california commercial real estate investor panel: office, retail and industrial executives discuss...
TRANSCRIPT
Timing Matters
DISTRESSED REAL ESTATE SUMMIT: CALIFORNIA
Fred CordovaFebruary 4, 2010
CRE Value & the 4th Dimension
January 1, 2009
Capital Markets• EPS – $49.51• S&P 500 - $932• Commodities – C: $1.45• Home Inventory – 11 Mo
CRE GLA Office Market• Effective Rent - $29.29• Vacancies – 10.9%• Values - $180-$300• Sales Volume – 4Q08: $200m
2009’s Wild Ride
Capital MarketInstitutional $
January 1, 2010
Capital Markets• EPS - $56.21/ F: $74.98• S&P 500 - $1126 (15.25 X F)• Commodities – C: $3.40• Home Inventory - TBD
CRE GLA Office Market• Effective rents - $26.41• Vacancies – 13.5%• Values - $180-$300 psf• Sales Volume – Q4 $200m
2009’s Wild Ride
Capital MarketInstitutional $Lender / ServicerForeign / Private $
Where are we now?
Economy is
Bottoming GLA Fundamentals
Still Weakening
Capital Markets Surging
CRE Markets
Enter Capitulati
on
Where are we now?
S&P is up > 65% from 3/9/09 lowCommodity prices are surgingFeds proceeding with TALFCMBS II is underwayREIT stocks have rebounded
$1.5 to $2.0 T CRE debt to be restructuredFundamentals still deterioratingValues still dropping Cap rate spreads over T’s are 2 x normTransaction pipeline is dry
• Unemployment >10%; Under Emp > 17%
• Consumers => savers; deleveraging• EPS flattens without top line revenue
growth• Federal, state, local deficits mounting
• Office: vacancy 55 msf (18%); some mkts > 20%• Industrial: availability 182 msf (12.43%); some mkts >
25%• Retail: rents in free fall; vacancies 20% to 50%• Multi-family: eff rents down > 25%; econ vacancy 40%• Development pipeline is dry across all
Office Values and Sales Volumes Plummeted in 2009
5.5%
6.0%
6.5%
7.0%
7.5%
8.0%
8.5%
9.0%
9.5%
Los Angeles 12-mo. avg
Los Angeles quarterly avg
US quarterly avg
CAP RATE (non-wtd)
$100
$150
$200
$250
$300
$350
$400
Q1'03
2 3 4Q1'04
2 3 4Q1'05
2 3 4Q1'06
2 3 4Q1'07
2 3 4Q1'08
2 3 4Q1'09
2 3
PRICE $/sq.ft. $233.1
$0.00
$2.00
$4.00
$6.00
$8.00
$10.00
$12.00
$14.00
$0.9
1$0
.91
$0.8
7$1
.54
$1.1
9$1
.17
$1.7
2$1
.46
$1.5
8$1
.86
$1.9
8$1
.12
$0.7
9$3
.77
$1.7
2$3
.78
$4.0
9$2
.42 $3
.34
$1.4
5$1
.39
$0.6
9$0
.71
$0.2
2$0
.06
$0.2
1$0
.28
rolling 12-mo. total
quarterly vol.
VOLUME in bil
Source: RCA Q3 -09
2009’s Wild Ride
Recapitalizing CRE2000 - 2010
With Values down 40%-50%,
most equity is GONE
Source: Emerging Trends in Real Estate (PWC/ULI)
Looks Ominous
$1.8T Bank debt is near term concern $215B near term CMBS will “extend and mend”
Source: Emerging Trends in Real Estate (PWC/ULI)
Debt Maturities
But is Manageable