a revolution in marketing
DESCRIPTION
Chicago Booth Magazine, Spring 2009: A Revolution in MarketingTRANSCRIPT
-
Chicago Booth Magazine Spring 2OO922
Cover A Revolution in Marketing
A Revolution in MARketing
-
23Spring 2OO9 Chicago Booth Magazine
The days of the big, splashy television commercial are not over. But the ads have become
part of an expanding and more exacting set of marketing tacticsviral videos, Twitter
feeds, and customized messagesthat companies use to connect with consumers.
Explosions in technology have given marketers unparalleled freedom in how they promote
a brand, and as a result, marketing is undergoing a revolution. Firms now start by devel-
oping a finely honed marketing strategy for a brand and end by capturing measurable
results with hard dataan approach that has long been in fashion at Chicago Booth. In
fact, an unprecedented amount of data will be available this year with ACNielsens new
agreement to share household panel data with Chicago Booths Marketing Data Center,
putting the school at the forefront of marketing for the 21st century. By Patricia Houlihan
How Chicago Is Going Beyond the Buzz
A Revolution in MARketing
-
Chicago Booth Magazine Spring 2OO924
Everybody loves a great ad. Done well, it not only moves more product, it also generates conversation around the water cooler at the office and even media buzz. This was the case with the Doritos 30-second television com-
mercial during the 2007 Super Bowl, a humorous episode that
showed a cute couple meeting after a fender-bender induced
by their mutual love for the snack chip. What drew the media
spotlight was the fact that it had been made by a Doritos fan
and was the winner of a competition sponsored by Frito-Lay,
a gutsy move that deepened the brands relationship with its
16- to 24-year-old consumers. The innovative shift has shaped
the firms approach to Super Bowl advertising, and the con-
test is now an annual event. This year, the consumers ad for
Doritos actually beat out all other ads to place number-one
in the two most-watched Superbowl polls in USA Today and
YouTube, proving that taking risks and doing marketing dif-
ferently can pay huge dividends, said Ann Mukherjee, 94,
group vice president for marketing at Frito-Lay North Amer-
ica, who led the effort.
Frito-Lay has large, mature brands. To drive ongoing
growth of something this big, we had to move beyond tradi-
tional marketing, she said. For the Super Bowl, she said, we
bought a TV spot and said to consumers, You create an ad. We
wont edit it. And well let other consumers pick the winner,
which well put on the largest advertising stage possible. Thats
the kind of fundamental shift weve created at Frito-Lay.
Being able to lead a team of executives to consider the strat-
egy is where her training at Chicago Booth came into play,
Mukherjee said. Thats where I learned to look at a business
holistically and under-
stand the economic
value that marketing
drove within that model.
Marketing is not a sup-
port function; marketing
becomes a key enabler
for understanding how
to generate sustainable
growth for a business.
In the changing environment that we live in today, you have
to be nimble enough to drive different frameworks and keep
ahead of the pace.
Mukherjees experience illustrates how Chicago Booths
approach to marketing is not only changing the field, its
also shaping the world of business. Peter Rossi, Joseph T. and
Bernice S. Lewis Professor of Marketing and Statistics, said,
What distinguishes Chicago Booth marketing is a melding
of models and data. We are not content to simply describe
or measure the effects of marketing actions; we also opti-
mize the use of marketing funds. We bring the results of that
research to the classroom. Thats where Chicago Booth stu-
dents learn how to apply innovative marketing theory in a way
that marketing becomes a key driver of business growth.
Taking an innovative route is something David Appel,
AB 81, MBA 82, understands in a way few marketers do.
Currently CEO of Vision LLC, he left Accenture to join the
family business, Orange
Glo, the cleaning prod-
ucts firm that beat such
industry giants as Clorox
with its innovative mar-
keting of OxiClean. Pro-
moted through infomer-
cials, the stain remover
captured a majority of
the U.S. retail market,
making it the first mass-distribution consumer product to
succeed using that channel. Annual revenue exceeded $300
million before Orange Glo was sold in 2006.
Appel thinks of himself as a marketer, although he led that
company and now heads two other firms. His concentration
at Chicago Booth included finance and accounting as well as
marketing. The best marketers have a complete view of the
business and understand everything about bringing a prod-
uct to market, because if youre not the leader of the business,
who is? he said. Quantitative tools help you make good
marketing decisions. How do you decide what makes a com-
pany valuable? You try to create a brand thats worth some-
thing and repeatable and sustainable and has fairly limited
competitive threats.
Managing a Brandor a Company
Among those who have a master grasp of brand potential is
James Kilts, 74, who built a reputation and a career on his
ability to rejuvenate stagnant brands and revitalize trou-
bled corporations. He has restored the flagging sales of Kool-
Aid, Oscar Mayer, Oreo, Life Savers, Kraft cheese, and Plant-
ers peanuts. When Nabisco named him president and CEO
in 1998, its market share for brands representing 90 percent
of the companys U.S. sales was declining. In just 18 months,
Kilts engineered a turnaround that resulted in market share
growing for 90 percent of its brands. His success attracted the
Cover A Revolution in Marketing
-
25Spring 2OO9 Chicago Booth Magazine
attention of the Gillette Company,
which appointed Kilts chairman
and CEO in 2001, the first outsider
to run the firm in 70 years. The
razor and battery maker had missed
its quarterly earnings estimates for
four years; its stock had plummeted
62 percent in two years. Kilts led a turnaround and sold Gil-
lette to Procter & Gamble for $57 billion in 2005.
Whats important is understanding how to turn data into
information and knowing how to make decisions about the
results, he said. At Chicago, I learned to be very analytical,
to absorb as many facts
as possible, and then [to]
extract direction and, ulti-
mately, conclusions from
those facts. Kilts, who
gave the naming gift for
the James M. Kilts Center
for Marketing at Chicago
Booth, describes his expe-
riences in the book, Doing
What Matters: How to Get Results That Make a DifferenceThe
Revolutionary Old-School Approach. There are a lot of general-
izations about consumers that everyone is fond of making, but
what you really have to do is understand how the consumer
thinks in the context of your category, Kilts explained. You
need to know the consumers wants, needs, and tradeoffs, and
that requires good analytical workboth qualitative research
and, importantly, quantitative research.
Now a partner at Centerview Partners, an investment bank-
ing and private equity firm, Kilts said marketing remains his
passion. Its all about finding the fundamental connection
with consumers, making sure all the programs and communi-
cation around the brand are focused on linking with those con-
sumers and their fundamental needs, and making those needs
relevant to todays marketplace.
Todays marketers say analytics have become even more rel-
evant, said David Knoepfle, 03, marketing manager at Wm.
Wrigley Jr. Company. One of the common challenges we face
is a constant pressure to justify the expenditures we make and
to ensure our programs are giving our shareholders an ade-
quate rate of return, he said. It goes back to ROI. With the
economy this tough, having a strong understanding of the P&L
for the program youre putting into place and the return it will
give you is key. Having people who are well versed in analyzing
the business and analyzing the decisions we make is a definite
asset at any time, but particularly in a down economy.
Broad Audience for the Chicago Approach
In teaching strategic marketing, faculty drive home the fun-
damentals of how to run a business. The fundamentals dont
change because of trends like the internet or because were
in a recession. Theres no new set of principles, said Jean-
Pierre Dub, Sigmund E. Edelstone Professor of Marketing.
Marketing faculty at Chicago Booth focus their research on
typical problemsadvertising, pricing, customer segmenta-
tion, customer preferences. But with economics as the basis
for forming theories and constructing models, the papers are
published in top marketing, economics, statistics, and psy-
chology journals, giving Chicago Booth research a broader
audienceand a broader impact.
In fact, Dub; Sanjay Dhar, James H. Lorie Professor of
Marketing; and Bart Bronnenberg shared the 2008 Paul E.
Green Award for their study Consumer Packaged Goods in
the United States: National Brands, Local Branding, which
documented striking geographic patterns in the performance
of national brands. Two coffee brands, Folgers and Maxwell
House, dominate the U.S. market with roughly equal shares of
volume sold. However, in some regions, Folgers garners consid-
erably more share than Maxwell House; in other regions, the
situation is reversed. We went through company archives and
traced when these brands rolled out in different cities, Dub
said. We did this for several product categories and found
that being the first to roll out in these marketssometimes
over a century agois
a very good predictor of
whether a brand has the
highest market share in
that market today. This
incredible degree of per-
sistence is surprising
both for academics and
for brand managers in
these categories.
Whats important is understanding how to turn
data into information and knowing how to make
decisions about the results.James Kilts, 74
A Revolution in MARketing
-
Chicago Booth Magazine Spring 2OO926
Cover A Revolution in Marketing
In a follow-up study, Dub and Matthew Gentzkow, asso-
ciate professor of economics and Neubauer Family Faculty
Fellow, are working with co-author Bronnenberg on why his-
tory would persist in the current performance of a brand.
Weve obtained shopping data on 75,000 households across
the country from ACNielsen, then surveyed these house-
holds about the city where the primary shopper was born,
was educated, and currently resides. Were studying whether
people buy the brands that are popular where they currently
live versus where they grew up; were testing whether shoppers
take their brand preferences with them when they move to a
region that has different brand-buying habits.
Enriching the Marketing Data Center
Faculty have gained an important step toward having even
greater access to data this year. Nielsen agreed to share
its household panel data with Chicago Booth and to
update it annually. Housed at the Kilts Center, the Marketing
Data Centercreated by Rossi with the help of Kiltswill
enable Chicago to develop the first longitudinal marketing
data sets available for academic study and classroom use.
Over time, well be able to accumulate a data set that is
unique and will allow us to answer questions people have
posed that were unanswerable in the past, Rossi said. Tradi-
tional marketing research has been viewed as one-off studies,
but this data set will help managers understand how things
might evolve rather than just focusing on the next quarter.
Well have a confluence of data and models, and to bring sci-
ence to marketing, you need both.
The Marketing Data Center puts Chicago Booth on the
map as the premier source for mar-
keting data in the world. If you
really understand marketing, its
clear that a revolution is taking
place, said dean Edward Snyder.
Its moving from people with some
judgment, anecdotes, and stories
to professionals with deep insights
into markets and organizations who can use more sophisti-
cated tools and data to draw even more insights from broad-
based experiments that let them evaluate data, test results, and
improve performance.
That revolution, Snyder said, is going to happen at Chi-
cago Booth. We have the faculty, and now well have the data
from Nielsen. Were deep into experiments with such faculty
as Steven Levitt [William B. Ogden Distinguished Service
Professor in Economics and the College] and such experien-
tial learning as Management Lab, Marketing Research, and
Consumer Behavior, courses designed to prepare students
for roles where marketing integrates with other business func-
tions to drive growth. Hopefully, well have partnerships with
other schools that will generate even more data, ensuring flow
from different product sets and geographies, Snyder said.
Nielsen data will allow more and better quantitative market
research, an area where
Chicago Booth faculty
have taken top prizes.
Associate professor of
marketing Gnter Hitsch
won the Frank M. Bass
Award from the Institute
for Operations Research
and the Management
Sciences (INFORMS) in
2007 for his research on dynamic decision models, a frontier
area for marketing. Ive been able to make progress by advanc-
ing statistical methods, especially computational techniques
that allow me to tackle previously unsolvable, complex deci-
sion problems, he explained. Much of his research focuses on
dynamic marketing strategies, i.e., situations where marketing
decisions that firms make today have effects on future sales,
profits, and competitive reactions.
In the paper Tipping And Concentration in Markets With
Indirect Network Effects that Hitsch coauthored with Dub
and Pradeep Chintagunta, Robert Law Professor of Market-ing, they noted that sudden shifts in market share are likely
in industries that have competing yet incompatible stan-
dards. In the market for video game consoles, for instance, the
industry is characterized by indirect network effectsthe
positive feedback loop in which increased hardware sales
result in more software titles, which, in turn, increase hard-
ware sales. As a result, indirect network effects can cause a
market to tip quickly in favor of one standard.
They developed a model calibrated with data from the
Well have a confluence of data and
models, and to bring science to marketing,
you need both.Professor Peter Rossi
-
27Spring 2OO9 Chicago Booth Magazine
OLD APPROACH
Reliance on survey data
Focus on outcomes of consumer decisions
Measuring marketing effects
Use descriptive models
Focus on short-run profitability
REvOLuTiOnARy APPROACH
Insights from marketplace data
Examine the process consumers use to make decisions
Optimizing marketing activities
Use models based on behavioral processes
Emphasize drivers of long-term value
video game console market that generates predictions that
can be used to measure the extent of tipping. In that market,
he said, this tipping depends on consumers valuations of soft-
ware and on consumer expectations. The work was one of sev-
eral papers presented at the Quantitative Marketing and Eco-
nomics (QME) conference in 2007, hosted by the Kilts Center,
Chicago Booth, INFORMS Society for Marketing Science,
and Springer, publisher
of the QME journal.
The latest faculty
accomplishments build
on a tradition of innova-
tive marketing research
at Chicago. For instance,
Rossi proved the value
of targeted couponing
based on household pur-
chase histories, which he outlined in the paper The Value of
Purchase History Data in Target Marketing, published in Mar-
keting Science in 1996. Rossi and other faculty in the statistics
group pioneered advanced modeling methods that facilitate the
estimation of large-scale modelsmodeling used by Demand-
Tec, which makes software that helps manufacturers and such
retailers as Wal-Mart and PETCO predict consumer demand
and develop strategies for pricing and promotions.
Among alumni who employ the analytical approach are
Dhiraj Rajaram, 03, founder and CEO of Mu Sigma, a pioneer in analytics outsourcing and data-driven decision
making, and Dick Buell, 78, chairman and CEO of Catalina Marketing, which triggers promotions and advertisements
based on the consumers purchase behavior (either UPC scans
or ID cards) that are delivered at the point of sale.
Preparing the next Generation of Marketers
Faculty take their research into the classroom, and also gain
insight from students, said Dub, who teaches pricing. Every
year, I try to add something new related to my research.
While the class content is getting richer each year, its also
getting slightly harder, but the students always rise to the
challenge. Students also inform faculty research by sharing
what goes on in the field. Weve nailed consumer behavior,
but firms dont always behave the way we would predict with
our theories, he said.
Coursework laid the foundation quickly for Jessica Lindor,
a career-changing first-year student who landed a market-
ing internship at Kraft. The Marketing Strategy course
gave me the entire framework for analyzing problems. In my
Data-Driven Marketing course, we used Nielsen data, so I
understood what all the terms meant before I got to Kraft.
Assigned to the California Pizza Kitchen (CPK) brand, she
had three assignments, including bringing the consumer to
life. I came up with the idea of creating a website, which was
so well-received that I spent my last week on the road, show-
ing it to people outside the brand team. That was great because
I saw it wasnt just an internship project, it was a tool that
could be used by everybody at Kraft who needed a really good
understanding of the consumer in the years to come. n
Some indications that the Revolution is under WayHere are highlights of the revolutionary approach to marketing that is under wayapproaches led by Chicago Booth.
A Revolution in MARketing
-
Chicago Booth Magazine Spring 2OO928
Cover A Revolution in Marketing
David Booth, 71, provisionally agreed in the summer of 2008 to give a gift that could change the name of his alma mater. Although the change hinged on approval from the University of Chicago Board of Trustees that fall,
dean Edward Snyder and executive director of marketing Chris
iannuccilli immediately embarked upon a massive, secret
effort over 20 weeks to rename the schoolprovided the vote
was favorable.
Their first step was to quickly convene a steering committee
comprised of deputy deans Richard Leftwich, Mark Zmijewski,
and Stacey Kole to guide the renaming and plan its announce-
ment. They also sought out Gary i. Singer, 78, founder of Red-
line Results, for his renaming
expertise and corporate branding
experience, and Bart Crosby of
Crosby Associates, who had
designed the schools wordmark
and brand identity a decade ago. Singer conducted stake-
holder interviews with the steering committee, Booth,
former deans Robert Hamada and Jack Gould, and key alumnus
James Kilts, 74, to see where everyone aligned and diverged.
Selecting the schools name was a major step, one that
involved much discussion among committee members who
heard several recommendations, debated them, and resolved
them. The steering group recognized that Davids generous
gift offered the school the opportunity to help close its repu-
tational gap, Singer said. Moving from the combination of
a place name (Chicago) and the generic description of what
the school does (graduate school of business) to the right
name that offered the potential to create a more ownable
brand was an important decision treated with Chicago-style
seriousness and rigor.
After lengthy consideration, the committee also decided to
replace the word graduate with Booths last name. By decid-
ing to drop graduate, we join the brands that have left the name
of what they do behindApple Computers is now Apple, which
has allowed it to be so much more, Iannuccilli said.
Ultimately, we chose the University of Chicago Booth
School of Business as the formal name and Chicago Booth as
a common version that could eventually be shortened further
to Booth. The committee members agreed that this was the
best direction for the school.
As a marketer, Iannuccilli was charged with the next steps:
develop a messaging strategy for the name change (and, effec-
tively, for the school), create a new visual identity, craft a media
strategy that maximized the window of interest created by the
gift and naming, develop advertising to splash the new name,
launch a new website, and change the building signage on four
campuses. Additional wrinkles included announcing the
gift publicly three days after a presidential election and a day
after Chicago Booth would be defending its number-one rank-
ing as the countrys best business school when BusinessWeek
released its biannual report. And the announcement had to be
kept secret until members of the University of Chicago Board
of Trustees voted on it.
What Works
The steering committee also agreed upon key points, which
provided focus and momentum, Iannuccilli said. For
instance, closing both the brand and endowment gaps was
the most strategic imperative for the school, and continuing
to embrace and celebrate its rich heritage, values, and accom-
plishments was essential. Our key competitive advantage
is our outstanding faculty, who are the drivers of past and
future success. We realized the renaming gift gave us a unique
opportunity to clarify what makes the school meaningfully
distinctive, and to tell our story more crisply and concisely,
he said. Finally, committee members knew that implementa-
tion would have to be bold and aggressive.
The Branding of the Gift The strategy behind the naming of Chicago Booth
We knew we had to maximize the moment when the spotlight was on us.Chris iannuccilli
-
29Spring 2OO9 Chicago Booth Magazine
Successfully creating or strengthening a brand begins with
identifying core characteristics, and Singer had led numerous
firms through this exercise, including McDonalds, as one of
the leading branding experts at Leo Burnett, DArcy, McKin-
sey, and Interbrand. Chicago is one of the places where you
can come up with a long list of attributes, too, Singer said.
Ultimately, we identified three core values: intellectual rigor
and debate, continuous ideas that shape business, and people
who create lasting value. Well-identified, the values strike a
resounding chord with everyone who has a stake in the brand,
both internal and external constituencies.
Crosby, who had been involved early in the process, was
given free rein to
develop the new visual
identity, a blank slate
in terms of colors,
fonts, looks, and treat-
ment. We explored
hundreds of them,
Iannuccilli said. It
was an opportunity
to address all sorts of
brand evolutions and
needs. The new iden-
tity was selected both
for its link to the now-
familiar Chicago GSB
logo, but also for its
bold, streamlined, graphic presence thats easily adaptable to a
range of uses, from signage to gear, he said.
Communications strategy for the November 7 launch was
planned and executed by select high-level staff who worked
with trusted, longtime partners. University-wide public rela-
tions professionals including Allan Friedman of Chicago Booth
gave the Wall Street Journal, Chicago Tribune, and New York
Times access to key sources in exchange for an embargoed story,
then handled the media-wide announcement. Alumni affairs
staff arranged for a champagne toast with full-time students,
faculty, and staff in the Rothman Winter Gardena surprise
announced 30 minutes earlier. Marketing staff prepared a
special issue of the magazine and developed a web microsite,
homepage rotation, and email notifications. Building signage
was created and was installed overnight. We were able to rely
on vendors and partners we had worked with for years, Ian-
nuccilli said. We said, The gift could be jeopardized if this gets
out. We have to give the trustees the ability to vote on it.
The culmination came at 5:23 pm, when Snyder made the
official announcement and the Wall Street Journal sent an email
blast to millions of subscribers with the news, Iannuccilli said.
I got it on my iPhone when I was in the winter garden.
Spreading the Word
Full-page ads ran immediately. Media around the world
picked up the story. And BusinessWeek postponed its rank-
ing announcement by one week, enabling Chicago Booth to
gain extra time in the spotlight when the school maintained
its number-one status. We got a bit lucky on the media
front, but we were ready, he said. We knew we had to max-
imize the moment
when the spotlight
was on us.
Executing from
that point forward
was key. We werent
able to bring alumni,
students, or faculty
into the decision-
making process
ahead of time, so it
had to be done well,
Iannuccilli said. By
7 a.m. the follow-
ing day, much of the
signage at Chicago
Booths four campuses had been changed. We wanted stu-
dents to be proud of their school and to see this was the
way we were going to move forward. And we gave away
gear immediately so they could start participating in it and
become part of it. We couldnt do that with 43,000 alumni
but we sent out the special issue, and Ted had an online chat.
We wanted them to get to know David, to learn how he based
his investment management approach on the efficient mar-
kets theory of Gene Fama, which led to the incredible suc-
cess of Dimensional Fund Advisors. It was perfect for us to
rename ourselves after David.P.H.
Learn more about the renaming effort at ChicagoBooth.
edu/booth/, or recapture the excitement of the November
7 announcement by going to ChicagoBooth.edu/ontheweb and
entering the keyword excitement. See whats new in Chicago Booth
gear at ChicagoBooth.edu/store.
A Revolution in MARketing
-
Chicago Booth Magazine Spring 2OO930
Cover A Revolution in Marketing
in the constant battle for brand recognition, renaming a brand presents a rare opportunity: a time of heightened visibility and a chance to re-tell a brands timeless story in a way thats fresh and forward-looking. Those who do it well
find a balance between celebrating the brands heritage and
jump-starting it with an aspirational pushand avoid the
pitfalls along the way.
Successful marketers know that every discussion about managing a brand starts at the same place: defining in simple
terms what truly makes it meaningfully distinctive. First, you
have to understand what makes the brand timeless to begin
with, said Ann Mukherjee, 94, group vice president for mar-
keting at Frito-Lay North America.
What are some of the things that
are non-negotiable in terms of what
the brand represents?
The answer drives value in every-
thing you do, said Gary i. Singer, 78,
founder of Redline Results, a brand-
ing consulting firm. You can use it
as a decision-making tool to decide
what your priorities are, as an align-
ment to get your employees to figure
out whats important to do when they
get to work, as a tool to sharpen your go-to-market offerings
the products or services you sell and what makes you different.
And it goes beyond the functional. It also includes the tenor of
the place, the DNA.
In changing a brands name, organizations that manage the
transition successfully are able to link the new name with the
long-standing core attributes. When a donation from an indi-
vidual renames an organization, the new name is a particu-
larly good fit if the donors personal story illustrates the orga-
nizations core values. Such is the case with Booth, said noted
turnaround expert James Kilts, 74, now a partner at Cen-
terview Partners. David epitomizes the values of the school.
Hes a financial expert, an entrepreneur, and a great marketer.
And as he says, he owes all those characteristics to his success
at the university, Kilts said. Ann McGill, Sears Roebuck Pro-
fessor of General Management, Marketing, and Behavioral
Science, echoed the sentiment. David is the Chicago Booth
School of Business.
Managing Mistakes
Singer admits its easy to get caught up in the search for the
perfect name. He recalled a point working on a project for
McDonalds when it was decided to take a pass on an answer
that was really elegant and cooland if you wrote it up in
a marketing textbook, people would say, Thats really excit-
ingfor another answer that was probably 70 to 80 percent
as good as the first one but was more likely to be embraced
by several critical internal constituents. Mary Dillon, McDon-
alds chief marketing officer, made the smart call that getting
successful adoption and implementation was a lot more pow-
erful than coming up with a really cool answer.
Singer says that in most cases, there are probably three or
four names that are good enough. The real trick is to come up
with a brand name and a process that engage the right people
in the right way so that theyre enthusiastic about it and sup-
port it and give it momentum.
Firms that use renaming to try to solve a business prob-
lem, such as a poor public image, do not succeed. I dont
know how many years its been since Philip Morris changed
its name to Altria, Singer said. To this day, I hear people
Building a 21st-Century Brand Using a renaming opportunity to boost brand equity
The real trick is to come up with a brand
name and a process that engage the right
people in the right way so that theyre
enthusiastic about it and support it and
give it momentum.Gary i. Singer, 78
-
31Spring 2OO9 Chicago Booth Magazine 31
say, Altria, formerly Philip Morris. What did they accom-
plish? Theyve actually heightened the fact theyre a cigarette
company, as opposed to diminishing it. Mukherjee called
it being apologetic. She said, Theyll become apologetic
for who they are and try to stand
for something theyre not. Great
marketing isnt giving people a dif-
ferent answer, its helping them
reframe the way theyre thinking
about the question.
Companies also invariably fail
when they try to attach the new
name to something that lacks the core characteristics. Long-
time marketer Rishad Tobaccowala, 82, now CEO of Denuo,
recalled Coca-Colas disastrous introduction of New Coke.
What they tried to do was keep the same name with a new
moniker, which was New Coke, but make a drink that was
more like Pepsi. In that particular case, what Coke stood for
was consistency and a link through time, so it was not just a
formula of water and cola.
In effect, by saying theres Coca-Cola and theres New
Coke, it was basically the equivalent of saying, There are two
business schools: theres the GSB and now there is Booth,
and you can choose between the two flavors. It was a very
bad case of Coke trying to rename and rebrand at the same
time, not knowing what the hell they were doing. In the case
of Booth, we do not have the same problem that Coke had. In
our case, what the school stands for remains the same and, in
fact, is reinforced by the new name since David is a success-
ful product of the schools philosophy and belief in analytics,
markets, and new knowledge.
Meeting Challenges Head-On
Even done well, renaming brings challenges for the best of
marketers. Consumers become attached to names, Mukher-
jee said. We think its just a name, but for some people, it rep-
resents something, and
its important we under-
stand what it represents.
Kilts pointed out that the
younger the audience, the
more quickly they adapt.
In some cases, it takes
a while because theres
a connection to history
and what you grew up
with. At Gillette when we introduced our new Mach3 razor,
our target audience was 18- to 25-year-olds because they were
the quickest to adopt. We didnt convert a lot of people over
50, although we converted some, Kilts said. Youre always
going to have that with a major name change. That shouldnt
bother you. Its just the nature of business and the nature of
consumer behavior.
In addressing the issue, Singer said its important to con-
sider it from the perspective of all key constituents, includ-
ing the internal constituency, which is often overlooked but is
very important. How is this going to make people feel? How
is it going to help them do their job better? In the case of
Chicago Booth, Singer said, we looked at current and pro-
spective students, faculty, alumni, current and prospective
recruiters, and current and prospective contributors to the
school. Its important to think about it quite broadly in terms
of the constituents involved.
Faculty were among the early adopters at Chicago Booth,
said Sanjay Dhar, James H. Lorie Professor of Marketing. The
reason David Booth gave this money is that he established this
partnership, as he calls it, with the school many years ago.
And he is a person who reinforces what the school stands for.
My first reaction when I heard why he had given the money
was that my teaching job becomes a lot easier now. I can tell
students, The impact of what I teach you may be pushing you
to think in the fundamental core values of Chicago, which is
that discussion and debate leads to the creation of new knowl-
edge. In David Booth, you see someone whos successful and
who acknowledges that, and this is the reason he supports us.
I think its a real reinforcement of what the school stands for,
and why we teach here and not at another school.P.H.
A Revolution in MARketing
First, you have to understand what makes the brand timeless to begin with. Ann Mukherjee, 94