budget monitoring south asia. some examples - bangladesh in 2005, ‘people’s report of mdgs’...

BUDGET MONITORING

SOUTH ASIA

Some Examples - BANGLADESH In 2005, ‘People’s Report of MDGs’ Civil Society actors Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (central authority-debated) Used participatory methods-bringing people’s perceptions Global Report on MDGs in 2005-triggered initiatives in specific

countries-part of it went into the global report Huge discrepancies in people’s perceptions and quantified

data Mode of data collection- Focus Group Discussions Acceptability, Accessibility and Affordability- parameters

forming the background Stratified sampling Initiative was spearheaded by 20 organizations across

Bangladesh Nepal also came out with its own report BMDGs – Bangladesh MDGs

INDIA In 2005, initiative ‘Securing Rights –

Citizen’s report on MDGs’ Also looked at National

Development Goals and NCMP of the Govt.

Same methodology as Nepal and Bangladesh

National Development Goals and NCMp more ambitious

NEPAL Report ‘Whose Goals?’ –first initiative of a critical

review Other set of indicators which were Nepal specific Goals should be tailored to situation of Nepal Do not talk about societies which are stratified

along caste, arm insurgency We need to go Beyond MDGs To reduce poverty – Political Liability At civil society level, a coalition of 2-3 organizations These reports questioned the legitimacy of MDGs

PAKISTAN

World Bank, ADB also reporting Civil society is confused on reliable

data Bureau of statistics

Gaps – Government Reports

Not placed in the public domain No Tripartite arrangement –

DONORS, CIVIL SOCIETY and GOVT. – which

is claimed

Indicators

POVERTY AND HUNGER HEALTH EDUCATION

Monitoring Initiatives

Data collection For Eg. Focus Group Discussions

MDG monitoring committee at each level

Civil society participation Develop a database with a

procedure for updating it

Capacities and Skills

Collaboration of Govt and NGOs Tripartite engagement Training sessions in term of

awareness and data collection