public patent foundation appendix/ja ii of iii.pdf · 2012- 1298 gibson moore appellate services,...

Post on 05-Aug-2020

1 Views

Category:

Documents

0 Downloads

Preview:

Click to see full reader

TRANSCRIPT

2012-1298

GibsonMoore Appellate Services, LLC 421 East Franklin Street ♦ Suite 230 ♦ Richmond, VA 23219 ♦ 804-249-7770 ♦ www.gibsonmoore.net

I n T h e

U n i t e d S t a t e s C o u r t O f A p p e a l s F o r T h e F e d e r a l C i r c u i t

ORGANIC SEED GROWERS AND TRADE ASSOCIATION, ORGANIC CROP IMPROVEMENT ASSOCIATION INTERNATIONAL, INC., THE CORNUCOPIA INSTITUTE,

DEMETER ASSOCIATION, INC., CENTER FOR FOOD SAFETY, BEYOND PESTICIDES, NAVDANYA INTERNATIONAL, MAINE ORGANIC FARMERS AND GARDENERS

ASSOCIATION, NORTHEAST ORGANIC FARMING ASSOCIATION OF NEW YORK, NORTHEAST ORGANIC FARMING ASSOCIATION/MASSACHUSETTS CHAPTER, INC.,

NORTHEAST ORGANIC FARMING ASSOCIATION OF NEW HAMPSHIRE, NORTHEAST ORGANIC FARMING ASSOCIATION OF RHODE ISLAND, CT NOFA,

NORTHEAST ORGANIC FARMING ASSOCIATION OF VERMONT, RURAL VERMONT, OHIO ECOLOGICAL FOOD & FARM ASSOCIATION, FLORIDA CERTIFIED ORGANIC

GROWERS AND CONSUMERS INC., SOUTHEAST IOWA ORGANIC ASSOCIATION, MENDOCINO ORGANIC NETWORK, NORTHEAST ORGANIC DAIRY PRODUCERS

ALLIANCE, MIDWEST ORGANIC DAIRY PRODUCERS ALLIANCE, WESTERN ORGANIC DAIRY PRODUCERS ALLIANCE, CANADIAN ORGANIC GROWERS, PEACE RIVER ORGANIC

PRODUCERS ASSOCIATION, FAMILY FARMER SEED COOPERATIVE, SUSTAINABLE LIVING SYSTEMS, GLOBAL ORGANIC ALLIANCE, FOOD DEMOCRACY NOW!, FARM-TO-CONSUMER LEGAL DEFENSE FUND, WESTON A. PRICE FOUNDATION, MICHAEL FIELDS

AGRICULTURAL INSTITUTE, FEDCO SEEDS INC., ADAPTIVE SEEDS, LLC, SOW TRUE SEED, SOUTHERN EXPOSURE SEED EXCHANGE, MUMM'S SPROUTING SEEDS, BAKER CREEK

HEIRLOOM SEED CO., LLC, COMSTOCK, FERRE & CO., LLC, SEEDKEEPERS, LLC, SISKIYOU SEEDS, COUNTRYSIDE ORGANICS, WILD GARDEN SEED, CUATRO PUERTAS,

SEED WE NEED, ALBA RANCH, WILD PLUM FARM, GRATITUDE GARDENS, RICHARD EVERETT FARM, LLC, PHILADELPHIA COMMUNITY FARM, INC, GENESIS FARM, CHISPAS FARMS LLC, MIDHEAVEN FARMS, KOSKAN FARMS, CALIFORNIA CLOVERLEAF FARMS,

NORTH OUTBACK FARM, TAYLOR FARMS, INC., RON GARGASZ ORGANIC FARMS, ABUNDANT ACRES, T & D WILLEY FARMS, FULL MOON FARM, INC., COMMON GOOD FARM, LLC, AMERICAN BUFFALO COMPANY, RADIANCE DAIRY, QUINELLA RANCH,

NATURE'S WAY FARM LTD., LEVKE AND PETER EGGERS FARM, FREY VINEYARDS, LTD., BRYCE STEPHENS, CHUCK NOBLE, LARHEA PEPPER, PAUL ROMERO, BRIAN WICKERT,

BRUCE DRINKMAN, MURRAY BAST, and DONALD WRIGHT PATTERSON, JR., Plaintiffs-Appellants,

and

OCIA RESEARCH AND EDUCATION INC., NORTHERN PLAINS SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURE SOCIETY, MANITOBA ORGANIC ALLIANCE, UNION PAYSANNE, FAMILY FARM DEFENDERS INC., INTERLAKE FORAGE SEEDS LTD.,

KIRSCHENMANN FAMILY FARMS INC., and JARDIN DEL ALMA, Plaintiffs,

v.

MONSANTO COMPANY and MONSANTO TECHNOLOGY LLC, Defendants-Appellees.

Appeal from the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York in case no. 11-CV-2163, Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald.

______________________

JOINT APPENDIX VOLUME II OF III (Pages 862 to 1345)

______________________

(Please See Reverse for Continued Cover)

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 1 Filed: 10/04/2012

Daniel B. Ravicher Sabrina Y. Hassan PUBLIC PATENT FOUNDATION BENJAMIN N. CARDOZO SCHOOL OF LAW 55 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10003 (212) 790-0442 Counsel for Appellants

Seth P. Waxman Carolyn J. Chachkin Gregory H. Lantier Rachel Weiner Paul R. Wolfson Todd C. Zubler WILMER CUTLER PICKERING HALE & DORR, LLP 1875 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. Washington, DC 20006 (202) 663-6000 Counsel for Appellees

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 2 Filed: 10/04/2012

-i-

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Volume I of III

Page

Memorandum and Order

filed February 24, 2012 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1

Civil Judgment

file February 27, 2012 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A25

Docket Entries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A26

Complaint,

With Exhibit,

filed March 29, 2012 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A54

Exhibit:

1. Monsanto Technology/Stewardship Agreement Form

undated . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A101

Plaintiffs’ Rule 7.1 Statement

filed March 29, 2012 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A106

Plaintiffs’ First Amended Complaint,

With Exhibits,

filed June 1, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A108

Exhibits:

1. Monsanto Technology/Stewardship Agreement Form

undated . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A172

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 3 Filed: 10/04/2012

-ii-

Exhibits to

Plaintiffs’ First Amended Complaint

filed June 1, 2011, Continued:

2. Monsanto News and Views Article

“PUBPAT Allegations Are False, Misleading

and Deceptive”

dated March 29, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A176

3. Letter to Todd Zubler from Daniel Ravicher

Re: Request for Waiver of Claims and

Covenant Not to Sue

dated April 18, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A179

4. Letter to Daniel Ravicher from Seth Waxman

Re: Organic Seed Growers and

Trade Association, et al. v. Monsanto Coal, et al.

dated April 28, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A182

Defendants’ Notice of Motion to

Dismiss for Lack of Subject-Matter Jurisdiction

filed July 12, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A230

Defendants’ Memorandum of Law in Support of

Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Subject-Matter Jurisdiction

filed July 12, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A232

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 4 Filed: 10/04/2012

-iii-

Declaration of Carolyn Jacobs Chachkin in

Support of Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for

Lack of Subject-Matter Jurisdiction,

With Exhibits,

filed July 12, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A257

Exhibits:

A. Excerpts from Monsanto Company,

2010 Form IO-K, available at http://www.sec.gov/

Archives/edgar/data/III0783/000095012310096537/

c60329el0vk.htm

dated October 27, 2010 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A261

B. Report in Brief, National Research Council, The Impact

of Genetically Engineered Crops on Farm Sustainability

in the United States, available at http://dels.nas.edu/

resources/static-assets/materialsbased-on-reports/

reports-in-briefigeneticallLengineered_crops_

report_brieCfinaLpdf

dated 2010 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A315

C. Ralph E. Heimlich et al., Genetically Engineered

Crops: Has Adoption Reduced Pesticide Use?

available at http://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/

agoutlooklaug2000/ao273f.pdf

dated August, 2010 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A319

D. Excerpts from U.S. Dep’t of Agriculture,

Monsanto Company and KWS SAATAG Supplemental

Request for Partial Deregulation of Sugar Beet

Genetically Engineered to be Tolerant to the Herbicide

Glyphosate: Final Environmental Assessment

dated February, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A324

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 5 Filed: 10/04/2012

-iv-

Exhibits to

Declaration of Carolyn Jacobs Chachkin in

Support of Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for

Lack of Subject-Matter Jurisdiction

filed July 12, 2011, Continued:

E. Dan Towery & Steve Werblow, Conservation

Technology Information Center, Facilitating

Conservation Farming Practices and Enhancing

Environmental Sustainability with Agricultural

Biotechnology, available at http://www.ctic.org/

BiotechSustainability

dated 2010 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A375

F. Janet E. Carpenter & Leonard P. Gianessi, Nat'l Center

for Food and Agricultural Policy, Agricultural

Biotechnology: Updated Benefit Estimates 39

dated January, 2001 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A403

G. B. Rosie Lerner & Michael N. Dana,

Growing Sweet Corn, available at

http://www.hort.purdue.edu/ext/HO-98.pdf

dated May, 2010 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A451

H. Declaration of Cindy J. Smith, Administrator of

USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service,

filed in Center for Food Safety, et al., v.

Thomas J Vilsack, et al., No. 3:08-cv-484-JSW (N.D. Cal.)

dated February 12, 2010 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A454

I. U.S. Dep't of Agriculture, Economic Research Service,

Organic Production Data Set, available at

http://www.ers.usda.gov/Data/Organic/

last visited July 11, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A472

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 6 Filed: 10/04/2012

-v-

Exhibits to

Declaration of Carolyn Jacobs Chachkin in

Support of Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for

Lack of Subject-Matter Jurisdiction

filed July 12, 2011, Continued:

J. U.S. Dep't of Agriculture, Record of Decision:

Glyphosate-Tolerant Alfalfa Events nO1 and J163:

Request for Nonregulated Status 4, available at

http://www.aphis.usda.govlbrs/aphisdocs/

04_11001p_rod.pdf

dated January 27, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A475

K. U.S. Dep't of Agriculture, Animal and Plant

Health Inspection Service, Biotechnology Regulatory

Services, Coordinated Framework for the Regulation

of Biotechnology, Program Aid No. 1862, available at

http://www.aphis.usda.gov/publicationslbiotechnology/

content/printable_version/BRS_CoordFrameBro.pdf

dated April, 2006 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A492

L. Policy Memorandum, U.S. Dep't of Agriculture,

available at http://www.ams.usda.gov/AMSv1.0/

getfile?dDocName=STELPRDC5090396

dated April 15, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A497

M. Letter from U.S. Dep't of Agriculture Under Secretary

Bill Hawks to Gus Douglass, Nat'l Assn. of State Dep’ts

of Agriculture, available at http://www.co.lake.ca.us/

Assets/BOS/GE+Crops+CommitteeIUSDA+Letter.pdf

dated December 21, 2004 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A501

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 7 Filed: 10/04/2012

-vi-

Exhibits to

Declaration of Carolyn Jacobs Chachkin in

Support of Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for

Lack of Subject-Matter Jurisdiction

filed July 12, 2011, Continued:

N. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency,

Demographics, at http://www.epa.gov/agriculture/

ag1 0 l/demographics.html

last visited July 11, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A506

O. Monsanto’s Commitment: Farmers and Patents . . . . . . . . A508

Declaration of James P. Tobin

filed July 12, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A509

Attachment to

Farm and Ranch Freedom Alliance, et al.,

Amicus Curiae Brief in Support of Plaintiffs’ Opposition to

Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss

filed August 10, 2011:

E. L.F. Friesen et al., Evidence of Contamination of

Pedigreed Canola (Brassica napus) Seedlots in Western

Canada with Genetically Engineered Herbicide

Resistance Traits, 95 Agronomy J. 1342-1347

dated 2003 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A630

Plaintiffs’ Memorandum of Law in Opposition to

Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for Lack of

Subject Matter Jurisdiction

filed August 11, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A674

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 8 Filed: 10/04/2012

-vii-

Declaration of Bryce Stephens in Support of

Plaintiffs’ Memorandum of Law in Opposition to

Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for Lack of

Subject Matter Jurisdiction

filed August 11, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A705

Declaration of Frederick Kirschenmann in Support of

Plaintiffs’ Memorandum of Law in Opposition to

Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for Lack of

Subject Matter Jurisdiction

filed August 11, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A710

Declaration of C.R. Lawn in Support of

Plaintiffs’ Memorandum of Law in Opposition to

Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for Lack of

Subject Matter Jurisdiction

filed August 11, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A714

Declaration of Donald Wright Patterson, Jr. in Support of

Plaintiffs’ Memorandum of Law in Opposition to

Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for Lack of

Subject Matter Jurisdiction

filed August 11, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A718

Declaration of Chuck Noble in Support of

Plaintiffs’ Memorandum of Law in Opposition to

Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for Lack of

Subject Matter Jurisdiction

filed August 11, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A721

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 9 Filed: 10/04/2012

-viii-

Declaration of Daniel B. Ravicher in Support of

Plaintiffs’ Memorandum of Law in Opposition to

Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for Lack of

Subject Matter Jurisdiction,

With Exhibit,

filed August 11, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A724

Exhibit:

A. Plaintiffs Response to Defendant’s

First Set of Requests for Admissions, filed in

Monsanto Company, et al. v.

Boggs Farm Center, Inc., et al.,

4:10-cv-00286 (E.D.M.O.)

filed July 19, 2011 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A726

Transcript of Hearing before

The Honorable Naomi Reice Buchwald

on January 31, 2012 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A831

Plaintiffs’ Notice of Appeal

filed March 28, 2012 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A857

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 10 Filed: 10/04/2012

-ix-

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Volume II of III

Page

PATENTS:

U.S. Patent No. 5,322,938

dated June 21, 1994 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A862

U.S. Patent No. 5,352,605

dated October 4, 1994 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A878

U.S. Patent No. US 5,352,605 C1

dated March 4, 2008 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A899

U.S. Patent No. 5,362,865

dated November 8, 1994 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A906

U.S. Patent No. 5,378,619

dated January 3, 1995 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A937

U.S. Patent No. 5,424,412

dated June 13, 1995 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A965

U.S. Patent No. 5,463,175

dated October 31, 1995 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1010

U.S. Patent No. 5,530,196

dated June 25, 1996 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1063

U.S. Patent No. 5,554,798

dated September 10, 1996 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1082

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 11 Filed: 10/04/2012

-x-

U.S. Patent No. 5,593,874

dated January 14, 1997 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1109

U.S. Patent No. 5,641,876

dated June 24, 1997 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1153

U.S. Patent No. 5,659,122

dated August 19, 1997 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1182

U.S. Patent No. 5,717,084

dated February 10, 1998 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1207

U.S. Patent No. 5,728,925

dated March 17, 1998 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1246

U.S. Patent No. 5,750,871

dated May 12, 1998 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1282

U.S. Patent No. 5,859,347

dated January 12, 1999 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1301

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 12 Filed: 10/04/2012

-xi-

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Volume III of III

Page

PATENTS, Continued:

U.S. Patent No. 6,025,545

dated February 15, 2000 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1346

U.S. Patent No. 6,040,497

dated March 21, 2000 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1501

U.S. Patent No. 6,051,753

dated April 18, 2000 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1560

U.S. Patent No. 6,083,878

dated July 4, 2000 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1572

U.S. Patent No. 6,753,453

dated June 22, 2004 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1581

U.S. Patent No. 6,825,400 B2

dated November 30, 2004 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1638

U.S. Patent No. RE38,825 E

dated October 11, 2005 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1653

U.S. Patent No. RE39,247 E

dated August 22, 2006 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1728

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 13 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A862-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 14 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A863-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 15 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A864-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 16 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A865-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 17 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A866-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 18 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A867-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 19 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A868-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 20 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A869-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 21 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A870-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 22 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A871-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 23 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A872-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 24 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A873-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 25 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A874-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 26 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A875-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 27 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A876-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 28 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A877-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 29 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A878-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 30 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A879-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 31 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A880-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 32 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A881-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 33 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A882-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 34 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A883-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 35 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A884-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 36 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A885-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 37 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A886-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 38 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A887-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 39 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A888-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 40 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A889-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 41 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A890-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 42 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A891-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 43 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A892-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 44 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A893-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 45 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A894-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 46 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A895-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 47 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A896-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 48 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A897-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 49 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A898-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 50 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A899-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 51 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A900-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 52 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A901-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 53 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A902-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 54 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A903-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 55 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A904-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 56 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A905-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 57 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A906-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 58 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A907-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 59 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A908-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 60 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A909-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 61 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A910-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 62 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A911-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 63 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A912-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 64 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A913-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 65 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A914-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 66 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A915-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 67 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A916-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 68 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A917-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 69 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A918-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 70 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A919-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 71 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A920-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 72 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A921-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 73 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A922-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 74 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A923-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 75 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A924-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 76 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A925-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 77 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A926-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 78 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A927-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 79 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A928-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 80 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A929-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 81 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A930-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 82 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A931-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 83 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A932-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 84 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A933-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 85 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A934-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 86 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A935-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 87 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A936-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 88 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A937-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 89 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A938-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 90 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A939-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 91 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A940-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 92 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A941-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 93 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A942-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 94 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A943-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 95 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A944-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 96 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A945-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 97 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A946-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 98 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A947-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 99 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A948-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 100 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A949-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 101 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A950-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 102 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A951-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 103 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A952-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 104 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A953-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 105 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A954-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 106 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A955-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 107 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A956-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 108 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A957-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 109 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A958-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 110 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A959-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 111 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A960-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 112 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A961-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 113 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A962-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 114 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A963-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 115 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A964-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 116 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A965-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 117 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A966-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 118 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A967-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 119 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A968-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 120 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A969-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 121 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A970-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 122 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A971-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 123 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A972-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 124 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A973-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 125 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A974-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 126 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A975-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 127 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A976-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 128 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A977-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 129 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A978-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 130 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A979-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 131 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A980-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 132 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A981-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 133 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A982-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 134 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A983-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 135 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A984-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 136 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A985-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 137 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A986-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 138 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A987-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 139 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A988-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 140 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A989-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 141 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A990-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 142 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A991-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 143 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A992-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 144 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A993-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 145 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A994-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 146 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A995-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 147 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A996-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 148 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A997-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 149 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A998-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 150 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A999-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 151 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1000-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 152 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1001-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 153 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1002-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 154 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1003-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 155 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1004-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 156 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1005-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 157 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1006-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 158 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1007-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 159 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1008-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 160 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1009-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 161 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1010-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 162 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1011-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 163 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1012-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 164 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1013-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 165 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1014-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 166 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1015-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 167 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1016-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 168 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1017-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 169 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1018-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 170 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1019-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 171 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1020-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 172 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1021-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 173 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1022-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 174 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1023-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 175 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1024-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 176 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1025-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 177 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1026-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 178 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1027-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 179 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1028-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 180 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1029-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 181 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1030-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 182 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1031-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 183 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1032-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 184 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1033-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 185 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1034-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 186 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1035-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 187 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1036-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 188 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1037-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 189 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1038-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 190 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1039-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 191 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1040-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 192 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1041-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 193 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1042-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 194 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1043-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 195 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1044-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 196 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1045-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 197 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1046-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 198 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1047-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 199 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1048-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 200 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1049-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 201 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1050-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 202 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1051-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 203 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1052-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 204 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1053-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 205 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1054-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 206 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1055-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 207 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1056-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 208 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1057-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 209 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1058-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 210 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1059-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 211 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1060-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 212 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1061-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 213 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1062-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 214 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1063-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 215 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1064-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 216 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1065-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 217 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1066-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 218 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1067-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 219 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1068-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 220 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1069-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 221 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1070-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 222 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1071-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 223 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1072-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 224 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1073-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 225 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1074-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 226 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1075-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 227 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1076-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 228 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1077-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 229 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1078-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 230 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1079-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 231 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1080-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 232 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1081-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 233 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1082-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 234 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1083-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 235 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1084-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 236 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1085-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 237 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1086-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 238 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1087-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 239 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1088-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 240 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1089-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 241 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1090-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 242 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1091-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 243 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1092-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 244 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1093-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 245 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1094-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 246 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1095-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 247 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1096-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 248 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1097-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 249 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1098-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 250 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1099-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 251 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1100-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 252 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1101-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 253 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1102-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 254 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1103-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 255 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1104-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 256 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1105-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 257 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1106-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 258 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1107-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 259 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1108-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 260 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1109-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 261 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1110-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 262 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1111-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 263 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1112-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 264 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1113-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 265 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1114-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 266 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1115-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 267 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1116-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 268 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1117-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 269 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1118-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 270 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1119-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 271 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1120-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 272 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1121-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 273 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1122-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 274 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1123-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 275 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1124-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 276 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1125-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 277 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1126-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 278 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1127-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 279 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1128-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 280 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1129-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 281 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1130-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 282 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1131-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 283 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1132-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 284 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1133-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 285 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1134-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 286 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1135-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 287 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1136-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 288 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1137-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 289 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1138-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 290 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1139-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 291 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1140-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 292 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1141-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 293 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1142-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 294 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1143-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 295 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1144-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 296 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1145-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 297 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1146-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 298 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1147-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 299 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1148-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 300 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1149-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 301 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1150-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 302 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1151-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 303 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1152-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 304 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1153-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 305 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1154-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 306 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1155-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 307 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1156-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 308 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1157-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 309 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1158-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 310 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1159-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 311 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1160-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 312 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1161-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 313 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1162-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 314 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1163-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 315 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1164-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 316 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1165-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 317 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1166-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 318 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1167-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 319 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1168-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 320 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1169-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 321 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1170-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 322 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1171-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 323 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1172-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 324 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1173-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 325 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1174-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 326 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1175-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 327 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1176-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 328 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1177-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 329 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1178-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 330 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1179-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 331 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1180-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 332 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1181-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 333 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1182-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 334 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1183-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 335 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1184-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 336 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1185-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 337 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1186-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 338 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1187-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 339 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1188-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 340 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1189-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 341 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1190-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 342 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1191-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 343 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1192-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 344 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1193-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 345 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1194-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 346 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1195-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 347 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1196-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 348 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1197-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 349 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1198-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 350 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1199-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 351 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1200-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 352 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1201-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 353 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1202-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 354 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1203-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 355 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1204-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 356 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1205-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 357 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1206-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 358 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1207-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 359 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1208-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 360 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1209-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 361 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1210-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 362 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1211-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 363 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1212-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 364 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1213-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 365 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1214-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 366 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1215-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 367 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1216-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 368 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1217-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 369 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1218-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 370 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1219-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 371 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1220-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 372 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1221-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 373 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1222-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 374 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1223-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 375 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1224-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 376 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1225-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 377 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1226-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 378 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1227-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 379 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1228-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 380 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1229-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 381 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1230-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 382 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1231-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 383 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1232-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 384 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1233-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 385 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1234-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 386 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1235-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 387 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1236-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 388 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1237-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 389 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1238-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 390 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1239-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 391 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1240-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 392 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1241-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 393 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1242-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 394 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1243-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 395 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1244-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 396 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1245-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 397 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1246-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 398 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1247-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 399 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1248-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 400 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1249-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 401 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1250-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 402 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1251-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 403 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1252-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 404 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1253-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 405 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1254-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 406 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1255-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 407 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1256-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 408 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1257-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 409 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1258-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 410 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1259-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 411 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1260-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 412 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1261-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 413 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1262-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 414 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1263-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 415 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1264-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 416 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1265-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 417 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1266-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 418 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1267-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 419 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1268-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 420 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1269-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 421 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1270-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 422 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1271-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 423 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1272-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 424 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1273-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 425 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1274-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 426 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1275-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 427 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1276-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 428 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1277-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 429 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1278-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 430 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1279-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 431 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1280-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 432 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1281-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 433 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1282-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 434 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1283-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 435 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1284-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 436 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1285-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 437 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1286-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 438 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1287-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 439 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1288-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 440 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1289-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 441 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1290-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 442 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1291-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 443 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1292-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 444 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1293-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 445 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1294-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 446 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1295-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 447 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1296-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 448 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1297-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 449 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1298-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 450 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1299-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 451 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1300-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 452 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1301-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 453 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1302-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 454 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1303-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 455 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1304-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 456 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1305-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 457 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1306-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 458 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1307-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 459 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1308-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 460 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1309-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 461 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1310-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 462 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1311-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 463 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1312-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 464 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1313-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 465 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1314-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 466 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1315-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 467 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1316-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 468 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1317-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 469 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1318-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 470 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1319-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 471 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1320-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 472 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1321-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 473 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1322-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 474 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1323-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 475 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1324-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 476 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1325-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 477 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1326-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 478 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1327-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 479 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1328-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 480 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1329-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 481 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1330-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 482 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1331-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 483 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1332-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 484 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1333-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 485 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1334-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 486 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1335-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 487 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1336-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 488 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1337-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 489 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1338-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 490 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1339-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 491 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1340-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 492 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1341-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 493 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1342-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 494 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1343-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 495 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1344-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 496 Filed: 10/04/2012

-A1345-

Case: 12-1298 Document: 54-2 Page: 497 Filed: 10/04/2012

top related