written statement, objections to ia and ia of defendant draft in injunction suit
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
1/21
^ILK@TKOO _/S DHOH@DL@T
_KGL[LILMSBAK & FTBHZS GL[LAAL
Urktth` stlthah`t okihd jy dhoh`dl`t u`dhr Frdhr
_KKK Zuih < fo cpc7-
Tbh dhoh`dl`t buajiy sujakts ls ofiifws
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
2/21
:
?. Kt ks rhsphctouiiy sujaktthd tblt, tbh cf`th`ts fo plrl-? ks `ft dksputhd.
5. Kt ks rhsphctouiiy sujaktthd tblt, tbh plrl -5 fo tbh pilk`t ks blio jlmhdl`d akxhd wktb olish l`d truh olcts. Tbh dhoh`dl`t blvk`e ak`hs
ikch`sh tf df qulrryk`e wfrm k` surv hy `uajhr 4:/4 ks `ft dksputhd,
tbh hxclvltkf` fo 3>ot ks lisf `ft dksputhd. Tbh lvhrah`ts tblt f` >?-
>:-:> lt
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
3/21
3
l`d sueehsstkf olisk. Bh`ch, tbh sukt ks ikljih tf jh dksaksshd f` tbks
erfu`d lif`h.
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
4/21
4
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
5/21
8
tblt tbh Urktth` stlthah`t scbhduih prfphrty blvh vlikd ak k`e
ikch`sh.
@F DFCXAH@T L@@HRXZH
< GFK@T SXZ_H[ AL^ FO AK@HS/OFZHST/ZH_H@XH
SBFUK@E FTBHZ IKCH@CHD \XLZKHS
G
: ASC\I 4->8 DLTHD ::-4 OFZ SXKT
SCBHDXIH IL@D
M
3 DH^LZTAH@T FO AK@HS ZH ^HZAKSSKF@ TF
CF@TK@XH AK@K@E DLTHD 8-:>>;
I
>->> f` >3->4-
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
6/21
?
:>>, dhal`dhd sfah ou`ds ofr tbh
olakiy `hchsskty l`d lothr rhousli tf prfvkdh sucb dhal`ds tbhy aldh
eliltl k` tbh qulry prhakshs l`d stfpphd wfrm wktb eff`dl hihah`ts
durk`e :>>>. Tbh dhoh`dl`t wktb `f suppfrt orfa l`y lehd alih
kssuhs blvh shttihd tbh altthr jy ekvk`e rhphlthdiy tbh af`hy ls l`d
wbh` tbh 3rd pilk`tkoo l`d ftbhr ahajhrs fo pilk`tkoo olakiy
dhal`dhd. Ok`liiy sbh eft hxhcuthd Zheksthrhd cf`sh`t dhhd f` >> orfa 3rd pilk`tkoo. Tbh Cfpy fo tbh cf`sh`t dhhd ks
prfduchd bhrhwktb ls L``hxurh-^ ofr tbh mk`d phrusli fo tbks Bf`jih
Cfurt.
::.Tbh dhoh`dl`t ourtbhr sujakt tblt, tbus pilk`tkoos blvh jhh` bljktulitrfujih crhltfrs, l`d blvk`e sfah jilcmalkik`e lttktudh lrh dfk`e
al`y strl`eh tbk`es blvh rhch`tiy dhal`dhd dhoh`dl`t tf ply af`hy
fr tf olch cfurt clsh. Dhoh`dl`t lothr shhk`e lii tbh jld l`thchdh`ts
blvh hxblusthd lii bhr hoofrts k` sltksoyk`e tbh pilk`tkoos kiiheli
dhal`d ofr af`hy. F` :-:> hvh`k`e dhoh`dl`t : clah tf tbh
qulry l`d tbrhlth`hd wfrmhrs `ft tf cfah orfa afr`k`e jhclush
cfurt bls stfpphd qulrryk`e.
:3.Tbh Dhoh`dl`t sujakt, tblt Tbh pilk`tkoo k` `f wly blvk`e l`y rkebtstf Urktth` stlthah`t scbhduih prfphrty, l`d k` `f wly rhshrvhd tbhkr
rkebts l`d k` `f wly blvk`e l`y al``hr fo rkebt fr tktih fr aucbihss
pfsshsskf` fvhr wrktth` stlthah`t scbhduih prfphrty, lrh usk`e tbhkr
af`hy, auscih, fookckli l`d pfiktkcli pfwhr l`d lrh crhltk`e `uksl`ch
jy trhssplssk`e f` tbh sukt scbhduih prfphrty tf stfp tbh ikch`shd
qulrry wfrm, l`d lisf succhhdhd k` stfppk`e wfrm orfa
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
7/21
5
dhalrcltkf` fo il`ds l`d ftbhr il`ds lrfu`d jy gfk`t survhy fo
Ofrhst/Ak`hs/Zhvh`uh dhplrtah`t, sucb h`crflcbah`t dfhs `ft
lrksh. Tbh ^ilk`tkoos lrh almk`e aucb elilttl l`d sch`h orfa
afr`k`e fo
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
8/21
2
:. Lii tblt, pkhch l`d plrchi fo tbh Kaafvljih ^rfphrty sktulthd ltMliu`lylml`lBliik Erlal, Sfapurl Bfjik, @hilal`elil Tlium, Jl`elifrh
Dkstrkct, jhlrk`e Sy `f7 4:->3-:>
DHOH@DL@T
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
9/21
;
K@ TBH CFXZT FO CK_KI GXDEH (GD)
LT @HILAL@ELILFS - ?4 /:>
^ILK@TKOO _/S DHOH@DL@T
_KGL[LILMSBAK & FTBHZS GL[LAAL
FJGHCTKF@S TF KL FO ^ILK@TKOO X@DHZ FZDHZ3;
ZXIH
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
10/21
5. Kt ks shttihd prk`ckpih fo ilw tblt wbh` sukt ks `ft alk`tlk`ljih k`thrkarhikho cl``ft jh erl`thd. Bhrh sukt ks `ft alk`tlk`ljih ofr blvk`e
rhikhd f` olish olcts l`d prkal olckh olish lsshrtkf` wktbfut
kapihldk`e rhli phrsf`s tfwlrds `frt hlsthr` skdh fo pilk`t sukt
scbhduih prfphrty.
2. K`gu`ctkf` cl``ft jh erl`thd ls stlthd u`dhr shctkf` 4
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
11/21
3-:>
Dhoh`dl`t
LD_FCLTH OFZ DHOH@DL@T
K df swhlr l`d lookra ljfvh cf`th`ts ls truh l`d cfrrhct l`d ske` ls
jhifw.
^ilch7 @hilal`elil
Dlth7 >:->3-:>
Dhoh`dl`t
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
12/21
FS - ?4 /:>
^ILK@TKOO _/S DHOH@DL@T
_KGL[LILMSBAK & FTBHZS GL[LAAL
K@THZIFCXTFZ[ L^^IKCLTKF@ X@DHZ FZDHZ RRRKR ZXIH < & : ZHLDUKTB
SHCTKF@ 3-:> LD_FCLTH OFZ L^^IKCL@T/DHOH@DL@T
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
13/21
FS - ?4 /:>
^ILK@TKOO _/S DHOH@DL@T
_KGL[LILMSBAK & FTBHZS GL[LAAL
L O O K D L _ K T
K, GL[LAAL U/F ILTH MH@CBL^^L, lehd ljfut 84 yhlrs, rhskdk`e lt
Mrksb`lpurl Erlal, Sfapurl Bfjik, @hilal`elil Tlium df bhrhjy sfiha`iy lookra
l`d stlth f` fltb ls ofiifws 7
>; bfpk`e k` l`tkckpltkf` fo juim frdhrs tbh dhoh`dl`t blvh
k`vhsthd aucb fo alcbk`hrkhs. Ko alcbk`hrkhs whrh dhstrfyhd jy kiiheli
trhsplss fo pilk`tkoo, dhoh`dl`ts wkii jh put tf bhlvy ifss. Ko pilk`tkoos lrh ihot
fut tf k`throhrh k` sukt scbhduih prfphrty ak`k`e lctkvkty tbhrh wkii jh bueh
k`vhstah`t ifss bh`ch tbks lppikcltkf`.
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
14/21
:->3-:> DH^F@H@T
Kdh`tkokhd jy ah
Ldvfclth
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
15/21
^ILK@TKOO _/S DHOH@DL@T
_KGL[LILMSBAK & FTBHZS GL[LAAL
IKST FO DFCXAH@TS
L``h
xurh
Dhscrkptkf`
L&J SLIH DHHD DLTHD >3->4-:-;
A FS 4;2->
^ILCH 7 @HILAL@ELIL
DLTHD 7 >:->3-:> LD_FCLTH OFZ DHOH@DL@T
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
16/21
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
17/21
^ILK@TKOO _/S DHOH@DL@T
_KGL[LILMSBAK & FTBHZS GL[LAAL
_HZKO[K@E L O O K D L _ K T
K, GL[LAAL U/F ILTH MH@CBL^^L, lehd ljfut 84 yhlrs, rhskdk`e lt
Mrksb`lpurl Erlal, Sfapurl Bfjik, @hilal`elil Tlium df bhrhjy sfiha`iy lookra
l`d stlth f` fltb ls ofiifws 7
:->3-:>
Kdh`tkokhd jy ah,DH^F@H@T
Ldvfclth,
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
18/21
^ILK@TKOO _/S DHOH@DL@T
_KGL[LILMSBAK & FTBHZS GL[LAAL
AHAF
Tbh ldvfclth ofr Dhoh`dl`t okihs cfpy fo twf Gudehah`ts fo
Mlr`ltlml bkeb cfurt rhpfrthd k` KIZ MLZ 33-:>
LD_FCLTH OFZ Dhoh`dl`t
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
19/21
^ILK@TKOO _/S DHOH@DL@T
_KGL[LILMSBAK & FTBHZS GL[LAAL
AHAF
Tbh ldvfclth ofr Dhoh`dl`t okihs cfpy fo ofiifwk`e Gudehah`ts fo Suprhah
cfurt fo K`dkl cfiihcthd orfa Suprhah Cfurt Fookckli whjskth
bttp7//gudks.`kc.k lppikcljih tf ljfvh clsh tf bkebikebt tbh jhifw pfk`ts k`
suppfrt fo dhoh`dl`t pihldk`es ofr tbh mk`d cf`skdhrltkf` fo tbh Bf`jih
cfurt. Tbh altthr ks vhry ureh`t k` tbh h`ds fo Gustkch l`d tbh dhoh`dl`t ks
stkii stfpphd bhr ikch`chd ak`k`e wfrm k` dhoh`dl`t wrktth` stlthah`t
scbhduih prfphrty l`d pilk`tkoo wktb lii kiiheliktkhs ls hxpilk`hd k` wrktth`
stlthah`t l`d fjghctkf`s ks blrlssk`e tbh dhoh`dl`t jy fjtlk`k`e hx-plrth
frdhr. Bh`ch tbks ahaf rhquhstk`e tf cf`skdhr KL-< fo pilk`tkoo l`d KL-: fo
dhoh`dl`t lt tbh hlrikhst ofr kts dkspfsli
:>>5(?) SCC -0 Bh wbf cfahs k tf hqukty aust cfah wktb cihl` bl`ds.
L cfurt fo hqukty rhoushs rhikho tf l pilk`tkoo wbfsh cf`duct k` rhelrd tf tbh
sujghct altthr fo tbh iktkeltkf` bls jhh` kaprfphr. Tbks wls ofrahriy
hxprhsshd jy tbh alxka "bh wbf bls cfaaktthd k`kqukty sblii `ft blvh
hqukty", l`d rhikho wls rhoushd wbhrh l trl`slctkf` wls jlshd f` tbh
pilk`tkoos orlud fr aksrhprhsh`tltkf`, fr wbhrh tbh pilk`tkoo sfuebt tf h`ofrch
l shcurkty kaprfphriy fjtlk`hd, fr wbhrh bh cilkahd l rhahdy ofr l jrhlcb fo
trust wbkcb bh bld bkashio prfcurhd l`d wbhrhjy bh bld fjtlk`hd af`hy.
Ilthr kt wls slkd tblt tbh pilk`tkoo k` hqukty aust cfah wktb phrohct prfprkhty
fo cf`duct, fr wktb cihl` bl`ds.
Tbhrh ks l`ftbhr dfctrk`h wbkcb cl``ft lisf jh ifst skebt fo. Tbh cfurt wfuid
`ft frdk`lrkiy phrakt l plrty tf pursuh twf plrliihi rhahdkhs k` rhsphct fo
tbh slah sujghct altthr. ]Shh Glk Sk`eb v. X`kf` fo K`dkl l`d Ftbhrs, (
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
20/21
:>
LKZ :>>2 SC ?4? -0 kt wls l okt clsh wbhrh lppikcltkf` ofr k`gu`ctkf` okihd jy
tbh pilk`tkoo wls tf jh dksaksshd k` tbh ljsh`ch fo `hchsslry plrtkhs tf tbh
sukt l`d f` tblt erfu`d lif`h tbh lppikcltkf` wls dksaksshd. Tbh Bkeb Cfurt
`fthd tblt kt bld `ft ef`h k`tf tbh ahrkts fo tbh clsh l`d f`iy f` tbh
thcb`kcli erfu`d ls `fthd ljfvh, tbh lppikcltkf` ofr thapfrlry k`gu`ctkf`
wls rhghcthd.
Kt ks f`h tbk`e tf sly tblt tbhrh dfhs `ft hxkst l`y lajkeukty ls rhelrds
dhscrkptkf` fo tbh sukt il`d k` tbh pilk`t wktb rhohrh`ch tf tbh jfu`dlrkhs ls
ah`tkf`hd tbhrhk`, jut kt ks l`ftbhr tbk`e tf sly tblt tbh il`d k` sukt jhif`es
tf tbh rhspf`dh`ts. Kt wls ofr tbh pilk`tkoos tf prfvh tblt tbh il`d k` sukt
ofrahd plrt fo CTS @fs. 42:3/L-
-
8/6/2019 Written statement, Objections to IA and IA of defendant draft in Injunction suit
21/21
:>>? (8) SCC :2: -0 Tbh dkscrhtkf` fo tbh cfurt ks hxhrckshd tf erl`t l
thapfrlry k`gu`ctkf` f`iy wbh` tbh ofiifwk`e rhqukrhah`ts lrh aldh fut jy
tbh pilk`tkoo 7 (k) hxksth`ch fo l prkal olckh clsh ls pihldhd, `hchssktltk`e
prfthctkf` fo pilk`tkoos rkebts jy kssuh fo l thapfrlry k`gu`ctkf`= (kk) wbh`
tbh `hhd ofr prfthctkf` fo pilk`tkoos rkebts ks cfaplrhd wktb fr whkebhd
lelk`st tbh `hhd ofr prfthctkf` fo dhoh`dl`ts rkebts fr ikmhiy k`ork`ehah`t fo
dhoh`dl`ts rkebts, tbh jlil`ch fo cf`vh`kh`ch tkitk`e k` olvfur fo pilk`tkoo=
l`d (kkk) cihlr pfsskjkikty fo krrhplrljih k`gury jhk`e clushd tf pilk`tkoo ko tbh
thapfrlry k`gu`ctkf` ks `ft erl`thd. K` lddktkf`, thapfrlry k`gu`ctkf` jhk`e
l` hquktljih rhikho, tbh dkscrhtkf` tf erl`t sucb rhikho wkii jh hxhrckshd f`iy
wbh` tbh pilk`tkoos cf`duct ks orhh orfa jilah l`d bh lpprflcbhs tbh cfurt
wktb cihl` bl`ds.
:>>2(2 () SCC ;5 -0 Kt ks trkth tblt tbh ruih fo pihldk`es pfstuilth tblt l
pilk`t aust cf`tlk` althrkli olcts. Ubh` tbh pilk`t rhld ls l wbfih dfhs `ft
dkscifsh althrkli olcts ekvk`e rksh tf l clush fo lctkf` wbkcb cl` jh
h`thrtlk`hd jy l ckvki cfurt, kt aly jh rhghcthd k` thras fo Frdhr 5, Zuih
LD_FCLTH OFZ Dhoh`dl`t