antarctic impulsive transient antenna university of hawaii at manoa peter gorham, pi john learned...

42
ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and Amy Connelly versity of California, Los Angeles id Saltzburg Washington University Bob Binns and Marty Israel University of Delaware John Clem , David Seckel Katy Mulrey and Peng Cao University of Kansas David Besson University College London Ryan Nichol National Taiwan University Jiwoo Nam Jet Propulsion Laboratory Kurt Liewer, Charles Naudet and Andres

Upload: oliver-clifton-hubbard

Post on 19-Jan-2016

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna

University of Hawaii at ManoaPeter Gorham, PI

John Learned and Gary S. Varner

Ohio-State UniversityJim Beatty and Amy Connelly

University of California, Los AngelesDavid Saltzburg

Washington UniversityBob Binns and Marty Israel

University of DelawareJohn Clem , David Seckel Katy Mulrey and Peng Cao

University of KansasDavid Besson

University College LondonRyan Nichol

National Taiwan UniversityJiwoo Nam

Jet Propulsion LaboratoryKurt Liewer, Charles Naudet and Andres Romero-Wolf

Page 2: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

If GZK (Greisen–Zatsepin–Kuzmin)process is the source of the UHE cutoff

What can we learn from studying EeV neutrinos?

UHE neutrinos may be observed as byproducts of the GZK process, or they may be observed from the same astrophysical sources that produce UHECR.

UHECR provide only local source information Cosmic Accelerators likely to evolve in many ways: strength, metallicity, number density, … GZK neutrino spectra are direct from sources at all epochs

UHECR propagate through intergalactic space filled with the 3K cosmic microwave background radiation blue shifted to GeV gamma in CM frame

Page 3: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

How can we measure EeV neutrinos? Detection of neutrinos requires a target for conversion of the UHE neutrino to a high-energy particle cascade, followed by observation of electromagnetic radiation signatures of the particle cascade.

“Shower” is actually a thin disk of HE particlesA few mm thick and few cm wide in solidsAt radio wavelengths longer than ~10-20 cm: appears as a single charge of Z~108 Z2=1016 x single e-

Particle cascades result in an evolving population of electrons, positrons, and photons.– Positrons are depleted by in-flight annihilation.– Additional electrons are upscattered from the medium.– The net effect is a negative charge excess (~20%) in the shower moving relativistically.

Askaryan effect: coherent Cherenkov light

Coherent Cherenkov Radiation at long wavelengths!

At smaller wavelengths, Cherenkov light experiencesdestructive interference from electrons at different parts of the shower.

Shower

Page 4: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

Askaryan emission from two simulations for a 100 TeV primary neutrinoAs the observation moves away from the Cerenkov angle, the frequency cutoff amplitude.

Page 5: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

silica salt ice

“Askaryan” effect have been confirm in these materials

Select materials with long attenuation lengths in the RF have been tested at SLAC in a photon and electron beams.

Page 6: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

For ANITA, the target is the Antarctic ice, which is observed from balloon altitudes.

ANITA field of view

The combination of the Antarctic polar vortex, providing excellent coverage of the large areas of very deep ice, and the remarkable radio-frequency clarity of ice leads to ANITA’s essential methodology:

The radio emission from a neutrino-initiated cascade is beamed into a radio-Cherenkov ring, which must then point toward ANITA’s direction for detection

A radio-triggered waveform recorder using an antenna array to observe nearly the entire lower hemisphere, with an effective target of order a million cubic km of ice in view at any time.

Page 7: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

Cerenkov is linearly polarized perpendicular to cascade momentum and wave front

Askaryan signals originating in the ice strongly favor vertical polarizationOnly top of the cone escapes total internal reflection

Polarization

Page 8: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

provide superb impulse response & bandwidth

Seavey, dual-polarized horn antennas

Page 9: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

A photograph of the ANITA 1 balloon payload before launch in December2006, along with labels which indicate various important components of the experiment.

ANITA 1 Instrument

Broadband (0.2~1.2GHz) Antenna Array(Dual-polarized horn antennas)

Page 10: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

ANITA 1 Trigger/ Digitizer Data

Stream

Dual signal path: 1 for trigger and 1 for digitization

Use multiple frequency bands for trigger

Trigger Pattern requires > 3 antennas in both upper/lower rings (100-200kHz@Level1 trig.)

Digitizer only runs when triggered to save power

Page 11: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

ANITA-I Flight

Successful flight during 2006-2007 austral summer 35 days, 3.5 orbits

8.2M events recorded, 17.25 days of total cumulative live time

Launch(Dec 15 2006)

At float (38km)(Photo by James

Roth)

Landing

Page 12: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

CalibrationGround Based Pulser System

Borehole TX

ANITA

Surface TX

IceRF(200-300km)

System Verification

Trigger Test

Propagation and Surface

Timing / Angular

Resolution

Clear borehole pulse on event display and Trigger Pattern

Pulser Amplitude vs. distance

Page 13: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

Angular Resolution (Bore Hole Pulse

Events)zenith

azimuth

0.2o

0.8o

Excellent angular resolution

Reconstructed RF source positions

Payload positionDuring this segment

Page 14: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

Event Reconstruction

t (up-down)

Plane wave

RF direction

T = L / c

Angular reconstruction is a crucial part in the ANITA data analysis.

Powerful background rejection

Incoherent thermal events (99% of

data set)

Anthropogenic RF events from

existing bases

Angular reconstruction using

Interferometry.

Page 15: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 16: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 17: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 18: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 19: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 20: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 21: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 22: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 23: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 24: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 25: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 26: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 27: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

ANITA 2 InstrumentDec 2008

Page 28: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

Limits from IceCube and ANITA-2,along with, expected sensitivity for ANITA-3+4for a combined 100 days, and a wide range fluxmodel predictions for cosmogenic neutrinos.

Page 29: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

Neutrino signals vs. EAS signals

RF Cherenkov

neutrino

Shower ~10m length

(20% e- excess)

ANITA

EASANITA

Geomagnetic Field

Synchrotron Emission (H-pol.)

Cosmic Ray

Neutrino Detection RF Cherenkov by Askaryan Effect Low Frenel coeff. for tranverse

electric waves at the air-ice boundary. H-pol signal supressed Predominately V-pol

EAS Detection H-pol predominate RF signal by

geosynchrotron emission V-pol component is further

suppressed in the reflectionPredominately H-pol

V-pol predominate after refraction

Page 30: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

The analysis of the data from ANITA’s first flight found no neutrinos, but it did reveal asignificant above-background signal of horizontally polarized events

The measured signal polarizations in comparison to known geomagnetic field angles to show that the detected events have the signature of geosynchrotron emission.

Measured polarization angle versusgeomagnetic field angle, where the geomagnetic field angle has been modified by the vertical and horizontal Fresnel components for the angle of reflection observed in each event. The green line represents polarization along the direction of the Lorentz force

Page 31: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

Preliminary results from the SLAC T-510 experiment. A 1 kGauss vertical magnetic field is applied to an EM shower in dielectric producing a horizontally-polarized pulse that is otherwise absent. The beam pattern of the pulse is in good agreement with current simulations.

Page 32: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

ANITA 3 Hang Test8/7/2014

48 New Seavey Horns180- 1200 MHz band

Horizontal and VerticalPolarization Trigger

Ultra-light-weight deployable low-frequency quad-slot Hpol antenna with sensitivityover the 30-80 MHz band.

Page 33: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 34: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 35: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 36: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

Trigger/ Digitizer Data Stream

Dual signal path: 1 for trigger and 1 for digitization

Use multiple frequency bands for trigger

Trigger Pattern requires > 3 antennas in both upper/lower rings (100-200kHz@Level1 trig.)

Digitizer only runs when triggered to save power

Page 37: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

Data Analysis for Neutrino Hunting

An example of impulsive event

Blinding analysis to avoid biases, blinding 90% of data, use 10% for background study

Event selection criteria (1) Plane wave reconstruction (reject thermal noise) (2) Impulsive event selection (3) Anthropogenic background rejection -isolated from camps, isolated from other evnets (4) V-pol dominant event selection

Signal efficiency on data analysis is about 80%.

Page 38: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 39: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and
Page 40: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

48 dual-polarization radio antennas (180-1200 MHz)

ANITA 3

An incident neutrino interacting in the Antarctic ice would emit a radio Cherenkov signal which would be refracted at the surface and observed at the payload, up to 700km away.

Page 41: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

atomic

atomic

• “Entrainment” of electrons from the medium as shower penetratesExcess negative charge develops (electrons) →

• Main interactions contributing:

Net negative charge: Askaryan effectG. Askar´yan, Soviet Phys. JETP 14, 441 (1962)

Askaryan effect present in any medium with bound electrons (for instance in air).

G.A. Askaryan

Compton Moeller

Bhabha

e+ annhilation

Askaryan effect confirmed in SLAC experiments

atomic

25%)N(e)N(e

)N(e)N(eΔq

“Low” energy processes ~ MeV

Page 42: ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna University of Hawaii at Manoa Peter Gorham, PI John Learned and Gary S. Varner Ohio-State University Jim Beatty and

ANITA Concept

• UHE Neutrino Detection• Radio Cherenkov signals in Antarctic ice. • Excellent sensitivity in 1019- 5x1020 eV. • Large volumes of ice• Excellent transparency of the Antarctic ice (RF attenuation length: ~ 1km.)

• UHE Cosmic Ray Detection• EAS with Geo-synchrotron radiation • Handful number of events of UHE• Large field of view• Partially coherent emission in ANITA’s frequency band (0.2~1.2GHz) .