business assessment of rising inflation in india
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/11/2019 Business Assessment of Rising Inflation in India
1/12
1 Business Analysis II Group Assignment
BUSINESS ANALYSIS - II
GROUP ASSIGNMENT
BY
DEEPAK SINGH (36452)
SAMEER KUDHALE (36467)
SANJEEV MHASAWADE (36468)
SAURABH R. DESHPANDE (36470)
SUYOG MOTGHARE (36476)
EXE. MBAII
DIV - B
-
8/11/2019 Business Assessment of Rising Inflation in India
2/12
2 Business Analysis II Group Assignment
QWhat is the bigger problem in India ? Growth or Inflation ? Justify
your answer.
A
Out of the two, inflation is a bigger problem in India as compared to lack
of growth. India, in spite of being Asias third largest economy, is still
stuck at growth less than 5% while inflation is rising at a faster pace
(around 10%).
India has demonstrated remarkable reliance in the past with respect to
growth. Even during global financial crisis, when the world was
recording very low growth, India grew at a reasonable rate. There is a
underlying dynamism in Indias economic growth.
On the other hand, India is chronically supply-constrained. This increases
inflation which is also a bigger problem for the poor. The biggest
problem of high inflation is that it reduces the purchasing power of
money. Investments are damaged as returns on deposits are lower.
Purchase of non-financial assets like real estate and gold is encouraged
due to high inflation, thus contributing to the widening of Indias current
account deficit.
Figure 1 - Impact of Inflation on Economy
High Inflation
Lesser
PurchasingPower
Lesser Savings
Lesser
Demand
LesserProduction
Shrinking ofEconomy
-
8/11/2019 Business Assessment of Rising Inflation in India
3/12
3 Business Analysis II Group Assignment
Major reasons for Indias sustained high inflation are as follows
o Supply Side Bottleneck, Limited Infrastructure & Inadequate
Manufacturing Growth
o Weak Public Distribution System
o
Deregulation of Energy Prices
o Persistent Double Digit Food Inflation
o Unbalanced Economic Growth
o Increase in Spending Due to Govt. Schemes
o Rising Import Prices
o Indias Ever Growing Population
It is a debate whether Indian government should takes steps to reduce
inflation or the RBI should adapt easy monetary stance, risking inflation
rise but making an effort to curb growth. However, inflation being the
bigger devil, steps need to be taken to control inflation in India.
Supply in India is constant due to lack of investment while demand is
ever increasing due to population growth. To control inflation, this huge
gap needs to be filled. To achieve this, capacity of present production
units need to be increased or new ones need to be build.
Infrastructure should be build and utilized efficiently to bring down
prices. Lesser dependence on foreign liquidity and higher productivity is
also the key to lowering inflation.
Population should be made more literate and educated rather than feeding
them on food security programs which ultimately add to Indias fiscal
deficit.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
QWhat is the IIP ? How does it help to understand growth levels in
India ?
A
Index of Industrial Production (IIP) is one of the Prime indicators of the
economic development for the measurement of trend in the behaviour of
Industrial Production over a period of time.
Index of Industrial Production (IIP) is an index which details out the
growth of various sectors in an economy.
The period of time that is used for measurement is called the base year.
-
8/11/2019 Business Assessment of Rising Inflation in India
4/12
4 Business Analysis II Group Assignment
Index of Industrial Production (IIP) is an abstract number, the magnitude
of which represents the status of production in the industrial sector for a
given period of time as compared to a reference period of time.
Currently base year of India for IIP is 2004-05. Indian IIP particularly
focuses on Manufacturing, Mining and Electricity with the biggest weight
given to Manufacturing sector i.e. 75%. The all India IIP is compiled and
published monthly by Central Statistics Office (CSO) with the time lag of
six weeks from the reference month.
Its important for the Government and RBI to frame their respective
policies adequately and also as its being released monthly and has up to
date report of the performance of different Industries, Government can
take required measures on time .So that the policies eventually turn out
helping the Industrial growth. IIP also has a significant impact on the
stock market as continuous poor IIP could lead to lower stock valuation
because of which foreign investors could pull out their money in the
market and which results into weakening of Rupee.
Recent revision of IIP released by CSO with 2004-05 as the base year
comprises 682 items. This index shall give a better picture of growth in
various sectors of the economy, because it is broader and includes
technologically advanced goods such as cell phones and iPods. The
previous base year (199394) was not usable as the list contained an array
of outdated items such as typewriters and tape recorders.
Weighted arithmetic mean of quantity relatives with weights being
allotted to various items in proportion to value added by manufacture in
the base year by using Laspeyres' formula :
I = summation (Wi*Ri) / summation (Wi)
where
I is the index of industrial production
Ri is the production relative of the ith item for the month in question
Wi is the weight allotted to it.
IIP is compiled using data received from 16 source agencies viz.
Department of Industrial Policy & Promotion (DIPP); Indian Bureau of
Mines; Central Electricity Authority; Joint Plant Committee; Ministry of
Petroleum & Natural Gas; Office of Textile Commissioner; Department
of Chemicals & Petrochemicals; Directorate of Sugar; Department of
-
8/11/2019 Business Assessment of Rising Inflation in India
5/12
5 Business Analysis II Group Assignment
Fertilizers; Directorate of Vanaspati, Vegetable Oils & Fats; Tea Board;
Office of Jute Commissioner; Office of Coal Controller; Railway Board;
Office of Salt Commissioner and Coffee Board.
India is big in mining sector and has to encourage with different
beneficiary policies. Mining sector helps for manufacturing as well as
electricity generation sector.
Indian market should be made more aggressive on the Indian made
product in the consumer durable sector, more and more manufacturing
should be encourage with quality product output. Indian consumer should
be attracted more towards Indian products which will help in
strengthening the GDP of the country.
More focus should have to be given on Petroleum and Natural gas
resources, the import should have to bring down to margin and grow
Rupee strength.
Investment revival in India should be given more focus which will give
upturn in manufacturing sector.
India would need policy framework that would encourage the capital
goods sector, which at moment is falling drastically and contractions.
In India we observe the Industrial production higher in few months like in
October November as it is big festive season and a boom of purchase in
Indian market.
Currently the scenario showing saturation in manufacturing sector, India
has to rely more on agriculture and service sector.
Finance minister has always to make a note of IIP and has to address in
the budget the positive beneficiary steps towards industries to bail out
them from falling situation. At moment we see in India more capital is
wasted on the unwanted and unnecessary bills passed by standing
government just for vote bank purpose keeping aside the Indian economicgrowth and GDP growth.
So IIP does not merely an index for measuring the industrial growth but
impact our economy significantly.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
8/11/2019 Business Assessment of Rising Inflation in India
6/12
6 Business Analysis II Group Assignment
QWhy is it the case that WPI inflation is far lesser than CPI inflation in
India ?
A
A consumer price index (CPI)measures changes in the price level of
a market basket of consumer goods and services purchased by
households. The CPI is a statistical estimate constructed using the prices
of a sample of representative items whose prices are collected
periodically. Sub-indexes are computed for different categories and sub-
categories of goods and services, being combined to produce the overall
index with weights reflecting their shares in the total of the consumer
expenditures covered by the index. The annual percentage change in a
CPI is used as a measure of inflation. A CPI can be used to index (i.e.,
adjust for the effect of inflation) the real value of wages, salaries,
pensions, for regulating prices and for deflating monetary magnitudes to
show changes in real values.
However for calculation of Wholesale Price Index (WPI), a set of 435
commodities and their price changes are used for the calculation. The
selected commodities are supposed to represent various consumers
belonging to difference financial backgrounds and are supposed to give a
comprehensive WPI value for the economy.
WPI is calculated on a base year and WPI for the base year is assumed to
be 100. To show the calculation, lets assume the base year to be 1970.
The data of wholesale prices of all the 435 commodities in the base year
and the time for which WPI is to be calculated is gathered.
WPI inflation is calculated using formula:
(WPI of end of yearWPI of beginning of year)/WPI of beginning of
year x 100
The divergence in the food inflation data in the two indices is largely due
to:
o CPI does include data from PDS (Public Distribution System)
shops. In WPI, when we take cereals, only the market price is
reflected, while in CPI cereals prices are calculated taking into
account the weighted average price between the market price and
-
8/11/2019 Business Assessment of Rising Inflation in India
7/12
7 Business Analysis II Group Assignment
public distribution system price. The PDS price is constant so it
tends to pull down the CPI food inflation.
o CPI is calculated on prices at the retail level whereas WPI is done
using prices at the mandi level. I.e. WPI accounts for changes in
general price level of goods at wholesale level, it fails to
communicate actual burden borne by the end consumer.
o The Wholesale Price Index focuses (WPI) on the price of goods
traded between corporations (wholesalers or producers).
o As data used in CPI was collected by the government from shops
where the prices of food products were artificially controlled to
paint a better picture for consumer inflation. If the price data taken
is actually from shops where the prices are controlled, which does
not accurately reflect the rise in food prices.
o Commodity compositions as well as weightage used causes
difference in WPI and CPI. For example, high weightage of food
prices in calculation of CPI. In the WPI, food articles have a
14.33% weight. In the CPI (Rural+Urban), the food index has a
47% weight. 47% weight in CPI makes WPI very less as compared
to WPI.
o The widening gap between prices at wholesale level and retail level
can be because of supply chain issues which impede the process of
smooth distribution of goods. Post-production hurdles at several
levels including storage, packaging, marketing and infrastructure is
a major fuel to retail prices.
Thus to summarize, the computation of CPI takes into account price
changes and the actual inflation that affects the end consumer. CPI is thus
a reflection of changes in the retail prices of specified goods and services
over a time period which is traded by particular consumer group. But due
to incorrect weight of food articles, soaring prices of fuel and
measurement of indexes at different level with distinct methodologies and
introduction of (supply chain) additional cost burden WPI inflation is far
lesser than CPI inflation in India.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
8/11/2019 Business Assessment of Rising Inflation in India
8/12
8 Business Analysis II Group Assignment
QWhy did the RBI Governor not raise rates on 1stApril 2014 policy
review even when the inflation continues to be a concern ?
A
The RBI has kept the policy repo rate under the liquidity adjustment
facility (LAF) unchanged at 8.0 per cent and the cash reserve ratio (CRR)
of scheduled banks unchanged at 4.0 per cent on the basis of an
assessment of the current and evolving macroeconomic situation.
In its assessment, RBI said that outlook for global growth continues to
remain moderate with an uneven recovery across industrial countries
while pointing out that activity in major emerging market economies
barring China has decelerated on account of weak domestic demand even
though there has been some improvement in export performance.
The central bank's policy is firmly focused on curbing inflation - The
Bank's policy stance will be firmly focussed on keeping the economy on
a disinflationary glide path that is intended to hit 8 percent CPI inflation
by January 2015 and 6 percent by January 2016. The Consumer Price
Index (CPI) inflation eased to 8.1 per cent in February while the
Wholesale Price Index (WPI) slowed to a 9-month low of 4.68 per cent.
The RBI Governor Raghuram Rajan has said that if inflation continues
along the intended glide path, further policy tightening in the near term is
not anticipated at this moment.
It is appropriate to hold the policy rate while allowing the rate increases
undertaken during September 2013-January 2014 to work their way
through the economy.
Risks to the central forecast of 8 percent CPI inflation by January 2015
stem from a less-than-normal monsoon predicted due to possible El Nino
effects. However, food production will decline because of this issomething that cannot be taken for granted. There is a lot of uncertainty.
If foodprices do increase, itll need to be evaluated if it is a temporary or
a permanent phenomenon and then accordingly take a call on the policy.
Retail inflation measured by the consumer price index (CPI) moderated
for the third month in succession in February 2014, driven lower by the
sharp disinflation in food prices, although prices of fruits, milk and
products have started to firm up. Excluding food and fuel, however, retail
inflation remained sticky at around 8 per cent. This suggests that somedemand pressures are still at play.
-
8/11/2019 Business Assessment of Rising Inflation in India
9/12
9 Business Analysis II Group Assignment
Rajan has said that RBI will wait for some more data before taking any
policy action. While there has been a significant fall in vegetable prices at
both wholesale and retail level, current inflation is still too high.
He stated that the RBI will not react to any spike in inflation that is
temporary in nature.
Rajan may also want to wait for a glimpse of the next government's
economic policies as well as the outlook for monsoon season rains that
begin in June before making a policy move.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
QIf you were the Finance Minister of the new Government, what would
be the chief three policies you would try to announce in the budget in June
2014 ?
A
In the economy of a developing country like India, the role of the Finance
Minister is a crucial one. This is even more crucial in the case of the
country which has chosen path of planned development, just like Indian.
However it equally becomes difficult when Government is not formed by
a single party unanimously. However as a part of commitment towardsreforming Indian economy following are the policies which I might try to
announce in the budget in June 2014:
Revising tax structure by utilizing black money invested in other
countries :
If I ever get the opportunity to become Finance Minister of this country, I
will first try to bring back all black money residing outside of the country.
It is black money which is one of the key reasons of increase in inflationand to the rise in prices, and this makes financial control almost
impossible. One more primary reason of targeting black money is that
no tax is paid on this money. Thus for heavy amounts of black money,
government receives no benefit. Government receives no money which
can be used for common mansalaried people and business community
of the society. Due to huge amount of presence of black money, if I could
bring back this black money, it would help me lessen burden on the tax
structure of the society. With a more reasonable and fair tax - structure,the temptation to evade taxes, would no longer be there.
-
8/11/2019 Business Assessment of Rising Inflation in India
10/12
10 Business Analysis II Group Assignment
Handling Growth and Inflation in a long term is extremely crucial as it
directly affects dayto-day living. Since black money is the money on
which tax has not been paid, I will see to it that that evasion is reduced to
a minimum. With this end in view, tax structure will be rationalized. The
taxation rate will be brought down so as to provide relief to the salaried
people as well as to the business community. With a more reasonable tax
- structure, the temptation to evade taxes, would no longer be there.
Those who still avoid payment of direct taxes, plugged, so that tax-
evaders are not able to escape the law. All anti-social elements of the
society who run a kind of parallel economy, would also be severely dealt
with Laws in this respect would also be made more stringent, and the
concerned Government officials would be given more power to deal with
such offenders. In this way, the inflation rate would be brought down, and
relief provided to the people, groaning under the burden of rising prices
and increasing taxation.
Lower subsidies :
It is always said that inflation is a tax on whole society while subsidies is
tax on the subset of society. This statement makes a lot of sense in
reality even when needs and consumption patterns of individuals vary
based on their financial capabilities.
Subsidies provided on different types of commodities are till now seen as
governments contribution towards welfare of the society. But in the past,
government has been spending a lot on subsidies which has drastically
increased governments expenditure. These subsidies for imported
expensive goods such as petrol, diesel contributes to the large
Government expenditure thus increasing governments need of money.
However subsidies on the consumable commodities do not really
contribute to the Gross Domestic Productivity (GDP) of the country.
They just act as Social Welfare expenditure which puts huge burden on
the Indian Economy. So I will take some measures to reduce subsidies if I
become Finance Minister of this country. This reduction in subsidies can
be implemented based on two criterias :
o Category of commodities
o Financial capabilities of consumers consuming commodity
Category of commodities is extremely important when deciding on the
subsidies. For example, I would prefer giving out subsidies for cooking
-
8/11/2019 Business Assessment of Rising Inflation in India
11/12
11 Business Analysis II Group Assignment
fuel over Motor fuel. Financial capabilities of consumers consuming
commodity can also be one of the factors. For example, removing
subsidies on diesel may have a severe impact on society and inflation
because the fact that most of the commercial vehicles which are used in
the movement of goods run on diesel. On the contrary, the impact of
removing subsidies may be lesser on petrol as it is being used in mostly
personal cars segment.
Improvements in credit facilities through bank networking :
In order to increase growth in the country inflation needs to be control as
inflation never adds up to the Gross Domestic Productivity (GDP) within
the country. But whenever topic of GDP comes into picture, it is usually
associated with multiple factors. One of those factors can be investments.
For any large scale or small scale industry/businesses to increase its
production, needs money to invest. This money is needed for numerous
reasons starting from purchasing raw materials to strengthening
distribution channels. In short in order to improve GDP, availability or
supply of money is required for business to grow and increase their
production. In order to achieve this, from governments standpoint, I will
see to it that credit facilities are liberalized. Banking services will be
extended to the rural areas i.e. improving bank network. With this end in
view, banks will be encouraged to open their braches even in remote
villages. Indian farmer is poor, and owning to his poverty and illiteracy
he has always been exploited by the local money lenders.
Instructions will be used to the banks (through the Reserve Bank of India)
that the needy farmers be given loans on easy and liberal terms. This will
enable them to purchase good quality seeds, fertilizers, tractors, etc.
Agriculture would thus be modernized and this would lead to increase
production. Construction of tube-wells would also be encouraged and
villages would be rapidly electrified, so that agriculture production is no
longer at the mercy of rains.
While I will continue to encourage large scale industries, the growth of
small industries would also be encouraged. They would also be provided
with soft loans by the nationalized banks, and if need be more banks
would be nationalized. Technicians, live T.V and Radio mechanics,
Internet, professional people like Doctors and other self-employed
people, would also be given financial help by the banks.
-
8/11/2019 Business Assessment of Rising Inflation in India
12/12
12 Business Analysis II Group Assignment
All these measures, I hope, would go a long way toward revamping the
Indian economy. Still, if considered necessary, I will not hesitate to
accept foreign aid or to take loans from International Financial
Institutions like the I.M.F Funds would also be raised through borrowings
from the public. However, I am hopeful that such measures would not be
necessary. To summarize, it is extremely difficult to implement policies
considering Indias political, current economic situation.However,
reduction in fiscal deficit, better credit facilities, inflation reduction
targeting policies by revision of tax structure, reduction in non-planned
expenditure and lowering the subsidies can be couple of policies that I
would focus on primarily if I become Finance Minister of India.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------