exhibit a - moritz college of lawmoritzlaw.osu.edu/.../documents/exhibita021716.pdfexhibit a case...

Exhibit A

Case 3:15-cv-00357-HEH-RCY Document 168-1 Filed 02/17/16 of 24 PageID# 2449

Plaintiffs' Objections to Defendants' Exhibit List Lee v. Virginia State Board of Elections

Case No. 3:15-cv-357-HEHDate Description Author Recepient Beg. Bates Ending Bates Party Objecting Nature of Objection Authority for Objection

DX 1 11/4/2014 Email RE communication with voter concerning provisional ballot issue Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) VSBE0000883 VSBE0000887

DX 2 11/4/2014 Email RE guidance on IDs with addresses and provisional ballots Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT); Lee, Susan (ELECT)

VSBE0000890 VSBE0000890

DX 3 11/4/2014 Email RE guidance on employee IDs Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) 'Alan Cole' VSBE0000893 VSBE0000894 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 4 2/19/2014 Meeting notes from Voter ID SBE workgroup VSBE0003606 VSBE0003606 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 5 4/15/2014 Voter Identification Workgroup Meeting Presentation VSBE0003738 VSBE0003755 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 6 8/20/2013 Meeting notes from Voter ID SBE workgroup VSBE0003841 VSBE0003842 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 7 9/24/2015 Voters Issued a Free Photo Id.csv VSBE0008491 VSBE0008491 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 8 1/31/2013 Email RE SB1256 Legislative Action Summary Riemer, Justin (SBE) Pugh, Logan (GOV) VSBE0028657 VSBE0028660 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 9 3/15/2013 Email RE SB1256 Enrolled Bill Review 2013 Riemer, Justin (SBE) Pugh, Logan (GOV) VSBE0029315 VSBE0029323 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 10 4/29/2014 Email re Voter ID application Cortes, Edgardo (SBE) 'Gaylene Kanoyton' VSBE0029626 VSBE0029627 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 11 7/16/2014 Church Partner letter for SOA.docx Lee, Susan (ELECT) VSBE0030735 VSBE0030735 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 12 7/16/2014 Email re Outreach to Church partners regarding SB 1256 and

attachmentsLee, Susan (ELECT) Rodrigues, Nancy (GOV) VSBE0030734 VSBE0030737 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 13 10/3/2012 Email RE Voter Fraud Inquiry Requested for Prince William County Riemer, Justin (SBE) Sheridan, Nikki (SBE) VSBE0031564 VSBE0031566 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 14 5/16/2014 Email RE presentation to Norfolk Democratic Committee regarding the voter ID law

Bettye Potts Cortes, Edgardo (SBE) VSBE0032272 VSBE0032273 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 15 5/20/2014 RE: Scheduling Meeting Hope Amezquita 'Cortes, Edgardo (SBE)' VSBE0032414 VSBE0032416 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 16 5/20/2014 Email RE setting up a meeting with ACLU of Virginia regarding Photo ID McClees, Myron (SBE) Therese & Bernard Martin VSBE0032535 VSBE0032538

DX 17 5/27/2014 Email with League of Women Voters regarding photo ID implementation The official communication list for the Electoral Board Members of the Commonwealth. on behalf of Lee, Susan (SBE)

[email protected] VSBE0032647 VSBE0032658 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 18 5/28/2014 Email RE Photo Training Rodrigues, Nancy (GOV) Cortes, Edgardo (SBE) VSBE0032703 VSBE0032704 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 19 5/29/2014 Meeting Invite RE Voter Photo ID Demonstration to the members of the Virginia Board of People with Disabilities

Lee, Susan (SBE) Sasnett, Cameron; Wagoner, Terry (SBE)

VSBE0032764 VSBE0032764 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 20 5/29/2014 Email RE Draft Guidance on Assistance for Voter Photo ID Card Application

Brissette, Martha (SBE) Palmer, Don (SBE); Cortes, Edgardo (SBE)


DX 21 5/28/2014 20-40-10 Definitions_v3.docx McClees, Myron (SBE) VSBE0032886 VSBE0032887DX 22 5/30/2014 20-40-90 Voter Identification Cards_v4.docx McClees, Myron (SBE) VSBE0032888 VSBE0032890DX 23 5/30/2014 4 Regulation 20-40-10 with Staff Recommendations.doc McClees, Myron (SBE) VSBE0032891 VSBE0032892DX 24 5/30/2014 Email re staff recommendations for the Voter ID regulations and

attachmentsMcClees, Myron (SBE) Kimberly Bowers VSBE0032884 VSBE0032894 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 25 6/5/2014 Meeting Invite RE AARP - Meeting to discuss voter ID project Lee, Susan (SBE) Cortes, Edgardo (SBE) VSBE0033069 VSBE0033069 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 26 6/10/2014 Email RE Call with Democratic Party of Virginia Gaylene Kanoyton 'Cortes, Edgardo (SBE)' VSBE0033219 VSBE0033222 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 27 6/10/2014 Email attaching Voter ID update Palmer, Don (SBE) Mansfield, Rose (SBE); Cortes,

Edgardo (SBE)VSBE0033244 VSBE0033246 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX NO.

Page 1 of 23



Case No. 3:15-cv-357-HEHDate Description Author Recepient Beg. Bates Ending Bates Party Objecting Nature of Objection Authority for ObjectionDX NO.

DX 28 6/12/2014 Email RE involvement of voter ID Workgroup and VRAV leadership Palmer, Don (SBE) '[email protected]'; Cortes, Edgardo (SBE)


DX 29 6/13/2014 FW: Church Addresses Rodrigues, Nancy (GOV) Cortes, Edgardo (SBE); Lee, Susan (SBE)


DX 30 6/13/2014 Email RE Voter Photo ID Implementation - Update The official communication list for the General Registrars of the Commonwealth on behalf of Palmer, Don (SBE)


DX 31 6/16/2014 Email RE Meeting with Senator Obenshain on photo ID regulations Cortes, Edgardo (SBE) '[email protected]' VSBE0033779 VSBE0033779

DX 32 6/17/2014 Email RE Religious Objectors to Photographs Brissette, Martha (SBE) McClees, Myron (SBE); Lippolis, Emily (SBE); Lee, Susan (SBE); Cortes, Edgardo (SBE)


DX 33 2/6/2014 Meeting Invite RE Voter ID Workgroup meetings Lee, Susan (SBE) 'Barbara Bosserman - GR Clarke'; Fox, Gary (SBE); 'Gary Scott - Fairfax'; 'Kirk Showalter -GR Richmond'; Lee, Susan (SBE); Baldwin, Victoria (SBE); Harman, Terri (SBE); Sasnett, Cameron; 'Lisa Wooten - Waynesboro'; McClees, Myron (SBE); 'Russ Boraas - EB Hanover'; 'Susan B. Kellom - EB Alexandria'; 'Tammy Alexandria - EB Petersburg'; 'Teri Smithson - GR Hanover'; Wagoner, Terry (SBE); Cortes, Edgardo (SBE)


DX 34 2/6/2014 Meeting Invite RE Voter ID Implementation Lee, Susan (SBE) Palmer, Don (SBE); Mansfield, Rose (SBE); Cortes, Edgardo (SBE)


DX 35 6/18/2014 Meeting Invite RE Voter ID Lee, Susan (SBE) Fox, Gary (SBE); Sasnett, Cameron; Baldwin, Victoria (SBE); Cummins, Joe (SBE); Harman, Terri (SBE); Palmer, Don (SBE); Cortes, Edgardo (SBE); Davis, Matthew (SBE); McClees Myron (SBE)


Page 2 of 23




DX 36 2/11/2014 Meeting Invite RE Voter ID Lee, Susan (SBE) Fox, Gary (SBE); Sasnett, Cameron; Baldwin, Victoria (SBE); Cummins, Joe (SBE); Harman, Terri (SBE); Palmer, Don (SBE); Cortes, Edgardo (SBE); Davis Matthew (SBE)


DX 37 2/20/2014 Email re Photo Voter Identification Law - Schedule of Training and Draft Application

The official communication list for the Electoral Board Members of the Commonwealth. on behalf of Palmer, Don (SBE)


DX 38 6/25/2014 Email RE Testing of Voter Photo ID Equipment Sasnett, Cameron (ELECT)

Hill, Michael (ELECT); Lee, Susan (ELECT); Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT); Davis, Matthew (ELECT); Cummins, Joe (ELECT); Harman, Terri (ELECT); Sears, Matthew (ELECT); Baldwin, Victoria (ELECT); Fox, Gary (ELECT); Mcclees, Myron ( )


DX 39 6/25/2014 Email RE comments on Obenshain letter Palmer, Donald (ELECT) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT); Mansfield, Rose (ELECT)


DX 40 2/28/2014 Email re Photo Voter Identification Law - Schedule of Training and Draft Application and attachments

The official communication list for the Electoral Board Members of the Commonwealth. on behalf of Palmer, Don (SBE)


DX 41 12/26/2013 Sample ID final(watermark).pdf The official communication list for the Electoral Board Members of the Commonwealth. on behalf of Palmer, Don (SBE)

VSBE0034945 VSBE0034945

DX 42 2/27/2014 VoterID.PDF The official communication list for the Electoral Board Members of the Commonwealth. on behalf of Palmer, Don (SBE)

VSBE0034946 VSBE0034946

Page 3 of 23




DX 43 3/10/2014 Email RE Photo Voter Identification Law - VEBA Presentation and attachments

The official communication list for the General Registrars of the Commonwealth on behalf of Palmer, Don (SBE)


DX 44 7/1/2014 FINAL VA photo ID postcard.pdf Tram Nguyen VSBE0035337 VSBE0035338 Plaintiffs Hearsay; Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901DX 45 7/1/2014 photo ID outreach materials Tram Nguyen Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT); Lee,

Susan (SBE)VSBE0035336 VSBE0035339 Plaintiffs Hearsay; Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901

DX 46 7/1/2014 Email RE Voter Photo ID First-Date Stats Harman, Terri (ELECT) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT); Lee, Susan (ELECT); Davis, Matthew (ELECT); Sasnett, Cameron (ELECT); Cummins, Joe (ELECT); Baldwin, Victoria (ELECT); Mcclees, Myron (ELECT); Fox, Gary (ELECT); Ellis, Garry (ELECT)


DX 47 3/21/2014 Email RE fraud warning on photo ID application Brissette, Martha (SBE) McClees, Myron (SBE); Cortes, Edgardo (SBE)


DX 48 7/17/2014 Email RE Mobile photo ID units Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) Rodrigues, Nancy (GOV); '[email protected]'


DX 49 5/2/2014 Email RE Evaluation of Cost for Voter Photo ID Cards - In House Solution Davis, Matthew (SBE) Cortes, Edgardo (SBE); Palmer, Don (SBE); Lee, Susan (SBE); Woo, Sharon (SBE)


DX 50 8/9/2014 Email RE Call with NAACP about Voter Outreach from the Virginia Department of Elections

Lee, Susan (ELECT) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) VSBE0038247 VSBE0038248 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 51 8/13/2014 Email RE response to ACLU Letter regarding voter ID Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) VSBE0042901 VSBE0042902 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 52 8/14/2014 Email RE Recent developments regarding "valid" IDs Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) [email protected]; '[email protected]'

VSBE0043186 VSBE0043187

DX 53 8/15/2014 [GRLIST] OFFICIAL COMMUNICATION NCOA, ERIC, and Interstate Crosscheck m... (20.4 KB) 000.msg

Brissette, Martha (ELECT)


DX 54 1/2/1900 VA-CROSS_STATE-20140129.html Brissette, Martha (ELECT)


DX 55 1/2/1900 VA-CROSS_STATE-20140416.htm Brissette, Martha (ELECT)


DX 56 8/13/2014 locality precinct count of voters without dmv ids.xlsx Brissette, Martha (ELECT)

VSBE0043462 VSBE0043462

DX 57 2/25/2014 Locality and State Stats.xlsx Brissette, Martha (ELECT)


DX 58 8/19/2014 Email RE guidance on photo ID services Brissette, Martha (ELECT)

Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) VSBE0043662 VSBE0043671 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 59 8/28/2014 Email RE Spanish language translation of voter materials Quinn, Cameron P. 'Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT)'; Flaig, Judy


Page 4 of 23




DX 60 8/29/2014 Email RE use of HSS grant funding for purchase of laptops for mobile vote ID outreach

Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) Lee, Susan (ELECT) VSBE0044238 VSBE0044239 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 61 9/2/2014 Email RE Voter Photo ID Outreach Lee, Susan (ELECT) Mansfield, Rose (ELECT) VSBE0044301 VSBE0044301 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 62 9/2/2014 Email RE Voter Photo ID Software - Offline Version and attachment Lee, Susan (ELECT) [email protected] VSBE0044311 VSBE0044314 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 63 9/4/2014 Email RE private high school IDs Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) Judd, Charles VSBE0044761 VSBE0044765 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 64 8/11/2014 Acceptable ID (SBE 643A).docx Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0044847 VSBE0044847 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 65 8/11/2014 Provisional Ballot Log (SBE-653 LOG).doc Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0044848 VSBE0044848

DX 66 8/11/2014 PROVISIONAL VOTE ENVELOPE.doc Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0044849 VSBE0044849

DX 67 8/11/2014 PROVISIONAL VOTE ENVELOPE--ID ONLY.doc Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0044850 VSBE0044850

DX 68 7/10/2014 PROVISIONAL VOTER NOTICE - Identification.docx Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0044851 VSBE0044851

DX 69 8/22/2014 WHAT IFS 8-11-2014.doc Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0044852 VSBE0044872

DX 70 9/4/2014 Email re Updated Guidance Documents and attachments Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) VSBE0044845 VSBE0044874 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 71 9/4/2014 Email re Petersburg General Registrar Voter ID Outreach Mailing Dawn Williams 'Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT)' VSBE0044875 VSBE0044876 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 72 9/8/2014 Email RE Temp. Voter Photo ID The official

communication list for the General Registrars of the Commonwealth on behalf of Diane Klausen


DX 73 9/8/2014 Email RE VoPho App for web Sasnett, Cameron (ELECT)

Davis, Matthew (ELECT) VSBE0045095 VSBE0045095 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 74 7/11/2014 Voter Photo ID Application for Web.pdf Sasnett, Cameron (ELECT)

VSBE0045096 VSBE0045096

DX 75 9/10/2014 Email RE - Voter Photo ID Outreach - Mailer Lee, Susan (ELECT) Grlist ([email protected]) VSBE0045245 VSBE0045245 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 76 9/10/2014 VDE-5003_Voter_Direct Mailer 11x6 v 4 (2).pdf Lee, Susan (ELECT) VSBE0045246 VSBE0045247 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 77 9/11/2014 Email RE City of Manassas Photo ID PR Ann Bausch '[email protected]

IRGINIA.GOV'VSBE0045283 VSBE0045284 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 78 9/15/2014 Email RE Update on Voter ID Outreach Lee, Susan (ELECT) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT); Mansfield, Rose (ELECT)


Page 5 of 23




DX 79 9/15/2014 Email RE General Registrar - Outreach Efforts Survey The official communication list for the Electoral Board Members of the Commonwealth. on behalf of Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT)


DX 80 9/23/2014 Email RE Social media posts regarding photo ID law Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) Rodrigues, Nancy (GOV) VSBE0046168 VSBE0046168 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 81 9/10/2014 2014 09 Unregistered Resident Postcard.pdf Lee, Susan (ELECT) VSBE0046180 VSBE0046181 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 82 9/23/2014 Email RE - ELECT Mailings to Voters and attachments Lee, Susan (ELECT) 'Grlist ([email protected])' VSBE0046179 VSBE0046183 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 83 9/24/2014 Email RE Student IDs Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT); 'Jenny Lee Sanders'


DX 84 9/24/2014 Email RE Meeting with Non-partisan voter protection and outreach groups

Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) Mansfield, Rose (ELECT) VSBE0046222 VSBE0046223 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 85 9/25/2014 Email RE Outreach Efforts Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) Rodrigues, Nancy (GOV) VSBE0046250 VSBE0046250 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 86 9/26/2014 Email RE Press Release regarding Voters Impacted by New Photo ID Requirement in Virginia

The official communication list for the Electoral Board Members of the Commonwealth. on behalf of Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT)


DX 87 9/30/2014 Voter ID (275 KB)_000.msg Brissette, Martha (ELECT)

[email protected]; [email protected]


DX 88 9/26/2014 Voter Photo ID Stats by Locality 09-26-2014.xlsx Brissette, Martha (ELECT)

VSBE0047106 VSBE0047106

DX 89 9/30/2014 Email RE Response to FOIA Request concerning Voter ID Law and attachments

Brissette, Martha (ELECT)

Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT); Mcclees, Myron (ELECT); Braun, Brooks (ELECT); Sasnett, Cameron (ELECT)


DX 90 9/12/2014 Voter Photo ID What If Guide, rev 09-14 (1).docx Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0047464 VSBE0047468

DX 91 9/15/2014 Election Day Guide.doc Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0047469 VSBE0047500 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 92 8/11/2014 Acceptable ID (SBE 643A) (1).docx Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0047501 VSBE0047501 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 93 9/5/2014 Voter Photo ID User's Guide rev.09-14.pdf Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0047502 VSBE0047523 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 94 5/27/2014 Voter Photo ID Software Install Step-by-Step.pdf Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0047524 VSBE0047533 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 95 6/19/2014 Voter Photo ID Camera Shillouette.pdf Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0047534 VSBE0047534 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

Page 6 of 23




DX 96 6/19/2014 Examples of Bad Photos.pdf Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0047535 VSBE0047535 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 97 9/12/2014 Voter Photo ID What If Guide, rev 09-14.docx Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0047536 VSBE0047540

DX 98 5/6/2014 SBE 404-ID (Spanish).pdf Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0047541 VSBE0047541

DX 99 7/11/2014 SBE 404-ID (English).pdf Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0047542 VSBE0047542

DX 100 8/14/2014 List of Institutions of Higher Education.xlsx Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) VSBE0047543 VSBE0047543 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 101 10/2/2014 Email RE Training Documents and attachments Mcclees, Myron (ELECT) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) VSBE0047460 VSBE0047544

DX 102 10/6/2014 Email RE Photo ID Report and Related Maps Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) '[email protected]'; Sasnett, Cameron (ELECT)


DX 103 10/10/2014 Email RE Voter Photo ID Outreach - Update The official communication list for the Electoral Board Members of the Commonwealth. on behalf of Davis, Matthew (ELECT)


DX 104 10/20/2014 Email RE Virginia Voter Photo ID PSA Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) Rodrigues, Nancy (GOV) VSBE0049351 VSBE0049351 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 105 10/20/2014 RE: OFFICIAL ELECT COMMUNICATION - Voter Photo ID Information Quinn, Cameron P. 'Lee, Susan (ELECT)' VSBE0049377 VSBE0049378DX 106 10/31/2014 Email RE Photo ID reminders Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) [email protected] VSBE0050392 VSBE0050393 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 107 11/3/2014 Email RE pre-election ELECT Press Release - November, 3 2014 and attachment

Lee, Susan (ELECT) '[email protected]'


DX 108 11/4/2014 Email RE Election Day Update Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) Rodrigues, Nancy (GOV) VSBE0051268 VSBE0051269 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 109 11/6/2014 Email RE ELECT Press Release - November 6, 2014-Post Election Update and attachment

Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) Coy, Brian (GOV); Rodrigues, Nancy (GOV)


DX 110 11/10/2014 Email RE Social Media and Voter Photo ID Statistics and attachment Sasnett, Cameron (ELECT)

Mansfield, Rose (ELECT) VSBE0051651 VSBE0051652 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 111 11/14/2014 Email RE Count of Provisionals and attachment Pak, Sang (ELECT) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT); Harman, Terri (ELECT)


DX 112 11/21/2014 Email RE 2014 After Action Report and attachment Lee, Susan (ELECT) Rodrigues, Nancy (GOV) VSBE0051861 VSBE0051861 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 113 11/21/2014 2014 After Action Report (Final).pdf Lee, Susan (ELECT) VSBE0051862 VSBE0051877 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 114 11/25/2014 Email RE Summary of Election Day and attachment Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) Rodrigues, Nancy (GOV) VSBE0052009 VSBE0052010 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 115 12/11/2014 Email RE Voting Equipment Q&A and attachment Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) Mcclees, Myron (ELECT); Lee, Susan (ELECT); Fox, Gary (ELECT)


DX 116 12/11/2014 voting equipment Q&A.docx Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) VSBE0052202 VSBE0052203 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 117 5/21/2015 Email RE Additional Media Buys FOR Voter Photo ID PSA Lee, Susan (ELECT) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) VSBE0055649 VSBE0055649 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

Page 7 of 23




DX 118 6/16/2015 Email RE Voter ID Numbers and attachment Davis, Matthew (ELECT) Pak, Sang (ELECT) VSBE0056049 VSBE0056057 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 119 7/8/2015 Email RE Use of Mobile Photo ID Unit Lee, Susan (ELECT) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) VSBE0056898 VSBE0056899 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 120 2/27/2014 Email RE Update on Voter ID Application and Voter ID Training The official

communication list for the Electoral Board Members of the Commonwealth. on behalf of Wooten, Lisa P


DX 121 1/31/2013 Email RE Edits to Legislative Action Summary for SB 1256 and attachment

Palmer, Don (SBE) Riemer, Justin (SBE) VSBE0067180 VSBE0067183 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 122 3/15/2013 Email RE Draft Enrolled Bill Review for SB 1256 and attachment Riemer, Justin (SBE) Palmer, Don (SBE) VSBE0067465 VSBE0067473 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 123 3/15/2013 Email RE Edits to Draft Enrolled Bill Review for SB 1256 and attachment Palmer, Don (SBE) Riemer, Justin (SBE) VSBE0067474 VSBE0067482 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 124 3/26/2013 Email RE SB 1256 Standard Riemer, Justin (SBE) Palmer, Don (SBE) VSBE0067517 VSBE0067517 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 125 4/1/2013 Email RE Veterans ID Sample Riemer, Justin (SBE) Pierce, David (DMV) VSBE0067624 VSBE0067625 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 126 4/22/2013 Email RE Virginia Advocates United Leading Together Comments on the

SBE websitePalmer, Don (SBE) executivedirector@virginiavaul

t.orgVSBE0067799 VSBE0067800 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 127 7/3/2013 Email RE Funds Approved for Photo ID Implementation Woo, Sharon (SBE) Palmer, Don (SBE); Lee, Susan (SBE); Sheridan, Nikki (SBE); Riemer, Justin (SBE)


DX 128 9/7/2012 Email RE Virginia Chamber of Commerce Voter ID Law Outreach Dunn, Ryan [email protected] VSBE0069443 VSBE0069443 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 129 8/15/2013 Email RE Voter Id Workgroup Lee, Susan (SBE) Barbara Bosserman - GR Clarke; Fox, Gary (SBE); Fraser, Lindsay (SBE); Gary Scott - Fairfax; Kirk Showalter - GR Richmond; Lee, Susan (SBE); McClees, Myron (SBE); Russ Boraas - EB Hanover; Susan B. Kellom - EB Alexandria; Tammy Alexandria - EB Petersburg


DX 130 9/11/2013 Meeting Invite RE Voter ID - SB1256 Lee, Susan (SBE) McClees, Myron (SBE); Brissette, Martha (SBE); Palmer, Don (SBE); Riemer, Justin (SBE)


DX 131 12/9/2013 Email RE Locality Voter ID Outreach Palmer, Don (SBE) Wooten, Lisa P. VSBE0073526 VSBE0073528 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 132 5/30/2014 Email RE Voter Photo ID Outreach to Aging and Disabled Population Lee, Susan (SBE) Palmer, Don (SBE) VSBE0074781 VSBE0074781 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 133 11/4/2013 Email RE Final Version of Implementation Plan and attachment Fraser, Lindsay (SBE) Sheridan, Nikki (SBE) VSBE0089987 VSBE0090010DX 134 9/4/2014 Email RE Virginia Voter Photo Identification Briefing Rodrigues, Nancy (GOV) Cortes, Edgardo (ELECT) VSBE0092570 VSBE0092571 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 135 5/9/2014 Spreadsheet RE Voter ID Hardware Survey Responses VSBE0095313 VSBE0095313 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 136 1/5/2015 Spreadsheet RE Fiscal Impact SB1256 VSBE0095321 VSBE0095321 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

Page 8 of 23




DX 137 7/29/2014 Headdress_Policy_Memo VSBE0095817 VSBE0095817DX 138 3/10/2014 Email RE Responses to Questions from Franklin County Electoral Board Palmer, Don (SBE) Jody Brown VSBE0103802 VSBE0103804 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 139 7/19/2013 Email RE Response to Questions from Fairfax County regarding New Photo ID law

Brissette, Martha (SBE) Riemer, Justin (SBE); Sheridan, Nikki (SBE); McClees, Myron (SBE)


DX 140 8/9/2013 RE: Photo Identification Implementation for July, 2014 Changes--Official SBE Communication--

Barbara Gunter 'Riemer, Justin (SBE)' VSBE0119205 VSBE0119207 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 141 7/10/2014 Voter Photo Identification Workgroup Meeting Agenda Presentation VSBE0125490 VSBE0125490 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 142 8/30/2012 2012 Voter ID Changes Presentation for Website VSBE0125491 VSBE0125491 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 143 4/15/2014 Voter Photo ID Workgroup Webinar Presentation VSBE0125493 VSBE0125513 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 144 10/8/2014 Photo ID Mailer.pdf VSBE0125536 VSBE0125537 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 145 9/22/2014 Poster Concepts for Photo ID VSBE0125538 VSBE0125542 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 146 10/10/2014 Department of Elections Script for 15 second radio PSA on Voter Photo

IDVSBE0125572 VSBE0125572 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 147 10/10/2014 Department of Elections Script for 60 second radio PSA on Voter Photo ID


DX 148 9/30/2014 Your Voice Flyer with Social Media for Voter Photo ID VSBE0125685 VSBE0125685 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 149 9/30/2014 What if . . . for Voter ID Guide VSBE0125692 VSBE0125696DX 150 8/19/2014 Suffolk Press Release RE Hampton Road's First Mobile Photo Voter ID

RegistrationVSBE0125784 VSBE0125784 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 151 7/8/2014 Spreadsheet RE Voter ID Outreach Event Tracking VSBE0125790 VSBE0125790 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 152 4/2/2014 Voter, Are you ID Ready - Flyer Fillable with Locality Info VSBE0125794 VSBE0125794 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 153 7/14/2014 Voter, Are you ID Ready ELECT - Flyer VSBE0125796 VSBE0125796 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 154 1/19/2015 Virginia Voter Photo ID Brochure VSBE0125810 VSBE0125815 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 155 10/22/2015 Spreadsheet RE VoterPhotoID Reconciliation VSBE0125824 VSBE0125824 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 156 10/22/2015 Spreadsheet RE VoterPhotoID Reconciliation FY 2015 Discrepancy VSBE0125825 VSBE0125825 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 157 10/22/2015 Spreadsheet Voter ID Outreach Expense Tracking FY 2015 VSBE0125828 VSBE0125828 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 158 10/22/2015 Spreadsheet Voter ID Outreach Expense Tracking FY 2016 VSBE0125830 VSBE0125830 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 159 5/28/2015 VCE Release for printing Invoice VSBE0125832 VSBE0125832 Plaintiffs Relevance; Hearsay;

AuthenticityFRE 401, 402, 801, 802, 901

DX 160 6/8/2015 Voter ID Invoice Social Media Graphics 2015 VSBE0125833 VSBE0125833 Plaintiffs Relevance; Hearsay; Authenticity

FRE 401, 402, 801, 802, 901

DX 161 5/19/2015 Invoice Sasnett, Cameron (ELECT)

VSBE0125836 VSBE0125836 Plaintiffs Relevance; Hearsay; Authenticity

FRE 401, 402, 801, 802, 901



FRE 401, 402, 801, 802, 901



FRE 401, 402, 801, 802, 901



FRE 401, 402, 801, 802, 901

DX 165 5/14/2015 VA ELECT Scan[3].pdf Sasnett, Cameron (ELECT)


FRE 401, 402, 801, 802, 901

DX 166 5/19/2015 Email RE Invoices from King Agency and attachments Sasnett, Cameron (ELECT)

Lee, Susan (ELECT) VSBE0125834 VSBE0125844 Plaintiffs Relevance; Hearsay; Authenticity

FRE 401, 402, 801, 802, 901

Page 9 of 23




DX 167 5/19/2015 Email RE Revised Radio Production Invoice and attachment Bill Boger Sasnett, Cameron (ELECT); Lee, Susan (ELECT)


FRE 401, 402, 801, 802, 901

DX 168 5/26/2015 Invoice for Voter ID Awareness Additional Media Placement VSBE0125848 VSBE0125848 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 169 5/19/2015 King Agency Invoice for May/June Radio Production VSBE0125851 VSBE0125851 Plaintiffs Relevance; Hearsay;

AuthenticityFRE 401, 402, 801, 802, 901

DX 170 5/19/2015 King Agency Invoice for Broadcast Media Costs VSBE0125852 VSBE0125853 Plaintiffs Relevance; Hearsay; Authenticity

FRE 401, 402, 801, 802, 901

DX 171 5/29/2015 King Agency Signed Contract 2014 VSBE0125858 VSBE0125880 Plaintiffs Relevance; Hearsay; Authenticity

FRE 401, 402, 801, 802, 901

DX 172 5/14/2015 King Agency Memo RE May/June Voter ID Outreach Campaign VSBE0125885 VSBE0125887 Plaintiffs Hearsay; Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901DX 173 5/26/2015 Email RE Additional Voter ID Spend Bill Boger Lee, Susan (ELECT) VSBE0125888 VSBE0125888 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 174 5/14/2015 King Agency Task Order for PSA and Facebook Ad Campaign Task Order

3VSBE0125889 VSBE0125890 Plaintiffs Hearsay; Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901

DX 175 5/26/2015 King Agency Task Order for PSA and Facebook Ad Campaign Task Order 4

VSBE0125891 VSBE0125892 Plaintiffs Hearsay; Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901

DX 176 5/26/2015 King Agency Task Order for PSA and Facebook Ad Campaign Task Order 5

VSBE0125893 VSBE0125894 Plaintiffs Hearsay; Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901

DX 177 9/24/2014 Computer, Webcam, SigPad, and Tripod Quotation VSBE0125913 VSBE0125914 Plaintiffs Relevance; Hearsay; Authenticity

FRE 401, 402, 801, 802, 901

DX 178 6/16/2015 Application for Grant Funds VSBE0125915 VSBE0125915 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 179 6/17/2015 Spreadsheet RE Voter Photo ID Reimbursement Tracking VSBE0125921 VSBE0125921 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 180 10/21/2015 Spreadsheet RE ELECT Outreach Partners contact 2015 VSBE0125937 VSBE0125937 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 181 9/22/2015 ELECT Outreach Partners.xlsx VSBE0125938 VSBE0125938 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 182 9/15/2014 Spreadsheet RE Voter Outreach VSBE0126174 VSBE0126174 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 183 9/22/2014 Voter Education Event VSBE0126176 VSBE0126176 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 184 9/17/2014 Email RE Event Turnout Iles, Stephanie Sasnett, Cameron (ELECT) VSBE0126177 VSBE0126177 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 185 9/23/2014 Spreadsheet Mobile Voter Photo VSBE0126181 VSBE0126181 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 186 7/11/2014 Spreadsheet Outreach Partners General VSBE0126190 VSBE0126190 Plaintiffs Relevance; Hearsay FRE 401, 402, 801, 802DX 187 7/16/2014 Advocacy Handout for Photo ID VSBE0126191 VSBE0126191 Plaintiffs Hearsay, Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901DX 188 7/16/2014 Advocacy Handout for Photo ID VSBE0126192 VSBE0126193 Plaintiffs Hearsay, Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901DX 189 9/9/2014 AARP VA Event List VSBE0126194 VSBE0126194 Plaintiffs Relevance; Hearsay FRE 401, 402, 801, 802DX 190 9/9/2014 AARP Event VSBE0126195 VSBE0126195 Plaintiffs Relevance, Hearsay FRE 401, 402, 801, 802DX 191 9/9/2014 Social Media Strategy for 2014 Election VSBE0126196 VSBE0126196 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 192 5/29/2015 Draft Outreach and Implementation VSBE0126197 VSBE0126209 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 193 7/1/2014 News Release - Voter Photo ID VSBE0126283 VSBE0126283 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 194 9/22/2014 National Voter Registration Day News Release VSBE0126287 VSBE0126287 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 195 10/21/2015 Spreadsheet RE 2015-2016 Planning VSBE0126334 VSBE0126334 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 196 9/14/2015 November 3, 2015 General & Special Elections Information VSBE0126335 VSBE0126337 Plaintiffs Hearsay, Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901DX 197 10/1/2015 Spreadsheet RE Social Media Stats 2015-2016.xlsx VSBE0126339 VSBE0126339 Plaintiffs Hearsay, Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901DX 198 9/8/2014 Email RE Governor's Voter Photo ID Presentation and attachment Mansfield, Rose (ELECT) VSBE0045883 VSBE0045984DX 199 The Heritage Foundation Issue Brief, Lessons from the Voter ID

Experience in GeorgiaNon-Party Legislators 000000297

Non-Party Legislators 000000300

Plaintiffs Improper Opinion Testimony; Hearsay; Relevance

FRE 401, 402, 701, 801, 802

DX 200 Email RE Voter Fraud Non-Party Legislators 000002211


Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

Page 10 of 23




DX 201 Email RE SB 1 -- Honest Elections and the Need for Photo ID Non-Party Legislators 000000702



DX 202 Email RE SB 1 Voter ID - Request Requirement of Photo ID Non-Party Legislators 000000707



DX 203 Email RE "It does not exist" Non-Party Legislators 000008721



DX 204 Email RE "It does not exist" Non-Party Legislators 000009227



DX 205 Email RE "Pass this Legislation" Non-Party Legislators 000009345



DX 206 Email RE SB 1 Voter ID - Request Requirement of Photo ID Non-Party Legislators 000009441



DX 207 1/25/2013 "It does not exist" <[email protected]> on behalf of Rob Bell

[email protected] LS00011372 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 208 Email RE Voter Fraud LS00006442 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 209 1/14/2013 Line Amendment and Stats on Voter ID Riemer, Justin \(SBE\) [email protected] LS00010410 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 210 2/5/2013 Email RE "It does not exist" <[email protected]

m> on behalf of Rob Bell


DX 211 1/31/2013 Email RE "It does not exist" <[email protected]> on behalf of Rob Bell

Pat Dolan LS00016711 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802


Linda Finstad LS00016717 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802


LYNN TUCKER LS00016722 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802


Karl Partner LS00016726 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802


Young, Robert E *HS LS00016731 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 216 2/6/2013 Email RE"It does not exist" <[email protected]> on behalf of Rob Bell


Page 11 of 23




DX 217 2/6/2013 Email RE"It does not exist" <[email protected]> on behalf of Rob Bell

Terry Rizor LS00016737 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802


Robin Davis LS00016741 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802


Tom Marshall LS00016747 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 220 9/24/2015 Provisional Voters 2014.csv VSBE0008489 VSBE0008489 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 221 10/20/2014 Email RE Voter Photo ID Information Lee, Susan (ELECT) Grlist ([email protected]) VSBE0049374 VSBE0049374 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 222 3/26/2013 Email RE SB 1256 signed by Governor McDonnell Riemer, Justin (SBE) Sheridan, Nikki (SBE) VSBE0117492 VSBE0117493 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 223 4/11/2013 FW: Executive Order 62 - SBE Mansfield, Rose (SBE) Riemer, Justin (SBE) VSBE0117874 VSBE0117877DX 224 1/6/2014 Spreadsheet 2014 Provisional Ballots VSBE0132246 VSBE0132372 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 225 1/5/2016 2015 Election Night Provisional Counts VSBE0134640 VSBE0134646 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 226 1/15/2016 Overview of Voter Photo ID Survey Results VSBE0134790 VSBE0134791 Plaintiffs Hearsay; Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901DX 227 1/11/2016 Lot Signs new VSBE0134792 VSBE0134814 Plaintiffs Hearsay; Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901DX 228 1/28/2016 Election Survey Results VSBE0134817 VSBE0134817 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 229 1/28/2016 Election Survey Results VSBE0134818 VSBE0134818 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 230 12/15/2015 King Agency Signed Contract for 2016 VSBE0134819 VSBE0134844 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 231 Benagh Voting History VSBE0134698 VSBE0134702 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 232 Chang Voting History VSBE0134703 VSBE0134705 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 233 Cheeks Voting History VSBE0134706 VSBE0134709 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 234 Cotten Voting History VSBE0134710 VSBE0134713 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 235 Csontos Voting History VSBE0134718 VSBE0134721 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 236 Deitz Voting History VSBE0134722 VSBE0134725 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 237 Etheredge Voting History VSBE0134726 VSBE0134728 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 238 Hilt Voting History VSBE0134729 VSBE0134731 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 239 Jackson Voting History VSBE0134732 VSBE0134734 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 240 Jones Voting History VSBE0134735 VSBE0134738 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 241 Lamb Voting History VSBE0134739 VSBE0134741 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 242 Leone Voting History VSBE0134742 VSBE0134746 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 243 Okiakpe Voting History VSBE0134747 VSBE0134749 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 244 Person Voting History VSBE0134750 VSBE0134753 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 245 Pfolhl Voting History VSBE0134754 VSBE0134757 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 246 Pitts Voting History VSBE0134758 VSBE0134763 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 247 Polatty Voting History VSBE0134764 VSBE0134767 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 248 Samson Voting History VSBE0134768 VSBE0134770 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 249 Smith Voting History VSBE0134771 VSBE0134773 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 250 Stallings Voting History VSBE0134774 VSBE0134777 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 251 Tidd Voting History VSBE0134778 VSBE0134781 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 252 Woodson Voting History VSBE0134782 VSBE0134786 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 253 Zando Voting History VSBE0134786 VSBE0134789 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 254 John Voting History VSBE0134845 VSBE0134847 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 255 Stallings Voting History VSBE0134848 VSBE0134850 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

Page 12 of 23




DX 256 DRAFT March 1st VoPho Campaign VSBE0134851 VSBE0134853 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 257 Photo of Ads VSBE0134854 VSBE0134854 Plaintiffs Hearsay; Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901DX 258 Photo of Ads VSBE0134855 VSBE0134855 Plaintiffs Hearsay; Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901DX 259 Photo of Ads VSBE0134856 VSBE0134856 Plaintiffs Hearsay; Authenticity FRE 801, 802, 901DX 260 8/14/2015 Amended ComplaintDX 261 Yair Ghitza's Report on Statistical Estimation of the Race of Individual

Registered Voters in TexasDX 262 Article entitled "Using the census bureau's surname list to improve

estimates of race/ethnicity and associated disparities"Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 263 Short Article/Opinion Piece by Dr. SmithDX 264 Article published in Time Magazine by Dr. SmithDX 265 Government Accountability Office ReportDX 266 Study by the Brennan Center for JusticeDX 267 New York Times Article by Carl Hulse Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 268 Document titled "Building Confidence in U.S. Elections" dated

September 2005Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 269 Document titled "Voter IDs Are Not the Problem: A Survey of Three States," dated 1-9-08


DX 270 Department of Elections Voter Overview Summary for Barbara Lee Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet received; Hearsay

FRE 801, 802

DX 271 Article "Building Confidence in U . S . Elections" Plaintiffs Hearsay (Duplicate of DX 268)

FRE 801, 802

DX 272 Article "Modeling Problems in the Voter Identification- - Voter Turnout Debate"

DX 273 The Southern Manifesto (Text and Signatories) Website Printout DX 274 Results of SurveyUSA Market Research Study Number 20443 Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 275 Article, Effects of Identification Requirements on Voting: Evidence From

the Experiences of Voters on Election Day, by Ansolabehere DX 276 Essay, Vote Fraud in the Eye of The Beholder: The Role of Public Opinion

in the Challenge to Voter Identification Requirements, by Ansolabehere and Persily


DX 277 Quinnipiac University Poll, by Peter Brown, For Release February 21, 2013


DX 278 Article, Broad Support for Photo ID Voting Requirements, by Pew Research Center, October 11, 2012


DX 279 Citizens Without Proof: A Survey Of Americans' Possession of Documentary Proof of Citizenship And Photo Identification, Brennan Center for Justice at NYU School of Law

DX 280 The Texas Voter ID Law and the 2014 Election: A Study of Texas' 23rd Congressional District, by Governor Bill Hobby, et al., August 2015

DX 281 Maryland State Board of Elections, Early Voting, Website Printout Plaintiffs Hearsay; Relevance FRE 401, 401, 801, 802DX 282 Article, "Much Ado About Nothing? An Empirical Assessment of the

Georgia Voter Identification Statute," by Hood and Bullock Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 283 IN.gov, Photo ID Law, Website Printout Plaintiffs Hearsay; Relevance FRE 401, 401, 801, 802DX 284 NCSL, Voter Identification Requirements, Voter ID Laws Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

Page 13 of 23




DX 285 New York Times Op-Ed, Voting Reform Is In the Cards DX 286 Article, "On Judging the Significance of Differences by Examining the

Overlap Between Confidence Intervals," by Schenker and Gentleman Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 287 Cornell University, Cornell Statistical Consulting Unit, StatNews No. 73, Overlapping Confidence Intervals and Statistical Significance, October 2008


DX 288 Handbook of Biological Statistics, Confidence Limits Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 289 Article, "Do Non-citizens Vote U.S. Elections?" By Richman, et al. Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 290 CCES Dataverse Homepage Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 291 Article, "The Perils of Cherry Picking Low Frequency Events in Large

Sample Surveys," by Ansolabehere, et al. DX 292 The Washington Post Monkey Cage Blog "Could non-citizens Decide The

November Election?" by Richman and EarnestPlaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 293 The Washington Post Monkey Cage Blog "Methodological Challenges Affect the Study of Non-Citizens' Voting," by Tesler

DX 294 The Washington Post Monkey Cage Blog, "What Can We Learn About the Electoral Behavior of Non-Citizens From a Survey Designed to Learn About Citizens?" By Ahlquist and Gehlbach

DX 295 RGJ.com Article, "Fact Checker Updated: Will Noncitizen Voters Help Dems?" by Robison


DX 296 Winter 2010 Virginia Capitol Connections Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 297 PBS Interview Transcript DX 298 Election Reform after HAVA article Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 299 Jim Crow 2.0 article DX 300 GAO Report DX 301 1/8/2016 Janet Thornton Expert Report Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 302 1/8/2016 Jesse Richman Expert Report Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 303 1/8/2016 Karen Owen Expert Report Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 304 1/8/2016 Daniel Palazzolo Expert Report Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 305 2/12/2016 Janet Thornton Declaration Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 306 Voter Identification Chart Rev 1/16 (Edgardo Cortes Deposition Exhibit

16)DX 307 Voter Photo ID Statistics 7/1/2014-7/23/2015 (Edgardo Cortes

Deposition Exhibit 17)DX 308 Financial Summary – Project Expenditure by Account Voter Photo ID

(Edgardo Cortes Deposition Exhibit 19)DX 309 Voter Photo Identification Card Application (Susan Lee Deposition

Exhibit 8)Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 310 § 5 Submission for Chapter 839 of the 2012 Acts of Assembly to Department of Justice

Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet received; Hearsay

FRE 801, 802

DX 311 Provisional Ballots 2012 Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet received; Hearsay

FRE 801, 802

DX 312 “In-Person Voting,” Virginia Department of Elections, accessed at http://elections.virginia.gov/casting-a-ballot/in-person-voting/


Page 14 of 23




DX 313 “Military Active-Duty Personnel, Civilians by State,” accessed at http://www.governing.com/gov-data/military-civilian-active-duty-employee-workforce-numbers-by-state.html


DX 314 “Photo ID Required to Vote,” Virginia Department of Elections, accessed at http://elections.virginia.gov/registration/photo-ids-required-to-vote/


DX 315 “Post Election Update: Local Canvass Information,” Virginia Department of Elections press release dated November 6, 2014, accessed at https://elections.virginia.gov/Files/Media/ELECTPressRelease-11-6-2014-


DX 316 “Profile of SNAP Households,” March 2015, United States Department of Agriculture, Food and Nutrition Service, Office of Policy Support, accessed at http://www.fns.usda.gov/sites/default/files/ops/Virginia.pdf


DX 317 “SNAP – Screening for Eligibility & Applying,” Virginia Department of Social Services, accessed at http://www.dss.virginia.gov/benefit/snap.cgi


DX 318 “System Map,” GRTC Transit System, accessed at http://www.ridegrtc.com/planning-your-trip/system-map/


DX 319 “Total fall enrollment in degree-granting postsecondary institutions, by state or jurisdiction: Selected years, 1970 through 2012,” National Center for Education Statistics, Digest of Education Statistics 2013, Table 304.10, accessed at http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=98


DX 320 “Voter Photo ID Outreach Materials,” Virginia Department of Elections, accessed at http://elections.virginia.gov/registration/virginia-voter-photo-id-outreach-materials/index.html


DX 321 “Post Election Update: Local Canvass Information,” Virginia Department of Elections press release dated November 6, 2014, accessed at https://elections.virginia.gov/Files/Media/ELECTPressRelease-11-6-2014-PostElectionUpdate.pdf

Plaintiffs Hearsay (Duplicate of DX00315)

FRE 801, 802

DX 322 Voter Registration Application, accessed at http://elections.virginia.gov/Files/Forms/VoterForms/VoterRegistrationApplication.pdf

DX 323 “SNAP Community Characteristics – Virginia,” United States Department of Agriculture, Food and Nutrition Service, accessed at http://www.fns.usda.gov/ops/snap-community-characteristics-virginia


DX 324 “Summary of Virginia Registration & Turnout Statistics, November General Elections: 1976-Present,” Virginia Department of Elections, accessed at http://elections.virginia.gov/resultsreports/registration-statistics/registrationturnout-statistics/index.html


Page 15 of 23




DX 325 Voter Registration and No DMV-ID Statistics July 2015 (Janet Thornton Deposition Exhibit 3)


DX 326 List Maintenance Guidelines, accessed at http://elections.virginia.gov/Files/maintenance-reports/2013SBEListMaintenancereport.pdf


DX 327 Congressional Record excerpts: 148 Cong. Rec. S2527 (2002); 148 Cong. Rec. S10488 (2002); 148 Cong. Rec. S10489 (2002); 148 Cong. Rec. H7853-54 (2002); 148 Cong. Rec. S710 (2002); 148 Cong. Rec. S10419 (2002); 148 Cong. Rec. S10490; 148 Cong. Rec. S10492-93; 148 Cong. Rec. S10501 (2002); 148 Cong. Rec. S10515 (2002)

Plaintiffs Untimely

DX 328 Commission on Federal Election Reform (Carter-Baker Commission) Report, Building Confidence in U.S. Elections (Sept. 2005)


DX 329 Field Hearing in Atlanta, Georgia to Receive Testimony on Election Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet received; Hearsay

FRE 801, 802

DX 330 Reform Before the Sen. Comm. on Rules and Admin., 107th Cong. (2001) Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet received; Hearsay

FRE 801, 802

DX 331 Hearing on Federal Election Practices and Procedures Before the Sen. Comm. on Governmental Affairs, 107th Cong. (2001)

Plaintiffs Untimely; Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 332 Hearing on Federal Election Reform Before the House Comm. on Admin., 107th Cong. (2001)


DX 333 Hearing on H.R. 3295 "Help America Vote Act of 2001" Before the House Judiciary Comm., 107th Cong. (Dec. 5, 2001)


DX 334 Remarks by President Bush at Signing of H.R. 3295, The Help America Vote Act of 2002, October 29, 2002


FRE 801, 802

DX 335 Requirements for Voter Identification, Nat'l Conf. of State Legislatures (Feb. 1, 2007), available at http://www.ncsl.org/programs/legismgt/elect/taskfc/VoterIDReq.htm


FRE 801, 802

DX 336 Hearing before the U.S. Comm’n on Civil Rights (Oct. 13, 2006) Plaintiffs Untimely; Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 337 Hearing before the U.S. Election Assistance Comm'n (Dec. 7, 2006) Plaintiffs Untimely; Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 338 Hearing on H.R. 3295 Before the H. Comm. on the Judiciary, 107th Cong.

(2001), available at 2001 WL 1552086 (F.D.C.H.)Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet

received; HearsayFRE 801, 802

DX 339 H.R. 105-416, 105th Cong. (1998) Plaintiffs Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 340 Preliminary Findings of Joint Task Force Investigating Possible Election

Fraud, DEPT. OF JUSTICE, May 10, 2005Plaintiffs Hearsay; Relevance FRE 401, 402, 801, 802

DX 341 Remarks by President at Signing of H.R. 3295, The Help America Vote Act of 2002, October 29, 2002, 2002 WL 31415995 (White House)


DX 342 U.S. Department of Justice, Letter to Sen. Bond, Feb. 26, 2002, at http://www.usdoj.gov/crt/voting/hava/bond ltr.htm


DX 343 Michael Alvarez, Delia Bailey, Jonathan N. Katz, The Effect of Voter Identification Laws on Turnout, CAL. INST. OF TECH., Soc. Science Working Paper 1267 (Oct. 2007)


Page 16 of 23




DX 344 Randal C. Archibald, Arizona Ballot Could Become Lottery Ticket, N.Y. TIMES, July 17, 2006, A1

Plaintiffs Hearsay; Relevance FRE 401, 402, 801, 802

DX 345 Bruce Ashton, Dead Man Voting, THE RIVERFRONT TIMES, Apr. 4, 2002 Plaintiffs Hearsay; Relevance FRE 401, 402, 801, 802

DX 346 Michael Barone, Web Blog, Message to the Secretaries of State: 1679 and 2006, U.S. NEWS AND WORLD REPORT, Feb. 6, 2006, available at: http://www.usnews.com/blogs/barone/2006/2/6/message-to-the-secretaries-of-state-1679-and-2006.html


DX 347 Greg Borowski, Inquiry Finds Evidence of Fraud in Election: Cast ballots outnumber voters by 4,609, MILWAUKEE JOUR. SENT., May 11, 2005, 1A


DX 348 Russ Buettner, Exposed: Scandal of Double Voters, N.Y. DAILY NEWS, Aug. 22, 2004, 4


DX 349 Tracy Campbell, DELIVER THE VOTE: A HISTORY OF ELECTION FRAUD, AN AMERICAN POLITICAL TRADITION – 1742-2004 (2005) – Selected Excerpts.


FRE 801, 802

DX 350 Jimmy Carter, TURNING POINT (1995) – Selected Excerpts. Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet received; Hearsay

FRE 801, 802

DX 351 Lisa M. Collins, In Michigan Even the Dead Vote, DETROIT NEWS, Feb. 26, 2006, 1A


DX 352 David DeCamp, Double Voting Being Investigated, FLA. TIMES-UNION, Jan. 25, 2005, B-1


DX 353 Developments in the Law: Voting and Democracy, 119 HARV. L. R. 1127 (2005)


FRE 801, 802

DX 354 Geoff Dougherty, Dead Voters on Rolls, Other Glitches Found in 6 Key States, CHICAGO TRIBUNE, Dec. 4, 2004, C13


DX 355 Editorial, Miserable Tradition, ST. LOUIS POST DISPATCH, Dec. 11, 2000, B2


DX 356 Keith Erwin, Potential Fraud Feared In Drive To Sign Up Voters, SEATTLE TIMES, Feb. 23, 2007, B1


DX 357 Keith Erwin, Three Plead Guilty in Fake Voter Scheme, SEATTLE TIMES, Oct. 30, 2007, B5


DX 358 Keith Erwin, Woman Registers Her Dog to Vote; Prosecutors Growl, SEATTLE TIMES, June 22, 2007, B1


DX 359 The Florida Election Debacle: Can it Happen in Missouri?, JOUR. OF THE MISSOURI BAR, Nov-Dec 2001, 294-30


DX 360 John Fund, Opinion Journal, How to Run a Clean Election, What Mexico can teach the United States, WALL STREET JOUR., July 10, 2006, available at: http://www.opinionjournal.com/diary/?id=110008630

Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet received; Hearsay; Relevance

FRE 401, 402, 801, 802

DX 361 John Fund, STEALING ELECTIONS: HOW VOTER FRAUD THREATENS OUR DEMOCRACY (2004) – Selected Excerpts.


FRE 801, 802

DX 362 John Fund, WALL STREET JOUR., Opinion Journal, May 21, 2006, available at: http://www.opinionjournal.com/diary/?id=110008411


Page 17 of 23




DX 363 Susan Greene & Karen E. Crummy, Voter Fraud Probed in State Double Dippers, DENVER POST, Mar. 24, 2005, A-01


DX 364 Andrew Gumbel, STEAL THIS VOTE: DIRTY ELECTIONS AND THE ROTTEN HISTORY OF DEMOCRACY IN AMERICA (2005)


FRE 801, 802

DX 365 Mark F. (Thor) Hearne II, The Missouri Voter’s Protection Act – Real Election Reform for All Missouri Voters, ST. LOUIS LAWYER (June 2006)


FRE 401, 402, 801, 802

DX 366 Scott Hiaasen, Dave Davis and Julie Carr Smyth, Voters Double-Dip in Ohio, Fla., CLEVELAND PLAIN DEALER, Oct. 31, 2004


DX 367 Lawsuit Off Base In Challenging Voter ID Rules, ARIZ. DAILY STAR, May 15, 1006, A6

Plaintiffs Untimely; Hearsay; Relevance

FRE 401, 402, 801, 802

DX 368 John R. Lott Jr. & Maxim C. Lott, Look South: Americans could learn from Mexican elections, NATIONAL REVIEW ON-LINE, July 6, 2006, at http://article.nationalreview.com


FRE 401, 402, 801, 802

DX 369 Jim Ludwick, Critics: Mail-in Voters Should Show ID, Too, ALBUQUERQUE JOUR., Sept. 12, 2005, A1


FRE 401, 402, 801, 802

DX 370 Man Arrested After Voter Forms Turned in For Mary Poppins, Michael Jordan, Ohio Officials Say, THE ASSOCIATED PRESS, Oct. 19, 2004


DX 371 Dan McKay, Voter Picture ID Has Wide Support, ALBUQUERQUE JOUR., Aug. 24, 2005, A1


DX 372 Jeffrey Milyo, TRUMAN INST. OF PUB. POLICY, Report No. 10-2007, The Effects of Photographic Identification on Voter Turnout in Indiana: A County-Level Analysis (Nov. 2007), available at http://truman.missouri.edu/uploads/Publications/Report%2010-2007 pdf


DX 373 Missouri's Most Important Politician, 1999-2000 OFFICIAL STATE MANUAL


FRE 401, 402, 801, 802

DX 374 Doug Moore, Auditor Criticizes Election Board, ST. LOUIS POST-DISPATCH, May 26, 2004, C4


DX 375 NBC/WALL-STREET JOUR. Survey, available at: http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/poll20060426.pdf


DX 376 New ID Rule Passes Test, ALBUQUERQUE JOUR., Nov. 16, 2005, B1 Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet received; Hearsay; Relevance

FRE 401, 402, 801, 802

DX 377 Richard A. Posner, BREAKING THE DEADLOCK: THE 2000 ELECTION, THE CONSTITUTION, AND THE COURTS (2001) – Selected Excepts.


FRE 401, 402

DX 378 Questions Abound in Voter Push, KANSAS CITY STAR, Oct. 12, 2006, B1 Plaintiffs Hearsay; Relevance FRE 401, 402, 801, 802

DX 379 Greg Reeves, One Person, One Vote? Not Always, KANSAS CITY STAR, Sept. 5, 2004, A1.


DX 380 Report by Secretary of State Matt Blunt, Mandate for Reform: Election Turmoil in St. Louis (July 2001)


FRE 401, 402, 801, 802

Page 18 of 23




DX 381 Report by Secretary of State Rebecca McDowell Cook, Analysis and General Recommendation Report Regarding the November, 2000 General Election in the City of St. Louis 8-9 (Jan. 4, 2001)


FRE 401, 402, 801, 802

DX 382 Requirements for Voter Identification, Nat'l Conf. of State Legislatures (Feb. 1, 2007), available at: http://www.ncsl.org/programs/legismgt/elect/taskfc/VoterIDReq.htm

Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet received

DX 383 John M. Schaff, Utah Auditor General, to John L. Valentine, Utah State Senate President (Feb. 8, 2005), available at: http://le/utah.gov/audit/05 01ilr.pdf


DX 384 Brad Shannon, Fraud Alleged in 2004 Washington Voter-Registration Drive, THE OLYMPIAN, June 23, 2007, 1C


DX 385 Amy Sherman, Double-Voters’ Names Going to Prosecutors, MIAMI HERALD, Nov. 14, 2004, 5B


DX 386 Stephanie Simon, In St. Louis, Dead Are Causing Lively Debate with Their Votes, LOS ANGELES TIMES, February 28, 2001, A1


DX 387 U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service, Office of Policy and Planning, Estimates of the Unauthorized Immigrant Population Residing in the United States: 1990 to 2000, at 15, Table 1 (Jan. 2003), available at: http://www.uscis.gov/graphics/shared/aboutus/statistics/Ill_Report_1211 pdf


DX 388 Matt Wynn, Deceased Still On State's Voting Rolls, COLUMBIA MISSOURIAN, Nov. 2, 2006, 1A


DX 389 Marc Perrusquia, 3 District 29 Poll Workers Indicted, Accused of Faking Votes to Help Elect Ophelia Ford, MEMPHIS COMMERCIAL APPEAL, June 22, 2006.


DX 390 Lorraine C. Minnite, THE MYTH OF VOTER FRAUD, Cornell Univ. Press, 2011.

DX 391 Lorraine C. Minnite, Voter Identification Laws: The Controversy over Voter Fraud, LAW AND ELECTION POLITICS (Matthew Streb, ed.) (2013).

DX 392 Andrew Gumbel, STEAL THIS VOTE, Nation Books, 2005. Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet received; Hearsay

FRE 401, 402

DX 393 Video available at http://www.theguardian.com/world/video/2012/oct/25/voter-fraud-democrat-congressmans-son-patrick-moran-video.


FRE 401, 402

DX 394 Quinnipiac University Polling Center, February 21, 2013, “Virginia Voters Back Photo ID for Voting 3-1, Quinnipiac University Poll Finds.” Available at: http://www.quinnipiac.edu/news-and-events/quinnipiac-university-poll/virginia/release-detail?ReleaseID=1854


DX 395 Hood and Bullock, Much Ado About nothing? An Empirical Assessment of the Georgia Voter Identification Statute, STATE POLITICS AND POLICY QUARTERLY 12(4) 2012.


Page 19 of 23




DX 396 Pastor, et. al., Voter ID’s are Not the Problem: A Survey of Three States, Center for Democracy and Election Management, American University. 2008.


DX 397 Erickson and Minnite, Modeling Problems in the Voter Identification – Voter Turnout Debate, ELECTION LAW JOURNAL, Vol. 8, No. 2 (2009).

DX 398 Stephen Ansolabehere and Nathaniel Persily, Vote Fraud in the Eye of the Beholder: The Role of Public Opinion in the Challenge to Voter Identification Requirements, 121 HARVARD LAW REVIEW 1737 (2008)

DX 399 Virginia 2014 U.S. Senate election exit poll data (NBC), available at: http://www.nbcnews.com/politics/elections/2014/VA/senate/exitpoll


DX 400 Virginia 2014 U.S. Senate election exit poll data (CBS), available at: http://www.cbsnews.com/elections/2014/senate/virginia/exit/#


DX 401 Virginia 2006 U.S. Senate election exit poll data (CNN), available at: http://www.cnn.com/ELECTION/2006/pages/results/states/VA/S/01/epolls.0.html


DX 402 Virginia election results – provisional ballots Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet received; Hearsay

FRE 801, 802

DX 403 General Registrars and Electoral Board Handbook 2015 Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet received; Hearsay

FRE 801, 802


FRE 801, 802


FRE 801, 802


FRE 801, 802


FRE 801, 802

DX 408 VSBE 2015 voter identification training manual Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet received; Hearsay

FRE 801, 802

DX 409 Virginia election statutes Plaintiffs Relevance FRE 401, 402DX 410 Virginia Register of Regulations v.30 n.22 (June 30, 2014), available at:

http://register.dls.virginia.govDX 411 Virginia HB 9 legislative history, available at: http://lis.virginia.gov/cgi-

bin/legp604.exe?121+sum+HB9DX 412 Virginia SB 1256 legislative history, available at:

http://lis.virginia.gov/cgi-bin/legp604.exe?131+sum+SB1256DX 413 Virginia 2012 voter identification law preclearance materials Plaintiffs Untimely; Not yet

received; HearsayFRE 801, 802

Page 20 of 23




DX 414 Voter identification statutes: Indiana (§ 3-5-2-40.5, 3-10-1-7.2 and 3-11-8-25.1), North Carolina, South Carolina (§ 7-13-710), Georgia (21-2-417), Missouri, and Wisconsin (§ 5.02(6m) and 6.79(2)(a))

Plaintiffs Untimely; Relevance FRE 401, 402

DX 415 Brian Knight. July 2014. “An Econometric Evaluation of Competing Explanations for the Midterm Gap.” Working Paper No. 20311. The National Bureau of Economic Research.


FRE 801, 802

DX 416 Data from http://elections.virginia.gov/registration/photo-ids-required-to-vote/. Accessed January 4, 2016


FRE 801, 802

DX 417 David B. Muhlhusen and Keri Weber Sikich “New Analysis Shows Voter Identification Laws Do Not Reduce Turnout.” A Report of the Heritage Center for Data Analysis. www.heritage.org/Research/LegalIssues/cda07-04 cfm


DX 418 http://www.surveyusa.com/client/PollPrint.aspx?g=8c5c6269-5692-483a-a5f0-9662c4e5567e&d=0


DX 419 Jason D. Mycoff, Michael W. Wagner and David C. Wilson, "The Empirical Effects of Voter-ID Laws: Present or Absent?" PS: Political Science and Politics 42 (January 2009): 121-126


DX 420 John W. Kingdon. 2011. Agenda, Alternatives and Public Policies, 2nd Edition. Longman Publishers: Boston, MA, page 65


DX 421 Learning Curve." PS:Political Science and Politics 42 (January 2009): 117-120.


FRE 801, 802

DX 422 M. V. Hood, III, and Charles S. Bullock, III, “Much Ado about Nothing: An Empirical Assessment of the Georgia Voter Identification Statute.” State Politics and Policy Quarterly 12 (2012): 394 - 414


DX 423 Mark Hugo Lopez and Ana Gonzalez-Barrera. “Latino Voter Interest and Engagement.” Pew Research Center. October, 11, 2012. http://www.pewhispanic.org/2012/10/11/latino-voter-interest-and-engagement/


DX 424 Markus Schmidt. “Democrats Challenge Va. Photo ID law in court.” Richmond Times-Dispatch. June 11, 2015


DX 425 Quinnipiac University Polling Center. February 21, 2013. “Virginia Voters Back Photo Id for Voting 3-1, Quinnipiac University Poll Finds; Let Home-School Kids Play on School Teams, Voters Say.” Accessed at http://www.quinnipiac.edu/news-and-events/quinnipiac-university-poll/virginia/release-detail?ReleaseID=1854


DX 426 R. Michael Alvarez, Delia Bailey and Jonathan Katz, "The Effect of Voter Identification Laws on Turnout." (Pasadena, CA: CalTech/MIT Voting Technology Project, 2008)


DX 427 Richard Fenno. 1978. Home Style. Pearson, Boston, MA. Plaintiffs Untimely; Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 428 Robert Erikson and Lorraine Minnite, “Modeling Problems in the Voter

Identification—Voter Turnout Debate.” Election Law Journal 8(2009); 85-101

Plaintiffs Untimely

Page 21 of 23




DX 429 Stephen Ansolabehere and Nathaniel Persily, “Voter Fraud in the Eye of the Beholder: The Role of Public Opinion in the Challenge to Voter Identification Requirements,” Harvard Law Review 121 (2008), 1737 – 1774


DX 430 Stephen Ansolabehere, “Effects of Identification Requirements on Voting: Evidence from the Experiences of Voters on Election Day,” PS: Political Science and Politics (January 2009): 129

Plaintiffs Untimely

DX 431 The Almanac of American Politics 2014 Plaintiffs Untimely; Hearsay FRE 801, 802DX 432 Timothy Vercellotti and David Anderson, "Voter-Identification

Requirements and the Plaintiffs Untimely; Hearsay FRE 801, 802

DX 433 Trip Gabriel. “Virginia Lawmakers Pass Photo-ID Requirement for Voters.” The New York Times. (February 20, 2013). www.nytimes.com/2013/02/21/us/virginia-lawmakers-pass-photo-ID-voting-requirement html


DX 434 Virginia Department of Elections. http://elections.virginia.gov/resultsreports/registration-statistics/registrationturnout-statistics/index.html


FRE 801, 802

DX 435 Virginia Department of Elections. http://elections.virginia.gov/resultsreports/registration-statistics/registrationturnout-statistics/index.html


FRE 801, 802

DX 436 “U.S. gives preclearance to Virginia voter ID law,” Richmond Times Dispatch, August 12, 2012


FRE 801, 802

DX 437 Citrin Jack, Green Donald P., and Levy Morris. 2014. Election Law Journal: Rules, Politics, and Policy. June 2014


DX 438 Don Palmer, Faulty Data Fuel Challenges to Voter ID Laws, The Heritage Foundation Backgrounder No. 3069 (2016)


DX 439 Heather Ginsburg, “Over 40,000 People Are Registered to Vote in Both Virginia and Maryland,” Townhall.com, April 23, 2014, at: http://townhall.com/tipsheet/heatherginsberg/2014/04/23/cantor-goes-negative-in-ad-againstprimary-opponent-n1828238. For more on the Virginia Voters Alliance


DX 440 Jason D. Mycoff, Michael W. Wagner, & David C. Wilson, The Empirical Effects of Voter ID Laws: Present or Absent, 42 PS: POL. SCI. & POL. 121 (2009)


DX 441 John Fund, Report: New York Investigators Obtain Fraudulent Ballots 97 Percent of the Time, National Review, December 31, 2013


DX 442 Nielson, Lindsay. 2015. “Examining the Effects of Voter Identification Laws on Politically Disadvantaged Populations.” http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract id=2490043


DX 443 Richman, Chattha & Earnest, Do Non-citizens Vote in U.S. Elections, Electoral Studies 36 (2014)


DX 444 Rocha, Rene R., and Tetsuya Matsubayashi. 2014. “The Politics of Race and Voter ID Laws in the States: The Return of Jim Crow?” Political Research Quarterly, 67 (3) 666-679


FRE 801, 802

Page 22 of 23




DX 445 The Heritage Foundation, A Sampling of Election Fraud Cases from Across the Country


DX 446 The Heritage Foundation, Does Your Vote Count? Ensuring Election Integrity and Making Sure Every Vote Counts


DX 447 Tom Howell, Jr., Voter ID Activist Posing as Eric Holder OK’d at DC Primary Polls, Washington Times, April 9, 2012


Page 23 of 23
