dignity & fairness in process · and with dignity in the life of the university. my hope is...

36
DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS Human Rights Services Annual Report 2016-17 & 2017-18

Upload: others

Post on 13-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS

Human Rights Services Annual Report

2016-17 & 2017-18

Page 2: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

WE BEGIN BY LISTENING.

Page 3: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

"Every day, this team quickly responds to some of the most highly controversial and complex issues on our campus, and they do this work with integrity and humility."

Lisa Barnoff Dean, Faculty of Community Services Index

Introduction 4

A Message from Dr. Denise O'Neil Green, Vice-President, Equity & Community Inclusion 5

Director and Human Rights Services 6

Overview of Human Rights Services 7

Policies 11

Complaint Processes 13

Inquiries 15

Caseload Statistics and Trends 17

Disability 19

Creed 21

Race, Colour, Ancestry, Ethnic Origin and/or Citizenship 23

Sexual Violence 25

Sex, Sexual Orientation, Family Status, Gender Identity and/or

Marital Status 27

Human Rights Services Team 29

Prevention Through Partnerships and Education 31

Page 4: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

33

"I was apprehensive about voicing concerns regarding anti-Black racism to administration. In doing so, I was humbled by the work of the Director of the Human Rights Services Office and Office of the Vice-President, Equity and Community Inclusion. As reflections of the community they serve, the offices applied cultural relevance and policy to a dynamic matter. Being a person who intersects gender and ethnicity, I felt like my voice was heard and taken seriously. The offices were supportive and committed to a dignified resolution that not only addressed my concerns but facilitated better outcomes for diverse people at the University." Anonymous Participant of the Complaint Process

Page 5: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

4

Introduction

The two year period this report covers, May 2016 to April 2017 and May 2017 to April 2018, have

seen a significant transformation to the human-rights infrastructure at Ryerson University. This

report covers these changes and presents a clear summary of the work of Human Rights Services.

The transformation of human rights at Ryerson had two distinct phases. In 2016, the office

changed its name from Discrimination and Harassment Prevention Services to Human Rights

Services. This change reflected the vision of Dr. Denise O'Neil Green to make the office more

accessible as well as human-rights centred.

Dr. Denise O'Neil Green, then Assistant Vice-President and Vice-Provost, Equity, Diversity and

Inclusion, has been since promoted to Vice-President, Equity and Community Inclusion, making

her the first post-secondary Vice President in Canada with an exclusive equity focus. The Director

of Human Rights Services reports directly to Dr. Green, who in turn reports to the President. This

means human-rights issues are a priority to senior administration.

In January 2017, Human Rights Services welcomed a new Director, Tanya (Toni) De Mello. Under

Ms. De Mello's leadership, the office has doubled in size, adopted a new data collection method

for complaints, and developed communications materials to explain clearly the complaint process

to the Ryerson community. Dr. Green and Ms. De Mello have worked closely together to foster a

culture of prevention through education and to address human rights challenges at the earliest

stage, focusing on outreach, partnership building, and early resolution.

Over the same reporting period, we have also witnessed a significant change in the landscape of

human-rights complaints within post-secondary education. Students, staff and faculty have shown

an increased willingness to file formal complaints when they perceive someone to have engaged in

behaviour in contravention of human rights policy. There is also a change happening globally.

Human rights and equity issues are part of the public discourse more than ever, as seen in the

#metoo movement, the introduction of Ontario's sexual violence legislation (Bill 132), the rise in

students registered with disabilities requiring accommodations, and the complex issues

surrounding race and access to higher education. This report provides the human rights and

sexual violence complaint statistics at Ryerson, context for the statistics, and the innovative and

collabrative interventions Human Rights Services has developed, with other partners, to address

issues using a trauma-informed approach.

Page 6: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

5

Dr. Denise O’Neil Green Vice-President, Equity & Community Inclusion

It is with great pleasure that I present this report to the

Ryerson community. Human rights are a fundamental

aspect of equity, diversity and inclusion and, as such,

Ryerson is striving to become a human-rights centred

university. As Vice-President, Equity and Community

Inclusion, it is my responsibility to provide strategic

leadership, advocacy, and coordination needed to address

equity, diversity and inclusion throughout the entire

university community.

Human Rights Services is a unit of the Office of the Vice-President, Equity and Community

Inclusion (OVPECI), which serves all Ryerson community members by ensuring there is a fair process

to hear concerns and resolve complaints related to human rights and sexual violence. In 2017, I

welcomed Tanya (Toni) De Mello as the Director of Human Rights Services. Toni brings to the role a

wealth of experience in business, non-profit and government sectors.

The two years this report covers have seen a significant increase in human rights and sexual

violence complaints. The increase in sexual violence complaints results from multiple factors: the

2017 implementation of the province's new sexual violence legislation - Bill 132, social movements

challenging sexual violence such as #metoo movement and a broader shift towards individuals filing

equity complaints across the university sector. Human rights work is complex, calling upon a matrix

of legislation, investigation practices, alternative dispute processes and prevention through

education. It is important to recognize that the increase in complaints and investigations is a sign of

the university's commitment to hear concerns and respond by having a fair process to address equity

challenges.

This report is an opportunity to reflect on the essential work of Human Rights Services and enable

us to identify aspirational goals, which allow all Ryerson community members to participate fully

and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an

appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on the equity challenges of the 21st century.

Page 7: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

6

Tanya De Mello Director, Human Rights Services

Tanya De Mello, known at Ryerson as

"Toni," was appointed Director, Human

Rights Services in January 2017.

Toni has worked for over 20 years in

business, non-profit and government

sectors. She started her career as an

economist, working in business as a

consultant during the day and in the

community sector after hours.

Having worked as a management consultant for several years and co-founded two NGOs in

Toronto, Toni went on to complete two masters degrees at Princeton University, the first in

Public Administration and the second in Urban and Regional Planning.

Her studies led her into peacebuilding, first through the Office of the United Nations High

Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) in Geneva and later in the UNHCR Field Office for

Emergency Relief through the UN World Food Programme (WFP) in Senegal. She then returned

to the UNHCR to work in a field office in Colombia, South America.

As Director, Toni provides leadership and direction for the day-to-day management of Human

Rights Services, oversees the case management of human rights and sexual violence complaints,

and develops initiatives to foster a campus culture which centres on human rights. She partners

with faculties, staff departments, units and student groups on campus to carry out the work of the

office. She also conducts campus wide equity training on human rights issues as well as

individual coaching to help Ryerson members navigate complex human rights issues.

Toni also holds dual law degrees, BCL in civil law and LLB in common law, from McGill

University and was called to the bar in June 2012. She is currently completing her PhD in Social

Justice Education at the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education (OISE), where she is

examining equity in interview processes.

Page 8: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

7

Overview of Human Rights Services

Our Vision Through our work and our presence, we hope that every member of Ryerson University will feel

included and have equitable access to opportunities regardless of their identity. We envision

Ryerson as a human rights-centered campus where meeting the goals of equity and community

inclusion is a shared responsibility. We envision a strong community that values the human rights

and dignity of all its members and where members feel safe and valued, bringing their whole selves

to their work and learning environments.

Our Mission In cooperation with our campus partners, Human Rights Services works to promote an equitable

and inclusive campus community, free from discrimination and harassment based on the

protected grounds identified in the Ontario Human Rights Code.

Our Mandate Manage inquiries, consultations, alternative resolutions and investigations processes for

human rights and sexual violence issues using a trauma-infomed practice.

Establish strong working relationships with faculty, staff and student units to increase

awareness and implement proactive programming.

Deliver education on human rights and sexual violence issues through workshops and

speakers.

Provide consultation and coaching for members of the university community to

promote equity and community inclusion, accessibility and human rights.

Offer referrals to on-campus and off-campus services.

Page 9: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

8

Human Rights Services reports to the Office of the Vice President,

Equity and Community Inclusion (OVPECI) and plays a crucial role in

advancing the university's equity, diversity and inclusion values.

Equity Ryerson University values the fair and just treatment of all

community members through the creation of opportunities

and the removal of barriers to address historic and current

disadvantages for under-represented and marginalized

groups.

Diversity Ryerson University values and respects the diversity of

knowledge, worldviews and experiences that come from

membership in different groups and the contribution that

diversity makes to the learning, teaching, research and work

environment.

Inclusion Ryerson University values the equitable, intentional and ongoing

engagement of diversity within every facet of university life. It is

the shared responsibility of all community members to foster a

welcoming, supportive and respectful learning, teaching, research

and work environment.

Page 10: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

9

Our Services

Human Rights Services provides faculty, staff and students multiple supportive options

regarding complaint resolution processes, including coaching, consulting, mediation and

investigation of complaints based on human rights grounds or sexual violence. We support

Ryerson community members in addressing equity-based complaints between individuals as well

as systemic issues which create barriers. When a concern does not fall within our jurisdiction,

we refer the member to the appropriate support or services.

Human Rights Services offers a variety of events and workshops to promote equity. We work

with community members to deliver core and custom-designed workshops for classrooms and

departments. These initiatives provide education and awareness through training, outreach and

celebration of Ryerson's diverse community.

Our services are free, confidential and available to all members of the Ryerson community,

including students, staff and faculty.

We offer free and confidential complaint resolution services for human rights and sexual

violence issues. When a concern does not fall within our jurisdiction, we will refer you to

the appropriate service.

Conciliation is available through mediation when parties involved agree that an alternate

resolution is possible and preferable to an investigation.

Investigation of complaints is conducted where appropriate, including a written report to

the decision-maker.

Education is available through core and customized workshops, seminars and speakers

to promote awareness of human rights and sexual violence issues, the law, and the rights

and responsibilities of all members of the Ryerson community.

Support and referrals are provided in situations involving sexual harassment, sexual

assault and as requested.

Page 11: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

10

"Human Right Services was great in being in constant communication with me throughout the process and informing me of next steps. When a decision was made, I was notified when there was going to be a delay and proactively encouraged if I had any questions."

Anonymous Participant of the Complaint Process

Page 12: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

11

Policies Human Rights Policy Area Human Rights Services administers Ryerson's Discrimination and Harassment Prevention Policy

(DHP). We manage prevention, education, complaints and investigations under this policy with the

deepest regard for impartiality, confidentiality and freedom from reprisal.

The DHP is based on the Ontario Human Rights Code, which provides equal treatment without

discrimination on the basis of:

Age

Ancestry

Creed

Colour

Citizenship

Disability

Ethnic origin

Gender expression

Gender identity

Family status

Marital status

Place of Origin

Receipt of public assistance

Record of offences (employment)

Sex

Sexual Orientation Race

Sexual Violence Policy Area

In 2015, the Ontario Government introduced Bill 132, an Act to amend various statutes with

respect to sexual violence, sexual harassment, domestic violence and related matters as a response

to the Province's "It's Never Okay: An Action Plan to Stop Sexual Violence and Harassment." This

bill changed the responsibilities of post-secondary institutions to address sexual violence.

Ryerson's Sexual Violence Policy has been amended to accommodate the Bill and outlines a clear

process for handling complaints related to sexual violence. Both the Sexual Violence Policy and Bill

132 make clear Ryerson University's commitment to addressing sexual violence and rape culture

through survivor support, awareness, education, training and prevention programs, as well as the

appropriate handling of reports or complaints of sexual violence incidents. When Ryerson becomes

aware of allegations of sexual violence, we have a duty to respond accordingly, by taking

appropriate action guided by the university's policies. Human Rights Services manages the

complaint and investigations process as well as provides advice, consultation and training on the

complaint process.

Page 13: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

12

University Policies that Intersect with our Work Academic Accommodation of Students with Disabilities

Academic Integrity Policy

Accommodation for Persons with Disabilities Policy

Student Code of Non-Academic Conduct

Workplace Civility and Respect Policy

Human Rights Services and Ryerson University’s Academic Plan Human Rights Services plays an important role in supporting Ryerson University's Equity and

Community Inclusion initiatives. Some of the key areas in which we are working to support equity,

diversity and inclusion through the university's 2014-2019 Academic Plan include:

Develop a university-wide community engagement and communications strategy that values equity,

diversity and inclusion, leverages current engagement activity, and builds a more visible presence in

particular communities.

Expand engagement with local, national and international external organizations to enrich student

experiences and inclusion, increase civic engagement and create valuable academic, research and

innovation opportunities that contribute to Ryerson's profile and impact as a city-building university.

Develop access and program initiatives to support under-represented groups, including but not

limited to Aboriginal students, first-generation students, students with disabilities and

internationally-educated professionals.

Cultivate meaningful relationships with Aboriginal communities and students to create an

educational environment that embraces and supports Aboriginal perspectives and experiences

and builds community for Aboriginal people.

Page 14: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

13

Complaint Processes

Process Categories Our office has moved away from previous categories of “informal” and “formal”

complaints in order to better capture the range of services we provide in order to

resolve human rights and sexual violence issues. We developed new categories to

classify the processes by which we address concerns and complaints and applied

them to cases as of May 1, 2016. Human Rights Services now uses the following

categories to classify our complaint resolution processes: Consultation,

Alternative Resolution and Investigation. These new categories help us to

articulate the multiple processes we use to resolve concerns, issues and

complaints related to human rights and sexual violence for students, staff and

faculty at Ryerson.

Consultation: A case where an individual meets with an investigator where they

can review their concerns. The investigator might also consult with other university

offices, with the consent of the Complainant. We also provide coaching to students,

staff and faculty on a range of human rights and sexual violence matters, which often

resolves or prevents complaints.

Alternative Resolution: A case which involves a process outside of the

investigation process, which might include mediation, facilitation, training, counselling.

It may also result in consultation with other offices. Through this process, the

Complainant and Respondent reach an agreed-upon outcome. Alternative resolution

processes do not include a decision letter from a decision-maker.

Investigation: A case where there is an investigation into allegations which

may or may not result in findings. Investigation reports go to a decision-maker,

generally a senior administrator at Ryerson.

Page 15: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

14

Most of the Ryerson community members who

contact Human Rights Services have their

concerns addressed through the consultation

process. This often means that individuals

contacting the office want support around an

issue but do not necessarily want to engage in an

investigation or an alternative resolution process

for a variety of reasons. Human Rights Services

offers consultation and coaching in order to

support Ryerson community members who want

to navigate issues outside of the complaint

process.

Jurisdiction The Discrimination and Harassment Prevention Policy and the Sexual Violence Policy cover

behaviour which constitute discrimination, harassment and/or sexual violence which impact the

work and/or study environment of another member or members of the Ryerson University

community, whether or not they occur during normal working/school hours. Human Rights

Services may have jurisdiction where there is a nexus between the activity

and Ryerson.

Page 16: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

15

Inquiries

300Inquiries

We received approximately 250 inquiries in 2016-2017

and approximately 300 inquiries in 2017-2018. Ryerson

community members contact our office by email,

phone calls and in person. We begin by listening.

Human Rights Services answers hundreds of questions on human rights and sexual

violence a year. We provide complaints resolution options to individuals whose

complaints fall within our jurisdiction, and provides referrals when issues are unrelated

to the policies we administer.

We provided information and coaching to faculties, administrative units, staff and

students across campus on:

Human Rights Legislation

Discrimination

Harassment and Sexual Violence Policies

Disability

Religious and Family Accommodations

Issues of Equity

Diversity and Inclusion

Best Practices in the Workplace

Sex and Sexism

Sexual Violence and Bill 132

Gender Identity and Expression

Security Related Issues

Gendered Language

Inclusive Teaching

A significant component of the Human Rights Services is supporting Ryerson

community members outside of the investigations process. Inquiries are not listed in our

annual case statistics, which are comprised of investigations and other complaint

resolution processes that are detailed later in this report. Our inquiries process is a way

for students, staff and faculty to gain information and support with human rights issues,

which often resolves the individual's current challenges or prevents future complaints.

Page 17: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

From 2017 to 2018, Human Rights Services

was contacted by over 300 individuals, via

email, phone call or in person, to seek support

with human rights and sexual violence

challenges.

We provide complaint resolution options to people

whose complaint falls within our jurisdiction and

provide referrals to individuals whose complaints

are unrelated to the policies we oversee.

Many inquiries are resolved by answering

frequently asked questions on how policy and

legislation apply to specific situations. Many

other inquiries require multiple conversations

to support an individual.

On more complex inquiries, we consult with

partner offices within Ryerson and outside the

institution; provide research on relevant human

rights and sexual violence legislation, policies

and practices; and review documentation and

other evidence to resolve the inquiry.

About half of our inquiries enter our complaint resolution

process, with two thirds of those resolved through consultations

and alternative resolution and approximately a third resulting in

an investigation with a decision-maker. Detailed information

about our complaint resolution processes can be found on pages

17 to 28 of this report.

FAQ

Human Rights Services

16

We provide complaint resolution options to people

whose complaint falls within our jurisdiction and

provide referrals to individuals whose complaints

are unrelated to the policies we oversee.

Page 18: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

17

Caseload Statistics

Data Collection

On May 1, 2016, Human Rights Services changed its data collection methods,

making a direct comparison of complaint data from previous years not

possible. For transparency and accuracy purposes, we will be reporting on

data from May 1, 2016 onwards. The trends in this report are based on a

comparison between the May 1, 2016 to April 30, 2017 fiscal year and the May

1, 2017 to April 30, 2018 fiscal year.

85 Total Cases

2 0 1 6 / 2 0 1 7

3 Ancestry

13 Creed

22 Disability

2 Family Status

3 Gender Identity

14 Race

22 Sex Based

6 Sexual Violence

Page 19: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

18

155 Total Cases 2 0 1 7 / 2 0 1 8

82%

Incr

ease

2 Ancestry

1 Citizenship

19 Creed

37 Disability

1 Family Status

3 Gender Identity

1 Marital Status

1 Place of Origin

25 Race

37 Sex Based

5 Sexual Orientation

23 Sexual Violence

The case grounds noted in this report are the primary grounds identified in

the complaints to Human Rights Services; however, cases regularly involve

an intersection of multiple grounds of discrimination.

For a combination of reasons, students, staff and faculty have not made

complaints based on receipt of public assistance, record of offence or age

in the two year period of this report.

C

Page 20: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

19

Disability Cases

The most common complaints were centred on accessibility and

issues of accommodations for students with disabilities. Staff

complaints regarding accommodations were much less frequent.

Grade appeals constituted a large portion of our complaints based

on accommodations.

With the rise of students registering with Academic

Accommodation Support, we anticipate the number of

disability-related complaints will rise in the next few years.

Incr

ease

37 cases in 2017/18

22 cases in 2016/17

Page 21: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

20

Complainants

&

Respondents Please note one case might have multiple complainants and/or respondents.

2016/17 2017/18

Complaint Resolution Process Breakdown

Investigation

Alternative Resolution

Consultation 2016/17

32% 68%

2017/18

39%

6%

55%

33

7

3

2419

21 32

11

Page 22: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

21

Creed Cases

The majority of consultations that were based on creed are around

religious accommodations.

In the last several years, expressions of concern about

Islamophobia on campus have increased, yet few complaints

regarding Ryerson community members have been submitted. The

expressions of concern may be related to reports of anti-Muslim

and anti-immigrant sentiments in recent national and international

events. Some examples include the Quebec City Mosque Shooting

in 2017 as well as international terrorist attacks and increased

religious-based tensions.

Anti-Semitism reports on campus remain a concern. Human Rights

Services has developed a matrix to evaluate the types of issues

being expressed by community members and to track incidents

reported to Human Rights Services.

Incr

ease

19 cases in 2017/18

13 cases in 2016/17

Page 23: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

Complainants

&

Respondents Please note one case might have multiple complainants and/or respondents.

2016/17 2017/18

Complaint Resolution Process Breakdown

Investigation

Alternative Resolution

Consultation 2016/17

7.5% 92.5%

2017/18

21% 79%

14

39

68

52

12

11

122

1

6

3

22

Page 24: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

23

Race, Colour, Ancestry, Ethnic Origin and/or Citizenship

Most Complainants reporting discrimination based on colour, ancestry,

ethnic origin or citizenship generally identify the grounds for their

complaint as a "race" based complaint.

Racism is not necessarily expressed as explicit or overt; students, staff and

faculty report experiences of racism manifested through subtle

micro-aggressions. Therefore, complaints based on race are often complex

and require systemic analysis.

Human Rights Services conducts systematic analyses of university units and

individuals of concern. Systemic analysis strategies involve interviewing a

range of staff by conducting surveys and/or questionnaires, reviewing

troubling patterns such as the number of complaints against an individual,

and other strategies to determine if there are issues of racism within a

university unit or specific to an individual.

Incr

ease

28 cases in 2017/18

17 cases in 2016/17

Page 25: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

Complainants

&

Respondents Please note one case might have multiple complainants and/or respondents.

2016/17 2017/18

Complaint Resolution Process Breakdown

Investigation

Alternative Resolution

Consultation 2016/17

18% 6%

76%

2017/18

25%

21%

54%

7 8

222

2

5 5

5

45

1712

10 13

1

131

24

Page 26: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

25

Sexual Violence

Ryerson implemented a new Sexual Violence Policy in 2017 to coincide

with the implementation of Bill 132, the new provincial legislation on

sexual harassment and sexual violence. The policy sets out the process for

complaints relating to issues such as sexual harassment and sexual assault.

There has been a significant increase in the reporting of sexual violence

complaints at Ryerson. The increase is due to several factors, including but

not limited to: the work of Sexual Violence Support and Education office

and Human Rights Services to raise awareness; a global focus on sexual

violence that included broader social movements such as #metoo; Bill 132

and the provincial and federal focus on sexual violence; as well as an

increasing trend towards reporting across all universities and colleges in

North America.

In response to the increase of complaints, Human Rights Services has

begun working closely with units across the university to address these

issues, including the Office of Sexual Violence Support and Education,

Student Conduct Office, Human Resources, and General Counsel, where

appropriate.

Incr

ease

23 cases in 2017/18

6 cases in 2016/17

Page 27: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

15

2

54

15

2

Complainants

&

Respondents Please note one case might have multiple complainants and/or respondents.

2016/17 2017/18

Complaint Resolution Process Breakdown

Investigation

Alternative Resolution

Consultation 2016/17

50%

17% 33%

2017/18

54%

23%

23%

15

54

26

Page 28: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

Sex, Sexual Orientation, Family Status, Gender Identity and/or Marital Status

Gender-based complaints range from systemic discrimination to unwanted comments. We have

seen a significant increase in these types of complaints over the reporting period. This trend is in

line with other complaint categories where individuals are more willing to turn to university

policy to hold people they feel have caused harm accountable. In many ways, these complaints

represent a shift in the attitudes at work and in school to insist on dignity, fairness and equity.

Complainants

&

Respondents

Please note one case might have multiple complainants and/or respondents.

2016/17 2017/18

Incr

ease

47 cases in 2017/18 27 cases in

2016/17

101615

14

208

1910

8

22

1

222

3

1 5

2

27

Page 29: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

28

Complaint Resolution Process Breakdown

Investigation

Alternative Resolution

Consultation 2016/17

29%

4% 67%

2017/18

17%

19% 64%

"Human Rights Services' commitment to promoting a people first and human-rights centred culture sets this team apart. Championing culture change and accountability is no easy task. The team lead is passionate and invested in educating and challenging the Ryerson community to recognize our shared responsibility for fostering a community that is welcoming, respectful, inclusive and safe."

Marcelle Mullings Director, Student Advocacy & Accountability

Page 30: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

29

Human Rights Services Staff 2016 to 2018 "Their knowledge, expertise, and skills on human rights, equity and diversity have strengthened the University's approach to issues management. They are an invaluable member of the Ryerson family."

Michael Forbes Executive Director of Communications

Grace Chau Senior Investigator

Grace Chau joined Ryerson in November 2017 as a Senior Investigator with Human Rights Services.

She has a BA in Political Science and an LLB from the University of Windsor Law School.

Previously, Grace worked for over ten years at the Office of the Ombudsman of Ontario as an

investigator with the Special Ombudsman Response Team. Her previous work history includes

overseas internships with the United Nations High Commission for Refugees in Croatia and the Aga

Khan Rural Development Network in India. She also has prior experience working at the HIV/AIDS

Legal Clinic in Toronto.

Katie Solomon Complaints Resolution Advisor

Katie Solomon has been working in Human Rights Services since October 2006 and has been in

her role as Complaints Resolution Advisor since May 2012. Katie received her BA from the

University of Western Ontario in 2004. She also holds an Executive Certificate in Conflict

Management from the Stitt Feld Handy Group and the University of Windsor and a certificate as an

Advanced Investigator from Rubin Thomlinson. During Katie's time with Human Rights Services,

she has managed hundreds of cases, finding resolution through both the investigation process as

well as alternative resolution. She has also worked on policy development and has been involved in

several equity and inclusion projects across campus.

Page 31: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

30

Ahmed Ahmed Strategic Advisor, Analyst

Ahmed Ahmed holds an undergraduate degree in Equity Studies from the University of Toronto and

a Master's in Community Development and Adult Education from the Ontario Institute for Studies

in Education (OISE). Ahmed started in Human Rights Services in Spring 2017. He brings over 15

years of experience in program development and delivery, education and training, and strategic

planning from three sectors: community development, federal public service and post-secondary

education. He has recently undertaken a PhD in the Faculty of Education at York University.

Ahmed's research focuses on access to post-secondary education for traditionally under-represented

students. As Strategic Advisor and Analyst, Ahmed is responsible for embedding equity and human

rights into the policies, procedures and communications of Human Rights Services.

Elya Porter Intake and Administrative Assistant

Elya Porter joined Human Rights Services as the Intake and Administrative Assistant in July 2018.

She has been part of the Ryerson community for over ten years, having completed her Bachelor of

Commerce at Ted Rogers School of Management and having worked in a number of departments

across campus including Aboriginal Student Services, the Aboriginal Education Council, Law

Practice Program and the Office of the Vice-President, Equity and Community Inclusion. She also

brings experience working in marketing for Leukaemia and Lymphoma Research and Imperial

College in London, England.

Career Boost Students Human Rights Services has two Career Boost student positions. The student employees who fill

these positions support the work of the office by conducting outreach, completing administrative

tasks and promoting equity and diversity at Ryerson. They support the office, provide outreach to

students on campus and are vital members of our team.

Page 32: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

31

Prevention Through Partnerships and Education

Education Prevention through education is a major goal of Human Rights Services. We

work with the Ryerson community to empower individuals and university units

with the tools to address human rights concerns. Education and awareness are

integral to our values and help us to ensure that our work is preventative rather

than reactive. Education helps to create a campus community that values the

integrity and human rights of all our members.

Beyond Campus Canadian Association for the Prevention of Discrimination and

Harassment in Higher Education (CAPDHHE)

Canadian Association of College and University Student

Services (CACUSS)

Canadian Human Rights Practitioners (CHRP)

Association of Workplace Investigators (AWI)

Various Selected Committees Sexual Violence Support and Education Advisory Committee

Various Hiring Committees

International Women's Day Committee

December 6th Memorial Committee

Breast/Chest Feeding Committee

"Training sessions put on by Human Rights Services are boldly refreshing,

thought-provoking and deeply relevant. I walk away feeling inspired and further

equipped to navigate delicate, difficult conversations."

Gafira Kassam, Student Accommodation Facilitator, Academic Accommodation Support, Student Learning Support

Page 33: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

32

i

Training From 2016 to 2017, Human Rights Services conducted over 40

training sessions, and in 2017-2018, we conducted over 60 training

sessions. The office works with a range of groups, units, departments

to deliver training. The office also works with individuals on a

one-on-one basis to respond to training sanctions from investigations.

Who Received Training On Campus

Six out of Eight Ryerson Faculties

Student Affairs

Athletics

Communications

Human Resources

Ryerson's Learning Zones

Decision-Makers: senior leaders who decide

on formal investigations

Departmental Evaluation Committee

Faculty

Select Facilities and Food Services

Executive Group

Board of Governors

Research Ethics Review Board

Student Unions and Associations

Student Groups and Clubs

Office of the Registrar

Topics Covered

Unconscious Bias Training, specifically for

hiring committees and large staff teams

Equity and Diversity 101

Anti-Black Racism

Anti-Semitism

Homophobia and Transphobia

Workplace Harassment and the Ontario

Human Rights Code

Inclusive Facilitation

Body Shaming

First-Year Faculty Training

Human Rights and Accommodation

Religious Accommodation Training

Inclusive Classrooms

Complaints and Investigations Process 101

Decision-Maker Training

Discrimination and Harassment Prevention

Policy and Sexual Violence Policy Training

Human Rights Services has also presented to 15 off-campus partners including the University of

Toronto, University of Alberta, Humber College, Seneca College, Centennial College, Durham

College, Women's Legal and Action Fund, and the Urban Land Institute.

Page 34: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

33

We advocate for fairness of process and for a community where the dignity and human rights of all its members are respected and upheld.

Page 35: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

334

“I can’t thank you enough for helping put together today’s

[memorial] event. It was so important for the Jewish, non-Jewish,

and entire Ryerson community, and meant even more that we had

the support from the university.”

Elyse Wieskopf

Director, Hillel Ryerson

“The Office of Human Rights Services is an important ally to the

Muslim staff and faculty community network. The team has been

there for the us during key moments, from the time we were

trying to get the community network formalized at the university

to organizing healing circles and vigils for the community.”

Sakeena Mihar

Co-chair, Muslim Staff and Faculty Community Network

“The Human Rights office has delivered exceptional training and

coaching, both for myself personally, and for my direct reports.

Their ability to communicate complex concepts and initiate

productive conversation regarding sensitive topics is inspiring and

has been a valuable tool in empowering my leadership team to

bring awareness and navigate these concepts with their own

teams, schools and students.”

Charles Falzon

Dean, Faculty of Communication and Design

Page 36: DIGNITY & FAIRNESS IN PROCESS · and with dignity in the life of the university. My hope is that this report will give you an appreciation of the work done at Ryerson to meet head-on

Human Rights is all of our responsibility.