geological t-l-i ternary system

2
GEOLOGICAL T-L-I Ternary System Outline The truth-lie-ignorance (T-L-I) system in geology ranges from orthotruth to metaignorance, as shown in the graph below and accompanying glossary. This epitruthful system is from GEOLOG, the newsletter of the Geological Association of Canada. Glossary ORTHOTRUTH - the real truth; withstands the most severe scrutiny. Rare in geology. PARATRUTH - usually quantitative, well documented coincidence of several lines of evidence, but based in part on a supposition which may, in the future, prove to be incorrect. it is usually confused by most with orthotruth. MONOTRUTH - a hypothesis or idea not seriously contested, at present, by others. EPITRUTH - one hypothesis or interpretation among several others. HEMITRUTH - a halftruth, shows only one side of the picture. NEOTRUTH - a paleotruth quickly redressed by using the fashionable recent rhetorics. PALEOTRUTH - an archaic truth proved to be no longer valid. Common with geologists whose knowledge has remained frozen since time of graduation METATRUTH - any higher order of truth knowingly metamorphosed to suit ones preconceived idea. COTRUTH - a truth based upon an evidence by comparison, when the standard is not commensurable with the compared subject. GEOLOGICAL T-L-I Ternary System file:///Volumes/Foraminifera/archive/General1/humor/geotruth/... 1 of 2 7/29/12 8:29 PM

Upload: baculites

Post on 18-Apr-2015

155 views

Category:

Documents


8 download

DESCRIPTION

This is the ternary diagram for truth, lie, and ignorance in the Earth sciences

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Geological T-L-I Ternary System

GEOLOGICAL T-L-I Ternary System OutlineThe truth-lie-ignorance (T-L-I) system in geology ranges from orthotruth to

metaignorance, as shown in the graph below and accompanying glossary. This epitruthfulsystem is from GEOLOG, the newsletter of the Geological Association of Canada.

Glossary

ORTHOTRUTH - the real truth; withstands the most severe scrutiny. Rare in geology.

PARATRUTH - usually quantitative, well documented coincidence of several lines of evidence,but based in part on a supposition which may, in the future, prove to be incorrect. it is usually confused by most with orthotruth.

MONOTRUTH - a hypothesis or idea not seriously contested, at present, by others.

EPITRUTH - one hypothesis or interpretation among several others.

HEMITRUTH - a halftruth, shows only one side of the picture.

NEOTRUTH - a paleotruth quickly redressed by using the fashionable recent rhetorics. PALEOTRUTH - an archaic truth proved to be no longer valid. Common with geologists whose knowledge has remained frozen since time of graduation

METATRUTH - any higher order of truth knowingly metamorphosed to suit ones preconceivedidea.

COTRUTH - a truth based upon an evidence by comparison, when the standard is not commensurable with the compared subject.

GEOLOGICAL T-L-I Ternary System file:///Volumes/Foraminifera/archive/General1/humor/geotruth/...

1 of 2 7/29/12 8:29 PM

Page 2: Geological T-L-I Ternary System

ORTHOLIE - (or PSEUDOTRUTH as used by gentlemen geologists and old-schoolJapanese): a straightforward lie. It is rare in western geology. It has appeared from time to timein dogmatic and totalitarian societies.

HEMILIE - lie with a great deal of uncertainty.

ORTHOIGNORANCE - (or "different Opinion" by gentlemen): the zero knowledge withoutsmokescreen.

EPI-IGNORANCE - the ignorant unaware (but the audience aware) of his ignorance

PROTOIGNORANCE - the ignorant aware of his ignorance but trying to make his listenersunaware.

METAIGNORANCE - Ignorance substituted by a piece of unrelated knowledge. it is common inexams By Paul V. HeinrichPreliminary Draft (unedited)Version 1.0 - July 17, 2000

http://www.intersurf.com/~heinrich/geotruth.html

E-Mail [email protected]

Return to Home Page.

GEOLOGICAL T-L-I Ternary System file:///Volumes/Foraminifera/archive/General1/humor/geotruth/...

2 of 2 7/29/12 8:29 PM