-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
1/88
Ziqnvts Noc`clgtcil Tmvi~em Vcbn
Vnrngvbm Grrcrtglbn -ZNTVVG#/ 73336::4g zviknbt a~ldnd fs DACD/ `glgend fs CVVC cl boirn bioogfivgtcil uctm FVVC
Ongvlclegldn}znvcnlbnr
iatmnZNTVVGzviknbt/FGLEOGDNRM
ZNTVVG -gl n}znvc`nlt
cl zvi-ziivgevcb~ot~vgo
vnrngvbmNdctnd fs Lino Z, @geiv/ Gm`gd Rgogm~ddcl/
@g`~l~o Mgw~n/ Tgzgrm H, Fcrugr gld @gtt Fgllnv`gl
FIIH; 2)7:
ZNTVVG ziocbs fvcnarZNTVVG ziocbs fvcnar
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
2/88
Fiih 2, ZNTVVG ziocbs fvcnar
2,7 Avi` tnbmlioies ti ocqnocmiidr
2,6 Tnbmlioies/ nltcton`nltr gld avnndi` ia bmicbn
2,2 Zgtmugsr avi` ziqnvts;
mi~rnmiod onqno zvibnrrnr ia evgd~gtcil
2,4 Zvi`itcle v~vgo lil-agv` nbili`s ia Fgleogdnrm
2,> Avi` tnbmlioiecnr gld nltnvzvcrnr ti
`ivn r~rtgclgfon ocqnocmiidr
2,1 @gzzcle ziqnvts ia v~vgo Fgleogdnrm;
c`zocbgtcil ia zvi-ziiv dnqnoiz`nlt
2,5 Lgt~vn gld c`zgbtr ia ui`nl%r zgvtcbczgtcil cl
nbili`cb gbtcqctcnr cl v~vgo Fgleogdnrm
2,= Vcbn rnnd dnocqnvs rsrtn` gld
rnnd ziocbs cl Fgleogdnrm
2,3 Vcbn vnrngvbm gld ziqnvts goonqcgtcil cl Fgleogdnrm
2,7: Ocfnvgocrgtcil ia tmn bviz Rnbtiv;
bgl Fgleogdnrm uctmrtgld vnecilgo bi`zntctcil9
2,77 Fcitnbmlioies aiv vcbn c`zviqn`nlt
2,76 Nlmglbcle v~vgo ocqnocmiidr lnnd lit birt tmn ngvtm
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
3/88
Avi` tnbmlioies ti ocqnocmiidrAvi` tnbmlioies ti ocqnocmiidrGogrtgcv U, Ivv/ Agtc`g K, Rnn`g/ Rmgcog G, Lgfc gld Kghcv~o C, Zntnv
Ziocbs
fvcna li, 2,7
CLTVID^BTCILGevcb~ot~vn%r vion cl noc`clgtcle ziqnvts clFgleogdnrm mgr fnnl bmgoonlend fs tmneviutm ia tmn v~vgo lil-agv` rnbtiv, Tmcrmgr ond ti bogc`r tmgt %mgldr lit ogld%zviqcdn tmn `gcl zgtmugs avi` ziqnvts,
Gbbivdcle ti tmcr qcnu/ gevcb~ot~vn ucoobiltcl~n ti fn c`zivtglt aiv aiid rnb~vcts/f~t ct ucoo li oilenv zogs tmn dslg`cb vionct ilbn dcd d~vcle tmn evnnl vnqio~tcil, Liutmgt Fgleogdnrm cr rnoa-r~aacbcnlt cl vcbn/itmnv rnbtivr ia tmn nbili`s ucoo zviqcdntmn nlecln ia eviutm,
Gevcb~ot~vn%r ifct~gvs rnn`r zvn`gt~vn/miunqnv, Nqcdnlbn avi` ZiqnvtsNoc`clgtcil Tmvi~em Vcbn Vnrngvbm
Grrcrtglbn%r -ZNTVVG# tnbmlioies r~f
zviknbtr -RZr# bilqclbcleos dn`ilrtvgtnrtmgt gevcb~ot~vn gld zgvtcb~ogvos vcbn mgqn
oirt liln ia tmncv vnonqglbn cl bvngtclelnu nbili`cb izzivt~lctcnr aiv vnri~vbnziiv mi~rnmiodr/ gld tmgt tmns `gs mgqng `~bm ucdnv c`zgbt il ocqnocmiidr tmglrc`zos c`zviqcle bviz scnodr ivmi~rnmiod aiid rnb~vcts, ^laivt~lgtnos/tmn oclhgenr fntunnl tnbmlioies gldocqnocmiidr gvn lit gougsr bgzt~vnd cltnbmlcbgo nqgo~gtcilr, Gr g vnr~ot/ tmn
dslg`cb vion tmgt gevcb~ot~vn `gs
biltcl~n ti zogs cl noc`clgtcle v~vgoziqnvts cr ngrcos iqnvoiihnd,
Tmcr ziocbs fvcna n}zoivnr tmnrn ucdnv
dc`nlrcilr ia c`zgbt il ocqnocmiidr aiv
ai~v rnonbtnd tnbmlioies RZr, Tmns
unvn dnocfnvgtnos rnonbtnd fnbg~rn tmns
unvn tnbmlcbgoos r~bbnrra~o/ vnzvnrnltnd
dcaanvnlt tsznr ia tnbmlioies gld biqnvnd
tmn dcaanvnlt vnecilr umnvn ZNTVVG
uivhnd, Tmn RZr gld oibgtcilr qcrctnd gvn
ecqnl cl Tgfon 7,
Tmn `gcl w~nrtcilr gddvnrrnd fs tmcr
fvcna gvn;
Miu mgr tmn lnu tnbmlioies bmglend
ocqnocmiidr g`ile zgvtcbczgtcle
mi~rnmiodr gld cl tmn bi``~lcts gr g
umion9
Miu mgr tmn lnu tnbmlioies bmglendocqnocmiidr aiv ui`nl9
Miu zviactgfon gld miu gzzvizvcgtnmgr tmn lnu tnbmlioies fnnl aivvnri~vbnziiv agv` mi~rnmiodr9
Ti glrunv tmnrn w~nrtcilr/ un qcrctnd ngbmRZ gld dcrb~rrnd tmnrn crr~nr uctm
zgvtcbczgtcle mi~rnmiodr, Un mnod
`nntcler uctm `c}nd evi~zr/ uctm
R~f-zviknbt Ongd genlbs Dcrtvcbt qcrctnd Oibgo zgvtlnv
Rnnd mngotm CVVC Fievg VDG
Cltnevgtnd bviz FVVC Tmgh~vegil VDVR `glgen`nlt -CB@#
Vcbnd~bh FVVC Rsomnt ACQDF
Bigrtgo ugtnv FVVC Hm~olg MNND vnri~vbnr
Tgfon 7, R~fzviknbtr/ oibgtcilr gld genlbcnr aiv bgrn rt~dcnr
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
4/886
Avi` tnbmlioies ti ocqnocmiidr
rnzgvgtn evi~zr ia `nl gld ui`nl/ uctmagv` mi~rnmiodr/ gld uctm oibgoeiqnvl`nlt vnzvnrnltgtcqnr, Un ~rnd`gclos w~goctgtcqn `ntmidr gld tmn vnr~otrgvn lit g dnaclctcqn %ocqnocmiidr g~dct%, F~t
tmns di bgzt~vn tmn r~vzvcrcle vglen iac`zgbtr fs umgt `cemt gzzngv ti fnlgvviu/ %tnbmlioies% zviknbtr/ umcbm mgrc`zocbgtcilr aiv miu gevcb~ot~vn `cemt fn~rnd gr gl nltvsziclt aiv zvievg``nr tinoc`clgtn v~vgo ziqnvts, Dntgcond vnr~otr`gs fn ai~ld cl tmn ivceclgo vnzivt -Ivv/Rnn`g/ Gvcag Lgfc gld Zntnv/ 6::4#,
HNS OCLHGENR Tmn c`zgbt ia lnu tnbmlioies cr ochntmviucle g rtiln clti g zild, Tmnc``ndcgtn c`zgbt cr anot gt tmn mi~rnmiodonqno/ uctm bmglenr cl tmn ~rn iavnri~vbnr/ gld cl i~tbi`nr ochn aiidrnb~vcts iv clbi`n, Itmnv i~tbi`nr `gsfn onrr ngrs ti `ngr~vn, Mcemnv clbi`nr`gs vnd~bn q~olnvgfcocts fs c`zviqcle tmn
mi~rnmiod%r gfcocts ti bizn uctm g bvcrcr/ ivvnr~ot cl fnttnv mngotm/ iv ecqn g lnu
annocle ia unoofncle gld bilacdnlbn, Tmnvczzonr avi` lnu tnbmlioies `gs gori
rzvngd i~t ti clbo~dn bmglenr cl grrntr/ grmi~rnmiodr clqnrt n}tvg clbi`n/ gld cllnu ocqnocmiid rtvgtnecnr/ gr mi~rnmiodrbmglen tmn ugs cl umcbm tmns ~rnvnri~vbnr, F~t tmn vczzonr di lit rtiz gt
tmn fi~ldgvs ia tmn mi~rnmiod, Tmnstvgqno i~tugvdr ti clbo~dn bmglenr cl
qcoogenr/ cl ribcgo vnogtcilrmczr/ iv nqnl clribcgo liv`r/ r~bm gr miu ui`nl `cemtfnmgqn, Gld tmns `gs tvgqno nqnl a~vtmnv/bmglecle vnogtcilrmczr uctm tmn ^lcil/vnrngvbm clrtct~tcilr/ gld uctm zvcqgtnf~rclnrr,
Ace~vn 7 rmiur g enlnvgocrnd zcbt~vn iatmn tszn ia ocqnocmiidr c`zgbt tmgt unvn
ai~ld cl tmnrn ai~v tnbmlioies RZr, Tmnbilbnltvcb bcvbonr vnzvnrnlt dcaanvnlt tsznria c`zgbt, Tmn dcaanvnlt onqnor vnzvnrnltdcaanvnlt zgvtr ia tmn r~rtgclgfonocqnocmiidr -RO# avg`nuivh, C`zgbt fneclr
uctm i~tbi`nr/ tmnl `iqnr ti bmglenr clbgzctgo grrntr/ fnaivn `iqcle ti bmglenr clocqnocmiid rtvgtnecnr iv tmn ugs tmgtmi~rnmiodr `ghn g ocqcle, Fnsild tmn
mi~rnmiod/ c`zgbt tmnl ongdr ti bmglenrcl %rtv~bt~vnr% iv clrtct~tcilr -clbo~dcle
ribcgo liv`r# gld %zvibnrrnr% iv tmn ugscl umcbm lnu tnbmlioies vngbmnr agv`nvr,
Ace~vn 7,
Avi` tnbmlioies ti ocqnocmiidr; g enlnvgocrnd idno
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,7
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
5/882
Avi` tnbmlioies ti ocqnocmiidr
OCQNOCMIID C@ZGBTR
Bmglenr cl i~tbi`nr
@ivn clbi`n
Lnu tnbmlioies vgcrnd clbi`nrcelcacbgltos/ nrznbcgoos ca tmn birt ia lilz~vbmgrnd clz~tr cr n}bo~dnd -Tgfon 6#,Clbi`n bg`n lit k~rt avi` mcemnv scnodrf~t avi` vnd~bnd n}znldct~vn il clz~tr,
C`zviqnd aiid rnb~vcts
Mcemnv clbi`n mgd gl c``ndcgtn c`zgbtil mi~rnmiod aiid rnb~vcts/ rclbn clbi`n
ugr `gdn `irtos cl tmn aiv` ia vcbn, Ilgqnvgen/ lnu tnbmlioies vgcrnd vcbnrnoar~aacbcnlbs fs 76 `iltmr)sngv,
Mi~rnmiod bgrnrt~dcnr ri`ntc`nrrmiund clbvngrnr ia 21 `iltmr,
&Un gvn gfon ti ngt nli~em tmvnn tc`nr g dgs&-CB@#,
&Rmn cr uctm rnnd mngotm gfi~t 5 rngrilr gld 4 sngvr gei rmn lnndnd ti z~vbmgrn vcbn aiv 24`iltmr, Aiv tmn ogrt 6 sngvr tmns di lit lnnd ti
z~vbmgrn gls vcbn evgcl&-rnnd mngotm#,
Fnttnv mngotm&Ca qcoogen dibtivr gvn lit gfon ti cdnltcas i~v
rcbhlnrr un bgl ei ti tmn rznbcgocrt cl Vglez~v&-CB@#,
Vnd~bnd q~olnvgfcocts
&Umnl un mgvqnrtnd ilos iln bviz un mgd ti
fivviu `ilns iv vcbn avi` tmn ungotmcnv ag`cocnrd~vcle tmn rngril&-bigrtgo ugtnv#,
&D~bh vngvcle cr g rgants gooiuglbn aiv tmnmi~rnmiod/ ca tmns lnnd gls bgrm `ilns tmns bglngrcos rnoo neer iv d~bhr&-vcbnd~bh#,
&Un ~rnd ti rnoo vcemt gatnv mgvqnrt f~t liu unbgl ugct aiv zvcbnr ti vcrn&-CB@#,
Clbvngrnd bilacdnlbn gld rnoanrtnn`
&Un ~rnd ti fog`n ziiv scnodr il fgd o~bh-hizgo hmgvgz#, Liu un hliu ct cr hliuonden
&D~bh vngvcle cr g rgants gooiuglbn aiv tmn
mi~rnmiod/ ca tmns lnnd gls bgrm `ilns tmnsbgl ngrcos rnoo neer iv d~bhr& -Vcbnd~bh#,
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,7
+ Agv`nvr vnzivtnd tmcr gr tmn `g}c`~` angrcfon gvng ia vcbn-d~bh tmgt bi~od fn `glgend fs iln mi~rnmiod
Tgfon 6, Bmglenr cl clbi`n vnr~otcle avi` lnu tnbmlioies
R~fZviknbt
Rnnd mngotm
Rnnd mngotm
Rnnd mngotm
CB@
CB@
CB@
Vcbn-d~bh
Vcbn-d~bh
Bigrtgo ugtnv
Bigrtgo ugtnv
Lnu tnbmlioies
Mngotms vcbn rnnd
@Q fivi uctm mngotms rnnd
@Q t, g`gl uctm mngotms rnnd
@Q t, g`gl ( vgfcbviz ( fivi
C`zviqnd cvvcegtcil
R~zzon`nltgvs cvvcegtcil aiv@Q t, g`gl
@Q vcbn( Hmghc Bg`zfnoo d~bhr
Vngvcle 2: d~bhr aiv rgon
@Q fivi
@Q t, g`gl
Lnt vnt~vlr iqnv n}crtcle
zvgbtcbn -bgrmbirt fgrcr#
5>
=/115
7>/22>
76/>43
--
77/15>
>77
1/>2>
77/7:>
6=/433
^lct
Th,)6: he,
Th,)mnbtgvn
Th,)mnbtgvn
Th,)mnbtgvn
Th,)mnbtgvn
Th,)mnbtgvn
Th,):,:1mnbtgvn+
Th,)sngv
Th,)mnbtgvn
Th,)mnbtgvn
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
6/884
Avi` tnbmlioies ti ocqnocmiidr
tmgt `ghnr zvid~btcil eiid iv fgd& -rnndmngotm#,
&Fnaivn un unvnl%t tvngtnd zioctnos umnl unqcrctnd tmn mi~rn ia g unoo-iaa znvril/ umi
grr~`nd un bg`n ti fivviu ri`ntmcle, Liu tmns evnnt ~r/ grh ~r ti tghn g rngt/ gld grh tmnz~vzirn ia i~v qcrct&-CB@#,
&Fnaivn un unvnl%t clqctnd ti tmn rgocrm/ gld i~vuivd ugrl%t tv~rtnd, Liu unoo-iaa znizon tv~rt~r gr uctlnrrnr cl qcoogen dcrz~tnr&-CB@#,
@ivn mgv`ils uctmcl tmn mi~rnmiod
&Umnl un ~rnd ti agco ti zvnrnvqn eiid w~goctsrnndr/ m~rfgldr ~rnd ti w~gvvno uctm ~r grhcle
ums un agcond&,&Umnl si~ gvn ziiv/ si~ dil%t uglt ti bilr~otuctm si~v ucan iv ag`cos `n`fnvr, %Tghg tmghon/f~dmmnn fmgoi%/ ri si~ anno ochn bilr~otcle itmnvr&-CB@#,
Bmglenr cl grrntr
M~`gl bgzctgo clbvngrnd tmvi~emc`zviqnd hliuonden ia @Q vcbnb~otcqgtcil/ gld lnu rhcoor cl rnndbonglcle/ d~bhvngvcle/ ugtnv`glgen`nlt/ gld anvtcocrnv ~rn, Ri`nrhcoor unvn fncle tvglranvvnd ti itmnvgbtcqctcnr/ aiv n}g`zon/ d~bh qgbbcln tizi~otvs/ gld rnnd bonglcle ti `gc{n8
Zmsrcbgo bgzctgo clbvngrnd gr rgqcler unvn clqnrtnd cl lnu grrntr, Vnzogbcletmgtbm uctm bivv~egtnd cvil viiaclergqnd tmn lnnd aiv gll~go vnzgcvr8
&Uctm tmn zviactr avi` vcbn rgonr mn mgr `glgend
ti f~s g biu/ tcl rmnntr aiv mcr mi~rn/ gld mcvn g
zvcqgtn t~tiv aiv mcr ril umi cr rt~dscle cl Bogrr
>&-bigrtgo ugtnv#,
Aclglbcgo bgzctgo clbvngrnd tmvi~em tmnrgon vcbn rnnd/ rnndocler/ zgdds/ `~rtgvd/gld neer, Tmcr `gdn ct ngrcnv aiv
mi~rnmiodr ti rgqn/ f~s boitmnr/ clqnrtcl nd~bgtcil aiv tmncv bmcodvnl/ entrnvqcbn oiglr avi` LEIr/ iv vnlt ogldaiv bgrm vgtmnv tmgl bvizrmgvn,
&Un bgl rgqn ri`n `ilns avi` n}znldct~vnr il
aiid fnbg~rn ia eiid zvid~btcil avi` vcbn&
-CB@#,
&Vcbn-d~bh mgr zviqcdnd tmn` uctm g octton n}tvgclbi`n/ vnd~bcle tmn lnnd aiv oiglr ti nd~bgtn mcr
nodnrt dg~emtnv&-vcbnd~bh#,
&Un unvn ungvcle rmivt-onletm %Tgtcgo% rgvc umcbm
un z~vbmgrnd aiv Th, 1:/ liu un ungv rgvcr
uivtm Th, 6::-2::&-CB@#,
Lgt~vgo bgzctgo clbvngrnd/ gr mi~rnmiodrgdiztnd mcemnvscnodcle @Qr/ ~rnd ogld
cl tmn dvs rngril/ cltvid~bnd cvvcegtcil/gld n}zgldnd tmn gvng tmns b~otcqgtnd,
&Tmcr cr tmn acvrt tc`n un gvn enttcle vcbn bviz tui
tc`nr g sngv&-bigrtgo ugtnv#,
Bmglenr cl ocqnocmiid rtvgtnecnr
Ui`nl%r clqioqn`nlt cl gevcb~ot~vnclbvngrnd gr tmns ongvlt lnu rhcoor, Tmnsfnegl ti zgvtcbczgtn cl acnod iznvgtcilr/ri`ntc`nr aiv tmn acvrt tc`n, Ui`nl`nltcilnd gbtcqctcnr ochn zvnzgvcle vcbnrnndfndr/ unndcle/ mgvqnrtcle gldbgvvscle bvizr avi` tmn acnod/ gldacldcle annd aiv d~bhr,
&Gt acvrt rmn anot rms ti uivh cl tmn vcbn acnodr, Ca
mnv agtmnv iv ~lbon rgu mnv/ rmn ~rnd ti mcdn cl tmn
%Tile% &-rnnd mngotm#,
Mcemvcrh rtvgtnecnr unvn vnzogbnd fsrtvgtnecnr uctm oiunv vcrhr gld mcemnvvnt~vlr,
&Rnrg`n ugr vcrhs ti mgvqnrt bi`zgvnd ti vcbn
fnbg~rn ct bgl fn ugrmnd gugs d~vcle `ilriil&-bigrtgo ugtnv#,
&Un ~rnd ti rnoo vcemt gatnv mgvqnrt f~t liuun bgl ugct aiv zvcbnr ti vcrn& -CB@#,
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,7
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
7/88>
Avi` tnbmlioies ti ocqnocmiidr
&Un gvn lit cltnvnrtnd ti rmgvnbviz gls `ivn/ unuglt ti uivh uctm i~v iul gevcb~ot~vgo ogld&-CB@#,
Gevcb~ot~vn zviqcdnd aclglbn aiv
rngrilgo/ lilagv` rtvgtnecnr,&Un gvn gfon ti rtgvt r`goo f~rclnrrnr ochn evibnvsrmizr/ qnentgfon rnoocle/ rnoocle `iogrrnr&-CB@#,
Bmglenr cl rtv~bt~vnr
Tmn r~bbnrr ia tmnrn zviknbtrvnaonbtnd clbo~rcil ia goo rtghnmiodnvr,Zviknbtr unvn c`zon`nltnd `irtos clzgvtlnvrmczr uctm LEIr iv oibgoeiqnvl`nlt, Lnu oclhgenr unvn bvngtndclqioqcle agv`nvr/ vnrngvbmnvr/ gld oibgoeiqnvl`nlt vnzvnrnltgtcqnr,
&Cl tmn acvrt sngv/ lilzgvtcbczgtcle agv`nvrzvitnrtnd gegclrt f~codcle n`fglh`nlt il bglgo,Tmns tmi~emt tmncv rnrg`n bviz ui~od fndg`gend, Tmn `n`fnv ia zgvocg`nlt -@Z# `gdntmn` ~ldnvrtgld gld `glgen tmn zvifon`r, Mngori mnoznd ongrclecl tmn bglgo avi` oibgo
eiqnvl`nlt&-bigrtgo ugtnv#,
&Liu foibh r~znvqcrivr bi`n ti ~r gld nqnl grh
~r aiv rio~tcilr&-rnnd mngotm#,
Bmglenr cl zvibnrrnr
Bmglecle gttct~dnr g`ile rbcnltcrtr,Agv`nvr% qcnur gld hliuonden mnozndgdgzt tmn lnu tnbmlioies ti `ghn ct`ivn vnonqglt gld gzzvizvcgtn aiv tmncvbcvb~`rtglbnr, Aiv n}g`zon/ agv`nvrrmiund rnnd mngotm vnrngvbmnvr tmgttmns bi~od rgqn ogfi~v fs vie~ncle ilosg zgvt/ vgtmnv tmgl tmn umion acnod/ gld
tmgt fngtcle vcbn rtgohr tmvnn tc`nrfnaivn tmvnrmcle vn`iqnd n`zts evgclr,Vcbnd~bh agv`nvr rmiund tmgt d~bhrbi~od fn r~bbnrra~oos vngvnd ~rcle oibgovnri~vbnr/ ucttmi~t tmn lnnd aivn}znlrcqn annd,
&Umgt C dcd cl tmn ogrt 76 sngvr ugr`nglcleonrr, Aiv tmn acvrt tc`n/ C vngocrn tmgt C g`dicle vnrngvbm uctm agv`nvr il tmncv vngo ocan
zvifon`r, C ugr g unoor~ctnd rbcnltcrt gld liu
`s gttct~dn cr bi`zontnos bmglend& -rnndmngotm#,
&Fnaivn un unvn gavgcd ia VDG, Ct cr g unoozvitnbtnd gvng gld fce iaacbnvr `gs lit tgoh uctm~r, Liu un gvn zvi~d ti tgoh ti rbcnltcrtr&-rnnd mngotm#,
Agv`nvr ongvlt gfi~t tmn lnutnbmlioies tmvi~em %ongvlcle fs dicle%vgtmnv tmgl aiv`go tvgclcle, Tmcrzviqcdnd tmn fgrcr aiv bi``~lcts fgrndn}tnlrcil/ uctm zgvtcbczgltr tvgclcletmncv lncemfi~vr gld agv`nvr avi`itmnv qcoogenr, Zgvtcbczgltr mnod acnoddgsr ti rmgvn hliuonden uctm itmnvr,
&Tmcr tvgclcle cr `ivn zvgbtcbgo gld vngo/ un bglzvgbtcbn ct cl i~v vngo ocan&-CB@#,
&Tvgclcle goiln crl%t nli~em ti dcrrn`clgtn lnutnbmlioies, Dn`ilrtvgtcil/ boirn oclhgen uctmvnrngvbmnvr/ gld biltcl~i~r ongvlcle cr nrrnltcgo tidcrrn`clgtn gld bi``~lcbgtn gls lnutnbmlioies& -~lcil zgvcrmgd X^ZP bmgcv`gl/rnnd mngotm#,
Tvgclcle ui`nl/ lit ilos cl rnndrtivgen gld bviz zvibnrrcle/ f~t cl tmn
umion vglen ia lnu vcbn tnbmlioies/
clbo~dcle rnndfnd zvnzgvgtcil/ anvtcocrnv~rn/ gld znrt `glgen`nlt, Tmcr gooiund
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,7
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
8/881
Avi` tnbmlioies ti ocqnocmiidr
tmn` ti rmgvn dnbcrcilr gfi~t vcbnb~otcqgtcil uctm tmncv m~rfgldr gld egqntmn` bilacdnlbn ti uivh cl tmn vcbnacnodr,
&Ca clrnbtr gttgbh vcbn/ ui`nl bgl cdnltcas tmn zvifon` gld claiv` tmncv m~rfgldr ti oiih aivrio~tcilr&-CB@#,
ENLNVGO BILBO^RCILR Umcon ngbm zviknbt ugr dcaanvnlt/ tmnsrmgvnd ri`n bi``il angt~vnr/ umcbmzviqcdn ~rna~o onrrilr,
Umgt cr `irt rtvchcle cr tmn rmnnv rbgon
ia tmn ocqnocmiid egclr, Gevcb~ot~vgotnbmlioies-
zgvtcb~ogvos lnu vcbntnbmlioies- bgl mgqn g fce c`zgbt cl g
qnvs rmivt tc`n, Ti vgcrn vcbn rnoar~aacbcnlbs fs 2 `iltmr cl k~rt iln sngviv k~rt iln rngril cr li `ngl angt, Ctbi`zgvnr agqi~vgfos uctm tmn r`goonv/`ivn evgd~go c`zgbt ia LEI `cbvibvndct zvievg``nr, Gevcb~ot~vn%r c`zgbtcr mcem fnbg~rn;
Vnt~vlr avi` ogld gvn mcemnv tmglilnr avi` `cbvinltnvzvcrn iv ugenogfi~v/ gld vcbn bgl fn eviul cl tuirngrilr8
Zgsfgbh znvcid cr rmivt fnbg~rn ilnrngril cr ilos aiv 2 `iltmr8 gld
Birtr gvn oiu fnbg~rn tnbmlioiesf~codr il rtvnletmr gld n}zoictr~l~rnd vnri~vbnr -ugtnv/ agooiu ogld/mi~rnmiod ogfi~v#,
C`zgbt ugr rcelcacbglt lit k~rt fnbg~rn ia
ctr rbgon f~t fnbg~rn ct clqioqnd vcbn, Tmn
bnltvgocts ia vcbn `ghnr ct g rtvile nltvs
ziclt aiv bmglecle ocqnocmiidr, Tc`n gld
gegcl/ mi~rnmiodr tiod ~r tmgt mgqcle
`ivn vcbn gooiund tmn` ti f~s `ivngrrntr/ ngt fnttnv/ fn mngotmcnv/ gld gori
bmglen tmncv fnmgqci~v/ w~gvvnocle onrr/
fncle `ivn ucoocle ti dcrb~rr zvifon`r/
gld g enlnvgo clbvngrn cl unoofncle gld
zngbn ia `cld, Clbvngrn cl clbi`n aiv g
ziiv mi~rnmiod/ gld si~ ucoo clbvngrn
n}znldct~vn il vcbn, Clbvngrn cl vcbn
zvid~btcil/ bgrm/ tc`n gld nlnves gvn
vnongrnd aiv itmnv gbtcqctcnr8
Clbi`n avi` lnu tnbmlioies ugrvnclqnrtnd cl gevcb~ot~vn gr unoo gr lil
agv` grrntr gld rtvgtnecnr, Tmnvn ugr li
ac}nd zgttnvl ia clqnrt`nlt/ umcbm
dnznldnd il mi~rnmiod bcvb~`rtglbnr,
F~t ct ugr bi``il ti acld mi~rnmiodrf~scle biur -umcbm zvid~bn `ivn grrntr
cl bgoqnr#/ f~scle clz~tr/ vnltcle `ivn
ogld/ gld ructbmcle avi` bviz rmgvn
biltvgbtr ti `ivtegen iv hmgchgogrmc/
umcbm gvn `ivn agqi~vgfon aiv tnlgltr,
Tmnvn ugr g litcbngfon zvnanvnlbn aiviul b~otcqgtcil iqnv lilagv` kifr ochn
ogfi~vcle iv qgldvcqcle/ umcbm unvn
oiuzgscle/ ri`ntc`nr vcrhs/ gld tiih
m~rfgldr gugs avi` mi`n, F~t
mi~rnmiodr unvn gori oiihcle tiugvdrtmn a~t~vn, Gld mnvn tmns unvn `ghcle
rgbvcacbnr aiv tmncv bmcodvnl/ clqnrtcle cl
nd~bgtcil gld mcvcle zvcqgtn t~tivr ti
ecqn tmn` g fnttnv a~t~vn, Tmcr clbo~dnd
nd~bgtcil aiv dg~emtnvr/ ri tmgt tmns`cemt ngvl gl clbi`n gatnv `gvvcgen,
Glitmnv ugs tmgt ZNTVVG%r RZr `gdngl c`zgbt il ocqnocmiidr ugr tmvi~em tmn
ugs tmns unvn c`zon`nltnd, Tmcr ugrzgvtcb~ogvos c`zivtglt aiv bmglenr clrtv~bt~vnr gld zvibnrrnr, Tui n}g`zonrrtgld i~t,
Ui`nl vnbncqnd tvgclcle cl goo grznbtria lnu vcbn tnbmlioies, Zvnqci~ros/
ui`nl ~rnd ti vnbncqn tvgclcle ilos clgbtcqctcnr aiv umcbm tmns unvn
&Ca clrnbtr gttgbh vcbn/ ui`nl bgl cdnltcas
tmn zvifon` gld claiv` tmncv m~rfgldr tioiih aiv rio~tcilr& -CB@#,
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,7
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
9/885
Avi` tnbmlioies ti ocqnocmiidr
tvgdctcilgoos vnrzilrcfon ochn rnndrtivgen iv bviz zvibnrrcle, Tmcrvnclaivbnd n}crtcle enldnv vionr gldn}bo~dnd ui`nl avi` `gls ia tmncvm~rfgld%r dnbcrcilr gfi~t gevcb~ot~vn,
Tvgclcle ui`nl mgr n`ziunvnd tmn`ti rmgvn cl dnbcrcil`ghcle gldr~znvqcrn mcvnd ogfi~v, Tmcr mgrclbvngrnd ui`nl%r rnoanrtnn` gld tmnsmgqn vnbncqnd vnrznbt avi` `nl, Unlitnd g eviucle %an`clcrgtcil% iagevcb~ot~vn gr ui`nl fnbg`n `ivnclqioqnd uctm acnod gbtcqctcnr, @nlgzzvnbcgtnd tmcr/ fnbg~rn ct rgqnd mcvcleogfi~v gld avnnd tmncv tc`n aiv itmnv
zvid~btcqn gbtcqctcnr, Un gori ai~ld tmgt`nl umirn ucqnr uivhnd cl tmn acnodr unvn ri`ntc`nr zvnzgvnd ti rmgvnbmcodbgvn gld ri`n di`nrtcb tgrhr8
Enldnvgugvnlnrr mgr vnzogbnd g lgqn/
~lctgvs `idno ia tmn agv` mi~rnmiod uctm iln fgrnd il rnzgvgtn enldnv
vionr, Tmcr cr ~rna~o aiv glgosrcr, F~t ctmgr gori ond ti rnzgvgtn %rzmnvnr ia
hliuonden% umnl ct bi`nr ti lnu
tnbmlioies, Fs tvngtcle ui`nl gld`nl nw~goos/ gr `n`fnvr ia iln
mi~rnmiod/ ZNTVVG mgr ecqnl ui`nlgbbnrr ti hliuonden tmgt tmns unvn
dnlcnd fnaivn, Cl iznvgtcilgo tnv`r/
tmnvnaivn/ tvngtcle tmn mi~rnmiod gr grcleon ~lct mgr ecqnl ui`nl ~loc`ctnd
gbbnrr ti lnu hliuonden/ uctmvn`gvhgfon vnr~otr, Tmcr `gs mgqn
c`zocbgtcilr aiv bmicbn ia rtvgtnecnr/ ca ui`nl mgqn dcaanvnlt zvcivctcnr avi`
`nl, Ca ui`nl gvn `ivn bilbnvlnd tinlr~vn tmgt bmcodvnl gvn unooli~vcrmnd/tmcr bi~od ongd ti evngtnv n`zmgrcr il
mi~rnmiod aiid rnb~vcts vgtmnv tmglbgrm clbi`n8
Oibgo eiqnvl`nlt bgl zogs g hns
vion cl rbgocle ~z gld tnbmlioies
dcrrn`clgtcil, ^Z bmgcv`nl gvngbbi~ltgfon ti tmn nonbtivgtn gld mgqn
g~tmivcts ti clctcgtn bmglen, Tmncv
zgvtcbczgtcil cr nrrnltcgo aiv ~rn iabi``il zviznvts vnri~vbnr -bigrtgo
ugtnv#, Tmns bgl %fvihnv% rnvqcbnr aiv
qcoogenvr avi` vnrngvbmnvr gld LEIr/gld foibh r~znvqcrivr `ivn naanbtcqnos
ca ~ldnv oibgo biltvio, Cl uivhcle uctmoibgo eiqnvl`nlt/ bgvn ucoo fn lnndnd
ri tmgt tmn aib~r il tmn vnri~vbnziivcr lit oirt8
Lnu tnbmlioies cl tmnrn ai~vzviknbtr ugr hliuondencltnlrcqn,
Tmcr hliuonden ugr lit ngrs tibi``~lcbgtn tmvi~em ilniaa%dn`ilrtvgtcilr% iv rc`zon%vnbi``nldgtcilr%, Agv`nvr mgd tiongvl fs dicle, Tmcr vnw~cvnd g lnu`idn ia uivhcle aiv rbcnltcrtr
clqioqcle agv`nv zgvtcbczgtcil/ cltnlrcqntvgclcle gld boirn r~znvqcrcil, Tmcrvnw~cvnd zgvtlnvrmczr uctm oibgoiveglcrgtcilr tmgt lit ilos hlnu tmntgvent evi~z -vnri~vbnziiv agv`nvr#f~t hlnu miu ti uivh uctm tmn` gldbi~od clbivzivgtn tvgclcle clti tmncvzvievg``nr8
Aiv tmn tmvnn zgvtlnv LEIr - VDVR/MNND/ gld FDR - tmcr ugr tmncv acvrt
&Un bgl rgqn ri`n `ilns avi` n}znldct~vnr
il aiid fnbg~rn ia eiid zvid~btcil avi`vcbn& -CB@#,
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,7
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
10/88
Avi` tnbmlioies ti ocqnocmiidr
n}znvcnlbn ia uivhcle dcvnbtos uctmvcbn, Tmncv `gcl gbtcqcts ugr `cbvi-bvndct aiv lil-agv` gbtcqctcnr, Tmncvclqioqn`nlt uctm gevcb~ot~vn ugraib~rnd il mi`nrtngd egvdnlcle, Liu
tmgt tmns mgqn rnnl tmn zitnltcgo ia lnuvcbn tnbmlioies aiv tmncv tgvent evi~z/tmns gvn hnnl ti biltcl~n, Tmcr `gvhrgl c`zivtglt rmcat cl tmncv znvbnztcil iagevcb~ot~vn gr g zgtmugs avi` ziqnvts8
ZNTVVG%r ntmir - znizon-aib~r/zgvtcbczgtivs/ enldnv-gugvn/zgvtlnvrmczr - mgr fnnl g zirctcqnn}znvcnlbn aiv vcbn rbcnltcrtr,
ZNTVVG%r n}znvcnlbn bongvos rmiur tmgt
vcbn tnbmlioies bgl mgqn g `~bm ucdnvc`zgbt il ocqnocmiidr tmgl `cemt fnr~rznbtnd, Tmcr r~eenrtr tmgt gevcb~ot~vnrtcoo mgr tmn zitnltcgo ti zogs g dslg`cbvion cl tmn noc`clgtcil ia v~vgo ziqnvts,
Gbmcnqcle tmcr eigo ucoo vnw~cvn g lgtcilgoziqnvts rtvgtnes tmgt `ghnr a~oo ~rn litilos ia %mgldr%/ f~t gori %ogld% gld gfiqngoo/ %mngdr%, F~t aiv gevcb~ot~vn ti zogs tmcrdslg`cb vion naanbtcqnos/ ZNTVVG%r
onegbs ia qgo~n-fgrnd vnrngvbm-
znizon-
aib~r/ zgvtcbczgtivs/ enldnv-gugvn/ gldzgvtlnvrmczr -- ucoo fn a~ldg`nltgo, Gldri ucoo fn tmn r~zzivt ia ziocbs `ghnvr clvngaacv`cle tmn ziunv ia lnu tnbmlioiesti tvglraiv` ocqnocmiidr,
&Fnaivn un unvn gavgcd ia VDG, Ct cr g unoozvitnbtnd gvng gld fce iaacbnvr `gs lit tgohuctm ~r, Liu un gvn zvi~d ti tgoh tirbcnltcrtr& -rnnd mngotm#,
Tmcr fvcna cr tmn i~tz~t ia 4 bgrn rt~dcnr aiv rnnd mngotm c`zviqn`nlt/ vcbn-d~bh agv`cle/ bigrtgo ugtnv
`glgen`nlt gld CB@ tnbmlioies r~f-zviknbtr bild~btnd aiv gl ~ldnvrtgldcle ia c`zgbt avi` tnbmlioies ti
ocqnocmiidr, Tmn dntgcond bgrn rt~ds vnzivtr gvn gqgcogfon cl ZNTVVG unfrctn zntvvg,cvvc,ive
R~eenrtnd bctgtcil;
Ivv/ G, U,/ Rnn`g/ A, K,/ Lgfc/ R, G, gld Zntnv/ K, C, 6::5, Avi` tnbmlioies ti ocqnocmiidr, Cl; @geiv/ L, Z,/ Rgogm~ddcl/
G,/ Mgw~n/ @,/ Fcrugr/ T, H, gld Fgllnv`gl/ @,/ ndctivr, ZNTVVG - gl n}znvc`nlt cl zviziiv gevcb~ot~vgo
vnrngvbm, Ziocbs fvcnar li, 2,7, Dmghg -Fgleogdnrm#; Ziqnvts Noc`clgtcil Tmvi~em Vcbn Vnrngvbm Grrcrtglbn
Zviknbt/ Cltnvlgtcilgo Vcbn Vnrngvbm Clrtct~tn, = z,
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,7
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
11/88
Lit oile gei/ tmn Lifno og~vngtn clNbili`cbr/ G`gvtgsg Rnl/ dnrbvcfnddnqnoiz`nlt gr n}zglrcil ia tmn rnt iabmicbnr ia tmn znizon, %Fneegvr bgllitfn bmiirnvr% - einr tmn gdgen uctm tmnc`zocbgtcilr tmgt gt zctca~oos oiu onqnor iaclbi`n/ znizon mgqn ti zvnanv nctmnv %tmcr%
iv %tmgt% bi``idcts f~ldon/ f~t lit fitm,Nbili`crtr bgoo ct g %bivlnv% rio~tcil cl glcldcaanvnlbn b~vqn glgosrcr ia bilr~`nvr/enlnvgoos tg~emt cl acvrt sngv nbili`cbrbogrrnr, F~t gr tmn clbi`n einr ~z/ znizontnld ti mgqn g bmicbn g`ile bi``idctsf~ldonr ti rgddon gt g ziclt umnvn tmnf~dent ocln - g zvi}s aiv gfcocts# cr tglenltti tmn cldcaanvnlbn b~vqn -g zvi}s aivzvnanvnlbn#, W~ctn ifqci~ros/ g tglenltrio~tcil cr zvnanvgfon ti g bivlnv rio~tcil
gr agv gr bilr~`nv unoagvn cr bilbnvlnd,
%RMCZ% tnbmlioies
Tnbmlioies gdiztcil cl gevcb~ot~vgozvgbtcbnr bi~od fn iln ia tmn hnsr tivgcrcle clbi`n, Tmn vcrn cl clbi`n bi~odgotnv tmn `gtvc} ia bmicbnr agbnd fs tmnmi~rnmiod iv bilr~`nv, Acvrt/ tnbmlioiesaiv tmn qnvs ziiv nlgfonr nltcton`nlt fsclbvngrcle tmn r~zzos ia aiid -aiv ziiv/
zvid~btcil ctrnoa cr nltcton`nlt gr tmnsbilr~`n umgt tmns zvid~bn# gld tmnlnlmglbn`nlt ia nltcton`nlt bi~od ongd tig qgvcnts ia bmicbnr tmgt tmn ziiv bi~odmgvdos tmclh ia cl tmn zvntnbmlioiesrtgtn,
Ti tmcr naanbt/ tmn c`zgbtr ia tmntnbmlioies ia tmn rnnd mngotmc`zviqn`nlt zviknbt -RMCZ# cr g bgrn clziclt, Cl rnqnl gvngr ia Fgleogdnrm;
Bm~gdgleg/ Fgvcrgo/ Vglez~v/ Fievg/
Mgfceglk/ Eg{cz~v gld Vgkrmgmc/ 2:agv`nvr avi` ngbm gvng mgqn vnbncqndtvgclcle il rnnd mngotm `glgen`nlt, Tmnagv`nvr gld tmncv rzi~rnr vnbncqndtvgclcle il %ums%/ %miu% gld %umnvn% rnndrrmi~od fn hnzt rganos aiv tmn rghn iar~vqcqgo,
Tmn zviknbt ugr cl iznvgtcil aiv ai~vsngvr gld un ugltnd ti iftgcl tmnvngbtcilr ia agv`nvr il tmn ribcinbili`cbr ia RMCZ, Un nrznbcgoos ugltndti hliumiu tmncv ocqnocmiidr unvnbmglecle gr g vnr~ot ia RMCZ gbtcqctcnr,R~f`cttnd fnoiu gvn ri`n ia tmnifrnvqgtcilr dvgul avi` g anu agv`nvr
umi gvn qnvs ziiv,
Bgrn ia gl iulnv-tnlglt
Agv~h Mirrgcl -4:# ia Fgf~eglk/ Fgvcrgomgr ti annd g ag`cos ia rnqnl, Mn ugr
uivhcle gr g dgs ogfi~vnv cl gddctcil tib~otcqgtcle mcr `ngenv g`i~lt ia ogld, Mnmgr li nd~bgtcil liv cr mcr ogldnldiu`nlt qnvs mcem; ilos 1: dnbc`goria iulnd ogld, Mn mgr ti vnlt vi~emos 4:dnbc`gor avi` itmnvr ti fn il gl nqnlhnno, Mirrgcl gld mcr ucan tiih ~z tmntvgclcle uctm eiid rzcvct, D~vcle tmn ogrt
g`gl rngril/ mn b~otcqgtnd FV77 timgvqnrt mi`n 74 `g~ldr znv Kgcrtmg -6:dnbc`gor#, K~rt ai~v sngvr gei/ fnaivntmnvn ugr gls RMCZ iv grribcgtnd tvgclcle/Mirrgcl ~rnd ti ent = `g~ldr avi` tmnrg`n g`i~lt ia ogld, Cl tmn fivi rngril/mn b~otcqgtnd hgkog gld mgvqnrtnd mi`n
76 `g~ldr bi`zgvnd ti 7: `g~ldr znvKgcrtmg zvnqci~ros, Tmn Agv~h ag`cos goriongvlt miu ti ~rn onrr anvtcocrnv gld
znrtcbcdnr,
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,6
Gfd~o Fgsnr
Tnbmlioies/ nltcton`nltr gld avnndi` ia bmicbnTnbmlioies/ nltcton`nltr gld avnndi` ia bmicbn
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
12/886
Tnbmlioies/ nltcton`nltr gld avnndi` ia bmicbn
Tmn clbvngrnd scnod avi` zgdds gld tmnrgonr ia rnndr tmgt mn vnbnltos n`fgvhnd~zil/ rnn` ti mgqn gotnvnd tmn `gtvc} iabmicbnr tmgt mn bilaviltnd cl tmn zgrt,Liu tmn ag`cos mgr tmvnn `ngor g dgs,
Ai~v sngvr gei/ tmn ag`cos mgd ilos ilnvcbn`ngo/ ri`ntc`nr k~rt fvngd gld gttc`nr unvn uctmi~t aiid, &Nhmil tcl fnog
eivi` fmgt hmgc/ gens nh fnog v~tc/ illi fnog lg
hmnsn hgtgctg`, Rmiztgmn d~ctg `~vec-i hmgc,&
-Liu un mgqn ugv` vcbn tmvnn tc`nr gdgs, Ngvocnv/ un ~rnd ti mgqn ilos ilnvcbn`ngo gld mgd ti rtgvqn ibbgrcilgoos,
Un bgl gori gaaivd ti mgqn tui bmcbhnlr gunnh#,
Agv~h ugr g dgs ogfi~vnv uivhcle clitmnvr% acnodr ti r~zzon`nlt mcr agv`clbi`n, &Nhmil fmgfbmmc ggv fidoc hmgtfilg,Lcknv ki`ctn hgk hivfi, G`gv airmio-n kitmnrmti,&-Liu C g` tmclhcle ia ecqcle ~z uivhclegr g dgs ogfi~vnv, Zvid~btcil avi` `siul agv` cr nli~em ti annd `s ag`cos#,
Agv~h mgr ~ldnvrtiid tmn rcelcacbglbn iand~bgtcil gld tmnvnaivn/ dnqitnr g zgvt iatmn clbvngrnd clbi`n il bmcodvnlr%
nd~bgtcil, Cl tmn zgrt/ mn bi~od mgvdosgaaivd ti rnld tmn bmcodvnl ti rbmiiodnrzctn tmn dnrcvn ti di ri,
Agv~h mgr lnqnv ~rnd rigz, Liu tmnag`cos ~rnr tui fgvr ia Ocanf~is rigznqnvs `iltm, A~vtmnv`ivn/ tmn ag`cos mgrructbmnd avi` ngtcle hgkog vcbn -vnogtcqnosbigvrn vcbn# ti FVVC dmgl63 -vnogtcqnosacln w~gocts vcbn#,
Agv~h liu vnbncqnr/ gatnv r~vvnldnvcle
mgoa ia tmn zvid~bn aiv vnlt cl ogld/gfi~t 7/7:: he, ia vcbn g sngv, Gatnv`nntcle mcr ag`cos%r lnnd ia gfi~t 7/:::he,/ mn rnoor tmn vnrt ti tmn `gvhnt, Clgddctcil/ mn gori rnoor rnndr ti lncemfi~vr,
Tm~r/ tmn tvgclcle avi` RMCZ clbvngrndtmn aiid nltcton`nlt ia tmn mi~rnmiod ti
umcbm Agv~h Mirrgcl fnoiler, Gt tmnrg`n tc`n/ tmn clbvngrnd clbi`n gld aiidrnb~vcts mgqn gotnvnd tmn bmicbnr ia tmn
ag`cos, Ngvocnv/ tmn ag`cos bi~od ilos mgqntmcr iv tmgt, F~t liu tmns bgl mgqn tmcr
gld gori tmgt, &gens zibmmildi hgvns hickgltg` lg, Gqgfcdnv gfgv zibmmildi hc' Nhmil
ifirtmg fnrm fmgoi, @gkmn `icdmns rmgd `ntgc,&-Un mgd li bmicbn cl tmn zgrt, Tmirn cl
uglt/ mgqn li bmicbn' Liu bildctcilr
mgqn c`zviqnd gld un tvs ti a~oacoo ri`ndnrcvnr#,
G tnlglt gld g tvgclcle
Un liu tghn ~z tmn bgrn ia g z~vn tnlglt, Gfd~o Hgdnv ia Rvnnz~v qcoogen -~ldnvEg{cz~v dcrtvcbt# oirt mcr agtmnv clbmcodmiid gld mcr evgldagtmnv dnzvcqndmc` ia mcr d~n rmgvn ia tmn clmnvctglbn,
Mn mgr li nd~bgtcil, Fivl ogldonrr/
Gfd~o Hgdnv mgr fnnl rtvcqcle mgvd aivdnbgdnr ti annd rnqnl `n`fnvr tmvi~emvnltcle i~t ogld, Tmi~em/ mcr nodnrt rilbiltvcf~tnr Th, 2/::: g `iltm uivhcle gr
g bgvznltnv/ tmgt cr `ngevn gr mcrmi~rnmiod vnw~cvnr 22,> he, znv dgs iavcbn k~rt ti r~vqcqn, Cl tmn k~rt aclcrmndfivi rngril/ mn b~otcqgtnd 4 fcemgr -7 fcemg
0 :,22 gbvn# ia ogld gld cl tmn ogrt g`glrngril/ 1 fcemgr, Ti vnzngt/ goo mcr
b~otcqgfon ogldr unvn vnltnd i~t tir~vvnldnv >:. ia tmn i~tz~t ti tmniulnv, Ochn `gls itmnvr/ Gfd~o Hgdnv cr
g z~vn tnlglt cl Rvnnz~v qcoogen,
Hgdnv vngznd g mgvqnrt ia 6: `g~ldrznvfcemg ia zgdds avi` zvid~bcle FVVC
dmgl6=, Mn gld mcr ucan `gdn a~oo ~rn iatmn tvgclcle il eiid w~gocts rnnd, Cl tmngfrnlbn ia r~bm tvgclcle/ umnl tmnsaiooiund tmn tvgdctcilgo zgtm ia rnndzvnrnvqgtcil/ tmn scnod ugr 75 `g~ldrznv
fcemg, Cl tmn g`gl rngril/ mn zvid~bndFV77 ti mgvqnrt 71 `g~ldr znv fcemggegclrt 76 `g~ldr znv fcemg cl zvnqci~rdgsr, Cl tmirn dgsr/ Hgdnv gld mcr ucan~rnd ti hnnz rnndr cl g rgbh ilos ti rnn
tmgt tmn rnndr unvn rzicond d~n ti gcvbiltg`clgtcil, Il `gls ibbgrcilr/ tmncvrnnd fndr unvn dg`gend - kgog `gvg enbmmn#z~ttcle tmn` cl dcvn rtvgctr, Tmns unvnmngqcos cldnftnd ti qcoogen `imgkilr gld
lncemfi~vr gr tmns mgd tghnl g m~en oiglumcbm bi~od lit fn vnzgcd,
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,6
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
13/882
Tnbmlioies/ nltcton`nltr gld avnndi` ia bmicbnTnbmlioies/ nltcton`nltr gld avnndi` ia bmicbn
Agtn`g Fne~`/ Hgdnv%r ucan rgsr, &Aiv tmn
ogrt ai~v sngvr/ un dcd lit fivviu `ilns aiv
b~otcqgtcil, Fnaivn tmgt/ un fivviund `ilns avi`
%`imgkilr%/ rgs Th, 7/::: gld mgd ti zgs
Th, 7:: znv `iltm gr gddctcilgo,&D~vcle tmn
ogrt fivi rngril/ tmns riod rnndocler uivtm Th, 2/:::/ fnaivn umcbm tmns mgd riod
rnndocler uivtm Th, 7/4:: gld fnaivn tmgt
Th, 7/6::, Tmn rnndocler gvn fi~emt lit
ilos fs lncemfi~vr umnl tmncvr agco ti
eviu/ f~t gori fs qcoogenvr avi` agv gld
ucdn,
Miunqnv/ cl tmn ogrt fivi rngril/ Hgdnv%r
ag`cos eit =: `g~ldr avi` ai~v fcemgr,
Gatnv r~vvnldnvcle mgoa ia tmn i~tz~t/ tmns
fvi~emt mi`n 4: `g~ldria zgdds, Tmnvn
cr gori clbvngrnd scnod avi` FV77 gld
tientmnv tmns eit =1 `g~ldr ia zgdds cl
iln sngv, Gatnv `nntcle mi~rnmiod lnndr/
tmcr tnlglt ag`cos n`nvenr gr g r~vzo~r
vcbn zvid~bnv, G zgvt ia tmn n}bnrr cr rnlt
ti tmn `gvhnt ti f~s g rgvcaiv Agtn`g iv
ti zgs t~ctcil annr aiv tmn dg~emtnv,
Agtn`g/ bmihnd uctm n`itcil/ umcon
n}zogclcle tmgt zvnqci~ros rmn bi~od lit
zviqcdn nd~bgtcil aiv mnv ril d~n tiziqnvts gld lnqnv dcd rmn iul tui rgvcr,
&C uivhnd gr g `gcd cl ri`nfids%r mi~rn k~rt
tmvnn ti ai~v sngvr fgbh, @glgecle aiid aiv tmn
ag`cos aivbnd `n ti fn g `gcd gld `s m~rfgld g
%`~lc% -sngv oile ogfi~v cl g mi~rnmiod#, Aiid
rmivtgen rtgsr gugs tmnrn dgsr d~n ti tmn mgvd
uivh un z~t cl tmn acnodr,&
&Nhhm~lc bmionl g`gv fgvct/ fcrmtvcrm `il
dmgl gbmmnc,&-Gbbi`zgls `n ti `s mi~rn/si~ ucoo acld 6:2: `g~ldria zgdds#,
Umgt gvn tmn fgrcb dcaanvnlbnr cl tmn
Hgdnv ag`cos tmgt mgqn n`nvend iqnv tmn
sngvr9 Agtn`g Fne~` vnzocnr r~zzivtnd
fs mnv m~rfgld gld glitmnv z~vn tnlglt/
Gfd~o @gonh/ &Rcv gens gbmmcog` hg`og
`gcsg/ imil icbmmc hvcrmgh `gcsg,&-Rcv/ C ugr
g `gcd rnvqglt/ liu C g` g agv`nv#,
Rnbild/ &nhmil cbmmg hivon rmiztgmn d~ctcldcl `gbmm hmgctn zgvc/ gens cbmmg tmghoni hmgctn
zgvc lgc,&-Liu/ ca un ucrm/ un bgl ngt acrm
tucbn g unnh/ ngvocnv bi~od lit dnrzctn tmn
dnrcvn#,
Tmcvd/ &gens g`gdnv evgg`ns fiveg zgig
kgctilg hgvil airmio mictilg gfile g`vg hmivibmhivtni zgvtg`lg, Nhmil fmgoi airmio dnchmg
`gochnvg emiivn ki`c dnsgv kicllg, Gv g`vg
bmcltg hivtnbmmc gvi fiveg lc`~ hc lc`~lg,&
-Cl tmn zgrt/ tmnvn ugr g rbgvbcts ia vnltnd
ogld gr bvizr agcond gld un/ tmn ziiv/
bi~od mgvdos fngv tmn birtr ia vgcrcle
i~tz~tr, Liu rnncle tmn scnod vgtn avi`
wiid w~gocts rnndr/ iulnvr gvn v~llcle
gatnv ~r gld grhcle ~r ti tcoo tmncv ogld, Un
gvn tmclhcle umntmnv ti vnlt cl `ivn iv
lit#,
Tmn zgvtcbczgltr ia RMCZ cl Rvnnz~v
qcoogen umi gvn `irtos ziiv/ anno tmgt tmn
clbvngrnd scnod gld tmn aiid rnb~vcts tmgt
vnr~otnd ti g vnd~bnd w~gltcts dnznld il
LEIr, Tmns fnocnqn tmns bgl rgqn gt ongrt
Th, 2:: znv fcemg avi` tmn nbili`cb ~rn
ia rnndr/ rnndocler gld fs qnvs octton ~rn ia
clrnbtcbcdnr, Tmcr mgr fnnl r~zzivtnd fs
tmn k~dcbci~r ~rn ia anvtcocrnvr, Goo ia tmnrndnqnoiz`nltr bg`n avi` tmn tvgclcle il
rnnd mngotm, Tmn bgrm birt lnndnd ti
b~otcqgtn iln fcemg uctm FVVC dmgl6=
bi`nr boirn ti Th, 2:: c`zoscle tmgt
tmnvn cr li lnnd ti rngvbm aiv bvndct
ri~vbnr,
Agtn`g Fne~` gld Rgo`g Hmgt~l/ fitm
ucqnr ia z~vn tnlglt agv`nvr gougsr mgqn
r`conr umcon tgohcle, Tmns qcrct acnodr
ibbgrcilgoos k~rt ti rnn aiv tmn`rnoqnr tmni~tz~t ia tmn mgvd ogfi~v tmns z~t clti
rnnd mngotm gbtcqctcnr, &Fivioihnv fi~vg
`gtmns kgslg hgvil divhgv lgc, G`vg eivcf,
Eivcfnv fi~vg `gtmns lg enon hc bmion9&-Ucqnr
ia vcbm agv`nvr di lit qcrct acnodr gr tmns
di lit lnnd ti, Un gvn ziiv, Un `~rt
qcrct acnodr#,
C ugr tiod tmgt tmncv m~rfgldr liu gougsr
dcrb~rr rnndr gld gevcb~ot~vgo zvgbtcbnr
uctm tmn`, Tmns mgqn `iqnd avi` aiiddnacbct ti aiid r~vzo~r mi~rnmiodr,
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,6
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
14/88
Rnnd gld Ncd
&Ums di si~ og~em ri `~bm umcontgohcle&9 un grhnd tmn` rnncle tmncvmgzzs agbnr, &Bmgv firiv gens gcon gc mgrmcdnmtnl lg Rcv, Eiti bmgv fibmmiv dmicvg ncd-ncdfmgf,& -Si~ ui~od lit mgqn litcbnd gr`con il i~v agbnr mgd si~ qcrctnd ~r ai~vsngvr gei, Aiv tmn ogrt ai~v sngvr un mgqngougsr fnnl cl g anrtcqn `iid#,
Ocemt gt tmn nld ia t~llno
Tmnvn gvn/ gd`cttndos/ `gls zviziivzviknbtr cl Fgleogdnrm f~t litmcle rnn`rti ri~ld `ivn avcnldos ti tmn ziiv tmglRMCZ, Rnnd `glgen`nlt mgd lnqnv fnnlgl c`zivtglt r~fknbt aiv dcrb~rrcilr cltmn geniod b~ot~vgo zvgbtcbnr, F~t aivdnbgdnr/ agv`nvr mgqn fnnl viffnd ia7:. ia tmn i~tz~t d~n ti oiu w~goctsrnnd, Liu tmn tvgclcle avi` RMCZ mgrnlgfond agv`nvr ti zvnrnvqn rnndr cl grbcnltcacb `gllnv, Gr g vnr~ot/ i~tz~t mgrvcrnl fs 7:76 . znv ~lct ia ogld, Aiv tmnvnri~vbnziiv agv`nvr/ tmn clbvngrnd scnod`nglt g oit, Acvrt/ ct clbvngrnd aiid
rnb~vcts ti tmn mi~rnmiod, Rnbild/ ctnlgfond w~gocts rnnd aiv rgonr gt 57:.mcemnv zvcbn tmgl itmnv ri~vbnr ia rnndr
cl tmn `gvhnt, Gld aclgoos/ tmn vnri~vbn
rgqcler/ ti tmn t~ln ia Th, 2::4/::: znv
22 dnbc`gor il gbbi~lt ia eiid
`glgen`nlt/ zgqnd ugsr aiv g fnttnv
ocqcle, Tmn bmicbnr `gdn fs tmn tvgclnd
agv`nvr/ `irtos ziiv ilnr/ n}zgldnd,Tmns mgqn clbvngrnd tmn w~gltcts ia aiid
cltghn/ gvn `iqcle tiugvdr fnttnv w~gocts
aiid/ fnttnv mi~rcle gld boitmcle gld
`irt c`zivtglt ia goo/ dnqitcle g zgvt ia
tmn clbvngrnd clbi`n tiugvdr nd~bgtcle
bmcodvnl, Goo tmnrn unvn `nvn dvng`r k~rt
ai~v sngvr gei,
Avi` bivlnv-ti-bnltnv
Tmncv zvid~btcil gld aiid nltcton`nltunlt ~z gld/ gt tmn rg`n tc`n/ tmncv rnt ia
bmicbnr n}zgldnd, Uctmcl g rzgl ia ai~vsngvr/ tmns `iqnd gugs avi` g rct~gtcil ia
%bivlnv% rio~tcil ti g zirctcil ia%tglenlbs% rio~tcil, Tmns bgl liu f~s vcbn
gr unoo gr lil-vcbn bi``idctcnr, Tvgclcletmgt nlegend fitm `nl gld ui`nl mnoznd
vgcrn i~tz~t r~frtgltcgoos ti z~t tmn
ziivnrt ia tmn ziiv cl g qcoogen il gl
nqnl hnno, Ti `n/ ri`n dnqnoiz`nlt grnrzi~rnd fs G`gvtgsg Rnl rnn`r ti mgqnmgzznlnd cl tmgt qcoogen,
Tnbmlioies/ nltcton`nltr gld avnndi` ia bmicbnTnbmlioies/ nltcton`nltr gld avnndi` ia bmicbn
R~eenrtnd bctgtcil;
Fgsnr/ G, 6::5, Tnbmlioies/ nltcton`nltr gld avnndi` ia bmicbn, Cl; @geiv/ L, Z,/ Rgogm~ddcl/ G,/ Mgw~n/ @,/
Fcrugr/ T, H, gld Fgllnv`gl/ @,/ ndctivr, ZNTVVG - gl n}znvc`nlt cl zviziiv gevcb~ot~vgo vnrngvbm,
Ziocbs fvcnar li, 2,6, Dmghg -Fgleogdnrm#; Ziqnvts Noc`clgtcil Tmvi~em Vcbn Vnrngvbm Grrcrtglbn Zviknbt/
Cltnvlgtcilgo Vcbn Vnrngvbm Clrtct~tn, 4 z,
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,6
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
15/88
Tmn @coonllc~` Eigo ti mgoqn n}tvn`n
ziqnvts uivoducdn fs 6:7> vnw~cvnr g
fnttnv ~ldnvrtgldcle ia tmn zirrcfon n}ct
vi~tnr avi` ziqnvts, Cl Fgleogdnrm/ umnvn
ziqnvts cr agoocle roiuos gt ilos 7. g sngv/
tmn lnnd ti gbbnonvgtn evgd~gtcil avi`
ziqnvts cr gb~tn, Snt umcon un hliu g oit
gfi~t ziqnvts ctrnoa gld umgt hnnzr znizonziiv/ un hliu `~bm onrr gfi~t `iqn`nlt
i~t ia ziqnvts, Umgt rtvgtnecnr di
mi~rnmiodr ~rn ti evgd~gtn avi` ziqnvts
gld umgt agbtivr dntnv`cln r~bbnrr9
Iln ugs ia glrunvcle tmnrn w~nrtcilr crti r~vqns tmn rg`n mi~rnmiodr %fnaivn%gld %gatnv% tmns nrbgznd ziqnvts, G vnbnltzglno r~vqns bild~btnd fs FgleogdnrmClrtct~tn ia Dnqnoiz`nlt Rt~dcnr -FCDR#
mgr rmiul/ aiv n}g`zon/ tmgt mi~rnmiodrtmgt evgd~gtnd avi` ziqnvts fntunnl73==6::6 clbvngrnd tmn rmgvn ia clbi`navi` lilagv` ri~vbnr/ gdiztnd `idnvlvcbn qgvcntcnr/ gld gbw~cvnd `ivn ogld-Rnl/ 6::2#, F~t tmcr `ntmid gori ongqnrri`n w~nrtcilr ~lglrunvnd, Evgd~gtcilcr lit k~rt g ziclt ia gvvcqgo glddnzgvt~vn/ f~t g zvibnrr, Miu dcdmi~rnmiodr cdnltcas rtvgtnecnr aivevgd~gtcil9 Miu dcd tmns rnw~nlbn tmnrn
rtvgtnecnr9 Miu dcd tmns bizn uctmrmibhr9 Miu dcd tmns r~bbnnd umnvnitmnvr agcond9 W~nrtcilr ochn tmnrn vnw~cvng w~goctgtcqn gzzvigbm tmgt n}zoivnr tmnbi`zon}cts ia mi~rnmiod dnbcrcil `ghcletmgt r~bbnrra~oos vnr~otnd cl g zgtmugsavi` ziqnvts,
Tmcr ziocbs fvcna i~toclnr vnr~otr avi` gw~goctgtcqn rt~ds ia miu mi~rnmiodrevgd~gtn avi` ziqnvts cl Fgleogdnrm, Tmn
rt~ds ugr ond fs tmn Lgt~vgo Vnri~vbnr
Clrtct~tn -LVC#^H uctm oibgozgvtlnvrmczr avi` FVVC/ FGVD/ gldVDG, ^lochn tmn FCDR zglno r~vqns/ tmnrt~ds ugr lit dnrcelnd ti ecqn vnr~otr tmgt unvn lgtcilgoos vnzvnrnltgtcqn iv g acv`fgrcr aiv ziocbs vnbi``nldgtcilr, Clrtngd/tmn ifknbtcqn ugr ti bi`zon`nlt tmn
w~gltctgtcqn dgtg avi` tmn zglno r~vqns fszviqcdcle clrcemtr il tmn zvibnrr iaevgd~gtcil avi` clrcdn tmn mi~rnmiod,
Dgtg gld `ntmidr
Vnrngvbm ugr bild~btnd cl tmvnn qcoogenr-gori r~vqnsnd fs tmn zglno r~vqns# tmgt
unvn rnonbtnd aiv dcaanvnlbnr cl gbbnrr tilnu vcbn tnbmlioies/ gevinbirsrtn`/ gldclavgrtv~bt~vn -Tgfon 7#,
Acnod vnrngvbm tiih iln sngv gld clbo~dndrctn bmgvgbtnvcrgtcil ~rcle zgvtcbczgtivsv~vgo gzzvgcrgo -ZVG#/ zgvtcbczgtivsziqnvts grrnrr`nlt -ZZG# ti ongvl
qcoogenvr% znvbnztcilr ia ziqnvts gld ziivevi~zr/ gld dntgcond bgrn rt~dcnr ia 2:mi~rnmiodr, Bmglenr cl ziqnvts gvn fgrndil qcoogenvr% iul znvbnztcilr vgtmnv tmglil ifknbtcqn `ngr~vnr,
Tmn ziqnvts zgvgdi}
Roiuos dnbvngrcle ziqnvts
Mi~rnmiodr cl tmn Bi`coog gld Fievg
qcoogenr vnzivtnd g dnbvngrn cl ziqnvts
Ziocbs
fvcna li, 2,2
Gogrtgcv U, Ivv gld F, Gdiozm
Dcrtvcbt
Qcoogen
Oibgtcil
Vcbnbvizzclezgttnvl
Bi`coog
Fmgfglcz~v
V~vgo
g~r -
t, g`gl -
fivi
Fievg
Dgvchg`gvc
Znvc-~vfgl
t, g`gl -
fivi
Fgvcrgo
Dgvcgfgd
Vn`itn
fivi
Tgfon 7
Zgtmugsr avi` ziqnvts; mi~rnmiod onqnozvibnrrnr ia evgd~gtcil
Zgtmugsr avi` ziqnvts; mi~rnmiod onqnozvibnrrnr ia evgd~gtcil
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
16/88
Zgtmugsr avi` ziqnvts; mi~rnmiod onqnozvibnrrnr ia evgd~gtcil
Bi`coog Fievg Fgvcrgo
Rg`n ^z Diul
:
7:
6:
2:
4:
>:
1:
5:
Ace~vn 6, Ziqnvts dslg`cbrg`ile ziiv mi~rnmiodr
6
fntunnl 73==6::6/ tmi~em tmn rmgvn iami~rnmiodr umi rgu tmn`rnoqnr gr %ziiv%vn`gclnd mcem, Tmn n}bnztcil ugr cl tmnFgvcrgo qcoogen/ umnvn ziqnvts rocemtosclbvngrnd -Ace~vn 7#,
F~t mcem vgtnr ia evgd~gtcilBiltvgrtcle uctm tmcr roiu dnbocln clziqnvts ugr tmn mcem onqno ia nbili`cb
`ifcocts g`ile mi~rnmiodr tmgt rtgvtndziiv, Ace~vn 6 rmiur tmgt;
Evgd~gtcil avi` ziqnvts ugr lit~l~r~go iv n}bnztcilgo/ uctm tucbn gr
`gls mi~rnmiodr `iqcle i~t iaziqnvts gr fnbi`cle ziivnv,
Evgd~gtcil ugr ucdnrzvngd gld ugr
Bi`coog Fievg Fgvcrgo
Fnaivn Liu
:
7:
6:
2:
4:
>:
1:
5:
=:
Ace~vn 7, Bmglenr cl ziqnvts/ goo mi~rnmiodr
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,2
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
17/882
lit bilaclnd ti zgvtcb~ogv oibgtcilr ivvcbn nbirsrtn`r f~t ibb~vvnd cl goo tmvnn
qcoogenr,
Tmn zvibnrr ia evgd~gtcil
Bgrn rt~dcnr ia mi~rnmiodr tmgt evgd~gtndavi` ziqnvts vnqngond bnvtgcl bi``il
angt~vnr, Ace~vn 2 fvcler tmnrn angt~vnr
tientmnv cl g rbmn`gtcb `idno ia tmn
zvibnrr ia evgd~gtcil, Ngbm bi`zilnlt cr
coo~rtvgtnd fs vnonqglt w~itgtcilr avi`
mi~rnmiod bgrn rt~dcnr,
Rmgvnd qcrcil
Gt tmn mngvt ia tmn evgd~gtcil zvibnrr crtmn qcrcil ia g fnttnv a~t~vn, Tmcr qcrcil
mgr ti fn rmgvnd fs tmn mi~rnmiod%r hnsdnbcrcil-`ghnvr aiv evgd~gtcil ti fnecl/ont goiln r~bbnnd, Zgvtlnvrmcz fntunnlm~rfgldr gld ucqnr cr c`zivtglt clrnttcle eigor/ gevnncle il ocqnocmiidrtvgtnecnr/ gld il miu `~bm ti rgqn, Zgvtia tmcr qcrcil cr tmn vnbielctcil fs fitmzgvtcnr ia ui`nl%r zvid~btcqn vion clenlnvgtcle clbi`n gld rgqcler,
&Avi` tmn qnvs fnecllcle tmncv `itcqn ugr ti rgqnri`n `ilns aiv dicle ri`ntmcle fnttnv,&
&Avi` 7331 ilugvd umnl L~v~o Crog` ugr
go`irt agcltcle avi` `nltgo n}mg~rtcil ti`glgen tmn `ilns/ @clgvg Fne~` zvizirnd tivnbncqn `ilns avi` tmn Evg`nnl Fglh,&
&Rmn ngvlnd gfi~t Th, 6>: znv `iltm tmvi~em
`ghcle fg`fii bvgatr gld ui~od rznld ct aiv
nlr~vcle tmncv bmcodvnl%r nd~bgtcil, Rmn fivn goo
tmn nd~bgtcilgo n}znlrnr ia mnv bmcodvnl,&
Rtv~bt~vn
Mi~rnmiod rtv~bt~vn ugr c`zivtgltfnbg~rn rnzgvgtcil avi` itmnv ag`cos
`n`fnvr ugr iatnl lnbnrrgvs aivmi~rnmiodr ti rgqn, Itmnvucrn/ nqnvstmcle
unlt ti r~zzivt tmn kiclt ag`cos, G`ilefnttnv-iaa mi~rnmiodr/ miunqnv/ g kicltag`cos rtv~bt~vn ugr c`zivtglt fnbg~rn ctgooiund tmn` ti ziio vnri~vbnr/ vnd~bntmn lnnd aiv n}tnvlgo mnoz/ gld vnbczvibgtngrrcrtglbn avi` itmnv ag`cos `n`fnvr,
&Mgv~l Fnzgvc ui~od di nqnvstmcle kicltos uctm
mcr agtmnv gld dcd lit rgqn glstmcle ia mcr iul,&
&Avi` 7333-6::: Rgvugv eit aclglbcgo r~zzivt
avi` mcr c``ndcgtn si~lenv fvitmnv @ilcv
fnbg~rn Rgvugv `gcltgclnd tmn umion ia mcrag`cos umnl mcr agtmnv dcnd,&
Rmgvnd
Qcrcil
Rgqcler
Rhcoor
Rnw~nlbn
R~zzivt
Rtvgtnes
Rtv~bt~vn
Ace~vn 2, Tmn zvibnrr ia evgd~gtcil
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,2
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
18/884
bglgo ~rcle hmgbmc, Mn lnqnv mcvnd ogfi~v, Goo
cltnvb~ot~vgo iznvgtcilr unvn diln fs mc`rnoa,&
&Tmns mgd gl cdng tmgt tmns `cemt entTh, 2:/:::2>/::: rnoocle tmn ogld gld tmnln}t dgs Rmg`r~o Mgw~n unlt ti tmn evg`rg`cts bmgcv`gl gld grhnd mc` aiv gTh, =:/::: oigl,&
Rhcoor
Evgd~gtcle mi~rnmiodr gbw~cvnd lnu
rhcoor tmvi~em gzzvnltcbnrmczr/ ugtbmcleitmnvr/ iv ongvlcle fs dicle,
&L~v~o Crog` mgd fnnl uivhcle gr tmn mnoznv iag `gril uctm a~oo bgvn avi` tmn qnvs fnecllcle
gld uctmcl 15 sngvr mn ugr gfon ti ongvl go`irtgoo tmn uivhr,&
&Umnl mn mgd riod mcr rmvc`z ti %gvgtdgv%-umionrgonvr#/ mn ifrnvqnd gld ongvlt miu tmnumionrgonvr fi~emt gld zvibnrrnd gld umnvn tmnsriod,&
&Cl `irt ia tmn bgrnr/ mn vnzgcvnd tmn vcbhrmgu fsmc`rnoa uctm tmn mnoz ia g `ghnv, Cl tmcr ugs mnongvlt miu ti vnzgcv vcbhrmgur/ qglr/ gldfcbsbonr&
Rtvgtnes
Ace~vn 4 bogrrcacnr tmn `gkiv ocqnocmiidrtvgtnecnr mi~rnmiodr ~rnd ti evgd~gtnavi` ziqnvts, Iln mi~rnmiod `cemt ~rnrnqnvgo rtvgtnecnr, Lilagv` gbtcqctcnr unvntmn `irt ziz~ogv rtvgtnes/ aiooiund fsgevcb~ot~vn gld iqnvrngr `cevgtcil,
Qcoogenr dcaanvnd cl tmncv bmicbn iartvgtnes/ vnaonbtcle tmn `c} ia izzivt~lctsgqgcogfon cl dcaanvnlt oibgtcilr gld g%rliufgoocle% naanbt gr mi~rnmiodr bizcndr~bbnrra~o lncemfi~vr, Iqnvrngr `cevgtcil
ugr tmn `irt bi``il rtvgtnes aivevgd~gtcil avi` ziqnvts cl tmn Bi`coog
qcoogen/ umnvngr cl tmn znvc~vfgl Fievg qcoogen lilagv` gbtcqctcnr -n,e,/ vcbhrmguz~oocle# unvn `ivn bi``il,
Rnw~nlbn
Rtvgtnecnr ~r~goos aiooiund g rnw~nlbn,
Mi~rnmiodr acvrt tvcnd ti nrtgfocrm g aiidrnb~vcts zogtaiv`/ ~r~goos vnltcle ogld gld
R~zzivt
Anu mi~rnmiodr evgd~gtnd uctmi~t ri`naiv` ia n}tnvlgo r~zzivt, Tmcr tiih
qgvci~r aiv`r, F~rclnrr zgvtlnvrmczr b~tbirtr gld rmgvnd vcrhr, Zgtvilgen ugrc`zivtglt/ umnvn g ag`cos avcnld iv
ungotmcnv vnogtcqn mnoznd rnb~vn g kif aivgl nodnv ril/ zviqcdnd g oigl/ iv gbtnd gr g%fvihnv% cl g f~rclnrr dngo, Zgtvilgen ugrgori c`zivtglt cl mnozcle mi~rnmiodr bizn
uctm rmibhr, R~zzivt gori clbo~dnd gbbnrr
ti bvndct avi` aiv`go iv claiv`go ri~vbnr,
&Gr mn mgd li aclglbcgo bgzctgo/ mn ugr tmn
zgvtlnv ia glitmnv znvril,&
& Avi` g f~rclnrr ri~vbn/ @v, @gllgl fnbg`ngbw~gcltnd uctm g fce `nvbmglt umirn lnzmnu
ugr g bioilno cl tmn gv`s, Mn bi``cttnd @v
@gllgl ti `glgen g kif aiv mcr ril Lgll~ cl
tmn Fgleogdnrm Gv`s,,, ,&
&Mn tiih g oigl avi` iln ia mcr fvitmnvrclogu
aiv Th, =:/:::, Mn gori tiih g oigl ia
Th, 7::/::: avi` rnqnvgo ia mcr vnogtcqnr, Fs
tmgt oigl Rmgmkgmgl rnlt mcr si~lenv fvitmnv ti
tmn @cddonngrt,&
Rgqcler
Rgqcler tiih dcaanvnlt aiv`r gt dcaanvnlt
rtgenr cl tmn zvibnrr ia evgd~gtcil, Cl tmn
ngvos rtgen/ mi~rnmiodr rgqnd tmvi~em
rtcltcle iv b~ttcle mi~rnmiod n}znldct~vn,
Tmns vn`n`fnvnd tmcr gr g tc`n
ia n}tvn`n mgvdrmcz, R~frnw~nltos/
mi~rnmiodr rgqnd fs `clc`crcle bgrm
i~togs/ aiv n}g`zon fs gqicdcle tmn lnnd
ti mcvn ogfi~v, Cl ogtnv rtgenr/ mi~rnmiodrtiih aiv`go oiglr ti aclglbn o~`zs
clqnrt`nltr/ f~t aiv fceenv gld
zvnr~`gfos `ivn vcrhs clqnrt`nltr/
mi~rnmiodr zvnanvvnd ti ocw~cdgtn grrntr iv
fivviu claiv`goos avi` avcnldr gld
vnogtcqnr,
&Tmns `clc`crnd tmcr dnacbct fs tghcle iln iv tui
vcbn `ngor g dgs gld ri`ntc`nr fivviucle vcbn
avi` g lncemfi~v,, Mn tmi~emt mn ui~od rgqn
`ilns ngbm sngv aiv mcr a~t~vn,&&Mn cvvcegtnd mcr bvizr ~rcle tcdnugtnv avi` tmn
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,2
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
19/88>
C`zocbgtcilr aiv ziocbs
W~goctgtcqn clrcemtr avi` tmvnn qcoogenrt~dcnr bgllit fs tmn`rnoqnr zvid~bnziocbs vnbi``nldgtcilr/ f~t tmns `gs
bi`zon`nlt gld vnclaivbn ziocbsvnbi``nldgtcilr dnvcqnd avi` lgtcilgor~vqns dgtg,
Fgleogdnrm%r roiu dnbocln cl ziqnvtsbin}crtr uctm r~vzvcrcleos mcem vgtnr iaevgd~gtcil avi` ziqnvts, Iln cl tmvnnmi~rnmiodr tmgt rtgvtnd ziiv r~bbnndndcl `iqcle i~t ia ziqnvts, Cldnnd/ ziivmi~rnmiodr unvn `ivn ochnos ti c`zviqntmncv zirctcil tmgl ent ziivnv,A~vtmnv`ivn/ evgd~gtcil ugr
ucdnrzvngd gld lit bilaclnd ti ilnoibgtcil iv vcbn nlqcvil`nlt, Tm~r/ziqnvts cr lit clnrbgzgfon/ zgtmugsravi` ziqnvts n}crt/ gld ziocbs mgr fnnlnaanbtcqn cl bvngtcle nbili`cbizzivt~lctcnr aiv evgd~gtcil,
Evgd~gtcil bgl fn gbbnonvgtnd fs lnuziocbs `ngr~vnr/ miunqnv, Avi` i~vbgrn rt~ds nqcdnlbn/ tmn zvibnrr iaevgd~gtcil ui~od mgqn fnnl ngrcnv ca
tmnvn unvn rnvqcbnr zviqcdcle `cbvibvndct aiv gevcb~ot~vn -lit k~rt lilagv`
clqnrtcle cl lnu vcbn tnbmlioies, Vnr~otr
avi` i~v `clcr~vqns rmiund tmgt
evgd~gtcil ugr grribcgtnd uctm gl
clbvngrn ia 62 `iltmr cl tmn l~`fnv ia
`iltmr tmgt mi~rnmiodr gtn tmncv iul
vcbn, Tmcr ugr c`zivtglt aiv tmncv zngbn ia
`cld,
&Mn tmi~emt tmgt ca ct bi~od fn zirrcfon ti
b~otcqgtn vcbn mn ui~od lit tmclh gfi~t vcbn,
Gr g vnr~ot/ ct ui~od fn mnoza~o aiv mcr a~t~vn
c`zviqn`nlt,&
&Mn ugr nlegend cl gevcb~ot~vn gr g rmgvnbvizznv
ti nlr~vn aiid rnb~vcts goo tmn sngv vi~ld ri tmgt
mn bi~od fn zrsbmioiecbgoos rtgfon,,, ,&
Mi~rnmiodr rnonbtnd ocqnocmiid rtvgtnecnrtmgt rc`~otglni~ros vnd~bnd tmn lnnd aiv
bgrm n}znldct~vn gld gori egqn bgrm
clbi`n -Ace~vn >#, Aiv n}g`zon/ f~scle
dvg~emt glc`gor ugr g eiid clqnrt`nlt
aiv g rmgvnbvizznv fnbg~rn ct rgqnd tmn
birt ia mcvcle gld gori zviqcdnd mc` uctm
clbi`n umnl mn mcvnd tmn` i~t ti itmnv
agv`nvr, Rc`cogvos/ cvvcegtcil z~`zr gld
ziunv tcoonvr rgqnd bgrm birtr gld ngvlnd
clbi`n, Tm~r/ ocqnocmiid rtvgtnecnr unvnbgvna~oos rnw~nlbnd ti ngrn bgrm aoiu,
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,2
Ace~vn 4, Rtvgtnes aiv evgd~gtcil
Gevcb~ot~vn
Ag`cos rtv~bt~vn
Dcqnvrcacbgtcil
@cevgtcil
Zgtmugsr avi` ziqnvts; mi~rnmiod onqnozvibnrrnr ia evgd~gtcil
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
20/88
Ziunv z~`z - acrm zildr
Ziunv tcoonv - tcoonv mcvn
Ziunv z~`z - ugtnv rgonr
Biur - coh
Iul f~ooibhr - glc`go mcvn
Rmgvnbvizzcle - vcbn
Dgs ogfi~v - ugenr
Tc`n
Ace~vn >, Rnw~nlbn
Ziocbcnr ti bvngtn nbili`cb izzivt~lcts
`~rt fn `gtbmnd fs ziocbcnr tmgt vnd~bn
q~olnvgfcocts, G`ile i~v bgrn rt~dcnr/
evgd~gtcil ugr avnw~nltos av~rtvgtnd fs
%rmibhr%, Tmnrn clbo~dnd tmn mcem birt
ia naanbtcqn mngotm bgvn/ ogbh ia
znvrilgo rnb~vcts gld tmn dglenv ia
tmnat/ gld ziocbn bivv~ztcil, Uctmi~t
naanbtcqn mngotm gld onego rsrtn`r/evgd~gtcil avi` ziqnvts ugr `gdn
`ivn dcaacb~ot, Ziocbs `ngr~vnr ti
vnd~bn tmn c`zgbt ia tmnrn rmibhr
ui~od gori vnd~bn tmn l~`fnv ia
%ti`ivviu%r ziiv% iv tmirn gt vcrh ia
agoocle clti ziqnvts, Cl r~`/ gbbnonvgtcle
ziqnvts dnbocln cl Fgleogdnrm vnw~cvnr gtucltvgbh rtvgtnes tmgt fitm zvi`itnr
izzivt~lctcnr aiv evgd~gtcil gld
vnd~bnr q~olnvgfcocts,
Tmn zvc`gvs zgtmugs avi` ziqnvts ugr
tmvi~em tmn v~vgo lilagv` rnbtiv/
f~t tmcr rmi~od lit dntvgbt avi`tmn c`zivtglbn ia gevcb~ot~vn aiv
ocqnocmiidr, Mi~rnmiod aiid rnb~vcts
vn`gclnd g hns ocqnocmiid i~tbi`n/
uctm evgd~gtcle mi~rnmiodr clqnrtcle clogld gld lnu vcbn tnbmlioies, Cldnnd/
gbtcqctcnr#/ gdqcbn aiv r`goo f~rclnrrnr/
tnbmlcbgo gdqcbn il gevcb~ot~vgo
dcqnvrcacbgtcil/ gld il tmn `gvhntcle ia
mcem qgo~n bvizr, Mnlbn/ mi~rnmiodr
lnnd/ lit ilos lnu aiv`r ia bvndct f~t
gori gbbnrr ti hliuonden gld
claiv`gtcil,
Ca izzivt~lctcnr aiv evgd~gtcil n}crt/
ums di ri `gls mi~rnmiodr vn`gcl
ziiv9 W~goctgtcqn vnrngvbm mnozr glrunv
tmcr w~nrtcil, Evgd~gtcil avi` ziqnvts
cr g `~otcdc`nlrcilgo zvibnrr/ gld dinr
lit dnznld il g rcleon/ dnbcrcqn agbtiv,
I~v rbmn`gtcb %5R%% `idno r~eenrtr
tmgt tmnvn cr li `gecb f~oont aiv r~bbnrr
f~t tmgt goo bi`zilnltr gvn nw~goos
c`zivtglt, Un `cemt nqnl ei a~vtmnv
gld rgs -fivviucle avi` nqio~tcilgvs
fcioies# tmgt r~bbnrr rtn`r avi`
gqicdcle `gls rnzgvgtn zirrcfon bg~rnr
ia agco~vn, Avi` tmcr gleon/ mnozcle
mi~rnmiodr ti evgd~gtn avi` ziqnvts crlit ilos gfi~t ziocbs `ngr~vnr ti
zviqcdn izzivt~lcts/ f~t gfi~t
`ngr~vnr tmgt mnoz ziiv mi~rnmiodr
iqnvbi`n tmn rmibhr gld rtvnrrnr tmgtzvnqnlt evgd~gtcil,
1
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,2
Zgtmugsr avi` ziqnvts; mi~rnmiod onqnozvibnrrnr ia evgd~gtcil
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
21/885
%Zgvttc`n% agv`nvr mgqn dcaanvnlt lnndravi` tmirn aiv umi` agv`cle cr g a~ootc`n ibb~zgtcil, Tmns gvn `ivn ochnosti fn bilbnvlnd uctm mi~rnmiod aiid
rnb~vcts tmgl uctm bviz dcqnvrcacbgtciliv bi``nvbcgocrgtcil,
c`zviqnd gbbnrr ti ogld ugr go`irt goct`~r tnrt aiv evgd~gtcil, Gr ungotmcnvmi~rnmiodr `iqnd i~t ia gevcb~ot~vn/rzgbn ugr bvngtnd aiv ziivnvmi~rnmiodr ti vnlt ogld, Mi~rnmiodr
bi`fclnd gld rnw~nlbnd ocqnocmiidrtvgtnecnr ti `c} tmn rnb~vcts grribcgtnd
uctm ogld gld tmn dcrzirgfon clbi`navi` lilagv` n`zois`nlt, Gvn un
uctlnrrcle %gl gevgvcgl vnqio~tcil avi`fnoiu% gr ziiv mi~rnmiodr `iqn cltitmn rzgbn qgbgtnd fs `cddon gld ogvenagv`nvr9
Bmglenr cl gbbnrr ti ogld gvn goribmglecle tmn tvgdctcilgo bocnlt fgrn aiv
gevcb~ot~vgo vnrngvbm gld n}tnlrcil,Agv`cle aiv tmnrn lnu nltvgltr crbi`fclnd uctm lilagv` gbtcqctcnr,
VNANVNLBNRnl/ F, 6::6, Dvcqnvr ia nrbgzn gld dnrbnlt; bmglecle mi~rnmiod aivt~lnr cl v~vgo Fgleogdnrm/
Uivod Dnqnoiz`nlt/ 27 -2#; >72>24,
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,2
Zgtmugsr avi` ziqnvts; mi~rnmiod onqnozvibnrrnr ia evgd~gtcil
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
22/88
R~eenrtnd bctgtcil;
Ivv/ G, U, gld Gdiozm/ F, 6::5, Zgtmugsr avi` ziqnvts; mi~rnmiod onqno zvibnrrnr ia evgd~gtcil, Cl; @geiv/ L, Z,/
Rgogm~ddcl/ G,/ Mgw~n/ @,/ Fcrugr/ T, H, gld Fgllnv`gl/ @/, ndctivr, ZNTVVG - gl n}znvc`nlt cl zviziiv
gevcb~ot~vgo vnrngvbm, Ziocbs fvcnar li, 2,2, Dmghg -Fgleogdnrm#; Ziqnvts Noc`clgtcil Tmvi~em Vcbn Vnrngvbm
Grrcrtglbn Zviknbt/ Cltnvlgtcilgo Vcbn Vnrngvbm Clrtct~tn, = z,
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
23/88
Tmcr ziocbs fvcna dngor uctm tmn b~vvnlt
rtgt~r ia v~vgo lilagv` -VLA# nbili`s
ia Fgleogdnrm, Ct dib~`nltr tmn bmglenr
ifrnvqnd cl tmn VLA rnbtiv, Ct gori
cdnltcacnr tmn bilrtvgcltr aiv agrtnv eviutm
cl tmcr rnbtiv gld r~eenrtr ri`n ziocbs
`ngr~vnr aiv zvi`itcle ct cl Fgleogdnrm,
Tmn fgbhevi~ld claiv`gtcil aiv tmcrziocbs fvcna cr dvgul avi` tmn iaacbcgo
rtgtcrtcbr z~focrmnd fs tmn Fgleogdnrm
F~vng~ ia Rtgtcrtcbr gld acldcler avi` glgtcilgoos vnzvnrnltgtcqn mi~rnmiod
r~vqns bild~btnd fs tmn Fgleogdnrm
Clrtct~tn ia Dnqnoiz`nlt Rt~dcnr -FCDR#
gld tmn Cltnvlgtcilgo Vcbn Vnrngvbm
Clrtct~tn -CVVC#/ mnlbnaivtm bgoond tmn
FCDRCVVC r~vqns, Tmn fnlbm`gvh
r~vqns ugr bild~btnd cl 73=5%==biqnvcle 7/64> mi~rnmiodr avi` 16
qcoogenr cl >5 dcrtvcbtr rnonbtnd tmvi~em g
`~otcrtgen vgldi` rg`zocle `ntmid,
Tmn rg`n mi~rnmiodr unvn r~vqnsnd
d~vcle 6:::%:7 znvcid ti grrnrr tmn
bmglenr cl v~vgo nbili`s d~vcle tmn
73=5%== ti 6:::%:7 znvcid, Tmn 6:::%:7
r~vqns biqnvr g rg`zon ia 7/==:
mi~rnmiodr, Vnrngvbm acldcler unvn
zvnrnltnd gt g dcgoie~n il %Zvi`itcle
v~vgo lilagv` nbili`s; cr Fgleogdnrmdicle nli~em9% Tmn dcgoie~n ugr
iveglcrnd fs tmn Bnltvn aiv Ziocbs
Dcgoie~n -BZD# il K~os 7=/ 6::6 gt g
mitno cl Dmghg, Fgrnd il tmn vnrngvbm
acldcler ia tmn Dslg`cbr ia Ocqnocmiid
Rsrtn`r -DIORsr# r~fzviknbt/ tmn
DIORsr Tng` Ongdnv Dv, @gmgf~f
Mirrgcl `gdn g hnslitn zvnrnltgtcil il
tmn b~vvnlt rtgt~r ia VLA rnbtiv cl
Fgleogdnrm, Zvianrriv @, G, Rgttgv
@gldgo/ aiv`nv `n`fnv ia tmn Zogllcle
Bi``crrcil gld Dv, @, Grgd~{{g`gl/
vnrngvbm dcvnbtiv gt FCDR big~tmivnd tmn
itmnv zgznv ia tmcr dcgoie~n, cld~rtvcnr
`clcrtnv @, H, Glugv gld aiv`nv
gevcb~ot~vn `clcrtnv Fne~` @gtcg
Bmiudm~vs gttnldnd tmn dcgoie~n gr bmcna
gld rznbcgo e~nrt/ vnrznbtcqnos, ZvianrrivVnm`gl Rifmgl/ bmgcv`gl ia BZD/ ugr
tmn bmgcv ia tmcr c`zivtglt dcgoie~n,
Clz~tr avi` tmn dcgoie~n zgvtcbczgltr gr
unoo gr avi` tmn vnrngvbm zgznvr gvn
clbo~dnd cl tmcr ziocbs fvcna,
CLTVID^BTCIL@nntcle tmn eviucle lnndr ia enlnvgtcle
zvid~btcqn n`zois`nlt aiv tmn nqnvclbvngrcle uivhcle gen ziz~ogtcil cl v~vgo
Fgleogdnrm cr g aiv`cdgfon bmgoonlen, Tmn
c`zivtglbn ia VLA gbtcqctcnr cl
enlnvgtcle n`zois`nlt gld clbi`nr
d~vcle tmn zvibnrr ia nbili`cb
dnqnoiz`nlt cr ucdnos vnbielcrnd, Cl
Fgleogdnrm/ VLA gbbi~ltr aiv iqnv 4:.
ia v~vgo n`zois`nlt, Tmn VLA rnbtiv
evnu gt >. znv gll~` fntunnl ogtn
ncemtcnr gld `cd lclntcnr, Cl 733>%31/ ctbiltvcf~tnd 21. ti tmn bi~ltvsr titgo
evirr di`nrtcb zvid~bt -EDZ# bi`zgvnd
ti gfi~t 27. fs gevcb~ot~vn,
Tmn VLA gbtcqctcnr clbo~dn gbtcqctcnr
i~trcdn gevcb~ot~vn tmgt clbo~dn ocqnrtibh/
acrmnvcnr gld aivnrtvs, Lil-agv` gbtcqctcnr
bgl fn bogrrcacnd clti tmvnn bgtneivcnr;
c# @irtos `gl~go ogfi~v fgrnd8 cc# M~`gl
bgzctgo fgrnd ibb~zgtcilr8 ccc# Zmsrcbgo gld
m~`gl bgzctgo cltnlrcqn gbtcqctcnr, @irtos
Ziocbs
fvcna li, 2,4
@gmgf~f Mirrgcl
Zvi`itcle v~vgo lil-agv`nbili`s; cr Fgleogdnrm dicle nli~em9
Zvi`itcle v~vgo lil-agv`nbili`s; cr Fgleogdnrm dicle nli~em9
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
24/88
`gl~go ogfi~v fgrnd gbtcqctcnr clbo~dnrnoa-n`zoisnd r~frcrtnlbn-ivcnltnd
bittgen cld~rtvcnr/ ugen n`zois`nlt cl
v~vgo f~rclnrr nltnvzvcrnr/ tvglrzivt
iznvgtcil/ gld bilrtv~btcil ogfi~v,
M~`gl bgzctgo fgrnd ibb~zgtcilr clbo~dn
rgogvcnd rnvqcbn cl z~focb gld zvcqgtn
iveglcrgtcilr/ tngbmnvr gld c`g`r/ qcoogen
dibtivr/ gld qgvci~r tsznr ia znvrilgo
rnvqcbnr, Zmsrcbgo gld m~`gl bgzctgo
cltnlrcqn gbtcqctcnr clbo~dn bi``nvbcgotszn v~vgo cld~rtvcnr/ clbo~dcle gevi-
zvibnrrcle/ rmiz-hnnzcle/ znddocle/ zntts
tvgdcle/ `ndc~` gld ogven rbgon tvgdcle/
gld biltvgbtiv rnvqcbnr,
BMGLEN CL TMN V^VGO NBILI@S Gevcb~ot~vn znvaiv`nd vnogtcqnos unoo cl
tmn 733:r, Tmn eviutm ia gevcb~ot~vgo
clbi`nr cr nrtc`gtnd gt 2,>. cl tmn 733:rbi`zgvnd ti 6,1. iqnv tmn 7354-%3:
znvcid, Tmn gbbnonvgtcil ia gevcb~ot~vgo
eviutm mgr biltvcf~tnd r~frtgltcgoos ti
c`zviqnd znvaiv`glbn ia tmn iqnvgoo
nbili`s, Tmn lgtcilgo clbi`n evnu gt
>,2. cl tmn 733:r bi`zgvnd ti 4,7.
d~vcle tmn zvnqci~r tui dnbgdnr,
Tmn gbbnonvgtcil cl tmn eviutm ia
gevcb~ot~vgo clbi`nr/ ugr `gclos il
gbbi~lt ia lil-bviz gevcb~ot~vgo rnbtivrzgvtcb~ogvos avi` ocqnrtibh gld acrmnvcnr
umcbm n}znvcnlbnd r~frtgltcgo clbvngrn clzmsrcbgo i~tz~t/ gr unoo gr gl clbvngrn clvnogtcqn zvcbnr bi`zgvnd ti itmnvgevcb~ot~vgo zvid~bn, Tmn acrmnvcnr clbi`nevnu fs 5,=. znv sngv cl tmn 733:r/bi`zgvnd ti 6,2. d~vcle tmn zvnqci~rtui dnbgdnr, Tmn clbi`n avi` ocqnrtibhgbtcqctcnr zcbhnd ~z cl tmn 73=:r gldbiltcl~nd ti eviu gt g vif~rt vgtn ia5,2. cl tmn 733:r, Ilos tmn aivnrtvs r~f-
rnbtiv evnu gt g `idnvgtn vgtn ia 2,=.znv sngv, Tm~r/ gevcb~ot~vn mgr fnbi`n`~bm `ivn dcqnvrcacnd tmgl ct ugr gtcldnznldnlbn, Tmn rmgvn ia ocqnrtibh/acrmnvcnr gld aivnrtvs cl gevcb~ot~vgoclbi`nr ugr ilos 6:. d~vcle 7352-%548fs 6:::-%:7 tmns biltvcf~tnd lngvos 44.ti gevcb~ot~vgo clbi`nr,
Tmn iaacbcgo lgtcilgo clbi`n rtgtcrtcbr clFgleogdnrm dinr lit zviqcdn g v~vgo-
~vfgl fvnghdiul ia n`zois`nltclbi`nr, Ri ct cr dcaacb~ot ti dvgu g vnocgfonzcbt~vn ia lgt~vn/ bi`zirctcil gldeviutm ia tmn v~vgo lil-agv` rnbtiv clFgleogdnrm, Tmn FCDR-CVVC rg`zonmi~rnmiod r~vqns cl 16 qcoogenr rmiundtmgt tmn n`zois`nlt cl tmn v~vgo lil-agv` rnbtiv mgr clbvngrnd fs 4,>. znvsngv umcon tmn l~`fnv ia uivhnvrn`zoisnd cl gevcb~ot~vn mgr dnboclnd fslngvos 7,6. znv sngv, Cl 6:::-%:7/ >6. ia
tmn ngvlcle `n`fnvr ia tmn mi~rnmiodrcl Fgleogdnrm vnzivtnd VLA gbtcqctcnr gr
6
Zvi`itcle v~vgo lil-agv` nbili`s ia Fgleogdnrm
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,4
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
25/88
tmncv zvc`gvs ibb~zgtcil gld glitmnv74. gr rnbildgvs ibb~zgtcilr/ umcbm`nglr tmgt lngvos tuitmcvdr ia tmn v~vgo
uivhnvr gvn clqioqnd cl v~vgo lilagv`gbtcqctcnr, Lilagv` gbtcqctcnr gbbi~lt aiv
>6. ia tmn clbi`n cl v~vgo Fgleogdnrm,Iqnv tmn 73=5%:: znvcid tmn mi~rnmiodclbi`n evnu gt 2,=. znv sngv, @irt iatmn eviutm bg`n avi` tmn v~vgo lilagv`rnbtiv -`gclos avi` rnvqcbnr gld tvgdngld f~rclnrr gld v~vgo tvglrzivtiznvgtcilr#, Tmn clbi`n avi` VLAgbtcqctcnr clbvngrnd gt 1,=. znv sngvbi`zgvnd ti ilos 7,4. znv sngv eviutm clgevcb~ot~vgo clbi`nr, Gr g vnr~ot/ tmn rmgvnia tmn lilagv` rnbtiv cl v~vgo mi~rnmiodclbi`n mgr fnnl clbvngrcle qnvs agrt,
HNS DVCQNVR IA VLA EVIUTMTmn `gbvi nbili`cb dvcqnvr clbo~dn ogvenrbgon ocfnvgocrgtcil ia `gvhnt gld tvgdnvnec`n/ vnd~btcil ia tgvcaa gld liltgvcaafgvvcnvr ti tvgdn gld zvcqgtcrgtcil iagevcb~ot~vn c,n,/ clz~t dcrtvcf~tcil/ evgcltvgdn/ ntb, Il tmn itmnv mgld tmn rnbtivgo
onqno dvcqnvr clbo~dn vgzcd rzvngd iacvvcegtcil tnbmlioiecnr aiv vcbn zvid~btcil/clbvngrnd `nbmglcrgtcil ia tcoogen-7>/::: ziunv tcoonvr gld 6:: tvgbtivr
c`zivtnd gll~goos#/ eviutm ia nw~cz`nlt`gl~agbt~vcle -l~`nvi~r `ntgo
uivhrmizr)agbtivs/ clbi`n vgcrnd#/r~zzivt rnvqcbnr aiv agv` nw~cz`nlt-7,5 coocil iulnvr)`glgenvr/ :,51 `coocil
iznvgtivr ia `gl~go cvvcegtcil dnqcbn/ :,71`coocil v~vgo `nbmglcbr/ bvngtnd 77/::: a~oo`glsngvr ia n`zois`nlt#/ clbvngrndtvgdn cl gevcb~ot~vgo clz~tr -4/::: anvtcocrnvdngonvr/ l~`nvi~r vntgco tvgdnvr/ ntb,#/clbvngrnd bnvngo zvid~btcil gldr~frnw~nlt evgcl rtivcle/ tvgdcle/ vcbnzgvficocle gld `coocle ntb, Gevcb~ot~vgodcqnvrcacbgtcil c,n,/ zi~otvs/ acrmnvcnr/ zogltl~vrnvcnr/ ntb, -`gl~agbt~vcle gld tvgdclecl zi~otvs anndr/ anndcle gld vngvclenw~cz`nlt#/ v~vgo tvglrzivtgtcil agbcoctgtndfs v~vgo clavgrtv~bt~vnr/ v~vgononbtvcacbgtcil/ vcrn cl mi~rnmiod clbi`ncld~bnd dn`gld aiv lnu VLA zvid~btr-mi~rn f~codcle/ rglctgtcil/ bgvznltvs/ v~vgornvqcbnr/ ntb,# gld vn`cttglbnr avi`i~trcdn tmn v~vgo rnbtiv,
HNS BILRTVGCLTR TI VLA RNBTIVDNQNOIZ@NLT
Tmvnn tsznr ia bilrtvgcltr/ lg`nos/`gvhnt vnogtnd bilrtvgcltr/ zmsrcbgobilrtvgcltr gld ziocbs bilrtvgcltr oc`ct tmn
2
Zvi`itcle v~vgo lil-agv` nbili`s ia Fgleogdnrm
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,4
Znvbnltiauivhn
vr
Agv`cle Tvgdn gldf~rclnrr
Rnvqcbnr Gevcb~ot~vgoogfi~v
Lil-gevcb~ot~vgoogfi~v
47
2>
7:
74 7>
67 66
77 77
7=
Ocqnocmiidr; N`zois`nlt fs ibb~zgtcil
7333-%::73=5-==
>:
4:
2:
6:
7:
:
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
26/88
Ocqnocmiidr; @gkiv ri~vbn ia clbi`n
Znvbnltiami~rnmiod
7333-%::73=5-%==
4543
7:76
71
27
67
74
Agv`cle Tvgdn gldf~rclnrr
Rnvqcbnr Ugen ogfi~v
1:
>:
4:
2:
6:
7:
:
Zvi`itcle v~vgo lil-agv` nbili`s ia Fgleogdnrm
4
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,4
7>.26.
7=.
67.
74.
Lil-vcbnagv`cle
Vcbnagv`cle
Ugenogfi~v
Rnvqcbnr
Tvgdn !f~rclnrr
73=5-%==; R $365 7333-%::; R $7/24=
Lil-vcbnagv`cle
Vcbnagv`cle
Ugenogfi~v
Rnvqcbnr
Tvgdn !f~rclnrr
64.
64.
71.
7:.
61.
Bi`zirctcil ia mi~rnmiod clbi`n
dnqnoiz`nlt ia VLA rnbtiv, @gvhntvnogtnd bilrtvgcltr gvn ogbh ia gdnw~gtndn`gld aiv bilqnltcilgo VLA zvid~btr/gotmi~em tmnvn cr g eviucle dn`gld aivlnu tsznr ia VLA eiidr gld rnvqcbnr,
Tmn zmsrcbgo bilrtvgcltr clbo~dn ogbh iazmsrcbgo clavgrtv~bt~vnr/ nonbtvcbcts/
rtgldgvd nw~cz`nlt gld hliu-miu, Tmnziocbs bilrtvgcltr clbo~dn clgdnw~gtn
bvndct/ cvvgtcilgo tg} rtv~bt~vn/ fcgr gegclrtv~vgo cld~rtvcgocrgtcil, Zvcbcle gevcb~ot~vgoclz~tr)i~tz~t gld bilrtv~btcil `gtnvcgor/gcvavncemt bmgvenr aiv gevcb~ot~vgon}zivtgfon ctn`r di gaanbt VLA rnbtiveviutm, Tmn gfrnlbn ia f~rclnrr gdqcrivsrnvqcbnr aiv VLA rnbtiv nltnvzvcrnr bgl
fn cdnltcacnd ti fn gl clrtct~tcilgobilrtvgclt ti tmn eviutm ia tmcr rnbtiv,
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
27/88>
Zvi`itcle v~vgo lil-agv` nbili`s ia Fgleogdnrm
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,4
RTVGTNECNR GLD ZIOCBCNR AIV TMNDNQNOIZ@NLT IA VLA RNBTIV
Tmn eiqnvl`nlt ri agv mgr bvngtnd g
l~`fnv ia clrtct~tcilr r~bm gr tmn
Fgleogdnrm R`goo gld Bittgen Cld~rtvcnr
Bivzivgtcil -FRBCB#/ Mgldoii` Figvd
-MF# gld Rnvcb~ot~vn Figvd -RF#/ ti bgtnv
ti tmn lnndr ia r`goo rbgon gld bittgen
cld~rtvcnr/ f~t tmns gvn clgdnw~gtnos
fgbhnd fs gooibgtcil ia aclglbcgo
vnri~vbnr gld gzzvizvcgtn `glgen`nlt
r~zzivt ti nlr~vn ri~ld clrtct~tcilgo
mngotm, Tmnvnaivn/ ti nlr~vn r~rtgclnd
eviutm ia tmn VLA rnbtiv tmnvn rmi~od
fn gl Clrtct~tcilgo mi`n aiv VLA
gbtcqctcnr, Tmnvn cr g eviucle lnnd iac`zon`nltgtcil ia zvizirgor ia zvnqci~r
zoglr, Tmn Rnbild AcqnSngv Zogl
zvizirnd tmn dnqnoiz`nlt ia V~vgo
Eviutm Bnltvnr cl c`zivtglt `gvhnt
zogbnr, Tmn cld~rtvcnr tmgt unvn rnonbtnd
ti fn zvi`itnd gvn `gl~agbt~vcle v~vgo
tvglrzivt nw~cz`nlt gld gevcb~ot~vgo
c`zon`nltr,
Tmn Tmcvd AcqnSngv Zogl zvizirnd ti rnt
~z N`zois`nlt gld Vnri~vbn Bnltvnr gttmn ~zg{cog onqno aiv tmn zvi`itcil ia
v~vgo lilagv` n`zois`nlt, Tmn bnltvnr
ui~od mgqn tvgclcle gld dn`ilrtvgtcil
~lctr aiv tmn dnqnoiz`nlt ia oibgo bvgatr
gld lnu zvid~bt oclnr, Ct gori zvizirnd ti
rtvnletmnl tmn tnbmlioies dnqnoiz`nlt
gld n}tnlrcil uivh ia tmn FRBCB/ MF/
RF gld tmn Clrtct~tn ia Gzzvizvcgtn
Tnbmlioies -CGT#, G lgtcilgo
biivdclgtcil bi~lbco ugr ti fn nrtgfocrmnd
ti aiv`~ogtn ziocbcnr/ biivdclgtn tmngbtcqctcnr ia qgvci~r genlbcnr nlegend cl
tmn zvi`itcil gld aclglbcle ia v~vgo
nltnvzvcrnr gld ti vnqcnu znvaiv`glbn
gld gbmcnqn`nltr ia r~bm genlbcnr,
Tmn ziocbcnr zvizirnd cl tmn Ai~vtm
Zogl clbo~dn; g# gzzvizvcgtn vnaiv` cl
n}bmglen vgtnr gld tgvcaa ziocbcnr ti
vn`iqn tmn fcgr gegclrt v~vgo cld~rtvcnr8
f# vnrtv~bt~vcle ia tmn ocbnlrcle rsrtn`
ri tmgt r`goo rbgon gld bittgennltnvzvcrnr bgl fnlnact avi` tmn
rsrtn`8 b# dnqnoizcle `nbmglcr`r aiv
cdnltcacbgtcil ia vngo nltvnzvnln~vr gld
nrtgfocrm`nlt ia g rsrtn` ia r~znvqcrnd
bvndct uctmi~t bioogtnvgo rnb~vcts8
d# cltnevgtcle bvndct uctm tvgclcle gld
tnbmlioies n}tnlrcil zvievg``n8 gldn# bilriocdgtcle tmn iznvgtcil ia FRBCB
ri tmgt tmn oc`ctnd aclglbcgo gld
`glgenvcgo vnri~vbnr gvn lit rzvngd tmclos
iqnv tii `gls zviknbtr, Tmn Ai~vtm Zogl
vnbielcrnd tmn vion ia EIr cl tmn
dnqnoiz`nlt ia rhcoor ia tmn ziiv gld
itmnv dcrgdqgltgend evi~zr tmvi~em
`itcqgtcil gld tvgclcle gld zvizirnd ti
nlbi~vgen/ biivdclgtn gld cltnevgtn lil
eiqnvl`nltgo iveglcrgtcil -LEI#
gbtcqctcnr uctm z~focb rnbtiv zvievg``nr
aiv v~vgo cld~rtvcnr, Tmnvn cr g lnnd aiv
rznbcacb gooibgtcil aiv v~vgo gvngr cl
liv`go dnqnoiz`nlt zvievg``nr r~bm gr
rnbildgvs nd~bgtcil/ vigd gld itmnv
tvglrzivt lntuivh/ v~vgo nonbtvcacbgtcil/
clavgrtv~bt~vn aiv tnonbi``~lcbgtcil gld
claiv`gtcil tnbmlioies ntb,
Rznbcgo zvievg``nr rmi~od fn og~lbmnd
r~bm gr qibgtcilgo tvgclcle aiv rnbildgvs
rbmiio dvizi~tr/ rtivgen gld zvibnrrcleagbcoctcnr aiv znvcrmgfon zvid~btr/ g aonnt ia
`idnvl tvglrzivt uctm vnavcenvgtcil
agbcoctcnr,
Tmn Fgleogdnrm Gevcb~ot~vgo
Dnqnoiz`nlt Bivzivgtcil -FGDB# `gs
gori fn vniveglcrnd aiv zviqcdcle tvgclcle
il tmn iznvgtcil gld `gcltnlglbn ia
gevcb~ot~vgo gld lilagv` `gbmclnvs
zgvtcb~ogvos aiv tmn mcem rbmiio dvizi~tr,
FGDB `gs gori nrtgfocrm rtivgen gldzvibnrrcle agbcoctcnr aiv znvcrmgfon
zvid~btr/ gld clqnrt cl dnqnoizcle g aonnt
ia `idnvl tvglrzivt uctm vnavcenvgtcil
agbcoctcnr/ tmn rnvqcbnr ia umcbm `gs
fn vnltndi~t ti v~vgo tvgdnvr gld
nltvnzvnln~vr,
DCGOIE^N IFRNVQGTCILR
Tmn dcgoie~n ugr zgvtcbczgtnd fscld~rtvcnr `clcrtnv @, H, Glugv/ aiv`nv
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
28/88
R~eenrtnd bctgtcil;
Mirrgcl/ @,/ 6::5, Zvi`itcle v~vgo lilagv` nbili`s; cr Fgleogdnrm dicle nli~em9 Vnzvcltnd avi` BZDCVVC
ziocbs fvcna rnvcnr fs Bnltvn aiv Ziocbs Dcgoie~n, Rnvcnr ndctiv ^, H, Dnf, Dmghg/ 6::6, Cl; @geiv/ L, Z,/
Rgogm~ddcl/ G,/ Mgw~n/ @,/ Fcrugr/ T, H, gld Fgllnv`gl/ @,/ ndctivr, ZNTVVG - gl n}znvc`nlt cl zviziiv
gevcb~ot~vgo vnrngvbm, Ziocbs fvcnar li, 2,4, Dmghg -Fgleogdnrm#; Ziqnvts Noc`clgtcil Tmvi~em Vcbn Vnrngvbm
Grrcrtglbn Zviknbt/ Cltnvlgtcilgo Vcbn Vnrngvbm Clrtct~tn, 1 z,
Zvi`itcle v~vgo lil-agv` nbili`s ia Fgleogdnrm
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,4
gevcb~ot~vn `clcrtnv Fne~` @gtcg
Bmiudm~vs/ aiv`nv aclglbn `clcrtnv Dv,
@, Rsnd~{{g`gl/ aiv`nv gdqcriv ti
tmn bgvntghnv eiqnvl`nlt Gfd~o @~snnd
Bmiudm~vs/ cld~rtvcnr rnbvntgvs Go G`cl
Bmiudm~vs/ Zvianrriv @, @~g{{g`M~rgcl/ aiv`nv rnbvntgvs Dv, Tg~acbn
Nogmc Bmiudm~vs/ Zogllcle Bi``crrcil
`n`fnv Zvianrriv @i`tg{ ^ddcl
Gm`nd/ Dv, Rgkkgd [gmcv/ Dv, Mirrgcl
[coo~v Vgm`gl/ Gfd~v Vif ia
Cltnv`ndcgtn Tnbmlioies Dnqnoiz`nlt
Evi~z -CTDE#/ Dv, Kgmglecv Gog` ia
Fgleogdnrm Gevcb~ot~vgo Vnrngvbm Bi~lbco
-FGVB# gld itmnvr, Zgvtcbczgltr
r~eenrtnd tmgt g rt~ds il dn`gld aiv tmn
zvid~btr gld rnvqcbnr cl tmn lilagv`
rnbtiv ti glgosrn tmn gfrivztcqn bgzgbcts
cl tmn di`nrtcb `gvhnt cr nrrnltcgo,
Tmn cld~rtvcnr `clcrtnv @, H, Glugv
~ldnvrbivnd tmn lnnd aiv nrtgfocrmcle
oclhgenr uctm tmn n}zivt `gvhntr aiv
fiirtcle tmn VLA rnbtiv, Tmn aiv`nv
gevcb~ot~vn `clcrtnv Fne~` @gtcg
Bmiudm~vs n`zmgrcrnd tmn lnnd aiv
evgd~gtcle oibgo agv`nvr avi` r~frcrtnlbn
onqno ti g vnogtcqnos fnttnv iaa onqno, Rmn~ldnvrbivnd tmn lnnd aiv g bilbvntn zogl
aiv dnqnoizcle tmn v~vgo lilagv` rnbtiv,
Rmn ifrnvqnd tmgt an`gon uivhnvr/ cl
ri`n bgrnr/ gvn n}zoictnd cl tmn n}crtcle
VLA rnbtiv, Aiv`nv gdqcriv ti tmn
bgvntghnv eiqnvl`nlt gld zvnrnlt
n}nb~tcqn dcvnbtiv ia Fgleogdnrm V~vgo
Gdqglbn`nlt Bi``cttnn -FVGB# Gfd~o
@~snnd Bmiudm~vs ~vend aiv
n`ziunvcle tmn oibgo eiqnvl`nlt fidcnr
clrtngd ia a~vtmnv n}tnldcle tmn gv`r ia
tmn bnltvgo eiqnvl`nlt aiv zvi`itcle
lilagv` nbili`s gr unoo gr aiv iqnvgoo
v~vgo dnqnoiz`nlt, Zvianrriv Vnm`gl
Rifmgl ~vend aiv n}zgldcle bvndct
zivtaiocir cl tmn aiv`go fglhcle gldLEI bmgllnor ri tmgt VLA rnbtiv bgl
tmvcqn gt g zviznv zgbn,
BILBO^DCLE VN@GVHRTmn c`zviqn`nlt cl tmn ocqnocmiid ia tmn
vnri~vbnziiv mi~rnmiodr bi~od fn fnttnv
gbmcnqnd tmvi~em agrtnv eviutm cl lil
bviz gevcb~ot~vn tmgl aiv tmn bviz rnbtiv/
fnbg~rn tmn ogttnv cr `~bm `ivn ogldcltnlrcqn tmgl tmn aiv`nv/ gld tmn ogld cr
ri rbgvbn gld ~lnw~goos dcrtvcf~tnd,
Tmn lilbviz gevcb~ot~vn enlnvgtnr
r~frtgltcgoos mcemnv qgo~n gddnd cl zirt
zvid~btcil -zvibnrrcle/ rtivgen gld
`gvhntcle# gbtcqctcnr tmgt bgl bvngtn
izzivt~lctcnr aiv mcemnv zvid~btcqn
n`zois`nlt aiv tmn ogldziiv
mi~rnmiodr, N}zoictgtcil ia tmcr zitnltcgo
ucoo miunqnv vnw~cvn r~zzivt avi` tmn
z~focb rnbtiv aiv bvngtcle gl nlgfoclenlqcvil`nlt8 fs dnqnoizcle v~vgo
clavgrtv~bt~vnr cl tmn acnod ia tvglrzivt/
ziunv gld bi``~lcbgtcilr8 c`zviqcle
tmn w~gocts gld biqnvgen ia rnbildgvs
gld tnbmlcbgo nd~bgtcil8 zviqcdcle
claiv`gtcil il `gvhntr gld agbcoctcnr
aiv tvgclcle cl nltvnzvnln~vrmcz
dnqnoiz`nlt gr unoo gr zviqcdcle gbbnrr
ti aclglbn aiv vnri~vbnziiv mi~rnmiodr,
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
29/88
CLTVID^BTCIL
Gevcb~ot~vn/ tnbmlioies tvglranv gld
vnri~vbn-ziiv agv`nvr
Aiv `gls sngvr/ vnrngvbmnvr/ n}tnlrcilcrtr
gld v~vgo dnqnoiz`nlt uivhnvr cl
Fgleogdnrm mgqn fnnl tvscle ti c`zviqn
tmn zvid~btcqcts ia r`goo agv` gevcb~ot~vgorsrtn`r cl dnqnoizcle bi~ltvcnr fscltvid~bcle lnu tnbmlioiecnr/ lnu bvizr
gld qgvcntcnr gld clbvngrcle clz~tr, Iatnltmcr mgr fnnl tmn cltvid~btcil ia rcleon
lnu qgvcntcnr gld tnbmlioiecnr cltibi`zon} rsrtn`r, Tmcr gzzvigbm mgr ilos
fnnl zgvtos r~bbnrra~o gld cl ri`n bgrnr
tmn cltvid~btcil ia tmn lnu tnbmlioiesmgr ilos fnnl r~bbnrra~o d~vcle tmn ocan ia
tmn zviknbt cl umcbm ct ugr cltvid~bnd,
Tmn cltvid~btcil mgr gori fnnl dnznldnltil g ogven r~frcds gld r~zzivt rsrtn`
umcbm cr lit r~rtgclgfon, R~bm gl
gzzvigbm mgr iatnl fnlnactnd ogvenvagv`nvr -tmirn uctm `ivn r~frtgltcgo
vnri~vbnr ia ogld gld itmnv grrntr# vgtmnvtmgl ziivnv ilnr, Tmn itmnv c`zivtglt
bmgvgbtnvcrtcb ia zgrt tnbmlioiecbgo
r~zzivt avi` vnrngvbm ugr tmgt tmn aib~r ugr go`irt nltcvnos il `gon agv`nvr fs
vnrngvbmnvr umi tmn`rnoqnr unvn `gon,
Tmn gvngr ia agv` gbtcqcts tmgt unvntvgdctcilgoos tmn di`gcl ia ui`nl
qnentgfonr/ mi`nrtngd egvdnlcle/ r`goo
ocqnrtibh/ zirtmgvqnrt zvibnrrcle gldr`goo nltnvzvcrnr unvn ecqnl octton
gttnltcil,
Tmn lnnd aiv g lnu gzzvigbm;
rsrtn`r/ zgvtcbczgtcil gld ocqnocmiidr
Cl vnbnlt tc`nr/ tmnvn mgr fnnl g
vnbielctcil tmgt r`goo agv`r gvn tmn fgrn
aiv bi`zon}/ cltnevgtnd ocqnocmiid rsrtn`r
umcbm gvn iznvgtnd fs agv`cle ag`cocnr/
tmn `n`fnvr ia umcbm mgqn dcaanvnltvionr gld a~lbtcilr gld gori grzcvgtcilr,
Ag`cocnr r~vqcqn tmvi~em g vglen ia
gbtcqctcnr/ ri`n ilagv` gld itmnvr
iaaagv` gld tmns `cemt nqnl mgqn
g rcelcacbglt clbi`n avi` g lilgevcb~ot~vgo ibb~zgtcil, Tmn zgvtcbczgtcil
ia goo tmn ag`cos `n`fnvr cl tmn vnrngvbm
gld dnqnoiz`nlt zvibnrr gld tmcr
clbo~dnr tmn dnrcel gld c`zon`nltgtcil
ia lnu tnbmlcbgo iztcilr mgr fnnl
vnbielcrnd gr nrrnltcgo ca tmnrn lnu cdngr
gvn ti `ghn g znv`glnlt dcaanvnlbn ti
ocqnocmiidr,
Dcaanvnltcgtcil ia agv`nvr
Glitmnv c`zivtglt dcrtclbtcil umcbm mgrfnnl vnbielcrnd fs vnrngvbmnvr cr tmgt gooagv`nvr gld agv`r gvn lit goo tmn rg`n
gld tmgt ziivnv ag`cocnr/ zgvtcb~ogvos tmirn
uctm `clc`go ogld/ mgqn evngt dcaacb~otcnr
`iqcle i~t ia tmncv rct~gtcil ia n}tvn`nziqnvts, R~bm ag`cocnr mgqn dcaanvnlt
zvcivctcnr gld dcaanvnlt zitnltcgor tmgl
ag`cocnr tmgt mgqn gbbnrr ti `ivn
vnri~vbnr gld tmnvnaivn tmn gzzvigbm ia
vnrngvbm gld dnqnoiz`nlt genlbcnr lnndrti fn dcaanvnlt aiv tmn`, Cl tmn Ziqnvts
Noc`clgtcil Tmvi~em Vcbn Vnrngvbm
Grrcrtglbn -ZNTVVG# r~fzviknbt -RZ#
tmn clctcgo dcqcrcil ia tmn agv`clebi``~lctcnr clti ogldonrr/ `gveclgo gld
r`goo agv`r ugr ti nlr~vn tmgt tmn
dcaanvnlt lnndr ia tmnrn evi~zr unvn
gddvnrrnd avi` gl ngvos ziclt, Ct ugr
vnbielcrnd tmgt tmn dcrtclbtcil fntunnltmnrn bgtneivcnr il tmn fgrcr ia
ogldmiodcle ugr r~fknbt ti ri`n
Ziocbs
fvcna li, 2,>
Dgqcd Ecffil
Avi` tnbmlioiecnr gld nltnvzvcrnr ti`ivn r~rtgclgfon ocqnocmiidr
Avi` tnbmlioiecnr gld nltnvzvcrnr ti`ivn r~rtgclgfon ocqnocmiidr
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
30/886
gli`gocnr -n,e,/ ri`n ogldonrr znizon`cemt mgqn mgd r~frtgltcgo iaaagv`n`zois`nlt umcbm bi~od mgqn `gdntmn` `~bm fnttnv - iaa tmgl glitmnvogldonrr agv`nvr umi mgqn li n}tnvlgo
n`zois`nlt#, Dnrzctn tmcr/ fs tghcle gogven rg`zon ia rt~ds agv`r -6: ogldonrr/6: `gveclgo gld 7: r`goo agv`r cl ngbm ia> rctnr gbvirr tmn bi~ltvs# ct ugr grr~`ndtmgt tmn dcaanvnltcgtcil ia agv`cleag`cocnr cl tmcr `gllnv ui~od mcemocemttmn dcrtclbtcqn lgt~vn ia agv`cle ~ldnvdcaanvnlt bcvb~`rtglbnr,
OCQNOCMIIDR; TMN LNU AIB^R Tmn fgrcr ia ocqnocmiidr glgosrcr cr tmgtagv`cle ag`cocnr mgqn acqn bgzctgo grrntr
umcbm gvn dcaanvnlt aiv nqnvs agv`, Tmnrngvn;
M~`gl; Znizon mgqn rhcoor gldhliuonden umcbm mgqn fnnl egclndavi` `gls dcaanvnlt ri~vbnr zgvnltr/rbmiior gld ocan n}znvcnlbnr,
Ribcgo; Ribcntcnr gvn `gdn ~z ia znizon
umi cltnvgbt cl g qgvcnts ia ugsr gldtmn rtvnletm ia g ribcnts `gs fn k~dendavi` tmn tsznr ia cltnvgbtcilr gldclrtct~tcilr tmgt znizon bgl f~cod ~ziqnv tc`n, Ribcgo cltnvgbtcilr `gs fn
ungh iv rtvile, Cl `irt ia tmn rt~dsgvngr ia tmn ZNTVVG RZ/ ui`nl%r
biiznvgtcil ugr lit rtvile fnaivn tmnzviknbt fnegl,
Zmsrcbgo; Ag`cocnr mgqn mi~rnr/ glc`go
rmndr/ rtivgen / nw~cz`nlt gld tiior
umcbm tmns f~cod ~z iqnv tc`n, @gls
ziivnv ag`cocnr cl Fgleogdnrm mgqn ti
vnlnu `~bm ia tmcr zmsrcbgo vnri~vbn
il g vne~ogv fgrcr avi` vnlnugfon
`gtnvcgor gr tmns di lit mgqn tmn
aclglbcgo vnri~vbnr ti z~vbmgrn `ivn
d~vgfon gtnvcgor,
Lgt~vgo; Agv`cle ag`cocnr mgqn gbbnrrti `ivn il onrr ogldmiodcler
mi`nrtngd gvngr/ ogld gvi~ld tmcr gld
ogld iulnd iv vnltnd iv rmgvnbvizznd
cl tmn qcbclcts, Tmns mgqn rnndr/ tvnnr/
bvizr gld ocqnrtibh umcbm `ghn ~z tmncv
lgt~vgo vnri~vbn fgrn,
Aclglbcgo; @n`fnvr ia agv`cle ag`cocnr
mgqn aclglbcgo grrntr umcbm gvn dnvcqndavi` ngvlnd clbi`n/ rgonr ia zvid~bn/
ecatr gld rgqcler gld tmnrn gvn r~fknbt
ti ao~bt~gtcilr iqnv tc`n gr g vnr~ot ia
dnftr gld itmnv bi``ct`nltr,
Goo ag`cocnr gvn r~fknbt ti g dnevnn ia vcrhgld ~lbnvtgclts fnbg~rn ia tmncv
bcvb~`rtglbnr/ nctmnv oibgo iv `ivn
vnecilgo, Aoiidr/ dvi~emt gld dngtm `gsfvcle g mcem dnevnn ia ao~bt~gtcil clti
aclglbcgo `glgen`nlt gr ucoo ziiv
zvid~btcil avi` lgt~vgo vnri~vbnr cl
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,>
Avi` tnbmlioiecnr gld nltnvzvcrnr ti`ivn r~rtgclgfon ocqnocmiidr
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
31/882
ziivnv tmgl gqnvgen sngvr% ungtmnv,
Ag`cocnr r~vqcqn fs tvglraiv`cle tmncvgrrntr tmvi~em tmncv iul rtvgtnecnr ti
zvid~bn dnrcvgfon i~tbi`nr, Ngbm ag`cos ucoo mgqn dcaanvnlt rtvgtnecnr gld tmn
i~tbi`nr ucoo fn dcaanvnlt aiv dcaanvnltbgtneivcnr ia agv`r gld aiv dcaanvnltcldcqcd~gor,
Ct cr tmn vnbielctcil gld ~ldnvrtgldcle ia
goo tmnrn agbtivr fs vnrngvbmnvr gldn}tnlrcilcrtr tmgt mgr zviqcdnd tmn
fgbhevi~ld ti tmn ZNTVVG ocqnocmiidr
RZ,
LNU TNBMLIOIECNR GLDNLTNVZVCRN R^ZZIVTTmn zviknbt mgr iaanvnd ti agv`nvr g ucdnvglen ia tnbmlioiecnr; lnu bvizr/ lnu
bviz qgvcntcnr/ qnentgfonr umcbm gvngdgztnd ti g ucdn vglen ia lcbmnnlqcvil`nltr gvi~ld tmn mi`nrtngd -n,e,/
r~lls zogbnr/ rmgds zogbnr/ iqnv tmn viia/il dnnz fndr#/ av~ct tvnnr/ r`goo ocqnrtibh
-bmcbhnlr/ eigtr/ zcenilr#/ ogven ocqnrtibh
-bgtton#/ acrm cl zildr gld tcdgo bglgor/bi`zirtcle/ bvgat nltnvzvcrn dnqnoiz`nlt-ne, rtiior/ fgtch/ rnucle boitm#, Ngbmtnbmlioies mgr fnnl gbbi`zglcnd fs
tvgclcle `id~onr gld fs tmn zvi`crn iafgbh ~z r~zzivt -aclglbcgo gld tnbmlcbgo#,
Agv`nvr -fitm `gon gld an`gon# mgqnfnnl gooiund ti bmiirn gr `gls gld
umcbm nqnv tnbmlioies tmns ucrm ti gdiztgld ct mgr fnnl vn`gvhgfon miu `gls
ui`nl mgqn fnbi`n nlegend cl tmcr
zvibnrr, Tmns mgqn fnnl qnvs hnnl ti tvsi~t `gls mi`nrtngd gvngr dnqnoiz`nlt
iztcilr/ qnentgfonr/ r`goo rtibh gld r`goonltnvzvcrn -gevcb~ot~vgo gld lil
gevcb~ot~vgo# dnqnoiz`nlt, Tmcr mgr ondti rcelcacbglt bmglenr cl ocqnocmiidr iaag`cocnr/ bcvb~`rtglbnr/ rtgt~r ia ui`nl
gld bmcodvnl cl tmn ag`cos gld cl tmncvbi``~lctcnr, @gveclgo agv`nvr rnn` ti
mgqn fnnl gfon ti vnrzild fnttnv ti tmnrn
clctcgtcqnr `ivn r~bbnrra~oos tmgl ogldonrriv r`goo agv`nvr,
OCQNOCMIID C@ZGBTR Tmn c`zgbt il ocqnocmiidr mgr fnnlbilrcdnvgfon, Tmn lnu bvizr; mcemscndocle -MS# vcbn qgvcntcnr/ zitgtinr/ ihvg/ntb, mgqn zvid~bnd r~frtgltcgo scnodclbvngrnr iqnv iodnv qgvcntcnr/ g lnu vglenia qnentgfon bvizr gvn liu eviulgoilercdn tvgdctcilgo qnentgfonr gld `glslnu lcbmnr cl tmn mi`nrtngd gvn liu~tcocrnd tmgt unvn lit zvnqci~ros ~rnd,Ricor mgqn fnnl c`zviqnd tmvi~em tmn ~rnia `gl~vn gld bi`zirt umcbm cr liuzirrcfon rclbn tmn cltvid~btcil iaocqnrtibh il zvnqci~ros rtibhonrr agv`r,Agv`nvr% rhcoor gld hliuonden mgqn
clbvngrnd dvg`gtcbgoos/ zgvtcb~ogvos uctmui`nl umi lnqnv mgd gbbnrr ti tmcr hcldia claiv`gtcil fnaivn, Uctm tmn`glgen`nlt ia ocqnrtibh/ tmn rhcoorlnndnd ti qgbbclgtn rtibh gld ti dnuiv`bgtton/ mgqn fnnl gbw~cvnd , Gl c`zivtgltgvng tmgt mgr fnnl zgvtcb~ogvos r~bbnrra~omgr fnnl uctm qnentgfon zvid~btcil/ tmneviucle gld n}bmglen ia zogltr gld rnndrgld tmn dnqnoiz`nlt ia g %rnnd e~gvdcglb~ot~vn% g`ile `gls an`gon agv`nvr,
@~bm hliuonden mgr fnnl egclndtmvi~em ongvlcle fs dicle gld fsn}bmglenr ia claiv`gtcil fntunnlagv`nvr gld rnvqcbn zviqcdnvr,
OCLHGENR/ RSRTN@R GLD RSLNVECNR;BSBOCLE/ DNZNLDNLBCNR/
N@NVENLT ZVIZNVTCNR
Avi` g agv`cle rsrtn`r znvrznbtcqn/ tmn
cltvid~btcil ia tmnrn `gls tnbmlioiecnrmgr mgd ri`n zirctcqn naanbtr il tmn aoiurgld oclhgenr fntunnl bi`zilnltr ia tmnrsrtn`, Ocqnrtibh anndr gvn zgvtos eviulgld gori z~vbmgrnd/ ocqnrtibh zvid~bn
ugrtn umcbm cr tvglranvvnd ti tmn bi`zirtzct, Tmn bi`zirt cr tmnl ogtnv rzvngd ilacnodr umcbm `gcltgclr tmn anvtcocts ia tmnrico, Bviz scnodr vcrn gld zvid~bnevngtnv zmsrcbgo r~vzo~rnr umcbm `gs fnbilr~`nd/ riod iv ~rnd aiv aiddnv iv
a~no, Fnttnv and ag`cos `n`fnvr gvnmngotmcnv gld gvn gfon ti uivh oilenv gld
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,>
Avi` tnbmlioiecnr gld nltnvzvcrnr ti`ivn r~rtgclgfon ocqnocmiidr
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
32/88
uctm evngtnv nlnves tmgl fnaivn, @gls
agv` rsrtn`r liu n}mcfct umgt gvn hliul
gr n`nvenlt zviznvtcnr umcbm gvn i~tz~tr
iqnv gld gfiqn tmn r~` ia tmn i~tz~tr
avi` tmn cldcqcd~go bi`zilnltr, Iln
n`nvenlt zviznvts ui~od fn tmn gfcocts iatmn rsrtn` -cl ctr nltcvnts# ti clbvngrn ctr
iqnvgoo zvid~btcqcts il g r~rtgclnd fgrcr,
Ribcgo rtgt~r cr vgcrnd uctmcl tmn
bi``~lcts gld ucdnv oclhgenr gvn
dnqnoiznd umcbm nlmglbn clbi`n
enlnvgtcle izzivt~lctcnr gld r~rtgclgfcocts
ia tmn ocqnocmiid,
OCQNOCMIID RTVGTNECNR; UI@NL%RVIONR -- UIVH OIGD/ TVGCLCLE/L^TVCTCIL IA AG@COS CLQNRT@NLTR
Ct cr ~ldi~ftndos tv~n tmgt tmn uivh oigdr
ia ui`nl gld bmcodvnl mgqn clbvngrnd gr
g vnr~ot ia tghcle il tmnrn lnu
tnbmlioiecnr, Tmn agv`cle ag`cocnr
dnbcdnd umcbm gld miu `gls
tnbmlioiecnr tmns ui~od gdizt, Iln
bilrnw~nlbn ia tmnrn bmglenr mgr fnnl
gl c`zviqn`nlt cl ag`cos aiid w~gltcts
gld w~gocts gld tmn enlnvgtcil ia
r~vzo~rnr aiv ecatr/ n}bmglenr gld aiv
rgonr, Gr g vnr~ot/ clbi`n mgr clbvngrnd
gld tmn ui`nl cl `gls qcoogenr mgqn
aiv`nd rgqcler evi~zr, Mnvn/ ui`nl
biltvcf~tn Th, 7: g `iltm gld gvn nocecfon
aiv oiglr aiv tmn z~vbmgrn ia ocqnrtibh
-aiv n}g`zon# iv cl tmn clqnrt`nlt ia lnulilgevcb~ot~vgo nltnvzvcrnr,
RTV^BT^VNR; LNTUIVHR GLDR^ZZIVT @NBMGLCR@R
Tmnrn qnvs rcelcacbglt bmglenr mgqn fnnl
fvi~emt gfi~t zgvtos fs tmn qnvs
bilrcdnvgfon clz~tr umcbm gvn vnbncqnd fs
agv`nvr avi` tmn zviknbt, Gt ri`n tc`n cl
tmn a~t~vn tmn zviknbt ucoo zmgrn i~t gld
fs tmgt tc`n tmnvn mgqn ti fn r~zzivt
`nbmglcr`r cl zogbn umcbm ucoo tghn tmn
zogbn ia tmn vionr umcbm gvn b~vvnltos
fncle zviqcdnd fs tmn zviknbt, Tmnrn
clbo~dn; rnnd r~zzos/ aiddnv aiv ocqnrtibh/
qgbbclgtcil/ dnuiv`cle `gtnvcgor/
rzvgscle ia av~ct tvnnr gld gbbnrr ti
anvtcocrnv, Gt tmn `i`nlt tmnrn rnvqcbnr
gvn/ gt ongrt cl zgvt/ zviqcdnd fs tmnzviknbt f~t rtnzr gvn fncle tghnl ti nlr~vn
tmgt agv`nvr gvn gugvn ia umnvn gld miu
ti gbw~cvn tmnrn clz~tr, R~bm `nbmglcr`r
govngds n}crt gld ct cr rc`zos g bgrn ia
iveglcrcle tmn gbbnrr gld dnocqnvs ia tmnrn
nrrnltcgo clz~tr gt tmn gzzvizvcgtn tc`n
nqnvs sngv, Glitmnv gvng umnvn eviucle
lntuivhr gvn c`zivtglt cr cl `gvhntcle ia
r~vzo~r zvid~bn, Aiv `gls ia tmn lnunv
bvizr/ `gvhntr gvn ilos k~rt dnqnoizcle
gld agv`nvr gvn ongvlcle miu gld umnvnti `gvhnt tmn zvid~bn tmgt tmns ui~od
ochn ti rnoo, B~vvnltos f~snvr gvn fnecllcle
ti qcrct qcoogenr cl ivdnv ti z~vbmgrn
zvid~bn dcvnbtos gld ri`n agv`nvr
-m~rfgldr gld rilr# gvn `gvhntcle cl
oibgo `gvhntr gld tiulr,
Tmnrn bmglenr mgqn vnr~otnd cl ui`nl
fnbi`cle `ivn bilacdnlt gld n`ziunvnd
gld tmns liu hliu umnvn ti ei ti iftgcl
rnvqcbnr gld clz~tr, Tmns gvn tmnvnaivnfnbi`cle `ivn cldnznldnlt ia tmn
zviknbt cl tmncv r~bbnrr, Tmnrn gvn zirctcqn
bmglenr cl m~`gl gld ribcgo bgzctgo,
Itmnv c`zivtglt r~zzivt `nbmglcr`r gvn
tmn oibgo rnvqcbn zviqcdnvr - n}tnlrcil
rnvqcbnr/ fitm enlnvgo gld rznbcacb -n,e,/
ocqnrtibh mngotm/ bviz rsrtn`r# - umcbm
gvn zviqcdnd ti mnoz gls oibgo agv`nvr,
Oibgo bi``nvbcgo cltnvnrtr gvn gori zgvt ia
tmn ucdnv lntuivh ti umcbm agv`nvr gvnfnecllcle ti fn oclhnd,
4
Ziocbsfvcna li, 2,>
Avi` tnbmlioiecnr gld nltnvzvcrnr ti`ivn r~rtgclgfon ocqnocmiidr
-
8/14/2019 Book 3: Policy briefs - PETRRA - An experiment in pro-poor agricultural research
33/88
ZVIBNRRNR; RBCNLTCRT GLDN]TNLRCILCRT BMGLENR GLD
ONGVLCLE/ AGV@NV ONGVLCLE/
LNTUIVH ONGVLCLE
Iln litgfon i~tbi`n avi` tmn zviknbtmgr fnnl tmn ongvlcle zvibnrrnr ia tmnlgt~vgo rbcnltcrtr gld n}tnlrcilcrtr umimgqn zgvtcbczgtnd, Tmns unvn ivceclgoosgevcb~ot~vgo evgd~gtnr umi `gclos dngot
uctm `gon agv`nvr gld unvn ilosbilbnvlnd uctm lnu vcbn qgvcntcnr/gotnvlgtcqn acnod bvizr gld bvizzclersrtn`r, Rclbn tmn zviknbt fnegl tmnsmgqn fnnl grhnd ti uivh uctm goo ag`cos`n`fnvr gld ti fn mcemos aon}cfon
cl dnqnoizcle tmirn nltnvzvcrnr tmgtcltnvnrtnd agv`nvr, Fs n}zir~vn ti tmcr
ucdn vglen ia iztcilr gld cl uivhcle uctm an`gon agv`nvr umi mgqn fnbi`nmcemos `itcqgtnd/ zvianrrcilgo rtgaa mgqnongvlnd g evngt dngo gfi~t tmn uivhcler iabi`zon} agv`cle rsrtn`r umcbm mgqn`gls non`nltr - mi`nrtngd bvizr/ tvnnrgld r`goo rtibh/ gvngr gvi~ld tmnmi`nrtngd/ bvizznd ogld -iulnd/ vnltnd/rmgvn bvizznd# gld lilgevcb~ot~vgonltnvzvcrnr, Tmncv nltm~rcgr` gfi~t tmnc`zgbt ia tmn zviknbt cr qnvs nqcdnlt gldtmncv vnogtcilrmcz uctm goo agv`nvr/zgvtcb~ogvos ui`nl/ mgr c`zviqnd evngtos,
Tmncv gfcocts ti bi``~lcbgtn unoo cl gvngrtmgt mctmnvti mgd fnnl bilrcdnvnd qnvsdcaacb~ot gld bilrnvqgtcqn -n,e,/ Lighmgoc#cr qnvs c`zvnrrcqn,
R^RTGCLGFCOCTS; R^ZZIVT RSRTN@RGLD NLQCVIL