f-3, midc area, andheri (e ast), mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/pa_defects_sep2014.pdf ·...

16
Baart sarkar Government of India kond`Iya ivaVut p`aiQakrNa Central Electricity Authority piScama xao~Iya ivaVut saimait Western Regional Power Committee ef -3, emaAayaDIsaI xao~, AMQaorI (pUva- ), mau Mba[- - 400 093 F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (East), Mumbai - 400 093 Aa[- esa Aao : 9001-2008 IS/ISO: 9001-2008 dUrBaaYa Phone: 022- 28209506, 28200195; 28200196; fO@sa Fax : 022 28370193 Website : www.wrpc.gov.in E-mail : [email protected] [email protected] NO. WRPC/Protection/PA/2014/1849 Date: 03.12.2014 To The Secretary, CERC, 4 th Floor, Chanderlok Complex, 36, Janpath, New Delhi 110001. Sub: Compliance Status of protection audit of Western Region for the quarter ending on 30.09.2014 Reg. Sir / Madam, Please find enclosed herewith the compliance status of protection audit carried out by utilities (Maharashtra as on 30.09.2014, Chhattisgarh as on 30.06.2014 and Madhya Pradesh as on 13.08.2014) in Western Region as on 30.09.2014, as per Hon’ble Commission’s order dated 05.03.2014 in petition no. 220/MP/2012. Gujarat intimated vide email that all deficiencies of category ‘Ahave been attended and there were no deficiencies of category ‘B’. Thanking you, Yoursfaithfully, Sd/- Satyanarayan. S, Member Secretary (I/c), WRPC. CC: 1. COO, CTU, PGCIL, Saudamini, Plot No. 2, Sector - 29, Gurgaon 122001.

Upload: duongnhan

Post on 05-May-2018

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

Baart sarkarGovernment of Indiakond`Iya ivaVut p`aiQakrNa

Central Electricity AuthoritypiScama xao~Iya ivaVut saimait

Western Regional Power Committeeef -3, emaAayaDIsaI xao~, AMQaorI (pUva-), mauMba[- - 400 093

F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (East), Mumbai - 400 093

Aa[- esa Aao : 9001-2008IS/ISO: 9001-2008

dUrBaaYa Phone: 022- 28209506, 28200195; 28200196; fO@sa Fax : 022 – 28370193Website : www.wrpc.gov.in E-mail : [email protected] [email protected]

NO. WRPC/Protection/PA/2014/1849 Date: 03.12.2014

To

The Secretary,

CERC, 4th Floor, Chanderlok Complex, 36,

Janpath, New Delhi 110001.

Sub: Compliance Status of protection audit of Western Region for the quarter ending on 30.09.2014 –

Reg.

Sir / Madam,

Please find enclosed herewith the compliance status of protection audit carried out by

utilities (Maharashtra as on 30.09.2014, Chhattisgarh as on 30.06.2014 and Madhya Pradesh

as on 13.08.2014) in Western Region as on 30.09.2014, as per Hon’ble Commission’s order

dated 05.03.2014 in petition no. 220/MP/2012.

Gujarat intimated vide email that all deficiencies of category ‘A’ have been attended and

there were no deficiencies of category ‘B’.

Thankingyou,Yours’ faithfully,

Sd/-Satyanarayan. S,

Member Secretary (I/c), WRPC.

CC:1. COO, CTU, PGCIL, Saudamini, Plot No. 2, Sector - 29, Gurgaon – 122001.

Page 2: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

Yes/

No

Whether

attended

Yes/No

If not

attended,

reason

Yes/

No

Whether

attended

Yes/No

If no, expected

date to attend

1 NAGOTHANE 400

At present only one 220 Volt DC Source

is in service / used instead of both 220V

DC source, even through the two DC

source are available.

Yes Yes Completed.

2 VASAI 220

The 220kV TBC bay is not taken into

service since commissioning due to

defective REC 670 relay.

Yes Yes

TBC is taken in service

on dt. 05.08.14.

Completed.

3 VASAI 220

The ABB make SCADA is in service with

standby PC not in working condition. The

GPS & SCADA timing is not matching

due to problem in GPS clock & system.

Yes No

4 VASAI 220TF LV side data is not available at SCADA

due to communication failure problems.Yes No

5 VASAI 220The 100kV Busbar protection scheme is

not in service.Yes No

Work is in progress &

will be completed by

March 2015.

6 TROMBAY 220

The ER make SMS is not in working

condition. UPS is not working. Two TF

bays & 220kV newly commissioned

Reliance bays are not intgrated with SMS

system.

Yes YesThe existing ER make

SMS is in put in service.

7 Wardha 220Faulty Annuciators shall be replaced

immediatelyYes No 31.08.14

Replaced on dt.

15.09.2014

ABB representative

visited site on

23/07/2014 & in co-

ordination with M/s

ABB work will be

completed by Dec.-

2014.

Present Status of Protection Audit Deficiencies (A & B type) in MSETCL for the year 2012-13 as on 30/09/2014

Sr.

No.

Name of S/s

identified for

Protection Audit

S/s

voltage

(kV)

Observations of protection Audit

Deficiencies that can be

corrected without

procurement (Category-A)

Deficiencies involving

procurement (Category-B) Present Status as on

30/09/2014

Page 3: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

Yes/

No

Whether

attended

Yes/No

If not

attended,

reason

Yes/

No

Whether

attended

Yes/No

If no, expected

date to attend

Sr.

No.

Name of S/s

identified for

Protection Audit

S/s

voltage

(kV)

Observations of protection Audit

Deficiencies that can be

corrected without

procurement (Category-A)

Deficiencies involving

procurement (Category-B) Present Status as on

30/09/2014

8 Wardha 220Diagnostic Testing progress needs to be

accelerated.Yes Yes - 100% completed

9 Umred 220Diagnostic Testing progress needs to be

accelerated. Yes Yes 100% completed

10MIDC

Chandrapur 220

Diagnostic Testing progress needs to be

accelerated. Yes Yes 100% Completed

11 Hinganghat 220Diagnostic Testing progress needs to be

accelerated.Yes Yes 100% Completed

12 Hinganghat 220

The annunciator of 220kV TSS-I &

Warora are out of service which need to

be replaced immediately.

Yes No 30.09.14Replaced on dt.

09.08.2014

13 Warora 220

The annunciator of 220kV Chandrapur-I

feeder is faulty which needs to be

replaced immediately.

Yes YesReplaced on dt.

12.08.2014

14 Warora 220The Differntial relay of 220/33kV 50MVA

T/F-II shall be replacedYes No 31.08.14

Replaced on dt.

16.09.2013

15 Khaperkheda 400

The time synchronization, GPS receiver

display problem, DR monitor problem

shall be resolved by concerned Engineer.

Yes Yes - - -Attended except time

synchronisaztion

16 Khaperkheda 400 The NDR relay shall be replaced Yes No 31.08.14Replaced on dtd.

07.06.2014

17 Koradi 400 The NDR relay shall be replaced Yes No 31.07.14Replaced on dtd.

11.06.2014

18 Deepnagar GCR 220 LBB scheme is not in service Yes No 31.12.14 work is in progress

19 Girwali 400400kV PGCIL CKT I & II -

Broken Conductor Detection is off.Yes No Pertains to PGCIL

Page 4: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

Yes/

No

Whether

attended

Yes/No

If not

attended,

reason

Yes/

No

Whether

attended

Yes/No

If no, expected

date to attend

Sr.

No.

Name of S/s

identified for

Protection Audit

S/s

voltage

(kV)

Observations of protection Audit

Deficiencies that can be

corrected without

procurement (Category-A)

Deficiencies involving

procurement (Category-B) Present Status as on

30/09/2014

20 Girwali 400400kV PGCIL CKT I & II - ZONE 3 &

ZONE 4 trip time is same to 1S .Yes No Pertains to PGCIL

21 Akola 220Busbar scheme for 132kV bus is not

providedNo -- -- Yes No -- Pl. ref. **

Note: ** Tender has been finalizaed for procurement of 76 Nos. of Busbar protection schemes at various EHV substations in MSETCL. Busbar

Protection schemes will be tentatively receved at site by 31/03/2015 & commissioning works will be taken up thereafter.

Page 5: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

Sr.

No.

Name of S/s

identified for

Protection Audit

S/s

voltage

(kV)

Observations of protection AuditExpected date to

attend Present Status as on 30/09/2014

1 PADGHE 400

Commissioning of 2 Nosof 220kV Hybrid PASS (GIS

Bus-sectionalizer) at Padghe alongwith additional

220kV TBC, 2 sets of PTs & shifting of 220kV side

bay of ICT3 & strenthening of 400kV & 220kV Bus

Within 1 Year (After

receipt of material

at site)

work is in progress.

2 PADGHE 400Replacement of 220kV & 100kV static Busbar

schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes.

Within 1 Year (After

receipt of material

at site)

Existing schemes are in service. However,

replacement by Numerical scheme is

planned. Pl. ref. **

3 BOISAR 220Replacement of 132kV Busbar protection schemes

by Numerical Busbar schemes.

Existing scheme is in service. However,

replacement by Numerical scheme is

planned. Pl. ref. **

4 KALWA 400Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection

schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes

Existing scheme is in service. However,

replacement by Numerical scheme is

planned. Pl. ref. **

5 KALWA 400Shifting of 500 MVA, 400/220kV ICT 1 from 400kV

Kalwa II ss to 220kV Kalwa I ss Completed.

6 URAN 220 All 220kV Control panels needs to be replaced.

The Control panels are very old & need

replacement. The scheme is being prepared

by field office. However, as existing panels

are in service, there is no urgency & will be

replaced in a phased manner.

7 APTA 220Replacement of 100kV Busbar protection schemes

by Numerical Busbar schemes.

Existing scheme is in service. However,

replacement by Numerical scheme is

planned. Pl. ref. **

Present Status of other issues identified during Protection Audit for system improvement in MSETCL for the year 2012-13

as on 30/09/2014

Page 6: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

Sr.

No.

Name of S/s

identified for

Protection Audit

S/s

voltage

(kV)

Observations of protection AuditExpected date to

attend Present Status as on 30/09/2014

8 APTA 220The C & R panels needs replacement with new

Control Room.

The C & R panels are very old & need

replacement. The scheme is being prepared

by field office. However, as existing panels

are in service, there is no urgency & will be

replaced in a phased manner.

9 KANDALGAON 220Replacement of 220kV Busbar protection schemes

by Numerical Busbar schemes.

Existing scheme is in service. However,

replacement by Numerical scheme is

planned. Pl. ref. **

10 KANDALGAON 220Replacement of 100kV C & R panels, also

replacement of TF C &R panels. Completed.

11 KANDALGAON 220Making LILO of 220kV Nagothane - Mahad line at

Kandalgaon.

The work is under progress & expected to

be completed by Dec. 2014.

12 NAGOTHANE 400Replacement of 400kV & 220kV Busbar protection

schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes.

Existing schemes are in service. However,

replacement by Numerical scheme is

planned. Pl. ref. **

13 KHARGHAR 400Replacement of 400kV & 220kV Busbar protection

schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes.

Existing schemes are in service. However,

replacement by Numerical scheme is

planned. Pl. ref. **

14 TROMBAY 220

The work of shifting of 220kV C & R panels from old

CR to newly constructed CR by REL is to be taken on

priority.

Order is placed & work will be completed

by March 2015.

15 Kaulewada 220

Internal module problems in the exisitng Busbar

scheme (ALSTOM-PBLSB). The scheme is

maloperated in the past hence needs to be replaced.

Existing scheme is in service. However,

replacement by Numerical scheme is

planned. Pl. ref. **

16 Bhandara 220

The exisitng Busbar scheme (ABB-RADSS) has

maloperated in the past due to RQDA module

problem and hence needs to be replaced.

Existing scheme is in service. However,

replacement by Numerical scheme is

planned. Pl. ref. **

17 Kanhan 220 48V DC battery set must be replaced immediately 30.09.14

Replacement planed. However, in the mean

time set reconditioned between 25.03.2014

to 31.03.2014

Page 7: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

Sr.

No.

Name of S/s

identified for

Protection Audit

S/s

voltage

(kV)

Observations of protection AuditExpected date to

attend Present Status as on 30/09/2014

18 Ambazari 220The deffective 220V DC battery sets shall be

replaced 31.12.14

19 Ambazari 22048V DC set no:-1 efficiency observed as 60%. Battery

set needs replacement.31.12.14

20 Ambazari 220

The exisitng Busbar scheme (ABB-RADSS) has

maloperated in the past due to RQDA module

problem and hence needs to be replaced.

Existing scheme is in service. However,

replacement by Numerical scheme is

planned. Pl. ref. **

21 Khaperkheda 220

The exisitng Busbar scheme (ABB-RADSS) has

maloperated in the past due to RQDA module

problem and hence needs to be replaced.

Existing scheme is in service. However,

replacement by Numerical scheme is

planned. Pl. ref. **

22 Butibori-I 220

The exisitng Busbar scheme (ABB-RADSS) has

maloperated in the past due to RQDA module

problem and hence needs to be replaced.

Existing scheme is in service. However,

replacement by Numerical scheme is

planned. Pl. ref. **

23 Khadka 400Electromechanical Relays of ICT to be replaced by

numerical one31.03.15 Tender finalised & LOA issued.

24 Chalisgaon 220Electromechanical Relays of ICT to be replaced by

numerical one. 31.03.15 Tender finalised & LOA issued.

25 BBLR 40002 number of Distance Protection scheme to be

commissioned

Will be done in

next immediate

outage

Non-availability of outage is major

constraint. Relays are available

26 Waghala 220 Line B/U electromechanical relays - 10 31.03.15 Order for retrofit of Back up relays is issued.

27 Akola 220Followg relays are non numerical: *Dist relays (132kV

feeders)- 5 nos. *B/U relays-5 nos *Diffl relays-3 nos. --

> Disatnce Relay received and configured

but pending for company representative/

engineer. The same are being retroffited by

Nov. 2014.

> Order placed by C.O. for Back up &

Differential relays and are yet to be received

at store. Works expected to be completed

by 31.03.15.

Page 8: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

Sr.

No.

Name of S/s

identified for

Protection Audit

S/s

voltage

(kV)

Observations of protection AuditExpected date to

attend Present Status as on 30/09/2014

28 Amravati 220

Followg relays are non numerical:

*Dist relays- 2 nos.

*B/U relays- 4 nos

*Diffl relays-3 nos.

31.03.2015

> Distance Relay retrofitted

>Order placed by C.O. for Back up &

Differential relays and are yet to be received

at store. Works expected to be completed

by 31.03.15.

29 Badnera 220

Followg relays are non numerical:

*Dist relays- 2 nos.

*B/U relays- 2 nos

31.03.2015

> Distance Relay retrofitted.

>Order placed by C.O. for Back up relays

and are yet to be received at store. Works

expected to be completed by 31.03.15.

Note: ** Tender has been finalizaed for procurement of 76 Nos. of Busbar protection schemes at various EHV substations in MSETCL. Busbar

Protection schemes will be tentatively receved at site by 31/03/2015 & commissioning works will be taken up thereafter.

Page 9: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

Remarks

Yes /No

WhetherattendedYes/No

If notattended,reason

Yes / NoWhetherattendedYes/No

If no,expecteddate toattend

Khedamara 400/ 220Main-II protection of 220 KVBRSS-I&II,220 KV Urla & 220 KV PGCIL feedersnot available.

Yes No Estimate submitted

Bemetara 220/ 132

1. Carrier protection is not available.2. 2nd DC battery set is not available.3. GPS time synchronizing facility is notavailable.4. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

Gurur 220/ 1321. Carrier protection is not available..2. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

Sohela 220/ 132

1. Carrier protection is not available..2. GPS time synchronizing facility is notavailable.3. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

Bhatapara 220/ 132

1. Carrier protection is not available..2. 2nd DC battery set is not available.3. GPS time synchronizing facility is notavailable.4. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.6. LBB protection not available.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

Mopka 220/ 132

1. Carrier protection is not available..2. 2nd DC battery set is not available.3. GPS time synchronizing facility is notavailable.4. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.6. LBB protection not available.7. Synchronization trolly not available.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

PROTECTION AUDIT DEFFICIENCIES/OBSERVATIONS COMPLIANCE [As on 30.06.2014]

Name of S/Sidentified for

protection audit

S/S voltage(kV)

Observations of protection audit

Deficiencies that can be correctedwithout procurement (Category-

A)

Deficiencies involving procurement(Category-B)

Page 10: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

Banari 220/ 132

1. Carrier protection is not available..2. 2nd DC battery set is not available.3. GPS time synchronizing facility is notavailable.4. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.6. LBB protection not available.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

Siltara 220/ 132

1. Carrier protection is not available..2. 2nd DC battery set is not available.3. GPS time synchronizing facility is notavailable.4. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.6. LBB protection not available.7. Synchronization trolly not available.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

Doma, Raipur 220/132

1. Carrier protection is not available..2. 2nd DC battery set is not available.3. GPS time synchronizing facility is notavailable.4. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

Paraswani 220/132

1. Carrier protection is not available..2. 2nd DC battery set is not available.3. GPS time synchronizing facility is notavailable.4. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.

- Yes No 14.08.14

Urla 220/ 132

1. Carrier protection is not available..2. 2nd DC battery set is not available.3. GPS time synchronizing facility is notavailable.4. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.6. LBB protection not available.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

Thelkadih 220/132

1. Carrier protection is not available..2. 2nd DC battery set is not available.3. GPS time synchronizing facility is notavailable.4. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

Barsoor 220/132

1. Carrier protection is not available..2. 2nd DC battery set is not available.3. GPS time synchronizing facility is notavailable.4. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.6. LBB protection not available.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

Page 11: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

Bhilai 220/132

1. Carrier protection is not available.2. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.4. LBB protection not available.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

Kotmikala 220/ 132

1. Carrier protection is not available..2. 2nd DC battery set is not available.3. GPS time synchronizing facility is notavailable.4. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.6. LBB protection not available.7. Synchronization trolly not available.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

Raigarh 220/ 132

1. Carrier protection is not available..2. 2nd DC battery set is not available.3. GPS time synchronizing facility is notavailable.4. M II protection for 220 KV feeder notavailable.6. LBB protection not available.7. Synchronization trolly not available.

- Yes No 14.08.14 -

1. Separate two sets DC system isrecommended for switchyard protection

No YesEstimate and Requisition forseparate DC source has been sendfor approval.

2. Carrier Protection is out of service. Yes

Yes, for220 kVKorba East-West I/CNo. I&II

Restfeeder'scarrier prot.ckt will bechecked

In E-W I/C No. I & II Carrierprotection checked & taken inservice.

3. Disturbance Recorder and SERs are notavailable.

Yes Estimate processed for approval.

4. Old THR make Static DPR relays needsto be replaced by numerical relays

Yes NA NA Tender to be opened on 13.08.2014

5. Auto re-closer is not available. Yes Nockt will bechecked

6. Bus Bar Differential scheme is notavailable.

Yes

3)Dual channel carrier protection is availablein all 220 KV feeders but kept out YES No

Due to nonavailabilityof Panel atremote end.

8) Auto reclose is available but presentlykept out. YES No

As carrierprotection isout.

9) Bus Bar differential scheme is availablebut presently kept out.

YES No

To becheckedbefore put inservice

KTPS, Korba(E)

220

DSPMTPS,Korba

220

Page 12: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

3) Non availability of B/B differential &LBB protection

Yes No 31.10.2014Bus Bar protection panel has beenreceived

4)GPS is available however no relay issynchronised with it.

Yes No 31.05.2014Relays have been synchronisedwith new GPS.

5) Replacement of ABCB with SF6 breakers& commissioning of isolator sequentialoperation with ABCB opening.

Yes No 31.03.2016

Replacement of ABCB with SF6breakers is included in the scope ofwork of R&M of station proposedin year 2015-16

1) Second DC system is recommended . Yes No 31.03.2015 In R&M

2) To renovate/retrofit Main-I & Main-IIProtection with numeric relays in all outgoing feeders. Yes No 30.09.2014

05 no. Numeric Relays have beenretrofitted as MainI/II protection inthe following feeders: KW-Churi I& II,KW-DSPM, KW-KE I & II .Rest will be fitted after the receiptof ordered material.

3) Carrier Protection is not in service. 02 no. havebeencommissioned in KEB-KWB interconnectors

Yes No 31.03.2016for other 4 feeders procurement isrequired

4) Disturbance Recoder and SER s are notavailable.

Yes No 31.09.2014

Bay control panels for SCADAsystem have been received .M/sABB is being persuaded tocommission the same as early aspossible.

5) Non availability of Auto reclose scheme.Yes No 30.09.2014

After the commissioning of thenumeris relays will be put inservice

6) Non availability of B/B differentialYes No 31.03.2015

Old scheme to be replaced by newone.Estimate is being sent forapproval.

8)GPS is available however no relay issynchronised with it. Yes No 31.03.2015

After commissioning of SCADApanel, Relays will besynchronised.GPS facility isavailable in SCADA.

Korba WestTPS

220

Korba WestTPS

400

Page 13: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

MfP'T"'c.,L-

MP Annexure - I~.--Name of Deficiencies that can be

Sl. Sub-S tation S/S corrected withoutNo.

identified for Voltage Observation of Protection Audit procurement (Category-Deficiencies involving procurement (Category-B) Remark

Protection kV A)Audit

Yes I Wether ifnot Wether

Noattended attended Yes I No attended if no, expected date to attendYeslNo reason YeslNo

I Bhopal 400 Providing of Separate Event LoggerYes No 4 months

Order placed. Panel not received atsubstation

2 Bhopal 400Replacement of220KV Static Bus Bar system Yes No 2 months 220 KV Numerical Bus bar panelwith Numeric received at Substation

3 Mandideep 220 Providing of220KV Bus Bar Protection SchemeYes No 2 months 220 KV Numerical Bus bar panel

received at Substation

4 Gwalior 220 220KV Bus Bar scheme to be providedYes No 4 months 221 KV Numerical Bus bar panel

received at Substation

5 Gwalior 220Providing ofNIFPS on 3x40MVA 220/1 32KV Yes No 6 monthsTransformer

6 Gwalior 220 Providing ofDG set Yes No 6 months

7 Bina 400 Providing of Separate Event Logger Yes No 4 months Under process

8 Katni 400 DG set not provided Yes No 4 months

9 Malanpur 220 Providing of DG set Yes No - Under process

10 Malanpur 220Providing ofNIFPS on 160MVA 2201132KV Yes No - Under processTransformer-II

II Mehgaon 220Providing ofNIFPS on 160MVA 220/132KV Yes No - Under processTransformer-II

12 Shujalpur 220 220KV Bus Bar scheme to be provided Yes No 4 months Under process

South Zone220KV Bus Bar protection scheme is ASEA 2 months

BEING COMMISSIONED,• 13 Indore

220 make needs to be replaced with numerical YES NO TO BE TAKEN IN SERVICEscheme

14 South Zone220 Providing of DG set YES NO 6 MONTHS UNDER PROCESS

Indore15 Pithampur 220 Providing of DG set YES NO 6 MONTHS UNDER PROCESS

220KV Bus Bar protection scheme is ASEA16 Barwaha 220 make needs to be replaced with numerical Yes No 4 months

scheme17 Barwaha 220 Providing ofDG set Yes I No Under Process

18 Jabalpur 220Air Conditioning system should be provided in

Yes No Matter is under consideration.the Control Room

19 Rewa 220Automatic Fire Protection System (NIFPS)to be Yes No Matter is under consideration.installed on all TransformersSynchronising scheme must be provided as many

20 Rewa 220 Hydel Generators are connected to the 220KV Yes Noand 132KV Bus.

21 Satna 220Automatic Fire Protection System( NIFPS) to be

Yes No Matter is under consideration.installed on 160MV A AREV A Transformer

22 Sagar 220Automatic Fire Protection System (NIFPS)to be

Yes No Matter is under consideration.installed on both Transformers

Page 14: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

,.

Name of Deficiencies that can beSL

Sub-Station . S/S corrected withoutNo.

identified for Voltage Observation of Protection Audit procurement (Category-Deficiencies involving procurement (Category-B) Remark

Protection kV A)Audit

Yes/Wether if not Wether

Noattended attended Yes/No attended if no, expected date to attendYes/No reason Yes/No

23 Sagar 220 220KV Bus Bar scheme to be provided Yes No 4 months

24 Julwaniya 220 220KV Bus Bar scheme to be provided Yes No 4 months

25 Nimrani 220 220KV Bus Bar scheme to be provided YES NO 2 months

26 Nagda 400 Separate event logger for S/S is not available and Yes No 6 Month Under processneeds to be orovided,

Tertiary Reactor of3l5MV A Tr-I & Il are notUnder process

27 Indore 400being taken in service due to high Tan delta

YES NO I

values of Bushings, which should be replaced -and reactors should be taken in to service.

On 400KV side Bus Bar relay make EE typeFAC is electromagnetic type relay and it is very

COMMISSIONED TO BE TAKEN28 InGbre 400 old and obsolete. Its spares are not available,This YES NO I 2 months

scheme may be replaced with the numerical Bus IN SERVICE

Bar protection scheme.

r:,1

Page 15: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

~I-<Y\·S~)

w..r .,.

Page 16: F-3, MIDC Area, Andheri (E ast), Mumbai - 400 093wrpc.gov.in/pcm/PA_Defects_Sep2014.pdf · Replacement of 400kV Static Busbar protection schemes by Numerical Busbar schemes Existing

••-lARDING IMPLEMENTING PROTECTION AUDIT RECOMMENDATIONS AND CERC - Reg https://mail.googlc.com/mail/u/Ol?ui=2&ik=b3d635c8bd&vicw=pt&cat=fortnight data grid dis

G~EJil~<...<::.~~r"

SP BirtO.-.

FOLLOW UP REGARDING IMPLEMENTING PROTECTION AUDIT RECOMMENDATIONS AND CERC - Reg1 message

Sidc Mpseb <sldcmpjbp@gmaiL

Sun, Aug l, 2014 at 11:25 AMsk.chakraborty <[email protected]>To: [email protected]: "s.sen" <[email protected]>, "rs.sharma" <[email protected]>, "rajncesh.gaur" <[email protected]>

This has reference to your message dated 31-07·14 on the above subject. The point and extract of the romarks from our consultant MIS TCE forwarded to you long ago arc given below once again. However initial data compilation and studies by MIS CPRI ,Bangalore forthe protection co ordination by third party as per recommendation from grid failure committee has already been conducted in the 4th week ofjuly 2014 and there draft report will be available by 2 months. Discussion regarding all these point will be held at that time and a

conscious decision will be taken at that time

~

'Iame ofSL Sub-StationNo. idertifi ed for

Observational Prctec ton .A,udltDefideccies that can be

corrected withoutprccuremera (CategiXy-A)

SiSVoltage

kV

Df!icienaes ervclving

prccuren eu (C"'~'Orr3)Remark

113 IJ""pee Bill. IPS I 4/J()1no. 0fI1igh..l,[ascto"·#rUtstaUednear400kVtrunsf" I~' I y",bus in he $'Ititchya,.d J ()

ir",dJtal E'F'rolIyuttiJ,g 1sec.f o- PGCIL i.1S<t:Jo,114 IJ",'P'"Bin. IPS I 4/J() I~"a lin e is 'ow,.""'" ~,",w '~.' •• IYes

rll/wJ.1.wd& rft:;.w

115 l,raypaBitta IPS I 4/J()Owr ,·oItag_ <w.g [or 4()O~vPGCIL&..IiPPTCL IiJI< Ir ••(11'6 not as per Q3IP r6commt18tion(GjO' REV :1'(4).

116 l1a.\.po141!'Billa. TPS

117

Twollo higlt masthasbe0.! gJYct,dartJucom e: ofs/s

I.:!""wei' from DIU' COrl.tuifaJlt ;:\:lIS TCE:jUirl7ctiottal..z{ispravwdto pr~cr &11

:rstotlfroIJthigr •.impeti.QJlcliliIt6/fUl1.Js.rMtV fdu.tCU1'I'ezttJ au £o.t! Sol seeopl1l'tliing time is sufJici21tC 1lHd. caJtb, used{or both It e tnes. Decreaseur tltI OfuraJing

timl!lttay CalUI1 Lito i.Jttff'f"nr wilt 31l1.. :;,ott~.MlflsetriJ.lgS.

COItUlUlH.ts

rMt OUl'

C01fSUi..t4/fi :"L~TeE is gi.VJ!1t

Our COUsullalft. feE t rip-lp :PtelLfIt /tOel

~

dutran in-S"taJUlZlt.,1I0US 01'6i" ••.•d.tage set.iJtg of ~co'"ttten.cs130~'phasetoPtas8cdnbeused. .•upu .taJt.da:rdr=:Wles are OlpttbU of :o:.::r:n! J£S

wihsta.Pt.dinglJO%ollrighl~uy$tnn volC4c':tf TeE is 'i.'m

a.c.po-t:lr frequencyfor 1 INUtUC6. So alXJ1I« gtIseuines are ok.

y"':rom our

./

Ourc~tS!d.taJtlrCE's r"npy ;.41 p.,.,.mu.,/axdtudpractict1, in/1!',.-tUr"ltp,.ocociimt isrovid8d on.ly whtlt! SpedFLCallj"

recolftJt1mtU:d.l1y dttl1t1aJtU!a.ctur8f.

1119 Va-. ~ BiJt.a. TPS I «oo (eriOdiCal fz$d.ttgoj relays & yartIgquipHtattntust b# eti~dit:aL.=« of I'B~ ~ yard}P dOIf2. eqlUppuftCJ - ({ uiJ! be ad)1t.V1t too. _-.J

RepLyfrom COIt.JI~b:zu1C TCE;A..r perrQC"otnm€f'ldai(mjrorn r'iilaynta.n.uai..s,si'tiiJlg of lito 30% it used for fifdth lfmtolf l.C bloc kUtg. A.r pu our stJutd4rdn-ITr'20~i.s''''ltf.r'''d!luzrmoni:b1.0<king.

IlUobsw-vsddlat!ofgilJUllCOt'P'Olt!ctiOtt "-ttdu . ... ColtttMltU. i----.--Jr,"'l""''''' "lay trips.nxin. 48.5I1z/m- Ssec.& owr • Ou,' <"",.,/tan"",ly Fr.qll.olltCy proOlcu.on rom 0"·

aypee Bma TPS! «oo .:s fer ' is u sed maiillvjo,.alcvm aJtdasp<IY ow'. . Irrequ.en(,~·TlSla..vt:rips(/ttiltg51.0HtforSs8c.I$taken.thll I' I I ..' hi . ts 'ads . ~Oi""!IalIt.\i,s

S'4ItIlma.pbsreu.ew4!AL I' r,.acr.u~aWtlfl L.Qyo;, $,I!CLS" qltau. I~CEis gt-a'1!11

118 IJ d•.•.•pee: 1)[1(a. rPS

Gr&Srr"-dtkarm.",,icsb1.od.'iJtgi.sdtJ~'for]O%,This'md,,.oesn,dies & revised:

4/J()

It turn procdioll has Me baJltproWled,dtrough irisIUJCOIttntendsdfOt' G~ItiUa1Dr'mO'8tJuz.n.l00 .MVA.

y",

Regards.

S.K. Chakraborty

4/J()

Jaypee Bina Thermal Power Plant(A Division of Jaiprakash Power Ventures Umited)RajN Nagar. Post Box No.1.

Sub P.O. Agasod

Tehsil & P.O: Bina-470113

Distt Sagar (MP)

Phone: 07580-277101-3

Contm2ncr

ConsUU41ft ;\£5TCE is gillen

iii.

Comments'rom. OIU"

consuuant: )1:S IrCEisgU~