casanova love in the time of

8/18/2019 Casanova Love in the Time Of

1/23

!"#$%&' )&**'+$

!"#$ &$ '()*+ &$ ,-$&./

0/121+ 3$&45#6&78 "9 !#&7&6/ :";-?/56&6@ !"#$%& ()") *"))+,- . /$0+,1 2+)3$#4 $5 36& 7+8+9& :&3;&&<

!,)3 ,./56 >7 7/5 A>7&"$>; 3$&45#6&78 &$ 2"$576B+ 3B#>&$5

C1 D"E>#F G5=675# H"-$F>7&"$ H5;;"E6/&I+ J#55$ :";;5K5 3!:+ LM'MNLM''1

H"-# O5># H5;;"E6/&I 9"# 0/121 P7-F5$76+ ?/5 3$&45#6&78 "9 !#&7&6/ :";-+LMM(NLM'L1QII&./ H>F->75 RE>#F+ ?/5 3$&45#6&78 "9 !#&7&6/ :";-+

LMM)NLMM(1

A-#;8 >#7&.;56 I-=;&6/5F &$ J5#$8+ 7/5 A57/5#;>$F6+ 3S


2/23

!"!

#$%&'(' &%*%+',%-

.',/ $+ 01/ 0$(/ '2 $+3$,$34%.$05

!"#$%&'(#)%"

R.>F5#./ "$ 7/5 ;&95 >$F E"#B6 "9 J&>."T'ULVN'U()W $FY"# #5/>=&;&7>7&"$"9 7/5 "=X5.7 "9 &$4567&K>7&"$1 ,"67 #5.5$7;8 D5;< 5ZI"-$F5F7/>7 [F"E$ 7" 7/5 I#565$7 F>8 7/5 E"#;F &6 I>66&$K "$ >$ &$."##5.7 &K5"9 :>6>$"4>\ T'V]W+ >$F 7/>7 7/5 65;9NI#".;>&;&5# F5 P5&$K>;7E>6 9># 75F $ "9 ;5775#6E/"65 &$75#5676 E5#5 [6>$"4> 6./";>#6/&I 545# 6&$.5 J-67>4 J-K&7^_ >775.&78 "9 7/5 :/54>;&5#_6 $ ̀ E5&K T'))'N'(]LW+ 9"#"$5+ &F5$7&9&5F 7/5 2+)3$#4 $5 >4 ?+5& >6 Q-#"I5_6 [$F > B58 &$.5$7&45 9"# 7/5 ."$7&$-&$K I-=;&6/&$K 599"#761'

?/565 599"#76 >#5 >F=;5+ >$F 7/5 #56-;76 >#5 ="7/ 9>6.&$>7&$K >$F&$6&K/79-;1 R7 7/5 6>K>&$67 7/5 [&$."##5.7 &K5\ "9 7/5

:/54>;&5# #>&656 >$ &$7#&K-&$K a-567&"$@ b9 :>6>$"4>_6 $ &$."##&K&=;5 I/&;>$F5#5#+ >6 I-;I9&.7&"$d ?/5 >$6E5# 655-65 7/5 2+)3$#4 $5 >4 ?+5& F"56 &$ 9>.7 F57>&; > E&F5 4>#&578 "9 5#"7&. 5ZI;"&761 O57 7" ;5>45 &7 >77/>7 E"-;F $ .-77&$K 6/"#7 > 6&K$&9&.>$7;8 6>$"4> />6 =55$7/5 9".-6 "9 B5$ "$ > 4>#&578 "9 $&$K6

&$ $ /&67"#8+ 6" />6 7/5 &F5> "9 7/5 c;"45#_ e >$F &7 >II5>#6


3/23

!""

+6/6&6 5789:;;< "=!!>"=!"

7/>7 c:>6>$"4>_ E>6 >=;5 7" B5 $&$K9-; 7/565 ./>$K&$K &F5>61 f##>7/5#@ ?/5 7/56 >=;5 7" >F>I7 7" 7/565 6/&97&$K I>#>F&K$F 7/-6&$7>&$ &76 I#".5 &$ Q-#"I5>$ .-;7-#>; _ 7/56 K#5>7 I"75$7&>; 7" 65#45 >6 > /5-#&67&.7""; 9"# 7/5 9&5;F "9 .-;7-#>; /&67"#8@ !8 >$>;8^&$K 7/5 7/5$K&$K >77&7-F56 7"E>#F6 ;"45&$ $ /&67"#81

?/5 9";;"E&$K >$>;86&6 E&;; 7/"#"-K/;8 &$4567&K>75 7/5 /&67"#&.>; ./>$K56&$ 7/5 :>6>$"4> 7/5$F ."$6&F5# 7/5 #56I5.7&45 6&K$&9&.>$.5 9#"< >6".&"N/&67"#&.>; I"&$7 "9 4&5E1 !-7 545$ =59"#5 5$K>K&$K &$ 7/&6 F&6.-66&"$+"$5 8 ."$X5.7-#5 &$ E/&./ E>8 7/5 F>I75F >975# 7/5I-=;&.>7&"$ "9 7/5 2+)3$#4 $5 >4 ?+5& &$ 7/5 5>#;8 $&$5755$7/ .5$7-#8 T>9C+ >=#&FK5F 5F&7&"$ >II5>#5F &$ J5#$ ')LLN')L)W1 ?/5 9>.7 "9 7/5775# &6 7/>7 7/5 /&67"#&.>; :>6>$"4> &6 >$ 5;-6&45 9&K-#5 E/5$ &7 ."; .>75K"#&^>7&"$61 b7 &6 &; E"#;F+ >6 /&6 >.7&"$6 e $"7 ;5>67 /&6 -$F"I7&"$ "9 >$"=;5 7&7;5 e 6-=45#7 7/5 67>7-6 "9 7/&6 .>6751 O57 "$5 E"-;F =5 5a->;;8 />#FI#5665F 7" ."N"I7 7/5 :/54>;&5# F5 P5&$K>;7 9"# 7/5 566@?/5 K>F45$7-#5# >$F I#"$F6 7"" 7"FF6 E&7/ ="-#K5"&6 &F5>;6 "9 &$F-67#8+ 675>F9>67$566 >$F #&7>; 9&F5;&781

?/5 ;>775# K#"-I $545#7/5;566 E5$7 "$ 7" .>$"$&^5 7/5 b7>;&>$ >F45$7-#5#1f$5 8 >66-7 7/&6 7" > .5#7>&$ 5Z75$7 I#56-II"65F c7>#>.75#1 ?5;;&$K;8+ :>6>$"4> 6/>#5F 7/&6 9>75 E&7/ 7/5 "7/5# K#5>75#"7"$&>. "9 Q-#"I5_6 ;&75#>#8 7#>F&7&"$@ 2"$ g->$1

*" *,,$%-)./#)%"0 1/2/"%3/ /"& 4%" 5'/"

?/5 I>67 7E" .5$7-#&56 />45 E&7$5665F $-$ >$F :>6>$"4>1 D5#$$ D56665_6 @,),$F 5I&6"F5 9#"< 7/5 2+)3$#4 $5 >4 ?+5& Ti";1 ib+ :/1 * >$F ]W>$F "I5$6 E&7/ 7/5 :/54>;&5#_6 >F4>$.56 "$ > 8"-$K ./>7 >`-#&./ &$$1 P/5 6/"E6 /5#65;9 E>#8 "9 7/5 67#>$K5#_6 >F4>$.56+ 7" E/&./:>6>$"4> #5I;&56@ [!-7 ./&;Fj 2" b ;""B ;&B5 > 2"$ g->$d R7 K5+ b ."-;F=5 8"-# 9>7/5#\ T]()W1 ?/5 "$8 &$ 7/&6 6.5$5 &6 54&F5$7+ >$F 7/5 #5>F5#.>$$"7 =-7 >6B &9 :>6>$"4>_6 ;&78 "9 :>6>$"4> >$F 2"$ g->$ &6 &$

9>.7 $"7 &$/5#5$7 7" 7/5 #56I5.7&45 7&"$ "9 7/5 7E"


4/23

!"?

2.'@$%+ #%**+/@

&6 "E5F 7" 7/5 #5.5I7&"$ I#".566 ;5>F&$K 7" 7/5 #56I5.7&45 .>$"$&^>7&"$1Q45$ &9 "$5 F&6#5K>#F6 7/5 9>.7 7/>7 :>6>$"4> &6 >$ /&67"#&.>; ./>#>.75#E/5#5>6 2"$ g->$ 6I#>$K 9#"< 7/5 ;&75#>#8 &K&$>7&"$ "9 7/5 P&K;" F5

f#"@ :"$6&F5#5F &$ 7/5 "#&K&$>; $&9567>7&"$6+ ="7/ >#5 E"#;F6 >I>#713$7&; 7/5 ;>75 5&K/755$7/ .5$7-#8+ 4&^1 -$7&; 7/5 5$F "9 J&>."_6 ;&957&6 > #5 ,";&$>_6 !1 A"#1,9$# 9& /&8+11, T.>1 'hLMW+ ,";&k#5_6 7$> D",./ "9 7/565 75Z76+ 7/5 /5#" 6-##5I7&7&"-6;8 "=7>&$6 >..566 7" > 8"-$K;>F8_6 =5F#""< >$F 6-=65a-5$7;8 B&;;6 /5# K->#F&>$ &$ > F-5;1 b$ ,";&k#5_6I;>8+ 2"$ g->$_6 65#4>$7 PK>$>#5;;5 F5.;>#56 /&6 675# 7" =5 [7/5 K#5>75676."-$F#5; E/" 545# E>;B5F 7/5 5>#7/+ > F F"K+ > F5#6 7" >;; #5I#">./56 >$F 7#5>7&$K >;; "-# $"=;567.#5F5$.56 >6 $"$65$65\ T(N'MW1 2"$ g->$_6 &$F&995#5$.5 7" 6".&>; $"##7&.-;>#;8 67#"$K E/5$ &7 I#5.&I&7>756 >$ >85F 2"o> Q;4>+ [7/>7/5 />6 ##&5F 8"-# B5 "9 /&6 I>66&"$+ /5_F />45 ##&5F 8"- 7""\

T'MW1 R$8 6&K$ "9 >995.7&"$ ."$ &6 =-7 > $6 7" =5$F"7/5#6 7" /&6 E&;;1?/5 /&67"#&.>; J&>." &$ 7/&6 #5K>#F B56 9"# > 67>#B

."$7#>671 b$ ;"45+ /5 I#"$5I"./ 7/>7 ."$6&F5#5F ;"45 >$F ##&>K5 F&6.#575 ."$.5I76 T.91 J>#$"7W1R.."#F&$K;8+ 7/5 2+)3$#4 $5 >4 ?+5& F&67&$K-&6/56 7/5 6"=5# ."$&"$6/&I"9 6I"-656 9#"< 7/5 5Z.566 "9 ;"45#61 [G/>7 &9 8"- F" $"7 ;"45 /&6>$"4> >6B6 "9 ,&66 C"$+ E/" &6 ."$4&$.5F 7/>7+ [7" =5 />II8\+ 6/5

#5a-8 =-7 [> B&$F /-6=>$F E5;; 5$"-K/ "99 9"# $87/&$K b $55F\1 [b9 /5 &6 /"$"-#>=;5 >$F B&$F\+ 7/5 C"$ 5ZI;>&$6+[/"E ."-;F b /5;I ;"4&$K /&7 8"- F" $"7 B$"E ;"45\+:>6>$"4> #57"#76 >6 /5 >=>$F"$6 /"I5 7" K>&$ 7/5 ;>F8_6 9>4"# TU@ ]'N]LW1P8+ 7/5 :/54>;&5# #5I#">./56 i5#"$&.> 9"# 7-#$&$K /&< F"E$ "$7/5 K#"-$F6 7/>7 [$5&7/5# "9 -6 .>$ =5 6-#5 "9 >$87/&$K >="-7 7/5 "7/5#1\?/&6 B&$F "9 I57&7N="-#K5"&6 7/&$B&$K #5>99&5#_6 F5.&6&"$ 7"[$545# ##8 -$7&; b 6/>;; />45 =5."


5/23

!"A

+6/6&6 5789:;;< "=!!>"=!"

b$ 7/5 ."$75Z7 "9 7/5 5&K/755$7/ .5$7-#8+ ;"45+ 7" #5>./ &76 9-;; I"75$7&>;+./5F 9#"< 545#8F>8 ."$6&F5#>7&"$61

q"45#6+ -$;&B5 6I"-656+ #F 7/5 $5 I#"=;5$F75#&>; 5Z/>-67&"$1 :>6>$"4>+ >6 `E5&K $&.5;8 "=65#456+ [K&456 /&.#&9&.5 545#87/&$K 5;65 7"> E"$\ e $"7 =5.>-65 /5 &6 "=;&K5F+ =-7 [=5.>-65 6/5 &6 > E"$\ TVhW1?/565 E"6-#5+ 7/5 ="F&;8 9"# 7/5 ="F&;8+ >$F$545# #-$6 &$7" F5=7 &$ 7/5 6I&7->; 6I/5#5\ TV)W1 D&6 75#&>; K5$5#"6&785a->;;8 7#>$6.5$F6 7/5 ="-$F>#&56 "9 ="-#K5"&6 ."-#76/&I+ >$F :>6>$"4> 9"#$F 7" "I5$ > 6;; 6/"I Ti";1ibb+ :/1 (Wp ,>F5$ &;;N9>75F 5;"I5$F#5."$.&;5F E&7/ /5# 9>


6/23

!"B

2.'@$%+ #%**+/@

45#&9&5F 9#&5$F6/&I =57E55$ :>6>$"4> >$F F> 0"$75+! >$F #5.5&45F 9-#7/5#9-5; 9#"< 7/5 F&6."45#8 7/>7 7/5 b7>;&>$ >F45$7-#5# &$F55F #56&F5F &$0#>K-5 &$ 7/5 E55B6 ;5>F&$K -I 7" 7/5 "I5#>_6 I#5I&7>;1 ?/5 ;&=#577&67 E>6 />#F I#5665F 9"# 7&1?/5 67"#8 7/5$ K"56 7/>7 F> 0"$75 [>6B5F /&6 9#&5$F+ :>6>$"4>+ 7" K&45,"^>#7 >$8 >66&67>$.5 /5 ."-;F\ TD-6658 ]ULW1" f7/5# 4>#&>$76 "9 7/&6;5K5$F 6-KK567 > ;566 &;&5# "$ 7/5 ;&=#577"1 R66-7 F> 0"$75 E>6 a-&75 9>#E&7/ :>6>$"4>_6 I5#6"$>; >$5.F"756+# 6./";>#6 />45 6"-K/7 7" F&6."45#."$6&F5#>=;5 6&7&56 =57E55$ 7$< E+$8,4 ?+5& 1[?/5 45 6&K$&9&.>$7 I>#>;;5;6 7" 7/5 "I5#>1 b7 655 65#&"-6 I"66&=&;&787/>7 2> 0"$75 =>65F B58 65.7&"$6 "9 /&6 ;&=#577" "$ 7/565 7E" 545$76 &$:>6>$"4>_6 ;&95\ TV*'W1 b$ 7/5 5$F+ 7/5 7#-7/ "9 7/5 775# &6 9"# "7/5#6 7"F5.&F5 >$F "9 $" /5-#&67&. 4>;-5 9"# 7/5 &$4567&K>7&"$ >7 />$F1 C>7/5#+ 7/5I"I-;>#&78 "9 7/&6 ;5K5$F e "9 7/&6 ."$$5.7&"$ =57E55$ :>6>$"4> >$F 2"$

g->$ e &6 &$ &765;9 6&K$&9&.>$71?/5 7E" 7#>F&7&"$6 >K>&$ >II5># ."$9;>75F &$ q"#F !8#"$_6 7$< D",


7/23

!"C

+6/6&6 5789:;;< "=!!>"=!"

F"751 R7 7&$F 7/&6 &6 5>6&;8 7/5 $ 545$ 57&.>;;8 #56&676 65F-.7&"$1 ?/&6 "..-#6+ 9"#&$67>$.5+ E/5$ /5 &6 6- J-;=58>^+ > E"$ [6"

9>YR6 545$ &$ > $^> :rrbrW1 ?/5 ;>F8 &6 .5#7>&$ 7/>7 7/5 8"-$K $E&;; &$67>$7;8 6-= 67".B I&5.5 "9 =-#;56a-5 ."- &F5>;\ T:>$7" bb+ P7>$^> ::rbW1 3$7&; 7/5 9&$>; .>$7"+ 7/5&6;>$F =5>-78 D>&Ft5 #5&$6 7/5 9".>; I"&$7 9"# g->$_6 >995.7&"$+ 6" 7/>7E/5$ J-;=58>^ B56 /5# >F4>$.56+

g->$+ E/" />F 67&;; /&6 &Ft5_6 &6;5 >$F 6"97 b"$&>$ 9>.5+H5;7 E>#< =;""F+ E/&./ &$ /&6 9>.5 E>6 K;"E&$K+C-6/ =>.B -I"$ /&6 /5>#7+ E/&./ 9&;;_F >I>.5+R$F ;597 /&6 ./55B6 >6 I>;5 >6 6$"EF#"I6 =;"E&$K@?/565 E"#F6 E5$7 7/#"-K/ /&6 6"-; ;&B5 R#>=N6I5>#6P" 7/>7 /5 6I"B5 $"7+ =-7 =-#67 &$7" 75>#6 T:>$7" i+ P7>$^> :ribbW1

f$;8 7"E>#F6 7/5 5$F "9 7/5 5I&. I"5< E&;; 8"-$K R-#"#> C>=8 #5>E>B5$&$ g->$ [6"F ;>75;8 ;"67Yf# />#F5$5Fp 955;&$K6 E/&./+I5#/>I6 &F5>;+YR#5 6" F&4&$5+ 7/>7 b l7/5 $>##>7"#m ;\T:>$7" rib+ P7>$^> :ibbW1 ?/-6+ !8#"$_6 7$< D",< #8 7#>F&7&"$@ ?/5 6&$K-;># ;"45# 5ZI#56656 /& />I/>^>#F 65Z->;&78 =-7 &$ /&6 65>#./ 9"# >$ 5a->;;8 6&$K-;>#;"451

,>8=5 6-#I#&6&$K;8+ 7/&6 9".-6 "$ > ;"45 E/&./ 7#>$6.5$F6 >;; "7/5#6.>$ >;6" =5 9"-$F &$ 7/5 2+)3$#4 $5 >4 ?+5& 1 b$ 7/5 6>8 7/>7 7/5 ;"66

"9 D>&Ft5 6/>775#6 g->$_6 E"#;F+ 7/5 9"#.5F 65I>#>7&"$ 9#"< 7/5 E&7/"-7 7/5 [6;&K/7567 >=&;&78 7" F" >$87/&$K7"E>#F ;&4&$K\ T*@ U)NU(W1 H"# > E/&;5+ /5 E&7/F#>E6 9#"< ;&95+ 955;&$K 7/>7/5 />6 9"#95&75F /&6 "$5 ./>$.5 9"# />II&$5661 f9 ."-#65+ 6-./ /8I5#=";56>#5 ./>#>.75#&67&. 9"# 5&K/755$7/ .5$7-#8 ,>$"# %,))+$$F 7/5 :/54>;&5# 9#5a-5$7;8 #5.>;;6 7/#"-K/"-7 7/5 ;< 7" 4 ?+5& 1 ?/5 75Z7 &6 $5&7/5# >$ 5;5K8 "$ 7/5 ;"66


8/23

!"D

2.'@$%+ #%**+/@

"9 D5$#&5775+ $"# &6 7/5 65>#./ 9"# ="-#K5"&6 />II&$566 &76 67#-.7-#&$KI#&$.&I;51 ?/5 $&$5755$7/ .5$7-#8+ /"E545#+ E&;; &$.#5>6&$K;8 9".-6 "97/&6 7/57&. I"75$7&>;+ ="7/ &$ 2"$ g->$ >$F :>6>$"4>1

R .>65 &$ I"&$7 &6 R;=5#7 q"#7^&$K_6 "I5#577> @,),;&5# $" ;"$K5# >II5>#6 > 65#&>;+ =-7 > 45#8 ="-#K5"&6 ;"45#1U ?/5"=X5.7 "9 /&6 >995.7&"$+ 8"-$K C"6>-#>+ &6 7" =5 ##&5F 7" 7/5 E5>;7/8J>6>$"4> "9 7/52+)3$#4 $5 >4 ?+5& + 655&$K 7/>7 /5 E>6 >;E>86 E5;; I;5>65F 7" 655 9"#67+ 7>B56 "995$.5 >7 7/57/"-K/7 "9 C"6>-#> &$ 7/5 >#;;8 6&$.5 e -$;&B5 /5#9&>$.t5 e /5 7#-;8 ;"456 7/5 K1 b$ 7/5 5$F+ :>6>$"4> $>K56 7" =#5>B"99 7/5 E5FF&$K+ >;7/"-K/ &7 #5&$6 -$.;5># E/57/5# /5 &$F55F &$75$F6 7"67>8 E&7/ C"6>-#>1 H"#57 7/5 ;&75#>#8 7#>F&7&"$ E"-;F 9"#.5 >$&$."$45$&5$7 >$6E5#1

?/&6 K#>F->; 7#>$69&K-#>7&"$ "9 :>6>$"4> >$F 2"$ g->$+ =-7 &$ I>#7&.-;>#7/5 655#7_6 "I5#> &$6IF =8 7/5 i5$57&>$ >F45$7-#5#d2"56 7/5 6I&7 "9 :>6>$"4> =#5>7/5 7/#"-K/ !8#"$_6 g->$d 2&F q"#7^&$K>;K>75 ."$75$1R6 &$F&.>75F >="45+ 9"# > F&6.-66&"$ "9 :>6>$"4>_6 .>$"$&^>7&"$ &7 &6 9>#$7 7" &$4567&K>75 7/5 6".&"N/&67"#&.>; 9>.7"#6 7/>7 &$F-.5F>$F F5 $&$K9-; 7/&6 6/&97 &$ 7/5 ;&75#>#8 7#>F&7&"$1 !8 5ZI;"#&$K 7/5#56I5.7&45 ./>$K56 &$ 7/5 >-F&5$.5_6 c/"#&^"$ "9 5ZI5.7>7&"$6_ Tg>-uW+ "$5.>$ 9-;;8 >II#5.&>75 /"E 7/5 $"$ =8 >FX-67&$K &76 I#>K7&. $5Z-61

?/5 54&F5$.5 6-#4585F 7/-6 9># 6-KK5676 7/>7+ &$ 7/5 ."-#65 "9 7/5$&$5755$7/ .5$7-#8+ 7/5 :>6>$"4> ;;8 6I5>B&$K+ "$5 .>$ >77567 > 6/&97 9#"<65F-.7&"$ 7" ."F&7&"$+ > =#5>B P759>$ `E5&K95#45$7;8 #5X5.75F1 [A"7/&$K\+ /5 F5.;>#5F+ [."-;F =5 $7/5 E>8 &$ E/&./ $8 "9 "-# &K&$>7&45 E#&75#6 E/" ./""65 :>6>$"4>>6 > /5#" "9 > I;>8 "# > $"45; F5I&.7 /&< >6 5$F"E5F E&7/ > 7/"#"-K/;8>;5#7 &$75;;&K5$.5+ >6 =5&$K > #59;5.7&45 78I5\ T]]W1 `E5&K E&;; $"7 >;;"E9"# 4>#&>7&"$6 9"# 95># "9 9"#95&7&$K 7/5 5665$.5 "9 7/5 :/54>;&5#@ [b$67&; $"


9/23

!"E

+6/6&6 5789:;;< "=!!>"=!"

65;9NB$"E;5FK5 >$F > 65$65 "9 #56I"$6&=&;&78+ >$F /5 E&;; $" ;"$K5# =5:>6>$"4>\ T]]W1 O57 &7 E"-;F >II5># 7/>7 7/&6 5665$.5 e "# >7 ;5>67 I>#76"9 &7 e />F K#>F->;;8 ;"67 &76 >II5>;1 ?/5 -$#59;5.7&$K 5#"7"$&>.+ &7

6557/5#+ 7/5 9".-66/&975F "$ 7/5 ; 7" F&6.-66 7/5 I#"=;56>$"4> K#>F->;;8 54";45F &$7" > I/"#7/>7 5995.7&45;8 ."$.5I7->;&^56 6 "9 ;"451 :"$.5I7->;I/"#6 9-$F>;;8 67#-.7-#5 6".&>; I5#.5I7&"$ >$F 7/-6 5$>=;5."; 75#$ 7/5 6&;;"E6 9"#1) ?/5I-#I"65 "9 7/5 I/"#+ /"E545#+ &6 6&;&^5 7/5

>.7&"$ &$ 545#8F>8 F&6."-#651',-$#.%(

&*

/',

0(.

&*

#"%.1

0 >$F(2.",&.*

',. 3$&4+&%-* >#5 X-67 > 95E "9 $5>#;8 &$9&$&75 I"66&=&;&7&56 7" 67#-.7-#5 "$5>#5> "9 5ZI5#&5$.5 E&7/ 7/5 /5;I "9 >$"7/5#1 RF67 F-5 7" 7/5 5;-6&45$566 "9 ="7/ I>#76 "97/5 5a->7&"$1 q"45+ &$ I>#7&.-;>#+ &$ 7/5 "96"7 &6 E/";;8 6-=X5.7&45+ $&$K 7/>7 &7 .>$$"7 =5 >#7&.-;>75F&$ >$ "=X5.7&45+ K5$5#>;;8 &$75;;&K&=;5 $$5#1 b7 &6 I#5.&65;8 7/&6 B&$F "9>7 .>;;6 9"# I/"#&.>; ."$.5I7->;&^>7&"$1

H#"< > 6".&";"K&.>; I"&$7 "9 4&5E+ 7/5$+ ;"45 7"F>8 I#565$76 &765;9 >6 >

.";;5$K5 7" ." I#566&$K 775# E&7/ 7/5 9-$.7&"$>; F&995#5$7&>7&"$( "9Q-#"I5>$ 6".&578 &$ 7/5 65;9N."$7>&$5F 68675< 7/>7 K5$5#>756 &76 "E$ ."F51 ?/&6 $7 7/>7+ >6 >6".&>; I/5$";"#&^>7&"$67/>7 >#5 $"7 6I5.&9&. 7" ;"451 C>7/5#+ &7 54";45F &$7" > #59;5Z&45 I#".566 7/>79";;"E5F &76 "E$ ;"K&.@ [q"45\+ q-/$$ 5ZI;>&$6 7/&6 6/&97+ $"E [7>#K576>$ b >$F > O"-+ +"06 >6 ="7/ >#5 ."$$5.75F 7/#"-K/ ;"45+ $&$K7/>7 7/58 #5.&I#".>;;8 5$>=;5 6-./ > #5;>7&"$6/&I e >$F $"7 =5.>-65 7/58

>#5 K""F+ "# =5>-7&9-;+ "# $"=;5+ "# E5>;7/8\ T'UVW1 ?/-6+ ;"45 =5."


10/23

!"F

2.'@$%+ #%**+/@

> 775# "9 #5.&I#".>75F c955;&$K1_ H"# > I5#6"$ 7" ;"45 $6 [7/>7 >."##56I"$F&$K 955;&$K &6 5;;8 6"-K/7 >$F ."$9 "$5 ;"456"$565;9 >6 ;"45# >$F =5;"45F+ >$F 7/>7 "$5 >;6" ;"456 7/5 "7/5# >6 ;"45#

>$F =5;"45F+ $&$K 7/>7 "$5_6 955;&$K6 >#5 F.75F I#5.&65;8 >7 7/5."&$.&F5$.5 "9 7/&6 955;&$K\ Tq-/$$ 'UVW1 q"45+ 7/5$+ &6 7/5 #5.&I#".>;>7&"$ "9 7/5 65;9 >$F 7/5 "7/5#1

J&>." &$ /&6 #>;&5#_6 #59;5.7&"$6 "$ /&6 >99> E&7/ ?"$&$>+9"# 5Z>75 7/>7 /5 E>6 >6 7 "$.5 $"4> #5.>;;6+ [b ."$K#>7-;>75F 6&;8\ T]@ 'V*N'V]W1 b$ > 6 7"$5+ 7/5 $"45#&>$ 6&675#61 R6 >;E>86+ 7/5 :/54>;&5#/>F "45#5Z75$F5F /&F&561 ?/5 #5."7&"$ "9 7/5 F5;&K/7 E5#5 9&5#8\+ :>6>$"4> #5.>;;61 [b>F"#5F 7/5< >$F >F"#5F ;&7&56 "9 7/5 =5;"45F1 b7 &6 > I#".566 &$ E/&./955;&$K &6 #5.&I#".>;;8 4>;"#&^5F >$F >+ 7/&6 $5E I"75$7&>; "9 ;"45 54";456 &$7" > 4&7>;

$6 7" ."$6";&F>75 65;9N/""F1 D&7/5#7"+ > 67#>7&9&5F 6-I5#67#-.7-#5 />F"#K>$&^5F 7/5 #5;>7&"$6/&I =57E55$ 6".&578 >$F 7/5 &$F&4&F->;1 H-$.7&"$>;F&995#5$7&>7&"$+ &$ ."$7#>67+ I5#I57->;;8 ./>;;5$K56 7/5 &$F&4&F->; 7"68$7/56&^5 7/5 F&67&$.7 #";56 &7 I;>86 E&7/&$ F&6.#575 6".&>; 68675##>7&451 ?/5 #56-;7 &6 > ."$7&$K5$7 65;9NI#"X5.7&"$ 7/>7 ;"45+/"E545#+ 8 ;5K&7&6 9"#7&"$ lA+19"; =#>.&$K\ Tq-/$$LM)W1 ?/&6 =#&$K6 >="-7 7/5 65>#./ 9"# > 6&K$&9&.>$7 "7/5#+ 9"# [6"7 ;5>67 B56 7/&6I>#7 "9 /&6 "E$ 65;9NI#"X5.7&"$ E/&./+ &$ 7-#$+ 7/5 "7/5# 75 65;9N/""F =8 5$>=;&$K &$F&4&F->;6 7" ;;8 4>;&F>75 >$F-I/";F 7/5 #56I5.7&45 &$75#I#57>7&"$ "9 7/5 E"#;F >$F 7/5 I;>.5 7/5#5&$1

?/&6 B56 9"# > I#5.>#&"-6 5a-&;&=#&-< =57E55$ ;"45#6+ K&45$ 7/>7545#8 ."$ 5;-6&45&F5>; "9 ."$.5 9"# 7/5 #5;>7&"$6/&I1 b$F55F+&7 &6 > />;;#B "9 ; #5;>7&"$6/&I6 >#5 "45#=-#F5$5F


11/23

!?=

+6/6&6 5789:;;< "=!!>"=!"

=8 5ZI5.7>7&"$6 9"# ."##56I"$F5$.5 E&7/ 7/5 "7/5#+ E/&./ I#5.&I&7>7567/5 =#5>B-I "9+ =-7 >7 7/5 6>7&"$6/&I6\ Tq-/$$ LMVW1 b$ 5Z7#5656+ ;"45 8 545$ 655< 7"

"995# ."7&"$ 9"# "7/5# >6I5.76 "9 5Z&675$.5 7/>7 >#5 9"-$F E>$7&$K1P-./ [/"I56 >$F 5ZI5.7>7&"$6 7" 9&$F 6"7 &6 6 #5&$5F -$9-;9&;;5F .>$ .#5>75 5ZI5.7>7&"$6 7/>7>#5 &&;-#5 "9 7/5 &$F&4&F->; 65;9NI#"X5.7&"$1

9%37 )2 1/2/"%3/?/&6 I#"=;5; #5;>7&"$6/&I6+ />6 K#>F->;;8 56 7/5 F"$795>7-#5 "9 7/5 :>6>$"4> 6 "I5$9"# > F&6.-66&"$ "9 7/&6 I#"=;5< >6 &7 I#";&95#>75F &$ 7/5 $&$5755$7/ >$F7E5$7&57/ .5$7-#8 65.-#5F 9"# :>6>$"4> > I;>.5 &$ 7/5 9-$.7&"$>; 6>$"4>_6

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

7/5 :/54>;&5#_6 65.#57 #57-#$ 7" i5$&.51 R ./>$.5 5$."-$75# #5-$&756 /&


12/23

!?!

2.'@$%+ #%**+/@

E&7/ /&6 9"# E/" 6&Z755$ 85>#6 >K"+ >6 :>6>$"4> $"E;5>#$6+ />F ="#$5 /&< > 6"$1 i&77"#&>_6 /-6=>$F q"#5$^" =5K&$6 7" 6-6I5.7>6 $F 95>#6 7/>7 /&6 E&95_6 ;"45 9"# /&< &6 $"7 -$."$75675F1 b$ 7/5

5$F+ :>6>$"4> >$F i&77"#&> F&66->F5 /&< >$F 7/-6 6>;4>K5 7/5 ##&>K51R7 7/5 6>65 &$ I"&$7 9"# 7/5 6/&97 &$ 7/5 7#>F&7&"$ &6 R#7/-# P./$&7^;5#_67#5>7 7/5#6 &$ 5Z&;5+ :>6>$"4> &6 >="-7 7"#5.5&45 /&6 I>#F"$ >$F #57-#$ 7" i5$&.5 E/5$ /5 5$."-$75#6 f;&4"+E/"65 9"#7-$5 /5 />F F5 =8 I#"4&F&$K /&< E&7/ 7/5 $6 7" ##8>$F 9"-$F > /"-65/";F1 f;&4" &$6&676 7/>7 /&6 =5$59>.7"# 6I5$F 6"E/"+ /"E545#+ F568 "$;8 7" ;&5 &$ 7/5 >#1G/5$ 7/5 8"-$K ;>F8 I#"456 &$6-6.5I7&=;5 7" /&6 >F4>$.56+ :>6>$"4>7#>$69"#$ "9 7/5 ";F 7#>F&7&"$1'' 2&6K-&65F >6 ,>#.";&$>_6;"45# q"#5$^& /5 5$X"86 /5# .>#56656+ =-7 975# =5&$K F&6."45#5F>$F B&;;&$K /&6 #&4>;1

D"9$$67/>;_6 I;>8 >$F P./$&7^;5#_6 $"45;;> />45 =55$ ."$4&$.&$K;8

F56.#&=5F >6 5ZI#566&"$6 "9 9&$ F5 6&k.;5 F5.>F5$.51 f$ 7/5 545 "97/5 HC G"#;F G>#+ >$ &$.#5>6&$K;8 $5-#>67/5$&. Q-#"I5 T.91 C>FB>-W#5&$75#I#575F :>6>$"4>_6 5Z&675$.5 >6 > 9&$>;+ &;;N9>75F -I#&6&$K >K>&$67 7/56I&7->; F56";>7&"$ .>-65F =8 6".&>; 67>$F>#F&^>7&"$1 [H"# 7/5 >-7/"#6 "97/5 7-#$ "9 7/5 .5$7-#8+ /5 #5I#565$75F 7/5 >$7&7/56&6 7" 7/5 .>;.-;>7&$K="-#K5"&6 >$F /&6 67#-KK;5 9"# 65.-#&78 E&7/&$ 7/5 #&6&$K &$F-67#&>; "#F5#l111m1 H"# 7/5 #>7&"$>;;8 67#-.7-#5F >$F 5;>="#>75;8 "#K>$&^5F E"#;F "9m ;&45F 9"# 7/5 $B>- '*UN'*)W1 q&B5 P>;"$F 7 .:&I"#&>6 "9 ;"451 R;#5>F8 &$ 7/5 5ZI"6&7&"$ "9 P./$&7^;5#_6 $"45;;>+ 7/5 .5$7#>;6&K$&9&.>$.5 "9 7/565 I#"=;5 75;;&$K;8 X-Z7>I"656 /5##&7>; ."+ >$F E/&./6/5 ;"$K6 7" 5ZI5#&5$.5 "$.5 >K>&$ T'U'W1 P ;; :>6>$"4>


13/23

!?"

+6/6&6 5789:;;< "=!!>"=!"

E/5$ /5 9&$>;;8 ."$6-#.";&$>@ [D5#5 >7 ;>67 E>6 7/5#5>;&78 E/&./ /5 />F "975$ 9>;65;8 &K&$5F /&77>&$&$K+ >$F E/&./ />F >;E>86 5;-F5F /&6 K#>6I1 H-;9&;6 /5#5 >7

,>#.";&$>_6 /5>#7\ TL*'W1 ?/5 6&K$>; E"#F6 /5#5 >#5 c=;&66_ >$F c9-;9&;;7&"$1 ?/5 5ZI5#&5$.5 "9 ;"45 &$67>756 7/565;9 >6 7/5 >=6";-75 I"&$7 "9 #595#5$.5 9"# &76 5$4"$_6m ;&I6d G>6 /5 $"7 >K"Fd l111m D"$F 5Z&;5+ 6I;5$F"# >$F + >$FE/" />F 9"-$F ,>#.";&$>d\ TL*'W1 q"45+ >6 q-/$$ I"&$76 "-7+ "995#67/5 6>$"4>_6 7#&-6,>#.";&$> &6 &K$"#>$7 "9 /5# =5F95;;"E_6 &F5$7&78+ E/"< 6/5 &$ 9>.7 =5;&54567" =5 q"#5$^&1 ?/5#59"#5+ >;7/"-K/ 9-;;8 >E>#5 7/>7 7/&6 &6 > F56I5#>75>775;&5# F5.&F56 7" K> F&6."45# /&6 &F5$7&78+ /"I&$K 7/>7 e &$ 7/5 >975#7/ "9 7/5="F&;8 -$&"$ e 6/5 E&;; 4>;&F>75 /&6 ;"45 >$F+ =8 5Z75$6&"$+ /&6 I5#6"$1[G&7/ 7/5 &$9>;;&=;5 ."$4&.7&"$ 7/>7 /5 8 9"# > K#5>767>B5+ 7/5 ;"66 "9 E/&./ /5 E"-;F />45 7" I>8 9"# E&7/ /&6 45#8 5Z&675$.5\TL*'W1 :>6>$"4> &6 .5#7>&$ 7/>7 7/&6 $>K$"#&6&6 E&;; F5.&F5 $"7"$;8 7/5 "-7." ."$6&F5#6 c/"$ "$5 E>81 ?/5 67"#8 &6 X-67 >6 ="-7 7/5 :/54>;&5#_6 #57-#$ 7"/&6 $>7&45 i5$&.5 >6 &7 &6 >="-7 9&$F&$K > 7#>$6.5$F5$7>; /"4"-#6 9>&; 7" ;;5$K5 "9 75$ 7E" F5.>F56 6I5$7 &$ 5Z&;5+ :>6>$"4> #57-#$6 7" 7/5,"67 P5#5$5 C5I-=;&. >6 >$ "-76&F5#+ -$>=;5 7" #5."K$&^5 7/5 /" >E>B5$6 &$ 7/5 75F =8 7/5 >-F>.&78 "9 7/5 :/54>;&5#+ =-7 6&;_6 I;>8 7 .:&+ >$F 7/5 65."$F &6 i&77"#&>_6 I#5.>#&"-6 #5;>7&"$6/&I

7" /5# /-6=>$F q"#5$^"1 ?/5 >##&4>; "9 7/5


14/23

!??

2.'@$%+ #%**+/@

q"#5$^" $"7 6&;"-6+ =-7 I>&$9-;;8 >E>#5 "9 /&6 6I&7->; F5I5$F5$.5"$ i&77"#&>@ [O"- >#5 545#87/&$K 7" 8+ 9"# =5775# "# 9"# E"#651 O"- >#5 7/5 "$;8 K&97 ;&95 />6 K&45$ 7"

K&97 7/>7 &$.;-F56 >;; "7/5#6\ T']UW1 i&77"#&> 6>95K->#F6 $"7/&$K ;5667/>$ 7/5 ."/5#5$.5 "9 q"#5$^"_6 &F5$7&781 [O"- >#5 7/5 #5>;&78 "9 66545#>756+ [7/5 67#"$K/";F -I"$ E/&./ b =-&;F #&"-6 ."$67#-.7&"$1'L ?" =5 6-67>&$>=;5+ &7 =;&6/ >$F &$7>&$ 7/5 &;;-6&"$ "9 I5#95.7."$K#-5$.51 ?" ="7/ 7/5 ;"45# >$F 7/5 =5;"45F &7 II5># 7/>7 7/5"7/5# &6 $"7 6&4&"-# e >7/5#>I&67 8 I5#9"#< 7/&6 7>6B e+ =-7 7/>7 "$5_6 "E$ E"#;F 4&5E &6 >;#5>F8&$.;-F5F &$ 7/>7 "9 7/5 "7/5#1 0>#>F"Z&.>;;8+ 7/&6 I#5.;-F56 ."7 6-./ ."7 9>&;6 7" >.."-$7 9"# 7/5 E"#;F 4&5E "97/5 "7/5# &6 >$ >99#"$7 7" 7/5 ."F5 "9 K56 7" I-7 &$7" a-567&"$ 7/5 45#8 5665$.5 "9 /&6##&>K5 7" i&77"#&>@ [O"- >#5 756+ [>$F /-6=>$F >$F E&95+I5"I;5 6>8+ >#5 "$51 b7 655#5 > E/";5 >$F b >< >;6" > E/";5+ >$F b .>$ "$;8 K&456 > E/";5p b .>$$"7 F&66";45 7/5 E#5>7/ 7/>7 &6 &656 7/5 a-567&"$ "9 E/57/5# P./$&7^;5# >$F D"9$$67/>;"995# 7/5 /5#"56 >;75#$>7&45 >$F 4&>=;5 $6 7" ."$6";&F>75 65;9N/""F1D"9$$67/>;_6 i&77"#&>+ &7 655F5a->.&56 =8I#"I>K>7&$K >$ >567/57&. 5Z&675$.5 >$F+ -;7&75;8+ E&7/F#>E&$K &$7" 7/5E"#;F "9 >#71 ?/&6 F5$"-575F &$ 7/5 .5$7#>; =>;;#""< 6.5$5+E/5$ i&77"#&> "=65#456 > "$.5 K#5>7 ."6 6&$.5 F5K5$5#>75F&$7" > K5#&>7#&. 6& ."$75$F6 7/>7 7/5 /5>#795;7 I>66&"$ /5 9C


15/23

!?A

+6/6&6 5789:;;< "=!!>"=!"

I-7 &$7" 7/5 ."$F 575#$>;;8 #5>;&^5F &$ 7/5I5#9"#$.51 R$>;"K"-6;8+ i&77"#&> &6 .5#7>&$ 7/>7 [E/5#545# E5 ;"45E5 .#5>75 6-./ >$ &$4&6&=;5+ K&.>; &6;>$F\ T'VVW1 ?/"-K/ 7/5 #5$5E5F

F5I>#7-#5 "9 :>6>$"4> ;5>456 /5# E"#;F &$ 6/>$F =5;"45F 8 .>##8 "$ &$ > 7#>$6.5$F5$7>;+ >567/57&. #5>;m .#5>75F\+ 6/5 >6B61 [b6 7/5#5 $"7 > 9&$ 7 "$.5 E>6 7/5 9 "9 /&6 6"-;d f9 E/>7 & 6"$K 775676+7/>$ >$87/&$K 6/5 />6 6-$K &$ 85>#61 f$;8 6-=;&7&"$+ &7 >II5>#6+ .>$B5 ;"45 7&F56 P./$&7^;5#_6 $"45;;>1 H#"< 7/5 67>#7&7 &6 54&F5$7 7" 7/5 :/54>;&5# 7/>7 >$8 >775#.";&$> E&;; =59-7&;51 Q45$ >6 /&6 [F568 K#5E =58"$F 6-#5+ l111m 7/5 #5."K$&7&"$ 7/>77/565 F568 E5#5 -775#;8 9"";&6/ >$F 9-7&;5 #5F-.5F /&< >;\T'U(W1 P7&;;+ 7/5 757&"$ 7" ."$6";&F>75 65;9N/""F 7/#"-K/ ;"45 &6 7""67#"$K+ E/&./ &6 E/8 :>6>$"4> .>$$"7 ."$75$7 /.";&$>_6=5F1 D5 $55F6 /5# 7" #5.&I#".>75+ 6I&7->;;8 >6 E5;; >6 I/86&.>;;81 ?/-6+:>6>$"4> &6 .5#7>&$+ ,>#.";&$>_6 ;"45 E&;; ."$.;-F5 /&6 67#-KK;5 9"# >$&F5$7&78 7/>7 &6 ="7/ ."$F 5$F-#&$K1 ?/&6+ /5 &K&$56+ E&;; =5

7/5 [7/5 .#"E$ "9 /&6 ;&95\@ ?/>7 [/5+ =8 7/5 "45#E/5;;&78+ E"-;F />45 E"$ 9"# /&$F 9"#545# 7/58"-$K567+ 7/5 $F c9-;9&;;#5 I#5.;-F5F >6 /&6c-$."$a-5#>=;5 I5#6"$>;&78_ &6 #5X5.75F >$F 7/-6 $5K>75F1 H"# P./$&7^;5#_6:>6>$"4>+ ;"45 =5." 7#>K5F8 &$ 7/5 F5.&6&"$ 6&7->7&"$ &$ E/&./ 5&7/5# ."-#65 "9>.7&"$ E&;; ;5>F 7" F&6>675#1 A" 775# /"E :>6>$"4> I#".55F6 e 5&7/5# /5>=>$F"$6 7/5 =5F#""< =59"#5 6-$#&65 "# /5 #545>;6 /$&$K

9"# #5.&I#".>; ;"45 E&;; #5&$ -$9-;9&;;5F1 b$ > 65$65+ 7/&6 I5#6&675$.5 &$ 7/59>.5 "9 &$54&7>=;5 9>&;-#5 8 =5 -$F5#67""F >6 > /5#"&. >.71 :>6>$"4> &6E&;;&$K 7" 6>.#&9&.5 545#87/&$K+ /&6 I#&F5+ /&6 /"$"-#+ >$F+ &$ 7/5 9&$>; F-5;E&7/ q"#5$^&+ 545$ /&6 ;&95 7" >77>&$ 7/5 -$>77>&$>=;51 R7 7/5 ."$.;-6&"$"9 @,),5,6#3 + 7/5 :/54>;&5# ;5>456 7/5 67>K5 >6 7/5 7#>K&. /5#""9 6 =5." />;;#B "9 7/5 :>6>$"4> 7/5;&5#+ &$ > /5#"&. >$F 5Z5#8 $$5#+ 7#>.56 7/5 I#"=;57&.$5Z-6 =57E55$ ;"45 >$F 65;9N/""F1 D5 &6 > #8 7>;5 "9 ;"45_6 6$>#561 G&11+


16/23

!?B

2.'@$%+ #%**+/@

T'(UhW &6 > I>#>F&K7&. 5Z>4 ?+5& e >#5=#"-K/7 7"K57/5# =8 7/5 /5#"_6 7#>K&." $&$K9-; &F5$7&781 ?/&6 F56 &6 $F F&6=5;&591 b$ #56I"$65+ 7/5 :/54>;&5# 6>$"4&676@ 7/>7 /5 &6 $"7X-67 >$ 5#"7"$&>.+ =-7 &$ 9>.7 [> I/&;"6"I/5#+ > $ "9 ;5775#6\1 ?/&6>6I5.7 "9 /&6 5Z&675$.5+ /"E545#+ 9>&;6 7" =;8+7/&6 6I&7->;+ cI/&;"6"I/&.>;_ ;"45 &6 $"7 ."$6-75 &7 E&7/ 7/5 >KK#566&45 >$F K#"756a-5 Tc:>6>$"4&>$_W .>#$>;&787/>7 #5.-#6 7/#"-K/"-7 7/5 9&;6>$"4> 9&$F6 >$F 7#>K&.>;;89"#95&76 7/5 7#>$6.5$F5$7 5Z&675$.5 /5 .#>456 9"#1

?5;;&$K;8+ 7/5 "$;8 7&6>$"4> 8 &$F55F I#"45 /&;&78@ ?/5 &;;-67#&"-6 K-5676 "9 > I>#78 .">Z 7/5 :/54>;&5# &$7" 6577;&$K> E>K5# 7/>7 /5 .>$ "-7I5#9"#< > .">./$ &$ 7/5 ="-F" ?/5 9";;"E&$K6.5$5_6 5Z>KK5#>75F ./"#5"K#>I/8+ E/&./ 8 67>$F &$ 9"# >;; F5I&.7&"$6"9 ."&7-6 &$ 7/5 9&;;6 7/5 $&.>; $>7-#5 "9 :>6>$"4>_6 65Z-61 b7&6 > I-=;&. 6I5.7>.;5 7/>7+ >;7/"-K/ >$ 5ZI#566&"$ "9 6-I5#/-$ 4&;&78+

.>$$"7 .#5>75 "# 6-67>&$ 5$F-#&$K I5#6"$>; #5;>7&"$61 ?/&6 &; =F 7/>7 >.."$&56 7/5 :/54>;&5# "$/&6 5#"7&. >F45$7-#56 >$F 7/>7 6I#&$K6 7" ;&95 E&7/ 7/5 =5K&$$&$K "9 7/5cI#".5F-#51_ b7 &6 7/5#59"#5 > .#-5; 857 9&77&$K "$8 7/>7 :>6>$"4> -;7&75;89&$F6 =;&66 &$ 7/5 >#.56 7/5 I> "$ > 9#"^5$ .>$>; &$ i5$&.5+ >;"$5 &$ 7/5 F>#B+ "=;&4&"-6"9 7/5 6-##"-$F&$K6+ -$ 6 9"-$F /&6 6&K$&9&.>$7 "7/5#+ =-7 7/&6 #56";-7&"$&6 7E&.5 #5;&78@ =8 &76 >#7&9&.&>; $>7-#5 >$F =8 7/5 9>.7 7/>7

&7 &6 =-7 > F#5>< 4&6&"$ "9 7/5 F&6&;;-6&"$5F+ ";F :>6>$"4>1R$ 5;5K&>. -$F5#7"$5 />6 ." 7/566-.7 7/>7 ;"45+ &$ 7/5 .5#=>7&$K 6".&>; I#566-#561 ?" #5>./ 6-./ > ."$.;-6&"$ E"-;F $9>;;&$K 6/"#7 "9 7/5 ;1 ?" =5K&$ E&7/+ "$5;; 6".&>; 68675;K&45$1 b7 &6 $"7 6"7 .>$ 5Z&67 "-76&F5 "9+ >$F 7/5#59"#5 9>;; 4&.7&<7" 6".&5781 q"45 &6 K5$5#>75F =8+ >$F 7/-6 > 9-$.7&"$ "9 6".&5781 P".&>;

9-$.7&"$6 .>$$"7 =5 ."$.5&45F "9 >6 7&$F &6+ >6


17/23

!?C

+6/6&6 5789:;;< "=!!>"=!"

"=X5.7&45 K""F6 7/>7 >#5 7/#5>75$5F =8 5Z75#$>; 6".&>; I#566-#561 C>7/5#+7/58 $55F 7" =5 ."$6&F5#5F 7/5 #56-;7 "9 >F>I7>7&"$6+ "9 54";-7&"$>#8+"I5$N5$F5F I#".566561 ?/58 >#5 $"7 7/5 6"-#.5 "9 ."$9;&.7+ =-7 T>;=5&7 "975$

&$." $6 7" >;;54&>75 7/5 67#>&$6 "9 9-$.7&"$>;F&995#5$7&>7&"$ "$ 7/5 &$F&4&F->;1 b7 &6 >$ &7 $545#7/5;566/";F6 7/5 I#" 7/57 $"7E&7/67>$F&$K 7/57#"-=;56 ;"45 5$7>&;6+ 7/5#5 &6 >$ &$/5#5$7 #5E>#F 7" &$7&.8+ > #5E>#F 7/>7"-7E5&K/6 7/5 657=>.B6 >$F F&6>II"&$7;; ."$6&F5#>7&"$6 I#5.;-F5 > ."$.&;&>7"#8F5$"-51 ?/5 9".-6 "$ 7/5 9>&;-#5 "9 &$7&.8 &$ 67#-.7-#>; $5.566&78+ F-5 7" 7/5 >=67#>.7 $>7-#5"9 7/5 6-=X5.71 ?/5 6I&7->; #57&"$ "9 ;"45 .>$ =5 5ZI;"#5F =-7&$F.7;8+ .#&9&.56 7/5 /5#" &6 E&;;&$K7" B5 &$ &76 I-#6-&71 05#6545#>$.5 &$ 7/5 9>.5 "9 .5#7>&$ 9>&;-#5 -651 ?/&6 &6+ 9"# &$67>$.5+ 7/567#-.7-#>; ;"K&. "9 P/>B56I5>#5_6 *$>&$ ,$F /5# ;"45# #5 ="#$+ I/"#6 E/&./ e >6 q>B"99>$F g"/$6"$ 5;-.&F>75F e >#5 $5.566>#8 7" ."$.5I7->;&^5 ." />II8 5$F&$K 9"# :>6>$"4>+>;7/"-K/ 6-./ >$ 5$F&$K E"-;F F&6I"66566 7/5 7/5;I"75$7&>; &7 />6 >..-75F "45# 7/5 85>#6 >$F E/&./ 65.-#5F 9"# 7/5$ .-;7-#>; $ 7/5 7#>K&. /5#" "9 #"$7&.;"451 R#K->=;8+ /5#5 ;>8 7/5 K#5>7567 ./>;;5$K5 9"# q>665 D>;;67#v75 7/5 D";;8E""F 678;5 $>##>7&45 9"# > #"$7&.

."$87/&$K =-7 > 9-7-#5 .;>66&. e &6 #5#B>=;5 9"# /"E 7/5 9&;< #5."$.&;567/5 ." K5$5#&. #"6>$"4> > />II8 5$F&$K E&7/"-7 />4&$K 7" 6>.#&9&.5 7/5 &F5>6 7/>7 >#5.5$7#>; 7" 7/5 7/5; 9"# ; 5#"7"$&> 7" I-#6-5 /&6 6&K$&9&.>$7 "7/5#1 b$ H#>$.56.>+ /5-$5ZI5.75F;8 F&6."45#6 7/5 E"$ E/" 8 9-;9&;; $"7 X-67 /&6 65$6->;+ =-7>;6" /&6 6I&7->; F56ȱ ?/5 ;&75#>#8 7#>F&7&"$ $>7-#>;;8 #>&656 7/5 a-567&"$

"9 7/5 I"75$7&>; ;"$K54&78 "9 7/&6 #5;>7&"$6/&I1 ?/&6 a-567&"$ &6 &$75$7&"$>;;8


18/23

!?D

2.'@$%+ #%**+/@

#5&$9"#.5F =8 7/5 9&;6>$"4> #5="-7 7/5 cH#>$.56.> 5I&6"F5_ >6 /5 I5$6 /&6 ; 7#>F&7&"$+ 7/5 5ZI"6&7&"$ 655 I"6&7&45

"-7."$.5 7/5 II8 5$F&$K &6 6>;4>K5F=8 > 9&.7&"$>; "I5#>7&"$1

b$ 7/5 9&; ;1 R 75;;&$K 6.5$56/"E6 >$ &K$"#>$7 i5$57&>$ >66-#5 :>6>$"4> 7/>7 /5 E"-;F E&7/"-7 9>&;#5."K$&^5 7/>7 9>8+ B$5E [45#8E5;;1\ R7 7/5 5$F "9 7/5 67"#8+ 7/&6 F&66".&>7&"$ "9 6&K$&9&5# >$F 6&K$&9&5FB56 &7 I"66&=;5 9"# 7/5 /5#" 7" I>66 "$ /&6 ;&75#>#8 &F5$7&78 7" > 9#&5$F E/"/5$.59"#7/ 575F E&7/ 7/5 $>$F E/" E&;;;>75# >-7/"# 7/5 2+)3$#4 $5 >4 ?+5& 1 ,5>$E/&;5+ :>6>$"4> >$F H#>$.56.>#57#5>7 7" 7/5 ."-$7#86&F5 >$F =5.".7"#6@ I#"9566&"$>;6 E/" >66-#>.75#6 e ./>#>.75#6 ;&B5 :>6>$"4> e &$ "#F5# 7" 5$75#7>&$+&$67#-.7+ >$F 5F&98 7/5 >-F&5$.51 P-./ 7 #5N5$>.7 7/5 >F45$7-#56 "9 7/5 :/54>;&5# E/"+ &$ 7-#$+I5#I57->;;8 6/&976 #";56 7" 54>F5 ;5K>; I#"65.-7&"$+ 7" >II5>65 /&6 F5=7"#6+

>$F 7" E&$ /&6 =#&F51 R;; 7/5 E"#;F_6 > 67>K5+ D>;;67#v< -$F5#6."#56+ >$F:>6>$"4> />6 =5."; &;&7&56 9"# #5I#565$7>7&"$6 "9 :>6>$"4> &$Q-#"I5>$ .-;7-#>; 7&"$6 "9 7/&6 9>6.&$>7&"$+ >$F 7" 5ZI;"#5 7/5 6".&"N/&67"#&.>; 9"-$F>7&"$61 ?/5 54&F5$.5 I#565$75F /5#5 57&.>;;8 6-KK56767/>7 7/5 :/54>;&5# F5 P5&$K>;7 E>6 .>$"$&^5F $"7 "$;8 =5.>-65 "9 /&69"#=;5 95>76 &$ 7/5 ="-F" ?/5 >II5>; "9 7/5 :>6>$"4> 7/5


19/23

!?E

+6/6&6 5789:;;< "=!!>"=!"

&$.5$7&456 9"# 7/5 ."$.>75$>7&"$1 b$ Q-#"I5_6 9-$.7&"$>;;8 F&995#5$7&>75F6".&57&56+ &$7&.8 />6 =5." 6>$"4> />6 ."K&. /5#" 7/>7 /5#"&.>;;8 9>.56 7/&6 ./>;;5$K5+ 7/5 ./>;;5$K5"9 ;"45 &$ 7/5 7K-56 7/>7 &$ 7/5 ; &$75#5676 .">;56.51 b$ /&6 2+)3$#4$5 /&I",1+34 + /5 ."$.;-F56 7/>7 7/5 &$F&4&F->; 7"F>8 &$ I>#7 6-=67>$7&>756&76 6".&>; 5Z&675$.5 =8 .";&781 [b7 &67/#"-K/ 65Z\+ H"-.>-;7 >665#76+ [7/>7 5>./ &$F&4&F->; />6 7" I>66 &$ "#F5#7" />45 >..566 7" /&6 "E$ &$75;;&K&=&;&78 l111m+ 7" 7/5 E/";5 "9 /&6 ="F8 l111m+7" /&6 &F5$7&78 l111m\ T'VVNVhW1 ?/565 >#5 &6&$K $-#7&.-;># >FF#56656 7/5 K#"E&$K 75$F5$.8 7" F&6K5>$F 7" 6&II#">./ 7" &$7&.8+q-/$$ "=65#456+ &6 5;"a-5$7 "9 >$ ["45#F575#B&$K 7/5< 65#&"-6;8\ TL']W1?/565 I#"=;5#&65 9#"< 7/5 $55F 7" -I/";F 7/5 &;;-6&"$ "9."E>8 E&7/ ##&>K5+;"45#6 >;;54&>75 7/5 #5;>7&"$6/&I "9 /8I5#=";&. 5ZI5.7>7&"$6 e c"$5$566+_c575#$&78+_ 57.1 e >$F 7/-6 $5-7#>;&^5 I"75$7&>; >#5>6 "9 ."$9;&.7+ 857 E&7/"-7.>;;&$K &$7" a-567&"$ 7/5 &$67&7-7&"$ "9 ;"45 &765;91 [A"7 7" ##8 5ZI#56656 >B&$F "9 #565#4>7&"$ e =-7 &$ > E>8+ 7/>7 >4"&F6 68K>&$67 7/5 ="$F&$K 68$F 6I&7->;&78+ E"-;F5Z."#&>75 7/5 .>;;"-6$566 "9 7/5 67#>75K&. 75;8 $55F6 9&K-#56 ;&B5 :>6>$"4>+ >6> -7/"# ."


20/23

!?F

2.'@$%+ #%**+/@

7/565 ."$4&.7&"$6 7" I>I5#+ 857 #>#5;8 >6 ."$.&65;8 >$F 57&.>;;8 >6 &$/&6 '(LV #54&5E "9 7/5 2+)3$#4 $5 >4 ?+5& 1 [P"-7&"$6+[65567+ 6"7 :>6>$"4> />F+ >$F 7/>7 "-# I>#5$76 />F+ >$F 7/>7 "-# "E$ 8"-7/ />F>$F E/&./ &$9-65F "-# 8"-7/ E&7/ K&.@ 7/5 45$5#>7&"$ 9"# ;"45 l111m1?"F>8+ $5&7/5# 7/5 7#>K&.+ $"# 7/5 4-"6&. ;"45#6 655< 7" 5Z&67 >$865 ##&>K5 &7/ l111m1 H#"< ="#&$K="-#K5"&6 R 7" 7/5 #5FF567 P"4&57 6".&>;&6< e &$ $" 7#-;8 c8 >$8 "7/5# I>#7 7/>$ 7/>7 "9 > $&^5F =8 > 95E/8K&5$&. #5.&I56\ T[w=5# :>6>$"4>\ ]U]N]UVW1 D5665 E&6/56 9"# E>8 9#"< 7/5 ./>;;5$K56 "9 ;"45 >$F 7" 5.5 7/&65665$7&>; 5ZI5#&5$.5 "9 7/5 /-$ ."$F&7&"$1 f#+ &$ "7/5# E"#F6@ D5665=5;&5456 7/>7 ;&77;5 1

P55$ &$ 7/&6 ;&K/7+ 7/5 7&7;5 "9 D5665_6 6/"#7 67"#8 @,),;&5#+ E5>#8 9#"< > 65#&56 "9 F45$7-#56/5 6-995#5F &$ :";"K$5 >$F P7-77K>#7+ />6 X-67 >##&45F &$ `-#&./ E/5$ /5F5.&F56 7" #5$"-$.5 7/5 E"#;F >$F 5$75# 7/5 f#F5# "9 P>&$7 !5$5F&.7 >77/5 Q&$6&5F5;$ R==581 D"E545#+ > 95E /"-#6 =59"#5 /5 &6 7" ." 95;5 7#>45;;5# =#&$K6 7/&6 I;>$

7" $"-K/71 ?/&6+ >$F $"7 :>6>$"4>_6 I>66&$K 6>$.7&8+ [9>#5E5;;+K"FF566 "9 9"#7-$5+ b />45 #5>./5F 7/5 I"#7\ T[:>6>$"4>6 !5B5/#-$K\VL'W+ 7/5 :/54>;&5# >..5I76 /&6 9>75 >6 >$ R/>6-5#-6 "9 ;"45+ F567&$5F 7"575#$>;;8 E>$F5# 7/5 5>#7/ &$ 65>#./ "9 #5F5$ >;; ."$.5$7#>7&"$ 7/55Z&675$.5 "9 7/5 /5#" &6 I-7 7" 7#&>; >$F F5.&F5F1 ?/5 :/54>;&5# &6 I-6/5F7" > I"&$7 E/5#5 /5 ;;8 .";&781 ,-./ 7" 7/5 6>7&69>.7&"$ "9 7/5 #5>F5#+ :>6>$"4>."$45#76 7" /&6 c7#-5 65;9_ e 9"# E/"< 5;65 ."-;F 7/5 #5>F5# ;""B 7"+ &9 7/5/5#" />F 6&


21/23

!A=

+6/6&6 5789:;;< "=!!>"=!"

?@' ?/5 K,C&) @,),8 &$ i&5$$> Ti"; *+ :/1 'LW1 ?/5 ;>67 7 2-Z &$ 'U(L F> 0"$75#5."-$76 &$ /&6 N&>$#+& Ti";1 L+ 071 '+ hNL*W1

* D-6658 =>656 /&6 >$>;86&6 "$ >F7 E5#5 9"-$F&$ :>6>$"4>_6 567>75 >$F 7/>7 6/"E 6&K$&9&.>$7 6&7&56 E&7/ 7/5 "I5$&$K"9 R.7 bb@ [?/5 "$;8 "7/5# 7/&$K 7/>7 655.76&6 7/>7 7/58 >#5 $"7 _6 />$FE#&7&$K "9 > 6.5$59#"< c2"$ J&"4>$$&1_ D5 E"-;F+ &$F55F+ />#F;8 />45 ."I&5F 7/5< "-7 >6

I&5.56 "9 I"57#8 E"#7/ #5."#F&$K1 ?/5 &$.".7 7/>7 7/58>#5 4>#&>$76 "9 7/5 6>$F >="45 >;;+ 7/5 $- 6.5$5 &$ 7/5 "I5#>1 ?/>77/58 >#5 &$75$F5F 9"# 7/5 c2"$ J&"4>$$&+_ E/&./ E5 B$"E >6 ,"^>#7_6+ >$F$"7 9"# 6"$ />#F;8 =5 F"-=75F+ 6&$.5 7/5 65$65 "9 7/5E"#F6 >$F 7/5 6&7->7&"$ ."&$.&F5 6" .;"65;8 E&7/ E/>7 67>$F6 &$ 7/5 >.7->;6."#51 b7 &6 .;5>#+ 7/5$+ 7/>7 :>6>$"4> F&F 6"$F &7 &6/&K/;8 &$8 I#>.7&.>; I-#I"65\ T]U'W1

] b$ 'U)U+ :>6>$"4> />F 857 7" =5K&$ E"#B "$ /&6 4 ?+5& 1h b$F55F+ :>6>$"4> a-&.B;8 9&$F6 6";>.5 &$ 7/5 ># &6 ;>#K5;8 =>65F "$ 7/5 i>-F54&;;5 @,),#&$ >$F 25645#K561) :";6" ."$6&F5#&$K 9>.7"#6

6-./ >6 I#&"# B$"E;5FK5+ I#>K7&. -$F5#67>$F&$K+ 5; &$75;;&K5$.5+57.1 Tq>B"99 >$F g"/$6"$ ''W1

( ?/&6 65.7&"$ #5;&56 "$ 7/5 E"#B "9 A&B;>6 q-/$$+ E/" I#"4&F56 >

..-$7&>; F&6.-66&"$ "9 9-$.7&"$>; F&995#5$7&>7&"$ &$ q-/$$+ A&B;>61E&)&11)06,53))3#"B3"# ",


22/23

!A!

2.'@$%+ #%**+/@

A!A9!=BC*DEF

D$)./$G @%'$(72R#>K"+ x7&5$$5+ 25645#K56+ >$F i>#&$1 :>6>$"4> >- 9"#7 P>&$7NR$F#t@ :".756+ $1 QF1 ?#-$ J1 P7599>$+ Q1 P7599>$ >$F G&;;&6

G1 0#>771 A5E D>45$@ O>;5 3$&45#6&78 0#566+ '()L1:>6>$"4> F5 P5&$K>;7+ g>.a-561 D&67" F5 4&5@ xF&7&"$ &$7tK#>;51 QF1 R$K5;&B>

Dz=6./5# >$F R#7/-# Dz=6./5#1 'L 4";61 0>#&6@ 0;"$+ '(hMNhL1:>6>$"4>+ J&>.".5 { G"#;F@ '(hhNU'1F> 0"$75+ q"#5$^"1 ,5 :5$5F>1 * i";61 A-"4>N

g"#.>@ !-$.5+ ')L(N*M1

F> 0"$75+ q"#5$^"+ >$F G";9K>$K RF5-6 ,"^>#71 2"$ J&"4>$$&@ q&=#577" Q$K;&6/{ b7>;&>$1 ?#>$61 R$F> >$F R$7/"$8 D";F5$1 q"$F"$@ 25-76./+ '()U1

H5;;&$&+ H5F5#&."+ F H5;;&$&_6 :>6>$"4>1 05#91 2"$>;F P-7/5#;>$F+ ?&$> R-##I&77>+ f;& :>#;&6&1 3$&45#6>; P7-F&"6+ LM''12i21

D5665+ D5#$$1 [:>6>$"4>6 !5B5/#-$K\1 P|$B9-#7 >1,1@ P-/#B>1 05#91 D5>7/ q5FK5#+ P&5$> ,&;;5#+ g5#5$9#5F D"II51H#>$B9-#7 >1,1@ P1 H&6./5#+ '((L1 (VN'UU1

q"#7^&$K+ R;=5#71 :>6>$"4>@ S"./ 5&$5<

9#>$^v6&6./5$ i>-F54&;;5 9#5& =5>#=5&7571 q5&I^&K@ !#5&7B"I9 -$F D|#75;+ ')]L1q"658+ g"65I/+ F ,"^>#7 e 2"$ J&"4>$$&1 05#91 C-KK&5#" C>&.-#F8+ QFF> ,"65#+ >$F S& ?5 S>$>E>1 P"$8 0&.7-#56 D"&$$61 JE8$$5QFE>#F61 G>#


23/23

!A"

+6/6&6 5789:;;< "=!!>"=!"

@7(%"&/$G @%'$(72\:>6>$"4>_6 ,5_6 q>67 RF45$7-#5\1 A;5 F5 H#>$.5+ 'h ,>#./ LM'M1 G5=1 ' g-$5 LM'L1

R66$$+ g>$1 7,) B"13"#&11& E&9F063$"4>6 ,5#8 LM'M1 G5=1 L),>#./ LM'L1

H"-.>-;7+ ,&./5;1 U6& 2+)3$#4 $5 /&I",1+34- ($1">& L- .< L-66+ D>$6 C"=5#71 [q&75#>#8 D&67"#8 >6 > :/>;;5$K5 7" q&75#>#8 ?/5"#81\ J&;?+3,#4 2+)3$#4 L1' T'(UMW@ UN*U1

q>B"99+ J5"#K5+ >$F ,>#B g"/$6"$1 N&3,%6$#) =& ?+8& A4 1 :/&.>K"@ 3$&45#6&78"9 :/&.>K" 0#566+ '()M1

q-/$$+ A&B;>61 ?+&:& ,1) K,))+$1,1@ P-/#B>FB>-+ g">./& >$F c2"$ J&"4>$$&_\1 U6& N")+0,1 U+>&)'L(1'U]) T'())W@ V*'1

`E5&K+ P759>$1 .9&%3) +< /&15OK$#3#,+3"#&- @,),-;

:5F>#1 A5E O"#B@ ?/5 i&B&$K 0#566+ '(L)1

casanova love in the time of

Documents