free press spring 2013 issue 2: privilege

Upload: uconnfreepress

Post on 03-Apr-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    1/28

    Spring 2013

    Issue 2: Privilege

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    2/28

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    3/28

    The people where I live

    are painted dark and bold.

    And sometimes though they are

    tinged with gold the darkness

    consumes their soul because they havebeen lled with years and years of need

    and want and of wants they believe they need

    but in reality its all a scheme

    to get them hWooked up and addicted

    to things they think are sweet

    but on the inside the things are rotten

    crawling with disease. And the truth is out there

    in caps and bold but theyre too often too busy

    holding hands up for handouts.Too busy looking for the next best thing instead of

    attempting to create it.

    But its a lifelong habit built or beat in by years

    and years of standardized tests and bubble sheets

    that by no means foster intelligence or individuality

    and by all means push uniformity and the idea that

    memorizing is ne if it gets you the 100 percent

    Even though next year youve forgotten 100 percent.

    And yeah its cold that the government has tuckedthe vast majority of us in a nice little fold labeled

    minority not because of color but due to wealth

    dont you be confused when I say the people where I live

    are painted dark;

    dark with ignorance but not necessarily stupidity.

    Painted Dark with defeat

    after countless failed attempts to break the cycle.

    Painted dark with failure

    that too many are too blind too see

    because they are consumed eyes covered by the newest Louis this

    or Prada that but at the end of the are left y

    souls painted dark. No gold.

    Still in societys nice minority fold.

    Painted Black

    - Nyanka

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    4/28

    I enter Bloomingdales. My outfit isnt unusual or dirty. I am clean and smell of

    dove soap. My sister and I walk the aisles looking for something fashionable

    to buy. We laugh, voices cracking like joy through thunderclouds. I can sense

    someone creeping behind us. I look back casually and see this woman in her

    Bloomingdales work clothes trailing behind us. Her eyes are sharp and her face

    is certain that we are up to no good. I know that face. It is the face that says

    I am not privileged enough to walk these aisles. It is the face that says I dont

    have the money, even though it weighs heavy in my tan purse over my shoulde

    to giggle through the aisles touching fabrics. It is the face Ive seen in countles

    stores, for countless years telling me that I dont have this privilege. But Ive

    learned to keep my cool. My sister and I continue caressing fabrics and crack-

    ing joy through thunderclouds. Weve never stolen anything and our shoulders

    support all the cash we need despite the color of our skin.

    Snapshots of BlThe best benet of privilege is not ha

    Young black and Hispanic men continued to be stopped in

    disproportionate numbers. They are only 4.7 percent of the citys

    population, yet these males, between the ages of 14 and 24,

    accounted for 41.6 percent of stops last year.

    (NY Times Injustices of Stop and Frisk May 13 2012).

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    5/28

    k Non-Privileges

    Nyanka

    to realize that you are blessed with it.

    In My younger and more vulnerable years my father gave me some

    advice that Ive been turning over in my mind ever since. Whenever

    you feel like criticizing any one, he told me, just remember that all

    the people in this world havent had the advantages that youve had.

    The Great Gatsby

    I am walking the streets of the inner city kid. It is 20 degrees. The boys of

    caramel and charcoal dont wear hoods on their heads. Most dont even wear

    hats or bubble coats. I remember hearing a mother scolding her son take your

    hood off.. you cant wear that hat.. it reminds us that we are cast into these

    roles. Teenage boys you are more likely to stopped by the police if you wear

    your hoody or wear certain hats. The weather does not dictate your attire socia

    standards do. If you want to stay out of trouble you will wear no hoodies andyou wont wear crip blues or blood reds. Your bubble jacket makes you a targe

    I am on the subway train. The train rattles my bones just as it rattles the bones

    of the old lady next to me. She smiles and I return her smile. Her pink painted

    lips have offered me a lifeboat in this box of uncertainty hurtling underground

    I am out of Brooklyn and though my attire is non-threatening the eyes of a

    select few bore at my black hair that isnt straight. It does not lay flat or tame. I

    is wild and maybe that is the reason for the skittery eyes that avoid my choco-

    late gaze. I believe Ive paid my $2.25 to be on this train.

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    6/28

    WHY ITS AWESOA LARGE PORTION OF OUR SOCIETY IS SIGNIFICANTLY MORE PRIVILEGED THAN THE REST.

    They have access to more opportunity than the rest of the population, and most ofthese people will not even admit it. I am, of course, talking about white people. Atrst,itmayseemawfultobewhite,sincewehavetowearsunscreeneverytimewe go outside, but I would argue the opposite. Its great to be white because our societywas set up FOR white people! We all have an inherent white privilege that makes our day-to-dayliveseasier,andmostofusstillndwaystocomplain.Insteadofcomplaining,weshould be aware of just how awesome our lives are.

    Now, I know youre thinking:

    Didnt Martin Luther King end racism fty years ago?

    I understand that this is a com-monly held belief, but this is just not thecase. There is still a large social gapbetween white people and minorities.For evidence of this, all we have to do islook at the source of power in theAmerican government: 43 out of 44U.S. Presidents have been white.

    White men essentially have adynasty on the executive chair. Its like

    if the Patriots won the Super Bowl everyyear for 237 years. Even if Obama is theman-in-charge now, its not like anyonesever taken a look at Congress and beenlike: Wow, what a diverse group of people.

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    7/28

    ME TO BE WHITESo if white people are practically locked into the most powerful parts

    of society, this is going to trickle down to the rest of us. Its kind of like the

    Reaganomics of Race. All authority is based on the traditional white role, andfor us white people, this is great. Whereas minorities generally have to bewaryoflawenforcement,wedonot.Policeofcershavebeenknowntoplantillegal substances on minorities to take advantage of them and arrest them. Ontheotherhand,whenthepolicendourdrugs,theyapologizeprofuselyfortheinconvenience and return everything. Sometimes they even throw in a freedimebag.

    You see, the whole legal system is geared towards whitepeople, not minorities. The law is a very malleable concept,especially in favor of those with paler skin. Basically, its cool to be

    white because the law actually applies to us when we need it, andit can be manipulated in our favor when we want. Minorities dontreally have this option, as the system is biased against them.

    Now most of you have probably heard this type of banter before, and itjust doesnt apply to you. After all, most people havent had an issue with thepolice or seen the inside of courtroom before. So youre wondering, How does

    beingwhiteREALLYbenetme?Wellforonething,awhitepersonneverhastofaceawkwardquestionslikeWhatethnicityareyou?orevenjustWhatareyou?Ifyoureaminoritylivinginawhite-dominatedsociety,theresboundtobe tons of cringeworthy encounters due to cultural differences. So if youre white,think about all these situations that youre avoiding. In other words, appreciatethe fact that you can openly listen to Macklemore and have no one judge you.

    And lastly, white people, be grateful for our whites-only dining hall underHorsebarn Hill. I know how we all complain how its so far away from campus, butthink about how good the food is compared to everywhere else. Theres nowhereelse in Storrs with a full sushi bar. And dont forget about Caviar Fridays! I mean,this is like the best privilege we have, and most of us dont take full advantage of

    it.NowdontworryaboutmepublicizingthisintheFreePress.Iknowitssup-posed to be a secret, but the minority community of UConn wont actually believeit; it sounds way too ridiculous. But think about it: why else would they have youputyourethnicityonyourapplication?

    - Scott

    ITS ACTUALLY ILLEGAL TO BE BLACK IN SIX STATES.[jk, but sometimes it seems like that]

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    8/28

    From early childhood, [we] are

    taught ambition. Drawing from par-

    ents repetitious advice, the lessons

    learnt in public (and private) class-

    rooms, and [our] own social growth,

    [we] are raised to economically com-

    pete. The degree to which one is an

    effective competitor, let alone whether

    this conditioning is effective, is en-

    tirely dependent on a wide range of

    socio-economic circumstances, that

    is the degree to which one is privi-

    leged. There are unavoidable material

    differences in the American population

    like race, gender, and especially eco-

    nomic class, and they cause problems.

    However, [our] old friend at the Free

    Press, the white male capitalist clich,

    is not solely responsible for all social

    strife and inequality. It is not only The

    Man that exploits this disenfranchised

    diversity; but it is also the foundation

    of the American dream - an easily di-

    gestible positive aspiration distorted

    into a promise that, when broken,creates millions of confused and bitter

    citizens that are subconsciously bent on

    [their] own self-destruction - under the

    impression that one may make it, or

    that one is inherently special. And so

    inequity persists.

    [These people] are the

    working-class tea party republicans

    that angrily shout, Get your govern-

    ment hands off my Medicare! be-

    cause their understanding of modern

    healthcare is less of an understanding

    and more of a chum bucket of talking

    points that is promptly dumped onto

    the head and into the mouth of any

    reasonable disagreement. But past

    the ideology and the stubbornness

    whether by a cruel twist of fate or

    by the invisible claw of GOP politi-

    cal strategy, these people have been

    mobilized against themselves, against

    their own (and most other civil)

    interest.

    [These people] are the seemingly

    indolent young men and women that

    champion an oppressive social

    hierarchy of superficiality. They are

    wearing, doing, and thinking on the

    subtle instruction of their parent com-panies and the overt dogma of their

    chapter predecessors. In this realm,

    differences and similarities solidify into

    identities and social life for the down-

    Give me a moment and a tear as I revisit the words of the dust bowl prophet, John Steinbeck:

    SOCIALISM NEVER TOOK ROOT IN AMERICA

    BECAUSE THE POOR SEE THEMSELVES NOT AS AN EXPLOITED

    PROLETARIAT BUT AS TEMPORARILY EMBARRASSED

    MILLIONAIRES

    THE MASSIVE MISCONCEPTIO

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    9/28

    trodden becomes an unwinnable game. It

    is a collective loss of goodwill-

    Subscribing to traditional notions of

    superiority comes with an intense social

    burden, regardless of whether your ego

    thinks you are an object of beauty or bad

    taste. The burden comes from the feeling,

    despite progressive logic and solidarity,

    that superficiality means nothing to the

    true human experience that a pound of

    makeup and some jungle juice is a

    terrible substitute for fifty milligrams of

    novocaine.

    The imperative of [our] situation isthat there is no other way for the elite to

    take advantage of the weakness of the

    general population than by the wide-

    spread subliminal suggestion of a selfish,

    narrow perspective. There is no overt rule

    by lawmakers, law enforcement, and their

    bankroll, as there has been in the recent

    past, as [I] have described before.

    [Our] Political reservations, [our] socialcowardice, and [our] minimization of

    egalitarian logic in favor of money, pow-

    er, or (imminent) instant gratification

    lead [us] down a slope slick with blood,

    gasoline, and gatorade perpetually

    Was a high wall there that tried to

    stop me

    A sign was painted said: Private Prop-

    erty,But on the back side it didnt say noth

    ing

    God blessed America for me.

    [This land was made for you and me.]

    When the sun come shining, then I wa

    strolling

    In wheat fields waving and dust clouds

    rolling;The voice was chanting as the fog was

    lifting:

    God blessed America for me.

    [This land was made for you and me.]

    One bright sunny morning in the shad

    ow of the steeple

    By the Relief Office I saw my people

    As they stood hungry, I stood there

    wondering if

    God blessed America for me.

    [This land was made for you and me.]

    OF THE MISANTHROPIC MASSES

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    10/28

    down, by the sheer force of gravity,

    and lending bright young minds of any

    denomination to hate their neighbor

    and love their feeding tubes; The teat

    tube, the [You]Tube[s], and the pneu-

    matic tubes that the monster of centralbureaucracy utilizes, with incredible

    efficiency, to give permission to the

    central bureaucracy to use pneumatic

    tubes.

    And without trying spoiling the

    meaning of [my] words; spoiler alert:

    [I] am utterly privileged. Many of [us],

    especially the people reading and writ-

    ing this [you] and [we] have grown

    up tall and strong by sucking down

    the artificial and subtle sustenance

    of oppression generated by privilege

    without any conscious notion of any-

    thing bad happening. Or maybe [we]

    do detect that something is wrong, but

    [we] dont know where to start count-

    ing it, let alone fighting or preventing.

    Good people at the top of societys

    web of oppression are now in the awk-

    ward position of constructing a viable

    privilege theory (see abbey volcanos

    privilege politics article below) with

    the responsibility to apply that theory

    in a reformist sense.

    To top all of this newfound re-

    sponsibility off, [we] have actual pre-

    dispositions towards privilege to main

    tain in the mean time [our] college

    careers and livelihood beyond while

    we try to figure out how to act right.[I] feel like a pretentious hypocrite in

    these moments of self-awareness.

    So, practically, what do [we] do?

    To spew some measured recipe for

    social justice would be difficult, and

    would fail to represent [our] point,

    which is

    collective, yet not at all contrary to the

    spirit of individual that lends itself to

    democracy. Like most aspects of

    leading a good life, the formula for

    justice is dependent on functional

    variables of positive will call it X or

    call it real civil rights and the exe-

    cution of that will by all that share it.

    Something that should be counted on

    is that [we] need to cut out the intel-

    lectual novocaine from [our] diet and

    let the disquieting compassion of activ

    ism hit [our] brains with the full force o

    CONSCIOUSNESS. This notion is a new

    political namaste of sorts a greetin

    representing a convergence of

    difference and rationality. Or to get as

    close to rationality as good humans ca

    possibly get.

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    11/28

    Intersectionality is the study of intersections between different group

    of minorities; specifically, the study of the interactions of multiple

    systems of oppression or discrimination. Intersectionality is a method-

    ology of studying the relationships among multiple dimensions and

    modalities of social relationships and subject formations. The theory

    suggestsand seeks to examine howvarious biological, social andcultural categories such as gender, race, class, ability, sexual orienta-

    tion, and other axes of identity interact on multiple and often simulta

    neous levels, contributing to systematic social inequality. Intersection

    ality holds that the classical conceptualizations of oppression within

    society, such as racism, sexism, homophobia, and religion- or be-

    lief-based bigotry, do not act independently of one another; instead,

    these forms of oppression interrelate, creating a system of oppressionthat reflects the intersection of multiple forms of discrimination.

    INTERSECTIONALITY

    quoted (with omissions) from wikipedia

    ONE BLOO

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    12/28

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    13/28

    In the United States of

    America today, there is no federal

    law that consistently protects

    individuals of the LGBT community

    from employment discrimination, let

    alone cultural discrimination. This

    information, provided by the Human

    Rights Campaign organization, also

    claries that there are only twenty

    states, as well as the District of

    Columbia, in the United States,

    that have recognition of same-sex

    partnerships and dependants. These

    statistics basically signify that

    individuals apart of the LGBT

    community are denied many of the

    rights and privileges that all Ameri-

    cans deserve. But aside from all the

    organizations and groups of people

    working towards equality in the

    United States, or all of those ragingagainst it, there remains to be an

    atmosphere of disparity amongst

    the privileges people are living with,

    because of their orientation. This

    disparity runs deeper than just one

    right or another. I mean dont get

    me wrong, marriage equality is a

    big deal, the right to employment

    without discrimination is a big deal,

    the right to love who you love is a big

    deal, but the disparity of privilege

    and security to just be who you are

    between those who are LGBT and

    those who are not, is grotesque.

    When I mention the word

    privilege, in terms of orientation

    equality, I am not just referring to the

    concept of relationships or partner-

    ships between genders; I am refer-

    ring to the basic lifestyles of people

    in the LGBT community everyday.

    When a heterosexual man or woman

    starts their day, they go to school, or

    go to work, and have the conforma-

    bility of doing their dailyactions without fear, without

    secrecy, and without caution,

    because they are who they are; they

    are the norm, they are individuals

    of heterosexuality, like most others,

    they live, they learn, they love. But

    for so many people of the LGBT

    community, in so many places of

    the world, they start their day, every

    day, with a caution to hide their

    true self, their true orientation. This

    doesnt just phase their sexual or

    relationship interests, it encroaches

    onto everything they do. I know what

    this is like, I am a homosexual man,

    and for almost 18 years of my life

    I lived under a cloak of falsehood

    in fear of judgment, discrimination,

    and shame. If I were walking in the

    hallways at school I would have to

    walk a certain way, out of fear: what

    if I walk too feminine, or too fast?

    They might think me to be gay! In

    gym class I was afraid of trying with

    sports because if I wasnt good

    enough I might be called gay or

    queer by the other guys. I was afraid

    of taking showers too long in themorning like my sister did, in case

    my father or brother thought me to

    be like a woman, hence gay

    Literally everything I did, my tone of

    voice, the way I wrote, they things

    I said in conversation with another

    person, the work I did in school, the

    job I had, the way I drove, the sports

    I played, the way I danced, the way

    I ate, the way I dressed, the way I

    looked, what I read, how I ran, who

    my friends were, what type of music

    I listened too, or even how much I

    displayed caring about any of these

    things to others, was constantly

    suppressed under a state of worry

    and stress in fear that I might be

    outed, for my entire life

    So before the day came when

    I summoned up the courage to just

    be happy with myself for who I was,

    against all the spite and wrath I was

    ready to receive from society, and

    come out, I was always in fear, I

    was always terried to access theprivileges of self security that I

    deserved, because of what others

    would think. All over the world, and

    in this very country, where we live as

    a community, there are still states

    where people of the LGBT

    community live in fear to be who they

    are every day, because of what the

    world might do to them, see them

    as, or judge them for, and its the

    most tragic thing Ive ever witnesse

    in my life. Regardless of orientation

    regardless of gender, and part-

    nerships; we are all people, every

    person is entitled to be who they ar

    every person is entitled to the basic

    human rights they were born with,

    to love who they love, and to love

    themselves without guilt or shame

    for existing.

    My name is Titus Abad. I am a

    gay man. I study Art & Human Right

    at UCONN. I am an individual, I am

    a citizen of the US, and I deserve al

    the same rights of a heterosexual i

    dividual, and vice versa. I deserve t

    live in peace; I deserve to feel secu

    and loved, as do we all,because we are all human beings.

    Now think what it would feel like to

    wake up every day, and be denied a

    of these privileges just because you

    orientation is not the same as

    everyone else, because of the way

    you were born. I was this person; I

    suffered as many others suffer in th

    scheme of society where inequality

    still exists. In our very country alone

    where we are rid of slavery, where

    we are unied, where we all have a

    cess to the rights of the constitutio

    there are still enormous amounts o

    people that are denied their basic

    life privileges to love. I am fortunate

    enough to have overcome the trials

    of an individual in the closet, and

    I will be a gay man for the rest of m

    life, but really, I am just a man, like

    other respectable men of this

    country that are free. Remember

    that your orientation gives you

    privilege, and that it shouldnt, and

    remember that your privilege shoulbe shared, so share it.

    ORIENTATION EQUALIT Y & PRIVILEG

    ART AND ARTICLE BY

    TITUS EZEKIEL ABAD(ASS)

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    14/28

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    15/28

    Privilege has turned out to bean elusive and fugitive subject.

    The pressure to avoid it is great,

    for in facing it I must give up

    the myth of meritocracy...

    ...If these things are true,

    this is not such a free country

    ones life is not what one makes

    it; many doors open for certain

    people through no virtues of

    their own.

    -Peggy McIntosh

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    16/28

    Many undergrads are introduced to the notion of

    privilege very early on. Often, as was my experience

    many moons ago, we are taught that privilege politics

    are uncontroversial when it comes to social justice.We are instructed to read Peggy McIntoshs Invisible

    Knapsack and we are taught that we all, in one way

    or another, have some sort of privilege that needs to

    be recognized and struggled againstwhite privilege,

    heterosexual privilege, male privilege, the list goes

    on. When we learn about intersectionality, we learn

    that oppressions, and therefore privileges, often

    overlap, and so we are afforded a somewhat more

    nuanced understanding of how power works and

    how privileges are created, used, and maintained,

    and the ways through which they might be destroyed.

    In the beginning we learn that privilege is often

    invisible to those who have it and that privilege can

    only exist if its exclusivemeaning for there to be

    privilege, some group or another is suffering because

    they lack that privilege. So we know that privilege is

    bad and that we need to struggle against the power

    structures that create privileges for some while oth-

    ers remain oppressed. Sounds pretty cut and dry.

    However, over the past year especially, many radicals

    have contributed critical analyses of privilege politics

    which need to be taken into account. Some of these

    critiques are imsy while others are spot-on and can

    help elucidate problems within privilege politics and

    offer better ways of conceptualizing power and

    structures of domination which can then, hopefully,

    help us gure out ways toward creating a more

    egalitarian, free, classless, and participatory society.

    Many of these critiques are quite lengthy, so Ill use

    the rest of this article to simply do an overview, as

    well as provide links for further reading.

    One of the rst pieces to come out in early 2012

    was guest post by Will on the Black Orchid Collectivewebsite. Will argues that privilege theory fails when

    put into practice within social movements. He claims,

    Privilege theorys main weakness are a tendency

    towards reformism, a lack of politics, and a politics of

    retreat. What he means by reformism in this regard

    is that privilege theory, for example, tells us that the

    most oppressed are at the most risk and so there-

    fore they should not be at the forefront of struggle

    because they have too much to lose. In turn, privi-

    lege theory is often used to justify less-oppressedpeople ghting on behalf of the oppressed since the

    can afford to get arrested without losing their home

    or being deported, for example. But it has been

    demonstrated, again and again, that the oppressed

    must take their struggles into their own hands, and

    the movements that succeed are the ones that do

    this. Reformism, by way of (some interpretations of)

    privilege theory, argues the opposite and turns the

    oppressed into helpless victims. In many ways, this

    peculiar situation reies white supremacy and othe

    structures of domination. By lack of politics, Will

    means that structures of power and domination areoften left unanalyzed while most effort is put into

    making sure that individuals somehow check their

    own privilege within social movements, thus depolit

    cizing these movements and turning

    revolutionary potential into individual attempts to

    check ones own privilege within personal settings

    Checking ones privilege is surely helpful and often

    appreciated, but the question remains as to what

    those attempts actually do to destroy current struc-

    tures of power and domination. Finally, Will argues

    that privilege theory is a politics of retreat because

    it thrives in depoliticized times when mass revolu-

    tionary movements are hard to nd. Again, Wills

    critiques of privilege theory come from his time spe

    organizing in mass movements which use privilege

    theory as a lter through which to make decisions

    and inform strategies and tactics. This argument is

    highly criticaland I think what we can learn from

    Will is a critique of how privilege theory plays out in

    mass movements rather than our debates about it

    our classrooms. There is no need to either fully agre

    or disagree with Will, but we should take his critique

    into account when we put theories of privilege intopractice.

    At the Bay of Rage website, CROATOAN critiques pr

    ilege theory because it tends to conceptualize white

    privilege, for example, as mainly a psychological

    problem created by the attitudes of individuals and

    SOME RECENT CRITIQUES OF PRIVILEGE POLITICSBY ABBEY VOLCANO

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    17/28

    that this view fails to address power and structures

    of domination in society, let alone change them.

    Many critiques of privilege theory argue against

    this very pointthe idea that privileges manifest in

    individual behaviors, which, in turn, require simply

    a change in such individual behaviors to eradicate

    complex structures of power such as white privilege,

    patriarchy, heterosexism, cissexism, ableism, etc.The critique here is that abolishing patriarchy, hetero-

    sexism, cisssexism, white supremacy, class society,

    etc., requires militant and radical social movements

    that will replace our old structures of oppression and

    domination with new structures which foster a

    classless, egalitarian, participatory, and, hopefully,

    a vastly less boring society. CROATOAN writes, We

    argue that prevailing discourses of personal privilege

    and political representation in fact minimize and

    misrepresent the severity and structural character of

    the violence and material deprivation marginalized

    demographics face. So not only do privilege politics

    miss the point, the politics, as they are deployed,

    actually set back militant class-struggle movements.

    Another critique of privilege politics is that they

    often fail to make sense of how capitalism, white

    supremacy, patriarchy, heteronormativity, etc., work

    together to maintain current power relationships

    and structures of domination in society. Rather,

    privilege politics have a strong tendency to isolate

    oppressions and their accompanying privileges. So,

    for example, there is both white privilege and maleprivilege. What does this mean for people who have

    one or the other? Both? Neither? How does this

    help us understand the intricate ways in which all

    hierarchies are woven together in society? Privilege

    politics are often based upon identity politics which,

    in many instances, fail to challenge power structures

    and instead rely on ghting against the laundry list

    of individual oppressions and the all too famous

    Oppression Olympics which grows out of these

    analyses. The critique is leveled that checking one

    privilege creates a situation where more authentic

    voices are made out of those suffering from the

    longest list of oppressionsagain, leading us back

    toward the Oppression Olympics, a game no one rea

    ly wins and one which is based on identity alone anlacking more nuanced analyses of power, capitalism

    the state, and the ways in which all hierarchies work

    together to maintain power-over. The critique isnt

    that identity isnt important or that the state and

    capitalism are more central to struggle, rather, the

    critique is that analyses of identity alone will not lea

    us toward struggles which can overturn all forms of

    hierarchy, oppression, and exploitation.

    But if privilege politics are a liberal fantasy as these

    critiques suggest, what are the alternatives? Which

    analyses can help us understand how domination,

    oppression, and exploitation manifest so we can de

    stroy such structures and create a better world with

    endless possibilities? How might we utilize theories

    of privilege in a revolutionary, rather than a liberal

    and coopted way? Or can we?

    Further reading:

    Be Careful With Each Other, So We Can Be Dangerous Together http://invisiblestrugglers.blogspot.com/2012/03/be-careful-with-each-other-so-w

    can-be.html

    Escalating Identity http://escalatingidentity.wordpress.com

    The Poverty of Privilege Politics http://shiftmag.co.uk/?p=679A Class Struggle Anarchist Analysis of Privi lege Theory from the Womens Caucus of AFed http://www.afed.org.uk/blog/state/327-a-class-strugg

    anarchist-analysis-of-privilege-theory--from-the-womens-caucus-.html

    http://www.cirtl.net/les/PartI_CreatingAwareness_WhitePrivilegeUnpackingtheInvisibleKnapsack.pdf

    http://blackorchidcollective.wordpress.com/2012/03/12/guest-post-privilege-politics/

    http://escalatingidentity.wordpress.com/2012/04/30/who-is-oakland-anti-oppression-politics-decolonization-and-the-state/

    See for example:

    http://www.academia.edu/2451610/Insurrection_at_the_Intersections_Feminism_Intersectionality_and_Anarchism

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    18/28

    I am American like I follow the 10 commandments-

    I mean, amendments.

    I am American like Bill of Rights-

    I mean, Bush of Wrongs.

    American like Freedom of Religion...

    including being atheist,

    Like sticking to your belief no matter how much people may say you need a

    particular god in your life

    or Jesus.

    I am American like freedom to profess

    Like freedom to profess my freedom to protest

    Like freedom to be stupid.American like British Child who threw tantrum and called it revolution;

    Ancestry forgotten.

    That explains our education.

    American like Occupy

    The I AINT MOVIN FO SHIT movement.

    American like American Pi,

    But not American like Pi

    Because we suck at mathematics.

    American like we translate freedom of speech to freedom to talk shit.

    American like wrote the second amendment

    HOLD UP, lets take a second,

    amend this.

    American like settling soldiers in the quarters of people without quarters.

    Like returning soldiers to their quarters

    But while they fight for a quarter for our freedom we put them in enough debt to

    return with no quarters.

    American like America, she has a cyst in her ovaries-

    I mean, Manifest Destinies

    Like destiny stretches across the Pacific to the middle east specifically

    Well assist the with an army to help you create diplomacy-

    I mean, democracy

    UN Diplomacy, UN Democracy

    Undiplomatic, undemocratic

    the irony.

    American like she cant have babies- I mean, countries of her own

    So she adapts them-

    I mean steals them

    American like Im Puerto Rican!

    So youre American.

    American like legal illegal search for and seizure of all that exists

    like Im a hypocrite, you're a colonist.

    American like the 99%

    Not the middle class

    Not the lower class

    The Upper Prison ClassAmerican like freedom to take your own freedom

    American like freedom to plead your guilt so the criminal can be the

    free one.

    American like right to a trial

    Like right to purchase.

    POP UP!

    You have the right to a 30 day free trial.

    American like no cruel punishment or torture

    Like cruel punishment being apart of a country that has so much

    but does nothing with it;

    So essentially cruel punishment and torture is

    being American.

    American like protect that not mentioned

    I am American like power t o the people

    Who are rich

    And want to pay less in taxation

    I am American like Bush of Wrongs

    I mean Bill of RightsAmerican like Political Parties

    American like ~I like to party~

    Political Party, ~I like to party~

    Same difference:

    You blow cash you dont have,

    think youre a celebrity,

    act like a fool.

    Fool like an American

    Who obeys the 10 amendments-

    I mean, commandments.

    By Sabir Askari Abdussabur

    I can taste the salty tidal wave of sweat cascading down my fa

    I can feel my lungs cringe at every exhalation

    Stillness has become an impossibility

    I am a lone rabbit caught silfaying at high noon

    My speed is my only ticket to salvation

    And its soon to expire

    I kick loose gravel into my wake

    Counting down the miles, the yards, the steps

    Past each onlooker eight dozen heartbeats behind

    Towards the spandex banner at the bottom of a blessed slope

    My throat cries at its transformation into sandpaper

    And every glance at my two ton wristwatch pushes me on

    I am at the top of hill overlooking the Promised Land

    My dash becomes flight as the ground waits beneath me

    I cross the final barrier and fall into a mangled heap

    I turn in a flurry of cotton as my nerves jump alive

    I seek traction in the grass

    But it too quickly turns to dirt

    Then to root

    Then to stone

    Then to grass again

    My legs relentless in their efforts to uncoil my jeans

    My eyes frantic to recognize solid black from transparent blac

    My brain trying to remember where my one acre of safety lies

    And just how far I was dumb enough to wander from it

    I had stared into the eyes of the wolf

    He showed me jaws of sawed off lead

    My fight becomes flight as I look to the ground to carry me

    I find a familiar patch of woods which I know lies behind the

    Promised Land

    I cross the final barrier and collapse into a mangled heap

    - Brendan Field

    BOLT10 COMMENDMENTS

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    19/28

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    20/28

    Our 43rd President, the leader of the free world for 8 years:

    December, 1966: Bush, after having a few beers, stole a Christmas wreath from a hotel in New Haven,

    Connecticut. Arrested for disorderly conduct.

    1967: Bush is arrested for disorderly conduct when he storms onto the Princeton University football field

    climbs onto the field goal crossbar, and tries to break off a piece as a souvenir.

    November 8, 1967: Bush defends the use of a red-hot coat hanger to brand pledges in The New York

    Times, claiming it is defensible because the resulting wound is equivalent to only a cigarette burn. Be-

    fore branding pledges, Bush would show them a full-sized branding iron to frighten them. His fraternity

    fined $1000.

    Late 1960s: After gaining entrance as a legacy student, Bush maintains a low C average at Yale, the ba

    minimum to graduate. In his freshman year, he was in the 21st percentile of his class. While at Yale, sayshe cannot wait to leave the school, and hates its intellectual snobbery.

    Late 1960s: Bush admonishes a Yale schoolmate for admitting plans to avoid serving in Vietnam; calls hi

    irresponsible.

    May 27, 1968: 12 days before his student deferment expires, George W. Bush applies to join the Texas

    National Guard. Despite a waiting list of 18 months, Bush is signed in the same day. Bush is assigned to a

    celebrity sons unit, with sons of two other senators (Bentsen and Towers), sons of oil magnates, and 7 son

    of Dallas Cowboys players. He was assigned to pilot duty despite a 25% score (lowest possible for duty),

    and was commissioned to 2nd Lt. despite lack of qualifications or passage through Officer CandidateSchool. Is trained to fly an F-102, which is being phased out, guaranteed to never be called into duty in

    Vietnam.

    1973: Bush applies for entrance into University of Texas law school, and is rejected. Harvard Business

    School apparently had lower standards than UT, as it accepted Bush. Bush graduates from Harvard with

    an MBA in 1975.

    September 4, 1976, a state trooper saw Bushs car swerve onto the shoulder, then back onto the road.

    Bush failed a road sobriety test and blew a .10 blood alcohol, plead guilty, and was fined and had his driv

    ers license suspended. Bush had several beers at a local bar before the arrest. His underage sister was

    the car when he was driving drunk.

    Bush got a court hearing to get his driving suspension lifted early, even though he had not completed a

    required driver rehabilitation course. He told the hearings officer that he drank only once a month, and

    just had an occasional beer. The officer granted his request. But Bush continued drinking for 8 years

    after that date and has said publicly that he drank too much and had a drinking problem during that time

    Directly quoted from http://www.blogd.com/bushrecord.html

    GWB - Great to Be White

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    21/28

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    22/28

    And so my writings lled with scorn and menace and complete condence in the demise of humani

    came to an end. Because I realized I could not make statements about what I could not dene. Humanity. O

    maybe what has so strongly, and so falsely, been dened and dictated to us. There is little spark to be foun

    in a people who have been told it is hopeless. Its interesting to observe, the ones on top, the ones with

    freedom, theyre lled with hopelessness. You go to the smallest, brownest village you can nd. You feel the

    hope, the love, the embrace. They arent perfect but they are certainly closer to humanity.

    Humanity is egalitarian. It is a noun, for sure, but it is also an expression and an ideal. It is a verb.

    Humanity is an action. Compare the connotations between Humanity and Human nature. Which overows

    with brilliant light; which uplifts and soars and insists on bringing you along? Two men stand, arms inter-

    twined and blood owing between bodies. They want life. It is theirs. We see this as human nature.

    Demographics are restrictive, if you think about it. We study the people who ght for marriage equa

    ity and afrmative action and abortion and say, dont they know its all the same ght? Join together! Demo

    graphics are oppressive. Dont we know we are the same people? We are so close to the chimpanzee. We

    are so much closer to each other.

    Of course there is culture and tradition. But culture is proud and alive and vibrant. We can love and

    embrace and hold our culture! We can open ourselves to yours. Demographics are dead. I am a politician

    now. I cannot open myself to the black vote. I will never be black. I will never have an abortion. All I can do

    talk, release campaign ads.

    I have the image of a dominant human this whiteness, and male-ness. Its a powerful tool to have

    and a great challenge. It is powerful because I can tell other dominant humans, you are not what you think

    you are. I am not going to be what you want me to be. Powerful because I can say, you dont understand, b

    you will watch me. They will watch me, because their human nature requires it. Like a missile locking on to

    target. I am followed.

    It is challenging because I must prove myself to every person I meet in every place I go. My words w

    be tuned out, useless, full of privilege and oppression, until my actions say otherwise. This is true humani-

    ty the embrace of self and lack of self; of identity and lack of identity. A mutual understanding: we dont

    really know. And something comes between us, recognizable yet undened. I know some day we will reclai

    that term, human nature. For now I must reject it, I must embrace our humanity.

    MUSINGS FROM A DOMINANT MIN

    - WESLEY NICHOLS

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    23/28

    Privilege is a weird animalIn no way is this more real to me than right now

    I try to stare out the train window, and look less lostLost as in spiritually lost?No, lost as in lost lost.

    Te train head-honcho decided to inorm me o this with a priceless sense o,Call it bravado

    Im rom connect-icut, the burbs, the sae place to raise your kidsAnd obviously this guy can smell it on me, or something

    Express to Grand Central, get o there, not hereoutstanding

    Its not like I havent been to New York beoreI was only going 20 minutes outside the city anyway

    However still, Im kind o lostLost as in existentially lost?

    No, lost as in complete moron lostTis train is packed

    I nd mysel arguing, with myselDo I think that because Im not used to it?

    I never ride trains, Im rom the burbs remember?Is it rude to think that this is crowded?Tis train is, like, ridiculously diverse

    New colors and sounds food my inexperienced senses

    A woman speaks happily in a Jamaican accentBouncing a small baby on her lap, rattling o about her other grandchildren

    Tis is beautiulKind o like the woman sitting across rom me

    Presumably an educated 20-somethingShes been reading the entire time

    I drop something and she looks up, nallyNow Im denitely being rude

    A man comes across cars and bursts through the back doorImmediately.Im in a staring contest

    Hes huge, with tattoos all over his armsHat to the side, wie beater

    And a stare that could scare any white-kid rap an out o the genreTis is lasting way longer than I anticipated

    Alright, too much intimidationOur contest is ended, when his curious son comes running up

    Remember what I said about eeling rude beore?yup

    We hit Harlem and 125th, the guy gives one last look, and they leaveI ask mysel the ever-important question,

    Who the hell am I?A ew stops later Im hal on the platormHal still stuck in the previous 20 minutes

    I imagined mysel as a walking,Tats why you dont talk to strangers advertisement

    How the hell did I get stuck on that train?Was it a sign?

    Was I due to reak out?I think about how many mornings I had an eect on

    How many people the dumb kid on the train disruptedOh wait, its the city and no one cares

    But still, why did having no control terriy me?

    Is it because o what I look like?I run through socio-economic acts

    Eugenic ctionAnything that my mind can conjure up about the history o race relations

    Ten I stop; Ive been overthinking, I know I haveIt hits meit is My privilege

    My white, rom the burbs privilege,Tat is to blame or the naivety and ear

    My conclusion is discouragingBut at least I realize my context,

    Eagerly anticipating a new train to study

    From Where I Was

    Alex Fontai

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    24/28

    Privilege Without Purpose

    I consider myself one of the most privileged people in the world.

    This issue is not intended to make you feel guilty. Sometimes you have to look at what you have and be appre

    tive. Take a good long look at what you have and give back to those less fortunate. While some view charities

    a way for the upper class to feel better about themselves, doing good should be its own reward. There will alw

    be somebody worse off than you. You may never meet them but he or she is out there. Everybody in the wor

    has the moral obligation to help one another and make the world a little bit better. I may live in a very

    idealist mindset, but there is nothing wrong with trying to make the world a safer, more caring place for everyo

    B. Caws

    I do not drive a Lamborghini. Nor do I have the newest pair of Air Jordans. Ialso dont have a high paying executive job waiting for me once I graduate. I

    do, however, come from a loving home where my parents are still married and,

    although they may have left home, none of the siblings have abandoned the

    family. Growing up, I always had a roof over my head and food in my stomach;

    which is a lot more than some people have. I am going to graduate in May and

    unlike many, I will not be upwards of $25,000 in debt. My parents have paid

    for my college experience; a favor I intend on repaying to my kids. I am com-

    pletely aware of how well off I am compared to hundreds of millions of people

    around the world.

    Privilege is a matter of perspective. While we may think of privilege as

    coming from a certain town or having a lot of money in the bank, every-

    body reading this is privileged. You live in a country that allows you to

    think, speak and publish (looking at this magazine) whatever you want.

    You go to one of the best colleges in the country and have access to

    eight dining halls! Elsewhere in the world, people struggle to nd clean

    water to drink. Every night you have a warm bed to sleep in, inside a

    building where people care what happens to you, whether it is a dorm

    hall, a frat house or your parents house.

    Being born with a silver spoon doesnt classify you as a person. Youare how you treat other people. Being born on either side of the spec-

    trum doesnt automatically make you a snob or a savage. Words like

    that dont describe who you are and shouldnt be used to describe

    anyone. They are anony-miscers. They allow small minded people to

    classify you as something rather than seeing you for what you really

    are: a human being. Where we come from should have no effect on

    how we view other people; but it does. We should see each other as

    people not members of social classes.

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    25/28

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    26/28

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    27/28

    Wed Like to Thank the

    Academy,[okay, not really, but heres a list of people who worked on this]

    Da

    niell

    e(centerfold)

    Ransom(pages 15,16, 18, 21, 22, 26)

    [you]

    Josh

    (cov

    er)

    Nyanka

    Sydney Rosendale (page 1)

    Scott

    OneBlood

    B. Caws

    Kasia

    (pages 24,25)

    Hay

    -Tay

    pg20

    Samm

    Abbey

    Volca

    no

    Alex Fontaine

    Titus Ezekiel Abad(ass)

    NABID

    KatieH

    ir

    Brend

    anField

  • 7/29/2019 Free Press Spring 2013 Issue 2: Privilege

    28/28

    Back Cover - Josh