commodities exchange: options for addressing price risk and price volatility in rice

28
Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc: Fptofds lfr @ggrcssodb ]rohc Uosk `dg ]rohc \fi`toioty od Uohc Lr`nrfzc ]fha`r` Df. 53 | @ubust 5=05  @G E Xust`od`eic Gcvcifpncdt   R fr ko db ]`pcr Xcrocs

Upload: asean-rice-trade-forum

Post on 11-Feb-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 1/28

Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc: Fptofds lfr @ggrcssodb]rohc Uosk `dg ]rohc \fi`toioty od Uohc

Lr`nrfzc ]fha`r`

Df. 53 | @ubust 5=05

 @GE Xust od`eicGcvcifpncdt  Rfrkodb ]`pcr Xcrocs

Page 2: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 2/28

 

Page 3: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 3/28

 

 @GE Xust`od`eic Gcvcifpncdt Rfrkodb ]`pcr Xcrocs

Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc: Fptofds lfr @ggrcssodb

]rohc Uosk `dg ]rohc \fi`toio ty od Uohc

Lr`nrfzc ]fha`r`

Df. 53 | @ubust 5=05

Wac `utafr os tac n`d`bodb gorchtfr fl @ro`dLod`dho`i @ssfho`tcs `dg tac lfrncr cxchutovcgorchtfr fl tac Xodb`pfrc Ncrh`dtoic Cxha`dbc`dg haocl cxchutovc fllohcr fl tac Gue`o Bfig `dgHfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc.

Page 4: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 4/28

 

 @so`d Gcvcifpncdt E`dk< @GE @vcduc, N`dg`iuyfdb Hoty033= Nctrf N`doi`, ]aoioppodcswww.`ge.frb

© 5=05 ey @so`d Gcvcifpncdt E`dk @ubust 5=05

]ueioh`tofd Xtfhk Df. R]X057?3?-8

Wac vocws cxprcsscg od taos p`pcr `rc tafsc fl tac `utafr `dg gf dft dchcss`roiy rclicht tac vocws `dg pfiohocs fl tac @so`d Gcvcifpncdt E`dk (@GE) fr ots Ef`rg fl Bfvcrdfrs fr tac bfvcrdncdts tacy rcprcscdt, fr fl tac odstotutofds `twaoha tac `utafr wfrks.

 @GE gfcs dft bu`r`dtcc tac `hhur`hy fl tac g`t` odhiugcg od taos pueioh`tofd `dg `hhcpts df rcspfdsoeoioty lfr `dyhfdscqucdhc fl tacor usc.

Ey n`kodb `dy gcsobd`tofd fl fr rclcrcdhc tf ` p`rtohui`r tcrrotfry fr bcfbr`paoh `rc`, fr ey usodb tac tcrn "hfudtry"od taos gfhuncdt, @GE gfcs dft odtcdg tf n`kc `dy jugbncdts `s tf tac icb`i fr ftacr st`tus fl `dy tcrrotfry fr `rc`.  

Sdicss ftacrwosc dftcg, ’$„ rclcrs tf SX gfii`rs.

Waos wfrkodb p`pcr scrocs os n`odt`odcg ey tac Ucbofd`i `dg Xust`od`eic Gcvcifpncdt Gcp`rtncdt. Ftacr @GEwfrkodb p`pcr scrocs `rc fd chfdfnohs, rcbofd`i hffpcr`tofd, `dg tac @GEO Rfrkodb ]`pcr Xcrocs. Ftacr @GEpueioh`tofds h`d ec lfudg `t www.`ge.frb/]ueioh`tofds/. Wac purpfsc fl tac scrocs os tf gosscnod`tc tac lodgodbs flwfrk od prfbrcss tf cdhfur`bc tac cxha`dbc fl ogc`s. Wac cnpa`sos os fd bcttodb lodgodbs fut quohkiy cvcd ol tacprcscdt`tofd fl tac wfrk os icss ta`d luiiy pfiosacg. 

]rodtcg fd rchyhicg p`pcr

Page 5: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 5/28

 

Hfdtcdts

 @eercvo`tofds ............................................................................................................................. ov

Cxchutovc Xunn`ry ....................................................................................................................v

0. Odtrfguhtofd ......................................................................................................................... 0

5. @XC@D Uohc Luturcs .............................................................................................................. 5

8. Uc`i-Iolc Cx`npics fl N`rkct Odstruncdts Sscg lfr ]rohc Uosk N`d`bcncdt ....................... 8

7. Uohc Wr`godb fd `d Cxostodb Ucbofd`i Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc od @XC@D ............................. 77.0 Gcvcifpncdt fl tac Uohc ]rohc Odgcx ........................................................................... 37.5 Xt`dg`rgoz`tofd fl Uohc ................................................................................................ 3

3. Gfncstoh Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc \`ro`dts ........................................................................... 2

<. Xw`p Odstruncdts `dg Lfrw`rg Hfdtr`hts ............................................................................ ?

<.0 Xw`p Wr`ds`htofd ........................................................................................................ ?<.5 Lfrw`rg Hfdtr`hts ......................................................................................................0=

2. Ftacr Euoigodb Eifhks lfr Xuhhcsslui Uohc Wr`godb ...............................................................0=2.0 R`rcafusc Uchcopt Xystcn `dg Lod`dhc ...................................................................0=2.5 H`p`hoty Euoigodb fl N`rkct ]`rtohop`dts .....................................................................002.8 ]rohc Gosscnod`tofd ....................................................................................................00

1. Ufic fl Xt`kcafigcrs od Uohc Wr`godb ...................................................................................051.0 Bfvcrdncdts ..............................................................................................................051.5 ]rov`tc Xchtfr .............................................................................................................071.8 @XC@D .......................................................................................................................03

?. Uchfnncdg`tofds `dg @htofd ]fodts .................................................................................03Uclcrcdhcs ...............................................................................................................................0?

Loburcs `dg Efxcs 

LoburcsLoburc 0: Hfrrci`tofd fl ]rohcs fl Wa`o 0==% E-Br`gc Uohc........................................................ < Loburc 5: Hfrrci`tofd fl ]`kost`d, Wa`oi`dg, `dg \oct D`n 53% ................................................. < 

Efxcs Efx 0: Xpft fr H`sa Cxha`dbc `dg Gcrov`tovcs Cxha`dbc ........................................................ 2 

Efx 5: 0,=== \oii`bcs, 0=,=== L`rncrs‟ Cguh`tofd ]rfbr`n......................................................00 Efx 8: Cxha`dbcs `dg ]rohc Odlfrn`tofd Gosscnod`tofd ...........................................................05 Efx 7: Ufic fl @bbrcb`tfrs .......................................................................................................07 

Page 6: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 6/28

 

 @eercvo`tofds

 @GE @LXUE @XC@DHEFWL@FBNXNX]SX

 @so`d Gcvcifpncdt E`dk @XC@D Lffg Xchuroty Ucscrvc Ef`rg @ssfho`tofd fl Xfutac`st @so`d D`tofdsHaoh`bf Ef`rg fl Wr`gcLffg `dg @brohuiturc Frb`doz`tofd fl tac Sdotcg D`tofdsBrc`tcr Nckfdb XuercbofdNodonun Xuppfrt ]rohcSdotcg Xt`tcs fl @ncroh`

Page 7: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 7/28

 

Cxchutovc Xunn`ry

Od tac `ltcrn`ta fl tac 5==2‘5==1 rohc prohc hrosos, ncnecr st`tcs fl tac @ssfho`tofd flXfutac`st @so`d D`tofds (@XC@D) `gfptcg tac @XC@D Odtcbr`tcg Lffg Xchuroty Lr`ncwfrk`dg Xtr`tcboh ]i`d fl @htofd fd Lffg Xchuroty od tac @XC@D Ucbofd tf `ggrcss ifdb-tcrn lffg

schuroty od tac rcbofd. @ hrotoh`i hfdstr`odt tf hfdguhovc `brohuitur`i tr`gc os prohc vfi`toioty, waohaa`s eccd tr`hcg od p`rt tf nfstiy eoi`tcr`i, fp`quc tr`ds`htofds dfw gfnod`todb rohc tr`gc. Fdcfl tac `vcducs ecodb cxpifrcg os wactacr rohc luturcs wfuig acip erodb gfwd prohc vfi`toioty. Waclc`soeoioty fl cst`eiosaodb ` rohc luturcs n`rkct od tac @XC@D rcbofd `dg ots pftcdto`i ecdclots odrcguhodb prohc vfi`toioty `dg n`d`bodb prohc rosks wcrc tac suejcht n`ttcr fl scp`r`tc stugocs ey

 @dgrcw NhKcdzoc `dg Noif A`noitfd. Waos p`pcr cx`nodcs tac kcy pfsotofds fl efta `utafrs`dg prcscdts v`rofus fptofds lfr rohc tr`godb ta`t a`vc tac pftcdto`i tf `ggrcss prohc rosk `dgprohc vfi`toioty.

NhKcdzoc `dg A`noitfd `brccg fd tac ecdclots fl ` rohc luturcs n`rkct od n`kodb prohcs nfrctr`dsp`rcdt `dg od scrvodb `s acgbodb odstruncdts. Wac twf `utafrs, afwcvcr, gollcrcg fd tactonodb fl `dg tac p`hodb lfr tac cst`eiosancdt fl ` rohc luturcs n`rkct od tac @XC@D rcbofd.

Raoic NhKcdzoc fpodcg ta`t tac rcbofd os dft prcp`rcg yct lfr ` rohc luturcs hfdtr`ht, A`noitfdhfdtcdgcg ta`t tac aurgics od gcvcifpodb ` rohc luturcs n`rkct od tac rcbofd `rc dftodsurnfudt`eic `dg ta`t tac prfhcss fl cst`eiosaodb taos safuig st`rt dfw.

Wacrc `rc scvcr`i cx`npics fl hfudtrocs `dg bfvcrdncdts (Er`zoi, Ctaofpo`, Odgo`, `dg N`i`wo)ta`t usc n`rkct odstruncdts lfr prohc rosk n`d`bcncdt, cotacr fvcr tac hfudtcr fr fdhfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcs. Waos p`pcr lfrw`rgs scvcr`i subbcstofds lfr rohc tr`godb od tac @XC@Drcbofd.

Lorst, rohc luturcs tr`godb wotaod tac rcbofd os `irc`gy pfssoeic tarfuba `d cxostodb rcbofd`ihfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc, suha `s od Afdbkfdb, Haod` fr od Xodb`pfrc. @ rcbofd`i rohc odgcx ta`tos rcprcscdt`tovc fl tac nfst cxpfrtcg `dg hfdsuncg br`gcs fl rohc h`d ec lc`soeiy gcvcifpcg

`dg uscg `s ` ecdhan`rk lfr @XC@D rohc prohcs. Luturcs `dg fptofds e`scg fd tac odgcx hfuigtacd ec tr`gcg fd tac rcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc.

Xchfdg, hfudtrocs ta`t `rc n`jfr cxpfrtcrs fl pfpui`r br`gcs fl rohc safuig cst`eiosa ` gfncstohhfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc `dg tr`gc tacor nfst pfpui`r ifh`i rohc br`gcs. Wacsc hfudtrocs hfuigonpicncdt ` icb`i `dg rcbui`tfry lr`ncwfrk `dg cdiost tchadoh`i suppfrt od scttodb up tacgfncstoh hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc `dg w`rcafusc rchcopt systcn. Wacy hfuig `isf euoigw`rcafusc odlr`struhturc `dg ic`sc taos tf prov`tc pi`ycrs fr prfvogc odhcdtovcs tf prov`tcpi`ycrs tf sct up tac odlr`struhturc.

Waorg, bfvcrdncdts, prov`tc pi`ycrs, `dg @XC@D h`d `ii pi`y ` rfic od tac gosscnod`tofd fl rohcprohcs `dg odlfrn`tofd fd rohc prfguhtofd, `s wcii `s od tac cguh`tofd fl n`rkct p`rtohop`dts.

Lod`iiy, @XC@D h`d pi`y ` n`jfr h`t`iytoh rfic od gcvcifpodb tac hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc `s `vo`eic fptofd lfr `ggrcssodb prohc rosk `dg prohc vfi`toioty od rohc. Ot hfuig wfrk tfw`rg rcnfvodbtac udhcrt`odtocs `dg `gvcrsc onp`ht fl udoi`tcr`i tr`gc pfiohy rcstrohtofds. Lurtacrnfrc, ot h`dodoto`tc stcps tfw`rg rohc st`dg`rgoz`tofd `dg tac gcvcifpncdt fl ` rcbofd`i rohc odgcx. @XC@Dh`d `isf prfvogc ` systcn`toh ncha`dosn lfr tac rcbofd`i hfdsuit`tofd fl v`rofus st`kcafigcrsod tac rohc v`iuc ha`od tarfuba vcducs suha `s tac @XC@D Uohc Wr`gc Lfrun.

Page 8: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 8/28

 

Od tac ncgoun tcrn, tac rcbofd h`d gcvcifp `d @XC@D odvcstncdt pi`d tf lfstcr tac brfwta fl `rcbofd`i rohc v`iuc ha`od hfrrogfr lfr scttodb up odlr`struhturcs ta`t `rc csscdto`i lfr tacgcvcifpncdt fl ` rcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc `dg ` suercbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc odtac Brc`tcr Nckfdb Xuercbofd, `s wcii `s n`rkct odlfrn`tofd `dg odtciiobcdhc suppfrt, `dgodstotutofd`i suppfrt lfr tac h`p`hoty euoigodb fl l`rncrs. Wac odvcstncdt pi`d h`d ec ` hfdhrctcrf`g n`p tfw`rg euttrcssodb tac onpicncdt`tofd fl tac Xtr`tcboh ]i`d fl @htofd fd Lffg

Xchuroty od tac @XC@D Ucbofd.

Page 9: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 9/28

 

0. Odtrfguhtofd

Od tac `ltcrn`ta fl tac 5==2‘5==1 rohc prohc hrosos, ncnecr st`tcs fl tac @ssfho`tofd flXfutac`st @so`d D`tofds (@XC@D) `gfptcg od 5==? tac @XC@D Odtcbr`tcg Lffg XchurotyLr`ncwfrk `dg tac Xtr`tcboh ]i`d fl @htofd fd Lffg Xchuroty od tac @XC@D Ucbofd. ]rcvcdtodb

cxtrcnc rohc prohc vfi`toioty `dg onprfvodb tac lffg schuroty sotu`tofd od tac rcbofd a`vc eccdlfrcnfst od tac `bcdg` fl @XC@D ic`gcrs, wota rohc ecodb ` st`pic lffg fl noiiofds flafuscafigs tarfubafut Xfutac`st @so`. Wac dcb`tovc onp`ht fl aobacr `dg nfrc vfi`toic rohcprohcs fd tacor pfpui`tofd `dg chfdfnocs os ` aubc hfdhcrd lfr bfvcrdncdts od tac rcbofd.0

 Od rcspfdsc tf taos sotu`tofd, tac @XC@D Lffg Xchuroty Ucscrvc Ef`rg (@LXUE) w`s t`skcgwota hfdvcdodb tac @XC@D Uohc Wr`gc Lfrun fd ` poift e`sos. Wac lfrun prfvogcs ` pi`tlfrn tfhfiichtovciy goshuss `dg tf prfnftc hffrgod`tcg pfiohocs fd rohc schuroty od tac rcbofd.Xpcholoh`iiy, tac lfrun sccks tf ciohot ogc`s tfw`rg acipodb prcvcdt fr notob`tc cxtrcnc rohc prohcvfi`toioty.

 @ hrotoh`i hfdstr`odt tf gcvcifpodb hfdguhovc tr`gc od lffg prfguhts os cxtrcnc prohc vfi`toioty.

 @nfdb tac n`dy l`htfrs hfdtroeutodb tf prohc spokcs os tac i`hk fl tr`dsp`rcdhy fl rcbofd`i rohctr`gc `dg tac ionotcg dunecr fl n`rkct pi`ycrs. Aubc, eoi`tcr`i, `dg fp`quc tr`ds`htofdsgfnod`tc tac rcbofd‟s rohc tr`gc.

Fdc fl tac `vcducs ecodb cxpifrcg os wactacr rcbofd`i rohc luturcs tr`godb wfuig acip erodbgfwd prohc vfi`toioty. Lffg schuroty fejchtovcs‗spcholoh`iiy, kdfwodb wacrc tac n`rkct os nfvodb`dg notob`todb n`rkct rosks‗a`vc trobbcrcg odtcrcst od tac pftcdto`i gcvcifpncdt fl ` rohcluturcs n`rkct od tac rcbofd (Wonncr 5=0=). Afwcvcr, sfnc hfdtcdg ta`t tac rfic fl rohc luturcsfd lffg schuroty os dft `s gorcht `s nc`surcs suha `s prfguhtovoty odvcstncdts ta`t `isf t`hkiclffg suppiy eftticdchks (NhKcdzoc 5=05). U`tacr, tac pron`ry rfic fl rohc luturcs wfuig ec odcdsurodb prohc goshfvcry `dg scrvodb `s acgbodb odstruncdts ta`t notob`tc tac hfsts fl gr`stohprohc ha`dbcs fd `htfrs od tac lffg ha`ods.

Waos p`pcr gcivcs odtf tacsc ossucs. Xchtofd 0 prcscdts tac kcy pfsotofds fl twf prfnodcdt`utafrotocs od tac locig fl luturcs n`rkcts `s tacsc fpcr`tc od gcvcifpcg chfdfnocs. Wacor vocwshfuig scrvc `s ` sprodbef`rg lfr cxp`dgodb v`rofus fptofds ta`t `rc `irc`gy `v`oi`eic rcbofd`iiy`dg hfuig p`vc tac w`y lfr nfrc tr`dsp`rcdt prohodb ncha`dosns od rohc tr`gc. Xchtofd 5prfvogcs cx`npics fl hfudtry cxpcrocdhcs ta`t usc gollcrcdt acgbodb odstruncdts `t tacgfncstoh icvci. Wac ncss`bc os ta`t tacrc `rc acgbodb tffis ta`t h`d wfrk eut tacsc dccg tf ect`oifrcg tf ifh`i hfdgotofds. Xchtofds 8 `dg 7 prcscdt twf h`tcbfrocs fl hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcs:rohc luturcs od `d cxostodb hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc `dg v`ro`dts fl gfncstoh hfnnfgotocs

0  Waos wfrkodb p`pcr w`s prcp`rcg ey tac `utafr lfr tac poift onpicncdt`tofd fl tac @XC@D Uohc Wr`gc Lfrun od

Xocn Uc`p, H`nefgo` lrfn 0? tf 5= Judc 5=05. Wac p`pcr, waoha w`s prcscdtcg od tac lfurta scssofd fl taclfrun, cx`nodcg ftacr fptofds lfr `ggrcssodb prohc rosk `dg prohc vfi`toioty od rohc. Wac @XC@D Lffg XchurotyUcscrvc Ef`rg hfdvcdcg tac poift lfrun od hffrgod`tofd wota tac @XC@D Xchrct`ro`t `dg tac @so`d GcvcifpncdtE`dk (@GE). @GE prfvogcg tchadoh`i `ssost`dhc, wota lod`dhodb lrfn tac J`p`d Ludg lfr ]fvcrty Ucguhtofd. Wac`utafr, Lr`nrfzc ]fha`r`, os ` h`pot`i n`rkcts vctcr`d wota fvcr 53 yc`rs fl cxpcrocdhc od tac odgustry. Ac os tacn`d`bodb gorchtfr fl @ro`d Lod`dho`i @ssfho`tcs `dg w`s tac lfrncr cxchutovc gorchtfr fl tac Xodb`pfrc Ncrh`dtoicCxha`dbc `dg tac haocl cxchutovc fllohcr fl Xodb`pfrc Ncrh`dtoic Cxha`dbc Hic`rodb Hfrpfr`tofd lrfn 5==2 tf5=00. Ac `isf scrvcg `s tac haocl cxchutovc fllohcr fl tac Gue`o Bfig `dg Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc `dgvohc-prcsogcdt lfr fpcr`tofds fl tac D`tofd`i Xtfhk Cxha`dbc fl Odgo`. Ac a`s ` n`stcr‟s gcbrcc od lod`dho`in`d`bcncdt lrfn tac Sdovcrsoty fl Nune`o, Odgo`.

Page 10: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 10/28

5 | @GE Xust`od`eic Gcvcifpncdt Rfrkodb ]`pcr Xcrocs Df. 53

cxha`dbcs. Xchtofd 3 goshusscs tac usc fl sw`ps, `d `itcrd`tc rosk n`d`bcncdt odstruncdt.Xchtofd < t`kcs up csscdto`i euoigodb eifhks suha `s h`p`hoty euoigodb fl l`rncrs `dg prohcn`rkct odlfrn`tofd. Xchtofd 2 pfsots tac rfics fl v`rofus pi`ycrs, odhiugodb tac pueioh schtfr `dg

 @XC@D. Wac i`st schtofd ogcdtolocs rchfnncdg`tofds lfr cdhfur`bodb rohc tr`godb `dg`ggrcssodb prohc vfi`toioty.

5. @XC@D Uohc Luturcs

Wf sacg iobat fd wa`t rohc luturcs h`d fllcr, tac @so`d Gcvcifpncdt E`dk (@GE) hfnnossofdcg @dgrcw NhKcdzoc, prflcssfr fl `brohuitur`i chfdfnohs `dg `broeusodcss `t tac Sdovcrsoty fl @rk`ds`s, tf n`kc ` stugy fd ` rohc luturcs n`rkct od tac @XC@D rcbofd.5

 

 @hhfrgodb tf tacstugy (NhKcdzoc 5=05), rohc n`rkcts od Xfutac`st @so` `rc hurrcdtiy fp`quc, `dg ` luturcshfdtr`ht hfuig acip odhrc`sc n`rkct prohc tr`dsp`rcdhy tf `og `ii n`rkct p`rtohop`dts odn`rkctodb `dg prfguhtofd gchosofds. Wac stugy st`tcg ta`t gcspotc ots ionotcg rfic od st`eoiozodbprohcs, ` rohc luturcs hfdtr`ht e`scg od tac rcbofd h`d a`vc tac ecdclots fl prohc goshfvcry, prohcrosk n`d`bcncdt, `dg onprfvcncdt fl tac cxostodb n`rkct systcn.

NhKcdzoc lurtacr pfsotcg ta`t hcrt`od pfiohy hfdgotofds `rc dchcss`ry tf hrc`tc ` suhhcsslui rohcluturcs n`rkct. Wacsc odhiugc rcbofd`i hffpcr`tofd fd rohc tr`gc pfiohocs, nodon`i bfvcrdncdtodtcrvcdtofd od prohcs, a`rnfdoz`tofd fl rohc qu`ioty `dg br`godb st`dg`rgs, odtrfguhtofd flw`rcafusc rchcopts, ` nfrc `htovc rfic lfr tac prov`tc schtfr od gfncstoh `dg rcbofd`i rohcn`rkctodb systcns, ecttcr `hhcss tf hrcgot, `dg gcvcifpodb ` h`sa prohc odgcx lfr tac @XC@Drcbofd. Afwcvcr, ac hfdhiugcg ta`t hurrcdt h`sa n`rkct ha`r`htcrostohs od tac rcbofd `rc dfthfdguhovc tf tac gcvcifpncdt fl ` suhhcsslui rohc luturcs hfdtr`ht, cotacr `t tac gfncstoh frrcbofd`i icvci. Wac stugy subbcstcg tac hfdsogcr`tofd fl `itcrd`tovc rosk n`d`bcncdt tffis suha`s sw`ps `s pftcdto`i acgbodb odstruncdts.

 @dftacr vocw fd rohc luturcs os ta`t fl Noif A`noitfd.8

 

Od ` pfsotofd p`pcr (A`noitfd 5=05), ac

fpodcg ta`t ’dfw os dft tff sffd„ tf st`rt tac gcvcifpncdt fl ` rohc luturcs n`rkct. Ac st`tcgta`t hrcgoeic `dg ioquog rohc luturcs h`d onprfvc tac pftcdto`i fl ` rohc l`rncr tf n`kc `prflot`eic n`rbod. Ol ` l`rncr h`ddft n`kc ` prflot, cvcryfdc woii sullcr, `s ure`doz`tofd, w`tcr,`dg lffg schuroty ossucs b`od tr`htofd. Ac lurtacr `rbucg ta`t rohc l`rnodb safuig nfvc lrfnsuesostcdhc l`rnodb tf ` eusodcss e`sos. Ac `brccg ta`t rohc luturcs woii dft sfivc `ii prfeicns,eut ` tr`dsp`rcdt, rosk n`d`bcncdt, `dg prohc goshfvcry tffi lfr rohc wfuig hfdtroeutc tfodcvot`eic ha`dbc od tac @so`d rohc n`rkcts od tac dcxt gch`gc.

Wac pfsotofd p`pcr fl A`noitfd lurtacr subbcstcg•  tr`godb ` SX gfii`r-gcdfnod`tcg, eicdgcg odgcx fl rohc prohcs fr ` rohc hfdtr`ht wota

fptofd`i frobod gciovcry `t tac pfrts fl n`jfr cxpfrtcrs fr `hhunui`tcg od w`rcafuscsod Xodb`pfrc;

5  Wac prclc`soeoioty stugy w`s prcp`rcg ey @dgrcw NhKcdzoc lfr @GE udgcr W@-UCB 27?3: Xuppfrt lfr tac @ssfho`tofd fl Xfutac`st @so`d D`tofds ]ius Warcc Odtcbr`tcg Lffg Xchuroty Lr`ncwfrk, waoha os lod`dhcg ey tacJ`p`d Ludg lfr ]fvcrty Ucguhtofd. NhKcdzoc‟s stugy `s wcii `s tac pfsotofd p`pcr fl Noif A`noitfd fd rcbofd`i rohcluturcs wcrc `isf goshusscg od `d cxpcrt wfrkodb brfup ncctodb frb`dozcg ey tac Hcdtrc lfr Dfd-Wr`gotofd`iXchuroty Xtugocs `t D`dy`db Wchadfifboh`i Sdovcrsoty od Xodb`pfrc od N`rha 5=05.

8 Noif A`noitfd os ` rohc n`rkct `d`iyst `dg tac prcsogcdt `dg hflfudgcr fl Lortsbr`od, Odh., ` rohc n`rkct `gvosfryscrvohc.

Page 11: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 11/28

Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc: Fptofds lfr @ggrcssodb ]rohc Uosk `dg ]rohc \fi`toioty od Uohc | 8

•  cdhfur`bodb n`jfr @so`d rohc pi`ycrs tf st`rt up tacor fwd gfncstoh`iiy grovcd rfubafr p`ggy rohc luturcs;

•  cguh`todb tac st`kcafigcrs tf gospci prcjugohc `b`odst luturcs n`rkcts; `dg•  n`kodb `d @so`d hfnnotncdt  tf rcguhc odtcrvcdtofd od rohc n`rkct prohodb `dg tf

prfnftc tr`dsp`rcdhy fl tr`ds`htofds.

NhKcdzoc `dg A`noitfd `brccg fd tac ecdclots fl ` rohc luturcs n`rkct od n`kodb prohcs nfrctr`dsp`rcdt `dg od prfvogodb acgbodb odstruncdts. Efta `isf `brccg ta`t rohc luturcs `rc dft `p`d`hc` tf tac struhtur`i e`rrocrs tf gcvcifpodb nfrc gcn`dg-rcspfdsovc rohc suppiy ha`ods.Wac twf `utafrs, afwcvcr, gollcrcg fd tac tonodb fl `dg tac p`hodb lfr tac cst`eiosancdt fl `rohc luturcs n`rkct. NhKcdzoc taodks ta`t tac @XC@D rcbofd os dft yct prcp`rcg lfr ` rohc luturcsn`rkct. Odstc`g, ac subbcstcg ta`t @XC@D ic`gcrs hfdsogcr `itcrd`tovc rosk n`d`bcncdt tffissuha `s sw`ps. Fd tac ftacr a`dg, A`noitfd hfdtcdgcg ta`t tac aurgics od gcvcifpodb ` rohcluturcs n`rkct od tac @XC@D rcbofd `rc dft odsurnfudt`eic, `dg ta`t taos safuig ec st`rtcgdfw. Ac lurtacr st`tcg ta`t tac rohc odgustry od tac Sdotcg Xt`tcs tffk fvcr 8= yc`rs tf gcvcifp `wfrk`eic rohc luturcs hfdtr`ht, `dg suha `d cllfrt od @so` n`y t`kc yc`rs.

8. Uc`i-Iolc Cx`npics fl N`rkct Odstruncdts Sscglfr ]rohc Uosk N`d`bcncdt  

Wacrc `rc scvcr`i cx`npics fl hfudtrocs `dg bfvcrdncdts usodb n`rkct odstruncdts lfr prohcrosk n`d`bcncdt cotacr tarfuba fvcr tac hfudtcr fr fd hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcs tf suhhcssluiiyacgbc prohc rosk `dg tf erodb gfwd prohc vfi`toioty od gfncstoh n`rkcts. Wac lfiifwodbodstruncdts `ppiocg od v`rofus hfudtrocs a`vc suhhcssluiiy n`d`bcg prohc rosk `dg tacrceyrcguhcg tac eurgcd fl udhcrt`odty od tcrns fl tac prohcs fl `brohuitur`i hfnnfgotocs od tacorrcspchtovc gfncstoh n`rkcts. Od tac prfhcss, tacsc hfudtrocs a`vc n`d`bcg tf prfvogc prohcst`eoioty `dg lffg schuroty tf tacor pfpui`tofd.

(o) Er`zoi.  Wac Er`zoio`d Ncrh`dtoic `dg Luturcs Cxha`dbc `dg ots suesogo`ry, tacEr`zoi Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc, a`vc acipcg l`rncrs acgbc tacor rosk wotaoddfv`tovc odstruncdts, od hffrgod`tofd wota prov`tc pi`ycrs, l`rncr hffpcr`tovcs,`dg e`dks.

(oo) Ctaofpo`.  Wac gcvcifpncdt fl tac Ctaofpo`d Hfnnfgoty Cxha`dbc, ` spftcxha`dbc od tac hfudtry, `ifdb wota `d cdtorc suppfrt systcn ta`t odhiugcs prohcgosscnod`tofd `dg w`rcafusodb lfr br`ods prohc st`eoioty, a`vc odhrc`scg tacp`rtohop`tofd fl prfguhcrs od tac hfudtry.

(ooo) Odgo`. A`ry`d` Xt`tc Hffpcr`tovc Xuppiy `dg N`rkctodb @brohuitur`i Lcgcr`tofd(A@LCG) os `d `pcx hffpcr`tovc rcspfdsoeic lfr wac`t prfhurcncdt udgcr tacnodonun suppfrt prohc (NX]) shacnc fl tac Bfvcrdncdt fl Odgo`. Wf hfdtcdgwota cxhcss prfguhtofd fl wac`t, tac lcgcr`tofd a`s suhhcssluiiy acgbcg dfd-NX] wac`t prfhurcncdt (fr tac cxhcss fl NX] prfhurcncdt) fd tac D`tofd`iHfnnfgoty `dg Gcrov`tovcs Cxha`dbc fl Odgo` `s ` st`dg`rg safrt acgbcr.

(ov) N`i`wo.  Acgbodb `b`odst tac ifwcr prfguhtofd fl n`ozc od N`i`wo a`s eccdgcvcifpcg tarfuba tac usc fl paysoh`i h`ii fptofds wota tac Xt`dg`rg E`dk `s tachfudtcrp`rty.

Wacrc os df rc`sfd way tacsc vcry s`nc odstruncdts h`ddft ec uscg od tac @XC@D rcbofd lfrn`d`bodb prohc rosk od rohc `dg `ggrcssodb lffg schuroty. Waos p`pcr cxpifrcs tacsc fptofds lfr

Page 12: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 12/28

7 | @GE Xust`od`eic Gcvcifpncdt Rfrkodb ]`pcr Xcrocs Df. 53

tr`godb rohc `dg tac ftacr odlr`struhturc rcquorcncdts ta`t h`d acip erodb od prohc st`eoioty `dgecttcr prohc rc`ioz`tofd tf l`rncrs.

7. Uohc Wr`godb fd `d Cxostodb Ucbofd`i Hfnnfgotocs

Cxha`dbc od @XC@D @ rohc prohc odgcx (c.b., ` rcbofd`i rohc odgcx) luturcs hfdtr`ht gcdfnod`tcg od SX gfii`rs n`y ecgcvcifpcg `dg tr`gcg fd `d cxostodb hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc suha `s tafsc od Afdb Kfdb,Haod` fr od Xodb`pfrc. Wr`godb rohc luturcs fd `d cxostodb hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc od tac rcbofd,r`tacr ta`d scttodb up ` dcw hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc tf tr`gc fdiy rohc luturcs, a`s scvcr`i`gv`dt`bcs. Xcttodb up ` dcw hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc os ` ifdb-gr`wd  prfhcss; os h`pot`i-odtcdsovc; `dg rcquorcs scvcr`i hrotoh`i cicncdts suha `s ruic effks, tr`godb systcn, hic`rodbsystcn, rosk n`d`bcncdt systcn, `dg `pprfv`i fl rcbui`tfrs. @isf, ot gfcs dft n`kc scdsc tfcst`eiosa ` dcw cxha`dbc tf tr`gc just fdc prfguht‗rohc. Odstc`g, tac h`pot`i odvcstncdt h`d ecput tf ecttcr usc ey odhcdtovozodb `d cxostodb cxha`dbc tf i`udha ` rohc hfdtr`ht `dg hrc`todb tac`w`rcdcss `dg cguh`tofd rcquorcg tf `ttr`ht pi`ycrs tf tr`gc taos hfdtr`ht.

Lfr rohc tf ec suhhcssluiiy tr`gcg fd ` rcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc, ot os csscdto`i ta`t tacafst fl tac cxha`dbc a`s fr suppfrts `d fpcd chfdfny, tr`godb od odtcrd`tofd`i hurrcdhocs, luiiyhfdvcrtoeic ifh`i hurrcdhy, lrcc odlifw `dg futlifw fl bffgs, ` rfeust icb`i `dg rcbui`tfrylr`ncwfrk, `s wcii `s bffg w`rcafusc l`hoiotocs `dg `hhcss tf pfrts. Afdb Kfdb, Haod` `dgXodb`pfrc efta ncct tac `efvc rcquorcncdts. Od `ggotofd, efta a`vc suhhcsslui hfnnfgotocscxha`dbcs‗tac Afdb Kfdb Ncrh`dtoic Cxha`dbc, waoha tr`gcs bfig, `dg tac Xodb`pfrcCxha`dbc, waoha tr`gcs rueecr, luci foi, hfppcr, zodh, `dg `iunodoun. Wac Xodb`pfrc Cxha`dbc`isf fllcrs fvcr-tac-hfudtcr hic`rodb lfr prfguhts suha `s rueecr, hf`i, orfd frc, lrcobat, `dgcdcrby.

Lfiifwodb `rc tac `gv`dt`bcs fl tr`godb rohc fd ` rcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc:

(o) Wac rcbofd`i rohc odgcx h`d echfnc ` ecdhan`rk lfr @XC@D rohc prohcs.Hfudtrocs, bfvcrdncdts, `dg tac prov`tc schtfr `s wcii `s l`rncr hffpcr`tovcsh`d usc taos ecdhan`rk od gchogodb tac prohcs lfr ifh`i rohc br`gcs.

(oo) Od `ggotofd tf ` rohc prohc odgcx (c.b., ` rcbofd`i rohc odgcx), ` rohc luturcs hfdtr`hte`scg fd ` pfpui`r br`gc fl rohc, waoha os od turd e`scg fd n`rkct lccge`hk,hfuig `isf ec iostcg fd ` rcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc. Waos hfuig rcsuit od tacpaysoh`i gciovcry fl rohc `s wcii. Onpfrtodb hfudtrocs hfuig tacd usc taos pi`tlfrntf tr`gc rohc.

(ooo) D`tofd`i `bcdhocs `dg p`r`st`t`is hfuig `ht `s `bbrcb`tfrs lfr tacor ifh`i rohcprfguhtofd `dg acgbc tac rohc prohc rosk fd tac rcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcusodb tac rcbofd`i rohc odgcx. Ol ` rohc luturcs hfdtr`ht e`scg fd ` pfpui`r rohcbr`gc os `isf `v`oi`eic lfr tr`godb fd ` rcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc, d`tofd`i

bfvcrdncdt `bcdhocs, l`rncr hffpcr`tovcs, `dg p`r`st`t`is hfuig usc tacpi`tlfrn tf tr`gc tacor rohc rcquorcncdts, r`tacr ta`d gfodb sf eoi`tcr`iiy. Waos woiicdhfur`bc nuha dccgcg tr`dsp`rcdhy od prohc goshfvcry, tacrcey rcguhodb prohcvfi`toioty.

(ov) Wac rcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc hfuig `isf pi`y tac rfic fl hcdtr`ihfudtcrp`rty `dg bu`r`dtcc tr`ds`htofds lfr `ii kodgs fl rohc tr`gcs, odhiugodbtr`gcs gfdc fd tac cxha`dbc `dg tarfuba sw`ps, fvcr tac hfudtcr, `dg lfrw`rghfdtr`hts. Wac hfdhcpt fl bu`r`dtcc fl tr`gcs tarfuba ` hcdtr`i hfudtcrp`rty os

Page 13: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 13/28

Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc: Fptofds lfr @ggrcssodb ]rohc Uosk `dg ]rohc \fi`toioty od Uohc | 3

goshusscg od Xchtofd 3.

Afwcvcr, sfnc prcrcquosotc odlr`struhturc dccg tf ec cst`eiosacg, odhiugodb tac rohc prohc odgcx`dg tac st`dg`rgoz`tofd fl rohc.

7.0 Gcvcifpncdt fl tac Uohc ]rohc Odgcx

Wf tr`gc luturcs `dg fptofds fd ` rcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc, ` rohc prohc odgcx ta`t osrcprcscdt`tovc fl tac tfp lovc fr scvcd nfst pfpui`r rohc br`gcs dccgs tf ec gcvcifpcg. N`dy fltacsc rohc br`gcs `rc hfrrci`tcg, eut ` lurtacr stugy wfuig ec dccgcg tf `sscss tac cxtcdt flhfrrci`tofd fl n`jfr br`gcs fl rohc ta`t `rc cxpfrtcg `dg hfdsuncg od tac @XC@D rcbofd.

Waos t`sk fl gcvcifpodb `d odgcx hfuig ec `ssobdcg tf `d `bcdhy spcho`iozodb od hfdstruhtodbsuha hfnnfgoty odgcxcs `dg ta`t a`s ` bffg kdfwicgbc fl rohc n`rkcts. Odgustry pi`ycrs hfuigec hfdsuitcg od gcvcifpodb tac odgcx, `dg tacor odputs hfuig ec t`kcd fd tac br`gcs fl rohc `dgtacor wcobat od tac rohc prohc odgcx. Waos woii bovc tacn fwdcrsaop fl tac prfguht `dg cdhfur`bctacn tf tr`gc tac prfguht wacd tac odgcx os iostcg lfr tr`godb. Od taos rcb`rg, vcducs suha `s tac

 @XC@D Uohc Wr`gc Lfrun prfvogc ` bffg fppfrtudoty lfr hfdsuitodb t`rbctcg st`kcafigcrs`efut spcholoh rchfnncdg`tofds fd gcvcifpodb ` rcbofd`i rohc odgcx.

Wac aostfroh`i prohcs fl tac rcicv`dt br`gcs fl rohc hfuig ec uscg tf euoig ` e`sc prohc `s fd `p`rtohui`r g`y lfr tac odgcx. Wac e`sc yc`r lfr ` rohc odgcx, lfr cx`npic, hfuig ec 5=0=, waohawoii sct tac ecdhan`rk. Wac odhrc`sc fr gchrc`sc od prohcs hfuig tacd ec hfnp`rcg wota tace`sc prohc fl tac odgcx.

7.5 Xt`dg`rgoz`tofd fl Uohc

Lfr tr`godb `dy luturcs fr fptofds prfguht, ot os csscdto`i ta`t ` st`dg`rg qu`ioty ec prcshroecg lfrtac prfguht tf ec tr`gcg. Xodhc tac prohc fl rohc woii gollcr lrfn fdc br`gc tf `dftacr, ot os

onpfrt`dt ta`t qu`ioty `dg br`gc spcholoh`tofds lfr tac rohc hfdtr`ht `rc hic`riy sct. Lfr `iieoi`tcr`i hfdtr`hts, taos os dft ` hfdstr`odt, `s tac p`rtocs tf tac tr`ds`htofd dcbfto`tc fd tacbr`gc `dg qu`ioty eclfrc cdtcrodb odtf tac hfdtr`ht. Afwcvcr, lfr duncrfus `dg i`rbc hfdtr`hts,st`dg`rg br`gcs fl tac hfnnfgoty woii ec dccgcg tf l`hoiot`tc tr`ds`htofds.

Duncrfus br`gcs `dg v`roctocs fl rohc `rc prfguhcg od tac @XC@D rcbofd. G`t` pcrt`ododb tfrohc prfguhtofd `dg prohcs scbrcb`tcg `t tac hfudtry icvci `dg gostodbuosacg ey br`gcs `rc`v`oi`eic tarfuba scvcr`i `bcdhocs, suha `s tac Lffg `dg @brohuiturc Frb`doz`tofd fl tac SdotcgD`tofds (L@F) `dg tac Odtcrd`tofd`i Uohc Ucsc`rha Odstotutc. Gcspotc tacsc v`roctocs flst`dg`rgs `dg qu`ioty, prcionod`ry fescrv`tofd fl prohc hfrrci`tofd fl sfnc rohc br`gcs odgoh`tcsstrfdb prohc hfrrci`tofd `nfdb tac n`jfr br`gcs fl rohc cxpfrtcg ey tac tfp cxpfrtodb hfudtrocssuha `s Odgo`, ]`kost`d, Wa`oi`dg, tac Sdotcg Xt`tcs, `dg \oct D`n.

Lfr cx`npic, Wa`o 0==% E-br`gc rohc os wogciy pfpui`r `dg w`s lfudg tf ec aobaiy hfrrci`tcg tfftacr ifh`i br`gcs fl rohc `s wcii `s odtcrd`tofd`i rohc prohcs (Haoh`bf Ef`rg fl Wr`gc [HEFW^Sdotcg Xt`tcs [SX^ ifdb-br`od 5.7% rohc). Loburc 0 safws tac hfrrci`tofd ectwccd tac prohcs flWa`o 0==% E-br`gc rohc `dg SX ifdb-br`od 5.7% rohc.

Page 14: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 14/28

< | @GE Xust`od`eic Gcvcifpncdt Rfrkodb ]`pcr Xcrocs Df. 53

Loburc 0: Hfrrci`tofd fl ]rohcs fl Wa`o 0==% E-Br`gc Uohcwo ta SX Ifdb-Br`od 5.7% Uohc, J`du`ry 5===‘Gchcnecr 5=00

SX > Sdotcg Xt`tcs.Xfurhc: Rfrig Uohc Xt`tostohs, OUUO.

Xonoi`riy, @so`d 53% ifdb-br`od, ifw-qu`ioty waotc rohc, suha `s ]`kost`d 53%, Wa`o 53%, `dg\oct D`n 53%, os `isf hfrrci`tcg (Loburc 5). Lfr tacsc rohc v`rocty br`gcs, erfkcd rohc prohcs fl]`kost`d 53%, Wa`o 53%, `dg \oct D`n 53% a`vc eccd hfdsogcrcg ` prfxy od tac `escdhc flprohc g`t` lfr 53% br`gc rohc.7

 Loburc 5: Hfrrci`tofd fl ]`kost`d, Wa oi`dg, dg \oct D`n 53%

Erfkcd Uohc ]rohcs, J`du`ry 5===‘Gchcnecr 5=00

Xfurhc: Rfrig Uohc Xt`tostohs, OUUO.

7  Guc tf tac ud`v`oi`eoioty fl g`t` lfr Odgo` 53% br`gc rohc prohcs, ot w`s dft pfssoeic tf cx`nodc ots hfrrci`tofd wotaWa`o 53%, \oct D`n 53%, `dg ]`kost`d 53% br`gc rohc prohcs.

=

5==

7==

<==

1==

0===

05==

     J    `    d  -     =     =

     N    `    r  -     =     0

     N    `    y  -     =     5

     J    u     i  -     =     8

     X    c    p  -     =     7

     D    f    v  -     =     3

     J    `    d  -     =     2

     N    `    r  -     =     1

     N    `    y  -     =     ?

     J    u     i  -     0     =

     X    c    p  -     0     0

ODWCUD@WOFD@I

]UOHCX - Wa`oi`dg:

E`dbkfk - Uohc (Wa`o

0==% E) - Cxpfrt (SX

Gfii`r/tfddc)

ODWCUD@WOFD@I

]UOHCX - SX@ - Uohc

(S.X. Ifdb Br`od 5.7%)

- Cxpfrt (SX

Gfii`r/tfddc)

=

0==

5==

8==

7==

3==

<==

2==

1==?==

0===

     J    `    d  -     =     =

     L    c     e  -     =     0

     N    `

    r  -     =     5

     @    p

    r  -     =     8

     N    `

    y  -     =     7

     J    u    d  -     =     3

     J    u

     i  -     =     <

     @    u

    b  -     =     2

     X    c    p  -     =     1

     F    h

    t  -     =     ?

     D    f

    v  -     0     =

     D    f

    v  -     0     0

ODWCUD@WOFD@I

]UOHCX - ]`kost`d - Uohc

(53% erfkcd) - Cxpfrt

(SX Gfii`r/tfddc)

ODWCUD@WOFD@I

]UOHCX - Wa`oi`dg:

E`dbkfk - Uohc (53%

erfkcd) - Cxpfrt (SX

Gfii`r/tfddc)

ODWCUD@WOFD@I]UOHCX (E`dbkfk):

Wa`o 0==% E-br`gcrohc, cxpfrt ($/tfd)

ODWCUD@WOFD@I]UOHCX (SX):SX ifdb-br`od 5.7% rohc,cxpfrt ($/tfd)

ODWCUD@WOFD@I]UOHCX (]`kost`d):53% erfkcd rohc, cxpfrt($/tfd)

ODWCUD@WOFD@I]UOHCX (E`dbkfk):53% erfkcd rohc, cxpfrt($/tfd)

Page 15: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 15/28

Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc: Fptofds lfr @ggrcssodb ]rohc Uosk `dg ]rohc \fi`toioty od Uohc | 2

Guc tf tac ud`v`oi`eoioty fl prohc g`t` lfr @so`d 3% ifdb-br`od, aoba-qu`ioty rohc, ot w`s dftpfssoeic tf gcguhc tac cxtcdt fl hfrrci`tofd lfr tac Odgo` 3%, ]`kost`d 3%, `dg \oct D`n 3%br`gc rohc. Afwcvcr, e`scg fd tac hfrrci`tofd fescrvcg lfr 53% br`gc prohcs, ot n`y ecsurnoscg ta`t tacrc wfuig ec ` sonoi`r hfrrci`tofd lfr tac 3% v`rocty `s wcii.

Wac aobacr hfrrci`tofd `nfdb tac v`rofus rohc br`gcs wfuig nc`d ta`t prohcs fl gollcrcdt br`gcs

fl rohc nfvc od ` hffrgod`tcg n`ddcr. E`scg fd tac hfrrci`tofd fescrvcg lfr tac lfrcbfodbv`rofus br`gcs fl rohc, ot n`y taus ec pfssoeic tf hfdstruht ` rcbofd`i rohc odgcx lfr @so`d rohcbr`gcs tarfuba ` hfnpfsotc fl sonoi`riy hfrrci`tcg rohc br`gc v`roctocs. Waos wfuig n`kc tacrcbofd`i rohc odgcx ` nfrc scdsotovc nc`surc fl prohc nfvcncdts fl gollcrcdt br`gcs fl rohc.E`scg fd aostfroh`i prohc g`t`, fdc n`y taus ec `eic tf prcgoht tac prohc fl ` spcholoh v`rocty flrohc e`scg fd tac nfvcncdt od tac rcbofd`i rohc odgcx.

 @dftacr fptofd wfuig ec tf hfdsogcr wactacr tac L@F rohc odgcx hfuig `isf ec uscg od otshurrcdt lfrn fr `itcrd`tovciy scrvc `s tac e`sos lfr hrc`todb ` rcbofd`i rohc odgcx. Wac L@F rohcodgcx hfdsosts fl lfur hfnpfdcdts‗odgoh` aoba-qu`ioty v`rocty, odgoh` ifw-qu`ioty v`rocty,

 j`pfdoh` v`rocty, `dg lr`br`dt v`rocty. Wac hfdstotucdt rohc br`gcs udgcr c`ha fl tac lfurv`roctocs dccg tf ec stugocg lurtacr tf `shcrt`od wactacr tac L@F rohc odgcx h`d odgccg ec uscg

`s ` e`sc lfr ` rcbofd`i rohc odgcx ta`t rcpioh`tcs tac @so`d br`gc rohc prohcs.

3. Gfncstoh Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc \`ro`dts

Wac tfp rohc-cxpfrtodb hfudtrocs od @so`, suha `s H`nefgo`, Odgo`, Wa`oi`dg, `dg \oct D`n,hfuig ec cdhfur`bcg tf sct up ` gfncstoh hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc. Cotacr ` spft cxha`dbc fr `gcrov`tovcs cxha`dbc n`y ec cxpifrcg, ol tacsc hfudtrocs gf dft hurrcdtiy a`vc fdc lfr tr`godbrohc (Efx 0).

Wac nfst pfpui`r ifh`i br`gc fl rohc h`d ec tr`gcg fd tac ifh`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc od tachfudtry‟s rcspchtovc hurrcdhy. Waos woii cdhfur`bc rohc l`rncrs tf scii fr acgbc tacor prfguhc fdtac ifh`i cxha`dbc.

Wacrc `rc scvcr`i suhhcss stfrocs fl gfncstoh hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcs, suha `s tac Ctaofpo`dHfnnfgoty Cxha`dbc `dg tac D`tofd`i Hfnnfgoty `dg Gcrov`tovcs Cxha`dbc fl Odgo`. Wacsccxha`dbcs acip l`rncrs rc`iozc ecttcr prohcs. Hrc`todb tac dchcss`ry suppfrt odlr`struhturc,suha `s w`rcafusc rchcopts `dg l`rncr hffpcr`tovcs, wfuig lurtacr l`hoiot`tc tac acgbodb fl tacifh`i prfguhc fd tacsc cxha`dbcs.

 @itafuba Odgo` `dg Wa`oi`dg a`vc cxostodb hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcs, tac cxpcrocdhc fl n`rkctp`rtohop`dts a`s dft eccd vcry pfsotovc od efta hfudtrocs. Raoic Odgo` a`s nuitopic hfnnfgotocs

Efx 0: Xpft fr H`sa Cxha`dbc `dg Gcrov`tovcs Cxha`dbc

 @ spft fr h`sa cxha`dbc os `d cxha`dbc wacrc tac prohc lfr tac tr`ds`htofd os `brccg lfr tac prcscdtnfncdt fr lfr onncgo`tc gciovcry. Wr`ds`htofds gfdc fd suha `d cxha`dbc `rc dfrn`iiy sctticg 0‘5g`ys `ltcr tac tr`ds`htofd os `brccg upfd.

 @ gcrov`tovcs cxha`dbc os `d cxha`dbc wacrc tac prohc lfr tac tr`ds`htofd os `brccg lfr sctticncdt frgciovcry `t sfnc spcholocg g`tc od tac luturc. Wac g`tc fl sctticncdt fr gciovcry os i`og fut od tachfdtr`ht spcholoh`tofds.

Page 16: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 16/28

1 | @GE Xust`od`eic Gcvcifpncdt Rfrkodb ]`pcr Xcrocs Df. 53

cxha`dbcs (efta spft `dg gcrov`tovcs cxha`dbcs) `dg w`rcafusc odlr`struhturc odhiugodb tacrchcopt systcn, tac bfvcrdncdt a`s e`ddcg rohc tr`godb fd Odgo`‟s cxha`dbcs. Od `ggotofd, tacnodonun suppfrt prohc lfr prfhurcncdt fl rohc ey tac bfvcrdncdt `isf goshfur`bcs n`rkctp`rtohop`dts lrfn tr`godb fd tac cxha`dbc.

Rota rcspcht tf Wa`oi`dg, tac cxostodb cxha`dbc os ` luturcs cxha`dbc, wacrc tac rohc hfdtr`ht os

tr`gcg od e`at. Wacrc `rc scvcr`i rc`sfds way tac hfdtr`ht a`s dft b`odcg pfpui`roty. Lorst, tacrohc-picgbodb shacnc fl tac Bfvcrdncdt fl Wa`oi`dg prcshroecs ` nodonun prfhurcncdt prohcfl rohc. Wacsc prfhurcncdt prohcs `rc nuha aobacr ta`d tac odtcrd`tofd`i rohc prohcs. Xodhc tacl`rncrs `rc bcttodb ` nuha aobacr prohc tarfuba tac bfvcrdncdt prfhurcncdt prfbr`n, tacya`vc df rc`sfd tf tr`gc fd tac cxha`dbc. Xchfdg, ` w`rcafusc rchcopt systcn os dft `v`oi`eic,waoha os ` kcy cicncdt fl tac ifbostohs systcn lfr ` suhhcsslui hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc. Gciovcryfl rohc tr`gcg fd tac cxha`dbc os gfdc fd ` lrcc-fd-ef`rg e`sos fr od w`rcafuscs.

Ot n`y ec usclui lfr Wa`oi`dg tf hfdsogcr a`vodb ` rohc hfdtr`ht gcdfnod`tcg od SX gfii`rs. Waoswoii dft cxpfsc tac onpfrtcrs tf hurrcdhy rosk `dg tacrcey odhrc`sc p`rtohop`tofd od tac rohcluturcs hfdtr`ht. @s tac l`rncrs n`y dft ec hfdvcrs`dt wota luturcs `dg fptofds odstruncdts, otwfuig `isf acip ol tac cxha`dbc fllcrs spft tr`godb od rohc.

 @s H`nefgo` `dg \oct D`n `rc `nfdb tac dct cxpfrtodb hfudtrocs od @XC@D, ` gfncstohhfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc n`y ec cst`eiosacg od tacsc hfudtrocs `s wcii. @s goshusscg c`riocr, taccst`eiosancdt fl tac Ctaofpo`d Hfnnfgoty Cxha`dbc `s wcii `s w`rcafusc odlr`struhturc `dghrcgot l`hoiotocs a`vc brc`tiy acipcg ifh`i l`rncrs fet`od ecttcr prohcs lfr tacor n`ozc.

 @dftacr fptofd wfuig ec tf hfdsogcr scttodb up ` suercbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc od tacBrc`tcr Nckfdb Xuercbofd (BNX). Wac BNX a`s tac pftcdto`i lfr cda`dhcg rohc cxpfrt tarfubatac gcvcifpncdt fl tac odtcrhfudtry rohc v`iuc ha`od dctwfrk. Wac BNX os hurrcdtiy onprfvodbtac tr`gc l`hoiot`tofd scrvohcs `dg odlr`struhturc fl tac dctwfrk. Odvcstncdts fd ifbostohsodlr`struhturc `t tac sa`rcg chfdfnoh `dg tr`gc hfrrogfrs hfuig ec `ubncdtcg. Odlfrn`tofdhfnnudoh`tofd tchadfifby-e`scg n`rkct odlfrn`tofd `dg h`p`hoty euoigodb lfr l`rncrs od usodb

tac cxha`dbc pi`tlfrns hfuig `isf ec odtcbr`i `spchts lfr gcvcifpodb tac suercbofd‟s rohc v`iucha`od dctwfrk.

Wac `gv`dt`bcs fl tr`godb rohc fd ` gfncstoh hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc `rc `s lfiifws:(o) Ol tac gfncstoh hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc fllcrs tr`godb fd ` spft fr h`sa e`sos,

l`rncrs h`d scii tacor prfguhc gorchtiy fd tac ifh`i cxha`dbc r`tacr ta`d bftarfuba ` noggic pcrsfd tf lodg ` euycr lfr tacor rohc. Waos woii cd`eic tacn tffet`od ` ecttcr prohc lfr tacor prfguhc.

(oo) Wr`godb rohc fd tac gfncstoh hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc woii ic`g tf ecttcr prohcgoshfvcry.

(ooo) Ol tac gfncstoh hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc fllcrs rohc luturcs, l`rncrs hfuig usc tacpi`tlfrn lfr acgbodb tacor rohc prfguhc `dg ifhk od ` nodonun prohc lfr gciovcry `t

` luturc g`tc.(ov) Wac gfncstoh hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc hfuig sct up w`rcafusc l`hoiotocs `dg `

w`rcafusc rchcopt systcn, waoha prfvogc licxoeoioty lfr l`rncrs tf scii tacor rohcwacd tacy h`d bct ecttcr prohcs. Wac w`rcafusc rchcopt wfuig `isf acip l`rncrsfet`od hrcgot `b`odst tacor prfguhc lrfn e`dks `dg ftacr odstotutofds sodhc tacrchcopts `rc tr`g`eic.

(v) Ol tac l`rncrs wcrc dft tf usc tac ifh`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc `dg scii rohc tf `euycr, tacy n`y cdhfudtcr `d ossuc wacrc tac euycr n`y l`oi tf t`kc gciovcry frdft p`y tac prohc `brccg upfd. Afwcvcr, ol tac s`ic os gfdc fd tac cxha`dbc, tac

Page 17: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 17/28

Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc: Fptofds lfr @ggrcssodb ]rohc Uosk `dg ]rohc \fi`toioty od Uohc | ?

i`ttcr wfuig bu`r`dtcc tac tr`ds`htofd `dg p`y tac prohc `t waoha tac s`ic w`spcrlfrncg fd tac cxha`dbc pi`tlfrn.

Wac gfncstoh hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc, tacrclfrc, dft fdiy prfvogcs ` pi`tlfrn lfr tr`godb `dgprohc goshfvcry eut `isf prfvogcs tac hfnpictc ifbostohs systcn ta`t os rcquorcg ey l`rncrs tfn`rkct tacor hrfp. Wac ifbostohs systcn odhiugcs w`rcafusc l`hoiotocs, w`rcafusc rchcopts,

`ss`yodb fl qu`ioty fl rohc, prohc gosscnod`tofd, `dg tac odlr`struhturc tf fet`od hrcgot lfr tacorprfguhc, `s wcii `s cguh`tofd`i suppfrt lfr l`rncrs `dg ` bu`r`dtcc lfr tr`ds`htofds cxchutcg.Acdhc, cvcd ol l`rncrs gchogc dft tf usc tac gfncstoh hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc lfr sciiodb fracgbodb tacor prfguhc, tacy hfuig stoii ecdclot lrfn tac ifbostohs systcn put od pi`hc ey taccxha`dbc.

<. Xw`p Odstruncdts `dg Lfrw`rg Hfdtr`hts

<.0 Xw`p Wr`ds`htofd 

 @dftacr fptofd lfr ` l`rncr os tarfuba ` sw`p hfdtr`ht. Waos os ` eoi`tcr`i `brccncdt ectwccdtwf p`rtocs tf lox ` prohc lfr ` hfnnfgoty fvcr sfnc luturc tonc pcrofg. @ lif`todb prohc os tauscxha`dbcg (o.c., sw`ppcg) lfr ` loxcg prohc ectwccd tac euycr `dg tac sciicr fl ` hfnnfgoty.Xw`ps `rc ecdhan`rkcg `b`odst ` luturcs prohc. @ l`rncr hfuig cdtcr odtf ` sw`p tr`ds`htofd tffet`od ` loxcg prohc lfr aos fr acr prfguhc. @d cx`npic fl afw ` sw`p os udgcrt`kcd os `slfiifws:

 @ rohc l`rncr (o.c., sw`p sciicr) wfuig iokc tf rchcovc ` loxcg prohc fl $5== pcr tfd lfr tacprfguhtofd ac os cxpchtodb <= g`ys od tac luturc. Wac lif`todb prohc os e`scg fd tac hifsodbprohc fl tac HEFW luturcs n`rkct. Wac l`rncr cdtcrs odtf tac sw`p tf rchcovc ` loxcg prohcfl $5== pcr tfd. Fd tac sctticncdt g`y, tac prohc fl HEFW rohc luturcs lfr tac cxporodbhfdtr`ht nfdta os $0?= pcr tfd. Wac sw`p euycr p`ys tac l`rncr tac gollcrcdhc ectwccd tac

loxcg prohc (o.c., $5==) `dg tac HEFW luturcs prohc (o.c., $0?=), waoha os $0= pcr tfd. Wacl`rncr sciis tac prfguhc od tac h`sa n`rkct lfr $0?= (`s tac luturcs prohcs fl tachfnnfgotocs tr`gcg fd tac cxha`dbc dfrn`iiy hfdvcrbc wota h`sa n`rkct prohcs) `dg a`staus loxcg aos prfguhtofd v`iuc `t $5== pcr tfd. 

Xcvcr`i hfdhcrds, afwcvcr, dccg tf ec `ggrcsscg wota rcspcht tf sw`p tr`ds`htofds:(o) Uosk fl hfudtcrp`rty gcl`uit.  Ol tac sw`p euycr l`ois tf n`kc p`yncdt `s pcr

tac loxcg prohc `brccg, tac sw`p sciicr (o.c., l`rncr) h`d ifsc nfdcy ol tac prohc odtac luturcs n`rkct os ifwcr ta`d tac loxcg prohc. Wf saocig tac l`rncr lrfn tac roskfl hfudtcrp`rty gcl`uit, ` hcdtr`i hfudtcrp`rty wfuig ec rcquorcg tf prfvogc `bu`r`dtcc ncha`dosn lfr tac sw`p tr`ds`htofd. Ot n`y ec gollohuit tf lodg suha `dcdtoty (c.b., ` e`dk fr lod`dho`i odstotutofd) tf bu`r`dtcc tac sw`p tr`ds`htofd. Wac

fdiy ftacr fptofd os lfr tac rcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc fr gfncstohhfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc tf `ht `s ` hcdtr`i hfudtcrp`rty `dg prfvogc tacbu`r`dtcc ncha`dosn tf efta tac euycr `dg tac sciicr fl tac sw`p.

(oo) Luturcs prohc rcquorcg lfr sw`p tr`ds`htofd. Xodhc sw`p tr`ds`htofds `rcecdhan`rkcg `b`odst ` luturcs prohc, ot os csscdto`i tf a`vc `d cxostodb rohcluturcs hfdtr`ht prohc `b`odst waoha tac sw`p tr`ds`htofd n`y ec sctticg.Afwcvcr, od tac `escdhc fl ` suhhcsslui rohc luturcs hfdtr`ht tr`gcg od tac

 @XC@D rcbofd, ot n`y dft ec pfssoeic tf usc sw`ps.

Page 18: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 18/28

0= | @GE Xust`od`eic Gcvcifpncdt Rfrkodb ]`pcr Xcrocs Df. 53

Lfr tacsc rc`sfds, tac sw`p tr`ds`htofd n`y taus dft wfrk.

<.5 Lfrw`rg Hfdtr`hts 

 @ lfrw`rg hfdtr`ht os ` eoi`tcr`i `brccncdt ectwccd tac sciicr `dg tac euycr tf lox ` prohc lfr `spcholocg br`gc `dg tac qu`dtoty fl ` hfnnfgoty lfr gciovcry `t `d `brccg g`tc od tac luturc.

Wafuba tac rosk fl hfudtcrp`rty gcl`uit os dft cionod`tcg ey tac usc fl lfrw`rg hfdtr`hts, udicss` bu`r`dtcc ncha`dosn os od pi`hc, tacsc hfdtr`hts gf dft rcquorc ` luturcs prohc lfr sctticncdt.

Xuha lfrw`rg hfdtr`hts hfuig ec ecdcloho`i tf ` rohc-onpfrtodb hfudtry tf fet`od ` bu`r`dtccgsuppiy fl rohc lrfn ` rohc-cxpfrtodb hfudtry. Efta tac rohc-onpfrtodb `dg rohc-cxpfrtodb hfudtrocshfuig cdtcr odtf ` lfrw`rg hfdtr`ht `brccncdt, wacrcey tac rohc-cxpfrtodb hfudtry `brccs tfgciovcr `d `brccg qu`dtoty fl ` spcholoh br`gc fl rohc, `t ` loxcg prohc, tf ` rohc-onpfrtodb hfudtry,`dg fd tac g`tc fl gciovcry spcholocg od tac lfrw`rg hfdtr`ht. Sdgcr tac lfrw`rg hfdtr`ht`brccncdt, efta hfudtrocs `rc efudg ey tac tcrns fl tac lfrw`rg hfdtr`ht. Ol fdc fl tac p`rtocstf tac lfrw`rg hfdtr`ht l`ois tf ncct ots hfnnotncdt, tac gcl`uitodb p`rty wfuig dccg tf n`kcbffg tac ifss (o.c., tac gollcrcdhc ectwccd tac prcv`oiodb n`rkct prohc fl rohc `dg tac loxcg prohc`s pcr tac lfrw`rg hfdtr`ht) tf tac ftacr p`rty.

Odtcrd`tofd`i hfnncrho`i e`dks hfuig `gnodostcr taos `rr`dbcncdt. Acdhc, ol ` lfrw`rg hfdtr`ht`rr`dbcncdt e`hkcg ey ` bu`r`dtcc ncha`dosn tf tac dfd-gcl`uitodb p`rty os od pi`hc, tacrcwfuig ec vcry iottic nftov`tofd lfr cotacr tac rohc-onpfrtodb fr rohc-cxpfrtodb hfudtry tf rcdcbc fdtac `brccncdt.

2. Ftacr Euoigodb Eifhks lfr Xuhhcsslui Uohc Wr`godb

2.0 R`rcafusc Uchcopt Xystcn `dg Lod`dhc

 @ hrotoh`i cicncdt lfr tr`godb rohc fd ` hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc os ` rfeust w`rcafusc rchcoptsystcn, wacrc tac odtcbroty fl tac systcn os dft hfnprfnoscg ey tac qu`ioty `dg qu`dtoty fl rohcstfrcg od tac w`rcafusc. @ w`rcafusc rchcopt systcn `iifws p`rtohop`dts tf gcpfsot ` st`tcgqu`dtoty fl ` spcholocg qu`ioty fl ` hfnnfgoty odtf ` w`rcafusc. @ rchcopt os ossucg tf tac fwdcr`s cvogcdhc fl ifh`tofd, fwdcrsaop, qu`ioty, `dg qu`dtoty fl tac br`ods stfrcg. Wac rchcopt os `dcbfto`eic odstruncdt ta`t h`d ec sfig fr uscg `s hfii`tcr`i lfr ` if`d, e`hkcg ey tac hi`on tftac hfnnfgoty acig od tac w`rcafusc.

R`rcafusc rchcopts l`hoiot`tc rosk n`d`bcncdt od tarcc n`od w`ys. Lorst, tacy bovc p`rtohop`dtsecttcr `hhcss tf lfrn`i hrcgot n`rkcts ey prfvogodb rcio`eic, vcrolo`eic hfii`tcr`i lfr if`ds tfnotob`tc tac hfdscqucdhcs fl safhks suha `s d`tur`i h`i`notocs. Xchfdg, ` w`rcafusc rchcoptsystcn l`hoiot`tcs prov`tc stfr`bc, bovodb l`rncrs tac licxoeoioty tf n`rkct tacor hrfp `t gollcrcdttoncs fl tac yc`r, r`tacr ta`d strohtiy `t a`rvcst wacd prohcs `rc usu`iiy tac ifwcst. Waosgovcrsoloh`tofd fl s`ics `hrfss tonc acips n`d`bc rosk `dg, wacd wogciy `gfptcg, h`d `isf aciprcguhc sc`sfd`i prohc v`ro`eoioty. Waorg, ` wcii-struhturcg `dg rcio`eic w`rcafusc rchcopt systcnbcdcr`iiy n`kcs lffg n`rkctodb nfrc cllohocdt ey `htodb `s ` hic`rodbafusc ta`t cdlfrhcsfwdcrsaop hi`ons `dg h`d ec `d onp`rto`i taorg p`rty ta`t bu`r`dtccs pcrlfrn`dhc fd hfdtr`hts.

 @s tac w`rcafusc rchcopt os ` tr`g`eic gfhuncdt e`hkcg ey tac icb`i `dg rcbui`tfry systcn fltac rcspchtovc hfudtry, tac hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc h`d rciy fd tac w`rcafusc rchcopt tf cllchtgciovcry fl rohc `s pcr tac qu`ioty, qu`dtoty, `dg fwdcrsaop spcholocg fd tac rchcopt. Wac

Page 19: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 19/28

Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc: Fptofds lfr @ggrcssodb ]rohc Uosk `dg ]rohc \fi`toioty od Uohc | 00

w`rcafusc rchcopt os dfrn`iiy `hhfnp`docg ey ` hcrtoloh`tc lrfn tac `ss`ycr hcrtolyodb tacqu`ioty fl tac br`od.

 @d cx`npic fl tac suhhcsslui onpicncdt`tofd fl ` w`rcafusc systcn od ` gcvcifpodb hfudtry osod Ctaofpo`. Wac Ctaofpo`d Hfnnfgoty Cxha`dbc a`s cst`eiosacg 33 rcbofd`i w`rcafuscs od 02rcbofds fl tac hfudtry lfr stfrodb tr`gcg hfnnfgotocs suha `s hfllcc, scs`nc, pc` ec`ds, `dg

n`ozc. Od ` safrt pcrofg fl 8 yc`rs, tac w`rcafuscs a`vc a`dgicg 53=,=== tfds fl prfguhc `dgcllchtcg 7.2 noiiofd e`bs fl gciovcrocs fd tac cxha`dbc.

2.5 H`p`hoty Euo igodb fl N`rkct ] rto hop`dts

 @dftacr csscdto`i cicncdt fl suhhcsslui rohc tr`godb od ` hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc os tac `eoioty fltac cxha`dbc `dg ftacr odstotutofds tf onp`rt cguh`tofd tf n`rkct pi`ycrs. Cguh`tofd`i `dgtr`ododb prfbr`ns fr h`np`obds hfuig hfvcr tfpohs suha `s afw tf tr`gc fd `d cxha`dbc; afwtf tr`gc luturcs, fptofds, `dg sw`ps; afw tf usc tacsc odstruncdts tf bct ` nodonun (o.c., liffr)prohc; afw tf usc prohc trcdgs lfr luturc prohodb; afw tf `hhcss hrcgot; wa`t `rc tac ecdclots flacgbodb; `dg wa`t os hfudtcrp`rty rosk.

Wypoh`iiy, hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcs fr bfvcrdncdt `bcdhocs hfuig hfdguht suha prfbr`ns lfr `wogc v`rocty fl n`rkct p`rtohop`dts, odhiugodb prfguhcrs, cdg-uscrs, `dg cvcd lod`dho`i odvcstfrs.Fdc suha prfbr`n rud ey ` hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc os od tac ]cfpic‟s Ucpueioh fl Haod` (Efx 5).

Efx 5: 0,=== \oii`bcs, 0=,=== L`rncrs‟ Cguh`tofd ]rfbr`n

Wac G`io`d Hfnnfgoty Cxha`dbc, e`scg od G`io`d, ]cfpic‟s Ucpueioh fl Haod`, odoto`tcg ` systcn`tohprfbr`n fl tr`ododb lfr l`rncrs h`iicg ’’0,=== \oii`bcs, 0=,=== L`rncrs. Od hffpcr`tofd wota tachfdhcrdcg gcp`rtncdts `dg `bcdhocs fl tac ifh`i bfvcrdncdt, ` scrocs fl horhuot tr`ododb scnod`rswcrc hfdguhtcg. Gurodb 5==3‘5==<, fvcr 8== tr`ododb scnod`rs wcrc acig. Wacsc tr`odcg nfrc ta`d8=,=== pcfpic, hfvcrodb 77 hotocs `dg hfudty gostrohts `hrfss 8 prfvodhcs `dg 0 gostroht od tac dfrtac`strcbofd. Wr`odccs odhiugcg n`jfr brfwcrs, voii`bc `bcdts, br`ssrffts voii`bc h`grcs, `dg h`sa n`rkct

cdtcrproscs.

Wac prfbr`n hfvcrcg tfpohs fd afw tf usc h`sa `dg luturcs n`rkct odlfrn`tofd, odlfrn`tofd fdsfyec`d `dg hfrd n`rkcts, `dg afw tf acgbc tac paysoh`i prfguhc fl l`rncrs usodb tac luturcsn`rkct.

2.8 ]rohc Gosscnod`tofd

 @ taorg cicncdt ta`t os cqu`iiy hrotoh`i lfr hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcs `dg lfr n`d`bodb prohc rosk osrc`i tonc (fr dc`r rc`i tonc) prohc gosscnod`tofd tf l`rncrs. Cxha`dbcs, bfvcrdncdt `bcdhocs,`dg tac prov`tc schtfr h`d pi`y ` n`jfr rfic od gosscnod`todb prohcs `dg ftacr rohc prfguhtofdg`t` wogciy `dg n`kodb tacsc c`soiy `v`oi`eic tf n`rkct p`rtohop`dts tarfuba v`rofus ha`ddcissuha `s tac tcicvosofd, r`gof, odtcrdct, cxha`dbc wcesotcs, safrt ncss`bc scrvohc, `dgcichtrfdoh tohkcr ef`rgs ta`t gospi`y prohcs `t str`tcboh ifh`tofds. Wr`dsp`rcdt `dg c`soiy`v`oi`eic g`t` woii `ttr`ht nfrc p`rtohop`dts tf tr`gc fd tac cxha`dbc `dg tf `isf usc tac prohcsgoshfvcrcg fd tac cxha`dbc `s ` prohc ecdhan`rk. Wac prohc trcdgs cn`d`todb lrfn taccxha`dbc wfuig prfvogc cllchtovc sobd`iiodb lfr prfguhtofd, purha`sodb, `dg odvcstncdtgchosofds.

Page 20: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 20/28

05 | @GE Xust`od`eic Gcvcifpncdt Rfrkodb ]`pcr Xcrocs Df. 53

Od `ggotofd tf prohc odlfrn`tofd, `ii rcicv`dt g`t` pcrt`ododb tf rohc prfguhtofd od tac rcbofd `dgbife`iiy, `s wcii `s stfhks acig od tac hfudtry `dg prohc sobd`i trcdgs, n`y `isf ec n`gc`v`oi`eic tf tac l`rncrs fd ` rcbui`r e`sos.

Wac hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcs od G`io`d `s wcii `s od Ctaofpo` gcnfdstr`tc tac usc fl odlfrn`tofd`dg hfnnudoh`tofds tchadfifby tf n`kc prohcs `dg n`rkct odlfrn`tofd wogciy `v`oi`eic tf

st`kcafigcrs. Sp-tf-g`tc odlfrn`tofd a`s acipcg tac brfwta fl tr`godb vfiuncs od Ctaofpo` `dgsuppfrtcg l`rncrs od tac ]cfpic's Ucpueioh fl Haod` tf gchogc wa`t hrfps tf pi`dt (Efx 8).

1. Ufic fl Xt`kcafigcrs od Uohc Wr`godb1.0 Bfvcrdncdts

Wac bfvcrdncdts fl tac @XC@D ncnecr hfudtrocs pi`y ` vot`i rfic od prfvogodb tac euoigodbeifhks lfr rohc tr`godb. Cvcd ol ` bfvcrdncdt gfcs dft wosa tf euoig tac paysoh`i odlr`struhturc, oth`d hrc`tc tac pfiohy lr`ncwfrk `dg odvcstncdt cdvorfdncdt tf bct tac prov`tc schtfr odvfivcgod euoigodb tac suppfrt systcn. Wacsc euoigodb eifhks odhiugc (o) odlr`struhturc gcvcifpncdt, (oo)

Efx 8: Cxha`dbcs `dg ]rohc Odlfrn`tofd Gosscnod`tofd

Wac Ctaofpo`d Hfnnfgoty Cxha`dbc `haocvcg `d odlfrn`tofd cxpifsofd usodb cichtrfdoh tohkcrs, `wcesotc, ncss`bcs fd rcbostcrcg nfeoic pafdcs, `dg tfii-lrcc h`ii dunecrs lfr prfvogodb prohcodlfrn`tofd tf l`rncrs, tr`gcrs, `dg ftacr uscrs. Ot a`s fvcr 1= cichtrfdoh tohkcrs sprc`g `hrfssCtaofpo`, hfvcrodb `ii tac tr`gc hcdtcrs lfr prohc gosscnod`tofd. Ot rchcovcs fvcr 0 noiiofd h`iis pcrnfdta lfr prohc odlfrn`tofd.

Rota suha tr`dsp`rcdt `dg cllohocdt odlfrn`tofd systcn od pi`hc, tac tr`godb vfiuncs fd tac cxha`dbc

a`vc rcbostcrcg pacdfncd`i brfwta, lrfn 081,=== tfds od 5==1‘5==? tf 3=1,=== tfds od 5=0=‘5=00.

Wac G`io`d Hfnnfgoty Cxha`dbc gosscnod`tcs h`sa `s wcii `s luturcs n`rkct odlfrn`tofd lrcc flha`rbc tf prfguhcrs, voii`bc frb`doz`tofds, `dg cdtcrproscs ta`t `rc `htovc od hfnnfgoty suppiyha`ods od tac n`od prfguhodb rcbofds od tac ]cfpic‟s Ucpueioh fl Haod`. Wac cxha`dbc `isf rchcovcs`dg gostroeutcs n`rkct odlfrn`tofd fd sfyec`d `dg hfrd lrfn ` dunecr fl bfvcrdncdt `dg prov`tcodlfrn`tofd scrvohc `bcdhocs, odhiugodb tac D`tofd`i Br`od `dg Fois Odlfrn`tofd Hcdtrc `dg tac ]rohcNfdotfrodb Hcdtrc fl tac D`tofd`i Gcvcifpncdt `dg Uclfrn Hfnnossofd. @ r`dbc fl futicts `rcuscg: tcicvosofd, r`gof, dcwsp`pcrs, wcesotcs, `dg tac cxha`dbc‟s fwd pueioh`tofd, Odlfrn`tofdRcckiy.

Wac G`io`d Hfnnfgoty Cxha`dbc hfii`efr`tcs wota twf odlfrn`tofd p`rtdcrs, Haod` Xfyec`d Dct `dgHaod` Hfrd Dct, tf prfvogc tcicpafdc hfdsuit`tofds lrcc fl ha`rbc tf l`rncrs, 57 afurs ` g`y. @d`iysts `t tacsc twf frb`doz`tofds ncct cvcry nfrdodb tf `sscss tac n`rkct sotu`tofd `dg rc`ha

hfdscdsus fd onpfrt`dt odlfrn`tofd ta`t n`rkct p`rtohop`dts nobat rcquorc gurodb tac g`y. Od N`y5==2, fvcr 0==,=== lrcc tcicpafdc hfdsuit`tofds wcrc prfvogcg tf l`rncrs. Xafrt ncss`bc scrvohc(XNX) os `dftacr onpfrt`dt ha`ddci. Gurodb 5==<, 70=,=== XNX ncss`bcs wcrc scdt hfdt`ododbn`rkct odlfrn`tofd upg`tcs.

Gurodb tac sprodb pi`dtodb sc`sfd od 5==<, ifh`i l`rncrs od tac hoty fl A`oiud od Acoifdbjo`db ]rfvodhcwcrc l`hcg wota gchiododb sfyec`d prohcs, `dg wcrc udhcrt`od `efut waoha hrfp tf pi`dt. Ssodb taccxha`dbc‟s prohc odlfrn`tofd, tac l`rncrs h`nc tf udgcrst`dg ta`t pi`dtodb hfrd odstc`g fl sfyec`dwfuig odhrc`sc rcturds. 

Page 21: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 21/28

Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc: Fptofds lfr @ggrcssodb ]rohc Uosk `dg ]rohc \fi`toioty od Uohc | 08

gosscnod`tofd fl g`t` ta`t `llcht prohodb fl rohc, (ooo) h`p`hoty euoigodb fl n`rkct p`rtohop`dts, `dg(ov) suppfrtovc bfvcrdncdt pfiohocs.

Odlr`struhturc gcvcifpncdt.  Bfvcrdncdts od tac tfp rohc-cxpfrtodb `dg tfp rohc-prfguhodbhfudtrocs h`d prfvogc odhcdtovcs tf tac prov`tc schtfr (c.b., pueioh‘prov`tc p`rtdcrsaop shacncs)tf euoig w`rcafuscs `t str`tcboh pi`hcs wotaod tac hfudtry wota prfxonoty tf pfrts fr l`rni`dgs. Od

`ggotofd, tac bfvcrdncdt hfuig prfvogc tac dchcss`ry icb`i lr`ncwfrk lfr tac odtrfguhtofd `dgusc fl ` w`rcafusc rchcopt systcn. Wac stfr`bc fl bffgs od ` w`rcafusc e`hkcg ey `w`rcafusc rchcopt systcn woii brc`tiy ecdclot l`rncrs `dg cdg-uscrs. Od `ggotofd, tac cdtotocsscttodb up `dg n`d`bodb suha w`rcafuscs h`d lurtacr cxp`dg tacor `htovotocs ey prfvogodb`ss`yodb (o.c., qu`ioty hcrtoloh`tofd) scrvohcs lfr tac bffgs stfrcg od tac w`rcafuscs `dgtr`dspfrt `dg ifbostoh`i suppfrt lfr erodbodb bffgs lrfn tac l`rn tf tac w`rcafuscs fr tf tacpfrts lfr cxpfrt.

Gosscnod`tofd fl g`t` ta`t `llcht rohc prohodb. Bfvcrdncdts h`d pi`y ` rfic od tac hfii`tofd,pueioh`tofd, `dg gosscnod`tofd fl rohc prohcs `dg prfguhtofd odlfrn`tofd tf n`rkct p`rtohop`dts,waoha hfuig n`d`bc prohc rosk `dg notob`tc prohc vfi`toioty. @s sccd lrfn tac cxpcrocdhc od tac]cfpic‟s Ucpueioh Haod`, tac gosscnod`tofd fl prohcs `dg prfguhtofd g`t` od ifh`i `dg wfrig

n`rkcts cd`eicg l`rncrs tf rc`iozc n`xonun yocig lfr tacor hrfps. Xonoi`riy, suehfdtr`ht`rr`dbcncdts fr pueioh‘prov`tc p`rtdcrsaop v`ro`dts h`d ec cnpifycg lfr tac cdb`bcncdt flprov`tc fr rcsc`rha odstotutofds tf prfvogc n`rkct odlfrn`tofd.

Wac Sdotcg Xt`tcs Gcp`rtncdt fl @brohuiturc pi`ys ` vot`i rfic od tac hfiichtofd, pueioh`tofd, `dggostroeutofd fl g`t` lfr rohc `dg ftacr `brohuitur`i prfguhts. @ sonoi`r d`tofd`i `bcdhy od c`ha fltac rohc prfguhodb hfudtrocs fr ` hcdtr`i rcbofd`i `bcdhy, odhiugodb tac @LXUE, hfuig pi`y ` rficsonoi`r tf tac gcp`rtncdt. Xuha `d `bcdhy hfuig `isf sct up ` acipiodc tf prfvogc buog`dhc tfl`rncrs fd waoha hrfp tf pi`dt, br`gc fl rohc tf ec pi`dtcg tf fet`od aobacr yocigs, `dg `dy ftacrsuppfrt dccgcg ey l`rncrs lfr rohc prfguhtofd (c.b., dcw tchadoqucs, pcst rcsost`dt br`gcs, frlcrtoiozcrs tf ec uscg).

H`p`hoty euoigodb fl n`rkct p`rtohop`dts.  @s ncdtofdcg od Xchtofd <.5, h`p`hoty euoigodbtarfuba tac cguh`tofd fl n`rkct p`rtohop`dts os `d csscdto`i euoigodb eifhk lfr suhhcsslui rohctr`godb od hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcs. @b`od, tac bfvcrdncdt `dg ots `bcdhocs, prov`tc cdtotocs, frpueioh‘prov`tc p`rtdcrsaops hfuig ec cdb`bcg od taos prfhcss fl h`p`hoty euoigodb.

Xuppfrtovc bfvcrdncdt pfiohocs. Bfvcrdncdt pfiohocs suha `s lrcczodb cxpfrts tf st`eoiozcifh`i prohcs, prfvogodb odhcdtovcs tf cxpfrts (`t tac tonc fl surpius prfguhtofd), icvyodb aobat`xcs fd cxpfrts (`t tac tonc fl gclohot prfguhtofd), `dg br`dtodb odhcdtovcs fd onpfrts (`t tactonc fl gclohot prfguhtofd) h`usc prohc vfi`toioty `s wcii `s gollohuitocs lfr tr`gcrs od gclododb vo`eiceusodcss pi`ds lfr tac cxpfrt `dg onpfrt fl `brohuitur`i hfnnfgotocs. @isf, ot os dft udhfnnfdlfr bfvcrdncdts tf e`d luturcs `dg fptofds tr`godb fd hfnnfgotocs wacd prohcs st`rt rosodb.

 @ggotofd`iiy, prohc suppfrt `dg odtcrlcrcdhc od n`rkct gostroeutofd `t tac ifh`i icvci a`vc

g`npcdodb cllchts fd rohc tr`godb. Xuha bfvcrdncdt `htofds rcsuit od aobacr prohc vfi`toioty od`ggotofd tf tac vfi`toioty `rosodb fd `hhfudt fl gcn`dg‘suppiy `dg ftacr prfguhtofd rci`tcgl`htfrs.

 @ stugy fd tac safrt-tcrn `dg ifdb-tcrn cllchts fl suha ifh`iozcg `htofd hfuig ec hfdguhtcg ey`d @XC@D `bcdhy suha `s tac @LXUE `dg sa`rcg wota tac bfvcrdncdts od tac rcbofd, sf ta`todlfrncg `dg `pprfpro`tc pfiohy gchosofds `rc hfdsogcrcg.

Page 22: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 22/28

07 | @GE Xust`od`eic Gcvcifpncdt Rfrkodb ]`pcr Xcrocs Df. 53

1.5 ]rov`tc Xchtfr

Od gcvcifpodb hfudtrocs, tac p`rtohop`tofd fl prov`tc pi`ycrs od tac `brohuitur`i tr`gc v`iuc ha`odos ifw. _ct sonoi`r tf tac bfvcrdncdt `dg ots `bcdhocs, tac prov`tc schtfr h`d pi`y ` hruho`i rficod gcvcifpodb tac odlr`struhturc lfr rohc tr`godb. Lfr cx`npic, odvcstncdts lfr hrc`todb

odlr`struhturc, suha `s w`rcafuscs, `rc h`pot`i-odtcdsovc. @isf, rcstrohtovc `dg odhfdsostcdtbfvcrdncdt pfiohocs goshfur`bc tac prov`tc schtfr lrfn n`kodb tac aubc odvcstncdts rcquorcgod suha prfjchts. Bfvcrdncdts hfuig prfvogc if`ds tf prov`tc schtfr cdtototcs `t hfdhcssofd`ir`tcs; wota ifdbcr p`ye`hk pcrofgs, t`x afiog`ys, fr t`x hfdhcssofds; `dg scii i`dg lfr scttodb upw`rcafuscs `t ` hfdhcssofd`i r`tc.

]rov`tc p`rtohop`dts h`d pi`y tac lfiifwodb rfics od tac `brohuiturc prfguhts v`iuc ha`od:(o) ]rov`tc pi`ycrs h`d pi`y tac rfic fl `bbrcb`tfrs `dg acgbc tac prohc rosk fd `

hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc fd eca`il fl tac l`rncrs, waoic `t tac s`nc tonc prfvogodb` nodonun prohc bu`r`dtcc tf tacn (Efx 7).

(oo) ]rov`tc pi`ycrs h`d ec cdhfur`bcg tf sct up w`rcafusc odlr`struhturc, waoha os `n`jfr safrthfnodb od @so`d hfudtrocs. Wacy hfuig `isf prfvogc v`iuc-`ggcg

scrvohcs suha `s `ss`yodb.(ooo) Xodhc tac prfguhc os stfrcg od tac w`rcafusc rud ey tacn, prov`tc pi`ycrs h`d

`isf prfvogc hrcgot fr lod`dhc fptofds tf l`rncrs cotacr fd tacor fwd (`dg c`rd `gchcdt rosk-lrcc rcturd) fr od hfdjudhtofd wota e`dks `dg lod`dhc odstotutofds.

(ov) Wacy h`d sct up tr`dspfrt `dg ifbostohs eusodcsscs tf nfvc tac rohc lrfn tacl`rn tf tac w`rcafusc, pfrts, fr ftacr ifh`tofds.

(v) ]rov`tc pi`ycrs h`d pi`y ` n`jfr rfic od tac h`p`hoty euoigodb fl n`rkctp`rtohop`dts. Wacy h`d cguh`tc tac l`rncrs fd wa`t odstruncdts tf usc `dg udgcrwaoha horhunst`dhcs. Wacsc odstruncdts odhiugc odsur`dhc prfguhts, lod`dhodbprfguhts, gcrov`tovcs prfguhts, `dg fvcr-tac-hfudtcr odstruncdts.

(vo) ]rov`tc pi`ycrs h`d `isf ec odvfivcg od prfguhodb rcsc`rha rcpfrts fd hrfps odtcrns fl prohc trcdgs `dg gcn`dg `dg suppiy gurodb tac a`rvcst `dg pfsta`rvcst

pcrofgs. Waos odlfrn`tofd hfuig tacd ec gosscnod`tcg tf l`rncrs gorchtiy frtarfuba bfvcrdncdt `bcdhocs `t ` prohc.

Efx 7: Ufic fl @bbrcb`tfrs

Od @so`, tac `rc` fl tac l`rni`dgs huitov`tcg ey nfst l`rncrs os vcry sn`ii. @isf, sn`ii l`rncrs gf dfta`vc tac cxpcrtosc tf tr`gc fr acgbc tacor rohc prfguhc fd ifh`i, rcbofd`i, fr bife`i cxha`dbcs. Cvcdol tacy wcrc tf tr`gc fd tac cst`eiosacg cxha`dbcs, tac hfdtr`ht sozcs od tacsc cxha`dbcs `rc tffi`rbc lfr tacsc l`rncrs tf acgbc tacor prfguhc. Lurtacr, luturcs tr`godb dchcssot`tc p`yncdt fln`rk-tf-n`rkct n`rbods (o.c., ifsscs) fd ` g`oiy e`sos, waoha wfuig `isf ec hunecrsfnc lfr sn`iil`rncrs.

Acdhc, tacrc os ` dccg lfr `bbrcb`tfrs waf woii hfdsfiog`tc tac prfguhc fd eca`il fl sn`ii l`rncrs

`dg acgbc fd hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcs. Warfuba acgbodb, l`rncrs h`d fet`od ` nodonun prohc lfrtacor prfguhc, `dg od h`sc fl `d upsogc, tac prflots h`d ec gostroeutcg `nfdb tac l`rncrs.

Wac systcn fl `bbrcb`tfrs fr cicv`tfrs os prcv`icdt od Er`zoi, tac Sdotcg Xt`tcs, `dg n`dy ftacrhfudtrocs. ]rov`tc cdtotocs, l`rncrs, `brohuiturc hffpcr`tovcs, fr ` bfvcrdncdt `bcdhy hfuig pi`y tacrfic fl `bbrcb`tfrs.

Page 23: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 23/28

Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc: Fptofds lfr @ggrcssodb ]rohc Uosk `dg ]rohc \fi`toioty od Uohc | 03

1.8 @XC@D

 @XC@D h`d pi`y ` erf`gcr rfic od pfiohy lfrn`tofd `dg str`tcboh buog`dhc tf tac bfvcrdncdts odtac rcbofd. Wac pfiohy `dg str`tcboh odputs hfuig ec rci`tcg tf pfiohy nc`surcs ta`t `rchfdguhovc tf odlr`struhturc odvcstncdts, suha `s scttodb up hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcs `dg

w`rcafusc odlr`struhturc wotaod ` hfudtry, `dg cst`eiosaodb rcbofd`i `dg gfncstoh hfnnfgotocscxha`dbc pi`tlfrns lfr hfudtry-spcholoh rohc rcquorcncdts (onpfrts fr cxpfrts). @XC@D h`d `isfpi`y ` n`jfr rfic od tac hfii`tofd, pueioh`tofd, `dg gostroeutofd fl rohc g`t` tf bfvcrdncdts `dggorchtiy tf l`rncrs.

Od `ggotofd, @XC@D h`d prfvogc buog`dhc `dg rcsfurhcs tf hfudtrocs i`hkodb tac tchadoh`ikdfw-afw lfr scttodb up tac dchcss`ry odlr`struhturc `dg tac icb`i lr`ncwfrk (lfr ha`dbcs odi`ws) tf onpicncdt suha pfiohocs. @d onpfrt`dt `rc` lfr hfdsogcr`tofd ey @XC@D ncnecrhfudtrocs os `d cd`eiodb i`w ta`t wfuig suppfrt tac tr`dslcr fl fwdcrsaop fl rohc tarfubaw`rcafusc rchcopts.

Sdgcr tac @XC@D e`ddcr, ` hfnnfd gfncstoh hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc hfuig ec cst`eiosacg lfr

tr`godb rohc lrfn H`nefgo`, Wa`oi`dg, `dg \oct D`n. Afwcvcr, bfvcrdncdt pfiohocs od tcrns flonpfrt `dg cxpfrt fl rohc `hrfss efrgcrs, `dg tac hurrcdhy od waoha tac rohc hfdtr`ht n`y ectr`gcg, wfuig dccg tf ec cx`nodcg.

 @XC@D fr `d `bcdhy od @XC@D n`y `isf try fut ` lfrw`rg hfdtr`ht `rr`dbcncdt ta`t h`dcdhfur`bc rohc-onpfrtodb hfudtrocs tf rcguhc scil-sullohocdhy od rcturd lfr ` hfnnotncdt lrfnrohc-cxpfrtodb hfudtrocs ta`t tacy woii dft udoi`tcr`iiy e`d tac cxpfrt fl rohc. Wac hfudtrocs,onpfrtcr `dg cxpfrtcr, hfuig cdtcr odtf ` lfrw`rg hfdtr`ht hic`riy spcholyodb tac qu`ioty `dgqu`dtoty fl rohc, g`tc fl gciovcry, `dg tac prohc `t waoha tac rohc woii ec cxpfrtcg. Waos lfrw`rghfdtr`ht wfuig ec eodgodb fd efta hfudtrocs.

Xuha lfrw`rg hfdtr`hts hfuig ec `gnodostcrcg fr fvcrsccd ey odtcrd`tofd`i hfnncrho`i e`dks

ta`t hfuig scrvc `s tac hcdtr`i hfudtcrp`rty. Od h`sc fdc fl tac hfudtrocs l`ois tf afdfr otsfeiob`tofd, taos p`rty hfuig stcp od tf cdsurc ta`t tac hfudtry waoha gog dft ncct ots hfnnotncdts`s pcr tac lfrw`rg hfdtr`ht, n`kcs bffg tac ifss (gollcrcdhc ectwccd prohc fl rohc od tacodtcrd`tofd`i n`rkct icss tac prohc `brccg od tac lfrw`rg hfdtr`ht) tf tac dfdgcl`uitodb hfudtry.

Ol tac hfudtry ta`t onpfscs e`ds os rcquorcg tf n`kc bffg tac ifss lfr dft luiloiiodb otshfnnotncdts, bfvcrdncdts woii gcsost lrfn t`kodb suha udoi`tcr`i gchosofds `s onpfsodb e`ds frrcstrohtofds. @t tac nodonun, cxpfrts fr onpfrts udgcr suha lfrw`rg hfdtr`hts woii dft hfncudgcr tac purvocw fl tac cxpfrt fr onpfrt e`d.

?. Uchfnncdg`tofds `dg @htofd ]fodtsLorst, rohc luturcs tr`godb wotaod tac @XC@D rcbofd os `irc`gy pfssoeic tarfuba `d cxostodbrcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc. Wf l`hoiot`tc ots gcvcifpncdt, tac lfiifwodb nc`surcs wfuigdccg tf ec udgcrt`kcd:

(o) @d cxostodb odtcrd`tofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc od tac @XC@D rcbofd safuig ecogcdtolocg `s tac rcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc lfr tr`godb rohc prohc odgcxluturcs `dg fptofds. @ lc`soeoioty stugy wfuig ec dccgcg tf `shcrt`od tac stcps odots gcvcifpncdt. @XC@D h`d acip ey l`hoiot`todb tac hfiichtofd `dg gosscnod`tofd

Page 24: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 24/28

0< | @GE Xust`od`eic Gcvcifpncdt Rfrkodb ]`pcr Xcrocs Df. 53

fl odlfrn`tofd csscdto`i tf tac lc`soeoioty stugy, `dg scttodb up hfdsuit`tofds wotav`rofus st`kcafigcrs fd tacor dccgs ta`t hfuig ec nct ey rohc luturcs.

(oo) @ rcbofd`i rohc odgcx, waoha os rcprcscdt`tovc fl tac nfst cxpfrtcg `dghfdsuncg br`gcs fl rohc, safuig ec gcvcifpcg. Luturcs `dg fptofds e`scg fdtac odgcx hfuig tacd ec tr`gcg fd tac rcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc.

(ooo) @ lurtacr stugy safuig ec hfdguhtcg tf `shcrt`od prohc hfrrci`tofds `nfdb

v`rofus br`gcs fl rohc tr`gcg od tac rcbofd.(ov) D`tofd`i `bcdhocs `dg p`r`st`t`is safuig ec cdhfur`bcg tf tr`gc fd taos

odtcrd`tofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc. Wac p`r`st`t`is safuig `ht `s `bbrcb`tfrslfr tacor ifh`i rohc prfguhtofd `dg acgbc tac rohc prohc rosk fd taos cxha`dbc usodbtac rcbofd`i rohc odgcx, eut taos dccgs tf ec tonc-efudg wota hic`r buogciodcs `dgbrfudg ruics.

Xchfdg, hfudtrocs ta`t `rc n`jfr cxpfrtcrs fl pfpui`r br`gcs fl rohc safuig cst`eiosa ` gfncstohhfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc `dg tr`gc tacor ifh`i rohc br`gcs. Xcvcr`i nc`surcs hfuig ec t`kcd odtaos rcb`rg:

(o) Bfvcrdncdts hfuig prfvogc tac odhcdtovcs tf prov`tc pi`ycrs tf sct up w`rcafuscodlr`struhturc suha `s tarfuba pueioh‘prov`tc p`rtdcrsaops. ]rov`tc cdtotocs `dg

l`rncr hffpcr`tovcs safuig ec cdhfur`bcg tf `ht `s `bbrcb`tfrs `dg tf cguh`tctac l`rncrs fd tac odstruncdts lfr acgbodb tacor prohc rosk `dg lfr fet`ododb hrcgotl`hoiotocs lfr tacor prfguhc.

(oo) @ rcbui`tfry lr`ncwfrk lfr tac cst`eiosancdt fl ` w`rcafusc rchcopt systcnsafuig ec poiftcg od tac n`jfr rohc-prfguhodb hfudtrocs. Waos woii acip l`rncrsgchogc fd tac tonc tf scii tacor prfguhc `dg `isf l`hoiot`tc lod`dhodb ey e`dks `dgftacr odstotutofds.

(ooo) Wac BNX a`s tac pftcdto`i lfr cda`dhcg rohc cxpfrt tarfuba tac gcvcifpncdt fl`d odtcrhfudtry rohc v`iuc ha`od dctwfrk. Wac BNX os hurrcdtiy onprfvodb otstr`gc l`hoiot`tofd scrvohcs `dg odlr`struhturc od taos dctwfrk, eut odvcstncdts fdifbostohs odlr`struhturc `t tac sa`rcg chfdfnoh `dg tr`gc hfrrogfrs safuig ec`ubncdtcg. Wa`oi`dg `dg \oct D`n, lfr cx`npic, tfbctacr wota tacor rcspchtovc

noiiodb `dg tr`dspfrt schtfrs, hfuig onprfvc tacor gfncstoh hfnnfgotocscxha`dbcs wota tac cst`eiosancdt fl w`rcafusc l`hoiotocs (e`hkcg ey w`rcafuscrchcopts systcns) od str`tcboh ifh`tofds `ifdb tac hfrrogfrs. H`nefgo`, tac I`f]cfpic‟s Gcnfhr`toh Ucpueioh, `dg Ny`dn`r hfuig odoto`tc cxha`dbc pi`tlfrnsta`t fllcr spft tr`godb od rohc. Odlfrn`tofd hfnnudoh`tofd tchadfifby-e`scgn`rkct odlfrn`tofd `dg h`p`hoty euoigodb lfr l`rncrs od usodb tac cxha`dbcpi`tlfrns hfuig `isf ec odtcbr`i `spchts lfr gcvcifpodb tac suercbofd‟s rohc v`iucha`od dctwfrk.

Waorg, @XC@D h`d pi`y ` n`jfr h`t`iytoh rfic od gcvcifpodb tac hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc `s `vo`eic fptofd lfr `ggrcssodb prohc rosk `dg prohc vfi`toioty od rohc od tac lfiifwodb w`ys:

(o) @s ` lorst stcp, ot wfuig ec usclui tf wfrk tfw`rg rcnfvodb tac udhcrt`odtocs `dg

`gvcrsc onp`ht fl udoi`tcr`i tr`gc pfiohy rcstrohtofds. Od taos rcb`rg, @XC@Dsafuig ec cdhfur`bcg tf spc`rac`g t`iks wota Odgo`, ]`kost`d, `dg ftacr n`jfr

 @so`drohc-cxpfrtodb hfudtrocs tf goshuss hffrgod`tcg `dg hfacrcdt pfiohocs `s wcii `stac gos`gv`dt`bcs fl odtrfguhodb udoi`tcr`i cxpfrt e`ds `dg ftacr onpfrt-rcstrohtodb nc`surcs. @ pfssoeic w`y lfrw`rg os tac cst`eiosancdt fl ` rohcn`rkct odlr`struhturc gcvcifpncdt pi`d, waoha odhiugcs rcbofd`i `dg gfncstohhfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcs, w`rcafusc systcns, `dg odlfrn`tofd systcns.

Page 25: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 25/28

Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc: Fptofds lfr @ggrcssodb ]rohc Uosk `dg ]rohc \fi`toioty od Uohc | 02

(oo) @XC@D n`y `isf t`kc tac dchcss`ry stcps tfw`rg rohc st`dg`rgoz`tofd `dg tacgcvcifpncdt fl ` rcbofd`i rohc odgcx.

(ooo) Wac gosscnod`tofd fl rohc prohcs `dg prfguhtofd g`t` fl ifh`i `dg bife`i n`rkctstf l`rncrs `dg ftacr n`rkct p`rtohop`dts safuig ec gfdc tarfuba tac @XC@DLffg Xchuroty Odlfrn`tofd Xystcn, od hffrgod`tofd wota spcho`iozcg rcbofd`i rohcg`t` hcdtcrs suha `s L@F `dg tac Odtcrd`tofd`i Uohc Ucsc`rha Odstotutc.

(ov) @XC@D safuig prfvogc ` systcn`toh ncha`dosn lfr tac rcbofd`i hfdsuit`tofd flv`rofus st`kcafigcrs od tac rohc v`iuc ha`od. Ucbui`rozodb tac @XC@D Uohc Wr`gcLfrun `s ` pi`tlfrn lfr vcttodb ossucs `dg ogc`s os ` pfsotovc stcp tfw`rggcvcifpodb tac rcbofd`i rohc v`iuc ha`od dctwfrk.

(v) Od tac ncgoun tcrn, tac rcbofd safuig gcvcifp `d @XC@D odvcstncdt pi`d tflfstcr tac brfwta fl ` rcbofd`i rohc v`iuc ha`od hfrrogfr. Wac odvcstncdt pi`d n`yodhiugc sh`iodb up odlr`struhturc ta`t os csscdto`i lfr tac gcvcifpncdt fl `rcbofd`i hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbc, tac cst`eiosancdt fl ` suercbofd`i hfnnfgotocscxha`dbc od tac BNX, n`rkct odlfrn`tofd `dg odtciiobcdhc suppfrt, `s wcii `sodstotutofd`i suppfrt lfr tac h`p`hoty euoigodb fl l`rncrs. Wac pi`d hfuig `isfodhiugc odvcstncdts lfr cda`dhodb rohc prfguhtofd `dg prfguhtovoty od tac rcbofd.Wac odvcstncdt pi`d h`d ec ` hfdhrctc rf`g n`p tfw`rg euttrcssodb tac

onpicncdt`tofd fl tac Xtr`tcboh ]i`d fl @htofd fd Lffg Xchuroty od tac @XC@DUcbofd.

Page 26: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 26/28

 

Uclcrcdhcs

 @dgcrsfd, K., X. Ja`, `dg @. Xtrutt. 5=05. Uc-cx`nododb ]fiohocs lfr Lffg Xchuroty od @so`. @GEChfdfnohs Rfrkodb ]`pcr Xcrocs. Df. 8=0. N`doi`: @so`d Gcvcifpncdt E`dk.

Hi`rctc, U. 5=05. @vfogodb Cxtrcnc Uohc ]rohc \fi`toioty `dg Onprfvodb Ucbofd`i Uohc Wr`gc.]rcscdt`tofd `t tac Wchadoh`i Rfrksafp fd Uohc ]rohc \fi`toioty `dg Wr`gc. E`dbkfk. 5<∕52

J`du`ry.

G`d`, J., G. Ufare`ha, `dg J. Xyrfk . 5==2. Uosk N`d`bcncdt Wffis lfr N`i`wo Lffg Xchuroty.attp://sotcrcsfurhcs.wfrige`dk.frb/ODWHFNUOXN@D/Ucsfurhcs/n`i`wo.pgl

B`erc-N`gaod, C. 5=05.  @ N`rkct lfr @egu: Hrc`todb ` Hfnnfgoty Cxha`dbc od Ctaofpo`. R`saodbtfd, GH: Odtcrd`tofd`i Lffg ]fiohy Ucsc`rha Odstotutc.

A`noitfd, N. 5=05. @ ]fsotofd ]`pcr fd Rfrig Uohc Luturcs. Xuenottcg tf tac @so`d UohcLuturcs N`rkct‘Cxpcrt Rfrkodb Brfup Ncctodb, X. U`j`r`td`n Xhaffi fl Odtcrd`tofd`i

Xtugocs  Hcdtrc lfr Dfd-Wr`gotofd`i Xchuroty Xtugocs,  D`dy`db Wchadfifboh`i Sdovcrsoty.Xodb`pfrc. 55∕58 N`rha. 

Odtcrd`tofd`i Uohc Ucsc`rha Odstotutc (OUUO). Rfrig Uohc Xt`tostohs.attp://orro.frb/odgcx.pap6fptofd> hfnVk5&vocw>otcn&og>00=0<&Otcnog>0==550&i`db>cd

NhKcdzoc, @. 5=05. ]rclc`soeoioty Xtugy fl `d @XC@D Uohc Luturcs N`rkct.  @GE Xust`od`eicGcvcifpncdt Rfrkodb ]`pcr Xcrocs. Df. 0?. N`doi`: @so`d Gcvcifpncdt E`dk.

Wonncr, H. ]. 5=0=. Uclichtofds fd Lffg Hroscs ]`st. Lffg ]fiohy. 83 (0): 0‘00.

Sdotcg D`tofds Hfdlcrcdhc fd Wr`gc `dg Gcvcifpncdt. 5==2. Ucpfrt fl tac SDHW@G XtugyBrfup fd Cncrbodb Hfnnfgoty Cxha`dbcs: Gcvcifpncdt Onp`hts fl Hfnnfgoty LuturcsCxha`dbcs od Cncrbodb N`rkcts. attp://`rhaovc.udht`g.frb/schtofds/whnu/gfhs/h0cn88p=7Vcd.]GL6ehsoVsh`dV?<11e<82`7<3<1ge>=&ehsoVsh`dVloicd`nc>h0cn88p=7Vcd.]GL

Rfrig E`dk. 5==3. N`d`bodb Lffg ]rohc Uosks `dg Odst`eoioty od `d Cdvorfdncdt fl N`rkctIoecr`ioz`tofd. R`saodbtfd, GH.

Page 27: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 27/28

 

Page 28: Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

7/23/2019 Commodities Exchange: Options for Addressing Price Risk and Price Volatility in Rice

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/commodities-exchange-options-for-addressing-price-risk-and-price-volatility 28/28

Hfnnfgotocs Cxha`dbc: Fptofds lfr @ggrcssodb

]rohc Uosk dg ]rohc \fi`toioty od Uohc

Od taos p`pcr, Lr`nrfzc ]fha`r`, ` h`pot`i n`rkcts vctcr`d wota fvcr 53 yc`rs fl cxpcrocdhc od tacodgustry, t`kcs fll lrfn tac gollcrodb vocws fl twf prfnodcdt `utafrotocs `efut rohc luturcs od tac@ssfho`tofd fl Xfutac`st D`tofds (@XC@D) `dg t`hkics v`rofus fptofds `t tac hfudtry `dg rcbofd`i

icvcis tf lfstcr prohc goshfvcry `dg prohc rosk n`d`bcncdt. Ac prcscdts cx`npics fl hfudtrocssuhhcssluiiy usodb hfnnfgotocs cxha`dbcs `dg gollcrcdt acgbodb odstruncdts `dg pfsots ta`ttacrc os df rc`sfd way tacsc vcry s`nc odstruncdts h`ddft ec uscg od tac @XC@D rcbofd tfn`d`bc tac rosks fl rohc prohc vfi`toioty `dg acip `ggrcss lffg schuroty. Wac ncss`bc os ta`t tacrc`rc tffis ta`t h`d wfrk eut tacsc dccg tf ec t`oifrcg tf ifh`i hfdgotofds. Xt`kcafigcrs, odhiugodbtac pueioh `dg prov`tc schtfrs `dg @XC@D, dccg tf i`y gfwd tac csscdto`i odlr`struhturc ta`t h`dacip erodb od prohc st`eoioty `dg ecttcr prohc rc`ioz`tofd tf l`rncrs.

@efut tac @so`d Gcvcifpncdt E`dk 

@GE‟s vosofd os `d @so` `dg ]`holoh rcbofd lrcc fl pfvcrty. Ots nossofd os tf acip ots gcvcifpodb

ncnecr hfudtrocs rcguhc pfvcrty `dg onprfvc tac qu`ioty fl iolc fl tacor pcfpic. Gcspotc tacrcbofd‟s n`dy suhhcsscs, ot rcn`ods afnc tf twf-taorgs fl tac wfrig‟s pffr: 0.1 eoiiofd pcfpic wafiovc fd icss ta`d $5 ` g`y, wota ?=8 noiiofd strubbiodb fd icss ta`d $0.53 ` g`y. @GE os hfnnottcgtf rcguhodb pfvcrty tarfuba odhiusovc chfdfnoh brfwta, cdvorfdncdt`iiy sust`od`eic brfwta,`dg rcbofd`i odtcbr`tofd.

E`scg od N`doi`, @GE os fwdcg ey <2 ncnecrs, odhiugodb 71 lrfn tac rcbofd. Ots n`ododstruncdts lfr acipodb ots gcvcifpodb ncnecr hfudtrocs `rc pfiohy go`ifbuc, if`ds, cquotyodvcstncdts, bu`r`dtccs, br`dts, dg tchadoh`i ssost`dhc.

@so`d Gcvcifpncdt E`dk < @GE @vcduc, N`dg`iuyfdb Hoty033= Nctrf N`doi`, ]aoioppodcswww.`ge.frb/pfvcrty]ueioh`tofd Xtfhk Df. R]X057?3?-8