and for conduclinatteMabilily teltina u neceaauy to evalubull the performance and cOlt of the treatmentteehaoloaies lnd 1upport lhe deaip of selected remedies The PS continues to serve u themedlaniJm for lbe devel-t saeeninJ IIIII detailed evoluotion of potemiol mediolaltemarivea
~12JHAZ2732 2-1
This work plan follows the Interim Final Guidance for Conduttinl Remedial
lnvestisltions and Feuibility Studies Under CERCLA (OSWER Directive 93553-01) which
varies rrom older romws in that the current RIFS process is much more interactive with the Rl
beins divided into two phases and the FS in1o three phases Some of the Rl and FS phases run
concurrently and the objeclives of the laner phases of the R1 are tailored to meet specific FS
data needs Exhibit 2-1 depicts the new process
It is important to note that because portions of tbe RI and FS are conducted concurrently
data collected in tbe Rl will influence the development of remedial alternatives in the FS which
in rum affects the dau needl and scope of treatability studiea and additional fteld investiJations
Two conceptS are ueful to understand the new phued IUIPS proceaa Pint data can be
collected in severalalqes with initial data collection efforts usually beina limited to deve1opinamp
a pnera1 undmllnclint of the aile AI die site is better cbancterized sublequent data colleclion
cfforu c be foculed 10 fill Ill wcm 11p1 in he diU Second lhil phued un1
__idemiflcllloaofkeydolaaeodlueadyinlhe_ll_iblero_
lhll dill collectioa is alwaya direcled toward providina infOIIDIIion relevanr to bullaecuon of a
remedial aetioa In this way die overall aile charwcerirMicm effort cm be continually acopecl to
minimize he oolloclion of-dolallld muimizo dolo qualily
Colleclion of llldiiiOIIIIdD 1111 commenced wilb a Field llemeftl Sllldy whidl il aimed
II clotinl - in die -- t for die Rlllld tilt- (RA) Wbile a basic plaD
of operaion 1111 - delopod t cleacribed in a Field - Wost Plan he clala
oolleclion prooou will conlinuo 10 be _mro he dolo aeodl of die PS
Upon ltltgtqgt1e1ion of he Field llemeftla Sllldy lhe new- will be evalualed wilh IOipOCI
10 die dD IIIII coadaailtn of die Rlllllll RA and a delcrmilwion made 11 10 he neceaally of
bini porliona ofeilbor - middot The Dover Manicipal Landfill PS will incorponlte he foUowm lalks subjeclro EPA
approval
TASK 1 Scoojns pftbc FS
Adminillralive Order Data Oaps
Field Elemenl SIUdy Wort PIUI
Draft Feuibilily SIUdy Wost PIUI
TASK 2 Sjtc CbepmriprjM
bull Field SIUdy Elemenu Repon
2middot2
u~============J _mz~
~~S2-l
shy
I I
~ I I
TASK 3 DeyclQIDCot gf Rcspons Qbjectiycs NMi Respow Actiqps Pinal Pcuibility Study Work Plan
Letter repon with sugsested tcchnolosies for consideralion and discussion of
Applicable or Relev111t and Appropriate Requitemenu (ARARs)
TASK 4 Baseline Risk AmnDfDt
Sununuy of Existing Baseline Risk Assessment specifically the identification
of sensitive recepton and remedial clean-up objectives whith may be modifed
based on the tonclusions of the Field Elemenu Study Completion of this tuk
would be tontincent upon Field Element Study dltl and EPA ipprOVal
TASK RcmcdiallnycMitbulliqn Rcpoa Summary of lWatinl Draft R1 Report speltifiltally the contaminant fate IUid
U1n1p011 Ulelllnenl which may be updlled bued on tbe conclusiona of the
Field llemonts Study Such on updlte would be campewl upon BPA _II
TASK 6 Dcycl- gf Altmperiyg
Briltfinl to pmeat pellmitwy _ objoctma ond criteria
Letter_ cliaataainl pellmitwy - objoctigta ond criteriaLetter_ Olllliaiac tomedilllloomarivea clnelopocl
TASK 7 lnitjal Sgwginf of Altmneriva
TASK 8 trmllbjljrv SDMjca (Optional)
Benchsclleshybull T~Wmihy Studiel
TASK 9 Qaailcd ANIYia of Rmbulljnjnr Altrmlljyg
Summary table and narntive description of ldvamqes and disadvan111eS of
eaeh allemllive
TASK 10 PrciJamprJtjoogfDqft PS Repon
TASK II Final PS Rcpon
TASK 12 Pmjmjnary DesjroofSclcctod Rrmt4ja] Ahcmatiyc
(Developed after ROD Siplinamp)
2112HAZ-2732 2-4
TASK 13 MwpmmtandCoordjnlljon
TASK 14 Cmrunynjty RclatjgM Sygpon
22 SCOPE OF WORK
This section discusses current EPA FS guidance as it applies to the FS tasks and amplifies
the scope and HMMs approach to the tub
221 Tuk 1 bull Scgpina of the FS
The Dover Municipal Landfill Rl lq)OR was prepared in IICCordance with the NCP and
prevlilina JUiltlonce undolt CERCLA HMM will updl1e the site _ infomwion
preiOIIIOdln the Remediallnvatiaation Report Agt - previowly the FS procetJ under SARA (ond Ill other new ampderol reaulationl)
hu become more -ive willgt 1he remedial endpoira belri fottorecl inlo 1he invettiaative
pngtCOII from 1he projoltt planninl- duouch1he mnoinder of 1he invellipdCOI
Tbr pwpooe of Tlllt I will be to dovolop a wor1t plan IWinamp IMgtw tpeeifiC diu llpl are to
be 8llecl Tbeae diu - lndude - outliDed in 1he Admirlilualve Order bull u u 1he oddidonll dlla requlrementl 11111 have dovolopod duoup 1he review of 1he Remedial
fnvestiaatiCOI (Rl) (Docomber 1981) ond lUolt -t(RA) (Mardi 1988) Tbr field wort
will be conc1ucted u put of 1he Site Cbancterizltioo (TIIIt 2)
Tbeae efforu have reoulted In the clovelopment of 1he Field 11ement Study Wort PlOD
docamatlinl1he JCopiq - Uld pmenq orwicipoted future wb It olao tervet II I
voluable tool fw uailrgtirtlmpooaiblliliea ond eatabliohini 1he projoltt t tchedule
222 Tuk 2 middot Sifl aizbullion
The exiltifta Rl report delcribea tbe fe1d investiallive work conducted to eWe by previous
inveatiaators The dlta and concluaiona presented in the Rl and RA reports form the buis for
lhe cwrmt understandinc of site conditions
Based on HMMs review of the Rl and RA repons and in liaht of current SARA guidance
Uld anticipated remecliol _ options data saps 10 be lldclreoaed duoup funlrer freld
investiJarion wete outlined in Task 1 field Element Study Wort Pllll
2512HAZ-2732 2-5
I I
- I I
Upon completion ofTuk I through onaoina cUcussions wilh the EPA and NH DES he
new database will be reviewed relative to the interpretaJion and conclusions of the previous Rl
and RA repons Specific attention will focus on the contaminant fate and transport model of the
Rl repon as well as the identification of sensitive receptors and the remedial objective(s) and
criteria developed in the Risk Assessment This updated Site Characterization will be presented
in a Draft Field Element Study Report submined to EPA and NH DES for review
223 Tuk 3 - Dcyelgpncm gf RcapoOR Obicctjycs and Rcsponsc Actions
General response actions that miampht be taken at a site are initially deftned during scoping
and are refmed throusflout the PS process u a better undentandina of site conditions is aained FoUowinamp completion of the site characterization and reduction and interpre111ion of the
resul11111 data HMM in conjwxtion with EPA and NH DES will re-evaluate the e~oisting
rapo- objectives opplicable technoloJieo ond ARARs for lhe Dever Municipal Landfill The
results of this uaesamem will be uted to revile and fanalize thiJ Draft Peuibility Study Wort
Plaa ThiJ evaluation will detormiDe whether new infOIDIIlion lllhmd durinamp the Sile
Chlraclerizllion would result in moclificatioaa to responae objectives and criteria for eath
COftlarninaled medium Pwthamore each response technoiOIY orilinaiJy identified would be
re-cvallllled for ita opplicability 10 site conditions ond odditioaal rechnoloJieo would be
idenlilled for lilnher c-idenltion u wunnoecl Finally the idenlifled ARARs would be
re-cuminocl to eruwe t1w they opplicable to the reviled raponse objeetiveo ond
tecbDoloPet New EPA pidance relative to ARARJ is in development IDd is avai1able in drift
form (Relerence Review Dnft CERCLA C-lilnce With Other Laws Mtnual OSWER
Direcrive 92341~1 (May 6 1981)) ond pidance is also anilable in the EPA Re1ion I
S~al Riolt Alletlmenr Oaidance for the Supetfund Propam
The responae objectivea techaolotiea and ARARs lhll evolve from thiJ process will
serve u lhe buil for initillinamp dilcualionJ reaardinc more specific upecu of remedial response such u site-speciamp delft--up aoals If an ARAR is delermined to be protective of the human
health or the eavizonmenr it will be used to establish the acceptable exposure level If an
ARAR is not proceaive of the population or environmem does not exist for 1he specific
chemical or pathways of concem or does not apply because multiple contaminants may be
posina a cumulative risk acceptable exposure leveb will be identifted through the risk
usesament process The Supcrfwxl Puhljc Health Enluarjoo Manual provides additional details
on establishinamp acceptable exposure levels when no ARARs exist
2112HAZ-2732 2-6
This reevalUillon process will result in the preparaalon of a Pinal Peuibility Srudy Work
Plan which will outline what refmements if any would be required in the development and
evalualion process of remedial alternatives
224 Task 4- Bwlinc RN Assuqcnr
A3 the Site Characterization nean completion the resultutt data wiU be evaluated in
conjunction with data from the existinc Baseline Risk Assessment The objective of this
useumem will be a determination of the nanue and sipiftcanee of the risk posed to public
health welfan or the environment by the contaminlnta preaenc The Bueline Riak Aueument
is euemially an useumem of the riat usociated with the No-Action alternative (ie the
prellld futuJe rilt in tbe oboence of my odditional mpo111lt lltliou)
Tho Bueline Riallt --r metilodoiOSY obould be bued on lbe moot cumnt-shyocoepoed by tbe US Em-Il r-aioa Aptyeny u publilbed in lbe ledenl Repoer
(49FIU27 et teq) IDd in lbl fiaa1 s Ppbljs Health Pxeluim Mnbull (US BPA
~1-16-060 Ootobor 1916) llld lbe s- of New llamplbile o Riallt --r Oftlce
Oaldellnu 110 IIJo -lded in lbe lleJlon I Sllflll-1 Riallt --r Ouldaxe for lbe
s__ Propm Tbe publicbeallb riltc- obou1d _--
fillY pt bull ideMification of tboee individual~ or JIVUPI wbo 11e 11
rilt of _ via inbololion iopllion clinlct COIIIICI or olber _ of
_ Tbla -Ia buedupon idonliflcolion ofeltJ1011110 pGwamp)l
bued on ealadq cilia IIIII - cilia fngtm lbe Silo Cbarw1eriuoion llld conalderl
f_ mecblalomo for lbe COIIIIminlaao of concern
Iqaisicy bullmiddot=-=middot a compuilon of contaminant concentrationlll the titc with
COIItllniDID-apecific ARARJ to determine acceptable concentnlions for each
rnecliam of ccoem for tbe conwninants of concern
Rid Oypstcrizerigp m inlepation of fmdinamps ampom the expn~UR usessment
and toxicity asaeument to determine the potential for ldvene health or
environmentampl effecu for each exposure scenario
2$12JHAZ2732 2-7
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
13 SITE USTQRY
The Dover Municipal Landfill beaan active operation in 1960 or 1961 and continued until
1979 at which time diJposal operacions ceased ln the course of faciliry operltion the landfill
received solid waste macerials comprised of domeStic and industrial sludges leuher tanninc and
shoe wute products oraanic solvents wute oil and munidpampl solid wute Closure of the site
consistinJ of a cover oper11ion consuu~ion of a surface waterJ1uchate drainqe channel and 0
P O site access control wu completed in 1980 Olt 3m
The proximity of two major municipal water supply sources the Calderwood WeU (City ~ z ~ 3of Dover) and the BeUamy Reservoir (City of Ponsmoulh) prompted Dover city officials and VC ~z
repla1ory penonnel to initiate a poundwater monitorina proaram in 1977 follow ina site ~ ~
closure lhe monitorina proanm wu expmded to include aeveral residential wella Laboratory H lt P 11111)1lt1 of w11er collec1ed from raideatillwe1111ocaoed on Tolencl Rood t Olen Hill mr
Rod revealed that m p some of the wdlt were conlllninlampecl primarily with vo~ile OfJIIlk r n z
_ Baecl on public hoal1b concema woci- wilh lhe exiltinJ nl pocential 0 0 - of - public t privooe middot- 1Upply _ lhe Dover Municipol LlndfU 0 ~ wu nabd n1 ploced on the EPAs Nlliollll Priori) Lill
In occonllnlte wilh lhe _of lhe Nllional C-mency Pl111 a Remedial Action
- Plan (RAMP) wu -- f0lt 1be oite in 1913 The RAMP iDcluded a _
ocopo of MrVicel for romodlol oct1on activldoa bull the olio t called fOlt complollon of
a RaDocllolJmaliilllionPeaoibllity Shldy
In order to ptweed with the RaDocllol lnapionPeuibillly Shldy of the Dover
Municipal Landfill tbe s- of New H w- $apply t PoUutloll C-1
Commlulon (NHWSPCC) executed a _nve - wid the IPA Thio _ment enablocl EPA to _n fundi fOlt invatilllion of lhe obe in accordance wid lbe
Comprehensive Enviroamontal R- c_ion t Liability Act of 1910 (CERCLA)
for RemodiallnveaticllionPeuibllity Study aaivitieo
23 I2HAZ-2732 1-3
20 SCOPE OF WORK AND SCHEQWE
21 RIFS PRQCESS
Thi3 wort plan for the Dover Landfill feasibility Study (FS) was based on the scope ofwork oudined in the Administrative Order for the Feasibility Study (See Anactunent A as
0~0
updated in accordance with EPAs Interim Final Guidance for Conductins Remedial Oltlnvestisatioru and Feasibility Studies Thi3 tpproach meets all the mandates of SARA in order middotz- for NHJDES and EPA to develop 1ft eteeptable Record of Decision (ROD The new provisions ~3VC~zunder SARA havifta the peltelt impact on the IUIFS proceaa are the Clunup Standards These ~sundardt create a bulluona llatutory preference for remediea dw are hiafdy rdiable and provide ~~ lt ~ lona-tenn proceaion In addition to the requimnent that remedies be both cott-eftective and ~mr
pngtlteclive of shy heollb llld lbe environment oeleltlion of a mnedial llfiacll mull abo rconaldor lbe followinl Uclelineo n z ~
0 0 0~
rrA JRfaonco for mnedial aotionl thai ~oy tre-t that pe-y llld
aipilkoally -lbe volame tollicity or mobility of hazanloul Rlbouncapoll- aad contalllitwa u lbeir prialtipal-
Avo- of ofampilo -pot~ aad ~ - _ wllen otherpnaicalgtle _lecbDol01ioa availlble
The need to - lbe ue of pe~ aoludOftl md altemllive treamenttedtaotopea or - tOCOVery oocmolopu IIIII lbem to lbe muimwn
pnaicoble
Althoqb the new proriliona of CERCLA have reaulted in aonw modificatioru to theIUIPS procea lbe buic componenu of lhe procesa remain inUMt The Rl continues to serve uthe mechaniam for collectlaa dMa for aile and wute chlncterizalion and for conduclinatteMabilily teltina u neceaauy to evalubull the performance and cOlt of the treatmentteehaoloaies lnd 1upport lhe deaip of selected remedies The PS continues to serve u themedlaniJm for lbe devel-t saeeninJ IIIII detailed evoluotion of potemiol mediolaltemarivea
~12JHAZ2732 2-1
This work plan follows the Interim Final Guidance for Conduttinl Remedial
lnvestisltions and Feuibility Studies Under CERCLA (OSWER Directive 93553-01) which
varies rrom older romws in that the current RIFS process is much more interactive with the Rl
beins divided into two phases and the FS in1o three phases Some of the Rl and FS phases run
concurrently and the objeclives of the laner phases of the R1 are tailored to meet specific FS
data needs Exhibit 2-1 depicts the new process
It is important to note that because portions of tbe RI and FS are conducted concurrently
data collected in tbe Rl will influence the development of remedial alternatives in the FS which
in rum affects the dau needl and scope of treatability studiea and additional fteld investiJations
Two conceptS are ueful to understand the new phued IUIPS proceaa Pint data can be
collected in severalalqes with initial data collection efforts usually beina limited to deve1opinamp
a pnera1 undmllnclint of the aile AI die site is better cbancterized sublequent data colleclion
cfforu c be foculed 10 fill Ill wcm 11p1 in he diU Second lhil phued un1
__idemiflcllloaofkeydolaaeodlueadyinlhe_ll_iblero_
lhll dill collectioa is alwaya direcled toward providina infOIIDIIion relevanr to bullaecuon of a
remedial aetioa In this way die overall aile charwcerirMicm effort cm be continually acopecl to
minimize he oolloclion of-dolallld muimizo dolo qualily
Colleclion of llldiiiOIIIIdD 1111 commenced wilb a Field llemeftl Sllldy whidl il aimed
II clotinl - in die -- t for die Rlllld tilt- (RA) Wbile a basic plaD
of operaion 1111 - delopod t cleacribed in a Field - Wost Plan he clala
oolleclion prooou will conlinuo 10 be _mro he dolo aeodl of die PS
Upon ltltgtqgt1e1ion of he Field llemeftla Sllldy lhe new- will be evalualed wilh IOipOCI
10 die dD IIIII coadaailtn of die Rlllllll RA and a delcrmilwion made 11 10 he neceaally of
bini porliona ofeilbor - middot The Dover Manicipal Landfill PS will incorponlte he foUowm lalks subjeclro EPA
approval
TASK 1 Scoojns pftbc FS
Adminillralive Order Data Oaps
Field Elemenl SIUdy Wort PIUI
Draft Feuibilily SIUdy Wost PIUI
TASK 2 Sjtc CbepmriprjM
bull Field SIUdy Elemenu Repon
2middot2
u~============J _mz~
~~S2-l
shy
I I
~ I I
TASK 3 DeyclQIDCot gf Rcspons Qbjectiycs NMi Respow Actiqps Pinal Pcuibility Study Work Plan
Letter repon with sugsested tcchnolosies for consideralion and discussion of
Applicable or Relev111t and Appropriate Requitemenu (ARARs)
TASK 4 Baseline Risk AmnDfDt
Sununuy of Existing Baseline Risk Assessment specifically the identification
of sensitive recepton and remedial clean-up objectives whith may be modifed
based on the tonclusions of the Field Elemenu Study Completion of this tuk
would be tontincent upon Field Element Study dltl and EPA ipprOVal
TASK RcmcdiallnycMitbulliqn Rcpoa Summary of lWatinl Draft R1 Report speltifiltally the contaminant fate IUid
U1n1p011 Ulelllnenl which may be updlled bued on tbe conclusiona of the
Field llemonts Study Such on updlte would be campewl upon BPA _II
TASK 6 Dcycl- gf Altmperiyg
Briltfinl to pmeat pellmitwy _ objoctma ond criteria
Letter_ cliaataainl pellmitwy - objoctigta ond criteriaLetter_ Olllliaiac tomedilllloomarivea clnelopocl
TASK 7 lnitjal Sgwginf of Altmneriva
TASK 8 trmllbjljrv SDMjca (Optional)
Benchsclleshybull T~Wmihy Studiel
TASK 9 Qaailcd ANIYia of Rmbulljnjnr Altrmlljyg
Summary table and narntive description of ldvamqes and disadvan111eS of
eaeh allemllive
TASK 10 PrciJamprJtjoogfDqft PS Repon
TASK II Final PS Rcpon
TASK 12 Pmjmjnary DesjroofSclcctod Rrmt4ja] Ahcmatiyc
(Developed after ROD Siplinamp)
2112HAZ-2732 2-4
TASK 13 MwpmmtandCoordjnlljon
TASK 14 Cmrunynjty RclatjgM Sygpon
22 SCOPE OF WORK
This section discusses current EPA FS guidance as it applies to the FS tasks and amplifies
the scope and HMMs approach to the tub
221 Tuk 1 bull Scgpina of the FS
The Dover Municipal Landfill Rl lq)OR was prepared in IICCordance with the NCP and
prevlilina JUiltlonce undolt CERCLA HMM will updl1e the site _ infomwion
preiOIIIOdln the Remediallnvatiaation Report Agt - previowly the FS procetJ under SARA (ond Ill other new ampderol reaulationl)
hu become more -ive willgt 1he remedial endpoira belri fottorecl inlo 1he invettiaative
pngtCOII from 1he projoltt planninl- duouch1he mnoinder of 1he invellipdCOI
Tbr pwpooe of Tlllt I will be to dovolop a wor1t plan IWinamp IMgtw tpeeifiC diu llpl are to
be 8llecl Tbeae diu - lndude - outliDed in 1he Admirlilualve Order bull u u 1he oddidonll dlla requlrementl 11111 have dovolopod duoup 1he review of 1he Remedial
fnvestiaatiCOI (Rl) (Docomber 1981) ond lUolt -t(RA) (Mardi 1988) Tbr field wort
will be conc1ucted u put of 1he Site Cbancterizltioo (TIIIt 2)
Tbeae efforu have reoulted In the clovelopment of 1he Field 11ement Study Wort PlOD
docamatlinl1he JCopiq - Uld pmenq orwicipoted future wb It olao tervet II I
voluable tool fw uailrgtirtlmpooaiblliliea ond eatabliohini 1he projoltt t tchedule
222 Tuk 2 middot Sifl aizbullion
The exiltifta Rl report delcribea tbe fe1d investiallive work conducted to eWe by previous
inveatiaators The dlta and concluaiona presented in the Rl and RA reports form the buis for
lhe cwrmt understandinc of site conditions
Based on HMMs review of the Rl and RA repons and in liaht of current SARA guidance
Uld anticipated remecliol _ options data saps 10 be lldclreoaed duoup funlrer freld
investiJarion wete outlined in Task 1 field Element Study Wort Pllll
2512HAZ-2732 2-5
I I
- I I
Upon completion ofTuk I through onaoina cUcussions wilh the EPA and NH DES he
new database will be reviewed relative to the interpretaJion and conclusions of the previous Rl
and RA repons Specific attention will focus on the contaminant fate and transport model of the
Rl repon as well as the identification of sensitive receptors and the remedial objective(s) and
criteria developed in the Risk Assessment This updated Site Characterization will be presented
in a Draft Field Element Study Report submined to EPA and NH DES for review
223 Tuk 3 - Dcyelgpncm gf RcapoOR Obicctjycs and Rcsponsc Actions
General response actions that miampht be taken at a site are initially deftned during scoping
and are refmed throusflout the PS process u a better undentandina of site conditions is aained FoUowinamp completion of the site characterization and reduction and interpre111ion of the
resul11111 data HMM in conjwxtion with EPA and NH DES will re-evaluate the e~oisting
rapo- objectives opplicable technoloJieo ond ARARs for lhe Dever Municipal Landfill The
results of this uaesamem will be uted to revile and fanalize thiJ Draft Peuibility Study Wort
Plaa ThiJ evaluation will detormiDe whether new infOIDIIlion lllhmd durinamp the Sile
Chlraclerizllion would result in moclificatioaa to responae objectives and criteria for eath
COftlarninaled medium Pwthamore each response technoiOIY orilinaiJy identified would be
re-cvallllled for ita opplicability 10 site conditions ond odditioaal rechnoloJieo would be
idenlilled for lilnher c-idenltion u wunnoecl Finally the idenlifled ARARs would be
re-cuminocl to eruwe t1w they opplicable to the reviled raponse objeetiveo ond
tecbDoloPet New EPA pidance relative to ARARJ is in development IDd is avai1able in drift
form (Relerence Review Dnft CERCLA C-lilnce With Other Laws Mtnual OSWER
Direcrive 92341~1 (May 6 1981)) ond pidance is also anilable in the EPA Re1ion I
S~al Riolt Alletlmenr Oaidance for the Supetfund Propam
The responae objectivea techaolotiea and ARARs lhll evolve from thiJ process will
serve u lhe buil for initillinamp dilcualionJ reaardinc more specific upecu of remedial response such u site-speciamp delft--up aoals If an ARAR is delermined to be protective of the human
health or the eavizonmenr it will be used to establish the acceptable exposure level If an
ARAR is not proceaive of the population or environmem does not exist for 1he specific
chemical or pathways of concem or does not apply because multiple contaminants may be
posina a cumulative risk acceptable exposure leveb will be identifted through the risk
usesament process The Supcrfwxl Puhljc Health Enluarjoo Manual provides additional details
on establishinamp acceptable exposure levels when no ARARs exist
2112HAZ-2732 2-6
This reevalUillon process will result in the preparaalon of a Pinal Peuibility Srudy Work
Plan which will outline what refmements if any would be required in the development and
evalualion process of remedial alternatives
224 Task 4- Bwlinc RN Assuqcnr
A3 the Site Characterization nean completion the resultutt data wiU be evaluated in
conjunction with data from the existinc Baseline Risk Assessment The objective of this
useumem will be a determination of the nanue and sipiftcanee of the risk posed to public
health welfan or the environment by the contaminlnta preaenc The Bueline Riak Aueument
is euemially an useumem of the riat usociated with the No-Action alternative (ie the
prellld futuJe rilt in tbe oboence of my odditional mpo111lt lltliou)
Tho Bueline Riallt --r metilodoiOSY obould be bued on lbe moot cumnt-shyocoepoed by tbe US Em-Il r-aioa Aptyeny u publilbed in lbe ledenl Repoer
(49FIU27 et teq) IDd in lbl fiaa1 s Ppbljs Health Pxeluim Mnbull (US BPA
~1-16-060 Ootobor 1916) llld lbe s- of New llamplbile o Riallt --r Oftlce
Oaldellnu 110 IIJo -lded in lbe lleJlon I Sllflll-1 Riallt --r Ouldaxe for lbe
s__ Propm Tbe publicbeallb riltc- obou1d _--
fillY pt bull ideMification of tboee individual~ or JIVUPI wbo 11e 11
rilt of _ via inbololion iopllion clinlct COIIIICI or olber _ of
_ Tbla -Ia buedupon idonliflcolion ofeltJ1011110 pGwamp)l
bued on ealadq cilia IIIII - cilia fngtm lbe Silo Cbarw1eriuoion llld conalderl
f_ mecblalomo for lbe COIIIIminlaao of concern
Iqaisicy bullmiddot=-=middot a compuilon of contaminant concentrationlll the titc with
COIItllniDID-apecific ARARJ to determine acceptable concentnlions for each
rnecliam of ccoem for tbe conwninants of concern
Rid Oypstcrizerigp m inlepation of fmdinamps ampom the expn~UR usessment
and toxicity asaeument to determine the potential for ldvene health or
environmentampl effecu for each exposure scenario
2$12JHAZ2732 2-7
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
20 SCOPE OF WORK AND SCHEQWE
21 RIFS PRQCESS
Thi3 wort plan for the Dover Landfill feasibility Study (FS) was based on the scope ofwork oudined in the Administrative Order for the Feasibility Study (See Anactunent A as
0~0
updated in accordance with EPAs Interim Final Guidance for Conductins Remedial Oltlnvestisatioru and Feasibility Studies Thi3 tpproach meets all the mandates of SARA in order middotz- for NHJDES and EPA to develop 1ft eteeptable Record of Decision (ROD The new provisions ~3VC~zunder SARA havifta the peltelt impact on the IUIFS proceaa are the Clunup Standards These ~sundardt create a bulluona llatutory preference for remediea dw are hiafdy rdiable and provide ~~ lt ~ lona-tenn proceaion In addition to the requimnent that remedies be both cott-eftective and ~mr
pngtlteclive of shy heollb llld lbe environment oeleltlion of a mnedial llfiacll mull abo rconaldor lbe followinl Uclelineo n z ~
0 0 0~
rrA JRfaonco for mnedial aotionl thai ~oy tre-t that pe-y llld
aipilkoally -lbe volame tollicity or mobility of hazanloul Rlbouncapoll- aad contalllitwa u lbeir prialtipal-
Avo- of ofampilo -pot~ aad ~ - _ wllen otherpnaicalgtle _lecbDol01ioa availlble
The need to - lbe ue of pe~ aoludOftl md altemllive treamenttedtaotopea or - tOCOVery oocmolopu IIIII lbem to lbe muimwn
pnaicoble
Althoqb the new proriliona of CERCLA have reaulted in aonw modificatioru to theIUIPS procea lbe buic componenu of lhe procesa remain inUMt The Rl continues to serve uthe mechaniam for collectlaa dMa for aile and wute chlncterizalion and for conduclinatteMabilily teltina u neceaauy to evalubull the performance and cOlt of the treatmentteehaoloaies lnd 1upport lhe deaip of selected remedies The PS continues to serve u themedlaniJm for lbe devel-t saeeninJ IIIII detailed evoluotion of potemiol mediolaltemarivea
~12JHAZ2732 2-1
This work plan follows the Interim Final Guidance for Conduttinl Remedial
lnvestisltions and Feuibility Studies Under CERCLA (OSWER Directive 93553-01) which
varies rrom older romws in that the current RIFS process is much more interactive with the Rl
beins divided into two phases and the FS in1o three phases Some of the Rl and FS phases run
concurrently and the objeclives of the laner phases of the R1 are tailored to meet specific FS
data needs Exhibit 2-1 depicts the new process
It is important to note that because portions of tbe RI and FS are conducted concurrently
data collected in tbe Rl will influence the development of remedial alternatives in the FS which
in rum affects the dau needl and scope of treatability studiea and additional fteld investiJations
Two conceptS are ueful to understand the new phued IUIPS proceaa Pint data can be
collected in severalalqes with initial data collection efforts usually beina limited to deve1opinamp
a pnera1 undmllnclint of the aile AI die site is better cbancterized sublequent data colleclion
cfforu c be foculed 10 fill Ill wcm 11p1 in he diU Second lhil phued un1
__idemiflcllloaofkeydolaaeodlueadyinlhe_ll_iblero_
lhll dill collectioa is alwaya direcled toward providina infOIIDIIion relevanr to bullaecuon of a
remedial aetioa In this way die overall aile charwcerirMicm effort cm be continually acopecl to
minimize he oolloclion of-dolallld muimizo dolo qualily
Colleclion of llldiiiOIIIIdD 1111 commenced wilb a Field llemeftl Sllldy whidl il aimed
II clotinl - in die -- t for die Rlllld tilt- (RA) Wbile a basic plaD
of operaion 1111 - delopod t cleacribed in a Field - Wost Plan he clala
oolleclion prooou will conlinuo 10 be _mro he dolo aeodl of die PS
Upon ltltgtqgt1e1ion of he Field llemeftla Sllldy lhe new- will be evalualed wilh IOipOCI
10 die dD IIIII coadaailtn of die Rlllllll RA and a delcrmilwion made 11 10 he neceaally of
bini porliona ofeilbor - middot The Dover Manicipal Landfill PS will incorponlte he foUowm lalks subjeclro EPA
approval
TASK 1 Scoojns pftbc FS
Adminillralive Order Data Oaps
Field Elemenl SIUdy Wort PIUI
Draft Feuibilily SIUdy Wost PIUI
TASK 2 Sjtc CbepmriprjM
bull Field SIUdy Elemenu Repon
2middot2
u~============J _mz~
~~S2-l
shy
I I
~ I I
TASK 3 DeyclQIDCot gf Rcspons Qbjectiycs NMi Respow Actiqps Pinal Pcuibility Study Work Plan
Letter repon with sugsested tcchnolosies for consideralion and discussion of
Applicable or Relev111t and Appropriate Requitemenu (ARARs)
TASK 4 Baseline Risk AmnDfDt
Sununuy of Existing Baseline Risk Assessment specifically the identification
of sensitive recepton and remedial clean-up objectives whith may be modifed
based on the tonclusions of the Field Elemenu Study Completion of this tuk
would be tontincent upon Field Element Study dltl and EPA ipprOVal
TASK RcmcdiallnycMitbulliqn Rcpoa Summary of lWatinl Draft R1 Report speltifiltally the contaminant fate IUid
U1n1p011 Ulelllnenl which may be updlled bued on tbe conclusiona of the
Field llemonts Study Such on updlte would be campewl upon BPA _II
TASK 6 Dcycl- gf Altmperiyg
Briltfinl to pmeat pellmitwy _ objoctma ond criteria
Letter_ cliaataainl pellmitwy - objoctigta ond criteriaLetter_ Olllliaiac tomedilllloomarivea clnelopocl
TASK 7 lnitjal Sgwginf of Altmneriva
TASK 8 trmllbjljrv SDMjca (Optional)
Benchsclleshybull T~Wmihy Studiel
TASK 9 Qaailcd ANIYia of Rmbulljnjnr Altrmlljyg
Summary table and narntive description of ldvamqes and disadvan111eS of
eaeh allemllive
TASK 10 PrciJamprJtjoogfDqft PS Repon
TASK II Final PS Rcpon
TASK 12 Pmjmjnary DesjroofSclcctod Rrmt4ja] Ahcmatiyc
(Developed after ROD Siplinamp)
2112HAZ-2732 2-4
TASK 13 MwpmmtandCoordjnlljon
TASK 14 Cmrunynjty RclatjgM Sygpon
22 SCOPE OF WORK
This section discusses current EPA FS guidance as it applies to the FS tasks and amplifies
the scope and HMMs approach to the tub
221 Tuk 1 bull Scgpina of the FS
The Dover Municipal Landfill Rl lq)OR was prepared in IICCordance with the NCP and
prevlilina JUiltlonce undolt CERCLA HMM will updl1e the site _ infomwion
preiOIIIOdln the Remediallnvatiaation Report Agt - previowly the FS procetJ under SARA (ond Ill other new ampderol reaulationl)
hu become more -ive willgt 1he remedial endpoira belri fottorecl inlo 1he invettiaative
pngtCOII from 1he projoltt planninl- duouch1he mnoinder of 1he invellipdCOI
Tbr pwpooe of Tlllt I will be to dovolop a wor1t plan IWinamp IMgtw tpeeifiC diu llpl are to
be 8llecl Tbeae diu - lndude - outliDed in 1he Admirlilualve Order bull u u 1he oddidonll dlla requlrementl 11111 have dovolopod duoup 1he review of 1he Remedial
fnvestiaatiCOI (Rl) (Docomber 1981) ond lUolt -t(RA) (Mardi 1988) Tbr field wort
will be conc1ucted u put of 1he Site Cbancterizltioo (TIIIt 2)
Tbeae efforu have reoulted In the clovelopment of 1he Field 11ement Study Wort PlOD
docamatlinl1he JCopiq - Uld pmenq orwicipoted future wb It olao tervet II I
voluable tool fw uailrgtirtlmpooaiblliliea ond eatabliohini 1he projoltt t tchedule
222 Tuk 2 middot Sifl aizbullion
The exiltifta Rl report delcribea tbe fe1d investiallive work conducted to eWe by previous
inveatiaators The dlta and concluaiona presented in the Rl and RA reports form the buis for
lhe cwrmt understandinc of site conditions
Based on HMMs review of the Rl and RA repons and in liaht of current SARA guidance
Uld anticipated remecliol _ options data saps 10 be lldclreoaed duoup funlrer freld
investiJarion wete outlined in Task 1 field Element Study Wort Pllll
2512HAZ-2732 2-5
I I
- I I
Upon completion ofTuk I through onaoina cUcussions wilh the EPA and NH DES he
new database will be reviewed relative to the interpretaJion and conclusions of the previous Rl
and RA repons Specific attention will focus on the contaminant fate and transport model of the
Rl repon as well as the identification of sensitive receptors and the remedial objective(s) and
criteria developed in the Risk Assessment This updated Site Characterization will be presented
in a Draft Field Element Study Report submined to EPA and NH DES for review
223 Tuk 3 - Dcyelgpncm gf RcapoOR Obicctjycs and Rcsponsc Actions
General response actions that miampht be taken at a site are initially deftned during scoping
and are refmed throusflout the PS process u a better undentandina of site conditions is aained FoUowinamp completion of the site characterization and reduction and interpre111ion of the
resul11111 data HMM in conjwxtion with EPA and NH DES will re-evaluate the e~oisting
rapo- objectives opplicable technoloJieo ond ARARs for lhe Dever Municipal Landfill The
results of this uaesamem will be uted to revile and fanalize thiJ Draft Peuibility Study Wort
Plaa ThiJ evaluation will detormiDe whether new infOIDIIlion lllhmd durinamp the Sile
Chlraclerizllion would result in moclificatioaa to responae objectives and criteria for eath
COftlarninaled medium Pwthamore each response technoiOIY orilinaiJy identified would be
re-cvallllled for ita opplicability 10 site conditions ond odditioaal rechnoloJieo would be
idenlilled for lilnher c-idenltion u wunnoecl Finally the idenlifled ARARs would be
re-cuminocl to eruwe t1w they opplicable to the reviled raponse objeetiveo ond
tecbDoloPet New EPA pidance relative to ARARJ is in development IDd is avai1able in drift
form (Relerence Review Dnft CERCLA C-lilnce With Other Laws Mtnual OSWER
Direcrive 92341~1 (May 6 1981)) ond pidance is also anilable in the EPA Re1ion I
S~al Riolt Alletlmenr Oaidance for the Supetfund Propam
The responae objectivea techaolotiea and ARARs lhll evolve from thiJ process will
serve u lhe buil for initillinamp dilcualionJ reaardinc more specific upecu of remedial response such u site-speciamp delft--up aoals If an ARAR is delermined to be protective of the human
health or the eavizonmenr it will be used to establish the acceptable exposure level If an
ARAR is not proceaive of the population or environmem does not exist for 1he specific
chemical or pathways of concem or does not apply because multiple contaminants may be
posina a cumulative risk acceptable exposure leveb will be identifted through the risk
usesament process The Supcrfwxl Puhljc Health Enluarjoo Manual provides additional details
on establishinamp acceptable exposure levels when no ARARs exist
2112HAZ-2732 2-6
This reevalUillon process will result in the preparaalon of a Pinal Peuibility Srudy Work
Plan which will outline what refmements if any would be required in the development and
evalualion process of remedial alternatives
224 Task 4- Bwlinc RN Assuqcnr
A3 the Site Characterization nean completion the resultutt data wiU be evaluated in
conjunction with data from the existinc Baseline Risk Assessment The objective of this
useumem will be a determination of the nanue and sipiftcanee of the risk posed to public
health welfan or the environment by the contaminlnta preaenc The Bueline Riak Aueument
is euemially an useumem of the riat usociated with the No-Action alternative (ie the
prellld futuJe rilt in tbe oboence of my odditional mpo111lt lltliou)
Tho Bueline Riallt --r metilodoiOSY obould be bued on lbe moot cumnt-shyocoepoed by tbe US Em-Il r-aioa Aptyeny u publilbed in lbe ledenl Repoer
(49FIU27 et teq) IDd in lbl fiaa1 s Ppbljs Health Pxeluim Mnbull (US BPA
~1-16-060 Ootobor 1916) llld lbe s- of New llamplbile o Riallt --r Oftlce
Oaldellnu 110 IIJo -lded in lbe lleJlon I Sllflll-1 Riallt --r Ouldaxe for lbe
s__ Propm Tbe publicbeallb riltc- obou1d _--
fillY pt bull ideMification of tboee individual~ or JIVUPI wbo 11e 11
rilt of _ via inbololion iopllion clinlct COIIIICI or olber _ of
_ Tbla -Ia buedupon idonliflcolion ofeltJ1011110 pGwamp)l
bued on ealadq cilia IIIII - cilia fngtm lbe Silo Cbarw1eriuoion llld conalderl
f_ mecblalomo for lbe COIIIIminlaao of concern
Iqaisicy bullmiddot=-=middot a compuilon of contaminant concentrationlll the titc with
COIItllniDID-apecific ARARJ to determine acceptable concentnlions for each
rnecliam of ccoem for tbe conwninants of concern
Rid Oypstcrizerigp m inlepation of fmdinamps ampom the expn~UR usessment
and toxicity asaeument to determine the potential for ldvene health or
environmentampl effecu for each exposure scenario
2$12JHAZ2732 2-7
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
This work plan follows the Interim Final Guidance for Conduttinl Remedial
lnvestisltions and Feuibility Studies Under CERCLA (OSWER Directive 93553-01) which
varies rrom older romws in that the current RIFS process is much more interactive with the Rl
beins divided into two phases and the FS in1o three phases Some of the Rl and FS phases run
concurrently and the objeclives of the laner phases of the R1 are tailored to meet specific FS
data needs Exhibit 2-1 depicts the new process
It is important to note that because portions of tbe RI and FS are conducted concurrently
data collected in tbe Rl will influence the development of remedial alternatives in the FS which
in rum affects the dau needl and scope of treatability studiea and additional fteld investiJations
Two conceptS are ueful to understand the new phued IUIPS proceaa Pint data can be
collected in severalalqes with initial data collection efforts usually beina limited to deve1opinamp
a pnera1 undmllnclint of the aile AI die site is better cbancterized sublequent data colleclion
cfforu c be foculed 10 fill Ill wcm 11p1 in he diU Second lhil phued un1
__idemiflcllloaofkeydolaaeodlueadyinlhe_ll_iblero_
lhll dill collectioa is alwaya direcled toward providina infOIIDIIion relevanr to bullaecuon of a
remedial aetioa In this way die overall aile charwcerirMicm effort cm be continually acopecl to
minimize he oolloclion of-dolallld muimizo dolo qualily
Colleclion of llldiiiOIIIIdD 1111 commenced wilb a Field llemeftl Sllldy whidl il aimed
II clotinl - in die -- t for die Rlllld tilt- (RA) Wbile a basic plaD
of operaion 1111 - delopod t cleacribed in a Field - Wost Plan he clala
oolleclion prooou will conlinuo 10 be _mro he dolo aeodl of die PS
Upon ltltgtqgt1e1ion of he Field llemeftla Sllldy lhe new- will be evalualed wilh IOipOCI
10 die dD IIIII coadaailtn of die Rlllllll RA and a delcrmilwion made 11 10 he neceaally of
bini porliona ofeilbor - middot The Dover Manicipal Landfill PS will incorponlte he foUowm lalks subjeclro EPA
approval
TASK 1 Scoojns pftbc FS
Adminillralive Order Data Oaps
Field Elemenl SIUdy Wort PIUI
Draft Feuibilily SIUdy Wost PIUI
TASK 2 Sjtc CbepmriprjM
bull Field SIUdy Elemenu Repon
2middot2
u~============J _mz~
~~S2-l
shy
I I
~ I I
TASK 3 DeyclQIDCot gf Rcspons Qbjectiycs NMi Respow Actiqps Pinal Pcuibility Study Work Plan
Letter repon with sugsested tcchnolosies for consideralion and discussion of
Applicable or Relev111t and Appropriate Requitemenu (ARARs)
TASK 4 Baseline Risk AmnDfDt
Sununuy of Existing Baseline Risk Assessment specifically the identification
of sensitive recepton and remedial clean-up objectives whith may be modifed
based on the tonclusions of the Field Elemenu Study Completion of this tuk
would be tontincent upon Field Element Study dltl and EPA ipprOVal
TASK RcmcdiallnycMitbulliqn Rcpoa Summary of lWatinl Draft R1 Report speltifiltally the contaminant fate IUid
U1n1p011 Ulelllnenl which may be updlled bued on tbe conclusiona of the
Field llemonts Study Such on updlte would be campewl upon BPA _II
TASK 6 Dcycl- gf Altmperiyg
Briltfinl to pmeat pellmitwy _ objoctma ond criteria
Letter_ cliaataainl pellmitwy - objoctigta ond criteriaLetter_ Olllliaiac tomedilllloomarivea clnelopocl
TASK 7 lnitjal Sgwginf of Altmneriva
TASK 8 trmllbjljrv SDMjca (Optional)
Benchsclleshybull T~Wmihy Studiel
TASK 9 Qaailcd ANIYia of Rmbulljnjnr Altrmlljyg
Summary table and narntive description of ldvamqes and disadvan111eS of
eaeh allemllive
TASK 10 PrciJamprJtjoogfDqft PS Repon
TASK II Final PS Rcpon
TASK 12 Pmjmjnary DesjroofSclcctod Rrmt4ja] Ahcmatiyc
(Developed after ROD Siplinamp)
2112HAZ-2732 2-4
TASK 13 MwpmmtandCoordjnlljon
TASK 14 Cmrunynjty RclatjgM Sygpon
22 SCOPE OF WORK
This section discusses current EPA FS guidance as it applies to the FS tasks and amplifies
the scope and HMMs approach to the tub
221 Tuk 1 bull Scgpina of the FS
The Dover Municipal Landfill Rl lq)OR was prepared in IICCordance with the NCP and
prevlilina JUiltlonce undolt CERCLA HMM will updl1e the site _ infomwion
preiOIIIOdln the Remediallnvatiaation Report Agt - previowly the FS procetJ under SARA (ond Ill other new ampderol reaulationl)
hu become more -ive willgt 1he remedial endpoira belri fottorecl inlo 1he invettiaative
pngtCOII from 1he projoltt planninl- duouch1he mnoinder of 1he invellipdCOI
Tbr pwpooe of Tlllt I will be to dovolop a wor1t plan IWinamp IMgtw tpeeifiC diu llpl are to
be 8llecl Tbeae diu - lndude - outliDed in 1he Admirlilualve Order bull u u 1he oddidonll dlla requlrementl 11111 have dovolopod duoup 1he review of 1he Remedial
fnvestiaatiCOI (Rl) (Docomber 1981) ond lUolt -t(RA) (Mardi 1988) Tbr field wort
will be conc1ucted u put of 1he Site Cbancterizltioo (TIIIt 2)
Tbeae efforu have reoulted In the clovelopment of 1he Field 11ement Study Wort PlOD
docamatlinl1he JCopiq - Uld pmenq orwicipoted future wb It olao tervet II I
voluable tool fw uailrgtirtlmpooaiblliliea ond eatabliohini 1he projoltt t tchedule
222 Tuk 2 middot Sifl aizbullion
The exiltifta Rl report delcribea tbe fe1d investiallive work conducted to eWe by previous
inveatiaators The dlta and concluaiona presented in the Rl and RA reports form the buis for
lhe cwrmt understandinc of site conditions
Based on HMMs review of the Rl and RA repons and in liaht of current SARA guidance
Uld anticipated remecliol _ options data saps 10 be lldclreoaed duoup funlrer freld
investiJarion wete outlined in Task 1 field Element Study Wort Pllll
2512HAZ-2732 2-5
I I
- I I
Upon completion ofTuk I through onaoina cUcussions wilh the EPA and NH DES he
new database will be reviewed relative to the interpretaJion and conclusions of the previous Rl
and RA repons Specific attention will focus on the contaminant fate and transport model of the
Rl repon as well as the identification of sensitive receptors and the remedial objective(s) and
criteria developed in the Risk Assessment This updated Site Characterization will be presented
in a Draft Field Element Study Report submined to EPA and NH DES for review
223 Tuk 3 - Dcyelgpncm gf RcapoOR Obicctjycs and Rcsponsc Actions
General response actions that miampht be taken at a site are initially deftned during scoping
and are refmed throusflout the PS process u a better undentandina of site conditions is aained FoUowinamp completion of the site characterization and reduction and interpre111ion of the
resul11111 data HMM in conjwxtion with EPA and NH DES will re-evaluate the e~oisting
rapo- objectives opplicable technoloJieo ond ARARs for lhe Dever Municipal Landfill The
results of this uaesamem will be uted to revile and fanalize thiJ Draft Peuibility Study Wort
Plaa ThiJ evaluation will detormiDe whether new infOIDIIlion lllhmd durinamp the Sile
Chlraclerizllion would result in moclificatioaa to responae objectives and criteria for eath
COftlarninaled medium Pwthamore each response technoiOIY orilinaiJy identified would be
re-cvallllled for ita opplicability 10 site conditions ond odditioaal rechnoloJieo would be
idenlilled for lilnher c-idenltion u wunnoecl Finally the idenlifled ARARs would be
re-cuminocl to eruwe t1w they opplicable to the reviled raponse objeetiveo ond
tecbDoloPet New EPA pidance relative to ARARJ is in development IDd is avai1able in drift
form (Relerence Review Dnft CERCLA C-lilnce With Other Laws Mtnual OSWER
Direcrive 92341~1 (May 6 1981)) ond pidance is also anilable in the EPA Re1ion I
S~al Riolt Alletlmenr Oaidance for the Supetfund Propam
The responae objectivea techaolotiea and ARARs lhll evolve from thiJ process will
serve u lhe buil for initillinamp dilcualionJ reaardinc more specific upecu of remedial response such u site-speciamp delft--up aoals If an ARAR is delermined to be protective of the human
health or the eavizonmenr it will be used to establish the acceptable exposure level If an
ARAR is not proceaive of the population or environmem does not exist for 1he specific
chemical or pathways of concem or does not apply because multiple contaminants may be
posina a cumulative risk acceptable exposure leveb will be identifted through the risk
usesament process The Supcrfwxl Puhljc Health Enluarjoo Manual provides additional details
on establishinamp acceptable exposure levels when no ARARs exist
2112HAZ-2732 2-6
This reevalUillon process will result in the preparaalon of a Pinal Peuibility Srudy Work
Plan which will outline what refmements if any would be required in the development and
evalualion process of remedial alternatives
224 Task 4- Bwlinc RN Assuqcnr
A3 the Site Characterization nean completion the resultutt data wiU be evaluated in
conjunction with data from the existinc Baseline Risk Assessment The objective of this
useumem will be a determination of the nanue and sipiftcanee of the risk posed to public
health welfan or the environment by the contaminlnta preaenc The Bueline Riak Aueument
is euemially an useumem of the riat usociated with the No-Action alternative (ie the
prellld futuJe rilt in tbe oboence of my odditional mpo111lt lltliou)
Tho Bueline Riallt --r metilodoiOSY obould be bued on lbe moot cumnt-shyocoepoed by tbe US Em-Il r-aioa Aptyeny u publilbed in lbe ledenl Repoer
(49FIU27 et teq) IDd in lbl fiaa1 s Ppbljs Health Pxeluim Mnbull (US BPA
~1-16-060 Ootobor 1916) llld lbe s- of New llamplbile o Riallt --r Oftlce
Oaldellnu 110 IIJo -lded in lbe lleJlon I Sllflll-1 Riallt --r Ouldaxe for lbe
s__ Propm Tbe publicbeallb riltc- obou1d _--
fillY pt bull ideMification of tboee individual~ or JIVUPI wbo 11e 11
rilt of _ via inbololion iopllion clinlct COIIIICI or olber _ of
_ Tbla -Ia buedupon idonliflcolion ofeltJ1011110 pGwamp)l
bued on ealadq cilia IIIII - cilia fngtm lbe Silo Cbarw1eriuoion llld conalderl
f_ mecblalomo for lbe COIIIIminlaao of concern
Iqaisicy bullmiddot=-=middot a compuilon of contaminant concentrationlll the titc with
COIItllniDID-apecific ARARJ to determine acceptable concentnlions for each
rnecliam of ccoem for tbe conwninants of concern
Rid Oypstcrizerigp m inlepation of fmdinamps ampom the expn~UR usessment
and toxicity asaeument to determine the potential for ldvene health or
environmentampl effecu for each exposure scenario
2$12JHAZ2732 2-7
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
u~============J _mz~
~~S2-l
shy
I I
~ I I
TASK 3 DeyclQIDCot gf Rcspons Qbjectiycs NMi Respow Actiqps Pinal Pcuibility Study Work Plan
Letter repon with sugsested tcchnolosies for consideralion and discussion of
Applicable or Relev111t and Appropriate Requitemenu (ARARs)
TASK 4 Baseline Risk AmnDfDt
Sununuy of Existing Baseline Risk Assessment specifically the identification
of sensitive recepton and remedial clean-up objectives whith may be modifed
based on the tonclusions of the Field Elemenu Study Completion of this tuk
would be tontincent upon Field Element Study dltl and EPA ipprOVal
TASK RcmcdiallnycMitbulliqn Rcpoa Summary of lWatinl Draft R1 Report speltifiltally the contaminant fate IUid
U1n1p011 Ulelllnenl which may be updlled bued on tbe conclusiona of the
Field llemonts Study Such on updlte would be campewl upon BPA _II
TASK 6 Dcycl- gf Altmperiyg
Briltfinl to pmeat pellmitwy _ objoctma ond criteria
Letter_ cliaataainl pellmitwy - objoctigta ond criteriaLetter_ Olllliaiac tomedilllloomarivea clnelopocl
TASK 7 lnitjal Sgwginf of Altmneriva
TASK 8 trmllbjljrv SDMjca (Optional)
Benchsclleshybull T~Wmihy Studiel
TASK 9 Qaailcd ANIYia of Rmbulljnjnr Altrmlljyg
Summary table and narntive description of ldvamqes and disadvan111eS of
eaeh allemllive
TASK 10 PrciJamprJtjoogfDqft PS Repon
TASK II Final PS Rcpon
TASK 12 Pmjmjnary DesjroofSclcctod Rrmt4ja] Ahcmatiyc
(Developed after ROD Siplinamp)
2112HAZ-2732 2-4
TASK 13 MwpmmtandCoordjnlljon
TASK 14 Cmrunynjty RclatjgM Sygpon
22 SCOPE OF WORK
This section discusses current EPA FS guidance as it applies to the FS tasks and amplifies
the scope and HMMs approach to the tub
221 Tuk 1 bull Scgpina of the FS
The Dover Municipal Landfill Rl lq)OR was prepared in IICCordance with the NCP and
prevlilina JUiltlonce undolt CERCLA HMM will updl1e the site _ infomwion
preiOIIIOdln the Remediallnvatiaation Report Agt - previowly the FS procetJ under SARA (ond Ill other new ampderol reaulationl)
hu become more -ive willgt 1he remedial endpoira belri fottorecl inlo 1he invettiaative
pngtCOII from 1he projoltt planninl- duouch1he mnoinder of 1he invellipdCOI
Tbr pwpooe of Tlllt I will be to dovolop a wor1t plan IWinamp IMgtw tpeeifiC diu llpl are to
be 8llecl Tbeae diu - lndude - outliDed in 1he Admirlilualve Order bull u u 1he oddidonll dlla requlrementl 11111 have dovolopod duoup 1he review of 1he Remedial
fnvestiaatiCOI (Rl) (Docomber 1981) ond lUolt -t(RA) (Mardi 1988) Tbr field wort
will be conc1ucted u put of 1he Site Cbancterizltioo (TIIIt 2)
Tbeae efforu have reoulted In the clovelopment of 1he Field 11ement Study Wort PlOD
docamatlinl1he JCopiq - Uld pmenq orwicipoted future wb It olao tervet II I
voluable tool fw uailrgtirtlmpooaiblliliea ond eatabliohini 1he projoltt t tchedule
222 Tuk 2 middot Sifl aizbullion
The exiltifta Rl report delcribea tbe fe1d investiallive work conducted to eWe by previous
inveatiaators The dlta and concluaiona presented in the Rl and RA reports form the buis for
lhe cwrmt understandinc of site conditions
Based on HMMs review of the Rl and RA repons and in liaht of current SARA guidance
Uld anticipated remecliol _ options data saps 10 be lldclreoaed duoup funlrer freld
investiJarion wete outlined in Task 1 field Element Study Wort Pllll
2512HAZ-2732 2-5
I I
- I I
Upon completion ofTuk I through onaoina cUcussions wilh the EPA and NH DES he
new database will be reviewed relative to the interpretaJion and conclusions of the previous Rl
and RA repons Specific attention will focus on the contaminant fate and transport model of the
Rl repon as well as the identification of sensitive receptors and the remedial objective(s) and
criteria developed in the Risk Assessment This updated Site Characterization will be presented
in a Draft Field Element Study Report submined to EPA and NH DES for review
223 Tuk 3 - Dcyelgpncm gf RcapoOR Obicctjycs and Rcsponsc Actions
General response actions that miampht be taken at a site are initially deftned during scoping
and are refmed throusflout the PS process u a better undentandina of site conditions is aained FoUowinamp completion of the site characterization and reduction and interpre111ion of the
resul11111 data HMM in conjwxtion with EPA and NH DES will re-evaluate the e~oisting
rapo- objectives opplicable technoloJieo ond ARARs for lhe Dever Municipal Landfill The
results of this uaesamem will be uted to revile and fanalize thiJ Draft Peuibility Study Wort
Plaa ThiJ evaluation will detormiDe whether new infOIDIIlion lllhmd durinamp the Sile
Chlraclerizllion would result in moclificatioaa to responae objectives and criteria for eath
COftlarninaled medium Pwthamore each response technoiOIY orilinaiJy identified would be
re-cvallllled for ita opplicability 10 site conditions ond odditioaal rechnoloJieo would be
idenlilled for lilnher c-idenltion u wunnoecl Finally the idenlifled ARARs would be
re-cuminocl to eruwe t1w they opplicable to the reviled raponse objeetiveo ond
tecbDoloPet New EPA pidance relative to ARARJ is in development IDd is avai1able in drift
form (Relerence Review Dnft CERCLA C-lilnce With Other Laws Mtnual OSWER
Direcrive 92341~1 (May 6 1981)) ond pidance is also anilable in the EPA Re1ion I
S~al Riolt Alletlmenr Oaidance for the Supetfund Propam
The responae objectivea techaolotiea and ARARs lhll evolve from thiJ process will
serve u lhe buil for initillinamp dilcualionJ reaardinc more specific upecu of remedial response such u site-speciamp delft--up aoals If an ARAR is delermined to be protective of the human
health or the eavizonmenr it will be used to establish the acceptable exposure level If an
ARAR is not proceaive of the population or environmem does not exist for 1he specific
chemical or pathways of concem or does not apply because multiple contaminants may be
posina a cumulative risk acceptable exposure leveb will be identifted through the risk
usesament process The Supcrfwxl Puhljc Health Enluarjoo Manual provides additional details
on establishinamp acceptable exposure levels when no ARARs exist
2112HAZ-2732 2-6
This reevalUillon process will result in the preparaalon of a Pinal Peuibility Srudy Work
Plan which will outline what refmements if any would be required in the development and
evalualion process of remedial alternatives
224 Task 4- Bwlinc RN Assuqcnr
A3 the Site Characterization nean completion the resultutt data wiU be evaluated in
conjunction with data from the existinc Baseline Risk Assessment The objective of this
useumem will be a determination of the nanue and sipiftcanee of the risk posed to public
health welfan or the environment by the contaminlnta preaenc The Bueline Riak Aueument
is euemially an useumem of the riat usociated with the No-Action alternative (ie the
prellld futuJe rilt in tbe oboence of my odditional mpo111lt lltliou)
Tho Bueline Riallt --r metilodoiOSY obould be bued on lbe moot cumnt-shyocoepoed by tbe US Em-Il r-aioa Aptyeny u publilbed in lbe ledenl Repoer
(49FIU27 et teq) IDd in lbl fiaa1 s Ppbljs Health Pxeluim Mnbull (US BPA
~1-16-060 Ootobor 1916) llld lbe s- of New llamplbile o Riallt --r Oftlce
Oaldellnu 110 IIJo -lded in lbe lleJlon I Sllflll-1 Riallt --r Ouldaxe for lbe
s__ Propm Tbe publicbeallb riltc- obou1d _--
fillY pt bull ideMification of tboee individual~ or JIVUPI wbo 11e 11
rilt of _ via inbololion iopllion clinlct COIIIICI or olber _ of
_ Tbla -Ia buedupon idonliflcolion ofeltJ1011110 pGwamp)l
bued on ealadq cilia IIIII - cilia fngtm lbe Silo Cbarw1eriuoion llld conalderl
f_ mecblalomo for lbe COIIIIminlaao of concern
Iqaisicy bullmiddot=-=middot a compuilon of contaminant concentrationlll the titc with
COIItllniDID-apecific ARARJ to determine acceptable concentnlions for each
rnecliam of ccoem for tbe conwninants of concern
Rid Oypstcrizerigp m inlepation of fmdinamps ampom the expn~UR usessment
and toxicity asaeument to determine the potential for ldvene health or
environmentampl effecu for each exposure scenario
2$12JHAZ2732 2-7
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
I I
~ I I
TASK 3 DeyclQIDCot gf Rcspons Qbjectiycs NMi Respow Actiqps Pinal Pcuibility Study Work Plan
Letter repon with sugsested tcchnolosies for consideralion and discussion of
Applicable or Relev111t and Appropriate Requitemenu (ARARs)
TASK 4 Baseline Risk AmnDfDt
Sununuy of Existing Baseline Risk Assessment specifically the identification
of sensitive recepton and remedial clean-up objectives whith may be modifed
based on the tonclusions of the Field Elemenu Study Completion of this tuk
would be tontincent upon Field Element Study dltl and EPA ipprOVal
TASK RcmcdiallnycMitbulliqn Rcpoa Summary of lWatinl Draft R1 Report speltifiltally the contaminant fate IUid
U1n1p011 Ulelllnenl which may be updlled bued on tbe conclusiona of the
Field llemonts Study Such on updlte would be campewl upon BPA _II
TASK 6 Dcycl- gf Altmperiyg
Briltfinl to pmeat pellmitwy _ objoctma ond criteria
Letter_ cliaataainl pellmitwy - objoctigta ond criteriaLetter_ Olllliaiac tomedilllloomarivea clnelopocl
TASK 7 lnitjal Sgwginf of Altmneriva
TASK 8 trmllbjljrv SDMjca (Optional)
Benchsclleshybull T~Wmihy Studiel
TASK 9 Qaailcd ANIYia of Rmbulljnjnr Altrmlljyg
Summary table and narntive description of ldvamqes and disadvan111eS of
eaeh allemllive
TASK 10 PrciJamprJtjoogfDqft PS Repon
TASK II Final PS Rcpon
TASK 12 Pmjmjnary DesjroofSclcctod Rrmt4ja] Ahcmatiyc
(Developed after ROD Siplinamp)
2112HAZ-2732 2-4
TASK 13 MwpmmtandCoordjnlljon
TASK 14 Cmrunynjty RclatjgM Sygpon
22 SCOPE OF WORK
This section discusses current EPA FS guidance as it applies to the FS tasks and amplifies
the scope and HMMs approach to the tub
221 Tuk 1 bull Scgpina of the FS
The Dover Municipal Landfill Rl lq)OR was prepared in IICCordance with the NCP and
prevlilina JUiltlonce undolt CERCLA HMM will updl1e the site _ infomwion
preiOIIIOdln the Remediallnvatiaation Report Agt - previowly the FS procetJ under SARA (ond Ill other new ampderol reaulationl)
hu become more -ive willgt 1he remedial endpoira belri fottorecl inlo 1he invettiaative
pngtCOII from 1he projoltt planninl- duouch1he mnoinder of 1he invellipdCOI
Tbr pwpooe of Tlllt I will be to dovolop a wor1t plan IWinamp IMgtw tpeeifiC diu llpl are to
be 8llecl Tbeae diu - lndude - outliDed in 1he Admirlilualve Order bull u u 1he oddidonll dlla requlrementl 11111 have dovolopod duoup 1he review of 1he Remedial
fnvestiaatiCOI (Rl) (Docomber 1981) ond lUolt -t(RA) (Mardi 1988) Tbr field wort
will be conc1ucted u put of 1he Site Cbancterizltioo (TIIIt 2)
Tbeae efforu have reoulted In the clovelopment of 1he Field 11ement Study Wort PlOD
docamatlinl1he JCopiq - Uld pmenq orwicipoted future wb It olao tervet II I
voluable tool fw uailrgtirtlmpooaiblliliea ond eatabliohini 1he projoltt t tchedule
222 Tuk 2 middot Sifl aizbullion
The exiltifta Rl report delcribea tbe fe1d investiallive work conducted to eWe by previous
inveatiaators The dlta and concluaiona presented in the Rl and RA reports form the buis for
lhe cwrmt understandinc of site conditions
Based on HMMs review of the Rl and RA repons and in liaht of current SARA guidance
Uld anticipated remecliol _ options data saps 10 be lldclreoaed duoup funlrer freld
investiJarion wete outlined in Task 1 field Element Study Wort Pllll
2512HAZ-2732 2-5
I I
- I I
Upon completion ofTuk I through onaoina cUcussions wilh the EPA and NH DES he
new database will be reviewed relative to the interpretaJion and conclusions of the previous Rl
and RA repons Specific attention will focus on the contaminant fate and transport model of the
Rl repon as well as the identification of sensitive receptors and the remedial objective(s) and
criteria developed in the Risk Assessment This updated Site Characterization will be presented
in a Draft Field Element Study Report submined to EPA and NH DES for review
223 Tuk 3 - Dcyelgpncm gf RcapoOR Obicctjycs and Rcsponsc Actions
General response actions that miampht be taken at a site are initially deftned during scoping
and are refmed throusflout the PS process u a better undentandina of site conditions is aained FoUowinamp completion of the site characterization and reduction and interpre111ion of the
resul11111 data HMM in conjwxtion with EPA and NH DES will re-evaluate the e~oisting
rapo- objectives opplicable technoloJieo ond ARARs for lhe Dever Municipal Landfill The
results of this uaesamem will be uted to revile and fanalize thiJ Draft Peuibility Study Wort
Plaa ThiJ evaluation will detormiDe whether new infOIDIIlion lllhmd durinamp the Sile
Chlraclerizllion would result in moclificatioaa to responae objectives and criteria for eath
COftlarninaled medium Pwthamore each response technoiOIY orilinaiJy identified would be
re-cvallllled for ita opplicability 10 site conditions ond odditioaal rechnoloJieo would be
idenlilled for lilnher c-idenltion u wunnoecl Finally the idenlifled ARARs would be
re-cuminocl to eruwe t1w they opplicable to the reviled raponse objeetiveo ond
tecbDoloPet New EPA pidance relative to ARARJ is in development IDd is avai1able in drift
form (Relerence Review Dnft CERCLA C-lilnce With Other Laws Mtnual OSWER
Direcrive 92341~1 (May 6 1981)) ond pidance is also anilable in the EPA Re1ion I
S~al Riolt Alletlmenr Oaidance for the Supetfund Propam
The responae objectivea techaolotiea and ARARs lhll evolve from thiJ process will
serve u lhe buil for initillinamp dilcualionJ reaardinc more specific upecu of remedial response such u site-speciamp delft--up aoals If an ARAR is delermined to be protective of the human
health or the eavizonmenr it will be used to establish the acceptable exposure level If an
ARAR is not proceaive of the population or environmem does not exist for 1he specific
chemical or pathways of concem or does not apply because multiple contaminants may be
posina a cumulative risk acceptable exposure leveb will be identifted through the risk
usesament process The Supcrfwxl Puhljc Health Enluarjoo Manual provides additional details
on establishinamp acceptable exposure levels when no ARARs exist
2112HAZ-2732 2-6
This reevalUillon process will result in the preparaalon of a Pinal Peuibility Srudy Work
Plan which will outline what refmements if any would be required in the development and
evalualion process of remedial alternatives
224 Task 4- Bwlinc RN Assuqcnr
A3 the Site Characterization nean completion the resultutt data wiU be evaluated in
conjunction with data from the existinc Baseline Risk Assessment The objective of this
useumem will be a determination of the nanue and sipiftcanee of the risk posed to public
health welfan or the environment by the contaminlnta preaenc The Bueline Riak Aueument
is euemially an useumem of the riat usociated with the No-Action alternative (ie the
prellld futuJe rilt in tbe oboence of my odditional mpo111lt lltliou)
Tho Bueline Riallt --r metilodoiOSY obould be bued on lbe moot cumnt-shyocoepoed by tbe US Em-Il r-aioa Aptyeny u publilbed in lbe ledenl Repoer
(49FIU27 et teq) IDd in lbl fiaa1 s Ppbljs Health Pxeluim Mnbull (US BPA
~1-16-060 Ootobor 1916) llld lbe s- of New llamplbile o Riallt --r Oftlce
Oaldellnu 110 IIJo -lded in lbe lleJlon I Sllflll-1 Riallt --r Ouldaxe for lbe
s__ Propm Tbe publicbeallb riltc- obou1d _--
fillY pt bull ideMification of tboee individual~ or JIVUPI wbo 11e 11
rilt of _ via inbololion iopllion clinlct COIIIICI or olber _ of
_ Tbla -Ia buedupon idonliflcolion ofeltJ1011110 pGwamp)l
bued on ealadq cilia IIIII - cilia fngtm lbe Silo Cbarw1eriuoion llld conalderl
f_ mecblalomo for lbe COIIIIminlaao of concern
Iqaisicy bullmiddot=-=middot a compuilon of contaminant concentrationlll the titc with
COIItllniDID-apecific ARARJ to determine acceptable concentnlions for each
rnecliam of ccoem for tbe conwninants of concern
Rid Oypstcrizerigp m inlepation of fmdinamps ampom the expn~UR usessment
and toxicity asaeument to determine the potential for ldvene health or
environmentampl effecu for each exposure scenario
2$12JHAZ2732 2-7
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
TASK 13 MwpmmtandCoordjnlljon
TASK 14 Cmrunynjty RclatjgM Sygpon
22 SCOPE OF WORK
This section discusses current EPA FS guidance as it applies to the FS tasks and amplifies
the scope and HMMs approach to the tub
221 Tuk 1 bull Scgpina of the FS
The Dover Municipal Landfill Rl lq)OR was prepared in IICCordance with the NCP and
prevlilina JUiltlonce undolt CERCLA HMM will updl1e the site _ infomwion
preiOIIIOdln the Remediallnvatiaation Report Agt - previowly the FS procetJ under SARA (ond Ill other new ampderol reaulationl)
hu become more -ive willgt 1he remedial endpoira belri fottorecl inlo 1he invettiaative
pngtCOII from 1he projoltt planninl- duouch1he mnoinder of 1he invellipdCOI
Tbr pwpooe of Tlllt I will be to dovolop a wor1t plan IWinamp IMgtw tpeeifiC diu llpl are to
be 8llecl Tbeae diu - lndude - outliDed in 1he Admirlilualve Order bull u u 1he oddidonll dlla requlrementl 11111 have dovolopod duoup 1he review of 1he Remedial
fnvestiaatiCOI (Rl) (Docomber 1981) ond lUolt -t(RA) (Mardi 1988) Tbr field wort
will be conc1ucted u put of 1he Site Cbancterizltioo (TIIIt 2)
Tbeae efforu have reoulted In the clovelopment of 1he Field 11ement Study Wort PlOD
docamatlinl1he JCopiq - Uld pmenq orwicipoted future wb It olao tervet II I
voluable tool fw uailrgtirtlmpooaiblliliea ond eatabliohini 1he projoltt t tchedule
222 Tuk 2 middot Sifl aizbullion
The exiltifta Rl report delcribea tbe fe1d investiallive work conducted to eWe by previous
inveatiaators The dlta and concluaiona presented in the Rl and RA reports form the buis for
lhe cwrmt understandinc of site conditions
Based on HMMs review of the Rl and RA repons and in liaht of current SARA guidance
Uld anticipated remecliol _ options data saps 10 be lldclreoaed duoup funlrer freld
investiJarion wete outlined in Task 1 field Element Study Wort Pllll
2512HAZ-2732 2-5
I I
- I I
Upon completion ofTuk I through onaoina cUcussions wilh the EPA and NH DES he
new database will be reviewed relative to the interpretaJion and conclusions of the previous Rl
and RA repons Specific attention will focus on the contaminant fate and transport model of the
Rl repon as well as the identification of sensitive receptors and the remedial objective(s) and
criteria developed in the Risk Assessment This updated Site Characterization will be presented
in a Draft Field Element Study Report submined to EPA and NH DES for review
223 Tuk 3 - Dcyelgpncm gf RcapoOR Obicctjycs and Rcsponsc Actions
General response actions that miampht be taken at a site are initially deftned during scoping
and are refmed throusflout the PS process u a better undentandina of site conditions is aained FoUowinamp completion of the site characterization and reduction and interpre111ion of the
resul11111 data HMM in conjwxtion with EPA and NH DES will re-evaluate the e~oisting
rapo- objectives opplicable technoloJieo ond ARARs for lhe Dever Municipal Landfill The
results of this uaesamem will be uted to revile and fanalize thiJ Draft Peuibility Study Wort
Plaa ThiJ evaluation will detormiDe whether new infOIDIIlion lllhmd durinamp the Sile
Chlraclerizllion would result in moclificatioaa to responae objectives and criteria for eath
COftlarninaled medium Pwthamore each response technoiOIY orilinaiJy identified would be
re-cvallllled for ita opplicability 10 site conditions ond odditioaal rechnoloJieo would be
idenlilled for lilnher c-idenltion u wunnoecl Finally the idenlifled ARARs would be
re-cuminocl to eruwe t1w they opplicable to the reviled raponse objeetiveo ond
tecbDoloPet New EPA pidance relative to ARARJ is in development IDd is avai1able in drift
form (Relerence Review Dnft CERCLA C-lilnce With Other Laws Mtnual OSWER
Direcrive 92341~1 (May 6 1981)) ond pidance is also anilable in the EPA Re1ion I
S~al Riolt Alletlmenr Oaidance for the Supetfund Propam
The responae objectivea techaolotiea and ARARs lhll evolve from thiJ process will
serve u lhe buil for initillinamp dilcualionJ reaardinc more specific upecu of remedial response such u site-speciamp delft--up aoals If an ARAR is delermined to be protective of the human
health or the eavizonmenr it will be used to establish the acceptable exposure level If an
ARAR is not proceaive of the population or environmem does not exist for 1he specific
chemical or pathways of concem or does not apply because multiple contaminants may be
posina a cumulative risk acceptable exposure leveb will be identifted through the risk
usesament process The Supcrfwxl Puhljc Health Enluarjoo Manual provides additional details
on establishinamp acceptable exposure levels when no ARARs exist
2112HAZ-2732 2-6
This reevalUillon process will result in the preparaalon of a Pinal Peuibility Srudy Work
Plan which will outline what refmements if any would be required in the development and
evalualion process of remedial alternatives
224 Task 4- Bwlinc RN Assuqcnr
A3 the Site Characterization nean completion the resultutt data wiU be evaluated in
conjunction with data from the existinc Baseline Risk Assessment The objective of this
useumem will be a determination of the nanue and sipiftcanee of the risk posed to public
health welfan or the environment by the contaminlnta preaenc The Bueline Riak Aueument
is euemially an useumem of the riat usociated with the No-Action alternative (ie the
prellld futuJe rilt in tbe oboence of my odditional mpo111lt lltliou)
Tho Bueline Riallt --r metilodoiOSY obould be bued on lbe moot cumnt-shyocoepoed by tbe US Em-Il r-aioa Aptyeny u publilbed in lbe ledenl Repoer
(49FIU27 et teq) IDd in lbl fiaa1 s Ppbljs Health Pxeluim Mnbull (US BPA
~1-16-060 Ootobor 1916) llld lbe s- of New llamplbile o Riallt --r Oftlce
Oaldellnu 110 IIJo -lded in lbe lleJlon I Sllflll-1 Riallt --r Ouldaxe for lbe
s__ Propm Tbe publicbeallb riltc- obou1d _--
fillY pt bull ideMification of tboee individual~ or JIVUPI wbo 11e 11
rilt of _ via inbololion iopllion clinlct COIIIICI or olber _ of
_ Tbla -Ia buedupon idonliflcolion ofeltJ1011110 pGwamp)l
bued on ealadq cilia IIIII - cilia fngtm lbe Silo Cbarw1eriuoion llld conalderl
f_ mecblalomo for lbe COIIIIminlaao of concern
Iqaisicy bullmiddot=-=middot a compuilon of contaminant concentrationlll the titc with
COIItllniDID-apecific ARARJ to determine acceptable concentnlions for each
rnecliam of ccoem for tbe conwninants of concern
Rid Oypstcrizerigp m inlepation of fmdinamps ampom the expn~UR usessment
and toxicity asaeument to determine the potential for ldvene health or
environmentampl effecu for each exposure scenario
2$12JHAZ2732 2-7
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
I I
- I I
Upon completion ofTuk I through onaoina cUcussions wilh the EPA and NH DES he
new database will be reviewed relative to the interpretaJion and conclusions of the previous Rl
and RA repons Specific attention will focus on the contaminant fate and transport model of the
Rl repon as well as the identification of sensitive receptors and the remedial objective(s) and
criteria developed in the Risk Assessment This updated Site Characterization will be presented
in a Draft Field Element Study Report submined to EPA and NH DES for review
223 Tuk 3 - Dcyelgpncm gf RcapoOR Obicctjycs and Rcsponsc Actions
General response actions that miampht be taken at a site are initially deftned during scoping
and are refmed throusflout the PS process u a better undentandina of site conditions is aained FoUowinamp completion of the site characterization and reduction and interpre111ion of the
resul11111 data HMM in conjwxtion with EPA and NH DES will re-evaluate the e~oisting
rapo- objectives opplicable technoloJieo ond ARARs for lhe Dever Municipal Landfill The
results of this uaesamem will be uted to revile and fanalize thiJ Draft Peuibility Study Wort
Plaa ThiJ evaluation will detormiDe whether new infOIDIIlion lllhmd durinamp the Sile
Chlraclerizllion would result in moclificatioaa to responae objectives and criteria for eath
COftlarninaled medium Pwthamore each response technoiOIY orilinaiJy identified would be
re-cvallllled for ita opplicability 10 site conditions ond odditioaal rechnoloJieo would be
idenlilled for lilnher c-idenltion u wunnoecl Finally the idenlifled ARARs would be
re-cuminocl to eruwe t1w they opplicable to the reviled raponse objeetiveo ond
tecbDoloPet New EPA pidance relative to ARARJ is in development IDd is avai1able in drift
form (Relerence Review Dnft CERCLA C-lilnce With Other Laws Mtnual OSWER
Direcrive 92341~1 (May 6 1981)) ond pidance is also anilable in the EPA Re1ion I
S~al Riolt Alletlmenr Oaidance for the Supetfund Propam
The responae objectivea techaolotiea and ARARs lhll evolve from thiJ process will
serve u lhe buil for initillinamp dilcualionJ reaardinc more specific upecu of remedial response such u site-speciamp delft--up aoals If an ARAR is delermined to be protective of the human
health or the eavizonmenr it will be used to establish the acceptable exposure level If an
ARAR is not proceaive of the population or environmem does not exist for 1he specific
chemical or pathways of concem or does not apply because multiple contaminants may be
posina a cumulative risk acceptable exposure leveb will be identifted through the risk
usesament process The Supcrfwxl Puhljc Health Enluarjoo Manual provides additional details
on establishinamp acceptable exposure levels when no ARARs exist
2112HAZ-2732 2-6
This reevalUillon process will result in the preparaalon of a Pinal Peuibility Srudy Work
Plan which will outline what refmements if any would be required in the development and
evalualion process of remedial alternatives
224 Task 4- Bwlinc RN Assuqcnr
A3 the Site Characterization nean completion the resultutt data wiU be evaluated in
conjunction with data from the existinc Baseline Risk Assessment The objective of this
useumem will be a determination of the nanue and sipiftcanee of the risk posed to public
health welfan or the environment by the contaminlnta preaenc The Bueline Riak Aueument
is euemially an useumem of the riat usociated with the No-Action alternative (ie the
prellld futuJe rilt in tbe oboence of my odditional mpo111lt lltliou)
Tho Bueline Riallt --r metilodoiOSY obould be bued on lbe moot cumnt-shyocoepoed by tbe US Em-Il r-aioa Aptyeny u publilbed in lbe ledenl Repoer
(49FIU27 et teq) IDd in lbl fiaa1 s Ppbljs Health Pxeluim Mnbull (US BPA
~1-16-060 Ootobor 1916) llld lbe s- of New llamplbile o Riallt --r Oftlce
Oaldellnu 110 IIJo -lded in lbe lleJlon I Sllflll-1 Riallt --r Ouldaxe for lbe
s__ Propm Tbe publicbeallb riltc- obou1d _--
fillY pt bull ideMification of tboee individual~ or JIVUPI wbo 11e 11
rilt of _ via inbololion iopllion clinlct COIIIICI or olber _ of
_ Tbla -Ia buedupon idonliflcolion ofeltJ1011110 pGwamp)l
bued on ealadq cilia IIIII - cilia fngtm lbe Silo Cbarw1eriuoion llld conalderl
f_ mecblalomo for lbe COIIIIminlaao of concern
Iqaisicy bullmiddot=-=middot a compuilon of contaminant concentrationlll the titc with
COIItllniDID-apecific ARARJ to determine acceptable concentnlions for each
rnecliam of ccoem for tbe conwninants of concern
Rid Oypstcrizerigp m inlepation of fmdinamps ampom the expn~UR usessment
and toxicity asaeument to determine the potential for ldvene health or
environmentampl effecu for each exposure scenario
2$12JHAZ2732 2-7
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
This reevalUillon process will result in the preparaalon of a Pinal Peuibility Srudy Work
Plan which will outline what refmements if any would be required in the development and
evalualion process of remedial alternatives
224 Task 4- Bwlinc RN Assuqcnr
A3 the Site Characterization nean completion the resultutt data wiU be evaluated in
conjunction with data from the existinc Baseline Risk Assessment The objective of this
useumem will be a determination of the nanue and sipiftcanee of the risk posed to public
health welfan or the environment by the contaminlnta preaenc The Bueline Riak Aueument
is euemially an useumem of the riat usociated with the No-Action alternative (ie the
prellld futuJe rilt in tbe oboence of my odditional mpo111lt lltliou)
Tho Bueline Riallt --r metilodoiOSY obould be bued on lbe moot cumnt-shyocoepoed by tbe US Em-Il r-aioa Aptyeny u publilbed in lbe ledenl Repoer
(49FIU27 et teq) IDd in lbl fiaa1 s Ppbljs Health Pxeluim Mnbull (US BPA
~1-16-060 Ootobor 1916) llld lbe s- of New llamplbile o Riallt --r Oftlce
Oaldellnu 110 IIJo -lded in lbe lleJlon I Sllflll-1 Riallt --r Ouldaxe for lbe
s__ Propm Tbe publicbeallb riltc- obou1d _--
fillY pt bull ideMification of tboee individual~ or JIVUPI wbo 11e 11
rilt of _ via inbololion iopllion clinlct COIIIICI or olber _ of
_ Tbla -Ia buedupon idonliflcolion ofeltJ1011110 pGwamp)l
bued on ealadq cilia IIIII - cilia fngtm lbe Silo Cbarw1eriuoion llld conalderl
f_ mecblalomo for lbe COIIIIminlaao of concern
Iqaisicy bullmiddot=-=middot a compuilon of contaminant concentrationlll the titc with
COIItllniDID-apecific ARARJ to determine acceptable concentnlions for each
rnecliam of ccoem for tbe conwninants of concern
Rid Oypstcrizerigp m inlepation of fmdinamps ampom the expn~UR usessment
and toxicity asaeument to determine the potential for ldvene health or
environmentampl effecu for each exposure scenario
2$12JHAZ2732 2-7
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
I I
~ I I
The comparison of the Bueline Risk Assessment f111dinp with the results of the Site
Characterization will enable HMM NH DES and EPA to further evaluate the need for an
approach to site remediation in considerllion of the current and future risks associated with the
No-Action altemacive
225 Task 5 bull Remedial Inycstiution Rcpon
1be results of the Site Characterization as outlined in the Field Element Study Repon will help to funhe r defme the nature and extent of contamination specifically the contaminant
fate and transpon assessment presented in the RI Repon which may be updated based on the
conclusion of the field Elements Study
226 Iuk 6 - DcvcRIID pf AJtcmativcbull
The primary objective of this phaac of the FS ia to develop allemaaivea ttw procea human
healdt and the environment IDd e~ 1 nnp of appropriale wute rnanaprrtem optionamp
Altemllivea typically developed concumndy with doe Rl silo clwlclerizllion (Ie Rl silo chulcleriution data are ued to develop alternatives and saeen technolopet) with lhe reaulta of
OM IDiluencilll lbe odler ill on ilma fubioo In developilll altemlliveo two iqgtorqpl
Klivitieawilloccur
Pint vol1111101 or of media (_tgtie 1Diils) will be idondfiod to which
_ IIIII ICiioos- be Piiod poosibly ill eambinolioo with
excavalioft clilpoall or iDitkutional actions The media to be crelled or contained will be determined baed on information on the DIIUre lnd extent of cODtlininalion ARARs rilt f1lt1on
Secood doe ~lt~Dedi~~ llt1ion altenulives IIIII uaociated teebnolopes identified
c1uri1Ji projeet planoinc ond ony newly idemilied teelmolopes will be scroened to
identify thole diM would be effective for tbe contaminants lnd media of interest 11
the si1e The information obtained durina theae two activities will be used in
usemblinc teehnolops (IIIII lbe media to which doey will be opplied) into
alternatives for the site u a whole or a specific operable unit
In consultation wilh NH DES and EPA HMM will develop alternatives for remediation
by uaemblina combinations of technolopes and the media to which they would be applied into
2512HAZ-2732 2-8
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
alternatives thai addreaa contamitwion on 1 aile-wide buia or for 1n identified componenl of rhe site u oudined below
Develop remedial resporue objectives bued on medii p1thw1ys lnd crileria such as level of protection 1nd ARARs
Identify volumes or treu of environmental media to which aeneral leSJOnat
actions miaht be tpplied
Identify llld screen the elthnoloaJes applicable to each nenl response objelttive and medium of concern
Identify IIIII evale techooiY optiona IIIII oelect bull technoiJ b- on site specific criteria
ANemble the oelocted --tedlnolopo 11tto ~~-- bull _of-~~~~~--
227 TMir 7 lpiciel Sqrminr qf AIMmetjm
w- middot- - opdono mJabt be _ llld dneloped the - ~-w be tolbdlllll_to_the_of__dlarwlU
be -yzed ia detoil be -_ ellloctive duplloase - for
spociflc _ ob)ecliVOI IIIII - altomaiVOI thll naliotlcoiiy would not 1111Yive the neu let ofevai- lbeto --oy- dlodnct condocled the ICIOenina of alteiDiliveo
Second die aleenwivea ue evaiUIIed on a pnera1 buil to determine their effectiveness implememlbility lnd eost
Third a decision is made bued on thil evaluation 11 to which altenlltivea should be retained for further analysis
2-9
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
HMM will further refme the altemllives by better quantifyina the areu and volumes of
media of interest and the sizes and capacities of the process options thai make up each of the ahernatives During this phase the remedial action objectives developed earlier for each
medium or operable unit will be re vised as necessuy to incorporate any new risk assessment
infonnation being generlted from the Rl effon to ensure that the alternatives provide an adequate level of protection of human health and the environment
Screening will be used primarily to identify and distinguish any differences among the
various altema1ives and evaluate each alternative with respect to its effectiveness
implementability and cost Only the alternatives judged as the best or most promising on the buis of these evaluation fac1on will be retained for funher considemion and analysis
Tbe remainina altern11ives will be the most promisinc altemllives which encompu~ an
appropriale rqe of wute manqement options This rqe could cover a brot spectrum of
remedial proamprams ampom the No Action Alternative to a lona-tenn monitoring proaram to
IRIIDent systans for aile specific w111e ca~eaoriea
At the completion of this tuk HMM will ptqgtUlt IIIII preoem 1 brielinJ SUIIIIIIariiJt the
reiUIII of the initial ~ of alllemllivea IDd plana for the detailed analysis
228 Tyk 8- LebgptporlimteiJjUrv Shldjq COpjmel)
The - _ PS -~~ il Intended to beltlr focua tbe site invUIIion so that only thobull cilia necasary to 111J1P011 the PS ltld tbe cleciaiottmatinl procasue collected o neoda
will first be identifJOd tbe buil of tbe uttderauotcliq of the aile bull the time the PS il initially scopod AI site irtformaaion il collelt1ed durina the Rl and alterttlli~ belttc evaluated
HMM 1111) identify additional cilia neoda to odoqualy eval- alterttllives durina the detailed
Wyail Additional cilia neoda IIIIJ include aubiliry IIUdiea to provide cilia technoloaia
idenlilied durina the almllive dmolopttelll procas Tllllgtility telliq lt111 be perfotmed by
usittc bencll-acale or pUot-scale -- Bendt OIUIIIy il perfonned in 1 laboratOI)
usinamp compuativdy amall volumes of wute whkh a tested for die individual panmeten of 1
treatment ledmolou Pilot siUdiel ue inlencied to simulate the phys~al u weU u chemical
panmecen of a full-scale proceu IDd dlerefore the trullnent unit sizes lnd the volume of wute
to be processed in pilot syslmla peady increue over thote of bench scale New EPA guidlnce
on liability studiea (40 CFR Puu 260 and 261 Identification and ListinJ or Hazardous
Wute Treatability Studies Sample Exemptions Pinal Rule) will be used as appropriate
A decision to conduct treatability testint may be made durinamp project scopine if infoonation indicates that such testina is appropriate However the decision to conduct these
activities must be TMde by weiamphinJ the cost and time required to complete the investiaation
2512HAZ-2732 2-10
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
against the potemial value of the information in resolvins uncenainties wociated with selection
of a remedial action In some situations the need for treatability investiampations may not be
identified until later in the process and therefore may be postponed until the remedial desisn
phase If laboratorytreatability studies appear warranted HMM will prepare a work plan for
EPAJNH DES approval prior to iniliatinsthese activities
229 Tuk 9- Dcrajlcd AoaJysjs of Rcmajnjnr Altcnwivcs
The detailed analysis of alternatives follows the development and screenins of alternatives
and precedes the actual selection of a remedy The evalualions conducted durinamp the detailed
analysis phue will be influenced by the available data the number and types of alternatives
beinamp onalyzed ond the de to whidl lltemllives weno previoualy lttllyzed durinamp their
developnent ond oaeeninampmiddot Thia pllue also incorpontel my aebullobiliry study dota ond
additional sire chancterization infollllltion that may have been collected durina the Rl
1be lltemuivea dill - after oaeeninamp tD1J1 - to be refiDed more completely or moclilied prior to the ~ lttllyala to mategt contaminated media ond the opecific remedial
mponae objectives developed ond modified throuJb the coune of tbe PS -middot Clwtpa in tbe _ objocliveo t1w coulclrault in tedeflninamp the telectod lltemalvea tDIJI include
Compresaed time-fnmu for aoune contngtl mnediation or oquifer Oullllinamp
pOPIIDihindmd by pltyaicllcbemicll soil intenttion
Ttellmetlt- modifitltiona to meet cbetnical-apecific rilk-bued clean-up
WJeUIII0-6
Cblqea in openliDa cost~ffectiveness based on the potential increase in the
volume ofcordlllliDated material widt more strmsent clean-up levels
The information developed to define alternatives at this stage in the FS process may
conslst of preliminary deaiJn calcularions process flow diqrlms sizing of key process
components pre1iminuy site layouts and a discussion of limiwions usumptions and
uncenainties concernina each alternative
2512HAZ-2732 2-11
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
Eya]npjoo Criteria
HMMs detailed analysis of alternatives will be based on nine evalualion criteria u outlined below
1) ShonTcan Bffcctjyenc
This evaluation addresses the effects of lhe alternative dwina the construction and
implementllion phue until remedial response objectives ue met Alternatives would be
evllualed with mpea lo heir effects on hwnu heallb llld lhe envizoamenlt ~Mim of lhe Jemedilllltlioa uaU lhe followina crileria
Time adlmllcllal- ob)eclivto 110 ocldovod
2) ampggrwm ICrwjy_ lld Penn
The evolaadoa olllllemodveo wW -he Naill ole I8IIOdlol lltlion ill_ oldie
riot_ --ob~ - The primuy f0lt111 ollbil illbe--~ofbe- _be roqaired 10 _ riot
-by-raiduolalllltlor-bull- _ onlbefollowJna
Adequocy of conorols
Reliability of controb
2-12
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
3) Rcductjgo gflgxjsjcy Mgbildy wl Yolymc
HMMs evaluation will address the slltutory preferences for selectinJ remedial actions
thll employ trellmenttechnoloampies thll permanently and sianificanlly reduce toxicity mobility
or volume of the huardous substances u their principal elemem This preferenoe is satisfied
when treument is uaed to reduce the principal threats at a site throush destruction of to1ic
contaminants reduction of the total mus of toxic conWninanu imvenible reduction in
oomaminant mobility or reduction of total volwae of contlminated mediL
HMM will ebullll lbe lechnicll ond odminillrad fuolbilily of eoch lite~ Thia
evahaarion will cons_ider whether the raources reqaiml to ~ lbe altemadve are (or wW
be) lilable PIltIOft doal will be coaoldered include lbe fltgtllowilll
Tecbaiill Peuibillly
evllulioft of lbo tecbnicll cWIIculdes ond - -- wilb eocb -
Admlaillrlll Peuibillly
lbe ~ to wbiltb permittisJ suJOilon or Jeialod ICrYices could limil
implemenlation of a mnedialiiCIion
availability of adequbull offsite ttellmenl storap capacity dilponl services
eiC
~12HAZ-2732 2middot 13
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
timina of availability of technology required by remedial action
availability of requisite services and materials particuluty for new or innovative -wroaches
This evaluation will include four specific cost components which provide individual
points of comparison u well as a benchmartlevel of coet-effeaiveneu of the alternative
Ctpilal ltOils lt0111is1in1 of dinco (COIIIINctioo) llld indiJoa (noncoNaucliOIIIIId ovemed) costa
Amual JIOIIltonslrllllion COlli neceawy IO COIIIinuod ~of I oemedloiiCtion
Pmeno Wonb Wysis whicb II ued lo npendilwa lhll oocar _
-- rime periodo by dlocounoinJ I]J fu- COlli IO I _ - yell Ulllllly _yeor
Silivily Anllylil 10- - eftecl dw middot-in opeciflc ~ 1110ltillled wilb - dellp _-- ~ -llldelrecdve lileofbulllloemlllveconblveoa-_cOIIof--
6) Cqgpl pjcb
HMM will evaluMe eiCh altenwives compliance widl AllARJ u defined in SARA
Section 121 Theoe duoe aenenl-Jories of ARARJ cbomicll-opocific10CIIion-tpeeif~lt lnd ICdollmiddotlpeCi6c AllARJ for each ClleJOf) will have been identified ill previoulaa of the FSproceas
7) Oup PmiJCtigp
HMM will evaluaae the extent to which each alternative u a whole is proteCtive of human healdl and dle environmem
2512HAZ-2732 2-14
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
II
~ II
8) StarcAccqxaocc
Because HMM and NH DES will be workins toaelher closely throughout the Rl and FStasks all altemarives will be developed with sensitiviry to State concerns and requirementsexpressed subsequent to review of the FS and proposed remedial plan
09 ) COOliJnpjY AcccptiDjC lgtO
Olt3m~z ~
~ 3Each alternative will be evaluated in liampht of community concelN and preferences ~zexpreued subsequent to review of the PS and proposed remedial plan ~~
~~~
Comptncjvc Aoalyaia ot Alfmllljyg ltmrlgt
o rfl lgtn z
Once die ll1enwivea haYe been individually - 0 0 qainll die niae crileria IIMM will ~ -
condua a companlive aaalyail to evil- die telaive petfomtoDco of eodt abemadve iD 0~IOIIIioa to eodt opecific evil- criterioo lhil il iD - to die - eoalyoia iD which each ll1enuave ia aaalyad ladepoadoady w- die coaaidendoa of iaoe_ipo_ lllenuoivea The_ of dtia compantive aaalyail ilto illontify die adv- Utddiaadv-ofeodt lllenuoiveNiative to- -todlaldlebytndeofampcanbeevalualed
2210 Till 10- _ oflluft fS a_
IIMM will~ a dnft PS repon to be praented to EPA for toview IIIII comment Therepon will m die - nemeclill lllenwivea IIIII die ralioaale for ct-ina dleaelllenuoivea The formal ( amphiblt 2-2) for die fcuibility repon will conform to die repon format apecilled iD die PS paidance A by elen1e0t of die dnft PS repon will be die prepuation of a tomprebealive eucutive l1lftiW) which will ~erve u a me1n1 of preentina projectflftdinp to die pablic Teo copieo oldie draft PS repon will be providrd to EPA for ~eView Utdcomment and five additional copiea will be provided to NH DES
2211 Tyk II - fipal FS Rcpon
HMM will review reapond to and incorporate all of tbe commena received from thepublic EPA and NH DES HMM will prepare five bound copies each of the Final PS Reportfor EPA and NH DES Ilona with a camera-ready unbound copy
~12HAZ-2732
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
I I
~ I I
EXIIIIIIIll EXAMPLE FS RBPQRT FORMAT
Executive Sununuy
Introduction
~ ~~~~c~S~~ from Existina RI and RA Repons) 121 Site Description 0 122 Site History ~0
0lt 123 Nature and Extent of Contamination 3m
~124 Contaminant Pate lnd Tranaport z 125 Bueline lWIlt ANcl ~3
voc ~z
ldencifJCation a Scranina ofTedmolosiebull H 2llnboduclion H Q
~ 22 Remedial Action Objectiv bull Pnsenu lhe devcl_ of laigtOdial lltlion lt~
objective~ for eacb medium of interest (ie pouadwller soil surface w11er air mr
01lt) ForeodlmodiumlhefoUowlnawillbe~ r ~ n z 00Coatllllinlnu of iDterut
Allowlble aponre biiOd on rilt Ulelllftelll 0H r
Allowable UJgtOIUI booed on ARARI r oiopnenl of laigtOdiallltlion objoctiveo
23 Omonl ~ Actiono bull For e11lth medium of- doocribeo lhe e11imllion of ueu or volama to whkh treallllellt CODIampinmenl or upotWe tochnoloaiel may be opplied
24 ldenlillold011 md 5lt-1 ofTecbooiOIY Typoo IIIII _ Optiono middot For e~ltb
meclium of- doocribeo 241 ~llldScnoninamp ofTecbool 242 Bv- ofTedlocllcgtplllld Seleltlioa of lteploMolaUve Tedlnol
~t~~-Oucribel rltionale for combinltioo of rechnotoaiaJmedia into altenwiva
32 Scnoninamp of Allenwiv 32llnboduclion 322 Allemllive 1
Deocriplion Bvlluaion
- Bffectiveneu lmplemoulabilily - Cost
323 Allemllive 2 bull Descriplion - Bvalullion
324 AltenWive 3 323 Summuy of Se
~12HAZ-2732 2-16
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
~(conld)
Derailed Analysis of Altembulltives 41 Introduction 4 2 Alternative Analysis
421 Alternative 1 4211 Description 4212 Asaetomenl
ShonTenn Effectiveness LonamiddotTenn Effectiveneu and Pennnence ReductionofMobiliry ToxiciryIOd Volume ~eme111abUily COOl
=~ARARJs- AcceplanCO COIIIIIIIUillyAccep~mce
422 Allemolive2 4221 Detcriplloa 4222 shy
423 Allemolive3 424 S-y ofAI-- Allolyaio
43 Comporioon -AIIOIIIOIIYa 431 Sbolt-TOIID-shy432 -middotTerm--tPe_ 433 ReclacdoaofToaldlylllobilllyllldVolshy434 _obilily43 Call 436 cu- wilb ARARt 437 onu 431 -shy439 ~Accoplonce 4310 S-yotC---AJshy
44 S~~~~~~~~a~y ofDelaiJed Allolyaio
~
m 2JHAZ2732 2-17
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
I I
- I I
2212 Taak 12 Prcljmjpvy Dcajp gfSelcctcd Rcmcdial Altcmatjvca
1be preliminary desian of the selected remedial alternative presented in the ROD will
fonn the basis for the fulll design stqe Details penainina to enaineering design criteria
layouts cost (capital and OampM costs) and safety will be presented The preliminary design will
provide the engineerinJ technical and layout requirements of the selected alternative lbe
desipt will be of sufficient detall to aUow a specification packqe to be prepared 1be following
elements will be included in the preliminary desiampn the qineering approach includinJ
scheduling special implementation requirements institutional requirements preliminary desip
criteria preliminary layouts budJetuy cost es1imates (includina QaM costs) an oudine of a
sofety plan ond other special coouidefllions Addilionol infonnalion ~ltquiftd to complete and
implement the final deliln will be identified
2213 Iak J]MWscrcymtgiCoordUMjm
Tebalcll ~ Rcpom Por eocb 001bullinl wort elena HMM will submitshy
repor11 with the foiiOWinl den~
Jdenlilktlioa of aile Ktivity
s- ofwort the site lldpoo todate
Pe-of completion
Dillltallia- clurini the period Aolioubeinltobntoteelifyprobleml
Aclivilios pbmed for the next month
CbqeainpeiiOIIIIOI
The monthly - roport will Ust WJet and ICIUII completioo dices for each element of activity includiDamp project completion lnd provide 111 uplanation of any deviation from the
milestones in the wolk pllllacbedule Monthly propeu meetinp will be held to review the propess repon with an emphasis on
asswina there are no milundentandinp on propen technical approach content of deliverables
and problem resolution
Sclwhlc Coggpl The Project Manager ls responsible for overall schedule control At
the beampinninc of the project HMM will develop a sununary project schedule in conjunction with
EPA and NH DES This schedule will identify sWt dates due dices and requitltd precedent
taskl to meet EPAs ROD commitment date
2312IIAZ-2732 2-18
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
On 1 monthly buil the Project Manapr identiftes completed milestones identifes and
initiates nsolution of problem anu and includes 1 detailed schedule swuslpercent complete
determination in the proanss repon to the client
Ouajry Cmtrpl The Project Manqer is responsible for uswinamp that all project wort
mee11 HMM NH DES ond EPA standards
HMM hu in place a written quality assurance plan which is consistem with EPA
Uclelines This pl111 is implemented throuJhout HMM by the ltOtptgtnle QAIQC Monqer This
plan defines quliity wunncequality control ond procedures for bull ond r~eld
meuwemenu laboratory analysia dlla hlndlin1 lnd inmurnentron and includes a nview
protocol for project clelirables
2214 Tak 14 - Pnnmjty ime sIIIIP
1bo IIMM -ay te1atioatt _ wWpvvicle infomlllloaaldltato mombenof
tile -ay conoemotl wi1b or polllllillly lmpOCIOd by tile oite It io ~ tb11 BPA
wW - tile comtDuaity relalioogto _ wilb Dl implorrnttbullion oupport shyIIMM IIMM IUpporl wiD laclutlo panicipolion bull -- or -c _
piOYilloD of vioall lido Dl oqulpMD Dl --to BPA iD a ~i-5urnt1101)
2middot19
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
ATTACJIMENJ A
ADMINISI1IAnvB ORDER- SCOPS OF WOIUt
251 1IIAXI2732
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
Appendi x 1
ICQfl pr vgg
1 INDQQllCTIQH
Tbh Scope ot Vorll provlclea aa outUae at 1rtv t11at1oGa to be pertoraacl at tba Dover ltuaio1pal LaadtUl Slte located 1A Dover Nev apabira Tbe purpoaa of tbla Scope ot Vorll b to aupport ae1otiat1ona between tbe lnvlroaaantal ProteoUoa Acencr IIPA) aacl tbe Potentiallr apoAilble Partlea (piPbull) It prov1clea the aecaashyaarr iatonatlon tor tba PUa to oollduot a reulbUitr Stuclr (fS)
aad to partora aclcUUonal feulbUHr Stuclr fleld llau vblcb are neoaaaarr to aupplent tile Ibullbullbull~Ual laveat11ation 1111 Tbia Scope ot Vorll olarltlea tbe obJ180tlv aAcl acope of taa atucli allovlnl tbe nPa to partiolpate ill tbe ualraia aiampOeaaarr tor tbe aalaoUon of a reaecUal teolutolo17 aad to execute tAe tamp8IU cleacrlbed v1 tbla Durllll tbe rs I tbe vUl develop detaUacl work and operational plaaa 1 vticb aball be carrietl out uacler tbe aupervhion of IPA
I QIJICTIYU
ne pr117 taalla tbt will be ooKuotecl for tlaa h iaollde
1 Tile taplataUoa of oertala Jeamp8UtUity ltIQ Jleltl llnta to better evaluate ebullJatlac ooUtloaa at tlae lite
1 ne tUat1fioat1oa of applicable or ralavaat ud appropriate rat~uire8eata (AIAia) --loll will proviU criteria for evaluaUoa ot rbullecUal altaraalvea
1 Tile tdaattfioatioa of potaatial reaedtal teoMololiea toolucUac iaaovative teollaolo11ea amp evaluatioa of applioabilitJ of aaoll for 1aolua1oa ia H8Mial altaraative Uvaloat
4 ne davelot of _ial napoaae altanativea ~t nacbull froa No Aotioo to aa altaraativa ~t a11aiaataa tlle uecl for loDI tara alta ___at
S AD iait1a1 aaaiaa to recluoe t~e bullbullIter of ampltanaativea aubJeotad to detailed aaalnia by uaaaalaa tlte efteotinaeaa iaplaaeatabilitJ aacl ooat factora aaaociatacl viU eacb alternative
1 A clataUecl aaalyaia of altaraativea reaaiaiq after iaitial acreeniaa bullbullbullbullbullbullbullc of eacll altanatlbullbull aaaiut bull raale ot evaluatioa faetora and ooapariaoa of eacll vitA oae aaottler All alternativebull vUl conaicler both allortbulltara aacl loaabulltar hctora and vUl be evallatacl tor tbe fo11ov1DI
a Coapliance vlth dAJla b Recluctlon or toaic l tr aobiUt1 or voluae ot
contui nanta
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
IIII
c Sbort-tera effectivent
d LoatbullteN ettectlvenett aaci peNanence
e lapleaentabUitff CoeuC Cobullwaitf acceptanceb State aoceptaaoe i Overall protection of buaan bealtb aaci tbe
env1roft8ent
Selection of reaedial action alteraative7
3 norobullG aegn or agytcu
la order to acccapUtll tbe previoutb ttated obJectivebull aoci to
euble tbe aelecUon of tAe optiau reeedial reaponbullbull
alteraaUbullbull tbat it to be iapleaentecl Ue folloviac acope of
aervicea baa been developed
Durinc tbe rebulllev of tbe clrah leae41al laveatication prepared
bf tlellru laciaaerlac Corporation aa4 OolcllaercmiddotZoiao ancl
Aaaooiataa lao IPA aad tba Mev palaire Dapartaeat of
bYiroatal lerYioaa (NIDU) it vu aot tllat eddltioaal
field iabullaaUpUoa -otibullitiea warbull MCae to naolbullbull
oertaia outataadiu iaauaa na tollowlu field al~MBta an
aori-amp Mlow
1 Cleoploniaal data obtaiMd br lfooOa Oooroioal lao
cUreotlJ auaaata ~t ia Ue araa l-liatal7 aoutlleut ampacl
aoutll of Ue lUUl la Ua -rlaa ola7 uait Uo atntua of
-iae olampJ eaooatored olaowltere aonaa tile aita aot De
Ia orclar to aYaluata tllia po8amp1bUi tFooatlauoua la Ula uaa aad tile bullartioal laUilMatloa of OMtaal-ta two eddiUoaal
oluater altea an propoaed aouttleaat ef lle laalltill alou
bullbull1-io llae I aa akova oa tlle attaollM bullPmiddot fte tirat oluatercletiaed br ~~
vUl M located ia tlle oeater of tte pl u fta aeooad
eleotratio torraia ooDCluotlbullitJ emu allfaJ
oluetar vUl M located oa tile eutarlr trlaaa or tile plue
fte tltioDeaa of Ula liae olaF lanr Cit eaoouatarecU will be
sral itoriac walla willUteniaH at aeoll oluetar lite
tllea be plaoed la tJae upper llUOceolocio uit -ed oa
litllolocio data ucl f1bull1bull eoNOalac tor YOlatUa orcuio
Vater tabla wellbull alao will be plaoacl atobullpowula CYOCa) aaola looatioe abobull bull aad Juet below tile upperaoat aqui tarbull bullbull bull
cllecll oa poaaible parclled vampter table cDClitioaa
2 An adcUtlonal boriabull i a Ulle vic iaitf of OV-1 lA Ibullbullbull attaclled ia required to cleteraiae tile deptb to bedrock In
ampdeli Uoa a well aorean will be plaoecl in tile lover aqu i fer toAaalyah
bullonitor anr poatibla coatuiaatlon at tllia locatloa
for the full llaaardoua aubatanca Uet (BSL will De required
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
2 Aa actditional vall ol~ampater aortbwaat ot tba luclt i ll fbullbullbull attaetlecl -bullbull vUl dao ba required Split apooa aaapl wUl be tiald acraanecl and rapraatativa aaaplaa vUl be autittecl for UL ual7aia The purpoaa ot tbia activitF ia to obtaia baallaroUAcl aoil ucl arouacl water data
4 A vall oluater batveaa tba landfill uct OV-3 1bullbullbull attacbed _ will need to be batallecl aod aaapla4 Tba purpoae of tbh vall h to aatablhb a chao bouaciarF batveea tba lampfUl aod tile foNar PUaiobiello lrotllen acrap tal raM looatacl oa Glen Hill Road vbtcb _ rapreaent ao aclditioaal aouroe of ooacaashyioatioa aeparata froa the landfill s pUnc of Olfbulll allall be parforaed at tlla aaaa tiaa tba vall oluatar h aaaplad 1bh oluatar would be located at leaat SO feat avar tree ampaF areaa aucll aa roada or olearinca tllat appear to llave beea aaaooiated vitb vabioular traffic or llaaYT aquis-ant uaa aad vtliclt _ coatain fuel or oil apUla or laaampa
5 (a) Soil bull-plea will be takaa at tArH U I looatloaa batvaea tba laadfUl and IbullU aloaa tile olcl lOII1DI roada ( bullbullbull attacbed up) laaplaa will be takaa at oaa tvo ampAd aia fHt to bullbullbullbullbullbull tbe vertical axteat of ooataalaaUoa naaa aaapla looatioaa are propolampd to datartaa if ooataalaattoa 41eoovaled at taa 1middot13 location b lamplatacl to looallaacl aothmiddot1Uaa tLat tooll place aloac tba road Ol to ooataiAampAt traupolt froe tala ludtlll
(b) A aoll apUDC llld aurrouadiAI 1-lJ ca attaolt bullPI 1a plopoaecl to aaaaaa areal axtaat of ooa-iuttoa fta aaap11q aUll be at tba deptH aa daaollbecl Uowa Uatanl _11q crid alabull to be datanlaecU bull
1 AD additloaal wall oluatar la tlaa vlota1t7 of 1-1 ud ov-a Ca attaobacl MJ) 1a raquinrcl la tlaa upper ectUifer fta JNIpoampa of tlaia vall ia to furUar aabullbullbullbull Ua Yamprtloal diatriktioa of ooaiaaaU ia tloe upper 4Uifor rvU DL uolnie will be NftuiiM U bullitla Ua oar 11 oluetan ampOIHa plat vUl be _i litloolocio amp1111 o ioal ta bullbull iaale approvecl -F Ule IPA amp1111 IIIIDD u of -11bull 1-1 amp1111 011-1 Uall be partoa ooeournatlF vUJa uapliq of UHe acl41t1-1 11a
1 Addltiosal air bullbull1torlq M7 be aaoHa to ampYaluata tlle aabiaat laftlD ooourrlq oa tile alte Alao bull uac alta tkat le repleaaatatlbullbull of leatdeatial eapoaura will be laoludecl ill tbla MD1tor1 ne exact looatioaa aod Ubull of aaapliac vUl be approvecl -F Ula IPA amp1111 JIIIIIS bull
I Upoa ooplation of tbe work a rapolt akall ba developed bull--ribulllnl tile obJacUvea of tka aclditloaal tialcl labullaatilatlon and laterpletatioa of reaulta Tbe report akall alao iaclude all
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
I I
- I I
vall iaatallaUon lolt cbaaical clata tablet 1rouaci vater thvashytion tablet revitecl plana or aacl aar oUer latoraation aa aeceaaarr
In order to eaaure tbat the proper prooecluret for tilt above taalu are follovecl tilt PampPt tball ti tber cievelop a Qua11 tJ Atturuoa ProJect Plaa CQAPP) or utUht tbe QAIP pravloutl7 clevalopecl tor tile ampI Tht QAPP tball be twMitteci for raviav ucl approval b7 the IPA aacl NH DIS
3 Z VetlaaclaPloodplain Uaeaeat
Tile PRPt tball prepare a vatlaaciatloodJJlaia uatataaat to acltquatalr bullbullbullbullbullbull tile txiaUac ttatua of vatlaacta u4 tloodJJlampiat vbicll be ampdvaraelJ affeottd b7 tbe Dover LampAdfUl All raaeclial alteraativta oonaidartcl ia tbe faaaibUitJ ltudJ auat aaaeaa tbair iapact oa tbe vetlaadt aacl ita valuea Tlth aaalrta vUl be oonaitteat vitb tba raquiratt of 40 en Part I bull Appenclix A
Tbt folloviac iteaa thould be ooatidartcl ia tJte clevalopatat of tbt bullbullbullbullbullbullbullbullat
1 cbaraoteriaatioa of Ut vetlaada 2 fuaotioaal value of tile wetlU iaPM of Joe lU14fUl oa Joe weu-
middot Debullelo- of AUoable or lelt- _priate _ta(AaAial
Tile - ollall lUtif7 all prolla-le f ral u-le or relet aad approp~iate J14111ir-ata CAampAaa) New -pallire AlAampamp aad local r~viata ftete 1M f ral atata looal bullbullbulllroaaeatal aad puiiUo ~ealtll t~ reculatioaa IUiclaaoe adYitoriet or oiCliaaaoea ~ otlaer oriteria adviaoriea ampDill 1lidaaoet aUll IN
1 Couiclend la te of tteir olaaaioal-apeolfio looatioa-apeoifio aM aotibull-bull-alfio atUliNt
2 avaluatM for ola Ua Caurtaoe tar aro1llllcl tar tar a1Msta aoil air ttlota aM faollitiaa) partioularlT for ola-ioalapeoifio Altdt tNt ioolucUaa otker AIAaa u approprlbullte
3 DiatiDCUiahad tor tub teoluaoJpo coulclered parti shyoularl for aotioaapeoifio a but iaolucliq otber dAampe u approJJriata
4 CoDaidered bullt eacb aaJor ataae of the rs vbart tbampJ are indicated
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
Ia aeneral icleatLticatioa of cllebullical uct eitemiddotapecitic AAAJt1are ore ibullportampDt iD tJle beCiADiDI I~ampCII of the fS vhereaatlae icleatitioatioa ot actioabullapeoitio AIAaa caia taportucalater cluriaa tlae bullore rs-oriaatecl ltaCito However liace the1cleatit1oattoa of oUAAa baa not Mea acoobullpltallecl in tllhaanaer it 11 tbullportaat tbat all AampAa icleatlfioatioa be oobullpleteclin tile tirat tuk of tile rs 0
CllebullicalbullapeoUio ALUla are uauallr llealth or rhkbullbaaednuaerical valueamp UbullitLnl the uouat of or ooaceatratioa of aohebullica1 ~bat _ be found in or cliacbarced to the aabieatenvironaento The Maxlbullua Contuiaaat Levell (PfCL) of tbe bullsateDrinkinl Vater ACitbull and the Feltleral Ubieat Water QuaUtrCriteria of tbe Clean Vater Ao are ao- exuplea of obnicalmiddotapecific AllAiao AdditLve riaka aball be evaluated aacl itappropriate ahall be utilhecl aa a nbullecliatioa aoal o
Looation-apeoitlo AIAIa are aeneral reatrioUoaa plaoecl upon tbeooncentratioa ot llaaardoua aubataaoaa or tJle ooaduot ofaotivitiea aolelr beca~o~ae tbe7 are 1D apeclal looattonao Sobullbullexupha of apee~lal locationa iaolude but are aot l1bull1ted to floodplainamp vetlaacla biltorio placea placeamp vitb obJeota otarcllaeoloampio daaificaaoe aad aeadtive eooantebullbull or UbitataoA tev exuplea of looatioa-apecitio ALUe are tile middotrloodplalattuaceat lxeoutive Order CIO 11111) bull Ue bullPHteoUoa ofVetlaadll lxeovtive Order (10 llttotbull aad Ua replatioaaproaulaated pvrauaat to tJla bullMatJoaal IJatorto bull1aoea Aot bull
Aot1oa-apeoit1o AAAaa ue uauallr teoluaoloaJ or aot1vlt7middotMaedclireatioaa or 11bull1 tat1oaa loA ooatrol aotiou tuu at CDCLAaltaa AoUoa-apeoifio AampAa8 u tlae tapUee covera be-dial utJoaa Tile bullICIA lubput G Cloaun lenlati- bull tJle bullacampA lubpart 0 laaiaeratioa leaulatioaa bull ampad tlte middot-bull LuulDhpoaal aatriotioubull are a eaplea or aoUoabullapeo1t1o
Ae part of tile aoopiaa tlte ahll proYlda a 11at ia obrtto or oriterla autUObullbull 11aitat1 viiJola bull-ould-middotiaJUallJ M eDautiYe of all bullbullk lru fte llet ablliacUoate WetJler eaoil requlrat ia potaatiallJ aw11oaltle orrelevaat aacl appropriate olluJoal-apeoitio looatioo-apeoificor act1oa-epao1f1o pertJaeat to ampUIfaoe water arouad bulltereo11 air biota or faoUiUea aacl attiaM vitlt apeoitio levelampor IOampla toM attaiaecl It apecifio levela or coala middotareattiaacl tAeJ bulluat be eaueratecl ia tJle obarto
I8bull1
Data reqvirata ia teraa of pbJaical aAd cltioal obaraoterhshyUoe aeedM to evaluate UAJie vtll be reviewed ampDel OHiparecl with4ata obtalaecl clurinc the at o Sucb requtreata _ iaolude but
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
are not Uaited to cllaaical r iduah backcround levels or varioua aodelinc parbull ten middot middot
A partial lilt of potential AlAlia ia preaented in tbe preubh to tbe NCP aa uanded in Novaaber UU Section 4 of CyidMqe grfeteibllitr Sty41et yoder CI8C4 IPAUOCmiddotIImiddot003 Jypt ltl5 alto 11bullbullbull aoat potential aourcea of utUa Ad41tional utAJla will bt eoucbt br tbt PRPa cturinC a thoroucll atrch of tedaral and atatt anvLroaaental atatutaa
Tbt NHDES and USIPA vill have tiaal autboritr h dacidial with ALUa are retained or added tor conaiclaration and tbt utant to vbicb tbt7 auat bt coaaidered ia rtatcl7 aalactioa clurLna tbt IS Sutticiant Juatiticationa tor incorporatinl or aliaiaaeinc a requirtaant will be provi cltd at tacb atap wbart 1ucb clachLona art aade
3 4 Davaloeat of _ial leapoaae ObJeaUbullbullbull aad leapoaae Actioaa
laatd on the t1ncUn1a of the at tba praliaiaarr reaponat obJtctivaa will bt clevalopacl Prior to tatablhbaant of the reapoaae obJeotivea aicaifieut alta problaaa oontaaiDut ai1rat1on patbvara aa4 AampAaa vUl be iclaatltlecl aacl aaaaaaecl Acoowttlaa tor tbeaa taatora aacl focualac oa Ua tlacliqa of tbe lialr AaaeaaMat aotivltiaa aoMuctM tor tlae 11 rtatclial reapoaaa obJaotivea vUl be foraulatM to addrtll ampDJ euttataatial rielra to publio llealtll ampDII tlae bullbullbulllro--t vltll ooulcltrat1oa C1Yta to alta-eaiflo ooaditiou laatcl oa tlat napoua objaothmiddotea aeaaral reapout utlou vUl 1M cltbulleloped to aclclreaa aaob of tilt altabull protlbull anu neat raapoua aotiou vUl fora tile touaclatioa tor tYaluatloa of tlat potaatial r_ial taclulolo1laa tltat were iclaat1tltcl u part of Ut 11 aoUvitiee ampAd for aubetquaat taollaolOI7 cltYtloat clurlaa Tuk 3 5 ampDel for alteraatJva ~middotbullbullloaat aDd aonaaiac clurlac talk 3 1
rolloviac tilt cltYtlo-aat of tllt r~ial reapoua ottJaotivee ucl reapoaaa aotiou aDd icltatitloatloa of dAb tlta flh allall ooacluot a brlatlaa for IPA aad tilt lfiDU la orcltr to prebulltat prashyUainampr7 raapoue olllJaotlbullbullbull ampAcl oleaau~t oritarla tor eaoll aecliua requiriac reaeclial aotioa amp8111 to olttaia iaput oooourraooe
3 S luHol of -a1 Toolloololloo
Curiae tlat cltYelo-at of tba 11 a preaeatatioa of poteathllr a~tplioabla r Mial taobaolOiibullbull vaa p~epartcl tba iclaatifild tecllaololiea acoouattd tor botla aouiCa coatrol uul bullbullbullbullbullbullant of al1ratioa raatdlae laltd oa tilt eltt-apeoifio probhbullbull idantititcl cluriDI the 11 ud alao tbt reaecliel rebullpoaaa objtetivea and aotioaa claveloptcl la Tuk 34 of tbe n all potential reaediel tecJUlololita will bt aubJected to a acrebullninl
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
IIII
prooeaa Tile obJemiddototiYe h to elie1naU troa further eondderat i on
aar teobnolociea wbicll woulct be ctitt1cult to iapleeant nquire
iaappropriate Ubullbull perioda require ebullceaahe ooata r on
uaproven teobaolociea or are Wlrpoadve to ctevelopiq reculatorT
piclalloe Tile aoreeniac proeeaa wUl tooua oa wute
obaraoteriatica aaci aite-apeoltio concliUoaa identified cturinc the
81 tbat preclude iapleaentation of a liven tecbaolOIJbull lDberantTecbaolocha atill
tecbaolOI7 Uaitationa wUl alao be evaluated
ooaaidered to be viable after tbe acreenial proceaa would 1M
included in the foraulation of reaedial alternativea
Por crourul water reaponae actionbull the PaPa aball develop a
Uaited aueber of reaedial alternat i vebull within a pertoraanee raace
detinecl in teraa of varrinc reaediaUoa hvala azulthat h Vhere haaible one alternativediffereftt ratea of raatoration aboYlcl be oonficured that would r tore crouad water to a 10middot bull
auiaua lifeti ebullobullbullbull oaaoer riak level witbiD five U I rean
AdclitioDAl IViclampDoe for clevelopiQC alternativeamp ia liVeD ia
bullauidaaoe oa Peaaib111tr StucUaa uzuler CUCLA bull IPA140crIS003
Juae ltiS aacl tbe bullxnterla Ouiclaaoe on luperfuacl SeleotionlaaedJ
(OSVU 135100middot11)
Debulleloat aacl loreeaiDI of aclial AltenatieJl
Uaiaa tlla reaulta of tbe Taaara 34 aacl Jl ~e aball develop
nelaquolial altanatibullebull vlaiU ue Hapoulbullbull to aeo~ lcleatifiacl aite laoll r~ial altenati e~oulcl
ooUtioa nquiriaa r iatioala UUoa tJae ao-tioa altanaUbulle
M u obullanll aUa will M ooaaiclere4 ud oarrtbull t~louela be fttiH aorMatac
fte tolloviaa olaaaea of altetia at M ooaaiclerbullproaeaa
Altenatibullebull for treataeat or cliapoaal at aa offmiddotaite
CAA tiPUA aacl IDtiA IPPIOYid faailitiea U appropriate1
tao111tl approv br IPA UoolwUaa ICamp fiCA CVA
2 Altenatlbullbullbull vlllob Usaia applloable ampad relebullut federal
publlo kaaltla or bullbullbulllroDMatal ataadarda
J Aa appropriate altenatlbullbullbull did aaasl appli~le aacl
releYampDl publio Jtealta or bullbullbulllro-tal ataaduda
4 41tanatia vlaiob clo aot atuta aplloatle or relevut
pultlio Maltb or eaviroatal ataadartla but vUl recluce
t~a llllellllood of preaeat or future tlareat f~ tlae Tbh auat iaolude aa altenative
baaucloubull aubatucea d1U oloaell approCbea tba leWel of proleotioa probull
bull14 ltJ tile appUeable or relevaat ataadarcla aacl aeeU
CIICLA a objective of adequatelr protection public llealtb
welfare aacl environaent
5 A no-action alternative
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
Screeninl abould preaerve a raa1e of the DOlt proailinl alterftashytivea aa deteninecl br tbeir lUrelr eftectiveneaa iapleaefttshyabtlitr and coat lfteoUveaeaa aball be evaluated on wbetbei- it adequatelr proteota huaan bealtb and the anviroueat baaed ia part on ALIa d1nificanU7 ampad peraaaantlr nduoea tbe toxio l tr aobUitT 1 or vole of baaardoua coaatituaau aad other relevant criteria taplaaaatabtlity of alternativeamp aball be avaluatecl oft teohaical teaalbUitr iaoludial abort - tara aad loa1-tera ettectivaneaa availabilit7 of tecbnololylal tor aaob alternative iaat i tutLonal teaaibUitr aacl aclainhtrative teaaibiUty Coat of conatructioa iaolucUal lon1 tan ooata to operata -iataia udor replace raaecUal tacUitiea 1t paedad aball abo be aval~oampamptad
Special oonaideration aball h civen to evaluatiDI iaaovativa tachshyaololiea They abould be carried throucb tbe initial aoraenial U there h evi dence incUcatiAI tter otter better attactiveaeaa or iaplaaentabilitr fever ampvane tapacta or lover ooata tbu aatablhbed tecbaolociea The faotora relatiac to tile eftectiveneaa iaphaeatabUtt y aad ooet aball be veicbed leaa lleavtlr than thoae tor eatab11abed tecllaolo11ea
Tbe contat aaat ud no-aotiOIIl alteraativea aboulcl be carried tbroulb tbe acreeaiat aa4 aaalyaecl 4ur1DI ~middot cleta1led 1avaat1shyIampUon fte altarut1vea CUt are olearl F not feaalble or appropriate prior to uaclertakl cletaUM aYampluat1oa of ~middot r-laiac altaraathmiddotaa an eltiutecl na nt1oula for tala el1a1aat1oa of alteraat1bullbullbull ut M clooted la tJaa feullt11it7 atucll o
ne follovi ooaa1clerat1oaa are uad u tbe buia for aoreealac of alteraatibullea
- Coat aa alteraattbullbull wlloaa ooat fu bullbulloU tJaat of ot ller alteraat1bullbullbull ampad cloaa aot provicle aubataat1all7 1nater public g llealtla or eayen1roatal proteotloa or teolualoal nl1U1Ut7 vUl be alia1-tad na tocal ooat of aa altenat1va vUl M ooaa1clarad aad will taolude tile coat ot 1apl-bullt1 tala altershyutibullbull and tJaa ooat of operat1oa ampDCI aalateaaaoa A pnaeat vortla
bull C
aaal7aia t aeaalt1bullit7 aaalnia vtll be ooDduotad for eaob alteraat1bullbullmiddot Aa alternative tllat far eao_ taaa ooeta ot otller alteraat1bullbullbull aYampluatecl aa4 tbt cloaa aot provlcla aubetaat1allT 1reatar pult11o llaealtb or eavlroaaental proteotioa or teoluaical 8re1Jab1lit7 aUll be bullbulloluclad froa furtber evaluatioa
lffect1ftaaaa alteraativea poalnl lilnltlcaat Mvene enviroaaeatal iapacta ampAd rir7 liaited eaviroaaeatal beaefita vUl be bullbulloludad OD17 tboaa alteraativea that aatlety tbe reaponae obJectlbullbullbull and contribute aubataatiallr to tile protection of public bealtb welfare or tile eaviroaaent eball be conaiclerecl furtllar Source control altaraathea auat acbieve adeqyate control of aource Mterlala MampAa1aaeat of ai1raUon
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
IIII
alterftatiYea alould aiticata the tbraat of ban to public
baaltb velfampll 01 the eaYilOUIDt
altenaeUbullbullbull uat be taaaibla- Aooaptabla lebulltartoc Practtoaa
tor tha location aad coacUtioaa of tba ralaaaa applicable to tba
problaa aacl rapreaant a reliable aeaaa of aclclraadoc tAa problaa difficult to iaplat vill
AltaraamptiYaa that U7 prove extreael7
not achieve tbe raaadial obJactLvea in a reaaoaabla tiae period or
that rely on Uaprobullea tecbnoloiY vUl be eUaiaatM
Upon coaplation of tlbullbull ini tial acreeainl of alterutivea the PRPa
aball prepare an Initid Soreeninc Report tor aubaiaaioft to tbe IPA
aad NHDIS The report shall include a oilart abovtaa all the altershy
nativaa and the analyaia of tbe bade faotora deaoribM above Tbe
report ahall contain Juatitioatioa tor clroppial raUaiaa andor
addial alteraativea aact alao ideatity all Uta raqutreftta
naoaaaary to aelect a raaadr
J T Treatability ltuclyPUot TaatiU
Tba obJective of tbla taak ia to obtaia acldtUoaal iafonatioa
aaoeaaary to evaluate tba attaotlveaeaa of r ial treataeat
taclutolobulllbullbull Laboratory aoale prooeaa a1bullulat1ou aMll be
ooDCluoted to avallampta tile treatabUitJ of ooataaiut aroIACI fta faotora detaralaad 1a Ua
water aurfaaa tar ampIMl aoUa
laboratoiJ ara u tollowa
- ooataaiaaat reaoval efflolaaoy
- fouilliUty- coat affeottbullbullbullbullbullbull- anarcy coat - ooatrollaldlltraafatr
fta Uta 4avalopacl frbull adclitloaal uapUac bullroan aad Ua data
pnbullioualF pulllio~od t~o aito nould pnbullido uato llookarouad
to dolop a 11-daai pilot proana Prior to _io
cleltac Meola eoala tuta viU M oOIMIMta4 to aatUUall fta Neall aoala teaU rill povlde a
prelia1-rJ treatalt1Ut7 pralta1DampI7 aonabulli of tlae availaltla tnac-at teollaolobulltbullbull middot A
datanlaatioa of ~middot aaK to rva pilot aoala prooa tnia vUl M
t tlloae raaulta
3 1 Deta1lod Aaamplnia of Altou
~il~~=i 1-t~~ ribull~ad~=bar ot la order
parforaacl purauaat to Tu- 3 I ot the fauibUitr nucl)o
to provide conahteat baaaa tor tbaae aaal7aaa aaolil alternative
ahall be daacribad ia clataU Thia cleacrlptioa ahall iaclude
- appropriate traataaat aacl dhpo1al tacbaolo11
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
II
- II
10
bull apecial lftliaeerinl couiclarationa required co iapleaent
tba alternative (a a pilot pia~~t atudta aclcUtionaJ
atucu 1t ur needed to proc~aed uitb tiaal reaedial
claeiiDI
operatioa uiDtenampnce and aonitorinl requiraaeata ofbull
tbe raaedT
bull aahtJ requiraaenu ( illcludinl on ampad offbullaita baaltb uci
aatetr conaideratioaal
bull a deaoription of ltov altarnativaa ooYlcl be pllaaed into
operable unite Tile claaoriptioa vill iDolucla a dhshy
ouaaioa of llav varioua operable uiU of tba total
raaedr could be laplaatecl 1Ddividampamplh or ia aroupa
raaultiDI 1A a liampAitloaat iaprovat ia tba qualitr
of tba aaviroaaeat or coat aavia
iaplanted a claaortptioa of llov aaob altaruUva oould N
la aodulaa to allow pbaaecl coaatruoUoa ucl operatioa
a review of UF off-alta faoUltiaa provlcle4 b7 the Statebull
to clataniaa it tbaF are la obullpUaaobull vita appUoable ICIA
requlata tao ovreat IIA polloi oa offbullalte dlapoul
vtaloll rulrea taat Qe fao111t7 1M la OMpUuoe wltll ICaA
rellllamptloaa ampad M approbull Ill DA at Clio tl8e of t taeat
or diapoaal -amp 1M followed
Tile rtlal alteraatlbullbullbull loll paaa Qo laltlampl aorHaiDI prooeaa
aut M enluat oa Qo llula of perfoaoo 1a alaia111DI r1H to
publlo llealtla welfare or tllo nbulllt Aa 1a Qo iaitlal
aoraiac proooaa 1bullpl-atalt111t7 effeot1Yeaoaa t ooat vill
1M ooaalclerM no offeotlbullbullbull oalbulltloa aUll oouldor publioof AMaa Aa 104lirecl
lloaltll oabulllroatampl lbullpeota ampad at~
Ill leotloa UlCitlfUCA-G) of IAampA tao uaH-t of ampltonaUvo
r-11amp1 aotloa Ull at a elaiaua tallo lato aoooat tlae follovlq
faotora
a loaabulltoN uaoortaiaUea uaoo1atecl vUIl laad 41apoaal
b tao aoala oltJeotlbullbullbull aacl a1naeata of tlao loUd
Vuto Dlapoaal Act
o tllo porahteace toxioltr Mb111t7 ud propoaaitl to
b1oaooueulato of aiaob ltaaardoue aubatampAOoa aacl tlleir
ooaatltuoata
d abort aact lollCbulltore potoatlal for adveno boalth
affeota frobull buaampA oxpoauro
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
11
bullmiddot loncbulltera uintenance coah
t tha pouaUal tor future reaedial actioa coau it tba altaraaUva reclial action ia quaaUoa vera to tail
Imiddot tba potentLal tbreat to buaampa baaltb aad tba aavironshybullaat uaociated vitb excavation traaaportamptioD uui rediapoaal or coatainaaat
Aa part of tba racHal alternativaa avaluatioa procaaa tlla nPa eball davelop and uae a aerioal cgtdal to dbullulata lectecl alternative reaKtal actiYitiaa Tba liataila outliainl tbe tYPe of bullodbulll to be utilised aball be autittecl to tba IPA ud NGIS tor review aacl approval
Aa previoudr lpeCit1ed uaci1r tbamp ObJeotiYII for tba Fl tbamp PRPa will addraaa ampDd evaluate aiaa(l) epeoitio criteria ia tbe cletaUacl aoalnia of alterutivea A deaoripUoa of tDbullbullbull alae orharia tollova
311 Cepllyge wiJl 41Me
AlteruUbullbullbull alaould 1M uaaaaed bullbull to ftatllar tiler attala laaallr Aide ot otllor federal aacl atate eav1roueatal ud publio llealtt lava 1aolMiiaa u appropriate
- ooatu1-tmiddotapeoifia AampUa Cbullmiddotbullmiddot IICLa IIAAQe)
- loaaUoa-apeoltla AlAIamp Cbullmiddotbullmiddot natriotiou oa aotlou at lliatorio noeUoa aitoo)
- aaUoabullaltia AIAia lbullmiddotbullmiddot ICaA -1ta tor 1aoiaonshyt1oa oloavre)
IAIA prov14u ala waiven tor aitutioaa wllen aot all AampAa bull- M bullt ia leotioa 111()(4) fte ua of bulllbullera Mamp8t be J1111Uf1 la lao -ri of -laloa (-1
3 11 Wpetlg eC Teleltz laltlllU er Yl shy
fto to diola altonattv eeploF trbullteat tMt roduaaa toxioitJ bullb111t7 or vol- aiiH14 M uaoaaecl faotora Itampt alallt llo nlot laoludo
- ttao t ceat procbullbullbullbullbull tllat lao rampIIHioa nploJ aacl ateriala tlteJ will -roat
- Ue aMIIIt ot llaaardoua aatertaia tllat will be claatroracl or troatacl
tba clacrbullbull ot oxpootacl roducUoa ia toxtcitr aobUitr or voluao
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
II
- II
lZ
tile decree to wbicb tbt treatbullent il irreversible
- tbe reeiduala tbat vUl rebullaia toUowtnc treaueat coftshy
tlclerlDc tbe perehteaoe todcttr bullobU1tr aod propendtr
to bloacouaulate of aucb ba~ardoue aubetaacbullbull ucl their
ooaatitueau
3 a s Jagrs-tbulln bullcruuxbullobullbullbull
Tbe abort-tera effectibulleDeta of alUrDativea altoulcl be
bullbullbullbullbullbullbulld coneiclerina appropriate faotore aaoac tbbullbull beinl tbe
followinc
caitiMie of reduotion of exiatiaa rialla
- abortbullttra rhlla tbat aicbt be poaecl to tbe oo-uaitr
vorllera or Ut eaviroaMat cluriac lbullplataUoa of aA
altenaUve laalMilac poteatial Ureate to ll-- llealtb
and tbe eaviroaaent uaociatecl vtU bullbulloavatioa tlUlabull
portatLoa aacl recliepotal or ooataiueat
- ltnltb of tiM required Mfore full protectLoa 11 aollhvecl
aet tey-ttn u ne-middot AlteraaUbullbullbull allould M uaoaaK for ~middot loacbullton offeoUYobull
bullbullbullbull aaoo ~t ~afford aloac wit-~middot P of
oartaia1 ~ tlao bullill proH auaooaafvl raoton
diola aiP M ooaaiUrH an
bull ucaitlda ot realdal rlalla la tol88 of_ aM ooabull
oaaratlou of vaato rlalac bull followlaa tal-tatioa of
a reeeclial aoloa ooulrlac tlao peralataa toxloltF
bullttlUt1 ampad propeaal tF to bloaoouaulata of auala llaaaarctoua
aultataaooa aecl tllolr ooaatltuoau
- trpe aad UIIM of lobulltan re41-1rM laoludlac
MaltorlDI al oporatloa ampad latoaaaoo
bull pocntlal for eapoaure of ~~~ -bull1-atal roooptora
to Ualal waata oouldarl t1ae -ttlal ~t to
llUMB lloaltll uul tba bullbullbulllroaaeat uaoolatM wltll oxoayenampbull
tloa traaaportaUoa rlapoaal or ooatalat
loalbulltora raUabUitr of tho oaclaooriaa ampad laatltuUoaal-ooatrola iaoludlDC wacortaiatibullbull aaaooiated with laad
diapoaal of uatraated waatea aad roaiduab
- potential fteacl for replaceaoat of tile
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
ll
Tile aaae or clifficuhr of ieplaaUnl tile altaraauv can ba uaaaaed bJ ooadclerinl till follovhl t7JN1a of factore
decree of cUftloultr aaaociatH vttb conatructlac the teobaoloiJ
aqraquoaoted operational rdiabUltr of tbe tecluloloclbullbull
need to ooor4iaata vi tb aad obtain aecaaaan approvall and peraitl fbullmiddotbullmiddot NPOIS Dreclaa ampad fUl Parwita) frobull otber ofticaa ancl acanoiea
availabUitF of necaaaamprJ aqutnt IIAd apecialhta
- available capacitJ aACl looatioa of aaeclM traacant a tor_bull aacl 4iapoaal aarvioaa
bullbullbull Ou1
Tba t-pea of coata tbat aboulcl be aaaaaaecl iaolalla tba followtaa
- oapltal coati
- operatioa a -lbulltbull~bull ooata
- ooata of fibulla ar rabulli- ftara ~lled
- aat praaaat ftltM of bullpltal OUI ooata
- potntial futva rHlal actloa ooata
JIT e-middotbullsz AaebulleHMbull
Clauly a full uaaaat of ao-ltJ attitMiea tovaN Ua altanatlbullbullbull oaaaot 1M _ uatil tta tonal lio -at porlo4 oa tile propoootl ploa - IIn - ld laiUor raampeliaca of o-ua1t7 aooaptuoe ot plafenaoH tile altoraatibullebull will clopeM oa ~e clelleo ud tJPO ot o_itr iabullolbullbull 1a a proJect clu1ac tile llft pnoobullbullmiddot ftia aaaeaaMat etioulcl loot at
- ooepoaeata of tbe alteraativea tkat tbe c-mitJ aupporta
- teatunbull of Ue alteraathmiddotea alaout vbicll tile oo-ua1tr llaa reaervatlou
- elbullbullbullata of tbe altanatibullbullbull vUcb tbe citJ atronbulllr oppoaea
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
II
- I I
2bull1 1 I tbullU bullssbullatyse Statea are Joint rht UDampIeU vi tb IPA in tbe Superfundproceaa of tao takinl the had tor raaedial iavaatilttioaa udteaaibUitr atucu abalinl ooata of tbe reeedial aotionaud payinl tor tile operaUoa ampAd tataDaaca oat tlaa reaecliaa leoauaa of oloae iataraotion UtlOUihOwt raaecUal proJeou iteay aot be necaaaarr to addraaa atata oonoarna vttb propoaeddtarnativaa aa a apaoitio evalwation criterion vhea oobullparinlalterllltivea ln 1011 ouea laovever it ear be DeceaaarTto incorporate ewch ooacerna into the evaluatioa vitll re1arclto
bull coepollenta of tba altarnativaa the State awpporta
bull taatwree of tlaa alteraativea about vbioh the State baartiiiYitiODI
elaetatl of tbe al terutibullbullbull Iader ooaaicleratioa Uat tileState atroa~hmiddot oppoaaa
3 11 OVemll Prptgtipa pC 1Jwa IMllr M4 Iabull lpytrgetp
rollovia~ tile aaalrale of r ial optioae amplampiut 1Miviclualaval~~amptioa olitaria tbullbull alteraathmiddotea allould M aabullbullbullbull frbullUe ataadpoiat of vlaatlter tile probulllcle Metauate proteotlbull ofb_ llealtb ud eavtroat ooae1clerilll tlte altiple Oliter1a
11 _ - COUlabull of uuu
fte retultbull of tile 4eta11M evaluatioa of altenatlwebull Cooetteollaioal ooaa1deratioa pultl1o Ileal~ welfare ud eavtroataliapaot) are bull-rhld to utitt ia UA 1 bullbullleotibull of a ooetshyefteotive ial alterutive tllat effeotiwel aitilamptu ucla1a1bull1bullbullbull tllreata to aad provi4tla ampequate proteotioa ot pultUobullbullal til aacl lfan ampad tile eabullirODMat la aeleoti thappropriate ext1at of UA vUl oouiclar ooatteollaolocr relialt1Ut adaiaiatntibullbull oamplter ooMena udtlleil relet etfeota oa JNItlio Ileal tta velfan a tkeeaviroat A IIUrat1ve cleaoriptioa of tile aYampatacea ampad41aavaaampCOI of eaota altonative oou1claracl alaampll 1M PJOparacl
3 10 r-l-UU~ 1IIQ Iapan
The Pllbull allall foraulate a recobullaDClocl realdr aACl 1aolu4e allpertiaeat ooaceptual cloaica ia a do11bullbullrible oatitlld bulloraft rs bullTbe report bulllaall iaclucla a ataart vbiclt clellaoatea eaclt factorlilted abobullbull tor oaob alteraative aacl taoUitatebull aaal laadinlto rebulleclr bullbulllectJoa
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
II
- II
Tbe 4ratt rs report will iaclude an execut1ve suaaanmiddot an
iatroduotLoa a eaumiddot ot aU alteruUbullbullbull aad a debullcrLption ot It vUl Laolude a bulluarr ot
tlae aoreeaina aad evaluation procen
tlae detailed tecbaical and COlt evaluatioaa aad a coaparative
evaluatioa of aU raaedial altarnaUvbullbullmiddot Tbia bull~rr will belactcup iatoraauon
preaeated in a tabular utricea trpe toraatappeaclicee
aad calculationbull will ba iDcludecl u
The draft fS ehall than be 1Ubal1ttecl tor IPANHDIS review Tbe
report vUl include a detailed executive _ vh1ob oan be ubulled
to praeent the results of the rs report to tbe public
It ia tba opia1on ot the PRP1 NKnU or IPA ampclditional stucliebull ar1
raquirecl to ooaplate the rs the Pile shall develop and auNit tor
approval aa Additional Stuclhbull Vorll Plaa ooiUluot auoh ltud1ea and
prepare a Draft rs tor IPANimiS revilv Upon cleteraiution br
IPA aacl NHDIS Uat oo ampclditioaal atudiea are required the PRPs
upoll requeat b7 IPA lball prepare a tiul clratt fl vbiob vill be
prepared tor public oobulleata Subaequaat to tba public c_at
perio4 the PRP1 upoa requaet bJ JPA eball aaaiat IPA La tlle vbiob allall be intacrated
praparatioa ot a aapoabulliveaau 1~17 1
b7 tba PIPe in tbl final draft fS Ooaati tutiDI tba tiul fl
311 feuibiUt7 ltucb lupport Aotivltiu
1111 DI-PS SMrdiesipe
fte nPa vill uiatala affeotive -ualoatioa ritlt DA ucl
MliDU tbroucllout tlle h - a Matll17 lllula bull At a aiaiaua
tloe will loold ooololJ -uaao Wilo A 1111 DU
cllaouaa probullrbullbullbullbull probl_ ud ~fflnlUea eaoouater
Vrittaa aiautaa of ubbull tiaaa vUl M -iataibullmiddot
na IPA vill clabullalop a c-tt7 lelatiou lupport Plaa
(CUPJ to acrlbe pultlio ralat1 aot1v1t1aa aatioipatecl
Tile- olooll -lop o CUP wlooeo obJeoUvbullduriac Ue n1bull to auura aa4 apao1f7 edlq1IampCI aupport r Ua tor
filiittaa oaitJ ralatiou aftorta of IPA a QDU
aupport will be at t o reqvaat ot ud MJ 1aolu4bull
- partloipatioa at public iaforatloul or teoluaioal
atia 1Dcluclibullbull provlcliaa vleual ai4a aacl equlpaeat
- publication ampDel COfJinl ot tact abaete or upclatee
aaaiatalloe in preparation of a raapoaahmiddotaaaaa euaaary-
after tba public rs middotbull-bullat period
All of tbo above activ1tiaa eball be proviclacl in the PRP1
CliP and ahaU be eubJact to revtov ucl approval ot EPA
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827
I I
~ I I
11
3 U l Qua 11$ Aeeuryge
u part of aa overall QveUtr uauruce Plan 11cb techn i cal report vUl be reviewed interullr to taiUII tbe lat11ri tJ of tte ooauau prior to auNi ttal to tbe IPA AIMliU vUl be oomluotecl br QA ataff to enaure that tbe QC fuaotion h beial oarrtH out
3 11 4 kpgr$ PrtMttUpp
tn addltioa to tbt reporu and work plua diacYa4 earlier aontbb pro1r111 reporta vUl be prepared br the PtP1 Tbeae reporu vUl taolucle at a ataiata tAe folloviDI tafo r bull -uoa
bull atatul of vorll at tlte eite ampn4 pro1r111 to elate
reeulta of pllAC teeta aacl all otller data reoehecl
aatidUbullbull plauecl for tbe aext aoatta
a u De1iYerablbullbull
Ia aooorclaaoe vltll Ute Adaiaiatrathmiddote Order U tile of Vorll cJle alaall aod autU tollowtac laquolteUYenltlea to tile DA IUd IQIDU tor rebull1bullbull aacl approYal
1 Draft Vorb 1 t flM1 Wrk bull1u a rlbUltF ltud7 fle111 11-au re 4 Tloal -middot--~amp1 --middot OIIJeothea a
--AoUou 1 IalUal loraw bullbull I TrbulltabUUJ ltud7Uot TooUaa Worb Uaa 1 Dnrt rolbUltF ltud7 bullbull I rlul reulbUUF ltud7 t tloatlltlr Teolulloal Pro1rbullbullbull leporta
au -Mubull fte nall abullalop a ault to UA a IIIDU a praaoll aolleclule for let1 tlle 14eat1UM culla 1a tile loope of Work fte aollwlbull 0amp11 H baaecl oa tae requlrat ~t tllte Draft feulbllUJ ltud7 be aulttoll to tllo UA a DU vltbla eL1kt (I) -tile of approval_ of tile final Work Plu
NOnCE ift~u--11 1111 cloar than thl1 DOVER MVNlCI PAL LANDFILLnotice tt 11 due to the A0Ml-IOiRA71VE RECORD
of the document
1-__bullbull_ ~~~~~~f-~IsectIW~1)( -~_aH~-=~oco --11~~~-- ---7
-~- bull
(
cr --- shy
middot I middot -- ~
~-
- barcode 558827
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 558827