distribution of grammatical aspect morphemes in interlanguage dr. p. gonzález leiden university
Post on 22-Dec-2015
213 views
TRANSCRIPT
DISTRIBUTION OF GRAMMATICAL ASPECT MORPHEMES
IN INTERLANGUAGE
Dr. P. GonzálezLeiden University
Abstract Initial stage(s) of the acquisition of the L2 Spanish
aspectual system by L1 Dutch adult learners
Aspect Hypothesis
Predicational Effect Hypothesis
17 Dutch classroom L2 learners of Spanish following a beginner’s course took part on this experiment. They wrote a number of compositions
A hypothesis comparing analysis shows that it is not the lexical semantics of the verbs what partly influences the verb choice but the predicational aspect
4 steps: (1) Cross-linguistic analysis
(2) Acquisition theory
(3) Study
(4) Methodological implications
(1)Cross-linguistic analysis
General linguistic principles: Tense and aspect are often treated
as a twin pair having complementary tasks:
a) tense provides the location; b) aspect gives information about the
perspective from which the eventuality is described.
Tense (pasts) Dutch: the voltooid tegenwoordige tijd (present perfect) the verleden tijd (simple past) Spanish: the pretérito perfecto compuesto (present perfect) the pretérito perfecto simple (simple past
perfective) the pretérito imperfecto (simple past
imperfective)
Aspect Grammatical: Spanish: the pretérito perfecto simple
(simple past perfective)the pretérito imperfecto (simple
past imperfective)
Predicational: Dutch: terminative eventualities
durative eventualities Spanish: terminative eventualities
durative eventualities
Table 1: Dutch pasts
Imperfect(onvoltooid)
Perfect(voltooid)
Durative 1 Zij zong she sang
2 Zij heeft gezongen she has sung
Terminative
3 Zij zong een lied she sang a song
4 Zij heeft een lied gezongen she has a song sung
Table 2: Spanish pastsImperfecto(Imperfect)
Perfecto simple(Simple perfect)
Perfecto compuesto(Compound Perfect)
Durative
1 cantaba sang.IMP.3rdp
2 cantó sang.PF.3rdp
3 ha cantado has sung
Terminative
4 cantaba una canción sang.IMP.3rdp a song
5 cantó una canción sang.PF.3rdp a song
6 ha cantado una canción has sung a song
Comparison between systems: Dutch Tense versus Spanish Tense: 1 tense
more in Spanish
Spanish Grammatical Aspect: no formal equivalent in Dutch
Dutch Predicational Aspect versus Spanish Predicational Aspect: the same in both languages!!
(2)Acquisition TheoryEffect of the L1
Which effect will a learner’s native language have on the acquisition of the aspectual properties of the L2?
What do they know about their L1’s temporal-aspectual system?
Aspect in Dutch: terminative/durative; will this have an effect?
New L2 information
Which aspectual information the L2 learner confronts for the first time?
In Spanish, the terminative/durative distinction does no have any influence on the choice of verb form
Different approaches to the acquisition of aspect and tense
Functional/pragmatic/context oriented research: Salaberry
Sentential level research: Andersen and his Aspect Hypothesis
Aspect Hypothesis “(…) Second language learners will initially
be influenced by the inherent semantic aspect of verbs or predicates in the acquisition of tense and aspect markers associated with or affixed to these verbs”
The AH is based on Vendler’s quadripartition: states, activities, accomplishments and achievements (verbal meanings)
“why use 4 when everything that needs to be accounted for
holds for 2”
Bipartitions: a) terminative and durative (predicational
meanings)b) perfective and imperfective (grammatical
meanings) Predication Effect Hypothesis: A division into terminative and durative predications presents an optimal description of what happens to the Spanish past tenses in the interlanguage of Dutch L2 learners
(3) Experimental Study 17 1st year students 11 weeks Compositions about the past Statistical analysis and comparison
Table 3: Use perfective/imperfective according to quadripartition by Dutch L2 learners of Spanish
1 2 3 4 5
Week of Measurement
40
60
80
100
App
eara
nce
(Per
cent
ages
)
Achievement AchievementAccomplishment Accomplishment
Accomplishment
Accomplishment AccomplishmentActivity
Activity
Activity
Activity
State State
State
State
State
Table 4: Use perfective/imperfective according to terminative/durative division of predicates
Dutch beginner students DO rely on the predicational aspect the eventuality
conveys to use the perfective/imperfective morphology of the verb
Perfective = Imperfective =
Terminative Durative
(and not on the quadripartition)
Showing that it is not always valid may be the key
towards successful instruction
(All this may mean pedagogical implications!!!)
(4) Methodological implications
Knowing the differences among the languages at stake won’t be enough
Pointing out the problem won’t be enough Analysing the acquisition problem + Understanding the theoretical
foundations behind the problem ------------------------------------------------------------
Proper understanding of the acquisition difficulties
How: via an instruction including 3 parts:
1 - instruction on terminativity in the L1 (Dutch)
2 - instruction on terminativity in the L2 (Spanish)
3 - instruction on perfectivity in the L2 (Spanish).
Conclusions The use of verbal morphology is clearly
influenced by predicational aspect In essence, the use of the perfective is
extended to all predications Application: these findings have allowed
to create a new method to teach Dutch learners of Spanish the functions of the two simple-past tenses
References: Andersen, R. (1991). Developmental sequences: the emergence of
aspect marking in second language acquisition. In T. Hueber & A. Ferguson (Eds.), Crosscurrents in SLA and linguistic theories (pp. 305-324). Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
Bardovi-Harlig, K. (2000). Tense and aspect in second language acquisition: form, meaning and use. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
González, P. (2003). Aspects on Aspect: Theory and Applications of Grammatical Aspect in Spanish. PhD. Dissertation. University of Utrecht. Lot series 71.
Li, P. & Shirai, Y. (2000). The acquisition of lexical and grammatical aspect. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Salaberry, R. (2000). The development of past tense morphology in L2 Spanish. In K. de Bot & T. Huebner (Eds.). In series Studies in Bilingualism, Vol. 22. Amsterdam/ Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
Vendler, Z. (1957). Verb and times. Philosophical Review, 66, 143-160. Verkuyl, H. J. (1999). Aspectual issues. Studies on time and quantity.
California: CLSI Publications.