abel-violent_affect_literature_cinema

8/7/2019 abel-violent_affect_literature_cinema

1/313


2/313

Violent Aff ect


3/313


4/313

U ni v e r s i t y o f N e b r as k a P r e s s L i nc o l n and L o nd o n


5/313

C J I N E : Aff C V A eri n Psy ho,

An e ki . ( ): . A &F , :// . . . /j .

C DD L I R F : L ,I , R Seein / , -

pmla . ( ): .

B R U N

A M U S A

L C C - -P DA , M .V ff : , , q

/ M A .

. .I ( . ) .isbn- : - - - - ( . )isbn- : - - -x ( . )

. A H . . V . . V

. I. .ps .v a

'.

S C P B R z.D A J .


6/313

F M R A

I M L ( )


7/313


8/313

P A

. T e Violence of Sensation Mi ers Crossin , Aff , M

. Judgment Is Not an ExitR , Aff , A eri n Psy ho

. Are We All Arnoldians?

A C G J

. Serializing ViolenceP H E P

V

. Becoming-Violent, Becoming-DeNiroR V V S

. Don DeLillos In the Ruins of the FutureV , P , R S /

N B I


9/313


10/313

T e vio en e of sens tion is o osed to the vio en e of the re re-sented (the sens tion , the i h). T e for er is inse r b e froits dire t tion on the nervous syste , the eve s throu h whi hit sses, the do ins it tr verses: bein itse f Fi ure, it usth ve nothin of the n ture of the re resented ob e t. [Vio en e] isnot wh t one be ieves it to be, nd de ends ess nd ess on wh t is

re resented.G D z ,Fr n is B on

I nt he but dre bout kind of riti is th t wou d not tryto ud e.M F , T M P

A j , ,

. M , ( ) (

?). D

, , I

j ,


11/313

Pref e

. S , ff ,

P ( , ), C S ( ), J. D

( ), S J S ( ), J R. G( )

, , of , ,

re ity ( ). P ff ,

,

( ) , , ff , .

W ff ff ? B S z - ,

j , -

j ( q

j ). I S z ,

( ) . I , j ,re resent.

O

, ,

( ) .

A , ,


12/313

Pref e

. I ,

, q -

(

( P , F S ). I H , N B T W ,

H . T

C , , H . W ? A

I T K . A C H , . N ff

, B

q

z j : .

I , , on y

j I . A

. T ,

, .

I , S z


13/313

Pref e

(

) . L , (

) . T ff

( ) ff , ( ) ff

B , ff

. A , ( )

, . B , ,

ff , , ,

.I , . B

( ) re resent tions -

, , - ud -

ent . T ( ) j , , ,

P. T

( j ) j ( ) ff

ff ( ). T , j

j j ( j j ( , ),


14/313

Pref e

j . (I. .,

z j , ,

.) T j q

ffi )

, . (

ff ( ) z .

M , ,

( ) ,

. I , I q is , . M

ff

.I ff

ff j j , , q

j how

, , . T , , j

( - ). I j . S

, q , if


15/313

Pref e

ex eri ent ?

T , j

r ti e ed o i for e , , . S ,

- - . N

- J q D , M F , G

I, , . H

, F

, D z . W , Dis , F

, D z

z for e, , -. H , ,

- I ,

j T A ,

I ( )

( D z F , AM H A N ) ,

D z ,

:M so his : Co dness nd Crue ty Fr n is B on: T eLo i of Sens tion. I , j D z ( D


16/313

Pref e

z F G ) ,

j , ( ) D z ( )

.G , I

, ex eri-ent . T

WII A ,

. O - , z

. I , I D z

( . ., ), , ,

(Or ns without Bodies ).O , D ,

, , , , - . H , I D z

. J

I , ff

s e

, , D z G , . T ,

- ff ( )

, . E


17/313

Pref e

( D

, , , ff ) .

W ff ,

, . H , osts

ff , , ff ,

C B ,

B E E A eri n Psy ho M H H , R D N

D D L / . T

, - : , ff

; , . E

q

q .

T ,

how

j before . I , I -

, q (

before j , .


18/313

I , I B E EA eri n Psy ho. F ,

. A , I

A , G . E

F -

E . B ff

, I . I I

E ff

, E E .

B ( )

I I . I

. I . S , I


19/313

j . F , I K H , J ff . N , J M

I . M

j

!

A , I : R

E W , S S , C S , P D S , J ff K , J R , R N z ,

B , C H , K D L , P GE , D H , E z M zz ff

j

D E U N , : ,

L

W W DG A F ,

. L R P , -

j unl, , J R

. F , I N S ,

, ! L R ! A , , L

U N P

A J R S T M H

A know ed ents


20/313

, ,

I .B

ff , . H G U S , I

G , M D , C W z, J M , H , U z F , , A , , . S B . W I

, I . L ,

R G , .

I , , -

, R M A . T ( G ), I

.

A know ed ents


21/313


22/313

T e Vio en e of Sens tion

V . M ,

, , , ,

. A , -

, , , . V tv

. A

N J T ffi j

other , . B j

. C

, , , O , q

:

W - ? W ff

,

Millers Crossing , Aff ect, and Masocriticism


23/313


? T / , ,

z . B

, z ?O , , I

( ?),

W C . T U.S.

I

: I j , I

z , . T

M , L , E , /

G S ,

.I ,

, diff erent, V

ff .1 I ,

ff event -

, .B ,


24/313


I , ,

.2 , - W

, , q

. A , j ,

-PC: B B -H . W

, , ( , B )

q ethi . I ,

z . I

the se ves q

I re -

ity .

T e Violence of Sensation

, ,Mi ers Crossin ( ), A - C B

q . T

z . A ,

I A : I I . I , L , I

I . J ,


25/313


, , - . T

. V

H L C (

E G. R M L R Litt e C es r[ ]),P E ( J C W W

), S ( M H H ). A z

, J C (J P ) :

Y I . I B I . W I , I

, I I ff . B I B B , I , , I

T I . H I .

A , - C ,

. T : S , I ? C L (A F ),

, : AB L

, C , - , I . N , , ? F

. I C ,

L


26/313


(G B ), C , D (J. E. F )

. R j . T . W ,

. W B B ff , - . A . A

, L C , S ? D , C , , F .

O , . V

. W , , /

.3 I ,

V , : ,

.

Y , ff . I

- - . T ff before

, . I

, G B

F B . A D z , B

(Fr n is B on ). T , B ff

( ) ff ( ).P


27/313


O S N tur Born Ki ers( ) R - R zSin City( )

ff - - . N

, z ( ) ,

. R

, (D z ,Fr n is B on ). A , -

j : B : ff ,

( ). A ff , ( ),

ffi [ ]

. B P ( ). S ff j :

. W

ff q ), ff D z ff

z , .4

D ff , (D z ,Fr n is B on ) .

A D z , 5 I

C

q Mi ers Crossin . W - ( D z ), intensify

q B F


28/313


I B , F ,

( ) . A D z F

. . ., . . . ( ). T F , : , ur tive, i ustr -

tive, n rr tive F ( ). I C B , J P

, ff

C z P

, , . L B , C

, , , . T ff

- j who es e j .

W , , C . F

, ,

(D z ,Fr n is B on ).W ,

? S , , , , , B

Mi ers Crossin C . H , q B C , us , z ? M

,

. T B


29/313


[ ] (

, for es of the fu-ture ( , ). A ,

, ff ff

. B , B in

, j .

W ? W future - . B

, sus endin q ,

z ,Fr n is B on ). W ,

. A , D z H : D j , ,

A D z , B ,

( ). T

F ( , , , ,

ffi F M H , j

, . F D z , ,

[ ] ffi , , F G

,Wh t Is Phi oso hy?( ). I , , - z D z


30/313


31/313


, q j

this .6 A ,, B , q

, , z .

T e Violence of Ethics

I , q , q

, - , . T z q j

J ff N hoosin , ffi r-

tion . [ . . . ] R , res onse , . T

I s if I -; , I A terity

Po iti s ). T ff ,

. T rior z ,

z ff

z , I - . W -

before

ff , z - (

A ff e tive eff e ts


32/313


. A

. , ff

q , j j .7 B ff , ,

I j ( ff z

, B M , ( ). Aff , ,

ff ; ff [

,

( ).T , I , Mi ers Crossin

, q

. T q , ,

. H ,

ff

. I , q

Q , S P , - -, ,

( ff ). O , ,

T e Wi d Bun h( . S P , ) Pu Fi -tion ( . Q , )

within .

B Mi ers Crossin ff


33/313


, - , ff . I

( ) , 8 T

C

. ,

. O , C

, , q

( ?)

.9 I , C

. O , L C B , B , . D ff , L

B C ? A

, L , C

. O , L C , L . C L L

. F C ,

, , : , .

H , j C - -

. R , re dy

T


34/313


ff ,

E ( ), sense C ( ) ;

. T ,

C , , , - -

C . C ,

, - . R z

. R , , ,

.W C ,

C B ood Si e

F r o, sty e ff sense . C

,Mi ers Crossin - ff

C .10 S

- , ,

C : j , ,

C . A , C j

; ,we re e nt to sense the vio en e of ethi s .A ,

- - , . B

- - , . B ,


35/313


C , , B ood Si e -

F r o. L , C

, - . Y

C , . B

, N tur Born Ki ers, -

. W ( )

( , . .), Mi ers Crossin eff e t

[ ] ,

). I ,

ff .T

q shou d (z ffi

); ,Mi ers Crossin - ,

q before . H , , - ? A

, -

- z j ? I

Mi ers Crossin :

( ) , ?


36/313


T e Violence of Masochism

I Fr n is B on, D z z ffi . I , D z

, :

, ( ). D z

, - . F

, - , in . J ,

D z N z E RI ( )

E R , D z Nietzs he nd Phi oso hy E R

ff .On y - . W , , , , ff . FDif-

feren e nd Re etition, D z , D S

, D z - , D z

B on y . I B

, B , , q , , D .

I F B ,

, q , , (D z ,Fr n is B on

), , z


37/313


. B q ( ) .11 H

D z [ ] [

( ). M ,

.

C , B , . H

knows wh t he w nts to do, he does not know how to et there,

(D z ,Fr n is B on ). A q

: how

? T ,

( ) , q , event .C B

, D z . T

, ( ), ,

, ( ,

(Fr n is B on ). A , :

ff ? B ffi , ,

. T , ffi , . T

, N z sin e


38/313


. T ffi : I

, , . O ,

, (D z ,Nietzs he nd Phi oso hy ).

W I , , D z B ff

ffi

I D z B

q .12C , , C B F r o, -

, . S , D z

L S -M ,

M s-o his ). Y ,

: z (

z (

.13 T , ,

( ). T ,

, , ,

z ( ). W ,

this


39/313


: , ff ,

. T j . I ,

C q , , is ,

. W , ethi -

. I ,

( ) ( ). Y , D z , [ . . . ]

z . [I ], z ,

[ ] ( ).

T F r o. I -

, ,

z . S q ,

,

.14 F r o -

j , . Y ,

, q I I I

I -before ( ). I ,

C , C


40/313


. C , ,

.R F r o -

, ffi

ethodo o i -

D z . T , , ;

,

, - . S

q , ff ( )

ff . O ff ( )

j . W

j ,

, , z sty e

. W q .

I , I ,

(

?). H , , D z


41/313


, (Fou u t ). H ,

. T H

. R , , j (

), . E , ,

, . O , D z ,

: D I . O ,

Diff er-en e nd Re etition ).

C , j

ed o y of

vio en e . M . M

. A D z , D

,

: z z

(M so his ). C N z

ffi ,

?

H , , q ? F ,

, , D z ,


42/313


z , , - ,

q , ;

(M so his ). T z - ,

, (

) z ( ). J -

- , , D W

z ( )

z . I

: C B , B E E , P H

R D N , D D L , , , G D z .O j , ,

; ,

ff , . O , , ,

z , ; . P , ,

, ,

j (M so his ).T , , tive y

. I

. D z


43/313


. T z

,

: I (D z ,Cine ). T

: j . H ff ff . B ,

, z , S

( q

).15 A ffi ff , . H

j . H

B - . H , j

, A D z ,

, ( )

. H . T

(M so his ). A z

j ,

). T -

.


44/313


E , -, ,

j , . T , j ,

q , , ffi

,

q , z . I

; , ,

,

.

Masocriticism

G , -

q qrodu tion. C z ,

, j ,

, ff ,

.16C ,

, ; , , ,

. I ,

, . T

j


45/313


. R

, ff , - ,

. A q ,

.17M , I

I P M

. H , , I

: T H (

H ). M

( ). V D z ( G ), I

M . M

re u tin . T -

. T needs . T

z j

( ), j ( ). T

- , - , , .A z

: j , j ,

),


46/313


j , ( ) ,

ff , ff , , z

. I

, q O ,

- , ff ff .

C q , D z . A

, - , : , -

, itse f rodu es

o e tive utter n es. [ . . . ] N ,

- . T - ,

(Cine ). A

. I , , ,

. N q - .

, . T

. A

: ,

o e tive . B ffi q

, in


47/313


,in , ( )

- .M , , j

, . T ,

, ff . W

, ,

- C

q ).A ,

, ,

,

, . I , , . T

, , ,

z .I , /

: I I ? T

q ffi , ffi , , ,

( ff

) : ( ) ffi

ff .


48/313


I , , D z

- , sus ension of the wor d ff disturb n e, ,

[ ] , q

(Cine ). T - ( ,

). B ( ) , , j ff

(e S F

: ). , , j

T , , , , D z ,

[ ] j

( ) ff (Cine ).T

j . C A eri n Psy ho

q j ; P H

j ; R D N

( ) ;

D D L / ff -

T , I :


49/313


, I

, I . O , j I throu h

. T

ff . M , ff

, ,

( ) . I j j (

!) , , .


50/313

Jud ent Is Not n Exit

Comparison, Representation, Judgment

M H B E E A eri n Psy ho

J -L G - , ,

- C hiers du Cin - G Pierrot Le Fou Pierrot (G -

, L P ). A , , ( )

, . C ,

, H , , ,

, H

P B W S . G

E q

A , H

.1

Representation, Aff ect, and American Psycho


51/313


T zz , ff -

. T

ff , , - .2 A ,

, . Y ,

I

zz . W

.W G ,

. O , E

q ff . A

q

q W S P

, EI A eri nPsy ho j E

R , H

, , ud ent ( ) .3

R , H ,


52/313


E .4 E , . I ,

. F , Si ht nd Sound ( ).

H , , , , M G

. [ . . . ] [ ] j ( ). H , ,

?

H ff ? T q

( )

ff

ff

q , I ff , , q B E E

. T , , ( )

I A P .

q , ,

T

. U

, I A eri n Psy ho

. T ,

, (


53/313


D H , RC , J M. C ).

W , , ? O . J

, , (tv, , ) . I ,

, .5 A

D , j . I

- -

. I ff ff

,

, .A , , ,

, , 6 A , ,

ff : . N -

( L-A-N-G-U-A-G-E ), P

; P ,

j 7 T , ;

q .8 O ,

, P , q


54/313


A . H , A eri n Psy ho, I

sty e

P : ,

, , j .

F A P , , . R , I

, , :

) ff j . T q

,

N z . A A P q

, q ,

.9G , q

, j

. O , ff ,

( . .,ny ,

j ), j ?10 T

. R ,

j ,


55/313


j .

Deleuzes Symptomatology

W , , j ? C q

K , ( ) G D z

, , ff j , ,

. E F N z , B S z , A, D z H D J

j : J . F

, ,

, . H , , :to brin into existen e nd not to ud e. I

j , q ,

j ( , ). I D z

. I , D z - J q D M F

, . G N z ,

, G

, N z ,

. I , j ( ) ,

/ ff 11D z S z


56/313


. F D z q j

ff :

ff e tive ( , , )

ff ff ? HD z ,

, , ff

, L , I , ff

j , ff

- , not q

j . F D z [ . . . ]

(B I S j

q , ffi j

, . A , D z

, ff ,

- ff .P ,

D z . H

( ) ( N z ,

) :


57/313


, . I

is, , D z

T q , diff er-ent y? A P P , D z

, W [ ] , j

. T

(R

,

, . H

( ,

, ), is, do , ff .

P ff , D z 12

H ff

. [ . . . ] A (B I S ). D z

,

. O , . F , S j

[ ] (P ). H , , ff D z

L L j


58/313


L , j , , . I , L

D z . I D z J q L

, ff .13

F D z , , ff j z ff

, , L L

F , ff , j ff

. , jthrou h

, ,

, , ff .I , A B , q

, ( ). H

( ) j

. C

M M H A D z

,

z z

, ( ). I , .


59/313


, , B q j , I

j

, : M H E -A eri-

n Psy ho. R D z j , I

ff

, , ff E i e S y

, P B , . A ,

E . I

ff

I D z , M so his : S -

q ff

ff ( ). B

A P nd I

E

, , , G S ,

( ).

M , I

A eri n Psy ho - ffi H


60/313


b ). A H E ,

( , ,

) - E

.14 I

[ ], ff

,

(NI , I

E H ff , . P

q , I ff ,

ff , ff A eri n

Psy ho .

Harrons Film as a Double Response

F , q E :

, A eri n Psy ho ,

. T

j E C H , , , I

[ ]


61/313


, , j , .A eri n Psy ho -

, ,Ru es of Attr tion (q . L ).

: I . I , , ( ). A ,

, R R New York i es ff E

, , [ ] j .

T

ff .15 C E

, , j

ff : j ; j 16

R j , z ;

. I ffi , A eri n Psy ho

,

. I , E

, j

.

N , j


62/313


q j ff . A ff

j ,

E A eri n Psy ho M H . I , H -

E ,

17 W E

, H Ethrou h

. Gq H

E .

z , H - ,I Shot Andy W rho( ), VS , scum (S CM ) A W

E : , .O , j

, X , O S ,

, .) H , I

u ntity , ,

H ff . Aff

q ,

,


63/313


S ; ( D z G ,T ous nd P te us

). T q , , ff A eri n Psy ho ,

. C , , G

ff E

? T , G q B ? A ? wo or

T ree T in s , ) .

I , z E re y

q , q .18 F -

A P ,

. T z A

, . (I ,

. E .19 W

q , , E W S A ; ,

j . T ,

z .

F ffi

q . F ff

B . S


64/313


z E , ,

20 S , H

E . T B

,

. T , J (CS ), B ffi

- . E B . M

: . I

(

E ), q re y . T

,

.21T , H C B ff P B

A P . C B

. I ,

, B

.22 I -, z

z B

. F , H


65/313


, , S . V , , ,

, , ,

, H

. C , H

.23

S I j H

, , H eff e t , ff

, H E : ,

H j ff

. H , I j ost - -

-

z ) E . A

W A eri n Psy ho

( ) ? W ffi

? W ff ff , ,


66/313


B j (

)?24 A , , A eri n Psy ho

, , z

W , , ff E (

H

E ? , H

:

B .

T e Boredom of Violence, the Violence of Boredom

T ff H E

. R ,

, , , , , q

A , ( , ) E

. (R

.) T , ,

B

B


67/313


. B , ,

q

ff ff

, , , ( )

.25H , ,

:

, . I E z

, E E . R ff q , ,

, , ff ff . C , ,

, for e - :

B . W , , (E

ff ff .

C , B

q ff

, ff . H ,

q B , q q


68/313


, ff ff

. ,

q . T q, , ,

q

.Y , q

q ff , .26 B j , ,

, throu h ( -)

A eri n Psy-ho. J ff N q : S

j , , :

j

. T , (Doub e Re din ). I

; , I , s owin down .W , , ff ff q

A eri n Psy ho . I

ff , ffi ff

.27 P A -


69/313


N W H . T

, -- A

(Doub e Re d-

in ). V , , . D z

, B M

, , - ff (28S ,

, , , , ;

, , , , I , ,

. T ff ,

A eri n

Psy ho , B , . A , ff

, , ? H

ff , , z

-

?

B I q . F

A eri n Psy ho ff ;


70/313


( ),

.29 B , , ,

ff ffi ff ( - )

, ,

. M , H , P , , H C , D , D C , H , D CB M , V S , F , D ,

,

ff . S . C

q , B

, , . S ,

ff , ,

ff . N , I , q

,

q

ff ,

ff . R q 30

W I


71/313


,

ff , F J

ff , , D C B

, ffO , ff

ff j . I , ff

ff . T ff

. B D C Frisk ( ) T e S uts ( ),

B E T P L (T e Brotherhood of Muti tion( ), ff , z

j ( , ff q j )

. A P , E

, H . A ,

B ff

. H ; B ; B

ffi ; ;

; D , j ; -


72/313


;

. A qT , , B H , - ,

. A , I q ,

. T

. P

, , .

H , q , if ff E . H ,

. A H , I

(H , E , B ). H , .H rron s eeds u re ise y

th t whi h is bout s owness in the book . T ,

ff H

ff . F , H

, , . N j

, , .F , ff

. F , ,


73/313


U E S . Y ,

- - . P

.) A , ff ff

T j , , , , z

. B , B zG , W H , H L N

,

ff D B

? A q ? T B ,

A eri n Psy ho - ff

. (B H L

B Sq H

B ,

.W

. A ( B ,


74/313


75/313


A eri n Psy ho,

. (,

, , E .) T

I

, ( ) , ,

j H , - ff

. T , ff z

. T ( S S

), ff

, () j , j .

I z E

, z ,

- : ff . I , ff

not ff

. B , , , ,

. (N A eri n Psy ho

. H


76/313


ff .) T ff

ff . T ,

, H E , ff A S N ff ,

, z

( ).

H E ff

-

, ff : . L

, q

, ,

ff j .

N z , , ,

, ff

q , , .32 T , ,

j ff ff . I

j ff , , , j

H , ,


77/313


j q . I

q , , , E , ff

. B , D z , H

, ? I . W

,

(Diff eren e nd Re etition ).I

,

z .33 H , ej E

H ,A eri n Psy ho

. (A

H ff I ,

, , ,

: . R ( )s ,

ff ff , , q

D z j , : Aff , j

: I I I j Cine).


78/313


Representation(al) Costs

S ,

, . I , z H E

A eri n Psy ho

( ) . A , ? N , -

I

( , , !) , ,

( ) . I ,

BE not ( ) does, ,

A eri n Psy ho z

. I . R ,

A

the -

.34A , , ff

j . W A eri-

n Psy ho , ,


79/313


, , ff ff .35 C

O , ff

E , , , j (

- j j ). B

( ), ( ), j

j . (N ,

, L , eff e tive

. I , B ff

,

, B . [. . .] I .) I

. A j

q , I ,

q j . I e er en e

,

j (

) not , I .

C , q ff


80/313


ff , ff

. D z , ff q ( : q

ff .36 T , -

D z G ; , ff ,

ff . F , , q : H ? I

? A ? H , q

, I , E z H - ff

ff M

, . I , ff

q ff

A eri n Psy ho.37


81/313


82/313

Are We A Arno di ns?

( ), j

. H , , B

, , ]

, , ( ).

A . H

, , j . A j

, , (Norton ),

j : , j

, ,

, ( ). Y , z ,

A . A

, L

S , T H H ffi

. A H

[ ] ( )

, , q

, A j ,

.


83/313


A , , A ? YC , ,

z

. I , zEntert in ent Week y, New York i es, tv Ebert nd Ro er t the Movies

j ,

. T . T q j

, , .

C L G (We Gott Get Out ). T

, , . F ,

P P D A (mppda), ff (S z H

mpaa , , , . L

tv A

H . W

, . L

,

F ,

; , j

.


84/313


C , j

. I H ffi

M A . A T F

T e Con uest of Coo , . A

, . A

, A ffi : ,

, ff . E ,

; , ,

, ,

I H - ,

C q , W W II. W

tv ( . ., V , JF L H O )

, H z

(

). T H

j ,

,


85/313


, vhs dvd. , ,

,

j ,

j H . T j

, M G T e P ssion of the Christ ( )

.B , - ,

, A A . Y ,

j .1 I ,

, P M , ,A e ories of Re din ,

j .2 W A

M S q

. I

A j . H ,

M ) A

M j q

. W


86/313


j M

.

Paul de Man: Debunking Meaning

D M S R A

j (N C )

( ).3 H q ,

q :

W ff . N

, : or ons ien e . B

,

, ori er tive ,

, ff . ( , )I , M

, ,

ff . T

,

M : , / j

.


87/313


C , , M ,

, not j .I ,

ff . W N C , ,

, q

q . A M ,

, ,

( ). H , N C

, , .4T M /

q ( ) z

/ , / , , / . D

q how , M

. I ,

: ,

G I , ( ).

F , , M A B , W B

M P ( . .,

). W, , . H


88/313


,

- . T

, , ff ,

. S

q

v ue ud ents :

, , , , . ( , )

M , , M z

( q ) ,

, z

.] ( ). W

M ( ) ,

( ).

Y , N z , M

(

[ ]) -( ) . A M ,

],

( ). T

,


89/313


( ). N

. S ,

; . T , , , z M

, z ( ). T ,

[ ]

; ( ).

H M , q

. H

A . A , , M

j .

/ ,

J ff N , (A terity Po iti s )

. A /

j , M ffi j . A , , ,

j , j . I , M

,


90/313


( ?) . W

j , M

) :

is . I , M ff

j ,

( ) .

Lawrence Grossberg: Aff ecting Cultural Studies

B M

j , : , , A

j ? I

q L Gq , . C , j N H

N M , , ,

.5 R q ,

, , ff

.6 Y , , G , , , I ,

, M j j : ,the e ono y of re resent tion itse f now

e er es s the rob e . J M ff -


91/313


( -

G

.7 I G -

, , .

I T V C , G o i (

). D j j

,

( ). S ,

, G , ,

, , , ff ( ). O , G

z ; F , z

. ., O L E -M S ),

G D z M F . Y , I q G ,

ff ,

:

N A M z

, , ). T


92/313


, ,

, . A ,

ff , , , , j ,

. ( )

N z q

, ,

S , G ,

z ff : . I I

q A eri n Psy ho

q , j . T

G I

inst .T G

, , . O

( ). C , G ,

ud e

( , ). T , , , j

( ). R A (q . G

G


93/313


8 T

z A

, , ( I ) B E

. A , E Less T n Zero

( ) no du our - , - q

E W C . P q E A eri n Psy ho : /

E , j

; E A eri n

Psy ho, , . T , ,

, z j

z .9

S , E ( ) j , A eri nPsy ho T

E , , ,

( ) , , . T

q , ,


94/313


95/313


( ) . I

G q (

, j

S , G

[ ] ( ). T

. A , I ,

F

ff .11

G . S , , ff

, . C ff , G

, , ff -K [ , , j

-

( ). W G , , ff ff

.W B M z G

G


96/313


12 J M

A , G M j

, , : F G ,

j ; ,

.

G , , . R ,

ff

, W

. O , , S

, ( ). C B q

: P, [ ] ,

( ) ( ) ( ) - (- ),

[ z. , ] . A

[ . . . ] ( j ) ( ).

G B ( , , B ,

[ ] ( )? q , B G

G D z , , 13


97/313


T G D z z

. T , M q

j ;

M q

(A ) . T

e n? -

. L , ,

( G . I , ( )

( ) . I ,

q ,

, , j .14

T , , D z

, N H , q mla D z

, N H , D /D . S

j D

j .15 W


98/313


? W D z

( ffi ,

, ffi

), I , G , D

. O , ,

D z D z

, j I 16

, D z , T S A P

-

z ( ).

Gilles Deleuze: Overcoming Platonism

N z P , D z

(S ). I D

q P . A P

. A J q D q W P

M H , P

. A , ,


99/313


P . M , q

B P j ,

, , ,

. S , M j

G

D z j . T ,

P j

.

W , , P D z ? I P . D z , ,

P , , ,

; (S ). P - P

S .17 A , D z ,

. I P ( ),

, , j

A , P , . T , I

ff j ( ). I I

,


100/313


, ,

T , P I - j ( ). W D

ud ent P - , . T

D z P :

.I P , D z ,

[ ] - , ;si u-r , ,

(S

P ff , , ,

( ) I : T

I . T j

) I . H qq j , )

(j ). I , I ,

( ), ,

dissi i rity I : I ff

.O D z

,

B F J .18 T D z ff in kind ; -


101/313


ff . C

, eff e t: [ ] ff

; [ ]

. T ;

T , , ( ). F P

( -)P C ,

I (P

G (C ). F , C , D, G . T

, ,

. W . W ( ). C j ;

, , z .

D z , , . D z

V ,

: L L , R ,

O , , B the ori in nd the o y,the ode nd the re rodu tion ( ). T ( ) onstitutive

, .19 T


102/313


ff ,

, ff , , T C R

, , I

T , , (zz , ,

:

, .20

B P . R ,

, P ,

( ). B

, , K , j ,

. A , j : ff

; (

O , C C , j

, - W ,

j , within . B

(A , , P

j j ; ,

. T


103/313


, , 21 T j ,

(D z , S ), ff ( ), - ( )

, P , W ( j ) , .22

A D z , P z :

- , j ,

( ). A , ff

,

(P ). L

j

. T , , j j ,

j . O , N z j P ff

. A P , , , ,

(N z , U D ). D z P ,

P N z

.23 R , I D z P ( ). P

j . T

ffi j z , j ,


104/313


, A

.24

I , , q . A ,

( ), j j ,

. I , A

F , ( , , .)

j j

. F j

ff j j , - . H , D

P P z

; j .25 R ,

j

. T j q , ff ; , E

A eri n Psy ho( H T e ented Mr. Ri ey), j q : ff

q .

B ffi j

( , ) 26


105/313


W M

, ff (

, D z ff

q , q W

W - , , ? O

q , D z , N

S S .W I

, I , H I . T , D z

j , I j

( j

, ), j , ,is -

. M D z ,

vio en e is there is ff ff

. Y

, B

. I , 27

I , , ff


106/313


107/313


ff ff , , . T

ff , : , ff .28

j j ; , ,

q

.29T , , : ff ,

) , , , . B, ,

ffff diff erent . B j j

ff ; , ( ) ff . T

q ( R , q

, ,

, , , , .30


108/313

A I , B E E

A eri n Psy ho. V M

A ,

z . W C D A M P HT e

ented Mr. Ri ey A ff ,

A .1 A -

, , New Yorker New York i es

H . F , New Yorker

- S C M H ,

L , New York i es H F , N , M K ,

, R E L .2 T

F R -

Patricia Highsmiths Empirical Pedagogy of Violence


109/313

Seri izin Vio en e

S M z T e ented Mr. Ri-ey - - A . F

T J M , A( ) ,

.I M

A A T e En ish P tient( )

P HA q ,

E ff U S

/ / L ( , . ., S

D ), C H ( )

E U S ( ). R

H ffi UM B U H [ ], -

( ). I M , H

. I j T e Se e ted Stories of P tri i Hi hs ith( ) Noth-

in T t Meets the Eye: T e Un o e ted Stories of P tri i Hi hs ith ( ), N H

- , Str n ers on r in( ), B j

, A W Be utifu Sh dow( ). , H M j M

Hi hs ith: A Ro n e of the s( ), . T

, U.S. M , M


110/313

Seri izin Vio en e

H z

q or ity ud -ent . T ,

H ,

, R , . F R C D

[ ] , ,

H . L ,

, T T eented Mr. Ri ey . S

j . H , T

A H

.3 I , M ,e -

. H R

Si ht nd Sound , I

. I I j . I ettin w y with it is his unish ent (J , M B

V , ). L , B , ( )

. I ,

M , j

R q .


111/313

Seri izin Vio en e

I B E E , j

. E z j ,

P B V W , G or ( )

. M A eri n Psy ho

j

. L j , ( ) , I H

j .

H , I ,

, , ff .

A M , H

j .4 H , I H

.5 I , I H z j

. I , P H q j ff

H . I

H F , , q

rob ti ues , ,


112/313

Seri izin Vio en e

(Fou u t Re der ). M - F , j G D z ,

, (Diff eren e nd Re etition ).6 I ,

ff F . H , . Y

(Fou u t Re der ). A

H jT ff , , ,

throu h q ,

. T , - -

, , P ot-tin nd Writin of Sus ense Fi tion( ), H

, , q j q

.7I , H , q j

, H

T H

q z j ,

, , ff . M

j . I , j , , . H

, , R (

j


113/313

Seri izin Vio en e

. I , H

, , . S

, P ottin nd Writin )

j . ,

, z ( ). I ,

q , j ( ). F H , ,

j , , ,

.I , I j H

R

A q j q . H

ff ,

. T ( H ) j ,

j ff ,

.I ,

, , H A N

,E ire, D z G . J

H ,

, H N


114/313

Seri izin Vio en e

, ,

j, ,

A . A j E ire -

ff , H

E . H ff ,

ff :

E .T H

, ,

,

j E . I ,

intensities , H

, , , . V , H ,

. T

q

( ) .

Violence, Judgment, and Writing

R P H -

q


115/313

Seri izin Vio en e

j , . I . A H ,

: S [ ] I didnt ind . S

, I , P . I

.I didnt ind one bit (D , ). I , ff

, ,

ff . I

sty e H

.,

, , ,

H , q , .M

j . I j

. C

, q .8 A D z

, , , q

q j , , ,

, , ,


116/313

Seri izin Vio en e

( H D ). A , H B q I

, j .9

, I not H -

; q

. R , I sty e ,

, . H ,

, I ttitude H

z . J

( ) j , j .

q j

mfa U S

S P , A S , L . S

I , , , I , I I

(D ). H j - O

z ),


117/313

Seri izin Vio en e

N z

.10 I , I H . R ,

, H

. T , , , rob ti ue. R

, , . T , ,

.

R H

,

, , , ff D z

. W D z (

), H

, j . B H D z j J H

, D z ,

, . [ . . . ] W (L L ).11 I ,

q , z

.


118/313

Seri izin Vio en e

T H q

q j q

. H : W , I

, I (H, ). W , , ,

j H ? A , , , ff

ff q j ff ?12

H , R , H

. G z H

qj ff

z . C H R H ,

q K , , R

R

- - : [ . . . ] - S

: j K G K R

, j (F , R , H

, , ( ). T


119/313

Seri izin Vio en e

H j H

.I , I , R

intensi tion H

. T z

. E H

I , , ,

z ,

I . H

,

, . I

, , j .

I , ff

. C ,

. A , H

. A

,

F zz

. T rob ti ues H ,


120/313

Seri izin Vio en e

, , ,

.

A H

. T T e ented Mr. Ri ey .Str n ers on r in( )

(B ) (G ).T e Pri e of S t

( ) ( . .

. T j

.O , , H . A H

C ro ( H ),

T e Pri e of S t ,

. P , A

, , ( ),

q H

, C M , ( ), j

; ,

ff .E T e Pri e of S t -


121/313

Seri izin Vio en e

H , ,

. A H q

T e Pri e of S t, ff q ff

Found in the Street [ ] S : Su er Idy). F , T e B underer ( ), ,

(W S ) j (G K ), , .

I , . I , R R , ,

( ff

j ) () , ,

H , , , z . O , ,

q ( ), j

J ff Str n ers on r inT e B underer. T H

, . O , H

j j

ff A D C , W , T e B und-erer, z

[ ] C [


122/313

Seri izin Vio en e

], K [ ,

ff ( ) W see in . K W ,

, K . B W

K

j K , ,

W K .B ,

q ) R , H q j j q ff , ,

. T , , q j , ,

q j , .13S

, . B

. ,

T e ented Mr. Ri ey, H . T

,

ff I , R

, ,

H , ,

.14I ,


123/313

Seri izin Vio en e

. I H

q j , H

. T

. I ,

D z

, (Cine ).15 A

A , N Y , E , F , S z ,

G F , H E

A z .16 B

A ,

- ( H

K

; ,

, ,

(D z ,Cine ). R , H

j

, , . N , , H R

(P ottin nd Writin ).


124/313

Seri izin Vio en e

Becoming-Violent

T e ented Mr. Ri ey H R , q

. I , R ,

, q P . H

, R . I ,

R T e ented Mr. Ri ey - j -

M . R G ,

, I , D , U

j G . R ,

q D , . E , , D . R

, D . T

, I q D , M , ,

F M , D R . B

, R , , , ,

, .

C T e ented Mr. Ri ey,

M , H q R . B R

,


125/313

Seri izin Vio en e

H , ,

RD R ,

,

ff , R

, ffi ff e tive R

, , E H ( ) 17

M , , z R j

q

R . Y , ff -

ffi R , , H

H j . I

H j ff

R - .18B , G - ,

( ) M . G R . H

q

. L G , ( )

q , , , -


126/313

Seri izin Vio en e

. F ( ),

H . I So e-thin in hi h d s e t it out nd e t t it even before his br in ( ,

). T H , (H

) , R

, B , F , D z , :

( ) z

.C R

, H R

. H , H R ff

, ( ), ( )

ff e tive .D z :

T . [ . . . ] D

. R ,

. [ . . . ]So ethin in the wor d for es us to think.T j

en ounter. [W ] ff e tive : , , ,

ff . I , . (Diff eren e nd Re etition ,

)


127/313

Seri izin Vio en e

D z [ R

H : R . M , Rre-

s onds . T , , . H

( ), R not -

, , z .

I , , D z G -

19 B -, A T ous nd P te us,

( ), [ ] ( ). - . R

q D D . F , , ; ,

( ), ( ), ( ), ff ( ), ff

z ( ). I , ,

z

, - (D z P ,Di o ues ). -D

,

,

: , j ,

,


128/313

Seri izin Vio en e

. [ . . . ] T

. I zone of roxi -

ity (T ous nd P te us ). A H ,

G , ff

ff ff [ ]

(T ous nd P te us ). R .S , , H

n of res onse.I j G (

D ), R

. I , R

, ff . B D z : W -

(

T q . I ,

(Fou u t ). T -, , ,

z , . T ff , , . T

. H , , H :

, ff I

, ff

. T D . B ,


129/313

Seri izin Vio en e

z , -D j : ,

M D , .20 R M , D

( ), i ines , ,ex erien es ff j : T

, , M

( ). T , (R

[ ] M . G ), . S

q M jM

D ), , D

( ). I , ( ).

A ff , -D . H ,

D j M (

. I ,

[ . . . ] ood

te er ent , . T

( , ). I , H sty e,

, . A

ff ,


130/313

Seri izin Vio en e

.21 A , ,

, : tv. -D , j ,

ff . I - D . H -D

. T z DL D ,

D . W z G

z - . T

D / - , D

- : D -D .22W C S

D , ff , , , ,

- : D

z , ff , , . H

D . I . B , ,

. N , , D

, ? H D ( ). I ,


131/313


132/313

Seri izin Vio en e

H j is .

. M - ,

( R

[ ]) -

: H , , , , , t

( ). T ,

, intense y, intense y

( , ). I , , , , ff ,

z , .H ff , q

, ff : , ( Hq z ) -D . T

, H

E , T e ented Mr. Ri ey, H -

( D, [ ])

. I , ( ). B I H

j ,

q


133/313

Seri izin Vio en e

( ) , , .24 I , H j

is -. T H q j

(T e B underer) q intense

j .

, , q . I ,

H rob ti ue:

q j , q

. Y j . F ,

ff ,

- -D , D q - . F ,

j . A , j

D M , ,

( ). J , ro eeds with too u h s eed j -

. I q j .

Empirical Violence

W H

rob ti ue j ,


134/313

Seri izin Vio en e

j . Y R ff C , H

T eented Mr. Ri ey. T , ,

Dee W ter T e wo F es of J nu ry, , (T is Sweet Si kness [ ] T e wo F es of J nu ry) -

(Dee W ter, A G e for the Livin [ ]; T e Cry of the Ow [ ],

). G ,

. I , , j , , -

( ) . A ,

D S H . R ,

ff

, H

,

) . I , 25

F , T e wo F es of J nu ry, RK , CM F , ( )

ff K . D M F K , K . . B


135/313

Seri izin Vio en e

, K M F ,

M M F K ,

. L , D K T is Sweet Si k-ness

, K z . T

H , . K

, , ff .

B q :

H ? S

zz j q

O H , P C T e G ss Ce

( ) S B T e Story- e er( ).T e G ssCe ff

j . I , q P : ,

. M ff T e Story- e er. H ,

B , - , :

( ) . R T e Story-

e er


136/313

Seri izin Vio en e

, H , ,

, H . H , H ,

Str n ers on r in, q , I

(C -C ). H ,

H q ,T ose Who W k Aw y

( ) T e re or of For ery ( ), - (

- , , H

, , , j . T

H . A H, ;

j , , .

I , , H j ,

T e ented Mr. Ri ey. R

H ( ), I ffi

ff , , . A ffi

26 I , H ff . A

T e re or of For ery , -


137/313

Seri izin Vio en e

- , H I , A ,

. A N Y

I , j . O ,

. N ,

, . T : j

?27 O

?R - -

-

H , , q j ( , -

z : G , , - , ,

S U [I ] , A ,

. A I , ,

q j , . M , A ,

, ( ?)

I . S , A I A

J -C . A I ( )


138/313

Seri izin Vio en e

. I , D J, A z

A ,

A . C , H ,

j , ( A

).W , H j , j

. S ,

, j

q j ( )

. T , , j .T e ented Mr. Ri ey

. T H

( j

N ,T e re or of For ery j . I , ,

T eented Mr. Ri ey; , H

, .

O , ff

( , q

), ff H ,


139/313

Seri izin Vio en e

. I , H , :

j . T , I

, I (P ottin nd Writin ). I ,

ff

, B , ,

. (I . R , ,

T ff

. I , , H

rob ti ue,

j . H h d ff

I , J S , H , j H

R : T M . R , H

. V,

, ( , ). I , S

ff H. H : H

, rob -ti ue,


140/313

Seri izin Vio en e

j . A I H , , . T , ,

; , T e ented Mr. Ri ey,

, (R ),

. T , , j , , . I H

, ,

, , , , ,

V ff ,

q . P, rob ti ue

. T : , H

/j / .

T H Ri ey Under Ground ( )

, W W II (A )

W . M H A N E -

ire j

W z RB W W II ,

, , E : I


141/313

Seri izin Vio en e

E . I de entered deter-

ritori izin ,

, , . T

( ).

T z

: E W z

, , ,

. E , , ,

, D z G , T

, (Anti-Oedi us ).T q z . A H

, ( ,

M ). N

, , E z ff

. [B ] [ . . . ] reor nize redire t

. [ . . . ] T E ,

( , ). A , .

H , I z ,

H N


142/313

Seri izin Vio en e

, , ( ) . F

, H N

, : D [ ff ],

E

, -

. W E M

( ).H N

( ) [ ]:

this , -

( ). I , , ffi j . I , q

, H N

ff . I , E

ff ( ).28 H ,

. T , ( ) ; ,

, .29

q j , ,


143/313


144/313

Seri izin Vio en e

: -

( , , .), ,

o i ity (Or ns without Bodies ). T -

or , , ( ) ,

, . L ,

, , ,

. A

H N :

I C

. W

, ngo ( E q

. I ,or

intervention h s be o e front ine for e of i eri interven-tion. I ff ,

, , ff

. T ngo - E ;

j . [ . . . ]Mor intervention often serves s the rst tth t re res the st e for i it ry intervention. ( ,

)


145/313

Seri izin Vio en e

I q , ,

( ff ). A , j

. I , I N , j

q ff

, , , q , . J zthe out-

side is intern ized ( ), j E , j

.

Intensifying Violence through Serialization

P H ,T e ented Mr. Ri ey. H , ,

H N

, ,

.30 O A - E ,

A z , , H ff H

Y , j E ire W W

H ff , j

, ,


146/313

Seri izin Vio en e

, ffi . A

H throu h ,

R . C R

, , RH , H

q ( ), I

,

( ),

ff N z , .

T , , H . R

ff z ,

, D z G

itiner tion, z E R

ff .I H

, , .31 F H ,

, , , . F ,

,

R S B


147/313

Seri izin Vio en e

. Y ,

. I , ff : . H

, , . T , . S

z . H ,

. V , ,

T H . I , re e ted . A

, , I R re or of

For ery.32

R , , H I K z

(Found tions . ),

H N z z

H ,

. R , H

ff . I z H

q N z .33 I ,

, D z N z H

. A D z , N z K , , ,


148/313

Seri izin Vio en e

(Diff eren e nd Re etition ).H

K z

( ); , beyond . [ . . . ] T

, ,

, j

abel-violent_affect_literature_cinema

Documents