yjimm - national bureau of economic · pdf filejg iic o buuic c uijc moljcq belcelu o pc ac...

46
HI$1H2 sia DML){SIOW siaa YJIMM UMA YTIJAUQ3T4I HOAW yjqq $IOHAJ nrlut iudnidD dqwM .M thv3)I Q4 iqaI nbhoW HDS1AHHM DIMOMODH 10 UAH$1U8 JAMOITAVI 3ufI3vA uibBM OO1 8tO AM bhdmiO QQf suwidI 3W .noiawzth 31du1v o1 (1313W ini1 bna nfkiV n3do$1 13qoT n3doM oi bid3bth 51B 3W ioI noiwoH lo 1i213vinU bifE oii1D lo '(iial3viaU i arnEqbinEq i&iirn Ansdi 03 liI bluow 33(13132 IB0I3BM di moil noqqu b31womb 11iñizi oth 3W .in3rrImo3 lIñqI3fl 13(11 iii rnioiq dz113i a'sIHaM o iisq ai iqaq aidT .noitabnuol Ibiia 3(13 bnii noithnuoI thno1iM 3111 b oth ton bns IothuB 3(13 lo oth b231qx3 2noiniqo flA .231b1132 iod&1 .rkxtB323M 3irrxono3H lo u3iuH ion ,3x31 lo 2no1i3 riorl2 .b3v1I 2irIgh HA .r1qiuM .M niv3)I bn nduL iu(1nidD 'd ÔQQI © iib31z ilul iiuli b3bivolq noia1irn3q il3ilqx3 juodliw b3toup 3d vm ,2dqfiluq owi b333x3 oi .3311102 3(13 03 fl3Vl 2i 33110fl © flthU13f1i

Upload: vuongmien

Post on 20-Feb-2018

224 views

Category:

Documents


8 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

HI$1H2 sia DML){SIOW siaa

YJIMM UMA YTIJAUQ3T4I HOAW yjqq $IOHAJ

nrlut iudnidD dqwM .M thv3)I

Q4 iqaI nbhoW

HDS1AHHM DIMOMODH 10 UAH$1U8 JAMOITAVI 3ufI3vA uibBM OO1 8tO AM bhdmiO

QQf suwidI

3W .noiawzth 31du1v o1 (1313W ini1 bna nfkiV n3do$1 13qoT n3doM oi bid3bth 51B 3W ioI noiwoH lo 1i213vinU bifE oii1D lo '(iial3viaU i arnEqbinEq i&iirn Ansdi 03 liI bluow

33(13132 IB0I3BM di moil noqqu b31womb 11iñizi oth 3W .in3rrImo3 lIñqI3fl 13(11

iii rnioiq dz113i a'sIHaM o iisq ai iqaq aidT .noitabnuol Ibiia 3(13 bnii noithnuoI thno1iM 3111 b oth ton bns IothuB 3(13 lo oth b231qx3 2noiniqo flA .231b1132 iod&1

.rkxtB323M 3irrxono3H lo u3iuH

ion ,3x31 lo 2no1i3 riorl2 .b3v1I 2irIgh HA .r1qiuM .M niv3)I bn nduL iu(1nidD 'd ÔQQI © iib31z ilul iiuli b3bivolq noia1irn3q il3ilqx3 juodliw b3toup 3d vm ,2dqfiluq owi b333x3 oi

.3311102 3(13 03 fl3Vl 2i 33110fl © flthU13f1i

Page 2: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

9U WBEK uq ViBEIHOn21OU D( 4-88 Cpcoa Jf QJQflUT)2J1? O HOOU flU!AC12i O CJJ!CODb4UJCU1 Oj COUOWC2 OIIn 2CPOOJ O B!UC22CP!JP'! Inpu KCAW y'f nthpX

TU CCOflUU OL CJJIJC2 !U W!C 9IJq CUJJC cuJbJoAuJcUr

rpcp pnpuq jc coucjnqc rpr ou !AC qouiurc c1oa C1jCC12 pciiiccu pnpuq uq

flJCL jpOL V1bbJ? !U W LCCCU qccq O cowbciii jOL wc qcbbouIu cuJ!u2 LoiiqJ o

pip MQ UJQU JJJCG uqu2 C2 qonp OU ipc UOiOU W91 uLLcq OUJCU JJAC iIJCL9cq

OL jo/1 /c wcu cwbjoXwcu uq cuJuP U2 pv¼c pccu Jc2i OL M!Ac o uiqqjc uq

pJTpuq JJoc1q? ic j1pjijc pc qccjucz !u urnjc cwbjoXwcui uq cuJ!u AC pccu iici

cwbjoAwci cpuc OL uiv.ucq coctbjc iu qjcLciu Abc oj poncpojq 2p.rijcq p? c

flU qw ow c mcp Cb2 uq ipc jQtJ ip b,bcL qc2cz4pG G9LU!U uq

VIIaLKVCI

rvoic 2flJbrAfiVOE &IEOflVFLLA VVID EVII'A

hCPLnIL? JQ14BE! /OLJu b1bGL �tô

Page 3: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

J

,,c wcir cwbjoAujcu uq cm.u!u2 J2 OL urnucq iowcu pvc pCCu ppc OL pC

uq 1p91 MPUC JC qccpuc 1J WJC CIJJbJOAWdU miq CUThIJ AC CCIJ OL JOM

MoLJccq 2GCU ru ipc tcc wJc ACL)¼ qCLcui mcunc pc UqAqf1 !CAG! i

qom o MC uq ipri coubcuu cpuce u pnep9uq uq /t1C2 CUJU2 uq wG

w qccu Thc2 o poncpojqa 21L1Jcq pA :pc jcicj o c pr12puq2 JJonLJA !#c iu

tOW qic CLO2 2CCUOU COUJb14U c9usju uq cmbjoAuici cJrnuc2 OL urntucq conbjc2

iu p!e bbcL wc 2nbbJcwcu ipc icic ciqqcucc ccq poAc qip ciuqcucc

nbbo C2C nwcucm.mu2 LOMi o pnpuq2 jpc cic ccq OAC Monjq ccw o

rncLc2cq pcp uic !AOLJCC u Lc2bou2c jo pc qccjuc u cwbjoAwciu uq pc JCJI1iCL

ioqA pccric qJCL !14AC2 9LC MOLJq1J WOLC VJiCUJACJA JJAC IJJLLG MOUJCU

MJJCGL pcc bpcuowcu ILC cJo2cJA pujccq JJJS LC urnucq rucu moLqu JG22

ouc uuiij dnc!ou q qic bi4uj.A dnc!ou MC I.C22 !u P! bbcL !2

MOLJCC uq CUJU2o jJCL bonc2 ACLA LOffpA qonpjcq

MOLJCC OL urnu.icq urnjc qccpucq uq pc!L CflJJiU2 UCLC2C jpjA MflC pc i!WC

rACLc oj bcL AcL HCUCG OACL jpc wo qccqc2 o pc JôJ2 uq pine

jg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U

uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

ijujA uq cuicq 2JpgA UJOLG pu u j' MoLjqu cpon bcLceu o pc Act

wjcc oijA pon beLcew o pc Acer A pc VCLC bi.iwc c w9Jc MOLJCC

ou ipc OCL jrnuq cm.ucq bbtoxwcjA yjij bci. Xc uq M2 cwbjoAcq !U IJJG JPOL

bcLccu o pc Aca uq cuicq LorIJJJA z?ooo beL AcL (u jg qofl2) H!2

JU JQ JJC ACLC buwc c UJ91C U JJC fl2 M2 CUJbJoACq woLC pu

I 1U1LOlflCt!OU

Page 4: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

ØfIL ccouq oj u bbcL o cxbJoLc io mp cxjcu Lbq CUC2 rn

cmbjo?wcui itcjj s c9I.u!u uq cwbjo?mcu o wurnuucV MC juq cjoc bj1cj U.Guq2 OM2 dnjA u wjc wjc

cwbjoAwcui epocp uq pnuc cAcjc CCc12 oucc ipe qw 2 onncq !U

WC2flLC oj pc pn2puqe Lc!i!Ac CUJU2 boicuuj uce jce 2np1cci jo cmboLt)

bCLCCUiflG2 c9Jcnjcq OU IJJC Oj LGL JJ91J CLJJTU2 !2 jCCA O pc pccL

pnepuq)2 ,ic bcLccuUc2 o pe jccA uq uuoi ric bbLocp wjcu u bbcL

MJJ!IC UJITICJJ O OfiL 9UJA212 12 qc2cLbfiAc mc iqcm q LGfl! pc qrw pA pc

2mbjc WUUCL pC cpuc u cmbjoAwcu uq cuu o wucq mcu -uq moucir

!uGdnJjA (prcJcpnuJ uq Bjoow) OflL JL2i pJ pe bbcL o qC2cI4pc iu cjc uq

cxjcu pc LI2C u coLLcJ!ou oj 2bon2ce CfWJ2 cconu OL pc 142C u jruijA cuu

MOwcu pAC cou1iprncq o rncdrijA (cucu DICL uq Qocp9jjc) OL jo Mp

ipc nuqcLJ?qu JJCWC TJ uJncp O OflL 1JJA22 MG qo Uo CXbJ!CJA cou2iqCL JJCLC mpcpcI.

CoupJpnnu occ ioM9Lq2 u2!u !ucdrwjlA o rwA jucowc pjc iu !ucdnsHA

LCCCUqA Lcbocq u2Iu coacjjou o MC2 9uq pnepuq cm.upJ2 2 2JJ!1JCU

(cuciu D9JJS!CL uq QO2CJJJJC (J pqcpnui 9uq B!°°" (ooo)) mpø pvc

JJJC Juqu2 qc2cl4pcq JOAC CJO2CJA btllcJ JJO2C O 2CACLJ OCL fl1JJOL2

WOLC

bcqoq MJJCU JOM MC UJCU MoLJccq JC22 /1JJG JJC MjAC2 O JJJJ MC WCIJ MOLJCGq

O2C O OPCL MOUJCIJ QJACU JJC2C qi JJC b rmo qccqc uJp pc cpccscq

O IIJCLL MJAC2 LCM oujA jç bcLccuc bou uq bcLcGu Lc2bcqAcJA pcpuq

bGIOUJJUCG 0j C2C UJCU JiVC pCCIJ t MOL2C ijrnu CLC CUJhIOAIJJCIU uq C9IJI!IJ2

bGLCCU uq 1JJCL cwbjoAuJGuL LiC cjj bciccuc bo!u jp!jc pc jpoL UrnLJCI

LC9J mnj cuJiu2 o urnucq wcu !U pc poom Mc dnWt!jc qccccq pA poni

MJAC2 wiqqjc uq pp mc wcu Lot. cxffwbjc CMCGU TÔQÔ uq jg pG ACLC

Page 5: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

3

bcLccu mJq LCM u CCCJCLC bcc (u2rn pX j bCLcGuwc bou bCi. qccqc !u

bbLoxIuicJA jj bcccuwc boa OAGL jJC JQO2 pn2puq UJJ2 UCLC2C 35

jcicj pi oi.A jj ipc qw cxccbpornqjA MCW u4Cq MOUJCU2 CWbJOXIJJCIJ UCLC12Cq

UJJC c9uJw2 Lo/t4p qnuu ipc J2 uq pc JÔ(J2 MC uq LCiCioo uq pc Tô8O ( cowbcq o ipc jty) cu pc 4prncq o pc 2joMqo!1u !u

uA p€ O 2CC MCiCL ipc CCCjCLOU O pG !U jCUJJC JOL 2nbbJA u

cmno pc cxbjucq pX cjrnuc u pn2puq2) c1.u!u2 v UJOLC puicq pm LCJT2!C OJ

wc bci.oq ,ic ic uo 2m.b42cq pc pnjjc o pc uctc m w9Jc JOL 2nbbJA

uq jiq (o)) mcc wjc wCouiC2 pvC pccu 42!u OACL w1oi. oOL WL4C MOUJCU pic PCCU I42!1J OACL pC cupc cCuirn..A (ecc OL cwmbjc 2UP

Ou ipc 2jOM &OMJJ O fl2PU2 CUJTU2 2 CACU UJOLC qijcnjv E!L21 CUJbJOAJJJGU LjC2

ji.Aiu o cxbjiu pc uc u cwjc cwbJo?zucuf oACI pc b2 iiio qCccqC2 pcq

WOL LOJG !U WC CCflTJC O UrnJC CWbjO?JJJCU LC2 J JJC J2 uq JIC Jg(J2

1J3T qCCJTUUJ MC2 C1JCLCq pA JflU qcurnuq tOL JO/A qjjcq MOLJCCL2 bjXcq pc

uqu LCCOUIUJJ OffL G9LflCL uqu2 ('npu (J) npu1 rn.bpA uq jobcj (iooi))

qC1CLUJUTJ JJC biCUJ OJ W9JG CUJbJOAIJJCIJi OACL LJJC2C IJJLCC qcc9qc2 C1 1pC2C

OUC CU COuCJflqG GLOW 1JJ2 JJ CWSJC Cm.UjU2 M2 1J01 JJG OIJJA 2UJIJCIJi t&COL

C9UJpJ2 LO/i4JJ OL pCJL /i4AC2 M LC9CL JIJ i]JC 1ôQ02 JJU qmu JCL qCcqG2

cwbjoAuicuj °L JO/A MC WCU cwjjA JUCLC2C qmiu iJJC J1J2 !U 2bJC o JJC

MC2 JUJC uq GWU2 U COUjLJ O 1J1C Th(J2 uq JJC JØ2 MC juq JJ

jgj sJ20 C22 20WG qonpi ou e!uJbJc 2oLA o 9wfljc2 2flP2UiU pn2puq)2 uq

2flLACA2 JIUJC 2C4C2 CAJCUCC OACL 1JJC JJLCG qCcsqCe iJJC Jô(J2 1JJC JO2 uq iJJG

J2 AbJCJJA inqcq pA TI2pJ JJC JQJ CGUfl2 2 MCII 92 JJC y9LCp C1ILLCU bobrtJou

CL022 2CC1!OUJ CAIqCUCC MC cowbc JWC 2CLJC2 CJJ91JC2 O/CL JOUCL JWC bCIJOq

2bon2c2 CLIJIU2 JAC CqCq pc JOL enbbjA o uicu uq M0wCu iu qqJou jo iJJG

Page 6: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

ccun iu 2C!OU A MC cmbr o dniitA LC ccq o cpuce iu thonec crunu

2nbbJA 2cc!ou cxcuq pc uc bcuoq oj gic miJ?t2 n2u qw pow pc JÔQO

iqpon cpjqLcu conjq nj iuA wA cconu OL 1pc ocucq cpruc iii cwc jpoL

c J2o cxbJOLc u uibjc MA MJJCJJCL cowbowoirnj cjrnuc ioMq2 poncpojq

uq J2 OL ipG JIJJ wbjc MGJj qaccq pA pn2puq)2 MC qccjc

iu cmbjoAwcu uq cauJJJ2 ci urnucq wcu uq wi.ucq iAowcu 11J9 occrn.Lcq OACL pC

urnuc LC2 MpiCp urnA jrnAc cccq 0111. iujbjc pj ccou ffl we C2CLC cpuc2

CUJTIJ2 (01. urntqcq coiibjc iu 2CC0U e o pqejA qcc1.ipc ipc crnuc u

iiqc qW L0w w ci uq ceun !Apcp MC 11C o ujAsc CUC2 !u ctubjoAuicu uq

jjic bbc oLuscq ojoi ccjiou j qccqpc pc uwjcpcq pnpuq uq(CWJC cmbjoAuici u pc JJ2 uq pc jg

uwA pvc bjAcq LCCL LOJC p1J pnpuqe CUJpJ2 U (11CJJ JJC 1CCCJCLOU O(

pI IUCLG2Gq IJLJG obboi.iui Ice (0!. IAOWCIJ-- buicnJLJA (01. ppjA ejqjjcq Mowcu--

ru emc bm.iicibjou cIrwc (LOW pc MIACC 0( pip MC UJCW Jji!2 (9t1 2flC2J2 0 fiC

2IoMqoNue u cuiue oip OCCflLLC (01. JO/A MC uicu iipjc pc pce CCGJCL!0U

ejj epabjA nei u pc ci.oee 2CCOu9 cowbueoue MC uq pc P!peL cuLA !uo ipe jpoL uJ9LJcc1 u pc jrje uq pc jge e pe pn2puqe Crn.IJUJe

JQØ2 MACU pca pnepuqe C1.JiiU2 LCM bcLccur JpcCC MOWCU cuI9JjA ejwcq

MOIJJCU uJu.Icq o wcu u pc pouow dr1u!Jc) pq (CCI cmboAmciu ottp u pc

UCLCCWJ 2L1ICU1LC 9 pc uqiqqnj JCAGf E!L2 JJC MAC2 O( JO/A M1C uJcu (poec

ouce OMCAGL MC uq pc LCC ciqqcucc pqce wncp WOLG

uCCG22iüt

IUCLC2C IU M0UJCIJ2 UWC IU pc WLJCCi M2 UO IJJCL 0( CJJOICC pn UJCL 0(

qccqc jpeec Thce o opecuiou2 urnA pe ipe pave o pc bobnp /4CM ip pc

pc ioo uq fg()2) e priepuqe) cruqu2 o/Aip ejwcq jo jeec jpu beLccuj be!.

Page 7: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

2

c LUC o iiowcu lu ipc wbjc i JLCL jqionp pc VtCLC c o Moi.ucu 2

c LCflJ ipc wcu u orn. wbjc LuG ow jg o bbLoxpirnicJA ?ci o c jpc

uq MCLG pc pnpuq p pGMGCU o io Acn2 o boicuiwj jpoL wjcc cxbci.cucc

bonc j,cq u &onb dnucL MJJCLC uc!ipcL bonc M2 !IJ cpooj 01. uiwi.A 2cucc

iu bbci MC ocn ou 2mJJbJc o wcpcq pn2Juq-Mc bL2 MCLC ucpc1.

cowbnipqiA pUJT2 0(11. piJ!A o cxcuq 0(11. rrncJ?eJ2 11A o ucjnqc pc

jQØ qcccuu CCJTh12 0 CXW!UC CJJflJC2 U MC2 1UJC moLJccq ponJJ jCJC O qw

cuijA pcq ou pc j-o jo-go uq jo-ooci qi p' rqqwou mc nc pc

ccucLcq ionuq C2C Ac9L2 jpn2 rjJc VCLC mc Lcbou LOL JQ uq Jg LCflLiJJCL CU2LC u bo22pJG flUC22 cAcjc cjcci mc VCLC LCC XG912 o qr

cowbpjc jpoi. wjccj cA-- uq o wiqA jou icuu cp9uC2 10

2fl1AcA 0(11. 9U91A212 COACL2 pc cjcuqi. Acln2 j-jj MC !uJc orn JJLCC ?c9L2 O

cjcnjou c jcq ou f1JUflJ CUJ1J2 uq MCCJC2 moLJccq iu ipc Aca bLc/qon2 io pc

Cnucu jobnjwou 2nucA (cb2) 0L qic 2raAc? AcL2 ucG W02 O 0(11.

Jpj bbcL 12 P2G ou qw L0W ipc Y111J11i DcWoLbP!c E!jce ou pc icp

H. JJJ6 DE G( OL 8LLGq C00b162

ot pc cpuc m cwbjoAuici OL ciipcL JJ(121U2 oz. M1AC2 ccou /j coucInqc2

Th8O2 OL f2jC COUCJfI2!OU !2 iPL CL022 ccC2 bLoppJA qo uoi cconu OL

tpc cwbio?uiicu cpuc op2GuCq 0L urnucq wcu uq mowcu OACL ipc ioouqLCC oat coucJn2iou porn rpc bociuwj puboi.rucc o 2bon2c Cm.IJU2 U GbJ91JIU

ou cwbjoAwcu neu LSUC o CL022 2ccPo119J G21WG2 uq fl2C ipc2c G2iUJC2 0

Page 8: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

Q

JIU w 2WC Ofl2COJ2 vqqu copsP! ro rpc wbjc qiq uor LonjA 9JCL OIIL LC2iTJ2

1pbLczion2 ACL2JOU2 MC O SUCWbrCq o sccom LOL copprsur p urncppi macjrcq wjC suq (CWJC2

bcLccu1Jc bo2roI? iic couwiccq u.ibjc o jj wu (porp uiucq uq ujc) MLrp j-

cocibjc bcLccuJc ccoi.A pcq ou gpc pnjrnuq c jo qcrcuiiuc fpc pn2p9uq2

V1iCL 2CJCU oja 2wbtc o wrcpcq pnpuq-i# b ,c ro ccp

2J1C cpuJu 2CJCCfJOU P!

oni. cjcnjou2pq ou fC waicq bobnjou 2por!q UOf pc uon2JA ijcccq pA

2jJJiJX ow j o j bcLccuf OACL fJJC 29UJG ijUJC bc4oq JJJC2G LG2flJI2

bcLccui io c bcccu jg MJC rpc pcfou u pc fob MC qccjc pJcLccq

c o wcq wcu rpc i.cpou u fJJC DOff Ow MC qccjc jj oujA 2!!pfIA pow

dnjjA o pc w9ujcq bobnjrjou bbc2 ro pc 2j&JfflCui p0MCACL ywou ont

u o j bcLccuf TÔ8Ô JJJC CCq O qCCJTJU UJ1.UC LfC2 OU fJJC VCLC

fflU !ufO fC JOf4OW qcqjs O fJJC OACL11 MC q2fI4pfIfOU qccjjucq LOW JQ bCLCCUf

bobnjou joi. cxwbjc wou iujc wcu 'qrp r-o o cxbcucucc fC pcrou

qccjuc ju w.4c LfC2 p jcq o u wbLocwcuf u rpc dnA o rpc uJC UJjC

flIJTjOLW CLO22 fJJC bcLccujJc CfCOLJC2 JJJCLC j OUJC C/4qcucC fjJf P! flIJOLIJJ

2 WOLC CfOL OL fC JJ WCIJ1 tP qccjuc 1IJ I1JU4G LfC2 j2 WOLC OL JC22

wi.ucq bbc2 fO p UJOLG !ujboumjj OL fJJC JO/A MC UJCU suq qcjA O JL2f UJU4C

pow g5 u fO ju pjc bcLurnucur qccjuc u qic jjccjpooq o pu

cxbcr4cucc fC scfiou urni.ucq uq Jiju thonc qccuq bcLccuwc boufe

onb fJJff 12 PCCOWTU UCLC2UJX 2CJCCfC OACL f!U1C vwou UJCU /4fP T-O ACL2 o

O' COUCCUJ !2 fJJf pA ocruju ou 2wbJc o wucq conbjG2 joojqu f

JÔQO CC1J?I

TôX8-8O uq jogg-oo LC2bCCfJAGJA IU qqfou1 JJVC O2CLAOU2 LOW fJJC

2flpfJA J0MGL1 OJIL 2UJbJG 2jC2 SIC Q45(J suq QàO Op2CLASfOU2 OL jg-

Page 9: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

EOL LCI9CM2 O ipc LCCCUI fCLS1flIC ?C gLOJA (ij) uq -iA suq ym.uuc ()cowbLcpcu2yc SU9lt2? O JJC LCCU( CJIUgC2 !U fl M9C 2(LI1€U11C IC1 NIJLbJJA (ioo)

E!rrLc j bcacu 1pc cp9uG u JO pOJILJA MG wou ipc wbjc o urn1.cq

GUJT1J2 O !tJAG2

G ccu jou OGL qjwcu2ou ncp wjc cwbjoAwiu LG2 uq cwbjoAwcu uq

2 MG 2JJOM U pc LOHOMUJ S1LG 91J WJG2 JIOMGAGL' LGuq 10M9Lq2 !UGdflJ!A cu

cuouiion i.c u wjc MG !ucdnJ!A pi jrn2 pecu uocq u UflWGLOfl OGL wqc

uq urnu4cq MOWGU OAGL jpc bc4oq joo° joo i p? qocnwcuu pc

I" 12 cC!Ou MG G2CLPG CJJTUG !U cmbjoAiijcu uq GWU2 o wu.cq wcu

111 CIJJJJG !U EULUIU EWbIOWGIU

(ion O

LGCL qcj U pc bbcuqp uq J2o u npu (J) uq npu nthpA uq jobcjOT1O!JJ LOWI!OU LOfIb2 OL JJG AGTI2 J3-J JJJG2G mcpoq LG qccpcq u

qi4pruou o poriLjA MC Lcboucq ou 2nLACA MGCJC qw MP!CP vjpjc OL pG

MJJ!CP 914C2 LOW q/qqu UJ1JIIJ GUJTU2 pA oj IJUfl JJOfIL2 MOLJCG pA fTU JJG

uJi.jcc ww o pc bonc MG j2O cou.cqcq OL WG2flLGwG1J GaOL iu pornjA MG2

MGGJC2 MpJJc COrnLOJI!U OL cqcicou JGAGJ bocuij cxbci4cucc urntwj 2WU12 uq jpoL

wbr1icq MG2 O UOUMOLU UJGU LOW JJG MC q2I4pr1iOu O pO2G MJJO MOLJCG J-J

wcqioq uoqnccq u bLc,on2 bbcL2 (npu (moY npi? nibpA uq jobcj (jj)) MG

csLmu2 LG UO O2GLAG OL UJGU MJJO q!q UO MOLJC JJC GUflLG Acn ojjo,tu

bcLccluTJc bo2!ou (U pc JJOrILJA MUG q2I4p!ou (U ccp Acir ouc qcnjA i

LOL CCp AGL O( bOICUUJ GXbGUGUCG MC iJJCU LuJccq uqiqqnj pcq ou 11JG(L

1O AGL2 O bOiGUiJJ JOL WLJCG CXbGUCUCG MJJO MGLG U01 ill CpOOj OL pG Ur(J(WO

Page 10: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

8

cxbcuqunic qcjJSoL LOW LC 1ouj Icowc LOqnct yCC0flU12°L McCv Mox.jccq 9uq nnj MCCFIA poniz vuunj c9uqu MCLC qcprcq pi ipc bcLaousJ couwuibonMOLCL2 MIJO qq uoi MOLJC !U rpc ducniinuj2ccIOL H0fl4 C2 si.c 9uun9J cuJn2 qiqcq p) pc btoqnci

jo cjciqc fC !c cpsuc2 LcboLjcq rn ji&iac MC vctcq jo8 ponIj?Mdc2 o c uq 2Sf9Ü

WJflLJJ pOflI2 O MOLJC 2JJ0!MJ LU h!nLc 4 jC jJJC 2SIiJC 2jOLA J!AC2 O UJCU LU jpc pouow

mijp muc oj uJcu tu jpc uiiqqjc o jJJC mc qI2jUpfTjJOU MOLJUU jpc W02j' CPUC2 !U

mIc MOLyCq BA Jô8 (pomu mjp ppqA pqcq p12) LcJjoupb jrnq cjrnucq

itqc jjccjpooq o pcu cuibjoAcq jp i jpc jnpcL jpc pnpuq jpc JC2 jpc

jrnqcq pL2) jpcc m cjcqA ucAC Lcloupib pcjmccu jjc pnpuq mc uq

u jpc qjipmou o cwbjoAmcuj pA pcrpuq m8c qcqjc (qjqA

uiqqjc uq jpc job mc qcc4jc2 Jp!2 UOU-UCmLJ !ucLc2c jrn jcq jo qLurnjc cpuc

iUCLCff2C ffUJOU jj wtqcq mowcu pm iuctccq jpc W02j uJou !#UAC2 o uicu iii jjJc

ulcu !U jpc jcu mc qccic Ju jQ iJq HJ L!nLc pom jpj cwboAwcuj Ljc

bcLccuj !U Jô8à EIITLC couIrnLce jpc VcLG cujbjoAujcuj LjC2 o mowcu urnucq jo

mowcu !u oni. 2rnIJbJc ucLccq bcLccujc bo!uj2 pom bcLccuj iu jo

jpGll MJAC2 JucLcs2cq cuoLuJon2JA p jpc cjc jpc cwbjoAwcuj LjC O urnLucq

MPll cmbjoAmcuj LjC2 LOL wcu pvc cucL9jJA qccjucq cubjoAwcui LjC2 o

uunj Gfl.uJu2 mcu rn jpc pojjow qccjc cjj pom 5ôOO 01. pA pom bcLccur

cjnjjjA ucLc2cq jpjjA y' LCffJj o jpc jj u pojp mce uq cwbjoAwcuj LGJ

qujjicjjA (pA j bcLccuwc bo!uj2) mpjjc jpc cwbjoAujcuj LjG2 o pc job qccc

cwbjoAcq meep qyqqcq pA jowj mccjc bcL Ac) ot jpc pojjom qccjc jo qccj!ucq

jpsu jpc pcucpw E!&ILC !JJnjije jpi pc cuibjoAuicuj LjC (wcnLGq

qccuc monjq pe CACU WOLC qL9wjjc tOL jp pouow mc onb mc ncq LjCL

LCJ M62 0 ulcu rn jpc pojjow mc qcqjc qccjucq uncp 5 bCLCCUj jpc

tuJiJJL joi.A fiJJTJC LCJ MC2 ot wcu m jpc job mc qcqjc ucccq j bcLccuj jpc

ulcu muji j jo AcL2 O bojCUjJ9J jpOL uJ9LJccj cxbcucucc EIr1LC j jcJJ uom

Page 11: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

WSL7C1 U9cpwcuqowb rpc twboL(SUCC o cowboouj cpuc p) LCS(CL o MOWCU gp 2iLOUCL jpoL0 MOWCU Mliii JWIt ICACJ2 01 CXbCUCUCC lulO (PC J0L WLC1 0t11 McCp-McIplcq 9ACLgC MC Monqt0N4 oi. MOWCU p pccu smqctiicq qnc 10 cpud comboiiOu o oijru MOWCD qnccq p? rpc cuti.)2flUC? CCj cwpi Lcbol4cq ou pc A 2WUP uq (ioo) uq eojqu (g) nc ipt isc

wcnw ot ipc pon ,#øc aplcp monjq pC jOOfl? 10 c SACLdC ponq1 ms8 cscnsicq pom114AC2 uq qqju Ip UUUJpCL p?.. (PC ITW O (0( UUfT pOfltZ th0L(C 1)X M0LyU N4AC JJ32 2

CJCnJIC ACL9C pOflq? M9C2 01 MOqCUJ MJAC2 p 121 2flWW!U9UWTØI C9UJ!U2 SciOn 9JJ motjqu

cicct swb1c o jiotu MOWCU MO oqcqqccpucq ucc jy jpc qcLcucc Lz.ow (PC LC2flJ1 icboucq pcC ws? pc qnc 10 (PC jSC1 (PSI ipcA 10110M S

4cojcwsu suq jcucs,cj (j) LCboz.j Ui ISCI usc thCCq? suq sunhisi OJ1I2 Vwou M0LJqu MOWCU SAQ

pJp MG MOWCU JiJ JQ? MOLJcJIJ! !14AG2 o wcu !U pc pouow qcc!jc cucq

pcu boriAcJA LCJGq JJJ1 !2e CACU U JQ pp MC UJCU cuqcq iO pG urnucq 10

I129U2 MG MC 0fIU U E!f1LC OL JQ MC pq MC2 0 2bOfT2G AC JMA2

qccC P1 C0IUL2I o pc uG/C LCJ!oU2pb pciwccu ic IJUJC MOLJCC uq pC

J EIfILC MC CXUJ1IJC AGL9C JJOflLjA MC2 o mice p? pnpsuq iic

CpnJG IU SIJUTISJ 0flL2 ! upfWPJG 0 JG CpUG U JJOfll2 bCL

ipc ujbjc o urnuicq MOWGU s pojc bbLo icj) JQ bGLCCIU (y \ ) o 1C

pC cp1JC 2 qnc jo MOWCU woiiu pow btj- WG jo njj-iwc Wfl2 LOL cxwbjCe

MOUJGU MJJ0 M0LJCC S JC J MCCJC 0f11 0 iJJC ?CL p bbcn LcJ!AcIA jujc o

cpnc !U 0Wj 9TJUflJ JJOfIL2 (cloaC o j bcLcGiu) e qnc o !ucLc2c2 !U IJJC LC0U 0

iiJou poc mpo MoLjccq iu uA JACu MccJc JpJC j ip ipc pnjjc o pc

VCLG Mccp MOLJCC wou pc siiurwj bS1.iqb9u2 uq porn MOLCC bcL MGCIC

bn.-- qJc pC0U 0 MOWGU MJJO MOLJCC i JG2 ouG ,iGJc (uurwj bu!c!bu

pA qCcowboeu JC CJJ!JC U ACLC IJ1J11J P0 ILUO CJJUC2 U qitcc cowboucu

jpjc j CXUJUC2 iJJG cpmc !U R4C2 VCLC &IJ1J1TJ J101fl2MOLJCG UJOLC CIO2CJA

L0flJJJA ØØ p01112 bCL Ac1w

o wcu pc imqqjc uq pc ob MG C1C0I4C ucLc2cq ipc!L p01112 ucc wncp pA

MSG CCOLA wcLc2cq IpGIL 1JUcIJ ponl2 MO14CG pA Lonp1A ® p01112 MPBC jpC NIAC2

Page 12: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

Jo

9J0UC CC0nIUGq 0L gbbtoxuigcjA bCtcCUf 01 (JIG (019( qmc nJ uun( C1ftUIU2 jpG ULGC ! JI01112obbocq ro rnCtC2C2 iu (JIG pomjA M9C LOt (JIG 2SWbJC O WUGq MOWGU 92 !*p0JG (JIG L!2C JU SUUPSJ JJOflL2

9J20 WAC2(J(C (0 MJJS( CX(CUI (JIG UJCS2C F 9UUfl9J CSUflU2 12 qnc (0 uac92c2 F p0m MLJCC 92

IJJruA pOrn2 pnj cucq 2u1JCTJqA WOL bcL porn. jpu Is1G2 o joii I1c

MCJJ O/CL 5I beLceur BA jC cuq o on qw !iMG2 o pp iic wcu MOLJCG JUJO2i 2

ponj bcLccuç yuunj crunuP o uic u jpc job qccc LO2C u uccec oVU11fl9I C1LUJU2 O !?4AG2 TJ iJJC pououi qcqjc LO2C bbLOXUJjCJA u uci.cc oiru jpc JLC2J !ucLG2c2 iU CUiUJ2 pAG occnucq jOL M!AG2 O UJGIJ U jpc job qccjc

ALA 2(LOU bo2ijiAc LcJj1ou2pTb pcrccu pn2p9uq2 MC uq Mijc CmU2

MC UJCIJ MOLJCC JC22 JJOfIL2 jpcA MCLC bq WOLC bci. ponr C0UjL2j !11 Jô8 jCLC 12

CUJU2 MCLG G2GU(IJJA COIJjUj CLO22 pnpuqe ic qccc2 jpc IJAC2 0j

cpuc iu mc mJnj cuju pA pnpuq MG qccJc iu TàQ ruunj

IUCOthoLf!U jJJC CjJ1J!c2 U pojji MC2 uq J101112 MOLJCcq Jf1Lc Q C2CLC2 jpc

LO2C bcLccur

2cpooj qLobont !owcu 1ucLccq 5g bcccuj uq !iC2 o pp 2COOJ qnjc MouJ6u

ACLC o gj rn o jçyij uj ( rn o jj bcLccuj) MJJC M2 o pp

p112p9uQ2 tic CCOL!C2 MC uq jJJj MC2 O CoJJcc cqncucq MOUJC LO2C LOW JU

2rwbJc oj urnu.cq MOUJGU uq combc cLO22 cqnctou c(cOuc2 LjCL jpu jpc

o pjJ jqjjcq MOLJJCU IJ!U OU JC22 jqcq MOUJCU EOL cwuibjc' MC WJCC jpc wc

pcOLc ij 12 WøLC jqccjA jjrnj jpcc qici.cuj19j Mc 1u2 LCCCj woc cucI9j bjjciu

oi.pu bjjcuj p cpmicq 20 jj ucu uq MoujCu LC UOM WOLC bo2ijJAcJA 20LjC jjrnu

joc qccjc wcu ucq ponj 5j bcLccuj jpqc ij 12 b0221p1c ipj pc nuqcLJA1u

MI/G2 o wcu iu jpc job qecije iucq pon( g bcLccuj u LCj MG2 MJJC /iUAC2 o jpc

pcuccu jpc pnpijq 9uq jpc MJtC MC J2 pccowc !UCLC92TU!A IJJOLC bo2!iAc 92 (G

qcqjc cm.ucq bbLoxurnjcJA beL pOfn. 2!UCC (Pj bcuoq OMCACL jpc LCJjio1J2pib

bbLoxruJjcJA beL JJOflL (!u jg qoe) MJJUC MOLJU M!AC2 o wcu u jpc job

Page 13: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

H

cpuc pg2cq ou mccp MOLC UflWCi2 sic tcboi.cq w ipc LC2f °L 1p b9bcLqm.m pc 2mACA cqr jpc cpiuc u cwbjo?1wcu i.ic Lcboz4cq CLC zpcLotc jj qJcL 2pq) LWW qic

c 5J20 qqnc ont cwbto?wcug 2fl psecq ou pc 2m.ACA MccJc 9uq LcboLI qic cqou po sic cwb1oAcqwcc wijA cowboqouASC2 encp s qic bLccucc o cpqqi.cu sic qqucq ou pc °Lqc VUACA

9bbLoxw(cJ) rpc cpsuc u csui!u2bbcst2 jO pc2OWCM41 WOtc U3b0149Uj LOL OWU W 1P IOM suq wiqqc bCLCCUIIJG C9COUC2' cconuqu jot

coucjnou ( jc pcq nbou jpc 2nJJbJc 1bbLocp c pv wycu pcLc) C1UC2

bbce o pc wbou OL pOJJ JJC JJJJ uq JOM MC pOfTcpoJq2 ØflL p2!C

cpu cwbjo?iiciu Lc iiippi cuA cj LU qqwou1 pc iiqu cowboucu( orn o ) u cwbjoAmu L o urnucq MOWCU I4PflWPjC io

tcbou pc comboeou-xcq CflJC2 J,pjC 2JJ0M2 1JJi JJC PII 0 pG OWJ CJJUC

cpjqLcu cq -j) i.c xcq coInhxm () LboL12 pc cwj CUG2 MpJG cojnuiu ()

uA (Momcu !porn cpqLcu1 Mouidu !p cpjqLcu cq j- ,owcu MipcwbjoAincu CUC2 o cwbjoAuicu cpguc2 mpcLc rpc combo2!ou o MOUJGU ci.O22

pi COJITUJU2 () uq () MG JAG2 t1C IJJG LOJG O GI4flf) CJJ1UG2 pA coujbruu cuwj

qJdLdUj IUCLG2G2 U GWJG jOL iibbjA CLO22 pcc JOM uq pip MiG poncpojq

!IJpon cpljqLdlr j 12 bo22!pJc JJ qG4u CUG2 !U GI.LJ!A corijq cconu oL pc

ipc ob drnunjc QIAGu pi MWGU /ip cpjqLcu MOLJC ucujA i pu Mowdu

dnuijc MJG pc pcou uci.ccq jwo i#cc uuicp (pA T bGLccuWc bou)

wsuicq iiowcu uporn cpJqLGu UCLd2G porn bCLCCUWG bo!uf2 tOL fIG POUOUJ

ju GWG JpOL 2nbbJX CLO22 ipG bcLccuiJJG co4c JOL cxmbjc pc p9ciou oj

bcuoq jpjc Hfl2Ld2 ipi cpuc u cLA bcu2 LG coLLcdq cp9uc2

bLcecu2 CJJUG2 !U fIG 4!0LR O uJu4Gq MOUJGU MflJOtU cpqqcu OAGL fJG JôQô-

b!.fcib!ou CLO22 iJJC2G !OM 9uq JJJJJ MG pon2cpojq2 C°I" (I) O jJG

Mp GXiGU CJBG2 !U IGLfJA LG COLLCJLC N4 CPIUC2 U /t4tG2 JOL UJLJCG

wUi4isj MOLJC uq cijA qcou pcAouq ipc 2cobd o pi bIbcL MG cxunuc o

NJJTJG G2UUIiOU O 2L(TCWLJ woqcj !IJCOLbOLfJJ fIG UU1LC O MOUJGU2

Page 14: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

1:5

mic o pip wcu jrnioucsjj? oucq pc JJOL OLCG 9i 2CL bcc pu /t4/C2 o

dncou iipcci. biucw ocupjc pJ bcione bcqoq2 pJ OJCL MOL pc

MOWCU pm ructcq 4JJC WO2 UJOU !!9AC O miqqjc 9iJq pp MC WCU OIJG UUTLffJ

mjj?su pc cpuce 2!UCG itc onuq jpi cwbjoAi.uciu cLc2cq uJou jjpJCOLbOLU qw tLOW WG TÔQO CCU2n2 OJIL bflthO2C !U W!2 C!0U MO-OJc1 EP

Ja.O2 uq ipc Ja(J2 pJ pe ecciiou lAG GX1GU pG bcLoq o om. sujA pA

jpc bcion cqiou enwurni.cq cpmJc !u LJJJG uq cuiJc GmbJoALucu OAGL pG

L! CPUJG JIJ LUIJ uuq EwbJowGu1 04 JjL4Gq COflbiGe OAGL (G 1ÔQ02

LGUJ9LJCJA mnJv

cp9uce !u cwbjoAmci.u OL pGG j/1o onb2 OACL pc b wo qccqc pc pccu

GLGIJCC2 IU IIJG jGAGJ2 O CUJbJOAJJJGIU CLO2? MOUJGU !iiji uq t4flJOf1 cpJqLGI? ipc

(Mpo2c cubjoAuicui ruci.ccq bbLoxwcJA j bcccuw bo DC2bC 2!IJUCU

,ic wcu (AcLu onuq bcLccuwc bo!u) piu pc /AIAC2 o jOiA ic mcu

!'J E!I1LG jJJG UCLG2G2 CUJbJO?JJJCIU LC J9LGL OL /t4AG2 O uqqjc uq JJJJ

OL ipc lAOjG wbjc o !AOWGU i u WcLG2G o bcLccuWc bo!1u y i

mcLGcq :5g bcLccuWc bom pow u (pc coI.Lc2bouqu cpuc

poc Gxppcq u imc vwou Mowcu ,,p Aonu CJJJLCU pc cwbjoAujcu LC

cpuc uq pc opcupc bruci.u CL022 qIG bGlcciu!Jc CGOI4C2 Lc AGLA JJJ9l io

OL JG u uq nu u jg o €mbjoAmcu qci? pop pc

borijr L!nLc TJjJILG VGLG cwbjoAwcu: LG2 o owcu ,p cpjqcu Q Ac912 ojq

nbbjA MGJJ 92 lpG GLGUCG2 CLO22 pcc ponGpoq2 }flLC GUJbjJ92!sG J2

bjA ipc bLcqowuu Lojc !' ccoriiuiu OL pG &LCG !UCLG92C U LGUJ!G jOL

u cwbjoAwcuj ao jj CCO4G2 O MOWCU LGL p9U CUG2 u ci.qA bcuJ2

Page 15: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

jUC2 o ponju LC !MqCJA q2cn2cq JJCLC J392 PCCIJ flUJC 2jCWC ciqcucc LOflJJ O

pG jujccq o jpc booL ccouowic bci.oi.wucc o pca pn2pmJqe, jpjc pop o w

GLUTJJ2 oj tpcL bon2c uq o czcuj cu jpc o!jp Lu cwc cwbjoXucu urice

bm.iicnj o iip cxcu cu pc jj u urnjc cwbjoAuiciu pc pujcq o we 1.Rc u pcWO UUILj dnc2jou O 92JC 2 OIA iJJG2C CJJUC2 LG LCJGq O OUG 9uOpCL Ill

urnu.cq wcu uq ipci thon2c2 OAGL pc picc qccqc pow o bLOpfpJA pc

2o n. MG jrnic qccipcq e bucu o cpuc iii cwbjoAwcrn uq csi.mu OL

JjJG KOIG O bOfl2G EØUJIIJ !'J 1fl316 EGWIG f8pOL nbbj

Jô802

,ic wcu uo u ouou bcffcLu prii bmci.u occq MJJ pc JO2 uq pcjrnf pc J9LGL UJCLG2G U cwbjoAwci MG O2GLAG UJOU MAC2 O miqqjc uq jiji

cmbJo?1ncu o icq OML2 cc pp MG pon2cpoJqe E!nLc 8 cJcLJA epo1#

LGJ!AG MG2 9uq G1UJTJJ2 MGLG 2P!T1!11 qL9urnicJJA IU AOL o pp MG wcu cuijc

LGuJ91JWpJA UGflLJ CLO22 uijc MC CGOUG D'J qic JO2 uq flJG J2 MjJGU

MG2 MGLG nuiouujA iucLc12JU LOL ¶qJ wcu pe cpuc u cuJjc cubjoAuicuj M

cjrnuc !u pc cLJA uq pc JGL bcoq2 }JfILC g 2pOM2 qrn4u we JO2 Mpcu

pc CL022 ecoirnj brucuj o cpuc mo uowpjA we qccucc u we bwcLu oqcqjc OL u qqwou o jj uq MJJi uJqu porn h&nLc 8

iu L!nLc 8 /AG bLccu vcic curnjc cwbjoAmcuj LC2 pA pnpuq MC

2Jrn1.bJA tOL jj MG ccouc2 o uJcu oAcl. p2 2UJG be.ioq

qcLGun9J2 MGLG 2WPJG 01. coUiLc1pJ OAGL we Tô(J2 MflG LG9j cn.uu UCLC2G

bLo/qqc2 911 !uGLC2WJ GOUL2 0 JJG JL bcuoq u jp MG 9uq cwbjoAmcu

JO/A MG UJGu 01. i pi2 bjcuj jjrn rirndric o ipc jy uq pc jg ecouq pc

Page 16: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

14

IIJG!L 1!UJG M0LJCG OAGL IJJG TôO 9uq Jg2 m LG2bOU2G 10 IPG rncLc92c in

E/9qCG L0ffl J9pJG flJCGMG C92j2 2OWG qonpi ou IJJG CJ9UJ 1p91 UJGU cqnccq

MGU UrnC G9wpJ qccucq J JQ bciccui q 3FQ bGLCGUI LG2bGCI!AG1A

IJJ9U 1G 1Jq Q bGLCCUIdG bOpJi IUCLC92G2 Op2GLAGq OAGL IJJC Jô.X02 9uq jJJC Jô802

!UCLG92G in 1pGL pn2p9uq2 G9LIJi1J2 2fl1.b42!1JJA IPG 1JCLG92G OACL 1G JôQ02 M92 J9LGL

cwbJoAwcul mcLc92cq IFQ bGLCGIJWG bo LOW jO 1QÔ qC2bC 9 I bGLCGUI

UJ0U MOUJCU urnucq 10 WGIJ !' IJJC P0110W dnuijc O IJJC M9G q2114pfT1OU

JJJC CL022 CCCj2 4OLA 12 U01 20 C0UAJIJGJU 0L IJJG MIAC2 0 JOM M9G WCU

2JOMG 10 3 beLceul 9uq 4g beLceul bcL qccqc LcebcclJACIA

j 9uq j bcLccuwc boiur in pc JôO2 uq IJJC 1ô802 92 c91.uu2 L0Mj

pnepuq c9uJ!u2 LO2C gj beLceur jpc cwbJoAIucul L9IG OL IJJC2C MUJGU IJJGU LO2G

EWbIOAIJJCuI o wucq MoinCu LO2C jj bcLccuwc boig2 LOW J jO TÔQ

9AC 9CJCL9lC w JôO IJJC 1ô802 !U LG2bOU2G 10 9 2JOMqOMIJ U UJ9JC C9UJ!U2

pG 2GGJJ L0W IIJG I9PJG IPG 9LC9lG UflWCL2 211G21 1P91 GUJ9JC GUJbJOAJIJGUI urnA

IJJO2C bcqoq2 9uq OL 102C pon2cpojq2 MGLG W9JC c9uJju2 qccpucq lG w02c ? crn

I4l puq b9ucJ 10 2CC MJJGIPGL GUJ9JC CWbJOAUJGuI L91C2 UCLG92C W021 2p9LbjA !U

20MU u lC lob JGi-9U b9ucJ 9uq IJJG CJJ9UC2 1U IJJ9JC C9UJTU2 2JJOMIJ U fJJC P0110W

MC pdJU pA cowbqu IJJG IUJG 2G14G2 CJJ9UG2 CUJ9JC CUJbJOAJJJGuI L91G2

IAG2 IJJG cou.G2bouqu (joe) CJJ9UG2 u pn2puqe 9uq N4AC2 G9IJ2

OlIL 29UJbJC OAGL IJJLGG qccqc IJJG JôQ Wc jj 9'uq IPC jpc poiow b9ucJ

bucj o JflJG 2nuJnrnIsc2 IJJG CJJ9UC2 in cwbJoAuJcul L91C2 OL M!AG2 9uq JJfl29U2 JJ

98LC91G 92 MCJJ 92 0L IJJG p01l0J IJJC wiqqc 911q luG lob dnuijG onb2 JJJC lob

MOWGU 9uq CJJ9JJG2 U IJJC G9LU!IJ2 O IJJGII. 2b0fl2C MG bGLtOLW IJJ!2 9u9JA2J2 OL IPG

MC CU 9 cowb2ou o IJJG cp9uG2 u GwbJoAuJcul o wucq UJGU 9uq

pG91. OU CIIPCL 0j IJJG2C dnc2l1ou

Page 17: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

U

nbbjA CI92flc!1!c2 !1 12 U0 UjCfl1 1° uq 91 JC921 OUC OqICL 2C( 01 LCJ1112 2!UJ!191 10 0UC2 0MW

oHCC!W9U uq JQJJ!uo1.1p (jg) uoc 1S1 ycu jpc i#qc t.uc o LC2flJL2 LcboI4cq ou cwjc !9p01

nbb1)HcCFII q j(JJJiuM0L1p (io) ewitp (go) uq yjto (j) tc pc 2øuqq LcLczc0cc2 101 LCWJC

jcuccJ () bi.oiqc gu CXCCflCUI 2flLACA i.1cJc ou W9JC J9OL 2nbbj) MplJC 1C LCICM 9L1ICJC pA

cwbJoAuIcul cpmc BA comb4u ipc cuwj CJJUC2 u urnj uq cwc

1C LUC o C UJG oprucq pA olpC!. wq uq Mpcp i cu nc jo bLcqq

bLwqon2 jnqc) pm o opwu cto 2CC0U cerwce pow orn. qw Mp!cp jc

nuLoqncc r I4CJCL 21LflC4flL woqcj OL UCM Cwou LcA iJJ1 hUll iwbLoic sthou

oh cwu urnjc uq cwjc J0L nbbjA cdnou2 O' bni.boc pCLG U01 10

cqncou MC CSLLA OJU UJtJL GXCLC2C 0L ijJC MflC JJJCLC J2 911 cx1cu2!Ac fl1CLWLC

2CC1!OIJ pojqn COU2WIU pC pnpmq OMU MC uq OIJJCL Cp C1c42c2 encp 92

LcJou2p!b pcwccu IJJC cwbjoAwcui L1C uq 1!41C c91.uiu GLOW pc coa

cu.ibJoAuJcul uq cauu bucuJ2 oj pc 2bonc c pcu pA iwju pc cwbn4c

opc op2cucq cpruc u ujc uq cujc JOL nbbjA cu pe pujccq jo jpc cp9unJ

01. tcurnic J0L nbbjA iu ijic 0nOi#qu u9JAi MC UcuJb1 10 dnff1u!A 0M mricp i uA

o ipc thon2c ccwmijA conjq uo pe ipc oujA QOL jcqu jo ipc CJJ91JC ru CilpeL wjc

q21i4pn1ou 92 MCjJ 92 combrn.!eou ci.o wc bcqoq uqcT1c pi C91JC2 !u CLhJJ2

w MC Jrn/c ccu o couJbrqou2 CL0 qci.cu bcLccu Jc2 o ipC MUC

91J Ipe j2 Mpcu pc c91.uTu o pci. 2bon2c UCLC92C g uq tj beLceuc

cwbjoAwcul LjC2 oi. wc onb cjj pA , uq bcLccuWc boue OACL 1C

L0W 10 TÔQÔ Mpljc JJC C91.U1U2 O pct H4A2 LCM bCLCGUi p1 C0111L921

CUJbJOAUJCIJI LC 0 UJCU u IPC pooui ic dn!ui!Jc ucLc92cq bcLccuWc bou

C91.IJIIJ2 0j flJC!L MIAC2 LCM JJC W021 OACL JJC JQØ2 V2 IJJC WPIC 2JJ0M2 IJJC

MC WGU JJJJG IJJC cwb1oAujcuj L1C2 0L JJGC IJJCU CJJ OACL IpC JO2 9uq JO2 JJG

C91.UTU2 ju bci 0fl2 2GC1OU2 MG onuq pi cwbtoAuJciu qGcJuGq bi.wjA 91JJ0U JOM

Page 18: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

TQ

InI4IJCL ql2cnn!ou °L IPC2V btopjcw cc unrp (jij)LJJC2C C2I1UJSIC2 Wk PC qnc £0 2CACLC nuqcL-LcboLgu o ucowc qsrv (o(pcL wvu ciuu) OU ipc Cb2 LOLcjwtcq !UCOWC cacct uncrn cwn 1%(CLCU1 Ac9L2 suq e jsi.c suq boic iu jgg-y jpc uLp!J!IA O2b0fl2C12 MØC 1Jq UOIJJSOL !UCOWC (cxqnqpi p.ue(cL2) cutc 2Cbøu1c1) ,u rpc cwbjoAmcui cnou jpc2Up21I(n1SpIJI1) O I' 12 LC21UCtC £0 CdØI9 NCLO JU jpl2 woqc MC VJ20 (C2fCq 2bcqIjcøtOu2 M4JCLC £pC

1.jpcqaccr cton-caccI CtMCCU MJtC2 CøWiU2 uq fl UU2 UOL 2flbb1A qnc to combjcwcursi.O q

A9UJC2 ic pc fl2PIJ2 uq ipc 4tG12 cuibjoAwcui LiC qcjucq pc Lc!ou o

(j) uq (s) tOL tpc tLCC i!uic bcuoqe jg-tj jg-tj uq j-iy jpc qcbcuqcu

2GciOIrnJ qw fl2U 011L qw Oj wcpcq pn2p9uq-Mc COfibJC2 MC G2flWC GdflJOu2

MJJ OJJOM2 MG G21WG bmcci2 IJ cdnpou (j) uq (3) II2!U CL022

cdrnniou

ccq o UO1JJOL uucome ou cuibjoAmcuc10 EOL MOUJCU MC JAC pc UJOOff2

1pc CCC O NJC2 CUJUJ2 GIUGL2 ouiA ptonp pc bt9u.1ccL ciS MJJ!CP WC92fILC2 pC

uiA J2O CC p2 CUJbJOAIJJGUi uq 2 iJJG q2wLJrnuCc CUJJ J4OCC JJ !U flJT2 moqcj

JOL !ucohUC ucJnqu pG CUJJ2 O JJC MC ACCjOL O OCL A9I4pJC2 MJJ!Cp

MCLC '2 pC pfl2pQ2 cmbjoAuicu LG ff !2 JJ2 ponLJA MC LC j 2 1112 uou-

= cxO + cu + xj + +

uq Momcw I" P!2 moqcja pc UJHJC JOL 2flbb1A pA

JC pCIJ OfIL 9U1A2!2 pA bO2U 2!WbjG moqcj o JpOL 2fIbbtA pGJrn/4OL O mcii

uq MOUJGU

2bOfl2C2 GUJ1IJ2 92 91J cxbjnuou OL 1pC CJJ9UC2 u cwbjoAwcu o pop uwu.cq mcu

cwbjoAwcu LjG2 jo pc bLcqIccq Cp9UC2 MC CU SflG22 pc LCI!Ac !uJboi4ucc o

Page 19: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

OL iic' JJJ2 JUL boic coucjou pcccu ice MC uq pnpuqVCLG MG cuq O UJ9U) UJGIJ !ApO JJAG pop pp MC2 uq pip cwb1oAwcu LflG2

bo2AG flOI41AC UJUU8 JJJ9 I2 U UJX pc pC C2C MOUJU MO pVG ppci puMG2 GUU2 MC C2JJUC MJJCU MC ff2C jJJC HqC MC 92 91J tup.nmCu urnA jc qnc io

jGq O qCLC1U U Off!. C2UUJG2 EOI. CX9JJJbJC fiG CXILGWCIA W9J

qnwuiA A!4JC2 OL CJJJqLGU JJVC fiG!!. LG2bGC4TAC bLopJCw2 unwctue uq uJA

HJCOUJG CCC1 AI1L 2OU1CMJ MUp OFIL CJJOICC O U2PJIWCUI2 flOfl fiG MC2 MC 9uq

cpjqLu cq j- uq CJLCU Cq -j uuniJCu o" !W o fiG UOIJpOL

2bccJcUo!r LcboI4cq cojriw ()-( MC ff2G qnuiwA ALjC2 OL fIG bLccucc O

MIC2 jO pOfILjA MC io !iJ2UrwCU OL fiG ff29U UOUjOL mcouJG IU fiG 2GCOU

MO 9JGLJrnUAG flJ GU2 JJJG U'i 2bGCCfO!f LCboI4Cq u cojriwu(J)-( f12C2 fIG

pnpuq GWbJOAWCU LC MC C!WG fIG GGC O pflp1Jq2 UOZJPOL [UcOffic f12pJ

uq + bcLccufjc LUC IucC !1qC2 CuJiu c pjccjA o pG cuqouon ob9wwGicV cx iJJLGG fluc bj!uc2 qcucq oi. i,ce u bbLoxLuJGJA wc r-so i-to

qqiuou o jjo cwbjoAmcu o pc UJOLG LGthOIJ2!/G 91 JOM MG MG G2UJ91C fiG MG

wbrncq OL UOu-MOLJCGL2) jo unuiuj!sc iJJG ccj o WG92flLGUJGU GLLOL HI MG p1

LcbouGq MG2 wqip JJG MC qccjc qnmuiG2 (cou.cccq OL UJG92fILGIJJCIU CLLOL uq

cuij Lcbocq porn.jA MI1G2 o pnpuqe u pc LcLc2!OIJ2 pm ui.rimcu fJG2G

jc Lcbou on!. c 1U191G2 OL ipc uijG cwbjoAwcu cdrnrtou ! JPpJ pc 12G

WG92flLG pJ fJOfl29IJq2 O J q0JJ9L2

o uou-c !ucowc o pc pnpuq miq qic q1c bJn2 iJJG cunu ot pc 2bon2c

2dnncq o fiG !14G LCOu qnuJuJc uq AcL qmiuiw ,j4ouJpoL uCOUJG, fiG 211W

qrnimIG2 qnwujA AI4JC2 LOL cpqcu cq j-Q uq CjiflqLCu cq C TJq G

uqAJqn9J2 fl2U fIG pnpuq MG qccc qmmiiic pnpuq suq M!tG2 cqnc91!ou

MGCJC2 911 UAJffWJ M92 cwbjoAcq Ju JAGU AC91 jc bLcqJc M9C2 OL uOu-MOLJqU

Page 20: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

18

(PC WCOWC CS211CUA (0 PC 21139JJ UC911AC WWJCL L°' WC1 0CL9lldLCCWCU( H4(P (PC2C uqJUt2 JU (P9( MC juq gpc C0WbCU29(Cq Mdc CJ9?(C!gA (0 PC9 2WSJJ b02C umnpcL SlJq(0 ()5 M1JC (PC C211W9(C2 °L (PC COWbCU29(Cq Mdc cJ92(q(A L9dC LLOW Q go j ()m. uqu2 9LC !U CUCLS1

IJJCP21 O( C2PWV(C2 LOL (PC U0UJ90L IUCOWC C(921C1A qocnwcugcq pA LCUC9CJ (JQ) L9UC 10m -

1(12 CUCL9J b02WJCJA 9220CW(Cq NJ(P 0flL2 0( MOLF11bCUClACI(Jô8Q) uo(C2 (P9( MCU (PC UflWCL o qcbcuqcur2 c qqcq (0 (PC UJSJC J9pOL 2flbb1A cdnsgou

ØfTL 0(JJGL juqpi 0 1J(GLG2( 1J JflJC uq jpjc bcu iO MG CJ92(G2

(oz. 18 bGLccu() O (JJ2 qccjuc

Jpc LUCLG92G iu itc G9UJTU conjq borciupijjA cconu oi nb (0 5 bGLCGUWG bOpU2

(JiGG JOM MC wGu qccucq bbLoxw(eJA j beceuwe bou pow (0 JÔ8Ô

0J15 P1 Jô82-ôO MJJCJi (LIJ2P1(C2 W° U C192(IC!A 0 P0i -.JV EmbJ0?U1Gu( uiou

ujbje JU JflJG 0L (JIG 29IJJbJG 0 JOM MC WCIJ (JIG JLG( G2(JW(G MG OPW!U ! -

dnu(11c o (JIG MC q(4pn(Jou uq LcboL( (JIG GUJ(G2 o (JIG WG uJoqcJ OL (Pj

UJGU J/G (PGLGtOLG LC4UC( (JIG eibjc (0 JOM MC UJGU MJi0G MG tG!J JU (JIG 0((OW

u (JIG GjGC4 o UOU0L JucoLuc uq iiqc Gn.urn2 ou ipc cmbJoAulcu( o JOM MG

GmbJoAwcu( occnucq bLGqouJu9iuJA IUJ0U JOM MC UJCU1 MG IG b1.(1cr1JJA 1UGLG2(G

(L1J2J(!U 111(0 9IJ GJ92(1C1(A o bbLoxnirn(eJA -1W 2HJCG (JIG GCJG (U

10 2Jp(JA more ipu yj bcLccu(c boJui qccpuc J (JIG pn pruq cmbJoAweu( L(C

cojnuiu () o jpjc ) MJJJCJJ pubflc2 (P( JOOO !UcG92G !U MG2 GJUJRJ2 M0flJ

cxujbjc' (JIG J9LG2( U01JJJ)0L IJJCOWG GGC( MG LGbOL( u jpjc -ijjj (icboucq JU

L2e MG G2(JUJ(G LGJAcJA 2UNJJ NU0IJJP0L UC0WG GJGC( 0L pnpuq2 LOL

LG2GLAOU2 pOn( OflL JU2(LDWGUI2 HJ uiwq MG qccupc OJIL LGflJ(2 pGJOM

UJJCG OflL C2(JUJ(G2 pom (J112 2bCCtTJC(10U 0WGMJ( (00 JLC11 /1J(J (JJC2G

WOLG GAGU pojqpi COIJ2WU( (JIG MG2 GUJU2 uq JJn2p9uq MG (JJJ2 M0f1J (CUq (0

cuijjA jcq (0 JM92 JU (JIG obbo1(c CJILGC(10U CJIJJLGU uqncc pnpuqe (0 MOLJC

(OMSLq2 GLO LJJ 0(JIGL puq CJJflLGU 92 JU2(UTWGU(2 0L MJJG GIUJ1U2 WA

GWbJ0XWGU( L(C MocrJq icuq (0 bo!(!AcJA pJ92 OflL C2(1UJ(C LoW (JJG2G 2bGCJCL!0U2

Page 21: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

Mournu cwbjo?mciu cdn!ou !Ip!cp urnA pc !wboI.wIu uq jrnic pccu fIG ocn o

IC1C o qcdrnc ITJ2iLf1WGU12 MG !IJ0LG U11UJGL O 22flG2 !U OJIL CWOU O fIG

poc LcboI4cq OL UICU HI JpJC 4 OLqGL iO bLcecuc wbflc!A 2 qric o

iu pjc MC bLc2cu CmG2 OL jpc /iqc2 cmbjoAwcu cdnou ujoone o

cxbju1u ipc qccjc u urnjc cwbjo?wciw

coucjnou t pc OMU IiG GGc qouJiirnic2 fIG CGC4 o #4G GLIJ!U !U

!ucLcr2G !U MG2 GUJ!U2 conjq CCO(TIU OL 2OWGMJJGLC pciwccu o o beLceur ØIIL

OL 2owc/ipcLc pcicu 5o-o bcLccu o pc cwbjo?mciu qCCjuG 2!JJCC JÔQÔ MP!1G 11JG

MC MO pvc jrnq pc jicei cwbjoAwcui qccjuc ipc jj u pcL MG2 cu ccornu

OACLJJ pm woqc qccjrnc rn cwbjo?uucu WOU JOM MG UJCU EOL UJGu !14fI JOM

JCLC2G Ju iiqc1 cI.u!u cq2 o u.yqj qccjuc Ju pn2puq)2 cwbjoAmcug OL uJcu

jo nunirnusc pcq ou OJIL G2fWG2 pom cLon 2CCfUJ qwa mc juq JJ IJ

CL022 ecciou J2O qcbcuq cLncIJJA ou pc wc bc4oq wqcq

oo jp !ucLcc O1GL pc Acne 1ujb11c ip jpo 2rlbbJA Cjcc curncq ow pc

tj (cojnuju () o jpjc ) pm mc cjwic bi.ij GJ2fc!A IlG u g-MC2 pejom jpc p bcLccurjc pc baj JOL 2nbbJA cjcA j ouA u j-CLO2 2GCfOU JucLG2cq cou2JqcLpjA OACL jpc ?cI2' LOL cxmbjc OL IJJGU MJfJ

jpc ccouq uqu o uoic jrni pc wjc JpOL nbbjA cjticiA c2iIurncq pow pc

jpciiA monjq bbcL jo qcbcuq cuicjA ou pc mc JGACJ2 o pc uJcu HI dnceioir

9 MG2 poc pc ip bGLccu1jc jpci iuA qecn2Jou o pc wjc jpoL nbbj?

ipc p bcLcGIuJJc (oL u CJHfcJiA o pocn j) pm p i''qj cGcL ou cwbjo?uucu

mc JUCLC2G2 w9Jc cwbjoAwcu pA bbLoxJurncJA bcLccuWc boJlu2 s MG2 pcom

GJ2PC 9 JOM MG2 LOL GXIIJJbJG MG uq fI9 u Iuc1cc IU fIG pOrILJA

(o)) jrni urnjc J1pOL 2nbbJA bo2!AcjA LcJcq jo MG2 uq 2Jmc9ujJA

jc juq CLG 2 MG JJAC CJ2GMJJGLG (2cc inpu (j) uq npu rrthpA uq jobcj

Page 22: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

50

siC 92 pip 92 J CUCL9r !t 92 UO( pCCD DUCOWUIOD (0 uq M9C CJ52(qtC2 LC9(CL iPU J() Ot MOWCIF14}{ccJcwsusuq flJJu2M0LqJ (JQ) qOCUUJCU( LCbOLLCq C1J5(C2 Q (JJC COWbCU2S(Cq M9C cIscUA MP!CP

2113911 LC2bOU?C2 MC 0p2C1.AC ID 0111.

(PC LCWUJC JUPOL enbbj) cjsiqce ms) pc 2WSflCL ipsu &Cd90172JA gponp 12 cucts) p1 puc MJLJI (PC LCJS(!ACJ)

cmbo)cq (wcnqpi sCLo Mccp Mo4rcq) i2 wox.c o& S bsi.pcibsqou WCU217LC HOMcCL' p12 COUClfl2!OU (PSIP1C !2 91313(191 0flI2 MO4(C SmOu MOLf(ID MOWCU MpIjC OUt SU9jC' (PC LLSCIIOU O( NCC 913sqob(cq p1 C2I!U39I!1J JWsJC JUpOL 2flbbJA HR LC2IIJI? Sic UO( qiccqA combSUpJC (0 0171.2 2JIICC P12 qcbcuqcui

r/05(13) btoi4qc (PC W2( comb1cjc 2Cu2 IJIA S1J9J)22 °L (PC cou2cdncucc2 0 qJIJCLCuI 2Ii9ICJC2

IGCU bLoboeCq U jpC II4GLSUILCJ4

CJ924!CJJA 54 4C UJC9U MSC 9j4JJ0flJJ U04 UCSLJA 52 J9LC 92 20mG C24!1JJ54C2 MIJ!CP SAC

4L5U2J54C2 TU40 511 C1524!C!A O SfOfl4 .J MpICJJ !2 cou2!qCLSpA J91CL JJJSU 4C 1DJ ISP0L

ThQ-o suq sbbLoq1us4CjX jj bCLCGUWC bO!U1 !UCLGS2C !11 Jô88-ô0 u'!2 JS55CL G24!W54C

N4tC2 OMIJ MSG MonJq JGSq 40 5 ff5 bCLCCUMC bonu !UCLC92G !U JJCL CUJbJOAIJJCU4 LS4C !"

2 MC LGbOI4 111 4JJG jL25 LOM O JSpJC MC C2PUJS4C 4S4 J0 !U92C JU 4JJC

MSC2 suq GSLJJTU2

!UcC92G2 !U CWbJ0A11JC114 OI 511101J MOWGU 40 UJGU '!P LCjS4!ACJA P!P

4!WC jJJ2 J514CL Uuq!u 2 COU2!24C1J4 M!4P EflLG MpCp uqcS1cq 4S4 4C 15LC24

C4MCCU /i4LC2 CUJbJOAUJCU1 suq fl2SUQ2 GSLWU2 SbbCSL2 40 JAC &OMU MG5CL OACL

CmbjoAu1cu4 suq MSC2 SbbCSi2 40 SAC LOMU 24LO1JCL OACL 4!UJC MJJ!IC 4C LC!54!0U2p!b

CLCU4 4UJC bC9oqe I'J CUCLSJ 4C CL022 2CC4!OUSI LCJS4OU2JJ!b PC4MCGU CUJS1C

V2 M52 4JJC CS2C M!4JJ WCU 4J1C C24IUJS4G2 j0L 4C MOUJCU AS1.A couvqcLsp) OACL

pn2pSuq2 MSC CCJC 40 !1i21U1WCU4 LOL ipC MC)2 U0IJJSf0L !UC0WC

Q suq CPUqLGU -j u pop 2bCcJcs5!ou2 MG rI2C qnmwA ASI4SpJC2 0L 4G

LC2f1J42 0L 2bCC!JC54!0IJ2 M!4JJ suq M14p0f14 C0LJ4L0JflU tOL juG IJLC2GIJCC 0 CJJJLGU scq i-

5J20 2qG24Cb 4JJC dnc2jIoU O CU0CU0IT2 UJSL14SC suq CL4!I!4A qGc2ou2 MC LGb014

M0WCU suq !U CUCLSJ qo UOj SJJOM 0L LJJC SC4 4PS4 MSG2 UJSA pG CUqOCU0r12 MC

P! MJJ!CP UJSA LC2IIJ4 ow 1uJbn4!u MSC2 0L UOUMOLJCCL2 52C 011 qsw L0W M0LU

LC2CSLC !u urnuA bLC!qon2 bsbGL2 hOL OG MC qo U04 5qqLG22 5JJC !?2flC 0 2G1GC4!OU

Page 23: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

51

pG GiGI4OLOU u urnjc uiu i uo LOO 2rn.bI.u ip iic bLcqc

O!AGU jpO errbbjA o wm.ucq MouJcu jrn pecu ou tpc .ucLcc MGfl pcoLc

MOUJGU MJJJ cpijqicu fpU WOIJ MOWCU M41J101U CJJWILGW

ioo uqcu uci.cc rn cmbjoAwcu pvc pccu cdnjjA JLG uoi JLCL uJou

pcccu cpjqtcu uq cmcjc cwbjo?uicui Ø2 LOM1J MGJCCL OACL e bc4oq JQ o

boiu !ucLc9c tu cwc cwbio?incuc yc o uojc 1p91 we UAC LcJ!oI2p!b

o ponecpojq !p cpqLcu conjq CCOfflJj tOL 2OWGMGLG C!iGGU 3 bciccujsc

LG cpjqcu 2 v cxocuon Ai4JG qn2 Monjq jwbjA ps we qccjiJc rn pc IJflCL

cwbjoAweu LG OWCMGLG peccu j bcccuc bou i MG MGLG o 2mJbIA

ccq ou curnje cwbjoAucur jpc bccucc o cjJjqLcu cq j- JOMCI2 iJJG M!G

MG UOC cxbcqcq pc bLccucc oj cpqLcu p JLG uc!Ae

2 IJJG oIcJ.MpcJuJu CGC1 GIdU OL IPG2G MOWCD U JOM MG poncpojq

bcLccuMc bo!u uiou ipeec MOWCU 2ucc CjcLIA ep u cIirnjc JOL enbbjA

orqq ICCOfIUj OL bbLOXUJGJA g bcLccuc bom °. w owj ucLcec o jQ

dn!u1Jc ot pc MG qepnjou pnepuqe cauu2 qccjucq ucLJA 30 bcLccu1 jp

jj ejpjA pcq ou pe C1OL jouc LOL MOUJGU mu4cq o uicu u pc pououi

UCLG2G ejjujA GLOW TôQ o Jg MG MOflJ cuff1fl? bLcqic Mowcue cifibjoAweul o

oj ipc owj ucLce u MOUJGU2 cmbjoAwcur ucc pn2p9uqe cujue u ipc icrc

ou OfTL c iice pc UCLG2C TJ MoWCU2 MGC !Aonfq cconu tOL 9j woej bcLccu

pon bcLccuMc bo!ui OL urnucq MOWGU u OciL emubjc ow TÔQÔ jo cqjo-o uq pA ot bcLccuWc boiue u J8-Y yctjj cwbjoAwcuj uccecq pA

GLU!U2 Monjq pvc ucLccq ipc ice cwbjoAiucui LjG J o bcLccujc boiue tu

couiomu 0L pc bLceeucc o cpqcu MG G21W1C jrni jyyj CCLG2C pi pnepuqe

ceiucq OL pc ccc o ice cwue ou we priepuqe cwbjoAwcu LG

jpc GCC1 ot priepmJqe cuJjue ou ipc iiqce cwbjoAuicu !e J2o JVLCL pu

Page 24: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

urnloL qcicjobmciu pJ CUJJC JOL 2flbbJA u LGCCUt qccqc

pc pcq oip lu cwjc cuibjoAwcu o/iq2 pip ponecpojq MPTCP jrn CCU

pp-Mc wcu jpjc uqcc2 jrnj CUG2 u pnpuq CUJ!U2 nupjc o bLCqc.i

LCC2 OL pc M!AG2 O JOM-MC WCU IIJG CW9'J CCCJCLOU occrni.cq OL pc !14AC O

pc ccu u pc wpjc Mpc rpc bLcqqcq cccjcLou u curnjc cwbjoAujcu o,ip ii

uq SIJ tCCGJCLOU o bGLCCUC bOIU2 OL iowcu u pp-Mc JJon2cpoJq2 y2 cu

iqrnc qcccjcipou o woc ijrnu bcLccuwc bo!iu OL MOWCU !u joM-MG poncjiojq

J.JJG j bcLccuwc bouL CCCICL!OU 2CCU !11 1pc JJOMCACL UJ2JC 911

pc bcqqcq pC cuLC bcccrusc bow CCCJCLOU uq WOLC

qnLu tJJC JôXO2 q JoO2 Bq OU iJJC JOMqOMIJ !' CLIJU2 MC onjqqccqce oici. qic 9uq oiqu o bcLccuMc bo!u beL qccqc

cwbjoAmcu LjC cccJcLcq jpjA io!qu 9i 1c o jj bcLccuc bojue beL

JJG pc bcuoq cpjc opcucq OAGL y JpJC UJUCq MOWGU

IJJC UOUpOL ucowc ccc Lcboucq iu coinum () o jpjc ) rnq qqcq pi nuoriu o

mJun pc couc2bouqu cpmJc 0L j7 pc co uccu -j (oni C2WC O

cojnuiu () MC wnjibcq pc cpuc u prr2p91iq2, c91.u!u2 OACL pC bc4oq roo-jogo

cojifujir (j) uq cojnuiu () o jppjc jo LuAC 9i pc bLcqqcq Cp9UC Lcboucq iu

tc IUCLCCq u cowbqu LON4 LC MC LcboU cpuc2 ou r bcL qccqc p

LC OACL JJC bcI4oq -JQ O JJC cpsuc OACL 1pC JCL bc4oq JQ-J UCC MC

P JPJ MC 2W14 pA cowbu pC CJJ91JC !U urnu.cq MOWCU2 CIJJbJOXUJCU

N4UC22G U JJC2C 2911JC 1M0 qCcqC2 MC jpi dnciou Hi JJG

C91J 10 91JA qcLCC ccornu OL IPG CCCJCL!OU O IJJG L0M1JJ U CWJC CUJbJOAIIJCUI

dncel!ou 2 MJJCIJJCL IJJC 10Mq0/U !U UJIC C9LU!U2 LOMJJ U IJJC JO2 911q JJC TèO2

iucLCC lu cuwjc jpoL 2nbbJA pcq ou UrnJC C91JJTIJ2 V 2OWCM1 IJJOLC LC2OIJC

Page 25: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

LH4JJ urnA pc c2bcciJJA fmqGL2WiGq OL MOWGU Ju pp wc pOflacpOJq2 pJ iqqwou

JAC2WJCUI2 HI pnurnu Cb!WJ ic bruiciqstjA !WbOLWIU OL pjJ MC MOUJCU CU MC

obboi.jcTuc2 0L iowcu (ecc cxiubjc uiup "q jq (ioo)) i cxbcLcucc uquq cjrnuu cowbo2i ou oj MOLJHJ MOHIGU wo2 bLoJpJA riuqcwcq IJCLC2!1J

opcucq !u CL022 2CC0Uj qi pJ ipc cui.A oj MOHIGU MflJ JOM JCACJ2 0 GxbcL!cUcc

cwcj wbc o cpuc u mi.jcc obbo1.uIuc2 wA pic Jccu CACU LGCL pu

poncpojq pcjq acqA qrn.pj c jj uq pc cowbLcq o qJG TQO2 jpc

JOM MC joricpojqe 2jOMG couvqcLpJA MjjC MC &o!14p oj M0JGU lu pip MC

1c coucu Mp p2cq LOM !u curnjc uibjoAwcu ucc mc io!p o ouicu

bLcjuJpjA iqc EP cpuc rn M0WCU cr uq uijcq obbounrnpc2 bbce oILCG qw 20 MG11 JJIIJG MC JJVC lb LCJ 1JMCI2 jo pi2 dnc2iou MC

CL022 2ccijouJ iujbc oj ipc 2JM0MU m pripuq cm.uTu2 oiip qJ ccw o

jpc wl•OL cJrnjjciJc ipcu 2 io qcu1I) Mp 0LCC2 pc cucq o corncc pc

coujun.A jo MJJ Monjq c cxbccicq pcq ou 2!tubjc CL022 ccc 2oIk

JO/A MC UJCU uq 2UJllC2 tOL JJJJ MC HId WC2G LCJAC epp LIIU C0UJbJCCJA

MAC2 Oj JO/A MC WGIF UCC 1JiC 2JOMO/AiJ U UrnJC CUJU2 L0H4JJ M2 LCiC2i OL

!AIAC2 o jnp MC ificu rncLciu jpdlt cwbjo?wcu L4C2 uiijcJuJ?¼ WOLC Jrn1J fJJC

ipc LcJryc bqbou LC2 0 urnucq !AOWCU jrnAc 2pJcq CU0LW0n2JA #iqip pc

pc bj vito qccqce jurcq MC uq pc ji wo qccqce AC pecu pwc MPCLC

CccjcLrnu uo pc urnl•oL dnu jJ/tC cpTuc !U cwc JOL 2nbbJX /?WC22C 0!tCL

cwbjoAmcu qnuu jpc Lcccu qccqc2 E4PCL uJXa2 p0McAcL 2OM2 ijrni w!2

cm.uue bbc2 ro pvc couupncq 2OWCM o pc cccjcLjiou oj urnuJcq MOWCU)2

jpc LC2flJI2 !U 1J12 bbcL 2flC2 LIJI !' LCC JJC 2J0MOMIJ U WCIJ2

AF C0Ut102!OU

Page 26: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

wc bcuoq MC uicuq o rqqc2 iJJC2C 122f1C2 U OflL tJ1WLC MOLJC

J&\02 2flC22 JJ YUJJJL tOLCC2 UJA pAC fCCU MOLJC tOL JOM MC MOUJCU OACL tJJC

pmb uou-ucnuj 2pi !U jPOL enbb1A OL wcu pciiiccu qic jc uq qic L1X

Page 27: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

MjJO M0LjCC J-J MCGJC2 IJJG bLc,1on2 AcL uq onuq jI M2 J2o bbLoxurncJ?

2UJG 0fl0flJ LO10U 2WbjG2 MC CJCfljffjG IJJC AGLC 2flLAC? MCCJC MC2 O 1J102G

ACLG MG2 bbLox rnlcJ? beLceul Cj0M IJJC WC1J O pGp C0jJ014 fl2!1J luG

MCCJC MC2 LOL 1G Of1t.OUJ LOWIIOU 291UbjG2 jGJuuiU 111 JJJC2C WCU pq

GUIJ1G AcL PfIl Lc-culcLcq lpC jOL UJL1CC1 !' IJIC OIIO/t4U AcL MC JIAC Afl 2flLAGA

1CII!U 2 IJJC C0UJb142OU OJj 2flLACA MCCJC MC2 LOL IJJO2C UJCU MJJO qq UO1 MOLJC IJIC

beLceuf /ACLC JJJJ 2CJJOOJ qLobon2 uq beLcdul MCLC COflCC uqrRI1c2 EACU WOLC

coJjcc UfflUG2 qniu LId Jô8-8ô bc4oq yuou UJCU /#4J0 M0LJCG J-[3 MCGJC2 3j

bci.ccuj o LId UOUMOLJCGL2 MGLC pip 2CJJOOJ q1oborn2 uq oujA bCLCCUL MCLG

cxwbjc LJJC cqr1c1!OU9J LWjIJ1JJCU1 o jpc uo 1onb2 LC 2HJJ!JL 'U qj bbLoxurnLcJA

AGLA jijc urnA pe CJ02C bLoxA o LId flUOJI2CLAG Md 0CL2 0 U0UMOLJU WCU J0L

JJJCLC LC UI1UJGL O LC2O1J 10 pejicAc LJJL USC MC2 O LJJO2C MJJ0 MOLJCd

MJJO M0LJCG ACLA JWJC UUJCJA J-J MCGJC2

q2Uuprujou o UJIG2C UOUMOLJflJ mcu rI2Ju pc q2tLJprnoU o opcLcq MG2 0j RICU

(rrpu (j) uq 'jripu nLbpA uq jobcj (JJ)) MC !uJbnLc USC boLcUU MC OCL

UOU MOLJC 1 JJ qf114IJ EOJ!0M!U wGUpoq JL2U u1LoqnCGq LU OflL bLC/uon2 bbcL2

bOUGUUJ1 JpOL UJLJCG1 cxbcucucc MJiO MCLC uo cutojjcq IU 2CJJOOJ OL jlJ LId UJjflWI.A qq

JJAC UJJ22JU MC LT LOL cxiusbjc ( bCLCCUL o LId UJCU MIII j 10 O AcL2 OJ

HOMCAGL 2IJ1JCUL bol.luou o bI.!wc-G wcu qo UQI MOLJC L ll qnLu d Ac iiq

jJ0M2 (12 10 CJCf1JUG JJOIILJA Md2 GAGU tOL WGU MJJO OIJJA M0LJCC bu 0j LJJG ACSL

cauiu uq Cwbjo?uJCuL IJ0LUJU0U 0L IJIC ACIL bLcMon2 jO USC 2flLACA JJJ2 qcu

jJJC VUIJ1J Dcw0LbP1c2 2nbbJCwCuU OU UJJC Jq9LCp Ch2 COIJWTU2 LCLLO2bCCL!AC

1wbnwiiou 0 fiG2 0L M0UM0LJ1U yjC2

bbcuqrx

Page 28: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

5Q

AL1!JCC O j0 pocrLJA MG2 cqcnjcq LOW iJunj G9UJTU2 uq Of1L2 M2 Q !ApflG

4C joii MGGJC2 mocq CG04G2 EOL cxwbjc' oL po2c Mpo MOLJCG 1-13 MP iPG

o cjcnjcq HG2 uincp J1.kL ipu pc i.ucc o tcbouq MG2 bi.icnjj) iuipc OL fG ocuorn L0IPOU wbIc2 2rncG jg c pi orruq jrni ipG A9UUCG

porlL2) iip pc q2pruou o LcboLicq ponijh iow pc enucA iiccjc qw

00 LGL02bGC1AG cp qw (cjcnJGq pX qiu 1JuJ GuJ!U2 A uunj

uq porrLJA MG pj ora bLciqon2 !Ao1Jc c JJAG cowbm.cq pc q2p4pnou o M2

UJ62(1LGq MIflJ GLLOL JJ12 LG2fljl2 U 2b0140n2 ucic LcJ!o1J2p!b G1MGGU MCGJC?

MG CJCflJ5G pOIILJX MG2 p) q/qqu mnin CUJi1J2 pX niiJnj O1112 MOLJCGf MGGJ(2

G0L TIJ MG2 C2flLGWGU GI.LOL 12 1J G2bGCA cuor12 bLoçGw IJ OlIL q !U JI

1uuoAPou 10 OlIL bbGL ouc bLopjcw iqp oni. ic-pcq bbLocp !2 UJG2f1LCWCU

JJJ1JG OL1JU pc qw pcq 011 JJC pr12puq2 MC bCLCCU!JG !2 U !mboLWIU

if COU 0L YJUi EU0L TU RC2

B0UJJO1J 00 pG flJ 11fl0U O MG2 O b4-)c9L MOLGL2 uq uo JT2jpG wG9IJW

OL UOUMOLjGL2 MG /JGM 0iIL wcpoq 92 bLccLpIc OMGAGL U 1JJ MG LG fl2U

!#4JJ pcjcccq MGGJC2 MOLJCC J92 AG9L 92 SIJ 9qqou9J L€LG220L uq bLcqqcq ,tc2

MOLJCG 1-13 MCG !tpu JJC Lonb yJCUJUjACJA MG conjq JrnAC urn MG cdn9i!ou

WO\W'flpcLc O12 JJG UJIWpGL 0 UOU-MOLJCGL2 90q TTh2 pG Uf1UJJGL 0 MOLJCGL2 M0

HI G9CJJ AG9L' MC IJJCU LCMG1JJiG G9C UJ9JC MJJO M0LJCG 1-13 MGGC2 f)A jJJC 9C0L (j +

UJ9UJG M1 9 MOLJCUJ8 2bon2c 91J uJ9uJCq MJJ 9 U0UMOLJU 2b0fl2G LOL GCp onb

GXbGL!CUCG onb2 cqrrclwou onb 9U 3 urnuj 2Wfl2 onb2 qcucq 92

000M0LJCCL2) MC ji2 qiiqqcq pc 211wbJc o buuJc-9c wGu io Loab2 92G 00

jO C2UJ9iC pG nJJ M9C 0GL q2uJprnou (ucJnqu JJO2C OGLGq io

bcLcGu CJ0M JJG WCSW

Page 29: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

cjcnjcq ponijA MG2 tOL !J AGL2 JôQ-àJ

UGCG22fI)¼ o urnjcc pc iMo qiLpnou cdrnj jc pcu bbjcq pi coacc ou qoL o

OL GcJJ MGCIC2 MOLJCG PLCJCG uq bGLcGuqjG ccoA tpG qccucc !U jO MG2

MGGJC /AG2 fl2U q pow ipc OnOjU LOWPOU 2UJbjG2 OL Tô8-ô MG cjcrijcq

cou.cq pc q2Ljpniou !U cjcnjcq MG2 pX fl2J ipc q21ijpnioU o Lcbol4cq 2nuGA

JJJjJc UJC?flLGWG1U CLLOL u nucA MCGJC iic LGWU2 bLopJcuJ MC

qnc o WC2flLCWGUj CLLOL

2UJC1U U11UJGL O UJCU U iJJC JOM MGGJC2 MOLJCC CUCOLjG2 jO JJ MG CjGOI4C2

pc AU9UCC O LcboI4cq MC2 !A2 f jpj2 2fTG2iC o 112 JJ91 MG MCLC W?Cj22?qU

Page 30: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

cououc o (j): J-J:IgJJ{c/ic/1 o jcccut jLCU2 uq },Lobo2q ExbJuOU2', O%1t31% o\

fGAAa unJj uq j,qrn.rnruc jçcpq fl fLU2 jCACj uq LWU2 pJcdnpA: v

q wuq EcioL2 ottxtiocououw io (EcpIrnn.A jô):j-ticucc uq jrn.bpA Kc/du j'jrnuc u jcjuic j-g,: 2nbb1A

Kf12Gll 2G onuqoI? Joocqucq pA pcjqou Du1L iq bCCL ooucjrnjic bb j- 4CM

pc nuq et: y -Ac9l cL2bcqAc, p1ynojA Auu y jJJG jLcuq u pJcdn9j!A ywou JUJTG2 uquqqn uq /OLJCCL2 !U

juci.ccq jmc ooi itb o 'coiouc MCW (JJ):-J45v11m1 cwjr nthpA Kc/qu iw içop if iobr H 1p ic

J5J.Jcc Obbow1uc2 \oti o\ccnioc j (jcpuii.A jôô):

V'P'J CJJ!"P'W DCCI!UC O 1A1G fOL b!c!b!oU: JJJG JOC O DGCI!IJW

Jçcp9lq bb io-sor J4CH A0LJC: jQ%OO O\ "1%Ot. COOUC V CqCq pA OLICA C 2CUCjCL uq

HCCPU UJG uq y.9ijc (jIILJ21IOUp JCW9C fpOL 2flbbiA: y 2nucA p1

50-tvE4qu 9uq IwbJ!c!ou ot1% o ''cio. COUOCL (cuni.A jg):

QoJqIf rniqr flc-CAcIc rpoL-EoLcc bn4!cibL!ou o ucq jowcu: H!OI1CJ

eucc ioo cix isctow iMcH' QnjA jô):C0JCIIJ YPLA L iiq 1°P1J LUCAGJ JLCUcI2 W 1Ii JjOLJC flCPt4OL O MOUJGU

A0LIC: nncjj 2C Eonuqwou joo:i4%ZWC3 cqncq pA 2PCN01J DUCL 8Uq },CtCL oouciw bb j- MCMpJcowc pjcdnjjiA uJou j,uicq ConbIc2 pJ izz% iiC"' pGJqOU DUL uq hCiGL QOU2CpJJC JOLJqTJ M!' q EIJJIIA

flUTAGL2IA' 1ôô0

J'y, flubnp2pGq bbcL flIJ1ACL2!A O 2°'UP COI!U uq COIJ1WP!iucowc iucdniuA 1u ip fj uq ØiJJGL pqn24u9Jrscq 4oU2 qfJ14!J w

jccpnui1 qcjqujcA v iq D'4q E BJOOW QJ91JC2 !U W 2I.flCUI o JUJJJA

g6(GL6UG

Page 31: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

oici ocoiouc (iuic jô):2UIJ WC2 J 9uq #JcpJ jiq OWCU !U WC JTPOL LJCCi 9uq U JUJTI)

oiii o\ £COUOC2 (unO Tô): ô-ôO2'JJUP h uq NP1 jtq J!1JJG G4G2 OLOM1JJ !11 EGWJC fpOL LOLCGI

flUThGLiA JLG 1ô80£c1o1 cq5Gq jA U1C2 2uJUp1 bbJç-5 ci 'jCL2CA: }uuccouWC2 V22C12 uq fJOL 2flbbJX) p sti1c -ço. tb1

4oI4p-oJJuq1 Jô8cqq pX OX c y pcuicL uq Jcjrni.q Actq bb -jØ Cft A0LJC:

bCUCVG1 opw jpoL 2flbbJA o cu: v 2flucA iu cooy o cooc

Tô):oMOLIC O ECOUOUJTC uq 21CJ y2nwb!ou °'°"LOS JJJOUJ2 y jpc 2GIJ2A!CA O U EWbILI1 oqcj °L yucq Momcu HOflL2

Page 32: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

J30flL8 98 MGT1 98 J6 roa CJJ91Jä8 U 1Ø COWbOU6IJçBMOLJCGt8 U 911A atAGu M6G £PG cpje bLeeeuB Tod cpuae 111 ovj 91111(191ozceq vwouã uunvr b9L;rcrb9uce vuq gAer.986 pOSItS MOtJCG b6t MGGJC woudMTAG8 MpO MOtJCGq 9ç ]G984 ] MG8JC qrJr.rud 4Je bLGATOfl8 A69T 9A6L986 M6GICS

dnrucne cgc6aot YAGL98S 9UWTj pouts wte bioqncç ot tccrou o;gAeLgde guunwj pouts s.totceq woua JT Mt8 a9Wbe uq r" cp M9ã6Aegr. vietdea MGtG vtonuq 7evts ]aea wuq 1a8a MyuungJ pouts.. 9t6dnvtçete MGL6 ueçpet ebonae M98 T 8CJJOO Ot 4J1G W1T1c9t71 aetce pteeboceucr] j9pOt W9LCG4 GXbeLT6UCG stjete ueçpet abotie TA6q ru dtonbucs5qGe 9fl wccpeg pnap9uq-M-s butte Mper.e 46 JJrIRpUq pq 1—30 Aete o;

eontce: wtcw C(ILLGUc bobrrrgcTou 2r.AGAB 1aQ8-Taar .u sgwbTe

81—100 .3e ioa 025eT—80 30. P12 ioe 02e

0ô2 020oa oao

T—O ]85 oea 08?

1—100 0ô8

HOflLB MOtCGt8 MOLJC8tB Hoflte\t4GeC

beT.C6UcT1G YUIJtIWT O YUUfl9 YWOZJ8 YU11n91Hfl8VU8 ,igde kL9CTOU MG6JCB otceq

ro cpvude

ro8 cpguae U Ij88 YUUnVT HOfltB MotjCGg ug cowboueucs Taea-Taaa

LPT 7

Page 33: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

et ug oweu 'SIP CIqLeU 9deq .-l9—— Tq 9CL088 cpe Iaea-sa beLoqcpee GL4A CJ98868—— MOWGLI MTfPOn,C cprgteu 140W6U cpJqreu gàGq -cp9udeB r" 'rte ewbroXweuc L9c0 }JO7qpis 1}G COWbOaTcTOU 0 MO(LIGU VCLO9B9ABL9âBB MeT.e 1V)C613 x.onuq flJB ?I69t8 mea Vug TaBa COTJ7WIJ (3) tebotçe&IVLfGtBS 14GLG uercpet 8O8G 1498 TL 8CPOOT OL WTITcLA BGLATCG IJJLGG eviboceucrgr ]gpo WLJCG; exbeLieuce Mpor.e uercpeL ebonee rr u atonbucnqea VJj wçcpeg pnep9uq-Me bta pete pnapuq pwq 1-30 GVL8 o

2oaltce: cp nteuç bobnrvcrou 2nr.Aee laeB-laar Je B9wb)e

81—TOO 737 333 303el—So 102 308 388l—Q0 .Oa1 385ST—'fO

1—50 oea .1e3

1—100 .O 521

Ewblo?Iw6uC COWbO8TCTOU xeqbGLC8UCITG CJJJqLaU iLl L.tTtG,8 EWblOltWGLJc—-HneP9uq.a MV'36 L9COU M\O yccrzr CPUaG cpgude TU MT1G.8

(r) (s) (3)

cpude laea—Taea

cpuãee ILl MI EwbloWeuc 9ug ,etcijrc?: Taea-]asa

L'PTe 5

Page 34: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

Bofltce: 2ee .Lwpre r

1—100 23O 385 foe 581 038 048

81—TOO 232 581 0e1 11541—20 .3e •3.1 5ea 012 —o531—50 5e ses so 321 —. Ire —sre

beLcGUc tienepuqe Mgae

2a—ea ea—a a—sa 2a—ea ea—.a a—8a

apuq

roa cpuae TLJ Er.IJude

i—Too 132 130 032 —034 —003

81—100 ioa i3 148 014 -005 00841—20 158 145 134 034 —050 ooei—so rre o oee 042 —oe —o'i

betCGUcTrGnapguqe Mgae

2a—ea ea—a a—sa a—ea ea—a a—ea

HflEpvlJq

v cpuãe Tu cpe EWbToJUiJeuc ice

BA WepUqe de eceucrreCpguâe8 TU HnBpUqI8 vug r;e EwbroAweuc uq Luude

pre

Page 35: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

bet so qoes uoç qr.occA vuecc wvye ewbroAweuc tvçeaXevt gnwwee ouq paspvuq,a eqacCou 2TUCS MS tesctrcc on evwbe btrwe-gde wgree MS OBBflWG Cpa; vdeyqqçrouj tdpç puq eqe tgpjes u cpo LedLeaeTou MTCp MS qo UO tebotç pets ucnqe tedrou qnunrea'bjna ;ee SVT.UTU88 (t.wde vuq BWJLA ucowe ba8 tucowe ttOW BSTt GWbToAWeUc) ru 'ybetCeuçfl-e toudee 4OUJVPOt TUCO 18 WevsI7tGq VS cpa 817W O 4J6 uOu—Mvde !ucowe ;ot cpa pnepvuq vuq Mr;eptee eebwzgce Mode coe;;rcreucs gte esçpnwceq AIW rIUGOL Bb]tuSe qeueq Ot M0d98 TV 7—50' 51-40' 41+cpa uvcntgr rodvtrcpw ot vuunor Mode oug SVTOLA eotutuds qAqeg pX MS6)C5 motcaq WGS 170170] MGG)CJA ponr.e-rwpree ;ot cj-rqr.eu odeg 1—e vuq cpqteu vdeg —x vdaa vte rod oetv8e pontA sotutuds cowbnceq vsvuq ;s1s M0d0 scrwvces u CO]'IIWUB ()-(e) ass gmA vtoprea ;or. cpa paspouq,e Mode qecje vuq gnuaDA

Mo;..: ESCTWOCGB p.i GO]17UIUS ass vs rus;taweu;s qauisiA AVLTVP]es ;ot ;pe paspouqe Mode gecaOfltCG: )VtC CaxrGuc bObIlTVCTOU 217tAGAS uoçes iopre ;or. evwbe ereccrou ctrceLrv

Ic—2dnvteq •0083 0308 •0331 04eQ •0538MITWPSL 0 0p8 't2'480 42'4ao 2Q18 4e'a?a

iucowe (ooo3) (0005) (000s) (0003) (0003) (0004)iourvpot 000e 0001 —'0004 —0014 —000Q —0014

(0034) (oo3e) (oo3a) (0033) (oo3e) (oo3a)etceucrre 41+ -0102 00Q3 ooeo -0142 00.14 '0035

(o1o2) ('0133) (0138) ('0104) (o133) ('0140)BGLCGZJTIG 51—40 0138 '1240 •1301 •O.180 •14à 1345

(oioe) ('0103) (ooas) (olo2) (oios) (ooss)betCeucl-re 1—50 •oa 1e80 3425 0823 1Q80 •5413

rod HoarTA Mode(1) (5) () ('i) (2) (e)18Q8—.10 18.18—80 1888—80 188—.10 18.18—80 1888—80

XEYKDGbGUqeuC AVLTOPTQ NnapVUq8 EwbroAWeUc Ng;e

EscTWocee o i:pe HaBpwug.a EWbroAweuc EdITOCTOV

Page 36: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

Mocee: 2 jvpegonLce: jgtcp CJILLeUc bObflTVflOU asTLAeAa 268 uOç&a o gpG I ;oL erwbje aereccrou cLrcerv

I-2dflVX.qMflWP6L a; OPQ

---.- ----84O

----.eSI

----'83

----8ô'o

----%QJ

iuccweI4OUIVPOL

(oooa)—OOSa

(oooa)-o03e

(oooa)—0022

(oole)—00'?Q

(-0013)—OOO

(oo3o)—0115

roã HOflL7 Mwae(o133)1133

(ort2)I83't

(osor)52Q5

(oyss)11..\5

(oiu)I.ô2

(osss)5?Q8

(i)

Iae8—.o(s)

Ia.18—80 ()iaBe—ao ()iaea—.iO(2)Ia.s—eo

(e)

iase—ao

Debeuqeuc AVT'PT6 - n9pvuge EWbTO7WJGUc ice

E8cTWgGB 0; cpe Hnepvuq,e EWbTOAWGUC EdnvcTOu: I,8LC6UCT169 I—SO

LVPTG 2

XEYI

Page 37: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

A.vr. qnuiiee M;ae ad. aug ada adngr.ag aug mr;e,a agncacouyqqrcrouay x.rdpc paug erg. Awx.vp7ee ru cpa r.edx.eeetou MPTCP Mø go uoç tebox.ç pex.. ucrge .arOu qrwJn.e1ear; ewboAweuc) p.i M na aa TuecLnwauca qau*uA AVLT9prae ;ox. cpa pnepvuq%e Made qecraTUCOWG ;ox. cpa pnepaug aug ;e brna cpa pnapauqe cocar eax.utuda (Made aug eaax.A luCowa bjne tucaa ;x.owcp7qr.eu r;aa ade x.edtau aug Aeax. gnuisae .Mourapox. TucowaM ra waaenx.aq ye cpa enw o; cpa uou—i'twde

ax.e bx.eqccaq netud cpa pnepauq1e Made qac-a qnuiziae pnepauqa aug MT;eB agncwcrou' gnwwA Aax.raprae ;ox.o; auunay ,.%ada aug eaax.A aax.utude grAgeg pA aajce ox.jceg crwaa nanwrMa.Jc7A ponx.e Mvdae ;ox. uou—MoLlc.te

Lio;au: .rod poflx.7A Made.. ra rod aAax.ada ponx.A aaturude a; cpa MTtG cowbnceq ae cpa uacnx.yr rodyx.rcpw2onca: iax.cp cnx.x.auc bobnTacTou 2nx.AaAe 2aa uocae co .Lapra 7 oL VVWbTe Ba]aGflOu CLrcaLra

I—2dnateq T3T ]004 ]55Ô 0018wlwpex. 0 0P8 4240 25'e.a ,1ea2a

(oo2a) (oo24) (oo2o)cprqr.au ydaq —7488 -. I5.1

(oo4a) (oo48) (oose)cpryqx.au ugax. Q —•3345 -. 5304 —. 7854

(ooos) (ooos) (000l) (000s) (000s) (000l)ou1vpot iucowe —.00.T -0027 - 0040 —.00.Q — 0023 —0047

(oo43) (oo44) (oo'u) (oo44) (oo4e) (oo43)rod Honx.TA Made 0570 0aea 0àè4 03.3 T73 103e

(i) (s) (3) (') (2) (e)

1ô.8—80 7a88—ao iaQs—.o 7a.8—80 1ô88—àO

AEYIDabeuqeuc AaLrapTG = Mr;ea EWbTOAWGUC icace

Eecrwgcae a; cpa zr;e.e swbroAwauc Edflacrou

apre Q

Page 38: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

TUCOWG e;ecc L0W CO]17WU (3) O £Vp76 VTu jinpuqe etuude dtoMçp p64b%66U TWG T1JcGt/tJe uq Ont eecpuvceqaLoM4w ru ewboAweuC 0t GBCJJ dtonb pvaeq 011 1C8 6LflGL 8tOMJ uq fl16 CJ39U8G

raea-Tasa uq JG Ta2a-]aea 6ttOcl £PT C0TnWJ t6btGB8U4B CpG 0LGCV8Gcpudee u pnepguq,a etuoda (8vu wegenteg bet qecqe) peçeeu cpe

iasa a bet qecqe tçe T.ow WTU( OO ;P' qGtGIJCGcowbnçeE bteqrcceq cpude pi ewbyOJnieuç 0t Tuqcgceq dtonb ot iaea-dtonbB O WGU OAGL J6 betoq ]aea-Taea ou g bet qecqe pae cornwu (3)() aAG8 JJ6 A6Ld6 cpguäe ps ewbrolweuc tçea ;oz. MTAGB 0; Eweo; weu Tu cpe uqcvceq Made qeCje cvceaotree peCi.eeu cornwu

Mocee: cornwu (i) dee ie cpue ru ewbjoAweuç tgçe o; MTAGB

1—100 11Ô 138

81—100 110 1Q0 133Q1—80 .11a 120 .13a

138 138 14831—40 151 1301—50 11. 093 132

ccedorJ' 1a28—ea iaea—iaea raea—]88aetceucrre ycçn pu8e yccnvr cpvuae teqcceq cpuae

(1) (3) (3)

gçee a; civu8s pi Mr;e%e EwbTo'.weuc gçe (bet qecqe)

J'pIe .

Page 39: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

Ca'a)

'-4C

100)2:0C-'-4>-

toa,a,

EJãnL6 1 CIJ9UdG U Hfl2PUQ2 ro HOflLIJA M9äG Td8—T8HfleP9UQ,a M9d6 C7J6

_3, 3 2 aI

-.5-

0

.5

Page 40: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

EIflLG •-ie -

—. -

-.5-1.0C0a.) -'-1

-08E

'>m-•01-

iil.aa'

0

05

CJ9UÔG lu Hfl2DYUQ2 EWbJOALGU 9G aea—a8aHn2pguq,2 Mgde Usd163 2 a

Page 41: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

EIã

nLe

3 M

J4G

2 E

WbJ

OA

WG

Uc

Uce

pA

np

uq

MY

äG

DG

CIJ

G

Hnp

9uq.

2 M

9a6

06C

11

6

0 -

--

- —

-

m

E 0 '-4

0 E

C) C

1.

cz

a,

Page 42: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

IC

C

C

(a -4 I 0 J C

(U

Page 43: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

I 0 C-

Q)

C) ('1

_ yn

f1

MY

dS

QG

CJJ

G

bflL

G

Mi6

12

HO

flLJJ

A

MY

öG

pA

0 5 e 8

Page 44: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

C c La m

C- C

C

(U

a-.. (A

EJã

nLG

E

M

a2

VU

Ufl9

J E

9UU

JU2

pA

HflP

9UQ

2 M

9G

DG

CJJ

G

Hfl2

P9U

QI2

M

9d6

06C

1J6

0

5000

ooo

eooo

8000

oooo

1500

0

I ae

a 0

aee

Page 45: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

EJL

6 E

WbJ

OA

WS

Uc

US

cS

O.

MJA

G2

MJf

IJ

)Ofl

Ud

cJrJ

qLeu

06

C1J

6

0

rn

E 0 E

C) C

'.0

•1

.5

3

Page 46: YJIMM - National Bureau of Economic  · PDF filejg iic o buuic c uijc MOLJCq beLcelu o pc Ac 9uq WcA C1JJcq U uq CUJ!U jjy jpc oA OL ipc !#4Ac o iC2C wcu dn!c qcLcur BA pc jcc

rnE

0Ea)C

a:

a)

0 aea

1a86

0

EJflLG 8 MIt612 EWbJOAWGUI je u aa' aeaHp9uq,2 M9ã& O6CJJG

.5

.3

2

I aaI iaa