Data GroupData Group1.1. Natalya (UNEP), Natalya (UNEP),

2.2. M. Tanzir Wilson (ASEAN Sec),M. Tanzir Wilson (ASEAN Sec),

3.3. Sri (Indonesia),Sri (Indonesia),

4.4. Jinhua (UNEP),Jinhua (UNEP),

5.5. Virancy (Lao)Virancy (Lao)

6.6. Akira (Japan)Akira (Japan)

7.7. Sharma (India)Sharma (India)

8.8. Tepa (SPREP)Tepa (SPREP)

DATA GROUPDATA GROUP

I.I. Data collectionData collection

II.II. Data access & reliabilityData access & reliability

III.III. Data representability & scaleData representability & scale

IV.IV. Data proxiesData proxies

V.V. Related monitoringRelated monitoring

VI.VI. Experience SharingExperience Sharing

I & II. COLLECTION & RELIABILITYI & II. COLLECTION & RELIABILITY

Rank the Sources:Rank the Sources:1.1. Official Sources: UN, IGOs, Government Official Sources: UN, IGOs, Government

(Statistics),(Statistics),

2.2. Specialized Sources: University, Research & Specialized Sources: University, Research & Technology Institutions, Donor AgenciesTechnology Institutions, Donor Agencies

3.3. Other Sources: NGOs Other Sources: NGOs

4.4. Remote Sensing Systems: GEIOSRemote Sensing Systems: GEIOS

Reliability:Reliability:1.1. National statistical offices certify the data reliabilityNational statistical offices certify the data reliability

2.2. Expert groups examine and certify the data Expert groups examine and certify the data reliabilityreliability

III & IV. DATA AVAILABILITY, III & IV. DATA AVAILABILITY, QUALITY, REPRESENTABILITY & QUALITY, REPRESENTABILITY & SCALESCALE

Dependent upon the data sourceDependent upon the data source Representability like reliability depends on official Representability like reliability depends on official

sources and expert groupssources and expert groups1.1. National statistical offices certify the data reliabilityNational statistical offices certify the data reliability2.2. Expert groups examine and certify the data reliabilityExpert groups examine and certify the data reliability3.3. Main segment and sector should be representedMain segment and sector should be represented4.4. Before use of data, data should be checkedBefore use of data, data should be checked

ScaleScale1.1. Recommend scale is 1:10,000 or more detail to capture the Recommend scale is 1:10,000 or more detail to capture the

complexity of city issues (drivers, pressures, state/trends, & complexity of city issues (drivers, pressures, state/trends, & impacts)impacts)

2.2. Controlled by National Policies (e.g. national security policies)Controlled by National Policies (e.g. national security policies)

V. DATA PROXIESV. DATA PROXIES

Do not use proxiesDo not use proxies Exceptional cases use them with Exceptional cases use them with

appropriate certificationappropriate certification

VI. RELATED MONITORING PLANVI. RELATED MONITORING PLAN

Different levels to consider for monitoring Different levels to consider for monitoring implementation of recommendations:implementation of recommendations: Porfolio monitoring and evaluationPorfolio monitoring and evaluation Impact monitoring and evaluationImpact monitoring and evaluation

V. Related: experience V. Related: experience sharingsharing

Cross-national collaborationsCross-national collaborations Sharing informtion systemsSharing informtion systems AttachmentsAttachments Etc.Etc.