1 cisr-consultancy challenges “customer ask us what to do next” keywords: “customer ask us...
TRANSCRIPT
1 CISR-consultancy
Challenges
Keywords: ““Customer ask us what to do nextCustomer ask us what to do next””
From Policy to Practise
The world is going to be more and more complex
There are fundamental changes in our information challenges
Network Enabled Capabilities create new ways of working, higher efficiency and effectively. Endless combinations, interconnections and possibilities. Information technology is paving the way for new solutions and new concepts of operation
BUT…. With all the information it is still a complex world.
Clear goals, risk assessment and feasibility are a must
Roadmaps are crucial
Governments, civil organisations and industries are open to collaborate on new Concept in Communication and Information Environment through
Concept Development & Experimentation
Concept Development & Experimentation
17
UNCLASSIFIED
Command and Control / Combat Management
Organic Sources
Information Sharing
TraditionalCollaborative
PlanningSelf-Synchronisation
0
1
2
34
No Advantage
Not Possible
Shared Awareness
* Source: Information Age Transformation, D.S.Alberts
Developing Situation Awareness
2 CISR-consultancy
Network Centric Evolution
Cost-Risk analysis
Enabling NEC
Transformation
NEC
Government Civil organisation Industry
the enabling technology to share information, decision making, shared operations, integrated/enterprise solutions…
technology not developed specifically because of NEC, but relevant for (the evolution) of NEC …
the new ways to protect our citizens …
Homeland securitypublic safety
civil domains of transformation
Transformation
informationsuperiority
shared information;shared decisions
shared information;shared decisions
Public OpinionGovernment
Integration
Platform development &
integration
Access control, Surveillance, Identification, interlink Information systems,…
Collaborative decision making
Media, businessesPublic OpinionRisk assessment
the new ways to become more
effective …
e.g. e-government,e-travel, mass events
3 CISR-consultancy
ConceptDefinition
ConceptDevelopment
ConceptRefinement
ConceptImplementation
Concept AnalysisModelling & Simulation
Demonstrations &Trials
Experiments
Fielded Capability
Concept Refinements
User Feedback
Assessment Results
The Concept Development process is an iterative process of increasing fidelity as the Concept develops into a Fielded Capability
Co-evolution in all Lines of Development
OrganisationProcedures TrainingPersonnelEquipment Sustainment
Leadership
Concept Development and Experimentation Process
4 CISR-consultancy
Evolving requirements
Towards more sharing and more cooperation‘How much is feasible, desirable, can be funded’
AUDIT :
Identify current stage
Of given customer
CD&E :
Identify desirable
Customer goals
Building roadmap how
To get there
5 CISR-consultancy
NEC: Complex adjustment
Considerable re-adjustment is necessary in parallel (out-of-the-box thinking) in the following areas:
Processes e.g. joint operations, new CONOPS, information sharing, collaborative
working
Organisation e.g. command structure, size and types of units, joint units, matching
‘peace, crisis, war, civilian military operations’
System Architecture & Equipment e.g. info infrastructure, security, bandwidth, connectivity, QoS, new sensors
& applications, adapt legacy systems
Due to the complexity of this process, experimentation with new concepts and solutions will be essential
Budget optimisation
Technology insertion and roadmaps
Inter-operability and system implementation
De-risking
6 CISR-consultancy
CISR - IDEA ©
Audit+
ExpertiseResearch
Identify - Vulnerabilities - Current Conops - Trends + threats
Develop
- Baseline scenario- Experimentation- Plan and tactics
Experiment
Design Prepare Conduct Estimate Design
Assess
Result Impact
Risk
Questionnaire Workshop LabDecision support
ScenarioInformation
Model
ScenarioPhases
Architecturealternatives
Metrics
Desirableroadmap
I D E A
Auditoutput
7 CISR-consultancy
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Time allocation
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
Delivery of data captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rva
vib
ility
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
pe
d
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
DescriptionPost-threat
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Time allocation
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
Delivery of data captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rviv
ability
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
pe
d
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
Description
assessment
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Time allocation
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
Delivery of data captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rva
vib
ility
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
pe
d
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
DescriptionEffector
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Time allocation
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
Delivery of data captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rviv
ability
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
pe
d
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
Description
Planning
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Time allocation
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
Delivery of data captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rva
vib
ility
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
pe
d
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
DescriptionDecision
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Time allocation
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
Delivery of data captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rviv
ability
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
pe
d
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
Description
Organisation
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Time allocation
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
Delivery of data captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rva
vib
ility
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
pe
d
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
DescriptionNetwork
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Time allocation
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
Delivery of data captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rviv
ability
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
pe
d
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
Description
effectiveness
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Time allocation
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
Delivery of data captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rva
vib
ility
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
pe
d
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
DescriptionCommunication
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Time allocation
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
Delivery of data captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rviv
ability
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
pe
d
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
Description
infrastructure
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Time allocation
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
Delivery of data captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rva
vib
ility
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability ,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
pe
d
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
DescriptionInformation
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Time allocation
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
Delivery of data captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rviv
ability
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability ,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
pe
d
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
Description
infrastructure
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rva
vib
ility
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
pe
d
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
DescriptionInformation capture
How is time shared for various data capture activities
Time
Mixing info captured of various sources
Data fusion
Storage of data capturedDistribution of data captured
DeliveryData captured
Format of data capturedFormat of data captured
How is space shared for various data capture activities
Space allocation
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Temporary detection
Nature of data capture deviceSystem used
Permanent detection
Su
rva
vib
ility
Dep
en
de
nc
y,
inte
rop
erab
ility
Dep
loy
ability,
flexib
ility
Res
po
ns
ive
ne
ss, sp
eed
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
co
ord
ina
te,
co
op
erate
Ratin
g
ca
pa
bility
to
sh
are
info
rmatio
n
DescriptionInformation capture Preset values for easy and quick assessment
CISR - IDEA ©
allocation
8 CISR-consultancy
Transformation is a collaborative process involving Management, Operational users and Technology providers
• Management, to provide requirements and validation
• Operational users, to provide legacy, personnel and Concept of Operations
• Industry to provide technology
Capabilities
• Propose and execute CD&E and architecture studies
• Design and demonstrate new NEC solutions for systems of systems
• Create a common approach and knowledge base for Information assessment
• Imagine and assess new ways of conducting operations and use of technology
The BTC’s Area of Interest
ConceptDefinition
ConceptDevelopment
ConceptRefinement
ConceptImplementation
ConceptDefinition
ConceptDevelopment
ConceptRefinement
ConceptImplementation
Concept AnalysisModelling & Simulation
Demonstrations,Trials & Exercises
Experiments
Fielded Capability
Concept Refinements
User Feedback
Assessment Results
The Concept Development process is an iterative process of increasing fidelity as the Concept develops into a Fielded Capability
Concept Development and Experimentation Process
Co-evolution in all Lines of Development
OrganisationCONOPS/Doctrine TrainingPersonnelEquipment Sustainment
Leadership
Co-evolution in all Lines of Development
OrganisationCONOPS/Doctrine TrainingPersonnelEquipment Sustainment
Leadership
Via CD&E process towards Transformation